Edition date : 15 May 2012

Comments detail on project 07746W - Electricity & Automation

Parent Ref Date
07-04-08

Comment

Type

Status
Submitted

Customer
ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360065.009 - Bilge system Single line diagram LPO163635 (Rev. G) 29.360066.107 - Main SWBD. General Electrical LPO590946 Diagram (Rev. F) 29.360066.107 - Main SWBD. General Electrical LPO591053 Diagram (Rev. F)

25-11-11

CB 011.1 We noted that LAH CB 011.1 intended for void space stbd Note fr131-fr151 is CB011. Harbor generator To be reWe noted that no more harbor generator fitted. Therefore submitted item 4 in the sheet 5/31 should be deleted. P9-9 Cable size The cable size of P9-9 is not suitable (sheet 23/31). To be updated. Intended fire doors To be resubmitted

Pending

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

25-11-11

Pending

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360066.229 - Fire doors and water proof doors LPO592248 closing Structural diagram (Rev. A)

25-11-11

It seems that not all fire doors required to be remote closed To be reindicated in the drawing 29.360060.32, Rev.I, submitted CONSTRUCTIVE FIRE PROTECTION AND WAYS OF EVACUATION are not included in this drawing. To be reconfirmed with the latest information. Simultaneously closing

Pending

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360066.229 - Fire doors and water proof doors LPO592253 closing Structural diagram (Rev. A)

25-11-11

We noted that the doors can be closed only individually from the control panel. The doors should be able to close simultaneously or in groups. BV Rules, Pt C, Ch 4, Sec 5, 3.2.1.3)

To be resubmitted

Pending

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Folder bow thruster switch cabinet for bow thrusters 1 and 2 (Rev. 0)

LPO118427

04-05-07

Technical Comments

To be dealt Pending with

Uwe E. Zoller GmbH Elektrotechnik

Page 1 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
Remarks:

Type

Status

Customer

VE125080012 - Electrical drawings (Rev. 0)

LPO332426

17-07-09

1. All wire cross section and ratings (e-motor) should be indicated in the drawings. 2. All used electronics and e-motors are to be of approved type, list of uses materials to be submitted for review. To be dealt Pending 3. Duplicated electric power circuits are to be separated as with far as practicable. Duplicated steering gear control systems with their associated components are to be separated as far as practicable. Verify that in case on single failure (plc system) that the steering gear or a part remains operable. 4. Final approval subject satisfactory testing.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Type approvals 29.360062.005 Navigation lights arrangement (Rev. E) Navigation lights, signal lights, signal equipment are to be of type approved by the flag authorities. COLREG Annex I, To be dealt Pending 13 with Answered OTHE Navigation lights, signal lights, signal equipment will be of R type approved by the flag authorities. COLREG Annex I, 13 Visibility of lights 29.360062.005 Navigation lights arrangement (Rev. E) LPO371099 21-11-11 Visibility of lights (navigation/signal) are to be in line with COLREG Part C, Rule 22. To be dealt Pending with Answered ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

LPO371098

21-11-11

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360062.005 Navigation lights arrangement (Rev. E)

LPO371150

21-11-11

OTHE Visibility of lights (navigation/signal) are in line with R COLREG Part C, Rule 22. YIII: Restricted manoeuvrability light The restricted manoeuvrability light comprises Red-WhiteTo be dealt Pending Red. Part C, Rule 27 with Answered OTHE The restricted manoeuvrability light comprises Red-WhiteR Red

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 2 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
Side light position

Type

Status

Customer

29.360062.005 Navigation lights arrangement (Rev. E)

LPO371152

21-11-11

The sidelights of a power-driven vessel shall be placed at a height above the hull not greater than the three-quarters of that of the forward masthead light. They shall not be so low as to be interfered with by deck lights. COLREG Annex I, 2 To be dealt Pending (g) with Answered The sidelights of a power-driven vessel placed at a height OTHE 6.4m. Forward masthead light placed at a height 12m. R 29.360062.005 Rev.E Aft anchor light The forward anchor light prescribed in Rule 30(a)(i), when two are carried, shall not be less than 4.5 metres above the To be dealt Pending after one. COLREG Annex I, 2 (k) with Answered OTHE The forward anchor light placed at a height 6m. The aft R anchor lights placed at a height 1.5 m M/E shutdown by thrust bearing pad high temp M/E shutdown is to be achieved by thrust bearing pad high temp or bearing oil outlet temp high.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360062.005 Navigation lights arrangement (Rev. E)

LPO371153

21-11-11

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.003 (1/3) - Oil System Schematic Diagram (Rev. F/1)

LPO163721

21-11-11

To be dealt Pending Answered ME1 thrust bearing high temp: 1ML064, 1ML065, 1ML066 with OTHE ME2 thrust bearing high temp: 2ML065, 2ML066, 2ML067 R These signals are transferred to AMS, ME1&ME2 shutdown will be achieved on Wheel house control panel

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 3 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
HFO tank No.1 and No.2

Type

Status

Customer

29.360064.007 (1/4) - Fuel LPO163834 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, monitoring items intend for HFO tank No.1 and No.2 are not correct. To be verified. To be dealt Pending with Answered OTHE Please see 29.360066.211 Rev.B , 29.360064.007 Rev.J R LPO Noted. FT031/LAH is still missing to be added ih the 29.360064.007 (1/4). HFO transfer pump No.3 and MDO transfer pump Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, AC135 and AC136 are PCAL instead of PCL. To be verified. OTHE AC135 and AC136 are PCAL R LPO Noted. 29.360064.007 (1/4) is to be updated. HFO settling tank No.5 Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, SF063/TIAH is TIAL. To be verified. OTHE SF063/TIAL R LPO Noted. 29.360064.007 (1/4) is to be updated. MDO tank No.9 Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, SF063/TIAH is TIAL. To be verified. OTHE MDO Tank N09 - FT002/LIALH R LPO Noted. 29.360064.007 (1/4) is to be updated.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.007 (1/4) - Fuel LPO163835 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.007 (1/4) - Fuel LPO163846 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.007 (1/4) - Fuel LPO163847 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 4 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
MDO tank No.8 Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, FT001 is LIALH instead of LAH. To be verified.

Type

Status

Customer

29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel LPO163794 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered OTHE LIALH - Analogue measurement 29.360064.007 (4/4) rev.J R LPO Noted. The drawing 29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel oil systems is to be updated. MDO tank No.9 Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, FT002 is LIALH instead of LIAH. To be verified.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel LPO163795 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered OTHE LIALH - Analogue measurement. R Noted. The drawing 29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel oil systems LPO is to be updated. HFO settling tank No.5 Further to monitoring/alarm list: 29.360066.211, SF063/TAL is TIAL. To be verified.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel LPO163825 oil systems (Rev. J)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered OTHE SF063/TIAL R Noted. The drawing 29.360064.007 (4/4) - Fuel oil systems LPO is to be updated.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 5 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
MSB Main busbar connecting devices The disconnecting device fitted on main bus bar /Synchronization section is to be clarified. Pt C, Ch 2, Sec 3. 3.5.1 and IACS UI SC136 It is to be disconnected by - circuit breaker without tripping mechanism; or - disconnecting link or - switch by which bus bars can be split easily and safely. Bolted links, for example bolted bus bar sections, are not to be accepted.

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.107 - Main SWBD. General Electrical LPO131007 Diagram (Rev. F)

25-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

The disconnecting device fitted on main bus bar OTHE /Synchronization section is provided : QBTpage 18. R 29.360066.107 Rev.F LPO To be re-confirmed that circuit breaker without tripping mechanism.

Page 6 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
1. Electric cables, switching devices are to be... 1. Electric cables, switching devices are to be of type approved by the society. BV Rules (04/2005), PtC, Ch2, Sec15, 2.1.1 2. "REMOTE CONTROL" indicated on sheet 3 is to be specified. 3. Cable size from ESWB to LSANP1 is to be verified. 4. Number of emergency lightings and load balances are to be specified to verify their cables capacities at each feeder panel.

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.117 - Primary emergency lighting LPO66676 Electrical one line diagram (Rev. F)

21-11-11

1. Following type of the cables, produced by France company "Nexans", used at ship: MPRX, MPRXCX, MPRX331, MPRXCX331, TX(I), TX(C), TCX(I), TCX(C), TX331(I), TX331(C), TCX331(I), TCX331(C).This cables has BV type approval certificate: MPRX - 04793/D0 BV; MPRXCX - 04793/D0 BV; MPRX331 - 12399/A2 BV; MPRXCX331 - 09880/B0 BV; TX(I) - 05563/D2 BV; TX(C) 05563/D2 BV; TCX(I) - 09881/B2 BV; TCX(C) - 09881/B2 OTHE BV; TX331(I) - 05563/D2 BV; TX331(C) - 05563/D2 BV; To be dealt Pending R TCX331(I) - 09881/B2 BV; TCX331(C) - 09881/B2 BV. with Answered Switching devises will have type approval certificates. This requirement including in the drawing. 2. The drawing revised. 3. The drawing verified and revised. 4. We show installed emergency lights load for each feeder according lighting calculation. The cable size calculated according with it's loading.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

1. Following type of the cables, produced by Turkey company "UNTEL", used at ship: M2XH, M2XCH, M2XH FFR, M2XCH FFR, FMGCH, FMGCH FFR, FMGCCH, FMGCCH FFR. BV type approval certificate will be provided to the local surveyor. OTHE Switching devises will have type approval certificates. This R requirement including in the drawing. 2. The drawing revised. 3. The drawing verified and revised. 4. We show installed emergency lights load for each feeder according lighting calculation. The cable size calculated according with it's loading.

Page 7 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
BV Type approval BV Type approval certificates for UMS2100, UCS2100, PMS2100 are to be submitted for confirmation.

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.201 - Auxiliary Mechanism and Systems LPO66949 Automation System Explanatory Book (Rev. 0)

21-11-11

OTHE The BV Type approval certificate No 09705/CO BV dated R 25 Oct. 2006 valid for 25 Oct. 2011. OTHE BV type approval certificate on Automation Sytem will be R provided to the local surveyor.

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360066.203 - ME-CPP Control and Safety System LPO131320 Explanatory Book (Rev. A)

21-11-11

BV Type approval Lipstronic 7000 and WECS2000 are to be of type approved by the society. To be dealt Pending with Answered OTHE BV type approval certificate on Lipstronic 7000 and R WECS2000 provided to the local surveyor. Back-up system We assume that back up system in clause 8, page 16 is only intended for CPP control. In order to inform operator, an indicator which indicates stand-by system is in service and overload protection is not available is to be provided. OTHE An indicator which indicates stand-by system is provided R by WARTSILA Control position transfer In order to clarify BV Rules, Pt C, Ch 3, Sec 2, 4.2.5, Control position transfer procedure is to be verified.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360066.203 - ME-CPP Control and Safety System LPO131327 Explanatory Book (Rev. A)

21-11-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

29.360066.203 - ME-CPP Control and Safety System LPO131329 Explanatory Book (Rev. A)

21-11-11

To be dealt Pending ME-CPP control and safety system is provided by with Answered WARTSILA. Remote control from Navigation bridge is OTHE executed according to BV Rules, Pt C, Ch 3, Sec 2, 4.2.1, R 4.2.5 . BV approval certificate are provided to the local surveyor.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 8 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
The alarm items are to be listed at monitoring ... The alarm items are to be listed at monitoring list (29.360066.211). OTHE The alarm items included at monitoring list 29.360066.211. R

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.210 - Bilge system Combined block diagram (Rev. D)

LPO66946

21-11-11

The alarm items included at monitoring list 29.360066.211 Rev.B and 29.360065.009 Rev.G OB001, OB002, OB005, OB006, OB007,OB008 To be dealt Pending The pump stop on pressure failure (AC143), a signal with Answered emergency level is absent. OTHE Pump stop on pressure failure (AC143), a signal emergency level remained. In system there will be a signal R the Emergency stop of the pump. The pump works more 300sec. - In system there will be a signal "Long time work of the pump", that mean a water inflow in engine room. CB031 - ENGINE ROOM FLOODING

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

BV Type Approval 29.360066.214 Automation, monitoring and control systems Combined block diagram (Rev. 0) BV Type approval for automation monitoring and control system is to be submitted for confirmation. LPO66945 21-11-11 OTHE The BV Type approval certificate No 09705/CO BV dated R 25 Oct. 2006 valid for 25 Oct. 2011. OTHE BV approval certificate are provided to the local surveyor R To be dealt Pending with Answered ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Page 9 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
To be approved by the flag Authorities We reviewed the drawing only in concerning classification matter since it has not been requested to review in scope of SOLAS. So it is to be approved by the flag Authorities. OTHE The drawing will be approved by the flag Authorities. R

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.301 Navigation Equipment List LPO66721 (Rev. 0)

LPO 21-11-11

In scope of review of SOLAS our additional comments are as follows, 1. The type approval certificates for navigational equipment required by SOLAS Ch V, Reg 19 & 20 are to be submitted for information. 2. A bridge navigational watch alarm system (BNWAS) is To be dealt Pending to be fitted not later than the first survey after 1 July 2012. with Answered 3. A second automatic radar plotting aid, or other means is to be fitted. SOLAS Ch V, Reg 19, 2.8.1

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

1. Type approval certificate will be provided to the local surveyor. 2. A bridge navigational watch alarm system (BNWAS) will be fitted not later than the first survey after 1 July 2012 OTHE 3. Two radars Marine X-band radar, 9 GHz, 12 kW and R Marine S-band radar, 3 GHz, 30 kW is established on a vessel, each of which is equipped by system ARPA. Besides, system ECDIS is established on a vessel which also carries out of problem ARPA .

Page 10 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
BV Type approval Electric cables are to be of type approved by the society. BV Rules (04/2005), PtC, Ch2,Sec15, 2.1.1

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.305 - Battery les telephones Electrical one line diagram (Rev. E)

LPO66508

21-11-11

Following type of the cables, produced by France company "Nexans", used at ship: MPRX, MPRXCX, MPRX331, MPRXCX331, TX(I), TX(C), TCX(I), TCX(C), TX331(I), TX331(C), TCX331(I), TCX331(C).This cables has BV type approval certificate: MPRX - 04793/D0 BV; MPRXCX OTHE 04793/D0 BV; MPRX331 - 12399/A2 BV; MPRXCX331 R To be dealt Pending 09880/B0 BV; TX(I) - 05563/D2 BV; TX(C) - 05563/D2 BV; with Answered TCX(I) - 09881/B2 BV; TCX(C) - 09881/B2 BV; TX331(I) 05563/D2 BV; TX331(C) - 05563/D2 BV; TCX331(I) 09881/B2 BV; TCX331(C) - 09881/B2 BV. This requirement including in the drawing.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

Following type of the cables, produced by Turkey company "UNTEL", used at ship: M2XH, M2XCH, M2XH FFR, OTHE M2XCH FFR, FMGCH, FMGCH FFR, FMGCCH, R FMGCCH FFR. BV type approval certificate will be provided to the local surveyor.

Page 11 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
To be approved by the flag Authorities 1. We reviewed the drawing only in concerning classification matter since it has not been requested to review in scope of SOLAS. So it is to be approved by the flag Authorities. 2. The cables installed on exposed decks are to be with suitable impervious sheath. 3. Electric cables are to be of type approved by the society. BV Rules (04/2005), PtC, Ch2, Sec15, 2.1.1

Type

Status

Customer

29.360066.308 - Radio Communication Electrical one line diagram (Rev. 0)

LPO66724

21-11-11

1. The drawing will be approved by the flag Authorities. 2. The cables MPRXCX from France company "Nexans", that installed on exposed decks, are to be with suitable impervious sheath. 3. Following type of the cables, produced by France company "Nexans", used at ship: MPRX, MPRXCX, MPRX331, MPRXCX331, TX(I), TX(C), TCX(I), TCX(C), OTHE TX331(I), TX331(C), TCX331(I), TCX331(C).This cables R has BV type approval certificate: MPRX - 04793/D0 BV; MPRXCX - 04793/D0 BV; MPRX331 - 12399/A2 BV; MPRXCX331 - 09880/B0 BV; TX(I) - 05563/D2 BV; TX(C) - To be dealt Pending Answered 05563/D2 BV; TCX(I) - 09881/B2 BV; TCX(C) - 09881/B2 with BV; TX331(I) - 05563/D2 BV; TX331(C) - 05563/D2 BV; TCX331(I) - 09881/B2 BV; TCX331(C) - 09881/B2 BV. This requirement including in the drawing.

ALEXANDRIA SHIPYARD

LPO

In scope of review of SOLAS our additional comments are as follows, 4. The type approval certificates for GMDSS equipment required by SOLAS Ch IV are to be submitted for information. SOLAS Ch IV, Reg 14

1. The drawing will be approved by the flag Authorities. 2. The cables M2XCH from Tutkey company "UNTEL", that installed on exposed decks, are to be with suitable impervious sheath. 3. Following type of the cables, produced by Turkey OTHE company "UNTEL", used at ship: M2XH, M2XCH, M2XH R FFR, M2XCH FFR, FMGCH, FMGCH FFR, FMGCCH, FMGCCH FFR. BV type approval certificate will be provided to the local surveyor. 4. Type approval certificate will be provided to the local surveyor.

Page 12 of 15

Parent
E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0)

Ref

Date

Comment
Final acceptance will be granted after satisfac... Final acceptance of PMS will be granted after satisfactory testing and trials. MANU Will be presented in commissioning stage on board. For main engines it seems that not all alarms/p... For main engines it seems that not all alarms/protections indicated in BV Rules, Pt.F, Ch.3, Sec.1, Tab.3 are provided. To be revised. Alarms are reported to AMS by Main Engine's via serial link, as provided by ME manufacturer. Attached signal list on each ME coming via serial (file: ME serial link list.pdf). For main engines following alarms should be provided as indicated in BV Rules, Pt.F, Ch.3, Sec.1, Tab.3: - lubricating oil pressure - alarm low - lubricating oil pressure - low low alarm (shutdown protection) - lubricating oil differential pressure - alarm high - lubricating oil inlet temperature - alarm high - oil mist concentration in crankcase - alarm high - sea water (LT) cooling pressure - alarm low - sea water (LT) pump pressure - alarm low - cylinder water inlet pressure - alarm low and slowdown protection - cylinder water outlet temperature - alarm high and slowdown protection - level in cooling water expansion tank (LT) - exhaust gas temperature after each cylinder - exhaust gas temperature after each cylinder deviation from average - overspeed - shutdown protection

Type

Status

Customer

LPO466054

18-01-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

RETEC S.A

MANU

E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0)

LPO470441

19-01-11

To be dealt Pending with Answered

RETEC S.A

LPO

Page 13 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
For reduction gear/reversing gear following ala... For reduction gear/reversing gear following alarms/protections should be provided: - lubricating oil pressure alarm low should trigger shutdown of main engine protection, - oil tank level - alarm low.

Type

Status

Customer

E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0)

LPO471086

19-01-11

- Item still under verification. MANU - New alarms have been implemented: 11916 - ME1 CPP HEADER TANK LOW LEVEL 12716 ? ME2 CPP HEADER TANK LOW LEVEL LPO It should be confirmed that gearbox lubricating oil pressure will trigger shutdown of main engine protection.

To be dealt Pending with Answered

RETEC S.A

For boilers (oil fired and exhaust gas) alarms ... For boilers (oil fired and exhaust gas) alarms and protections indicated in BV Rules, Pt.F, Ch.3, Sec.1 should be provided or if cause to group alarm should be presented to local surveyor. To AMS connected only generalized alarm from boiler (as provided by boiler manufacturer): To be dealt Pending MS202 (13303) - AUX BOILER CC100 CRITICAL ALARM with Answered MANU MS203 (13304) - AUX BOILER CC100 CRITICAL ALARM The control systems of boilers is local automation system approved by BV. We assume all necessary alarms according to rules are present in their system.

E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0)

LPO471235

19-01-11

RETEC S.A

LPO

Remark to be cleared by local surveyor after satisfactory testing and trials on-board.

Page 14 of 15

Parent

Ref

Date

Comment
Fresh water pump pressure or flow - alarm low s... Fresh water pump pressure or flow - alarm low should be provided.

Type

Status

Customer

E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0)

LPO471238

19-01-11

The output of HT pump directly connected to ME inlet (parameter PT401 according to list of parameters of Wartsila), the LT pump directly connected to CAC of ME (parameter PT471). Requested alarms for water pumps To be dealt Pending MANU present in AMS: with Answered 11314 1FW001 ME1 HT WATER PRESS ENGINE INLET 11315 1FW002 ME1 LT WATER PRESS CAC INLET 10514 1FW001 ME1 HT WATER PRESS ENGINE INLET 10515 1FW002 ME1 LT WATER PRESS CAC INLET

RETEC S.A

Remark remains. Indicated channels can not be found in the I/O list submitted. To be confirmed that for diesel engines driving... LPO E.D. - Electrische documents (Rev. 0) LPO471297 19-01-11 To be confirmed that for diesel engines driving generators, lubricating oil pressure low-low alarm will trigger also engine shut-down protection. MANU Item still under verification. To be dealt Pending with Answered RETEC S.A

Page 15 of 15