Buckling
Hdi Sellami
Centre de Gosciences
Slide 1 of 42
Buckling : cas du forage
Slide 2 of 42
Mode sinusodal
Slide 3 of 42
Mode helicodal
Slide 4 of 42
Mode helicodal
Slide 5 of 42
Sinusoidal Buckling in a Horizontal Wellbore
When the axial compressive load along the tubing
reaches the following sinusoidal buckling load Fcr,
the intial (sinusoidal or critical) buckling of the
coiled tube will occur in the horizontal wellbore.
Fcr = 2 (E I We / r )
0.5
Slide 6 of 42
Sinusoidal Buckling Load
Slide 7 of 42
Helical Buckling in a Horizontal Wellbore
When the axial compressive load reaches the
following helical buckling load Fhel in the horizontal
wellbore, the helical buckling of coiled tubing then
occurs:
Fhel = 2 2 2 1
E I We
r
Slide 8 of 42
General Equation
A more general helical buckling load
equation for highly inclined wellbores
(including the horizontal wellbore) is:
Fhel = 2 2 2 1
EIWe sin
r
Slide 9 of 42
Helicoidal Buckling Load
Slide 10 of 42
Helicoidal Buckling
Pitch = pas
Z(m)
Y(m)
X(m)
SPE 102850
Slide 11 of 42
Buckling in Vertical Wellbores:
In a vertical wellbore, the buckling of pipes will
occur if the pipe becomes axially compressed and
the axial compressive load exceeds the buckling
load in the vertical section.
This could happen when we slack-off weight at
the surface to apply bit weight for drilling and
pushing the pipe through the build section and into
the horizontal section.
Slide 12 of 42
Buckling in Vertical Wellbores:
Lubinski derived in the 1950s the following
buckling load equation for the initial
buckling of tubulars in vertical wellbores:
2 1/ 3
Fcr ,b = 1.94(EIWe )
Fcr ,b = 1.94(30 *106 * 0.3869 * 0.22252 )1/ 3
Fcr ,b = 161 lbf
Slide 13 of 42
Helical Buckling in Vertical Wellbores:
A helical buckling load for weighty tubulars in
vertical wellbores was also derived recently
through an energy analysis to predict the
occurrence of the helical buckling:
2 1/ 3
Fhel , b = 5.55(EIWe )
= 461 lbf
Slide 14 of 42
Stability analysis results for 5 in., 19,5 lb/ft DP
with 20,000 lbf axial compr. load
20
HOLE DIAMETER, in
BUCKLING OCCURS
IN THIS REGION
NO BUCKLING
IN THIS REGION
10
INCLINATION ANGLE, deg
90
Critical buckling loads vs.hole angle and hole
size, for 5 in. 19.5 ppf steel DP
HOLE DIAMETER, in
20
10
INCLINATION ANGLE, deg
90
Three possible buckling situations for 5 in.
19.5 ppf steel DP at 20,000 lb axial
compressive load.
UNACCEPTABLE BUCKLING HERE
BUCKLING
OK HERE
NO BUCKLING HERE
Flambage des tiges
Flambage sinusodale
Pour Inc>3 :
Pour Inc<3 :
Flambage hlicodal
Pour Inc>3 :
Pour Inc<3 :
Slide 18 of 42