Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TREND SURVEY
2014 2015
sponsored by
CONTENTS
Executive Summary.......................................................................................... 3
Section I: Risk Management............................................................................. 4
Section II: Organizational Performance and Efficiency...................................... 9
Section III: Combating Worker Fatigue........................................................... 14
Conclusion..................................................................................................... 17
About............................................................................................................. 18
Appendix: Demographic Information............................................................. 19
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Employers have long relied on workforce management
processes to deploy, measure, and improve the effectiveness
of their labor pool.Those same functions are now playing a
bigger role in recruitment and retention. As the goals for these
processes evolve, so do the enabling technologies. For instance,
while time and attendance practices remain the cornerstone
of workforce management, leave administration and time-off
policy design are emerging as focal points.
For the past five years WorkForce Software LLC, in
conjunction with Workforce magazine, has endeavored
to identify, document and analyze these advances in
workforce management practices through an annual
market survey. This years study examines the results
of the most recent survey, while also drawing upon
findings from previous surveys, when applicable, to
illustrate the evolution underway.
This years survey explored three specific areas of
workforce management:
PARTICIPANTS
SECTION I:
RISK MANAGEMENT
EMPLOYEE MORALE TOPS THE LIST
OF NONCOMPLIANCE CONCERNS
FIGURE 1
Decline in
employee morale
69%
Brand equity/
damaged reputation
67%
Fines and
penalties
66%
Litigation
65%
64%
Increased attrition
62%
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
QUESTION:
1
2
FIGURE 2
60%
Brand equity/
damaged reputation
76%
79%
63%
Decline in
employee morale
80%
75%
61%
Fines and
penalties
68%
66%
10
Small
3
4
5
6
20
30
Midsize
40
50
60
70
80
Large
Stebner, B. (2013), Workplace morale heads down: 70% of Americans negative about their jobs, Gallup study shows. New York Daily News.
Baker, B (2013). Employee morale still on the decline, but benefits education can help. Reuters.
Engardio, P. and Arndt, M. (2007). What price reputation? Bloomberg Businessweek Magazine.
Cable, D. and Turban, D. (2003). The value of organizational reputation in the recruitment context: a brand-equity perspective. University of Missouri.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
FIGURE 3
8%
32%
Much/
Somewhat Harder
About the Same
Much/
Somewhat Easier
60%
7
8
Ruggles, M. and Brown, C. (2013). New compliance obligations for 2014: fewer new laws, but important changes for employers. Littler Mendelson P.C.
English, S. and Hammond, S. (2014). Cost of compliance. Thomson Reuters Accelus.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
FIGURE 4
32%
16%
Hours
Not Sure
Days
21%
Minutes
31%
FIGURE 5
68%
HR
55%
18%
Operations
29%
5%
Payroll
5%
3%
Finance
5%
10
2013
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
2014
SECTION II:
FIGURE 6
50%
4%
9%
No Automated Alerts
1%
Phone
9%
Online Message
Other
10%
Social
17%
Text
QUESTION:
FIGURE 7
Pairing senior
workers with them
59%
Structuring
learning courses
in their schedule
49%
Rotating through
different shifts
and positions
27%
We dont, but we
would like to
13%
We dont and
we have no
current interest
11%
Other
6%
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
FIGURE 8
63%
37%
FIGURE 9
Could prove it
would improve
productivity
53%
Could prove it
would improve
retention
40%
Could prove it
would reduce
absenteeism
36%
Could prove it
would attract
better candidates
32%
None of
the above
25%
Other
8%
10
20
30
40
50
60
11
Physical
Health
71%
Religious
Holidays
57%
Parental
Obligations
56%
Life
Event
55%
Mental
Health
47%
Volunteering/
Charitable Work
29%
Other
15%
85%
Bereavement
20
40
60
80
100
FIGURE 11
8%
43%
Labor Analytics
Time and Attendance
Absence and
Leave Management
13%
Staff Scheduling
Other
13%
23%
10 SHRM (2008). Examining paid leave in the workplace: helping your organization attract and retain talented employees.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
12
QUESTION:
If you were to evaluate a new workforce
management solution today, which function
would be your primary focus?
47%
High/
Medium Priority
FIGURE 13
Finance/
insurance
62%
Low Priority
Not a Priority
Retail/
hospitality
32%
61%
21%
Health care
48%
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
FIGURE 14
51%
27%
22%
13
SECTION III:
13
14
FIGURE 15
71%
Major/
Moderate
Impact
75%
22%
Minor Impact
18%
7%
No Significant
Impact
8%
10
2013
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
2014
Chee, E., Ricci, J. A., Lorandeau, A. L., & Berger, J. (2007). Fatigue in the U.S. workforce: prevalence and implications for lost productive work time.
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 49(1):1-10.
Rosekind, M., Gregory, K., Mallis, M., Brandt, S., Seal, B. and Lerner, D. (2012). The cost of poor sleep: workplace productivity loss and associated costs.
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 52(1):91-98.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
14
FIGURE 16
Flextime
38%
None; my
organization does
not have programs
to address
employee fatigue
33%
Adjust
scheduling
practices
32%
Telecommuting/
work from home
28%
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
FIGURE 17
42%
Budget
constraints
49%
39%
Understaffing
relative to
workload
45%
30%
Not a
management
priority
36%
32%
Poor understanding
of the impact of
employee fatigue
on the business
35%
10
2013
20
30
40
50
2014
15
FIGURE 18
Absence Patterns
69%
Hours Worked
67%
Extended Leave
66%
Other
65%
Shift Changes
64%
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
15 Mollie Lombardi (2013). Total Workforce Management 2013: Absence Management. Aberdeen Group.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
16
CONCLUSION
Workforce management systems and practices are continuing to play a
bigger role in securing top talent and improving business performance. On
the HR side, the majority of organizations are already designing scheduling
and time-off programs to cater to new hires and retain their best employees.
Most organizations offer leave policies more generous than those required
by law, which suggests that employees expect them to go above and beyond
what is simply required by law to stand out as an employer of choice. On
the operations side, those same policies are being scrutinized to understand
their effect on company profitability, and businesses have a big appetite
for better labor analytics tools to help inform company strategy. Critically,
these two drivers are closely interrelated, rather than being separate goals.
Organizations are starting to recognize the relationships between intricate
functions like labor compliance and employee morale, and many are testing
out new ways of strengthening the employer-employee bond particularly
at sensitive times, such as a leave of absence. When organizations get it right,
they are rewarded not only with improved morale, but also with a resulting
boost in productivity as a result of keeping employees informed, engaged,
and incented to remain part of the team.
17
ABOUT
WORKFORCE MAGAZINE
The Human Capital Media (HCM) Research and Advisory Group is the
research division of Human Capital Media, publisher of Chief Learning Officer,
Talent Management and Workforce magazines. The Research and Advisory Group
specializes in partnered research solutions customizable and proprietary
deliverables that integrate seamlessly with existing sales and marketing programs.
Leveraging our access to senior-level decision-makers and proven HR industry
expertise, we undertake market and thought leadership research in the human
resources industry. Creating custom content and presenting thought leadership
research are all part of the Research and Advisory Groups focus.
If you have any questions, contact Sarah Kimmel, research director:
skimmel@humancapitalmedia.com.
Workforce Management Trend Survey 2014-2015
18
APPENDIX:
DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION
COMPANY SIZE
GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION
INDUSTRY
Finance/Insurance: 6 percent
Manufacturing: 12 percent
Other: 33 percent
19