Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bachelor’s Party!!!
Executive Summary
Consolidation - A Global Phenomenon
Banking sector consolidation is not just an Indian phenomenon but a Global reality on the back of Basel II implementations.
As India integrates itself with the world – the increased adherence to global compliance standards will become a major tool
for sustenance.
Indian Banking Character- Unlike globaly, the Indian Banking system is characterized by large number of small banks
participating in a large market. The top 5 banks cover around 45% of Assets in India, while globally they cover 75-95%
assest. We feel that size will soon emerge as a strategic compulsion to remain competitive in the emerging opportunities
from the Indian economic renaissance. Barring sparse instances, consolidation in Indian Banking industry till date has
been undertaken primarily as an external compulsion than internal strategic initiative.
Asian Experience - The Asian region (Malaysia, Taiwan, Singapore, Indonesia, South Korea and Japan), particularly after
the 1997 South East Asian Crisis, has witnessed its own share of consolidation in the recent past. Further, recent M&A
activity in the region has witnessed deal executions at 40%+ premia of prevailing valuations.
The Indian Banking Industry is governed by a regulator with pedigree of taking proactive measures that facilitate integration
of Indian Banking sector with emerging global trend. To facilitate timely entry of relevant global players in the banking
space, RBI has set its roadmap for consolidation in two phases –
l Phase I (2005-2009) – focused on enabling Indian Banks to become more competitive
l Phase II (post-2009) – providing competitive entry opportunities (Open branches and take over private banks) to foreign banks.
As we move closer to the 2009 deadline – both domestic as well as cross-border M&A activity is expected to gather further
pace. We also expect some of the futuristic bank managements to take complementary overseas bets during this period.
We also expect the activity to heighten further (post-2009) – given the strategic opportunity for the Global banks to
participate in the Indian pie.
Valuations
Till the actual action… Valuation segmentation – a natural transition
Till 2009 - the strategic complements in business, contemporariness of the bank, and its relevance/ ability/willingness to
participate in the activity, would start reflecting in valuation – thereby sharpening the valuation differentials further.
The new-age private banks with their wide/decent spread of network, diverse product offerings, and better technology and
customer base – offer the best participation in this space for foreign banks. In this scenario, our top picks are ICICI Bank,
Kotak Mahindra Bank, Centurion Bank of Punjab and YES Bank.
16 May, 2007 2
DOLAT CAPITAL
Commercial Banks are further divided into Schedule and non Schedule Commercial Banks. However, in India these Banks
are classified as Public sector Banks, Private Banks (Old Private sector Banks New Private sector Banks) and Foreign
Banks. (Refer Annexure I )
Further, Indian Banking system is fragmented with top 5 banks covering around 45% of Assets, where-as world wide top 5
banks cover around 75-95% of the Assets. The Indian Banking system is characterized by large number of small
banks rather than a few banks participating in a large market.
Public Sector Banks (PSB) are still dominant in the business profiles of Indian banks, with around 28 of them controlling
around 74% and 72% of the Total Deposits and Total Advances respectively. The Private Sector Banks (a dominant
phenomenon post economic reforms) represent around 21% market share each in Total Deposits and Advances. On the
other hand, Foreign Banks (so far restricted in terms of local aggression for the limited scope offered by law), have mere
5.6% and 7.1% share in the Total Deposits and Advances respectively.
40
40
30
30 20.6 20.8
17.0 20
20 14.0
5.6 7.1
10 4.0 10
1.0
0 0
Public Sector Private Sector Foreign Banks Public Sector Private Sector Foreign Banks
Banks Banks
Only 22 of Indian Banks figure among the top 1,000 banks in the world. State Bank of India (SBI), the largest bank of India
is around one-tenth the size of Citigroup, the world largest Bank on the Tier I basis. Further, SBI has around 90-100mn
customers and an Asset Base of $155bn; where as Bank of America has customer base of around 30mn and the Asset
Base of more than trillion dollars. In Asia, India’s SBI is the only local bank that had made it to the top 25 list. In comparison
China’s 4th largest bank is 2.5 times that of SBI. Also, the 5th largest Bank in China is probably larger than the top five banks
in Indian on the Total Asset front on aggregate basis.
16 May, 2007 3
DOLAT CAPITAL
Tabel 1: -Banks in Different Categories
$Bn (March 2006) Tier I Capital Assets Profits RoA (%)
World
Citigroup 79 1,494 29.0 1.97
HSBC Holdings 74 1,502 21.0 1.40
Bank of America 74 1,292 25.0 1.95
JP Morgan Chase 73 1,199 12.0 1.02
Mitsubishi UFJ Financial group 64 1,509 13.0 0.85
Asia
China Construction Bank Corp. 36 568 7.0 1.21
Industrial & Commercial Bank of China 32 800 7.0 0.92
Bank of China 31 587 7.0 1.14
National Australia Bank 17 299 5.0 1.67
Kookmin Bank 12 181 3.0 1.78
India
SBI 8 155 1.9 0.89
ICICI Bank 4 56 0.7 1.23
PNB 2 33 0.5 1.09
BoB 2 23 0.3 0.79
Canara Bank 2 30 0.3 1.16
Source: Industry
Further, the statistics for Bank Credit to GDP (x), clearly indicates that India is still an under-banked country.
167
156
133
113 113
94
76 77
47
25 35
Thailand
China
UK
Hong
Brazil
Singapore
USA
Kong
Korea
Taiwan
Malaysia
India
Russia
16 May, 2007 4
DOLAT CAPITAL
Asian Experience
In Asian region, Malaysia had reduced the number of banks from 55 to 10; while, Taiwan aims to bring down the number of
state banks from 12 to 6 (FY2004). Singapore government has also guided the banking system to lower the number of
Banks to mere 3 players with DBS being supported to become a regional leader. Similar initiatives have been undertaken
in Indonesia, South Korea and Japan – particularly after the 1997 South East Asian Crisis.
16 May, 2007 5
DOLAT CAPITAL
Indian Banking Sector - Consolidation roadmap
The Banking sector reforms in India were initiated in 1992, with a core focus on ensuring the safety and soundness of
financial institutions and at the same time making the banking system strong, efficient, functionally diverse and competitive.
The reforms included measures for arresting the decline in productivity, efficiency and profitability of the Banking sector.
The idea was to prepare a robust financial structure that enables the economy to operate in an open world environment. All
the key parameters like Capital Adequacy, prudential regulations, and accounting and disclosure standards have been
subjected to compliance of international standards since. Today, the level of compliance of the sector with the Basel
Committee’s Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision, has refined financial soundness and consistent supervisory
practices of the Indian Banking system and made it resilient to absorb/respond global shocks.
While these initiatives on banking reforms have created a robust banking structure – it has also created a peculiar environment
by creation of multiple similar entities – small in size competing to create their sizeable identity over the next few years.
While base business growth remains favorable for each constituent in the current economic environment – size of business
(balance sheet) would remain a strategic compulsion to remain competitive in emerging opportunities from the Indian
economic renaissance. This makes mergers & acquisitions (both local as well as cross border) to form critical
components of the evolution of the Indian financial sector.
The major gains perceived from bank consolidation are the ability to withstand the pressures of emerging global competition,
to strengthen the performance of the banks, to effectively absorb the new technologies and demand for sophisticated
products and services, to arrange funding for major development products in the realm of infrastructure and telecom, etc
which require huge financials outlays and to streamline human resources functions and skills in tune with the emerging
competitive environment.
Banking Industry vision 2010 – a vision document of Indian Banks Association (IBA) has also highlighted consolidation and
M&A activity as an immediate agenda – driven mainly by expectations of shareholders. It sets a vision to deliver 4-5 world
class Indian banks by the year 2010. It also envisions a roadmap where Indian Banking system would witness emergence
of a few national banks of global scale and a number of regional players.
RBI has also on its part defined a clear roadmap recently to enable, facilitate and also regulate developments that make
consolidation an executable reality. The roadmap is split in two phases–
l Phase I (2005-2009) – focused on enabling Indian Banks to become more competitive (Refer Annexure II)
l Phase II (post-2009) – providing competitive entry opportunities to foreign banks (Refer Annexure III)
16 May, 2007 6
DOLAT CAPITAL
Phase I (Pre-2009)
We expect following scenarios to evolve under these regulation during this phase. The existing banks will get
categorized in following six groups –
l Revitalized Banking Entities – Banks like Indian Bank/ IDBI (which have been at the receipt of Govt funding/ largesse
in the form rupee recapitalization/ favorable regulatory exemptions in the past) – would be allocated / acquire other
banks to become strong with wider reach.
l Public Sector Banks - with large domestic presence (Tier I banks – like SBI, PNB, Canara, BoB, BoI, Central, etc.)
that want to acquire bank with an overseas presence to become global entities. The Tier II banks (like Dena, Vijaya,
BoM, Andhra, etc.) in this segment might re-align to any of the bigger umbrella from among the first layer.
l Large Private Sector Banks – with contemporary management practices and high growth ambitions (ICICI Bank,
Kotak Mahindra Bank, HDFC Bank, UTI Bank)
l Niche New-Age Private Sector Banks – headed by aggressive CEOs, who have been leading ex-bankers (CBoP, Yes
Bank, DCB, etc.) and are driven by ambition to create a sizeable banking entity (through organic as well as inorganic growth)
l Niche Old Private Sector Banks – boutique regional presence with decent growth focus (Federal, South India, Karur
Vysya, Karnataka) – to align for strategic partnership options with a larger national player (foreign or domestic)
l Small Banks – Banks, which find organic growth restrictions with size and capital and would need to align with larger
banks to remain viable (Dhanalakshmi, City Union, etc). These are definite potential targets.
SBI offers maximum clarity on the structure and method of its evolution through this face to emerge as a larger participant
in the system.
The impact of the entry of Foreign Banks on domestic Banks is likely to depend on various factors such as the structure,
strength and competitiveness of domestic Banks, the share of foreign banks, and the regulatory/supervisory framework.
16 May, 2007 7
DOLAT CAPITAL
Scenario–I - BUY SBI – for clarity on means and end
SBI Clearly stands as a best bet amongst the PSB’s (on consolidation theme) on the back of the emerging clarity towards
the consolidation/ merger with its seven banking subsidiaries (3 listed and 4 unlisted).
Benefits for SBI and Group: - Currently, the subsidiaries together form the 2nd largest banking entity on consolidated
bases. The merger of these Banks with SBI would propel SBI to a newer orbit in terms of business, Balance Sheet to play
the larger turf globally.
The Government has kept the forum open for the Nationalized Banks towards Consolidation. However, due to the lack of
initiatives from respective banks and also due to issues related to cultural mis-match, technology implementation and also
various other factors like human resource optimiz ation, over-lapping of branches; consolidation remains an unclear vision
for the Indian PSBs.
The proposed merger of Canara Bank and Dena bank has already sounded the bugle for the consolidation exercise. We
expect the momentum to only build from hereon. The obvious participants would be banks which need a definite capital
infusion, having GoI holding at threshold limit (51%) and on stand-alone find themselves in a non-distinctive market position.
However, there remains a possible outside trigger of substantial re-rating in this space if and when GoI decides to reduce
its controlling stake to 33% from the current 51% levels. (Refer Annexure IV)
We feel the value unlocking from consolidation opportunity in this segment is limited on account of lack of clarity on the
roadmap and higher complexities (in terms of internal realignments within PSB units) – and hence should be explored from
Value perspective as against consolidation perspective. We like PNB, IOB, BoB and Andhra Bank in this space on pure
valuation basis. (Refer Annexure V)
Smaller Private Banks:- Amongst the Indian Private Sector Banks, the weaker and small banks are definite candidates
for the consolidation on account of lower Networth and inability to face competition. (City Union Bank, Dhanalakshmi etc).
However, the desire being on the seller’s side to raise capital and also to support the regulatory norms, we expect limited
upside to happen in this segment of private banks.
New Private Sector Banks: - Post reforms in 1992, the new age private banks (ICICI Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank, HDFC
Bank, YES Bank, CBoP etc) has captured a substantial share in the Indian Banking system. Further, these banks have
also built strong / decent franchise, products and services to cater the entire needs of customer. These Banks are expected
to takeover / merger some of the weak and smaller banks along with some cross border acquisitions to enhance their core
competency. Private sector banks are expected to witness a spate of mergers, acquisitions, and open offers post 2009
from global banks seeking complementary India Strategy.
India had its own-share of M&A over the last decade (Refer Table 3, Annexure VI)
We feel that there exists very limited possibility to ride these banks from a sell out perspective. However – they do possess
a strategic relevance as channel partners/ strategic allies – which allow them to ride on their current channel strength and
improve fee based incomes through partnerships (non-core business income for foreign banks). We expect this to be the
natural transgression given their pedigree on technology, product offerings and market aggression. This could see the
emergence of niche alliances in differential functional areas and business segments such as housing, credit cards, mutual
fund, insurance etc.
16 May, 2007 9
DOLAT CAPITAL
Banks Particulars
IDBI & UWB IDBI paid a decent value to acquire UWB.
IDBI branch network reached to 425 branches with the acquisition of UWB’s 195 branches
(70% of the branches in the urban areas).
The strong branch network is expected to benefit IDBI to garner higher Retail Credit and also Low Cost
Deposits (CASA) Portfolio.
CBoP& Lord Krishna Bank CBoP continued its inorganic growth strategy and paid fair value to acquire LKB.
(LKB) LKB’s 112 branches and 44 ATMs extends around 50% geographic reach to CBoP, especially in Kerla.
LKB also increases CBoP Balance Sheet size by around 20%, thus making it the 9th largest Private Sector
Bank in India.
Source : Dolat Research
Foreign Banks having global presence strategy are expected to react in a different way depending on the level of presence
in India. These Banks are expected to have two options to spread their reach, expand business, customer base viz.
l Open newer branches and expand rapidly into newer areas,
l Buy out any Private Bank and expand on the ready made branches, customers and business.
If the foreign Banks opt to buy out private sector banks they would seek –
Retail - Credit
16 May, 2007 10
DOLAT CAPITAL
Presence and Non Presence of Foreign Banks in India – what they look for...
Foreign Banks
Banks Banks
CBoP ICICI Bank
YES Bank Kotak Bank
Indusind Bank HDFC Bank
DCB UTI
Regional Banks
Federal Bank
KTK
SIB
KVB
16 May, 2007 11
DOLAT CAPITAL
How Much??? - Beauty lies in the eyes of beholder; Valuation in those of buyers!!!
The valuations for the eventual transactions would be driven by the ultimate strategic premia that the buyers would be keen
to pay for gaining access/ control in the Indian banking space.
16 May, 2007 12
DOLAT CAPITAL
Table 5: -Global M&A activity - Premiums paid
Sr no Acquire Bank Target Bank Deal Premium
1 H&CB kookim Bank 0.2%
2 Overseas Union Bank United Overseas Bank Ltd 26.8%
3 DBS Bank Hong Kong DBS Group Holdings Ltd 61.4%
4 Taipei Bank Fubon Financial Holding Co 46.0%
5 Chohung Bank Shinhan Financial Group Ltd 7.0%
6 Chohung Bank Shinhan Financial Group Ltd 22.1%
7 Chohung Bank Shinhan Financial Group Ltd 5.2%
8 Ufj Holdings inc Mitsubishi UFJ Financial 35.8%
9 Bank Nisp Pt Overseas Chinese Banking Corp 5.1%
10 Prudential Bank Bank of Philippine Islands 95.6%
11 Equitable PCI Bank Banco De Oro Universal Bank 15.2%
12 Bank Buana Indonesia United Overseas Bank Ltd 0.9%
13 Farners Bank of China Taiwan Cooperative Bank 5.3%
14 Momji Holdings Inc Yamaguchi Bank Ltd -28.2%
15 Southern Bank Berhad Bumiputra Commerce Hldgs 6.8%
Average 20.3%
16 Centurion Bank Bank of Punjab 4.6%
17 ICICI Bank Bank of Madhura 100.0%
18 HDFC Bank Times Bank 8.1%
19 IDBI United Western Bank 21.0%
Average 33.4%
Combined Average 27%
Source : Bloomberg
Challenges in Consolidation
Some of the major concerns or issues for the Consolidation in the Indian Banking could be:
l Adaptation of Technology or technology platforms.
l Culture, working environment (Labor problems).
l Change in Government / Government Guidelines.
16 May, 2007 13
DOLAT CAPITAL
We expect the momentum to also build in terms of valuation differentials with a further sharpening during this period
towards the likely beneficiaries, vis-à-vis the ones where the chances for M&A/ consolidation are lower.
We expect SBI to be the natural beneficiary (among the PSB segment) – and a direct play given clarity on the end and
means of its M&A related initiatives and preparedness. In its peer-set - value would remain a dominant investment theme
along with a possible outside trigger of substantial re-rating in this space if and when GoI decides to reduce its controlling
stake to 33% from the current 51% levels.
The new-age private banks with their wide/decent spread of network, diverse product offerings, and better technology and
customer base – offer the best participation in this space.
In this scenario, our top picks are ICICI Bank, Kotak Mahindra Bank, Centurion Bank of Punjab and YES Bank.
16 May, 2007 14
DOLAT CAPITAL
Annexure I
Structure of Indian Banking system
Public sector bank Private sector bank Foreign sector bank Regional rural bank
Annexure II
One track is consolidation of the domestic banking system in both public and private sectors. The second track is gradual
enhancement of the presence of foreign banks in a synchronized manner.
16 May, 2007 15
DOLAT CAPITAL
4. Acquisition of Shareholding in select Indian Private Sector Banks
In order to allow Indian banks sufficient time to prepare themselves for global competition, initially entry of foreign banks
will be permitted only if private sector banks that are identified by RBI for restructuring. In such banks, foreign banks
would be allowed to acquire a controlling stake in a phased manner.
In considering an application made by foreign bank, for acquisition of 5% or more in the private bank, RBI will take into
account the standing and the reputation of the foreign bank, globally as well as in India, and the desired level and the
nature of presence of the foreign bank in India. RBI may, if it is satisfied that such investment by the foreign bank
concerned will be in the long term interest of all the stakeholders in the invested bank, permit acquisition of such
percentage as it may deem fit. The RBI may also specify, if necessary, that investor bank shall make a minimum
acquisition of 15% or more and may also specify the time frame for such acquisition. The over all limit of 74% will be
applicable.
Where such acquisition is by a foreign bank already having a presence in India, a time bound plan covering a period not
exceeding six months to conform to the ‘one form of presence’ concept will have to be submitted by the foreign bank
along with the application for acquisition.
Annexure III
16 May, 2007 16
Annexure V: - Public Banks Valuation
16 May, 2007
Banks CMP EPS(Rs) P/E (x) B.V. (Rs) P/BV (x) P/ABV (x) RoANW (x)
(Rs) FY07E FY08E FY09E FY07E FY08E FY09E FY07E FY08E FY09E FY07E FY08E FY09E FY07E FY08E FY09E FY07E FY08E FY09E
Allahbad Bank 83 16.8 23.0 27.3 4.9 3.6 3.0 100.2 118.2 140.2 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.9 0.7 0.6 18.5 21.1 21.1
Andhra Bank 92 11.1 12.7 15.0 8.3 7.2 6.1 66.5 74.6 84.6 1.4 1.2 1.1 1.4 1.3 1.1 17.6 18.0 18.8
Bank of Baroda 276 28.1 35.5 44.0 9.8 7.8 6.3 235.2 262.8 298.4 1.2 1.0 0.9 1.2 1.1 1.0 12.5 14.3 15.7
Bank of India 207 23.0 28.0 32.8 9.0 7.4 6.3 121.7 145.7 174.6 1.7 1.4 1.2 1.9 1.5 1.3 17.4 16.8 18.6
Canara Bank 243 35.5 39.8 45.6 6.9 6.1 5.3 201.6 232.6 268.2 1.2 1.0 0.9 1.4 1.1 1.0 18.9 18.3 18.2
Corporation Bank 321 37.1 43.5 49.9 8.7 7.4 6.4 264.0 298.4 339.3 1.2 1.1 0.9 1.3 1.1 1.0 14.9 15.5 15.6
IDBI 100 9.1 11.3 13.6 11.0 8.8 7.4 94.8 103.5 113.9 1.1 1.0 0.9 1.2 1.0 0.9 9.9 11.4 12.5
IOB 118 18.5 22.8 27.6 6.4 5.2 4.3 76.1 98.1 125.1 1.6 1.2 0.9 1.7 1.2 1.0 27.6 26.2 24.8
PNB 557 50.7 61.1 84.5 11.0 9.1 6.6 340.2 392.9 468.9 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.7 1.4 1.2 15.9 16.7 19.6
SBI* 1,284 86.3 99.2 115.1 14.9 13.0 11.2 596.1 678.8 776.8 2.2 1.9 1.7 2.6 2.2 1.9 15.4 15.6 15.8
Syndicate Bank 82 13.7 16.0 18.4 6.0 5.1 4.5 64.9 77.5 92.2 1.3 1.1 0.9 1.4 1.1 0.9 23.0 22.4 21.7
Union Bank 122 16.7 19.8 22.9 7.3 6.2 5.4 102.6 117.4 135.3 1.2 1.0 0.9 1.4 1.2 1.0 17.4 18.0 18.1
CMP as on 16/05/2007
* Standalone
DOLAT CAPITAL
17
DOLAT CAPITAL
Annexure VI: - Valuation table for the recent mergers and acquisitions
16 May, 2007 18
DOLAT CAPITAL
Annexure VIII: - Valuing an Acquisition
Value the combined firm with synergy built in. This may include Which firm is indispensable for the
A higher growth rate in revenues: Growth synergy synergy?
Higher Margins, because of economies of scale If It is the target, you should be
Synergy Lower Taxes, because of tax benefits: Tax synergy willing to pay up to the synergy.
Lower cost of debt: Financing synergy If it is the bidder, you should not.
Higher debt ratio because of lower risk: Debt capacity
Subtract the value of the target firm (with control premium) +
Value of the bidding firm (pre- acquisition). This is the value of
the synergy.
Value the company as if optimally managed. This will usually If motive is control or in a stand alone
mean that investment, financing and dividend policy will be valuation, this is the maximum you
altered: should pay
Investment Policy: Higher returns on projects and divesting
Control Premium unproductive projects.
Financing Policy: Move to be a better financing structure
Dividend Policy : Return unsused cash
Practically,
1. Look at industry averages for optimal ( if lazy)
2. Do a full fledged corporate financial analysis
Status quo Valuation Value the company as is, with existing inputs for investments, If motive is undervaluation,
financing and dividend policy. this is the maximum you should pay
16 May, 2007 19
DOLAT CAPITAL
The ratings are based on the absolute upside of our target price from the current price.
Upside Ratings
> 25 % Buy
15% - 25% Accumulate
0% - 15% Reduce
<0% Sell
This report contains a compilation of publicly available information, internally developed data and other sources believed to be reliable. While all reasonable care has been taken
to ensure that the facts stated are accurate and the opinion given are fair and reasonable, we do not take any responsibility for inaccuracy or omission of any information and
will not be liable for any loss or damage of any kind suffered by use of or reliance placed upon this information. For Pvt. Circulation & Research Purpose only.
16 May, 2007 20