ISLAMIC AWARENESS HAS ACCEPTED SOME SUGGESTIONS

OF Respectable Dr Jurge Os!g"

T#!s !s t#e!r r!g#t but t#ese Suggest!$s
are $t c$%!c!g&
a' s$(e c$((ets are presete' $
t#e("
It !s $pel) STATED THAT ISLAMIC AWARENESS IS
NOT RESPONSI*LE ARE OUR COMMENTS
WHICH ARE GI+EN *ELOW
AND WE ARE ONL, AND ONL, RESPONSI*LE FOR EACH ONE OF THEM AND
NONE OTHER THAN US IS RESPONSI*LE"
WE FIRST PRODUCE A -UOTATION FROM AN ARTICLE A*OUT HAMAN *,
WWW"ISLAMIC.AWARENESS"ORG a' t#e s#all
/r!te s$(e c$((ets a' re(a0s b) $ursel%es1() sel2 "
We are resp$s!ble 2$r a) p$ss!ble 3a/ ! THEM &NOT
ISLAMIC. AWARENESS
4444 Dr" Maur!ce *uca!lle& per#aps t#e earl!est sc#$lar t$ 'eal /!t#
5Ha(a6 ! t#e -ur6a as a a(e 2r$( t#e p$!t $2 %!e/
$2 Eg)pt$l$g)& (a'e a !terest!g suggest!$" He sur(!se' t#at s!ce
5Ha(a6 /as (et!$e' ! t#e -ur6a 'ur!g
t#e t!(e $2 M$ses ! Eg)pt& t#e best c$urse $2 act!$ /as t$ as0 a e7pert !
t#e $l' Eg)pt!a laguage& !"e"& #!er$gl)p#s&
regar'!g t#e a(e"89:9; T#e e7pert ! #!er$gl)p#s suggeste' t$ Dr" *uca!lle
t$ c$sult Ra0e6s /ell.0$/ b$$0 D!e
<g)pt!sc#e Pers$ea(e"T#e latter state' #e #a' 2$u' t#e a(e
5Ha(a6 ! !t& !"e"& t#e '$$r =a(b c$ta!!g 5>(.>6
as (et!$e' ! F!gure ?"
Alt#$ug# Dr" *uca!lle6s suggest!$ s$u's se'uct!%e& t#ere are '!@cult!es" At
t#e reAuest $2 a all!ace $2 Eur$pea
e%agel!cal C#r!st!a (!ss!$ar) $rga!sat!$s& E(er!tus Pr$2ess$r Dr" JBrge
Os!g $2 t#e <g)pt$l$g!sc#es Se(!ar&
Fre!e U!%ers!tCt *erl!& a respecte' sc#$lar $2 Eg)pt$l$g)& /as s$l!c!te' 2$r
#!s c$((ets regar'!g Ha(a as 'ep!cte'
! t#e -ur6a a' t#e !'et!Dcat!$ $2 a ac!et Eg)pt!a !scr!pt!$
allege'l) bear!g #!s a(e" SubseAuetl) ! Jul)
9EE? Os!g rea' a earl!er %ers!$ $2 $ur art!cle FT!tle'G 5H!st$r!cal Err$rs O2
T#e -urHaG P#ara$# I Ha(a6& Last Up'ate'G
:t# Jue 9EEJK a' (a'e a u(ber $2 $bser%at!$s& spec!Dcall) 2$cus!g $
$ur aal)s!s $2 a !scr!pt!$ /#!c# !s 2$u'
$ sa!' '$$r =a(b 0ept ! t#e Lust#!st$r!sc#es Museu(& +!ea" Regar'!g
t#!s !scr!pt!$ /#!c# c$ta!e' t#e
a(e 5>(.>6& /e suggeste' t#e Dal 5>6 /as $t actuall) part $2 t#e a(e&
stat!g t#e re(a!!g letters c$ul' p$ss!bl)
be re'ere' as 5Ha(a6" T#!s !s !c$rrect" T#e !terpretat!$ $2 t#e Dal 5>6 !s
Auest!$able& but $t !ts e7!stece as part
$2 t#e a(e" T#e Dal 5>6 !s ($st pr$babl) a abbre%!at!$ 2$r(!g a
t#e$p#$r!c a(e" We /$ul' l!0e t$ t#a0 Os!g 2$r
t#!s c$rrect!$" A''!t!$all) #e p$!te' $ut t#at !t see(e' '$ubt2ul t#at t#!s
part!cular pers$ be!g a $%erseer $2 t#e
Auarr) /$r0ers&
usually only of local importance,
would have been entrusted with the building of such a mighty
edifce,
let alone be a close confdant of the Pharaoh
M a c$s!'erat!$ /e #a' $%erl$$0e'" F$r clar!Dcat!$ /e /$ul' l!0e t$
e(p#as!se t#at at $ p$!t #a' /e e%er state' t#e 5Ha(a6 /e t#$ug#t /as
(et!$e' ! t#!s !scr!pt!$ /as t#e Ha(a
$2 t#e -ur6a" W#at /e #a' sa!' /as t#at !t /as a p$ss!b!l!t)& #$/e%er& t#!s !s
$ l$ger t#e case" F$r t#e sa0e $2
c$(pleteess a' t$ '!spel a) '$ubts regar'!g t#e !scr!pt!$& 2ull 'eta!ls
#a%e bee pr$%!'e' ab$%e"NNNN
COMMENTS AND REMARKS
O;A*U JALAL NAD+I A SCHOLAR HAD ALSO TRIED TO TRACE HAMAN"
*ELOW IS HIS WORDS GI+EN IN ENGLISH TRANSLATION"Acc$r'!g t$ Abu Jalal
Na'%! Ha(aG !s Aa(. Htb t#e t#!r'
/#$ /as a c$ ruler $2 THOTHMESPIII QQQQR 4TAMUT.SNAND SON IN LAW OF
0!g MTNI 44D.S.R.TNN& als$ 0$/ as Ru(!!a"He /as calle' Ha Aa(." H!s
e7!stece /as #!''e !
T.L HMraa#" Ha (. beca(e Ha(a" U2$rtuatel) He '!' $t (et!$e'G.
!; U2$rtuatel) t#e Egl!s# spell!g $2 MTNI 44MaTaGN!GNN AND 44 D.S.R.
TNN !s $t g!%e b) Abu Jalal Na'%!"
!!; Was T#$t#(es t#e t#!r'QQQ T#e as/er !s ! a@r(at!$" T#e spell!g !
Arab!c Alp#abets !s T.T MU.SHE"
!!!;Acc$r'!g t$ A*U JALAL NAD+I t#e P#ar$a# $2 E7$'us !s AT MUSHE als$
spelle' as Tet#e($s!s" I2 s$ t#e Tut#($se II
!s t#e P#ar$a# $2 OPPRESSION $t Hats#epsut
!%;T#e argu(et g!%e b) A*U JALAL !s as 2$ll$/G
M$ses 44MA, THE PEACE OF GOD *E UPON HIMNN SPEND :E ,EARS
*EFORE IS PROPHETHOOD IN EG,PT 44MISGRNN
M$ses 44MA, THE PEACE OF GOD *E UPON HIMNN SPEND :E ,EARS AFTER
HIS PROPHETHOOD IN EG,PT 44MISGRNN
M$ses 44M"P"G"U"HNN spe' 9E )ears ! TIAH"
TOAL ,EARS OF MOSES
:ES:ES9ETO9E
T#ere !s $ P#ar$a# /#$ re!ge' 2$r UE )ears ! Eg)pt"
S $ t#e P#ar$a# Pre1Ate Pr$p#et#$$' $2 M$ses /as '!Veret 2r$( t#e
P#ar$a# P$st Pr$p#et#$$'"
C$((et G T#e argu(et !s !c$(plete"
%!; A*U JALAL CLAIMS THAT HAGMAGM WAS ALSO LNOWN AS G.
HA. AAM.N &RA AAM.N & RUMIIA 44 RUMIIA I"E M, SON AS CALLED *, THE M.
TA NI LING D.S.R.T &#!s 2at#er ! la/NN
%!!; A*U JALAL t#!0s t#atHA AAM.N /as Arab!t!se' as HAGMAGN"
%!!!; E%!'ece $2 HAGMAGN /as 2$u' ! T.L AL H.MRAGNAH"
!7; Acc$r'!g t$ A*U JALAL NAD+I HAGMAGN WAS WWWW AAM.N H.T.* t#e
T#!r'WWWW" H.T.* !s sec$' part $2 t#e c$(p$s!te
pr$per $u $2 t#e pers$ u'er '!scuss!$" Dr Maur!ce *uca!lle !s $t t#e
Drst pers$ /#$ #as atte(te' t$ '$ s$"
Abu Jalal Na'%! als$ tr!e' t$ D' HAGMAGN but ! t#e t!(e $2 THETHMOSIS III"
4444 A*U JALAL NAD+I A CHOLAR OF ANCIENT LANGUAGES ECT""NNNN
9; T#e Dal #H (a) be $t a part $2 t#e $2 t#e Drst part $2 c$(p$s!te $u
44 HH( HHNN a' !ts !s part $2 t#e c$(p$s!te $u
)et !t ca $t egate t#e P$ss!b!l!t) t#at 44 HH(.HHNN !s t#e $r!g! $2 t#e
N$u 44 HAMAGNNN"
S!ce Ha(aG !s t#e Arab!se' 2$r( $2 t#e N$u& a' Arab!c '!' $t Arab!se' !t
as acc$r'!g t$ t#e C$(p$s!te T#e$($rDc
N$u & but regar'!g t#e C$(p$s!te N$u as a Mult!s)labl!c s!gle $u&
regar'less $2 !ts (ea!g a' !rrelet!%e $2 !ts
c$(p$s!t!$" It !s p$ss!ble t#at Arab!c '!' 'r$ppe' t#e last letter"T#e $b=ect!$
!s base' $ a supp$s!t!$ t#at Arab!c (ust
c$ser%e t#e t#e$2$r(!c a' c$(p$s!te ature $2 t#e N$ Arab!c N$u
ecessar!l) $r Necessar!l) N$t 'r$p a) c$s$et
/#!le Arab!t!s!g !t"
T#ese are $t rules $2 Arab!t!sat!$& a' !2 t#e) are t#e $e $2 t#e( !s #ar'
a' 2ast"
X;It (a) be sa!' t#at HH ca$t be c#age' b) H s!ce b$t# letters H a' HH
e7!st ! Arab!c" Arab!c (ust ecessar!l) #a%e
c$ser%e' HH a' (ust $t #a%e re%erte' !t t$ H& e%e !2 !t #a' 'r$ppe' t#e
Dal HH"
T#!s !s s$(e/#at ($re p$/er2ul argu(et t#e t#e 2$r(er"
*ut !2 !t !s less pr$bable !t !s $t !(p$ss!ble "T$ pr$%e t#at !t !s /r$g /!t#
certa!!t) a !(p$ss!b!l!t) !s reAu!re' $t
=ust a lesser pr$bal!t) $r a !(pr$bal!t)" W#) Arab!c c#age' !!t!al HG b) H
(a) be as/ere' & t#at t#!s /as pr$bebl) 'ue
t$ t#e reas$ t#at t#ere alrea') e7!ste' t#e $u $2 a $t#er c#aracter
HAMAGN& a' Arab!c u!De' b$t# $2 t/$ $ Arab!c N$us
as Oe N$u"*ut t#!s !s $t t#e $l) p$ss!ble reas$" It (a) be 'ue t$ a
A7!$( O2 C#$!ce s!ce t#ere /as $ Har' a'
Fast Rule 2$r Arab!t!s!g a N$ Arab!c N$u"
Dr Hurge Os!g (a) be a g$$' Eg)pt$l$g!st a' per#aps #!s /$r's are Dal
! Eg)pt$pl$g)& ca$t be c#allege' &
*UT !2 #e cla!(et# t#at HGMN.HG ca$t be HAGMAGN =ust because HG ca$t
be c#age' t$ H ! Arab!c b) Arab!c #!s
c$=ectures t#at Arab!c ca$t c#age HGMN HG AS Ha(a 44H.M.NNN !s u
acceptable" I2 #e '!' $t cla!( s$ a' t#!s !s =ust
a 2alse !(press!$ 2r$( #!s /$r0 & t#e One May Make An Apology .
S!ce t#e /$r' I2 !s preset & a' t#e /$r' HH!2HH egatet#
t#e Occurac!al Necess!t)" I2 t#e /$r' HH!2HH '$et# $t agatet# t#e state'
ab$%e ecess!t) $2 $ccurrace t#e t#e e7press!$
HH Oe Ma) Ma0e A App$l$g)HH MUST *E c#age' b) HH Oe Must (a0e a
Ap$l$g)HH"
X;Oe (a) sa) t#at Respectable Os!g (a) be c$rrect /#e #e p$!ts at t#e
allege' 2act WW
#e p$!te' $ut t#at !t see(e' '$ubt2ul t#at t#!s part!cular pers$ be!g a
$%erseer $2 t#e
Auarr) /$r0ers& usuall) $l) $2 l$cal !(p$rtace& /$ul' #a%e bee etruste'
/!t# t#e bu!l'!g $2 suc# a (!g#t) e'!Dce&
let al$e be a cl$se c$D'at $2 t#e P#ara$#"
T#!s c$=ecture !s !c$rrect s!ce $ $e #as g$e bac0 ! t!(e t$ see t#e
Mutual relat!$s $2 P#ar$a# a' HG(.HG
It !s p$ss!ble t#at ! #!s 'esperate atte(ts t$ re2ute GREAT PROPHET MOSES
44PEACE *e Up$ MOSESNN P#ar$a# #a' ta0e
s$(e uusual steps" As P#ar$a# /as Aut$crat!c a' '!' $t act acc$r'!g t$
a) c$'e& a' #!s /$r's /ere 'egrees&
It (a) be t#e case t#at #e arb!trar!l) e7alte' t#!s c#aracter b) 'e%$t!g
spec!al attet!$ t$/$r's #!(" E%e t#e best $2
all Eg)pt$l$g!sta ca$t cla!( t#at #e #a%e a c$(plete rec$r' $2 eac# a'
e%er) act '$e b) P#ar$a# $' E7$'us /!t#
$ut a) e7cept!$"
:; Supp$s!g t#at t#!s HGMN.HG !s a $t#er #!st$r!cal c#aracter & $t#er t#e
$e t#at !s State' I H$l) -ur.aG &!t !s p$ss!ble
t#at pers$s $2 suc# N$us D!' E7!st ! t#e t!(e $2 P#er$a# $2 E7$'us" A'
t#!s !s su@c!et t$ pr$%e t#at !t !s p$ss!ble t#at a
HAGMAGN '!' e7!st ! t#at per!$' $2 t!(e & a' /as cl$se t$ t#e P#ar$a#" A
p$ss!b!l!t) a' a C$teg!c) are su@c!et
t$ '!spr$%e t#e (a! $b=ect!$ t#at HaG(aG '!' $t e7!st at t#!s per!$' $2
t!(e" S!ce t#!s cla!( !s base' $ t#e I(p$ss!b!l!t)
a' absu'!t) $2 t#e e7!stece $2 t#e pers$ HaG(aG ! t#at per!$' $2
t!(e"E%e Respectable Os!g '$es accept t#at !t
!s '$ubtable" He '$es $t sa) !t !s I(p$ss!ble"44 AN, THING DOU*TA*E IS
CERTAINL, NOT IMPOSSI*LE"NN
Y; Ha(a (a) be a $t#er $u $r ep!t#et $2 a pers$ $t 0$/"
J; It !s P$ss!ble #$/s$e%er !(pr$bable ! appearece t#at b$t# parts $2 t#e
c$(p$u' $u HGMN a' HG /ere c$((ute'
s$ t#at !t beca(e HA HAMAN a' 'ue t$ a rep!tat!$ $e $2 t#e t/$ HH#aHH
sall)bles /as 'r$ppe'"
Ol) presete' p$ss!b!l!t!es a' c$t!g!c!es ARE PRESENTED& s!ce t#ese
are $t ! THE '$(a! $2 Del' $2 Respectable
Os!g" HIS WORDS MA, *E FINAL a' uc#allegeable !2 #e sa)sG.
AN HGMN.HG !s t#e a(e 2$u' & a' $t HAGMAGN"
*N F!al HG !s Auest!$able but $t 'r$ppable
*UT #!s /$r's are certa!l) $t acceptable G.
AN!2 #e sa)s t#at !t HGMN.HG !s $t t#e $e State' I -urHaG base' $ t#e
!(p$ss!b!l!t) $2 re%ers!$ $2 HG ! H ! Arab!c"
*N I2 #e sa)s t#at t#e Dal HG !s Auest!a able but !ts e7!tece !s $t
'!sputable ! t#e 2$u' N$u& #ece !t !t !s $t 'r$ppable
b) Arab!c" S!ce !t !s base' $ t#e !(p$ss!bl!t) $2 'r$pp!g"