Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hudson County
(Wildenhus Case)
Author's Note: Wildenhus and Fijens were Belgian sailors aboard a Belgian steamship anchored in the port
of Jersey City, New Jersey. In a fight below decks, Wildenhus stabbed and killed Fijens. The Jersey City
police learned about this incident and arrested Wildenhus. Several Belgian crew members witnessed this
incident. They also were placed in the port jail as witnesses for the proceedings against Wildenhus.
.....The treaty between Belgium and the US ceded "primary" jurisdiction over onboard crimes to the
respective flag States to which the vessels were registered. A Belgian consular official in New Jersey relied
on this treaty and thus sought the release of the Belgian sailors to his custody. This foreign official was acting
on behalf of Belgium, referring to himself as the "petitioner." The issue was whether the port tranquility
doctrine should be applied to deprive the flag State (Belgium) of its primary jurisdiction under the treaty.
.....The first portion of the reported case is a factual account provided by the lawyers representing the US (on
behalf of the prosecution by the state of New Jersey). In the latter portion of this opinion, the Chief Justice
then delivered the Supreme Court's decisionagreeing with the lower courts that the treaty permitted New
Jersey to prosecute the Belgian sailor under the circumstances. This particular homicide provided cause for
invoking the port tranquility exception to Belgian jurisdiction over events occurring aboard its vessel.
Court's Opinion:
.....This appeal brought up an application made to the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of
New Jersey, by Charles Mali, the "Consul of His Majesty the King of the Belgians, for the States of New
York and New Jersey, in the United States," for himself as such consul, "and in behalf of one Joseph
Wildenhus, one Gionviennie Gobnbosich, and one John J. Ostenmeyer," for the release, upon a writ of habeas
corpus, of Wildenhus, Gobnbosich, and Ostenmeyer from the custody of the keeper of the common jail of
Hudson County, New Jersey, and their delivery to the consul, "to be dealt with according to the law of
Belgium." The facts on which the application rested were thus stated in the petition [requested by Belgium].
................................................................................... . .
.....Second. That on or about the sixth day of October, 1886, on board the Belgian steamship Noordland, there
occurred an affray between the said Joseph Wildenhus and one Fijens, wherein and whereby it is charged that
the said Wildenhus stabbed with a knife and inflicted upon the said Fijens a mortal wound, of which he
afterwards died.
................................................................................... . .
.....Fifth. That at the time said affray occurred the said steamship Noordland was lying moored at the dock of
the port of Jersey City, in said state of New Jersey.
................................................................................... . .
.....Seventh. That said affray occurred in the presence of several witnesses all of whom were and still are of
the crew of the said vessel, and that no other person or persons except those of the crew of said vessel were
present or nearby. . . .
.....Article XI of a Convention between the United States and Belgium "concerning the rights, privileges, and
immunities of consular officers" . . . is as follows:
..........The respective consuls-general, consuls, vice-consuls, and consular agents shall have exclusive charge
of the internal order of the merchant vessels of their nation, and shall alone take cognizance of all differences
which may arise, either at sea or in port, between the captains, officers, and crews, without exception,
particularly with reference to the adjustment of wages and the execution of contracts. The local authorities
shall not interfere, except when the disorder that has arisen is of such a nature as to disturb tranquility and
public order on shore, or in the port, or when a person of the country or not belonging to the crew, shall be
concerned therein.
..........In all other cases, the aforesaid authorities shall confine themselves to lending aid to the consuls and
vice-consuls or consular agents, if they are requested by them to do so, in causing the arrest and