Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
Volume 1
Introduction
In our previous work [1], we developed a semi-classical conformal theory of quantum gravity and electromagnetism in
which both gravity and electromagnetism were successfully
unified and linked to each other through an external quantum space-time deformation on the fundamental Planck scale.
Herein we wish to further explore the geometrization of the
electromagnetic field in [1] which was achieved by linking
the electromagnetic field strength to the torsion tensor built
by means of a conformal mapping in the evolution (configuration) space. In so doing, we shall in general disregard the
conformal mapping used in [1] and consider an arbitrary, very
general torsion field expressible as a linear combination of the
electromagnetic and material spin fields.
Herein we shall find that the completely geometrized
Yang-Mills field of standard model elementary particle physics, which roughly corresponds to the electromagnetic, weak,
and strong nuclear interactions, has a more general form than
that given in the so-called rigid, local isospace.
We shall not simply describe our theory in terms of a Lagrangian functional due to our unease with the Lagrangian approach (despite its versatility) as a truly fundamental physical
approach towards unification. While the meaning of a particular energy functional (to be extremized) is clear in Newtonian physics, in present-day space-time physics the choice of
a Lagrangian functional often appears to be non-unique (as it
may be concocted arbitrarily) and hence devoid of straightforward, intuitive physical meaning. We shall instead, as in
our previous works [13], build the edifice of our unified field
theory by carefully determining the explicit form of the connection.
e
F u + S ;
2 mc2
where the components of the third-rank material spin (chirality) tensor 3 S are herein given via the second-rank antisymmetric tensor 2 S as follows:
S = S u
S u :
S u = 0 ;
such that
S u = 0 :
We note that 3 S may be taken as the intrinsic angular momentum tensor for microscopic physical objects which may
be seen as the points in the space-time continuum itself. This
way, 3 S may be regarded as a microspin tensor describing the
internal rotation of the space-time points themselves [2]. Al3
2 The determination of the explicit form of the connec- ternatively, S may be taken as being purely material (ention for the unification of the gravitational, electro- tirely non-electromagnetic).
The covariant derivative of an arbitrary tensor field T is
magnetic, and material spin fields
given via the asymmetric connection by
::: = @ T ::: + T ::: + T ::: +
We shall work in an affine-metric space-time manifold S4
r T:::
:::
:::
:::
(with coordinates x ) endowed with both curvature and tor T :::
T ::: : : : ;
sion. As usual, if we denote the symmetric, non-singular, fun :::
:::
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
31
Volume 1
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
1
= g (@ g @ g + @ g ) +
2
g g [ ] + g [] :
[ ]
where
1
= g (@ g @ g + @ g ) +
2
e
F u F u F u +
+
2 mc2
+ S g (S + S ) ;
1
= g (@ g
2
@ g + @ g )
are the components of the usual symmetric Levi-Civita connection, and where
K
e
=
F u F u
2 mc2
g (S + S )
F u + S
1
= g (@ g @ g + @ g ) +
2
e
+
F u F u F u + 2 S u :
2
2 mc
January, 2008
At this point, we may note that the spin vector ' is always
orthogonal to the world-velocity vector as
' u = 0 :
In terms of the four-potentialA, if we take the electromagnetic field tensor to be a pure curl as follows:
A
@ A = r
F = @ A
r A ;
[ ] F + [] F + + [] F
J =
c
r F :
4
c
:
r
[] F
4
If we further take J = em u , where em represents the
r J =
electromagnetic charge density (taking into account the possibility of a magnetic charge), we see immediately that our
J = 0,
electromagnetic current is conserved if and only if r
as follows
r J = @ J + J =
J :
J + e F J u = r
=r
mc2
In other words, for the electromagnetic current density to
be conserved in our theory, the following conditions must be
satisfied (for an arbitrary scalar field ):
J =
[ ]
c
4
[] F ;
= @ @ :
e
F u + F u + S u + S u ; we have made use of the relation (r r r r ) =
2 mc2
= 2 [ ] r .
e
Now, corresponding to our desired conservation law for
=2 =
F u :
' = K
[]
mc2
electromagnetic currents, we can alternatively express the
=
( )
connection as
We also have
=
= +
e
F u ;
mc2
ln
det (g ) :
Contracting the above relation, we obtain the simple relation = 6 @ . On the other hand, we also have
the relation = + mec2 F u . Hence we see that
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
January, 2008
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
is a constant of motion as
Volume 1
then, as usual,
1
R = C + (g R + g R g R
2
1
g R ) + (g g g g ) R ;
d
6
= 0:
ds
where C is the Weyl tensor. Note that the generalized Ricci
These two conditions uniquely determine the conserva- tensor (given by its components R ) is generally asyme
@ =
F u ;
6 mc2
Du
= u r u = 0 ;
Ds
must hold in S4 in order for the gravitational, electromagnetic, and material spin fields to be genuine intrinsic geometric objects that uniquely and completely build the structure of
the space-time continuum.
e
Recalling the relation ( ) = 2 mc
2 F u +
+ F u + S u + S u , we obtain the equation of motion
e
du
+ u u = 2 F u ;
ds
mc
metric.
Let us denote the usual Riemann-Christoffel curvature
, i.e.,
tensor by R
R = @
:
The symmetric Ricci tensor and the Ricci scalar are then
= R and R = R .
given respectively by R
Furthermore, we obtain the following decomposition:
K
R = R + r
K
r K
+ K
K :
K
= 2 , we obtain
Hence, recalling that ' = K
[]
K
K
K
R = R + r
r ' + 2 K ' ;
' ' ' K K :
R = R 2 r
We then obtain the following generalized Bianchi identiwhich is none other than the equation of motion for a charged ties:
particle moving in a gravitational field. This simply means
2
R + R + R = 2(@ [] + @ [ ] +
that our relation F = 2 mc
u
does
indeed
indicate
a
e [ ]
valid geometrization of the electromagnetic field.
+ @ [] + [ ] + [] + [] ) ;
In the case of conserved electromagnetic currents,
we have
r R + r R + r R = 2 [] R +
du
+ u u = 6 g @ :
ds
(r r
r r ) V = R V
[ ] V ;
(r r
+: : :
Of course,
R = @
@
+
R = R ;
R = R ;
:
r
R
R
[] + [] R
1
g R = 2 g
2
R + R ;
[]
[]
+ F @ u
F @ u + (@ u
+ (F u
F u
F u
@ u ) F +
F u ) + (F u
F u
F u
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
F u
F u
33
Volume 1
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
e
F u ) +
(F F
2 m c2
e
F F ) u u +
F F F F u u +
2
2mc
e
e
+
(F F F F ) u u +
F F
2
2mc
2 mc2
e
F F F F u u +
F F ) u u +
2
2 mc
e
e
+
F F u u +
F F u u
2 mc2
2 mc2
e
e
F F u u
F F u u +
2 mc2
2 mc2
o
e
+
F F F F +
;
2
2 mc
where the tensor
consists of the remaining terms containing
the material spin tensor 2 S (or 3 S ).
e
Now, keeping in mind that ( ) = 2 mc
2 F u +
+ F u + S u + S u and also
= = +
+ mce 2 F u , and decomposing the components of the generalized Ricci tensor as R = R( ) + R[ ] , we see that
(F u
F u
1
R( ) = @ ( )
(@
+ @
) + ( )
2
1
+ ;
2
1
R[ ] = @ [ ]
(@
@
) + [ ]
2
1
:
2
1
g R = kT ;
2
r G = 0 ;
is the symmetric Einstein tensor, T is the energywhere G
momentum tensor, and k = 8 cG
4 is Einsteins coupling
constant in terms of the Newtonian gravitational constant G.
Taking c = 1 for convenience, in the absence of pressure, traG = R
ditionally we write
DF
e
F r u +
+ r S +
R[ ] =
2 mc2
Ds
1
+ (@
@
) ;
2
DF
where Ds
R[ ] =
e
DF
F r u +
+ (@ F
2 mc2
Ds
@ F ) u + F @ u F @ u + r S :
1
1
G = k m u u +
F F
g F F ;
4
4
where m is the material density and where the second term
= 2
In other words,
r G = k 2 g
1
R[ ] = @ [ ]
(@
@
) + [ ]
2
1
=
2
= @ [ ] + [ ] + []
[] +
1
1
+ (@
@
) = r [ ] + (@
@
) :
2
2
January, 2008
F F
[ ]
1
F J :
4
r
R
e
1
1
g R = 2 F R + F R u +
2
mc
2
+ 2 S R + S R :
1
e
1
r
g R = 2 F R + F R u +
2
mc
2
+ S R u S u R + S R
S R u :
R
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
January, 2008
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
S
x T
lows:
1
x r T
2
x r T :
r
=
1
1
e
g R = 2 F R + F R u :
2
mc
2
R
1R
If we further assume that the sectional curvature = 12
of S4 is everywhere constant in a space-time region where
the electromagnetic field (and hence the torsion) is absent, we
may consider writing R = (g g g g ) such
that S4 is conformally flat (C = 0), and hence R =
= 3 g and R[ ] = 0. In this case, we are left with the
simple expression
r
R
1
eR
g R =
F u :
2
6 mc2
6
du
+ u u =
r R
ds
R
4
2e
e2
r
f
+
F
S
F F u u :
mc2
2 m2 c4
Assuming that accounts for both the total (material-
x T d ;
m
where now T is the total asymmetric energy-momentum tensor in our theory, we see that, in the presence of matter, the
condition S = 0 implies that
T [ ] =
1
g R :
2
2e
r f + 2 S S
mc2
K() K () ;
for the curvature scalar of S4 . Here f = F u can be said
Volume 1
2e
r
f + F S
2
mc
The last two terms on the right-hand-side of the expression can then be grouped into a single scalar source as fol-
&
R
e2
F F +
2 m2 c4
det (g ) d4 x :
) appears
In this minimal fashion, gravity (described by R
as an emergent phenomenon whose intrinsic nature is of electromagnetic and purely material origin since, in our theory,
the electromagnetic and material spin fields are nothing but
components of a single torsion field.
5
In S4 , let there exist a space-like three-dimensional hypersurface 3 , with local coordinates X i (Latin indices shall run
from 1 to 3). From the point of view of projective differential
geometry alone, we may say that 3 i s embedded (immersed)
in S4 . Then, the tetrad linking the embedded space 3 to the
enveloping space-time S4 is readily given by
1
@X i
@x
;
!i = !i
:
=
@x
@X i
Furthermore, let N be a unit vector normal to the hypersurface 3 . We may write the parametric equation of the hypersurface 3 as H (x ; d) = 0, where d is constant. Hence
!i =
N =
g @ H
;
g (@ H )(@ H )
N N = 1 :
In terms of the axial unit vectors a, b, and c spanning the
hypersurface 3 , we may write
N =
" a b c
;
" N a b c
where " are the components of the completely antisymmetric four-dimensional Levi-Civita permutation tensor
density.
Now, the tetrad satisfies the following projective relations:
!i N = 0 ;
!i !i =
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
Volume 1
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
January, 2008
i
[kl]
1 i
! ! F
2 k l
1
! ! @ !i
2 k l
@ !i :
[ei ; ek ] = ei
ek
p
ek
ei = Cik
ep ;
p
Cikl = hip Ckl
= 2 i[kl] =
i g^ 2ikl ;
@
where ei = eA
i A are the elements of the basis
p vector spanp @X
ning 3 , Cik are the spin coefficients,
i
=
1, g^ is a coup
where Z is the extrinsic curvature tensor of the hypersurface pling constant, and 2ikl = det (h) "ikl (where "ikl are
3 , which is generally asymmetric in our theory.
the components of the completely anti-symmetric threeThe connection of the hypersurface 3 is linked to that of dimensional Levi-Civita permutation tensor density).
the space-time S4 via
Hence we obtain
p
ik
! ! :
i k
i = @ !i
F
Bi = !i :
Hence, at last, we arrive at the following important exThe fundamental geometric relations describing our empression:
bedding theory are then given by the following expressions
i = @ Bi
i
i
k l
i k
(see [4] for instance):
F
@ B + i g^ 2 kl B B + 2 Z k B[ N ] :
!i jkl ;
rl Zik rk Zil =
Actually, these relations are just manifestations of the following single expression:
(rk rj
hik = ik ;
det (h) = 1 ;
p
[jk] Zip N + ijk :
i
kl
p
We may note that [ik] and
Rijkl
= @k ijl
@ !i
=2
Hence letting
36
!i [ ]
i !k !l
[kl]
i = 2 !i ;
F
[ ]
+ Z ik ![k N ]
ikl
i[kl]
l[ik]
k[il]
Zik = 0 :
p i
jk pl
1
i g^" ;
2 ikl
are the components of the torsion tensor and the intrinsic curvature tensor of the hypersurface 3 , respectively.
Now, let us observe that
@ !i
Fi = @ Bi
@ B i + i g^"ikl Bk B l :
~ = Bi ei , we
In other words, setting F~ = Fi ei and B
obtain
F~ = @ B~
@ B~
B~ ; B~ :
Finally, let us define the gauge field potential of the second kind via
p
!ik = "ikp B ;
Indranu Suhendro. A Unified Field Theory of Gravity, Electromagnetism, and the Yang-Mills Gauge Field
January, 2008
PROGRESS IN PHYSICS
such that
Dedication
1
Bi = "ikl !kl :
2
such that
p =
F
1
2
2pik Rik :
@ ! ik + !ip ! kp
Volume 1
!kp ! ip ) :
References
1. Suhendro I. A new conformal theory of semi-classical Quantum
General Relativity. Progress in Physics, 2007, v. 4, 96103.
2. Suhendro I. A four-dimensional continuum theory of spacetime and the classical physical fields. Progress in Physics, 2007,
v. 4, 3446.
3. Suhendro I. A new semi-symmetric unified field theory of the
classical fields of gravity and electromagnetism. Progress in
Physics, 2007, v. 4, 4762.
4. Suhendro I. Spin-curvature and the unification of fields in
a twisted space. Ph. D. Thesis, 2003. The Swedish Physics
Archive, Stockholm, 2008 (in print).
Conclusion
We have just completed our program of building the structure of a unified field theory in which gravity, electromagnetism, material spin, and the non-Abelian Yang-Mills gauge
field (which is also capable of describing the weak force in
the standard model particle physics) are all geometrized only
in four dimensions. As we have seen, we have also generalized the expression for the Yang-Mills gauge field strength.
In our theory, the (generalized) Yang-Mills gauge field
strength is linked to the electromagnetic field tensor via the
relation
2
2
F = 2
mc
e
u
[ ]
mc i
F u ;
e i
1
1
i u
= g (@ g @ g + @ g ) + ui F
2
2
F i u F i u + S g (S + S ) ;
37