Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5. Any loss or profit on re-issue should be debited to Forfeited share a/c. The loss on re-issue should
not exceed the forfeited amount. The loss should be credited to share capital a/c while the profit on
re-issue should be credited to capital reserve a/c.
6. Whenever any Journal entries are to be passed, you should remember to give narration alongwith
the entries. The narration carries marks in the examination. The students are generally seen to
forget this important point in their replies.
7. The credit balance of Forfeited shares a/c cannot be treated as surplus or profit until these shares
are re-issued. Discount if any, will be adjusted against the credit balance of Forfeited shares a/c.
The Journal entries are as follows
Forfeiture of shares:
It is assumed here that the Securities Premium a/c was created on due basis at the time of making
final call.
Equity Share capital a/c (at Rs. 10)
Dr.
3,000
securities premium a/c (at Rs. 3)
900
To Share Final Call a/c (Rs. 10)
3,000
To Forfeited shares a/c (amount received on share capital a/c)
900
(Being forfeiture of 300 shares numbered from. to held by Unfortunate for non payment of final
call of Rs. 10, the amount received on share capital a/c on application Rs. 1 and on allotment Rs. 2
being credited to forfieted shares a/c vide Board resolution dated..............)
Reissue of Shares :
Computation of profit / loss on reissue of 300 shares:
Amount forfeited on Share capital a/c (Rs. 3)
Amount received on re-issue (Rs. 25)
Total amount received
The balance amount on 300 shares :
On share capital a/c at Rs. 10 (share capital was reduced
at the time of forfeiture)
securities premium a/c at Rs. 3 (Rs. 17 already received)
Rs.
900
7,500
8,400
3,000
900
3,900
4,500
Rs.
3,000
7,500
4,500
Rs.
3,000
900
4,500
Glamour Ltd. invitited applications for 15,000 shares of its equity shares of Rs. 10 each issued at
Rs. 11.50 payable as follows: (in Rs./share)
On application 1st July, 09
7.5
On allotment on 31st July, 09 (including premium)
2.0
On first and final call on 31st August, 09
2.0
Applications were received for 18,000 shares and it was decided to deal with the same as follows in
arrangement with the stock exchange authorities :
(a) To refuse allotment to an applicant for 800 shares.
(b) To give full allotment to an applicant for 2,200 shares.
(c) To allot the remaining shares prorata amongst other applicants.
(d) To utilise the surplus received on applications in part payment of dues on allotment.
An applicant to whom 40 shares were allotted, failed to pay the amount due on the first and final call
and her shares were forfeited on 31st Oct.09. These shares were re-issued on 15th Nov.09 as fully
paid at Rs. 9 per share.
Give journal entries including those relating to cash to record the above transactions.
Solution :
Read the tutorial notes of previous problem again.
Disposal of application money :
Shares Paid Rs.
Rs.
18,000
135,000
Application money received
7.5
800
6,000
Less :
Return
7.5
2,200
16,500
Less :
Full allotment
7.5
22,500
Balance to be allotted on prorata basis
112,500
Applicants for 15,000 shares (18,000 800 2,200) were allotted 12,800 shares (15,000 2,200)
on prorata basis. Let us compute the amount adjusted towards allotment, for these applicants.
It should be noted that if Premium is included in the Allotment money, the excess of application
money is first adjusted towards Securities Premium a/c and balance is adjusted towards share
capital.
To understand this properly, you should make separate computations for full allotment of 2200
shares where no money is adjusted towards allotment and for 12,800 shares where some
application money is adjusted towards allotment and Securities premium a/c.
On prorata allotment of 12,800 shares :
Shares Rs./share
Amount
15,000
7.50
112,500
Application money paid
12,800
7.50
96,000
Application money adjusted
16,500
Balance to be adjusted toward allotment money
12,800
1.5
19,200
Securities premium due on allotment
16,500
Securities premium adjusted from application money
Received
To
be called
On Allotment
Required
6,400
6,400
On 12,800 shares :
Share capital
0.5
2,700
Securities Premium
1.5 19,200 16,500
1,100
1,100
On 2,200 shares
Share capital
0.5
3,300
3,300
Securities Premium
1.5
13,500
Total money due on allotment
(Share capital : 6,400 + 1,100) and Securities Premium : (2,700 + 3,300)
On the basis of above, you can make entries as follows : (narration left to you)
Dr.
To Share Application Money a/c
Share Application Money a/c
To Bank
(refund on application money of 800 shares)
Share Application Money a/c
To Share Allotmoney a/c (2200 shares)
To Share Allotmoney a/c (12800 shares)
To Securities Premium a/c
Bank
135,000
135,000
6,000
6,000
129,000
Total
16,500
96,000
16,500
129,000
16,500
Share Allotmoney a/c
16,500
To Share Capital a/c (2200 x 7.5)
96,000
Share Allotmoney a/c
96,000
To Share Capital a/c ( 12800 x 7.5)
13,500
Share Allotmoney a/c
7,500
To Share Capital a/c (12,800 x 0.5 +2,200 x 0.5)
6,000
To Securities Premium a/c
13,500
Bank a/c
13,500
To Share Allotmoney a/c
For the story of First and final call, following entries can be made :
Shares
Rs. Amount
15,000
Call money required
2 30,000
14,960
Call money received
2 29,920
40
80
Call money not paid
2
At this time, 40 shares will be forfeited. The share capital created upto the point of forfeiture is to be
cancelled. The securities premium received at the time of allotment is NOT to be forfeited, it will
remain in securities premium a/c. The amount received on account of share capital upto the point of
forfeiture will be credited to share forfeiture a/c.
30,000
Share First and Final Call a/c
30,000
To Equity Share Capital a/c
29,920
Bank a/c
29,920
To Share First and Final Call a/c
Cancellation of Share capital
400
Equity Share Capital a/c
80
To Share first and final call a/c
320
To Share forfeiture a/c
The amount standing towards share forfeiture a/c cannot be treated as surplus until these shares
are reissued. In the present case, the amount forfeited is Rs. 8/ per share and the shares are being
re-issued at Rs.9 per share. Thus in all the share has fetched Rs. 17/ per share against the face
value of Rs.10/share indicating that the profit on re-issue is Rs.7 per share amounting to Rs. 280 (for
40 shares) which will be credited to Capital Reserve a/c.
The entry on re-issue of forfeited shares would be as follows:
Bank a/c
360
Share Forfeiture a/c
40
To Share Capital a/c
400
5. The forfeited shares were re-issued at Rs. 9/share. The amount due at the time of forfeiture was
Rs. 2/ share. Thus the profit out of re-issue amounts to Rs. 7/share (Rs. 9 Rs. 2) totalling Rs.
3,500 (500 x 7). The profit on re-issue is to be credited to capital reserve a/c while being debited to
share forfeited a/c.
6. In the trial balance Forfeited Shares A/c will appear on the credit side. In the balance sheet it is
shown as an addition with the paid-up share capital.
7. The brokerage and commission should be calculated on face value of share (Rs. 10 each) and
not on issue price of Rs. 15/shares.
8. Whenever any Journal entries are to be passed, you should remember to give narration alongwith
the entries. The narration carries marks in the examination. The students are generally seen to
forget this important point in their replies.
You should prepare the following working notes to support your answer.
Working Note 1:
Application money received (35,000 shares @ Rs. 6/share)
Less : Amount refunded (10,000 shares @ Rs. 6/share)
Application money available with the company
Adjustment of Application money :
To Share capital a/c
To securities premium a/c
To Share Allotment a/c
Working Note 2: Account of Shares Forfeited :
Amount forfeited on 500 share (at Rs. 13/share)
Adjustment of Share forfeited amount:
To Share Capital a/c ( @ Rs. 8/share)
To securities premium a/c (@ Rs. 5/share)
Working note 3: Computation of profit / loss on re-issue of forfeited shares:
Amount due on forfeited shares (@ Rs. 2/share for 500 shares
Amount received on forfeited shares (@ Rs. 7/share)
Profit on re-issue to be transferred to Capital reserve a/c
Working note 4: Allotment money due:
Allotment money due (Rs. 5/share on 20,000 shares)
Less : Adjustment from application money
Banalce to be called
The Journal entries are as follows
In the books of D Ltd.
Journal Entries
Particulars
Dr. Rs.
Bank A/c
210,000
To Share application a/c
(being the application money received on 35,000 shares @ Rs.
6/share)
Share Application a/c
60,000
To Bank a/c
(application money on 10,000 shares refunded)
Share Application a/c
120,000
Rs.
210,000
60,000
150,000
60,000
60,000
30,000
6,500
4,000
2,500
1,000
3,500
2,500
100,000
30,000
70,000
Cr. Rs.
210,000
60,000
To Share capital
To Securities premium
( application money on 20,000 shares transferred to share capital a/c
and securities premium a/c)
Share Application a/c
30,000
To share allotment a/c
(Excess application money adjusted against allotment money due)
Share allotment a/c
100,000
To Share capital a/c
To securities premium a/c
( amount due on allotment @ Rs. 5/share on 20,000 shares including a
premium of Rs.2/share as per Board's resolution no. Dated)
Bank A/c
70,000
To share allotmetn a/c
(balance of allotment money received in full)
Share First Call a/c
40,000
To Share capital a/c
( call money due @ Rs. 2/share for 20,000 shares)
Bank A/c
40,000
To Share First call money a/c
Share final call money a/c
40,000
To Share capital a/c
(final call due on 20,000 shares @ Rs. 2/share)
Bank A/c
39,000
To Share Final call money
(final call received on 19,500 shares)
Share capital a/c
5,000
To Share final call a/c
To Share forfeited a/c
(500 shares forfeited)
Bank A/c
4,500
Share forfeited a/c
500
To Share capital a/c
(forfeited shares reissued @ Rs. 9/share)
Share forfeited a/c
3,500
To Capital reserve a/c
(profit on reissue transferred to capital reserve a/c)
Brokerage a/c
6,000
Commission a/c
6,000
To Share capital a/c
To securities premium a/c
(Brokerage @ 3% of Rs. 2 lacs and commission @ 3% of Rs. 2 lacs
being paid by shares Rs.10 with premium of Rs.5/share. 800 shares
being issued)
60,000
60,000
30,000
60,000
40,000
70,000
40,000
40,000
40,000
39,000
1,000
4,000
5,000
3,500
8,000
4,000
D Ltd.
Balance sheet as at
Rs. Assets
Fixed assets :
Liabilities
Rs.
Share Capital:
Authorised Capital :
40,000 shares of Rs. 10 each
400,000
Issued, subscribed and paid up capital
Investment
20,800 shares of Rs. 10 each
208,000
Current assets, Loans and
(800 shares being issued on consideration other
advances
than cash)
Reserve and Surplus:
Bank
303,500
Capital reserve
3,500
Securities premium
104,000 Miscellaneous expenditure :
Brokerage on issue of shares
6,000
Commission on issue of share
6,000
315,500
315,500
Problem : CWA Foundation June 2003 revised
Varieties Ltd. issued 30,000 shares of Rs. 10 at Rs. 12 per share payable Rs. 3 on application, Rs. 5
on allotment including premium, Rs. 2 on first and Rs. 2 on final call. Applications were received for
40,000 shares and the company refunded the application money of 4,000 shares and rest of the
excess application money was adjusted with allotment. All the calls were duly paid except Mr. A
holding 300 shares failed to pay the allotment and on his failure to pay 1st call his shares were
forfeited. B holding 200 shares failed to pay the 1st call and on his failure to pay final call his shares
were forfeited. C holding 100 shares failed to pay the final call. The company reissued 450 shares
(including the shares of A) at the rate of Rs. 10 per share.
Pass Journal entries in the Books of the Company.
Solution :
1. The allotment is not on pro-rata basis. This is assumed that Mr. A had applied for 300 shares and
was allotted the same number of shares. Same is the case with B and C.
2. Before the forfeiture, A had paid Rs. 900 as share application. B had paid Rs. 1,600 (Rs. 8 x 200)
i.e. Rs. 1,200 towards share capital and Rs. 400 towards share premium. C had paid Rs. 1,000
(Rs.10 x 100) i.e. Rs. 800 towards share capital and Rs. 200 towards share premium.
3. Note that C has failed to pay the final call. Question does not mention that his shares have been
forfeited. Thus share forfeiture a/c will be credited with Rs. 900 for A and Rs. 1,200 for B (amount
paid by them towards share capital). As the shares of C are not yet forfeited, share forfeiture a/c will
not be affected.
4. You have already studied in tutorial notes of previous questions that the amount paid towards
share premium is not forfeited or written off even if the shares are forfeited in future.
The solution goes as follows :
The various steps of Journal entries have been explained as follows. The explanations are given for
better understanding of the entry and these should not be treated as part of entry.
1. Bank a/c
To Share application
120,000
120,000
120,000
90,000
12,000
18,000
58,800
58,800
At this point shares of B are forfeited. B has paid Rs. 1,200 (200 shares @ Rs. 6/share) towards
share capital a/c which will be forfeited and will be credited to Share forfeiture a/c. B has paid Rs.
600 (200 shares @ Rs. 3/share) towards share premium a/c which will not be forfeited.
Share Capital a/c (200 x Rs.10)
2,000
To Share First call a/c
400
To Share final call a/c
400
To Share forfeiture a/c ( 300 x Rs. 3)
1,200
The company has issued 450 shares out of 500 forfeited shares @ Rs. 10/share. The forfeited
shares were issued earlier at Rs. 12/share including Rs. 2/share as premium. The share premium is
not being called and it will be adjusted against share forfeiture a/c. The balance left with share
forfeiture a/c is Rs. 2,100. Out of this, Rs. 900 (Rs.2/share on 450 shares) will be adjusted towards
share premium a/c and the balance of Rs. 1,200 will be transferred to Capital reserve a/c.
Bank a/c ( Rs. 10 x 450 shares)
4,500
Share forfeited a/c
600
To Share capital a/c (450 x Rs. 2)
4,500
To Share Premium a/c (300 x 2)
600
Share forfeited a/c
1,200
To Capital Reserve a/c
1,200
Problem : (CWA Inter Dec.05)
Flamingo Ltd. offered for public subscription of 5,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each at a premium of
Rs. 2.50 per share payable as follows:
On application Rs. 2, On allotment Rs. 4.50 (including premium), On first call Rs. 4.0 and On second
call Rs. 2.0 per share.
Applications were received for 7,500 shares and allotment was made prorata to applicants of 5,000
shares, letters of regret being issued for remaining applications. Money overpaid on application by
the allottees was adjusted with allotment amount.
Rahim to whom 100 shares were allotted failed to pay the allotment money and on his failure to pay
the first call, his shares were forfeited.
Haq, the holder of 150 shares failed last two calls and his shares were forfeited after the second call
was made.
Of the shares forfeited, 200 shares were allotted as fully paid up to Karim for Rs. 8 per share paid in
cash.
Show journal entries to record the forfeiture and reissue of forfeited shares including those relating
to cash, assuming that the whole of Rahim's shares have been reissued.
Solution :
1. The journal entries are asked only for forfeiture and reissue of forfeited shares. All transactions
are not to be journalised.
2. You should calculate the forfeited amount of Rahim and Haq separately because their shares
were forfeited at different points of time.
3. It is not clear in the question that which shares were allotted to Karim. Two possible combinations
are (i) 100 shares of Rahim and 100 shares of Haq or (ii) 50 shares of Rahim and 150 shares of
Karim. The first combination of 100 shares each of Rahim and Haq is followed here.
4. Let us consider the case of Rahim first. His shares were forfeited when he failed to pay the
allotment money. He was allotted 100 shares. As the allotment was made on prorata basis at the
ratio of 7500 : 5000 or 3:2, Rahim must have applied for 150 shares paying application money of Rs.
300 (150 x 2). The excess money paid with application is Rs. 100 which was adjusted towards
allotment money.
5. At the time of forfeiture, entire amount paid towards the share capital is forfeited and transferred
to Share Forfeiture a/c. Thus for Rahim, the share capital a/c will be debited by Rs. 300 (as the
entire amount of Rs. 300 paid alongwith application was adjusted towards share capital ), and Share
Forfeiture a/c will be credited.
6. A word about the Securities Premium a/c is necessary here. Securities premium a/c may be
created on due basis or payment basis. On due basis the securities premium a/c is also credited
alongwith Share capital a/c when due money is called. On cash basis, the Securities premium a/c is
created only after receiving the actual cash. First method is followed here.
7. So in case of Rahim, the journal entries would be as follows :
At the time of allotment following entry must have been made in the books in respect of Rahim
Share Application a/c
300
To Share Capital
300
He paid Rs. 300 alongwith application and entire money was adjusted with Share capital a/c at the
time of allotment.
Allotment money due is Rs. 4.5 x 100 shares = Rs. 450. Out of this Rs. 100 was excess money with
application, hence net money due would be Rs. 350 consisting of Rs. 100 on share capital a/c and
Rs. 250 on securities premium a/c. The following entries must have been passed.
Allotment money due a/c
350
To Share capital a/c
100
To Securities premium a/c
250
At this point he failed to pay the allotment money but his shares were forfeited only after he failed to
pay the first call money. He was called to pay Rs. 400 (Rs.4 x 100 shares). At the time of first call,
following entries must have been made:
Share First Call a/c
400
To Share Capital a/c
400
So you can see, that at the point of forfeiture the Share capital created was Rs. 800 out of which Rs.
300 was received. For forfeiture of these shares all entries must be reversed and the received
amount of Rs. 300 will be credited to Share Forfeiture a/c. Since no money was received on
Securities Premium a/c, this a/c must also be debited.
The above narration is for better understanding only. You are required to present the following entry
only as per the question :
Thus the required journal entry would be like this :
Share Capital
Securities premium a/c
800
250
Ravi who had applied for 100 shares and who was allotted all the shares applied for could
not pay allotment money. Ruby who was alloted 60 shares on the proportion basis could
not pay the final call. After due notices all such shares were forfeited and re-issued at a
discount of 20% of the face value of the share to Mr. Reddy.
Pass the journal entries to record the above transactions in the books of the Company.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Let us do the computations as per the process of allotment of shares.
2. First step is application money. Application money for 4,000 shares were received @
Rs. 40/share. Thus the application money received is Rs. 160,000. Application money for
1,400 shares (Rs. 56,000) were returned. Application money adjusted towards the share
capital a/c will be Rs. 80,000 (Rs.40 x 2000 shares).
3. The balance of application money Rs. 24,000 (160,000 56,000 80,000), will be
adjusted towards allotment money. The allotment money due is Rs. 100,000 (2000 x Rs.
50) against which Rs. 24,000 has already been received with application. Ravi was alloted
100 shares has failed to pay allotment money of Rs. 5000. This shows that allotmoney
received would be Rs. 71,000 (100,000 24,000 5,000). This is your working note no.
2. Calls in arrears a/c has to be opened here and debited with Rs.5,000 not paid by Ravi.
4. The allotment money includes premium @ Rs. 20/share. Once share premium money
is received, it cannot be written back even if the shares are forfeited in future. Ruby has
failed to pay the call money (60 x Rs. 30). Thus call money received would be Rs. 60,000
less due to Ruby Rs. 1,800 and less due to Ravi Rs. 3,000. Cash received against the call
money would be Rs. 55,200. This is your working note no. 3. Calls in arrears a/c should
be debited with Rs.4,800.
5. The shares are forfeited after final call has been made. The forfeited amount would the
total amount received against share capital a/c. Ravi has paid Rs. 4,000 and Ruby has
paid Rs. 4,200 ( 60 shares x Rs.70), thus amount forfeited would be Rs.8,200. This is your
working note no.4.
6. Number of shares forfeited is 160. Share capital should be debited with Rs. 100 x 160
i.e. Rs.16,000. The money received on these shares on account of share capital would be
forfeited. Money received is (i) 100 shares @ Rs. 40 = Rs. 4,000 and (ii) 60 shares @ Rs.
70 = Rs. 4,200 totalling Rs. 8,200. The balance (16,000 8,200) of Rs. 7,800 will be
debited to calls in arrears a/c.
You can prepare the following working notes :
Disposal of application for 4,000 shares :
Application
200
1,400
2,400
4,000
Amount
received;
Disposal of Application money :
Refund
Allotment
200
0 Rejected
1,800
2,000
Rs. 160,000
56,000
Adjusted in application
Adjusted in allotment
100,000
For allotment :
Amount due
(50 x 2,000)
24,000
Amount adjusted
76,000
Balance to be called
5,000
Amount not paid by Ravi (50 x 100)
71,000
Allotment money received
For Share First and Final Call :
Amount due (30 x 2,000)
Less : Amount not paid
3,000
By Ravi (30 x 100)
1,800
By Rubi (30 x 60)
80,000
24,000 160,000
60,000
4,800
55,200
Journal Entries in the books of ABC Ltd.
Dates and narration have been left for reader.
160,000
Bank a/c
160,000
To Share Application a/c
160,000
Share Application a/c
80,000
To Share Capital a/c
56,000
To Bank a/c
24,000
To Share Allotment a/c
100,000
Share Allotment a/c
60,000
To Share Capital a/c
40,000
To Securities premium a/c
71,000
Bank a/c
5,000
Calls in arrears a/c
76,000
To Share Allotment a/c
60,000
Share First and Final Call a/c
60,000
To Share Capital a/c
55,200
Bank a/c
4,800
Calls in arrears a/c
60,000
To Share First and Final call a/c
16,000
Share capital a/c
2,000
Securities Premium a/c
9,800
To Calls in Arrears a/c
8,200
To Share Forfeited a/c
12,800
Bank a/c
3,200
Share Forfeiture a/c
16,000
To Share Capital a/c
5,000
Share Forfeiture a/c
5,000
To Capital Reserve a/c
(ii) Resolution must specify the maximum discount allowed. Resolution must be passed at GM and
sanctioned by CG.
(iii) Not allowed within one year from the date of commencement of business.
(iv) Issue must be made within time limit sanctioned by the CG.
Section 79 A : Issue of Sweat Equity Shares
Debit bank and credit Share application a/c with the amount received.
Rs. lacs
Bank
15
To Share appl. a/c
15
Convert Share application a/c to Share capital a/c by the following entry:
Share App. a/c
15
To Share capital a/c
15
Option 1 : The Securities premium a/c is created at the time of money being Due:
Share capital must be created before making call for allotment money by the following entry:
Share allotment a/c
20
To Share Capital a/c
10
To Securities Premium a/c
10
Bank
20
To Share allotment a/c
20
Option 2 : The Securities premium a/c is created at the time of actual receipt of money
In this case, only Share capital is created although the money is demanded inclusive of premium.
In this case, the amount of premium is ignored when is passed for making the allotment money (or the call)
due. Thus Share allotment a/c will be debited and Share capital a/c will be credited with the amount of portion
of share capital. No entry is passed for premium becoming due.
Share allotment a/c
10
To Share Capital a/c
10
When the allotment money is actually received, Bank will be debited with the total amount received and Share
allotment a/c will be credited for share capital portion only and Securities Premium a/c will be credited with the
amount of premium.
Bank
20
ca inter
ca final
4
1
0
6
11
A note on determination of capital employed for the purpose of evaluating Goodwill :
Determination of capital employed is hard not because of any computational complexity but because of
diverse opinion in respect of inclusion or exclusion of items. A wide spread view is to recognise the capital
employed as fixed assets (less depreciation) plus working capital. This may also be expressed as
aggregate of share capital, reserves and retained earnings and long term loans (less of course, the
fictitious assets like preliminary expenses, debit balance of profit and loss a/c, discount on issue of shares
etc). Non-trading assets, that is, assets acquired because of spare funds such as government securities,
bonds or other outside investments, are excluded.
One school of thought views goodwill as an advantage accruing to the shareholders of the company and as
such the amount of debentures and long-term loans should be excluded from capital employed. The
meaning of capital is funds of owener. If this stand is taken, capital employed should include only those
amounts which belong to the oweners i.e. the shareholders.
In most of the model answers supplied by ICAI, debentures and the long term loans have been excluded
from capital employed whereas in the model answers supplied by ICWAI, the debentures and long term
loans have been taken as components of capital employed in majority of instances.
The question is generally silent in this respect as to the components of capital employed. You can take your
own stand but whatever stand you take, you must invariably state your assumption.
When capital employed is computed taking only the funds belonging to shareholders, in consideration, it is
termed as equity approach. If long-term loans are also included in capital employed, it is called long-term
fund approach. Both approaches naturally lead to different values of goodwill.
Since the profits are expressed in terms of current prices, it is proper that the fixed assets and current
assets should also be valued at current prices. While doing this, the additional depreciation on revalued
assets should also be kept in mind.
Capital employed should be computed with revised value of stocks. You have to keep this revised value in
mind while computing the FMF. Students generally loose sight of this point. The take the revised value of
fixed assets while computing the capital employed but forget to take additional depreciation in computation
of FMF. You should be aware of this lacuna. Any increase or decrease in value of stocks should not only be
reflected in the computation of capital employed but also in computation of FMF.
As a prudent practice, the goodwill should be computed not on actual capital employed but on average
capital employed.
Problem 1: CWA Inter June 05
The balance sheet (summarised) of Tinkar Ltd. as on March 31, 2005 was as follows :
Liabilities
Rs. Assets
Rs.
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
5000000 Goodwill
500,000
General Reserve
1000000 Plant & machinery
5500000
Dividend Equilisation
500,000 Investments
500,000
Share Premium
300,000 Stocks
800,000
Profit and loss a/c
200,000 Debtors
950,000
Creditors
1500000 Cash and Bank
250,000
8500000
8500000
The company's profit and loss a/c for the year ended 31 March, 2005 showed a net profit (before tax) of
Rs. 25,00,000. The profit includes interest on investment of Rs. 50,000. Goodwill is being written off Rs.
50,000 per annum.
The applicable income tax rate is 40%. It is expected that the company will be able to maintain its present
level of performance. Plant & machinery is revalued at Rs. 70,00,000. Future depreciation charge is to go
up by Rs. 100,000. Normal return on capital employed may be taken as 10%.
Compute the value of goodwill of the company based on 4 years' purchase of maintainable super profit.
The capital employed figure is to be calculated on the basis of last year end position.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Use figures in lacs or thousands to save time and labour. It is more convenient as well.
2. Super profit is excess of actual profit over normal profit. Normal profit is given as 10% on capital
employed. The capital employed is not given, it is to be computed. Think how can you compute the capital
employed. You should compute the capital employed from the liabilities side as well as from the assets
side.You can compute normal profit as 10% of capital employed.
3. How will you calculate average profit ? How will it be adjusted for income from investments and
additional depreciation ?
3. Actual profit implies profit from trading activity. The investment is not a trading activity and its income
should be excluded while computing profit for the purpose of valuation of shares and goodwill. Average
profit is given as Rs. 25 lacs. Average profit less income from investment less taxes will give you actual
profit. Note that additional depreciation is to be provided. What will you do with goodwill of Rs.50,000
written off during the year ?
4. Once average profit is known, super profit being the difference between average profit and normal profit
becomes known. The Goodwill will be four times the super profit.
The solution goes as follows :
Computation of capital employed :
Capital employed will be computed on revalued figures because the maintainable profit is futuristic in
nature.
From Liability side
Rs. lacs From Assets side
Rs. lacs
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each
50 Plant & machinery
70
General Reserve
10 Stocks
8
Dividend Equilisation
5 Debtors
10
Share Premium
3 Cash and Bank
3
Profit and loss a/c
2
90
Add:Capital reserve due to revaluation
15 Less: Creditors
15
85 Capital employed
75
Less: Investment outside business
5
Less: Intangible asset Goodwill
5
Capital Employed
75
Computation of average profit and Goodwill :
Rs. lacs
Profit before tax
25.0
Less:
Additional Depreciation
1.0
Income from Investment
0.5
Add :
Goodwill written off
0.5
1.0
Adjusted profit before tax
24.0
Less : Tax @ 40%
9.6
Profit after tax
14.4
Less : Normal return
7.5
Super Profit
6.9
Goodwill (4 years' super profit)
27.6
Problem 2: (CWA Inter June 05)
The balance sheet of Bomex Ltd as at 31 March 2005 was as follows :
Liabilities
Assets
Equity shares (Rs. 10)
1000000 Goodwill
200,000
General Reserves
500,000 Equipment at cost
1800000
200,000 Stocks
700,000
600,000 Debtors
300,000
300,000 Cash and bank
150,000
80,000 Advertisement suspense
50,000
150,000 account
370,000
3200000
3200000
You are required to calculate the value of each share on assets basis.
The following information is available :
(1) A fair after tax return on capital employed for this type of business is 18%.
(2) Equipment is to be revalued at Rs. 16,00,000.
(3) Stocks are considered to have a net realisable value of Rs. 600,000.
(4) Goodwill in this type of business is normally valued at 3 years' super profits.
(5) Included in debtors is a balance of Rs. 20,000 which may prove irrecoverable.
(6) Profits for the last three years before interest and taxes are :
2004--05 Rs. 10,80,000
2003--04 Rs. 10,20,00
2002--03 Rs. 11,00,000
(7) Company profits are taxed at 40%.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Use figures in Rs.'000 to reduce time and labour.
2. Compute the capital employed from both the sides of balance sheet.
3. The net value of equipment is Rs. 15.0 lacs (18.0 depreciation 3.0 lacs). Thus equipment is to be
revalued at Rs. 16.0 lacs. The increased value will demand additional depreciation to be provided on
equipment. The question is silent about this matter. You can make a mention of it in your answer and state
that depreciation on additional value has been ignored. The revaluation of equipment will have no impact
on current year profit but will be used in determination of capital employed.
4. Staff welfare fund is not a liability at all. It can be taken as part of capital employed if you are calculating
it from the liabilities side. It can be ignored if you are calculating the capital employed from assets side.
5. Debentures may be or may not be taken as part of capital employed. You must state your assumption in
this regard. In the following solution the debentures are taken as part of capital employed hence the
interest payable thereon has not been deducted from operating profit.
3. While determining the capital employed, you may wonder what to do with advertisement suspense
account. The question is silent about it. You may assume that it has no realisable value and should
therefore be ignored. Similarly the staff welfare fund is not a liability but proposed dividend is.
7. Current year profit of Rs. 10,80,000 will have to adjusted in the light of new valuations. The stock is
devalued by Rs. 40,000 while debtors are devalued by Rs. 20,000. The current year profit will be taken as
Rs. 10.20 lacs for computation of goodwill.
Computation of capital employed :
From Liabilities side
Rs.'000
Equity shares
1,000
General Reserve
500
Profit and loss a/c
200
12% Debentures
600
Provision for depreciation
300
Staff Welfare fund
80
Less:
Decrease in equipment
200
Decrease in stock value
40
2,690
520
2,170
Bad debts
20
Advertising suspense
50
Goodwill
200
Capital employed
Alternatively :
From Liabilities side
Equity shares
General Reserve
Profit and loss a/c
12% Debentures
Staff Welfare fund
Add : Increase in value of equipment
510
2,170
Rs.'000
1,000
500
200
600
80
2,380
100
2,480
Less:
Decrease in stock value
40
Bad debts
20
Advertising suspense
50
Goodwill
200
310
Capital employed
2,170
Computation of actual profit for the year 2004--05 :
Rs.'000
Profit as per profit and loss a/c (without adjustments)
1,080.0
Less :
Decrease in value of stock
40.0
Bad debts
20.0
Adjusted profit before tax
1,020.0
Average annual operating profit before interest ( debentures are treated as part of capital employed) :
(10.20 + 10.20 + 11.00) / 3
Rs. lacs
1,047.0
Less : Tax @ 40%
418.8
Profit after tax
628.2
Less : Normal return @ 18% of capital employed
390.6
Super Profit
237.6
Goodwill at 3 years profit
(237.6 x 3)
712.8
Computation of Net assets and value per share :
Rs.'000
Capital employed
2,170.00
Add : Goodwill
712.80
Less : Debentures
600.00
Net assets available to equity shareholders
2,282.80
Intrinsic value of equity share ex-dividend 2,282.80 / 100 = Rs. 22.82
Intrinsic value of equity share cum-dividend (2,282.80 + 150) / 100 = Rs. 24.32
Problem 3:(CWA Inter June 07)
From the following Balance sheet of A Ltd. as at 31st March, 2007, compute the value of Goodwill on the
basis of Super profits method assuming 3 years' purchase. Show necessary workings.
Liabilities
5000, 10% Pref. shares of Rs. 10 fully paid
25,000 equity shares of Rs.10 fully paid
Profit and loss a/c
Balance on 1.4.06
30,000
Add: Profit for 2007
170,000
Creditors
The following information is furnished to you:
Rs.
Assets
50,000 Building less depreciation
250,000 Plant & machinery less depre.
Investment @ 8% p.a.
Stock
200,000 Debtors
20,000 Cash at bank
520,000
Rs.
150,000
200,000
50,000
40,000
60,000
20,000
520,000
Average profit before tax of the company is Rs. 12,00,000 and 12.5% of the profit is transferred to general
reserve, rate of taxation being 50%. Normal dividend expected on equity shares is 8% while fair return on
capital employed is 10%. Goodwill may be valued at 3 years' purchase of super profits.
Ascertain the value of each equity share under fair value method.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Use figures in lacs or thousands to save time and labour. It is more convenient as well.
2. Super profit is excess of actual profit over normal profit. Normal profit is given as 10% on capital
employed. The capital employed is not given, it is to be computed. Think how can you compute the capital
employed. You should compute the capital employed from the liabilities side as well as from the assets
side.You can compute normal profit as 10% of capital employed.
3. Actual profit implies profit from trading activity. The investment is not a trading activity and its income
should be excluded while computing profit for the purpose of valuation of shares. Average profit is given as
Rs. 12 lacs. Average profit less income from investment less taxes will give you actual profit. Note that
income from investment will be 10% of its normal value and Not of balance sheet value nor of present
market value.
4. Super profit can now be calculated as excess of actual profit over normal profit. The goodwill is three
times super profit. Compute goodwill which will be used in computation of intrinsic value of shares.
5. Transfer to reserve and preference dividend will have to be removed from actual profit to compute return
to shareholders.
6. Fair value of share is average of Intrinsic value and Yield value. Yield value is very easy to calculate. The
trading profit after tax and pref. dividend is the profit available to shareholders. This is yield when
expressed as %.
7. For computation of intrinsic value, Goodwill will have to be computed. Goodwill is given in balance sheet
as Rs. 5,00,000. This should NOT be taken for valuation of shares because the question specifically asks
you to compute the goodwill as three years purchase of super profits.
8. Intrinsic value for equity shareholders is sum of Capital employed plus Goodwill plus Investment less
preference capital. Intrinsic value per share is Total intrinsic value / no. of shares.
9. You should attempt to solve this problem on the above lines and compare your solution with solution
given below.
Solution goes as follows :
Computation of capital employed :
From Liabilities side
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each
12% Pref. shares of Rs. 100 each
General Reserve
Profit and loss a/c
Rs. Lacs
10.00
10.00
6.00
4.00
Add : Revaluation
Building
17.00
Less: Liabilities
Plant
8.00
15% Debentures
10.00
Stock
(1.50)
Creditors
8.00
Debtors
(0.40)
23.10 Capital employed
Less :
Goodwill
5.00
Preliminary expenses
2.20
Investment outside business
4.80
12.00
Capital employed
41.10
Normal profit is 10% of the capital employed : 10% of Rs. 41.10 lacs i.e. Rs.4.11 lacs.
Computation of Average profit and yield value of shares
Rs. Lacs
Average profit as given
12.00
Rs. Lacs
32.00
18.00
4.50
3.60
1.00
59.10
18.00
41.10
0.50
11.50
Less tax @ 50%
5.75
Actual profit
5.75
Less transfer to reserve @ 12.50%
0.72
5.03
Less : Preference dividend
1.20
Profit for equity shareholders
3.83
No. of shares in lacs
10.00
Yield % ( Profit / No. of shares)
38.30%
Value per share when normal dividend is 8% = (38.30% x 10) / 8
Rs. 47.90
Computation of super profit and valuation of goodwill :
Actual profit
5.75
Normal profit as 10% of capital employed
4.11
Super profit
1.64
Goodwill as three years' purchase of super profits
4.92
Net assets for equity shareholders :
Capital employed
41.10
Goodwill
4.92
Investment
4.80
Less : Preference capital
(10.00)
Net assets for equity shareholders
40.82
No. of shares in lacs
1.00
Intrinsic value of shares
Rs. 40.82
Value per share as per fair value method = Average of (Intrinsic value + Yield value)
= ( Rs. 47.90 + Rs. 40.82) / 2 = Rs. 44.36
Problem 5 : (CS Inter Dec. 08)
The balance sheet of Beauty Ltd. as at 31st March, 2008 was as follows :
Liabilities
Rs. Assets
Rs.
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each
10,00,000 Goodwill
2,00,000
General reserves
5,00,000 Equipment at cost
18,00,000
Profit and loss a/c
2,00,000 Stocks
7,00,000
12% Debentures
6,00,000 Debtors
3,00,000
Provision for depreciation on equipments
3,00,000 Cash at bank
1,50,000
Staff welfare fund
80,000 Advertisement suspense a/c
50,000
Proposed dividend
1,50,000
Sundry creditors
3,70,000
32,00,000
32,00,000
The following further information is available :
(i) For this type of business, a fair return on capital employed after tax is 18%.
(ii) Equipments are to be revalued at Rs. 16,00,000.
(iii) Stocks are considered to have a net realisable value of Rs. 6,60,000.
(iv) Goodwill in this type of business is normally valued at 3 years' super profits.
(v) Included in the debtors is a balance of Rs. 20,000 which may prove irrecoverable.
(vI) Profits for the last three years (before interest and taxed) are as follows :
Year
2007 08 : Rs. 10,80,000
2006 -- 07 Rs. 10,20,000
2005 -- 06 Rs. 11,00,000
(vii) Company profits are taxed @ 40%.
You are required to calculate :
(i) value of goodwill (ii) Value of each equity share on net asset basis.
Solution :
Tutorial notes :
2006 -- 07
2005 -- 06
10.20
11.00
31.40
Rs. Lacs
Average profit before interest and taxes
(31.40/3)
10.47
Less : Interest on debentures @ 12% on Rs. 6.0 lacs
0.72
Profit before taxes
9.75
Less : Tax @ 40%
3.90
Profit after tax
5.85
Less : Normal profit on capital employed @ 18% on Rs. 15.70 lacs
2.83
Annual super profit
3.02
Goodwill at three years' of super profit
9.06
Answer (ii) Calculation of net assets :
Capital employed
15.70
Add : Goodwill
9.06
Net assets available to shareholders
24.76
No. of share in lacs
1.00
Intrinsic value of equity share
(24.76 / 1.00)
24.76
Problem 6: (CA Final Nov. 03)
The balance sheets of R Ltd. for the year ended on 31/03/00, 31/03/01 and 31/03/02 are as follows :
Liabilities
(in Rs.)
31/3/00
31/03/01
31/03/02
320,000 Equity shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
3,200,000
3,200,000
3,200,000
General Reserve
2,400,000
2,800,000
3,200,000
Profit and loss a/c
280,000
320,000
480,000
Creditors
1,200,000
1,600,000
2,000,000
7,080,000
7,920,000
8,880,000
Assets :
Goodwill
2,000,000
1,600,000
1,200,000
Building and Machinery(less : Depre.)
2,800,000
3,200,000
3,200,000
Stock
2,000,000
2,400,000
2,800,000
Debtors
40,000
320,000
880,000
Banak Balance
240,000
400,000
800,000
7,080,000
7,920,000
8,880,000
Actual valuation were as under:
Building and Machinery
3,600,000
4,000,000
4,400,000
Stock
2,400,000
2,800,000
3,200,000
Net profit (including opening balance)
(after writing off goodwill and depreciation,
tax provision and transfer to G.reserve)
840,000
1,240,000
1,640,000
Capital employed in the business at market values at the beginning of 1999 2000 was Rs. 73,20,000,
which included the cost of goodwill. The normal annual return on average capital employed in the line of
business engaged by R Ltd. is 12.5%.
The balance in the General Reserve account on 1st April, 1999 was Rs. 20 lakhs.
The goodwill shown on 31/03/2000 was purchased on 1/4/1999 for Rs. 20,00,000 on which date the
balance in the Profit and loss a/c was Rs. 240,000. Find out the average capital employed each year.
Goodwill is to be valued at 5 years purchase of super profits (simple average method). Also find out the
total value of the business as on 31.3.2002.
Solution :
Tutorial notes :
1. Read the tutorial notes of the previous problem carefully. Use figures in Rs. ' 000.
2. Goodwill has been acquired on payment basis. The cost should be included in capital employed.
3. Closing capital of a year would be opening capital of subsequent year.
31/03/02
3,200
3,200
480
1,200
400
8,480
7,520
8,000
1,000
1,200
4,400
3,200
880
800
10,480
2,000
8,480
7,520
8,000
1,640
320
400
400
1,320
400
400
2,120
1,000
1,120
Rs.' 000
4,110
4,400
3,200
880
800
13,390
2,000
11,390
Rs. Lakhs
148.30
0.50
2.00
5.00
18.00
13.30
2.70
6.40
47.90
100.40
8. The exchange rate gains / losses should be adjusted in pre-tax profit. All non recurring items, should
also be properly adjusted. Find out the FMF. Reduce it by 40% (not 50%) to arrive at FMF after tax.
9. The capitalisation method and super profit method should be employed to arrive at goodwill.
10. Tersely speaking, this problem can be solved on the following lines. (i) find out the average capital
employed with balance sheet figures taking fixed assets and stock, at their current value. (ii) find out the
profit after tax from the above data. Adjust tax of 50% and find the pre-tax profit.(iii) Adjust the pre-tax
profit, in the light of (a) non-trading income (b) exchange rate fluctuations in debtors and creditors (c) non
recurring items of subsidy and R&D expenditure and (d) for the revaluation of stock. You must be careful
while computing exchange loss/gain on creditors/debtors.
Solve on the above lines and compare your solution with the one given below.
The solution goes as follows:
1. Average Capital Employed :
31/3/06
31/3/07 Outside liabilities
Rs. Lakhs
Current cost of fixed assets
2,200.0
2,532.8 Term Loans
370.0
330.0
Current cost of stock
670.0
750.0 Creditors
70.0
96.0
Debtors
340.0
222.8 Tax provision
22.5
25.0
Cash and Bank
92.5
100.0
Err:522
Err:522
3,302.5
3,605.6
Less: Outside liabilities
462.5
451.0
2,840.0
3,154.6
Average capital employed : (2840 + 3154.6) / 2
2,997.3
Normal profit @ 15%
449.6
2. Future Maintainable Profit:
1. The profit after tax can be determined with balance sheet figures. Can you determine? Try yourself.
Increase in general reserve
50.0
Increase in profit and loss a/c
55.0
Proposed dividend
250.0
Profit after tax
355.0
Profit before tax (tax rate 50%)
710.0
Less:
Non-trading income
49.0
Exchange loss on creditors
(21.5 16.5) x 1.20 lakh
6.0
Subsidy
120.0
Closing stock at old figures
600.0
Opening stock at new figures
670.0
1,445.0
Add:
Exchange gain on debtors
(21.5 17.5) x 0.70 lakh
2.8
R and D costs
247.0
Opening stock at old figures
550.0
Closing stock at new figures
750.0
1,550
Adjusted Pre-tax profit
814.8
Less : Tax 40%
325.9
Future Maintainable Profit
488.9
3. Valuation of Goodwill :
(1) Capitalisation Method
2. Super Profit Method
Value of FMF @ 15% (488.9 / 0.15)
3,259.2 FMF
488.9
Less: Average Capital employed
2,997.3 Normal profit
449.6
261.9 (15% of capital employed)
39.3
Under both the methods, the exists some value for goodwill. The contention of director is not correct.
Problem 9: (CA Final May 2004)
On the basis of the following information, calculate the value of goodwill of Gee Ltd. at three years
purchase of super profits, if any, earned by the company in the previous four completed accounting years.
2000
2001
2002
3,190
2,500
3,108
Adjustments
(100)
50
(54)
3,090
2,550
3,054
Weights
1
2
3
Weighted profits
3,090
5,100
9,162
Weighted average profit : 28,736 / (4+3+2+1)
2003
2,900
(54)
2,846
4
11,384
28,736
2,874
50
2,824
988
1,836
1,620
216
647
144.8
14.5
24.2
(2.0)
4.0
26.2
Less :
Income tax @ 45%
11.8
Future Maintainable Profit
14.4
Average Capital Employed :
Goodwill will obviously, be not considered for computation of capital employed.
Assets
Rs. Lakhs
Land and buildings at cost
32.0
Plant & machinery at cost
28.0
Stock
32.0
Debtors considered good
20.0
112.0
Less :
Outside liabilities
Bank overdraft
18.6
Creditors
21.1
Provision for taxation
5.1
44.8
67.2
Add :
Dividend paid during the year @ 15%
7.5
Less :
Half of the profit earned during the year
8.5
Average Capital Employed :
66.2
Normal Profit :
Average dividend for past four years : (10+10+15+15) / 4 = 12.50%
Market price of the share
Rs. 125.0
Normal return : 12.50 / 125.0
= 10%
Valuation of Goodwill :
FMF
14.4
Less : Normal profit @ 10% on capital employed
6.6
Super Profit
7.8
Goodwill at 3 years purchase of super profit
23.4
Problem 11: (CA Final Nov. 06)
The following is the extract of Balance sheets of Popular Ltd. :
Liabilities
31/3/04
31/3/05 Assets
31/3/04
31/3/05
Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs
Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs
Share capital
500
500 Fixed assets
550
650
General reserve
400
425 10% Investments
250
250
Profit and loss a/c
60
90 Stock
260
300
18% Term Loan
180
165 Debtors
170
110
Creditors
35
45 Cash at bank
46
45
Provision for tax
11
13 Fictitious assets
10
8
Proposed Dividend
100
125
1,286
1,363
1,286
1,363
Additional Information :
(i) Replacement values of fixed assets were Rs. 1,100 lakhs on 31/3/04 and Rs. 1,250 lakhs on 31/3/05
respectively.
(ii) Rate of depreciation adopted on fixed assets was 5% p.a.
(iii) 50% of the stock is to be valued at 120% of its book value.
(iv) 50% of investments were trade investments.
(v) Debtors on 31/3/05 included foreign debtors of $ 35,000 recorded in the books at Rs. 35 per US Dollar.
The closing exchange rate was $ 1 = Rs. 39.
(vi) Creditors on 31/3/05 included foreign creditors of $ 60,000 recorded in the books at $ 1 = Rs.33. The
closing exchange rate was $ 1 = Rs.39.
(vii) Profits for the year 2004 05 included Rs. 60 lakhs of government subsidy which was not likely to
recur.
(viii) Rs. 125 lakhs of R and D expenditure was written off to the profit and loss a/c in the current year. The
expenditure was not likely to recur.
(ix) Future maintainable profits (pre-tax) are likely to be higher by 10%.
(x) Tax rate during the 2004 05 was 50%, effective future tax rate will be 40%.
(xi) Normal rate of return expected is 15%.
One of the directors of the company Arvind, fears that the company does not enjoy a goodwill in the
prevalent market circumstances.
Critically examine this and establish whether Popular Company has or has not any goodwill.
If your answers were positive on the existence of goodwill, show the leverage effect it has on the
company's results.
Industry average return was 12% on long-term funds and 15% on equity.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes:
1. The capital employed can be deternimed in two ways viz. with equity approach where only shareholders'
funds are considered and with long-term funds approach in which the long-term funds are also considered
as components of capital employed. Capital employed may also be determined as average of the capitals
employed of both years or adding back half year profits to the closing capital employed. Both will give you
different amount of capital employed. You must express your stand clearly in your answer.
2. What do you make out by the term leverage effect on goodwill ? Leverage implies existence of debt in
the capital structure. To show leverage effect on goodwill, you should determine goodwill with and without
debts and show the difference.
3. Additiona information says that rate of depreciation on fixed assets is 5%. Where do you intend to use
this information?
4. Since the profits are expressed in terms of current prices, it is proper that the fixed assets and current
assets should also be valued at current prices. While doing this, the additional depreciation on revalued
assets should also be kept in mind.
5. Fictitious assets go down from Rs. 10 lakhs to Rs. 8 lakhs, where will you use this information?
6. Capital employed should be computed with revised value of stocks. You have to keep this revised value
in mind while computing the FMF. Students generally loose sight of this point. The take the revised value of
fixed assets while computing the capital employed but forget to take additional depreciation in computation
of FMF. You should be aware of this lacuna.
1. Determination of Capital employed :
Assets
31/3/04
31/3/05
Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs
1,100
1,250
286
330
125
125
170
111
46
45
1,727
1,861
180
165
35
49
11
13
226
227
1,501
1,634
1,568
Rs. Lakhs
25
30
Proposed Dividend
Closing capital as on 31/3/05
Less : Half of actual profit for 2004-05
125
180
1,634
90
1,544
267 / 0.12
1,568
172
1,740
2,225
1,740
485
113
Similarly Prepaid expenses are different from Preliminary expenses. Prepaid expense is a
current asset while Preliminary expense is a fictitious asset.
Divisible Profit : Divisible profits means profits available for distribution of dividend to shareholders.
The company is governed by the Companies Act 1956 and as such, it must compute profit in
accordance with recognised accounting standards and policies.
Sources for payment of dividend :
Dividend can be declared only after adequate provision for depreciation.
1. Current Year Profit : Provisions of section 205 must be followed.
2. Previous years Profit :
3. Aggregate Profits : Current year profit plus previous year profits.
4. Moneys provided by State / Central Govt. for this purpose.
For distribution of dividend, the company must ensure compliance with the following :
1. Depreciation : Full depreciation upto the date of declaration must be provided.
2. Past Losses : Amount of loss or amount of depreciation WEL (whichever is less) should be
provided.
3. Transfer to Reserves Section 205 provisions should be followed.
4. Dividend out of Reserves (sec. 205) : Declaration of dividend out of reserves rules 1975 must
be followed.
5. Dividend out of Guarantee Money : A company can also declare dividend out of the moneys
provided by state / central Govt. for the purpose.
6. Dividend out of Capital profits : Capital profits are included in divisible profits, provided
1. The Capital profits remain after revaluation of all assets and liabilities.
2. The Capital profit is realised in cash.
3. The Articles of Association permit such distribution.
Transfer of Profits to Reserves Rules 1975:
Proposed rate of Dividend
% of Profit to be transferred to reserves:
Upto 10%
Nil
Exceeding 10% but not exceeding 12.5%
Not less than 2.5% of current year profits
Exceeding 12.5% but not exceeding 15%
Not less than 5% of current year profits
Exceeding 15% but not exceeding 20%
Not less than 7.5% of current year profits
Exceeding 20%
Not less than 10% of current year profits
Declaration of Dividend out of Reserves Rules 1975
Following conditions must be satisfied for utilisation of reserves for distribution as dividend:
1. The rate of dividend must be 10% or the average of the rates of five preceding years, WEL
(whichever is less)
2. The amount drawn from such reserves should not exceed an amount equal to one-tenth of the
sum of its paid up capital (not authorised capital) and free reserves. The amount so drawn must first
be utilized to set off losses incurred in the current fy and only the balance can be utilized for the
declaration of dividend.
3. The balance of reserves after such draw shall not fall below 15% of its paid up capital. Capital
includes Preference and Equity shares both.
Transfers not permitted from following reserves :
Following capital profits are not permitted for declaration of dividend :
(i) Securities Premium (ii) Profit on re-issue of forfeited shares (iii) Capital Redemption Reserve (iv)
Profits made prior to incorporation (v) Profit on revaluation of reserve.
Problem : (CA Inter Nov. 98)
The trial balance of Complex Ltd. as at 31st March, 1998, shows the following items :
Particulars
Dr. Rs.
Cr. Rs.
Advance payment of Income tax
220,000
120,000
The following further information are given :
(1) Advance payment of income-tax includes Rs. 140,000 for 96 - 97.
(2) Actual tax liability for 96 - 97 amounts to Rs. 152,000 and no effect for the same has so far been
given in accounts.
(3) Provision for income - tax has to be made for 97 - 98 for Rs. 160,000.
You are required to prepare (i) Provision for income-tax account (ii) advance payment of income-tax
account (iii) Liabilities for taxation account and also show, how the relevant items will appear in profit
and loss a/c and balance sheet of the company.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Advance payment for tax was paid Rs. 140,000. As the final accounts were not ready, the tax
liability could not be ascertained.
2. From the trial balance, final accounts are prepared. On the basis of self assessment, the
company makes the provision of Rs. 120,000 for tax. Profit and loss a/c is closed.
3. Tax liability is finally assessed as Rs. 152,000 for 96 - 97. Payment has already been made at Rs.
140,000. Rs. 12,000 now remains to be paid.
You can draw accounts in the same sequence as above.
First let us take advance payment of tax a/c. The opening balance is Rs. 220,000. In Rs. 220,000,
advance payment of Rs. 140,000 for 96 - 97 is included. The liability for 96 - 97 has been
ascertained as Rs. 152,000. Which of these figures will appear in Advance payment of Tax a/c ?
The advance payment of Rs. 140,000 will be adjusted against the liability of Rs. 152,000. The
advance payment of Rs. 140,000 will now be transferred to Provision for tax a/c. Credit Advance
payment of tax a/c and debit Provision for tax a/c. Draw the ledger of Advance payment of tax a/c.
Now you can come to Provision for tax a/c. It has an opening balance on credit side of Rs. 120,000.
Total tax liability has been ascertained as Rs. 152,000 which means an additional amount of Rs.
32,000 will have to be withdrawn from Profit and loss appropriation a/c (the profit and loss a/c for 9697 is already drawn and closed).
While drawing Provision for tax a/c, how will you enter the tax liability of Rs. 152,000 ? The tax
liability is entered in two parts (i) advance payment of tax of Rs. 140,000 and (ii) balance tax to be
paid of Rs. 12,000. The balance to be paid is termed either as tax liability a/c or as tax payable a/c.
You can now draw the Provision for tax a/c.
The provision required for 97 - 98 is Rs. 160,000. There is no balance in Provision for tax a/c as the
entire provision of Rs. 120,000 was consumed by tax liability of Rs. 150,000. The entire provision of
Rs. 160,000 will have to be drawn from profit and loss a/c of 97 - 98. Make a simple entry and draw
the Provision for tax 97 - 98 a/c.
Advance Payment of Tax a/c
To Opening balance
220,000 By Provision for Tax a/c
140,000
By Closing balance
80,000
220,000 (balancing figure)
220,000
Provision for Tax a/c (96 97)
To Advance payment of tax a/c
140,000 By Opening balance
120,000
To Tax payable a/c
12,000 By Profit and loss appropriation a/c
32,000
152,000
152,000
Liability for taxation a/c
The tax liability is the difference between Advance tax paid and Actual tax liability. The liability for
taxation arises only when actual tax liability comes out to be more than the advance payment of tax.
The liability for tax is closed by debiting Provision for taxation a/c.
When tax is finally assessed, it is debited to Income tax a/c or to Provision for income tax a/c. It is
adjusted for Advance payment of tax a/c and the remaining balance is credited to Tax liability a/c.
The following journal entry is passed:
Provision for tax a/c
152,000
2. Profit is determined after providing for depreciation and taxation. Transfer to reserve would be as
follows :
Profit for the year
Less :
Depreciation
Taxation
Profit for the year
Transfer to reserve @ 20%
31,200
80,000
111,200
888,800
177,760
711,040
3. Second condition says 10% of equity dividend shall be set aside for staff bonus. Dividend would
be 20% of 70,000 x Rs. 10 = Rs. 140,000. The amount of staff bonus would be Rs. 14,000 (10% of
Rs. 140,000).
Balance available after providing staff bonus :
Less :
Less :
Less :
Less :
711,040
14,000
697,040
Section 80
(iii) Shares will be redeemed out of profits of the company available for distribution as
dividends
OR fromwill
thebeproceeds
fresh
issue
of shares
the purpose
of redemption.
(iv) The premium
providedofout
of the
profits
or out for
of Securities
Premium
a/c before the
shares
arewill
redeemed.
(v)
Profits
be transferred first to Capital Redemption a/c with nominal value of shares to be
Methods
of Redemption :
(a) From the proceeds of fresh issue of shares;
redeemed.
(b) From the undistributed profits
(c) Combination of both
Capital redemption reserve a/c must be credited with an amount equal to amount repaid on
account
face value lessof
proceeds
of a fresh
capital made1996),
for theapurpose
of cannot
After
theof
commencement
the Company's
Actissue
1956of(Amendmend
company
redemption.
The
Capital
redemption
reserve
a/c
can
be
used
only
for
issue
of
fully
paid
issue
any
preference
share,
which
is
irredeemable
or
is
redeemable
after
the
expiry
of
abonus
The proceeds from issue of debentures cannot be utilised for the purpose.
shares,
this
a/c
cannot
be
distributed
as
dividend
period
of
twenty
years
from
the
date
of
issue.
Section 78 : Issue of Shares at Premium :
The Companies (Amendment) Act, 1999 has substituted the word '' securities' for the
word
'share'
it occurs
in Section
78 of the Companies
Act,
1956.
You should
Section
78 of wherever
the Companies
Act 1956
states that:Securities
Premium
may
be applied
for
use
Securities
Premium
A/c
in
place
of
Share
Premium
A/c.
(i) issue of fully paid bonus shares (ii) writing off preliminary expenses (iii) writing off discount
(commission)
and
debentures
(iv) providing
for premium
payableononredemp.
redemption
It is interestingon
to shares
note that
clause
(vi) of section
78, provides
for premium
of of
shares
and
debentures.
Pref.shares
to be
adjusted
Problem
(cwa
stage
1 Decagainst
2002) Securities Premium a/c but for redemption itself cannot be
financed
out
of
Securities
Premium
a/c.as on 31st December, 2001, inter alia includes the
The Balance sheet of M/s Raman Ltd.
Rs.
following :
50,000, 8% preference shares of Rs. 100 each, Rs. 70 paid up
35,00,000
1,00,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each, fully paid up
1,00,00,000
Securities Premium
5,00,000
Capital Redemption Reserve
25,00,000
General Reserve
45,00,000
The Board decided to redeem the entire preference share capital at a premium of 5% on
31.03.02.
In order
to finance
the redemption,
the Company
makes aconditions
right issueofofsection
50,00080 of
The preference
shares
were redeemed
after fulfilling
the necessary
equity
shares
of
Rs.
100
each
at
Rs.
110
per
share,
Rs.
20
being
payable
on
application,
Rs.
the Companies
1956.inThe
company
decided
to make
minimum
utilisation
of general
Show
the journalAct,
entries
the books
of the
Company
andthe
prepare
the relevant
extracts
from
35
(including
premium)
on
allotment
and
the
balance
on
January
1,
2003.
The
issue
was
fully
reserve.
the
Balance
Solution
: sheet as on March 31, 2002 with the corresponding figures as on 31st Dec.2001.
subscribed and allotment made on March 1, 2002. The monies due on allotment were
Tutorial Notes :
received by March 30, 2002.
1. You must revise section 80 of Companies Act, 1956 regarding redemption of preference
shares.
Following
points
are placed
below
your
not
part ofmust
the solution.
2. No shares
can be
redeemed
unless
theyfor
are
fullyrevision.
paid, i.e.These
partlyare
paid
shares
be
made
fullycan
paidbe
before
they can
redeemed.
3.
Shares
redeemed
onlybe
out
of profits of the company which would otherwise be
available
dividend or
of proceeds
of aCapital
fresh issue
of shares
made for
the purpose
of
4.
For thefor
redemption
of out
preference
shares,
Redemption
Reserve
Account
must be
redemption.
Note
that
the
word
'proceeds'
does
not
include
the
amount
of
premium
if
shares
created
only
from
such
accounts
as
represent
divisible
profits.
The
credit
balance
of
profit
and
5. Amounts in Securities Premium Account, Forfeited Shares Account, Profit prior to
are
issued
at
a
premium.
loss
a/c,
General
Reserve,
Dividend
equalisation
Reserve
are
the
examples
of
the
balances
incorporation
account
and Capital
must
not be
transferred
to Capital
6.
If the shares
are redeemed
at a Reserve
premium,Account
as is the
present
case,
the premium
payable on
available
for
distribution
of
dividend
and
hence
for
transfer
to
Capital
Redemption
Reserve
Redemption
Reserve
Account.
redemption
must
be
provided
for
from
the
profits
of
the
company
or
from
the
Securities
7. Use of Share premium a/c has been detailed in Section 78 of the Act. It does not
say that
Account.
Premium
Account.
the
amount
received
on account of share premium can be utilised for redemption of pref.
Tutorial
Notes
:
shares.
1. Proceeds of fresh issue is to be utilised for payment to shareholders. Thus Application
money
Rs.partly
20/share
Allotment
of Rs. 25/share
(Rs. The
35 less
of be
Rs.to10)
2. Sinceofthe
paid and
shares
cannotmoney
be redeemed
(section 80),
firstpremium
entry must
can
be
utilised
for
making
payment
to
pref.
shareholders.
Note
that
the
word
'proceeds'
does
callThe
money
@ Rs.
30/share
for 50,000
useisfigures
in lacs (Rs.
or thousands
3.
amount
received
on account
of pref.shares.
premium on You
freshmust
shares
Rs. 500,000
10/share
not
include
the
amount
of
premium
if
shares
are
issued
at
a
premium.
to
time
and
labour.
on
50,000
shares).
The
to be paid
the redemption
of pref.
shares
is Rs.
250,000.
3.save
The
Pref.
shares
are premium
to be redeemed
at aon
premium
of 5%. Thus
total
amount
to be
paid to
Thus
only
Rs.
250,000
can
be
utilised
out
of
proceeds
of
share
premium
received.
The
share
The solution
goes as
pref.
shareholders
willfollows:
be Rs. 50 lacs plus Rs. 2.50 lacs. The pref. shareholders will have
to
premium
a/c
already
has
Rs.
500,000
as
credit
balance
hence
after
redemption
it
will
have
pay Rs. 15 lacs to make their shares fully paid up. This will be utilised to pay them back. The
Rs.
750,000
(500,000
+ 500,000
250,000)
credit.of share capital and Rs. 5.00 lacs on
proceeds
from
fresh issue
are Rs22.50
lacs on
on its
account
account of share premium account. Out of these, Only Rs. 25.00 lacs (Rs 22.50 + 2.50) will
be utilised to pay the pref.shareholders. The balance of Rs. 12.50 lacs will have to be
obtained from present cash and bank balance. Show these figures by way of working notes.
Working notes :
1. Amount to be paid to pref. shareholders :
Face value of shares 50,000 shares @ Rs. 100
Premium @ 5%
2. Accounts against which the redemption will be affected :
Capital redemption reserve :
Balance available on 31.12.01
Transfer from general reserve (balance available on 31.12.01 Rs. 45.0 lacs.)
3. Arrangement of cash for payment to Pref. shareholders :
Call money on pref. shares @ Rs.30/share on 50,000 shares
Proceeds of fresh issue (Rs. 20 + Rs. 25) x 50,000 shares
Proceeds of fresh share premium (to be used to pay premium on redemption)
Total cash available
Balance to be obtained from Cash and Bank Balance
Rs. lacs
50.00
2.50
52.50
25.00
27.50
52.50
15.00
22.50
2.50
40.00
12.50
52.50
To
Security premium a/c
5.00
[Being the amount due on 50,000 equity shares @ Rs. 35/share including premium
of Rs. 10 vide Board Resolution dated .]
8% Pref.share capital a/c
50.00
Premium of redemption of preference share capital a/c
2.50
To
Pref. shareholders a/c
52.50
[Being the transfer of amount payable to pref. shareholders a/c]
Pref. share holders a/c
52.50
To
Bank
52.50
[Being payament made to pref. shareholders]
Security Premium a/c
2.50
To
Premium on redemption of pref. share a/c
2.50
[Being premium payable on redemption transferred to security premium a/c]
General Reserve a/c
27.50
To
Capital redemption reserve a/c
27.50
[Being the amount to capital redemption reserve for the balance not covered by
proceeds of fresh issue]
Balance sheet of M/s Raman Ltd. as at 31.03.02
(after redemption of preference shares) (figures in Rs. Lacs)
Liabilities :
31.03.02
31.12.01
Share Capital :
Issued subscribed and paid up :
100,000 Equity shares of Rs. 100 each fully paid up
10.00
10.00
50,000 Equity shares of Rs. 100 each Rs. 45 called and paid u
8% 50,000 Redeemable Pref. shares of Rs. 100 each
Rs. 70 called up and redeemed on 31.3.02
Reserve and Surplus :
Capital Redemption Reserve
Security Premium a/c
General Reserve
22.50
35.00
52.5
7.50
17.50
25.00
5.00
45.00
Note : The cash and bank balance available will be reduced by Rs. 12.50 lacs after redemption.
Problem (CWA Foundation June 06)
The Balance sheet of a Company on 31.3.2006 is as follows:
Liabilities
Rs. Assets
Rs.
Share capital
Fixed assets
345,000
Pref. Shares of Rs. 100 each fully paid
65,000 Investments
18,500
Equity shares of Rs. 50 each fully paid
225,000 Bank
31,000
Profit and loss a/c
48,000
Creditors
56,500
394,500
394,500
In order to facilitate the redemption of Pref. shares at a premium of 10%, the Company decided :
Opening balance
Loss on sale of investments
For redemption of Pref.shares
For transfer to CRR as per section 80
Balance in profit and loss a/c to be carried to balance sheet
Bank a/c
Opening balance
Add:
Share Application
Sale of investments
Less:
Rs.
225,000
31,250
256,250
48,000
3,500
250
33,750
37,500
15,000
37,500
10,500
31,000
52,500
83,500
71,500
12,000
Payment of pref.shareholders
Closing balance
Balance sheet after redemption
Liabilities
Rs.
Assets
Rs.
Equity Share Capital
256,250
Fixed assets
345,000
CRR
33,750
Bank
12,000
Profit and loss a/c
10,500
Creditors
56,500
357,000
357,000
Problem (CWA Foundation June 02)
The following are the extracts from the Balance sheet of ABC Ltd. as on 31.12.01:(in Rs.)
40,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
400,000
1000, Redeemable Pref. shares of Rs. 100 each fully paid
100,000
Reserves and Surplus:
Capital reserve
50,000
Securities Premium
50,000
General Reserve
75,000
Profit and loss a/c
35,000
On 1st Jan. 2002, the BOD decided to redeem the preference shares at par by utilisation of reserve.
Pass journal entries including cash transactions in the books of the company.
Solution :
Tutorial notes :
1. Redemption is not at premium. Hence Securities premium a/c can not be utilised (read
2. Capital
Section
78reserve
again). cannot be utilised for the redemption purposes.
3. General reserve will be fully utilised for this purpose. Balance of Rs. 25,000 will be provided
4. Don't
to transfer
the nominal value of redeemed shares to CRR a/c.
by
profit forget
and loss
a/c.
The Journal entries are as follows:
General Reserve a/c
Dr.
75,000
Profit and loss a/c
Dr.
25,000
To CRR a/c
100,000
(transfer of nominal amount as per section 80 of the Act)
PSC a/c
100,000
To Pref. Shareholders a/c
100,000
2. sufficient
Face value
preference
shares to be
redeemed
100,000
is
to of
take
care of redemption
premium.
Balance of Rs. 2,000 will be carried forward
to balanceGeneral
sheet. Reserve a/c
(80,000 20,000)
60,000
Profit and loss a/c
10,000
Investments allowance reserve
(10,000 5,000)
5,000
75,000
Amount for which fresh shares are to be reissued
25,000
3. Amount to be transferred to CRR a/c
Nominal value of shares to be redeemed
100,000
Less:
Nominal value of equity shares issued
25,000
75,000
4. Sometimes Investments allowance reserve is also termed as investments fluctuations fund.
Authorised
Issued
10% Redeemable pref. shares of Rs. 100 each fully paid
Equity Shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
Reserves and Surplus:
Capital Reserve
Share Premium
Revenue Reserves
Funds employed in
Fixed assets at cost
Less : Depreciation
Investment at cost (market value Rs. 400 crores)
Current assets
Less : Current liabilities
100
75
25
15
25
260
100
100
100
300
400
0
100
340
40
300
400
The company redeemed preference shares on 1st April, 2001. It also bought back 50 lakh
You
areshares
askedoftoRs.
: 10 each at (i)
Pass
journal
entries
to record for
thethe
above
andwere made out
equity
Rs.
50 per
share.
The payment
above
of the huge bank balances, which
as part sheet.
of current assets.
(ii) appeared
Prepare balance
Solution :
Tutorial Notes : You can revise the relevant sections of The Company's Act (Amendment)
Section 80 : Redemption of Preference Shares
1999:
Section 77A : Buy back of shares. A brief description of both sections is as follows:
Section 80 states that the redemption of redeemable preference shares can be made out of
either
the proceeds
a fresh
issue or
the profit
available
distribution.
Section
80A states
The expression
'buyofback
of shares'
means
purchasing
of for
own
shares of the
company.
that
all
preference
shares
which
are
irredeemable
shall
be
redeemed
by
the
company
on the
Sources of Funds for buy-back (Section 77A(ii) of Company's Act 1956) : A company
can
due
date
for
redemption
or
within
a
period
not
exceeding
ten
years
from
such
buy its own
shares
out of : ; or
(a)Free
reserves
(b)The securities premium account ; or
commencement, whichever is earlier.
(c)The proceeds of any shares or other specified securities.
Buy-back from whom [Section 77(A)(5)]: A company can buy its own shares from either of the
following(a)Existing
:
equity shareholders on a proportional basis;
(b)Open market;
(c)Odd lot of shareholders;
(d)Employees of the company.
Conditions of buy-back : A company can buy-back its shares or other specified securities only
if
(a)The buy-back is authorised by its Articles of Association.
(b)A special resolution is passed in the general meeting of the company authorising the buyback.
(c)The buy-back is or less than twenty five per cent of the total paid-up capital and free
reserves
of the company.
maythe
bebuy-back
noted that
in a year
buy-back
cannot
twenty
(d)The debt-equity
ratio It
after
should
not be
less than
2 : 1.exceed
Debt for
the five
percent of
its total
paid-up
capital.
purpose
shall
bebeing
secured
debt
as well
unsecured
(e)The
shares
bought-back
areas
fully
paid up. debt.
(f)If the shares or other specified securities are listed on a recognised stock exchange, then buy-back
must
comply ifwith
the regulations
by SEBI
behalf. of section 159, 207 and 211 of
(g)Further,
a company
has notmade
complied
with in
thethis
provisions
the Company's
Act 1956,
then
the company
cannotprocess
buy-back
its own
shares
securities.
The
company shall
have to
complete
the buy-back
within
a period
ofand
twelve
months
from
the
date
of
passing
the
special
resolution
or
the
resolution
passed
by
the
Board
of kind within a
The company is not allowed to issue further shares or other specified securities of similar
Directors.
A company
prohibited
of its ownof
shares
and securities
:
period
of sixismonths
fromfrom
the buy-back
date of completion
buy-back,
except where
they have been issued by
way of bonus
shares
or
in
discharge
of
subsisting
obligation.
(a)Through any subsidiary company including its own subsidiary companies.
75.00
60.00
3.50
56.50
4.00
1.00
2.50
3.00
2.00
61.50
13.50
4.73
8.77
7.50
1.27
Mehul Ltd.
Balance sheet as at 30th November, 2000
Sources of Funds :
Shareholder's Fund :
Share capital
Reserves and Surplus :
Capital Reserve
General Reserve
Surplus
Funds employed in :
Fixed assets : Cost
8.00
Less : Provision for depreciation
1.00
Current assets :
Inventory
cost
Dues fromatcustomers
- unsecured but considered good for less than six
months
Balance with scheduled bank in current account
Advances recoverable in cash or in kind ( 50,000 + 150,000)
Tax payment pending assessment
Total
Rs. lacs
25.00
2.00
2.50
1.27
30.77
7.00
3.50
32.00
2.00
2.00
4.00
50.50
10.00
0.20
1.00
1.80
4.73
2.00
19.73
30.77
Amount used
Rs. 100,000 for 9 months
31.12.97
31.12.98
31.12.99
31.12.00
31.3.02
1.4.01
To Premium on redemption
of debenture a/c
To Closing balance
60,000
4,000
64,000
36,000
1.4.01
To Bank
Working notes :
The amount payable to debenture holders
Investments required to be sold for this amount
The cost of Investments to be sold
Sale proceeds of Investments
Profit on sale of investments
28,000
64,000
30,000
6,000
Rs.
36,000
40,000
32,000
36,000
4,000
Bonus Shares :
Some points to remember :
1. Bonus shares are free of cost shares issued to existing shareholders . The bonus issue
shall be made out of free reserves built out of the profits and / or out of Securities Premium a/c
collected in cash only.
2. Reserve created out of revaluation of fixed assets are not allowed to be used for issuing
bonus shares. In other words, the revaluation reserves are not capitalised.
3. Capital redemption reserve can be used for issuing bonus shares.
4. The bonus issue is not made unless the partly paid shares are made fully paid.
5. Proportional shares should be kept reserved for convertible part of FCDs and PCDs on
same terms.
6. The company has not defaulted in payment of interest or principal in respect of fixed
deposits, debentures etc. It has made all the statutory dues fully and timely.
7. The company must implement the proposal within 6 months from the date of such approval.
The company shall not have option of changing the decision.
8.The AOA shall contain a provision for capitalisation of reserves. If not, the company should
pass a resolution in GM for making such provision.
9. After issue of bonus shares, if the share capital exceeds the authorised capital, a resolution
shall be passed in the GM for increasing the authorised capital.
10. Bonus shares can be issued only after the expiry of 12 months from the date of public
issue or rights issue.
Problem : (CA Inter May 2000)
Following is the extract of Balance sheet of Beltex Ltd. as at 31st March, 2000
Authorised Capital :
Rs.
10,000 12% Preference Shares of Rs. 10 each
100,000
100,000 Equity Shares of Rs. 10 each
1,000,000
Issued and Subscribed Capital :
8,000 12% Preference Shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
80,000
90,000 Equity Shares of Rs. 10 each, Rs. 8 paid up
720,000
Reserves and Surplus :
General Reserve
120,000
Capital Reserve
75,000
Securities Premium
25,000
Profit and loss a/c
200,000
Secured Loan :
12% Partly Convertible Debentures @ Rs. 100 each.
500,000
On 1st April, 2000 the company has made final call @ Rs. 2 each on 90,000 equity shares.
The call money was received by 20th April, 2000. Thereafter the company decided to
capitalise its reserves by way of bonus at the rate of one share for every four shares held.
Share premium of Rs. 25,000 includes a premium of Rs. 5,000 for shares issued to vendors
pursuant to a scheme of amalgamation. Capital reserves include Rs. 40,000 being profit on
sale of plant and machinery. 20% of 12% debentures are convertible into equity shares of Rs.
10 each fully paid up on 1st July, 2000.
Show necessary entries in the books of the company and prepare the extract of balance sheet
immediately after bonus issue but before conversion of debentures. Are the convertible
debentureholders entitled to bonus shares ?
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Capital Reserve realised in cash can be utilised for issue of fully paid bonus shares.
2. Share Premium collected in cash can be utilised for issue of bonus shares. In this case, Rs.
5,000 of Securities premium a/c has not been collected in cash hence not eligible for issue of
bonus shares. Only Rs. 20,000 (25,000 5,000) can be utilised for issue of bonus shares.
3. At the time of issue of bonus shares, the convertible portion of PCDs should also be taken
into account. Proportion number of shares should be kept for converted shares. 20% of PCDs
will be converted to shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid. The number of converted shares would
be ( 20% of Rs. 500,000) / Rs. 10 = 10,000 shares. The bonus is one share for every four
held. Bonus shares to PCD holders would be 10,000 / 4 = 2,500 shares.
4. The authorised share capital should not be exceeded after the issue of bonus shares. If it is
so, the company should pass a resolution in its general meeting to raise the authorised
capital.
5. In this case, the authorised share capital is 100,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each. 90,000
shares are already issued. The bonus to existing shareholders is 90,000 / 4 = 22,500 shares
and to PCDs holder 2,500 shares totalling 25,000 bonus shares. The share capital after bonus
shares is 115,000 shares which is more than authorised shares of 100,000. It is assumed that
the company has completed all the statutory requirements in this regard. It may also be noted
here that the shares to PCDs holders are not being issued at the moment but are being kept
reserved for them for issue at the time of conversion of PCDs into shares.
Internal Reconstruction :
Problem (cwa inter June 03)
Following is the balance sheet of Y LTd
Liabilities
Share Capital
Issued and paid up 250,000 shares Rs.10 each as
Rs.8 paid up
100,000 (10%) Pref.shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid
up.
Reserve and Surplus
General reserve
Profit and loss a/c
Current liabilities
Creditors
Workman's profit sharing fund
Rs.
2000000
1000000
600,000
800,000
Assets
Fixed assets
Goodwill
Building
Plant & machinery
Current assets
Stock
Debtors
Bank
Misce. Exp.
Preliminary exp.
Rs.
800,000
700,000
1300000
700,000
900,000
660,000
400,000
40,000
300,000
5100000
5100000
X Ltd. decided to absorb the business of Y ltd. at the respective book value of assets and trade liabilities
except Building which was valued at Rs. 12,00,000 and Plant & machinery at Rs. 10,00,000.
The purchase consideration was payable as follows :
(a) Assumption of trade liabilities;
(b) Payment of liquidation expenses Rs. 5,000 and workman's profit sharing fund at 10% premium;
(c) Issue of equity shares of Rs. 10 each fully paid at Rs. 11 per share for every pref. share and every equity
share of Y ltd. and a payment of Rs. 4 per equity share in cash.
Calculate the purchase consideration, show necessary ledger accounts in the books of Y ltd. and Journal
entries of X Ltd.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
You must revise the following before attempting to solve the above problem. These should not be treated as
part of answer in the examination.
1. AS -- 14 deals with the accounting problems relating to amalgamation. According to AS -- 14, there are two
types of amalgamation (i) amalgamation in the nature of merger and (ii) amalgamation in the nature of
purchase.
2. AS -- 14 defines Purchase consideration as '' the aggregate of the shares and other securities issued and
the payment made in the form of cash or other assets by the transferee (amalgamating) company to the
shareholders of transferor (amalgamated) company.''
3. Points to Remember regarding purchase consideration :
3.1 Only payment of shareholders is to be taken into consideration.
3.2 Consideration for debenture holders will NOT be included in the purchase consideration.
3.3 Liquidation expenses or payment for cost of absorption are NOT included in purchase consideration.
In the instant case, the description of consideration to be paid to various parties has already been defined.
Consideration means the amount payable to the liquidator of the transferor company and does not include the
amount of liabilities taken over by the transferee company.
As given in the question, the consideration is to be utilised or payable in the following manner :
1. Payment of liquidation expenses of Rs. 5,000;
2. Payment for Workman's profit sharing fund of Rs. 300,000 at a premium of 10%. This amounts to Rs.
330,000;
3. Payment of Rs. 4/share for 250,000 shares amounting to Rs. 10,00,000;
4. Payment Rs. 11/ pref. share in the form equity shares for 100,000 pref. shareholders amounting to Rs.
11,00,000;
5. Payment of Rs. 11/ equity share in the form of equity shares for 250,000 shares amounting to Rs.
27,50,000.
It should be remembered here that the mode of discharge of consideration by the transferor (amalgamated)
company and the purpose for which the transferor company uses the consideration received do not affect the
amount of consideration.
The calculation for Purchase consideration goes as follows :
1. Cash for liquidation expenses
2. Cash for payment of Workman's profit sharing fund
3. Cash on 250,000 shares @ Rs. 4/ share
4. Equity shares for Pref. shareholders (100,000 x Rs. 11)
5. Equity shares for Equity shareholders (250,000 x Rs. 11)
5,000
330,000
1,000,000
1,100,000
2,750,000
5,185,000
Building a/c
Plant & machinery a/c
Stock a/c
Debtors a/c
Bank a/c
Goodwill a/c (bal. fig.)
Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Rs. Lacs
1,200
1,000
700
900
660
1,125
To Creditors
To Liquidator of Y Ltd.
Liquidator of Y Ltd.
To Bank
To Equity Share capital
To Share Premium
Student should write the narration himself.
Rs. Lacs
400
5,185
5,185
1,335
3,500
350
Share Premium
Profit and loss a/c
Long term Loan
Proposed Dividends
Sundry creditors
18.0
20.0
5.0
20.0
15.0
13.5
16.5
10.0
5.0
173.0
30.0
50.0
Land and buildings
60.0
5.0
Plant & machinery
50.0
10.0
5.0
Stock
35.0
5.0
10.0
Debtors
20.0
5.0
15.0
Bank
8.0
10.0
15.0
173.0
30.0
50.0
P Ltd.takes over R. ltd. by buying all the assets. The purchase consideration is 6,00,000 equity shares at a
premium of 10%. The creditors of R. Ltd. will be taken over by P. Ltd. The assets of R. Ltd. are valued at :
(fig. in Rs.)
Land and buildings
10,00,000
Plant & machinery
300,000
Stock
700,000
Debtors
12,50,000
P Ltd. takes over Q Ltd. by exchanging with the shareholders of Q Ltd. two shares in P Ltd. at a premium of
10% for every share they hold.
a) State the nature of the two types of acquisitions involved here :
b) Give journal entries to record the acquisitions in the books of P ltd.
c) Close the books of R Ltd. and
d) Prepare the post acquisition balance sheet of P Ltd.
Solution :
a) In the first case. P ltd. takes over the assets and liabilities of R ltd and R ltd ceases to exist.
In the second case, Q Ltd. still exists but as a cent percent subsidiary or wholly owned subsidiary of
P ltd.This is a case of amalgamation in the nature of purchase.
b) Journal entries to record the acquisitions in the books of P ltd.
Tutorial notes :
1. The assets of R Ltd. bought by P Ltd. will be recorded in the books of P Ltd. as per the values accepted by
P ltd at the time of taking over. The values appearing in the books of R ltd. which is being taken over have no
relevance at all as far as recording in the books of P ltd is considered.
2. The sequence of entries is generally like this: 1. the liquidator is credited with business purchase a/c. 2. the
assets and liabilities taken over are recorded as per the values accepted by the purchasing company. The
business purchase a/c is credited and the difference is accounted as goodwill or capital reserve as the case
may be. 3. the liquidator is debited with the shares, debenture or cash as a discharge for purchase
consideration.
3. The share capital should be recorded at face value of shares irrespective of the values of shares whether
at premium or at discount. The discount or premium should always be recorded in a separate account.
In the books of P Ltd.(relating to R ltd.)
The journal entries are as follows :
J1:
Business purchase a/c
To Liquidator of R Ltd. a/c
(being the purchase consideration for the take over of R ltd.)
J2:
Land and buildings
Dr.
1000000
Plant & machinery
Dr.
300,000
Stock
Dr.
700,000
Debtors
Dr.
1250000
Bank a/c
Dr.
1500000
Goodwill
(bal. fig.) Dr.
2350000
(Note here that the balance sheet values of R ltd are not at all relevant here. The values accepted by P ltd will
be recorded here because this is journal of P ltd.)
To
Business purchase a/c
6600000
To
Creditors a/c
500,000
(assets and liabilities of R Ltd. taken over)
J 3:
Liquidator of R ltd. a/c
6600000
To
Equity share capital a/c
6000000
To
Share premium a/c
600,000
(purchase consideration discharged in the form shares at 10% premium)
In the books of P Ltd.(relating to Q ltd.)
The journal entries are as follows :
Investment in Q Ltd. a/c
Dr.
3300000
To
Equity Share Capital a/c
3000000
To
Share Premium a/c
300,000
c) Closing entries in the books of R Ltd.
All the assets and liabilities shown in the balance sheet will be closed as per their balance sheet values. The
purchase consideration received by R ltd. is Rs. 66.0 lacs. Total assets are of Rs. 50.0 lacs and creditors are
Rs. 5.0 lacs. The profit on realisation would be Rs.21.0 lacs which will go to Shareholder's a/c.
Initially P ltd. will be debited by purchase consideration of Rs. 66.0 lacs. Finally the shareholder's a/c will be
debited and P ltd. will be credited by purchase consideration.
The creditors of R Ltd. are assumed by P ltd. hence balance sheet of P ltd will include these creditors as well.
Realisation A/c
(fig.in '000 Rs.)
500 By P ltd.
6,600
500 By Creditors
500
1,000
1,500
1,500
2,100
7,100
7,100
The share capital a/c, profit and loss a/c will be closed by debiting these accounts and crediting the
shareholder's a/c. The shareholders a/c will be debited to P ltd with the amount of purchase consideration.
You can now check whether all the ledger accounts appearing the balance sheet of R ltd. are closed or not.
To
Shareholder's a/c
(fig. in '000)
To
P ltd. a/c
6,600 By Share capital a/c
2,500
(600,000 shares of Rs. 10 with
By Profit and loss a/c
2,000
a premium of 10%)
By Realisation a/c
2,100
6,600
6,600
d) Post balance sheet of P ltd.
This is the case of amalgamation in the nature of purchase, hence the accounting needs to be done as per
the Purchase method.
You should revise your knowledge on purchase method as per the following :
Under purchase method :
1. The assets and liabilities of the transferor company (Q ltd. in this case) are to be recorded at their existing
carrying amount or alternatively, the consideration should be allocated to individual assets and liabilities on
the basis of fair value at the date of amalgamation while preparing the financial statements of the transferee
company (P ltd. in this case).
2. The identity of the reserves of the transferor company (Q ltd.) other than the statutory reserves, is not
preserved. The identity of the statutory reserves is preserved in the same form and is recorded in the books
of the transferee company by a corresponding debit to Amalgamation adjustment a/c. (Note : This is not
applicable in the instant case.)
3. Excess or shortfall of the consideration over the value of net assets acquired should be credited / debited
as Capital reserve / Goodwill, as the case may be.
The post balance sheet may be prepared after following computation. This is for better understanding only.
Liabilities
Share Capital
Share Premium
Profit and loss a/c
Long term Loan
Proposed dividend
Sundry Creditors
For R ltd.
60.0
6.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
5.0
71.0
For R ltd.
10.0
3.0
Total
180.0
27.0
20.0
15.0
13.5
21.5
277.0
Assets
Total
Land and buildings
70.0
Plant & machinery
53.0
Investments in Q ltd.
33.0
Stock
35.0
0.0
7.0
42.0
Debtors
20.0
0.0
12.5
32.5
Bank
8.0
15.0
23.0
173.0
0.0
47.5
253.5
Goodwill
23.5
Balance sheet of P Ltd. (after the acquisition)
Liabilities :
Rs. Lacs Assets
Rs. Lacs
Share Capital
Goodwill
23.5
Equity share capital
180.0 Land and buildings
70.0
Share Premium
27.0 Plant & machinery
53.0
Profit and loss a/c
20.0 Investment in Q ltd.
33.0
Long Term Loan
15.0 Stock
42.0
Proposed Dividend
13.5 Debtors
32.5
Sundry Creditors
21.5 Bank
23.0
277.0
277.0
Additional knowledge : Section 212 of the Company's Act 1956 requires that a holding company shall attach
to its balance sheet the following documents:
1. A copy of the balance sheet of the subsidiary;
2. A copy of the profit and loss a/c of the subsidiary;
3. A copy of the BOD report and Auditor's report;
4. A statement of holding company's interest.
Problem : (cwa inter June 05)
On the eve of proposed absorption of A Ltd. by B Ltd., following summarised details are given :
A Ltd.
B Ltd.
Net Assets
Rs.
33,30,000
41,25,000
Number of equity shares of Rs. 200 each
9,000
15,000
Reserves
Rs.
15,30,000
11,25,000
Terms of proposed absorption are as follows :
The holders of every three shares of A Ltd. were to receive four shares in B Ltd. plus as much cash as is
necessary to adjust the rights of shareholders of both the companies in accordance with intrinsic value of their
respective shares.
You are required to :
(a) Compute the purchase consideration ;
(b) Present the projected balance sheet of B Ltd. as if the proposed absorption is put through.
Solution :
Tutorial notes :
1. Can you find out orally the intrinsic value of each share of both the companies ?
2. What is the significance of reserves of A Ltd. ?
3. Intrinsic value per share is 33,30,000 / 9,000 = Rs. 370 for A ltd. and 41,25,000 / 15,000 = Rs. 275 for B ltd.
4. Holders of 3 shares of A ltd. (value Rs. 370 x 3 = Rs. 1110) are to receive 4 shares of B ltd. (value Rs. 275
x 4 = Rs. 1100). The rights of shareholders of A ltd. is less by Rs. 10 per three shares which has to be paid in
cash. Calculate the amount of cash payment to shareholders of A ltd.
5. The purchase consideration is to be paid in terms of shares @ Rs. 275/share. The face value of share is
given as Rs. 200 each. Thus the premium per share is Rs. 75 which should be shown separately in Share
premium account. The share capital to be issued would be Rs. 24,00,000 (Rs. 200 x 12,000) and the share
premium account would be Rs. 900,000 (Rs.75 x 12,000). Why 12,000? Just think and find out.
6. As the intrinsic value of shares of A ltd. has been calculated on net assets, there is no significance of
reserves of A ltd.
7. For every 3 shares of A ltd., B ltd. is to issue 4 shares. You can easily calculate the number of shares to be
issued to shareholders of A ltd. as 9000 x 4/3 = 12,000 shares. Intrinsic value of shares of B ltd. is Rs. 275 as
calculated earlier. Thus value of shares issued is Rs. 275 x 12,000 = Rs. 33,00,000. The net assets of A ltd. is
Rs. 33,30,000. Thus cash to be paid is Rs. 30,000.
8. The total assets taken over by B ltd. would be Rs. 33,00,000 and not Rs. 33,30,000. Why?
9. Prepare your solution on the lines supplied above, and compare it with the one furnished below:
Computation of intrinsic value of shares of A ltd. and B ltd.:
A Ltd.
B Ltd.
Net assets
Rs.
33,30,000
41,25,000
No. of shares
no.
9,000
15,000
Value per shares
Rs.
370
275
Value of 3 shares
Rs.
1,110
Value of 4 shares
Rs.
1,100
Difference of Rs. 10 (1110 1000) for every 3 shares of A ltd. is to be paid in cash.
Amount of cash payment = Rs. 10 x (9000 / 3) = Rs. 30,000.
No. of shares to be issue : ( 9000 / 3) x 4 = 12,000 shares of Rs. 275.
Share Capital : 12,000 x Rs. 200 = Rs. 24,00,000
Share Premium : 12,000 x Rs. 75 = Rs. 9,00,000
Projected Balance sheet of B Ltd.
Liabilities
Rs. Lacs Assets
Rs. Lacs
Share capital
Net Assets
Authorised, Issued, Subscribed,
(41.25 + 33.30 less
27,000 shares of Rs. 200 each, fully paid up
54.00 cash paid 0.30)
74.25
(of these 12,000 shares issued for consideration
other than cash)
Share Premium
9.00
Other Reserves
11.25
74.25
74.25
Problem : (cwa final June 00)
ABC Ltd. decided to reorganise itself following a period of adverse trading conditions. The summarised
Balance sheet of the company at 31st March, 2000 was as follows:
Rs. Lacs
Rs. Lacs
12% Cumul. Pref.shares of Rs.10 each
42.0 Goodwill
3.0
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each
120.0 Patents and franchises
2.6
Share Premium account
5.0 Land and buildings
80.2
14% Debentures
48.0 Plant & machinery
6.2
Interest payable on debentures
13.4 Investments
16.0
Loan from directors
4.8 Stocks
62.0
Creditors
16.8 Debtors
42.0
Bank Overdraft
Tutorial notes:
1. You can begin to solve from any where you like. However, it is suggested that you should go along with the
scheme as given. You should take each point of scheme and present the required solution.
2. Let us take first point. The existing equity share capital of shares of Rs. 10 is to be converted to Rs. 2
shares. The existing share capital will be debited and new capital will be credited. The balance of Rs. 8 per
share will be credited to Capital reconstruction account. This account is of the nature of revaluation or
realisation account.You should now write the first journal entry.
3. The existing 12 lakhs shareholders subscribe 2 shares for 3 shares at Rs. 3.50 per share. The amount
received must be Rs. 28.0 lacs [(12/3) x 2 x 3.5]. You can write the journal entry, remember that Rs. 1.5 per
share is the premium and should be credited to share premium account.
4. Next point is reconstruction of pref. share capital. Old and new amount are same, hence the capital
reconstruction a/c will not be required. Write the journal entry.
5. Interest payable to debholders is Rs. 13.4 lacs which is to be settled by 250,000 equity shares of Rs. 2.
The balance of Rs. 8.4 lacs will be credited to capital reduction a/c. This will close the item of interest payable.
Write the entry.
6. Read the point 3 again. Can you write the journal entries of this point?
7. Existing dholders are to accept 15% debentures in place of 14% debentures. Debit 14% debentures with
Rs. 48.0 lakhs and credit 15% debentures with the same amount.
8. 15% debentures of value Rs. 800,000 are to be further issued at a discount of Rs. 10. Thus 8000
debentures will be issued at Rs. 90 bringing in cash of Rs. 720,000. How will you record the discount of Rs.
10? Will you write it as discount on issue of debentures or will you write something else? Think.
9. Point 4 is easy. Half of loan i.e. Rs. 240,000 will be credited to capital reduction a/c. Half will be settled by
48,000 shares of Rs. 2 each amounting to Rs. 96,000. What about the balance amount of Rs. 144,000
(240,000 96,000) ? Think.
10. Investments have book value of Rs. 16.0 lacs. It is sold for Rs. 10.0 lakhs. The balance will be debited to
capital reduction a/c.
11. Close the other entries as per the scheme. Pay bank overdraft and creditors. All fictitious assets be
debited to capital reduction a/c. Settle the liability of damage by paying cash of Rs. 880,000. Insurance
receivable is Rs. 150,000 and the rest of damage will be debited to capital reduction a/c.
12. The share premium a/c is to be utilised in full as mentioned in the question. Can you say how can this be
utilised?
13. The gains and losses out of revaluation of various items of balance sheet are to be transferred to capital
reconstruction a/c. Read the point carefully and compute the losses on plant & machinery, stocks and debtors
a/c. You are likely to commit mistakes here. Compute the gain on Land a/c.
14. Compute the net gains or losses in capital reconstruction a/c and close it by opening capital reserve a/c or
goodwill a/c.
15. Use figures in lacs to save time and labour.
Write your journal entries on the lines given above compare them with the ones given below.
In the books of ABC Ltd.
Rs. Lacs Rs. Lacs
Journal Entries
Dr.
Cr.
Equity Share capital a/c
120.0
To Equity share capital (Rs. 2) a/c
24.0
To Capital reconstruction a/c
96.0
(cancellation of share capital of face value Rs. 10 and reissue of Rs. 2 shares.
Balance transferred to c.rec. a/c)
Cash a/c
28.0
To Equity share capital (Rs. 2) a/c
16.0
To Share Premium a/c
12.0
(Issue of new equity shares to the existing sholders on the basis of 2 for 3 at a
premium of Rs. 1.5/share)
12% Cumul. Pref.shares capital a/c
42.0
Rs.
68,000
140,000
240,000
324,000
248,000
320,000
48,000
440,000
1,828,000
4. 8% Pref. share capital stands at Rs. 640,000. It is to be reduced by Rs. 2.5 per share. The reduction will be
credited to Reconstruction a/c. There is no other adjustment in pref. share capital. You should draw the ledger
of 8% pref. share capital before you proceed further. As per question, 8% pref. share capital a/c is to be
closed and 10% pref. share capital a/c is to be opened. Can you close the 8% pref. share capital a/c ?
5. You can now open the 10% pref. share capital a/c. They would take up one pref. share for every 4 held.
They would take up 16,000 shares of Rs. 10 each. Can you draw the a/c now? Total pref. share capital would
be 64,000 + 16,000 = 80,000 shares of Rs. 7.50 each.
6. Same treatment as above can be given to equity share capital a/c for reduction of Rs. 7.5 per share. This
reduction of amount of Rs. 480,000 (64,000 x Rs. 7.5) would be credited to reconstruction a/c. You have
already opened reconstruction a/c. Credit it with Rs. 480,000 and debit the equity share capital a/c.
7. The investment in shares of Q Ltd. is to be valued. Read the point (d) again. Can you determine the value
of these 21,600 shares ? What will you do with the value so determined ? How this value is related to
reconstruction a/c ?
The value can be easily determined by capitalizing the profit of Rs. 250,000 @ 12%. The value will be Rs.
20,83,333 (250,000 / 0.12). The investment held is 15% of total value. The value of investment would Rs.
312,500 (15% of Rs. 20,83,333).
8. Provision for bad debts is required to be created as 2%. Debtors are Rs. 320,000, provision to be created
would be Rs. 6,400. Where will it be recorded ? How will it appear in the balance sheet after reconstruction?
9. You can make a comparative statement of valuation of other assets as per balance sheet and as per
reconstruction scheme. What will you do with the difference ?
Particulars
Balance sheet values
New values
Increase/decrease
Intangibles
68,000
48,000
(20,000) decrease
(100,000) decrease
Plant
240,000
140,000
Freehold premises
140,000
380,000
240,000 Increase
Stocks
248,000
250,000
2,000 Increase
Increase in values will be credited to Reconstruction a/c and vice versa.
10. The profit and loss a/c debit balance and deferred revenue expense would be eliminated. How can you
eliminate them?
11. Loans from directors would be satisfied by shares of Rs. 2.5 each. Shares required would be 60,000 / 2.5
= 24,000 shares.
12. Total number of shares (including those issued to directors in settlement of their loans) is 64,000 + 24,000
= 88,000. Scheme says that the shareholders would receive 2 shares for every one share held. The new
shares would be 2 x 88,000 = 176,000. Total shares would thus be 88,000 + 176,000 = 264,000. The share
capital would Rs. 660,000 (264,000 x Rs. 2.5)
13. The new equity shares would fetch Rs. 440,000 ( Rs. 2.5 x 176,000). Equity share capital a/c will be
credited and Bank a/c will be debited.
14. It is difficult to decide which ledger is to be opened first. Let us open Bank a/c and Equity Share Capital
a/c as per first adjustment.
15. After reading the above tutorial notes, it should not be hard to draw the various accounts. It is advised that
you should draw all those accounts and only after doing that you should see the following.
To
Reconstruction a/c
Closing balance
Rs.
480,000
160,000
60,000
440,000
1,140,000
To
Equity share capital a/c
Equity share capital a/c
Pref. share capital a/c (16,000 x Rs. 7.5)
Rs. By
160,000 Opening balance (given)
440,000 Closing balance
120,000
720,000
Liabilities
Authorised Capital
140,000 Equity shares of Rs. 10 each
Equity share capital
268,000 shares of Rs. 2.5 fully paid up
(of these 24,000 shares were issued for
consideration other than cash)
10% Pref.Share capital a/c
Capital reserve
Creditors
Rs.
208,000
512,000
720,000
Rs.
21,600
2,083,333
312,500
324,000
11,500
Rs.
640,000
640,000
Rs.
480,000
120,000
600,000
Rs.
160,000
480,000
2,000
240,000
882,000
Rs.'000
48.0
380.0
140.0
312.5
250.0
313.6
512.0
1,956.1
Fixed assets
Investments
B Vertical Form
Balance sheet of
As at
Schedule no.
Figures for
Current
I. Sources of Funds :
year
(1) Shareholder's Funds
(i) Capital
(ii) Reserves and Surplus
(2) Loan Funds
(i) Secured Loans
(ii) Unsecured Loans
II. Application of Funds :
(1) Fixed assets :
(i) Gross Block
(ii) Less : Depreciation
(iii) Net Block
(iv) Capital work-in-progress
(2) Investments :
(3) Current assets and advances
(a) Inventories
(b) Sundry debtors
(c) Cash and Bank balances
(d) Other current assets
(e) Loans and advances
Less :
Current liabilities and Provisions
(a) Liabilities
(b) Provisions
Previous
year
(4)
Cr. Rs.
1000000
200,000
350,000
525,000
50,000
1,000
210,000
150,000
250,000
200,000
121,000
13,300
247,000
30,000
100,000
60,000
42,700
200,000
68,000
1909000
1909000
3. No provision is made for capital expenditure due for next year. The contract for the erection of machinery is
capital expenditure in nature and therefore will not appear in the balance sheet, but a note to this effect showing
this as contingent liability will have to be given at the foot of Balance sheet.
4. Additional information has reference to Miscellaneous expenses and balance sheet does not have any item of
miscellaneous expenses. The balance sheet has preliminary expenses as one item which can be treated as
miscellaneous expenses.
5.The assets and liabilities should be shown side by side. It is for convenience that they are shown vertically.
6. The discounted bills receivables should be mentioned in notes to accounts at the foot of balance sheet. Same
is the case with audit fees and expenses paid to auditors which are included in miscellaneous expenses.
7. In this problem, almost no calculations are involved. You are to present the given figures in the prescribed
format. The format is all that materials here. Remember the proper format.
Solution :
PRINTEX LTD.
Balance sheet as at 31st March, 2002
(drawn as per Part-I Schedule VI, Section 211 of the Company's Act)
Liabilities :
Rs.
Rs.
Authorised : Equity Shares of Rs. . each
Issued and Subscribed 10,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each fully called up
1000000
( of the above, 200 equity shares of Rs. 100 each have been issued for consideration other
than cash.)
Less : Calls in arrears
1,000 999,000
Reserves and Surplus :
General Reserve
210,000
Profit and loss a/c
100,000
Secured Loans
Loans from SFI (secured by hypothecation of Plant and machinery)
142,500
Unsecured Loans
Unsecured Loans
121,000
Current liabilities and Provisions
A. Current liabilities :
Sundry Creditors for goods and expenses
200,000
Interest accrued but not due (SFC)
7,500
B. Provisions
Provision for taxation
68,000
Proposed Dividend
60,000
1908000
Assets :
Land
Building
Less : Depreciation
Plant and machinery
Less : Depreciation
Furniture
Less : Depreciation
Investment
200,000
400,000
50,000 350,000
700,000
175,000 525,000
62,500
12,500 50,000
0
200,000
50,000 250,000
52,000
148,000
0 200,000
30,000
245,000
2,000 247,000
42,700
13,300
1908000
Contingent Liability : Estimated amount of contract remaining to be executed on Capital account and not
provided for Rs. 250,000.
Notes :
1. The bills receivables maturing on June 30, 2002 amounting to Rs. 275,000 have been discounted on ..
2. Preliminary expenses include :
Audit fees
Rs. 5,000
Out of pocket expenses paid to auditors
Rs. 700
Problem : (cwa foundation, Dec. 2002)
X Ltd. was registered with an authorised Capital of Rs. 10,00,000 divided into shares of Rs. 10 each, of which
40,000 shares had been issued and fully paid.
The following is the Trial balance extracted on 31st March 2002 :
Dr. Rs. Cr. Rs.
Stock (1.4.2004)
186,420
Returns
12,680
9,850
Sundry manufacturing expenses
19,240
18% Bank Loan (secured)
50,000
Office salaries and expenses
17,870
Director's Remuneration
26,250
Freehold premises
164,210
Furniture
5,000
Debtors and Creditors
105,400
62,220
Cash at bank
96,860
Profit and loss a/c on 1.4.2001
38,640
Share capital
400,000
Purchases and Sales
718,210 1169900
Manufacturing wages
109,740
Carriage inwards
4,910
Interest on Bank loan
4,500
Auditor's Fees
8,600
Preliminary expenses
6,000
Plant and machinery
128,400
Loose Tools
12,500
Cash in hand
19,530
84,290
1730610
1730610
You are required to prepare Profit and loss a/c for the year ended 31st March 2002 and a Balance sheet as at
that date after taking into consideration the following adjustments :
(i) On 31st March 2002, outstanding manufacturing wages and outstanding office salaries stood at Rs. 1,890 and
Rs. 1,200 respectively. On the same date stock was valued at Rs. 1,24,840 and loose tools at Rs. 10,000.
(ii) Provide for interest on bank loan for 6 months.
(iii) Depreciation on Plant and machinery is to be provided @ 15% while on office furniture it is to be @ 10%.
(iv) Write-off one third of balance of preliminary expenditure.
(v) Make a provision for income tax @ 50%.
(vi) The directors recommended dividend @ 15% for the year ending 31st March 2002 after a transfer of 5% of
total profits to general reserve.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. You should open two formats on two different pages, one for trading and profit and loss a/c, and the other for
balance sheet. You should take each item of trial balance, see the adjustments and place the figure in the
respective formats.
2. First item is Opening stock of Rs. 186,420. This belongs to the debit side of trading a/c, you can place it there.
Opening stock is followed by Purchases so you look for purchases as Rs. 718,210 and write this below opening
stock. You can see returns as next item. The purchase returns of Rs. 9,850 should be placed below and
deducted from purchases. This automatically takes you to the figures of Sales and Sales returns. No
adjustments are required in these figures. You place the figures of Sales and Sales returns on credit side of the
trading a/c. The final figure of Sales less returns is now available on credit side of trading a/c.
3. Next item of manufacturing expenses has no adjustments. Place it below purchases on trading a/c. You can
scan the trial balance to seek other items belonging to trading a/c. You find manufacturing wages and carriage
inwards and you place these two items below manufacturing expenses. Outstanding wages should be added to
manufacturing wages and at the same time outstanding wages should go to liability side of balance sheet. In
adjustments you find closing stock as Rs. 124,840, you place it below net sales and also write this on assets side
of Balance sheet at suitable place.. Your trading a/c is now complete and you can compute the gross profit and
place it on credit side of profit and loss a/c.
4. Next in the list is 18% Bank Loan. Write the amount of loan on liability side, the adjustments say that interest
@ 18% on loan is outstanding for six months. You place this figure of Rs. 4,500 below the loan amount on
balance sheet. You also write the interest as expense on p/l a/c. Interest paid and interest outstanding should be
agreegated and total amount be shown as expense.
5. Directors remuneration is an expense, and you should debit the profit and loss a/c by Rs. 26,250. You can
also write here that the remuneration payable to the directors of a company, shall be determined by Section 309
and Section 198 of the Companies Act, 1956, and it is assumed that those provisions have been followed in toto.
6. Next is freehold premises. You take this to asset side of balance sheet as no adjustments except depreciation
are required. You see that question is silent about depreciation on freehold premises, so you also remain silent
about it. You can however, add a note that depreciation on freehold premises has been ignored.
7. The item of furniture of Rs. 5,000 should go to assets side of balance sheet. The depreciation @ 10% should
be debited to profit and loss a/c and at the same time this should also be written on balance sheet and net figure
of Rs. 4,500 should be written on balance. You can here give similar treatment to Plant and machinery. The
balance sheet should show the original cost of asset, total depreciation upto date and the net cost of asset.
8. Debtors and creditors have no adjustments and should therefore go straight to balance sheet. The balance
sheet should show the debts outstanding for more than six months separately, you can write a note at the foot of
balance sheet in this regard.
9. The next item is Opening balance of profit and loss a/c on 1.04.01. You should be careful about this entry.
You should NOT place it as an opening entry of profit and loss a/c because the tax has already been paid on it.
This amount will be opening balance of Profit and loss appropriation a/c and will be followed by profit after tax of
the current year, if any.
10. No adjustments in share capital are mentioned. This will go to balance sheet straight away. The format of
schedule VI requires Authorised, Issued, Subscribed and Paid up capital to be disclosed and you are expected to
adhere to that prescribed format.
11. You also find that no amount of carriage outward is mentioned in the trial balance. You can make a note
stating that the amount of purchase returns is inclusive of carriage outwards.
12. The auditors' fees is an expense and should be charged to profit and loss a/c.
13. Preliminary expenses should be written off to the extent of one-third of Rs. 6,000. Charge profit and loss a/c
with Rs.2,000 and place the balance item on the bottom of assets side on balance sheet. The original figure of
Rs. 6,000 less written-off Rs. 2,000 should be disclosed there.
14. Loose tools represent expense and should be charged to profit and loss a/c. The adjustments show the
closing loose tools as Rs. 10,000. You should charge the profit and loss a/c with Rs. 2,500 (12,500 10,000).
15. Cash in hand and advance payment of tax will go to the assets side of balance sheet. No adjustments are
required in these items.
16. The cash at bank should be shown on two banks i) with scheduled bank and ii) with others.
Please solve the problem on the guidelines supplied above and compare your solution with the solution provided
below :
The solution goes as follows :
Answer 1: Trading and Profit and loss a/c of X Ltd. for the year ended 31.03.2002
In the books of X Company Ltd.
Trading and Profit and loss a/c for the period ended 31.3.02
Particulars
By Sales
Less : Returns
By Closing stock
Rs.
Rs.
1169900
12,680
1157220
124,840
1282060
Particulars
To Opening stock as on 01.04.01
To Purchases
Less : Returns
To Wages
Add : Outstanding wages
To Mfg. expeneses
To Carriage inward
Total of Debit side
Rs.
Rs.
186,420
718,210
9,850 708,360
109,740
1,890 111,630
19,240
4,910
1030560
To Gross profit
251,500
1282060
By Gross profit
To Interest on Bank Loan
4,500
Add : Outstanding
4,500
Office salaries and expenses
17,870
Add : Outstanding
1,200
Auditors' Fees
Directors' Remuneration
Provision for depreciation :
Furniture
500
(10% of Rs. 5,000)
Plant and machinery
19,260
(15% of Rs. 128,400)
Loose tools
Opening balance
Less : Closing balance
Preliminary expenses written off (one-third of Rs. 6,000)
Total of debit side
To Net profit before tax
251,500
9,000
19,070
8,600
26,250
19,760
12,500
10,500
2,500
2,000
4,500
247,000
251,500
164,320
123,500
82,160
Creditors
Outstanding Mfg. Wages
Outstanding office salaries
Interest on Bank Loan
Provisions
Provision for Taxation
Provision for Dividend
62,220
1,890
1,200
4,500
Loose Tools
10,000
Stock
124,840
Debtors
Outstanding for more than six months
Others
82,160 Less : Provisions
105,400
60,000 Cash at bank
i) With Scheduled Bank
ii) With Others
96,860
Cash in hand
19,530
Loans and Advances
Advance payment of taxes
84,290
Miscellaneous Expenditure
4,000
(Preliminary expenses Rs. 6,000 4,000)
722,770
722,770
Problem : cwa foundation June 2004 revised
Golden spoon Ltd. issued 5,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each at a premium of Rs. 2 per share payable as follows
:
On application : Rs.7/share (including premium); On allotment : Rs. 3/share and On : First and final call : Rs.
2/share.
The company has received 6,000 applications for 5,000 equity shares. The allotment was made on prorata.
Excess application money was utilised towards dues on allotment.
Mr. Y who held 200 shares, failed to pay allotment money and first and final call. These shares were forfeited.
The company reissued 150 shares out of 200 shares forfeited shares to Mr. K as fully paid for Rs. 8/share.
Required :
Pass Journal entries in the Books of the Company.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. 'Pro-rata allotment ' means allotment in proportion of shares applied for. For example in the present case the
company receives application for 6,000 shares against the offer of 5,000 shares. The allotment is on prorata
basis therefore applicants of 6,000 shares will be allotted 5,000 shares i.e. in the ratio of 6:5. Any applicant who
has applied for 6 shares will be allotted 5 shares. Worded differently, shareholder having 500 shares must have
applied for 600 shares and paid the application money for 600 shares.
2. The allotment is on prorata basis. Thus Mr. Y holding 200 shares must have applied for 240 (200 x 6000/5000)
shares paying Rs. 1,680 (240 x Rs. 7) along with application.
3. The excess money paid by him is Rs. 280 (40 x Rs. 7), which will be adjusted towards allotment money. The
allotment due on his account stands at Rs. 600 (200 x Rs. 3) out of which the company has already Rs. 280 as
adjustment of application money. Thus he has failed to pay the balance amount of Rs. 320.
4. The total allotment money due is Rs. 15,000 (5000 x Rs. 3). The money to be transferred from application
money is Rs. 7,000 (1000 x Rs. 7). Thus the money called from shareholders would be Rs. 8,000 out of which
Mr. Y has failed to pay Rs. 320. The money received by company must be Rs. 7,680 (8,000 320).
5. The amount forfeited will be the total amount paid except the amount paid towards share premium a/c. The
total amount paid by Mr. Y is Rs. 1,680 out of which Rs. 400 is towards share premium which will not be
forfeited.The share forfeiture a/c will be credited by Rs.1,280.
6. The company issued 150 shares as fully paid at Rs. 8 per share. What will be the loss per share (i) Rs. 4 per
share because these shares were earlier issued at a premium of Rs. 2 or (ii) Rs. 2 per share as per face value of
share. Since the share capital created against these shares will be at face value, the loss will be computed
against the face value. This loss of Rs. 300 (150 x 2) will be debited to share forfeiture account.
7. You must show all the above calculations by way of working notes which carry marks in the examination,
The Journal entries in the books of Golden Spoon Ltd.
The naration has been left to reader. The word share has been used in place of 'equity
share'.
1
Bank a/c
Dr. 42,000
To Share application a/c
42,000
2
Share application a/c
Dr. 35,000
To Share capital a/c
25,000
To Share premium a/c
10,000
3
Share allotment a/c
Dr. 15,000
To Share capital a/c
15,000
4
Bank a/c
Dr.
7,680
Share application a/c
7,000
To Share allotment a/c
14,680
5
Share first and final call a/c
Dr. 10,000
To Share capital a/c
10,000
6
Bank a/c
Dr.
9,600
To Share first and final call a/c
9,600
7
Share capital a/c
Dr.
2,000
To Share first and final call a/c
400
To Share allotment a/c
320
To Forfeited shares a/c
1,280
8
Bank a/c
Dr.
1,200
Forfeited shares a/c
300
To Share capital a/c
1,500
9
Forfeited shares a/c
Dr.
980
To Capital Reserve a/c
980
Problem : cwa foundation Dec. 2004.
PGG Limited has authorised capital of Rs. 10,00,000. The company issued 75,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each
at a premium of Rs. 4 per share payable as follows :
On application : Rs. 7 (including premium of Rs. 2), on allotment : Rs. 5 (including the balance premium), and
the balance in two calls in equal instalements.
Applications were received for 100,000 shares. The applicants were divided as follows:
(a) Those who applied for 25,000 shares were allotted in full.
(b) Those who applied for 60,000 shares were allotted 50,000 shares on prorata.
(c) The applicants for the balance applications were refunded in full.
Excess payment received on application was adjusted against allotment money.
Shareholders holding 5000 shares failed to pay when the second and final call was made. These shares were
forfeited and reissued at Rs. 9/share.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes :
1. Amount to be credited to share forfeiture a/c can easily be computed. The shareholders have paid Rs.
13/share (Rs..9 towards share capital a/c and Rs. 4 towards share premium a/c) at the time of forfeiture. The
amount paid towards share capital will be forfeited i.e. Rs. 9 x 5,000 shares = Rs. 45,000.
2. You have already solved some questions of this type. You should solve this one on your own and compare
your solution with the one given below. In journal entries the naration carries marks and you should be particular
about writing the naration of every journal entry.
Working notes :
1
3
4
Rs.
700,000
105,000
375,000
150,000
70,000
375,000
Allotment money due (75,000 x Rs. 5)
70,000
Adjustment from application money
305,000
Balance to called from shareholders
225,000
Adjustment towards share capital a/c (75,000 x Rs. 3)
150,000
Adjustment towards share premium (75,000 x Rs. 2)
Share forfeiture a/c will be credited with the amount paid towards share capital up
to the point of forfeiture i.e. Rs. 9 x 5,000 shares = Rs. 45,000.
The forfeited shares were reissued at Rs. 9/share.
Amount received on account of reissue
Amount received on account of forfeiture
Total amount received
Less Face value of the shares
Profit to be transferred to Capital reserve
In the books of PGG Limited
Journal Entries
Particulars
Rs.
Bank a/c
Dr.
700,000
To Share application money a/c
( Being application money received on 100,000 shares @ Rs. 7/share)
Share application money a/c
Dr.
105,000
To Bank a/c
(excess application money on 15,000 shares being refunded)
Share application money a/c
Dr.
525,000
To Share capital a/c
To Share premium a/c
(Application money transferred to share capital a/c and share premium a/c)
Share application money a/c
Dr.
70,000
To Share allotment a/c
( Excess allotment money transferred to share allotment a/c)
Share allotment a/c
To Share capital a/c
To Share premium a/c
( allotment money due)
Bank a/c
305,000
45,000
45,000
90,000
50,000
40,000
Rs.
700,000
105,000
375,000
150,000
70,000
(c) in writing off the expenses of, or the commission paid or discount allowed on, any issue of shares or
debentures of the company; or
(d) in providing for the premium payable on the redemption of any redeemable preference shares or of any
debentures of the company.
You must revise the following regarding the redemption of preference shares.
1. You must revise section 80 of Companies Act, 1956 regarding redemption of preference shares. Following
points are placed below for your revision. These are not part of the solution.
2. No shares can be redeemed unless they are fully paid, i.e. partly paid shares must be made fully paid before
they can be redeemed.
3. Shares can be redeemed only out of profits of the company which would otherwise be available for dividend or
out of proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made for the purpose of redemption. Note that the word 'proceeds'
does not include the amount of premium if shares are issued at a premium.
4. For the redemption of preference shares, Capital Redemption Reserve Account must be created only from
such accounts as represent divisible profits. The credit balance of profit and loss a/c, General Reserve, Dividend
equalisation Reserve are the examples of the balances available for distribution of dividend and hence for
transfer to Capital Redemption Reserve Account.
5. Amounts in Securities Premium Account, Forfeited Shares Account, Profit prior to incorporation account and
Capital Reserve Account must not be transferred to Capital Redemption Reserve Account.
6. If the shares are redeemed at a premium, as is the present case, the premium payable on redemption must
be provided for from the profits of the company or from the Securities Premium Account.
7. Use of Share premium a/c has been detailed in Section 78 of the Act. It does not say that the amount received
on account of share premium can be utilised for redemption of pref. shares but it says the such amount can be
used for paying premium on redemption of pref. shares.
Tutorial Notes regarding solution of this problem :
1. Amount required for redemption of preference shares
Amount required for redemption on face value of pref. shares
Add : Amount required for premium to be paid on redemption
Amount which can be transferred from the Securities premium a/c
Amount which can be transferred from the Profit and loss a/c
Amount which can be transferred from General Reserve
Amount required from fresh issue of shares
Balance amount required to be raised from Loan
Arrangement of cash for redemption would be as follows:
From fresh issue of shares :(2,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each)
From Share Premium a/c
From Loan from Bank
The Journal entries are as follows :
(date and folio column omitted)
Particulars
Bank a/c
Rs. Lacs
5.0
0.5
5.5
0.5
1.0
2.0
3.5
2.0
3.0
Cr.
Rs.
7. If the shares are re-issued at a price which is more than the face value of the shares, the excess amount will
be credited to Securities Premium Account.
8. If the re-issued amount and forfeited amount (taken together) exceeds the face value of the shares re-issued,
it is not necessary to transfer amount to Securities Premium account.
Tutorial Notes regarding solution of this problem :
1. Rahim failed to pay the allotment money. Thus he has not paid any amount towards share premium because
allotment money was inclusive of share premium. Since he is allotted 100 shares on pro-rata basis, he must
have applied for 150 shares and must have paid Rs. 300 alongwith the application. The amount of Rs. 300 will
be forfeited and will be credited to Forfeited Shares account.
2. Rahim's shares were forfeited after the first call. Thus entries regarding his shares upto the point of First call
must be cancelled. Share capital created upto the point of forfeiture is Rs. 8 /share (application : Rs. 2,
allotment : Rs. 2 and First call : Rs. 4). The forfeiture will reduce the share capital to the extent of Rs. 800 (100 x
Rs.8). The Share premium created of Rs. 250 (100 x Rs. 2.50) will have to be debited because of forfeiture. The
credit will be on account of Share allotment a/c, Share First call a/c and Share forfeiture a/c. Can you compute
the amount against these accounts ?
3. Rahim paid Rs. 300 alongwith application out of which Rs. 200 was adjusted towards application money and
balance of Rs. 100 was adjusted towards allotment money. He was called to pay Rs. 350 on allotment (Rs. 450
due less Rs. 100 already paid with application). Thus at forfeiture, the share allotment a/c will be credited with
Rs. 350 (and NOT with Rs. 450).
4. On the same logic, you can write the journal entries for the forfeiture of 150 shares of Haq who failed to pay
the first call and whose shares were forfeited after the second call. The share capital and the share premium
created up to the point of forfeiture of Haq's 150 shares will have to be cancelled. Can you determine the amount
forfeited on Haq's account ?
5. The amount of Rs. 200 in respect of 50 shares of Haq yet reissued, will remain in the Forfeited Shares
Account.
The solution goes as follows :
Working notes :
1. Rahim must have applied for 150 shares to be allotted 100 shares on prorata basis:
Amount paid towards application money
(150 shares @ Rs. 2/share)
Amount adjusted towards allotment ( 100 shares @ Rs. 2)
Amount due on allotment ( 100 x Rs. 4.50 less Rs. 100)
2. Amount forfeited on a/c 150 shares of Haq (Rs. 2 + Rs. 2) x 150 shares
3. Re-issue of 200 forfeited shares to Karim at Rs. 8 per share
Amount paid by Rahim (100 shares reallotted)
Amount paid by Haq (100 shares reallotted)
Amount paid by Karim @ Rs. 8/share x 200 shares
Total amount received on account of re-issued shares
Face value of shares
Profit on re-issue of shares
Alternatively :
Paid by Rahim on 100 shares (reallotted)
Paid by Haq on 100 shares (reallotted)
Discount allowed to Karim
Profit on shares re-issued
Rs.
300
200
350
600
300
400
1600
2,300
2,000
300
Rs.
300
400
700
400
300
350
400
300
600
300
600
2,000
300
Amalgamation
Problem : (cwa inter june 04)
The summarised balance sheets of X Ltd. and Y Ltd. as on 31st March 2004 were as follows :
X Ltd.
Y Ltd.
Rs.
Rs.
Fully paid up equity shares of Rs. 10 each
10,00,000
6,00,000
Share premium a/c
2,00,000
--General Reserve
3,00,000
2,50,000
Profit and loss a/c
1,80,000
1,60,000
10% Debentures
5,00,000
--Secured Loan
--3,00,000
Sundry Creditors
2,60,000
1,70,000
24,40,000
14,80,000
Land and Buildings
9,00,000
4,50,000
Plant and Machinery
5,00,000
3,80,000
Investment (5000 shares in Y Ltd.)
80,000
--Stock
5,20,000
3,50,000
Debtors
4,10,000
2,60,000
Bank
30,000
40,000
24,40,000
14,80,000
The companies agree on a scheme of amalgamation on the following terms :
(a) A new co. XY Ltd. is to be formed.
(b) XY Ltd. to take over all assets and liabilities of the existing companies.
(c) For the purpose of amalgamation, the shares of the existing companies are to be valued as under :
X Ltd.
Rs. 18 per share
Y Ltd.
Rs. 20 per share
(d) A contingent liability of X Ltd. of Rs. 60,000 is to be treated as real liability.
(e) The shareholders of X Ltd. and Y Ltd. are to be paid by issuing sufficient number of shares in XY
Ltd. at par.
(f) The shares in XY Ltd. are to be of Rs. 10 each.
Required :
(i) Show the computation of the number of shares XY Ltd. will issue to the shareholders of the existing
companies.
(ii) Pass the journal entries to close the books of X Ltd. and
(iii) Prepare the opening balance sheet of XY Ltd.
(Ignore liquidation and formation expenses.)
Solution :
General Tutorial Notes :
You must revise the following before attempting to solve the above problem. These should not be
treated as part of answer in the examination.
1. AS -- 14 deals with the accounting problems relating to amalgamation. According to AS -- 14, there
are two types of amalgamation (i) amalgamation in the nature of merger and (ii) amalgamation in the
nature of purchase.
2. AS -- 14 defines Purchase consideration as '' the aggregate of the shares and other securities issued
and the payment made in the form of cash or other assets by the transferee (amalgamating) company
to the shareholders of transferor (amalgamated) company.''
3. Points to Remember regarding purchase consideration :
3.1 Only payment of shareholders is to be taken into consideration.
3.2 Consideration for debentureholders will NOT be included in the purchase consideration.
3.3 Liquidation expenses or payment for cost of absorption are NOT included in purchase
consideration.
Tutorial Notes relating to problem :
1. 5,000 shares of Y Ltd. are held by X Ltd. These shares are assets for X ltd. As all the assets and
liabilities are taken over by XY Ltd., it will pay Rs. 20 per shares for 55,000 shares of Y Ltd. and NOT
for 60,000 shares. You should understand this properly.
2. You should compute the purchase consideration first. Rs. 18 per share is to be paid to the
shareholders of X Ltd. Total amount to be paid is Rs. 18.0 lacs. Thus XY ltd. will issue 180,000 shares
of face value of Rs. 10 each, to X ltd. Likewise it will pay Rs. 20/ shares for 55,000 shares of Y ltd in the
form of 110,000 shares of face value of Rs. 10 amounting to Rs. 11.0 lacs.
You can now compute the purchase consideration as follows :
X Ltd.
Y Ltd.
Existing shares
100,000
60,000
Less : Held by X Ltd.
5,000
55,000
Agreed value per share in Rs.
18
20
Total value in Rs. lacs
18.0
11.0
No. of shares to be issued (Rs. 10)
180,000
110,000
Journal entries in the books of X Ltd.:
A contingent liability of Rs. 60,000 is to be taken as real liability, it implies that profit and loss a/c is to be
debited and creditors to be credited. Thus profit and loss a/c will reduce to Rs. 120,000 from Rs.
180,000 and creditors will increase to Rs. 320,000 from Rs. 240,000.
For journalising the entries for the closure of X Ltd. Open a realisation a/c and transfer all assets and
liabilities (excluding fictitous assets) to this a/c and also credit this a/c with the purchase consideration.
Calculate profit and loss due to realisation.
The profit or loss so computed will be transferred to shareholders' a/c.
You can directly compute the profit on realisation as the difference between the net assets and
purchase consideration. The net assets = 900+500+80+520+410+30 -- 500 -- 260 --60 = Rs.16,20,000.
The purchase consideration is Rs. 18.0 lacs hence the profit on realisation is Rs.180,000.
Realisation a/c
Rs.'000
Rs.'000
Land and Buildings
900 10% Debentures a/c
500
Plant and Machinery
500 Creditors a/c
320
Investment
80 XY Ltd.
1,800
Stock
520
Debtors
410
Bank
30
Net profit
180
2,620
2,620
You can easily make journal entries of above ledger.
The profit on realisation will now be transferred shareholders a/c. Shareholders are the actual owners
of the company. They will also receive the shares issued by XY Ltd. as purchase consideration.
While transferring differenct assets to Realisation account, following points should be kept in mind:
1. For this purpose agreed valuations are absolutely immaterial.
2. Intangible assets like patents, trademarks and goodwill etc. are transferred to the realisation a/c at
their balance sheet values.
3. The fictitous assets like, discount on issue of shares and debentures, debit balance of profit and loss
a/c, preliminary expenses etc. are Not transferred to realisation account.
4. If the Pref. Shareholders are paid more or less than the amount due to them as per Balance sheet,
the difference should be transferred to Realisation a/c.
While transferring differenct liabilities to Realisation account, following points should be kept in mind:
1. Items in the nature of ' Provisions' are to be transferred to Realisation a/c but those in the nature of
'Reserves' should Not be transferred to Realisation a/c. All 'Reserves' should be transferred to
Shareholders a/c. The funds are reserves and not provisions, thus all funds should be transferred to
Shareholders a/c.
You should learn the following Journal entries properly :
Journal entries in the books of X Ltd.:
fig.' Rs.'000
Realisation a/c
2,440
To Land and buildings
900
To Plant and machinery
500
To Stock
520
To Debtors
410
To Investment
80
To Bank
30
Profit and loss a/c
60
To Creditors
60
(contingent liability treated as real liability)
10% Debentures
500
Creditors a/c
320
To Realisation
820
(Being liabilities transferred to realisation a/c)
XY Ltd. a/c
1,800
To Realisation
1,800
(being the purchase consideration received)
Share Capital a/c
1,000
Share Premium a/c
200
General Reserve
300
Plant and Machinery a/c
120
Realisation a/c
180
To Shareholders a/c
1,800
(being transfer of ledger balances)
Shareholders a/c
1,800
To Shares in XY Ltd
1,800
(being closure of shareholders a/c)
In the books of XY Ltd.
X Ltd.
Y Ltd.
XY Ltd.
Rs.
Rs.
10% Debentures
500
--500
Secured Loan
--300
300
Sundry Creditors
320
170
490
Land and Buildings
900
450
1,350
Plant and Machinery
500
380
880
Stock
520
350
870
Debtors
410
260
670
Bank
30
40
70
XY Ltd. Opening Balance sheet as at
Liabilities
Rs.'000 Assets
Rs.'000
Equity shares of Rs. 10 each issued
2,900 Goodwill
350
for consideration other than cash
Land and buildings
1,350
10% Debentures
500 Plant and machinery
880
Secured Loan
300 Stock
870
Creditors
490 Debtors
Bank
4,190
670
70
4,190
Sundry Creditors
Sundry Provisions
1,080
463
1,830
702
33,400
12,500
Assets
Bimal Ltd.
Robin Ltd.
Rs. Lacs
Rs. Lacs
Land and Buildings
6,000
--Plant and machinery
14,000
5,000
Furnitures
2,304
1,700
Stocks
7,862
4,041
Debtors
2,120
1,020
Cash at bank
1,114
609
Bills receivable
--80
Cost of issue of debentures
--50
33,400
12,500
All the bills receivable held by Robin Ltd. Were Bimal Ltd's acceptances.
On 1st April 2006 Bimal Ltd took Robin Ltd. In an amalgamation in the nature of merger. It was agreed
that in discharge of consideration for the business, Bimal Ltd. Would allot three fully paid shares of Rs.
10 each at par for every two shares held in Robin Ltd. It was also agreed that 12% debentures in Robin
Ltd. would be converted into 13% debentures in Bimal Ltd. of the same amount and denomination.
Expenses of amalgamation amounting to Rs. 1.0 lakh were borne by Bimal Ltd.
You are required to :
1. Pass journal entries in the books of Bimal Ltd.
2. Prepare Bimal Ltd's Balance sheet immediately after the merger.
Solution :
General Tutorial Notes :
You must revise the following before attempting to solve the above problem. These should not be
treated as part of answer in the examination.
AS -- 14 recognises two types of amalgamation : (a) amalgamation in the nature of merger and (b)
amalgamation in the nature of purchase
An amalgamation is in the nature of merger if all of the following conditions are satisfied :
(i) All the assets and liabilities of transferor company are taken over by the transferee company.
Transferee company means purchasing company or the amalgamating company.
(ii) The shareholders holding at least 90% or more of the equity shares of the transferor (amalgamated)
company become the equity shareholders of the transferee company.
(iii) Consideration for the amalgamation is paid in equity shares by the transferee company to the
shareholders of tramsferor company (except fractional shares which can be paid in cash).
(iv) Business of the transferor company is intended to be continued by the transferee company.
(v) No adjustment is made in the book values of the assets and liabilities of the transferor company by
way of revaluation or otherwise, except to ensure the uniformity of the accounting policies. For
example, if transferor company follows SLM for depreciation while transferee co. follows WDVM, the
transferee company can adjust the book value of fixed assets of transferor company in the books of
transferee company only for the difference of the depreciation between the two methods. Such
adjustment in the book value of fixed assets will not be treated as revaluation.
It must be noted here that the difference between the amount recorded as share capital issued plus any
additional consideration in the form of cash or other assets on one hand and the amount of share
capital of the transferor (amalgamated) company on the other hand is adjusted in reserves.
An amalgamation is in the nature of purchase if any of the conditions regarding amalgamation in the
nature of merger is not satisfied.
Points to Remember regarding purchase consideration :
Only payment of shareholders is to be taken into consideration.
For preparation and presentation of balance sheet after merger, you must revise the disclosure
requirements as follows (this is for your revision and does not form part of the answer in the
examination)
Disclosures :
For all amalgamations, the following disclosures should be made in the first financial statements
following the amalgamation :
(a) names and general nature of business of the amalgamating companies;
(b) effective dale of amalgamation for accounting purposes;
(c) the method of accounting used to reflect the amalgamation;
(d) particulars of the scheme sanctioned under the law.
For amalgamation under pooling of interest method (amalgamation in the nature of merger), the
following additional disclosures should be made in the first financial statements following the
amalgamation;
(a) description and number of shares issued, together with the percentage of each company's equity
shares exchanged to effect the amalgamation.
(b) the amount of any difference between the consideration and the value of net identifiable assets
acquired, and the treatment thereof.
Balance sheet
Liabilities :
Rs. Lacs
Share Capital
Authorised, issued and subscribed:
24 crores equity shares of Rs. 10 each, fully paid up
(of the above shares, 9 crores shares have been issued for
consideration other than cash)
24,000
Reserves and Surplus
Share Premium
3,000
General Reserve
310
Foreign project reserve
9,699
Profit and loss a/c
3,645
Secured Loan
13% Debentures
1,000
Current liabilities and provisions
Bills payable
40
Creditors
1,543
Sundry Provisions
2,532
45,769
Assets :
Fixed assets
Land and buildings
6,000
Plant & machinery
19,000
Furniture etc.
4,004
Current assets, Loans and Advances:
Stock
11,903
Debtors
3,140
Cash at Bank
1,722
Loans and Advances
0
45,769
Problem : (ca pcc nov. 99, cwa inter june 07)
The following are the balance sheets of Good Ltd. and Bad Ltd. as on 31.3.07
Good Ltd.
Bad Ltd.
Rs. Crores
Sources of Funds
Share Capital Authorised
Issued and fully paid up equity shares of Rs. 10
Reserves and Surplus
Shareholders Fund
Unsecured loan from Good Ltd.
Funds employed in:
Fixed assets at cost
Less: Depreciation
Written down value
Investment at cost
30 lacs equity shares of Rs. 10 each of Bad Ltd.
Long term loan to Bad Ltd.
Current assets
Rs. Crores
25
12
88
100
5
10
10
25
80
60
20
40
34
6
3
10
0
0
200
(133)
134
67
(115)
19
100
25
On that day Good Ltd. absorbed Bad Ltd. The members of Bad ltd. are to get one equity share of Good
Ltd. issued at a premium of Rs. 2 per share for every five equity share held by them in Bad Ltd. The
necessary approvals are obtained.
You are asked to pass journal entries in the books of the two companies to give effect to the above.
Solution :
Tutorial Notes:
1. You can begin with the books of either companies. In either case you will have to calculate the
purchase consideration to be paid to shareholders of Bad ltd. Can you calculate the purchase
consideration?
2. Let us first take journal entries of Bad ltd. For journalising the entries for the closure of Bad Ltd.
Open a realisation a/c and transfer all assets and liabilities (excluding fictitous assets) to this a/c and
also credit this a/c with the purchase consideration. Calculate profit and loss due to realisation.
3. The profit or loss so computed will be transferred to shareholders' a/c.
4. All books of B ltd. are to be closed. Thus the written down value of the fixed assets will NOT be
transferred to realisation a/c. The realisation a/c will be debited with the fixed assets at cost and will be
credited with depreciation accumulated. This entry will close the books of fixed assets and depreciation.
In the opening entries of Good ltd., the fixed assets will be recorded at its value of Rs. 6.0 crores.
Similar is the case with current assets. The net current assets have been given as Rs. 19 crores but
the realisation a/c will NOT be debited with this amount, Instead, it will be debited with total amount of
Rs. 134 crores and simultaneously credited with current liabilities of Rs. 115 crores. You must take a
serious note of this entry.
5. The absorbing company i.e. Good Ltd. already has 30 lacs shares of absorbed company i.e. Bad
Ltd. The total number of shares in Bad Ltd is 50 lacs (500 / 10). This is amalgamation in the nature of
merger. The AS-14 should be followed.
Steps to solve this problem may be something like the one supplied below:
1. Compute the purchase consideration. For every five shares of Bad ltd., Good ltd will issue one equity
share of Rs. 10 at a premium of Rs. 2. Bad Ltd. has 50 lacs shareholders. Thus 10 lacs shares of Rs.
12 each amouting to Rs. 120 lacs will be purchase consideration. Show it as your first working note.
2. To compute the profit or loss on realisation, you need to prepare Realisation a/c. Compute the profit
or loss on realisation, and transfer this to Shareholders a/c. Don't forget to credit the realisation a/c with
purchase consideration. Prepare your realisation a/c and compare it with the one given below. Can you
compute the profit or loss on realisation without preparing any a/c? Think over it before you read any
further. The Balance sheet shows the net worth of the company as Rs. 15.0 crores [( 5+10) or (6+19
10)]. The consideration being paid is Rs. 1.20 crores thus the loss on realisation would be Rs. 13.80
crores.
Realisation A/c
40.0
134.0
Rs. Crores
By Provision for depreciation
By Current liabilities
By Loan from G ltd.
By Purchase consideration
34.0
115.0
10.0
1.2
174.0
160.2
By Shareholders (loss)
13.8
174.0
174.0
The loss to B ltd. will be a gain for Good ltd. Thus Good ltd. will have a capital reserve of this amount in
its balance sheet.
3. You must now close the Share capital a/c and Reserve a/c by debiting these to Shareholders a/c.
To Fixed assets
To Current assets
4. Good ltd. holds 60% of Bad ltd. The purchase consideration is Rs. 1.2 crore. Out of this, 60% i.e. Rs.
0.72 crore will go back to equity shareholders of Good ltd. and the balance of Rs. 0.48 crore will bo to
other shareholders of Bad ltd. Think how can you record this transaciton in the books of Bad ltd.
Prepare Journal entries in the books of Bad Ltd. and compare them with the entries furnished below.
Note that whenever journal entries are asked, entries should be supported by narration.
Journal Entries in the books of Bad Ltd(Rs. In crores)
Dr.
174.0
Realisation a/c
40.0
To Fixed assets a/c
134.0
To Current assets a/c
(being the assets taken over by Good Ltd. transferred to Realisation a/c)
Dr.
34.0
Provision for depreciation a/c
Dr.
115.0
Current liabilities a/c
Dr.
10.0
Loan from G ltd. a/c
159.0
To Realisation a/c
(transfer of liabilities and provisions to R a/c)
Dr.
1.2
G Ltd. a/c
1.2
To R a/c
(purchase consideration credited to R a/c)
Dr.
13.8
Equity shareholders a/c
13.8
To R a/c
(loss on realisation transferred to equity shareholders a/c)
Dr.
5.0
Equity share capital a/c
Dr.
10.0
Reserve and Surplus a/c
15.0
To Equity shareholders a/c
Dr.
0.72
Equity shareholders a/c (G ltd.)
0.72
To G ltd. a/c
(60% of consideration due from G ltd is adjusted against the amount due to G ltd.)
Dr.
0.48
Equity shares of G ltd. a/c
0.48
To G ltd.
(receipt of 4 lacs shares of Rs. 10 each at a premium of Rs. 2
for outside shareholders of B ltd.)
For journal Entries in the books of Good Ltd.
Tutorial Notes :
1. G ltd already has an investment of Rs. 3.0 crores in B ltd. which it is going to absorb. From the
above it is clear, that G ltd. is paying Rs.1.2 crores as purchase consideration out of which it will adjust
Rs. 0.72 crores as 60% because it has 60% shares of B ltd. Thus there is Loss of Rs. 2.28 crores to G
ltd. in this investment. Overall the Profit to G ltd. is Rs.13.8 crores as computed earlier.
2. You must be careful to create Share premium a/c separately, whenever the shares are issued at
premium. Rs. 0.48 crores to be allotted in the form of shares to outside shareholders of B ltd. You
should credit Rs. 0.40 crores to Share Capital a/c and Rs.0.08 crore to Share Premium a/c.
3. As the G ltd. is absorbing B ltd., The mutual owings like the investment in B ltd. a/c and the Loan to
Bad ltd. a/c will be closed.
The Journal entries are as follows :
Rs. In crores
Business purchase a/c
Dr.
1.20
To Liquidator of Bad Ltd.
1.20
(amount of purchase consideration)
Fixed assets a/c
Dr.
6.00
Current assets a/c
Dr.
134.00
To Current liabilities a/c
115.00
To Loan a/c
10.00
To Business purchase a/c
1.20
To Capital reserve a/c
13.80
(assets and liabilities are taken over, the difference is
transferred to capital reserve)
Liquidator of Bad Ltd. a/c
Dr.
0.72
Capital reserve a/c
Dr.
2.28
To Investment in B ltd. a/c
3.00
(investment a/c closed and loss transferred to capital reserve)
Liquidator of Bad Ltd. a/c
Dr.
0.48
To Equity share capital a/c
0.40
To Security Premium a/c
0.08
(allotment to outside shareholders of B ltd at a premium of Rs. 2)
Loan from G ltd. a/c
Dr.
10.00
To Loan to B ltd. a/c
10.00
(cancellation of mutual accounts)
Problem (ca pcc may 04)
Super express ltd. and Fast express were in competing business. They decided to form a new
company named SuperFast express Ltd. The balance sheets of both the companies were as under:
Balance sheet of Super express as at 31.12.99
Liabilities
Rs. Assets
Rs.
20,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each
### Buildings
###
Providend Fund
100,000 Machinery
400,000
Sundry Creditors
60,000 Stock
300,000
Insurance Reserve
100,000 Sundry debtors
240,000
Cash at Bank
220,000
Cash in hand
100,000
###
###
Balance sheet of Fast express as at 31.12.99
Liabilities
Rs. Assets
Rs.
10,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each
### Goodwill
100,000
Employees profit sharing fund
60,000 Buildings
600,000
Sundry Creditors
40,000 Machinery
500,000
Reserve account
100,000 Debtors
40,000
Surplus
100,000 Stock
40,000
Cash at Bank
10,000
Cash in hand
10,000
###
###
The assets and liabilities of both the companies were taken over by the new company at their book
values. The companies were allotted shares of Rs. 100 each in lieu of purchase consideration.
Prepare opening balance sheet of Super Fast Express Ltd.
Solution:
Tutorial Notes :
This is a very easy question. You should find no difficulty in solving it.
1. You are to decide whether this is amalgamation in the nature of merger or purchase. The question is
silent about this and It has not been mentioned whether the amalgamation is in the nature of merger or
purchase. What you are supposed to do?
2. If it is full marks question, you must go for both the options. First you should assume that this is
amalgamation in the nature of merger and employ the pooling of interest method to prepare the
balance sheet. Then you should assume the other option of amalgamation in the nature of purchase
and go for purchase method. In case if the question is of less marks say 6 or 8 marks, you can go for
any one of the two options.
3. For better understanding, let us prepare the balance sheet as per both the options. At this stage you
are advised to go through the difference between two methods viz. Pooling of interest method and
Purchase method. It is the easiest, to prepare balance sheet as per pooling of interest method. You can
do it without any complex calculation.
4. How will you determine the purchase consideration? For Super Express Ltd., the provident fund is a
fund meant for employees and has to be utilised for specific purpose if the company goes into
liquidation. Thus this will not be considered for computing the purchase consideration.
5. Please compute the purchase consideration for Super Ltd. In purchase method, the purchase
consideration is paid on the basis of net assets of the companies. Compute the net assets of both the
companies from both the sides viz. Liabilities side and Assets side.
6. For Fast Ltd. the employees profit sharing fund will not be considered in calculating the net worth
(and consequently the purchase consideration) as this fund will be utilised for employees only. You
should compute the purchase consideration of the Fast ltd. on net assets basis.
7. For amalgamation in the nature of merger, you have just to combine the two balance sheets as no
adjustments are required as per the question. See how these two balance sheets can be combined:
Amalgamation in the nature of merger:
Balance sheet of Super express as at 31.12.99
Liabilities
Rs. Lacs Assets
Rs. Lacs
20,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each
20.0 Buildings
10.0
Providend Fund
1.0 Machinery
4.0
Sundry Creditors
0.6 Stock
3.0
Insurance Reserve
1.0 Sundry debtors
2.4
Cash at Bank
2.2
Cash in hand
1.0
22.6
22.6
Balance sheet of Fast express as at 31.12.99
Liabilities
Rs. Lacs Assets
Rs. Lacs
10,000 equity shares of Rs. 100 each
10.0 Goodwill
1.0
Employees profit sharing fund
0.6 Buildings
6.0
Sundry Creditors
0.4 Machinery
5.0
Reserve account
1.0 Debtors
0.4
Surplus
1.0 Stock
0.4
Cash at Bank
0.1
Cash in hand
0.1
13.0
13.0
2.3
1.1
34.6
10.0
14.0
34.0
8.0
22.0
2.2
2.0
1.0
0.5
12.0
16.0
4.0
90.0
14.0
12.0
1.8
60.0
2.5
1.8
0.3
8.0
Rs. Lacs
Additional Information:
(1) Particulars of investments are as follows :
33.6
X Ltd.
Investments in 160,000 shares in Y Ltd.
0.4
Investments in 5,000 shares in Z Ltd.
2.2
Y Ltd.
Investments in 12,000 shares in Z Ltd.
0.5
Z Ltd.
Investment in Growth Sector Bonds (FV : Rs. 50,000)
(2) The acquisition of investments took place in the manner indicated below:
Balance in Profit and loss a/c
Date
Y Ltd.
Z Ltd.
X Ltd.
14.0
1.00
160,000 shares in Y Ltd.
1st April 1999
0.20
5,000 shares in Z Ltd.
1st April 1997
Y Ltd.
0.72
12,000 shares in Z Ltd.
1st April 1998
(3) X Ltd. has proposed 15% dividend for the accounting period ended on March 31,2000. This amount is
included
in debtors
sundry creditors.
(4)
Sundry
of Y Ltd. include Rs. 30,000 representing sum due from X Ltd. Sundry creditors of X Ltd.
Prepare a consolidated Balance sheet of X Ltd. and its subsidiaries as at March 31,2000.
Solution :
You can straight away prepare most of Consolidated Balance sheet of X Ltd. by simply adding up the assets
Consolidated Balance sheet of X Ltd. as at 31 March, 2000
Rs. Lacs
Liabilities
Rs. Lacs Assets
30.0 Goodwill
?
Equity Share Capital
?
Land
and
buildings
(10+8+2)
20.00
Profit and loss a/c
? Plant & machinery (14+22+1)
37.00
Capital Reserve
25.0
Investment
in
bonds
0.50
Secured Loan (15+8+2)
7.0
Stocks
(12+14+2.5)
28.50
Unsecured Loan (5+2)
28.8
Debtors (16+12+1.75)
29.8
Creditors (12+14+2.8)
4.5
Less: Intercompany debt
0.3
29.45
Less: Proposed dividend
Cash
in
transit
(15% of Rs. 30.0 lacs)
0.2
24.1 Cash (4+1.8+0.25)
6.05
Less: Intercompany debt
4.5
Proposed Dividend
?
Minority Interest
To fill the various blanks you have to prepare working notes. Following guidelines will be helpful.
1. On the date of consolidation, X Ltd. has 80% control on Y, it also has 25% control on Z. On the same date Y
2. Minority interest in Y is 20% as X has 80% control. As Y holds 60% shares in Z, the MI of Y will hold 20% of
Solution goes as follows :
X in Y
80% (2) Minority Interest X in Y
20%
(1) Controlling interest :
X in Z (direct)
25%
X in Z (15% + 20% of 60%)
27%
X in Z (indirect
48%
(3) Pre-acquisition (capital) profit
X's share in Y
80% of Rs. 14.0 lakhs
X's share in Z direct
25% of Rs. 20,000
indirect
48% of Rs. 1.0 lakh
(4)_Post acquisition (revenue) profit :
X's share in Y
80% of Rs. 2.0 lakhs
X's share in Z direct
25% of Rs. 1.0 lakh
indirect
48% of Rs. 20,000
Z Ltd.
Total
0.40
1.76
2.16
33.60
0.40
1.76
35.76
0.50
0.96
1.46
0.70
0.53
0.17
17.46
17.46
18.30
11.73
6.57
33.60
33.60
Less : Nominal value of shares held
X in Y (80%)
X in Z (direct 25%)
X in Z (indirect 80%)
34,600
194,600
28,00,000
29,94,600
16.00
16.00
17.60
11.20
6.40
4.00
0.54
4.54
3.20
0.32
3.52
7.20
0.86
8.06
Less: Share of cost of investment in Z Ltd.
0.44
0.44
6.76
0.86
7.62
Consolidated Balance sheet of X Ltd. as at 31 March, 2000
Liabilities
Rs. Lacs Assets
30.00 Goodwill
Equity Share Capital
29.95 Land and buildings (10+8+2)
Profit and loss a/c
0.00 Plant & machinery (14+22+1)
Capital Reserve
25.00 Investment in bonds
Secured Loan (15+8+2)
7.00 Stocks (12+14+2.5)
Unsecured Loan (5+2)
28.8
Debtors (16+12+1.75)
Creditors (12+14+2.8)
4.5
Less: Intercompany debt
Less: Proposed dividend
Cash in transit
(15% of Rs. 30.0 lacs)
0.2
24.10 Cash (4+1.8+0.25)
Less: Intercompany debt
Rs. Lacs
6.57
20.00
37.00
0.50
28.50
29.8
0.3
29.45
0.10
6.05
Proposed Dividend
Minority Interest
4.50
7.62
128.17
128.17