AIAA980517

AIRFOIL GEOMETRY AND

COMPRESSIBILITY EFFECTS
ON WING AND BLADE FLUTTER
K.D.Jones and M.F.Platzer
Naval Postgraduate School
Monterey, CA

36th Aerospace Sciences

Meeting & Exhibit
January 1215,1998 / Reno, NV
For permission to copy or republish, contact the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
1801 Alexander Bell Drive, Suite 500, Reston, VA 20191




 
  !""
#$

%
&
'($") **
+,#$
-
%.$
/0210-35476985:<;=>69?A@0%BC02D-EF=HGJIK89LNM
OPKQKPSRUTWVSXYZS[PS\>]^PSY_a`9bJc>V9VSR
deVSf9Y_g[_gh5ikj2PSRmlonpV5[f>lmP
q rtsUuvq%w2u
x fy]>f>XY_gPS\^hSiYNz%V|{}\>lm~_gf>XlmV5f>PSR&ilmf>bgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_
CVSY_fHYlmPSRo{pCVKzXV5RQ5_g[UPSf^\PSf]>f>XY_gP5\>h5iYNz2VK{N\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSR&i
bgV5~>[_gXXl^R_]^R_[KO'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gX7VKzXVSRmQS_[PS[_bgVS]9{
>Rm_g\zlmYcPYNz2VK{N\>_gZ5[_g_J{NVKn{pnp[_g_g\>V5~XY[]>bgY]>[P5R7~V9\>_gRnpV5[
Yc^_Ylm~_{}\>V5~P5lfabgVS~>]>YP5YlmVSfVKntPS_[V9_gRmPSXYlmb[_XCVSf>X_K
j2VS~>PS[lmXVSf^XPS[_~PS\>_C_gYNz2_g_gfA[_X]>RmYXnp[VS~Yc>_YNz2V
7VKzXVSRmQ5_g[XP5f>\zlmYc7]>YY_g[a7V5]>f>\>P5[h^[_g\>lmbgYlmVSf>XaVKn
Rmlmf>_gPS[aYc^_gVS[hST[_X_gf9Y_\[_gX]>RmYX\>_g~VSf>XY[PSY_Xlm~lmRmPS[
\>_gXYP5>lmRlmglmf>Z_JU_gbgYXn&VS[CVSYcAlmf>bg[_gPSXlmf>ZPSlm[Nn&VSlmR%Yc>lmbJS{
f>_gXXP5f>\$lf^bg[_gP5Xlmf>Zd$P5bJcf9]>~C_g[%d$VS[_lm~7V5[YP5f9YRmhSi
lmY(lmXXc>VKzf Yc>PSYRmlmf>_gP5[(Yc>_gVS[h h9lm_gRm\>Xa]>f9{NbgVSf>X_g[QKP5YlmQS_
7]>YY_g[{}Q5_gRmV9bglmYNh>[_g\^lbYlmVSf>X c>lmRm_Rmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_gV5[h>[_J{
\>lmbgYXYc>P5Y$Xlmf>ZSRm_J{N\>_gZ5[_g_{}V|n{pn&[_g_g\^VS~>lmYbc^lf^ZH7]>YY_g[
bgP5f>f>VSYVHbbg]>[_g9bg_>Y(zlmYcP5f]>f>[_PSRmlmXYlmbgP5RmRh$c>lmZ5cX_gbJ{
YlmV5f>PSRC~V5~_gf9YVKnlmf>_g[YlmP>i>lmY2lmX%Xc>VKzfc>_[_Yc>P5YYc>lmbJS_[
PSlm[npVSlmRmXlmfbgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_27VKzX~PKh_PSXlmRmhP5bc^l_QS_2Xlmf>ZSRm_J{
\>_gZ5[_g_{}V|n{pn&[_g_g\^VS~7]>YY_g[']>f>\>_[[_gP5RlmXYlmbbgVSf>\^lYlmVSf>X
>
2
2

<

 @w9quv2
np[_g_gXY[_gP5~X7_g_\VKnXVS]^f>\
bJc>VS[\Rm_gf>Z5Yc
RmlonpY%bVH_bglm_gf9YC_g[]>f^lY2X^PSf
>lmYbJc>lmf>Z~VS~_gf9Y-bVH_bglm_gf9YC_g[]>f>lmYX^PSf
np[_g9]>_gf>bghlf_g[Y
C_gf>\>lmf>Z\>lmX>RmPSbg_g~_gf9YCVSXlYlmQS_\^VKzfHz2PS[\7
~V5~_gf9YtV|n-lmf>_g[YlmPPSCVS]^Y5C_g[]>f^lY2X^PSf
[_\>]>bg_g\np[_g9]>_gf>bgh5ik5 <S
[_\>]>bg_g\f>P5Y]>[PSRU>lmYbJc>lmf>Zan&[_g9]>_gf^bgh
[_\>]>bg_g\f>P5Y]>[PSRU>Rm]>f>Z5lmf>Zn&[_g9]>_gf^bgh
X^[lmf>ZbgV5f>XYPSf9YnpV5[%^R]^f>ZSlmf>Z
X^[lmf>ZbgV5f>XYPSf9YnpV5[%^lYbJc>lmf>Z
RmlonpY%C_g[']>f>lmYX>P5f
~P5XX2VKntYc^_zlmf>ZaC_g[]>f^lYX>PSf
>lmYbJc>lmf>Z~VS~_gf9Y-C_g[']>f>lmY%X>PSf
np[_g_gXY[_gP5~d$P5bJcf9]>~C_g[

; _X_gP5[bJc x XXlmXYP5f9YT[VKnmi>`9_gf>lmV5[d$_~7_g[i xNx'x
M T[VKnp_gXXV5[gi x XXVHblP5Y_(^_gRmRmVKzi x'Nxx
c>lmX$>PSC_g[lmX\^_gbgRmPS[_g\PAz%V5[V|nYc>_`CVKQ5_g[f9{
~_fHYPSf>\lXf>VSY2X]>S_gbgYYVabgV5Hh9[lZ5c9Y%>[VSY_gbgYlmV5flmfYc>_
f^lY_g\`9YP5Y_gX

5




H


tN

XYPSYlmb~V5~_gf9Ygi97
Yl~_
[_g\>]>bg_\7]^YY_[QS_RV9bglmYNh5i J ^
np[_g_gXY[_PS~Q5_gRmV9bglmYNh~PSZ5f>lmY]>\^_
Rm_gP5\>lmf>Z(_\>ZS_YV_gRmPSXYlmbPS9lmX%\>lmXYPSf^bg_
_gRmP5XYlmbP59lX2YVb_gf9Y_g['VKn-~PSXX%\>lmXYPSf^bg_
P5f>ZSRm_VKnPSYYPSbJ
]>f^bgVS]>^R_\f>PSY]>[P5RU7_f>\>lmf>Zanp[_gCi S
]>f^bgVS]>^R_\f>PSY]>[P5RUYV5[XlmV5f>PSRCnp[_gCmi 
np[_g_gXY[_PS~\^_gf>XlmYNh
f>V5f>\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSRCYlm~_Ki t|
\>loU_g[_fHYlmPSYlmV5fzlmYc[_gXC_gbgYYV
\>loU_g[_fHYlmPSYlmV5fzlmYc[_gXC_gbgYYV

& uv1w2u
x _[V9\>h9f>PS~lmbgPSRmRmh%\^[lmQS_gflf^XYP5>lmRmlYNh'VKn97_g9lm>Rm_tP5l[{
bg[PKnpY'bgVS~7V5f>_gf9YXc>P5XC_g_gfPYV5>lmbVKntbgV5f>Xlm\>_g[PS>Rm_almf9{
Y_[_gXYYV Yc>__gf>Z5lmf>_g_g[lf^Z bgV5~~]>f>lmYNh$n&VS[Yc>_Z5[_gP5Y_g[
>P5[YVKnUYc>lmXbg_gf9Y]>[h5 x >^RlmbgP5YlmVSf^XUnpV5[-X]>bJc[_gX_gPS[bJcPS[_
f9]>~_[VS]^Xlmf>bR]^\>lmf>Z$Yc>_\>_XlmZSfV|nP5l[bg[P|npYzlmf>Z5Xgi_g~{
C_gf>f>P5ZS_gXic>_gRmlmbgVS^Y_g[PSf>\A>[VSC_gRmR_[>RmPS\^_gXgiY]^[CVS~P|{
bJc>lmf>_g[hPSf>\_gQS_gf_gPS[Yc9{N7V5]>f>\aXY[]>bgY]>[_Xgc>_tPSbVS~P
OP5[[VKzX%X]>XC_gf>XlV5f>[lm\>ZS_Ki>\^_gXY[VKhS_\>P5balmf <|H P|n{
Y_[~PSf9hac>VS]>[XVKnt\>lmQS_g[ZS_gf9Yi7zlmf>\9{N\>[lmQ5_gfVSXbglmRmRP5YlmVSf^Xgi
lmXP(bRP5XXlb_g9PS~^R_V|n-Yc>lmXg
f
c>_gV9\>VS[X_gfC>[VKQHlm\>_\Yc^_7[XYbgV5~>P5bgY
Yc^_gVS[_gYlmbg<P55RKPS f>P5Rh9XlXV|nzlmf>ZP5f>\zlmf>ZH|PSlmRm_g[V5f$7]>YY_g[
c>_gV9\>V5[X_gfUXRmlmf>_gPS[lmg_g\Yc>_gV5[h~V9\>_gRm_g\$Yc>_PSlm[Nn&VSlmRP5X
P7PSY{}>RmP5Y_$PSf>\AYc>_$z%P5S_$PSXaPf>VSf{}\>_npVS[~lmf>Z>iX_~lo{
lmf97f>lmY_Xc>__gYVKntQSV5[YlmbglmYNhY[P5lmRlmf>ZaYc^_(P5l[npVSlmR&%`9YPS>lmRmlmYNh
PSf^PSRmh9XlmXz2PSX$C_g[NnpV5[~_g\lmfYc^_np[_g9]>_f>bgh5{}\^VS~P5lmf9h
~_PSf>XUV|nYc>_tYPS>]>RmP5Y_g\c^_gV9\>VS[X_gfRmlonpYU\>_7bglm_gf>bghnp]>f>bJ{
YlmV5fUc>_gV9\>V5[X_gfUXn&VS[~]^RP5YlmVSf^Xc>PKQS_C_g_gfPS>>Rmlm_g\
YV~PSf9hlmf9Y_g[_gXYlf^ZPS_g[VH\^hHf^PS~lmbgX^[VS^R_~X2lf^bgRm]>\>lmf>Z
zlmf>ZaPSf>\$PSlmRm_g[VSfC]>YY_g[9hc>_gV9\>V5[X_gfPSf^\ePS[[lmbCi
7P5>>lmf>ZK{Nzlmf>Z>[V5>]>RmXlmV5fHhP5[[lmbJ9PSf^\[VSYPS[hS{Nzlmf>Z
PS_[V9\>h9f>PS~lmbgX%9h$UV9_gzh5i aYVaf>P5~_-]>XYPanp_z
2_JnpVS[_c^_gV9\>VS[X_gfUX$z2VS[AlmYz2PSXYc>V5]>ZSc9YYc>P5Y
7]>YY_g[2[_H]^l[_g\$P~lmf>lm~a]>~VKnUYNz%V\^_gZS[_g_gXN{NVKn{pnp[_g_g\>V5~
VKz2_gQ5_g[giKc>_gV9\>V5[X_gf(\^_g~V5f>XY[PSY_g\Yc>P5YUXlmf>Z5R_{}\>_ZS[__J{
VKn{pnp[_g_g\>V5~p`^7]>YY_g[z2PSX2CVSXXlm>Rm_Ki7>]^Y%V5f>RmhPSY2P
QS_[hRmVKz [_g\>]^bg_g\Anp[_g9]>_gf>bhSi2bgVS[[_gX7V5f>\>lmf>ZYVPQ5_g[h
c>lmZSce7]>YY_g[Q5_gRmVHblYNh5 x \^\>lmYlmVSf>P5RmRh5ik`~lmRmZ(CVSlmf9Y_g\VS]^Y

 @ v2w2q@ku'1s
x _[V9_gRmPSXYlmbglmYNhlmXUP~]>RmYlo{N\>lmXbglm>Rmlmf>P5[htX]>SJ_gbgYbgV5~{
>lmf>lmf>ZP5_g[V9\>h9f>P5~lmbgXPSf^\XY[]>bgY]>[P5R\>h9f>P5~lmbgXgc>_
~_Yc>V9\>X]>X_g\lfYc>_^[_gX_gf9YXY]>\>hnpVS['_gPSbJc\^lXbglm>Rmlmf>_
PS[_VS]>YRlmf>_\lmfYc>_X_gbgYlV5f>XC_gRmVKz
qv-
1 'q@ mw%s
WRmVKz XV5Rm]>YlmVSf^XtPS[_bgVS~>]>Y_\]>Xlmf>ZYNz2V]>f>XY_gP5\>h
PSRmZ5VS[lmYc>~X P$7V5Y_gf9YlmP5R{&7VKzXVSRmQ5_g[npV5[lmf>bgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_
7VKzXP5f>\PSf]>Rm_g[|OPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YVSS_XbgV9\>_n&VS[bgVS~>[_XXN{
lm>Rm_'7VKzXg2VSYcbgV9\>_gXz2_g[_a>[_gQ9lV5]>XRmh$\>_gQ5_gRmVSC_g\P5f>\
PS[_z2_gRmR\>V9bg]>~_gf9Y_g\ lfAYc>_RmlmY_g[PSY]^[_Ki^]>Y>[lm_Jn(\>_J{
Xb[lm>YlmV5f>X%V|nYc>_'~_gYc>V9\>XtP5[_lmf>bR]^\>_g\c^_g[_npVS[2bgRmPS[lYNh5
m6 K4 9L&8S:g: >E8B>EF4 sC47E 9G F4769: f>bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_W7VKz
XV5Rm]>YlmVSf^XPS[_bgV5~>]>Y_g\]>Xlf^ZP5f]>f>XY_gPS\^h CVSY_fHYlmPSRo{
7VKziCVS[^PSf>_gRW~_gYc>V9\Uc>_>P5f>_gRbgV9\>_KiU\>_QS_gRmVSC_g\9h
_gf>Z^i c>PSX27__gf$z%_gRmRC\>V9bg]>~_gf9Y_g\lf>PSXY%^]>>RmlmbgPSYlV5f>X
_JnpX { g zlYc P5_g[V9_gRmPSXYlmbbVS]>>Rmlmf>Z\^_gQS_gRmV57_g\AP5f>\
Y_XY_\9h SV5f>_gX'PSf>\TRmPSYg_g[F
c>_>P5XlmbKiKXY_gPS\>h>P5f>_gR5bgV9\>_npV5RRmVKzXCYc>_PS>>[VSP5bc
VKnC_gXXtPSf>\`9~lYcUi zc^_g[_Yc>_%P5lm[NnpV5lR5lmX-P5>>[VKHlm~PSY_\
9hP$f9]>~7_[VKn2>PSf>_RXYNhH^lbPSRmRmh S { 9S iU_gPSbJczlYc
P]>f>lm9]>_Ki%\^lXY[l^]>Y_g\AXVS]>[bg_XY[_gf^ZSYcAP5f>\ P5RR2zlmYcP
bgV5f>XYPSf9Y$\>lmXY[lm>]>Y_\QSVS[YlmbglmYNhAXY[_gf>Z5YcU)>V5[ >PSf9{
_gRmXYc>_[_PS[_  ]>f>9f>VKzfXVS]>[bg_XY[_gf>ZSYc>Xg!i #"SiWPSf>\P5f
]>f>9f>VKzfQ5VS[YlmbglmYNhXY[_gf>ZSYcU
i $ 2VS]>f>\^PS[hbgV5f>\>lmYlmVSf^X
lmf>bgRm]>\>_aCVKz YPSf>Z5_gf>bghP5YYc^_~lm\>CVSlmf9YV|nYc>_ >PSf9{
_gRmX2PSf>\Yc>_ %]>YYPbgVSf^\>lmYlmVSfzc>lmbJcCVSXY]>RmP5Y_gXYc>PSY2Yc>_
>[_gXX]>[_aVSfYc>_]>>C_g[P5f>\RmVKz2_g[%X]>[Nn&PSbg_gX'VKnYc>_PSlm[npVSlmR
PSYYc>_Y[PSlmRmlf^Z(_g\^ZS_~]>XY2C__g9]>PSR&
c>_]>f>XY_gPS\^h>PSf>_RbgV9\>_P5\>VS>YX(Yc>_^[V9bg_g\>]^[_
VKna%P5X]PSf^\'PSf>bgV9bJCi  zc>_g[_PAz2PS5_>P5f>_gRlmX$PSYN{
YP5bJc>_g\YVYc>_aY[P5lmRlmf>Za_g\>Z5_(Yc>[V5]>ZSczc>lmbJcQSV5[YlblYNhlmX
Xc^_g\lmfHYVYc>_27VKzc>_2_gRm~c>VSRmYYc>_gV5[_g~ XYPSY_gX2Yc>P5Y
Yc^_CVS]>f>\Q5VS[YlmbglmYNhlmfP$CVKz [_g~P5lmf>XbgVSf>XYP5fHYi%YcH]^X
Pbc^PSf>Z5_lmfbglm[bg]>RmP5YlmVSfP57V5]>YYc>_$P5l[npVSlmRt~]^XY[_gX]>RmY
lmf$Yc>_[_R_PSX_VKntQSV5[YlmbglmYNhlmf9YVaYc>_z%P5S__g9]>PSRUlmf$~P5ZK{
f>lmY]^\>_(P5f>\VS>CVSXlY_lmf\>lm[_gbgYlmV5fUO]>~_g[lmbgP5RRmhYc>lmXlmX
ZSlmQ5_gf9h
&(' ) $+*( '-,/.0' .1'3254

zc>_g[_ & lmXYc>_tz2PSS_>PSf>_RHRm_gf^ZSYc 6i $ * lmXWYc>_t\^lXY[l^]>Y_g\

QSV5[YlblYNhXY[_gf>Z5YcVSf$Yc^_(z2PS5_^PSf>_gRP5f>\ . lmXYc>_bglm[N{
bg]>RmP5YlmVSfPSCVS]>YYc>_PSlm[Nn&VSlmR&ikP5f>\zc>_g[_Yc>_X]>>Xbg[lm>Y
lmf>\>lmbgP5Y_gXtYc>_bg]>[[_gf9Y2Ylm~_XY_Ui>PSf>\ 8 7 lmf>\>lmbgPSY_gXYc>_
>[_gQ9lV5]>XYlm~_XY_gU
c>_z%P5S_^PSf>_gRlf9Y[V9\>]>bg_XYNz%VPS\>\^lYlmVSf>P5R]>f9{
9f>VKzf>X >Yc>_'z%P5S_>P5f>_gRURm_gf>Z5YcP5f>\lmYX2VS[l_fHYPSYlV5fUi 9 '
c9]>XgiUYNz2VP5\>\>lmYlmVSf^PSRUbgV5f>\>lmYlmVSf^X~]>XY7_aXC_gbglo7_g\npV5[
bgRmVSX]>[_:
c>_2z%P5S_2>PSf^_gR>lmXtVS[lm_gf9Y_g\almf(Yc>_\>lm[_gbYlmVSfV|n7Yc>_
RmV9bgPSRU[_gX]>RmYPSf9YQS_gRmV9bglmYNhPSYYc>_>P5f>_gRU~l\^7V5lf9Y

Yc^PSY_gQ5_gfYc^VS]>Z5ce`^ 7]>YY_g[z2PSXYc>_gV5[_gYlbPSRmRmhCVSXN{

Xlm>Rm_Ki9lmYz%P5X-V|nkRmlmYYRm_%>[PSbgYlmbgPSRClmfHY_g[_XYgi>Xlmf>bg_Rmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_J{
VS[h [_g9]>lm[_g\Yc>_$X_gbYlmVSf>P5R~VS~_fHYV|nlmf>_g[YlmP>i i%YV
C_X_gQ5_g[P5RUVS[\^_g[X2VKnU~P5ZSf>lmY]^\>_tc>lmZSc^_g[tYc^PSflmXYNhH^lbPSRmRmh
npV5]>f>\V5f$PSlm[bg[PKnpY
f <
> i ]>f9h5PSf$Xc>VKz2_g\Yc>PSY7VKzbgVS~>[_gXXlm>lmRo{
lmYNhRVKz2_g[_g\Yc^_`>7]^YY_[-[_g\>]>b_g\QS_gRmV9bglmYNhX]>^XYP5f9{
YlmP5RRmhlmfc^lZ5c$X]>>XVSf>lmbP5f>\$RmVKzX]>C_g[XVSf^lb7VKz ac>lmX
lmXt\>lmXb]>XX_g\$lfXVS~_\>_gYP5lmR7lmf2lX>Rmlmf>ZSc>V|_gY2PSR& 'c>_gh
CVSlmf9YVS]^YYc^PSYzc^lRm_Yc>_a~lmf>lm~(]^~ lmf>_[YlmP5R>P5[PS~_gY_[
[_H]^l[_g\n&VS[W7]>YY_g[2lmX-XYlmRmR>YV9VRmP5[ZS_npV5[tPSfaPSlm[Nn&VSlmR9PSRmVSf>_|i
lmYtlmXt[_PSXV5f>PS^R_npVS[PbgVS~>Rm_gY_P5lm[bg[PKnpY-c>lmX2[_g~PS[lmX
VKn2RlmYYRm_bgVSf>b_g[fUic>VKz2_gQS_[giUPSX'lY'lmX]>f>RmlmS_RhYc>P5YPnp[_g_
7h9lmf>ZbgV5~>Rm_gY_-P5lm[bg[PKnpYWz%V5]>Rm\]^f>\>_g[ZSV`^~V5YlmVSf^Xg
Q5_gflon-Yc>_PSlm[bg[P|npYz%P5XY[_gPSY_g\P5XP[lmZSlm\7V9\>h5i7Yc>_g[_
z2VS]>Rm\PSRm~V5XYb_g[YPSlmf>RmhC_XVS~_(Y[PSf^XRmPSYlV5f>PSR~VSYlmV5f
VKnYc>_bg_gf9Y_g['VKntZS[PKQ9lYNh5
_bg_gf9YRmh5i(\>]>_YVP [PS^l\lmf>b[_gP5X_ lmfPKQKP5lRmP5>Rm_
bgV5~>]>YPSYlV5f>PSR2CVKz%_g[iP c^VSXYVKn]>f>XY_gP5\>hj2V5~>]>YPK{
YlmV5f>PSRWRm]>lm\h9f>P5~lmbgX$pjP5RZ5VS[lYc>~Xc>PKQS_C_g_gf
\>_gQ5_gRmVSC_g\Uc>_[_lmXPRP5[Z5_QKPS[lmP5YlmVSflmfYc>_PS>^RlmbgP|{
>lmRmlmYNhPSf>\bVS~^]>YP5YlmVSf>P5R<_bglm_gf>bghV|n>Yc>_gX_PSRmZSV5[lmYc^~Xg
'fVSf^_%_gf^\VKn7Yc>_tXbgPSRm_2PS[_QS_g[hn&PSXYWPSRmZSV5[lmYc^~XCXVSRmQ9lmf>Z
npV5[7V5Y_gf9YlmP5RU7VKzXikP5>>[VKHlm~PSYlmf>ZYc>_C]>lm\P5Xlmf>bgV5~{
>[_gXXl^R_|ilmfHQ9lmXbl\PSf>\lm[[VSYPSYlV5f>PSR&'fYc>_aVSYc>_g[_gf>\
VKnCYc>_tXbgPSRm_2PS[_%P5RZ5VS[lYc>~XCYc^PSYXVSRmQS_Yc>_2OPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YVSS_X
_g9]>P5YlmVSf>X
c>lmRm_P5RmRUVKn-Yc>_bgRmP5XXlmbgP5Rf9]>~_g[lmbgP5R7XY]>\>lm_gX'bglmY_g\
PSCVKQS_aC_g[NnpV5[~ XYP5>lmRmlYNhPSf>P5Rh9XlX'lmfYc>_anp[_H]^_gf>bgh\>VK{
~P5lmfUitYc>_\>_gQS_RV5>~_fHYaVKnYc>_gX_~V5[_ZS_gf>_[PSR&iYlm~_J{
XY_g>>lmf>ZPSRmZ5VS[lmYc>~X'X]>Z5ZS_gXYXYc^_]>X_V|nYlm~_{}\>V5~PKlmf
PS_[V9_gRmPSXYlmbP5RZ5VS[lYc>~XiUbgVS]>^Rlmf>Ze7]>lm\>XP5f>\XY[]>bgY]>[P5R
PSf^PSRmh9XlmX(lmfAPYlm~_J{}XY_g^>lmf>ZbgV9\>_K f>\^_g_g\Uif9]>~_g[V5]>X
XY]>\>lm_gXV|nYc^lXaf>P5Y]>[_c^PKQS_C_g_gfAC_g[Nn&VS[~_g\Uit>]^Yanp_gz
PS\^\>[_gXXXV5~_aVKnYc^_>P5XlmblmXX]>_gXaYc>P5Y(P5[lmX_an&[VS~ Yc>lmX
YNh97_V|n P5f>PSRmh9XlmX
fYc>_(^[_gX_gf9Y(XY]>\>hPCVSY_fHYlmPSRo{pCVKzXVSRmQS_g[P5f>\
PSf ]>Rm_g[|OPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YV5S_gX2XV5RmQS_g[2PS[_bgV5]>>Rm_g\zlmYcPaYNz%V|{
\>_gZ5[_g_{}V|n{pn&[_g_g\^VS~$XY[]>bgY]>[P5R(~V9\>_gRn&VS[$Yc>_
Ylm~_J{}\^VS~P5lfPSf^PSRmh9XlmXV|nkP5_g[V9_gRmPSXYlmbglmYNh5-2hRmlm~lmYlmf>Z2Yc>_
PSf^PSRmh9XlmXtYVPa[_RP5YlmQS_RhaXlm~>Rm_YNz%V|{}\>lm~_gf>XlmV5f>PSR9bgV5f97ZK{
]>[PSYlmV5fbgVS~>PS[lXVSf>XbgP5f C_~P5\>_zlmYcRmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_gVS[h
PSf^\7_YNz%_g_fYc>_(YNz2Va7VKzXVSRmQS_g[XYVPSbbg]>[P5Y_gRmh$PSXX_gXX
Yc^_lmf9C]>_gf>bg_XVKnz2PS5_f>V5f9{NRlmf>_PS[lmYl_Xgi9PSlm[NnpV5lmR7Z5_gVS~_gY[h
PSf^\CVKzbgVS~>[_XXlm>lmRmlmYNhS
lm~_UbgV5f>XY[P5lf9YXgiS]>fnpVS[Y]>f>P5Y_gRmh5i<c>PKQ5_Rlm~lY_g\Yc^lX
XY]>\>hYV`> {}^lYbJc>lmf>Zlmf>XYPS^lRmlmYlm_gXiKPSf>\V5f>Rmhlf9Q9lmXbglm\
PSf^PSRmh9XlmXz2PSXC_g[npVS[~_g\U>V5[Yc>_RmVKzPSf^ZSRm_gXN{NVKn{}P5YYP5bJ
bgV5f>Xlm\>_g[_g\c>_[_KiUYc^_CVKzXXc>V5]>Rm\C_PSYYPSbJc>_\PSf>\Yc>_
_JU_gbgYaVKn%Q9lmXbVSXlmYNhz2VS]^R\7_aQS_g[hX~P5RR&>]^[Yc^_g[~VS[_|i
Yc^_bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_$Xlm~]>RmPSYlV5f>XPS[_Rmlm~lmY_g\YVX]>^XVSf^lb
PSf^\RmVKzY[P5f>XV5f>lmbXC_g_g\>XX]>bJcYc>P5YXc>V9bJ>KCVS]>f^\>PS[hS{
RmPKhS_g[{}lmf9Y_[PSbYlmVSf_Jk_bgYXz2VS]>Rm\C_f>_ZSRmlmZSlm>Rm_K

9c>_aRm_gf>ZSYcVKn2Yc>_az%P5S_a>PSf^_gRlX'>[V57V5[YlV5f>PSRYV

Yc^_~PSZ5f>lmY]>\^_V|nYc>_RmV9bgPSR[_X]>RmYP5f9YQS_gRmV9bglmYNhP5Y
Yc^_^PSf>_gRW~lm\>CVSlmf9YPSf>\$Yc^_Ylm~_{}XY_gXlmg_K
c>__gXX_gf9YlmP5R_gRm_g~_gf9YXVKnYc>lmXXbJc>_g~_PS[_X]>~~PS[lmg_\
lmfWlmZ>

PSf^\ ! lmXaYc>_Yc>lmf9{NRmPKhS_g[PS^>[VK9lm~P5YlmVSfV|nYc>_$Q9lXbgVS]^X

7]>9_gXlfaYc^_\>lm[_gbYlmVSff>VS[~PSR5YVYc>_PSlm[npVSlmRSX]>[Nn&PSbg_<i
#$
* $+


4
,


%

7 :0 $ 
!  " $& 6 4 '  , 65 8
? >5
6 (
65 9

7
6 4 <
; , 65 9 7< = ,
( )
zc>_g[_
k
k

? @5
4  -7 ,  07 
k


,
? A5
7'  - ' :0 ( 
9
2 4:BDC2 4
( )
7
7
7


,
,
7

)
$

; ' (

PSf^\
<
{
<=  - ' , 50 (4E
c>_Y_g[~X P5f>\ 2 P5[_Yc>_bgV5fHY[PKQKP5[lmPSf9YQS_RV9bglmYNh

 `9bJc>_g~PSYlmb'VKn-Yc>_>P5f>_gRWbgV9\>_z%P5S_~V9\>_gR&
x YYc>__gf>\VKn_gP5bcYlm~_aXY_ Yc^_QSV5[YlblYNhbgVSf9{ bgV5~CVSf>_gf9YXZSlmQS_gf9h
YP5lmf>_g\lmfYc>_(z2PS5_(^PSf>_gRlmXbVSf>bg_fHY[P5Y_g\lf9YVPCVSlmf9Y
S

'
- , (
.0 ,

QSV5[Y_gzc>lmbJclmXUXc^_g\lmf9YVYc^_-z2PS5_PSf>\bVSf9QS_gbY_g\\^VKzf9{ PSf^\
XY[_gP5~ zlmYcYc>_7VKzi9lmf97]>_f>bglmf>ZP5f>\7_lf^Z(lmf97]^_gf>bg_g\
5
2 
'  - , ( :0 ,  
9hYc^_VSYc^_g[tXc^_g\QSV5[Ylmbg_X-P5f>\aYc>_P5l[npVSlmR&UOV5Y_Ki9lm~>Rm_J{
~_fHYPSYlV5fV|nHYc^lXWPS>^[VSP5bJc[_g9]>lm[_gXWPSflmY_g[PSYlQ5_tXbJc>_~_Ki PSf^F\ " lmX%Yc>_~_Y[lmb SPSbVS>lmPSf i>zc>_g[_
Xlmf>b_Yc^_QS_RV9bglmYNha\>lm[_gbYlmVSfPSf>\~PSZSf^lY]>\>_2]>X_\YVa\>_J{
7f>_Yc>_z%P5S_>PSf^_gRUPS[_f^VSYlmf>lmYlmPSRmRmh9f>VKzfUtO'VSY_P5RmXV
" 254 .GH 7 :G5 E
<
Yc^PSYYc^lXz2PS5_~V9\>_gRClmXf>VSf>Rmlmf>_gP5[g
w4HL&85:g:>E8B>EF4 sC4CE9G4C69: c>_(]^f>XY_gPS\>h5iUbgVS~{ T[_gXX]>[_lX'[_gRmP5Y_g\YVYc>_(V5Yc>_[QKP5[lmPS^R_XYc>[VS]>Z5cYc>_
>[_gXXl^R_]>Rm_g[|OPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YVSS_XPSRmZ5VS[lmYc>~ XVSRmQ5_gXYc>_ _g9]>P5YlmVSf$VKnXYPSY_'npV5[PSf$lm\>_gP5RUZSPSX
XY[V5f>ZbgV5f>X_g[QKPSYlV5f9{NRPKzn&VS[~ KV n%Yc>_YNz2VK{N\>lm~_gf>XlmVSf>P5Rpi
Yc^lf{}RmPKhS_[tOPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YVSS_X_g9]>PSYlV5f>X2lfP(b]>[Q9lmRmlf^_gPS[2bgVK{
/ $ 7 I  7 ' 7 , ( 7 K J
g
VS[\>lmf>PSY_XhHXY_g~ 
9J c^_Z5VKQS_g[f>lmf>Z_g9]>PSYlV5f>XPS[_
ZSlmQ5_gflmf$QS_gbYVS[2n&VS[~9h
OV5f>\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSRmlmgPSYlVKfV|n9X&{ g ClmXUC_g[Nn&VS[~_g\
>
]

X

l
^
f
Z
P5XtYc^_[_Jnp_[_gf>b_Rm_gf^ZSYc i PSXYc^_[_np_g[_f>bg_QS_J{
 ,  ,   254  ! 
p5 RmV9bglmYNhSi K PSX2Yc>_'[_Jnp_[_gf>b_Ylm~ _K i PSX2Yc^_[_Jnp_[_gf>b_
\>_gf^XlmYNh$PSf>\ 7 PSX'Yc>_a[_np_g[_f>bg__gf>_[ZSh5c>_n&VS[~
VKntYc>__g9]>P5YlmVSf>X\^VH_Xf^VSYbJc>PSf^ZS_P|npY_g['Yc>_f>VSf>\^l~_gf9{
zc>_g[_  lmX%Yc>_Q5_gbgYV5[V|n-bgV5f>X_g[QKPSYlQ5_QKPS[lmP5>Rm_gXgi
XlmV5f>PSRmlmgPSYlmVSfUO'VSY_Ki7Yc>lmX%f>V5f>\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSRmlmgPSYlV5f\>loU_g[X
p
n
[VS~Yc^_%>P5f>_gR9bgV9\>_ >]^Xlmf>Z PSXYc>_2[_Jnp_[_gf>b_QS_RV9bglmYNh
#$ * $+
>
c
_g[_K%c^lX2>[VKQHlm\>_XP(\>loU_g[_fHYYlm~_XbPSRm_PSf>\P(\>loU_g[N{
 % $& ' $ 

g
_
9
f
Y\>_J7f^lYlmVSf$npV5[Yc>_a[_\>]>bg_g\n&[_g9]>_gf^bgh -c>VKz2_gQ5_g[giCnpV5[
" )(
,
g
b
m
R
S
P
[lmYNhSi>Yc>_>[_gX_gf9Y_g\[_gX]^RYXc>PKQ5_7_g_f[_gXbgP5Rm_g\]>Xlf^Z

Yc^_%Yl~_P5f>\[_\>]>bg_g\an&[_g9]>_gf^bgh\>_JCf>lmYlmVSf>XWVKn7Yc>_t>P5f>_gR
bgV9\>_P5f>\Xc>VKzf$lmfYc>_f>VS~_gf>bgRmP5Y]>[_K
 PSf>\ !
 P5[_Yc^_lmfHQ9lmXbl\7]>QS_gbgYVS[Xgi
^VS[- ]>Rm_g[XVSRm]>YlmVSf>XWYc>_2Q9lXbgVS]^X-Y_g[~XV5fYc>_ `
S
P

[
%
_

X
g
_
t
Y
YVg_g[V>i9PSf>\7VKzYPSf>Z5_gf>bghCVS]^f>\>PS[hbgV5f>\>lmYlmVSf^X
#$
* $+
9,
S
P

[

_
S
P
>

Rlm_g\aPSYYc>_X]>[NnpP5bg_K%^VS[tO'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gXXV5Rm]>YlmVSf^X
.

.
/
 % $& )'C ,
.01/ $ 


Y
^
c

_
>
f
K
V
N
{

X
Rmlm(bVSf>\>lmYlV5f(lmXtP5>>Rmlm_g\aPSYYc>_'X]>[npPSb_K%'_gf>XlmYNh
"
(
 , /7 7
 / ,
PSf^\>[_XX]^[_P5[__HY[P57V5RP5Y_g\YVYc>_aX]^[NnpP5bg_n&VS[CVSYc
]>Rm_g[P5f>\ O'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gXXVSRm]>YlmV5f>Xgi2PSf>\ npVS[a]>f>XY_gP5\>h

~
V5YlmVSf^XYc^_7VKz2{NYP5f>ZS_f>bghPSf>\f>VK{NXRmlmbgVSf>\^lYlmVSf>XPS[_
#$
* $+
32 ,

/

~
V9\>lo7_\YValmf>bgRm]>\>_Yc>_RmV9bgPSRU~VSYlmV5f(V|n Yc>_X]>[npPSb_K
 % $& )'2 , 50/ $

f$Yc>_>[_gX_fHYXY]>\>hYc>__JU_gbgYV|n7VKzbgVS~>[_XXN{
"
(42
 , /C 2 7   / ,
lm>lmRmlYNhlmX$VKnlmf9Y_g[_gXYiYc>_[_JnpV5[_KiV5f>Rmh]>Rm_g[lmfHQ9lmXbl\C
k2

k1

w
k

j+1

k3

k2

Panel j
(qj )k
k

XV5Rm]>YlmVSf^XPS[_bgVS~>]>Y_\U f$np]>Y]>[_XY]>\>lm_gXQ9lmXbgV5]>XbgP5R{

bg]>RmP5YlmVSf>X~PKhC_C_g[NnpV5[~_g\YVlmf9QS_gXYlmZSP5Y_Yc^__Jk_bgYVKn
Xc^VHbJ>KCVS]^f>\>PS[h5{}RmPKhS_[lmf9Y_g[PSbgYlV5f>XPSf>\7VKzX_g>PS[PSYlV5f
VSf$Yc>_'7]>YY_g[[_gXCVSf^X_K
c>_Ylm~_J{NlmfHY_gZS[PSYlV5flmX7_g[npVS[~_g\]>Xlmf>ZYc>_]>9{
zlmf>\ ^lP5X_g\ itnpP5bgYV5[lmg_g\Ui2lmY_g[PSYlmQ5_Ki%lm~^RlmbglmYXbJc>_~_$VKn
j2c>P5H[PKQKPS[Yc9hPSf>\'Xc^_g[gi ZSlmQS_gf$9h

I ,  
    ' , &    2  '

J

2
2 4


    ' J
   ' , &    ' 7 
 I , 
 

4
     ' 7    '


7    ' 7   '

,    4 7 ' 7   2 4 7 '






,    ' 4 7 7   '2 4 7

 


2 4
7 
    '  4 7 7   '2 4 7 

PSlm[npVSlmR9X_gbYlmVSfUi>c^PSX >  C CVSlmf9YXgi9zlmYcP5flf^lYlmPSR9z%P5RmR

X^PSbglmf>ZVKn 5 i > 7V5lmfHYXlmfYc>_z%P5S_P5f>\PnpPS[7_gRm\
CVS]>f>\^PS[h < bJc>VS[\>Rm_gf>ZSYc>Xn&[VS~yYc>_X]>[Nn&PSbg_K

fC( 
Ji  & > &

_YbKmi  
       _gYbK
PS[_$Yc>_$C]> 5PSbgV5>lmPSfA~P5Y[lmbg_XPSf>\ i & PSf^\ PS[_
Yc^_$npVS[z%P5[\Ui>P5bJHz2PS[\PSf^\b_gf9Y[P5R\>lok_g[_gf>bg_V57_[PK{
YV5[Xi[_gX7_bgYlmQS_Rh5 c>_9]>PSf9YlYlm_gX     4 7  '5i    '  4 7
PSf^\   '  4 7 P5[_2f9]>~_g[lmbgPSR|7]>9_gXgtc^_%X]>7_[Xb[ lm>Y  
\>_gf^VSY_XYc>_Ylm~_XY_gUiPSf^\Yc>_(X]>C_g[Xbg[lm>Y F [_Jn&_g[X
YVO'_gzYV5f$X]>>lmY_g[P5YlmVSf>XzlmYc>lmf_PSbJc$Ylm~_'XY_U
c>_2lmfHQ9lmXbl\7]>9_gXgi A P5f>\   iSP5[__gQKP5Rm]>PSY_g\]>Xlf^Z
'Xc>_[gXYc^l[\9{NVS[\^_g[]>9zlmf>\>lmf>ZXbJc>_g~_K ^VS[Yc>_Rmlmf9{
_gP5[lmgPSYlmVSfVKnYc>_Rm_Jn&YN{Nc>PSf>\Xlm\>_V|n CU
Yc>_7]>( SPK{
bgV5>lmPSf~PSY[lmbg_gXgi  PSf^!\ iSP5[_2_gQKPSRm]>P5Y_g\9hYc^_`9Y_gZS_[N{
PS[~lmf>ZC]>5{}Q5_gbgYV5[X>RmlYYlmf>Z^ # " c>_QHlmXbgVS]>X 7]>9_gXPS[_
bgV5~>]>Y_g\zlmYcX_gbgV5f>\9{NVS[\^_g[bg_gf9Y[PSR\^lU_g[_gf>bg_gX
lm~_'PSbgbg]^[PSbhlmXlm~>[VKQ5_g\$Hh$C_g[Nn&VS[~lmf>ZO_gz2{
YV5fX]>>lmY_[PSYlmVSf>XYV$bgV5f9QS_g[ZS_gf>b_PSY_gP5bJcXY_gUc>_gX_
X]^>lmY_g[PSYlmV5f>Xt~lmf>lm~lg_tYc>_Rmlmf>_gP5[lmgP5YlmVSfaPSf>\npP5bgYV5[lmgPK{
YlmV5f_g[[VS[XtPSf>\ac>_gRma\>[lmQ5_%Yc>_%Rm_Jn&YN{Nc>PSf>\Xlm\>_VKnUC 

YVag_g[VPSYt_PSbJc$Ylm~_2XY_gU HC_g[l~_gf9YX29hYc>_'>[_gX_gf9Y
PS]^Yc>V5[Xn&VS]>f>\Yc>P5YRmPS[ZS_g[jf9]>~C_g[Xl& _|i>PRmP5[ZS_[
Ylm~_tXY_g7bgVS]>Rm\a7_']>X_\lnUYc^_fH]^~7_g[V|nkO'_gzYV5flY_g[N{
PSYlmVSf>Xtz2PSXlf^bg[_gP5X_g\ %c>_'VS>Yl~]^~X_g_g~_g\YVa\>_gC_gf>\
VSfYc>_ZS[l\YVSCVSRmVSZ5h(P5f>\a7VKzAbgV5f>\>lmYlmVSf^Xgi>>]>Y2Yc^_C_gXY
bgV5~>]>YPSYlV5f>PSR9C_g[Nn&VS[~PSf>b_X__g~_g\YV(V9bgb]>[zlmYc YV

X]^9{}lmY_g[P5YlmVSf>XVSfbVSPS[X_ZS[l\^Xp]>Rm_g[$Xl~]^RP5YlmVSf^XJi
PSf^\YV X]>9{NlmY_g[PSYlmV5f>XVSf$7f^_ZS[l\^XOPKQ9lm_g[N{`9YVSS_X
Xlm~]>RmP5YlmVSf>XJJCc>_%O'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gXWXVSRmQ5_g[Uc>PSXW7__gf(Y_gXY_g\
_g9Y_f>XlmQS_RhlfP'QKPS[lm_gYNh'VKn7]^f>XY_gPS\>hX]>>XVSf>lmbKi5Y[P5f>XV5f>lmb
PSf^\X]>C_g[XVSf>lmbXY]>\>lm_gXa _JnpXg7 { J
x YNh9>lmbgP5RbgV5~>]^YPSYlmVSf>P5R7Z5[lm\]>X_g\$npV5[Yc^_(]>Rm_g[
Xlm~]>RmP5YlmVSf>XlmX2Xc>VKzflf$WlZ^i>zlmYcPa\>_gYPSlmRm_g\Q9lm_gzVKn
Yc^_%X]>[NnpP5bg_2lfalmZ^ c>_2ZS[l\Xc>VKzfUi|npVS[WPO x j x S^


%$

]>Rm_g[ZS[l\p >  C i>_gQ5_g[h5{NVSYc^_g[Rmlf^_Xc^VKzf7J


%&]>Rm_g[Z5[lm\$X]>[npPSbg_\>_gYP5lmRp

c>_]^R_[(XVSRm]>YlmV5f>XPS[_P5bgY]>P5RmRhH]^lY_X_gf^XlmYlmQS_

YVYc>_almf>lmYlmPSRWz%P5RmRUX>P5bglmf>Z$PSf>\V5[Yc>VSZ5VSf>P5RlmYNhf>_gPS['Yc>_
z2PSRmR&c>lmRm_([_gRmPS9_g\ X]>[Nn&PSbg_$X^PSbglmf>ZP5f>\ f^VS[~PSRmX[_J{
X]^RYalmfPSRm~V5XY'f>VbJc>P5f>ZS_lmfYc>_RlonpYi-Yc>_gh[_gX]>RmYalmfP
XRmlmZSc9YXc^ln&YlmfYc>_~VS~_gf9YPSf>\Yc>_]>f>XY_gP5\>h^c>PSXlf^Z
VKnUYc^_~VS~_gf9YgUc>_2>c>P5X_VKnUYc^_~VS~_gf9YUlmXtYc>_5_ghYV
`> {}>lmYbc^lf^Za7]>YY_g[giWYc9]>XlmYXPSbbg]>[P5Y_abgVS~>]>YPSYlmV5f
lmX_gXX_gf9YlmPSR&
x f9]>~C_g[VKnQKPSRmlm\>PSYlmVSf _HC_g[l~_gf9YX$z2_g[_7_[N{
npV5[~_\YVQS_g[lonph Yc>_9]>P5RmlYNhV|nYc>_ZS[l\^Xgc>_Z5[lm\
\>_gf^XlmYNhz2PSXlmf>bg[_PSX_\YV S^  > iK[_gX]>RmYlmf>ZlmfQ9lm[Y]^PSRmRmh
f>VQKPS[lmP5YlmVSflfYc>_a>[_\>lmbgY_g\7]>YY_g['np[_g9]>_gf>bhS x \>\^l{
YlmV5f>PSRmRmhSi5Yc>_lmf>lmYlmPSRCz2PSRmR7X>PSblf^Zz%P5X[_g\>]^bg_g\YV S^ i

PSZ5PSlmfzlmYcf>_gZ5RmlZ5lm>Rm_lmf97]>_gf^bg_VSfYc>_[_gX]^RYXgOV5Y_Ki

npV5[Yc>_O x j x 5S >P5lm[NnpV5lRX_gbgYlmV5fUitPSflmf>lmYlmP5R-X>PSblf^Z
VKn S53
z2PSX[_g9]>lm[_g\f>_gPS[Yc>_Rm_gP5\>lmf>Z(_\>ZS_K
9C_g[lm~_fHYPSR5[_gX]>RmYXtzlmYcYc>_2>PSf^_gR9bgV9\>_%\^_g~V5f9{
XY[P5Y_g\Yc>P5YX_gQ5_g[P5Rlf^lYlmPSR&iHV5[XYPS[Y{}]^UiUVSXblRmRmPSYlmVSfbhS{
bgRm_gX'z%_g[_[_H]^l[_g\7_Jn&VS[_PSf$PSbgb]>[P5Y_~_gPSX]>[_g~_gf9YVKn
Yc^_7]^YY_[[_gXCVSf^X_bgV5]>Rm\7_VS^YPSlmf>_\U x YYc>_RVKz
np[_g9]>_gf>bglm_gXlmf9QSV5RmQS_g\almfYc>lmXtXY]>\>h5i9X_gQ5_g[P5RUbgh9bgRm_gX%bVS[[_J{
XCVSf^\>X%YVPbgV5~>]^Y_g\z2PS5_R_f>ZSYcVSfYc^_VS[\>_g[2VKn S
bJc>VS[\>Rm_gf>Z5Yc>X x bgV5~>]>YPSYlV5f>PSR\>V5~P5lfVKnYc^lXa~P5ZK{
f>lmY]^\>_lmXf>VSY[_gPSRmlmXYlbPSRmRmh$np_gP5Xlm>Rm_n&VS[Yc>_]>Rm_g[abgV9\>_K
VKz2_gQ5_g[gi>Yc>__JU_gbgY'VKnYc>_z%P5S_[_XVSRm]>YlmVSfz2PSXlf9Q5_gXYl{
ZSP5Y_g\ ikCVSYc9hlmf>bg[_gPSXlmf>ZYc>_(z2PS5_CVSlmf9Y\>_gf>XlYNh$P5f>\
9h \>V5]>>Rmlmf>ZYc^__g9Y_gf^XlmVSfVKnYc^_bgVS~>]>YPSYlmV5f>PSR2\>VK{
~P5lmflfAYc>_XY[_gP5~zlmX_$\>lm[_gbYlmVSfU^VS[Y]>f>P5Y_gRmh5i%>[_J{
\>lmbgY_g\C]>YY_g[np[_g9]>_gf>bglm_gXVSf>RmhQKP5[lm_g\9hPS^>[VK9lm~P5Y_gRmh
npVS[Yc^__g9Y_gf>\^_g\Ui>c>lmZSca\>_gf^XlmYNhbgV5~>]>YPSYlV5f>PSR5\>VK{
~ P5lmfUi-PQKP5[lmPSYlmVSfYc^PSYaz%P5X\>_g_g~_g\AYVSRm_g[PS>Rm_npVS[aYc>_
>[_gX_gf9Y'XY]^\>hS
sUuv2w2uv-q81 q@ mw%s
`9Y[]>bgY]>[P5R~VH\^_gRmlf^ZlmXnpPSblRmlmYP5Y_g\]>Xlmf>ZaPa
X^[lmf>ZH|~P5XXXh9XY_g~*pWlmZ> YVXlm~]>RmPSY_Yc>_(C_gf>\^lf^Z
PSf^\YNzlmXYlmf>ZaVKn-Pzlmf>Z^
xp

zc>_g[_

7
 <       < 7  
P5f>\
  72 

 
2 


PSf^\zc>_g[_$Yc>_>[lm~_gX\>_gf^VSY_\>lok_[_gf9YlmP5YlmVSfzlmYc[_J{
XC_gbgY'YVf>V5f>\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSRCYlm~_Ki
9]>P5YlmVSfa A5ClmXUPXh9XY_g~V|nHYNz2V>i<bVS]>>Rm_g\ iX_gbgV5f>\9{
VS[\>_g[if^VSf>Rmlmf>_gP5[giK\>lok_[_gf9YlmP5RS_g9]>P5YlmVSf>X KbgVS]>^R_\Yc>[VS]>Z5c
Yc^_Y_g[~XbgVSf9YPSlmf>lmf>Z aPSf>\aYc^_\>_gC_gf>\>_gf^bg_VKn P5f>\
V5f P5f>\ i<P5f>\f>V5f>Rmlf^_gPS[UYc>[V5]>ZScYc>_tf>V5f>Rmlmf>_gPS[lmYNh
VKn PSf>\
OV5f>\>lm~_f>XlmVSf^PSRmlmgPSYlVKf2n&VS[UYc^_%]>Rm_g[JKOPKQ9lm_g[{`9YVS5_gX
bgV9\>_lmX27_[NnpV5[~_\Xlm~lmRmPS[RmhKi5>]>YYc^_[_Jnp_g[_gf>bg_aQS_RV9bglmYNh
lmXYc>_tn&[_g_gXY[_gPS~ XC_g_g\V|n7XV5]>f>\Ui i5PSf>\Yc>_2[_Jnp_[_gf>b_
Ylm~_lmXYc>_f <K> c>_[_X]>RmYlmf>ZXh9XY_g~)VKnt_g9]>P5YlmVSf^X
lmXYc>_'XPS~_tPSX2C AS _g9bg_g>YnpVS[Yc>_ `aQS_gbgYVS[

zc>lmbJc$7_gbVS~_X
7  7 E


<

OV5Y_Yc>PSY PSf>\ P5>7_PS[lmf>Z$lmfYc>_~PSY[lm   %PS[_
[_\>]>bg_g\f>P5Y]>[PSR2np[_g9]>_gf>bglm_gX>PSX_g\V5f Yc^_$np[__gXY[_gP5~
XC_g_g\VKn-XVS]>f^\Ui7>]^Y%>[_gX_fHY_g\[_gX]>RmYXbVSf9QS_g[YYc>_~!YV
Yc^_bgVSf9QS_fHYlmVSf>P5R>\>_J7f^lYlmVSfUiS^PSX_\VSfnp[_g_gXY[_gP5~ QS_RV9bJ{
lmYNhSi9YVC_bgV5f>XlmXY_gf9YzlmYcYc^_lmf>bgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_'PSf>P5Rh9XlX
`9lm~]>RmPSYlmVKf>XtzlmYc$P`>P5[_C_g[Nn&VS[~_g\$9hX_YN{
Ylmf>Z PSf>\_glmYc>_g[ 
 P5f>\ V5[% 

PSf^\ n&VS[U>lmYbJc>lmf>Z|{}V5f>RmhVS[U>Rm]>f^ZSlmf>ZK{NVSf^Rh2~V5YlmVSf^Xgi
[_XC_gbgYlmQ5_gRmhS
9]>P5YlmVSfA ASlXPS\>QKP5f>bg_g\lmfYlm~_(9hlmf9QS_g[Ylmf>Z
Yc^_Xh9XY_~i7h9lm_gRm\>lmf>Z

 
 254
 7 
 2 4   
< &
Yc^_gf[_gz[lmYlf^ZYc>_a[_gX]>RmYPSXPXh9XY_~V|n%YNz2VbgV5]>>Rm_g\Ui
7[XYN{NVS[\>_g['_g9]>PSYlV5f>X




 
 2 4
 7 
 2 4   
  &
PSf^\UiK7f>P5RmRh5iKlmfHY_gZS[PSYlV5f(lmXtC_g[npVS[~_g\a]>Xlmf>ZP5f]>Rm_g[tV5[
P Yc9{}V5[\>_[ ]>f>Z5_J{ %]>YYPXbJc>_~_Ktc>_2>P5f>_gR>bgV9\>_]^X_gX
[_RP5YlmQS_RhRmPS[Z5_Ylm~_XY_g>XiPSf>\Yc9]>X[_g9]>lm[_gXYc>_ Yc9{
VS[\>_g[lf9Y_gZS[PSYlmV5f XbJc>_~_$npV5[(X]9bglm_gf9YP5bgbg]>[PSbgh5i>]^Y
Yc^_(XYPS^lRmlmYNh$[_g9]>lm[_g~_gf9YXV|n%Yc^_]^R_[KO'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gX
bgV9\>_PS[_X]>bJc Yc^PSYYl~_J{NXY_>XP5[_X~P5RmR_f>VS]>Z5cYV
PSbJc>lm_gQ5_X]9bl_fHY2PSbbg]>[P5bghzlmYcaP XYN{NVS[\>_g[]>Rm_g[tlmf9Y_J{
ZS[PSYlV5fXbJc>_~_KTP5f>_gRtXVSRm]>YlV5f>XYNh9>lmbgP5RmRhc>PKQS_aPSCVS]^Y
XY_g^XC_g[bgh9bgRm_KiPSf^\Yc>_]^R_[Xlm~]>RmPSYlV5f>Xc>PKQ5_

center
of mass

 

h
0



`9bJc>_g~PSYlmb'VKn-Yc>_X>[lmf>Z9K~P5XX2Xh9XY_g~

PSf^\

c>__g9]>P5YlmVSf>XZ5VKQS_g[f>lmf>ZaYc>lmX~V5YlmVSfP5[_
 ,A  , a 7 7


>5

 ,  , 7 
@5
zc>_g[_Yc>_\>VSYX\>_gf^VSY_\^lU_g[_gf9YlmPSYlV5fzlmYc[_gXC_gbgYYV
Ylm~_K-O'VSY_Ki>f>VXY[]>bY]>[PSR\>PS~>lmf>ZlmXbgVSf>Xlm\>_g[_\c>_g[_K
^VS[Yc>_2>PSf>_RHbVH\^_Yc>_2Xh9XY_g~lmXf>V5f>\>lm~_gf^XlmVSf>P5Ro{
lmg_g\]^Xlmf>Z P5XYc^_t[_Jn&_g[_gf^bg_Rm_gf>ZSYcUi  P5XUYc>7 _[_Jnp_[_gf>b_
QS_RV9bglmYNh5i <  P5XYc>_a[_np_g[_f>bg_$Ylm~_PSf>\ K P5X
Yc^_[_Jnp_g[_gf>bg_~P5XX _gz[lmYlf^ZYc>_$Xh9XY_g~lmf~PSY[lm
f>V5YPSYlmVSfUi>V5f>_VS>YPSlmf>X


 ,   


A5

 fWlmZ> ikYc>_Yc>[_g_aX_YXVKn%Yc>[__(bg]^[QS_X^RV5YYc>_

[_X]>RmYP5f9YVSXbglm
RmRP5YlmVSfnp[_H]^_gf>bgh5i iUPSXPn&]>f>bgYlV5f$VKntYc>_
]>f>\^PS~C_g\af>PSY]>[P5R>n&[_g9]>_gf^bghSi i5npVS[tYc>[__PSlm[npVSlmRmXP5f>\
Yc^[_g_$lmf>_g[YlmPSR2>PS[PS~_gY_g[Xg f_gPSbJcZS[V5]>>lmf>ZV|nYc>[_g_
Rmlmf>_gXgiCYc>_]>>C_g[Rlmf>_bgV5[[_gXCVSf>\^XYVPO x j x S^ aP5l[{
npV5lR&iYc>_~lm\>\^R_Rlmf>_YVP$O x j x S5 @PSlm[Nn&VSlmRPSf>\Yc>_
RmVKz%_[Rmlmf>_YVPO x j x SS^ PSlm[Nn&VSlmR&%c>_abglm[bgRm_KiUXH]^PS[_
PSf^\\^lP5~V5f>\Xh9~CVSRmX7\^_gf>VSY_tYc^_t7V5lmfHYUP5RmVSf>Z2Yc>_bg]>[Q5_gX
zc>_g[_7]>YY_g[V9bgbg]^[XWnpVS[UYc>_O x j x SS^ i SS @tP5f>\ S^
PSlm[npVSlmRmXgi>[_gXC_gbgYlQ5_gRmhS ~CVS[YPSf9Ynp_gPSY]>[_XYVf>V5Y_n&[VS~
WlmZ> PS[_Yc>PSYYc>_7]>YY_g[np[_H]^_gf>bgh$lmX%lmf>\^_g7_f>\>_gf9YVKn
Yc^_(lmf>
_g[YlmPSRW>PS[PS~_gY_g[i7lmfP5bgbgVS[\>PSf^bg_(zlmYcRmlf^_gPS['Yc>_J{
VS[hSi>Yc>_np[_g9]>_gf>bh[_gXCVSf^X_alXV5f>RmhXRmlmZSc9YRmh\>_7_gf^\>_gf9Y
VSfYc>_P5l[npVSlmR>Yc>lmbJHf^_gXXi7>]>YYc>_C]>YY_g[np[_g9]>_gf>bl_XPS[_
c>lmZSc^Rh\^_g7_f>\>_gf9YV5fYc>_aYc>lmbJ9f>_gXXiU[_g\>]^bglmf>Z$7V5Yc$Yc>_
7]>YY_g[Q5_gRmV9bglmYNh(P5f>\Yc>_~lmf>lm~(]^~[_g9]>lm[_g\$lmf>_g[YlmPSRC>PK{
[P5~_gY_g[g x XYc>_P5l[npVSlmR5Yc>lmbJ9f>_gXX2lmX[_g\>]^bg_g\Ui>Yc>_27]>YY_g[
np[_g9]>_gf>bghPS>>[VSP5bc^_gXYc>PSY>[_g\>lmbgY_g\9hRlmf>_PS[Yc^_gVS[hSi
PSRmYc>VS]>Z5cf>V5YPSXh9~>YVSYlmbgP5RmRh5i>Pn&PSbgYYc^PSY[_g9]>lm[_gXnp]>[N{
Yc^_g[P5YY_fHYlmVSflmfnp]>Y]>[_XY]>\>lm_gX
flmZ^) >'Yc>_'f>VSf>\^l~_gf>XlV5f>PSR|7]>YY_g[2QS_gRmV9bglmYNh5i 2i
lmX(^RV5YY_g\npV5[P[PSf^ZS_V|nPSlm[Nn&VSlmRmXP5X(Pnp]>f^bgYlmVSfV|nYc>_
f>V5f>\>lm~_gf^XlmVSf>P5Rlmf>_g[YlmPSR>PS[PS~_gY_g[i< !j2Rm_gPS[RhAP5l[{
npV5lR^Yc>lmbJ9f>_gXX2lmXtP\>_XYP5>lmRmllf^Znp_gP5Y]>[_>[VKQHlm\>lmf>Z~]>bJc
RmVKz%_[t7]^YY_[QS_gRmV9bglmYlm_gX2PSf>\PSY2~]>bJc~V5[_[_PSRmlmXYlmb'QKPSRo{
]>_gX'VKn

C_gYNz%__gf > S P5f>\ > S5 XY_g^X7_g[bgh9bgRm_Kit\>_gC_gf>\>_fHYV5f

Yc^_XYP5>lmRlmYNhRmlm~lmYP5YlmVSf^X-V|n-Yc>_(]>Rm_g[bVH\^_K
2v Usgus
f$Yc>_>[_gX_fHYXY]>\>hVSf>Rmh`>Xlm~]>RmPSYlmV5f>XtPS[_
C_g[NnpV5[~_g\Ui<[_gX_[Q9lmf>ZYc>_tbPSX_ npVS[UP2np]^Y]>[_tXY]>\>h5
fAYc>_7[XY>P5[YiYc>_$_JU_gbgY$VKnPSlm[NnpV5lmRtYc>lmbJ9f>_gXXlmXlmf9{
QS_XYlmZ5PSY_\lfalmf>bgV5~>[_gXXl^R_2CVKziSzlmYcabgVS~>PS[lXVSf>XYV
Rmlmf>_gPS[2Yc^_gVS[hSi>P5f>\lmfYc>_X_gbVSf>\^PS[Y2Yc^__k_gbYV|nU7VKz
bgV5~>[_gXXl^lRmlmYNhlmXlmfHQ5_gXYlmZSPSY_g\npVS[X_gQS_[PSRP5l[npVSlmRmX2zlYc
bgV5~>P5[lmXV5f>XYV Yc^_lf^bgVS~>[_gXXlm>Rm_Ki^PSf>_gRo{NbgV9\>_XVSRm]9{
YlmV5f>XPSf>\Rmlf^_gPS[Yc>_gVS[hS
x _[V9_gRmPSXYlmb%Xlm~]>RmPSYlmV5f>XUPS[_%>[V9\>]>bg_g\9hbgV5~>]>Y{
lmf>ZPXY_PS\>h7VKz XVSRm]>YlV5f P5YPSf
\>_gZS[_g_P5f>ZSRm_$VKn
PSYYP5bCi>P5f>\[_gRm_gPSXlf^Z(Yc>_PSlm[NnpV5lmR7P5Y%Yc>_XYP5[Y2VKnYc>_]>f9{
XY_gPS\^hXV5R]^YlmVSfU lYcYc>_aX>[lf^ZK{Nf>_g]>Y[PSRX_gYP5Y \>_J{
ZS[_g_gXiYc>_aXYPSYlbl~^PSRmPSf>b_bgP5]>X_gXYc>_(P5lm[NnpV5lRUYV>lmYbJcUi
PSf^\Yc>_ZSPSlmfV5[(RmVSXXVKn~_gbJc>PSf^lbPSRt_gf^_g[Z5hlXa]>X_g\ YV
~_PSX]^[_Yc>_XYP5>lmRmlYNhV|ntYc>_PSlm[npVSlmR&-c^_7]>YY_g['bgVSf>\^l{
YlmV5flmX~P5[S_\9hPbgVSf^XYP5f9Y~_gbJc>P5f>lmbgPSRU_gf^_g[Z5hS
U@ Uu5v !BUBUUw%us
faYc>_'RlmY_g[P5Y]>[_lYlmXtV|npY_gfXYP5Y_g\Yc>P5Yn&VS[tlmf>bgV5~{
>[_gXXl^R_'7VKz`> 7]>YY_g[lmf^lYbJc>lmf>Z&`>>Rm]>f>Z|{
lmf>ZlmXtP5Rz2PKh9XXYP5>Rm_<lXVSf>RmhaVKnUPSbgP5\>_g~lmblmf9Y_g[_gXYi>Xlmf>bg_
Rmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_gV5[h\>V9_gXaf>VSY^[_g\>lmbgY7]>YY_g[a_g9bg_g^Y(zlmYcP5f
PSlm[npVSlmRX_gbgYlV5f>PSR~VS~_gf9Y%V|n%lmf>_g[YlmPnpPS['_g9bg_g_g\>lmf>Z[_gP5R{
lmXYlbQKP5Rm]>_gX_KZ>mi _Jn&Xg
P5f>\ @Sc>_>PSf>_R%bgV9\>_lmX
]>X_g\c>_g[_YVlf9Q5_gXYlZ5PSY_(Yc>__JU_gbgYaVKnPSlm[NnpV5lmR-Yc>lmbJHf^_gXX
VSfYc>_>[_g\^lbY_g\$C]>YY_g[CVS]>f^\>PS[l_Xgtc>lmXz2PSX2\>VSf>_YV
XV5~_\>_gZ5[_g_lmf _Jn 
iUzlmYcYc>_a[_gRm_gQKP5f9Y[_X]>RmYX>[_J{
X_fHY_g\AYc>_[_lmf WlmZ> iPSf>\[_gC_gPSY_g\Ac>_g[_$lmf WlmZ>

c>_[_X]>RmYXP5[_'npV5[%X_gQS_g[PSRWXh9~~_gY[lbPSR>O x j x PSlm[NnpV5lmRX
>lmQSV5Ylmf>ZP57V5]>YYc^_glm[R_PS\>lmf>Za_g\>Z5_gXg

60
Linear theory
NACA0001
NACA0006
NACA0009
NACA0012
NACA0015

50

VF

40

30

unstable

20

0.20

10

0.15

stable
0

100

200

c>__k_gbYVKntYc^_(_gRmP5XYlmbP59lX'RmVHbPSYlmV5fz2PSX'lmfHQ5_gXN{
YlmZ5PSY_\lmf _npXg
PSf^\F>a]^Xlmf>ZRmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_gV5[h5 flmZ^ @
Yc^_Rmlmf>_gPS[[_gX]>RmYX2ZSlmQS_gflmf _Jn> V5[lmZSlmf>P5RRmh_g9Y[PSbgY_g\
np[VS~ _npXg
P5f>\ >5WPS[_^RV5YY_g\(P5RmVSf>Z'zlYc([_gX]^RYXtn&[VS~
Yc^_(>P5f>_gRbgV9\>_npVS['O x j x SS >aPSf>\O x j x 5>
PSlm[npVSlmR
X_bgYlmVSf^XgO'VSY_Yc>_~]>bJc c>lmZ5c>_g[[_g\>]>b_g\C]>YY_g[np[_J{
9]>_gf>bl_XbgVS[[_gX7V5f>\>lmf>ZYV~]>bJcaRmVKz%_g[[_g\>]^bg_g\7]>YY_g[
QS_RV9bglmYl_XnpV5[%Yc>_Yc>lmbJS_g[2X_bgYlmVSf^Xg x RmXVaf>VSY_Yc>PSY2YNz2V
X_YXVKn\>PSYPCVSlmf9YXnpV5[(Yc>_O x j x S5 >PSf>\ npVS]^[(X_gYX

0.10


WR]^YY_[QS_gRmV9bglmYNhQ5_g[X]>XYc>lmb9f>_XXP5f>\$

I=50
I=150
I=1250
I
NACA 0001
NACA 0007
NACA 0012
Linear theory

0.05

0.00
0.00

0.05

0.10

300

0.15



>[_g9]>_gf>bh[_gXCVSf^X_aPSf>\7]>YY_g[CVS]^f>\>PS[lm_gXg

>

npV5[Yc>_O x j x 5>
ibgV5[[_XCVSf>\>lmf>ZYV$\>loU_g[_fHYaQKPSRm]>_X

VKnt i7P5Xlmf>\>lmbgPSY_g\$lmfYc>_7Z5]>[_R_ZS_gf>\^XgiUPS[_lmf>bR]^\>_g\Ui
PSf^\PS[__gXX_gf9YlP5RmRhbVSlmf>bglm\>_gf9Y _gbgP5RmRCnp[V5~ WlmZ>
Yc>P5Y
Yc^_7]>YY_g['np[_g9]>_gf>bghz%P5XXc^VKzfYVC_lmf>\>_gC_gf>\^_gf9YVKn
f WlmZ> @i-Yc>lmXlmXXc>VKzfYV$7_Y[]^_npV5[P5RmRt_gRmPSXYlmb
PS9lmX2RV9bgP5YlmVSf^Xg

0.2

k and k

0.15

0.2
Linear theory
NACA0006, I=100
NACA0006, I=1000
NACA0015, I=50
NACA0015, I=100
NACA0015, I=200
NACA0015, I=1000

0.15

k for I=50
k for I=100
k for I=200
k for I=1000
k

stable

0.1

0.05

0.1
0

0.5

0
xp

_gZ5lmVSfVKnW7]>YY_g[{}lmf>XYPS^lRmlmYNhanpV5[P(O x j x S^

w2@ D2v%UsUs&rpCmu8 !BUBUUw%us
_X]>RmYXCn&[VS~Yc^_tbgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_t]>Rm_g[WbgV9\>_tP5[_bgVS~{
>P5[_g\azlmYclmf>bgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_tP5f>\bgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_tRmlf^_gPS[WYc>_J{
VS[h npVS[2Pa7PSY2>RmPSY_<2PSf^\zlmYcYc^_>PSf^_gRUbgV9\>_ npVS[P5l[{
npV5lRmXtV|n7f^lY_Yc>lmbJ9f>_gXX'PSf>\lmf>bgVS~>[_XXlm>Rm_7VKztYVlmf9{
QS_XYlmZ5PSY_$Yc>_$_Jk_bgYXVKnCVKz bgVS~>[_XXlm>lmRmlmYNhS x X(>[_J{
Q9lmVS]>XRh~_fHYlmVSf>_g\ itYc>_7VKz lmX[_gXY[lmbgY_\YVX]>^XVSf^lb
PSf^\QS_g[hRVKzY[PSf>XVSf>lmbX7__g\>XYV>[_gQ5_gf9Y(Yc>_n&VS[~PK{
YlmV5fVKnXY[VSf>ZXc>V9b9X%>V5[%Yc>_\>PSYP(>[_gX_fHY_g\c>_[_Yc>_
d$P5bcf9]>~C_g[lmXRmlm~lmY_g\YVP~P5Hlm~a]>~QKPSRm]>_VKn @i
PSf^\anpVS[tYc>_X~PSRmR9PSf>Z5Rm_VKnUPSYYPSbJ[P5f>ZS_V|nklmf9Y_[_gXYc>_g[_

  E
\>_gZ5[_g_XJiPQS_g[hz%_PSXc^VHbJlmXaQHlmXl^R_V5f
Yc^_X]^bgYlmVSfXlm\>_VKnPO x j x S^
PSYaPXYPSYlmbPSf^ZSRm_VKn
PSYYP5bVKn
\>_gZS[_g_gXi%PSXXc>VKzflmf lmZ^ c^_bgVSf9{
YV5]>[2Rlmf>_Xt\>_gf>V5Y_d$PSbJclmf9Y_[QKPSRmXtV|n 3
iSzlmYcYc>_Z5[_gh
V5[\>VSYY_g\CbgV5fHYVS]>[lmf>\^lbPSYlmf>ZYc>_XVSf>lmbRmlmf>_K



0.05
unstable
0

1.5

0.5

xp

f>bgV5~>[_gXXl^R_'7]^YY_[N{Nlf^XYP5>lmRmlYNh[_gZSlmV5f>Xg

`9lm~lmRmPS[\>PSYPPS[_aXc^VKzflmfeWlmZSX APSf>\ iCnpV5[Yc>_
O x j x S5 >PSf>\O x j x 5>
PSlm[npVSlmRmXgig[_gXC_gbgYlQ5_gRmhSt'VKz2{
_gQ5_g[gi>CVSYcYc>_'QKPSRm]>_gXtV|n aPSf>\ PS[_lmf>bR]^\>_g\lmfYc>_gX_
7Z5]>[_gX
tPSRm]>_XtVKn npVS[\>loU_g[_gf9Y2QKPSRm]>_gXVKnU<aPS[_>RmVSY{
Y_\ 9hYc^_Rmlmf>_gXzlYc_gPSbJcRlmf>_{}YNh9C_(P5XXV9bglmP5Y_g\zlYc
PaZSlmQS_gfQKPSRm]>_'VKn- i>P5X%lmf>\>lmbgP5Y_g\$lmfYc>_'7ZS]^[_Rm_gZS_gf^\>X
PSf^\Yc>_QKPSRm]>_gXV|n PS[_\>_gf>V5Y_g\9h Yc^_XYPS[Xg 'f>_
QS_[h$lm~CVS[YPSf9Ynp_PSY]^[_Xc>VKzflmflmZ5Xg AaPSf^\ lmXYc>P5Y
_gRmPSXYlmbJ{NPS9lmXURmVHbPSYlmV5f>XUYc>P5YU[_gX]>RmYlmf'7]>YY_g[C_gbgVS~_H]^lY_
Rmlm~lmY_g\P5X<lmX[_g\>]^bg_g\U




k for I=100
k for I=1000
k

k and k

0.1

0.05

0.5

0
xp




_gZ5lmVSfVKnW7]>YY_g[{}lmf>XYPS^lRmlmYNhanpV5[P(O x j x S 5 >

@


 
`9Y_gP5\>hdePSbJcbgVSf9YVS]>[Xk

E @9i E



  f>XY_gP5\>hd$PSbJc$bgVSf9YVS]>[X


 2f>XY_gP5\>hd$PSbJc$bgV5fHYVS]>[X


  2f>XY_gP5\>hd$PSbJc$bgV5fHYVS]>[X


  'f>XY_gPS\>h$d$PSbJc$bgV5fHYVS]>[X


 f>XY_gP5\>hd$PSbJc$bgV5fHYVS]>[X

> 


 
:%f^XY_PS\>hd$P5bc$bgV5f9YVS]^[X


5 

 fYc^_]>f>XY_gPS\^hbgPSX_Ki(P5YYc>_ 7]>YY_g[bgVSf^\>lmYlmVSf

! EF
S i E A i
5 PSf>\A ! Yc>_g[_
lmXtPX~PSRmR9X]>C_g[XVSf>lmb[_ZSlmVSfaVSf_glmYc>_g[2X]>[npPSbg_'VKQS_g[>PS[Y
VKntYc>_(bhHbR_|i>]>Y'f>VP5>>PS[_gf9YXc>V9bCiUPSX'Xc>VKzflmflmZ^
S iSPSY S \>_ZS[__lmf9Y_[QKPSRmXVKQS_[tc>PSRonUYc>_'bgh9bgRm_Ktc>_'bgVSf9{
YV5]>[Rm_gQS_RXP5f>\$XV5f>lmbRmlmf>_'PS[_lmf>\>lmbgP5Y_g\$P5XlfWlmZ> <
f WlmZ> Yc>_Rmlmf>_gP5[Yc>_gV5[h[_gX]>RmYXnp[VS~ _Jn @
V5[lmZSlmf>P5RmRh_g9Y[PSbY_g\np[V5~ _nH
PS[_Xc>VKzfan&VS[P7P5Y
>RmPSY_%V5XbglmRmRmPSYlf^ZPSCVS]>YWlYXR_PS\>lmf>Z'_g\>ZS_2PSYX_gQS_g[PSR7dePSbJc
f9]>~C_g[XPSf^\P5XPnp]>f>bgYlmVSfVKnYc>_lmf>_g[YlmPSR>PS[PS~_Y_g[
c>_Xc>lonpYlmfYc>_7]^YY_[7V5]>f>\>P5[lm_gXa\>]>_YVlmf>bg[_gPSXlf^Z
d$P5bcfH]^~7_g['lmXXlm~lRmP5[%YVYc^_(Yc>lmb9f>_XX_JU_gbgYXc>VKzf
lmfWlmZ> >
120

c>_2Y[_gf>\lmXlfaPSZ5[_g_~_gf9YzlmYcaRlmf>_PS[Yc>_gV5[h5iH>]^Y

Yc^_bgVS~>[_gXXlm>Rm_[_gX]>RmYX\>V$f>VSYP5>7_PS[YV$PSXh9~>YVSYlo{
bgP5RRmhPS>^[VSP5bJc Yc^_lmf>bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_Rml~lmYPSXaYc^_edePSbJc
f9]>~C_g[%lmX2[_g\^]>bg_g0\ UPnpPSbY%Yc>PSY2z%P5[[PSf9YX2np]^[Yc^_g[lmfHQ5_gXN{
YlmZ5PSYlmV5fU
fWlZ^ Yc>_bVS~^]>Y_g\ ]>f9YPS^R_$[_gZSlmVSf^XnpV5[P
O x j x S5 >PSf>\O x j x 5>
P5Yd$P5bJc ^PSf>_gR'bgV9\>_<
PSf^\d$P5bJc @ap]>Rm_g[bgV9\>_<P5[_bgV5~>P5[_g\aYVRmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_J{
VS[hnpV5[P[P5f>ZS_VKn_gRmPSXYlmbPS9_gX YlmX_gQ9lm\>_gf9YYc>PSYCVSYc
lmf>bg[_gPSXlf^ZP5lm[NnpV5lRWYc>lmbJ9f>_gXXPSf>\d$P5bcf9]>~C_g[Rm_gP5\YV
XlmZ5f>lo7bgPSf9YRh_H^PSf>\>_\[_gZ5lmVSf>XWVKnSC]>YY_g[lf^XYP5>lmRmlYNh57c^_
7]>YY_g[$CVS]>f^\>PS[h n&VS[Yc>_O x j x S^
P5Yd$P5bc @lmX
[V5]>ZSc^Rh\^VS]>>Rm_$Yc^PSYVKnRmlf^_gPS[aYc>_VS[hAP5f>\ ~VS[_Yc>P5f
npV5]>[Ylm~_gXYc>PSY>[_g\>lmbgY_\9h(lmf>bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_tRmlmf>_gPS[Yc>_J{
VS[hS

M=0.0
M=0.5
M=0.7

100

0.4

M=0.0 (flat plate)

M=0.7 (flat plate)
M=0.0 (NACA0006)
M=0.0 (NACA0015)
M=0.7 (NACA0006)
M=0.7 (NACA0015)

80

60

unstable

VF

0.3

stable

40

0.2

20
0.1
stable

100

200
I

300

unstable


 $ j2V5~>[_gXXlm>lmRlmYNha_JU_gbgYn&VS[P7PSY>RmP5Y_K

f(WlmZ> < Yc^_t7]^YY_[-CVS]^f>\>PS[lm_gXWnpVS[WPO x j x S^

>lmYbJc>lmf>ZP57V5]>YlmYX-Rm_gP5\>lmf>Z_g\>Z5_tPSYd$PSbJc >P5f>_gR9bgV9\>_<i
i P5f>\
&]>Rm_g[bgV9\>_<'PS[_(Xc>VKzfP5XPn&]>f>bgYlV5f
VKnYc>_lf^_g[YlP5RU>PS[PS~_gY_g[

VF

unstable

10

stable
50
I


 & j2V5~>[_gXXlm>lmRlmYNha_JU_gbgYn&VS[PaO

75

%w wCss
x YNz2VK{N\>_gZS[_g_J{NVKn{&np[_g_g\>V5~XY[]^bgY]>[PSR>~V9\>_gRz%P5XbgV5]9{
>Rm_g\lfYc>_Yl~_J{N\>VS~PSlmfzlmYcPSflmf>bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_>P5f>_gR
bgV9\>_'PSf>\aPSf]^R_[KO'PKQ9l_[N{`9YV5S_gXtbVH\^_KiHP5f>\Yc^_[_gX]>RmYN{
lmf>Z$PS_g[V9_gRmPSXYlmbXV5RmQS_g[X(z2_g[_]>X_\ YVbgVS~>]>Y_aYc^_]>f9{
XY_gPS\^h~VSYlmVSf>XWVKnUPSlm[NnpV5lmRX npVS[Yc>_>]^[CVSX_'VKn>[_g\>lmbgYlf^Z
PSlm[npVSlmR^7]>YY_g[g
c>lmRm_9]>PSf9YlmYPSYlmQ5_bgV5~>P5[lmXV5f>XzlmYc$Rmlf^_gPS['Yc>_J{
VS[hz2_g[_af>V5Y7V5XXlm>Rm_\^]>_YVYc>_[_g9]>lm[_g~_gf9YVKn7f^lY_
PSlm[npVSlmRYc>lmbJHf^_gXXlmfYc>_>[_gX_gf9Y~_gYc^VH\^XgiCVSYcYc>_lmf9{
bgV5~>[_gXXl^R_$>P5f>_gRbgV9\>_P5f>\AYc>_bgVS~>[_gXXlm>Rm_]>Rm_g[
bgV9\>_[_gX]>RmYX(>[VKQ9l\^_g\_g9bg_gRmRm_gf9Y9]>PSRmlmYP5YlmQS_PSZS[_g_g~_gf9Y
zlmYcRmlf^_gPS[$Yc^_gVS[hST[_gX_gf9Y_g\[_gX]>RmYX\>_~VSf^XY[PSY_g\
Xlm~lRmP5[\>_gXYP5>lmRlmglmf>ZY[_f>\>XnpVS[tlmf>b[_gP5Xlmf>ZaPSlm[NnpV5lmRHYc>lmbJS{
f>_gXXP5f>\$lf^bg[_gP5Xlmf>Zd$P5bJcf9]>~C_g[
c>lmRm_Rmlmf>_gP5[UYc>_VS[hc>P5XUc>lmXYVS[lmbgP5RmRhX]>ZSZ5_gXY_g\aYc>P5Y
Xlmf>Z5Rm_J{}\^_gZS[_g_J{NVKn{&np[__g\>VS~ 7]^YY_[(z2PSXVKnVSf^RhPSbgP5\>_g~lmb
lmf9Y_g[_gXY\>]^_YV(Yc>_]^f>[_gP5RmlXYlmbgP5RRmhac>lmZSclf^_g[YlP5R7^PS[P5~{

20

25



j2V5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_7]>YY_g[{}lmf>XYP5>lmRlmYNh[_gZSlmVSf^Xg

M=0.0
M=0.1
M=0.3
M=0.5

2
xp

30

100

x j x 5 > 9

 TRmPSY_g[giHd miO'_gPSb_Ki3%a`CPSf>\aTP5f>Z>iKj'%ami Jx _[VK{

\>h9f>P5~lmb x f>PSRmh9XlmXCVKn7WRP5>>lmf>Z2lmf>ZT[V5>]>RmXlmVSf i x'Nxx
TWPSC_g[O'V> 5 { K A iSP5fU <5S
lm_gXY_g[gitTW0 >mi Jx j2V5~>]>YPSYlV5f>PSRUP5f>\97_g[lm~_gf9{
YP5R fHQ5_gXYlmZSPSYlmVSfVKn f>bVS~^[_gXXlm>Rm_'XbglmRRmP5YVS[h x lm[npVSlmR
WRmVKz P5f>\ WRm]>YY_g[T [VS^R_~Xgi d$P5XY_[gXc>_gXlXitOPKQKP5R
TWVSXYZS[PS\>]^PSY_`9bJc>V9V5Rpi7deVSf9Y_g[_gh5ikj x i S]>f^_ S5
-]^[f>_g[iSdmi Jx j2VS~>]>YP5YlmVSf^PSR f9QS_XYlmZ5PSYlmV5fVKn>P5S_J{
f>\>]^bg_g\ x lm[NnpV5lRWRm]>YY_g[lmf f>bgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_ WRmVKzP5f>\
x bYlmQS_WRm]>YY_g[j2V5fHY[V5Rpi (dePSXY_g[gXc>_XlmXgiCOPKQKPSRTWV5XYN{
ZS[PS\>]^PSY_`9bJc>V9V5Rpi7deVSf9Y_g[_gh5ikj x i7dePS[bJcUi <5K
v%BUv%w'Us
5VSf>_Xgi %a-mi-'VSc>[lf^Z>i-j'-d PSf>\TRmPSYg_g[i%d-mi
c>_gV9\>VS[X_gf imi _gf^_g[P5Rc>_gVS[hVKn x _g[VH\^hHf^PS~lmb >P5[lmP5XSV5_(f`V|Yn>[O]^bg]>Y~]>[_g_g[XalmbgP5%RK_gPSc^f>lf^\\ 9TCRm]>_g[f>lmZS~lmf>_Z fHYx PSR lm[N n&VS_glmXRm]>X RmYXgx i j2xV5N~x'x {
f>XYPS^lRmlmYNhP5f>\(Yc>_de_gbJc>PSf>lmX~VKn-WRm]>YY_g[i O x j x _J{ TWPSC_g[O'V> >{ S @A9i <5 >9
CVS[Y 9 >i <S

c^_gV9\>VS[X_gfUiUPSf>\PS[[lmbJ7i 2mi d$_bc^PSf>lmX~ VKn x f^PSSRmVSh9f^X_glmXtXg-i VKnt%aUVKz2{t`9P5Cf>_g\_g\ Tx RmPSlmY[NgnpV5_gl[gRCidRm]>YY_g[mi i l~_J{V5~PKlmf
WRm]>YY_g[gi O x j x _gCVS[Y >A
i <K9
i tV5R& K i>O'V>
i7d$PKh <5 >9
P5[[lmbJCi k2mi T[V5>]>RmXlmVSf$V|n-PWRmPS>>lmf>ZaPSf^\e'XbglmR{
 _gXXg8
i >tPSf>\ `9~lmYcUi x d mi j2PSRmbg]>RmP5YlmVSfVKn
RmPSYlf^Z x l[npVSlmR&i O x j x _7V5[Y
>@9i S >
W
T
S
V

Y
g
_
9
f

Y
m
l
S
P
R7WRmVKz P57V5]>Y x [>lmY[PS[h(2V9\>lm_gXgi  

V9_gzhSi 7ami Jx z2VK{lm~_gf>XlmV5f>PSR x >^[VK9lm~PSYlmVSf

.
 ! K
 |i VSR& A9iS> { A9iSTW_g[ZSPS~VSf
YVYc>_t'f>XY_gPS\>h x _g[V9\>h9f>P5~lmbgXUVKn V5YPS[hlmf>Z5Xgi

T

[
g
_

X

X
i
'

p
n
V5[\Ui > >

.
 ! 
 Ki tVSR&U iWOV>i
^_gU 3
@9i9>U A { >
2PSX]Ui%'%j'tPSf>\P5f>bgV9bJ7ia! >mi c>_f>XY_gP5\>h
`~lmRmZ>ig'i c>_ f>XYPS^lRmlmYNhV|nkTlmYbJc>lmf>Z'XbglmRRmP5YlmVSf>XWVKn lmd$>RmV5_ Ylm VSf9fQ9lmVKXnbglmPa\ Wz%RmVKV|z{'i lm~_gf^XlmVSf>P5R x 
_g[VKnpV5lRU
lmf f> bgVS ~>[_
 XXN|{ i
PSf x lm[npVSlmR>lmf`9]>>XVSf>lmb f>bgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_TV5Y_gf9YlP5R7WRmVKzi tV5Rp A @i @ A9i>^U { > A
<

5


H
 ! K
 |i tVSR& >9iKOV^
>
i

O
K
V
C
Q

H
i
>

>
{
>

>

S
<|H
>
 ej2c^PS9[PKQKP5[Yc9h5ik`C UPSf>\'Xc>_[git`Cmi Jx O_gz j2RmPSXX
 ]^fHh5PSfUiKmi `9lmf>ZSRm_J{N\>_gZ5[_g_J{NVKn{pnp[_g_g\>V5~ WRm]>YY_g[j2PSRo{
VKn2lmZSc x bbg]>[P5bgh  `9bJc>_g~_gX'npVS['h97_[CVSRmlmb(j2VSf9{
bg]>RmP5YlmVSf>X'npV5[P lf^Zlmf`9]>>XVSf>lmbTWVSY_gf9YlmPSRtWRmVKzP5f>\ X_[QKPSYlmVSfUPKzXi xNx'x TWPSC_g[ A
{ S > i A

j2VS~>PS[lmXVSf^XzlmYcPSf97_[lm~_gf9Yi O x j x  O{ 5 >i #  PSl&id 7d>PSf>\$j2c>PS9[PKQKPS[Yc9hSi>`C mi x f ~>RmlblY
<
>
^VS[~V|nkYc>_Xc>_g[29zlmf>\`9bJc>_g~_|i
i
2lmX>Rmlmf>Z5c>VKi k mi x Xc>Rm_gh5iUUPSf^\P5Rn&~PSf i k mi
tV5Rp> i>OV^
ikdePKhSi < A A9i9>U @ 
{ @ H
x _[V9_gRmPSXYlmbglmYNh i x \>\>lmXVSf9{N_gXRm_ghT]>^RlmXc>lmf>Zj2VS~^PSf9hSi
# " `9Y_gZ5_g[g
i > %PSf^\P5[~lf^Z>i i Rm]> t_gbgYVS[
f>bKmi7d$P5XXPSbJc9]>X_gYYXi <
> i9>U > @{ >S
9
`
>

m
R
m
l

Y

Y
m
l
>
f

Z
K
V
nYc>_ f9Q9lmXbglm\PSXh9f>P5~lmb9]>PSYlV5f>X2zlYc
_gf>Z>i5OKmi c>_'_gQ5_gRmVS>~_gf9YV|n7Pj2V5~>]>Y_g[tj2V9\>_
x
^

>

m
R

b
S
P

Y
m
l
5
V
>
f
XYVWlmf>lmY_J{'lU_g[_gf>bg_d$_Yc>V9\>Xi
npV5[Yc>_aO]>~_g[lmbgP5R `VSRm]>YlmV5fVKnf>XY_gP5\>h5i f9QHlmXbglm\P5f>\

.

:
 |i tVSR& H i A i>>UU > {
f>bgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_RmVKzVKQS_g[tP5f x lm[Nn&VSlmR&i d$PSXY_g[X%c>_XlmXgi 5
OPKQKP5R>TV5XYZS[P5\>]>P5Y_`9bJc>V9VSR&i>d$VSf9Y_g[_gh5i>j x i35]>f>_ < A @
([VSc>X~_gh5_g[gi7`k7TWi7 KPSY_[lmf>PS[lmXgi > x >P5f>\TRmPSY_g[gi
TWPSf^Z>itj' %ai Jx j2VS~^]>Y_g[j2V9\>_npVS[f^XY_PS\>h f9{
bgV5~>[_gXXl^R_WRmVKz>P5XY$z%V x l[npVSlmRmXgi x _g[V5f>PS]>YlmbgPSR lmdf>Z>\>i Z5_tO]>_g~VS~_g[lm_gbgYP5[Rh V5f9fQS_g'XYh9lmf>ZSP5P5~YlmVSlmbf`9V|Yn-P5RmYRKc>VK_n Wx Ulm[N_gn&bgVSY'lmRmVKXgn-i _gPS\9{
 f>Z5lmf>_g_g[ Xc^_gXlmXgi2OPKQKP5RTWVSXYZ5[PS\^]>PSY_e`bc^VHV5R&i%d$VSf9{
Y _[_gh5ikj x ik`9_g^Yg AA9
gi x'Nxx TWPSC_g['OV> ^ { @ A9i S]^f>_ <S^
#"O_gP5bg_Ki %a `ki x j2VS~>]>YPSYlmV5f>PSRPSf^\ 97_g[lm~_gf9{
Y P5R f9Q5_gXYlZ5PSYlV5fV|nYc>_T [VS^]>RmXlmQS_P5f>\ UlonpYlf^Zej2c^PS[N{ j2RmPS[9XVSfUi >>i9KPSY_g[lmf>P5[lmXgi > x 9PSf>\T RP5Yg_[gi7d
SP bY_g[lXYlmbgXV|n-XbglmRmRP5Ylmf>Z x lm[NnpV5lRmXtP5f>\ x lm[npVSlmRUj2VS~>lmf>P|{ mi j2VS~^]>YP5YlmVSf>P5R f9QS_XYlmZ5PSYlmV5fVKn x lm[npVSlmR7`9YPSRmR7WRm]>YN{
Y lmV5f>Xlmf f>bgV5~>[_gXXlm>Rm_WRmVKzi (d$P5XY_[gXc>_XlmXgiU_>Yg Y_[gi >[_gX_gf9Y_g\P5Y-Yc>_
KV n x _g[V5f>PS]>YlmbgXPSf>\ x XY[VSf^PS]>YlbXgiO'PKQKPSRTWVSXYZS[PS\>]^PSY_
`9bJc>V9VSR&i7d$V5f9Y_g[_ghSiUj x i7`9_>Yg <S 9
Ji>`9_g>Yi S^
_gY_g[X2[_g9]>lm[_g\YVP5bJc>lm_gQS_27]^YY_[gi>Yc^_>PSf>_R>PSf>\Yc>_]9{
Rm_g[bgV9\>_^[_g\>lmbgY_g\XlZ5f>lo7bgP5fHYRmhZS[_PSY_[[_ZSlmVSf>X'VKnW7]>YN{
Y_[lmf>XYPS>lmRmlmYNhYc^PSfRmlmf>_gP5[lmg_g\Am7P5Y>RmPSY_Yc>_gV5[h5(>V5[
PaO x j x 5>
Yc>_'>PSf^_gRUbgV9\>_>[_\>lmbgY_g\$[_g\>]>bg_\$7]>YY_g[
QS_RV9bglmYl_XVKnC[VS]^ZSc>Rmhc^PSRon>Yc>P5Y>[_g\>lmbgY_\(9hlmf>bgVS~>[_XXN{
lm>Rm_Rmlf^_gPS[tYc>_gV5[h5i>PSf>\anpV5[tYc^_XPS~_%P5l[npVSlmR>P5Y%d$P5bc @
Yc^_]>Rm_g[abgV9\>_>[_\>lmbgY_g\[_g\^]>bg_g\7]>YY_g[aQS_RV9bglmYl_XVKn
c>P5Rn>Yc>PSYPSZ5PSlmfU^]>[Yc>_g[~VS[_KiSYc^_tO x j x S>
P5l[npVSlmRKP5Y
d$P5bc @z2PSXWnpVS]^f>\(YV7]>YY_g[zlYc(P5flmf>_g[YlmPSR9>PS[PS~_J{
Y_[tP'np]>RmR>VS[\>_g[tV|nk~PSZ5f>lmY]>\>_RVKz2_g[Yc^PSfaYc>P5Yt>[_\>lmbgY_g\
9hRmlmf>_gP5[%Yc>_gVS[hS













"!#$







&%' 











 









 












 





(









 

)



'#!"*

"

+',.-



 /



%'10





)




32'45262

7)7896:<;>=?@9A'B)8CED?GFHJIK;LCHDCMAB)8C)DN?@FOHQP.R1CHSUTVHQWYXE8Z

[ ST\S8FJS





&])^L_`4a8^/SUTO8C)^/?@X)8C;bB)DMcXH?@=DdX)8

e8fHV^/SJC)9gBh26ST\X9B)8C)DN?@FHJI62iSUTjXUCEFaXE=EHV^/?@FOH

^/?@FU?G^@BlX [#m

<

=TnJX)DNC)FJ_?G8SH&CE89lKMT\XVcfSO;@;>STJH

CE89k2iSUTjXUSO;>CgHaZ

 j2[lmbg_RRml&i x `CmiKPSY_g[lmf>P5[lmXgi5> x P5f>\TRmP5Yg_g[i-d

mi 'f>XY_gPS\>h x lm[NnpV5lR>WRmVKz`9V5Rm]>YlmVSf^X-V5fd$VKQ9lmf>Z
CVSf>P5R
[l\^Xgi


|i xNx'x
TWPSC_g[O'V> { 
KH i 5PSfU S 9
PS~CVS]>[f>_KiSO7j'i WRm]>YY_g[2lmff^_'_gZ5[_g_V|n->[_g_J{
\>V5~i TP5[Y i7j2c>P5>Y_[
i x x d$PSf9]>P5R7V5f x _[V9_J{
RmPSXYlmbglmYNhSi>_gf^_g[P5R-\UC7TW SV5f>_gXik'bgYg < >

62'45262

E^>_&2iST\XH/cC)FJSbF?@S8FJSH

]>f9h5PSfUimi j2]>f^f>lmf>ZSc>P5~iU!>PSf^\PSY9lmf>Xi
j'-2mi c>_VS[_YlmbgPSR fHQ5_gXYlmZSPSYlmVSfVKn`9_gQS_[PSR22hHC_gXaVKn
`9lmf>Z5R_'_gZ5[_g_$V|n>[_g_g\>V5~WR]^YY_[gi


.
 ! 
 Ki tV5Rp < i>OV^79i7^_gU 3
9

SaS^/?@8





 












#