Idecad VS Etabs Comparison

Instructor:Amer Ali Barzanji

Scope
Modeling and Analysis of the concrete building having 5
stories with vertical loads of(floor cover, live load ,
partition walls on the beams and self weights ) with two
engineering software (idecad statik & etabs ),and compare
the analysis results of (axial load on columns and shear
walls ,the moments of the beams and the moment on the
floors).

3D-model by idecad

3D-model by Etabs

Axial load by Etabs

Axial load by Idecad

Beams moment by Etabs

Beams moment by Idecad

slab moment by Etabs

slab moment by Idecad

Items

Etabs

Idecad % variation

Axial load on columns

569 kN

548 kN

3.69

Axial load on walls

1553 kN

1435 kN

7.6

Moment on Beams

19.71 kN.m 19.52 kN.m

Moment on Slabs M1 5.51 kN.m 5.27 kN.m

M2 5.53 kN.m 5.48 kN.m

0.96
4.35
0.90