Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vegetable Oils
Frank D. Gunstone
1. INTRODUCTION
This chapter is concerned with the major and minor vegetable oils. It includes a
brief account of the biosynthetic pathways for plant lipids and a description of min-
or, but important, components present in commercial vegetable oils. This is
followed by a description of the major and minor vegetable oils. The major oils
are discussed in more detail elsewhere in this work and in another recent book
(1). The natural oils do not always meet human dietary requirements and may
have to be modied. There is a discussion on what drives modication and of
the various ways in which this can be achieved. Finally, some production and trade
statistics are provided and discussed.
2. BIOSYNTHESIS
2.1. Introduction
This section provides a brief account of the biosynthetic pathways to triacylglycer-
ols in plants, but it requires a preliminary discussion of fatty acid biosynthesis.
The so-called acetate-malonate pathway leads to three different kinds of natural
products depending on the detailed pathway followed. Fatty acids result from a
reductive pathway to be described here, but acetate and malonate are also precur-
sors for the isoprenoids (terpenes and sterols) produced via mevalonic acid (C
6
) and
Baileys Industrial Oil and Fat Products, Sixth Edition, Six Volume Set.
Edited by Fereidoon Shahidi. Copyright # 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
213
for a wide range of phenolic compounds resulting from cyclization of polyacetate.
This illustrates the observation that nature is economical in the range of both
substrates and reactions employed in biosynthesis.
The major biosynthetic pathways to fatty in plants involve three stages (24):
de novo synthesis of palmitic (or other alkanoic) acid from acetate (C
2
, a
product of carbohydrate metabolism) by reaction with malonate (C
3
).
Further chain-elongation of saturated or unsaturated acids by two-carbon units.
Desaturation. Particularly of stearic acid, rst to oleic acid and then to linoleic
and linolenic acids.
These changes take place in different parts of the cell, under the inuence of spe-
cic enzymes or enzyme complexes, and they require the acids to be in appropriate
substrate form.
2.2. de novo Synthesis of Saturated Acids
In plant systems, de novo synthesis occurs in the plastid and results mainly in the
conversion of acetate to palmitate. All 16 carbon atoms in palmitic acid are derived
from acetatehalf from the methyl carbon and half from the acyl carbon. Two of
the carbon atoms (C-15 and C-16) come directly from acetate, and the other 14
come from acetate via the more reactive malonate. Production of malonate requires
the incorporation of an additional carbon atom into the acetyl group. This is sup-
plied as bicarbonate, and this same carbon atom is subsequently lost as carbon
dioxide. The acyl groups are attached to co-enzyme A (CoASH) during part of
the cycle and to acyl carrier protein (ACPSH) during another part. The abbreviated
symbols used for these co-enzymes emphasize the thiol groups (SH) to which the
acyl chains are attached.
In the de novo pathway, acetate and malonate react through a series of steps con-
verting acetate rst to butanoate (C
4
), then to hexanoate (C
6
), and then sequentially,
two carbon atoms at a time, to palmitate (C
16
). At this stage, a thioesterase liberates
the acyl chain from ACP. The thioesterase is not completely specic, and acids of
other chain lengths may be produced. This is obviously true in the lauric oils where
the specicity of their thioesterases causes lauric acid (12:0) to be the major satu-
rated acid, accompanied by lower levels of caprylic (8:0), capric (10:0), myristic
(14:0), and palmitic acid (16:0).
Conversion of acetyl-CoA to malonyl-CoA with a biotin enzyme (acetyl-CoA
carboxylase)
CH
3
COSCoA HCO
3
ATP ! HO
2
CCH
2
COSCoA P
I
ADP
Conversion of acetyl-ACP to butanoyl-ACP (four-step cycle)
CH
3
COSACP HO
2
CCH
2
COSACP ! CH
3
COCH
2
COSACP CO
2
ACPSH condensation
214 VEGETABLE OILS
CH
3
COCH
2
COSACP NADPH H
! CH
3
CHOHCH
2
COSACP
NADP
reduction
CH
3
CHOHCH
2
COSACP ! CH
3
CH
CHCOSACP
H
2
O dehydration
CH
3
CH
CHCOSACP NADPH H
! CH
3
CH
2
CH
2
COSACP
NADP
reduction
This four-step cycle includes condensation of acetate and malonate to give ketobu-
tanoate with subsequent reduction to butanoate in three further steps. These are
reduction to the 3R hydroxy acid, dehydration to the 2t acid, and reduction again.
Reduction is affected by NADPH and a proton. The process is then repeated to add
further two-carbon units until a thioesterase liberates the free acid. This sequence
requires a fatty acid synthase, which contains the enzymes needed for each of the
four steps viz. b-ketoacyl-ACP synthase, b-ketoacyl-ACP reductase, b-ketoacyl-
ACP dehydrase, and enoyl-ACP reductase, respectively.
There are several minor modications of the de novo process, but these are not
important for the major fatty acids occurring in vegetable oils. They are detailed in
more extensive accounts of this topic (24).
2.3. Desaturation to Monoene and Polyene Acids in Plant Systems
The rst desaturation of a saturated acyl chain occurs in the plastid. The most com-
mon is the conversion of stearate to oleate and involves the removal of pro-(R)
hydrogen atoms from C-9 and C-10 to give a cis-olenic bond under the inuence
of a 9 desaturase. The system is oxygen-dependent and involves the reduced form
of ferredoxin.
Further desaturation, occurring in the cytoplasm, converts oleate, in the form of
its phosphatidylcholine, to linoleate (12 desaturase) and linoleate, as the mono-
galactosyldiacylglycerol derivative, to linolenate (15 desaturase). The additional
double bonds have cis-conguration and are in a methylene-interrupted relation to
each other. This 1,4-diene unit is characteristic of polyunsaturated fatty acids and is
to be distinguished from the 1,3 (conjugated) systems in carotenoids and the 1,5
system in terpenes. It is of interest that the enzymes converting oleate to the acet-
ylenic acid crepenynic (9c12a18:2) and to the epoxy acid vernolic (12,13-epoxyo-
leic) are very similar to 12 deaturase, which converts oleate to linoleate. A small
change in DNA sequence is sufcient to lead to these different fatty acids from the
same substrate. The same holds for the conversion of oleate to ricinoleate where a
small change alters a desaturase to a hydroxylase (5).
Linoleic acid and linolenic acid are essential fatty acids that cannot be made by
animals and must be obtained by dietary intake from plant sources. When metabo-
lized in animals, these two acids each give rise to a family of C
18,
C
20
, and C
22
n-6
and n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids; thus:
BIOSYNTHESIS 215
n-6 acids based on linoleic acid 18 : 2 ! 18 : 3 ! 20 : 3 ! 20 : 4:
n-3 acids based on a-linolenic acid 18 : 3 ! 18 : 4 ! 20 : 4 ! 20 : 5 ! 22 : 5
! 24 : 5 ! 24 : 6 ! 22 : 6
Although common in animal systems, the 6 desaturase is less apparent in the
plant world, although it must operate in the production of g-linolenic acid (6, 9,
1218:3) from linoleate and of stearidonic acid (6, 9, 12, 1518:4) from a-linole-
nate. The C
20
and C
22
polyenes that characterize animal systems and particularly
sh lipids either do not exist in plant systems or are exceedingly rare. The produc-
tion of important acids such as arachidonic (5, 8, 11, 1420:4), eicosapentaenoic
(5, 8, 11, 14, 1720:5), and docosahexaenoic (4, 7, 10, 13, 16, 1922:6) in plant
systems is a challenge for plant geneticists (6).
2.4. Elongation
Elongation by two carbon atoms occurs commonly in fatty acid biosynthesis. It is a
variant of de novo chain-lengthening and occurs with acetyl or malonyl CoA or ACP
derivatives. The substrate is any preformed saturated or unsaturated acid. For exam-
ple, erucic (22:1) in high-erucic acid rapeseed oil and nervonic acid (24:1) in seed
oil are formed from oleic acid by two and three elongations, respectively:
18 : 19 ! 20 : 111 ! 22 : 113 ! 24 : 115
oleic cetoleic erucic nervonic
2.5. Formation of Triacylglycerols
The glycerol present in glycerolipids is derived from glycerol (1,2,3-trihydroxypro-
pane), glyceraldehyde (2,3-dihydroxypropanal), or dihydroxyacetone (1,3-dihy-
droxypropan-2-one), all of which are products of carbohydrate metabolism. The
triacylglycerols are made from phosphatidic acids or 1,2-diacylglycerols, which
are themselves interconvertible, and acylation is effected by fatty acids as their
CoA thiol esters. The esterication reactions are enzyme-controlled with marked
selectivity in the acylation of each hydroxyl group leading to a nonrandom distri-
bution of fatty acids in plant lipids. Saturated acids are selectively bound at the sn-1
position and unsaturated acids at the sn-2 position. The acyl transferase for the sn-3
position is less selective, and fatty acids in this position are largely controlled by the
composition of the acyl-CoA pool.
Although not shown in the following simplied scheme, the phospatidic acid/
1,2-diacylglycerol duo is also an intermediate in the pathway to the phospholipids
(phosphatidylcholines, phosphatidylethanolamines, phosphatidylinositols, phospha-
tidylinositols, and phosphatidylserines) and the mono- and digalactosyldiacylgly-
cerols.
216 VEGETABLE OILS
sn-glycerol-3-phospate HOCH
2
CHOHCH
2
OPO
3
H
2
acylation at sn-1 #
acylation at sn-2 #
phosphatidic acid R
1
COOCH
2
CHOCOR
2
CH
2
OPO
3
H
2
#"
sn-1;2-diacylglycerol R
1
COOCH
2
CHOCOR
2
CH
2
OH
acylation at sn-3 #
triacylglycerol R
1
COOCH
2
CHOCOR
2
CH
2
OCOR
3
3. MINOR COMPONENTS
Crude vegetable oils are mainly triacylglycerols (around 95%) along with some free
acids, monoacylglycerols, and diacylglycerols. They also contain variable amounts
of other components such as phospholipids, free and esteried sterols, triterpene
alcohols, tocopherols and tocotrienols, carotenes, chlorophylls and other coloring
matters, and hydrocarbons as well as traces of metals, oxidation products, undesir-
able avors, and so on. These are discussed in detail elsewhere. Rening procedures
have been developed to convert the crude oil into a bland product that meets a
dened specication. Some of the minor components are valuable in their own right
and should be retained in the rened oil and/or trapped in a side stream for recovery
and further utilization.
Crude oils generally contain phospholipids that are removed during the degum-
ming stage of rening as a crude mixture (lecithin). This valuable product is the
basis of the phospholipid industry, and phospholipids are used extensively in
food products, in animal feeds, and in industrial processes. The major members
are phosphatidylcholines, phosphatidylethanolamines, and phosphatidylinositols
and are accompanied by smaller proportions of other phospholipids. Soybean oil
(3.2%), rapeseed oil (2.5%), and sunower seed oil (1.5%) contain the proportions
of total phospholipids indicated in parentheses and are the main sources of commer-
cial lecithins, especially soya lecithin. Palm oil contains little or no phospholipids
(79).
Most vegetable oils contain 10005000 ppm (15 g/kg) of sterols, partly as free
sterols and partly as esteried sterols. Higher levels are present in rapeseed oil
(511 g/kg, mean 7.5) and in corn oil (822 g/kg, mean 14). Sitosterol is
generally the major phytosterol (5080% of total sterol) with campesterol, stigmas-
terol, and
5
-avenasterol also frequently attaining signicant levels. Brassicasterol
is virtually absent from the major seed oils except for rapeseed oil where it com-
prises 10% of the total sterol. Cholesterol is generally considered to be a zoosterol
and is not present in plant systems at any signicant level. The normal value of
2050 ppm in vegetable oils compares with the much higher levels reported for ani-
mal fats (up to 1000 ppm), sh oils (up to 7000 ppm), dairy fats (20003000 ppm),
and egg yolks (12,500 ppm). Phytosterols (and other compounds) can be recovered
from deodorizer distillate and are used to produce pharmaceutical steroids (10).
MINOR COMPONENTS 217
Tocol extracts are mixtures of up to eight compounds. There are four tocopherols
with a saturated, branched C
16
side chain and four analogous tocotrienols with three
double bonds in the side chain. The tocotrienols, although signicant in palm oil,
are generally less common than the tocopherols and much less is known about their
biological properties. The four tocopherols differ in the number of methyl groups
attached to the heterocyclic moiety. They are designated a (5,7,8-trimethyl), b (5,7-
dimethyl), g (7,8-dimethyl), and d (8-methyl). The tocols have two valuable proper-
ties: They show vitamin E activity, and they are powerful antioxidants. These two
properties are not identical. For vitamin E activity, the order is a (1.0) >b (0.5) >g
(0.1) >d (0.03) with total activity usually expressed in a-tocopherol equivalents.
For antioxidants, this order is reversed.
Natural tocopherol mixtures are used as antioxidants, usually at levels up to
500 ppm, along with ascorbyl palmitate to extend the antioxidant activity. At higher
levels (>1000 ppm), a-tocopherol is considered to act as a pro-oxidant. As vege-
table oils contain tocols at 200800 ppm, further additions show only a limited
effect. The tocols are very sensitive to oxidation and are more stable in esteried
form where the all-important hydroxyl group is not free. However such compounds
do not show antioxidant activity until they have been hydrolyzed in vivo to the free
phenolic form (11).
Hydrocarbons are very minor components of oils and fats but are of dietary and
legislative interest. They include alkanes, alkenes such as squalene and carotenes,
and polycyclicaromatic hydrocarbons. Squalene (C
30
H
50
) is a highly unsaturated
open-chain triterpene. It is used in the cosmetic industry after hydrogenation to
squalane (C
30
H
62
). The most abundant source of squalene is the liver oil of the
deep-sea dogsh (Squalus acanthushence the name squalene) and some other
marine species. Vegetable sources of potential interest include olive oil and amar-
anthus (Section 6).
Carotenes are minor components in many vegetable oils and particularly in palm
oil. They contain a long chain of conjugated unsaturation and are yellow/orange/red
in color. Crude palm oil normally contains 500700 ppm of carotenes. These are
mainly a-carotene (24 42% of total carotene) and b-carotene (5060%) along
with low levels of several other carotenes. Carotenes are also present in palm leaves
and in pressed ber remaining when oil has been expressed from palm fruits.
Attempts have been made to retain these valuable materials in rened palm oil
(red palm oil) or to recover them in concentrated form (12). Carotenes can be
recovered from palm methyl esters. The esters are prepared by methanolysis of
palm oil and are produced in large quantities for use as biodiesel, as a solvent,
for conversion to alcohols, and so on. The carotenes can be recovered from the
esters by chromatography in an open column or by molecular distillation. The latter
gives a carotene concentrate (8%) which can be puried (>90%) by chromatogra-
phy (1315). The concentrates are used as food-dyes, as a vitamin additive, and by
the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industries.
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are present at levels up to about 150 mg/kg
(ppb) in most crude vegetable oils, although slightly less after rening (<80 ppb).
They are removed only to a small extent during bleaching and somewhat more
218 VEGETABLE OILS
during deodorization. This holds more particularly for the more volatile tri- and tet-
racyclic compounds. The pentacyclic and other less volatile compounds are best
removed with activated charcoal added to the earth during bleaching. These low
values do not hold for crude coconut oil dried with combustion gases where values
around 3000 ppb are routinely recorded. Normal values are obtained after charcoal
treatment (16). Extracted oils may contain pesticides resulting from agricultural
practices, but these are usually removed during deodorization.
4. CLASSIFICATION OF VEGETABLE OILS
4.1. Classication by Source Type
One market analyst provides regular information on the production and trade of
17 commodity oils and fats. In Oil World Publications (ISTA Mielke GmbH, Ham-
burg, Germany), these are listed in the order: soybean, cotton, groundnut, sun-
ower, rapeseed, sesame, corn, olive, palm, palm kernel, coconut, butter, lard,
sh, linseed, castor, and tallow. The list includes 4 materials of animal origin and
13 of vegetable origin. This chapter will report on the 13 vegetable oils and some
others of plant origin.
The above list does not include cocoa butter nor minor oils such as rice bran oil
or safower oil. Nor does it distinguish between oils from a common botanical
source with a modied fatty acid composition, such as canola oil and high-erucic
rape seed oil, linseed oil and linola, or the various types of sunower oil.
The commodity vegetable oils can be classied in various ways. Some are
byproducts so that decisions regarding their production are largely controlled by
the nonoil component. Examples are corn oil and cottonseed oil. These are bypro-
ducts of cereal and ber production, respectively. Also, rice bran oil is a byproduct
of rice production. As a consequence, oil production is not the main economic fac-
tor that inuences the areas cultivated by these crops. It is sometimes argued that
soybean falls into this byproduct category and that the bean is grown as a source of
protein with the oil as byproduct. It is true that the bean produces only 18% of oil
against 79% of residual meal rich in protein, but the value of these two commodities
is evenly balanced and there are times when the demand is oil-led and other times
when it is meal-led.
Some commodity oils and fats such as palm, palm kernel, coconut, and olive are
tree crops. Once the trees mature, they continue to produce fruit for many years and
production levels cannot be greatly changed from season to season.
This leaves the annual crops of rape, sunower, and linseed (often called soft
oils) where planting decisions are made on a year-to-year basis depending on per-
ceived benet. Planting areas are decided on agricultural grounds (such as crop
rotation) and on economic grounds. Low prices and/or high stocks in one season
tend to lead to reduced plantings in the following season.
It is also possible to distinguish between oils from seeds, such as soybean and
rapeseed, and those coming from the eshy part of a fruit such as palm and olive.
An important point here is that for oilseeds, exports and imports are as seeds as well
CLASSIFICATION OF VEGETABLE OILS 219
as extracted oil, whereas for the other group, trade is conned to extracted oil.
When making comparisons, it is not sufcient to consider gures for traded oil
without also including the oil-equivalent of traded seeds.
The annual production of soybean oil exceeds that of palm oil, but it is claimed
that trade (imports/exports) in palm oil is larger. This view, based on the fact that
trade in palm oil far exceeds that in soybean oil, does not take into account the very
large exports of soybeans themselves. What are the numbers if exported beans are
also considered in terms of their oil-equivalent? The following gures for year
2000/01 are taken from Oil World Annual 2001. For soybean, 7.4 million tons
1
were exported as oil and a further oil-equivalent of 7.8 million tons was exported
in the form of beans. This latter gure is based on exports of 50.0 million tons of
beans, of which 85.2% was crushed (world average) with an oil content of 18.3%.
On this basis, the full level of exported soybean oil is about 15.2 million tons. This
is still lower than the gure for palm oil (16.8 million tons), but the disparity is not
so large (17).
The term tropical oils is correctly applied to oils and fats produced in the tropics
and refers particularly to the (highly saturated) lauric oils (Sections 5.3 and 5.10)
and to palm oil (Section 5.9). This term is frequently and unfairly used in a dero-
gatory sense, partly through ignorance about the difference in fatty acid composi-
tion and use between lauric oils and palm oil and of the considerable nutritional
value of the latter.
Castor oil is classed as an industrial oil because it is used only for nonfood pur-
poses (Section 5.1). Linseed oil also is used almost entirely for industrial purposes.
In its limited use as an edible oil, it is generally known by its alternative name of
axseed oil (Section 5.7).
4.2. Classication by Fatty Acid Composition
The list of natural fatty acids exceeds 1000, but commercial interest is limited to a
smaller numberperhaps around 20. Ignoring the lipid membrane, rich in a-lino-
lenic acid and present in all green tissue, the three dominant acids in the plant king-
dom are palmitic, oleic, and linoleic, sometimes accompanied by stearic acid and
by linolenic acid. Others, occuring in specialty oils, include myristic, lauric, erucic,
hexadecenoic, petroselinic, g-linolenic acid, eleostearic and isomers, ricinoleic, and
vernolic (Table 1).
Although it is convenient to categorize oils by their fatty acid composition, it
must be remembered that this is not the only index of their nutritional value or
of their oxidative stability. Attention must also be given to the minor components
in the crude oil and to those remaining after rening (see Section 3).
1
The gures cited in tons in this chapter have been taken from publications using tonnes, and at the
editors request, the numbers have not been adjusted: 1 ton is equivalent to 0.984 tons, and the numbers
are not signicantly different in the present context.
220 VEGETABLE OILS
TABLE 1. Structures of the More Common Acids in Vegetable Oils.
Trivial Name Symbol Unsaturation (if any)
Saturated
Lauric 12:0
Myristic 14:0
Palmitic 16:0
Stearic 18:0
Monounsaturated
Oleic 18:1 9c
Petroselinic 18:1 6c
Erucic 22:1 13c
Polyunsaturated (non-conjugated)
Linoleic 18:2 9c12c
Linolenic (a) 18:3 9c12c15c
Linolenic (g) 18:3 6c9c12c
Polyunsaturated (conjugated)
Eleostearic 18:3 9c11t13t
Calendic 18:3 8t10t12c
Oxygenated
Ricinoleic 18:1 12-OH 9c
Vernolic 18:1 12,13-epoxy 9c
TABLE 2. (a) Typical Fatty Acid Composition (%wt).
Oil source 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3
Cocoa butter 26 34 35
Corn 13 3 31 52 1
Cottonseed 27 2 18 51 Tr
Groundnut 13 3 38 41 Tr
Linseed 6 3 17 14 60
Olive 10 2 78 7 1
Palm 44 4 39 11 Tr
Palm olein 41 4 31 12 Tr
Palm stearin 4774 46 1637 310
Rape (high erucic)
3 1 16 14 10
Rape (low erucic) 4 2 56 26 10
Rice bran oil 20 2 42 32
Safower 7 3 14 75
Safower (high oleic) 6 2 74 16
Sesame 9 6 41 43
Soybean 11 4 22 53 8
Sunower 6 5 20 60 Tr
Sunower (Sunola) 4 5 81 8 Tr
Sunower (NuSun) 4 5 65 26
Adapted from Gunstone (11).
tr trace (<1%).
, crambe
Conjugated acid tung, calendula
Oxygenated acids castor, vernolic
5
CHOHCH
2
CH
CHCH
2
7
COOH
ricinoleic acid 12-hydroxyoleic acid
224 VEGETABLE OILS
Sulfation converts the hydroxyl group to a sulfate (OSO
2
OH) with improved
surfactant properties. Apart from soap, it is the earliest anionic surfactant
(dating back to 1874) and is still used in textile processing, leather treatment,
and as an additive for cutting oils and hydraulic uids. The sulfated hydro-
genated oil has the consistency of an ointment and gives adjustable viscosity
to water-based formulations with excellent skin compatibility.
Dehydration of castor oil and of castor acids gives products enriched in diene
acids, some with conjugated unsaturation. These products are valuable
alternatives to drying oils such as tung oil.
Hydrogenated castor oil and hydrogenated castor acids, with higher melting
points than the nonhydrogenated material, are used in cosmetics, coatings, and
greases. Greases prepared from tallow are much improved when salts of
12-hydroxystearic acid are added.
Castor oil reacts with isocyanates to give polyurethanes that are much used for
wood preservation and have been developed as encapsulating materials.
Splitting ricinoleic acid with caustic soda gives C
8
and C
10
products. At 180
200
C with a 1:1 caustic/castor ratio, the major products are 2-octanone and
10-hydroxydecanoic acid. At 250275
C), thereby extending the range of usefulness of this oil. With improved ltra-
tion procedures, the yield of olein has been increased to 7178%. This olein has a
cloud point of 710
N and 40
CHCH
2
4
OCOCH
CHCH
CHCH
2
4
CH
3
Coriander (Coriandrum sativum). See caraway. Attempts are being made both
to develop coriander as an agricultural crop and to transfer the necessary -6 desa-
turase to the rape plant (98).
Crambe (Crambe abyssinica, C. hispanica). Present interest in this oil, particu-
larly in North Dakota and in Holland, depends on the fact that it is a potential
source of erucic acid (5055%) that nds several industrial uses. This was once
the major acid in rapeseed oil, but modern varieties of this seed produce a low-
erucic oil (such as canola) suitable for food use. High-erucic rapeseed oil is still
grown for industrial purposes, and attempts are being made to increase the level
of this C
22
acid from around 50% to over 65% and even to 90% by genetic engi-
neering (2223, 44, 99102).
Cuphea. Cuphea plants furnish seeds with oils that may be rich in C
8
, C
10
, C
12
,
or C
14
acids. They generally contain >30% of oil and are expected to produce a
commercial crop in the period 20052010. Problems of seed dormancy and seed
shattering have already been solved. As markets for lauric oils already exist, there
should be no difculty in substituting cuphea oils. More recently, it has been
reported that cuphea will be used as a commercial source of lauric acid from
2003 onward (30, 102, 103). Pandey et al. (104) have described the oil (1729%)
from Cupea procumbens containing 8995% of decanoic acid. See also Section 9.2.
Dimorphotheca The seed of Dimorphotheca pluvialis is not very rich in oil (13
28%, typically about 20%), but it contains an unusual C
18
hydroxy fatty acid
(60%) with hydroxyl group adjacent (allylic) to a conjugated diene system.
This is very unstable and easily dehydrates to a mixture of conjugated 18:3 acids
(105).
CH
3
CH
2
4
CH
CHCH
CHCHOHCH
2
7
COOH
Dimorphecolic acid 9-OH10t12c-18 : 2
Evening Primrose (Oenothera biennis, O. lamarckiana, and O. parviora). see
Borage.
Gold of Pleasure (Camelina sativa, also called false ax). In addition to its
interesting fatty acid composition, this plant attracts attention because it grows
well with lower inputs of fertilizers and pesticides than traditional crops like rape-
seed and linseed. The plant can also be grown on poorer soils and shows better
gross margins than the other two plants after allowing for direct costs and (EU) sub-
sidy payments. The seed yield is in the range 1.53.0 t/ha, and the oil content is
between 36% and 47%. The oil has an unusual fatty acid composition. It contains
236 VEGETABLE OILS
signicant levels of oleic acid (1020%), linoleic acid (1624%), linolenic acid
(3040%), and C
20
and C
22
acids, especially 20:1 (1523%). Another publication
reports 3038% oil containing oleic (1420%), linoleic (1924%), linolenic (27
35%), eicosenoic (1215%), and other acids (1220%) along with a range of tocols
(522, mean 17 mg/100 g). Despite its high level of unsaturation, the oil shows rea-
sonable oxidative stability. Attempts are being made to optimize the agronomy. Its
use in paints, varnishes, inks, cosmetics, and even as a food oil is being examined
and developed. Permission for food use has been granted in France and Britain
(106110).
Grapeseed (Vitis vinifera). These seeds produce variable levels of oil (620%),
now available as a gourmet oil and for which Codex values have been reported. The
oil is rich in linoleic acid (6076%) and contains palmitic (68%), stearic (36%),
and oleic acids (1225%). In common with other oils rich in linoleic, it is reported
to have a benecial effect on the skin (79). Moret et al. (111) have described the
effect of processing on the content of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in this oil.
Hazelnut (Corylus avellana, also called lberts). The oil is rich in oleic acid
(6575% or even higher) and contains linoleic acid (16 22%). Its levels of satu-
rated acids are low. Grown in Turkey and New Zealand, the nuts produced 55
63% of oil with saturated acids (68%), monoene acids (7480%), and linoleic
acid (68%). A recent study indicates the presence of several monoene acids in
the C
16
C
22
range, although this may refer to a different species (79, 112115).
Hemp (Marijuana, Cannabis sativa). Hemp seed oil has an interesting fatty acid
composition. One report gives the followimg values: palmitic (49%), stearic (2
4%), oleic (815%), linoleic (5360%), a-linolenic (1525%), g-linolenic (05%),
and stearidonic acid (03%). The oil is being used in cosmetic formulations (116).
Evidence from a study in Finland indicates that dietary consumption of hemp seed
oil leads to increased levels of g-linolenic acid in blood serum (117). The growing
of hemp is banned in the United States, and therefore, hemp seed oil must be
imported into that country (118119).
Honesty (Lunaria annua). This seed oil contains signicant levels of erucic
(22:1, 41%) and nervonic acids (24:1, 22%) and is being studied as a new crop
because it is a good source of the latter acid, which may be useful in the treatment
of demyelinating dizease (120).
Illipe (Shorea stenoptera, also called Borneo tallow). This is one of a group of
tropical fats that are often confused with one another. They generally resemble
cocoa butter in their proportions of palmitic, stearic, and oleic acids and therefore
have similar triacylglycerol composition and display similar melting behavior.
Values of 18%, 46%, and 35% have been reported for palmitic, stearic, and oleic
acids and POP (7%), POSt (34%), and StOSt (47%) for the major triacylglycerols
(121125). It is one of six permitted fats (palm oil, illipe butter, kokum butter,
sal fat, shea butter, and mango kernel fat), which, in some countries at least, can
partially replace cocoa butter in chocolate (8687).
Kapok (Bombax malabaricum, Ceiba pentandra). This name is applied to a
number of tropical trees of the bombax family. The oil is a byproduct of kapok ber
production. Its major component acids are palmitic (22%), oleic (21%), and linoleic
SPECIALITY AND MINOR OILS 237
(37%), but it also contains about 13% of cyclopropene acids (malvalic and stercu-
lic), which make it unsuitable for food use.
Kokum (Garcinia indica). Both kokum and mahua fats are rich in saturated and
oleic acid and contain high levels of SOS triacylglycerols. They can be fractioned
separately or as blends of the two oils to produce stearins that can be used as cocoa
butter extenders (Table 8) (125). Kokum butter is one of six permitted fats (palm
oil, illipe butter, kokum butter, sal fat, shea butter, and mango kernel fat), which, in
some countries at least, can partially replace cocoa butter in chocolate (90).
Lesquerella. The only oil of signicance with a hydroxy acid is castor oil (Sec-
tion 5.1) but among the new crops being seriously developed are two containing
hydroxy acids. Lesquerella oils have some resemblance to castor oil, but Dimor-
photheca pluvialis seed oil contains a different kind of hydroxy acid.
Plants of the Lesquerella species are characterized by the presence of the C
20
bis-homologue of ricinoleic acidlesquerolic acidsometimes accompanied by
other acids of the same type at lower levels:
Ricinoleic acid 12-OH 9-18 : 1
Densipolic acid 12-OH 9; 15-18 : 2
Lesquerolic acid 14-OH 11-20 : 1
Auricolic acid 14-OH 11; 17-20 : 2
A typical analysis of L. fendleri seed oil showed the presence of 16:0 (1%), 18:0
(2%), 18:1 (15%), 18:2 (7%), 18:3 (14%), lesquerolic (54%), and auricolic (4%)
acids. As lesquerolic acid is the C
20
homologue of ricinoleic with the same
b-hydroxy alkene unit, it undergoes similar chemical reactions but produces
(some) different products. For example, pyrolysis should give heptanal and 13-tri-
decenoic acid (in place of 11-undecenoic acid). This could be converted to 13-ami-
notridecanoic acid, the monomer required to make nylon-13. Similarly, alkali-
fusion will give 2-octanol and dodecanedioic acid in place of decanedioic (sebacic)
acid. This C
12
dibasic acid is already available from petrochemical products and has
a number of applications. A recent account of the status of this oil is available
(126).
Macadamia (Macadonia integrifolia, M. tetraphylla). The nuts are used as a
snack food. They are rich in oil (6070%), which is used in cosmetics and is avail-
able as a gourmet oil. It is characterized by its high level of monoene acids [total
80%, 16:1 1623%, 18:1 5565%, 20:1 13%] and is a convenient source of the
TABLE 8. Fatty Acids and triacylglycerols of Kokum and Madhua Fats.
Fatty Acids Triacylglycerols
Oil source 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 StOSt POSt POP
Kokum 2.0 49.0 49.0 0 72.3 7.4 0.5
Madhua 23.5 20.0 39.0 16.7 10.6 22.2 18.9
Stearin
C and 200
over 30
60 minutes at a cost not very different from that for partial hydrogenation. It does
not require expensive equipment nor use explosive gases. To get a product with the
desired properties, a soft oil is interesteried with a hard stock, which may be a
fractionated stearin, a lauric oil, or a fully hydrogenated seed oil. This last is a
scientically acceptable choice but has the disadvantage that the word hydroge-
nated will have to appear on the label. The average customer does not appreciate
the difference between partially hydrogenated (with trans-acids) and fully hydroge-
nated (without unsaturated acids).
The catalyst normally employed is an alkali metal at a level of 0.10.2% or a
sodium alcoholate (usually sodium methoxide) at a 0.20.3% level. The true cata-
lyst is believed to be a diacylglycerol anion resulting from interaction of alkali and
triacylglycerol. The catalyst is easily destroyed by acid, water, or peroxides, so the
feedstock oil should be free of these impurities (188).
Natural oils and fractionated oils usually have their acyl chains organized in a
nonrandom manner, but they become randomized after interesterication with a
chemical catalyst. There is no change in fatty acid composition, only in triacylgly-
cerol composition, but this leads to a modication of the physical properties. More
selective interesterication can be achieved with enzymic catalysts (Section 8.5).
The following are typical applications of interesterication:
Lard, with an unusually high level of palmitic acid in the b-position, crystal-
lizes naturally in the b form. When randomized, the content of 2-palmito-
glycerol esters is reduced from around 64% to 24% and the interesteried
product crystallizes in the b
0
form with consequent improvement in shortening
properties.
The crystal structures of margarines based on sunower or canola oil (rape-
seed) along with hydrogenated oil are stabilized in the b
0
form by interester-
ication leading to randomization of the glycerol esters.
Solid fats with about 60% of essential fatty acids can be obtained by (reduced
temperature) interesterication of sunower oil and about 5% of hard fat.
Margarine made, for example, by interesterication of palm stearin and
sunower oil (1:1), contains no hydrogenated fat and therefore no trans-acids.
Chemical interesterication is used in the production of caprenin, salatrim,
and olestra.
8.5. Interesterication with an Enzymic Catalyst
Interesterication can also be catalysed by enzymes, many of which show useful
specicities. The 1,3-specic lipases, such as those derived from Aspergillus niger,
Mucor javanicus, M. miehei, Rhizopus arrhizus, R. delemar, and R. niveus, are par-
ticularly useful for interesterication. They are used to effect acyl exchange at the
sn-1 and 3 positions while leaving acyl groups at the sn-2 position unchanged.
TECHNOLOGICAL PROCEDURES USED FOR LIPID MODIFICATION 249
Many interesting changes of this type have been affected on a bench scale, but as
yet only a few have been commercialized and then only for products of high value
(186 190).
Unilever developed a method for upgrading palm mid-fraction (PMF) as a cocoa
butter equivalent. The PMF is too rich in palmitic acid and has too little stearic acid,
but this deciency can be repaired by enzyme-catalysed acidolysis with stearic acid.
Reaction is conned to the exchange of palmitic acid by stearic acid at the sn-1 and
3 positions with no movement of oleic acid from the sn-2 position. A similar pro-
duct is produced enzymatically by acidolysis of high-oleic sunower oil (rich in
triolein) and stearic acid.
POP St ! POSt StOSt
OOO St ! StOO StOSt
Chemical interesterication would lead to randomization of all of the acyl chains,
and the products would have different melting behavior from that required by a
cocoa butter equivalent (188).
Another product manufactured by Loders-Croklaan (Unilever) and named Beta-
pol consists mainly of triacylglycerols of the type UPU. This is used as a constituent
of infant formulas (191). Human milkfat is unusual in that it contains a signicant
proportion of its palmitic acid in the sn-2 position. Although this is true also for lard
(pig fat), it is not a feature of vegetable oils. Betapol is made from tripalmitin and
oleic acid using the lipase from Mucor miehei to promote 1,3-acyl exchange. These
materials are expensive, and in practice, fractionated palm oil, rich in tripalmitin, is
reacted with acids from high-oleic sunower or safower or from olive oil.
Bohenin (BOB) is the name given to glycerol 1,3-behenate 2-oleate, which
inhibits fat bloom when added to chocolate. It is produced in Japan by enzymic
interesterication of triolein and behenic (22:0) acid or ester in the presence of a
1,3 stereospecic lipase.
Diacylglycerols are being produced and used in growing quantities because of
their benecial effects in the management of obesity. Cooking oil containing at
least 80% of diacylglycerols (mainly the 1,3- isomer) has been marketed in Japan
since 1999 by the Kao company and thereafter in other countries, including the
United States by ADM.
There are many reports showing how, with an appropriate enzyme (Mucor mie-
hei and Candida antarctica are frequently used), long-chain polyunsaturated fatty
acids such as eicosapentaenoic acid and/or docosahexaenoic acid can be introduced
into vegetable oils or synthetic glycerides to give products with enhanced nutri-
tional value. In a similar way, C
8
and C
10
acyl chains can be introduced into vege-
table oils or sh oils with a consequent change in nutritional properties and energy
values. The products are triacylglycerols with either one long and two short chains
(LS
2
) or two long and one short chain (L
2
S). This reaction can be used to produce
triacylglycerols with easily metabolizable short- and medium-chain acids at the
sn-1 and 3 positions and an essential fatty acid at the crucial sn-2 position. This
topic is the subject of some recent reviews (190, 192, 193).
250 VEGETABLE OILS
9. BIOLOGICAL METHODS OF LIPID MODIFICATION
9.1. Introduction
New sources of oils and fats develop from plants in three different ways. One pos-
sibility is to take a wild plant that produces oil with an interesting fatty acid and/or
triacylglycerol prole and to make it suitable for commercial growing and harvest-
ing. This is generally a slow process requiring many years. Traits developed over an
evolutionary time scale to maintain the plant in the wild are not always appropriate
in domesticated plants and have to be bred out. This approach is being pursued,
particularly in North America and in Europe, for a number of species identied
as promising, and they are at differing stages of development (see Section 9.2).
A second approach, when a diverse gene pool is available, is to interbreed spe-
cies with appropriate traits by standard seed-breeding processes. This has been done
very effectively with species of brassica to yield the modern oilseed rape (canola).
If necessary, the gene pool can be extended by mutation resulting from chemical
treatment or from irradiation. This may produce novel varieties with interesting
traits and is the basis of the low-linolenic lines from linseed, and other examples
are described in Section 9.3.
Finally, genes required for particular aspects of fatty acid and triacylglycerol
biosynthesis can be identied in appropriate sources, cloned, and transferred to
other plants. Rapeseed has proved to be particularly exible in this respect, and
its fatty acid composition has been modied in several ways, some of which
have now reached or are very close to commercial application (Section 9.4). Genetic
modication procedures are also applied to soybean and other oilseed crops.
The commercial introduction of a new lipid source is not a trivial matter. Unless
the oil has some specic and novel property (like oils containing g-linolenic acid,
for example), it will have to compete with existing oils available in bulk at com-
modity prices. This exerts a number of constraints.
The new crop should be easily cultivated, harvested, processed, and marketed.
Additional costs may result from the need to have separate and distinct
harvesting, storage, processing, and marketing facilities.
The new crop must quickly become available in good and reliable quantities at
acceptable prices.
The demand for and interest in some new crops may come more from the
oleochemical industry than from the food industry, but traditionally the
oleochemical industry has used lower grade and cheaper oils than the food
industry.
Because the supply of new oil must start small and grow with demand, it is
useful to nd some low-volume, high-value products that will support the crop
through its early years of development until the supply is adequate to be used
for high-volume, low-value products.
The demand must be market-led (at least after the rst few years). At present,
there is an interest in new crops that produce oils with high levels of a single
BIOLOGICAL METHODS OF LIPID MODIFICATION 251
acid such as lauric, oleic, petroselinic, erucic, or acids with hydroxy or epoxy
groups.
Although agronomists must help to produce oils meeting these requirement,
chemists and technologists must assist in the substitution of existing oils by
new oils and in the development of new uses for new oils.
In addition, regulatory requirements will have to be met when the seed and/or
its products are novel. This topic has been reviewed (194, 195).
9.2. Domestication of Wild Crops
Serious attempts are being made in Europe and North America to develop a range
of wild oilseed crops, generally with a high content of one particular acid. The fol-
lowing account shows the variety of species being examined. Reference has already
been made to some of these in Sections 4 and 6.
Cuphea oils are interesting because they come from annual plants producing gly-
cerol esters based mainly on capric (10:0) or lauric acid (12:0) or occasionally on
caprylic (8:0) or myristic acid (14:0). Cuphea plants exhibit several wild plant char-
acteristics that need to be bred out. These include dormancy, nonuniform germina-
tion, indeterminate owering, seed maturation over a broad time period (six weeks),
extreme dehiscence (pod shattering), and the presence of viscid hairs on stem,
leaves, owers, and fruit. Several species are being studied in attempts to make
them commercial (30).
Oleic oils. Oleic acid is an important source material for the oleochemical industry,
and as the most common monoene acid, it has a good rating on dietary grounds. For
many oleochemical purposes, the presence of some saturated acid (palmitic, stearic)
is not signicant but levels of linoleic and linolenic acid should be as low as pos-
sible because they promote undesirable oxidation. All oils contain oleic acid, and
frequently, it is the dominant component. For example, the oils of rapeseed (56%),
macadamia (56% along with a further 22% of 16:1), almond (61%), high-oleic
safower (74%), olive (78%), and high-oleic sunower (82%) contain the levels
of oleic acid indicated. Of these, almond and rape also contain 2530% of linoleic
acid. Euphorbia lathyris (caper spurge) is a Mediterranean annual containing about
50% of oil in its seed and 8090% of oleic acid in the oil. This would make it an
excellent source of oleic acid. At present, it suffers from a number of deciencies,
especially seed shattering and the presence of a cocarcinogenic milky sap. But it is
hoped that these problems will be overcome through plant breeding. Other good
sources of oleic acidboth existing and potentialare discussed in Sections 9.3
and 9.4.
Petroselinic acid oils. Petroselinic acid is the 6 isomer of the more common oleic
acid (9). Although they share many properties, these acids display an interesting
difference in melting point. Petroselinic acid and its glycerol ester melt at 33
C and
28
C, respectively. The corresponding gures for oleic acid and its glycerol ester
are lower at 12
and 16
Canola 4 2 62 20 9 3
High in
16:0 10 1 51 19 13 6
16:0/18:0 9 10 57 14 4 6
16:0 29 2 31 22 13 3
18:0 4 34 22 18 18 4
12:0 40 4 3 1 29 12 8 3
14:0 40 3 1 29 10 7 10
18:1 4 1 84 5 3 3
18:2 4 2 33 49 7 5