K01/K02/K07/K08/K23/K24/K25/K99 Review

If you cannot access the hyperlinks below, visit http://grants.nih.gov/grants/peer/critiques/k.htm. Application #: Principal Investigator(s):

OVERALL IMPACT
eviewers will provi!e an overall impact score to reflect their assessment of the likelihoo! for the can!i!ate to maintain a strong research program, in consi!eration of the following five score! review criteria, an! a!!itional review criteria. An application !oes not nee! to be strong in all categories to have a ma"or impact. #verall Impact Write a paragraph summarizing the factors that informed your Overall Impact score.

SCORED REVIEW CRITERIA

eviewers will consi!er each of the five review criteria below in the !etermination of scientific an! technical merit, an! give a separate score for each. $. %an!i!ate Strengths Weaknesses &. %areer 'evelopment Plan/Career Goals & Objectives/Plan to Provide Mentoring Strengths Weaknesses (. esearch Plan Strengths Weaknesses ). *entor+s,, Co-Mentor(s), Consultant(s), Collaborator(s)

- %ritique .emplate /ast 0p!ate! August &, &1$1

Page 1 of 4

Strengths Weaknesses 2. 3nvironment an! Institutional %ommitment to the %an!i!ate Strengths Weaknesses

ADDITIONAL REVIEW CRITERIA

As applicable for the pro"ect propose!, reviewers will consi!er the following a!!itional items in the !etermination of scientific an! technical merit, but will not give separate scores for these items. A response for Protections for 4uman 5ub"ects, 6ertebrate Animals, an! 7ioha8ar!s is require !"r a## a$$#i%ati"ns. A response for Inclusion of 9omen, *inorities an! %hil!ren is require for 4uman 5ub"ects esearch Applications. Protections for 4uman 5ub"ects %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,: %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,: o esearch 'ata an! 5afety *onitoring Plan +Applicable for %linical .rials #nly,:

Inclusion of 9omen, Minorities and Children Applicable #nly for 4uman 5ub"ects %lick 4ere to 5elect ;en!er %o!e %lick 4ere to 5elect *inority %o!e %lick 4ere to 5elect %hil!ren %o!e %omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,:

6ertebrate Animals %lick 4ere to 5elect Page & of 4

%omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,:

7ioha8ar!s %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,:

esubmission %omments +if applicable,:

enewal +Applicable only for -1& an! -&), %omments +if applicable,:

evision %omments +if applicable,:

ADDITIONAL REVIEW CONSIDERATIONS

As applicable for the pro"ect propose!, reviewers will a!!ress each of the following items, but will not give scores for these items an! shoul! not consi!er them in provi!ing an overall impact score. .raining in the esponsible %on!uct of %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments on <ormat + equire!,: %omments on 5ub"ect *atter + equire!,: %omments on <aculty Participation + equire!= not applicable for mi!> an! senior>career awar!s,: %omments on 'uration + equire!,: esearch

Page ' of 4

%omments on <requency + equire!,:

5elect Agents %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments + equire! 0nless :ot Applicable,:

esource 5haring Plans %lick 4ere to 5elect %omments + equire! if 0nacceptable,:

7u!get an! Perio! of 5upport %lick 4ere to 5elect ecommen!e! bu!get mo!ifications or possible overlap i!entifie!:

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO APPLICANT

eviewers may provi!e gui!ance to the applicant or recommen! against resubmission without fun!amental revision. A!!itional %omments to Applicant +#ptional,

Page 4 of 4