Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Immunoassay
Urban A. Kiernan,* Riccardo Addobbati, Dobrin Nedelkov, and Randall W. Nelson
Intrinsic Bioprobes, Inc., 625 S. Smith Rd. Ste. 22, Tempe, Arizona 85281
Received March 23, 2006
Reported in this work is the development and application of a high sensitivity mass spectrometric
immunoassay for the quantitative analysis of C-reactive protein from human plasma. Multiplexed affinity
retrieval devices and methodology were developed to simultaneously target retinol binding protein,
C-reactive protein, serum amyloid P component, as well as an added exogenous internal reference
standard (staphylococcal enterotoxin B) for subsequent MALDI-TOF MS analysis. This approach allows
for semiquantitative analysis of both retinol binding protein and serum amyloid P component while
performing absolute quantitative measurements of C-reactive protein. The ability to qualitatively
differentiate between all three human proteins and their associated variants is also maintained. Standard
curve, QC, and human plasma samples were analyzed in a high throughput manner, which performed
with a CV < 15%. The resultant human plasma sample C-reactive protein quantitative measurements
were then compared to those achieved with a high sensitivity latex immunoturbidimetric assay.
Keywords: mass spectrometry Immunoassay C-reactive protein quantitation multiplexing human plasma
Introduction
The field of proteomics has extended its scope beyond basic
research and is now attempting to enter clinical application
and diagnostics. Historically, clinical biomarker screening has
been reserved for classical immunoassay methodologies, but
recent findings have shown that pertinent clinical data may
lie beyond the fidelity of such approaches 1. The use of protein
mass spectrometry in proteomics holds the key to this issue,
with the intrinsic ability to qualitatively discriminate between
multiple forms of the same target protein. However, a major
hurdle for proteomics, in entering the clinical and diagnostic
arena, is the inability to readily perform absolute protein
quantification. There are many quantitative proteomic approaches currently available, however, methodologies such as
Isotope-Coded Affinity Tags (ICAT)2 are only semiquantitative
in nature and have restricted data content due to being peptide
based. Such peptide based approaches may not allow for
accurate qualitative differentiation between the clinically relevant forms of the same protein.3-5
A potential solution to this problem is the mass spectrometric immunoassay (MSIA), a high content proteomics methodology based on immuno-affinity protein isolation combined with
mass spectrometric detection. This approach has a longstanding track record of performing both relative6-8 and
absolute quantitative analyses,9-12 which is augmented by its
unprecedented ability to qualitatively differentiate between
multiple forms of the same protein target1,13-19 in a single
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel: (480) 804-1778.
Fax: (480) 804-0778. Email: ukiernan@intrinsicbio.com.
1682
Experimental Procedure
Affinity Pipets. MSIA protein purification was achieved using
antibody derivatized affinity pipets (Intrinsic Bioprobes, Inc.,
Tempe, AZ). These pipets (commonly referred to as MSIA-Tips)
were produced using the same protocol as described previously.23 The affinity ligand used in this study was a mixture of
polyclonal antibodies targeting retinol binding protein (RBP:
8.0 mg/mL, Cat No. A0040, DakoCytomation, Carpinteria, CA),
C-reactive protein (CRP: 8.3 mg/mL, Cat No. A0073, DakoCytomation, Carpinteria, CA), serum amyloid P component
10.1021/pr0601133 CCC: $33.50
research articles
research articles
Kiernan et al.
m/z theoretical
(MH+)
m/z observed
(MH+)
RBP
RBP -Leu
CRP
SAP
SAP-Val
SAP-Sial
SEB
21 066.5
20 953.4
23 029.1
25 463.5
25 364.4
25 172.2
28 367.0
21 065.8 ( 3.7
20 952.9 ( 4.3
23 029.2 ( 3.5
25 466.0 ( 6.6
25 360.9 ( 3.0
25 174.5 ( 3.9
28 368.7 ( 4.4
RBP
curve 1
curve 2
low QC (0.075 g/mL)
med QC (0.750 g/mL)
high QC (2.500 g/mL)
13.634
6.242
4.192
13.752
9.676
CRP
SAP
6.373
7.115
10.134
6.252
11.640
2.354
11.590
11.932
research articles
Figure 3. Semiquantitative protein determination. (A) Normalized abundances of retinol binding protein and detected variants in each
of the 35 patient plasma samples. (B) Normalized abundances of serum amyloid P component and detected variants in each of the
same patient plasma samples.
sample. Such protein variation may hold significant information regarding the presence of disease.
Absolute CRP Quantitation. Regarding the quantitative CRP
analysis, the two generated standard curves of the normalized
CRP peak integrals verses CRP antigen concentration were
averaged, which resulted in the following equation (CRP/SEB )
1.3092[CRP mg/mL]0.6742). This average equation was then used
to translate the observed normalized CRP/SEB peak integral ratios
determined from each of the patient samples into CRP concentrations (mg/mL). Only two plasma samples (nos. 17 and
26) of the 35 analyzed using this approach resulted in concen-
research articles
Kiernan et al.
multiplexed proteomic analysis. Moreover, the QC and standard curve analyses demonstrated coefficients of variation that
were significantly better than other potential clinical proteomic
approaches28 again adding to the potential of the mass spectrometric immunoassay for routine and repetitive target protein(s) analysis, as a needed in a clinical and diagnostic application.
Finally, this demonstration of an improved multiplexed MSIA
approach sets the foundation for future developmental work,
which would include increased multiplexing for more protein
targets, as well as the simultaneous generation of multiple
standard curves for absolute multi-protein quantitative measurements in a single analysis.
Figure 4. Human plasma CRP concentrations. Comparison of the
CRP concentrations determined in each of the patient samples
(g/mL) via mass spectrometric immunoassay and immunoturbidimetric assay.
Conclusion
It has become readily apparent that proteomics has the
potential to become integral in clinical application. However,
the question still remains as to which form of the multiple
proteomics approaches available will translate into the mainstream of clinical and diagnostic use. Presented here was the
development and application of a novel multiplexed high
sensitivity-CRP mass spectrometric immunoassay. This approach allowed for simultaneous semiquantitative analysis of
human retinol binding protein and serum amyloid P component while performing rigorous quantitative measurements of
C-reactive protein. Qualitative protein characterization, of all
targets, is maintained in this high throughput approach. This
methodology described is a novel multiplexed approach that
is an improvement of a previously existing assay. The enhancement was achieved through the specific affinity targeting and
analysis of an exogenous protein (staphylococcal enterotoxin
B) that was added to all samples and co-analyzed for use as
an internal reference standard in peak integral normalization,
thus making the semi- and absolute quantitative measurements
possible. This is the first ever demonstration of such a
1686
research articles
(27) Apple, F. S.; Maturen, A. J.; Mullins, R. E.; Painter, P. C.; PessinMinsley, M. S.; Webster, R. A.; Spray Flores, J.; DeCresce, R.; Fink,
D. J.; Buckley, P. M.; Marsh, J.; Ricchiuti, V.; Christenson, R. H.
Clin. Chem. 1999, 45, 206-212.
(28) Aivado, M.; Spentzos, D.; Alterovitz, G.; Otu, H. H.; Grall, F.;
Giagounidis, A. A.; Wells, M.; Cho, J. Y.; Germing, U.; Czibere, A.;
Prall, W. C.; Porter, C.; Ramoni, M. F.; Libermann, T. A. Clin.
Chem. Lab. Med. 2005, 43, 133-140.
PR0601133