Professional Documents
Culture Documents
As November 6 draws
closer, the word "versus" has
cemented itself in our socio-
political culture.
Throughout the past year, we
have watched the parties and
their candidates struggle to
undo the threads of opposing
rhetoric and re-stitch that
of their own. With Obamas
Forward highly contrasting
the newly minted jeremiad of
|eoob||cao oe|eao |ooe,
the relationship between the
parties can be described as
nothing other than versus.
The word versus, especially in
regards to this years political
parties, creates a preeminent
binary. You are either
Republican or Democrat;
when you are condemned as
a godless liberal or a Jesus-
loving conservative in our
society, there is little motivation
to make your political opinions
known. It is easier, and perhaps
less frustrating, to hide behind
the convenient label of
independent.
But over the course of this
election, I have found that
versus, in regards to politics,
has taken on a far more
ironic meaning. As a politically
|ooeo |oo|v|ooa|, | oo
myself more isolated from
those who play no part in our
process or show no semblance
of interest in politics, perhaps
even more so than those I
blatantly disagree with. If no
one ever had the sense to
express an opinion, its not
hard to imagine we would still
be living in caves.
If the entirety of the
population agreed, we would
be living in a far more mindless
state. How can we forget the
sticky unanimity in Huxleys
Brave New World? Where
would the controversy, passion,
or motivation come from if all
of us were to hold no opinion?
Change is the byproduct
of our disagreements. Our
differentiating wants and
needs inform our policies; our
incongruities color our culture.
How we learn to accept
these differences is our
own call to versus. Through
our disagreements we are
eec|s|o t|e ||t to coo|ct
with one another. We learn
.|at |ts to o|c' aoo .|at
we can afford to lose. These
experiences, these discussions,
these emotions: they shape
us. They mold our beliefs and
polish our moral compasses.
And so, in the name of versus,
let us disagree.
In The Name of Versus
`A1`\c , feature
Her sister Rose was adding salt
to the soup when Leah told
her about the suffragist march
down in London next week.
She mustve known what Roses
answer would be, but Leah
proceeded to sew the banner
ao.a, o|c'|o |e oes
during late nights in Roses shop
after the dressmaking work was
done.
The morning of the march
she hurried down to the train
station before dawn, her face
pensive and her skirts too short
for her long legs. The unfamiliar
city was a whirlwind for Leah
with its streetcars and pelting
rain and policemen; unsettling
though not yet menacing.
At Parliament Square there
were throngs of women in lines
that knit themselves together,
and one of the leaders took
her by the elbow and gave
her wooden poles to hold
the banner. In the midst of
the march Leah felt a part of
things, and when the uniforms
descended she was full of
enough nervous resolve to
keep clutching the poles while
two of them argued over who
should take her banner away.
Finally one of them wrenched it
from her, twisting her wrist and
st|'|o |ao at |e oes.
Oh, she said, very quietly
despite the voices around them
t|at .ee s|oot|o. T|e as|
of pain mixed with a blur of
activity as they were rounded
into wagons and then cells
inside the station; the whole
thing seemed like a bad dream.
No one from home knew
where Leah was. It was cold
in the station, but the women
were singing and laughing,
calling her a brave girl. She fell
half asleep in a shivery haze
until she woke hours later to
the sound of Roses voice, and
a policeman unlocking the door
and saying her sister could take
her home.
Rose had brought the wagon
and halfway home she was too
angry to speak to Leah, sitting
st| oo||t as t|e .ee
jolted and bounced on the
wooden seat.
Finally Rose burst out, You
dont care anything about the
suffragists, Leah, youre only
doing this for a lark.
'e bo'e t.o o oes,'
Leah said, and Rose pulled the
reins up short.
What?
Taking my banner away. A
policeman broke two of my
oes.'
Rose took Leahs arm and
turned her hand over, surveying
the damage and sucking in a
sharp breath.
Just keep still until were
home, she said. Ill splint your
hand there.
They kept on, to where the
paved road turned to gravel,
to.aos t|e |os|, eeo e|os
and the still town and the close,
quiet room where endless
hemlines and the promise of
enough tiny stitches to make
Leahs eyes ache awaited.
At their driveway, Rose turned
back to her. We wont tell
anyone what happened today.
But you are not going back to
London.
Leah thought of how more
had happened to her on this
one day than ever in her
life before, and how next
time, no one would take the
banner from her. She started
to say something, when Rose
interrupted. Thats enough.
Thats all there is to it.
But it wasnt.
Jenny Crakes
The March