Shell Elements ABAQUS
Uploaded by
Ssr SaaneShell Elements ABAQUS
Uploaded by
Ssr Saane- Behavior of Plates: Details the mechanics and characteristics of plates under load, drawing comparisons to beams and focusing on isotropic homogeneous plates.
- Mindlin Plate Theory: Introduces the Mindlin plate theory, which includes transverse shear deformations, contrasting with the classical thin plate theory.
- Finite Elements for Plates: Discusses the application of finite element analysis to plate structures, including different element types and interpolation methods.
- Plate Modeling in ABAQUS: Explains the use of ABAQUS software for modeling plate structures, focusing on shell elements and their dimensional properties.
- Example Problem: Provides an example problem analyzed using finite element methods, illustrating the application of theoretical concepts.
- Finite Element Analysis: Presents an analysis of plate elements using finite elements, showcasing different models and comparing their results.
Common questions
Powered by AIFinite element methods in ABAQUS model plate bending using shell elements that capitalize on reduced or full integration techniques depending on the element's purpose. Critical aspects include the use of conventional shell elements, designated based on thickness and deformation considerations ('thick' vs 'thin'), to manage large rotations and small strains . Integration is crucial, with numerical methods such as selective integration being used to handle shear and bending strains differentially, e.g., one-point quadrature for transverse shear and four-point quadrature for bending strains . Degrees of freedom considerations are made to ensure accurate modeling; elements like S4 use a fully integrated approach with significant computational demand, but elements like S4R are used where reduced computation with adequate accuracy is sufficient . The choice between elements also involves considering strain levels, with finite-strain or small-strain options based on application needs . This diverse and adaptable approach ensures ABAQUS can provide tailored simulations across various plate configurations.
The main challenges of using discrete Kirchoff elements in plate modeling include their incompatibility due to non-continuous normal directions between element edges under certain loading conditions, which can cause inaccurate displacement predictions . They also struggle with representing states of constant curvature and twist accurately without introducing preferred directions . Numerical experiments can help address these challenges by allowing analysts to test the elements in simplified scenarios with known solutions, refining their understanding of element behavior and performance . This exploratory approach can lead to adjustments in element configuration or integration rules to mitigate identified issues and optimize element use in complex, real-world applications.
Plate thickness influences the choice between using thin or thick shell elements in finite element simulations because it determines the relevance of transverse shear deformations. In ABAQUS, thick shell elements are chosen when transverse shear flexibility is significant, typically when the thickness exceeds 1/15 of a characteristic surface length, as these elements capture shear deformations accurately . Thin shell elements, conversely, are suitable when transverse shear deformations are negligible, with a thickness less than 1/15 of the characteristic length . The Kirchhoff constraint is more effectively satisfied in thin shells, allowing for simplified, yet accurate models where shear deformations do not contribute significantly to the response . The proper selection based on thickness ensures the computational economy and fidelity of the simulation outcomes in ABAQUS.
The behavior of isotropic homogenous plates under bending differs from that of beams primarily due to their dimensional characteristics and load distribution methods. Both plates and beams carry transverse loads by bending action, but plates involve two-dimensional bending and can experience complex stress distributions, including twisting moments, which are not present in beam bending . The main theoretical approaches to model these behaviors are the Kirchhoff plate theory, which assumes thin plate scenarios ignoring transverse shear deformations, and the Mindlin plate theory, which includes transverse shear deformation effects, thereby providing a more accurate analysis for thick plates . Kirchhoff theory is suitable for plates whose thickness is much smaller compared to their dimensions, making shear deformation negligible .
The Mindlin plate element approach differs from the Kirchhoff element in computational implementation by addressing transverse shear deformations, which adds complexity to the model. Mindlin elements incorporate additional degrees of freedom, for instance, the rotations of normals to the middle surface (θx and θy), interpolated from nodal values for more detailed shear representation . This requires solving additional equations related to shear forces, increasing computational effort compared to Kirchhoff elements . Kirchhoff elements focus on bending deformations and are less computationally intensive because they exclude transverse shear, which is treated as negligible. The computational complexity of Mindlin elements is offset by their capacity to model thick plates more accurately, which Kirchhoff elements cannot do due to omitted shear effects .
In ABAQUS, using shell elements with different degrees of freedom per node is significant because it affects the element's ability to model various mechanical behaviors accurately. Elements like S4 use six degrees of freedom per node, which allows them to model both displacement and rotational characteristics thoroughly, leading to precise bending and membrane stress analyses . This is crucial for problems where large rotations or precise in-plane bending responses are expected, as S4 elements provide robust solutions without requiring hourglass control . However, elements like S4R5 use five degrees of freedom per node to economize on computational resources, making them more suitable for thin shell applications where transverse shear is negligible . The balance between computational efficiency and model fidelity is managed through these different DOF configurations, enabling ABAQUS users to tailor their analysis to specific mechanical and geometric constraints.
Mindlin plate theory has the advantage of incorporating transverse shear deformation effects, which makes it suitable for thick plates where shear deformations cannot be neglected . This leads to more accurate predictions of deflection and stress distribution for thick plates compared to Kirchhoff theory, which assumes shear deformations are negligible and is only appropriate for plates with thickness less than 1/10th of the smallest width . However, Mindlin theory requires solving additional equations for shear force equilibrium, increasing computational complexity. Kirchhoff theory simplifies the mathematical model and computations, making it more efficient for thin plates, but at the cost of reduced accuracy in predicting realistic deformations and stresses .
The twisting moment in the state of pure twist in plates is significant because it represents the primary stress condition when the plate deflection follows the function w=c*x*y. In this state, the twisting moment becomes the only non-zero stress component, distinctly different from regular bending moments . Physically, this state can be realized by applying two equal upward forces at diagonally opposite corners of the plate and two equal downward forces at the other pair of diagonally opposite corners . This experimental setup creates conditions where the plate experiences only twisting without bending, making it essential for analyzing stress distribution in composite plate systems.
Selective integration is used in the finite element modeling of plates to address numerical challenges associated with spurious shear stresses and to improve computational efficiency. It involves using different quadrature rules for different strain components, such as one-point quadrature for transverse shear strains to reduce shear locking, and higher-order quadrature (like four-point) for bending strains to ensure accuracy . This method helps in preventing overly stiff solutions that could result from a fully integrated approach, particularly in thin shell elements where transverse shear deformations should be minimized . As a result, selective integration enhances the accuracy of the model without significantly increasing computational effort, making it a practical approach for complex plate arrangements.
Applying a moment Mx on a beam causes deformation primarily in the x-z plane, with the narrow beam section preventing significant normal stresses on its sides, thus σy becoming nearly zero . This is due to the narrow cross-section being unable to transfer stress laterally. In contrast, the same moment on a plate does not produce curvature in the y-z plane because plates are wider, allowing σy to emerge as a compensatory stress due to Poisson's effect, which causes lateral contraction under longitudinal stress . This results in the plate having induced stiffness and constrained curvature δ2w/δy2, enhancing the plate's rigidity compared to a beam under similar loads . This difference highlights the necessity of using appropriate plate theories, such as the Kirchhoff or Mindlin, to accommodate these stress distributions in finite element modeling.
