You are on page 1of 392

Appendix A:

Analysis and Final Report:


Building 1Core Wall Only
Sample Design for PEER/CSSC,
Los Angeles, California

A N A LY S I S A N D D E S I G N F I N A L R E P O R T

Building 1 Core Wall Only Sample Design for


PEER/CSSC
Los Angeles, California

December 9, 2009

Structural + Civil Engineers


1301 Fifth Avenue, Suite 3200
Seattle, Washington 98101-2699
T: 206 292 1200 F: 206 292 1201

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

A N A LY S I S A N D D E S I G N C O M PA R I S O N

BUILDING CODES

Building Codes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Material Codes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

10

L OA D I N G C R I T E R I A

10

Gravity Loading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

10

Wind Design Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

11

Seismic Design Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

12

Seismic Response Spectra and Ground Motions for Non-Linear Response History Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . .

13

M AT E R I A L S

14

A N A LY S I S A N D D E S I G N S O F T WA R E

15

L OA D C O M B I N AT I O N S
Building 1A Load Combinations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

16

Building 1B and 1C Serviceability Load Combinations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

17

Building 1B and 1C MCE Load Combinations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

17

L AT E R A L M O D E L S U M M A RY
Elastic Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

18

Non-Linear Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

20

A C C E P TA N C E C R I T E R I A

20

Serviceability Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

20

NLRHA Acceptance Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

21

D E S I G N S U M M A RY
Building 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

22

Design Comparison Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

23

O B S E R VAT I O N S A N D C O N C LU S I O N S

A n a l y s i s a n d D e s i g n Fi n a l R e p o r t

43

Table of Contents
ii

Building 1 Core Wall Only Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Rebar Design Drawings (Buildings 1A , 1B, and 1C)
Appendix 2: Coupling Beam Design Charts (Buildings 1A , 1B, and 1C)
Appendix 3: Drift Plots MCE Level (Buildings 1B and 1C)
Appendix 4: Shear and Overturning Plots MCE Level (Buildings 1B and 1C)
Appendix 5: Coupling Beam Rotations MCE Level (Buildings 1B and 1C)
Appendix 6: Compression and Tension Strains MCE Level (Buildings 1B and 1C)
Appendix 7: Wall Panel Shear MCE Level (Buildings 1B and 1C)

A n a l y s i s a n d D e s i g n Fi n a l R e p o r t

Table of Contents
iii

Building 1 Core Wall Only Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

P R O J E C T D E S C R I P T IO N
Magnusson Klemencic Associates (MKA) performed the structural design for a sample building on behalf
of the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER) as part of the Tall Buildings Initiative (TBI).
The research project is done on behalf of the California Seismic Safety Commission (CSSC) and the
California Office of Emergency Services. The goal of the overall research project is to quantify and
compare seismic performance and expected losses of three hypothetical, yet realistic, tall buildings in
California.
The building designed by MKA consists of a representative structure with concrete core walls alone
serving as the lateral system. The building is located in Los Angeles, California, and is a 42-story hotel.
For the purposes of reporting, the building designed by MKA is called Building 1.
Three different designs for Building 1 were performed, as summarized below:

Building 1A: Prescriptive provisions of the IBC. All prescriptive provisions of the building code,
the 2006 edition of the International Building Code (IBC), were observed with one exception: the
height limit. Capacity design principles were not employed. A non-linear model of the resulting
design was created; however, a Non-Linear Response History Analysis (NLRHA) was not performed.
Building 1B: Performance-based design per LATBSDC criteria. A performance-based design
(PBD) was performed according to the 2008 edition of the seismic design criteria published by the
Los Angeles Tall Buildings Structural Design Council (LATBSDC), with the following exceptions:
The serviceability analysis considered an earthquake event with a 25-year mean recurrence
interval (MRI) and 2.5 percent viscous damping. Less than 20 percent of the ductile elements
were allowed to reach 150 percent of their capacity in the serviceability analysis.
The minimum base shear specified in the LATBSDC document was waived. The serviceability
earthquake in conjunction with design for wind forces determined the minimum strength of the
lateral system.

Building 1C: Higher seismic hazard PBD per PEER guidelines. A performance-based design
was performed similar to Building 1B but in accordance with the draft Guidelines for Seismic Design
of Tall Buildings dated August 4, 2009, as developed by the PEER under its TBI. For this design the
serviceability analysis considered an earthquake event with a 43-year MRI and 2.5 percent viscous
damping. All ductile elements were allowed to reach 150 percent of their capacity in the
serviceability analysis.

The seismological data (response spectra and earthquake records) for use in the design of the project
were provided by Mactec. Three sets of earthquake records were provided by Mactec:

Original Records: Used to complete the design of Building 1B.


Revised Records: Used to complete the design of Building 1C. The results in this report for
Building 1B also consider the revised records. However, the design for Building 1B was not updated.
Service-Level Records: Not used in MKA's design.

Analysis and Design Final Report


1

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Conceptual images of Building 1 are shown in Figures 1 through 5.

Figure 1. Building 1 Foundation Plan

Analysis and Design Final Report


2

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 2. Building 1 Tower Plan

Analysis and Design Final Report


3

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 3. Building 1 Tower Isometric

Analysis and Design Final Report


4

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 4. Building 1 Core Wall Elevations

Analysis and Design Final Report


5

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 5. Building 1 Core Wall Isometric

Analysis and Design Final Report


6

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

ANALYSIS AND DESIGN COMPARISON OVERVIEW


Since the results of the three designs will be compared, it is important to note the differences in design
approach taken for each of the three buildings. Comparison studies performed by others may not
provide the expected results. The shaded cells in Table 1 highlight the primary differences between the
three designs.

Table 1. Analysis and Design Approach Comparison

Topic

Building 1A
Prescriptive Code Design

Building 1B
LATBSDC PBD Design

Building 1C
PEER TBI PBD Design

Minimum
Strength

0.060 * 85% = 0.051W


(ASCE Equation 12.8-6)

25-year MRI, 2.5% damped


serviceability spectrum

43-year MRI, 2.5% damped


serviceability spectrum

Elastic
Computer
Model

Model of
Below-Grade
Structure

Specified material
properties
Gravity system not included
Stiffness assumptions
assume cracking at
DBE level ("more cracked"
model)

Model extends to foundation


mat including basement walls
and below-grade slabs. Mass
and mass moment-of-inertia
are included in the model.
Lateral resistance of the soil on
the foundation walls is
neglected.

Expected material
properties
Gravity system included
Stiffness assumptions
assume cracking at Service
level ("less cracked" model)

Model extends to foundation


mat including basement walls
and below-grade slabs. Mass
and mass moment-of-inertia
are included in the model.
Lateral resistance of the soil on
the foundation walls is
neglected.

Expected material
properties
Gravity system included
Stiffness assumptions
assume cracking at
Service level ("less
cracked" model)

Model extends to foundation


mat including basement walls
and below-grade slabs. Mass
and mass moment-of-inertia
are not included in the model.
Lateral resistance of the soil
on the foundation walls is
neglected.

Analysis and Design Final Report


7

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Topic

Building 1A
Prescriptive Code Design

Procedure
Used to
Provide Initial
Design of
Elements

Design followed the prescriptive


provisions of the building code
including the use of strength
reduction factors and specified
material properties.

Building 1B
LATBSDC PBD Design

Story drift limited to 0.5%


Coupling beams were
designed using specified
material strengths and
strength reduction factors in
accordance with material
codes. No more than 20%
of the beams are allowed
to have a demand-capacity
ratio greater than 1.0 but
less than 1.5.

Building 1C
PEER TBI PBD Design

Core wall shear and flexure


were designed using
specified material strengths
and strength reduction
factors in accordance with
material codes. All
demand-capacity ratios less
are than 1.0.

Story drift limited to 0.5%


Coupling beams were
designed using expected
material strengths and
strength reduction factors
set to unity. 100% of the
beams are allowed to
have a demand-capacity
ratio greater than 1.0 but
less than 1.5.
Core wall shear was
designed using specified
material strengths and
strength reduction factors
in accordance with
material codes. All
demand-capacity ratios
are less than 1.0.
For core wall flexure,
where the axial load on a
wall pier including EQ
effect (Pu) is less than or
equal to 0.3(f'c) using
expected material props,
P-M-M interaction design
considered expected
material strengths and
strength reduction factors
set to unity. The wall
piers were allowed to
have a demand-capacity
ratio greater than 1.0 but
less than 1.5. Where Pu
was greater than 0.3(f'c),
P-M-M interaction design
considered specified
material strengths and
strength reduction factors
in accordance with
material codes. All
demand-capacity ratios
were less than 1.0.

Analysis and Design Final Report


8

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Building 1A
Prescriptive Code Design

Building 1B
LATBSDC PBD Design

Building 1C
PEER TBI PBD Design

Non-Linear
Computer
Model

Model created using similar


techniques to Building 1B.
Model includes gravity system
approximation.

Non-linear model created as


summarized in MKA's
Non-Linear Response History
Analysis Model Report.

Model created using similar


techniques to Building 1B with
updated element properties
based on the design of
Building 1C.

MCE-Level
Hazard

MCE-level checks were not


performed.

Seven earthquake records


(original records) were used.
The revised records were
evaluated, but the design was
not updated for the new results.

Seven earthquake records


(revised records) were used.

MCE-Level
Checks

MCE-level checks were not


performed.

Topic

Ductile Actions and Drift:


Mean demands were used.
Capacities were calculated
using expected material
properties and strength
reduction factors set to
unity.
Brittle Actions: 1.5 times
the mean demands were
used. Capacities were
calculated using specified
material properties and
strength reduction factors
set to unity.

Ductile Actions and


Drift: Mean demands
were used. Capacities
were calculated using
expected material
properties and strength
reduction factors set to
unity.
Brittle Actions:
1.5 times the mean
demands were used.
Capacities were
calculated using specified
material properties and
strength reduction factors
set to unity.

B UI L D I N G C O D E S
The following building and material codes were used for the design:

BUILDING CODE

International Building Code, 2006 Edition (IBC 2006) with reference to Minimum Design Loads for
Buildings and Other Structures by the American Society of Civil Engineers, 2005 Edition (ASCE 7).
Alternative Seismic Design Criteria published by the Los Angeles Tall Buildings Structural Design
Council (LATBSDC), 2008 Edition.
Guidelines for Seismic Design of Tall Buildings developed by the Pacific Earthquake Engineering
Research Center under its Tall Buildings Initiative, March 21, 2009 draft with August 4, 2009 updates.

Analysis and Design Final Report


9

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

MATERIAL CODES

Reinforced Concrete: Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary by the
American Concrete Institute, 2008 Edition (ACI 318).

LOADING CRITERIA
A summary of the project-specific loading criteria follows.

GRAVITY LOADING
The gravity loads listed in Table 2 are in addition to the self weight of the structure. The minimum
loading requirements were taken from Table 4-1 of ASCE 7 as well as the loading criteria supplied by
PEER. Live loads were reduced where permitted in accordance with Section 4.8 of ASCE 7. Loads are
given in pounds per square foot (psf).

Table 2. Gravity Loads

Use

Live Loading

Superimposed
Dead Loading

Parking Garage

40 (not reduced)

Level 1 Retail (under tower footprint)

100 (not reduced)

110

Level 1 Plaza (outside tower footprint)

100 (not reduced)

350

Exit Areas (assumed inside core walls only)

100 (not reduced)

28

Residential/Hotel (used for all elevated


levels of the tower outside the core walls)

40

28

Mechanical/Electrical

100 kips at roof level only

Roof

25

28

In addition to these uniform slab loads, a perimeter dead load as shown in Table 3 was applied to the
structure to account for the weight of the cladding system.

Table 3. Cladding Loads

Load Type

Load (psf)

Exterior Cladding (curtain wall)

15 psf (wall area)

Analysis and Design Final Report


10

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

WIND DESIGN CRITERIA


Wind loading is in accordance with the ASCE 7 requirements as shown in Table 4. It was determined
that wind did not govern any portion of the design of Building 1.

Table 4. Wind Design Criteria

Parameter

Value

Basic Wind Speed, 3-second gust (V)

85 mph

Basic Wind Speed, 3-second gust (V), for serviceability wind


demands based on a 10-year mean recurrence interval

67 mph

Exposure

Occupancy Category

II

Importance Factor (Iw)

1.0

Topographic Factor (Kzt)

1.0

Enclosure Classification

Enclosed

Internal Pressure Coefficient (GCpi)

0.18

Mean Roof Height (h)

409'-10"

Analysis and Design Final Report


11

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

SEISMIC DESIGN CRITERIA


Seismic loads are in accordance with the ASCE 7 requirements as shown in Table 5. These code values
were used only in the design of Building 1A.

Table 5. Seismic Design Criteria Used for Building 1A Only

Parameter

Value

Building Latitude/Longitude

34.0495 N, 118.252 W

Occupancy Category

II

Importance Factor (Ie)

1.0

Mapped Spectral Acceleration

Ss = 2.147; S1 = 0.720

Site Class

Site Class Coefficients

Fa = 1.00; Fv = 1.30

Spectral Response Coefficients

SDS = 1.145; SD1 = 0.521

Seismic Design Category

Lateral System

Building Frame, Special Reinforced Concrete Shear Walls

Response Modification Coefficient (R)

Building Period (Tcode), Section 12.8.2

Tcode = 2.55 seconds (Based on H= 409'-10")

Cs (Equation 12.8-2)
Csmax (Equation 12.8-3)
Csmin (Equation 12.8-5, including

ASCE 7 supplement 2)

Csmin (Equation 12.8-6)

Cs =

S DS
= 0.19
(R / I )

Csmax =

SD1
= 0.034
T code (R / I )

Csmin = 0.044S DS I = 0.050


Csmin =

0.5S 1
= 0.060 governs
R /I

Seismic Response Coefficient

Cs = 0.060

Seismic Weight, weight above Level 1

W = 89,500 kips

Design Base Shear

V = 0.85C sW = 0.051W = 4,565kips

Analysis Procedure Used

Modal Analysis Procedure

Analysis and Design Final Report


12

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

SEISMIC RESPONSE SPECTRA AND GROUND MOTIONS FOR NON-LINEAR RESPONSE HISTORY ANALYSIS (NLRHA)
Seismic response spectra and seven pairs of site-specific ground motions were provided by Mactec for
this study. All spectra provided are at the ground surface level. Ground motions were provided as freefield motions (i.e., at the ground surface) and were spectrally matched to the Maximum Considered
Earthquake (MCE) spectrum. All spectra and ground motions were applied to the lateral models at the
level of the mat foundation.
The design spectra for the project, generated using the provisions of ASCE 7 -05, Section 21.3, are
shown in Figure 6.

Figure 6. Design Spectra

Analysis and Design Final Report


13

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

MATERIALS
The material properties used for the design are summarized in Tables 6 through 8. The modulus of
elasticity for concrete was calculated using Equation 5-1 of ACI 363.

Table 6. Concrete Properties, Compressive Strength, and Modulus of Elasticity

Member

Nominal f'c

Expected f'c

Nominal E

Expected E

Basement Walls

5.0 ksi

6.5 ksi

3,830 ksi

4,225 ksi

Foundation Mats

6.0 ksi

7.8 ksi

4,100 ksi

4,530 ksi

Non-Post-Tensioned Beams and Slabs

5.5 ksi

7.2 ksi

3,970 ksi

4,395 ksi

Post-Tensioned Floor Slabs

5.5 ksi

7.2 ksi

3,970 ksi

4,395 ksi

Columns

8.0 ksi

10.4 ksi

4,580 ksi

5,080 ksi

Shear Walls

8.0 ksi

10.4 ksi

4,580 ksi

5,080 ksi

Table 7. Reinforcement and Post-Tensioning Properties

Standard

Nominal fy

Expected fy

Expected fu

ASTM A615 Grade 60

60 ksi (non-seismic)

N/A

N/A

ASTM A706 Grade 60

60 ksi (seismic)

70 ksi

105 ksi

ASTM A615 Grade 75

75 ksi (used in coupling beams)

85 ksi

130 ksi

Table 8. Post-Tensioned Tendon Properties

Standard

Nominal fu

Expected fu

0.5-inch-diameter, 7-wire strand

fpu = 270 ksi

N/A

Analysis and Design Final Report


14

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

DESIGN AND ANALYSIS SOFTWARE


The computer software employed for the analysis of the structure is listed in Table 9.

Table 9. Design and Analysis Software

Structural Analysis

Computer Software

Elastic Response Spectrum Analysis

ETABS, version 9

Non-linear Response History Analysis

CSI Perform-3D, version 4

Concrete Core Wall Flexural Design

PCA Column, version 4

Concrete Core Wall Moment Curvature Analysis

UC Fyber, version 2.4

Post-tensioned Slab Analysis

Ram-Concept, version 2.1

Reinforced Concrete Slab Analysis

SAFE, version 8

Analysis and Design Final Report


15

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

LOAD COMBINATIONS
BUILDING 1A LOAD COMBINATIONS
The design basis event was analyzed with modal response spectrum analysis. The load combinations
shown in Table 10 follow the strength design load combinations listed in ASCE 7, Section 12.4.2.3.

Table 10. DBE Load Combinations

Identifier

Load Combinations

Load Combination 1

(1.2+0.2SDS)D QE + f1L

Load Combination 2

(0.9-0.2SDS)D QE

Where: D = dead load


L = reduced live load
f1 = 0.5 per ASCE 7, Section 12.4.2.3, Note 1
= the redundancy factor
0.2SDSD = Ev per ASCE 7, Section 12.4.2.2
QE = Eh per ASCE 7, Section 12.4.2.1
Seismic directional effects were considered as follows:

QEX = 1.0 Ehx 0.3 Ehy Thx

QEY = 0.3 Ehx 1.0 Ehy Thy


Where: Ehx and Ehy = earthquake forces in the primary structural directions, determined by spectral
analysis
Thx and Thy = accidental torsion per ASCE 7, Section 12.8.4.2 (forces in X and Y
directions, respectively)

Analysis and Design Final Report


16

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

BUILDING 1B AND 1C SERVICEABILITY LOAD COMBINATION


The serviceability event was analyzed using a modal response spectrum analysis. Accidental torsion was
not considered in this analysis, and one load combination was used, as shown in Table 11.

Table 11. Serviceability Load Combination

Identifier

Load Combination

Load Combination

1.0D + 0.25L 1.0Eservice

Where: D = dead load


L = unreduced live load
Eservice = serviceability response spectrum
Seismic directional effects were considered as follows:

Eservice = 1.0 Eservice_x 0.3 Eservice_y and 0.3 Eservice_x 1.0 Eservice_y

BUILDING 1B AND 1C MCE LOAD COMBINATIONS


The NLRHA utilized one load combination for the MCE event, as shown in Table 12. This load
combination was used for each of the seven ground motion records. Accidental torsion was not
considered in this analysis.

Table 12. NLRHA Load Combination

Identifier

Load Combination

Load Combination

1.0D + 0.25L +1.0E

Where: D = dead load


L = unreduced live load
E = earthquake load (ground motion records)
The ground motion records consist of two
components. The components were not
rotated to match the building axes.

Analysis and Design Final Report


17

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

L A T E R A L M O D E L S UM M A R Y
ELASTIC MODELS
Complete, three-dimensional elastic computer models for each building were analyzed using ETABS.
The models included the core walls, ground-level diaphragm, below-grade diaphragms, and basement
walls. The diaphragms and walls were modeled using shell elements. The coupling beams were
modeled using frame elements. Openings through the core walls were modeled with separate wall
elements coupled together with concrete beams.
The elastic model was used for both the code-level design of Building 1A and the serviceability analysis
of Buildings 1B and 1C. The stiffness parameters for the various elements were varied in each of the
models. Table 13 summarizes the stiffness assumptions in the computer models.
For the serviceability analyses only, slab outrigger effects were modeled using wide, shallow beams
connecting the core walls to lumped concrete columns in the ETABS model. The modeling approach
used for the slab outrigger beams is shown in Figure 7.

Figure 7. Slab Outrigger Modeling Approach

Analysis and Design Final Report


18

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Stiffness
The stiffness assumptions used vary for each computer model based on the expected demand level.
A summary of stiffness assumptions is shown in Table 13.

Table 13. Computer Model Stiffness Assumptions

Concrete Element

Serviceability Analysis
and Wind
All Buildings

MCE-Level
Code-Level Analysis Non-Linear Models
Building 1A Only
All Buildings

Specified vs. Expected


Concrete Strength

Expected concrete
strength

Specified concrete
strength

Expected concrete
strength

Core Walls/Shear Walls

Flexural 0.9Ig
Shear 1.0A

Flexural 0.6Ig
Shear 1.0A

Refer to non-linear
model summary

Basement Walls

Flexural 1.0Ig
Shear 1.0A

Flexural 0.8Ig
Shear 0.8A

Flexural 0.8Ig
Shear 0.8A

Coupling Beams

Flexural 0.5Ig
Shear 1.0A

Flexural 0.2Ig
Shear 1.0A

Refer to non-linear
model summary

Ground Level Diaphragm

Flexural 0.5Ig
Shear 0.8A

Flexural 0.25Ig
Shear 0.5A

Flexural 0.25Ig
Shear 0.25A

Basement Diaphragms

Flexural 0.5Ig
Shear 0.8A

Flexural 0.25Ig
Shear 0.5A

Flexural 0.25Ig
Shear 0.25A

Concrete Columns

Flexural 1.0Ig
Shear 1.0A
Axial 1.0A

Not included in
code design

Refer to non-linear
model summary

Outrigger Slabs

Flexural 0.35Ig
Shear 1.0A

Not included in
code design

Refer to non-linear
model summary

Soil Stru ctu re I n teraction Assu mption s


Design spectra were applied to all computer models at the level of the top of the mat foundation. The
flexibility of the subgrade and mat foundation was ignored, and the model was "fixed" at the top of the
mat. Vertical and horizontal supports with no rotational restraints were assigned to all of the nodes of
the model at the foundation level. The lateral resistance and damping effects of the soil on the sides of
the basement walls were neglected in all models.

Analysis and Design Final Report


19

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

NON-LINEAR MODELS
Non-linear verification models were built in CSI Perform-3D for each building. The models include
inelastic member properties for elements that are anticipated to be loaded beyond their elastic limits.
These include the coupling beams, core wall flexural behavior, and "slab-beams" to account for any
outriggering effect of the flat slabs. Elements that are assumed to remain elastic were modeled with
elastic member properties. These include core wall shear behavior, diaphragm slabs, columns, and
basement walls.
A detailed description of the non-linear modeling assumptions is included in a separate report entitled
"Non-Linear Response History Analysis Model Report".

ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
Acceptance criteria were required for the performance-based designs of Buildings 1B and 1C. The
acceptance criteria for each of the two demand levels evaluated are listed in Tables 14 and 15.

SERVICEABILITY ANALYSIS
Table 14. Serviceability Acceptance Criteria

Item

Value

Story Drift

0.5%

Coupling Beams

Shear strength to remain essentially elastic

Core Wall Flexure

Remains essentially elastic

Core Wall Shear

Remains elastic

Slab Outrigger Beams

End moment to remain essentially elastic

Columns

Remains elastic

Acceptance criteria related to essentially elastic behavior for ductile elements in Buildings 1B and 1C
were slightly different. A comparison can be found in Table 1 of this report.

Analysis and Design Final Report


20

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

NLRHA ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA


The following acceptance criteria were selected for Collapse Prevention performance under the
MCE-level demand.

Table 15. NLRHA Acceptance Criteria

Item

Value

Story Drift

3% under MCE, taken as the average of seven response


history results.

Coupling Beam Rotation

0.06 radian rotation limit, taken as the average of seven


response history results.

Core Wall Reinforcement


Axial Strain

Rebar tensile strain = 0.05 in tension and 0.02 in


compression, taken as the average of seven response
history results.

Core Wall Concrete


Axial Strain

Fully Confined Concrete Compression Strain = 0.015,


taken as the average of seven response history results.

Core Wall Shear

Verification performed for elastic behavior.

Slab Outrigger Beams

Included to study impact to core and column only.


The performance of the moment hinges was not specifically
reviewed.

Columns

Increases in column axial demands were reviewed.

The MCE-level acceptance criteria are summarized below:

Ductile Actions and Drift: Mean demands were used. Capacity was calculated using expected
material properties and strength reduction factors set to 1.0.
Brittle Actions: 1.5 times the mean demands were used. Capacity was calculated using specified
material strengths and strength reduction factors set to 1.0.

Analysis and Design Final Report


21

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

D E S I G N S UM M A R Y
BUILDING 1
The gravity column sizes determined for all three buildings are summarized in Table 16. While rectangular
columns would be expected in this type of building, square columns were selected for simplicity.

Table 16. Column Sizes

Column Mark

Levels

Size

D/3.5

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
21"21"
25"25"
30"30"

D/5

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
19"19"
24"24"
29"29"

D/6

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
18"18"
18"18"
24"24"

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
22"22"
26"26"
33"33"

E/6

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
18"18"
19"19"
26"26"

F/4

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
21"21"
26"26"
34"34"

F/5

Level 34 Roof
Level 22 34
Level 12 22
Fdn Level 12

18"18"
18"18"
21"21"
28"28"

E/5

Column Marks

D/3.5

F/4

D/5

D/6

E/5

E/6

F/5

Analysis and Design Final Report


22

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

DESIGN COMPARISON RESULTS


Key values from the design and selected element sizes are included in Table 17.

Table 17. Building 1 Comparison Results

Building 1A

Building 1B

Building 1C

Code/Service EQ Base
Shear (kips)

Vx = 4,581 (code)
Vy = 4,581

Vx = 5,013 (service EQ)


Vy = 6,018

Vx = 6,686 (service EQ)


Vy = 8,151

Code/Service EQ
Overturning Moment
(kip-ft)

My = 587,000 (code)
Mx = 697,000

My = 591,000 (service EQ)


Mx = 921,000

My = 892,000 (service EQ)


Mx =1,371,000

MCE Base Shear (kips)


Average of 7 EQs

VX = 13,718
VY = 13,899

VX = 13,025
VY = 12,449

MCE Overturning
Moment (kip-ft)
Average of 7 EQs

MY = 1,629,000
MX = 1,227,000

MY = 1,504,000
MX = 1,221,000

Core Wall Thicknesses


(inches)

Grade Lvl 25: 24


Lvl 25 Roof: 21

Grade Lvl 13: 28 (E-W)


32 (N-S)
Lvl 13 Lvl 31: 24
Lvl 31 Roof: 21

Grade Lvl 13: 32 (E-W)


36 (N-S)
Lvl 13 Lvl 31: 24
Lvl 31 Roof: 21

Period (seconds) in
ETABS Model

T1 = 6.7
T2 = 4.8
TT = 2.6

T1 = 4.0
T2 = 3.0
TT = 1.5

T1 = 4.0
T2 = 3.0
TT = 1.5

Period (seconds) in
Perform3D Model

T1 = 5.0
T2 = 3.8
TT = 2.4

T1 = 4.2
T2 = 3.4
TT = 2.3

T1 = 4.0
T2 = 3.2
TT = 2.2

Maximum Story Drift


(Service)

X = 0.25%
Y = 0.20%

X = 0.35%
Y = 0.28%

Maximum Story Drift


(MCE)

X = 1.1%
Y = 0.8%
Ref: Section 12.8.6

X = 2.0%
Y = 1.3%
Average of 7 EQs

X = 1.8%
Y = 1.1%
Average of 7 EQs

Figures 8 and 9 compare the shear and overturning moment demands on the three buildings.

Analysis and Design Final Report


23

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 8. Core Wall Shear Force Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
24

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 9. Core Wall Overturning Moment Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
25

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

The design of the coupling beams varied the most between the three different analyses. Figures 10 to
12 compare the rebar selected for each design.

Figure 10. Coupling Beam Reinforcement Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


26

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 11. Coupling Beam Reinforcement Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


27

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 12. Coupling Beam Reinforcement Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


28

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Comparisons of the vertical and horizontal reinforcing distributions that resulted from the three designs
are illustrated in Figures 13 through 20.

Figure 13. Wall Vertical Reinforcing Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
29

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 14. Wall Vertical Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


30

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 15. Wall Vertical Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


31

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 16. Wall Horizontal Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


32

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 17. Wall Horizontal Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


33

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 18. Wall Horizontal Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


34

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 19. Wall Horizontal Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


35

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 20. Wall Horizontal Reinforcing Comparison

Analysis and Design Final Report


36

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 21. MCE Core Wall Shear Force Comparison

Figures 21 and 22 compare the MCE shear force and overturning moment demands for Buildings 1B
and 1C.

Analysis and Design Final Report


37

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 22. MCE Core Wall Overturning Moment Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
38

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 23. MCE Story Drift Comparison

Figure 23 compares the calculated MCE drifts for Buildings 1B and 1C.

Analysis and Design Final Report


39

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 24. MCE Coupling Beam Rotation Comparison

Figures 24 to 26 compare the MCE coupling beam rotations for Buildings 1B and 1C.

Analysis and Design Final Report


40

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 25. MCE Coupling Beam Rotation Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
41

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Figure 26. MCE Coupling Beam Rotation Comparison


Analysis and Design Final Report
42

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

The appendices to this report contain more detailed information related to the design and verification
analyses performed on the three buildings.

Appendix

Title

Buildings

Rebar Design Drawings

1A, 1B, and 1C

Coupling Beam Design Charts

1A, 1B, and 1C

Drift Plots MCE Level

1B and 1C

Shear and Overturning Plots MCE Level

1B and 1C

Coupling Beam Rotations MCE Level

1B and 1C

Compression and Tension Strains MCE Level

1B and 1C

Wall Panel Shear MCE Level

1B and 1C

O B S E R V A T I O N S A N D C O N C L US I O N S
The following observations are made regarding the comparison of the three designs.

Core wall shear is the prevailing design parameter and governs the determination of wall thickness
for all of the designs. The thickest walls were required for Building 1C, and the thinnest walls were
required for Building 1A.
While MCE-level checks were not performed on Building 1A, wall shear demands are expected to
be well above the provided capacity and may lead to an increased likelihood of collapse when
compared to Buildings 1B and 1C. The provided shear reinforcing only meets the demands
required by the building code without consideration of the flexural strength of the core walls.
Serviceability-level demands for Building 1C were approximately 40 percent greater than those for
Building 1B due to the increase in seismic hazard (43-year MRI versus 25-year MRI). Wind
demands were not a controlling parameter in any of the designs.
Coupling beam reinforcement is smallest for Building 1C even though it has the largest calculated
coupling beam demands under the serviceability analysis. The reinforcement selected for the
coupling beams for Buildings 1A and 1B is approximately the same.
The provided vertical wall reinforcement is greatest for Building 1C and smallest for Building 1A.
This would indicate that Building 1C exhibits greater strong pier/weak coupling beam behavior than
do the other two designs.

Analysis and Design Final Report


43

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

Regarding the performance of Buildings 1B and 1C under MCE-level demands, the following
observations are made:

The average inter-story drifts fall below the acceptance criteria of 3 percent for both buildings. Drift
demands are slightly higher in Building 1B.
Coupling beam rotation demands are between 1 and 3 percent for Building 1C. Building 1B has
slightly lower demands of between 1 and 2 percent. For both buildings, coupling beam rotation
demands fall well below the acceptance criteria.
A preliminary assumption for areas of confined and unconfined concrete was needed in order to
build the non-linear model. The compression strain plots indicate that the concrete material used in
the core wall models remains elastic in compression for the full height of the tower. As a result, it
should be possible to reduce the amount of confinement initially assumed in the non-linear model.
This refinement was not employed for this case study.
At every level, the tensile strain demands meet the acceptance criteria. Small amounts of distributed
yielding are observed over nearly the full height of both buildings, with the largest tensile strains
occurring at the base of the core walls.
The revised earthquake records when applied to Building 1B lead to some of the wall panels being
slightly overstressed in shear. If this design were further developed, additional shear reinforcing
would need to be provided to address these localized areas of overstress. Based on the data from
the shear plot of Wall Pier 11, the thickness of the short walls of the core may also need to be
increased to limit shear stress to 10f'c.
Most of the wall panels for Building 1B were designed for roughly 3 to 3.5 times the shear force
calculated under the service-level analysis. The ratio for Building 1C is slightly lower, as design
values are two to three times the shear force calculated under the service-level analysis.
The wall thickness selected for Building 1C appears to be somewhat thicker than optimal. MCElevel wall pier shear demands fall below the code limit on shear stress, particularly in the lower
floors of the core. If this building were going to be constructed, MKA would likely iterate a few times
on the wall thickness to determine the optimal balance of concrete volume and rebar density.

Analysis and Design Final Report


44

"Building 1 Core Wall Only" Sample Design for PEER/CSSC, Los Angeles, California

APPENDIX 1
R E B A R D E S I G N D R AW I N G S
( B U I L D I N G S 1 A , 1 B, A N D 1 C )

A1-1

A1-2

A1-3

A1-4

A1-5

A1-6

A1-7

A1-8

A1-9

APPENDIX 2
COUPLING BEAM DESIGN CHARTS
( B U I L D I N G S 1 A , 1 B, A N D 1 C )

Building 1A

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 02

Roof

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 12

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof

81

L20

L15

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity
DCR

L05

L35
320

L30

280

240

429
432
434
438
442
447
452
456
457
455
448
466
483
512
531
541
540
540
540
540
540
528
453

200

L25

L20

160
L15
120

L10
Service EQ Demand

80

Provided Capacity
40

DCR

L05

372

-40

LB4
100

0.5

1.0

1.5

200

300

360

320

280

240

429
432
434
438
442
447
452
456
457
455
448
466
483
512
531
541
540
540
540
541
540
530
451

200

160

120

80

40

385

Ground

0.0

283
315
330
342
353
364
374
381
385
386
385
385
389
385
385

360

Story

Story

L25

L10

DCR

-0.5

400

L40

Elevation (ft)

L30

-1.0

224
283
315
330
342
353
364
373
381
385
386
385
385
389
385
385

L35

-1.5

164

224

L40

-2.0

81

400

164

-2.5

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-1

Building 1A

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 21
-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 33

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof 46

L40

L20

L15

L10

L05

L35
320

240

200

L15

L10
80

40

-40
300

400

L20

120

LB4
200

L25

160

100

L30

280

Ground

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

400

207
239
256
270
284
297
308
317
322
324
325
327
332
329
327
365
364
365
367
370
374
377
380
379
375
366
379
391
401
411
420
Service EQ Demand 428
433
Provided Capacity 434
430
DCR
416
389
340
266

360

Story

Story

L25

-1.0

220

Elevation (ft)

L30

-1.5

163

207
239
256
270
284
297
308
317
322
324
325
327
332
329
327
365
364
365
367
370
374
378
380
379
375
366
380
391
401
411
420
Service EQ Demand 428
434
Provided Capacity 435
431
DCR
417
390
340
267

L35

-2.0

Roof 46
400

221
163

L40

-2.5

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

L05

360

320

280

240

200

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

160

120

80

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-2

Building 1A

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 23

Roof

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 31

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof

127

L20

L15

L10

L05

Ground

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

400

L35
320

L30

280

240

200

L25

L20

160
L15
120

L10
80

40

331

L05

Ground

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

332

217

217

152

152

94

94

-40

LB4
0

DCR

-0.5

233
262
277
289
300
311
321
329
334
336
338
339
343
340
337
378
378
379
383
387
391
395
397
398
394
386
410
425
443
451
459
Service EQ Demand 461
461
Provided Capacity
461
460
DCR
461
461
452
382

360

Story

L25

Story

L40

Elevation (ft)

L30

-1.0

188

233
262
277
289
300
311
321
329
334
336
338
339
343
340
337
378
378
379
383
387
391
395
397
398
394
386
410
425
443
451
459
Service EQ Demand 461
460
Provided Capacity
461
460
DCR
461
461
452
381

L35

-1.5

131

188

L40

-2.0

127

400

131

-2.5

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1A - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-3

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 02
-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 12

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof 52

-2.5

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

400
188

L40

236
266
282
296
306
315
321
322
319
345
339
333
330
330
332
336
340
345
351
358
367
376
387
398
408
413
417

L30

L25

L20

L15

L35
320

L30

280

240

200

L25

Story

L35

236
266
282
296
306
315
321
322
319
345
340
333
330
330
332
336
340
345
351
358
367
376
387
398
408
413
417

360

Elevation (ft)

L40

L20

160
L15
120

519
530
539
555
574
592
608
619
618
601
549

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity
DCR

L05

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity

40

DCR

L05

478

-40

LB4
100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

519
530
539
555
573
592
608
618
617
602
544
492

L10
80

Ground

-1.0

139

188

Story

-1.5

Roof 52
400

139

L10

-2.0

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

80

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-4

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 21
-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 33

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof 43

L40

198
229
246
260
272
282
289
293
291
320
315
312
311
312
315
318
322
327
333
339
348
357
367
378
388
395
398

-1.0

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

L30

L25

L20

L15

L10
Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity
DCR

L35
320

L30

280

240

200

400
198
229
246
260
272
282
289
293
291
320
315
312
311
312
315
318
322
327
333
339
348
357
367
378
387
395
398

360

L25

Story

L35

L20

160
L15
120

455
463
475
490
505
519
531
538
537
522
478

L10
Service EQ Demand

80

Provided Capacity
40

DCR

L05

395

-40

LB4
100

200

300

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

455
462
475
489
504
519
530
537
535
519
477

80

40

394

Ground

-1.5

138
156

Elevation (ft)

L40

Story

-2.0

Roof 43
400

138
156

L05

-2.5

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-5

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 23

Roof

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 31

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof

105

L20

L15

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity
DCR

Ground

L35
320

L30

280

240

200

L25

L20

160
L15
120

476
486
500
517
535
553
571
585
593
589
566
503

L10

L05

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity

40

426

1.0

1.5

DCR

L05

Ground

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

428
276

198

199

125

125

-40

LB4
100

0.5

476
486
500
517
536
554
571
586
594
590
567
505

L10
80

275

0.0

211
240
256
269
279
289
296
300
298
328
324
321
319
320
322
326
330
336
342
349
358
368
379
390
401
410
414

360

Story

Story

L25

DCR

-0.5

400

L40

Elevation (ft)

L30

-1.0

171
211
240
256
269
279
289
296
300
298
329
324
321
319
320
322
326
330
336
342
349
358
368
379
390
401
409
414

L35

-1.5

121

171

L40

-2.0

105

400

121

-2.5

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-6

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 02

Roof

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 12

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

Roof

56

-2.5

L40
336
365
389
406
416
420
419
414
449
444
438
435
434
436
440
445
454
464
476
491
506
522
537
549
553
553

0.0

L25

L20

L15

L30

280

240

200

L25

L20

160
L15

DCR
L05

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

743
758
764
785
809
833
853
864
858
830
754

Provided Capacity

Provided Capacity

80

DCR

40

L05

649

-40

LB4
400

500

600

700

80

40

669

300

120

743
757
764
785
808
833
852
863
857
831
747

Service EQ Demand
L10

Ground

200

1.5

336
365
389
406
416
420
419
414
449
444
438
435
434
436
440
445
454
464
476
491
506
522
537
549
553
553

L35

Service EQ Demand

100

1.0

288

320

Story

L30

0.5

400

360

Elevation (ft)

L35

Story

DCR

-0.5

222
287

L10

-1.0

158

222

L40

-1.5

56

400

158

-2.0

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

800

900

1000

1100

1200

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-7

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Design Forces


-3.0

Roof

-2.5

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 33

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Roof

45

L40

L15

L35

240

L25

L20

160
L15

Provided Capacity
DCR

L05

Provided Capacity

80

DCR
L05

542

-40

LB4
100

200

300

400

500

600

1.0

1.5

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

80

40

540

Ground

0.5

659
661
673
690
710
728
743
750
745
720
658

Service EQ Demand
L10

40

0.0

400

120

660
662
673
691
711
729
744
752
748
723
659

Service EQ Demand
L10

L30

280

200

DCR

-0.5

287
316
341
360
374
383
386
384
424
419
418
418
420
423
428
434
442
452
463
476
490
504
518
529
534
528

320

Story

L20

-1.0

240

360

Elevation (ft)

L25

-1.5

45

L40
286
316
341
360
374
383
386
384
424
419
418
418
420
423
428
434
442
452
463
476
490
504
518
529
534
528

L30

-2.0

166
183

240

L35

-2.5

400

166
183

Story

-3.0

Elevation (ft)

CB 21

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

Ground

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-8

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Design Forces


CB 23
-2.5

Roof

-2.0

-1.5

-1.0

CB 31

DCR

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

-3.0

-2.5

Roof

116

L25

Story

1.0

1.5

L20

L15

L35

L30

280

240

200

L25

L20

160
L15

Service EQ Demand
Provided Capacity
DCR
L05

360

320

280

240

200

160

120

689
696
709
730
754
779
801
818
826
816
778
686

Ground

299
328
352
370
383
391
394
391
432
428
425
426
428
431
436
443
451
462
474
488
503
519
533
546
553
549

320

Story

L30

Provided Capacity

80

DCR

40

567

120

690
696
710
731
755
780
802
820
827
818
780
689

Service EQ Demand
L10

L05

Ground

80

40

570

343

345

225

226

129

129

-40

LB4
200

0.5

254

360

Elevation (ft)

L35

100

0.0

400

L40
299
328
352
370
383
391
394
391
432
428
425
426
428
431
436
443
451
462
474
488
503
518
533
546
552
548

DCR

-0.5

199
255

L10

-1.0

136

199

L40

-1.5

116

400

136

-2.0

Elevation (ft)

-3.0

Coupling Beam Design Forces

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

-40

LB4
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

1000

1100

1200

A2-9

APPENDIX 3
D R I F T P LOT S - M C E L E V E L
(BUILDINGS 1B AND 1C)

Building 1B

Building Maximum Interstory Drift

Building Maximum Interstory Drift

X Direction

Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160
L15

160
L15

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L10
80

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Landers, Yermo

Landers, Yermo
40

Kocaeli, Izmit

L05

Mean NLRHA Drift

3% Drift Limit

3% Drift Limit
0

Ground

-40

LB4
1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

40

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Drift

0.5%

80

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


L05

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

0.0%

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

3.0%

3.5%

4.0%

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0%

0.5%

1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

3.0%

Interstory Drift

Interstory Drift

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

3.5%

4.0%

A3-1

Building 1C

Building Maximum Interstory Drift

Building Maximum Interstory Drift

X Direction

Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160
L15

160
L15

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L10
80

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Landers, Yermo

Landers, Yermo
40

Kocaeli, Izmit

L05

Mean NLRHA Drift

3% Drift Limit

3% Drift Limit

Ground

LB4

-40
1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

40

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Drift

0.5%

80

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


L05

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

0.0%

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

3.0%

3.5%

4.0%

Ground

LB4
0.0%

-40
0.5%

1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

3.0%

Interstory Drift

Interstory Drift

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

3.5%

4.0%

A3-2

APPENDIX 4
S H E A R A N D O V E R T U R N I N G P LOT S MCE LEVEL
(BUILDINGS 1B AND 1C)

Building 1B

Accumulated Core Shear

Accumulated Core Shear

X Direction

Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L15

200

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test
Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L20

240

Elevation (ft)

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L30

280

L20

160
L15
120

L10

240

200

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

5,000

10,000

15,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

20,000

A4-1

Building 1C

Accumulated Core Shear

Accumulated Core Shear

Lateral Load in X Direction

Lateral Load in Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L15

200

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test
Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L20

240

Elevation (ft)

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L30

280

L20

160
L15
120

L10

240

200

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

5,000

10,000

15,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

20,000

A4-2

Building 1B

Overturning Moment

Overturning Moment

X Direction

Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L15

200

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test
Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L20

240

Elevation (ft)

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L30

280

L20

160
L15
120

L10

240

200

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

Moment (kip-feet)
PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

Moment (kip-feet)
PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

A4-3

Building 1C

Overturning Moment

Overturning Moment

Lateral Load in X Direction

Lateral Load in Y Direction

Roof

Roof
400

400
L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L15

200

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test
Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L20

240

Elevation (ft)

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn
Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha
Northridge, Sylmar Hosp
Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
Mean NLRHA Demand
Wind Demand
Service EQ Demand

L25

Story

L30

280

L20

160
L15
120

L10

240

200

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

Moment (kip-feet)
PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

Moment (kip-feet)
PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

A4-4

APPENDIX 5
C O U P L I N G B E A M R OTAT I O N S - M C E L E V E L
(BUILDINGS 1B AND 1C)

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 02

CB 12

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

280

L25

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

6% Rotation Limit

6% Rotation Limit

120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0%

240

Denali, Pump Station #9

Story

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-1

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 02

CB 12

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160
L15

160
L15

120

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10
80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


L05

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


40

Landers, Yermo

L05

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

Mean NLRHA Rotation


0

6% Rotation Limit

-40

LB4
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

40

Landers, Yermo

Kocaeli, Izmit
Ground

80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

0.0%

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

Ground

6% Rotation Limit

-40

LB4
0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-2

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 21

CB 33

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

280

L25

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

6% Rotation Limit

6% Rotation Limit

120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4
0.0%

240

Denali, Pump Station #9

Story

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4
0.0%

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-3

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 21

CB 33

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160
L15

160
L15

120

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10
80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


L05

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


40

Landers, Yermo

L05

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

Mean NLRHA Rotation


0

6% Rotation Limit

LB4

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

40

Landers, Yermo

Kocaeli, Izmit
Ground

80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

0.0%

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

Ground

6% Rotation Limit

LB4
0.0%

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-4

Building 1B

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 23

CB 31

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

280

L25

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

200

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L20

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

Mean NLRHA Rotation

L15

6% Rotation Limit

6% Rotation Limit

120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4
0.0%

240

Denali, Pump Station #9

Story

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-5

Building 1C

Coupling Beam Rotations

Coupling Beam Rotations

CB 23

CB 31

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160
L15

160
L15

120

120

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10

Denali, Pump Station #9

L10
80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


L05

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


40

Landers, Yermo

L05

Kocaeli, Izmit

Mean NLRHA Rotation

Mean NLRHA Rotation


0

6% Rotation Limit

LB4

-40
1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

40

Landers, Yermo

Kocaeli, Izmit
Ground

80

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

0.0%

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

Ground

6% Rotation Limit

-40

LB4
0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

Rotation

Rotation

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

6.0%

7.0%

A5-6

APPENDIX 6
COMPRESSION AND TENSION STRAINS MCE LEVEL
(BUILDINGS 1B AND 1C)

Building 1B

Core Wall Compression Strains

Core Wall Compression Strains

SW Corner

SE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400
L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30

320

L30

280

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9


240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


L15

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Story

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

240

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L25

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

L15
120

L05

40

-40

LB4
0.0000

L10
80

Ground

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

120

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

L10

0.0035

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9


L25

L05

Ground

40

LB4
0.0000

80

-40
0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

Compressive Strain

Compressive Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.0030

0.0035

A6-1

Building 1C

Core Wall Compression Strains

Core Wall Compression Strains

SW Corner

SE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400
L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30

320

L30

280

280
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9


240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


L15

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Story

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

240

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L25

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

L15
120

L05

40

-40

LB4
0.0000

L10
80

Ground

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

120

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

L10

0.0035

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9


L25

L05

Ground

40

LB4
0.0000

80

-40
0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

Compressive Strain

Compressive Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.0030

0.0035

A6-2

Building 1B

Core Wall Compression Strains

Core Wall Compression Strains

NW Corner

NE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30

320

L30

280

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


L15

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Story

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

240

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L25

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

L15
120

L05

40

-40

LB4
0.0000

L10
80

Ground

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

120

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

L10

0.0035

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9


L25

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0000

80

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

Compressive Strain

Compressive Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.0030

0.0035

A6-3

Building 1C

Core Wall Compression Strains

Core Wall Compression Strains

NW Corner

NE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30

320

L30

280

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


Denali, Pump Station #9
240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

200

Landers, Yermo

L20

Kocaeli, Izmit

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


L15

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Story

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

240

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

L25

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

160

Mean NLRHA Strain


Unconfined Concrete crushing strain

L15
120

L05

40

-40

LB4
0.0000

L10
80

Ground

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

120

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

Confined Concrete
crusing strain = 0.015

L10

0.0035

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9


L25

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0.0000

80

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

Compressive Strain

Compressive Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.0030

0.0035

A6-4

Building 1B

Core Wall Tensile Strains

Core Wall Tensile Strains

SW Corner

SE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160

160

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Denali, Pump Station #9

120

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha


L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

80

Kocaeli, Izmit

Kocaeli, Izmit
40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Ground

L05

Ground

0
Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050

-40
0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

0.014

40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050


LB4
0.004

80

Landers, Yermo

L05

0.002

120

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Landers, Yermo

0.000

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

0.016

LB4
0.000

-40
0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

Tensile Strain

Tensile Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.014

0.016

A6-5

Building 1C

Core Wall Tensile Strains

Core Wall Tensile Strains

SW Corner

SE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160

160

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Denali, Pump Station #9

120

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha


L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

80

Kocaeli, Izmit

Kocaeli, Izmit
40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Ground

L05

Ground

0
Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050

-40
0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

0.014

40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050


LB4
0.004

80

Landers, Yermo

L05

0.002

120

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Landers, Yermo

0.000

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

0.016

LB4
0.000

-40
0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

Tensile Strain

Tensile Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.014

0.016

A6-6

Building 1B

Core Wall Tensile Strains

Core Wall Tensile Strains

NW Corner

NE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160

160

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Denali, Pump Station #9

120

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha


L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

80

Kocaeli, Izmit

Kocaeli, Izmit
40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Ground

L05

Ground
Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050

-40
0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

0.014

40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050


LB4
0.004

80

Landers, Yermo

L05

0.002

120

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Landers, Yermo

0.000

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

0.016

-40

LB4
0.000

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

Tensile Strain

Tensile Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.014

0.016

A6-7

Building 1C

Core Wall Tensile Strains

Core Wall Tensile Strains

NW Corner

NE Corner

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

240

Story

200
L20

280

240

L25

Elevation (ft)

L25

Story

L30

280

200
L20

160

160

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test


L15

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Denali, Pump Station #9

120

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha


L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

L10

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

80

Kocaeli, Izmit

Kocaeli, Izmit
40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Ground

L05

Ground
Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050

-40
0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

0.014

40

Mean NLRHA Strain

Tension Strrain Limit = 0.050


LB4
0.004

80

Landers, Yermo

L05

0.002

120

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Landers, Yermo

0.000

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

0.016

-40

LB4
0.000

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

Tensile Strain

Tensile Strain

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

0.014

0.016

A6-8

APPENDIX 7
WALL PANEL SHEAR - MCE LEVEL
(BUILDINGS 1B AND 1C)

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 01

Pier 13

Roof

Roof
400
L40

400
#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

L40

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers
360

360

L35

L35
#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

320

L30

L30

280

280
#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160
#5 @ 6" 3 Layers

#5 @ 6" 3 Layers
L15

L15
120

L10

120

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers

L10

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers
80

L05

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers

40

80

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers

L05

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers

#5 @ 6" 4 Layers
0

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500

1,000

1,500

40

2,000

2,500

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500

A7-1

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 01

Pier 13

Roof

Roof
400
L40

400
#5 @ 4" EF

L40

#5 @ 4" EF
360

360

L35

L35
#5 @ 4" EF

#5 @ 4" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280
#5 @ 4" EF

#5 @ 4" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#5 @ 4" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#5 @ 4" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160
#5 @ 4" EF

#5 @ 4" EF
L15

L15
120

#5 @ 4" EF

L10

#5 @ 4" EF

L10

120

80

L05

#5 @ 4" EF

40

80

#5 @ 4" EF

L05

#5 @ 4" 3 Layers

#5 @ 4" 3 Layers
0

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500

1,000

1,500

40

2,000

2,500

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500

A7-2

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 03

Pier 11

Roof

Roof
400

400

#8 @ 12" EF

L40

#8 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

Story

L20

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

240

L25

#7 @ 6" EF
L20

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)


Provided Capacity

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

#7 @ 6" EF

320

160

#7 @ 6" EF

#7 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#8 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#8 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#9 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

L05

#9 @ 6" EF

#8 @ 6" 3 Layers
Ground

#8 @ 6" 3 Layers
0

LB4

-40
0

40

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

Ground

-40

LB4
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

A7-3

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 03

Pier 11

Roof

Roof
400

400

#8 @ 12" EF

L40

L40

#8 @ 12" EF

360

360

L35

L35
#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#7 @ 6" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#7 @ 6" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#8 @ 6" EF

#8 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#8 @ 6" EF

L10

120

L10

#8 @ 6" EF

80

#9 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

L05

#9 @ 6" EF

#9 @ 6" 3 Layers
Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

40
#9 @ 6" 3 Layers
0

Ground

-40

LB4
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

A7-4

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 20

Pier 34

Roof

Roof
400

400

#6 @ 12" EF

L40

#6 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#7 @ 12" EF

#7 @ 12" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L15

L15
120

#6 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#6 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#7 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#7 @ 6" EF

L05

#8 @ 6" EF

#8 @ 6" EF

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

40

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-5

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 20

Pier 34

Roof

Roof
400

400

#6 @ 12" EF

L40

#6 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#7 @ 12" EF

#7 @ 12" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#7 @ 12" EF

#7 @ 12" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#7 @ 12" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#7 @ 12" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L15

L15
120

#8 @ 12" EF

L10

120

#8 @ 12" EF

L10
80

#6 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#6 @ 6" EF

L05

#8 @ 6" EF

#8 @ 6" EF

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

40

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-6

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 22

Pier 32

Roof

Roof
400

400

#7 @ 12" EF

L40

#7 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#6 @ 6" EF

#6 @ 6" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#6 @ 6" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#6 @ 6" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#7 @ 6" EF

#7 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#8 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#8 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#9 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#9 @ 6" EF

L05

#8 @ 6" 3 Layers
Ground

#8 @ 6" 3 Layers
0

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

40

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-7

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 22

Pier 32

Roof

Roof
400

400

#7 @ 12" EF

L40

#7 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#7 @ 6" EF

#7 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

#9 @ 6" EF

#9 @ 6" EF

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

40

7,000

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-8

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 24

Pier 30

Roof

Roof
400

400

#7 @ 12" EF

L40

#7 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#7 @ 6" EF

#7 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

#9 @ 6" EF

#9 @ 6" EF

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

40

6,000

7,000

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-9

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 24

Pier 30

Roof

Roof
400

400

#7 @ 12" EF

L40

#7 @ 12" EF

L40
360

360

L35

L35
#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

320

L30

L30

280

280

#8 @ 12" EF

#8 @ 12" EF

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

Story

Provided Capacity

Elevation (ft)

1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

240

L25
1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)

#8 @ 12" EF

Provided Capacity

L20

200

10f'c*Ac

160

Elevation (ft)

240

L25

Story

320

160

#7 @ 6" EF

#7 @ 6" EF

L15

L15
120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10

120

#7 @ 6" EF

L10
80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

40

80

#8 @ 6" EF

L05

#8 @ 6" EF

#8 @ 6" EF

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

40

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-10

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 01

Pier 13

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


240

Story

Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

Elevation (ft)

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500

A7-11

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 01

Pier 13

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Story

Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

240

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

2,500

A7-12

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 03

Pier 11

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9


Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


240

Story

Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

Elevation (ft)

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

A7-13

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 03

Pier 11

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Story

Landers, Yermo
Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

240

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

200

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

L30

320

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

80

L05

40

Ground

-40

LB4
0

1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

A7-14

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 20

Pier 34

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


240

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

Elevation (ft)

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-15

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 20

Pier 34

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

240

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-16

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 22

Pier 32

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


240

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

Elevation (ft)

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-17

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 22

Pier 32

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

240

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-18

Building 1B

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 24

Pier 30

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Denali, Pump Station #9

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


240

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

Elevation (ft)

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1B - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-19

Building 1C

Core Wall Shear

Core Wall Shear

Pier 24

Pier 30

Roof

Roof
400

400

L40

L40
360

360

L35

L35
320

L30
Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

320

L30

280

Superstition Hills, Parachute Test

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp

Story

Landers, Yermo
200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn

240

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

L25

240

Northridge, Sylmar Hosp


Landers, Yermo

Story

Loma Prieta, Saratoga Aloha

Elevation (ft)

Northridge, Sylmar Conv Stn


L25

280

Denali, Pump Station #9

200

Kocaeli, Izmit
L20

Mean NLRHA Shear


1.5*(Mean NLRHA Shear)
Service Earthquake Demand

160

10f'c*Ac

Elevation (ft)

Denali, Pump Station #9

160

10f'c*Ac

L15

L15
120

L10

120

L10
80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

80

L05

40

Ground

LB4

-40
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear (kips)

Shear (kips)

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

PEER TBI - Building 1C - Core Only Building for CSSC

7,000

8,000

A7-20

APPENDIX B: PEER/SSC Tall Buildings Design


Case Study #2

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

PEER/SSCTALLBUILDINGDESIGNCASESTUDY#2

TonyGhodsi
JoseA.FloresRuiz
ClaireMassie
YangboChen

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Table of Contents
1.0

Dual System Basis of Design................................................................................................................ 1

2.0

General Building Properties ................................................................................................................. 4


2.1 Stiffness Assumptions .................................................................................................................. 5

3.0

Building 2A - Analysis Summary ......................................................................................................... 6


3.1 Building 2A - Seismic Design ...................................................................................................... 6
3.2 Building 2A - Wind Design ........................................................................................................ 15

4.0

Building 2B - Analysis Summary ....................................................................................................... 16


4.1 Serviceability Analysis Seismic Force Determination ................................................................ 21
4.1.1

Service Level Design Acceptance Criteria ................................................................... 22

4.2 Collapse Prevention Step by Step Non-linear Analysis .............................................................. 25


4.2.1

Collapse Prevention Acceptance Criteria...................................................................... 26

4.2.2

Core Wall Modeling Properties .................................................................................... 27

4.2.3

Coupling Beam Modeling Properties ............................................................................ 33

4.2.4

Moment Frame Beam Properties .................................................................................. 37

4.2.5

Moment Frame Column Properties ............................................................................... 42

4.2.6

Slab Modeling at Ground Level and Below .................................................................. 44

4.2.7

Basement Wall Properties ............................................................................................. 46

4.2.8

Damping ....................................................................................................................... 47

4.3 Results from Non-linear Analyses .............................................................................................. 49


4.3.1

Overall Behavior ........................................................................................................... 49

4.3.2

Core Shear Wall ............................................................................................................ 52

4.3.3

Frame Behavior............................................................................................................. 61

4.3.4

Basement walls ............................................................................................................. 64

References .................................................................................................................................................... 65

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

1.0

Dual System Basis of Design

This report shows the results obtained from two design approaches of a building located in Los Angeles,
California, laterally braced by a concrete shear wall elevator core and two four-bay concrete special moment
resisting frames (SMRF) in each direction. The building consists of 42 stories and a penthouse above ground level
and four subterranean levels. For the purpose of this report, this building is referred to as Building 2.
The design was first based on a modal response spectrum analysis as prescribed by International Building
Code 2006 (ICC 2006). The building was then redesigned to satisfy the service level criteria, and then its
components were checked to comply with the collapse prevention criteria under the Maximum Considered Seismic
Event (MCE) as described in Los Angeles Tall Building Structural Design Council An Alternative Design
Approach for Tall Buildings (LATBSDC 2008) with the exceptions mentioned under the Building 2B Analysis
Summary section. The resulting structure with its components designed per IBC 2006 is referred to as Building 2A,
and the structure with its components designed and revised to comply with the service and MCE level of forces is
referred to as Building 2B.
In all cases the X direction of the building is parallel to letter-gridlines and the Y direction parallel to
number-gridlines as shown in Figure 3.

Figure 1 - Three dimensional rendering of structure from ETABS (2008) model

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 2 - Typical plan view at ground floor and below

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 3 - Typical plan view at level 2 and above

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

2.0

General Building Properties

Figures 2 and 3 show the typical plan view of the ground floor and below and of the second level and
above. Table 1 shows the general building properties.

Table 1 General Building Properties

Story Height

10.5 At levels below Ground


13.67 From ground to 2nd
10.5 Typical from 2nd to 42nd
11.5 Roof
20 Pent-house

Number of Stories

42 above ground plus Pent-house


4 below ground

Slab Construction

10 thick reinforced concrete at Basement levels


12 thick reinforced concrete at Ground floor
8 thick post-tensioned concrete typical above Ground
10 thick reinforced concrete at Roof

Coupling Beam Depth

30 Typical

Basement Shear Walls

16 thick, fc = 5ksi

Moment Frames

(2) 4-bay SMRF in each direction

In addition to the self-weight of the structure, the loads listed in Table 2 are used for the calculation of
superimposed dead and live loads.
Table 2 Load Criteria
Use

Location

Superimposed
dead load
(psf)

Live Load
(psf)

50 (Reducible)

110

100 (Non-Reducible)

Parking

4 stories below ground

Retail

Ground Level inside area

Cladding

Perimeter of tower

Outside Plaza
Corridors and Exit
Areas
Residential

Ground level outside area

350

100 (Non-Reducible)

Inside elevator core

28

100 (Non-Reducible)

2nd floor up to 42nd floor

28

40 (Reducible)

Mechanical

At roof floor only

100 kip

25 (Reducible)

Roof

Roof floor

28

20 (Reducible)

15 psf per elevation

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

2.1

Stiffness Assumptions

The stiffness assumptions are listed in Table 3. When non-linear behavior of elements is modeled, stiffness
modifiers are applied to the assumed elastic portion of the force-displacement relationship.

Table 3 - Stiffness Assumptions

Building 2A
Element

Building 2B

Code-Level
Analysis

Serviceability
Design

MCE
Level

Modulus of Elasticity A

Specified concrete
strength

Expected concrete
strengthB

Expected concrete
strength

Core Walls

Flexural 0.6 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.9 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural See note C


Shear 1.0 GAg

Basement Walls

Flexural 0.8 EIg


Shear 0.8 GAg

Flexural 1.0 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.8 EIg


Shear 0.8 GAg

Coupling Beams

Flexural 0.2 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.5 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.2 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Ground Level and Basement


slabs

Flexural 0.25 EIg


Shear 0.5 GAg

Flexural 0.5 EIg


Shear 0.8 GAg

Flexural 0.25 EIg


Shear 0.25 GAg

Moment Frame Beams

Flexural 0.35 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.7 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.35 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Moment Frame Columns

Flexural 0.7 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.9 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

Flexural 0.7 EIg


Shear 1.0 GAg

A.

Modulus of elasticity is based on the following equations:


for fc 6000 psi

E c = 57000 f c

Ec = 40000 f c + 1106
B.
C.

for fc > 6000 psi

(per ACI 363R-921)

Per Table 2 of LATBSDC (2008), the expected material strengths are 1.3 fc for concrete and 1.17 fy for reinforcing steel.
Core walls are modeled using fiber sections. is used, if the concrete doesnt crack, EI is close to 1.0 times the gross concrete
properties (It is slightly bigger because of the steel). As the strains on the fiber elements increase, the effective EI decreases.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

3.0

Building 2A - Analysis Summary

The design of Building 2A was performed in general compliance with the IBC 2006, which adopts the
ASCE 7 (2006) and ACI 318 (2008).
The specified core wall thickness and strength throughout the height are shown in Table 4. For SMRF
properties and for core wall reinforcing see Figures 4 through 7. Table 5 shows the periods of Building 2A using the
stiffness assumptions listed in Table 3.

Table 4 Building 2A Specified Core Wall Thickness and Strength

Thickness
Specified concrete strength
(fc)
Specified reinforcing strength
(fy)

24 from foundation to 20th


18 Above 20th
6000 psi from foundation to 20th
5000 psi Above 20th
60 ksi (A706)

Table 5 Building 2A Code Design Periods


Vibration
Mode
1
2
3

3.1

Period

Dominant direction

Mass participation

5.50 s
4.97 s
2.98 s

Translation mode on X direction


Translation mode on Y direction
Torsional mode

67 %
68 %
75 %

Building 2A - Seismic Design

A linear modal response spectrum analysis was used for the seismic design of Building 2A. The design
forces were obtained from a provided 5% damped site-specific response spectra scaled in accordance with ASCE 7
(2006), Chapter 21.
Table 6 summarizes the factors used for this analysis. A comparison between the prescribed code spectra
and the site-specific spectra is shown in Figure 8.
The model for Building 2A was created using the program ETABS (2008) including only the lateral force
resisting elements which were modeled with the stiffness modified to match Table 3. When modeling the structure,
concrete shear walls and SMRF are modeled from the foundation level to the penthouse and roof levels,
respectively. Soil-structure interaction is ignored and the lateral stiffness of gravity elements is not included.
The design of structural components was based only on the modal analyses results. No special effort other
than those prescribed by code was made to detail building 2A.
The representative plots for the design of building 2A are shown in Figures 9 through 13.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Table 6 - Linear Dynamic Site Specific Response Spectrum Analysis Parameters


Ss

1.725 g

S1

0.602 g

Fa

Fv

1.3

SMs

1.718 g

SM1

0.782 g

SDS

1.145 g

SD1

0.521 g

7.0

Site Class

Cd

5.5

Cs

0.051A

Seismic Weight (W)B

102000 kips

Modal combination method

Complete quadratic combination


(CQC)

Redundancy factor ()C


Accidental eccentricity

1.0
5%

Base shear V (See section 12.8)

5202 kipsC

Modal Base shear Vt (See section 12.9.2)

Vtx = 11436 / R = 1634 kips


Vty = 11760 / R = 1680 kips

Modal base shear scaled to match 0.85 V

0.85 x 5202 = 4421 kips

Notes:
A. Cs values for both cases are governed by equation 12.8-5 of ASCE 7-05 (2006) as shown in its supplement 2.
B. Seismic weight accounts for the dead load of 2nd level and above.
C. The structure complies with 12.3.4.2-b, the redundancy factor equals 1.
D. Per section 12.9.4 of ASCE 7-05 (2006), Where the combined response for the modal base shear (Vt) is less than 85 percent of the
calculated base shear (V) using the equivalent lateral force procedure, the forces, but not the drifts, shall be multiplied by 0.85 V/Vt.
Hence, for strength design, the modal analyses are scaled to match 0.85V = 4421 kips.
E. Refer to ASCE 7-05 (2006) for the definition of each design parameter.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 4 - Elevation and Properties of Frames A and F for Building 2A

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 5 - Elevation and properties of frames 2 and 5 for building 2A


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 6 Elevation A and shear wall reinforcing for building 2A


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

10

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 7 Elevation B and shear wall reinforcing for building 2A


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

11

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

1.60

1.40

Acceleration (%g)

1.20

1.00

0.80

0.60

0.40

0.20

0.00
0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

8.0

9.0

10.0

Period (sec)
Code Design spectra

Site specific design spectra

Figure 8 5% damped code and site specific design response spectra

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0.000

0.005

0.010

0.015

0.020

0.025

Drift(in/in)
Xdir

Ydir

Figure 9 Building 2A inter-story drifts from seismic forces on X and Y directions


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

12

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

ShearXdirection(kip)
StoryShear

SheartakenbyFrames

SheartakenbyShearwalls

Figure 10 Building 2A modal analysis peak shear from seismic forces on X direction
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

ShearYdirection(kip)
StoryShear

SheartakenbyFrames

SheartakenbyShearwalls

Figure 11 - Building 2A modal analysis peak shear from seismic forces on Y direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

13

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

-5
0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

Moment (k-ft)
My Overall

My Core

Figure 12 - Building 2A modal analysis peak moments when seismic forces act parallel to the X direction (Ex)
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

-5
0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

Moment (k-ft)
Mx Overall

Mx Core

Figure 13 - Building 2A modal analysis peak moments when seismic forces act parallel to the Y direction (Ey)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

14

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

3.2

Building 2A - Wind Design

Wind forces were calculated using section 6 of ASCE 7-05 (2006). Table 7 shows the parameters and
resulting forces used for wind design.
Table 7 Wind Design Parameters per ASCE 7-05 (2006)
Basic wind speed (V)

85 mph

Occupancy category

II

Surface roughness

Exposure type

Gust effect factor (Gf)

0.89

Enclosure classification

Enclosed

Topographic factor (Kz)

Percent of critical damping ration ()

2.5 %

Wind shear at ground floor

1,345 kip

Wind overturning moment at ground floor

272,378 kip

Comparing the base shears and overturning moments from the wind and seismic design it can be concluded
that the design is governed by the seismic forces.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

15

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

4.0 Building 2B - Analysis Summary


Building 2B was designed and checked for the following two performance levels:
1.
2.

Serviceability level using an elastic ETABS (2008) model.


Collapse prevention level using a three-dimensional non-linear step by step time-history analysis with
the program Perform 3D (2007)

For both models the stiffness is obtained from expected material properties and the modification factors
given in Table 3.
The provisions for seismic design according to the LATBSDC (2008) recommendations are followed with
the following exceptions.

Service level check is for an earthquake event of 25 year return period with 2.5% viscous damping. Up
to 20% of the elements with ductile action are allowed to reach 150% of their capacity under the
serviceability check.
The minimum base shear specified in the LATBSDC (2008) is waived.

Building 2B core wall properties are summarized in Table 8. Table 9 shows the periods obtained from both
the serviceability and collapse prevention models using the stiffness assumptions from Table 3 and expected
material properties.

Table 8 - Building 2B Specified Core Wall Thickness and Strength

Thickness

A.
B.

24 from foundation to 20th


18 Above 20th up to 30th
16 Above 30th

Specified concrete strength


(fc)

8000 psi from foundation to 20th


6000 psi from 20th to 30th
5000 psi Above 30th

Expected concrete strengthA


(fcexp)

10400 psi from foundation to 20th


7800 psi from 20th to 30th
6500 psi Above 30th

Specified reinforcing strength


(fy)

60 ksi (A706)

Expected reinforcing strengthB


(fyexp)

70 ksi

fc expected equals 1.3 times specified fc


fy expected equals 1.17 times specified fy

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

16

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 14 - Elevation and properties of frames A and F for building 2B


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

17

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 15 - Elevation and properties of frames 2 and 5 for building 2B

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

18

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 16 - Elevation A and shear wall reinforcing for building 2B

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

19

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 17 - Elevation B and shear wall reinforcing for building 2B

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

20

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
The periods obtained by the program Perform 3D (2007) from the model used for collapse prevention are
obtained before the non-linear analyses are performed. The frame beams, columns and coupling beams reflect a
reduced stiffness as described in the stiffness assumption table when calculating the period, however, the core shear
walls are modeled using the uncracked properties of concrete. When the non-linear analyses are run, the stiffness of
the core shear walls is adjusted according to its strain profile. The periods obtained by the program ETABS (2008)
reflect the stiffness of elements modified per Table 3. Table 9 shows a summary of the periods obtained for building
2B.
Table 9 Building 2B Period Summary from the Computer Models Used to Check Serviceability
and Collapse Prevention Performance Levels

4.1

Period
At collapse prevention level
Perform 3D
ETABS

Vibration
Mode

At service level
ETABS

4.01 sec.

4.28 sec.

4.93 sec.

3.53 sec.

3.87 sec.

4.50 sec.

2.12 sec.

2.26 sec.

2.78 sec.

Dominant direction
Translation mode on X
direction
Translation mode on Y
direction
Torsional mode

Serviceability Analysis Seismic Force Determination

The design forces are obtained using an elastic site-specific response spectrum analysis where the spectrum
represents a mean recurrence interval of 25 years. This spectrum is shown in Figure 18. The stiffness assumptions
used are those summarized in Table 3.
0.40

0.35

Acceleration (%g)

0.30

0.25

0.20

0.15

0.10

0.05

0.00
0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

8.0

9.0

10.0

Period (sec)
Service Design Spectra

Figure 18 2.5% Damped service level site specific response spectra


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

21

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Accidental eccentricity is not considered for serviceability checks per Section 3.3.5 of the LATBSDC
(2008) document.

4.1.1 Service Level Design Acceptance Criteria


Building 2B is checked for the load combinations using dead load, live load and wind load as described in
IBC 2006 calculating the strength of each element as described in the same document.
For the seismic design, the load combination used is described by equation 1.
DL + 0.25LL Eservice

Eq. - 1

DL and LL are the dead and live loads, respectively, and Eservice refers to the earthquake demand at service
level. The live load is not reduced. 0.25LL is also referred to as the expected live load.
Orthogonal load combinations for earthquake loads are applied as required per Section 12.5 of ASCE 7-05
(2006).
Per Section 3.3.6 of the LATBSDC (2008) document, the overall inter-story drift of the structure should not
exceed 0.005 hn.
When checking against the load combination shown in Equation 1, 20% of the elements with ductile
actions are allowed to have a demand to capacity ratio between 1.0 and 1.5. The remainder of elements should have
a demand to capacity ratio of 1.0 or less. All elements with brittle actions should have a demand capacity ratio of 1.0
or less. For both ductile and brittle actions, strengths should be calculated using a strength reduction factor in
accordance with current material codes. For brittle actions, strength is calculated using specified material properties.
For ductile actions expected material properties are used. Figures 19 through 23 show the representative plots for
service level design.
Table 10 Design Acceptance Criteria for Service Level Design Earthquake

A.
B.
C.
D.

Element

Action type

Classification

Reinforced Concrete Frame Beam

Flexure
ShearB

Ductile
Brittle

Axial-Flexure
interaction C
ShearB

Ductile

Reinforced Concrete Frame Column


Reinforced Concrete Shear walls

FlexureC
ShearB

Ductile
Brittle

Reinforced concrete coupling beams

ShearD

Ductile

Brittle

Notes:
Care needs to be exercised when detailing elements for ductility. Refer to Paulay and Priestley (1992) or Englekirk (2003) for a
detailed discussion on detailing reinforced concrete elements for ductility.
Shear design for shear walls, frame beams and columns should be done using capacity design procedures as described by Paulay and
Priestley (1992).
To ensure that a column or a shear wall is ductile in flexure, the maximum axial compression should be limited as described in the
acceptability criteria for collapse prevention.
It is important to note that when detailed per ACI 318 (2008), coupling beams behave in a ductile manner as shown by Naish et al
(2009).

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

22

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

25

Level

20

15

10

5
0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

0.006

Drift(in/in)
Xdir

Ydir

Figure 19 - Building 2B peak inter-story drifts at service level from seismic forces on X and Y directions
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

ShearonXdirection(kips)
StoryShear

FramesShear

Coreshear

Figure 20 - Building 2B modal analysis peak shear at service level from seismic forces on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

23

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

ShearonYdirection(kips)
StoryShear

FramesShear

Coreshear

Figure 21 - Building 2B modal analysis peak shear at service level from seismic forces on Y direction
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

-5
0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

Moment (k-ft)
My Overall at Service Level

My Core at Service Level

Figure 22 - Building 2B modal analysis peak moments at service level when seismic forces are parallel to the
X direction (Ex)
Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

24

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

-5
0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

Moment (k-ft)
Mx Overall at Service Level

Mx Core at Service Level

Figure 23 - Building 2B modal analysis peak moments at service level when seismic forces are parallel to the
Y direction (Ey)

4.2

Collapse Prevention Step by Step Non-linear Analysis

Seven pairs of spectrally matched ground motions were used to represent the MCE with a mean recurrence
interval of 2475 years (2% probability of exceedance in 50 years).
A model was built in Perform 3D (2007) to represent the lateral system of the building. The seismic mass
equivalent to the dead load and its associated rotational moment of inertia is assigned at levels above the ground
floor. The mass associated to the ground level and below is ignored.
The core walls and moment frames extend down to the foundation level. The diaphragms at the ground
floor and below are modeled with a finite element mesh to account for their in-plane stiffness modified per Table 3.
The diaphragms above ground level are modeled as rigid diaphragms by slaving the horizontal translation degrees of
freedom. Ground motions are input at the top of the mat foundation. The foundation is idealized as rigid by
providing lateral and vertical supports at the top of the foundation. The lateral resistance of the soil surrounding the
subterranean walls is neglected.
Per LATBSDC (2008), if during the serviceability evaluation the factor Ax as described in ASCE 7-05
(2006) is greater than 1.5, accidental eccentricity should be considered during collapse prevention analysis. Because
the building being studied is regular in plan and elevation, the factor Ax is always less than 1.5.
P-Delta effects are considered in the model by the inclusion of a P-Delta Column at the center of mass of
the building with an axial load equivalent to the dead load plus the expected live load. This column is pinned at both
ends on each level with its nodes slaved to the diaphragm defined at each floor.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

25

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

1.60

1.40

1.20

Acceleration(%g)

1.00

0.80

0.60

0.40

0.20

0.00
0

Period(sec.)

Figure 24 Target acceleration response spectra at MCE level.

4.2.1 Collapse Prevention Acceptance Criteria


To prevent collapse at the MCE level of forces, the acceptance criteria shown in Table 11 should be met.
For actions classified as ductile, the strength should be calculated using expected material properties and a
strength reduction factor of 1.
For actions classified as brittle, the strength should be calculated using specified material properties and a
strength reduction factor of 1. This capacity should exceed the smaller of the average demand from the seven timehistory records times 1.5 or the maximum force that the structural system can deliver.
In order to achieve ductile behavior a plastic mechanism as described in the SEAOC Blue Book (2008)
should be observed in the frames. Care needs to be exercised when detailing elements for ductility. Paulay and
Priestley (1992) and Englekirk (2003) give an in-depth discussion on how to detail reinforced concrete elements to
achieve ductile behavior. ACI 318 (2008) provides guidelines to detail coupling beams to sustain the allowed
displacement demands as shown by Wallace (2007).

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

26

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
Table 11 Collapse Prevention Non-Linear Model Acceptance Criteria

Element

Action type

Classification

Expected
behavior

Acceptance limit for non-linear


behavior

Reinforced
Concrete Frame
Beam

Plastic hinge rotation


Beam Shear

Ductile
Brittle

Non-linear
Linear

Hinge rotation 0.045 rad


N.A.

Axial-Flexure
interaction

Ductile

Non-linear

Axial compression 0.40 fcexp Ag


Hinge rotation 0.025 rad

Shear
Axial-Flexure
interaction

Brittle
Ductile

Linear
Non-linear

Shear

Brittle

Linear

N.A.
Concrete compression strain 0.015
Reinforcing rebar tension strain 0.05
Axial compression force 0.35fcAg
N.A.

Shear

Ductile

Non-linear

0.06 rad chord rotation

Reinforced
Concrete Frame
Column
Reinforced
Concrete Shear
walls
Reinforced
concrete
coupling beams
N.A. Not applicable

4.2.2 Core Wall Modeling Properties


The core walls are modeled using non-linear vertical fiber elements representing the expected behavior of
the concrete and reinforcing steel. The shear behavior is modeled as elastic.
The concrete stress-strain relationship is based on the modified Mander model for confined concrete
(Mander et al., 1988) with a confining ratio as required per ACI 318 (2008), Section 21.4.4. The tension strength of
concrete is neglected.
For the fiber elements, all concrete is defined as confined. The wall thickness used to calculate the flexural
and shear stiffness of the wall section corresponds to the confined thickness in anticipation of spalling. If in the
MCE time history non-linear analysis the average concrete compression strain exceeds 0.002, confinement is
provided.
In order to match the curve defined by the modified Mander model (Mander et al., 1998), the initial elastic
stiffness used to model the concrete material for the fiber sections differs from that calculated by the equations given
in ACI 318 (2008) and ACI 363 (1992). Figure 25 shows the curve defined by the modified Mander model (Mander
et al., 1998) and the values that were used to model the stress-strain curve of concrete with specified strength (fc) of
8 ksi in Perform 3D (2007).
Table 12 shows a comparison of the elastic modulus calculated per ACI 318 (2008) and ACI 363 (1992)
using specified material properties, the same elastic modulus using expected material properties and the elastic
modulus used in the non-linear model adjusted to match the modified Mander model (Mander et al., 1998). Figures
26 and 27 show the Perform 3D (2007) screen shots used to define the concrete material for shear walls with a
specified strength of 8 ksi.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

27

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

16.00

0.0055,13.54

14.00
0.0043,13.54

12.00

Stress(ksi)

10.00

0.0024,10.40

8.00
0.0156,7.54

6.00

4.00

2.00

0.00
0.0000

0.0050

0.0100

0.0150

0.0200

Strain(in/in)
ModifiedMandermodel

TrilinearadjustedtomatchmodifiedManderModel

Figure 25 Expected stress strain curve for confined concrete with specified concrete strength
(fc) of 8 ksi
The steel stress-strain relationship is based on the material specifications for A706 reinforcing steel. The
steel material is modeled with a tri-linear stress-strain relationship with expected yield strength (fyexpected) of 70 ksi
and an ultimate strength of 105 ksi in both compression and tension.
The post-yield stiffness and cyclic degradation of reinforcing steel has been adjusted by modeling in
Perform 3D (2007) the rectangular wall described by Orakcal et al. (2006) and adjusting it to match the lateral load
vs. top displacement curve. The parameters used to define the reinforcing steel are shown in Figures 28 and 29.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

28

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
Table 12 Concrete Elastic Modulus Comparison
fc

Ec
Per ACI 318 (2008)
and ACI 363 (1992)

Ec expected
(1.14 x Ec)

Initial elastic stiffness


for non-linear model

(ksi)

(ksi)

(ksi)

(ksi)

4031

4595

3229

4098

4671

3597

4578

5219

4340

10

5000

5700

4941

Ec = 57000 fc; for fc < 6 ksi per ACI 318 (2008)


Ec = 40000 fc + 1x106; for fc 6 ksi per ACI 363 (1992)

Figure 26 Inelastic concrete material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

29

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 27 - Inelastic concrete material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 28 Inelastic reinforcing rebar material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

30

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 29 Inelastic reinforcing rebar material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 30 Shear wall elastic shear material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)
Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

31

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
Figure 31 shows the cross section used to define a 24 in. wall with minimum reinforcing. As mentioned
previously, the thickness is taken as 22 in. to account for concrete spalling. The reinforcing ratio is calculated per
Equation 2. Figure 32 shows the compound element that defines a 24 in. shear wall with a reinforcing ratio of
0.0025 and specified concrete strength (fc) of 8 ksi.
= 0.0025 x 24 / 22 = 0.00272

Eq-2

Figure 31 Fiber wall cross-section screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

32

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 32 Shear wall compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.3 Coupling Beam Modeling Properties


The coupling beams are defined as elastic beam elements with a nonlinear displacement shear hinge at the
mid-span of the beam. These are connected to the shear walls using embedded elements as suggested by Powell
(2007). The shear hinge behavior is based on test results by Naish et al. (2009).
To obtain the nominal expected shear capacity, the angle of the diagonals () is calculated using a distance
from the center of gravity of the diagonal reinforcing to the face of the beam of 5 in. when the diagonal reinforcing
consists of two layers of rebar and 7 in. when it consists of 3 layers of rebar. Figure 33 shows a sketch of the
coupling beam diagonal reinforcing.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

33

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Lb = Coupling Beam Length

Diagonal reinforcing

Distance to reinforcing C.G.

Figure 33 Coupling beam diagonal reinforcing sketch


To define the behavior of the displacement shear hinge, the displacement is related to the rotation of the
coupling beam as described in Equation 3.
= x Lb

Eq. 3

Where is the rotation in radians, Lb is the length of the coupling beam and is the equivalent
displacement at a rotation . The following figures show the back bone parameters used to define the shear
displacement hinges for coupling beams and screen shots from Perform 3D (2007) for a typical coupling beam.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

34

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

1.6

( 2% ,V uexp)

y =Maximumelasticdisplacement
V y exp = 2 As 1.17 fy sin( )
2% =Equivalentdisplacementfor2%chordrotation
6% =Equivalentdisplacementfor6%chordrotation
Vu exp = 1.42V y exp
10% =Equivalentdisplacementfor10%chordrotation

( 6% ,V uexp)

1.4

V = 0.25Vu exp
V y exp = 2 As 1.17r exp
fy sin( )

1.2

Vu exp = 1.42V y exp


Vr exp = 0.25Vu exp

V/Vyexp

( y ,V yexp)
0.8

0.6

0.4

( 10% ,V rexp)
0.2

0
0

10

12

14

16

Rotation(rad)

Figure 34 Shear displacement hinge backbone curve

Figure 35 Coupling beam elastic segment screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

35

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 36 Coupling beam displacement shear hinge screenshot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 37 Coupling beam displacement shear hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

36

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 38 Coupling beam compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.4 Moment Frame Beam Properties


The moment frame beams are defined as elastic beam elements with nonlinear rotation hinges and rigid end
zones at each end. The rigid end zones extend from the column centerline to the face of the column, with a stiffness
of 10 times the elastic stiffness of the beam.
Tests performed by Popov et al. (1972) are used to define the post-yield stiffness of the rotation hinges in
beams. Figure 40 shows the setup that was used to perform these tests as described by Englekirk (2003). Figure 41
shows the force displacement relationship for this beam.
Using a plastic hinge length of half the beam depth, the ultimate beam plastic rotation is 0.046 radians.
Strength degradation is not accounted for given that the acceptable rotation for the plastic hinge is lower than that
associated with this effect.
To define the post-yield stiffness, a ratio of 1.18 is observed between the strength at ultimate and at yield.
Using these values, Figure 39 shows the backbone curve used to define the behavior of beam rotation plastic hinges
in Perform 3D (2007).

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

37

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

1400

1200

( u ,Muexp)

1000

( y ,Myexp)

Moment(kft)

800

y =Maximumelasticrotation
u =Ultimaterotationobservedintest(0.046rad)
Myexp =Expectedmomentnominalcapacity
Muexp =Expectedmomentultimatecapacity(1.18 Myexp )

600

400

200

0
0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

Rotation(rad.)

Figure 39 Back bone curve for beam rotation hinge

Figure 40 Beam test subassembly as performed by Popov et al. (1972)


Figure taken from The Seismic Design of Reinforced and Precast Concrete Buildings by Englekirk (2003)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

38

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 41 Forcedeflection curve from test performed by Popov et al. (1972)

Figure 42 Frame beam cross section screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

39

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 43 - Frame beam cross section screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 44 - Frame beam rotation moment hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

40

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 45 - Frame beam rotation moment hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 46 - Frame beam rotation moment hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

41

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 47 - Frame beam compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.5 Moment Frame Column Properties


Plastic hinges are modeled at the top and bottom ends of every column. Columns at the upper levels are
expected to remain elastic but incursions into non-linear behavior are acceptable if the integrity of the structure is
not compromised.
To define a column plastic hinge, a moment-axial capacity interaction curve is calculated using the
columns expected material properties. The back bone curve is elastic-perfectly plastic, meaning the column strength
doesnt change once it reaches the yield point.
The following figures show an example used in Perform 3D (2007) to define a column at the seismic base
with plastic hinges at the face of the beam.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

42

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 48 Frame column compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 49 Frame column plastic hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)
Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

43

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 50 Frame column plastic hinge screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.6 Slab Modeling at Ground Level and Below


The slabs at ground level and below are modeled as a shell element with its stiffness modified per Table 3.
The stiffness factors are applied to the elastic modulus when defining the material. The shear modulus is
calculated by Perform 3D (2007) using Poissons ratio. The following figures show the screen shots used to define a
slab in Perform 3D (2007).

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

44

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 51 Slab elastic material screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

Figure 52 Slab elastic cross section screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)
Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

45

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 53 Slab compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.7 Basement Wall Properties


Basement walls are modeled as elastic finite elements with its stiffness modified per Table 3. The following
figures show the screen shots used to define a basement wall in Perform 3D (2007).

Figure 54 Basement wall cross section screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)
Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

46

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 55 Basement wall compound component screen shot from Perform 3D (2007)

4.2.8 Damping
Rayleigh damping is used to run the time-history non-linear analyses. To define the damping curve, the
damping is set at 2.5% of critical damping at a period of 0.2T1.and at a period of 0.9 T1, T1 being the fundamental
period of the structure. The and values are automatically calculated by Perform 3D (2007).

Figure 56 Rayleigh damping as defined in Perform 3D

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

47

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

Figure 57 Damping definition screen shot from Perform 3D

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

48

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

4.3

Results from Non-linear Analyses


The following figures represent the behavior of building 2B under the MCE records and its averages.

4.3.1 Overall Behavior


Table 13 Summary of Building 2B Behavior under MCE
Shear at grade level

Vx = 10,732 kips

Vy = 10,000 kips

Core average peak shear at grade level

Vx = 8,240 kips

Vy = 7,150 kips

Core average peak overturning moment at


grade level

My = 952,328 kip-ft

Mx = 739,130 kip-ft

Average maximum story drift


from non-linear analyses

x = 1.5 %

y = 1.0 %

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03

0.035

Drift(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanDrift

Figure 58 Peak inter-story drifts on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

49

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03

0.035

Drift(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanDrift

Figure 59 Peak inter-story drifts on Y direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Displacement(in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

Figure 60 Peak displacements at center of mass on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

50

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Displacement(in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

Figure 61 Peak displacements at center of mass on Y direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

2,000

4,000

6,000

8,000

10,000

12,000

14,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 62 Peak story shear on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

51

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

2,000

4,000

6,000

8,000

10,000

12,000

14,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meanshear

Figure 63 Peak story shear on Y direction

4.3.2 Core Shear Wall


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

2,000

4,000

6,000

8,000

10,000

12,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 64 Building 2B core peak shear on X direction


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

52

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 65 Building 2B core peak shear on Y direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

Shear(kips)
MeanShear

1.5xMean

8sqrt(f'c)

Figure 66 Building 2B average core peak shear values on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

53

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

Shear(kip)
MeanShear

1.5xMean

8sqrt(f'c)

Figure 67 Building 2B average core peak shear values on Y direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

200,000

400,000

600,000

800,000

1,000,000

1,200,000

Moment(kft)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanMoment

Figure 68 Building 2B core peak overturning moment over X

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

54

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

100,000

200,000

300,000

400,000

500,000

600,000

700,000

800,000

900,000

Moment(kft)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanMoment

Figure 69 Building 2B core peak overturning moment over Y


45

40

Maximum compression strain allowed for unconfined concrete


u = 0.003 in/in

35

Maximum compression strain allowed for confined concrete


u = 0.015 in/in

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0.0000

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

0.0035

Strain(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meancompressionstrain

Figure 70 Building 2B Maximum compression strains at core corner by Pier 1

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

55

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

Yield strain for reinforcing steel grade A706 with fy=60 ksi
y = 60x 1.17 / 29,000 = 0.0024 in/in

35

Maximum strain allowed for reinforcing steel grade A706


u = 0.05 in/in

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0.0000

0.0010

0.0020

0.0030

0.0040

0.0050

0.0060

0.0070

0.0080

0.0090

Strain(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meantensionstrain

Figure 71 Building 2B Maximum tension strains at core corner by Pier 1


45

40

Maximum compression strain allowed for unconfined concrete


u = 0.003 in/in

35

Maximum compression strain allowed for confined concrete


u = 0.015 in/in

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0.0000

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

0.0035

Strain(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meancompressionstrain

Figure 72 Building 2B Maximum compression strains at core corner by Pier 2

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

56

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

Yield strain for reinforcing steel grade A706 with fy=60 ksi
y = 60x 1.17 / 29,000 = 0.0024 in/in

35

Maximum strain allowed for reinforcing steel grade A706


u = 0.05 in/in
30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0.0000

0.0020

0.0040

0.0060

0.0080

0.0100

0.0120

Strain(in/in)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meantensionstrain

Figure 73 Building 2B Maximum tension strains at core corner by Pier 2


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 74 Building 2B Pier 1 peak shear on X direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

57

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

Shear(kips)
MeanShear

1.5xMean

10sqrt(f'c)

Figure 75 Building 2B Pier 1 average peak shear on X direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 76 Building 2B Pier 1 average peak shear on Y direction

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

58

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Shear(kips)
MeanShear

1.5xMean

10sqrt(f'c)

Figure 77 Building 2B Pier 1 average peak shear on Y direction


45

40

35

Maximum Coupling Beam rotation allowed


u = 0.06 rad

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

Chordrotation(rad)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Meanrotation

Figure 78 Building 2B elevation A coupling beam peak rotations


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

59

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

Maximum Coupling Beam rotation allowed


u = 0.06 rad

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

0
0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

Chordrotation(rad)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Average

Figure 79 Building 2B elevation B coupling beam peak rotations

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

60

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

4.3.3 Frame Behavior


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 80 Peak frame shear on X direction


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

MeanShear

Figure 81 Peak frame shear on Y direction


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

61

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
12,000

10,000

8,000

6,000

4,000

2,000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

0.4f'cexpAg

Figure 82 Corner column peak compression


45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

Figure 83 Maximum shear on X direction at corner column on gridlines A-2


Analysis and Design Summary
Building #2, Los Angeles, California

62

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
45

40

35

30

Level

25

20

15

10

5
0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,800

Shear(kips)
Mean

Meanx1.5

8sqrt(f'c)

Figure 84 Mean shear on X direction at corner column on gridlines A-2


45
40
Maximum Frame Beam rotation allowed
u = 0.045 rad

35
30

Level

25
20
15
10
5
0
5
0.000

0.005

0.010

0.015

0.020

0.025

0.030

0.035

0.040

0.045

0.050

Rotation(rad)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

Figure 85 Frame A beam rotation at face of column on gridlines A-2

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

63

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

4.3.4 Basement walls


0

Level

5
0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

Shear(kips)
S1

S2

S3

S4

S5

S6

S7

Mean

Meanx1.5

8sqrt(f'c)

Figure 86 Peak shear of basement wall on gridline Y1

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

64

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.

References
1.

ACI Committee 363 (1992). State-of-the-Art Report on High-Strength Concrete (ACI 363-92), ACI Manual
of Concrete Practice, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 2005.

2.

ACI (2008). ACI 318-08: Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete with Commentary, 2008 edition.
American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI.

3.

Adebar, P., Mutrie, J., and DeVall, R., (2004). Displacement-Based Design of Concrete Wall Buildings: The
2004 Canadian Code Provisions, 13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Vancouver, B.C.

4.

ASCE (American Society of Civil Engineers) (2006). ASCE 7-05, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and
Other Structures, Including Supplement No. 1. American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston, VA.

5.

E. P, Popov, V. V. Bertero and H. Krawinkler (1972). Cyclic Behavior of Three R.C. Flexural Members with
High Shear, Report No. EERC 72-5, Earthquake Engineering Research Center, University of California,
Berkeley, CA.

6.

Englekirk Robert.E. (2003). Seismic Design of Reinforced and Precast Concrete Buildings. John Wiley & Sons,
New York, NY.

7.

Englekirk, Robert E. and Llovet, Dani (2000). Cyclic Tests of Cast-in-Place High Strength Beam-Column
Joints, Carpenters/Contractors Cooperation Committee, Inc., High Strength Concrete Research, Los Angeles,
CA.

8.

ETABS Nonlinear Version 9.2.0 (2008). Extended 3D Analysis of Building Structures, Computers and
Structures, Inc. Berkeley, CA.

9.

ICC (International Code Council) (2006). 2006 International Building Code, International Code Council, Falls
Church, VA.

10. Los Angeles Tall Building Design Council (2008). An Alternative Procedure for Seismic Analysis and Design
of Tall Buildings Located in the Los Angeles Region, Los Angeles, CA.
11. Mander, J.B., Priestley, M.J.N. and Park, R. (1988). Theoretical Stress-Strain Model for Confined Concrete.
ASCE Journal of Structural Engineering, 114 (8), 1804-1826.
12. Naish, David, Fry, Andy, Klemencic, Ron and Wallace, John. (2009). Testing and Modeling of diagonally
Reinforced Concrete Coupling Beams. Paper submitted to ACI structural journal, Los Angeles, CA.
13. Orakcal, Kutay and Wallace, John W., (2006). Flexural Modeling of Reinforced Concrete Walls Experimental
Verification, ACI Structural Journal, V. 103, No. 2
14. Orakcal, Kutay, Wallace, John W. and Conte, Joel P., (2004). Flexural Modeling of Reinforced Concrete Walls
Model Attributes, ACI Structural Journal, V 101, No. 5
15. Paulay, T., and M.J.N. Priestley (1992). Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Buildings. John
Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.
16. Perform 3D Version 4.0.3 (2007). Nonlinear Analysis and Performance Assessment of 3D Structures,
Computers and Structures, Inc. Berkeley, CA.

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

65

ENGLEKIRK PARTNERS
Consulting Structural Engineers, Inc.
17. Powell, Graham H., (2007).Detailed Example of a Tall Shear Wall Building Using CSIs Perform 3D Nonlinear
Dynamic Analysis, Computers and Structures Inc., Berkeley, CA.
18. SEAOC Seismology Committee (2008). Reinforced concrete structures, September, 2008, The SEAOC Blue
Book: Seismic Design Recommendations, Structural Engineers Association of California, Sacramento, CA.
Accessible via the world wide web at: http://www.seaoc.org/bluebook/index.html
19. Wallace, John W., (2007). Modeling Issues for Tall Reinforced Concrete Core Wall Buildings, Published online
by Wiley Interscience at: http://www.interscience.wiley.com

Analysis and Design Summary


Building #2, Los Angeles, California

66

APPENDIX C: Detailed Design Write-up for


BRBF Building

DETAILED DESIGN WRITE-UP FOR BRBF BUILDING

Table of Contents
1.

2.

3.

4.

Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 1-1


1.1

Purpose ................................................................................................................. 1-1

1.2

Objective ............................................................................................................... 1-1

1.3

Scope .................................................................................................................... 1-2

1.4

Description of Project............................................................................................. 1-2

1.5

Information Provided by Others ............................................................................. 1-2

Code-based Design ......................................................................................................... 2-1


2.1

Purpose ................................................................................................................. 2-1

2.2

Design Description................................................................................................. 2-1


2.2.1

Gravity Analysis & Design .......................................................................... 2-1

2.2.2

Lateral Analysis.......................................................................................... 2-2

2.2.3

Lateral Force Resisting Member Design .................................................... 2-9

2.2.4

Story Drifts for Code Design..................................................................... 2-12

PERFORMANCE BASED DESIGN.................................................................................. 3-1


3.1

Service Level Earthquake Evaluation .................................................................... 3-1

3.2

Maximum Considered Earthquake Evaluation ....................................................... 3-3


3.2.1

Modeling of Critical Elements ..................................................................... 3-4

3.2.2

Selected Results from Non Linear Analysis................................................ 3-9

Enhanced PERFORMANCE BASED DESIGN................................................................. 4-1


4.1

Service Level Earthquake Evaluation .................................................................... 4-1

4.1

Maximum Considered Earthquake Evaluation ....................................................... 4-4

LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Response Spectrum for Code Analysis .................................................................... 2-4
Figure 2: Plan at Eleventh through Fortieth Floors .................................................................. 2-6
i

Figure 3: Elevation of Frame Along Line 2 Following Removal of a Brace............................... 2-7


Figure 4: Elevation of Frame Along Line D Following Removal of a Brace .............................. 2-8
Figure 5: Defining Box Column Section Properties in ETABS ............................................... 2-11
Figure 6: Response Spectrum for Serviceability Analysis........................................................ 3-2
Figure 7: Presumed Backbone Curve for Buckling Restrained Braces .................................... 3-4
Figure 8: BRBF Property Definition in Perform ........................................................................ 3-5
Figure 9: BRBF Compound Element in Perform...................................................................... 3-6
Figure 10: Column Section Definition in Perform..................................................................... 3-7
Figure 11: Column Strength Definition in Perform ................................................................... 3-8
Figure 12: Peak Interstory Drifts in the Y Direction.................................................................. 3-9
Figure 13: Peak Interstory Drifts in the X Direction................................................................ 3-10
Figure 14: BRBF Core Strain DCRs along Lines 2, 3 and 4 .................................................. 3-11
Figure 15: BRBF Core Strain DCR Along Line D................................................................... 3-12
Figure 16: Seismic Frame Column Axial Flexure Interaction Ratio along Line E ................... 3-13
Figure 17: Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in Y Direction................. 3-14
Figure 18: Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in X Direction................. 3-15
Figure 19: Response Spectrum for Enhanced PBE................................................................. 4-1
Figure 20: 3D Computer Model used for the Enhanced Performance Based Evaluation ......... 4-2
Figure 21: Peak Interstory Drifts in the Y Direction.................................................................. 4-5
Figure 22: Peak Interstory Drifts in the X Direction.................................................................. 4-6

ii

1.
1.1

INTRODUCTION
Purpose

This report presents the design basis for two alternative designs of a 39-story steel framed
office building located at a generic site in Los Angeles, California. One of these designs, termed
the code-based design conforms in all respects, except one, with the design criteria contained in
the following codes and standards:

2007 California Building Code

ASCE 7.05 Standard for Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures

AISC 360.05 Specification for Steel Buildings

AISC 341.05 Seismic Specification

ACUI 318-08 Building Code Requirements for Reinforced Concrete

The one exception to the requirements of these codes and standards is that the design does not
have a backup special moment-resisting frame as required by ASCE 7.05 for structures with a
height in excess of 160 ft.
The second design has been conducted using a performance-based approach generally based
on the criteria contained in a document published by the Los Angeles Tall Buildings Council.
1.2

Objective

Simpson Gumpertz & Heger, Inc. developed the two designs presented in this report on behalf
of the Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER) under its Tall Buildings Initiative
(TBI). The objective of the TBI is to develop recommended performance-based design criteria
for tall buildings as an alternative to the criteria contained in present building codes and
standards. These alternative performance-based criteria are intended to provide performance
that is at least equivalent to that intended for buildings designed in conformance with the code.
The buildings presented in this report, together with designs using other structural systems
developed by other designers, will be used by PEER to assess the cost and performance
capability of buildings designed using alternative design approaches and criteria.
information will guide the development of the PEER recommendations.
1-1

This

1.3

Scope

Our scope of work included the following:


1.

Meet with representatives of PEER and other design consultants engaged in the TBI
project to develop the general criteria for the designs.

2.

Develop a design, to a schematic level, for an essentially code-conforming steelframed building

3.

Develop a design, to a schematic level, for a performance-based steel framed building,


of similar height and footprint, using the procedures contained in design
recommendations prepared by the Los Angeles Tall Buildings Council.

4.

Prepare schematic level drawings documenting the design

5.

Prepare this design report

1.4

Description of Project

Both designs have typical above-grade floors comprised of lightweight concrete fill on metal
deck supported by composite steel framing with a foot print of 170 ft by 107 ft. Both designs
have four basement levels with a foot print of 227 ft by 220 ft. Both structures have lateral force
resisting systems comprised of buckling-restrained braced frames.
1.5

Information Provided by Others

The Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center provided geotechnical/seismicity data for
the hypothetical site including:

Code spectral response acceleration coefficients Ss and S1

Site Class

Ground motion records for use in analysis

General loading criteria

1-2

2.

CODE-BASED DESIGN

2.1

Purpose

This section provides a brief overview of the code based design. As discussed in the Design
Criteria, we used the International Building Code 2006 to perform this design.
2.2

Design Description

This design was conducted in conformance with all the prescriptive provisions of the
International Building Code 2006, and its referenced standards, except for the limitation on the
building height. The International Building Code would require that buildings in excess of 160 ft
and located on the site selected for this building be provided with a special moment-resisting
frame capable of resisting at least 25% of the specified design seismic forces. This design did
not incorporate such a frame. Salient features of this design are provided in the following
sections.
2.2.1

Gravity Analysis & Design

We designed the buildings vertical-load resisting system using gravity loads that consist of a
combination of self weight of the elements and additional superimposed loads. Based on the
design criteria document provided to us by PEER, we considered the following superimposed
loads at various floors in addition to the self weight.
Table 1 Gravity Loading Criteria
Description/Location

Superimposed Dead

Live Load

Reducability

Roof

28 psf

25 psf

Yes

Mechanical, Electrical at Roof

Total of 100 kips

Residential including Balconies

28 psf

40 psf

Yes

Corridors, Lobbies and Stairs

28 psf

100 psf

No

Retail

110 psf

100 psf

No

Parking Garage, Ramp

3 psf

40 psf

Construction Loading

3 psf

30 psf

No

Cladding

15 psf

1.

Yes

PEER document showed 50 psf. SGH considered 40 psf in keeping with ASCE 7-05.

2-1

We combined the element self weights with the superimposed loading from the above table and
performed a gravity-load design using the RAM Structural System software, version 12.1. We
have included a complete flat load table in Appendix A (Pages A1 through A4) for reference. In
those tables the highlighted cells add up to the superimposed loads shown in Table 1.
2.2.2

Lateral Analysis

Following design of the vertical-load carrying elements, we performed a lateral analysis of the
building. We considered both wind and seismic forces and designed each element for the most
severe requirements. A brief description of the wind and seismic design is given below.
2.2.2.1 Wind Analysis
We used ASCE 7-05, Method 2 for calculating the wind pressures. Table 2 lists the various
parameters used for calculating the wind pressure.
Table 2 Wind Design Criteria
Parameter

Value

Basic Wind Speed, 3 sec. gust (V)

85 mph

Basic Wind Speed, 3 sec gust (V), for serviceability wind demands
based on a 10 year mean recurrence interval

67 mph

Exposure

Occupancy Category

II

Importance Factor (Iw)

1.0

Topographic Factor (Kzt)

1.0

Exposure Classification

Enclosed

Internal Pressure Coefficient (GCpi)

0.18

Mean Roof Height (h)

544-6

Wind Base Shear along Two Orthogonal Directions

1436 kips and 2629 kips

We considered the four cases depicted in Figure 6-9 of ASCE 7-05. Each of these cases
includes the direct wind force in each orthogonal direction either alone or in combination with
story torsional moment caused by the eccentric application of this load.
We calculated the gust effect factor (Gf) following Section 6.5.8.2 of ASCE 7-05 for flexible or
dynamically sensitive structures for 1% damping.
2-2

We have included the details of the wind analysis in Appendix A pages A5 through A10. Page
A5 shows the calculation of the gust effect factor for the short normal (East West) direction of
the building. Page A6 shows the calculation of the wind pressure for the same direction over
the height of the building. Page A7 shows the story forces and story moments. Pages A8
through A10 show the identical quantities in the long normal (North South) direction of the
building.
2.2.2.2 Seismic Analysis
We used linear response spectrum analysis to calculate seismic forces and displacements. Per
ASCE 7-05, Cl 12.9.4, we scaled the forces to 85% of the base shear obtained from the
equivalent lateral force procedure of Cl 12.8. Table 3 lists the various parameters that we used
for the seismic design.
Table 3 Seismic Design Parameters
Parameter

Value

Building Latitude/Longitude

Undefined

Occupancy Category

II

Importance Factor (Ie)

1.0

Spectral Response Coefficients

SDS = 1.145; SD1 = 0.52

Seismic Design Category

D
Buckling restrained braced frames, non moment
resisting beam column connections

Lateral System
Response Modification Factor (R)

Deflection Amplification Factor (Cd)

5.5

System Overstrength Factor (0)

2.0

Building Period (T) using Cl. 12.8.2

3.16 sec

Seismic Response Coefficient Cs (Eq. 12.8-1)

0.051 W (Governed by Cs-min from Eq. 12.8-5)

Scaled Spectral Base Shear

3504 kips (85% of Static Base Shear)

Analysis Procedure
1.

Modal Response Spectral Analysis

Actual period from dynamic model: TY = 5.05 sec; TX = 3.62 sec

2-3

We performed the lateral analysis using the program ETABS, version 9.5.0. Page A11 of the
appendix A shows the modal information for the first 50 modes of the code model.
We used the 5% damped, acceleration response spectrum shown in Figure 1. We included
sufficient modes to obtain participation of at least 90% of the structures mass. We scaled the
results of the response spectrum analysis such that the base shear immediately above the
ground floor matched 85% of the static base shear from the equivalent static force analysis.
Page A12 of the appendix shows the distribution of the static lateral force Fx and the diaphragm
design force Fpx. The last columns of the same sheet shows the mass and mass moment of
inertia used in the model at various floors. Note that for levels below the ground floor, the mass
of the perimeter walls are automatically calculated by the program.

Spectral Acceleration, Sa (g)

1.6

1.2

0.8

0.4

0
0

Period (sec)
Figure 1: Response Spectrum for Code Analysis

IBC 2006 also requires the designer to calculate the redundancy factor () for seismic design.
We calculated the redundancy factor per 12.3.4.2 of ASCE 7-05. According to that section, a
building will qualify for a =1 provided that the removal of an individual brace or connection will
not result in more than a 33% reduction in story strength, nor will the resulting system have an
extreme torsional irregularity.

Extreme torsional irregularity is defined to exist when the

maximum story drift computed including accidental torsion, at one end of the structure
2-4

transverse to an axis is more than 1.4 times the average story drifts at the two ends of the
structure.
In order to calculate the redundancy factor when the seismic forces are acting in the North
South direction, we removed a brace from line 2 along the full height of the building. We then
subjected the building to the static lateral forces along with the 5% accidental torsion. We term
these forces as EQYPL (with the accidental eccentricity towards the positive right) and EQYMN
(with the accidental eccentricity towards the negative left). Since the building has at least 6
bays of braced frame in each principal direction, loss of a brace or connection will never reduce
the capacity by 33%. We found that that for the North South direction, the largest ratio of
maximum story drift over the average drift over the height of the building was 1.39 at Story 13
(see page A12). Since this is less than 1.4, we concluded that the redundancy factor in the
North South direction is 1. Figure 2 shows the plan view of the tower and Figure 3 shows the
elevation at Line 2 after the removal of the brace.
We also performed a similar analysis in the X (East West direction). In this model we removed
a single brace from Line D and subjected the building to static forces EQXPL ((with the
accidental eccentricity towards the positive top) and EQXMN (with the accidental eccentricity
towards the negative bottom). Figure 4 shows the elevation of the frame along Line D with the
brace removed. We then calculated the ratio of maximum to average drifts and obtained ratios
ranging from 1.468 to 1.408 from roof to Story 36. However, section 12.3.4.2 stipulates that this
ratio should strictly be studied for floors resisting more 33% of the base shear which is
numerically equal to 1156 kips. This only happens below Story 35 (see page A13). We found
that the ratio of maximum to average drift is only marginally greater than 1.4 at two stories with
a maximum value of 1.408 at Story 34 (D/C of 1.008). We arbitrarily declared that this met the
requirements of ASCE-7 for a redundancy coefficient, =1.

2-5

Figure 2: Plan at Eleventh through Fortieth Floors

2-6

Figure 3: Elevation of Frame Along Line 2 Following Removal of a Brace

2-7

Figure 4: Elevation of Frame Along Line D Following Removal of a Brace

2-8

2.2.3

Lateral Force Resisting Member Design

2.2.3.1 Buckling Restrained Brace Design


We designed the buckling restrained braces for the worst of the wind and seismic loads. In
almost all cases, seismic loads governed the design. The capacity of the braces in tension and
compression was both considered as AsFy, with = 0.9 and Fy = 38 ksi. Pages A14 through
A37 show the brace design details along lines 2, 3, 4 and D respectively.
2.2.3.2 Braced Frame Column Design
AISCs Seismic Provisions for Structural Steel Buildings (ANSI/AISC 341-05), require columns
in buckling restrained braced frames need to be checked for

Axial load and moment interaction for code level forces

For axial load only corresponding to the sum of the vertical component of all buckling
restrained braces that frame into the column along with tributary gravity loading

We checked the columns for both of the above criterion and found that the latter generally
produced larger D/C ratios. Since the current configuration uses columns that form part of
lateral framing in two orthogonal directions, we used the 100%-30% combination to calculate
the maximum compression from the braces. We established the maximum compression forces
from the brace as RyAsFy, where Ry =1.1, = 1.25 and = 1.1.
We used built up square box columns infilled with high strength (fc = 10 ksi) concrete to resist
the large compression force demands. The plate thicknesses of the box columns ranged from
1.5 in. at upper stories to 3 in. at lower ones. The plan dimension of the box columns ranged
from 18 in. to 57 in. We calculated the strength, axial area and stiffness of infill columns using
the provisions of Chapter I (Design of Composite Members) of the 13th edition LRFD Steel
Code. We included this enhancement of axial area and stiffness over the bare steel section
properties in the ETABS analysis model as well. We did this by defining a steel box section in
ETABS and then using the property modifier to account for the infill concrete. Figure 5 shows
the ETABS screen shot of how this is accomplished. Page A38 shows the detailed strength and
stiffness calculation for the box columns. Note that the last two columns calculate the axial and
inertial modifiers used in ETABS. Additionally pages A39 through A41 show the details of the
column design at C/2, D/2 and D/3 respectively.
2-9

2.2.3.3 Braced Frame Beam Design


We designed the braced frame beams for the horizontal component of the brace compression
along with unbalanced upward component of the buckling restrained brace given by
RyAsFy(1)sin where is the brace angle. Since BRBs are always stronger in compression
than tension, this moment is opposite in direction to the gravity moment. Page A42 shows a
sample beam design for the frame along line 2.

2-10

Figure 5: Defining Box Column Section Properties in ETABS

2-11

2.2.4

Story Drifts for Code Design

We calculated interstory drifts using the response spectrum analysis. ASCE 7-05 stipulates the
use of a response spectrum that is reduced by the response reduction factor, R. It also states
that the drifts obtained from this reduced spectral analysis be amplified by Cd to yield the
expected inelastic drifts. Table 4 shows the interstory drifts obtained at the various levels both
for the X and Y directions.

As can be seen, the maximum story drifts are less than the

permissible value of 0.02 at all levels.


Table 4 Story Drifts for Code Design
Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 40

0.013

0.005

Story 39

0.014

0.006

Story 38

0.014

0.006

Story 37

0.014

0.006

Story 36

0.014

0.006

Story 35

0.014

0.006

Story 34

0.014

0.006

Story 33

0.014

0.006

Story 32

0.014

0.006

Story 31

0.014

0.006

Story 30

0.014

0.006

Story 29

0.014

0.006

Story 28

0.014

0.006

Story 27

0.013

0.006

Story 26

0.013

0.006

Story 25

0.013

0.006

Story 24

0.013

0.006

Story 23

0.012

0.006

Story 22

0.012

0.006

Story 21

0.012

0.006

Story 20

0.012

0.006

Story 19

0.011

0.006

Story 18

0.011

0.006

Story 17

0.011

0.006

2-12

Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 16

0.010

0.006

Story 15

0.010

0.006

Story 14

0.010

0.005

Story 13

0.009

0.005

Story 12

0.008

0.005

Story 11

0.007

0.005

Story 10

0.004

0.004

Story 9

0.004

0.004

Story 8

0.004

0.004

Story 7

0.004

0.004

Story 6

0.004

0.004

Story 5

0.004

0.004

Story 4

0.003

0.004

Story 3

0.003

0.004

Story 2

0.003

0.003

Story 1

0.002

0.002

2-13

3.

PERFORMANCE BASED DESIGN

We based the seismic design for this alternate on the seismic design criteria (dated 29 April
2008) published by the Los Angeles Tall Building Structural Design Council (LATBSDC). Since
this design was not required to meet all of the prescriptive criteria contained in the building
code, we were able to reduce the size and number of bays of the buckling restrained frames.
Specifically, along lines 2 and 7 the two additional bays below level 10 were omitted and only a
single bay of bracing is provided. Table 6 lists the performance objectives we followed for this
design:
Table 6 Seismic Performance Objectives
Level of Earthquake

Earthquake Performance Objectives

Frequent/Service : 25 year return period, 2.5%


damping

Serviceability: Essentially elastic performance with


minor yielding of brbf-s. Drift limited to 0.5%

Maximum Considered Earthquake (MCE): As


defined by ASCE 7-05, Section 21.2, 2.5%
damping.

Collapse Prevention: Extensive structural damage,


repairs are required and may not be economically
feasible. Drift limited to 3%

3.1

Service Level Earthquake Evaluation

We used a response spectrum analysis for this evaluation. We used the response spectrum
shown in Figure 6, which was provided by PEER. The damping level was set at 2.5%. We
neglected accidental torsion in this analysis.

3-1

Spectral Acceleration, Sa (g)

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0
0

Period (sec)

Figure 6: Response Spectrum for Serviceability Analysis

We also evaluated the building for the same wind forces that we used for the code-based
design described in the previous section. We found that wind always governed the required
brace strength. Pages A43 through A48 show the representative details of the brace design
along line 3. The interstory drifts for the service level earthquake is shown in the following table.
As can be seen, the drifts are less than 0.5% at all levels.
Table 4 Story Drifts for Service Level Earthquake
Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 40

0.0031

0.0014

Story 39

0.0032

0.0015

Story 38

0.0033

0.0016

Story 37

0.0033

0.0017

Story 36

0.0034

0.0017

Story 35

0.0033

0.0018

Story 34

0.0033

0.0018

Story 33

0.0033

0.0018

Story 32

0.0032

0.0018

Story 31

0.0031

0.0018

Story 30

0.0031

0.0018

Story 29

0.0029

0.0018

3-2

3.2

Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 28

0.0028

0.0018

Story 27

0.0027

0.0018

Story 26

0.0026

0.0018

Story 25

0.0026

0.0018

Story 24

0.0025

0.0018

Story 23

0.0024

0.0018

Story 22

0.0023

0.0018

Story 21

0.0022

0.0017

Story 20

0.0021

0.0017

Story 19

0.0021

0.0017

Story 18

0.002

0.0017

Story 17

0.002

0.0017

Story 16

0.0019

0.0017

Story 15

0.0019

0.0016

Story 14

0.0018

0.0016

Story 13

0.0018

0.0016

Story 12

0.0017

0.0016

Story 11

0.0017

0.0016

Story 10

0.0016

0.0017

Story 9

0.0016

0.0017

Story 8

0.0016

0.0017

Story 7

0.0015

0.0017

Story 6

0.0015

0.0017

Story 5

0.0015

0.0017

Story 4

0.0014

0.0017

Story 3

0.0014

0.0016

Story 2

0.0012

0.0014

Story 1

0.0008

0.001

Maximum Considered Earthquake Evaluation

As required by the LATBSDC document, we performed a non linear response history analysis of
the building corresponding for maximum considered earthquake shaking as defined by the
building code. We used seven pairs of acceleration histories provided to us by PEER for this
3-3

purpose. We used the non linear analysis program CSI Perform, version 4.0.1 with a constant
modal damping level of 2.5% and 0.1% Rayleigh damping. We explicitly modeled the non
linearities in the buckling restrained braces.

We modeled columns and beams as elastic

elements and later verified that demands on these elements remained within their elastic
capacities. Details of the element modeling are discussed below.
3.2.1

Modeling of Critical Elements

3.2.1.1 Modeling of Buckling Restrained Braces


We modeled the buckling restrained braces (brb) using the perform BRB inelastic element in
series with an elastic spring that models the end attachment of the braces. The backbone curve
of the BRBs were modeled according to Figure 7 with Ry =1.1, = 1.25 and = 1.1. Figure 8
shows the screen shot of the Perform input form for the BRB definition and Figure 9 shows the
form for the compound element definition with the elastic end element in series. Note that the
initial stiffness (K0) of the buckling restrained brace is based on AsE/L with L equal to 70% of the
actual center to center length of the brace.

1.25%K o
wRyFyAs
RyFyAs

Tension
20Dy

10Dy

Ko

Dy
Dy

10Dy

20Dy

Compression
RyFyAs
bwRyFyAs

Figure 7: Presumed Backbone Curve for Buckling Restrained Braces

3-4

R yF yA s

70% Actual
1.25% Ko
Figure 8: BRBF Property Definition in Perform

3-5

Figure 9: BRBF Compound Element in Perform

3.2.1.2 Modeling of the Columns and Beams


We modeled the columns using the non prismatic steel sections in Perform. The moment of
inertia input in the form was adjusted to account for the additional stiffening due to the presence
of the infill concrete. Figure 10 shows the stiffness and area definition form for the 48 sq in. box
columns with 3 in. plates.
The axial load and moment strength for the same column is shown in Figure 11. The axial and
flexural strengths are corresponding to nominal material properties without any strength
reduction or factor.
The compound column element utilizes the cross sectional information and assembles the
column element as an elastic element. We have ensured that the column element always stays
elastic during the analysis by monitoring the axial flexure interaction ratios so that they are
always less than 1.
Beams are modeled in an identical fashion as the columns except that standard W sections are
used. Similar to the columns, the beams are also modeled as elastic elements.

3-6

Figure 10: Column Section Definition in Perform

3-7

Figure 11: Column Strength Definition in Perform

3.2.1.3 Modeling of the Diaphragms at Upper, Ground and Basement Levels


We modeled the diaphragms at all elevated floors as rigid diaphragms.

However, the

diaphragms at the ground and all basement floors were modeled with elastic shell elements with
30% of the gross cross section properties. We considered an effective thickness comprising of
the total thickness of the topping plus half the rib thickness. Thus the ground floor was modeled
as 10.5 in. thick slab as it represents a 9 in. topping and 1.5 in. half rib height. We followed the
same approach for the basement slabs except that that the modulus of elasticity also included
the modifier corresponding to lightweight concrete.
3.2.1.4 Modeling of Perimeter Walls
We modeled the perimeter shear walls as elastic wall elements with cracked stiffness equaling
50% of the gross stiffness. The elastic shear modulus was considered to be 40% of the gross
elastic (Youngs) modulus per ASCE 41, Supplement #1.

3-8

3.2.2

Selected Results from Non Linear Analysis

3.2.2.1 Story Drifts


We present the story drifts from the non linear analysis in Figures 12 and 13. Figure 12 shows
the drift in the Y direction whereas Figure 13 shows the corresponding drift in the X direction.
The maximum drift in the Y direction is around 2.13% while the maximum in the X direction is at
1.80%. As can be observed from the figures, the drifts are less than the permissible value of
3% in both directions and the mean peak drifts are generally on the order of 1.25% or less.

Peak Interstory Drift in Y Direction


40
35
30
25
20
y
r
o
t
S15
10
y

5
0
-5
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

Peak Interstory Drift (%)


Average

Parachute

Denali

Nridge Sylmar CS

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Figure 12: Peak Interstory Drifts in the Y Direction

3-9

Landers Yermo

Kocaeli

Peak Interstory Drift in X Direction


40
35
30

Story

25
20
15
10
5
dx

0
-5
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

Peak Interstory Drift (%)


Average

Parachute

Denali

Nridge Sylmar CS

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Landers Yermo

Kocaeli

Figure 13: Peak Interstory Drifts in the X Direction

3.2.2.2 Buckling Restrained Brace Core Strain


We also monitored strain in the cores of the buckling restrained braces and ensured that the
mean strain is less than of 0.013 (10y) obtained from the test results conducted at the
University of Utah by Romero and Reavely. Figure 14 shows the buckling restrained brace core
strain for lines 2, 3 and 4 respectively. The results are presented as D/C ratio with the capacity
being 0.013. Similar information for line D is presented in Figure 15. The ratios are all less than
unity implying acceptable performance.

3-10

Line 2

Line 3
Line 4
Figure 14: BRBF Core Strain DCRs along Lines 2, 3 and 4

3-11

Figure 15: BRBF Core Strain DCR Along Line D

3-12

3.2.2.3 Column Axial Flexure Interaction Ratio


Figure 16 shows the axial load and flexure interaction ratio for the seismic frame columns along
line E. As can be seen from the figure, the maximum mean interaction ratio is 0.54. The
absolute maximum from the seven analysis is 0.73 signifying elastic behavior of the columns.

Figure 16: Seismic Frame Column Axial Flexure Interaction Ratio along Line E

3-13

3.2.2.4 Story Shears


We also monitored the story shears over the height of the building. Figure 17 and Figure 18 plot
the story shears in the Y direction and X direction respectively. The effect of the stiff ground
floor diaphragms is easily observable form the plots. We have proportioned the ground floor
slab and the collectors so that it is capable of transferring this large reaction.

Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in Y Direction


40

Vy

35
30

Story

25
20
15
10
5
0
-5
0

2500

5000

7500

10000

12500

Accumulated Peak Story Shear (kips)


Average

Parachute

Denali

Nridge Sylmar CS

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Landers Yermo

Kocaeli

Figure 17: Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in Y Direction

3-14

Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in X Direction


40
35
30

Vx

Story

25
20
15
10
5
0
-5
0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

Accumulated Peak Story Shear (kips)


Average

Denali Ps

Landers Yermo

LP Gilroy

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar CS

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Parachute

Figure 18: Accumulated Peak Story Shear in Steel Superstructure in X Direction

3-15

4.

ENHANCED PERFORMANCE BASED DESIGN

We based the seismic design for this alternate on the seismic design criteria provided to us by
PEER. The following table shows summary of the criteria for this design.
Table 7 Seismic Performance Objectives
Level of Earthquake

Earthquake Performance Objectives

Frequent/Service : 43 year return period, 2.5%


damping

Serviceability: Drift limited to 0.5%. Demand


capacity ratio for buckling restrained braces not to
exceed 1.5.

Maximum Considered Earthquake (MCE): As


defined by ASCE 7-05, Section 21.2, 2.5%
damping.

Collapse Prevention: Extensive structural damage,


repairs are required and may not be economically
feasible. Drift limited to 3%

4.1

Service Level Earthquake Evaluation

We used a response spectrum provided to us by PEER for this evaluation. We observed that
using the BRB sizes from the Performance Based Alternate caused overstress in some of the
braces. This was particularly severe along the longitudinal direction of the building. As a result
we had to upsize some of the braces. Additionally, we had to use an outrigger that projected
out form the core on lines 2 and 7. This outrigger was provided at the roof, the 30th floor and the
20th floor. Figure 19 shows the response spectrum used for the evaluation and Figure 20 shows
the 3D view of the computer model along with the outriggers.

Spectral Acceleration, Sa (g)

0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0

Period (sec)

Figure 19: Response Spectrum for Enhanced PBE

4-1

Outrigger

Figure 20: 3D Computer Model used for the Enhanced Performance Based Evaluation

Table 8 shows the drifts from the service level evaluation along the transverse and longitudinal
directions of the building. As can be observed, the drifts are all less than the 0.5% limit.

4-2

Table 8 Story Drifts for Service Level Earthquake


Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 40

0.0031

0.0022

Story 39

0.0042

0.0024

Story 38

0.0047

0.0026

Story 37

0.0048

0.0027

Story 36

0.0049

0.0028

Story 35

0.0049

0.0029

Story 34

0.0049

0.0029

Story 33

0.0049

0.0029

Story 32

0.0049

0.0029

Story 31

0.0046

0.0030

Story 30

0.0034

0.0029

Story 29

0.0045

0.0029

Story 28

0.0047

0.0029

Story 27

0.0046

0.0029

Story 26

0.0046

0.0029

Story 25

0.0045

0.0028

Story 24

0.0044

0.0028

Story 23

0.0043

0.0028

Story 22

0.0041

0.0027

Story 21

0.0037

0.0027

Story 20

0.0029

0.0027

Story 19

0.0035

0.0027

Story 18

0.0037

0.0026

4-3

4.1

Story

Y Direction Drifts

X Direction Drifts

Story 17

0.0037

0.0026

Story 16

0.0036

0.0026

Story 15

0.0036

0.0026

Story 14

0.0035

0.0025

Story 13

0.0034

0.0025

Story 12

0.0033

0.0025

Story 11

0.0032

0.0025

Story 10

0.0031

0.0025

Story 9

0.0030

0.0025

Story 8

0.0030

0.0025

Story 7

0.0029

0.0025

Story 6

0.0028

0.0025

Story 5

0.0027

0.0025

Story 4

0.0025

0.0024

Story 3

0.0024

0.0023

Story 2

0.0021

0.0021

Story 1

0.0014

0.0014

Maximum Considered Earthquake Evaluation

We used the same time histories and modeling assumptions as presented earlier in the
Performance Based Evaluation section. Figure 21 shows the drift in the Y direction whereas
Figure 22 shows the corresponding drift in the X direction. The maximum drift in the Y direction
is around 1.33% while the maximum in the X direction is at 1.42%. As can be observed from
the figures, the drifts are less than the permissible value of 3% in both directions and the mean
peak drifts are generally on the order of 1.0% or less.

4-4

Peak Interstory Drift in Y Direction


40
35
30

Story

25
20
15
10
dy

5
0
-5
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

Peak Interstory Drift (%)


Average

Parachute

Denali

Nridge Sylmar CS

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Figure 21: Peak Interstory Drifts in the Y Direction

4-5

Landers Yermo

Kocaeli

Peak Interstory Drift in X Direction


40
35
30

Story

25
20
15
10
5
dx

0
-5
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

Peak Interstory Drift (%)


Average

Parachute

Denali

Nridge Sylmar CS

LP Saratoga

Nridge Sylmar Hosp

Landers Yermo

Kocaeli

Figure 22: Peak Interstory Drifts in the X Direction

We also examined the strains in the buckling restrained braces and the axial moment interaction
in the columns. In general they followed the same trend as the earlier Performance Based
Evaluation with the maximum strain demand capacity ratio of 0.58. The maximum demand
capacity ratio for the column was around 0.75.

4-6

APPENDIX A

A1
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.00

DATE

11/26/08

CLIENT

CSSC

BY

SUBJECT

LA BRBF Building, LA, CA

CHECKED BY

AD
ROH

ROOF FLAT LOADS

ROOF

Level

Material

Roof
"
"
"

Roofing
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
20 Ga. Metal deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frame
Partitions
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

"
"
"
"
"

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

5.0
48.5
3.0

5.0
48.5
3.0

2.0
2.0

2.0
2.0

5.0
48.5
3.0
5.0
2.0
2.0

5.0
48.5
3.0
5.0
2.0
2.0
1.5

19.0
79.5
25.0
104.5

19.0
79.5
25.0
104.5

19.0
92.5
25.0
117.5

5.0
48.5
3.0
5.0
2.0
2.0
1.5
8.0
5.0
14.0
94.0
94.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

11.5
1.0
96.0
40.0
136.0

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.0
11.5
1.0
88.0
88.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

15.0
1.0
99.5
40.0
139.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
15.0
1.0
92.0
92.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

8.0

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

Beam weight calculated by RAM


Ceiling mounted

19.0
86.0
25.0
111.0

TYPICAL FLOORS 39th THROUGH 33rd

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.0

Ceiling mounted

1.0
81.5
40.0
121.5

```

TYPICAL FLOORS 32nd THROUGH 28th

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

sheet: SteelRaisedFlr
file: Flat Loading

Remarks

Page 1 of 4

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5
1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

Ceiling mounted

```

4:23 PM
2/11/2009

A2
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.00

DATE
CLIENT

CSSC

BY

LA BRBF Building, LA, CA


FLOOR FLAT LOADS

SUBJECT

ROH

TYPICAL FLOORS 27th THROUGH 24th


Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

19.0
1.0
103.5
40.0
143.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
19.0
1.0
96.0
96.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

24.5
1.0
109.0
40.0
149.0

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
3.0
24.5
1.0
102.0
102.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous

2.0
3.0

2.0
3.0

2.0
3.0

2.0
3.0
2.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

30.0
1.0
114.5
40.0
154.5

2.0
3.0
2.5
30.0
1.0
107.0
107.0

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

FLOOR FLAT LOADS


Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

FLOOR FLAT LOADS


Level

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5

Ceiling mounted

1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

```

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0

Ceiling mounted

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

```

TYPICAL FLOORS 19th THROUGH 15th


Material

Sum of Dead Loads


Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

sheet: SteelRaisedFlr
file: Flat Loading

Remarks

TYPICAL FLOORS 23rd THROUGH 20th

Level

"
"
"
"
"

AD

CHECKED BY

Slab
(psf)

Level

Floor
"
"
"
"

11/26/08

Page 2 of 4

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

Ceiling mounted

```

4:23 PM
2/11/2009

A3
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.00

DATE
CLIENT

CSSC

11/26/08

BY

LA BRBF Building, LA, CA


FLOOR FLAT LOADS

SUBJECT

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

AD

CHECKED BY

ROH

TYPICAL FLOORS 14th THROUGH 10th


Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

38.0
1.0
122.5
40.0
162.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
38.0
1.0
115.0
115.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
55.0
134.5

1.0
79.5
55.0
134.5

43.0
1.0
127.5
55.0
182.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
43.0
1.0
120.0
120.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

50.0
1.0
134.5
40.0
174.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
50.0
1.0
127.0
127.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5

Ceiling mounted

1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

```

TYPICAL FLOORS 9th THROUGH 5th

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5
1.0
82.0
55.0
137.0

Ceiling mounted

```
Includes 15 psf partition loading

TYPICAL FLOORS 4th THROUGH 2nd

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

sheet: SteelRaisedFlr
file: Flat Loading

Remarks

Page 3 of 4

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5
1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

Ceiling mounted

```

4:23 PM
2/11/2009

A4
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

CSSC

11/26/08

BY

LA BRBF Building, LA, CA


FLOOR FLAT LOADS

SUBJECT

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
20 Ga. Metal deck
3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

087237.00

AD

CHECKED BY

ROH

1ST FLOOR
Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
2.0
3.0

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

1.0
79.5
40.0
119.5

60.0
1.0
144.5
40.0
184.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0
2.5
60.0
1.0
137.0
137.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
48.5
5.0
2.0
3.0

1.0
82.0
40.0
122.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

20.0
2.0
3.0
127.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
127.0
2.0
3.0

83.0
220.0
100.0
320.0

83.0
220.0
100.0
320.0

27.5
83.0
255.5
100.0
355.5

10.0
2.0
3.0
127.0
8.0
2.0
3.0
3.0
27.5
83.0
258.5
258.5

20.0
2.0
3.0
127.0

2.0
3.0

20.0
2.0
3.0
127.0
8.0
2.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

347.0
3.0
127.0

347.0
3.0
127.0
3.0

0.0
480.0
100.0
580.0

0.0
480.0
100.0
580.0

27.5
0.0
515.5
100.0
615.5

347.0
3.0
127.0
8.0
3.0
3.0
27.5
0.0
518.5
518.5

347.0
3.0
127.0

3.0

347.0
3.0
127.0
8.0
3.0

Slab
(psf)

Beam
(psf)

Cols
(psf)

Seismic
(psf)

Gr. Cols
(psf)

3.0
48.5

3.0
48.5
3.0

23.0

3.0
48.5
6.0
3.0
2.5
23.0

3.0
48.5

3.0

3.0
48.5
6.0
3.0

83.5
40.0
123.5

86.0
86.0

57.0
40.0
97.0

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
2.5

Ceiling mounted

```

GROUND FLOOR INSIDE CORE

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Partitions
Carpet floor finish
18 Ga. Metal deck
9" Nwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
Drop ceiling
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

2.0
3.0
3.0

Ceiling mounted

83.0
223.0
100.0
323.0

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

GROUND FLOOR PLAZA

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"
"

Plant beds etc.


18 Ga. Metal deck
9" Nwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

3.0
3.0

Ceiling mounted

0.0
483.0
100.0
583.0

FLOOR FLAT LOADS

BASEMENT

Level

Material

Floor
"
"
"
"
"
"

18 Ga. Metal deck


3-1/4" Ltwt. conc. over 3" mtl deck
Struct. Steel framing
MEP
Gravity columns
Seismic Frames
Miscellaneous
Sum of Dead Loads
Sum of Live Loads
Sum of Dead Plus Live Loads

sheet: SteelRaisedFlr
file: Flat Loading

54.5
40.0
94.5

54.5
40.0
94.5

Page 4 of 4

Remarks

Beam weight calculated by RAM

3.0
2.5

Ceiling mounted

4:23 PM
2/11/2009

A5

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT
SUBJECT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center


Gust Effect Factor in Short Normal Dir. for LA BRBF Bldg

Exposure =
Basic Wind Speed (V) =
h (Mean Roof Height) =
z-bar =
a-bar =
b-bar =
l=
e-bar =
n1 =
B=
L=
b=
gQ =
gv =
c=

BY

1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

B
85.00
544.50
326.70
0.25
0.45
320.00
0.33
0.25
107.00
170.00
0.01
3.40
3.40
0.30

mph
ft
ft
(Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
ft (Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
Hz
ft
ft
Damping
(Cl 6.5.8.2)
(Cl 6.5.8.2)
(Table 6-2)

Vz-bar =
Lz-bar=
N1 =
hh =
hB =
hL =
Rh =
RB =
RL =
Rn =
R=
gR =
Iz-bar=
Q=
Gf =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: Gf-SNorm

99.51 ft/s (Eq. 6-14)


687.11
1.73
6.29
1.24
6.58
0.15
0.51
0.14
0.10
0.65
3.84
0.20
0.79
0.97

4:26 PM
2/11/2009

A6
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

CLIENT
SUBJECT

Parapet Tip Height =


GCpn =

Elevation (z)

0
15
20
25
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
120
140
160
180
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550

B
85
1
1200
7
0.85
544.5
0.8
0.18
-0.18
551
1.5

mph (Fig 6-1)


(Table 1-1, 6-1)
ft (Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
(Table 6-4)
ft
(Fig 6-6)
(Fig 6-5 for Encl. Bldg.)
(Fig 6-5 for Encl. Bldg.)
ft
(6.5.12.2.4)

1/23/09

BY

Wind Pressures In Short Normal Direction for LA BRBF Bldg

Exposure :
Basic Wind Speed (V):
Importance Factor (I) :
zg =
a=
Kd =
h (Mean roof Height) =
Cp(windward) =
GCpi =

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

Topographic Factor
K1 =
K2 =
K3 =
Kzt =
Gf =
qh =

0
0
0
1
0.97
25.2

(Fig 6-4)
(Fig 6-4)
(Fig 6-4)

Parapet Pressure
Kz-parapet=
qz=qp =
pp =

psf

Main Wind Force Resisting System


Windward Pr.
Internal Pressure
Positive
Negative

Kz

qz

107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107

170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170

0.5747
0.57
0.62
0.67
0.70
0.76
0.81
0.85
0.89
0.93
0.96
0.99
1.04
1.09
1.13
1.17
1.20
1.28
1.35
1.41
1.47
1.52
1.57
1.61

9.04
9.04
9.81
10.46
11.01
11.96
12.75
13.43
14.03
14.58
15.08
15.54
16.37
17.10
17.77
18.38
18.94
20.19
21.27
22.22
23.09
23.88
24.61
25.29

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: ShortNormal

6.98
6.98
7.58
8.08
8.51
9.24
9.84
10.37
10.84
11.26
11.64
12.00
12.64
13.21
13.73
14.19
14.63
15.59
16.43
17.17
17.83
18.44
19.01
19.53

1.61 (Case 1 Table 6-3)


25.3
37.9 psf

4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54

-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54

Leeward Pr.

-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30

4:27 PM 2/11/2009

A7
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT
SUBJECT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center


Story Wind Forces in Short Normal Dir. for LA BRBF Bldg

BY =

107 ft

eY =

16.05 ft

Floor
Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

BY

Height
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

Cum Ht.
544.5
531
517.5
504
490.5
477
463.5
450
436.5
423
409.5
396
382.5
369
355.5
342
328.5
315
301.5
288
274.5
261
247.5
234
220.5
207
193.5
180
166.5
153
139.5
126
112.5
99
85.5
72
58.5
45
31.5
18
0

Wind Pressure
Windward
Leeward
19.47
19.33
19.19
19.05
18.90
18.75
18.60
18.44
18.28
18.11
17.95
17.78
17.60
17.42
17.24
17.05
16.85
16.65
16.45
16.23
16.00
15.78
15.54
15.28
15.02
14.76
14.49
14.19
13.88
13.55
13.20
12.81
12.40
11.96
11.47
10.92
10.29
9.54
8.62
7.34
6.98

-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30
-9.30

S=

Story Force
(KIPS)
41.58
41.37
41.17
40.96
40.75
40.53
40.31
40.09
39.85
39.61
39.37
39.13
38.87
38.61
38.35
38.07
37.78
37.49
37.20
36.88
36.56
36.23
35.90
35.52
35.15
34.77
34.37
33.95
33.49
33.01
32.51
31.95
31.36
30.73
30.02
29.22
28.31
27.23
25.89
32.06
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

MT
(KIP-IN)
8008.31
7967.87
7929.35
7888.90
7848.45
7806.08
7763.71
7721.34
7675.11
7628.89
7582.67
7536.44
7486.37
7436.29
7386.21
7332.29
7276.43
7220.58
7164.72
7103.09
7041.46
6977.90
6914.34
6841.16
6769.89
6696.71
6619.67
6538.77
6450.18
6357.73
6261.43
6153.57
6039.94
5918.60
5781.86
5627.78
5452.51
5244.50
4986.42
6174.76
0.00

1436.20

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: ShortNormStForce

4:28 PM 2/11/2009

A8

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT
SUBJECT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center


Gust Effect Factor in Long Normal Dir. for LA BRBF Bldg

Exposure =
Basic Wind Speed (V) =
h (Mean Roof Height) =
z-bar =
a-bar =
b-bar =
l=
e-bar =
n1 =
B=
L=
b=
gQ =
gv =
c=

BY

1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

B
85.00
544.50
326.70
0.25
0.45
320.00
0.33
0.20
170.00
107.00
0.01
3.40
3.40
0.30

mph
ft
ft
(Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
ft (Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
Hz
ft
ft
Damping
(Cl 6.5.8.2)
(Cl 6.5.8.2)
(Table 6-2)

Vz-bar =
Lz-bar=
N1 =
hh =
hB =
hL =
Rh =
RB =
RL =
Rn =
R=
gR =
Iz-bar=
Q=
Gf =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: Gf-LNorm

99.51 ft/s (Eq. 6-14)


687.11
1.38
5.03
1.57
3.31
0.18
0.44
0.26
0.11
0.75
3.79
0.20
0.78
1.00

4:29 PM
2/11/2009

A9
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

CLIENT
SUBJECT

Parapet Tip Height =


GCpn =

Elevation (z)

0
15
20
25
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
120
140
160
180
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550

B
85
1
1200
7
0.85
544.4
0.8
0.18
-0.18
551
1.5

mph (Fig 6-1)


(Table 1-1, 6-1)
ft (Table 6-2)
(Table 6-2)
(Table 6-4)
ft
(Fig 6-6)
(Fig 6-5 for Encl. Bldg.)
(Fig 6-5 for Encl. Bldg.)
ft
(6.5.12.2.4)

1/23/09

BY

Wind Pressures In Long Normal Direction for LA BRBF Bldg

Exposure :
Basic Wind Speed (V):
Importance Factor (I) :
zg =
a=
Kd =
h (Mean roof Height) =
Cp(windward) =
GCpi =

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

Topographic Factor
K1 =
K2 =
K3 =
Kzt =
Gf =
qh =

0
0
0
1
1.00
25.2

(Fig 6-4)
(Fig 6-4)
(Fig 6-4)

Parapet Pressure
Kz-parapet=
qz=qp =
pp =

psf

Main Wind Force Resisting System


Windward Pr.
Internal Pressure
Positive
Negative

Kz

qz

170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170
170

107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107
107

0.57
0.57
0.62
0.67
0.70
0.76
0.81
0.85
0.89
0.93
0.96
0.99
1.04
1.09
1.13
1.17
1.20
1.28
1.35
1.41
1.47
1.52
1.57
1.61

9.04
9.04
9.81
10.46
11.01
11.96
12.75
13.43
14.03
14.58
15.08
15.54
16.37
17.10
17.77
18.38
18.94
20.19
21.27
22.22
23.09
23.88
24.61
25.29

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: LongNormal

7.20
7.20
7.82
8.34
8.78
9.53
10.16
10.70
11.19
11.62
12.02
12.39
13.05
13.64
14.17
14.65
15.10
16.09
16.95
17.72
18.41
19.04
19.62
20.16

1.61 (Case 1 Table 6-3)


25.3
37.9 psf

4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54
4.54

-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54
-4.54

Leeward Pr.

-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56

4:29 PM 2/11/2009

A10
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT
SUBJECT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center


Story Wind Forces in Long Normal Dir. for LA BRBF Bldg

BY =

170 ft

eY =

25.5 ft

Floor
Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

BY

Height
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

Cum Ht.
544.5
531
517.5
504
490.5
477
463.5
450
436.5
423
409.5
396
382.5
369
355.5
342
328.5
315
301.5
288
274.5
261
247.5
234
220.5
207
193.5
180
166.5
153
139.5
126
112.5
99
85.5
72
58.5
45
31.5
18
0

Wind Pressure
Windward
Leeward
20.10
19.95
19.81
19.66
19.51
19.35
19.19
19.04
18.87
18.70
18.53
18.35
18.16
17.98
17.79
17.60
17.39
17.18
16.98
16.75
16.51
16.28
16.04
15.78
15.51
15.24
14.95
14.65
14.32
13.98
13.62
13.23
12.80
12.35
11.84
11.27
10.62
9.85
8.89
7.57
7.20

-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56
-12.56

S=

Story Force
(KIPS)
74.96
74.63
74.29
73.96
73.60
73.24
72.88
72.52
72.13
71.74
71.35
70.95
70.52
70.10
69.67
69.21
68.74
68.27
67.80
67.27
66.74
66.20
65.65
65.04
64.42
63.81
63.15
62.46
61.71
60.92
60.10
59.19
58.21
57.18
56.01
54.71
53.21
51.43
49.25
61.62
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

MT
(KIP-IN)
22937.76
22836.78
22732.74
22631.76
22521.60
22411.44
22301.28
22191.12
22071.78
21952.44
21833.10
21710.70
21579.12
21450.60
21319.02
21178.26
21034.44
20890.62
20746.80
20584.62
20422.44
20257.20
20088.90
19902.24
19712.52
19525.86
19323.90
19112.76
18883.26
18641.52
18390.60
18112.14
17812.26
17497.08
17139.06
16741.26
16282.26
15737.58
15070.50
18855.72
0.00

2628.84

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\ASCE7-05Wind Loading


Page 1 of 1
sheet: LongNormStForce

4:30 PM 2/11/2009

A11
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT
SUBJECT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

Mode

Period
(second)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50

5.05
3.62
3.53
1.38
1.19
1.15
0.72
0.65
0.64
0.47
0.44
0.44
0.35
0.34
0.33
0.27
0.27
0.26
0.23
0.23
0.21
0.19
0.19
0.18
0.17
0.17
0.16
0.15
0.15
0.14
0.13
0.13
0.13
0.12
0.12
0.12
0.11
0.11
0.11
0.11
0.11
0.10
0.10
0.10
0.09
0.09
0.09
0.09
0.09
0.08

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Modal Info


sheet: SGH Portrait

Perticipation Factor
Ux
Uy
0.00
43.98
0.00
0.00
10.99
0.00
0.00
3.32
0.00
0.00
1.71
0.00
0.00
1.19
0.00
0.89
0.00
0.00
0.79
0.00
0.00
0.74
0.00
0.00
0.85
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.00
0.00
1.43
0.00
0.00
2.55
0.00
0.00
6.45
0.00
0.00
10.94
0.00
5.31
0.00
0.00
1.74
0.00
0.00
0.57
0.00
0.00

Page 1 of 1

1/23/09

BY

Modal Information for Code Elastic Model of LA BRBF Bldg

34.40
0.00
0.00
15.06
0.00
0.00
6.71
0.00
0.00
2.90
0.00
0.00
1.51
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.11
0.00
0.00
1.17
0.00
0.00
1.16
0.00
0.00
1.15
0.00
1.36
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.41
0.00
0.00
3.32
0.00
0.00
7.95
0.00
0.00
9.10
0.00
3.88
0.00
0.00
1.65
0.00
0.00
0.68
0.00

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

S Participation Factor
Ux
Uy
0.00
43.98
43.98
43.98
54.96
54.96
54.96
58.28
58.28
58.28
59.99
59.99
59.99
61.18
61.18
62.06
62.06
62.06
62.85
62.85
62.85
63.59
63.59
63.59
64.44
64.44
64.44
64.44
65.45
65.45
66.88
66.88
66.88
69.43
69.43
69.43
75.88
75.88
75.88
86.82
86.82
92.13
92.13
92.13
93.87
93.87
93.87
94.44
94.44
94.44

34.40
34.40
34.40
49.46
49.46
49.46
56.17
56.17
56.17
59.07
59.07
59.07
60.58
60.58
60.58
60.58
61.70
61.70
61.70
62.86
62.86
62.86
64.02
64.02
64.02
65.17
65.17
66.53
66.53
66.53
66.53
67.95
67.95
67.95
71.26
71.26
71.26
79.21
79.21
79.21
88.32
88.32
92.20
92.20
92.20
93.85
93.85
93.85
94.53
94.53

4:31 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE

1/23/09

CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

BY

SUBJECT

Story Forces for Code Elastic Model of LA BRBF Bldg

CHECKED BY

V=
k=
SDS =

A12

AD

0.04335 W<-----(85% of Static Base Shear)


2
1.145

SD1 =

0.52

Floor

Height

Cumu Ht

Area

Perimeter

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
0
0
0
0

544.5
531
517.5
504
490.5
477
463.5
450
436.5
423
409.5
396
382.5
369
355.5
342
328.5
315
301.5
288
274.5
261
247.5
234
220.5
207
193.5
180
166.5
153
139.5
126
112.5
99
85.5
72
58.5
45
31.5
18
0
0
0
0

18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
18190
49940
49940
49940
49940

554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554
554

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Preliminary BRBF Sizing


sheet: SGH Portrait

Seismic
Flat Load
(psf)
94
88
88
88
88
88
88
88
92
92
92
92
92
96
96
96
96
102
102
102
102
107
107
107
107
107
115
115
115
115
115
120
120
120
120
120
127
127
127
137
506.85
86
86
86

Seismic
Line Load
(kip/ft)
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.203
0.233

Addl.
Loading
(kips)
100

Total Wt.

wi*hi^k

Cvx

1922.32
1713.18
1713.18
1713.18
1713.18
1713.18
1713.18
1713.18
1785.94
1785.94
1785.94
1785.94
1785.94
1858.70
1858.70
1858.70
1858.70
1967.84
1967.84
1967.84
1967.84
2058.79
2058.79
2058.79
2058.79
2058.79
2204.31
2204.31
2204.31
2204.31
2204.31
2295.26
2295.26
2295.26
2295.26
2295.26
2422.59
2422.59
2422.59
2621.11
25312.09
4294.84
4294.84
4294.84
80831.20

569930507.1
483050509.9
458800847
435175638.9
412174885.7
389798587.3
368046743.7
346919355
340279547.6
319556816.1
299485060.5
280064280.7
261294476.7
253082723
234903223.4
217401220.7
200576714.9
195259122.5
178881265.4
163220686.8
148277386.7
140246969.8
126113877.5
112731214.8
100098981.7
88217178.41
82534400.98
71419708.8
61108488.34
51600739.61
42896462.6
36439579.51
29049409.69
22495862.86
16778939.04
11898638.21
8290715.472
4905748.8
2403816.912
849240.288
0
0
0
0
7566259573.01

0.0753
0.0638
0.0606
0.0575
0.0545
0.0515
0.0486
0.0459
0.0450
0.0422
0.0396
0.0370
0.0345
0.0334
0.0310
0.0287
0.0265
0.0258
0.0236
0.0216
0.0196
0.0185
0.0167
0.0149
0.0132
0.0117
0.0109
0.0094
0.0081
0.0068
0.0057
0.0048
0.0038
0.0030
0.0022
0.0016
0.0011
0.0006
0.0003
0.0001
0.0000
0.0000
0
0.0000

Page 1 of 1

Equivalent Force
Fx
Vx
(kips)
(kips)
263.94
223.71
212.48
201.54
190.88
180.52
170.45
160.66
157.59
147.99
138.70
129.70
121.01
117.21
108.79
100.68
92.89
90.43
82.84
75.59
68.67
64.95
58.40
52.21
46.36
40.85
38.22
33.08
28.30
23.90
19.87
16.88
13.45
10.42
7.77
5.51
3.84
2.27
1.11
0.39
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
3504.03

263.94
487.65
700.13
901.66
1092.54
1273.07
1443.51
1604.18
1761.76
1909.75
2048.45
2178.15
2299.16
2416.37
2525.15
2625.83
2718.72
2809.15
2891.99
2967.58
3036.25
3101.20
3159.61
3211.81
3258.17
3299.03
3337.25
3370.32
3398.62
3422.52
3442.39
3459.26
3472.72
3483.13
3490.90
3496.41
3500.25
3502.53
3503.64
3504.03

Fpx
(kips)
Eq(12.10-1)
263.94
229.80
224.25
218.74
213.30
207.95
202.68
197.51
200.40
195.05
189.83
184.73
179.75
181.81
176.70
171.73
166.89
171.43
166.33
161.40
156.61
158.79
153.90
149.17
144.61
140.20
145.24
140.56
136.07
131.75
127.60
128.56
124.43
120.49
116.72
113.12
115.58
111.96
108.53
113.63

Diaphragm Design Force


Fpx
Fpx
(kips)
(kips)
Minimum
Maximum
440.21
880.42
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
392.32
784.64
408.98
817.96
408.98
817.96
408.98
817.96
408.98
817.96
408.98
817.96
425.64
851.29
425.64
851.29
425.64
851.29
425.64
851.29
450.64
901.27
450.64
901.27
450.64
901.27
450.64
901.27
471.46
942.93
471.46
942.93
471.46
942.93
471.46
942.93
471.46
942.93
504.79
1009.57
504.79
1009.57
504.79
1009.57
504.79
1009.57
504.79
1009.57
525.61
1051.23
525.61
1051.23
525.61
1051.23
525.61
1051.23
525.61
1051.23
554.77
1109.55
554.77
1109.55
554.77
1109.55
600.23
1200.47

Fpx
(kips)
Adopted
440.21
392.32
392.32
392.32
392.32
392.32
392.32
392.32
408.98
408.98
408.98
408.98
408.98
425.64
425.64
425.64
425.64
450.64
450.64
450.64
450.64
471.46
471.46
471.46
471.46
471.46
504.79
504.79
504.79
504.79
504.79
525.61
525.61
525.61
525.61
525.61
554.77
554.77
554.77
600.23

4:32 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

AD

CHECKED BY

X Direction Motion
Case:

1/23/09

BY

Redundancy Calculation for LA BRBF Bldg

A13

087237.10

Model:

121908Model1Rddn_X

EQXPL

Case:

EQXMN

Story

Height

Point

Disp

Drift

Point

Disp

Drift

Max/Avg-Drift

Verdict

Story

Height

Point

Disp

Drift

Point

Disp

Drift

Max/Avg-Drift

Verdict

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground

13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
0

52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52

18.981
18.608
18.198
17.750
17.293
16.809
16.305
15.819
15.319
14.803
14.279
13.772
13.260
12.739
12.207
11.674
11.158
10.642
10.123
9.603
9.082
8.560
8.039
7.520
7.004
6.493
5.987
5.487
4.993
4.507
4.026
3.545
3.074
2.616
2.172
1.745
1.336
0.951
0.598
0.291
0.023

0.372
0.411
0.447
0.457
0.484
0.504
0.486
0.500
0.516
0.524
0.507
0.512
0.521
0.532
0.533
0.517
0.516
0.519
0.520
0.521
0.522
0.521
0.519
0.516
0.511
0.506
0.500
0.494
0.486
0.481
0.481
0.471
0.458
0.443
0.427
0.409
0.385
0.354
0.306
0.268
0.023

54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54

23.401
22.821
22.207
21.559
20.899
20.214
19.509
18.820
18.120
17.408
16.688
15.992
15.296
14.599
13.904
13.215
12.546
11.885
11.230
10.580
9.937
9.300
8.672
8.054
7.447
6.850
6.265
5.692
5.133
4.591
4.068
3.571
3.090
2.624
2.175
1.742
1.330
0.944
0.590
0.286
0.023

0.580
0.615
0.648
0.660
0.684
0.705
0.689
0.700
0.713
0.720
0.696
0.696
0.697
0.695
0.689
0.669
0.661
0.655
0.650
0.644
0.637
0.628
0.618
0.608
0.596
0.585
0.573
0.559
0.543
0.523
0.497
0.481
0.466
0.450
0.432
0.412
0.387
0.354
0.305
0.263
0.023

1.218
1.199
1.18
1.18
1.17
1.17
1.17
1.17
1.16
1.16
1.16
1.15
1.14
1.13
1.13
1.13
1.12
1.12
1.11
1.11
1.10
1.09
1.09
1.08
1.08
1.07
1.07
1.06
1.05
1.04
1.02
1.01
1.01
1.01
1.01
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.01
1.01

Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground

13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
0

52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52
52

15.793
15.522
15.219
14.883
14.540
14.176
13.791
13.424
13.047
12.655
12.254
11.870
11.481
11.081
10.665
10.246
9.842
9.436
9.022
8.604
8.183
7.758
7.327
6.895
6.463
6.032
5.603
5.176
4.751
4.327
3.894
3.432
2.974
2.529
2.098
1.683
1.287
0.914
0.573
0.278
0.023

0.270
0.303
0.336
0.342
0.364
0.385
0.367
0.377
0.392
0.401
0.384
0.389
0.399
0.416
0.419
0.405
0.406
0.413
0.418
0.421
0.425
0.431
0.432
0.432
0.431
0.429
0.427
0.425
0.424
0.433
0.462
0.458
0.445
0.431
0.415
0.396
0.373
0.341
0.295
0.256
0.023

54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54
54

28.202
27.461
26.680
25.860
25.023
24.157
23.270
22.398
21.513
20.613
19.709
18.830
17.953
17.076
16.209
15.351
14.517
13.694
12.883
12.083
11.292
10.514
9.754
9.009
8.280
7.568
6.873
6.196
5.539
4.908
4.314
3.778
3.267
2.772
2.297
1.840
1.405
0.998
0.625
0.303
0.023

0.740
0.781
0.820
0.837
0.866
0.887
0.873
0.885
0.899
0.904
0.879
0.877
0.877
0.867
0.858
0.835
0.822
0.811
0.801
0.790
0.778
0.761
0.745
0.729
0.712
0.695
0.677
0.657
0.631
0.594
0.536
0.511
0.494
0.476
0.457
0.435
0.408
0.373
0.322
0.280
0.023

1.465
1.441
1.418
1.419
1.408
1.395
1.408
1.402
1.393
1.386
1.391
1.385
1.374
1.351
1.344
1.347
1.339
1.325
1.314
1.305
1.294
1.277
1.266
1.256
1.246
1.236
1.226
1.215
1.196
1.157
1.074
1.055
1.052
1.049
1.048
1.046
1.045
1.044
1.044
1.045
1.011

Extr Tor Irr


Extr Tor Irr
Extr Tor Irr
Extr Tor Irr
Extr Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Extr Tor Irr
Extr Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr
No Tor Irr

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Redundancy
sheet: TorIrrg

Page 2 of 2

4:41 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)


11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

A14

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindMTX
5.15
3.57
2.42
1.40
-0.06
-0.87
-1.40
-3.00
-4.56
-4.81
-5.33
-6.83
-8.03
-12.25
-13.58
-14.75
-16.41
-19.97
-22.03
-23.92
-25.21
-31.75
-33.30
-35.55
-38.35
-40.48
-43.13
-45.20
-44.04
-30.69
4.31
5.86
2.62
0.08
-2.71
-5.36
-7.73
-9.60
-10.94
-8.70
4.98
3.32
1.61
-0.13

WindMTX
-5.15
-3.57
-2.42
-1.40
0.06
0.87
1.40
3.00
4.56
4.81
5.33
6.83
8.03
12.25
13.58
14.75
16.41
19.97
22.03
23.92
25.21
31.75
33.30
35.55
38.35
40.48
43.13
45.20
44.04
30.69
-4.31
-5.86
-2.62
-0.08
2.71
5.36
7.73
9.60
10.94
8.70
-4.98
-3.32
-1.61
0.13

WindMTX
-46.26
-35.54
-33.30
-33.78
-32.99
-32.46
-32.21
-31.74
-30.96
-25.54
0.80
0.54
0.19
-0.20

WindFY
6.82
13.70
19.54
26.19
31.30
40.30
44.44
50.40
54.49
52.05
56.61
62.85
67.47
110.39
116.82
126.40
135.74
165.11
176.00
184.25
191.83
250.74
258.09
269.41
286.04
297.65
313.02
323.11
312.55
238.17
33.28
17.60
33.18
46.56
62.17
76.94
89.32
97.13
98.63
70.14
-32.99
-22.92
-9.90
4.43

WindFY
-6.82
-13.70
-19.54
-26.19
-31.30
-40.30
-44.44
-50.40
-54.49
-52.05
-56.61
-62.85
-67.47
-110.39
-116.82
-126.40
-135.74
-165.11
-176.00
-184.25
-191.83
-250.74
-258.09
-269.41
-286.04
-297.65
-313.02
-323.11
-312.55
-238.17
-33.28
-17.60
-33.18
-46.56
-62.17
-76.94
-89.32
-97.13
-98.63
-70.14
32.99
22.92
9.90
-4.43

WindFY
464.01
371.82
338.26
336.90
320.87
307.38
296.63
282.65
263.12
203.71
0.36
-0.80
1.49
5.26

WindMTY
14.84
10.31
7.00
4.08
-0.10
-2.42
-3.94
-8.53
-13.02
-13.75
-15.25
-19.55
-23.01
-35.16
-38.99
-42.38
-47.16
-57.42
-63.39
-68.85
-72.60
-91.48
-96.00
-102.51
-110.63
-116.84
-124.55
-130.58
-127.31
-88.89
12.18
16.64
7.27
-0.06
-8.14
-15.82
-22.67
-28.08
-31.97
-25.44
14.34
9.56
4.64
-0.37

WindMTY
-14.84
-10.31
-7.00
-4.08
0.10
2.42
3.94
8.53
13.02
13.75
15.25
19.55
23.01
35.16
38.99
42.38
47.16
57.42
63.39
68.85
72.60
91.48
96.00
102.51
110.63
116.84
124.55
130.58
127.31
88.89
-12.18
-16.64
-7.27
0.06
8.14
15.82
22.67
28.08
31.97
25.44
-14.34
-9.56
-4.64
0.37

WindMTY
-133.49
-102.65
-96.23
-97.68
-95.45
-93.97
-93.32
-92.02
-89.84
-74.20
2.33
1.57
0.56
-0.57

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.6

-1.6

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 4

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

-3.0
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.1
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6

-3.0
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.1
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6

7.9
18.9
28.2
38.8
47.0
61.2
67.8
77.3
83.8
79.9
87.1
97.1
104.4
173.1
183.4
198.6
213.6
260.6
278.0
291.3
303.4
397.6
409.4
427.5
454.1
472.8
497.3
513.4
496.5
377.6
49.8
24.8
49.7
71.1
96.1
119.7
139.4
152.0
154.4
108.9
-56.4
-40.3
-19.5
3.4

-13.9
-24.9
-34.3
-45.0
-53.2
-67.8
-74.4
-84.0
-90.6
-86.7
-94.0
-104.0
-111.5
-180.1
-190.5
-205.8
-220.8
-267.8
-285.2
-298.3
-310.5
-404.7
-416.5
-434.6
-461.2
-479.7
-504.3
-520.5
-503.6
-384.6
-56.7
-31.6
-56.5
-77.9
-102.9
-126.5
-146.4
-158.8
-161.2
-115.5
49.1
33.1
12.2
-10.7

5.2
13.4
20.4
28.4
34.5
45.1
50.0
57.1
62.0
59.0
64.5
71.9
77.4
128.9
136.6
148.1
159.3
194.5
207.6
217.6
226.6
297.3
306.1
319.8
339.7
353.7
372.1
384.2
371.5
282.3
36.5
17.7
36.4
52.5
71.2
88.9
103.7
113.1
114.9
80.9
-43.2
-31.1
-15.5
1.7

-11.2
-19.4
-26.5
-34.5
-40.7
-51.6
-56.6
-63.8
-68.8
-65.9
-71.4
-78.9
-84.5
-136.0
-143.7
-155.3
-166.5
-201.7
-214.8
-224.6
-233.7
-304.4
-313.3
-326.8
-346.8
-360.6
-379.1
-391.3
-378.6
-289.3
-43.4
-24.5
-43.2
-59.3
-78.0
-95.8
-110.6
-120.0
-121.8
-87.5
35.9
23.9
8.3
-9.0

5.2
13.4
20.4
28.4
34.5
45.1
50.0
57.1
62.0
59.0
64.5
71.9
77.4
128.9
136.6
148.1
159.3
194.5
207.6
217.6
226.6
297.3
306.1
319.8
339.7
353.7
372.1
384.2
371.5
282.3
36.5
17.7
36.4
52.5
71.2
88.9
103.7
113.1
114.9
80.9
-43.2
-31.1
-15.5
1.7

-11.2
-19.4
-26.5
-34.5
-40.7
-51.6
-56.6
-63.8
-68.8
-65.9
-71.4
-78.9
-84.5
-136.0
-143.7
-155.3
-166.5
-201.7
-214.8
-224.6
-233.7
-304.4
-313.3
-326.8
-346.8
-360.6
-379.1
-391.3
-378.6
-289.3
-43.4
-24.5
-43.2
-59.3
-78.0
-95.8
-110.6
-120.0
-121.8
-87.5
35.9
23.9
8.3
-9.0

3.2
1.3
-0.1
-1.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.0
-6.9
-8.9
-9.2
-9.8
-11.7
-13.1
-18.2
-19.9
-21.3
-23.3
-27.5
-30.1
-32.2
-33.8
-41.6
-43.5
-46.2
-49.6
-52.0
-55.3
-57.8
-56.4
-40.3
1.7
3.6
-0.3
-3.3
-6.7
-9.9
-12.7
-14.9
-16.6
-13.7
2.3
0.4
-1.7
-3.8

-9.2
-7.3
-5.9
-4.8
-3.0
-2.2
-1.6
0.3
2.1
2.4
3.0
4.7
6.1
11.2
12.7
14.1
16.1
20.4
22.8
25.2
26.7
34.6
36.4
39.1
42.5
45.1
48.3
50.7
49.3
33.3
-8.6
-10.4
-6.6
-3.5
-0.2
3.0
5.8
8.1
9.7
7.2
-9.6
-7.6
-5.5
-3.5

3.2
1.3
-0.1
-1.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.0
-6.9
-8.9
-9.2
-9.8
-11.7
-13.1
-18.2
-19.9
-21.3
-23.3
-27.5
-30.1
-32.2
-33.8
-41.6
-43.5
-46.2
-49.6
-52.0
-55.3
-57.8
-56.4
-40.3
1.7
3.6
-0.3
-3.3
-6.7
-9.9
-12.7
-14.9
-16.6
-13.7
2.3
0.4
-1.7
-3.8

-9.2
-7.3
-5.9
-4.8
-3.0
-2.2
-1.6
0.3
2.1
2.4
3.0
4.7
6.1
11.2
12.7
14.1
16.1
20.4
22.8
25.2
26.7
34.6
36.4
39.1
42.5
45.1
48.3
50.7
49.3
33.3
-8.6
-10.4
-6.6
-3.5
-0.2
3.0
5.8
8.1
9.7
7.2
-9.6
-7.6
-5.5
-3.5

23.0
25.8
28.8
33.2
34.3
42.2
45.3
46.9
46.4
42.5
46.2
48.5
49.8
86.8
89.8
97.2
102.7
125.6
131.5
135.0
139.5
187.6
190.9
196.8
206.9
213.5
222.7
227.5
218.7
175.6
51.1
37.7
45.1
52.4
61.4
69.9
76.5
79.4
76.5
50.4
-26.0
-19.6
-9.9
1.2

-12.6
1.1
12.0
23.5
34.6
48.0
54.7
67.4
77.6
75.5
82.8
95.4
105.1
171.1
183.4
198.9
215.9
263.4
283.7
300.2
313.8
407.1
421.3
442.8
472.5
493.9
521.6
540.9
524.3
388.9
21.9
-2.3
27.7
52.6
81.0
107.9
130.9
146.8
153.3
111.4
-60.4
-42.6
-21.1
2.1

6.6
-7.1
-18.1
-29.6
-40.8
-54.5
-61.4
-74.1
-84.4
-82.4
-89.7
-102.4
-112.1
-178.2
-190.5
-206.1
-223.1
-270.6
-290.9
-307.2
-320.9
-414.2
-428.5
-449.8
-479.6
-500.9
-528.6
-548.0
-531.4
-396.0
-28.8
-4.6
-34.5
-59.3
-87.8
-114.7
-137.8
-153.7
-160.2
-118.0
53.2
35.4
13.8
-9.4

-29.0
-31.8
-34.9
-39.4
-40.5
-48.7
-51.9
-53.6
-53.1
-49.4
-53.1
-55.4
-56.9
-93.8
-97.0
-104.4
-109.9
-132.8
-138.7
-142.0
-146.6
-194.7
-198.1
-203.8
-214.0
-220.4
-229.7
-234.6
-225.8
-182.7
-58.0
-44.5
-52.0
-59.2
-68.2
-76.8
-83.4
-86.3
-83.4
-56.9
18.7
12.4
2.7
-8.5

21.2
21.8
23.0
25.5
24.9
30.1
31.9
31.7
29.9
26.8
29.0
29.4
29.3
53.2
54.3
58.8
61.4
75.4
78.0
78.9
81.1
111.3
112.4
114.8
119.9
122.9
127.4
129.2
123.6
103.3
41.4
32.7
35.4
38.6
42.8
46.8
49.6
50.1
46.7
29.1
-15.9
-12.6
-6.9
-0.1

11.9
15.4
18.7
22.9
25.0
31.6
34.4
37.1
38.1
35.4
38.6
41.7
43.8
75.3
78.8
85.4
91.0
111.4
117.7
122.0
126.6
168.5
172.4
178.8
189.0
195.9
205.1
210.6
203.0
158.6
33.6
22.2
30.6
38.4
47.7
56.5
63.5
67.4
66.5
44.8
-24.9
-18.6
-9.8
0.1

21.2
21.8
23.0
25.5
24.9
30.1
31.9
31.7
29.9
26.8
29.0
29.4
29.3
53.2
54.3
58.8
61.4
75.4
78.0
78.9
81.1
111.3
112.4
114.8
119.9
122.9
127.4
129.2
123.6
103.3
41.4
32.7
35.4
38.6
42.8
46.8
49.6
50.1
46.7
29.1
-15.9
-12.6
-6.9
-0.1

11.9
15.4
18.7
22.9
25.0
31.6
34.4
37.1
38.1
35.4
38.6
41.7
43.8
75.3
78.8
85.4
91.0
111.4
117.7
122.0
126.6
168.5
172.4
178.8
189.0
195.9
205.1
210.6
203.0
158.6
33.6
22.2
30.6
38.4
47.7
56.5
63.5
67.4
66.5
44.8
-24.9
-18.6
-9.8
0.1

-5.6
3.3
10.4
18.1
25.1
34.4
39.0
47.0
53.3
51.5
56.5
64.6
70.8
116.5
124.6
135.2
146.4
178.9
192.2
202.9
211.9
276.1
285.4
299.5
319.2
333.4
351.8
364.4
353.0
263.4
19.4
2.7
22.3
38.7
57.5
75.3
90.5
100.7
104.3
75.0
-41.8
-29.9
-15.3
0.6

8.9
-2.8
-12.2
-21.7
-31.4
-42.6
-48.2
-59.1
-68.3
-67.0
-73.0
-83.9
-92.3
-145.7
-156.1
-168.9
-183.2
-222.0
-239.1
-253.1
-264.5
-340.4
-352.5
-370.6
-395.4
-413.3
-436.5
-452.9
-439.5
-325.8
-18.6
1.0
-24.4
-45.3
-69.2
-91.8
-111.3
-124.9
-130.9
-97.2
43.5
28.7
10.9
-8.1

-17.8
-21.4
-24.8
-29.1
-31.3
-38.2
-41.1
-43.8
-44.8
-42.2
-45.5
-48.6
-50.8
-82.3
-85.9
-92.6
-98.2
-118.6
-124.9
-129.0
-133.6
-175.6
-179.6
-185.9
-196.1
-202.8
-212.1
-217.7
-210.1
-165.6
-40.5
-29.0
-37.5
-45.2
-54.5
-63.3
-70.5
-74.3
-73.3
-51.4
17.6
11.4
2.6
-7.4

-27.1
-27.9
-29.1
-31.6
-31.2
-36.6
-38.5
-38.4
-36.6
-33.6
-35.9
-36.3
-36.3
-60.3
-61.4
-66.0
-68.6
-82.6
-85.2
-85.9
-88.2
-118.4
-119.6
-121.8
-127.0
-129.9
-134.4
-136.2
-130.7
-110.3
-48.3
-39.5
-42.2
-45.3
-49.6
-53.7
-56.5
-57.0
-53.6
-35.7
8.7
5.5
-0.3
-7.2

-17.8
-21.4
-24.8
-29.1
-31.3
-38.2
-41.1
-43.8
-44.8
-42.2
-45.5
-48.6
-50.8
-82.3
-85.9
-92.6
-98.2
-118.6
-124.9
-129.0
-133.6
-175.6
-179.6
-185.9
-196.1
-202.8
-212.1
-217.7
-210.1
-165.6
-40.5
-29.0
-37.5
-45.2
-54.5
-63.3
-70.5
-74.3
-73.3
-51.4
17.6
11.4
2.6
-7.4

-27.1
-27.9
-29.1
-31.6
-31.2
-36.6
-38.5
-38.4
-36.6
-33.6
-35.9
-36.3
-36.3
-60.3
-61.4
-66.0
-68.6
-82.6
-85.2
-85.9
-88.2
-118.4
-119.6
-121.8
-127.0
-129.9
-134.4
-136.2
-130.7
-110.3
-48.3
-39.5
-42.2
-45.3
-49.6
-53.7
-56.5
-57.0
-53.6
-35.7
8.7
5.5
-0.3
-7.2

-14.8
-3.2
6.1
15.6
25.2
36.0
41.5
52.4
61.5
60.2
66.1
76.9
85.2
138.6
149.0
161.7
175.9
214.9
231.9
246.0
257.4
333.3
345.4
363.5
388.3
406.4
429.5
445.9
432.3
318.7
11.7
-7.8
17.5
38.5
62.4
84.9
104.4
118.0
124.1
90.7
-50.8
-35.8
-18.2
0.8

-0.4
-9.3
-16.5
-24.3
-31.3
-41.0
-45.6
-53.7
-60.1
-58.3
-63.4
-71.6
-77.8
-123.6
-131.7
-142.3
-153.6
-186.1
-199.4
-210.0
-219.0
-283.2
-292.5
-306.5
-326.3
-340.4
-358.8
-371.5
-360.1
-270.5
-26.4
-9.6
-29.1
-45.5
-64.3
-82.2
-97.4
-107.6
-111.2
-81.5
34.5
22.7
8.0
-7.8

-14.8
-3.2
6.1
15.6
25.2
36.0
41.5
52.4
61.5
60.2
66.1
76.9
85.2
138.6
149.0
161.7
175.9
214.9
231.9
246.0
257.4
333.3
345.4
363.5
388.3
406.4
429.5
445.9
432.3
318.7
11.7
-7.8
17.5
38.5
62.4
84.9
104.4
118.0
124.1
90.7
-50.8
-35.8
-18.2
0.8

-3.0
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.1
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6

-3.0
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.1
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6
-3.6

-13.9
-24.9
-34.3
-45.0
-53.2
-67.8
-74.4
-84.0
-90.6
-86.7
-94.0
-104.0
-111.5
-180.1
-190.5
-205.8
-220.8
-267.8
-285.2
-298.3
-310.5
-404.7
-416.5
-434.6
-461.2
-479.7
-504.3
-520.5
-503.6
-384.6
-56.7
-31.6
-56.5
-77.9
-102.9
-126.5
-146.4
-158.8
-161.2
-115.5
49.1
33.1
12.2
-10.7

7.9
18.9
28.2
38.8
47.0
61.2
67.8
77.3
83.8
79.9
87.1
97.1
104.4
173.1
183.4
198.6
213.6
260.6
278.0
291.3
303.4
397.6
409.4
427.5
454.1
472.8
497.3
513.4
496.5
377.6
49.8
24.8
49.7
71.1
96.1
119.7
139.4
152.0
154.4
108.9
-56.4
-40.3
-19.5
3.4

-11.2
-19.4
-26.5
-34.5
-40.7
-51.6
-56.6
-63.8
-68.8
-65.9
-71.4
-78.9
-84.5
-136.0
-143.7
-155.3
-166.5
-201.7
-214.8
-224.6
-233.7
-304.4
-313.3
-326.8
-346.8
-360.6
-379.1
-391.3
-378.6
-289.3
-43.4
-24.5
-43.2
-59.3
-78.0
-95.8
-110.6
-120.0
-121.8
-87.5
35.9
23.9
8.3
-9.0

5.2
13.4
20.4
28.4
34.5
45.1
50.0
57.1
62.0
59.0
64.5
71.9
77.4
128.9
136.6
148.1
159.3
194.5
207.6
217.6
226.6
297.3
306.1
319.8
339.7
353.7
372.1
384.2
371.5
282.3
36.5
17.7
36.4
52.5
71.2
88.9
103.7
113.1
114.9
80.9
-43.2
-31.1
-15.5
1.7

-11.2
-19.4
-26.5
-34.5
-40.7
-51.6
-56.6
-63.8
-68.8
-65.9
-71.4
-78.9
-84.5
-136.0
-143.7
-155.3
-166.5
-201.7
-214.8
-224.6
-233.7
-304.4
-313.3
-326.8
-346.8
-360.6
-379.1
-391.3
-378.6
-289.3
-43.4
-24.5
-43.2
-59.3
-78.0
-95.8
-110.6
-120.0
-121.8
-87.5
35.9
23.9
8.3
-9.0

5.2
13.4
20.4
28.4
34.5
45.1
50.0
57.1
62.0
59.0
64.5
71.9
77.4
128.9
136.6
148.1
159.3
194.5
207.6
217.6
226.6
297.3
306.1
319.8
339.7
353.7
372.1
384.2
371.5
282.3
36.5
17.7
36.4
52.5
71.2
88.9
103.7
113.1
114.9
80.9
-43.2
-31.1
-15.5
1.7

-9.2
-7.3
-5.9
-4.8
-3.0
-2.2
-1.6
0.3
2.1
2.4
3.0
4.7
6.1
11.2
12.7
14.1
16.1
20.4
22.8
25.2
26.7
34.6
36.4
39.1
42.5
45.1
48.3
50.7
49.3
33.3
-8.6
-10.4
-6.6
-3.5
-0.2
3.0
5.8
8.1
9.7
7.2
-9.6
-7.6
-5.5
-3.5

3.2
1.3
-0.1
-1.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.0
-6.9
-8.9
-9.2
-9.8
-11.7
-13.1
-18.2
-19.9
-21.3
-23.3
-27.5
-30.1
-32.2
-33.8
-41.6
-43.5
-46.2
-49.6
-52.0
-55.3
-57.8
-56.4
-40.3
1.7
3.6
-0.3
-3.3
-6.7
-9.9
-12.7
-14.9
-16.6
-13.7
2.3
0.4
-1.7
-3.8

-9.2
-7.3
-5.9
-4.8
-3.0
-2.2
-1.6
0.3
2.1
2.4
3.0
4.7
6.1
11.2
12.7
14.1
16.1
20.4
22.8
25.2
26.7
34.6
36.4
39.1
42.5
45.1
48.3
50.7
49.3
33.3
-8.6
-10.4
-6.6
-3.5
-0.2
3.0
5.8
8.1
9.7
7.2
-9.6
-7.6
-5.5
-3.5

3.2
1.3
-0.1
-1.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.0
-6.9
-8.9
-9.2
-9.8
-11.7
-13.1
-18.2
-19.9
-21.3
-23.3
-27.5
-30.1
-32.2
-33.8
-41.6
-43.5
-46.2
-49.6
-52.0
-55.3
-57.8
-56.4
-40.3
1.7
3.6
-0.3
-3.3
-6.7
-9.9
-12.7
-14.9
-16.6
-13.7
2.3
0.4
-1.7
-3.8

-29.0
-31.8
-34.9
-39.4
-40.5
-48.7
-51.9
-53.6
-53.1
-49.4
-53.1
-55.4
-56.9
-93.8
-97.0
-104.4
-109.9
-132.8
-138.7
-142.0
-146.6
-194.7
-198.1
-203.8
-214.0
-220.4
-229.7
-234.6
-225.8
-182.7
-58.0
-44.5
-52.0
-59.2
-68.2
-76.8
-83.4
-86.3
-83.4
-56.9
18.7
12.4
2.7
-8.5

6.6
-7.1
-18.1
-29.6
-40.8
-54.5
-61.4
-74.1
-84.4
-82.4
-89.7
-102.4
-112.1
-178.2
-190.5
-206.1
-223.1
-270.6
-290.9
-307.2
-320.9
-414.2
-428.5
-449.8
-479.6
-500.9
-528.6
-548.0
-531.4
-396.0
-28.8
-4.6
-34.5
-59.3
-87.8
-114.7
-137.8
-153.7
-160.2
-118.0
53.2
35.4
13.8
-9.4

-12.6
1.1
12.0
23.5
34.6
48.0
54.7
67.4
77.6
75.5
82.8
95.4
105.1
171.1
183.4
198.9
215.9
263.4
283.7
300.2
313.8
407.1
421.3
442.8
472.5
493.9
521.6
540.9
524.3
388.9
21.9
-2.3
27.7
52.6
81.0
107.9
130.9
146.8
153.3
111.4
-60.4
-42.6
-21.1
2.1

23.0
25.8
28.8
33.2
34.3
42.2
45.3
46.9
46.4
42.5
46.2
48.5
49.8
86.8
89.8
97.2
102.7
125.6
131.5
135.0
139.5
187.6
190.9
196.8
206.9
213.5
222.7
227.5
218.7
175.6
51.1
37.7
45.1
52.4
61.4
69.9
76.5
79.4
76.5
50.4
-26.0
-19.6
-9.9
1.2

-27.1
-27.9
-29.1
-31.6
-31.2
-36.6
-38.5
-38.4
-36.6
-33.6
-35.9
-36.3
-36.3
-60.3
-61.4
-66.0
-68.6
-82.6
-85.2
-85.9
-88.2
-118.4
-119.6
-121.8
-127.0
-129.9
-134.4
-136.2
-130.7
-110.3
-48.3
-39.5
-42.2
-45.3
-49.6
-53.7
-56.5
-57.0
-53.6
-35.7
8.7
5.5
-0.3
-7.2

-17.8
-21.4
-24.8
-29.1
-31.3
-38.2
-41.1
-43.8
-44.8
-42.2
-45.5
-48.6
-50.8
-82.3
-85.9
-92.6
-98.2
-118.6
-124.9
-129.0
-133.6
-175.6
-179.6
-185.9
-196.1
-202.8
-212.1
-217.7
-210.1
-165.6
-40.5
-29.0
-37.5
-45.2
-54.5
-63.3
-70.5
-74.3
-73.3
-51.4
17.6
11.4
2.6
-7.4

-27.1
-27.9
-29.1
-31.6
-31.2
-36.6
-38.5
-38.4
-36.6
-33.6
-35.9
-36.3
-36.3
-60.3
-61.4
-66.0
-68.6
-82.6
-85.2
-85.9
-88.2
-118.4
-119.6
-121.8
-127.0
-129.9
-134.4
-136.2
-130.7
-110.3
-48.3
-39.5
-42.2
-45.3
-49.6
-53.7
-56.5
-57.0
-53.6
-35.7
8.7
5.5
-0.3
-7.2

-17.8
-21.4
-24.8
-29.1
-31.3
-38.2
-41.1
-43.8
-44.8
-42.2
-45.5
-48.6
-50.8
-82.3
-85.9
-92.6
-98.2
-118.6
-124.9
-129.0
-133.6
-175.6
-179.6
-185.9
-196.1
-202.8
-212.1
-217.7
-210.1
-165.6
-40.5
-29.0
-37.5
-45.2
-54.5
-63.3
-70.5
-74.3
-73.3
-51.4
17.6
11.4
2.6
-7.4

-0.4
-9.3
-16.5
-24.3
-31.3
-41.0
-45.6
-53.7
-60.1
-58.3
-63.4
-71.6
-77.8
-123.6
-131.7
-142.3
-153.6
-186.1
-199.4
-210.0
-219.0
-283.2
-292.5
-306.5
-326.3
-340.4
-358.8
-371.5
-360.1
-270.5
-26.4
-9.6
-29.1
-45.5
-64.3
-82.2
-97.4
-107.6
-111.2
-81.5
34.5
22.7
8.0
-7.8

-14.8
-3.2
6.1
15.6
25.2
36.0
41.5
52.4
61.5
60.2
66.1
76.9
85.2
138.6
149.0
161.7
175.9
214.9
231.9
246.0
257.4
333.3
345.4
363.5
388.3
406.4
429.5
445.9
432.3
318.7
11.7
-7.8
17.5
38.5
62.4
84.9
104.4
118.0
124.1
90.7
-50.8
-35.8
-18.2
0.8

11.9
15.4
18.7
22.9
25.0
31.6
34.4
37.1
38.1
35.4
38.6
41.7
43.8
75.3
78.8
85.4
91.0
111.4
117.7
122.0
126.6
168.5
172.4
178.8
189.0
195.9
205.1
210.6
203.0
158.6
33.6
22.2
30.6
38.4
47.7
56.5
63.5
67.4
66.5
44.8
-24.9
-18.6
-9.8
0.1

21.2
21.8
23.0
25.5
24.9
30.1
31.9
31.7
29.9
26.8
29.0
29.4
29.3
53.2
54.3
58.8
61.4
75.4
78.0
78.9
81.1
111.3
112.4
114.8
119.9
122.9
127.4
129.2
123.6
103.3
41.4
32.7
35.4
38.6
42.8
46.8
49.6
50.1
46.7
29.1
-15.9
-12.6
-6.9
-0.1

11.9
15.4
18.7
22.9
25.0
31.6
34.4
37.1
38.1
35.4
38.6
41.7
43.8
75.3
78.8
85.4
91.0
111.4
117.7
122.0
126.6
168.5
172.4
178.8
189.0
195.9
205.1
210.6
203.0
158.6
33.6
22.2
30.6
38.4
47.7
56.5
63.5
67.4
66.5
44.8
-24.9
-18.6
-9.8
0.1

21.2
21.8
23.0
25.5
24.9
30.1
31.9
31.7
29.9
26.8
29.0
29.4
29.3
53.2
54.3
58.8
61.4
75.4
78.0
78.9
81.1
111.3
112.4
114.8
119.9
122.9
127.4
129.2
123.6
103.3
41.4
32.7
35.4
38.6
42.8
46.8
49.6
50.1
46.7
29.1
-15.9
-12.6
-6.9
-0.1

8.9
-2.8
-12.2
-21.7
-31.4
-42.6
-48.2
-59.1
-68.3
-67.0
-73.0
-83.9
-92.3
-145.7
-156.1
-168.9
-183.2
-222.0
-239.1
-253.1
-264.5
-340.4
-352.5
-370.6
-395.4
-413.3
-436.5
-452.9
-439.5
-325.8
-18.6
1.0
-24.4
-45.3
-69.2
-91.8
-111.3
-124.9
-130.9
-97.2
43.5
28.7
10.9
-8.1

-5.6
3.3
10.4
18.1
25.1
34.4
39.0
47.0
53.3
51.5
56.5
64.6
70.8
116.5
124.6
135.2
146.4
178.9
192.2
202.9
211.9
276.1
285.4
299.5
319.2
333.4
351.8
364.4
353.0
263.4
19.4
2.7
22.3
38.7
57.5
75.3
90.5
100.7
104.3
75.0
-41.8
-29.9
-15.3
0.6

8.9
-2.8
-12.2
-21.7
-31.4
-42.6
-48.2
-59.1
-68.3
-67.0
-73.0
-83.9
-92.3
-145.7
-156.1
-168.9
-183.2
-222.0
-239.1
-253.1
-264.5
-340.4
-352.5
-370.6
-395.4
-413.3
-436.5
-452.9
-439.5
-325.8
-18.6
1.0
-24.4
-45.3
-69.2
-91.8
-111.3
-124.9
-130.9
-97.2
43.5
28.7
10.9
-8.1

-29.3
-26.7
-24.6
-24.1
-22.5
-20.7
-19.3
-17.6
-16.2
-13.0
-10.2
-9.0
-7.8
-6.7

-29.3
-26.7
-24.6
-24.1
-22.5
-20.7
-19.3
-17.6
-16.2
-13.0
-10.2
-9.0
-7.8
-6.7

713.1
568.2
516.6
515.0
490.9
471.1
455.3
434.6
404.8
313.0
-9.7
-10.2
-5.4
1.8

-771.7
-621.6
-565.9
-563.1
-535.9
-512.5
-493.9
-469.8
-437.2
-338.9
-10.8
-7.7
-10.2
-15.1

527.5
419.5
381.3
380.2
362.6
348.1
336.7
321.6
299.5
231.5
-9.8
-9.9
-6.0
-0.4

-586.1
-472.9
-430.6
-428.3
-407.5
-389.6
-375.2
-356.8
-332.0
-257.4
-10.7
-8.0
-9.6
-13.0

527.5
419.5
381.3
380.2
362.6
348.1
336.7
321.6
299.5
231.5
-9.8
-9.9
-6.0
-0.4

-586.1
-472.9
-430.6
-428.3
-407.5
-389.6
-375.2
-356.8
-332.0
-257.4
-10.7
-8.0
-9.6
-13.0

-84.8
-69.3
-64.6
-64.6
-62.1
-59.7
-57.9
-55.7
-53.4
-43.6
-9.3
-8.3
-7.6
-6.9

26.2
16.0
15.3
16.5
17.1
18.2
19.4
20.5
20.9
17.7
-11.2
-9.6
-8.0
-6.4

-84.8
-69.3
-64.6
-64.6
-62.1
-59.7
-57.9
-55.7
-53.4
-43.6
-9.3
-8.3
-7.6
-6.9

26.2
16.0
15.3
16.5
17.1
18.2
19.4
20.5
20.9
17.7
-11.2
-9.6
-8.0
-6.4

367.3
296.3
265.8
263.0
248.0
235.4
224.7
211.1
191.7
142.4
-7.0
-8.0
-5.3
-1.0

687.7
542.7
496.7
497.4
477.1
460.9
448.7
432.0
407.3
320.5
-12.6
-11.8
-6.7
0.3

-746.3
-596.0
-546.0
-545.5
-522.0
-502.3
-487.2
-467.2
-439.8
-346.5
-7.9
-6.1
-8.9
-13.7

-425.9
-349.7
-315.1
-311.1
-293.0
-276.8
-263.2
-246.4
-224.2
-168.4
-13.5
-9.9
-10.3
-12.3

226.8
183.8
163.4
161.0
150.9
142.3
134.9
125.5
112.0
80.7
-7.1
-7.8
-5.8
-2.6

310.1
247.8
223.4
221.9
210.3
200.8
192.9
182.7
167.8
126.7
-8.5
-8.8
-6.1
-2.3

226.8
183.8
163.4
161.0
150.9
142.3
134.9
125.5
112.0
80.7
-7.1
-7.8
-5.8
-2.6

310.1
247.8
223.4
221.9
210.3
200.8
192.9
182.7
167.8
126.7
-8.5
-8.8
-6.1
-2.3

467.3
368.7
336.7
337.0
322.8
311.6
303.0
291.3
273.8
214.4
-11.3
-10.6
-6.8
-1.6

-609.2
-486.1
-446.0
-446.0
-427.2
-411.5
-399.6
-383.7
-362.0
-286.3
-7.7
-6.3
-8.5
-12.1

-368.7
-301.2
-272.7
-270.0
-255.2
-242.2
-231.4
-217.9
-200.2
-152.7
-11.9
-9.2
-9.5
-11.1

-285.3
-237.1
-212.7
-209.1
-195.8
-183.7
-173.4
-160.7
-144.4
-106.6
-13.4
-10.2
-9.8
-10.7

-368.7
-301.2
-272.7
-270.0
-255.2
-242.2
-231.4
-217.9
-200.2
-152.7
-11.9
-9.2
-9.5
-11.1

-285.3
-237.1
-212.7
-209.1
-195.8
-183.7
-173.4
-160.7
-144.4
-106.6
-13.4
-10.2
-9.8
-10.7

550.6
432.8
396.7
397.8
382.3
370.1
361.0
348.5
329.6
260.4
-12.7
-11.6
-7.2
-1.2

-525.8
-422.1
-386.0
-385.1
-367.8
-353.0
-341.5
-326.5
-306.3
-240.3
-9.2
-7.3
-8.8
-11.7

550.6
432.8
396.7
397.8
382.3
370.1
361.0
348.5
329.6
260.4
-12.7
-11.6
-7.2
-1.2

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 1 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)


11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

A15

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

0.9

1.6

0.9

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Dead

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

WindMTX
5.15
3.57
2.42
1.40
-0.06
-0.87
-1.40
-3.00
-4.56
-4.81
-5.33
-6.83
-8.03
-12.25
-13.58
-14.75
-16.41
-19.97
-22.03
-23.92
-25.21
-31.75
-33.30
-35.55
-38.35
-40.48
-43.13
-45.20
-44.04
-30.69
4.31
5.86
2.62
0.08
-2.71
-5.36
-7.73
-9.60
-10.94
-8.70
4.98
3.32
1.61
-0.13

WindMTX
-5.15
-3.57
-2.42
-1.40
0.06
0.87
1.40
3.00
4.56
4.81
5.33
6.83
8.03
12.25
13.58
14.75
16.41
19.97
22.03
23.92
25.21
31.75
33.30
35.55
38.35
40.48
43.13
45.20
44.04
30.69
-4.31
-5.86
-2.62
-0.08
2.71
5.36
7.73
9.60
10.94
8.70
-4.98
-3.32
-1.61
0.13

WindMTX
-46.26
-35.54
-33.30
-33.78
-32.99
-32.46
-32.21
-31.74
-30.96
-25.54
0.80
0.54
0.19
-0.20

WindFY
6.82
13.70
19.54
26.19
31.30
40.30
44.44
50.40
54.49
52.05
56.61
62.85
67.47
110.39
116.82
126.40
135.74
165.11
176.00
184.25
191.83
250.74
258.09
269.41
286.04
297.65
313.02
323.11
312.55
238.17
33.28
17.60
33.18
46.56
62.17
76.94
89.32
97.13
98.63
70.14
-32.99
-22.92
-9.90
4.43

WindFY
-6.82
-13.70
-19.54
-26.19
-31.30
-40.30
-44.44
-50.40
-54.49
-52.05
-56.61
-62.85
-67.47
-110.39
-116.82
-126.40
-135.74
-165.11
-176.00
-184.25
-191.83
-250.74
-258.09
-269.41
-286.04
-297.65
-313.02
-323.11
-312.55
-238.17
-33.28
-17.60
-33.18
-46.56
-62.17
-76.94
-89.32
-97.13
-98.63
-70.14
32.99
22.92
9.90
-4.43

WindFY
464.01
371.82
338.26
336.90
320.87
307.38
296.63
282.65
263.12
203.71
0.36
-0.80
1.49
5.26

WindMTY
14.84
10.31
7.00
4.08
-0.10
-2.42
-3.94
-8.53
-13.02
-13.75
-15.25
-19.55
-23.01
-35.16
-38.99
-42.38
-47.16
-57.42
-63.39
-68.85
-72.60
-91.48
-96.00
-102.51
-110.63
-116.84
-124.55
-130.58
-127.31
-88.89
12.18
16.64
7.27
-0.06
-8.14
-15.82
-22.67
-28.08
-31.97
-25.44
14.34
9.56
4.64
-0.37

WindMTY
-14.84
-10.31
-7.00
-4.08
0.10
2.42
3.94
8.53
13.02
13.75
15.25
19.55
23.01
35.16
38.99
42.38
47.16
57.42
63.39
68.85
72.60
91.48
96.00
102.51
110.63
116.84
124.55
130.58
127.31
88.89
-12.18
-16.64
-7.27
0.06
8.14
15.82
22.67
28.08
31.97
25.44
-14.34
-9.56
-4.64
0.37

WindMTY
-133.49
-102.65
-96.23
-97.68
-95.45
-93.97
-93.32
-92.02
-89.84
-74.20
2.33
1.57
0.56
-0.57

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

0.9

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

1.2
-1.2

0.9

-1.2
1.2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

-1.2
-1.2

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

Figure 6-9 Case 4

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

-0.4
-9.3
-16.5
-24.3
-31.3
-41.0
-45.6
-53.7
-60.1
-58.3
-63.4
-71.6
-77.8
-123.6
-131.7
-142.3
-153.6
-186.1
-199.4
-210.0
-219.0
-283.2
-292.5
-306.5
-326.3
-340.4
-358.8
-371.5
-360.1
-270.5
-26.4
-9.6
-29.1
-45.5
-64.3
-82.2
-97.4
-107.6
-111.2
-81.5
34.5
22.7
8.0
-7.8

-5.6
3.3
10.4
18.1
25.1
34.4
39.0
47.0
53.3
51.5
56.5
64.6
70.8
116.5
124.6
135.2
146.4
178.9
192.2
202.9
211.9
276.1
285.4
299.5
319.2
333.4
351.8
364.4
353.0
263.4
19.4
2.7
22.3
38.7
57.5
75.3
90.5
100.7
104.3
75.0
-41.8
-29.9
-15.3
0.6

8.9
-2.8
-12.2
-21.7
-31.4
-42.6
-48.2
-59.1
-68.3
-67.0
-73.0
-83.9
-92.3
-145.7
-156.1
-168.9
-183.2
-222.0
-239.1
-253.1
-264.5
-340.4
-352.5
-370.6
-395.4
-413.3
-436.5
-452.9
-439.5
-325.8
-18.6
1.0
-24.4
-45.3
-69.2
-91.8
-111.3
-124.9
-130.9
-97.2
43.5
28.7
10.9
-8.1

-2.2
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7

-2.2
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7

8.7
19.7
29.0
39.6
47.7
62.0
68.6
78.1
84.6
80.7
88.0
97.9
105.3
174.0
184.2
199.5
214.5
261.5
278.9
292.2
304.3
398.5
410.3
428.4
455.0
473.6
498.2
514.3
497.4
378.4
50.7
25.6
50.5
72.0
96.9
120.5
140.3
152.8
155.2
109.8
-55.5
-39.4
-18.6
4.3

-13.1
-24.2
-33.5
-44.2
-52.4
-66.9
-73.6
-83.2
-89.7
-85.8
-93.2
-103.2
-110.6
-179.3
-189.6
-204.9
-219.9
-266.9
-284.3
-297.4
-309.6
-403.8
-415.6
-433.7
-460.3
-478.8
-503.5
-519.6
-502.7
-383.7
-55.8
-30.7
-55.7
-77.0
-102.0
-125.7
-145.5
-158.0
-160.4
-114.7
50.1
34.0
13.1
-9.8

5.9
14.2
21.2
29.1
35.2
45.9
50.8
58.0
62.8
59.9
65.3
72.8
78.3
129.8
137.5
149.0
160.2
195.4
208.5
218.5
227.5
298.2
307.0
320.7
340.6
354.6
373.0
385.1
372.4
283.2
37.3
18.6
37.2
53.3
72.0
89.7
104.6
114.0
115.8
81.7
-42.3
-30.2
-14.6
2.6

-10.4
-18.7
-25.7
-33.7
-39.9
-50.8
-55.8
-63.0
-67.9
-65.0
-70.5
-78.0
-83.6
-135.1
-142.9
-154.4
-165.6
-200.8
-213.9
-223.7
-232.8
-303.5
-312.4
-325.9
-345.9
-359.8
-378.3
-390.4
-377.7
-288.4
-42.5
-23.7
-42.4
-58.4
-77.2
-94.9
-109.8
-119.1
-120.9
-86.6
36.9
24.8
9.2
-8.0

5.9
14.2
21.2
29.1
35.2
45.9
50.8
58.0
62.8
59.9
65.3
72.8
78.3
129.8
137.5
149.0
160.2
195.4
208.5
218.5
227.5
298.2
307.0
320.7
340.6
354.6
373.0
385.1
372.4
283.2
37.3
18.6
37.2
53.3
72.0
89.7
104.6
114.0
115.8
81.7
-42.3
-30.2
-14.6
2.6

-10.4
-18.7
-25.7
-33.7
-39.9
-50.8
-55.8
-63.0
-67.9
-65.0
-70.5
-78.0
-83.6
-135.1
-142.9
-154.4
-165.6
-200.8
-213.9
-223.7
-232.8
-303.5
-312.4
-325.9
-345.9
-359.8
-378.3
-390.4
-377.7
-288.4
-42.5
-23.7
-42.4
-58.4
-77.2
-94.9
-109.8
-119.1
-120.9
-86.6
36.9
24.8
9.2
-8.0

4.0
2.0
0.6
-0.6
-2.4
-3.5
-4.2
-6.1
-8.0
-8.3
-9.0
-10.8
-12.3
-17.3
-19.0
-20.4
-22.4
-26.7
-29.2
-31.3
-32.9
-40.8
-42.6
-45.3
-48.7
-51.2
-54.4
-56.9
-55.5
-39.5
2.6
4.5
0.6
-2.4
-5.8
-9.0
-11.9
-14.1
-15.7
-12.9
3.2
1.3
-0.8
-2.9

-8.4
-6.5
-5.2
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8
1.1
2.9
3.2
3.8
5.6
7.0
12.1
13.6
15.0
17.0
21.3
23.7
26.1
27.6
35.4
37.3
40.0
43.4
46.0
49.1
51.6
50.2
34.2
-7.8
-9.6
-5.7
-2.6
0.7
3.9
6.7
9.0
10.5
8.0
-8.7
-6.7
-4.6
-2.6

4.0
2.0
0.6
-0.6
-2.4
-3.5
-4.2
-6.1
-8.0
-8.3
-9.0
-10.8
-12.3
-17.3
-19.0
-20.4
-22.4
-26.7
-29.2
-31.3
-32.9
-40.8
-42.6
-45.3
-48.7
-51.2
-54.4
-56.9
-55.5
-39.5
2.6
4.5
0.6
-2.4
-5.8
-9.0
-11.9
-14.1
-15.7
-12.9
3.2
1.3
-0.8
-2.9

-8.4
-6.5
-5.2
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8
1.1
2.9
3.2
3.8
5.6
7.0
12.1
13.6
15.0
17.0
21.3
23.7
26.1
27.6
35.4
37.3
40.0
43.4
46.0
49.1
51.6
50.2
34.2
-7.8
-9.6
-5.7
-2.6
0.7
3.9
6.7
9.0
10.5
8.0
-8.7
-6.7
-4.6
-2.6

23.8
26.5
29.6
34.0
35.1
43.0
46.1
47.7
47.2
43.4
47.0
49.3
50.7
87.6
90.7
98.1
103.6
126.5
132.4
135.8
140.4
188.5
191.8
197.6
207.8
214.4
223.5
228.4
219.6
176.5
52.0
38.5
46.0
53.3
62.3
70.8
77.4
80.3
77.4
51.2
-25.1
-18.7
-9.0
2.1

-11.9
1.8
12.8
24.2
35.4
48.8
55.6
68.2
78.5
76.4
83.7
96.3
105.9
172.0
184.3
199.8
216.8
264.3
284.6
301.1
314.7
408.0
422.2
443.7
473.3
494.8
522.5
541.8
525.2
389.8
22.7
-1.4
28.5
53.4
81.8
108.7
131.8
147.7
154.1
112.2
-59.5
-41.7
-20.2
3.0

7.4
-6.3
-17.3
-28.8
-40.0
-53.7
-60.5
-73.2
-83.5
-81.5
-88.8
-101.5
-111.2
-177.3
-189.6
-205.2
-222.2
-269.7
-290.0
-306.4
-320.0
-413.3
-427.6
-449.0
-478.7
-500.0
-527.7
-547.1
-530.5
-395.1
-27.9
-3.7
-33.7
-58.5
-86.9
-113.9
-137.0
-152.8
-159.3
-117.2
54.1
36.3
14.7
-8.5

-28.2
-31.1
-34.1
-38.6
-39.8
-47.9
-51.1
-52.8
-52.3
-48.5
-52.2
-54.6
-56.0
-92.9
-96.1
-103.5
-109.0
-131.9
-137.8
-141.1
-145.7
-193.8
-197.2
-202.9
-213.1
-219.6
-228.8
-233.7
-225.0
-181.8
-57.2
-43.6
-51.1
-58.3
-67.4
-75.9
-82.6
-85.4
-82.6
-56.1
19.6
13.3
3.6
-7.6

21.9
22.6
23.8
26.2
25.7
30.9
32.7
32.5
30.7
27.6
29.9
30.2
30.2
54.1
55.2
59.7
62.3
76.3
78.9
79.8
82.0
112.2
113.3
115.7
120.8
123.8
128.3
130.1
124.5
104.2
42.2
33.6
36.2
39.4
43.7
47.6
50.5
51.0
47.6
30.0
-15.0
-11.7
-6.0
0.8

12.6
16.1
19.4
23.7
25.8
32.4
35.3
37.9
38.9
36.3
39.5
42.5
44.6
76.2
79.7
86.3
91.9
112.3
118.6
122.9
127.4
169.4
173.3
179.7
189.9
196.7
206.0
211.5
203.9
159.5
34.5
23.0
31.5
39.3
48.6
57.3
64.4
68.3
67.3
45.6
-24.0
-17.7
-8.9
1.0

21.9
22.6
23.8
26.2
25.7
30.9
32.7
32.5
30.7
27.6
29.9
30.2
30.2
54.1
55.2
59.7
62.3
76.3
78.9
79.8
82.0
112.2
113.3
115.7
120.8
123.8
128.3
130.1
124.5
104.2
42.2
33.6
36.2
39.4
43.7
47.6
50.5
51.0
47.6
30.0
-15.0
-11.7
-6.0
0.8

12.6
16.1
19.4
23.7
25.8
32.4
35.3
37.9
38.9
36.3
39.5
42.5
44.6
76.2
79.7
86.3
91.9
112.3
118.6
122.9
127.4
169.4
173.3
179.7
189.9
196.7
206.0
211.5
203.9
159.5
34.5
23.0
31.5
39.3
48.6
57.3
64.4
68.3
67.3
45.6
-24.0
-17.7
-8.9
1.0

-4.8
4.0
11.2
18.9
25.9
35.2
39.8
47.9
54.2
52.4
57.3
65.5
71.6
117.4
125.5
136.1
147.3
179.8
193.1
203.8
212.8
277.0
286.3
300.4
320.1
334.3
352.7
365.3
353.9
264.3
20.3
3.6
23.1
39.5
58.3
76.1
91.3
101.6
105.2
75.8
-40.9
-29.0
-14.4
1.5

9.6
-2.1
-11.4
-21.0
-30.7
-41.7
-47.3
-58.3
-67.5
-66.2
-72.1
-83.0
-91.4
-144.8
-155.3
-168.0
-182.3
-221.1
-238.2
-252.2
-263.6
-339.5
-351.7
-369.7
-394.5
-412.4
-435.6
-452.0
-438.6
-324.9
-17.7
1.9
-23.6
-44.5
-68.3
-91.0
-110.4
-124.0
-130.1
-96.4
44.4
29.6
11.8
-7.2

-17.1
-20.7
-24.0
-28.3
-30.5
-37.4
-40.2
-42.9
-44.0
-41.4
-44.6
-47.8
-49.9
-81.4
-85.0
-91.7
-97.3
-117.7
-124.0
-128.1
-132.8
-174.7
-178.7
-185.0
-195.2
-201.9
-211.3
-216.8
-209.2
-164.8
-39.7
-28.1
-36.6
-44.3
-53.7
-62.5
-69.6
-73.4
-72.5
-50.6
18.5
12.3
3.5
-6.5

-26.4
-27.1
-28.4
-30.8
-30.4
-35.8
-37.7
-37.5
-35.8
-32.7
-35.0
-35.5
-35.5
-59.4
-60.5
-65.1
-67.7
-81.7
-84.3
-85.0
-87.3
-117.5
-118.7
-121.0
-126.1
-129.0
-133.5
-135.4
-129.9
-109.5
-47.4
-38.7
-41.4
-44.5
-48.8
-52.8
-55.7
-56.1
-52.8
-34.9
9.6
6.4
0.6
-6.3

-17.1
-20.7
-24.0
-28.3
-30.5
-37.4
-40.2
-42.9
-44.0
-41.4
-44.6
-47.8
-49.9
-81.4
-85.0
-91.7
-97.3
-117.7
-124.0
-128.1
-132.8
-174.7
-178.7
-185.0
-195.2
-201.9
-211.3
-216.8
-209.2
-164.8
-39.7
-28.1
-36.6
-44.3
-53.7
-62.5
-69.6
-73.4
-72.5
-50.6
18.5
12.3
3.5
-6.5

-26.4
-27.1
-28.4
-30.8
-30.4
-35.8
-37.7
-37.5
-35.8
-32.7
-35.0
-35.5
-35.5
-59.4
-60.5
-65.1
-67.7
-81.7
-84.3
-85.0
-87.3
-117.5
-118.7
-121.0
-126.1
-129.0
-133.5
-135.4
-129.9
-109.5
-47.4
-38.7
-41.4
-44.5
-48.8
-52.8
-55.7
-56.1
-52.8
-34.9
9.6
6.4
0.6
-6.3

-14.1
-2.4
6.8
16.4
26.0
36.8
42.4
53.3
62.4
61.0
67.0
77.8
86.1
139.5
149.9
162.6
176.8
215.7
232.8
246.9
258.2
334.2
346.3
364.4
389.2
407.2
430.4
446.7
433.2
319.6
12.5
-7.0
18.4
39.4
63.2
85.8
105.2
118.9
124.9
91.5
-49.9
-34.9
-17.3
1.7

0.3
-8.5
-15.8
-23.5
-30.6
-40.2
-44.8
-52.9
-59.2
-57.5
-62.5
-70.7
-76.9
-122.7
-130.8
-141.4
-152.7
-185.2
-198.5
-209.1
-218.1
-282.3
-291.6
-305.7
-325.4
-339.5
-357.9
-370.6
-359.2
-269.6
-25.5
-8.7
-28.3
-44.6
-63.4
-81.3
-96.5
-106.7
-110.4
-80.7
35.4
23.6
8.9
-6.9

-14.1
-2.4
6.8
16.4
26.0
36.8
42.4
53.3
62.4
61.0
67.0
77.8
86.1
139.5
149.9
162.6
176.8
215.7
232.8
246.9
258.2
334.2
346.3
364.4
389.2
407.2
430.4
446.7
433.2
319.6
12.5
-7.0
18.4
39.4
63.2
85.8
105.2
118.9
124.9
91.5
-49.9
-34.9
-17.3
1.7

0.3
-8.5
-15.8
-23.5
-30.6
-40.2
-44.8
-52.9
-59.2
-57.5
-62.5
-70.7
-76.9
-122.7
-130.8
-141.4
-152.7
-185.2
-198.5
-209.1
-218.1
-282.3
-291.6
-305.7
-325.4
-339.5
-357.9
-370.6
-359.2
-269.6
-25.5
-8.7
-28.3
-44.6
-63.4
-81.3
-96.5
-106.7
-110.4
-80.7
35.4
23.6
8.9
-6.9

-4.8
4.0
11.2
18.9
25.9
35.2
39.8
47.9
54.2
52.4
57.3
65.5
71.6
117.4
125.5
136.1
147.3
179.8
193.1
203.8
212.8
277.0
286.3
300.4
320.1
334.3
352.7
365.3
353.9
264.3
20.3
3.6
23.1
39.5
58.3
76.1
91.3
101.6
105.2
75.8
-40.9
-29.0
-14.4
1.5

9.6
-2.1
-11.4
-21.0
-30.7
-41.7
-47.3
-58.3
-67.5
-66.2
-72.1
-83.0
-91.4
-144.8
-155.3
-168.0
-182.3
-221.1
-238.2
-252.2
-263.6
-339.5
-351.7
-369.7
-394.5
-412.4
-435.6
-452.0
-438.6
-324.9
-17.7
1.9
-23.6
-44.5
-68.3
-91.0
-110.4
-124.0
-130.1
-96.4
44.4
29.6
11.8
-7.2

56.3
47.8
44.8
39.8
37.6
46.4
47.7
58.2
67.7
66.0
69.4
80.4
88.6
136.9
144.9
153.6
165.3
198.5
213.8
227.9
237.1
301.8
314.8
334.4
358.9
378.7
403.3
423.6
417.4
312.2
70.2
82.6
61.4
50.6
73.5
95.3
114.3
128.6
136.6
104.7
40.9
26.2
11.1
0.7

125.7
122.3
130.8
127.2
125.9
145.8
142.2
155.8
165.3
155.5
160.9
177.2
187.6
288.0
296.7
309.5
325.4
385.5
406.3
425.6
437.6
557.7
577.2
608.7
648.6
682.5
724.5
759.7
753.4
596.1
184.1
203.7
182.0
172.3
206.4
238.9
266.6
285.8
292.1
220.5
74.7
50.3
24.7
9.0

10.0
17.8
27.0
30.5
32.3
34.6
30.6
26.9
21.8
17.2
16.7
14.1
11.1
19.5
15.5
13.5
9.9
9.8
5.2
1.2
-1.9
-0.2
-3.1
-5.6
-8.7
-9.9
-11.9
-13.0
-9.7
12.7
31.0
29.2
40.1
46.8
41.8
37.1
32.5
28.1
22.6
13.9
-6.4
-4.8
-3.6
-1.5

111.8
113.3
125.4
124.4
124.3
142.3
137.1
146.4
151.6
140.9
145.1
157.3
164.3
252.7
257.9
267.5
278.8
328.9
343.7
357.6
365.9
467.1
481.8
506.7
538.4
565.9
599.9
628.8
625.3
506.2
172.4
187.7
175.6
171.1
196.9
221.5
242.0
255.7
257.9
193.3
60.5
40.9
20.3
8.4

-118.9
-120.4
-132.7
-131.7
-131.7
-150.1
-145.0
-154.4
-159.6
-149.0
-153.3
-165.6
-172.7
-261.1
-266.4
-276.0
-287.4
-337.4
-352.3
-365.9
-374.3
-475.6
-490.4
-515.1
-546.8
-574.2
-608.2
-637.2
-633.8
-514.6
-180.6
-195.8
-183.8
-179.2
-205.1
-229.7
-250.3
-263.8
-266.1
-201.1
-69.2
-49.5
-28.9
-17.1

-17.1
-25.0
-34.2
-37.8
-39.7
-42.4
-38.5
-34.9
-29.8
-25.4
-24.9
-22.4
-19.5
-27.9
-24.0
-22.0
-18.6
-18.3
-13.8
-9.6
-6.5
-8.2
-5.5
-2.8
0.2
1.7
3.5
4.5
1.2
-21.0
-39.3
-37.3
-48.3
-54.8
-50.0
-45.3
-40.8
-36.3
-30.9
-21.8
-2.3
-3.7
-5.0
-7.2

-63.4
-55.0
-52.1
-47.1
-45.0
-54.2
-55.6
-66.2
-75.7
-74.1
-77.6
-88.7
-96.9
-145.3
-153.4
-162.2
-173.9
-207.1
-222.4
-236.2
-245.5
-310.2
-323.3
-342.8
-367.3
-387.0
-411.7
-432.0
-425.8
-320.5
-78.4
-90.7
-69.6
-58.7
-81.6
-103.4
-122.5
-136.8
-144.8
-112.6
-49.5
-34.8
-19.7
-9.3

-132.8
-129.4
-138.0
-134.5
-133.3
-153.7
-150.1
-163.8
-173.4
-163.6
-169.1
-185.5
-195.9
-296.4
-305.2
-318.1
-334.0
-394.0
-414.9
-433.9
-446.0
-566.2
-585.7
-617.1
-657.1
-690.8
-732.8
-768.1
-761.9
-604.4
-192.4
-211.8
-190.2
-180.4
-214.5
-247.1
-274.8
-294.0
-300.3
-228.3
-83.3
-58.8
-33.3
-17.7

-5.6
3.3
10.4
18.1
25.1
34.4
39.0
47.0
53.3
51.5
56.5
64.6
70.8
116.5
124.6
135.2
146.4
178.9
192.2
202.9
211.9
276.1
285.4
299.5
319.2
333.4
351.8
364.4
353.0
263.4
19.4
2.7
22.3
38.7
57.5
75.3
90.5
100.7
104.3
75.0
-41.8
-29.9
-15.3
0.6

-0.4
-9.3
-16.5
-24.3
-31.3
-41.0
-45.6
-53.7
-60.1
-58.3
-63.4
-71.6
-77.8
-123.6
-131.7
-142.3
-153.6
-186.1
-199.4
-210.0
-219.0
-283.2
-292.5
-306.5
-326.3
-340.4
-358.8
-371.5
-360.1
-270.5
-26.4
-9.6
-29.1
-45.5
-64.3
-82.2
-97.4
-107.6
-111.2
-81.5
34.5
22.7
8.0
-7.8

-14.8
-3.2
6.1
15.6
25.2
36.0
41.5
52.4
61.5
60.2
66.1
76.9
85.2
138.6
149.0
161.7
175.9
214.9
231.9
246.0
257.4
333.3
345.4
363.5
388.3
406.4
429.5
445.9
432.3
318.7
11.7
-7.8
17.5
38.5
62.4
84.9
104.4
118.0
124.1
90.7
-50.8
-35.8
-18.2
0.8

-2.2
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7

-2.2
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7
-2.7

-13.1
-24.2
-33.5
-44.2
-52.4
-66.9
-73.6
-83.2
-89.7
-85.8
-93.2
-103.2
-110.6
-179.3
-189.6
-204.9
-219.9
-266.9
-284.3
-297.4
-309.6
-403.8
-415.6
-433.7
-460.3
-478.8
-503.5
-519.6
-502.7
-383.7
-55.8
-30.7
-55.7
-77.0
-102.0
-125.7
-145.5
-158.0
-160.4
-114.7
50.1
34.0
13.1
-9.8

8.7
19.7
29.0
39.6
47.7
62.0
68.6
78.1
84.6
80.7
88.0
97.9
105.3
174.0
184.2
199.5
214.5
261.5
278.9
292.2
304.3
398.5
410.3
428.4
455.0
473.6
498.2
514.3
497.4
378.4
50.7
25.6
50.5
72.0
96.9
120.5
140.3
152.8
155.2
109.8
-55.5
-39.4
-18.6
4.3

-10.4
-18.7
-25.7
-33.7
-39.9
-50.8
-55.8
-63.0
-67.9
-65.0
-70.5
-78.0
-83.6
-135.1
-142.9
-154.4
-165.6
-200.8
-213.9
-223.7
-232.8
-303.5
-312.4
-325.9
-345.9
-359.8
-378.3
-390.4
-377.7
-288.4
-42.5
-23.7
-42.4
-58.4
-77.2
-94.9
-109.8
-119.1
-120.9
-86.6
36.9
24.8
9.2
-8.0

5.9
14.2
21.2
29.1
35.2
45.9
50.8
58.0
62.8
59.9
65.3
72.8
78.3
129.8
137.5
149.0
160.2
195.4
208.5
218.5
227.5
298.2
307.0
320.7
340.6
354.6
373.0
385.1
372.4
283.2
37.3
18.6
37.2
53.3
72.0
89.7
104.6
114.0
115.8
81.7
-42.3
-30.2
-14.6
2.6

-10.4
-18.7
-25.7
-33.7
-39.9
-50.8
-55.8
-63.0
-67.9
-65.0
-70.5
-78.0
-83.6
-135.1
-142.9
-154.4
-165.6
-200.8
-213.9
-223.7
-232.8
-303.5
-312.4
-325.9
-345.9
-359.8
-378.3
-390.4
-377.7
-288.4
-42.5
-23.7
-42.4
-58.4
-77.2
-94.9
-109.8
-119.1
-120.9
-86.6
36.9
24.8
9.2
-8.0

5.9
14.2
21.2
29.1
35.2
45.9
50.8
58.0
62.8
59.9
65.3
72.8
78.3
129.8
137.5
149.0
160.2
195.4
208.5
218.5
227.5
298.2
307.0
320.7
340.6
354.6
373.0
385.1
372.4
283.2
37.3
18.6
37.2
53.3
72.0
89.7
104.6
114.0
115.8
81.7
-42.3
-30.2
-14.6
2.6

-8.4
-6.5
-5.2
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8
1.1
2.9
3.2
3.8
5.6
7.0
12.1
13.6
15.0
17.0
21.3
23.7
26.1
27.6
35.4
37.3
40.0
43.4
46.0
49.1
51.6
50.2
34.2
-7.8
-9.6
-5.7
-2.6
0.7
3.9
6.7
9.0
10.5
8.0
-8.7
-6.7
-4.6
-2.6

4.0
2.0
0.6
-0.6
-2.4
-3.5
-4.2
-6.1
-8.0
-8.3
-9.0
-10.8
-12.3
-17.3
-19.0
-20.4
-22.4
-26.7
-29.2
-31.3
-32.9
-40.8
-42.6
-45.3
-48.7
-51.2
-54.4
-56.9
-55.5
-39.5
2.6
4.5
0.6
-2.4
-5.8
-9.0
-11.9
-14.1
-15.7
-12.9
3.2
1.3
-0.8
-2.9

-8.4
-6.5
-5.2
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8
1.1
2.9
3.2
3.8
5.6
7.0
12.1
13.6
15.0
17.0
21.3
23.7
26.1
27.6
35.4
37.3
40.0
43.4
46.0
49.1
51.6
50.2
34.2
-7.8
-9.6
-5.7
-2.6
0.7
3.9
6.7
9.0
10.5
8.0
-8.7
-6.7
-4.6
-2.6

4.0
2.0
0.6
-0.6
-2.4
-3.5
-4.2
-6.1
-8.0
-8.3
-9.0
-10.8
-12.3
-17.3
-19.0
-20.4
-22.4
-26.7
-29.2
-31.3
-32.9
-40.8
-42.6
-45.3
-48.7
-51.2
-54.4
-56.9
-55.5
-39.5
2.6
4.5
0.6
-2.4
-5.8
-9.0
-11.9
-14.1
-15.7
-12.9
3.2
1.3
-0.8
-2.9

-28.2
-31.1
-34.1
-38.6
-39.8
-47.9
-51.1
-52.8
-52.3
-48.5
-52.2
-54.6
-56.0
-92.9
-96.1
-103.5
-109.0
-131.9
-137.8
-141.1
-145.7
-193.8
-197.2
-202.9
-213.1
-219.6
-228.8
-233.7
-225.0
-181.8
-57.2
-43.6
-51.1
-58.3
-67.4
-75.9
-82.6
-85.4
-82.6
-56.1
19.6
13.3
3.6
-7.6

7.4
-6.3
-17.3
-28.8
-40.0
-53.7
-60.5
-73.2
-83.5
-81.5
-88.8
-101.5
-111.2
-177.3
-189.6
-205.2
-222.2
-269.7
-290.0
-306.4
-320.0
-413.3
-427.6
-449.0
-478.7
-500.0
-527.7
-547.1
-530.5
-395.1
-27.9
-3.7
-33.7
-58.5
-86.9
-113.9
-137.0
-152.8
-159.3
-117.2
54.1
36.3
14.7
-8.5

-11.9
1.8
12.8
24.2
35.4
48.8
55.6
68.2
78.5
76.4
83.7
96.3
105.9
172.0
184.3
199.8
216.8
264.3
284.6
301.1
314.7
408.0
422.2
443.7
473.3
494.8
522.5
541.8
525.2
389.8
22.7
-1.4
28.5
53.4
81.8
108.7
131.8
147.7
154.1
112.2
-59.5
-41.7
-20.2
3.0

23.8
26.5
29.6
34.0
35.1
43.0
46.1
47.7
47.2
43.4
47.0
49.3
50.7
87.6
90.7
98.1
103.6
126.5
132.4
135.8
140.4
188.5
191.8
197.6
207.8
214.4
223.5
228.4
219.6
176.5
52.0
38.5
46.0
53.3
62.3
70.8
77.4
80.3
77.4
51.2
-25.1
-18.7
-9.0
2.1

-26.4
-27.1
-28.4
-30.8
-30.4
-35.8
-37.7
-37.5
-35.8
-32.7
-35.0
-35.5
-35.5
-59.4
-60.5
-65.1
-67.7
-81.7
-84.3
-85.0
-87.3
-117.5
-118.7
-121.0
-126.1
-129.0
-133.5
-135.4
-129.9
-109.5
-47.4
-38.7
-41.4
-44.5
-48.8
-52.8
-55.7
-56.1
-52.8
-34.9
9.6
6.4
0.6
-6.3

-17.1
-20.7
-24.0
-28.3
-30.5
-37.4
-40.2
-42.9
-44.0
-41.4
-44.6
-47.8
-49.9
-81.4
-85.0
-91.7
-97.3
-117.7
-124.0
-128.1
-132.8
-174.7
-178.7
-185.0
-195.2
-201.9
-211.3
-216.8
-209.2
-164.8
-39.7
-28.1
-36.6
-44.3
-53.7
-62.5
-69.6
-73.4
-72.5
-50.6
18.5
12.3
3.5
-6.5

-26.4
-27.1
-28.4
-30.8
-30.4
-35.8
-37.7
-37.5
-35.8
-32.7
-35.0
-35.5
-35.5
-59.4
-60.5
-65.1
-67.7
-81.7
-84.3
-85.0
-87.3
-117.5
-118.7
-121.0
-126.1
-129.0
-133.5
-135.4
-129.9
-109.5
-47.4
-38.7
-41.4
-44.5
-48.8
-52.8
-55.7
-56.1
-52.8
-34.9
9.6
6.4
0.6
-6.3

-17.1
-20.7
-24.0
-28.3
-30.5
-37.4
-40.2
-42.9
-44.0
-41.4
-44.6
-47.8
-49.9
-81.4
-85.0
-91.7
-97.3
-117.7
-124.0
-128.1
-132.8
-174.7
-178.7
-185.0
-195.2
-201.9
-211.3
-216.8
-209.2
-164.8
-39.7
-28.1
-36.6
-44.3
-53.7
-62.5
-69.6
-73.4
-72.5
-50.6
18.5
12.3
3.5
-6.5

0.3
-8.5
-15.8
-23.5
-30.6
-40.2
-44.8
-52.9
-59.2
-57.5
-62.5
-70.7
-76.9
-122.7
-130.8
-141.4
-152.7
-185.2
-198.5
-209.1
-218.1
-282.3
-291.6
-305.7
-325.4
-339.5
-357.9
-370.6
-359.2
-269.6
-25.5
-8.7
-28.3
-44.6
-63.4
-81.3
-96.5
-106.7
-110.4
-80.7
35.4
23.6
8.9
-6.9

-14.1
-2.4
6.8
16.4
26.0
36.8
42.4
53.3
62.4
61.0
67.0
77.8
86.1
139.5
149.9
162.6
176.8
215.7
232.8
246.9
258.2
334.2
346.3
364.4
389.2
407.2
430.4
446.7
433.2
319.6
12.5
-7.0
18.4
39.4
63.2
85.8
105.2
118.9
124.9
91.5
-49.9
-34.9
-17.3
1.7

12.6
16.1
19.4
23.7
25.8
32.4
35.3
37.9
38.9
36.3
39.5
42.5
44.6
76.2
79.7
86.3
91.9
112.3
118.6
122.9
127.4
169.4
173.3
179.7
189.9
196.7
206.0
211.5
203.9
159.5
34.5
23.0
31.5
39.3
48.6
57.3
64.4
68.3
67.3
45.6
-24.0
-17.7
-8.9
1.0

21.9
22.6
23.8
26.2
25.7
30.9
32.7
32.5
30.7
27.6
29.9
30.2
30.2
54.1
55.2
59.7
62.3
76.3
78.9
79.8
82.0
112.2
113.3
115.7
120.8
123.8
128.3
130.1
124.5
104.2
42.2
33.6
36.2
39.4
43.7
47.6
50.5
51.0
47.6
30.0
-15.0
-11.7
-6.0
0.8

12.6
16.1
19.4
23.7
25.8
32.4
35.3
37.9
38.9
36.3
39.5
42.5
44.6
76.2
79.7
86.3
91.9
112.3
118.6
122.9
127.4
169.4
173.3
179.7
189.9
196.7
206.0
211.5
203.9
159.5
34.5
23.0
31.5
39.3
48.6
57.3
64.4
68.3
67.3
45.6
-24.0
-17.7
-8.9
1.0

21.9
22.6
23.8
26.2
25.7
30.9
32.7
32.5
30.7
27.6
29.9
30.2
30.2
54.1
55.2
59.7
62.3
76.3
78.9
79.8
82.0
112.2
113.3
115.7
120.8
123.8
128.3
130.1
124.5
104.2
42.2
33.6
36.2
39.4
43.7
47.6
50.5
51.0
47.6
30.0
-15.0
-11.7
-6.0
0.8

9.6
-2.1
-11.4
-21.0
-30.7
-41.7
-47.3
-58.3
-67.5
-66.2
-72.1
-83.0
-91.4
-144.8
-155.3
-168.0
-182.3
-221.1
-238.2
-252.2
-263.6
-339.5
-351.7
-369.7
-394.5
-412.4
-435.6
-452.0
-438.6
-324.9
-17.7
1.9
-23.6
-44.5
-68.3
-91.0
-110.4
-124.0
-130.1
-96.4
44.4
29.6
11.8
-7.2

-4.8
4.0
11.2
18.9
25.9
35.2
39.8
47.9
54.2
52.4
57.3
65.5
71.6
117.4
125.5
136.1
147.3
179.8
193.1
203.8
212.8
277.0
286.3
300.4
320.1
334.3
352.7
365.3
353.9
264.3
20.3
3.6
23.1
39.5
58.3
76.1
91.3
101.6
105.2
75.8
-40.9
-29.0
-14.4
1.5

9.6
-2.1
-11.4
-21.0
-30.7
-41.7
-47.3
-58.3
-67.5
-66.2
-72.1
-83.0
-91.4
-144.8
-155.3
-168.0
-182.3
-221.1
-238.2
-252.2
-263.6
-339.5
-351.7
-369.7
-394.5
-412.4
-435.6
-452.0
-438.6
-324.9
-17.7
1.9
-23.6
-44.5
-68.3
-91.0
-110.4
-124.0
-130.1
-96.4
44.4
29.6
11.8
-7.2

-4.8
4.0
11.2
18.9
25.9
35.2
39.8
47.9
54.2
52.4
57.3
65.5
71.6
117.4
125.5
136.1
147.3
179.8
193.1
203.8
212.8
277.0
286.3
300.4
320.1
334.3
352.7
365.3
353.9
264.3
20.3
3.6
23.1
39.5
58.3
76.1
91.3
101.6
105.2
75.8
-40.9
-29.0
-14.4
1.5

0.3
-8.5
-15.8
-23.5
-30.6
-40.2
-44.8
-52.9
-59.2
-57.5
-62.5
-70.7
-76.9
-122.7
-130.8
-141.4
-152.7
-185.2
-198.5
-209.1
-218.1
-282.3
-291.6
-305.7
-325.4
-339.5
-357.9
-370.6
-359.2
-269.6
-25.5
-8.7
-28.3
-44.6
-63.4
-81.3
-96.5
-106.7
-110.4
-80.7
35.4
23.6
8.9
-6.9

-14.1
-2.4
6.8
16.4
26.0
36.8
42.4
53.3
62.4
61.0
67.0
77.8
86.1
139.5
149.9
162.6
176.8
215.7
232.8
246.9
258.2
334.2
346.3
364.4
389.2
407.2
430.4
446.7
433.2
319.6
12.5
-7.0
18.4
39.4
63.2
85.8
105.2
118.9
124.9
91.5
-49.9
-34.9
-17.3
1.7

56.3
47.8
44.8
39.8
37.6
46.4
47.7
58.2
67.7
66.0
69.4
80.4
88.6
136.9
144.9
153.6
165.3
198.5
213.8
227.9
237.1
301.8
314.8
334.4
358.9
378.7
403.3
423.6
417.4
312.2
70.2
82.6
61.4
50.6
73.5
95.3
114.3
128.6
136.6
104.7
40.9
26.2
11.1
0.7

125.7
122.3
130.8
127.2
125.9
145.8
142.2
155.8
165.3
155.5
160.9
177.2
187.6
288.0
296.7
309.5
325.4
385.5
406.3
425.6
437.6
557.7
577.2
608.7
648.6
682.5
724.5
759.7
753.4
596.1
184.1
203.7
182.0
172.3
206.4
238.9
266.6
285.8
292.1
220.5
74.7
50.3
24.7
9.0

10.0
17.8
27.0
30.5
32.3
34.6
30.6
26.9
21.8
17.2
16.7
14.1
11.1
19.5
15.5
13.5
9.9
9.8
5.2
1.2
-1.9
-0.2
-3.1
-5.6
-8.7
-9.9
-11.9
-13.0
-9.7
12.7
31.0
29.2
40.1
46.8
41.8
37.1
32.5
28.1
22.6
13.9
-6.4
-4.8
-3.6
-1.5

111.8
113.3
125.4
124.4
124.3
142.3
137.1
146.4
151.6
140.9
145.1
157.3
164.3
252.7
257.9
267.5
278.8
328.9
343.7
357.6
365.9
467.1
481.8
506.7
538.4
565.9
599.9
628.8
625.3
506.2
172.4
187.7
175.6
171.1
196.9
221.5
242.0
255.7
257.9
193.3
60.5
40.9
20.3
8.4

-118.9
-120.4
-132.7
-131.7
-131.7
-150.1
-145.0
-154.4
-159.6
-149.0
-153.3
-165.6
-172.7
-261.1
-266.4
-276.0
-287.4
-337.4
-352.3
-365.9
-374.3
-475.6
-490.4
-515.1
-546.8
-574.2
-608.2
-637.2
-633.8
-514.6
-180.6
-195.8
-183.8
-179.2
-205.1
-229.7
-250.3
-263.8
-266.1
-201.1
-69.2
-49.5
-28.9
-17.1

-17.1
-25.0
-34.2
-37.8
-39.7
-42.4
-38.5
-34.9
-29.8
-25.4
-24.9
-22.4
-19.5
-27.9
-24.0
-22.0
-18.6
-18.3
-13.8
-9.6
-6.5
-8.2
-5.5
-2.8
0.2
1.7
3.5
4.5
1.2
-21.0
-39.3
-37.3
-48.3
-54.8
-50.0
-45.3
-40.8
-36.3
-30.9
-21.8
-2.3
-3.7
-5.0
-7.2

-63.4
-55.0
-52.1
-47.1
-45.0
-54.2
-55.6
-66.2
-75.7
-74.1
-77.6
-88.7
-96.9
-145.3
-153.4
-162.2
-173.9
-207.1
-222.4
-236.2
-245.5
-310.2
-323.3
-342.8
-367.3
-387.0
-411.7
-432.0
-425.8
-320.5
-78.4
-90.7
-69.6
-58.7
-81.6
-103.4
-122.5
-136.8
-144.8
-112.6
-49.5
-34.8
-19.7
-9.3

-132.8
-129.4
-138.0
-134.5
-133.3
-153.7
-150.1
-163.8
-173.4
-163.6
-169.1
-185.5
-195.9
-296.4
-305.2
-318.1
-334.0
-394.0
-414.9
-433.9
-446.0
-566.2
-585.7
-617.1
-657.1
-690.8
-732.8
-768.1
-761.9
-604.4
-192.4
-211.8
-190.2
-180.4
-214.5
-247.1
-274.8
-294.0
-300.3
-228.3
-83.3
-58.8
-33.3
-17.7

-525.8
-422.1
-386.0
-385.1
-367.8
-353.0
-341.5
-326.5
-306.3
-240.3
-9.2
-7.3
-8.8
-11.7

467.3
368.7
336.7
337.0
322.8
311.6
303.0
291.3
273.8
214.4
-11.3
-10.6
-6.8
-1.6

-609.2
-486.1
-446.0
-446.0
-427.2
-411.5
-399.6
-383.7
-362.0
-286.3
-7.7
-6.3
-8.5
-12.1

-22.0
-20.0
-18.5
-18.0
-16.8
-15.5
-14.5
-13.2
-12.2
-9.7
-7.7
-6.7
-5.9
-5.0

-22.0
-20.0
-18.5
-18.0
-16.8
-15.5
-14.5
-13.2
-12.2
-9.7
-7.7
-6.7
-5.9
-5.0

720.5
574.9
522.7
521.0
496.5
476.3
460.2
439.0
408.8
316.2
-7.1
-8.0
-3.5
3.4

-764.4
-614.9
-559.7
-557.1
-530.2
-507.3
-489.1
-465.4
-433.2
-335.7
-8.2
-5.5
-8.2
-13.4

534.9
426.2
387.4
386.2
368.2
353.3
341.5
326.0
303.6
234.7
-7.2
-7.7
-4.1
1.3

-578.8
-466.2
-424.4
-422.3
-401.9
-384.4
-370.4
-352.4
-327.9
-254.2
-8.1
-5.8
-7.6
-11.3

534.9
426.2
387.4
386.2
368.2
353.3
341.5
326.0
303.6
234.7
-7.2
-7.7
-4.1
1.3

-578.8
-466.2
-424.4
-422.3
-401.9
-384.4
-370.4
-352.4
-327.9
-254.2
-8.1
-5.8
-7.6
-11.3

-77.5
-62.7
-58.4
-58.6
-56.4
-54.5
-53.1
-51.3
-49.3
-40.4
-6.7
-6.1
-5.6
-5.2

33.6
22.7
21.5
22.5
22.7
23.4
24.2
24.9
25.0
20.9
-8.6
-7.4
-6.1
-4.8

-77.5
-62.7
-58.4
-58.6
-56.4
-54.5
-53.1
-51.3
-49.3
-40.4
-6.7
-6.1
-5.6
-5.2

33.6
22.7
21.5
22.5
22.7
23.4
24.2
24.9
25.0
20.9
-8.6
-7.4
-6.1
-4.8

374.7
303.0
272.0
269.0
253.7
240.6
229.5
215.5
195.8
145.7
-4.5
-5.8
-3.4
0.6

695.0
549.4
502.9
503.4
482.7
466.1
453.5
436.4
411.4
323.8
-10.0
-9.6
-4.7
2.0

-739.0
-589.4
-539.9
-539.5
-516.4
-497.1
-482.4
-462.8
-435.7
-343.2
-5.3
-3.9
-7.0
-12.0

-418.6
-343.0
-308.9
-305.1
-287.3
-271.6
-258.4
-242.0
-220.1
-165.2
-10.9
-7.7
-8.3
-10.6

234.1
190.4
169.5
167.0
156.5
147.5
139.7
129.9
116.0
83.9
-4.5
-5.5
-3.8
-1.0

317.4
254.5
229.5
227.9
215.9
205.9
197.7
187.1
171.8
129.9
-6.0
-6.5
-4.2
-0.6

234.1
190.4
169.5
167.0
156.5
147.5
139.7
129.9
116.0
83.9
-4.5
-5.5
-3.8
-1.0

317.4
254.5
229.5
227.9
215.9
205.9
197.7
187.1
171.8
129.9
-6.0
-6.5
-4.2
-0.6

474.6
375.4
342.9
343.0
328.5
316.8
307.8
295.7
277.9
217.6
-8.7
-8.4
-4.9
0.1

-601.8
-479.4
-439.9
-439.9
-421.6
-406.3
-394.7
-379.3
-358.0
-283.1
-5.2
-4.1
-6.5
-10.4

-361.4
-294.5
-266.5
-264.0
-249.6
-237.0
-226.6
-213.5
-196.1
-149.4
-9.4
-6.9
-7.5
-9.4

-278.0
-230.4
-206.5
-203.1
-190.2
-178.5
-168.6
-156.3
-140.4
-103.4
-10.8
-7.9
-7.9
-9.0

-361.4
-294.5
-266.5
-264.0
-249.6
-237.0
-226.6
-213.5
-196.1
-149.4
-9.4
-6.9
-7.5
-9.4

-278.0
-230.4
-206.5
-203.1
-190.2
-178.5
-168.6
-156.3
-140.4
-103.4
-10.8
-7.9
-7.9
-9.0

557.9
439.4
402.9
403.9
387.9
375.2
365.8
352.9
333.7
263.6
-10.2
-9.4
-5.2
0.4

-518.5
-415.4
-379.9
-379.1
-362.1
-347.8
-336.7
-322.1
-302.2
-237.1
-6.6
-5.1
-6.9
-10.1

557.9
439.4
402.9
403.9
387.9
375.2
365.8
352.9
333.7
263.6
-10.2
-9.4
-5.2
0.4

-518.5
-415.4
-379.9
-379.1
-362.1
-347.8
-336.7
-322.1
-302.2
-237.1
-6.6
-5.1
-6.9
-10.1

474.6
375.4
342.9
343.0
328.5
316.8
307.8
295.7
277.9
217.6
-8.7
-8.4
-4.9
0.1

-601.8
-479.4
-439.9
-439.9
-421.6
-406.3
-394.7
-379.3
-358.0
-283.1
-5.2
-4.1
-6.5
-10.4

416.3
321.7
302.3
310.0
306.3
305.6
307.3
306.3
300.1
247.4
-3.1
-3.4
-5.2
-2.1

789.5
622.3
583.3
598.0
590.5
589.1
592.3
589.1
574.1
470.2
6.9
6.7
2.7
7.0

-31.7
-23.9
-22.7
-21.1
-18.6
-15.6
-12.9
-10.8
-10.6
-10.1
-10.5
-7.9
-6.3
-5.0

655.1
518.6
485.7
498.7
493.0
492.8
496.2
493.9
480.9
393.0
4.6
5.4
2.4
6.1

-724.8
-582.2
-544.4
-556.0
-546.5
-542.1
-542.1
-535.9
-519.5
-423.9
-29.0
-26.7
-20.9
-22.0

-38.0
-39.6
-36.0
-36.2
-34.9
-33.7
-33.0
-31.2
-28.0
-20.8
-13.9
-13.4
-12.3
-10.8

-486.0
-385.3
-361.0
-367.3
-359.7
-354.9
-353.2
-348.2
-338.7
-278.3
-21.3
-18.0
-13.4
-13.7

-859.2
-685.9
-642.0
-655.3
-644.0
-638.5
-638.2
-631.0
-612.7
-501.1
-31.2
-28.1
-21.3
-22.9

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 2 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)


11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22
D22

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

205
205
205
205
205
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
530
530
530
530
633
633
633
633
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
855
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

A16

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead

Live

-2.48
-2.51
-2.54
-2.56
-2.59
-2.73
-2.76
-2.79
-2.82
-2.85
-2.87
-2.90
-2.93
-2.94
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-2.99
-3.02
-2.93
-2.95
-2.95
-2.98
-2.94
-2.96
-2.89
-2.92
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.88
-2.84
-2.86
-2.82
-2.84
-2.86
-2.89
-2.85
-2.87
-2.74
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-3.04

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindMTX
5.15
3.57
2.42
1.40
-0.06
-0.87
-1.40
-3.00
-4.56
-4.81
-5.33
-6.83
-8.03
-12.25
-13.58
-14.75
-16.41
-19.97
-22.03
-23.92
-25.21
-31.75
-33.30
-35.55
-38.35
-40.48
-43.13
-45.20
-44.04
-30.69
4.31
5.86
2.62
0.08
-2.71
-5.36
-7.73
-9.60
-10.94
-8.70
4.98
3.32
1.61
-0.13

WindMTX
-5.15
-3.57
-2.42
-1.40
0.06
0.87
1.40
3.00
4.56
4.81
5.33
6.83
8.03
12.25
13.58
14.75
16.41
19.97
22.03
23.92
25.21
31.75
33.30
35.55
38.35
40.48
43.13
45.20
44.04
30.69
-4.31
-5.86
-2.62
-0.08
2.71
5.36
7.73
9.60
10.94
8.70
-4.98
-3.32
-1.61
0.13

WindMTX
-46.26
-35.54
-33.30
-33.78
-32.99
-32.46
-32.21
-31.74
-30.96
-25.54
0.80
0.54
0.19
-0.20

WindFY
6.82
13.70
19.54
26.19
31.30
40.30
44.44
50.40
54.49
52.05
56.61
62.85
67.47
110.39
116.82
126.40
135.74
165.11
176.00
184.25
191.83
250.74
258.09
269.41
286.04
297.65
313.02
323.11
312.55
238.17
33.28
17.60
33.18
46.56
62.17
76.94
89.32
97.13
98.63
70.14
-32.99
-22.92
-9.90
4.43

WindFY
-6.82
-13.70
-19.54
-26.19
-31.30
-40.30
-44.44
-50.40
-54.49
-52.05
-56.61
-62.85
-67.47
-110.39
-116.82
-126.40
-135.74
-165.11
-176.00
-184.25
-191.83
-250.74
-258.09
-269.41
-286.04
-297.65
-313.02
-323.11
-312.55
-238.17
-33.28
-17.60
-33.18
-46.56
-62.17
-76.94
-89.32
-97.13
-98.63
-70.14
32.99
22.92
9.90
-4.43

WindFY
464.01
371.82
338.26
336.90
320.87
307.38
296.63
282.65
263.12
203.71
0.36
-0.80
1.49
5.26

WindMTY
14.84
10.31
7.00
4.08
-0.10
-2.42
-3.94
-8.53
-13.02
-13.75
-15.25
-19.55
-23.01
-35.16
-38.99
-42.38
-47.16
-57.42
-63.39
-68.85
-72.60
-91.48
-96.00
-102.51
-110.63
-116.84
-124.55
-130.58
-127.31
-88.89
12.18
16.64
7.27
-0.06
-8.14
-15.82
-22.67
-28.08
-31.97
-25.44
14.34
9.56
4.64
-0.37

WindMTY
-14.84
-10.31
-7.00
-4.08
0.10
2.42
3.94
8.53
13.02
13.75
15.25
19.55
23.01
35.16
38.99
42.38
47.16
57.42
63.39
68.85
72.60
91.48
96.00
102.51
110.63
116.84
124.55
130.58
127.31
88.89
-12.18
-16.64
-7.27
0.06
8.14
15.82
22.67
28.08
31.97
25.44
-14.34
-9.56
-4.64
0.37

WindMTY
-133.49
-102.65
-96.23
-97.68
-95.45
-93.97
-93.32
-92.02
-89.84
-74.20
2.33
1.57
0.56
-0.57

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
74.07
47.92
28.59
14.89
8.41
18.88
27.33
50.09
73.38
77.99
84.31
106.06
123.81
187.73
206.87
224.11
248.37
301.79
333.64
362.35
382.17
482.88
508.21
543.60
587.66
621.36
663.87
698.01
682.78
478.83
62.57
85.33
34.11
6.15
50.60
92.92
130.69
160.69
182.24
145.17
75.51
49.69
23.49
3.48

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

58.2
49.7
46.8
41.8
39.5
48.5
49.8
60.3
69.8
68.2
71.6
82.6
90.8
139.1
147.2
155.9
167.6
200.8
216.1
230.1
239.3
304.0
317.1
336.6
361.1
380.9
405.6
425.8
419.6
314.4
72.3
84.7
63.6
52.8
75.6
97.4
116.5
130.8
138.8
106.8
43.2
28.5
13.4
3.0

127.6
124.2
132.7
129.1
127.8
147.9
144.3
157.9
167.5
157.7
163.1
179.4
189.8
290.2
299.0
311.8
327.7
387.8
408.6
427.8
439.8
560.0
579.5
610.9
650.9
684.7
726.7
762.0
755.6
598.3
186.3
205.8
184.2
174.4
208.6
241.1
268.8
288.0
294.3
222.6
77.0
52.5
27.0
11.3

11.9
19.7
28.9
32.5
34.3
36.7
32.7
29.0
23.9
19.4
18.8
16.3
13.4
21.7
17.8
15.7
12.2
12.1
7.4
3.4
0.3
2.0
-0.8
-3.4
-6.4
-7.8
-9.7
-10.7
-7.4
14.9
33.2
31.3
42.3
48.9
44.0
39.3
34.7
30.3
24.8
16.0
-4.1
-2.6
-1.3
0.8

113.7
115.2
127.4
126.3
126.2
144.4
139.2
148.5
153.7
143.0
147.2
159.5
166.5
255.0
260.2
269.7
281.0
331.1
346.0
359.8
368.1
469.4
484.1
508.9
540.6
568.1
602.1
631.0
627.5
508.4
174.6
189.8
177.8
173.3
199.1
223.7
244.2
257.8
260.1
195.4
62.8
43.2
22.6
10.7

-117.0
-118.5
-130.8
-129.8
-129.7
-148.0
-142.9
-152.3
-157.5
-146.9
-151.1
-163.4
-170.5
-258.9
-264.1
-273.7
-285.1
-335.1
-350.1
-363.7
-372.1
-473.3
-488.1
-512.8
-544.6
-572.0
-606.0
-634.9
-631.5
-512.4
-178.4
-193.6
-181.6
-177.1
-202.9
-227.5
-248.1
-261.7
-264.0
-199.0
-66.9
-47.2
-26.6
-14.8

-15.2
-23.1
-32.3
-35.9
-37.7
-40.3
-36.4
-32.7
-27.7
-23.2
-22.7
-20.2
-17.3
-25.6
-21.8
-19.7
-16.3
-16.1
-11.5
-7.4
-4.3
-6.0
-3.2
-0.5
2.5
3.9
5.8
6.8
3.5
-18.8
-37.1
-35.1
-46.1
-52.7
-47.8
-43.2
-38.6
-34.1
-28.7
-19.7
0.0
-1.4
-2.7
-4.9

-61.5
-53.1
-50.2
-45.2
-43.0
-52.1
-53.5
-64.1
-73.6
-72.0
-75.4
-86.5
-94.7
-143.0
-151.1
-159.9
-171.6
-204.8
-220.2
-234.0
-243.3
-308.0
-321.1
-340.5
-365.1
-384.8
-409.5
-429.8
-423.6
-318.3
-76.2
-88.5
-67.5
-56.5
-79.5
-101.3
-120.3
-134.6
-142.7
-110.5
-47.2
-32.5
-17.4
-7.0

-130.9
-127.5
-136.1
-132.6
-131.3
-151.6
-148.0
-161.7
-171.3
-161.5
-166.9
-183.3
-193.7
-294.1
-302.9
-315.8
-331.7
-391.8
-412.7
-431.7
-443.8
-563.9
-583.5
-614.8
-654.9
-688.6
-730.6
-765.9
-759.6
-602.2
-190.2
-209.6
-188.0
-178.2
-212.4
-244.9
-272.6
-291.8
-298.2
-226.3
-81.0
-56.5
-31.1
-15.4

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
127.56
-132.78
124.17
-129.44
132.72
-138.05
129.11
-134.49
127.82
-133.26
147.92
-153.65
144.33
-150.13
157.94
-163.80
167.48
-173.40
157.67
-163.64
163.06
-169.09
179.43
-185.52
189.78
-195.93
290.20
-296.37
298.97
-305.19
311.77
-318.06
327.65
-333.99
387.76
-394.04
408.61
-414.95
427.79
-433.94
439.84
-446.04
559.98
-566.17
579.46
-585.71
610.90
-617.06
650.89
-657.10
684.71
-690.78
726.67
-732.79
761.96
-768.14
755.64
-761.87
598.28
-604.44
186.31
-192.37
205.84
-211.80
184.16
-190.17
174.43
-180.35
208.58
-214.55
241.10
-247.11
268.76
-274.82
288.00
-293.98
294.31
-300.33
222.60
-228.34
76.96
-83.32
52.54
-58.81
27.01
-33.34
11.33
-17.71

0.65
0.63
0.67
0.66
0.65
0.50
0.49
0.53
0.56
0.53
0.55
0.60
0.64
0.56
0.58
0.60
0.63
0.62
0.66
0.69
0.70
0.66
0.69
0.72
0.77
0.81
0.86
0.90
0.89
0.71
0.36
0.40
0.36
0.34
0.40
0.47
0.52
0.55
0.57
0.43
0.16
0.11
0.06
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

58.2
49.7
46.8
41.8
39.5
48.5
49.8
60.3
69.8
68.2
71.6
82.6
90.8
139.1
147.2
155.9
167.6
200.8
216.1
230.1
239.3
304.0
317.1
336.6
361.1
380.9
405.6
425.8
419.6
314.4
72.3
84.7
63.6
52.8
75.6
97.4
116.5
130.8
138.8
106.8
43.2
28.5
13.4
3.0

127.6
124.2
132.7
129.1
127.8
147.9
144.3
157.9
167.5
157.7
163.1
179.4
189.8
290.2
299.0
311.8
327.7
387.8
408.6
427.8
439.8
560.0
579.5
610.9
650.9
684.7
726.7
762.0
755.6
598.3
186.3
205.8
184.2
174.4
208.6
241.1
268.8
288.0
294.3
222.6
77.0
52.5
27.0
11.3

11.9
19.7
28.9
32.5
34.3
36.7
32.7
29.0
23.9
19.4
18.8
16.3
13.4
21.7
17.8
15.7
12.2
12.1
7.4
3.4
0.3
2.0
-0.8
-3.4
-6.4
-7.8
-9.7
-10.7
-7.4
14.9
33.2
31.3
42.3
48.9
44.0
39.3
34.7
30.3
24.8
16.0
-4.1
-2.6
-1.3
0.8

113.7
115.2
127.4
126.3
126.2
144.4
139.2
148.5
153.7
143.0
147.2
159.5
166.5
255.0
260.2
269.7
281.0
331.1
346.0
359.8
368.1
469.4
484.1
508.9
540.6
568.1
602.1
631.0
627.5
508.4
174.6
189.8
177.8
173.3
199.1
223.7
244.2
257.8
260.1
195.4
62.8
43.2
22.6
10.7

-117.0
-118.5
-130.8
-129.8
-129.7
-148.0
-142.9
-152.3
-157.5
-146.9
-151.1
-163.4
-170.5
-258.9
-264.1
-273.7
-285.1
-335.1
-350.1
-363.7
-372.1
-473.3
-488.1
-512.8
-544.6
-572.0
-606.0
-634.9
-631.5
-512.4
-178.4
-193.6
-181.6
-177.1
-202.9
-227.5
-248.1
-261.7
-264.0
-199.0
-66.9
-47.2
-26.6
-14.8

-15.2
-23.1
-32.3
-35.9
-37.7
-40.3
-36.4
-32.7
-27.7
-23.2
-22.7
-20.2
-17.3
-25.6
-21.8
-19.7
-16.3
-16.1
-11.5
-7.4
-4.3
-6.0
-3.2
-0.5
2.5
3.9
5.8
6.8
3.5
-18.8
-37.1
-35.1
-46.1
-52.7
-47.8
-43.2
-38.6
-34.1
-28.7
-19.7
0.0
-1.4
-2.7
-4.9

-61.5
-53.1
-50.2
-45.2
-43.0
-52.1
-53.5
-64.1
-73.6
-72.0
-75.4
-86.5
-94.7
-143.0
-151.1
-159.9
-171.6
-204.8
-220.2
-234.0
-243.3
-308.0
-321.1
-340.5
-365.1
-384.8
-409.5
-429.8
-423.6
-318.3
-76.2
-88.5
-67.5
-56.5
-79.5
-101.3
-120.3
-134.6
-142.7
-110.5
-47.2
-32.5
-17.4
-7.0

-130.9
-127.5
-136.1
-132.6
-131.3
-151.6
-148.0
-161.7
-171.3
-161.5
-166.9
-183.3
-193.7
-294.1
-302.9
-315.8
-331.7
-391.8
-412.7
-431.7
-443.8
-563.9
-583.5
-614.8
-654.9
-688.6
-730.6
-765.9
-759.6
-602.2
-190.2
-209.6
-188.0
-178.2
-212.4
-244.9
-272.6
-291.8
-298.2
-226.3
-81.0
-56.5
-31.1
-15.4

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
127.56
-132.78
124.17
-129.44
132.72
-138.05
129.11
-134.49
127.82
-133.26
147.92
-153.65
144.33
-150.13
157.94
-163.80
167.48
-173.40
157.67
-163.64
163.06
-169.09
179.43
-185.52
189.78
-195.93
290.20
-296.37
298.97
-305.19
311.77
-318.06
327.65
-333.99
387.76
-394.04
408.61
-414.95
427.79
-433.94
439.84
-446.04
559.98
-566.17
579.46
-585.71
610.90
-617.06
650.89
-657.10
684.71
-690.78
726.67
-732.79
761.96
-768.14
755.64
-761.87
598.28
-604.44
186.31
-192.37
205.84
-211.80
184.16
-190.17
174.43
-180.35
208.58
-214.55
241.10
-247.11
268.76
-274.82
288.00
-293.98
294.31
-300.33
222.60
-228.34
76.96
-83.32
52.54
-58.81
27.01
-33.34
11.33
-17.71

0.65
0.63
0.67
0.66
0.65
0.50
0.49
0.53
0.56
0.53
0.55
0.60
0.64
0.56
0.58
0.60
0.63
0.62
0.66
0.69
0.70
0.66
0.69
0.72
0.77
0.81
0.86
0.90
0.89
0.71
0.36
0.40
0.36
0.34
0.40
0.47
0.52
0.55
0.57
0.43
0.16
0.11
0.06
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

434.8
338.6
317.9
325.2
320.4
318.7
319.5
317.4
310.3
255.6
3.4
2.3
-0.2
2.1

808.0
639.2
598.8
613.2
604.7
602.2
604.5
600.2
584.4
478.4
13.3
12.4
7.6
11.2

-13.2
-7.1
-7.2
-5.9
-4.4
-2.5
-0.7
0.4
-0.4
-1.9
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8

673.6
535.5
501.3
513.9
507.2
505.9
508.4
505.1
491.2
401.2
11.1
11.0
7.3
10.4

-706.3
-565.3
-528.9
-540.8
-532.4
-529.0
-529.9
-524.8
-509.3
-415.7
-22.5
-21.1
-16.0
-17.8

-19.5
-22.8
-20.4
-21.0
-20.7
-20.7
-20.8
-20.1
-17.8
-12.6
-7.4
-7.8
-7.3
-6.6

-467.5
-368.4
-345.5
-352.1
-345.6
-341.9
-341.1
-337.1
-328.5
-270.1
-14.8
-12.3
-8.5
-9.5

-840.7
-669.0
-626.4
-640.1
-629.8
-625.4
-626.0
-619.9
-602.5
-492.9
-24.8
-22.4
-16.4
-18.7

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
807.99
-859.21
639.18
-685.86
598.83
-641.96
613.20
-655.30
604.70
-644.00
602.22
-638.46
604.46
-638.18
600.19
-631.01
584.36
-612.74
478.41
-501.12
13.32
-31.22
12.41
-28.11
7.63
-21.29
11.23
-22.89

1.00
0.80
0.75
0.71
0.70
0.69
0.69
0.68
0.66
0.54
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.04

Status
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

SpecY
408.13
405.05
439.71
432.02
429.79
493.91
479.36
517.73
542.35
508.20
524.27
572.16
601.21
916.40
939.73
977.13
1022.60
1206.44
1266.12
1320.93
1354.99
1724.45
1781.60
1875.35
1995.09
2097.27
2224.06
2331.22
2314.95
1853.52
608.73
666.67
610.41
586.59
686.70
782.03
862.58
917.31
931.67
703.64
240.00
166.48
89.54
43.53

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 3 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A17

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

087237.10

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindMTX
46.04
35.36
33.10
33.60
32.79
32.27
32.01
31.55
30.76
25.36
-0.95
-0.66
-0.32
0.07

WindMTX
-46.04
-35.36
-33.10
-33.60
-32.79
-32.27
-32.01
-31.55
-30.76
-25.36
0.95
0.66
0.32
-0.07

WindMTX
46.26
35.54
33.30
33.78
32.99
32.46
32.21
31.74
30.96
25.54
-0.80
-0.54
-0.19
0.20

WindFY
-462.24
-370.11
-336.37
-335.13
-318.99
-305.57
-294.73
-280.93
-261.35
-202.06
1.03
1.94
-0.36
-4.13

WindFY
462.24
370.11
336.37
335.13
318.99
305.57
294.73
280.93
261.35
202.06
-1.03
-1.94
0.36
4.13

WindFY
-464.01
-371.82
-338.26
-336.90
-320.87
-307.38
-296.63
-282.65
-263.12
-203.71
-0.36
0.80
-1.49
-5.26

WindMTY
132.87
102.12
95.64
97.14
94.87
93.41
92.73
91.49
89.28
73.68
-2.77
-1.93
-0.92
0.22

WindMTY
-132.87
-102.12
-95.64
-97.14
-94.87
-93.41
-92.73
-91.49
-89.28
-73.68
2.77
1.93
0.92
-0.22

WindMTY
133.49
102.65
96.23
97.68
95.45
93.97
93.32
92.02
89.84
74.20
-2.33
-1.57
-0.56
0.57

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

16.5
14.0
11.9
11.4
9.7
8.0
6.6
5.0
3.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.5
-6.7

16.5
14.0
11.9
11.4
9.7
8.0
6.6
5.0
3.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.5
-6.7

-723.0
-578.2
-526.3
-524.8
-500.6
-480.9
-465.0
-444.5
-414.6
-320.9
-1.5
-1.2
-6.1
-13.3

756.1
606.1
550.1
547.6
520.1
496.9
478.1
454.5
421.7
325.7
-4.8
-7.4
-4.9
-0.1

-538.1
-430.2
-391.8
-390.8
-373.0
-358.6
-347.1
-332.1
-310.0
-240.1
-1.9
-2.0
-5.9
-11.6

571.2
458.1
415.5
413.5
392.5
374.7
360.2
342.1
317.2
244.8
-4.4
-6.6
-5.1
-1.7

-538.1
-430.2
-391.8
-390.8
-373.0
-358.6
-347.1
-332.1
-310.0
-240.1
-1.9
-2.0
-5.9
-11.6

571.2
458.1
415.5
413.5
392.5
374.7
360.2
342.1
317.2
244.8
-4.4
-6.6
-5.1
-1.7

71.8
56.4
51.6
51.7
49.1
46.8
45.0
42.9
40.5
32.8
-4.3
-5.1
-5.9
-6.6

-38.7
-28.5
-27.8
-28.9
-29.6
-30.7
-31.8
-32.8
-33.3
-28.1
-2.0
-3.5
-5.1
-6.7

71.8
56.4
51.6
51.7
49.1
46.8
45.0
42.9
40.5
32.8
-4.3
-5.1
-5.9
-6.6

-38.7
-28.5
-27.8
-28.9
-29.6
-30.7
-31.8
-32.8
-33.3
-28.1
-2.0
-3.5
-5.1
-6.7

-378.7
-307.6
-277.0
-274.2
-259.2
-246.6
-235.8
-222.3
-202.9
-151.7
-5.3
-4.3
-7.0
-11.4

-697.6
-552.7
-506.5
-507.3
-486.9
-470.7
-458.4
-441.9
-417.2
-328.5
1.4
0.3
-4.8
-11.9

730.7
580.6
530.3
530.1
506.4
486.8
471.5
451.9
424.3
333.2
-7.7
-9.0
-6.2
-1.4

411.8
335.5
300.8
297.0
278.7
262.6
249.0
232.4
210.1
156.4
-1.1
-4.3
-4.0
-2.0

-238.7
-195.6
-175.1
-172.7
-162.6
-154.0
-146.6
-137.2
-123.7
-90.4
-5.6
-4.9
-6.9
-10.1

-321.6
-259.3
-234.8
-233.3
-221.7
-212.1
-204.2
-194.1
-179.1
-136.1
-3.9
-3.7
-6.4
-10.3

-238.7
-195.6
-175.1
-172.7
-162.6
-154.0
-146.6
-137.2
-123.7
-90.4
-5.6
-4.9
-6.9
-10.1

-321.6
-259.3
-234.8
-233.3
-221.7
-212.1
-204.2
-194.1
-179.1
-136.1
-3.9
-3.7
-6.4
-10.3

-478.1
-379.6
-347.5
-347.7
-333.5
-322.3
-313.6
-302.0
-284.5
-223.2
-0.6
-1.4
-5.3
-10.5

594.1
471.2
430.9
431.0
412.1
396.5
384.4
368.9
347.1
273.6
-7.5
-8.4
-6.3
-2.7

354.7
287.2
258.6
256.0
241.2
228.2
217.3
204.1
186.3
140.9
-2.5
-4.9
-4.6
-3.1

271.8
223.5
198.9
195.5
182.1
170.1
159.7
147.2
130.9
95.2
-0.7
-3.7
-4.1
-3.2

354.7
287.2
258.6
256.0
241.2
228.2
217.3
204.1
186.3
140.9
-2.5
-4.9
-4.6
-3.1

271.8
223.5
198.9
195.5
182.1
170.1
159.7
147.2
130.9
95.2
-0.7
-3.7
-4.1
-3.2

-561.0
-443.3
-407.1
-408.3
-392.6
-380.4
-371.3
-358.9
-340.0
-268.9
1.1
-0.2
-4.7
-10.6

511.1
407.5
371.2
370.5
353.0
338.4
326.8
312.1
291.7
227.9
-5.7
-7.2
-5.7
-2.8

-561.0
-443.3
-407.1
-408.3
-392.6
-380.4
-371.3
-358.9
-340.0
-268.9
1.1
-0.2
-4.7
-10.6

16.5
14.0
11.9
11.4
9.7
8.0
6.6
5.0
3.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.5
-6.7

16.5
14.0
11.9
11.4
9.7
8.0
6.6
5.0
3.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.3
-5.5
-6.7

756.1
606.1
550.1
547.6
520.1
496.9
478.1
454.5
421.7
325.7
-4.8
-7.4
-4.9
-0.1

-723.0
-578.2
-526.3
-524.8
-500.6
-480.9
-465.0
-444.5
-414.6
-320.9
-1.5
-1.2
-6.1
-13.3

571.2
458.1
415.5
413.5
392.5
374.7
360.2
342.1
317.2
244.8
-4.4
-6.6
-5.1
-1.7

-538.1
-430.2
-391.8
-390.8
-373.0
-358.6
-347.1
-332.1
-310.0
-240.1
-1.9
-2.0
-5.9
-11.6

571.2
458.1
415.5
413.5
392.5
374.7
360.2
342.1
317.2
244.8
-4.4
-6.6
-5.1
-1.7

-538.1
-430.2
-391.8
-390.8
-373.0
-358.6
-347.1
-332.1
-310.0
-240.1
-1.9
-2.0
-5.9
-11.6

-38.7
-28.5
-27.8
-28.9
-29.6
-30.7
-31.8
-32.8
-33.3
-28.1
-2.0
-3.5
-5.1
-6.7

71.8
56.4
51.6
51.7
49.1
46.8
45.0
42.9
40.5
32.8
-4.3
-5.1
-5.9
-6.6

-38.7
-28.5
-27.8
-28.9
-29.6
-30.7
-31.8
-32.8
-33.3
-28.1
-2.0
-3.5
-5.1
-6.7

71.8
56.4
51.6
51.7
49.1
46.8
45.0
42.9
40.5
32.8
-4.3
-5.1
-5.9
-6.6

411.8
335.5
300.8
297.0
278.7
262.6
249.0
232.4
210.1
156.4
-1.1
-4.3
-4.0
-2.0

730.7
580.6
530.3
530.1
506.4
486.8
471.5
451.9
424.3
333.2
-7.7
-9.0
-6.2
-1.4

-697.6
-552.7
-506.5
-507.3
-486.9
-470.7
-458.4
-441.9
-417.2
-328.5
1.4
0.3
-4.8
-11.9

-378.7
-307.6
-277.0
-274.2
-259.2
-246.6
-235.8
-222.3
-202.9
-151.7
-5.3
-4.3
-7.0
-11.4

271.8
223.5
198.9
195.5
182.1
170.1
159.7
147.2
130.9
95.2
-0.7
-3.7
-4.1
-3.2

354.7
287.2
258.6
256.0
241.2
228.2
217.3
204.1
186.3
140.9
-2.5
-4.9
-4.6
-3.1

271.8
223.5
198.9
195.5
182.1
170.1
159.7
147.2
130.9
95.2
-0.7
-3.7
-4.1
-3.2

354.7
287.2
258.6
256.0
241.2
228.2
217.3
204.1
186.3
140.9
-2.5
-4.9
-4.6
-3.1

511.1
407.5
371.2
370.5
353.0
338.4
326.8
312.1
291.7
227.9
-5.7
-7.2
-5.7
-2.8

-561.0
-443.3
-407.1
-408.3
-392.6
-380.4
-371.3
-358.9
-340.0
-268.9
1.1
-0.2
-4.7
-10.6

-321.6
-259.3
-234.8
-233.3
-221.7
-212.1
-204.2
-194.1
-179.1
-136.1
-3.9
-3.7
-6.4
-10.3

-238.7
-195.6
-175.1
-172.7
-162.6
-154.0
-146.6
-137.2
-123.7
-90.4
-5.6
-4.9
-6.9
-10.1

-321.6
-259.3
-234.8
-233.3
-221.7
-212.1
-204.2
-194.1
-179.1
-136.1
-3.9
-3.7
-6.4
-10.3

-238.7
-195.6
-175.1
-172.7
-162.6
-154.0
-146.6
-137.2
-123.7
-90.4
-5.6
-4.9
-6.9
-10.1

594.1
471.2
430.9
431.0
412.1
396.5
384.4
368.9
347.1
273.6
-7.5
-8.4
-6.3
-2.7

-478.1
-379.6
-347.5
-347.7
-333.5
-322.3
-313.6
-302.0
-284.5
-223.2
-0.6
-1.4
-5.3
-10.5

594.1
471.2
430.9
431.0
412.1
396.5
384.4
368.9
347.1
273.6
-7.5
-8.4
-6.3
-2.7

-29.3
-26.7
-24.6
-24.1
-22.5
-20.7
-19.3
-17.6
-16.2
-13.0
-10.2
-9.0
-7.8
-6.7

-29.3
-26.7
-24.6
-24.1
-22.5
-20.7
-19.3
-17.6
-16.2
-13.0
-10.2
-9.0
-7.8
-6.7

-771.7
-621.6
-565.9
-563.1
-535.9
-512.5
-493.9
-469.8
-437.2
-338.9
-10.8
-7.7
-10.2
-15.1

713.1
568.2
516.6
515.0
490.9
471.1
455.3
434.6
404.8
313.0
-9.7
-10.2
-5.4
1.8

-586.1
-472.9
-430.6
-428.3
-407.5
-389.6
-375.2
-356.8
-332.0
-257.4
-10.7
-8.0
-9.6
-13.0

527.5
419.5
381.3
380.2
362.6
348.1
336.7
321.6
299.5
231.5
-9.8
-9.9
-6.0
-0.4

-586.1
-472.9
-430.6
-428.3
-407.5
-389.6
-375.2
-356.8
-332.0
-257.4
-10.7
-8.0
-9.6
-13.0

527.5
419.5
381.3
380.2
362.6
348.1
336.7
321.6
299.5
231.5
-9.8
-9.9
-6.0
-0.4

26.2
16.0
15.3
16.5
17.1
18.2
19.4
20.5
20.9
17.7
-11.2
-9.6
-8.0
-6.4

-84.8
-69.3
-64.6
-64.6
-62.1
-59.7
-57.9
-55.7
-53.4
-43.6
-9.3
-8.3
-7.6
-6.9

26.2
16.0
15.3
16.5
17.1
18.2
19.4
20.5
20.9
17.7
-11.2
-9.6
-8.0
-6.4

-84.8
-69.3
-64.6
-64.6
-62.1
-59.7
-57.9
-55.7
-53.4
-43.6
-9.3
-8.3
-7.6
-6.9

-425.9
-349.7
-315.1
-311.1
-293.0
-276.8
-263.2
-246.4
-224.2
-168.4
-13.5
-9.9
-10.3
-12.3

-746.3
-596.0
-546.0
-545.5
-522.0
-502.3
-487.2
-467.2
-439.8
-346.5
-7.9
-6.1
-8.9
-13.7

687.7
542.7
496.7
497.4
477.1
460.9
448.7
432.0
407.3
320.5
-12.6
-11.8
-6.7
0.3

367.3
296.3
265.8
263.0
248.0
235.4
224.7
211.1
191.7
142.4
-7.0
-8.0
-5.3
-1.0

-285.3
-237.1
-212.7
-209.1
-195.8
-183.7
-173.4
-160.7
-144.4
-106.6
-13.4
-10.2
-9.8
-10.7

-368.7
-301.2
-272.7
-270.0
-255.2
-242.2
-231.4
-217.9
-200.2
-152.7
-11.9
-9.2
-9.5
-11.1

-285.3
-237.1
-212.7
-209.1
-195.8
-183.7
-173.4
-160.7
-144.4
-106.6
-13.4
-10.2
-9.8
-10.7

-368.7
-301.2
-272.7
-270.0
-255.2
-242.2
-231.4
-217.9
-200.2
-152.7
-11.9
-9.2
-9.5
-11.1

-525.8
-422.1
-386.0
-385.1
-367.8
-353.0
-341.5
-326.5
-306.3
-240.3
-9.2
-7.3
-8.8
-11.7

550.6
432.8
396.7
397.8
382.3
370.1
361.0
348.5
329.6
260.4
-12.7
-11.6
-7.2
-1.2

310.1
247.8
223.4
221.9
210.3
200.8
192.9
182.7
167.8
126.7
-8.5
-8.8
-6.1
-2.3

226.8
183.8
163.4
161.0
150.9
142.3
134.9
125.5
112.0
80.7
-7.1
-7.8
-5.8
-2.6

310.1
247.8
223.4
221.9
210.3
200.8
192.9
182.7
167.8
126.7
-8.5
-8.8
-6.1
-2.3

226.8
183.8
163.4
161.0
150.9
142.3
134.9
125.5
112.0
80.7
-7.1
-7.8
-5.8
-2.6

-609.2
-486.1
-446.0
-446.0
-427.2
-411.5
-399.6
-383.7
-362.0
-286.3
-7.7
-6.3
-8.5
-12.1

467.3
368.7
336.7
337.0
322.8
311.6
303.0
291.3
273.8
214.4
-11.3
-10.6
-6.8
-1.6

-609.2
-486.1
-446.0
-446.0
-427.2
-411.5
-399.6
-383.7
-362.0
-286.3
-7.7
-6.3
-8.5
-12.1

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 4 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A18

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

087237.10

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

WindMTX
46.04
35.36
33.10
33.60
32.79
32.27
32.01
31.55
30.76
25.36
-0.95
-0.66
-0.32
0.07

WindMTX
-46.04
-35.36
-33.10
-33.60
-32.79
-32.27
-32.01
-31.55
-30.76
-25.36
0.95
0.66
0.32
-0.07

WindMTX
46.26
35.54
33.30
33.78
32.99
32.46
32.21
31.74
30.96
25.54
-0.80
-0.54
-0.19
0.20

WindFY
-462.24
-370.11
-336.37
-335.13
-318.99
-305.57
-294.73
-280.93
-261.35
-202.06
1.03
1.94
-0.36
-4.13

WindFY
462.24
370.11
336.37
335.13
318.99
305.57
294.73
280.93
261.35
202.06
-1.03
-1.94
0.36
4.13

WindFY
-464.01
-371.82
-338.26
-336.90
-320.87
-307.38
-296.63
-282.65
-263.12
-203.71
-0.36
0.80
-1.49
-5.26

WindMTY
132.87
102.12
95.64
97.14
94.87
93.41
92.73
91.49
89.28
73.68
-2.77
-1.93
-0.92
0.22

WindMTY
-132.87
-102.12
-95.64
-97.14
-94.87
-93.41
-92.73
-91.49
-89.28
-73.68
2.77
1.93
0.92
-0.22

WindMTY
133.49
102.65
96.23
97.68
95.45
93.97
93.32
92.02
89.84
74.20
-2.33
-1.57
-0.56
0.57

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

511.1
407.5
371.2
370.5
353.0
338.4
326.8
312.1
291.7
227.9
-5.7
-7.2
-5.7
-2.8

-478.1
-379.6
-347.5
-347.7
-333.5
-322.3
-313.6
-302.0
-284.5
-223.2
-0.6
-1.4
-5.3
-10.5

594.1
471.2
430.9
431.0
412.1
396.5
384.4
368.9
347.1
273.6
-7.5
-8.4
-6.3
-2.7

12.4
10.5
8.9
8.5
7.3
6.0
4.9
3.8
2.7
1.8
-2.4
-3.2
-4.1
-5.0

12.4
10.5
8.9
8.5
7.3
6.0
4.9
3.8
2.7
1.8
-2.4
-3.2
-4.1
-5.0

-727.2
-581.7
-529.3
-527.7
-503.1
-482.9
-466.6
-445.7
-415.5
-321.5
-0.7
-0.1
-4.7
-11.6

752.0
602.6
547.1
544.7
517.7
494.9
476.5
453.3
420.9
325.1
-4.0
-6.3
-3.5
1.6

-542.3
-433.7
-394.7
-393.6
-375.5
-360.7
-348.8
-333.4
-310.9
-240.7
-1.1
-0.9
-4.6
-10.0

567.1
454.6
412.6
410.7
390.1
372.7
358.6
340.9
316.3
244.2
-3.6
-5.6
-3.7
0.0

-542.3
-433.7
-394.7
-393.6
-375.5
-360.7
-348.8
-333.4
-310.9
-240.7
-1.1
-0.9
-4.6
-10.0

567.1
454.6
412.6
410.7
390.1
372.7
358.6
340.9
316.3
244.2
-3.6
-5.6
-3.7
0.0

67.7
52.9
48.6
48.8
46.7
44.7
43.3
41.6
39.6
32.2
-3.5
-4.0
-4.5
-4.9

-42.8
-32.0
-30.8
-31.8
-32.0
-32.7
-33.5
-34.1
-34.2
-28.7
-1.2
-2.4
-3.7
-5.1

67.7
52.9
48.6
48.8
46.7
44.7
43.3
41.6
39.6
32.2
-3.5
-4.0
-4.5
-4.9

-42.8
-32.0
-30.8
-31.8
-32.0
-32.7
-33.5
-34.1
-34.2
-28.7
-1.2
-2.4
-3.7
-5.1

-382.8
-311.1
-280.0
-277.1
-261.6
-248.6
-237.5
-223.6
-203.8
-152.3
-4.5
-3.2
-5.7
-9.7

-701.7
-556.2
-509.5
-510.2
-489.3
-472.8
-460.0
-443.1
-418.1
-329.1
2.2
1.4
-3.5
-10.2

726.5
577.1
527.3
527.3
504.0
484.8
469.9
450.7
423.4
332.6
-6.9
-7.9
-4.8
0.2

407.7
332.1
297.8
294.1
276.3
260.6
247.3
231.1
209.2
155.8
-0.3
-3.2
-2.6
-0.3

-242.8
-199.1
-178.1
-175.6
-165.0
-156.0
-148.2
-138.5
-124.6
-91.0
-4.8
-3.8
-5.6
-8.5

-325.8
-262.8
-237.7
-236.1
-224.1
-214.1
-205.9
-195.3
-180.0
-136.7
-3.1
-2.6
-5.0
-8.6

-242.8
-199.1
-178.1
-175.6
-165.0
-156.0
-148.2
-138.5
-124.6
-91.0
-4.8
-3.8
-5.6
-8.5

-325.8
-262.8
-237.7
-236.1
-224.1
-214.1
-205.9
-195.3
-180.0
-136.7
-3.1
-2.6
-5.0
-8.6

-482.2
-383.1
-350.4
-350.6
-336.0
-324.3
-315.3
-303.3
-285.4
-223.8
0.2
-0.3
-3.9
-8.8

590.0
467.7
427.9
428.2
409.7
394.5
382.8
367.7
346.3
273.0
-6.7
-7.3
-4.9
-1.0

350.6
283.7
255.6
253.2
238.7
226.2
215.7
202.8
185.4
140.3
-1.7
-3.8
-3.3
-1.4

267.6
220.0
196.0
192.7
179.7
168.1
158.0
146.0
130.0
94.6
0.0
-2.6
-2.7
-1.5

350.6
283.7
255.6
253.2
238.7
226.2
215.7
202.8
185.4
140.3
-1.7
-3.8
-3.3
-1.4

267.6
220.0
196.0
192.7
179.7
168.1
158.0
146.0
130.0
94.6
0.0
-2.6
-2.7
-1.5

-565.1
-446.8
-410.1
-411.1
-395.0
-382.4
-372.9
-360.1
-340.9
-269.5
1.9
0.8
-3.3
-9.0

507.0
404.0
368.3
367.7
350.6
336.4
325.1
310.8
290.8
227.3
-4.9
-6.1
-4.3
-1.1

-565.1
-446.8
-410.1
-411.1
-395.0
-382.4
-372.9
-360.1
-340.9
-269.5
1.9
0.8
-3.3
-9.0

507.0
404.0
368.3
367.7
350.6
336.4
325.1
310.8
290.8
227.3
-4.9
-6.1
-4.3
-1.1

-482.2
-383.1
-350.4
-350.6
-336.0
-324.3
-315.3
-303.3
-285.4
-223.8
0.2
-0.3
-3.9
-8.8

590.0
467.7
427.9
428.2
409.7
394.5
382.8
367.7
346.3
273.0
-6.7
-7.3
-4.9
-1.0

468.8
368.4
344.0
350.4
342.7
338.0
336.2
331.5
321.9
264.0
6.5
3.1
-1.6
-3.1

840.7
667.7
623.4
637.1
625.6
620.2
619.7
613.0
594.5
485.6
16.9
13.6
6.5
5.5

23.0
24.5
20.8
21.2
19.8
18.7
17.9
16.3
13.1
8.3
-2.4
-2.7
-3.9
-4.8

706.9
564.5
526.5
538.3
528.7
524.4
524.2
518.4
501.9
408.9
14.2
11.9
5.8
5.0

-667.5
-531.3
-498.2
-511.2
-505.5
-505.3
-508.6
-506.5
-493.3
-403.3
-21.8
-22.1
-18.9
-20.8

16.4
8.7
7.5
5.9
3.4
0.4
-2.3
-4.3
-4.5
-2.7
-5.1
-7.6
-9.2
-11.0

-429.5
-335.2
-315.6
-323.3
-319.5
-318.9
-320.6
-319.6
-313.3
-258.4
-14.0
-13.4
-11.5
-12.7

-801.3
-634.4
-595.1
-610.0
-602.4
-601.1
-604.1
-601.0
-586.0
-480.0
-24.4
-23.9
-19.6
-21.3

-478.1
-379.6
-347.5
-347.7
-333.5
-322.3
-313.6
-302.0
-284.5
-223.2
-0.6
-1.4
-5.3
-10.5

511.1
407.5
371.2
370.5
353.0
338.4
326.8
312.1
291.7
227.9
-5.7
-7.2
-5.7
-2.8

-561.0
-443.3
-407.1
-408.3
-392.6
-380.4
-371.3
-358.9
-340.0
-268.9
1.1
-0.2
-4.7
-10.6

12.4
10.5
8.9
8.5
7.3
6.0
4.9
3.8
2.7
1.8
-2.4
-3.2
-4.1
-5.0

12.4
10.5
8.9
8.5
7.3
6.0
4.9
3.8
2.7
1.8
-2.4
-3.2
-4.1
-5.0

752.0
602.6
547.1
544.7
517.7
494.9
476.5
453.3
420.9
325.1
-4.0
-6.3
-3.5
1.6

-727.2
-581.7
-529.3
-527.7
-503.1
-482.9
-466.6
-445.7
-415.5
-321.5
-0.7
-0.1
-4.7
-11.6

567.1
454.6
412.6
410.7
390.1
372.7
358.6
340.9
316.3
244.2
-3.6
-5.6
-3.7
0.0

-542.3
-433.7
-394.7
-393.6
-375.5
-360.7
-348.8
-333.4
-310.9
-240.7
-1.1
-0.9
-4.6
-10.0

567.1
454.6
412.6
410.7
390.1
372.7
358.6
340.9
316.3
244.2
-3.6
-5.6
-3.7
0.0

-542.3
-433.7
-394.7
-393.6
-375.5
-360.7
-348.8
-333.4
-310.9
-240.7
-1.1
-0.9
-4.6
-10.0

-42.8
-32.0
-30.8
-31.8
-32.0
-32.7
-33.5
-34.1
-34.2
-28.7
-1.2
-2.4
-3.7
-5.1

67.7
52.9
48.6
48.8
46.7
44.7
43.3
41.6
39.6
32.2
-3.5
-4.0
-4.5
-4.9

-42.8
-32.0
-30.8
-31.8
-32.0
-32.7
-33.5
-34.1
-34.2
-28.7
-1.2
-2.4
-3.7
-5.1

67.7
52.9
48.6
48.8
46.7
44.7
43.3
41.6
39.6
32.2
-3.5
-4.0
-4.5
-4.9

407.7
332.1
297.8
294.1
276.3
260.6
247.3
231.1
209.2
155.8
-0.3
-3.2
-2.6
-0.3

726.5
577.1
527.3
527.3
504.0
484.8
469.9
450.7
423.4
332.6
-6.9
-7.9
-4.8
0.2

-701.7
-556.2
-509.5
-510.2
-489.3
-472.8
-460.0
-443.1
-418.1
-329.1
2.2
1.4
-3.5
-10.2

-382.8
-311.1
-280.0
-277.1
-261.6
-248.6
-237.5
-223.6
-203.8
-152.3
-4.5
-3.2
-5.7
-9.7

267.6
220.0
196.0
192.7
179.7
168.1
158.0
146.0
130.0
94.6
0.0
-2.6
-2.7
-1.5

350.6
283.7
255.6
253.2
238.7
226.2
215.7
202.8
185.4
140.3
-1.7
-3.8
-3.3
-1.4

267.6
220.0
196.0
192.7
179.7
168.1
158.0
146.0
130.0
94.6
0.0
-2.6
-2.7
-1.5

350.6
283.7
255.6
253.2
238.7
226.2
215.7
202.8
185.4
140.3
-1.7
-3.8
-3.3
-1.4

507.0
404.0
368.3
367.7
350.6
336.4
325.1
310.8
290.8
227.3
-4.9
-6.1
-4.3
-1.1

-565.1
-446.8
-410.1
-411.1
-395.0
-382.4
-372.9
-360.1
-340.9
-269.5
1.9
0.8
-3.3
-9.0

-325.8
-262.8
-237.7
-236.1
-224.1
-214.1
-205.9
-195.3
-180.0
-136.7
-3.1
-2.6
-5.0
-8.6

-242.8
-199.1
-178.1
-175.6
-165.0
-156.0
-148.2
-138.5
-124.6
-91.0
-4.8
-3.8
-5.6
-8.5

-325.8
-262.8
-237.7
-236.1
-224.1
-214.1
-205.9
-195.3
-180.0
-136.7
-3.1
-2.6
-5.0
-8.6

-242.8
-199.1
-178.1
-175.6
-165.0
-156.0
-148.2
-138.5
-124.6
-91.0
-4.8
-3.8
-5.6
-8.5

590.0
467.7
427.9
428.2
409.7
394.5
382.8
367.7
346.3
273.0
-6.7
-7.3
-4.9
-1.0

-482.2
-383.1
-350.4
-350.6
-336.0
-324.3
-315.3
-303.3
-285.4
-223.8
0.2
-0.3
-3.9
-8.8

590.0
467.7
427.9
428.2
409.7
394.5
382.8
367.7
346.3
273.0
-6.7
-7.3
-4.9
-1.0

-482.2
-383.1
-350.4
-350.6
-336.0
-324.3
-315.3
-303.3
-285.4
-223.8
0.2
-0.3
-3.9
-8.8

507.0
404.0
368.3
367.7
350.6
336.4
325.1
310.8
290.8
227.3
-4.9
-6.1
-4.3
-1.1

-565.1
-446.8
-410.1
-411.1
-395.0
-382.4
-372.9
-360.1
-340.9
-269.5
1.9
0.8
-3.3
-9.0

468.8
368.4
344.0
350.4
342.7
338.0
336.2
331.5
321.9
264.0
6.5
3.1
-1.6
-3.1

840.7
667.7
623.4
637.1
625.6
620.2
619.7
613.0
594.5
485.6
16.9
13.6
6.5
5.5

23.0
24.5
20.8
21.2
19.8
18.7
17.9
16.3
13.1
8.3
-2.4
-2.7
-3.9
-4.8

706.9
564.5
526.5
538.3
528.7
524.4
524.2
518.4
501.9
408.9
14.2
11.9
5.8
5.0

-667.5
-531.3
-498.2
-511.2
-505.5
-505.3
-508.6
-506.5
-493.3
-403.3
-21.8
-22.1
-18.9
-20.8

16.4
8.7
7.5
5.9
3.4
0.4
-2.3
-4.3
-4.5
-2.7
-5.1
-7.6
-9.2
-11.0

-429.5
-335.2
-315.6
-323.3
-319.5
-318.9
-320.6
-319.6
-313.3
-258.4
-14.0
-13.4
-11.5
-12.7

-801.3
-634.4
-595.1
-610.0
-602.4
-601.1
-604.1
-601.0
-586.0
-480.0
-24.4
-23.9
-19.6
-21.3

467.3
368.7
336.7
337.0
322.8
311.6
303.0
291.3
273.8
214.4
-11.3
-10.6
-6.8
-1.6

-525.8
-422.1
-386.0
-385.1
-367.8
-353.0
-341.5
-326.5
-306.3
-240.3
-9.2
-7.3
-8.8
-11.7

550.6
432.8
396.7
397.8
382.3
370.1
361.0
348.5
329.6
260.4
-12.7
-11.6
-7.2
-1.2

-22.0
-20.0
-18.5
-18.0
-16.8
-15.5
-14.5
-13.2
-12.2
-9.7
-7.7
-6.7
-5.9
-5.0

-22.0
-20.0
-18.5
-18.0
-16.8
-15.5
-14.5
-13.2
-12.2
-9.7
-7.7
-6.7
-5.9
-5.0

-764.4
-614.9
-559.7
-557.1
-530.2
-507.3
-489.1
-465.4
-433.2
-335.7
-8.2
-5.5
-8.2
-13.4

720.5
574.9
522.7
521.0
496.5
476.3
460.2
439.0
408.8
316.2
-7.1
-8.0
-3.5
3.4

-578.8
-466.2
-424.4
-422.3
-401.9
-384.4
-370.4
-352.4
-327.9
-254.2
-8.1
-5.8
-7.6
-11.3

534.9
426.2
387.4
386.2
368.2
353.3
341.5
326.0
303.6
234.7
-7.2
-7.7
-4.1
1.3

-578.8
-466.2
-424.4
-422.3
-401.9
-384.4
-370.4
-352.4
-327.9
-254.2
-8.1
-5.8
-7.6
-11.3

534.9
426.2
387.4
386.2
368.2
353.3
341.5
326.0
303.6
234.7
-7.2
-7.7
-4.1
1.3

33.6
22.7
21.5
22.5
22.7
23.4
24.2
24.9
25.0
20.9
-8.6
-7.4
-6.1
-4.8

-77.5
-62.7
-58.4
-58.6
-56.4
-54.5
-53.1
-51.3
-49.3
-40.4
-6.7
-6.1
-5.6
-5.2

33.6
22.7
21.5
22.5
22.7
23.4
24.2
24.9
25.0
20.9
-8.6
-7.4
-6.1
-4.8

-77.5
-62.7
-58.4
-58.6
-56.4
-54.5
-53.1
-51.3
-49.3
-40.4
-6.7
-6.1
-5.6
-5.2

-418.6
-343.0
-308.9
-305.1
-287.3
-271.6
-258.4
-242.0
-220.1
-165.2
-10.9
-7.7
-8.3
-10.6

-739.0
-589.4
-539.9
-539.5
-516.4
-497.1
-482.4
-462.8
-435.7
-343.2
-5.3
-3.9
-7.0
-12.0

695.0
549.4
502.9
503.4
482.7
466.1
453.5
436.4
411.4
323.8
-10.0
-9.6
-4.7
2.0

374.7
303.0
272.0
269.0
253.7
240.6
229.5
215.5
195.8
145.7
-4.5
-5.8
-3.4
0.6

-278.0
-230.4
-206.5
-203.1
-190.2
-178.5
-168.6
-156.3
-140.4
-103.4
-10.8
-7.9
-7.9
-9.0

-361.4
-294.5
-266.5
-264.0
-249.6
-237.0
-226.6
-213.5
-196.1
-149.4
-9.4
-6.9
-7.5
-9.4

-278.0
-230.4
-206.5
-203.1
-190.2
-178.5
-168.6
-156.3
-140.4
-103.4
-10.8
-7.9
-7.9
-9.0

-361.4
-294.5
-266.5
-264.0
-249.6
-237.0
-226.6
-213.5
-196.1
-149.4
-9.4
-6.9
-7.5
-9.4

-518.5
-415.4
-379.9
-379.1
-362.1
-347.8
-336.7
-322.1
-302.2
-237.1
-6.6
-5.1
-6.9
-10.1

557.9
439.4
402.9
403.9
387.9
375.2
365.8
352.9
333.7
263.6
-10.2
-9.4
-5.2
0.4

317.4
254.5
229.5
227.9
215.9
205.9
197.7
187.1
171.8
129.9
-6.0
-6.5
-4.2
-0.6

234.1
190.4
169.5
167.0
156.5
147.5
139.7
129.9
116.0
83.9
-4.5
-5.5
-3.8
-1.0

317.4
254.5
229.5
227.9
215.9
205.9
197.7
187.1
171.8
129.9
-6.0
-6.5
-4.2
-0.6

234.1
190.4
169.5
167.0
156.5
147.5
139.7
129.9
116.0
83.9
-4.5
-5.5
-3.8
-1.0

-601.8
-479.4
-439.9
-439.9
-421.6
-406.3
-394.7
-379.3
-358.0
-283.1
-5.2
-4.1
-6.5
-10.4

474.6
375.4
342.9
343.0
328.5
316.8
307.8
295.7
277.9
217.6
-8.7
-8.4
-4.9
0.1

-601.8
-479.4
-439.9
-439.9
-421.6
-406.3
-394.7
-379.3
-358.0
-283.1
-5.2
-4.1
-6.5
-10.4

474.6
375.4
342.9
343.0
328.5
316.8
307.8
295.7
277.9
217.6
-8.7
-8.4
-4.9
0.1

-518.5
-415.4
-379.9
-379.1
-362.1
-347.8
-336.7
-322.1
-302.2
-237.1
-6.6
-5.1
-6.9
-10.1

557.9
439.4
402.9
403.9
387.9
375.2
365.8
352.9
333.7
263.6
-10.2
-9.4
-5.2
0.4

416.3
321.7
302.3
310.0
306.3
305.6
307.3
306.3
300.1
247.4
-3.1
-3.4
-5.2
-2.1

789.5
622.3
583.3
598.0
590.5
589.1
592.3
589.1
574.1
470.2
6.9
6.7
2.7
7.0

-31.7
-23.9
-22.7
-21.1
-18.6
-15.6
-12.9
-10.8
-10.6
-10.1
-10.5
-7.9
-6.3
-5.0

655.1
518.6
485.7
498.7
493.0
492.8
496.2
493.9
480.9
393.0
4.6
5.4
2.4
6.1

-724.8
-582.2
-544.4
-556.0
-546.5
-542.1
-542.1
-535.9
-519.5
-423.9
-29.0
-26.7
-20.9
-22.0

-38.0
-39.6
-36.0
-36.2
-34.9
-33.7
-33.0
-31.2
-28.0
-20.8
-13.9
-13.4
-12.3
-10.8

-486.0
-385.3
-361.0
-367.3
-359.7
-354.9
-353.2
-348.2
-338.7
-278.3
-21.3
-18.0
-13.4
-13.7

-859.2
-685.9
-642.0
-655.3
-644.0
-638.5
-638.2
-631.0
-612.7
-501.1
-31.2
-28.1
-21.3
-22.9

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 5 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv2

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27
D27

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28
D28

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

855
855
855
923
923
923
923
923
923
923
633
633
633
633

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead

Live

13.78
11.63
9.91
9.48
8.12
6.69
5.47
4.18
2.99
1.96
-2.64
-3.59
-4.58
-5.55

Dead
-24.39
-22.22
-20.54
-20.05
-18.72
-17.26
-16.06
-14.68
-13.51
-10.82
-8.53
-7.48
-6.51
-5.55

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A19

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

087237.10

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

WindMTX
46.04
35.36
33.10
33.60
32.79
32.27
32.01
31.55
30.76
25.36
-0.95
-0.66
-0.32
0.07

WindMTX
-46.04
-35.36
-33.10
-33.60
-32.79
-32.27
-32.01
-31.55
-30.76
-25.36
0.95
0.66
0.32
-0.07

WindMTX
46.26
35.54
33.30
33.78
32.99
32.46
32.21
31.74
30.96
25.54
-0.80
-0.54
-0.19
0.20

WindFY
-462.24
-370.11
-336.37
-335.13
-318.99
-305.57
-294.73
-280.93
-261.35
-202.06
1.03
1.94
-0.36
-4.13

WindFY
462.24
370.11
336.37
335.13
318.99
305.57
294.73
280.93
261.35
202.06
-1.03
-1.94
0.36
4.13

WindFY
-464.01
-371.82
-338.26
-336.90
-320.87
-307.38
-296.63
-282.65
-263.12
-203.71
-0.36
0.80
-1.49
-5.26

WindMTY
132.87
102.12
95.64
97.14
94.87
93.41
92.73
91.49
89.28
73.68
-2.77
-1.93
-0.92
0.22

WindMTY
-132.87
-102.12
-95.64
-97.14
-94.87
-93.41
-92.73
-91.49
-89.28
-73.68
2.77
1.93
0.92
-0.22

WindMTY
133.49
102.65
96.23
97.68
95.45
93.97
93.32
92.02
89.84
74.20
-2.33
-1.57
-0.56
0.57

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
712.85
549.78
516.59
526.47
516.33
510.53
508.84
504.04
493.74
408.85
14.21
9.25
3.74
2.73

SpecX
716.18
552.63
519.73
529.39
519.43
513.55
512.03
506.94
496.77
411.69
11.81
7.31
1.83
4.65

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

458.4
359.6
336.4
343.2
336.6
333.0
332.0
328.3
319.6
262.5
8.5
5.8
1.9
1.1

830.2
658.9
615.9
629.9
619.4
615.1
615.6
609.8
592.3
484.1
18.9
16.3
10.0
9.7

12.5
15.7
13.3
14.0
13.6
13.7
13.8
13.1
10.8
6.8
-0.4
0.1
-0.4
-0.6

696.5
555.7
519.0
531.1
522.5
519.3
520.1
515.2
499.6
407.4
16.2
14.6
9.3
9.2

-678.0
-540.1
-505.7
-518.4
-511.6
-510.3
-512.7
-509.6
-495.6
-404.7
-19.8
-19.4
-15.4
-16.6

6.0
-0.1
0.0
-1.2
-2.7
-4.7
-6.4
-7.5
-6.8
-4.2
-3.1
-4.9
-5.7
-6.8

-439.9
-344.0
-323.1
-330.5
-325.7
-324.0
-324.7
-322.7
-315.6
-259.9
-12.0
-10.7
-8.1
-8.5

-811.7
-643.2
-602.6
-617.2
-608.5
-606.1
-608.2
-604.2
-588.3
-481.5
-22.4
-21.2
-16.1
-17.1

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
840.66
-811.71
667.67
-643.25
623.42
-602.60
637.09
-617.18
625.57
-608.51
620.20
-606.14
619.70
-608.21
612.97
-604.19
594.54
-588.25
485.59
-481.46
18.89
-24.44
16.33
-23.87
10.00
-19.62
9.69
-21.34

0.98
0.78
0.73
0.69
0.68
0.67
0.67
0.66
0.64
0.53
0.04
0.04
0.03
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

458.4
359.6
336.4
343.2
336.6
333.0
332.0
328.3
319.6
262.5
8.5
5.8
1.9
1.1

830.2
658.9
615.9
629.9
619.4
615.1
615.6
609.8
592.3
484.1
18.9
16.3
10.0
9.7

12.5
15.7
13.3
14.0
13.6
13.7
13.8
13.1
10.8
6.8
-0.4
0.1
-0.4
-0.6

696.5
555.7
519.0
531.1
522.5
519.3
520.1
515.2
499.6
407.4
16.2
14.6
9.3
9.2

-678.0
-540.1
-505.7
-518.4
-511.6
-510.3
-512.7
-509.6
-495.6
-404.7
-19.8
-19.4
-15.4
-16.6

6.0
-0.1
0.0
-1.2
-2.7
-4.7
-6.4
-7.5
-6.8
-4.2
-3.1
-4.9
-5.7
-6.8

-439.9
-344.0
-323.1
-330.5
-325.7
-324.0
-324.7
-322.7
-315.6
-259.9
-12.0
-10.7
-8.1
-8.5

-811.7
-643.2
-602.6
-617.2
-608.5
-606.1
-608.2
-604.2
-588.3
-481.5
-22.4
-21.2
-16.1
-17.1

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
840.66
-811.71
667.67
-643.25
623.42
-602.60
637.09
-617.18
625.57
-608.51
620.20
-606.14
619.70
-608.21
612.97
-604.19
594.54
-588.25
485.59
-481.46
18.89
-24.44
16.33
-23.87
10.00
-19.62
9.69
-21.34

0.98
0.78
0.73
0.69
0.68
0.67
0.67
0.66
0.64
0.53
0.04
0.04
0.03
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

434.8
338.6
317.9
325.2
320.4
318.7
319.5
317.4
310.3
255.6
3.4
2.3
-0.2
2.1

808.0
639.2
598.8
613.2
604.7
602.2
604.5
600.2
584.4
478.4
13.3
12.4
7.6
11.2

-13.2
-7.1
-7.2
-5.9
-4.4
-2.5
-0.7
0.4
-0.4
-1.9
-4.0
-2.3
-1.4
-0.8

673.6
535.5
501.3
513.9
507.2
505.9
508.4
505.1
491.2
401.2
11.1
11.0
7.3
10.4

-706.3
-565.3
-528.9
-540.8
-532.4
-529.0
-529.9
-524.8
-509.3
-415.7
-22.5
-21.1
-16.0
-17.8

-19.5
-22.8
-20.4
-21.0
-20.7
-20.7
-20.8
-20.1
-17.8
-12.6
-7.4
-7.8
-7.3
-6.6

-467.5
-368.4
-345.5
-352.1
-345.6
-341.9
-341.1
-337.1
-328.5
-270.1
-14.8
-12.3
-8.5
-9.5

-840.7
-669.0
-626.4
-640.1
-629.8
-625.4
-626.0
-619.9
-602.5
-492.9
-24.8
-22.4
-16.4
-18.7

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
807.99
-859.21
639.18
-685.86
598.83
-641.96
613.20
-655.30
604.70
-644.00
602.22
-638.46
604.46
-638.18
600.19
-631.01
584.36
-612.74
478.41
-501.12
13.32
-31.22
12.41
-28.11
7.63
-21.29
11.23
-22.89

1.00
0.80
0.75
0.71
0.70
0.69
0.69
0.68
0.66
0.54
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.04

Status
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

SpecY
2516.92
2000.87
1871.75
1916.35
1887.55
1878.25
1882.96
1868.15
1815.51
1483.35
64.52
59.65
42.45
43.91

SpecY
2527.20
2010.14
1881.96
1925.81
1897.58
1887.89
1893.13
1877.38
1825.15
1492.10
59.84
55.86
39.45
48.45

Page 6 of 6

4:46 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv3

A20

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

Live

-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

Dead
-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindMTX
-5.98
-6.95
-9.82
-10.65
-11.83
-15.02
-15.54
-16.77
-17.98
-22.47
-23.20
-24.60
-25.74
-25.16
-25.84
-26.28
-26.79
-26.63
-26.95
-27.21
-27.10
-25.87
-25.56
-25.40
-25.22
-24.95
-24.68
-24.07
-22.36
-17.16
-4.90
-3.02
-3.47
-3.88
-4.51
-5.08
-5.60
-6.02
-6.27
-4.79
1.72
1.14
0.55
-0.06

WindMTX
5.98
6.95
9.82
10.65
11.83
15.02
15.54
16.77
17.98
22.47
23.20
24.60
25.74
25.16
25.84
26.28
26.79
26.63
26.95
27.21
27.10
25.87
25.56
25.40
25.22
24.95
24.68
24.07
22.36
17.16
4.90
3.02
3.47
3.88
4.51
5.08
5.60
6.02
6.27
4.79
-1.72
-1.14
-0.55
0.06

WindFY
10.93
19.09
33.74
44.73
54.14
61.30
70.77
81.57
91.08
109.86
119.52
129.82
138.37
136.19
144.19
151.63
157.93
158.59
163.47
167.15
169.08
163.29
164.13
166.22
169.30
171.59
174.25
172.28
157.24
107.38
-3.32
-23.82
-14.92
-3.29
11.94
25.72
38.86
49.24
55.26
39.08
-45.49
-31.11
-14.19
3.86

WindFY
-10.93
-19.09
-33.74
-44.73
-54.14
-61.30
-70.77
-81.57
-91.08
-109.86
-119.52
-129.82
-138.37
-136.19
-144.19
-151.63
-157.93
-158.59
-163.47
-167.15
-169.08
-163.29
-164.13
-166.22
-169.30
-171.59
-174.25
-172.28
-157.24
-107.38
3.32
23.82
14.92
3.29
-11.94
-25.72
-38.86
-49.24
-55.26
-39.08
45.49
31.11
14.19
-3.86

WindMTY
-17.19
-19.96
-28.19
-30.56
-33.97
-43.15
-44.63
-48.16
-51.65
-64.54
-66.64
-70.70
-73.99
-72.34
-74.30
-75.58
-77.09
-76.64
-77.58
-78.36
-78.05
-74.52
-73.66
-73.20
-72.69
-71.96
-71.20
-69.46
-64.55
-49.58
-14.24
-8.81
-10.12
-11.32
-13.13
-14.80
-16.32
-17.54
-18.26
-13.95
4.95
3.30
1.59
-0.17

WindMTY
17.19
19.96
28.19
30.56
33.97
43.15
44.63
48.16
51.65
64.54
66.64
70.70
73.99
72.34
74.30
75.58
77.09
76.64
77.58
78.36
78.05
74.52
73.66
73.20
72.69
71.96
71.20
69.46
64.55
49.58
14.24
8.81
10.12
11.32
13.13
14.80
16.32
17.54
18.26
13.95
-4.95
-3.30
-1.59
0.17

SpecX
98.15
114.72
162.72
174.62
194.43
243.00
252.32
269.80
288.78
358.45
368.56
388.56
405.65
394.86
404.88
410.72
418.24
415.04
420.19
423.22
421.74
403.70
399.76
397.22
395.05
391.06
387.72
379.36
354.10
274.28
85.84
57.07
64.94
72.16
82.81
92.11
101.17
108.08
112.65
91.05
36.29
26.76
17.55
11.20

SpecX
98.15
114.72
162.71
174.62
194.43
243.00
252.32
269.80
288.78
358.45
368.56
388.56
405.65
394.86
404.88
410.72
418.24
415.04
420.19
423.22
421.74
403.70
399.76
397.22
395.05
391.06
387.72
379.37
354.10
274.28
85.84
57.07
64.95
72.16
82.81
92.11
101.17
108.08
112.65
91.05
36.29
26.76
17.55
11.20

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.6

-1.6

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 4

SpecY
464.74
531.65
803.98
854.63
919.17
963.70
977.09
1023.59
1053.42
1233.65
1257.74
1305.85
1339.84
1275.89
1299.42
1321.96
1341.33
1326.06
1342.37
1359.40
1358.25
1305.59
1303.75
1311.10
1317.45
1322.03
1325.58
1311.55
1241.66
1015.16
567.79
525.89
543.95
557.92
583.44
612.17
638.33
656.07
651.27
485.78
172.46
120.46
63.31
35.95

-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.0
-3.0
-2.9
-2.9
-2.8
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.5
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.1
-2.1
-2.0
-1.9
-1.9
-1.8
-1.7
-1.7
-1.6
-1.5
-1.4
-1.4
-1.3
-0.7
-1.5
-1.5
-1.6
-1.6

-3.1
-3.2
-3.3
-3.5
-3.6
-3.8
-4.0
-3.9
-4.1
-4.0
-4.1
-4.1
-4.3
-4.1
-4.3
-4.2
-4.4
-4.4
-4.5
-4.3
-4.5
-4.6
-4.8
-4.7
-4.9
-4.8
-4.9
-5.1
-5.2
-5.2
-5.3
-5.3
-5.4
-5.6
-5.7
-5.6
-5.8
-5.7
-5.9
-6.3
-6.1
-5.9
-5.9
-5.9

14.4
27.4
50.7
68.2
83.2
94.5
109.6
127.0
142.1
172.2
187.6
204.2
217.8
214.4
227.2
239.1
249.1
250.3
258.0
264.0
267.0
257.7
259.0
262.4
267.3
271.0
275.3
272.1
248.0
168.3
-8.9
-41.6
-27.4
-8.9
15.5
37.6
58.6
75.2
84.8
59.0
-76.6
-53.5
-26.4
2.4

-20.6
-33.7
-57.3
-74.9
-90.0
-101.6
-116.8
-134.1
-149.3
-179.3
-194.8
-211.3
-225.0
-221.4
-234.2
-246.1
-256.2
-257.2
-265.1
-270.9
-274.0
-264.8
-266.2
-269.5
-274.4
-278.0
-282.3
-279.2
-255.2
-175.4
1.7
34.6
20.3
1.7
-22.7
-44.7
-65.8
-82.3
-92.0
-66.0
69.0
46.1
19.0
-9.9

10.0
19.8
37.2
50.4
61.7
70.2
81.6
94.6
106.1
128.6
140.2
152.7
163.0
160.4
170.0
179.0
186.6
187.5
193.4
197.8
200.2
193.2
194.3
196.9
200.6
203.4
206.6
204.3
186.3
126.5
-6.3
-30.8
-20.1
-6.1
12.2
28.8
44.6
57.1
64.4
45.5
-56.6
-39.4
-19.1
2.5

-16.2
-26.0
-43.7
-56.9
-68.3
-76.9
-88.3
-101.1
-112.5
-135.0
-146.6
-158.9
-169.1
-166.4
-176.0
-184.9
-192.4
-193.2
-199.0
-203.4
-205.6
-198.6
-199.6
-202.1
-205.7
-208.4
-211.6
-209.2
-191.1
-131.2
1.7
26.3
15.7
1.8
-16.4
-32.9
-48.6
-61.0
-68.2
-48.3
52.5
35.3
14.9
-6.8

10.0
19.8
37.2
50.2
61.4
69.8
81.1
94.0
105.3
128.0
139.4
151.8
161.9
159.5
168.9
177.9
185.3
186.2
191.9
196.5
198.7
191.6
192.5
195.1
198.6
201.4
204.5
202.0
183.9
124.1
-8.9
-33.4
-22.9
-9.0
9.1
25.7
41.4
53.9
61.0
41.3
-60.1
-42.7
-22.4
-0.8

-16.2
-26.1
-43.8
-57.1
-68.5
-77.3
-88.8
-101.7
-113.3
-135.7
-147.4
-159.8
-170.1
-167.4
-177.1
-186.0
-193.7
-194.5
-200.4
-204.7
-207.1
-200.3
-201.4
-203.9
-207.7
-210.4
-213.7
-211.4
-193.5
-133.6
-0.9
23.7
12.9
-1.1
-19.5
-36.0
-51.9
-64.3
-71.6
-52.5
49.1
32.0
11.7
-10.0

-10.3
-11.5
-15.0
-16.0
-17.5
-21.4
-22.0
-23.4
-24.8
-30.2
-31.0
-32.6
-34.0
-33.2
-34.0
-34.5
-35.0
-34.8
-35.1
-35.4
-35.3
-33.7
-33.3
-33.1
-32.8
-32.5
-32.1
-31.3
-29.2
-22.9
-8.2
-5.9
-6.4
-6.8
-7.5
-8.1
-8.7
-9.2
-9.4
-7.1
0.0
-0.7
-1.5
-2.2

4.1
5.2
8.5
9.5
10.9
14.7
15.3
16.9
18.3
23.8
24.7
26.4
27.8
27.2
28.0
28.6
29.3
29.1
29.5
29.9
29.8
28.3
28.0
27.9
27.7
27.4
27.1
26.5
24.4
18.3
3.6
1.4
2.0
2.5
3.3
4.1
4.7
5.3
5.6
4.3
-4.1
-3.5
-2.8
-2.1

-10.3
-11.5
-15.1
-16.2
-17.7
-21.8
-22.5
-24.0
-25.6
-30.8
-31.8
-33.5
-35.0
-34.2
-35.1
-35.6
-36.3
-36.1
-36.6
-36.8
-36.8
-35.4
-35.1
-34.9
-34.8
-34.4
-34.2
-33.6
-31.7
-25.4
-10.8
-8.5
-9.1
-9.7
-10.6
-11.2
-12.0
-12.4
-12.8
-11.3
-3.4
-4.0
-4.7
-5.4

4.1
5.2
8.5
9.3
10.7
14.3
14.8
16.3
17.6
23.1
23.8
25.6
26.8
26.2
26.9
27.5
28.0
27.8
28.1
28.5
28.3
26.7
26.2
26.1
25.7
25.5
25.0
24.2
22.0
15.8
1.0
-1.2
-0.8
-0.4
0.2
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.2
0.1
-7.5
-6.7
-6.0
-5.3

-10.6
-4.2
3.4
13.6
20.8
18.2
27.8
36.5
43.7
50.8
59.9
67.4
73.7
73.1
80.3
87.8
93.5
94.8
99.5
103.1
105.8
103.0
105.0
108.1
112.4
116.0
120.1
119.8
107.6
65.8
-24.7
-42.7
-33.6
-21.1
-5.1
9.5
23.4
34.5
40.8
26.6
-52.4
-37.1
-18.9
0.7

30.7
43.7
71.0
87.0
102.3
121.8
134.9
152.1
167.7
205.7
219.8
237.1
251.2
246.7
258.7
269.2
278.5
278.8
285.7
291.2
293.1
281.8
281.8
283.8
286.8
288.8
291.0
286.5
262.5
184.8
9.5
-21.5
-9.3
6.0
26.4
45.0
62.6
76.6
84.6
60.1
-64.3
-45.0
-22.7
1.1

-36.8
-50.0
-77.6
-93.7
-109.1
-128.9
-142.1
-159.2
-174.9
-212.8
-227.0
-244.2
-258.4
-253.7
-265.7
-276.2
-285.6
-285.8
-292.8
-298.1
-300.0
-288.9
-288.9
-290.8
-293.9
-295.8
-298.1
-293.7
-269.8
-191.9
-16.7
14.5
2.2
-13.2
-33.7
-52.2
-69.8
-83.7
-91.8
-67.1
56.8
37.6
15.2
-8.6

4.4
-2.1
-10.0
-20.3
-27.6
-25.3
-35.0
-43.6
-50.9
-57.9
-67.0
-74.5
-80.8
-80.1
-87.4
-94.8
-100.5
-101.8
-106.6
-110.0
-112.7
-110.0
-112.1
-115.1
-119.5
-123.1
-127.2
-127.0
-114.8
-72.9
17.5
35.6
26.5
13.9
-2.2
-16.7
-30.7
-41.6
-48.0
-33.6
44.9
29.7
11.4
-8.2

-14.1
-10.2
-7.1
-0.1
4.2
-0.6
6.1
11.7
16.0
17.3
23.5
27.9
31.6
31.7
36.6
41.8
45.6
46.8
50.1
52.5
54.7
53.7
55.6
58.1
61.5
64.5
67.9
68.2
60.7
34.0
-22.8
-34.7
-28.2
-19.2
-7.6
2.8
12.9
20.8
25.4
16.4
-37.5
-26.5
-13.4
0.7

-3.3
2.3
10.6
19.1
25.5
26.5
34.1
41.9
48.4
57.8
65.2
72.2
78.0
77.0
83.1
89.1
93.9
94.8
98.7
101.6
103.5
100.4
101.6
103.8
106.9
109.5
112.3
111.6
100.9
64.9
-14.0
-29.2
-22.0
-12.2
0.5
12.0
23.0
31.6
36.7
25.0
-40.5
-28.6
-14.4
0.8

-14.1
-10.2
-7.2
-0.2
4.0
-0.9
5.7
11.2
15.4
16.8
22.8
27.2
30.8
31.0
35.7
40.9
44.7
45.9
49.0
51.5
53.5
52.5
54.2
56.7
60.0
63.0
66.3
66.5
58.8
32.1
-24.8
-36.6
-30.3
-21.4
-9.9
0.5
10.4
18.3
22.8
13.2
-40.0
-28.9
-15.8
-1.7

-3.3
2.3
10.5
18.9
25.3
26.2
33.7
41.4
47.8
57.3
64.6
71.6
77.2
76.3
82.3
88.3
92.9
93.8
97.6
100.5
102.4
99.1
100.3
102.5
105.5
108.0
110.7
109.9
99.1
63.1
-16.0
-31.2
-24.0
-14.4
-1.8
9.7
20.5
29.2
34.1
21.9
-43.1
-31.0
-16.8
-1.6

16.9
25.8
43.7
54.9
65.4
77.2
86.6
98.4
109.0
133.6
143.5
155.3
164.9
162.0
170.4
177.9
184.5
184.9
189.9
193.7
195.3
188.0
188.3
190.0
192.5
194.1
196.1
193.4
177.0
123.3
2.8
-18.8
-10.0
1.2
16.0
29.5
42.3
52.4
58.3
41.5
-46.4
-32.5
-16.2
1.0

-33.8
-44.6
-67.9
-80.7
-93.3
-111.0
-121.4
-135.3
-148.1
-180.6
-191.9
-206.0
-217.7
-213.6
-223.2
-231.4
-238.9
-238.9
-244.4
-248.6
-250.0
-240.4
-240.1
-241.4
-243.5
-244.6
-246.1
-242.2
-222.6
-159.5
-16.9
8.2
-1.3
-13.2
-29.1
-43.5
-57.1
-67.9
-74.2
-54.0
44.5
29.5
12.2
-6.2

-2.8
-8.6
-17.1
-25.6
-32.1
-33.3
-40.9
-48.5
-55.0
-64.3
-71.8
-78.6
-84.4
-83.3
-89.4
-95.2
-100.0
-100.8
-104.6
-107.4
-109.3
-106.2
-107.4
-109.5
-112.6
-115.0
-117.8
-117.0
-106.3
-70.2
8.8
24.1
16.9
7.2
-5.5
-16.8
-27.7
-36.3
-41.3
-28.9
35.6
23.6
9.3
-5.9

7.9
3.9
0.5
-6.6
-11.0
-6.5
-13.4
-18.8
-23.2
-24.4
-30.6
-35.0
-38.8
-38.7
-43.6
-48.8
-52.7
-53.8
-57.2
-59.4
-61.6
-60.8
-62.7
-65.1
-68.6
-71.5
-74.9
-75.4
-67.9
-41.1
15.7
27.6
21.1
11.9
0.3
-10.0
-20.1
-27.9
-32.6
-23.4
29.9
19.1
5.9
-8.2

-2.8
-8.6
-17.2
-25.8
-32.3
-33.6
-41.4
-49.0
-55.6
-64.9
-72.4
-79.3
-85.2
-84.0
-90.2
-96.1
-101.0
-101.8
-105.7
-108.5
-110.5
-107.4
-108.8
-110.9
-114.0
-116.5
-119.4
-118.7
-108.2
-72.0
6.8
22.2
14.8
5.0
-7.8
-19.2
-30.2
-38.8
-43.8
-32.0
33.0
21.2
6.9
-8.3

7.9
3.9
0.6
-6.5
-10.8
-6.2
-12.9
-18.3
-22.7
-23.9
-30.0
-34.3
-38.0
-38.0
-42.8
-47.9
-51.7
-52.8
-56.1
-58.4
-60.5
-59.6
-61.4
-63.8
-67.1
-70.0
-73.3
-73.7
-66.0
-39.2
17.6
29.5
23.1
14.1
2.7
-7.7
-17.7
-25.5
-30.0
-20.2
32.5
21.5
8.3
-5.8

27.6
38.3
61.4
74.1
86.7
104.2
114.6
128.6
141.4
174.1
185.3
199.6
211.3
207.4
217.0
225.3
232.8
232.9
238.4
242.7
244.1
234.6
234.3
235.7
237.9
239.1
240.6
236.7
217.2
154.2
11.6
-13.4
-3.7
8.2
24.2
38.7
52.4
63.2
69.5
50.2
-49.5
-34.5
-17.2
1.1

-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.0
-3.0
-2.9
-2.9
-2.8
-2.7
-2.7
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.5
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.1
-2.1
-2.0
-1.9
-1.9
-1.8
-1.7
-1.7
-1.6
-1.5
-1.4
-1.4
-1.3
-0.7
-1.5
-1.5
-1.6
-1.6

-3.1
-3.2
-3.3
-3.5
-3.6
-3.8
-4.0
-3.9
-4.1
-4.0
-4.1
-4.1
-4.3
-4.1
-4.3
-4.2
-4.4
-4.4
-4.5
-4.3
-4.5
-4.6
-4.8
-4.7
-4.9
-4.8
-4.9
-5.1
-5.2
-5.2
-5.3
-5.3
-5.4
-5.6
-5.7
-5.6
-5.8
-5.7
-5.9
-6.3
-6.1
-5.9
-5.9
-5.9

-20.6
-33.7
-57.3
-74.9
-90.0
-101.6
-116.8
-134.1
-149.3
-179.3
-194.8
-211.3
-225.0
-221.4
-234.2
-246.1
-256.2
-257.2
-265.1
-270.9
-274.0
-264.8
-266.2
-269.5
-274.4
-278.0
-282.3
-279.2
-255.2
-175.4
1.7
34.6
20.3
1.7
-22.7
-44.7
-65.8
-82.3
-92.0
-66.0
69.0
46.1
19.0
-9.9

14.4
27.4
50.7
68.2
83.2
94.5
109.6
127.0
142.1
172.2
187.6
204.2
217.8
214.4
227.2
239.1
249.1
250.3
258.0
264.0
267.0
257.7
259.0
262.4
267.3
271.0
275.3
272.1
248.0
168.3
-8.9
-41.6
-27.4
-8.9
15.5
37.6
58.6
75.2
84.8
59.0
-76.6
-53.5
-26.4
2.4

-16.2
-26.0
-43.7
-56.9
-68.3
-76.9
-88.3
-101.1
-112.5
-135.0
-146.6
-158.9
-169.1
-166.4
-176.0
-184.9
-192.4
-193.2
-199.0
-203.4
-205.6
-198.6
-199.6
-202.1
-205.7
-208.4
-211.6
-209.2
-191.1
-131.2
1.7
26.3
15.7
1.8
-16.4
-32.9
-48.6
-61.0
-68.2
-48.3
52.5
35.3
14.9
-6.8

10.0
19.8
37.2
50.4
61.7
70.2
81.6
94.6
106.1
128.6
140.2
152.7
163.0
160.4
170.0
179.0
186.6
187.5
193.4
197.8
200.2
193.2
194.3
196.9
200.6
203.4
206.6
204.3
186.3
126.5
-6.3
-30.8
-20.1
-6.1
12.2
28.8
44.6
57.1
64.4
45.5
-56.6
-39.4
-19.1
2.5

-16.2
-26.1
-43.8
-57.1
-68.5
-77.3
-88.8
-101.7
-113.3
-135.7
-147.4
-159.8
-170.1
-167.4
-177.1
-186.0
-193.7
-194.5
-200.4
-204.7
-207.1
-200.3
-201.4
-203.9
-207.7
-210.4
-213.7
-211.4
-193.5
-133.6
-0.9
23.7
12.9
-1.1
-19.5
-36.0
-51.9
-64.3
-71.6
-52.5
49.1
32.0
11.7
-10.0

10.0
19.8
37.2
50.2
61.4
69.8
81.1
94.0
105.3
128.0
139.4
151.8
161.9
159.5
168.9
177.9
185.3
186.2
191.9
196.5
198.7
191.6
192.5
195.1
198.6
201.4
204.5
202.0
183.9
124.1
-8.9
-33.4
-22.9
-9.0
9.1
25.7
41.4
53.9
61.0
41.3
-60.1
-42.7
-22.4
-0.8

4.1
5.2
8.5
9.5
10.9
14.7
15.3
16.9
18.3
23.8
24.7
26.4
27.8
27.2
28.0
28.6
29.3
29.1
29.5
29.9
29.8
28.3
28.0
27.9
27.7
27.4
27.1
26.5
24.4
18.3
3.6
1.4
2.0
2.5
3.3
4.1
4.7
5.3
5.6
4.3
-4.1
-3.5
-2.8
-2.1

-10.3
-11.5
-15.0
-16.0
-17.5
-21.4
-22.0
-23.4
-24.8
-30.2
-31.0
-32.6
-34.0
-33.2
-34.0
-34.5
-35.0
-34.8
-35.1
-35.4
-35.3
-33.7
-33.3
-33.1
-32.8
-32.5
-32.1
-31.3
-29.2
-22.9
-8.2
-5.9
-6.4
-6.8
-7.5
-8.1
-8.7
-9.2
-9.4
-7.1
0.0
-0.7
-1.5
-2.2

4.1
5.2
8.5
9.3
10.7
14.3
14.8
16.3
17.6
23.1
23.8
25.6
26.8
26.2
26.9
27.5
28.0
27.8
28.1
28.5
28.3
26.7
26.2
26.1
25.7
25.5
25.0
24.2
22.0
15.8
1.0
-1.2
-0.8
-0.4
0.2
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.2
0.1
-7.5
-6.7
-6.0
-5.3

-10.3
-11.5
-15.1
-16.2
-17.7
-21.8
-22.5
-24.0
-25.6
-30.8
-31.8
-33.5
-35.0
-34.2
-35.1
-35.6
-36.3
-36.1
-36.6
-36.8
-36.8
-35.4
-35.1
-34.9
-34.8
-34.4
-34.2
-33.6
-31.7
-25.4
-10.8
-8.5
-9.1
-9.7
-10.6
-11.2
-12.0
-12.4
-12.8
-11.3
-3.4
-4.0
-4.7
-5.4

4.4
-2.1
-10.0
-20.3
-27.6
-25.3
-35.0
-43.6
-50.9
-57.9
-67.0
-74.5
-80.8
-80.1
-87.4
-94.8
-100.5
-101.8
-106.6
-110.0
-112.7
-110.0
-112.1
-115.1
-119.5
-123.1
-127.2
-127.0
-114.8
-72.9
17.5
35.6
26.5
13.9
-2.2
-16.7
-30.7
-41.6
-48.0
-33.6
44.9
29.7
11.4
-8.2

-36.8
-50.0
-77.6
-93.7
-109.1
-128.9
-142.1
-159.2
-174.9
-212.8
-227.0
-244.2
-258.4
-253.7
-265.7
-276.2
-285.6
-285.8
-292.8
-298.1
-300.0
-288.9
-288.9
-290.8
-293.9
-295.8
-298.1
-293.7
-269.8
-191.9
-16.7
14.5
2.2
-13.2
-33.7
-52.2
-69.8
-83.7
-91.8
-67.1
56.8
37.6
15.2
-8.6

30.7
43.7
71.0
87.0
102.3
121.8
134.9
152.1
167.7
205.7
219.8
237.1
251.2
246.7
258.7
269.2
278.5
278.8
285.7
291.2
293.1
281.8
281.8
283.8
286.8
288.8
291.0
286.5
262.5
184.8
9.5
-21.5
-9.3
6.0
26.4
45.0
62.6
76.6
84.6
60.1
-64.3
-45.0
-22.7
1.1

-10.6
-4.2
3.4
13.6
20.8
18.2
27.8
36.5
43.7
50.8
59.9
67.4
73.7
73.1
80.3
87.8
93.5
94.8
99.5
103.1
105.8
103.0
105.0
108.1
112.4
116.0
120.1
119.8
107.6
65.8
-24.7
-42.7
-33.6
-21.1
-5.1
9.5
23.4
34.5
40.8
26.6
-52.4
-37.1
-18.9
0.7

7.9
3.9
0.6
-6.5
-10.8
-6.2
-12.9
-18.3
-22.7
-23.9
-30.0
-34.3
-38.0
-38.0
-42.8
-47.9
-51.7
-52.8
-56.1
-58.4
-60.5
-59.6
-61.4
-63.8
-67.1
-70.0
-73.3
-73.7
-66.0
-39.2
17.6
29.5
23.1
14.1
2.7
-7.7
-17.7
-25.5
-30.0
-20.2
32.5
21.5
8.3
-5.8

-2.8
-8.6
-17.1
-25.6
-32.1
-33.3
-40.9
-48.5
-55.0
-64.3
-71.8
-78.6
-84.4
-83.3
-89.4
-95.2
-100.0
-100.8
-104.6
-107.4
-109.3
-106.2
-107.4
-109.5
-112.6
-115.0
-117.8
-117.0
-106.3
-70.2
8.8
24.1
16.9
7.2
-5.5
-16.8
-27.7
-36.3
-41.3
-28.9
35.6
23.6
9.3
-5.9

7.9
3.9
0.5
-6.6
-11.0
-6.5
-13.4
-18.8
-23.2
-24.4
-30.6
-35.0
-38.8
-38.7
-43.6
-48.8
-52.7
-53.8
-57.2
-59.4
-61.6
-60.8
-62.7
-65.1
-68.6
-71.5
-74.9
-75.4
-67.9
-41.1
15.7
27.6
21.1
11.9
0.3
-10.0
-20.1
-27.9
-32.6
-23.4
29.9
19.1
5.9
-8.2

-2.8
-8.6
-17.2
-25.8
-32.3
-33.6
-41.4
-49.0
-55.6
-64.9
-72.4
-79.3
-85.2
-84.0
-90.2
-96.1
-101.0
-101.8
-105.7
-108.5
-110.5
-107.4
-108.8
-110.9
-114.0
-116.5
-119.4
-118.7
-108.2
-72.0
6.8
22.2
14.8
5.0
-7.8
-19.2
-30.2
-38.8
-43.8
-32.0
33.0
21.2
6.9
-8.3

-23.0
-32.1
-50.2
-61.5
-72.0
-83.9
-93.4
-105.1
-115.7
-140.2
-150.1
-161.7
-171.3
-168.3
-176.7
-184.1
-190.6
-190.9
-195.9
-199.6
-201.1
-193.8
-194.1
-195.6
-198.1
-199.7
-201.6
-198.8
-182.3
-128.6
-8.0
13.7
4.9
-6.2
-21.0
-34.3
-47.1
-57.1
-62.9
-45.4
41.4
27.5
11.2
-6.1

27.6
38.3
61.4
74.1
86.7
104.2
114.6
128.6
141.4
174.1
185.3
199.6
211.3
207.4
217.0
225.3
232.8
232.9
238.4
242.7
244.1
234.6
234.3
235.7
237.9
239.1
240.6
236.7
217.2
154.2
11.6
-13.4
-3.7
8.2
24.2
38.7
52.4
63.2
69.5
50.2
-49.5
-34.5
-17.2
1.1

-3.3
2.3
10.6
19.1
25.5
26.5
34.1
41.9
48.4
57.8
65.2
72.2
78.0
77.0
83.1
89.1
93.9
94.8
98.7
101.6
103.5
100.4
101.6
103.8
106.9
109.5
112.3
111.6
100.9
64.9
-14.0
-29.2
-22.0
-12.2
0.5
12.0
23.0
31.6
36.7
25.0
-40.5
-28.6
-14.4
0.8

-14.1
-10.2
-7.2
-0.2
4.0
-0.9
5.7
11.2
15.4
16.8
22.8
27.2
30.8
31.0
35.7
40.9
44.7
45.9
49.0
51.5
53.5
52.5
54.2
56.7
60.0
63.0
66.3
66.5
58.8
32.1
-24.8
-36.6
-30.3
-21.4
-9.9
0.5
10.4
18.3
22.8
13.2
-40.0
-28.9
-15.8
-1.7

-3.3
2.3
10.5
18.9
25.3
26.2
33.7
41.4
47.8
57.3
64.6
71.6
77.2
76.3
82.3
88.3
92.9
93.8
97.6
100.5
102.4
99.1
100.3
102.5
105.5
108.0
110.7
109.9
99.1
63.1
-16.0
-31.2
-24.0
-14.4
-1.8
9.7
20.5
29.2
34.1
21.9
-43.1
-31.0
-16.8
-1.6

-14.1
-10.2
-7.1
-0.1
4.2
-0.6
6.1
11.7
16.0
17.3
23.5
27.9
31.6
31.7
36.6
41.8
45.6
46.8
50.1
52.5
54.7
53.7
55.6
58.1
61.5
64.5
67.9
68.2
60.7
34.0
-22.8
-34.7
-28.2
-19.2
-7.6
2.8
12.9
20.8
25.4
16.4
-37.5
-26.5
-13.4
0.7

-33.8
-44.6
-67.9
-80.7
-93.3
-111.0
-121.4
-135.3
-148.1
-180.6
-191.9
-206.0
-217.7
-213.6
-223.2
-231.4
-238.9
-238.9
-244.4
-248.6
-250.0
-240.4
-240.1
-241.4
-243.5
-244.6
-246.1
-242.2
-222.6
-159.5
-16.9
8.2
-1.3
-13.2
-29.1
-43.5
-57.1
-67.9
-74.2
-54.0
44.5
29.5
12.2
-6.2

SpecY
464.74
531.65
803.98
854.63
919.17
963.70
977.09
1023.59
1053.42
1233.65
1257.74
1305.85
1339.84
1275.89
1299.42
1321.96
1341.33
1326.06
1342.37
1359.40
1358.25
1305.59
1303.75
1311.10
1317.45
1322.03
1325.58
1311.55
1241.66
1015.16
567.79
525.89
543.95
557.92
583.44
612.17
638.33
656.07
651.27
485.78
172.46
120.46
63.31
35.95

Page 1 of 3

4:49 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

A21

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv3

Dead

Live

-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

Dead
-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindMTX
-5.98
-6.95
-9.82
-10.65
-11.83
-15.02
-15.54
-16.77
-17.98
-22.47
-23.20
-24.60
-25.74
-25.16
-25.84
-26.28
-26.79
-26.63
-26.95
-27.21
-27.10
-25.87
-25.56
-25.40
-25.22
-24.95
-24.68
-24.07
-22.36
-17.16
-4.90
-3.02
-3.47
-3.88
-4.51
-5.08
-5.60
-6.02
-6.27
-4.79
1.72
1.14
0.55
-0.06

WindMTX
5.98
6.95
9.82
10.65
11.83
15.02
15.54
16.77
17.98
22.47
23.20
24.60
25.74
25.16
25.84
26.28
26.79
26.63
26.95
27.21
27.10
25.87
25.56
25.40
25.22
24.95
24.68
24.07
22.36
17.16
4.90
3.02
3.47
3.88
4.51
5.08
5.60
6.02
6.27
4.79
-1.72
-1.14
-0.55
0.06

WindFY
10.93
19.09
33.74
44.73
54.14
61.30
70.77
81.57
91.08
109.86
119.52
129.82
138.37
136.19
144.19
151.63
157.93
158.59
163.47
167.15
169.08
163.29
164.13
166.22
169.30
171.59
174.25
172.28
157.24
107.38
-3.32
-23.82
-14.92
-3.29
11.94
25.72
38.86
49.24
55.26
39.08
-45.49
-31.11
-14.19
3.86

WindFY
-10.93
-19.09
-33.74
-44.73
-54.14
-61.30
-70.77
-81.57
-91.08
-109.86
-119.52
-129.82
-138.37
-136.19
-144.19
-151.63
-157.93
-158.59
-163.47
-167.15
-169.08
-163.29
-164.13
-166.22
-169.30
-171.59
-174.25
-172.28
-157.24
-107.38
3.32
23.82
14.92
3.29
-11.94
-25.72
-38.86
-49.24
-55.26
-39.08
45.49
31.11
14.19
-3.86

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

0.9

0.9

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

-1.2
-1.2

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

Figure 6-9 Case 4

WindMTY
-17.19
-19.96
-28.19
-30.56
-33.97
-43.15
-44.63
-48.16
-51.65
-64.54
-66.64
-70.70
-73.99
-72.34
-74.30
-75.58
-77.09
-76.64
-77.58
-78.36
-78.05
-74.52
-73.66
-73.20
-72.69
-71.96
-71.20
-69.46
-64.55
-49.58
-14.24
-8.81
-10.12
-11.32
-13.13
-14.80
-16.32
-17.54
-18.26
-13.95
4.95
3.30
1.59
-0.17

-23.0
-32.1
-50.3
-61.6
-72.2
-84.2
-93.8
-105.5
-116.3
-140.7
-150.7
-162.3
-172.1
-169.0
-177.5
-184.9
-191.6
-191.9
-196.9
-200.6
-202.3
-195.1
-195.4
-197.0
-199.6
-201.1
-203.2
-200.5
-184.2
-130.4
-10.0
11.7
2.8
-8.4
-23.3
-36.7
-49.5
-59.5
-65.4
-48.5
38.8
25.0
8.8
-8.5

27.6
38.3
61.3
74.0
86.5
103.9
114.2
128.2
140.9
173.6
184.7
198.9
210.5
206.7
216.1
224.4
231.8
231.9
237.3
241.7
243.0
233.4
233.0
234.4
236.4
237.6
239.0
235.0
215.4
152.4
9.7
-15.3
-5.8
6.0
21.8
36.3
49.9
60.8
67.0
47.0
-52.0
-37.0
-19.7
-1.3

-23.0
-32.1
-50.2
-61.5
-72.0
-83.9
-93.4
-105.1
-115.7
-140.2
-150.1
-161.7
-171.3
-168.3
-176.7
-184.1
-190.6
-190.9
-195.9
-199.6
-201.1
-193.8
-194.1
-195.6
-198.1
-199.7
-201.6
-198.8
-182.3
-128.6
-8.0
13.7
4.9
-6.2
-21.0
-34.3
-47.1
-57.1
-62.9
-45.4
41.4
27.5
11.2
-6.1

16.9
25.8
43.6
54.8
65.2
76.9
86.2
98.0
108.5
133.1
142.9
154.6
164.1
161.3
169.6
177.1
183.5
183.9
188.8
192.7
194.2
186.8
186.9
188.6
191.0
192.7
194.5
191.6
175.1
121.5
0.9
-20.7
-12.1
-1.0
13.7
27.2
39.8
49.9
55.7
38.4
-48.9
-34.9
-18.7
-1.4

-33.8
-44.6
-67.9
-80.8
-93.5
-111.3
-121.8
-135.7
-148.6
-181.1
-192.5
-206.7
-218.5
-214.4
-224.0
-232.3
-239.9
-239.9
-245.5
-249.6
-251.1
-241.7
-241.5
-242.7
-245.0
-246.1
-247.7
-243.9
-224.5
-161.3
-18.8
6.3
-3.4
-15.4
-31.4
-45.8
-59.6
-70.4
-76.7
-57.2
41.9
27.1
9.8
-8.7

-2.3
-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.1
-2.1
-2.0
-2.0
-1.9
-1.9
-1.8
-1.8
-1.7
-1.7
-1.6
-1.5
-1.5
-1.4
-1.4
-1.3
-1.2
-1.2
-1.1
-1.0
-1.0
-0.9
-0.8
-0.8
-0.7
-0.6
-0.5
-0.5
-0.4
0.2
-0.5
-0.6
-0.6
-0.7

-2.3
-2.4
-2.5
-2.6
-2.7
-2.9
-3.1
-3.0
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.7
-3.9
-3.8
-4.0
-3.9
-4.1
-4.2
-4.3
-4.3
-4.4
-4.4
-4.5
-4.7
-4.8
-4.7
-4.9
-4.8
-5.0
-5.4
-5.1
-4.9
-5.0
-5.0

15.2
28.2
51.5
69.0
84.1
95.4
110.5
127.8
143.0
173.1
188.5
205.1
218.7
215.3
228.0
240.0
250.0
251.1
258.9
264.9
267.9
258.6
259.9
263.3
268.2
271.9
276.2
273.0
248.9
169.1
-8.0
-40.8
-26.5
-8.0
16.4
38.5
59.5
76.1
85.7
59.9
-75.6
-52.6
-25.5
3.3

-19.8
-32.9
-56.5
-74.1
-89.2
-100.7
-115.9
-133.2
-148.4
-178.4
-193.9
-210.4
-224.1
-220.5
-233.4
-245.2
-255.3
-256.4
-264.2
-270.0
-273.1
-263.9
-265.3
-268.6
-273.5
-277.2
-281.5
-278.3
-254.3
-174.5
2.6
35.5
21.2
2.6
-21.8
-43.8
-64.9
-81.4
-91.1
-65.1
70.0
47.0
19.9
-9.0

10.8
20.6
38.1
51.2
62.5
71.1
82.5
95.5
107.0
129.5
141.1
153.6
163.9
161.3
170.9
179.9
187.5
188.3
194.2
198.7
201.0
194.1
195.2
197.7
201.5
204.3
207.5
205.2
187.2
127.4
-5.4
-29.9
-19.2
-5.2
13.1
29.7
45.5
58.0
65.3
46.4
-55.7
-38.5
-18.2
3.4

-15.4
-25.3
-42.9
-56.1
-67.4
-76.0
-87.4
-100.3
-111.6
-134.2
-145.7
-158.0
-168.2
-165.6
-175.1
-184.0
-191.5
-192.3
-198.1
-202.5
-204.8
-197.8
-198.7
-201.2
-204.8
-207.5
-210.7
-208.3
-190.2
-130.3
2.6
27.2
16.6
2.7
-15.5
-32.0
-47.7
-60.1
-67.3
-47.4
53.5
36.2
15.9
-5.8

10.8
20.5
38.0
51.1
62.3
70.7
82.0
94.9
106.2
128.8
140.3
152.7
162.8
160.3
169.8
178.8
186.2
187.0
192.8
197.3
199.5
192.5
193.4
195.9
199.5
202.3
205.4
202.9
184.8
125.0
-8.0
-32.5
-22.0
-8.1
10.0
26.6
42.3
54.8
61.9
42.2
-59.1
-41.7
-21.5
0.2

-15.4
-25.3
-43.0
-56.3
-67.7
-76.4
-87.9
-100.8
-112.4
-134.8
-146.5
-158.9
-169.2
-166.5
-176.2
-185.1
-192.8
-193.6
-199.6
-203.8
-206.3
-199.4
-200.5
-203.0
-206.8
-209.5
-212.8
-210.6
-192.6
-132.7
0.0
24.6
13.8
-0.2
-18.6
-35.1
-51.0
-63.4
-70.7
-51.6
50.0
32.9
12.6
-9.1

-9.5
-10.7
-14.2
-15.2
-16.6
-20.5
-21.1
-22.5
-23.9
-29.3
-30.1
-31.7
-33.1
-32.3
-33.1
-33.6
-34.2
-33.9
-34.3
-34.6
-34.4
-32.9
-32.4
-32.2
-31.9
-31.6
-31.2
-30.4
-28.3
-22.0
-7.3
-5.0
-5.5
-5.9
-6.6
-7.2
-7.8
-8.3
-8.5
-6.3
0.9
0.2
-0.5
-1.3

4.9
6.0
9.4
10.3
11.8
15.6
16.2
17.8
19.2
24.6
25.6
27.3
28.7
28.0
28.9
29.5
30.1
30.0
30.4
30.7
30.7
29.2
28.9
28.7
28.6
28.3
28.0
27.3
25.3
19.1
4.5
2.3
2.9
3.4
4.2
5.0
5.6
6.2
6.5
5.2
-3.2
-2.5
-1.8
-1.1

-9.5
-10.7
-14.3
-15.4
-16.9
-20.9
-21.6
-23.1
-24.7
-30.0
-30.9
-32.6
-34.1
-33.3
-34.2
-34.7
-35.4
-35.2
-35.7
-35.9
-35.9
-34.5
-34.3
-34.0
-33.9
-33.6
-33.3
-32.7
-30.8
-24.5
-9.9
-7.6
-8.2
-8.8
-9.7
-10.3
-11.1
-11.5
-11.9
-10.5
-2.5
-3.0
-3.8
-4.5

4.9
6.0
9.3
10.2
11.5
15.2
15.7
17.2
18.5
24.0
24.7
26.4
27.7
27.1
27.8
28.3
28.9
28.7
29.0
29.4
29.2
27.6
27.1
26.9
26.6
26.3
25.9
25.1
22.9
16.7
1.9
-0.3
0.1
0.5
1.1
1.9
2.4
2.9
3.1
1.0
-6.6
-5.8
-5.1
-4.4

-9.8
-3.4
4.2
14.5
21.6
19.1
28.7
37.4
44.6
51.7
60.8
68.3
74.6
74.0
81.2
88.6
94.4
95.7
100.4
104.0
106.6
103.9
105.9
109.0
113.3
116.9
121.0
120.7
108.5
66.7
-23.8
-41.8
-32.7
-20.2
-4.2
10.4
24.3
35.4
41.7
27.5
-51.5
-36.2
-17.9
1.6

31.4
44.5
71.9
87.8
103.2
122.7
135.8
153.0
168.6
206.6
220.7
238.0
252.1
247.6
259.5
270.0
279.4
279.7
286.6
292.0
293.9
282.7
282.7
284.7
287.7
289.6
291.9
287.4
263.4
185.7
10.4
-20.7
-8.4
6.9
27.4
45.9
63.5
77.5
85.5
61.0
-63.4
-44.1
-21.7
2.0

-36.1
-49.2
-76.8
-92.9
-108.3
-128.0
-141.2
-158.3
-174.0
-211.9
-226.1
-243.3
-257.5
-252.9
-264.8
-275.3
-284.7
-284.9
-291.9
-297.2
-299.2
-288.0
-288.0
-289.9
-293.1
-294.9
-297.2
-292.8
-268.9
-191.0
-15.8
15.4
3.1
-12.3
-32.8
-51.3
-68.9
-82.8
-90.9
-66.3
57.7
38.5
16.1
-7.7

5.2
-1.3
-9.1
-19.5
-26.8
-24.4
-34.1
-42.8
-50.0
-57.0
-66.1
-73.6
-79.9
-79.2
-86.5
-93.9
-99.7
-101.0
-105.7
-109.1
-111.9
-109.2
-111.2
-114.3
-118.6
-122.2
-126.3
-126.1
-113.9
-72.0
18.4
36.5
27.4
14.8
-1.3
-15.8
-29.8
-40.7
-47.1
-32.8
45.8
30.6
12.3
-7.2

-13.3
-9.4
-6.3
0.7
5.0
0.3
7.0
12.6
16.9
18.2
24.3
28.8
32.5
32.6
37.4
42.6
46.5
47.7
51.0
53.4
55.5
54.6
56.5
59.0
62.4
65.4
68.7
69.1
61.6
34.9
-21.9
-33.8
-27.3
-18.3
-6.7
3.7
13.8
21.7
26.3
17.3
-36.5
-25.6
-12.4
1.7

-2.6
3.1
11.4
19.9
26.4
27.4
35.0
42.8
49.3
58.7
66.1
73.1
78.9
77.9
84.0
90.0
94.8
95.7
99.5
102.4
104.4
101.2
102.5
104.7
107.8
110.3
113.2
112.5
101.8
65.8
-13.1
-28.4
-21.1
-11.3
1.4
12.9
23.9
32.5
37.6
25.9
-39.6
-27.6
-13.4
1.8

-13.3
-9.4
-6.3
0.6
4.9
0.0
6.6
12.1
16.3
17.7
23.7
28.1
31.7
31.9
36.6
41.8
45.5
46.7
49.9
52.4
54.4
53.4
55.1
57.6
60.9
63.9
67.1
67.4
59.7
33.0
-23.9
-35.7
-29.4
-20.5
-9.0
1.4
11.3
19.2
23.7
14.1
-39.1
-28.0
-14.9
-0.8

-2.6
3.1
11.3
19.8
26.2
27.1
34.6
42.3
48.7
58.2
65.5
72.4
78.1
77.2
83.2
89.1
93.8
94.7
98.5
101.4
103.2
100.0
101.2
103.4
106.3
108.9
111.6
110.8
100.0
63.9
-15.1
-30.3
-23.1
-13.5
-0.9
10.6
21.4
30.1
35.0
22.7
-42.2
-30.1
-15.9
-0.7

17.6
26.6
44.5
55.8
66.2
78.0
87.5
99.3
109.9
134.5
144.4
156.1
165.8
162.9
171.3
178.8
185.4
185.8
190.8
194.6
196.2
188.9
189.2
190.8
193.3
195.0
197.0
194.3
177.9
124.2
3.7
-17.9
-9.1
2.1
17.0
30.4
43.2
53.3
59.2
42.4
-45.4
-31.5
-15.3
2.0

-33.0
-43.8
-67.1
-79.9
-92.5
-110.1
-120.5
-134.4
-147.2
-179.7
-191.0
-205.1
-216.8
-212.8
-222.3
-230.5
-238.0
-238.0
-243.5
-247.7
-249.1
-239.5
-239.2
-240.5
-242.6
-243.8
-245.2
-241.3
-221.7
-158.6
-16.0
9.1
-0.5
-12.3
-28.2
-42.6
-56.2
-67.0
-73.3
-53.1
45.4
30.5
13.1
-5.3

-2.1
-7.8
-16.3
-24.8
-31.3
-32.4
-40.0
-47.6
-54.1
-63.5
-70.9
-77.8
-83.5
-82.4
-88.5
-94.4
-99.1
-99.9
-103.8
-106.6
-108.5
-105.3
-106.5
-108.6
-111.7
-114.1
-116.9
-116.1
-105.4
-69.3
9.7
25.0
17.8
8.1
-4.6
-15.9
-26.8
-35.4
-40.4
-28.0
36.5
24.5
10.3
-5.0

8.7
4.7
1.3
-5.7
-10.2
-5.6
-12.4
-17.9
-22.3
-23.5
-29.7
-34.1
-37.9
-37.8
-42.7
-47.9
-51.8
-52.9
-56.3
-58.6
-60.8
-59.9
-61.8
-64.2
-67.7
-70.6
-74.0
-74.5
-67.0
-40.2
16.6
28.5
22.0
12.9
1.2
-9.1
-19.2
-27.0
-31.7
-22.5
30.9
20.0
6.8
-7.3

-2.1
-7.9
-16.3
-24.9
-31.5
-32.7
-40.5
-48.1
-54.7
-64.0
-71.5
-78.4
-84.3
-83.2
-89.3
-95.2
-100.1
-100.9
-104.9
-107.6
-109.6
-106.5
-107.9
-110.0
-113.1
-115.6
-118.5
-117.8
-107.3
-71.1
7.7
23.0
15.7
5.9
-6.9
-18.3
-29.3
-37.9
-42.9
-31.1
34.0
22.1
7.8
-7.4

8.7
4.7
1.4
-5.6
-10.0
-5.3
-12.0
-17.4
-21.8
-23.0
-29.1
-33.4
-37.1
-37.1
-41.9
-47.0
-50.9
-52.0
-55.2
-57.6
-59.6
-58.7
-60.5
-62.9
-66.2
-69.2
-72.5
-72.8
-65.1
-38.4
18.5
30.4
24.0
15.0
3.6
-6.8
-16.7
-24.6
-29.1
-19.4
33.4
22.5
9.3
-4.9

28.4
39.1
62.2
75.0
87.6
105.1
115.5
129.5
142.3
174.9
186.2
200.5
212.2
208.2
217.8
226.1
233.7
233.8
239.3
243.6
245.0
235.5
235.2
236.6
238.8
240.0
241.5
237.6
218.1
155.1
12.5
-12.5
-2.8
9.1
25.1
39.5
53.3
64.1
70.4
51.0
-48.5
-33.6
-16.3
2.1

-22.3
-31.3
-49.4
-60.8
-71.4
-83.4
-92.9
-104.6
-115.4
-139.8
-149.8
-161.4
-171.2
-168.2
-176.6
-184.1
-190.7
-191.0
-196.1
-199.7
-201.4
-194.2
-194.5
-196.1
-198.7
-200.3
-202.3
-199.6
-183.3
-129.5
-9.1
12.6
3.7
-7.5
-22.4
-35.8
-48.6
-58.6
-64.5
-47.7
39.8
26.0
9.7
-7.6

28.4
39.1
62.1
74.8
87.4
104.8
115.1
129.1
141.8
174.4
185.6
199.8
211.4
207.5
217.0
225.3
232.7
232.8
238.2
242.6
243.9
234.3
233.9
235.2
237.3
238.5
239.9
235.9
216.3
153.3
10.6
-14.4
-4.9
6.9
22.7
37.2
50.8
61.7
67.9
47.9
-51.1
-36.0
-18.7
-0.4

-22.3
-31.3
-49.4
-60.7
-71.2
-83.1
-92.5
-104.2
-114.8
-139.3
-149.2
-160.8
-170.4
-167.4
-175.8
-183.2
-189.7
-190.0
-195.0
-198.7
-200.3
-192.9
-193.2
-194.8
-197.2
-198.8
-200.7
-197.9
-181.4
-127.7
-7.1
14.6
5.8
-5.3
-20.1
-33.5
-46.1
-56.2
-62.0
-44.5
42.4
28.4
12.1
-5.2

17.6
26.6
44.4
55.7
66.0
77.8
87.1
98.9
109.4
134.0
143.8
155.5
165.0
162.2
170.5
178.0
184.4
184.8
189.7
193.5
195.0
187.6
187.8
189.5
191.9
193.5
195.4
192.5
176.0
122.4
1.8
-19.9
-11.2
-0.1
14.6
28.1
40.7
50.8
56.6
39.3
-48.0
-34.0
-17.7
-0.5

16.9
25.8
43.6
54.8
65.2
76.9
86.2
98.0
108.5
133.1
142.9
154.6
164.1
161.3
169.6
177.1
183.5
183.9
188.8
192.7
194.2
186.8
186.9
188.6
191.0
192.7
194.5
191.6
175.1
121.5
0.9
-20.7
-12.1
-1.0
13.7
27.2
39.8
49.9
55.7
38.4
-48.9
-34.9
-18.7
-1.4

-33.8
-44.6
-67.9
-80.8
-93.5
-111.3
-121.8
-135.7
-148.6
-181.1
-192.5
-206.7
-218.5
-214.4
-224.0
-232.3
-239.9
-239.9
-245.5
-249.6
-251.1
-241.7
-241.5
-242.7
-245.0
-246.1
-247.7
-243.9
-224.5
-161.3
-18.8
6.3
-3.4
-15.4
-31.4
-45.8
-59.6
-70.4
-76.7
-57.2
41.9
27.1
9.8
-8.7

16.9
25.8
43.7
54.9
65.4
77.2
86.6
98.4
109.0
133.6
143.5
155.3
164.9
162.0
170.4
177.9
184.5
184.9
189.9
193.7
195.3
188.0
188.3
190.0
192.5
194.1
196.1
193.4
177.0
123.3
2.8
-18.8
-10.0
1.2
16.0
29.5
42.3
52.4
58.3
41.5
-46.4
-32.5
-16.2
1.0

-23.0
-32.1
-50.3
-61.6
-72.2
-84.2
-93.8
-105.5
-116.3
-140.7
-150.7
-162.3
-172.1
-169.0
-177.5
-184.9
-191.6
-191.9
-196.9
-200.6
-202.3
-195.1
-195.4
-197.0
-199.6
-201.1
-203.2
-200.5
-184.2
-130.4
-10.0
11.7
2.8
-8.4
-23.3
-36.7
-49.5
-59.5
-65.4
-48.5
38.8
25.0
8.8
-8.5

27.6
38.3
61.3
74.0
86.5
103.9
114.2
128.2
140.9
173.6
184.7
198.9
210.5
206.7
216.1
224.4
231.8
231.9
237.3
241.7
243.0
233.4
233.0
234.4
236.4
237.6
239.0
235.0
215.4
152.4
9.7
-15.3
-5.8
6.0
21.8
36.3
49.9
60.8
67.0
47.0
-52.0
-37.0
-19.7
-1.3

-2.3
-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.1
-2.1
-2.0
-2.0
-1.9
-1.9
-1.8
-1.8
-1.7
-1.7
-1.6
-1.5
-1.5
-1.4
-1.4
-1.3
-1.2
-1.2
-1.1
-1.0
-1.0
-0.9
-0.8
-0.8
-0.7
-0.6
-0.5
-0.5
-0.4
0.2
-0.5
-0.6
-0.6
-0.7

-2.3
-2.4
-2.5
-2.6
-2.7
-2.9
-3.1
-3.0
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.4
-3.5
-3.5
-3.6
-3.5
-3.6
-3.7
-3.9
-3.8
-4.0
-3.9
-4.1
-4.2
-4.3
-4.3
-4.4
-4.4
-4.5
-4.7
-4.8
-4.7
-4.9
-4.8
-5.0
-5.4
-5.1
-4.9
-5.0
-5.0

-19.8
-32.9
-56.5
-74.1
-89.2
-100.7
-115.9
-133.2
-148.4
-178.4
-193.9
-210.4
-224.1
-220.5
-233.4
-245.2
-255.3
-256.4
-264.2
-270.0
-273.1
-263.9
-265.3
-268.6
-273.5
-277.2
-281.5
-278.3
-254.3
-174.5
2.6
35.5
21.2
2.6
-21.8
-43.8
-64.9
-81.4
-91.1
-65.1
70.0
47.0
19.9
-9.0

15.2
28.2
51.5
69.0
84.1
95.4
110.5
127.8
143.0
173.1
188.5
205.1
218.7
215.3
228.0
240.0
250.0
251.1
258.9
264.9
267.9
258.6
259.9
263.3
268.2
271.9
276.2
273.0
248.9
169.1
-8.0
-40.8
-26.5
-8.0
16.4
38.5
59.5
76.1
85.7
59.9
-75.6
-52.6
-25.5
3.3

-15.4
-25.3
-42.9
-56.1
-67.4
-76.0
-87.4
-100.3
-111.6
-134.2
-145.7
-158.0
-168.2
-165.6
-175.1
-184.0
-191.5
-192.3
-198.1
-202.5
-204.8
-197.8
-198.7
-201.2
-204.8
-207.5
-210.7
-208.3
-190.2
-130.3
2.6
27.2
16.6
2.7
-15.5
-32.0
-47.7
-60.1
-67.3
-47.4
53.5
36.2
15.9
-5.8

10.8
20.6
38.1
51.2
62.5
71.1
82.5
95.5
107.0
129.5
141.1
153.6
163.9
161.3
170.9
179.9
187.5
188.3
194.2
198.7
201.0
194.1
195.2
197.7
201.5
204.3
207.5
205.2
187.2
127.4
-5.4
-29.9
-19.2
-5.2
13.1
29.7
45.5
58.0
65.3
46.4
-55.7
-38.5
-18.2
3.4

-15.4
-25.3
-43.0
-56.3
-67.7
-76.4
-87.9
-100.8
-112.4
-134.8
-146.5
-158.9
-169.2
-166.5
-176.2
-185.1
-192.8
-193.6
-199.6
-203.8
-206.3
-199.4
-200.5
-203.0
-206.8
-209.5
-212.8
-210.6
-192.6
-132.7
0.0
24.6
13.8
-0.2
-18.6
-35.1
-51.0
-63.4
-70.7
-51.6
50.0
32.9
12.6
-9.1

10.8
20.5
38.0
51.1
62.3
70.7
82.0
94.9
106.2
128.8
140.3
152.7
162.8
160.3
169.8
178.8
186.2
187.0
192.8
197.3
199.5
192.5
193.4
195.9
199.5
202.3
205.4
202.9
184.8
125.0
-8.0
-32.5
-22.0
-8.1
10.0
26.6
42.3
54.8
61.9
42.2
-59.1
-41.7
-21.5
0.2

4.9
6.0
9.4
10.3
11.8
15.6
16.2
17.8
19.2
24.6
25.6
27.3
28.7
28.0
28.9
29.5
30.1
30.0
30.4
30.7
30.7
29.2
28.9
28.7
28.6
28.3
28.0
27.3
25.3
19.1
4.5
2.3
2.9
3.4
4.2
5.0
5.6
6.2
6.5
5.2
-3.2
-2.5
-1.8
-1.1

-9.5
-10.7
-14.2
-15.2
-16.6
-20.5
-21.1
-22.5
-23.9
-29.3
-30.1
-31.7
-33.1
-32.3
-33.1
-33.6
-34.2
-33.9
-34.3
-34.6
-34.4
-32.9
-32.4
-32.2
-31.9
-31.6
-31.2
-30.4
-28.3
-22.0
-7.3
-5.0
-5.5
-5.9
-6.6
-7.2
-7.8
-8.3
-8.5
-6.3
0.9
0.2
-0.5
-1.3

4.9
6.0
9.3
10.2
11.5
15.2
15.7
17.2
18.5
24.0
24.7
26.4
27.7
27.1
27.8
28.3
28.9
28.7
29.0
29.4
29.2
27.6
27.1
26.9
26.6
26.3
25.9
25.1
22.9
16.7
1.9
-0.3
0.1
0.5
1.1
1.9
2.4
2.9
3.1
1.0
-6.6
-5.8
-5.1
-4.4

-9.5
-10.7
-14.3
-15.4
-16.9
-20.9
-21.6
-23.1
-24.7
-30.0
-30.9
-32.6
-34.1
-33.3
-34.2
-34.7
-35.4
-35.2
-35.7
-35.9
-35.9
-34.5
-34.3
-34.0
-33.9
-33.6
-33.3
-32.7
-30.8
-24.5
-9.9
-7.6
-8.2
-8.8
-9.7
-10.3
-11.1
-11.5
-11.9
-10.5
-2.5
-3.0
-3.8
-4.5

5.2
-1.3
-9.1
-19.5
-26.8
-24.4
-34.1
-42.8
-50.0
-57.0
-66.1
-73.6
-79.9
-79.2
-86.5
-93.9
-99.7
-101.0
-105.7
-109.1
-111.9
-109.2
-111.2
-114.3
-118.6
-122.2
-126.3
-126.1
-113.9
-72.0
18.4
36.5
27.4
14.8
-1.3
-15.8
-29.8
-40.7
-47.1
-32.8
45.8
30.6
12.3
-7.2

-36.1
-49.2
-76.8
-92.9
-108.3
-128.0
-141.2
-158.3
-174.0
-211.9
-226.1
-243.3
-257.5
-252.9
-264.8
-275.3
-284.7
-284.9
-291.9
-297.2
-299.2
-288.0
-288.0
-289.9
-293.1
-294.9
-297.2
-292.8
-268.9
-191.0
-15.8
15.4
3.1
-12.3
-32.8
-51.3
-68.9
-82.8
-90.9
-66.3
57.7
38.5
16.1
-7.7

31.4
44.5
71.9
87.8
103.2
122.7
135.8
153.0
168.6
206.6
220.7
238.0
252.1
247.6
259.5
270.0
279.4
279.7
286.6
292.0
293.9
282.7
282.7
284.7
287.7
289.6
291.9
287.4
263.4
185.7
10.4
-20.7
-8.4
6.9
27.4
45.9
63.5
77.5
85.5
61.0
-63.4
-44.1
-21.7
2.0

-9.8
-3.4
4.2
14.5
21.6
19.1
28.7
37.4
44.6
51.7
60.8
68.3
74.6
74.0
81.2
88.6
94.4
95.7
100.4
104.0
106.6
103.9
105.9
109.0
113.3
116.9
121.0
120.7
108.5
66.7
-23.8
-41.8
-32.7
-20.2
-4.2
10.4
24.3
35.4
41.7
27.5
-51.5
-36.2
-17.9
1.6

8.7
4.7
1.4
-5.6
-10.0
-5.3
-12.0
-17.4
-21.8
-23.0
-29.1
-33.4
-37.1
-37.1
-41.9
-47.0
-50.9
-52.0
-55.2
-57.6
-59.6
-58.7
-60.5
-62.9
-66.2
-69.2
-72.5
-72.8
-65.1
-38.4
18.5
30.4
24.0
15.0
3.6
-6.8
-16.7
-24.6
-29.1
-19.4
33.4
22.5
9.3
-4.9

-2.1
-7.8
-16.3
-24.8
-31.3
-32.4
-40.0
-47.6
-54.1
-63.5
-70.9
-77.8
-83.5
-82.4
-88.5
-94.4
-99.1
-99.9
-103.8
-106.6
-108.5
-105.3
-106.5
-108.6
-111.7
-114.1
-116.9
-116.1
-105.4
-69.3
9.7
25.0
17.8
8.1
-4.6
-15.9
-26.8
-35.4
-40.4
-28.0
36.5
24.5
10.3
-5.0

8.7
4.7
1.3
-5.7
-10.2
-5.6
-12.4
-17.9
-22.3
-23.5
-29.7
-34.1
-37.9
-37.8
-42.7
-47.9
-51.8
-52.9
-56.3
-58.6
-60.8
-59.9
-61.8
-64.2
-67.7
-70.6
-74.0
-74.5
-67.0
-40.2
16.6
28.5
22.0
12.9
1.2
-9.1
-19.2
-27.0
-31.7
-22.5
30.9
20.0
6.8
-7.3

-2.1
-7.9
-16.3
-24.9
-31.5
-32.7
-40.5
-48.1
-54.7
-64.0
-71.5
-78.4
-84.3
-83.2
-89.3
-95.2
-100.1
-100.9
-104.9
-107.6
-109.6
-106.5
-107.9
-110.0
-113.1
-115.6
-118.5
-117.8
-107.3
-71.1
7.7
23.0
15.7
5.9
-6.9
-18.3
-29.3
-37.9
-42.9
-31.1
34.0
22.1
7.8
-7.4

-22.3
-31.3
-49.4
-60.7
-71.2
-83.1
-92.5
-104.2
-114.8
-139.3
-149.2
-160.8
-170.4
-167.4
-175.8
-183.2
-189.7
-190.0
-195.0
-198.7
-200.3
-192.9
-193.2
-194.8
-197.2
-198.8
-200.7
-197.9
-181.4
-127.7
-7.1
14.6
5.8
-5.3
-20.1
-33.5
-46.1
-56.2
-62.0
-44.5
42.4
28.4
12.1
-5.2

28.4
39.1
62.2
75.0
87.6
105.1
115.5
129.5
142.3
174.9
186.2
200.5
212.2
208.2
217.8
226.1
233.7
233.8
239.3
243.6
245.0
235.5
235.2
236.6
238.8
240.0
241.5
237.6
218.1
155.1
12.5
-12.5
-2.8
9.1
25.1
39.5
53.3
64.1
70.4
51.0
-48.5
-33.6
-16.3
2.1

-2.6
3.1
11.4
19.9
26.4
27.4
35.0
42.8
49.3
58.7
66.1
73.1
78.9
77.9
84.0
90.0
94.8
95.7
99.5
102.4
104.4
101.2
102.5
104.7
107.8
110.3
113.2
112.5
101.8
65.8
-13.1
-28.4
-21.1
-11.3
1.4
12.9
23.9
32.5
37.6
25.9
-39.6
-27.6
-13.4
1.8

-13.3
-9.4
-6.3
0.6
4.9
0.0
6.6
12.1
16.3
17.7
23.7
28.1
31.7
31.9
36.6
41.8
45.5
46.7
49.9
52.4
54.4
53.4
55.1
57.6
60.9
63.9
67.1
67.4
59.7
33.0
-23.9
-35.7
-29.4
-20.5
-9.0
1.4
11.3
19.2
23.7
14.1
-39.1
-28.0
-14.9
-0.8

-2.6
3.1
11.3
19.8
26.2
27.1
34.6
42.3
48.7
58.2
65.5
72.4
78.1
77.2
83.2
89.1
93.8
94.7
98.5
101.4
103.2
100.0
101.2
103.4
106.3
108.9
111.6
110.8
100.0
63.9
-15.1
-30.3
-23.1
-13.5
-0.9
10.6
21.4
30.1
35.0
22.7
-42.2
-30.1
-15.9
-0.7

-13.3
-9.4
-6.3
0.7
5.0
0.3
7.0
12.6
16.9
18.2
24.3
28.8
32.5
32.6
37.4
42.6
46.5
47.7
51.0
53.4
55.5
54.6
56.5
59.0
62.4
65.4
68.7
69.1
61.6
34.9
-21.9
-33.8
-27.3
-18.3
-6.7
3.7
13.8
21.7
26.3
17.3
-36.5
-25.6
-12.4
1.7

-33.0
-43.8
-67.1
-79.9
-92.5
-110.1
-120.5
-134.4
-147.2
-179.7
-191.0
-205.1
-216.8
-212.8
-222.3
-230.5
-238.0
-238.0
-243.5
-247.7
-249.1
-239.5
-239.2
-240.5
-242.6
-243.8
-245.2
-241.3
-221.7
-158.6
-16.0
9.1
-0.5
-12.3
-28.2
-42.6
-56.2
-67.0
-73.3
-53.1
45.4
30.5
13.1
-5.3

17.6
26.6
44.4
55.7
66.0
77.8
87.1
98.9
109.4
134.0
143.8
155.5
165.0
162.2
170.5
178.0
184.4
184.8
189.7
193.5
195.0
187.6
187.8
189.5
191.9
193.5
195.4
192.5
176.0
122.4
1.8
-19.9
-11.2
-0.1
14.6
28.1
40.7
50.8
56.6
39.3
-48.0
-34.0
-17.7
-0.5

-33.0
-43.8
-67.1
-80.0
-92.7
-110.4
-120.9
-134.8
-147.7
-180.3
-191.6
-205.8
-217.6
-213.5
-223.2
-231.4
-239.0
-239.0
-244.6
-248.8
-250.2
-240.8
-240.6
-241.9
-244.1
-245.2
-246.8
-243.0
-223.6
-160.4
-17.9
7.2
-2.5
-14.5
-30.5
-44.9
-58.7
-69.5
-75.8
-56.3
42.9
28.0
10.7
-7.7

17.6
26.6
44.5
55.8
66.2
78.0
87.5
99.3
109.9
134.5
144.4
156.1
165.8
162.9
171.3
178.8
185.4
185.8
190.8
194.6
196.2
188.9
189.2
190.8
193.3
195.0
197.0
194.3
177.9
124.2
3.7
-17.9
-9.1
2.1
17.0
30.4
43.2
53.3
59.2
42.4
-45.4
-31.5
-15.3
2.0

-22.3
-31.3
-49.4
-60.8
-71.4
-83.4
-92.9
-104.6
-115.4
-139.8
-149.8
-161.4
-171.2
-168.2
-176.6
-184.1
-190.7
-191.0
-196.1
-199.7
-201.4
-194.2
-194.5
-196.1
-198.7
-200.3
-202.3
-199.6
-183.3
-129.5
-9.1
12.6
3.7
-7.5
-22.4
-35.8
-48.6
-58.6
-64.5
-47.7
39.8
26.0
9.7
-7.6

WindMTY
17.19
19.96
28.19
30.56
33.97
43.15
44.63
48.16
51.65
64.54
66.64
70.70
73.99
72.34
74.30
75.58
77.09
76.64
77.58
78.36
78.05
74.52
73.66
73.20
72.69
71.96
71.20
69.46
64.55
49.58
14.24
8.81
10.12
11.32
13.13
14.80
16.32
17.54
18.26
13.95
-4.95
-3.30
-1.59
0.17

Page 2 of 3

4:49 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv3

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14
D14

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

A22

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

0.9

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Dead

Live

-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

Dead
-2.57
-2.62
-2.74
-2.79
-2.85
-2.95
-3.00
-2.96
-3.01
-2.95
-2.99
-2.95
-2.99
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.91
-2.95
-2.87
-2.91
-2.94
-2.97
-2.93
-2.96
-2.92
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-2.96
-2.99
-2.95
-2.98
-3.00
-3.03
-2.99
-3.01
-2.97
-3.00
-2.92
-3.14
-3.09
-3.11
-3.13

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.11
0.16
0.22
0.24
0.31
0.28
0.34
0.36
0.43
0.40
0.46
0.47
0.54
0.54
0.61
0.56
0.62
0.69
0.75
0.75
0.82
0.82
0.88
0.95
1.02
1.01
1.08
1.08
1.15
1.22
1.29
1.29
1.36
1.35
1.41
1.75
1.43
1.35
1.35
1.35

WindMTX
-5.98
-6.95
-9.82
-10.65
-11.83
-15.02
-15.54
-16.77
-17.98
-22.47
-23.20
-24.60
-25.74
-25.16
-25.84
-26.28
-26.79
-26.63
-26.95
-27.21
-27.10
-25.87
-25.56
-25.40
-25.22
-24.95
-24.68
-24.07
-22.36
-17.16
-4.90
-3.02
-3.47
-3.88
-4.51
-5.08
-5.60
-6.02
-6.27
-4.79
1.72
1.14
0.55
-0.06

WindMTX
5.98
6.95
9.82
10.65
11.83
15.02
15.54
16.77
17.98
22.47
23.20
24.60
25.74
25.16
25.84
26.28
26.79
26.63
26.95
27.21
27.10
25.87
25.56
25.40
25.22
24.95
24.68
24.07
22.36
17.16
4.90
3.02
3.47
3.88
4.51
5.08
5.60
6.02
6.27
4.79
-1.72
-1.14
-0.55
0.06

WindFY
10.93
19.09
33.74
44.73
54.14
61.30
70.77
81.57
91.08
109.86
119.52
129.82
138.37
136.19
144.19
151.63
157.93
158.59
163.47
167.15
169.08
163.29
164.13
166.22
169.30
171.59
174.25
172.28
157.24
107.38
-3.32
-23.82
-14.92
-3.29
11.94
25.72
38.86
49.24
55.26
39.08
-45.49
-31.11
-14.19
3.86

WindFY
-10.93
-19.09
-33.74
-44.73
-54.14
-61.30
-70.77
-81.57
-91.08
-109.86
-119.52
-129.82
-138.37
-136.19
-144.19
-151.63
-157.93
-158.59
-163.47
-167.15
-169.08
-163.29
-164.13
-166.22
-169.30
-171.59
-174.25
-172.28
-157.24
-107.38
3.32
23.82
14.92
3.29
-11.94
-25.72
-38.86
-49.24
-55.26
-39.08
45.49
31.11
14.19
-3.86

-33.0
-43.8
-67.1
-80.0
-92.7
-110.4
-120.9
-134.8
-147.7
-180.3
-191.6
-205.8
-217.6
-213.5
-223.2
-231.4
-239.0
-239.0
-244.6
-248.8
-250.2
-240.8
-240.6
-241.9
-244.1
-245.2
-246.8
-243.0
-223.6
-160.4
-17.9
7.2
-2.5
-14.5
-30.5
-44.9
-58.7
-69.5
-75.8
-56.3
42.9
28.0
10.7
-7.7

68.8
79.9
119.2
127.4
139.4
158.4
162.4
172.2
180.7
218.8
224.0
234.7
243.0
234.0
239.2
243.1
247.1
244.8
247.9
250.4
249.8
239.4
238.0
237.9
237.7
237.0
236.2
232.3
218.0
172.8
73.6
60.9
64.9
68.4
74.0
79.6
84.7
88.5
89.5
68.0
22.4
14.8
6.7
2.3

144.8
166.3
252.2
268.4
289.6
307.3
312.1
327.8
338.4
399.0
407.1
423.5
435.2
415.1
423.1
430.4
436.9
432.1
437.4
442.9
442.4
424.8
423.9
425.9
427.5
428.6
429.3
424.3
400.9
325.6
173.9
158.7
164.8
169.6
178.2
187.8
196.4
202.5
201.4
149.9
50.6
34.2
16.2
7.3

7.4
8.2
17.5
18.2
17.7
6.4
4.6
3.4
0.1
-5.4
-6.5
-8.4
-10.7
-13.0
-14.0
-13.8
-14.5
-14.8
-15.0
-14.3
-14.0
-13.1
-12.1
-10.6
-9.4
-7.6
-6.3
-5.0
-3.4
1.2
19.9
25.2
24.3
23.3
22.2
21.9
21.4
20.9
19.0
11.0
-0.3
-2.0
-4.2
-4.7

126.4
144.8
221.7
235.7
253.1
261.7
264.8
277.1
284.2
331.8
338.0
350.6
359.1
341.1
347.1
353.4
358.4
354.2
358.6
363.5
363.2
349.1
348.9
351.4
353.4
355.2
356.6
353.1
334.5
274.2
157.8
148.0
152.6
156.1
162.7
170.5
177.4
182.2
180.3
132.8
43.8
29.2
12.9
5.2

-133.7
-152.3
-229.5
-243.7
-261.2
-270.1
-273.4
-285.6
-292.8
-340.2
-346.5
-359.0
-367.6
-349.4
-355.5
-361.7
-366.8
-362.5
-367.0
-371.7
-371.5
-357.5
-357.4
-359.7
-361.9
-363.6
-365.0
-361.6
-343.1
-282.6
-166.3
-156.4
-161.1
-164.7
-171.4
-179.0
-186.1
-190.7
-188.8
-141.2
-52.8
-38.0
-21.8
-14.2

-14.8
-15.7
-25.3
-26.2
-25.9
-14.8
-13.2
-11.9
-8.7
-3.0
-2.1
-0.1
2.2
4.6
5.6
5.5
6.0
6.4
6.5
6.1
5.7
4.7
3.6
2.2
0.9
-0.7
-2.1
-3.5
-5.2
-9.7
-28.5
-33.6
-32.8
-31.9
-30.9
-30.5
-30.0
-29.4
-27.6
-19.4
-8.6
-6.9
-4.6
-4.2

-76.1
-87.4
-127.1
-135.4
-147.5
-166.8
-171.0
-180.6
-189.3
-227.2
-232.6
-243.1
-251.6
-242.3
-247.6
-251.4
-255.6
-253.1
-256.3
-258.6
-258.1
-247.8
-246.4
-246.3
-246.2
-245.3
-244.6
-240.8
-226.6
-181.3
-82.2
-69.3
-73.5
-77.0
-82.7
-88.1
-93.3
-97.0
-98.0
-76.3
-31.3
-23.6
-15.6
-11.2

-152.1
-173.8
-260.1
-276.4
-297.7
-315.7
-320.7
-336.2
-347.0
-407.5
-415.7
-431.9
-443.8
-423.5
-431.5
-438.8
-445.3
-440.4
-445.8
-451.1
-450.7
-433.2
-432.4
-434.3
-436.0
-436.9
-437.7
-432.8
-409.5
-334.1
-182.4
-167.1
-173.3
-178.2
-186.9
-196.3
-205.0
-210.9
-210.0
-158.3
-59.6
-43.0
-25.1
-16.3

70.7
81.9
121.3
129.5
141.5
160.6
164.7
174.4
183.0
221.0
226.3
236.9
245.3
236.2
241.4
245.3
249.4
247.0
250.1
252.6
252.0
241.6
240.2
240.1
240.0
239.2
238.4
234.5
220.3
175.0
75.9
63.1
67.2
70.7
76.3
81.8
87.0
90.8
91.8
70.2
24.7
17.1
9.1
4.6

146.7
168.3
254.3
270.6
291.7
309.5
314.4
330.0
340.7
401.3
409.4
425.7
437.5
417.4
425.3
432.6
439.1
434.3
439.6
445.1
444.6
427.1
426.1
428.1
429.8
430.8
431.5
426.5
403.2
327.9
176.2
160.9
167.1
171.9
180.5
190.0
198.7
204.7
203.7
152.1
53.0
36.5
18.5
9.7

9.4
10.1
19.5
20.3
19.9
8.6
6.9
5.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.2
-6.1
-8.4
-10.8
-11.8
-11.6
-12.2
-12.6
-12.7
-12.1
-11.8
-10.9
-9.8
-8.3
-7.1
-5.4
-4.1
-2.8
-1.2
3.5
22.2
27.4
26.6
25.6
24.5
24.2
23.7
23.2
21.3
13.2
2.0
0.4
-1.9
-2.4

128.3
146.8
223.8
237.8
255.2
264.0
267.1
279.4
286.5
334.0
340.2
352.8
361.4
343.3
349.4
355.6
360.7
356.4
360.8
365.7
365.4
351.3
351.1
353.6
355.7
357.4
358.8
355.4
336.8
276.4
160.1
150.2
154.9
158.4
165.0
172.8
179.7
184.4
182.5
135.0
46.2
31.5
15.2
7.6

-131.8
-150.3
-227.5
-241.5
-259.1
-267.9
-271.1
-283.3
-290.5
-338.0
-344.3
-356.8
-365.4
-347.2
-353.3
-359.5
-364.6
-360.3
-364.7
-369.5
-369.3
-355.3
-355.1
-357.5
-359.6
-361.4
-362.8
-359.4
-340.8
-280.4
-164.1
-154.2
-158.9
-162.4
-169.1
-176.8
-183.8
-188.4
-186.6
-139.0
-50.4
-35.7
-19.4
-11.8

-12.8
-13.7
-23.2
-24.1
-23.7
-12.6
-10.9
-9.6
-6.4
-0.8
0.2
2.2
4.4
6.9
7.8
7.7
8.3
8.7
8.8
8.2
7.9
6.9
5.8
4.4
3.1
1.5
0.1
-1.2
-2.9
-7.5
-26.2
-31.4
-30.6
-29.6
-28.6
-28.2
-27.8
-27.2
-25.3
-17.1
-6.3
-4.5
-2.3
-1.8

-74.2
-85.4
-125.0
-133.3
-145.3
-164.6
-168.7
-178.4
-187.0
-225.0
-230.3
-240.9
-249.3
-240.1
-245.4
-249.2
-253.3
-250.9
-254.0
-256.5
-255.9
-245.6
-244.2
-244.0
-243.9
-243.1
-242.4
-238.5
-224.4
-179.0
-79.9
-67.1
-71.2
-74.7
-80.4
-85.8
-91.0
-94.8
-95.8
-74.1
-29.0
-21.3
-13.3
-8.8

-150.2
-171.8
-258.0
-274.3
-295.5
-313.5
-318.4
-334.0
-344.7
-405.2
-413.4
-429.7
-441.5
-421.3
-429.3
-436.6
-443.1
-438.2
-443.6
-448.9
-448.5
-431.0
-430.1
-432.0
-433.8
-434.7
-435.5
-430.5
-407.2
-331.9
-180.2
-164.9
-171.1
-175.9
-184.6
-194.1
-202.8
-208.7
-207.7
-156.0
-57.2
-40.7
-22.7
-13.9

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
146.72
-152.12
168.29
-173.80
254.31
-260.06
270.56
-276.43
291.72
-297.70
309.55
-315.74
314.40
-320.71
330.00
-336.21
340.69
-347.00
401.26
-407.45
409.40
-415.68
425.71
-431.91
437.47
-443.76
417.36
-423.47
425.32
-431.51
432.64
-438.76
439.13
-445.32
434.28
-440.39
439.63
-445.81
445.06
-451.10
444.56
-450.66
427.07
-433.24
426.12
-432.36
428.11
-434.26
429.79
-436.01
430.82
-436.95
431.55
-437.74
426.54
-432.79
403.21
-409.53
327.89
-334.11
176.16
-182.44
160.94
-167.13
167.07
-173.32
171.91
-178.22
180.54
-186.91
190.05
-196.32
198.72
-205.05
204.71
-210.95
203.68
-209.97
152.13
-158.25
69.96
-76.55
47.00
-53.49
19.91
-26.44
9.72
-16.30

0.64
0.73
0.84
0.90
0.97
0.84
0.85
0.89
0.92
0.88
0.90
0.94
0.96
0.92
0.93
0.95
0.96
0.95
0.97
0.98
0.98
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.95
0.95
0.94
0.89
0.72
0.40
0.36
0.38
0.39
0.40
0.43
0.44
0.46
0.45
0.34
0.17
0.12
0.06
0.04

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

28.4
39.1
62.1
74.8
87.4
104.8
115.1
129.1
141.8
174.4
185.6
199.8
211.4
207.5
217.0
225.3
232.7
232.8
238.2
242.6
243.9
234.3
233.9
235.2
237.3
238.5
239.9
235.9
216.3
153.3
10.6
-14.4
-4.9
6.9
22.7
37.2
50.8
61.7
67.9
47.9
-51.1
-36.0
-18.7
-0.4

68.8
79.9
119.2
127.4
139.4
158.4
162.4
172.2
180.7
218.8
224.0
234.7
243.0
234.0
239.2
243.1
247.1
244.8
247.9
250.4
249.8
239.4
238.0
237.9
237.7
237.0
236.2
232.3
218.0
172.8
73.6
60.9
64.9
68.4
74.0
79.6
84.7
88.5
89.5
68.0
22.4
14.8
6.7
2.3

144.8
166.3
252.2
268.4
289.6
307.3
312.1
327.8
338.4
399.0
407.1
423.5
435.2
415.1
423.1
430.4
436.9
432.1
437.4
442.9
442.4
424.8
423.9
425.9
427.5
428.6
429.3
424.3
400.9
325.6
173.9
158.7
164.8
169.6
178.2
187.8
196.4
202.5
201.4
149.9
50.6
34.2
16.2
7.3

7.4
8.2
17.5
18.2
17.7
6.4
4.6
3.4
0.1
-5.4
-6.5
-8.4
-10.7
-13.0
-14.0
-13.8
-14.5
-14.8
-15.0
-14.3
-14.0
-13.1
-12.1
-10.6
-9.4
-7.6
-6.3
-5.0
-3.4
1.2
19.9
25.2
24.3
23.3
22.2
21.9
21.4
20.9
19.0
11.0
-0.3
-2.0
-4.2
-4.7

126.4
144.8
221.7
235.7
253.1
261.7
264.8
277.1
284.2
331.8
338.0
350.6
359.1
341.1
347.1
353.4
358.4
354.2
358.6
363.5
363.2
349.1
348.9
351.4
353.4
355.2
356.6
353.1
334.5
274.2
157.8
148.0
152.6
156.1
162.7
170.5
177.4
182.2
180.3
132.8
43.8
29.2
12.9
5.2

-133.7
-152.3
-229.5
-243.7
-261.2
-270.1
-273.4
-285.6
-292.8
-340.2
-346.5
-359.0
-367.6
-349.4
-355.5
-361.7
-366.8
-362.5
-367.0
-371.7
-371.5
-357.5
-357.4
-359.7
-361.9
-363.6
-365.0
-361.6
-343.1
-282.6
-166.3
-156.4
-161.1
-164.7
-171.4
-179.0
-186.1
-190.7
-188.8
-141.2
-52.8
-38.0
-21.8
-14.2

-14.8
-15.7
-25.3
-26.2
-25.9
-14.8
-13.2
-11.9
-8.7
-3.0
-2.1
-0.1
2.2
4.6
5.6
5.5
6.0
6.4
6.5
6.1
5.7
4.7
3.6
2.2
0.9
-0.7
-2.1
-3.5
-5.2
-9.7
-28.5
-33.6
-32.8
-31.9
-30.9
-30.5
-30.0
-29.4
-27.6
-19.4
-8.6
-6.9
-4.6
-4.2

-76.1
-87.4
-127.1
-135.4
-147.5
-166.8
-171.0
-180.6
-189.3
-227.2
-232.6
-243.1
-251.6
-242.3
-247.6
-251.4
-255.6
-253.1
-256.3
-258.6
-258.1
-247.8
-246.4
-246.3
-246.2
-245.3
-244.6
-240.8
-226.6
-181.3
-82.2
-69.3
-73.5
-77.0
-82.7
-88.1
-93.3
-97.0
-98.0
-76.3
-31.3
-23.6
-15.6
-11.2

-152.1
-173.8
-260.1
-276.4
-297.7
-315.7
-320.7
-336.2
-347.0
-407.5
-415.7
-431.9
-443.8
-423.5
-431.5
-438.8
-445.3
-440.4
-445.8
-451.1
-450.7
-433.2
-432.4
-434.3
-436.0
-436.9
-437.7
-432.8
-409.5
-334.1
-182.4
-167.1
-173.3
-178.2
-186.9
-196.3
-205.0
-210.9
-210.0
-158.3
-59.6
-43.0
-25.1
-16.3

70.7
81.9
121.3
129.5
141.5
160.6
164.7
174.4
183.0
221.0
226.3
236.9
245.3
236.2
241.4
245.3
249.4
247.0
250.1
252.6
252.0
241.6
240.2
240.1
240.0
239.2
238.4
234.5
220.3
175.0
75.9
63.1
67.2
70.7
76.3
81.8
87.0
90.8
91.8
70.2
24.7
17.1
9.1
4.6

146.7
168.3
254.3
270.6
291.7
309.5
314.4
330.0
340.7
401.3
409.4
425.7
437.5
417.4
425.3
432.6
439.1
434.3
439.6
445.1
444.6
427.1
426.1
428.1
429.8
430.8
431.5
426.5
403.2
327.9
176.2
160.9
167.1
171.9
180.5
190.0
198.7
204.7
203.7
152.1
53.0
36.5
18.5
9.7

9.4
10.2
19.5
20.3
19.9
8.6
6.9
5.6
2.4
-3.2
-4.2
-6.1
-8.4
-10.8
-11.8
-11.6
-12.2
-12.6
-12.7
-12.1
-11.8
-10.9
-9.8
-8.3
-7.1
-5.4
-4.1
-2.8
-1.2
3.5
22.2
27.4
26.6
25.6
24.5
24.2
23.7
23.2
21.3
13.2
2.0
0.4
-1.9
-2.4

128.3
146.8
223.8
237.8
255.2
264.0
267.1
279.4
286.5
334.0
340.2
352.8
361.4
343.3
349.4
355.6
360.7
356.4
360.8
365.7
365.4
351.3
351.1
353.6
355.7
357.4
358.8
355.4
336.8
276.4
160.1
150.2
154.9
158.4
165.0
172.8
179.7
184.4
182.5
135.0
46.2
31.5
15.2
7.6

-131.8
-150.3
-227.5
-241.5
-259.1
-267.9
-271.1
-283.3
-290.5
-338.0
-344.3
-356.8
-365.4
-347.2
-353.3
-359.5
-364.6
-360.3
-364.7
-369.5
-369.3
-355.3
-355.1
-357.5
-359.6
-361.4
-362.8
-359.4
-340.8
-280.4
-164.1
-154.2
-158.9
-162.4
-169.1
-176.8
-183.8
-188.4
-186.6
-139.0
-50.4
-35.7
-19.4
-11.8

-12.8
-13.7
-23.2
-24.1
-23.7
-12.6
-10.9
-9.6
-6.4
-0.8
0.2
2.2
4.4
6.9
7.8
7.7
8.3
8.7
8.8
8.2
7.9
6.9
5.8
4.4
3.1
1.5
0.1
-1.2
-2.9
-7.5
-26.2
-31.4
-30.6
-29.6
-28.6
-28.2
-27.8
-27.2
-25.3
-17.1
-6.3
-4.5
-2.3
-1.8

-74.2
-85.4
-125.0
-133.3
-145.3
-164.6
-168.7
-178.4
-187.0
-225.0
-230.3
-240.9
-249.3
-240.1
-245.4
-249.2
-253.3
-250.9
-254.0
-256.5
-255.9
-245.6
-244.2
-244.0
-243.9
-243.1
-242.4
-238.5
-224.4
-179.0
-79.9
-67.1
-71.2
-74.7
-80.4
-85.8
-91.0
-94.8
-95.8
-74.1
-29.0
-21.3
-13.3
-8.8

-150.2
-171.8
-258.0
-274.3
-295.5
-313.5
-318.4
-334.0
-344.7
-405.2
-413.4
-429.7
-441.5
-421.3
-429.3
-436.6
-443.1
-438.2
-443.6
-448.9
-448.5
-431.0
-430.1
-432.0
-433.8
-434.7
-435.5
-430.5
-407.2
-331.9
-180.2
-164.9
-171.1
-175.9
-184.6
-194.1
-202.8
-208.7
-207.7
-156.0
-57.2
-40.7
-22.7
-13.9

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
146.72
-152.12
168.29
-173.80
254.30
-260.06
270.56
-276.43
291.72
-297.70
309.55
-315.74
314.40
-320.71
330.00
-336.21
340.69
-347.00
401.26
-407.45
409.40
-415.68
425.71
-431.91
437.47
-443.76
417.36
-423.47
425.32
-431.51
432.64
-438.76
439.13
-445.32
434.28
-440.39
439.63
-445.81
445.06
-451.10
444.56
-450.66
427.07
-433.24
426.12
-432.36
428.11
-434.26
429.79
-436.01
430.82
-436.95
431.55
-437.74
426.54
-432.79
403.21
-409.53
327.89
-334.11
176.16
-182.44
160.94
-167.13
167.07
-173.32
171.91
-178.22
180.54
-186.91
190.05
-196.32
198.72
-205.05
204.71
-210.95
203.68
-209.97
152.13
-158.25
69.96
-76.55
47.00
-53.49
19.91
-26.44
9.72
-16.30

0.64
0.73
0.84
0.90
0.97
0.84
0.85
0.89
0.92
0.88
0.90
0.94
0.96
0.92
0.93
0.95
0.96
0.95
0.97
0.98
0.98
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.95
0.95
0.94
0.89
0.72
0.40
0.36
0.38
0.39
0.40
0.43
0.44
0.46
0.45
0.34
0.17
0.12
0.06
0.04

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

WindMTY
-17.19
-19.96
-28.19
-30.56
-33.97
-43.15
-44.63
-48.16
-51.65
-64.54
-66.64
-70.70
-73.99
-72.34
-74.30
-75.58
-77.09
-76.64
-77.58
-78.36
-78.05
-74.52
-73.66
-73.20
-72.69
-71.96
-71.20
-69.46
-64.55
-49.58
-14.24
-8.81
-10.12
-11.32
-13.13
-14.80
-16.32
-17.54
-18.26
-13.95
4.95
3.30
1.59
-0.17

WindMTY
17.19
19.96
28.19
30.56
33.97
43.15
44.63
48.16
51.65
64.54
66.64
70.70
73.99
72.34
74.30
75.58
77.09
76.64
77.58
78.36
78.05
74.52
73.66
73.20
72.69
71.96
71.20
69.46
64.55
49.58
14.24
8.81
10.12
11.32
13.13
14.80
16.32
17.54
18.26
13.95
-4.95
-3.30
-1.59
0.17

Page 3 of 3

4:49 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

BRB Strength Check along Line 4 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

A23

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

Live

-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

Dead
-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv4

WindMTX
-1.24
-1.59
-1.88
-2.18
-2.53
-4.18
-4.33
-4.65
-4.89
-5.91
-5.82
-6.07
-6.26
-5.95
-6.08
-6.17
-6.30
-6.25
-6.38
-6.52
-6.56
-6.24
-6.25
-6.30
-6.36
-6.37
-6.38
-6.30
-5.86
-4.26
-0.32
0.15
-0.15
-0.39
-0.70
-1.01
-1.31
-1.56
-1.75
-1.38
0.71
0.47
0.23
-0.02

WindMTX
1.24
1.59
1.88
2.18
2.53
4.18
4.33
4.65
4.89
5.91
5.82
6.07
6.26
5.95
6.08
6.17
6.30
6.25
6.38
6.52
6.56
6.24
6.25
6.30
6.36
6.37
6.38
6.30
5.86
4.26
0.32
-0.15
0.15
0.39
0.70
1.01
1.31
1.56
1.75
1.38
-0.71
-0.47
-0.23
0.02

WindFY
10.92
19.08
26.23
34.59
41.46
59.07
67.19
76.71
84.68
100.37
107.97
116.09
121.87
117.07
121.84
128.17
132.91
134.54
140.27
146.15
150.43
147.20
150.88
155.26
160.95
163.20
166.02
164.39
149.91
100.33
-10.02
-27.67
-16.04
-4.65
10.32
26.09
41.28
53.29
61.10
44.32
-40.21
-27.61
-12.45
3.86

WindFY
-10.92
-19.08
-26.23
-34.59
-41.46
-59.07
-67.19
-76.71
-84.68
-100.37
-107.97
-116.09
-121.87
-117.07
-121.84
-128.17
-132.91
-134.54
-140.27
-146.15
-150.43
-147.20
-150.88
-155.26
-160.95
-163.20
-166.02
-164.39
-149.91
-100.33
10.02
27.67
16.04
4.65
-10.32
-26.09
-41.28
-53.29
-61.10
-44.32
40.21
27.61
12.45
-3.86

WindMTY
-3.56
-4.56
-5.40
-6.25
-7.26
-12.00
-12.44
-13.36
-14.04
-16.96
-16.72
-17.42
-17.99
-17.11
-17.48
-17.73
-18.12
-17.99
-18.37
-18.78
-18.89
-17.97
-18.00
-18.15
-18.34
-18.36
-18.41
-18.18
-16.93
-12.33
-0.95
0.40
-0.48
-1.17
-2.06
-2.97
-3.83
-4.55
-5.12
-4.04
2.05
1.37
0.66
-0.06

WindMTY
3.56
4.56
5.40
6.25
7.26
12.00
12.44
13.36
14.04
16.96
16.72
17.42
17.99
17.11
17.48
17.73
18.12
17.99
18.37
18.78
18.89
17.97
18.00
18.15
18.34
18.36
18.41
18.18
16.93
12.33
0.95
-0.40
0.48
1.17
2.06
2.97
3.83
4.55
5.12
4.04
-2.05
-1.37
-0.66
0.06

SpecX
20.78
26.65
31.57
35.88
41.86
67.72
70.60
75.26
79.13
95.03
93.43
96.45
99.18
93.71
95.42
96.62
98.47
97.70
99.78
101.75
102.35
97.73
98.08
98.83
100.03
99.86
100.34
99.38
93.04
68.41
7.70
4.27
5.69
9.42
14.43
19.54
24.38
28.30
31.52
25.80
13.27
9.29
5.51
2.68

SpecX
20.78
26.64
31.57
35.88
41.87
67.72
70.60
75.27
79.13
95.03
93.43
96.44
99.18
93.71
95.42
96.62
98.47
97.70
99.78
101.75
102.35
97.73
98.08
98.83
100.03
99.86
100.34
99.38
93.04
68.41
7.70
4.27
5.69
9.42
14.43
19.54
24.38
28.30
31.52
25.80
13.27
9.29
5.51
2.68

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1

1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 4

Figure 6-9 Case 1

SpecY
342.61
398.18
484.89
516.58
547.19
684.22
679.57
696.87
693.94
772.83
769.91
782.12
785.51
724.02
728.09
743.17
753.00
745.44
760.10
778.92
785.14
758.98
768.20
783.27
798.40
808.92
819.36
818.75
782.14
649.59
426.29
427.38
433.74
444.05
462.17
485.26
508.00
524.43
522.39
389.75
132.43
94.49
51.42
34.48

-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-2.9
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3

-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.4
-3.6
-3.8
-3.7
-3.8
-3.8
-3.9
-3.8
-3.8
-3.7
-3.8
-3.8
-3.9
-3.9
-4.0
-3.9
-4.0
-4.1
-4.1
-4.1
-4.1
-4.0
-4.0
-4.1
-4.2
-4.1
-4.1
-4.2
-4.3
-4.2
-4.2
-4.3
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2

14.4
27.4
38.8
52.1
63.0
91.0
103.9
119.2
131.9
157.1
169.2
182.2
191.4
183.8
191.5
201.5
209.1
211.7
220.8
230.3
237.1
231.9
237.7
244.8
253.9
257.6
262.0
259.4
236.2
156.9
-19.7
-47.9
-29.4
-11.1
12.8
38.0
62.3
81.6
94.0
67.4
-68.2
-47.9
-23.6
2.4

-20.6
-33.7
-45.2
-58.6
-69.7
-98.1
-111.1
-126.3
-139.1
-164.1
-176.3
-189.3
-198.5
-190.8
-198.4
-208.6
-216.2
-218.9
-228.1
-237.4
-244.3
-239.2
-245.1
-252.0
-261.2
-264.7
-269.2
-266.7
-243.5
-164.1
12.4
40.6
22.0
3.8
-20.2
-45.5
-69.8
-89.0
-101.5
-74.4
60.5
40.5
16.2
-9.9

10.0
19.7
28.3
38.2
46.5
67.4
77.1
88.6
98.2
117.1
126.2
136.0
142.9
137.2
142.9
150.5
156.2
158.1
165.0
172.1
177.2
173.3
177.7
183.0
189.8
192.6
196.0
194.0
176.6
117.2
-15.3
-36.5
-22.6
-8.8
9.1
28.0
46.2
60.7
70.0
50.1
-51.7
-36.5
-18.3
1.2

-16.2
-26.0
-34.7
-44.8
-53.0
-74.3
-84.1
-95.5
-105.0
-123.8
-132.9
-142.6
-149.6
-143.8
-149.5
-157.1
-162.8
-164.8
-171.7
-178.7
-183.9
-180.0
-184.4
-189.6
-196.5
-199.1
-202.5
-200.6
-183.2
-123.6
8.8
29.9
15.9
2.3
-15.7
-34.6
-52.9
-67.2
-76.6
-56.2
44.8
29.8
11.6
-8.0

10.0
19.7
28.2
38.2
46.4
67.3
76.9
88.4
97.8
116.7
125.8
135.6
142.5
136.8
142.5
150.1
155.7
157.6
164.4
171.5
176.6
172.7
177.0
182.4
189.1
192.0
195.3
193.3
175.9
116.4
-16.0
-37.3
-23.4
-9.6
8.3
27.2
45.3
59.8
69.2
49.2
-52.5
-37.2
-19.0
0.5

-16.2
-26.1
-34.7
-44.8
-53.1
-74.5
-84.3
-95.7
-105.4
-124.1
-133.4
-143.0
-150.0
-144.1
-149.9
-157.6
-163.3
-165.3
-172.2
-179.2
-184.4
-180.6
-185.1
-190.3
-197.1
-199.7
-203.1
-201.2
-183.9
-124.4
8.0
29.1
15.1
1.5
-16.5
-35.4
-53.7
-68.1
-77.5
-57.2
44.0
29.1
10.9
-8.7

-4.6
-5.1
-5.5
-5.9
-6.3
-8.5
-8.7
-9.0
-9.3
-10.4
-10.3
-10.6
-10.9
-10.4
-10.6
-10.7
-10.9
-10.9
-11.0
-11.1
-11.2
-10.8
-10.9
-10.9
-11.0
-10.9
-10.9
-10.8
-10.3
-8.4
-3.6
-3.1
-3.5
-3.7
-4.1
-4.5
-4.9
-5.2
-5.4
-4.7
-2.6
-2.8
-3.1
-3.4

-1.6
-1.2
-0.9
-0.6
-0.3
1.6
1.7
2.2
2.4
3.7
3.6
4.0
4.2
3.9
4.0
4.1
4.2
4.1
4.3
4.5
4.5
4.1
4.1
4.3
4.3
4.4
4.4
4.3
3.7
1.9
-2.9
-3.5
-3.1
-2.8
-2.4
-2.1
-1.8
-1.4
-1.2
-1.4
-4.3
-3.9
-3.6
-3.4

-4.6
-5.1
-5.5
-5.9
-6.4
-8.6
-8.9
-9.3
-9.6
-10.8
-10.8
-11.0
-11.3
-10.8
-11.0
-11.1
-11.4
-11.4
-11.6
-11.7
-11.8
-11.5
-11.5
-11.5
-11.6
-11.5
-11.6
-11.5
-11.1
-9.1
-4.4
-3.9
-4.3
-4.5
-4.9
-5.4
-5.8
-6.0
-6.3
-5.7
-3.4
-3.5
-3.8
-4.1

-1.6
-1.3
-1.0
-0.7
-0.4
1.4
1.5
1.9
2.1
3.4
3.2
3.6
3.7
3.5
3.6
3.6
3.8
3.6
3.7
4.0
4.0
3.5
3.5
3.6
3.6
3.8
3.7
3.6
3.0
1.2
-3.6
-4.2
-3.9
-3.6
-3.3
-2.9
-2.6
-2.2
-2.1
-2.3
-5.1
-4.6
-4.3
-4.1

5.7
14.3
21.8
30.7
37.7
52.9
62.1
72.5
81.2
96.6
105.9
114.9
121.1
116.5
121.7
129.0
134.2
136.3
142.6
149.3
154.2
151.4
155.8
160.9
167.5
170.3
173.5
171.8
155.9
102.0
-16.8
-36.4
-23.5
-10.6
6.2
24.0
41.2
54.8
63.4
44.8
-49.6
-35.2
-17.8
0.8

14.3
25.2
34.7
45.7
55.1
81.7
91.9
104.5
114.9
137.3
146.1
156.7
164.3
157.6
163.7
171.5
177.7
179.4
186.7
194.3
199.6
194.6
199.0
204.5
211.5
214.3
217.7
215.5
196.5
131.6
-14.5
-37.4
-22.4
-7.8
11.2
31.1
50.4
65.7
75.7
54.5
-54.5
-38.5
-19.4
1.0

-20.5
-31.5
-41.2
-52.3
-61.8
-88.8
-99.2
-111.6
-122.1
-144.3
-153.2
-163.7
-171.4
-164.5
-170.7
-178.6
-184.8
-186.6
-194.0
-201.5
-206.8
-201.9
-206.3
-211.7
-218.8
-221.4
-224.9
-222.7
-203.9
-138.8
7.2
30.0
15.0
0.5
-18.5
-38.6
-57.9
-73.1
-83.2
-61.6
46.9
31.1
12.0
-8.4

-11.9
-20.6
-28.2
-37.3
-44.4
-60.0
-69.3
-79.6
-88.4
-103.6
-113.1
-121.9
-128.2
-123.4
-128.7
-136.1
-141.3
-143.5
-149.9
-156.4
-161.5
-158.7
-163.2
-168.2
-174.8
-177.4
-180.7
-179.1
-163.2
-109.2
9.5
29.0
16.1
3.3
-13.6
-31.5
-48.7
-62.2
-70.9
-51.9
42.0
27.8
10.4
-8.3

2.4
8.5
13.9
20.3
25.2
35.2
41.9
49.4
55.8
66.4
73.5
80.0
84.5
81.4
85.2
90.6
94.3
95.9
100.6
105.5
109.2
107.4
110.6
114.4
119.3
121.4
123.9
122.7
111.1
72.1
-13.5
-27.8
-18.4
-9.0
3.4
16.5
29.1
39.1
45.4
31.9
-37.3
-26.6
-13.9
-0.1

4.6
11.4
17.3
24.2
29.8
42.7
49.7
57.8
64.6
77.1
84.0
91.0
95.8
92.1
96.1
101.7
105.7
107.2
112.1
117.2
121.0
118.6
121.9
125.8
130.8
132.9
135.4
134.0
121.7
79.8
-12.9
-28.1
-18.2
-8.3
4.7
18.3
31.5
41.9
48.6
34.4
-38.5
-27.5
-14.3
0.0

2.4
8.5
13.8
20.3
25.2
35.0
41.7
49.2
55.5
66.2
73.2
79.7
84.2
81.1
84.9
90.2
94.0
95.6
100.2
105.1
108.8
106.9
110.1
114.0
118.8
121.0
123.4
122.2
110.6
71.6
-14.1
-28.4
-19.0
-9.5
2.8
15.9
28.5
38.5
44.8
31.1
-37.8
-27.1
-14.4
-0.6

4.6
11.3
17.2
24.2
29.7
42.6
49.5
57.6
64.3
76.8
83.7
90.7
95.5
91.8
95.8
101.3
105.3
106.8
111.7
116.8
120.6
118.1
121.4
125.3
130.3
132.4
134.9
133.5
121.1
79.3
-13.5
-28.7
-18.8
-8.8
4.1
17.7
30.8
41.3
48.0
33.6
-39.1
-28.0
-14.8
-0.6

8.8
16.7
23.6
31.6
38.3
56.8
64.3
73.5
81.1
97.0
103.7
111.4
116.9
112.2
116.7
122.5
127.0
128.4
133.7
139.3
143.2
139.7
143.1
147.1
152.4
154.5
157.0
155.4
141.6
94.3
-11.8
-28.5
-17.6
-6.8
7.1
21.9
36.0
47.3
54.7
39.1
-41.0
-29.1
-15.0
0.0

-17.3
-25.9
-33.4
-42.0
-49.5
-71.3
-79.2
-88.8
-96.8
-114.4
-121.0
-129.1
-135.0
-129.5
-134.3
-140.4
-145.1
-146.4
-152.1
-157.8
-161.8
-157.8
-161.2
-165.3
-170.6
-172.6
-175.2
-173.5
-159.0
-108.7
4.5
22.0
10.5
-0.6
-15.2
-30.5
-45.2
-56.9
-64.6
-48.0
35.2
23.1
8.6
-7.0

-10.8
-17.7
-23.7
-30.7
-36.4
-49.7
-56.7
-64.7
-71.5
-83.9
-90.9
-97.7
-102.6
-98.7
-102.8
-108.4
-112.5
-114.0
-119.0
-124.0
-127.8
-125.5
-128.8
-132.6
-137.6
-139.5
-142.1
-140.7
-128.5
-86.5
6.2
21.3
11.3
1.5
-11.4
-25.2
-38.3
-48.7
-55.4
-40.7
31.5
20.6
7.4
-6.9

-8.6
-14.8
-20.3
-26.9
-31.9
-42.2
-49.1
-56.5
-63.0
-73.5
-80.7
-87.1
-91.7
-88.3
-92.2
-97.6
-101.5
-103.2
-107.9
-112.6
-116.4
-114.7
-118.0
-121.7
-126.7
-128.5
-131.1
-129.9
-118.4
-79.3
6.2
20.5
11.0
1.7
-10.8
-24.0
-36.6
-46.5
-52.9
-38.9
29.6
19.3
6.4
-7.4

-10.8
-17.7
-23.7
-30.8
-36.5
-49.8
-56.9
-64.9
-71.8
-84.1
-91.2
-98.0
-102.9
-99.0
-103.1
-108.7
-112.8
-114.4
-119.4
-124.4
-128.2
-125.9
-129.3
-133.0
-138.1
-140.0
-142.5
-141.3
-129.0
-87.0
5.7
20.7
10.7
0.9
-12.1
-25.8
-39.0
-49.3
-56.1
-41.4
30.9
20.1
6.9
-7.4

-8.6
-14.8
-20.3
-26.8
-31.8
-42.1
-48.9
-56.3
-62.7
-73.2
-80.4
-86.8
-91.3
-88.0
-91.9
-97.3
-101.1
-102.8
-107.5
-112.2
-116.0
-114.2
-117.5
-121.2
-126.1
-128.1
-130.6
-129.4
-117.9
-78.8
6.8
21.0
11.6
2.2
-10.2
-23.3
-36.0
-45.9
-52.3
-38.2
30.2
19.8
7.0
-6.9

11.1
19.6
27.0
35.5
42.9
64.3
72.1
81.9
89.9
107.6
114.1
122.4
128.2
122.9
127.6
133.6
138.3
139.6
145.2
151.1
155.0
151.0
154.3
158.5
163.8
166.0
168.5
166.8
152.2
102.0
-11.2
-28.8
-17.3
-6.1
8.4
23.7
38.4
50.1
57.8
41.6
-42.2
-29.9
-15.5
0.1

-15.0
-23.0
-30.0
-38.1
-45.0
-63.9
-71.5
-80.6
-88.2
-104.0
-110.8
-118.5
-124.1
-119.1
-123.7
-129.6
-134.1
-135.6
-141.0
-146.5
-150.5
-147.1
-150.4
-154.4
-159.7
-161.6
-164.2
-162.7
-148.9
-101.5
4.5
21.2
10.1
-0.5
-14.5
-29.3
-43.5
-54.7
-62.1
-46.2
33.3
21.7
7.6
-7.5

11.1
19.6
27.0
35.5
42.8
64.2
71.9
81.7
89.6
107.4
113.8
122.1
127.9
122.6
127.3
133.3
138.0
139.2
144.8
150.7
154.6
150.5
153.8
158.0
163.3
165.5
168.0
166.2
151.6
101.5
-11.8
-29.4
-17.9
-6.7
7.8
23.1
37.7
49.5
57.2
40.9
-42.8
-30.5
-16.0
-0.5

-15.0
-23.0
-30.0
-38.1
-44.9
-63.7
-71.3
-80.4
-88.0
-103.8
-110.5
-118.2
-123.7
-118.8
-123.4
-129.2
-133.8
-135.2
-140.6
-146.1
-150.0
-146.6
-149.9
-153.9
-159.2
-161.1
-163.7
-162.2
-148.4
-101.0
5.1
21.8
10.7
0.1
-13.9
-28.7
-42.9
-54.1
-61.5
-45.5
33.9
22.3
8.2
-7.0

8.8
16.7
23.6
31.5
38.2
56.6
64.1
73.3
80.8
96.7
103.3
111.1
116.6
111.9
116.4
122.2
126.6
128.0
133.3
138.9
142.8
139.3
142.5
146.7
151.9
154.0
156.5
154.9
141.1
93.8
-12.4
-29.1
-18.2
-7.4
6.5
21.2
35.4
46.7
54.0
38.4
-41.5
-29.6
-15.6
-0.5

-17.3
-25.9
-33.4
-42.0
-49.5
-71.4
-79.3
-89.0
-97.1
-114.7
-121.3
-129.4
-135.3
-129.8
-134.6
-140.7
-145.5
-146.8
-152.5
-158.2
-162.3
-158.3
-161.7
-165.7
-171.2
-173.1
-175.7
-174.0
-159.5
-109.2
4.0
21.4
9.9
-1.2
-15.8
-31.1
-45.9
-57.5
-65.3
-48.7
34.6
22.6
8.0
-7.5

-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.5
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3

-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.5
-2.6
-2.8
-2.9
-2.8
-2.9
-2.9
-3.0
-2.9
-3.0
-2.8
-2.9
-2.9
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.0
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3

-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.4
-3.5
-3.4
-3.4
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.2
-2.9
-3.3
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3

-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.4
-3.6
-3.8
-3.7
-3.8
-3.8
-3.9
-3.8
-3.8
-3.7
-3.8
-3.8
-3.9
-3.9
-4.0
-3.9
-4.0
-4.1
-4.1
-4.1
-4.1
-4.0
-4.0
-4.1
-4.2
-4.1
-4.1
-4.2
-4.3
-4.2
-4.2
-4.3
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2

-20.6
-33.7
-45.2
-58.6
-69.7
-98.1
-111.1
-126.3
-139.1
-164.1
-176.3
-189.3
-198.5
-190.8
-198.4
-208.6
-216.2
-218.9
-228.1
-237.4
-244.3
-239.2
-245.1
-252.0
-261.2
-264.7
-269.2
-266.7
-243.5
-164.1
12.4
40.6
22.0
3.8
-20.2
-45.5
-69.8
-89.0
-101.5
-74.4
60.5
40.5
16.2
-9.9

14.4
27.4
38.8
52.1
63.0
91.0
103.9
119.2
131.9
157.1
169.2
182.2
191.4
183.8
191.5
201.5
209.1
211.7
220.8
230.3
237.1
231.9
237.7
244.8
253.9
257.6
262.0
259.4
236.2
156.9
-19.7
-47.9
-29.4
-11.1
12.8
38.0
62.3
81.6
94.0
67.4
-68.2
-47.9
-23.6
2.4

-16.2
-26.0
-34.7
-44.8
-53.0
-74.3
-84.1
-95.5
-105.0
-123.8
-132.9
-142.6
-149.6
-143.8
-149.5
-157.1
-162.8
-164.8
-171.7
-178.7
-183.9
-180.0
-184.4
-189.6
-196.5
-199.1
-202.5
-200.6
-183.2
-123.6
8.8
29.9
15.9
2.3
-15.7
-34.6
-52.9
-67.2
-76.6
-56.2
44.8
29.8
11.6
-8.0

10.0
19.7
28.3
38.2
46.5
67.4
77.1
88.6
98.2
117.1
126.2
136.0
142.9
137.2
142.9
150.5
156.2
158.1
165.0
172.1
177.2
173.3
177.7
183.0
189.8
192.6
196.0
194.0
176.6
117.2
-15.3
-36.5
-22.6
-8.8
9.1
28.0
46.2
60.7
70.0
50.1
-51.7
-36.5
-18.3
1.2

-16.2
-26.1
-34.7
-44.8
-53.1
-74.5
-84.3
-95.7
-105.4
-124.1
-133.4
-143.0
-150.0
-144.1
-149.9
-157.6
-163.3
-165.3
-172.2
-179.2
-184.4
-180.6
-185.1
-190.3
-197.1
-199.7
-203.1
-201.2
-183.9
-124.4
8.0
29.1
15.1
1.5
-16.5
-35.4
-53.7
-68.1
-77.5
-57.2
44.0
29.1
10.9
-8.7

10.0
19.7
28.2
38.2
46.4
67.3
76.9
88.4
97.8
116.7
125.8
135.6
142.5
136.8
142.5
150.1
155.7
157.6
164.4
171.5
176.6
172.7
177.0
182.4
189.1
192.0
195.3
193.3
175.9
116.4
-16.0
-37.3
-23.4
-9.6
8.3
27.2
45.3
59.8
69.2
49.2
-52.5
-37.2
-19.0
0.5

-1.6
-1.2
-0.9
-0.6
-0.3
1.6
1.7
2.2
2.4
3.7
3.6
4.0
4.2
3.9
4.0
4.1
4.2
4.1
4.3
4.5
4.5
4.1
4.1
4.3
4.3
4.4
4.4
4.3
3.7
1.9
-2.9
-3.5
-3.1
-2.8
-2.4
-2.1
-1.8
-1.4
-1.2
-1.4
-4.3
-3.9
-3.6
-3.4

-4.6
-5.1
-5.5
-5.9
-6.3
-8.5
-8.7
-9.0
-9.3
-10.4
-10.3
-10.6
-10.9
-10.4
-10.6
-10.7
-10.9
-10.9
-11.0
-11.1
-11.2
-10.8
-10.9
-10.9
-11.0
-10.9
-10.9
-10.8
-10.3
-8.4
-3.6
-3.1
-3.5
-3.7
-4.1
-4.5
-4.9
-5.2
-5.4
-4.7
-2.6
-2.8
-3.1
-3.4

-1.6
-1.3
-1.0
-0.7
-0.4
1.4
1.5
1.9
2.1
3.4
3.2
3.6
3.7
3.5
3.6
3.6
3.8
3.6
3.7
4.0
4.0
3.5
3.5
3.6
3.6
3.8
3.7
3.6
3.0
1.2
-3.6
-4.2
-3.9
-3.6
-3.3
-2.9
-2.6
-2.2
-2.1
-2.3
-5.1
-4.6
-4.3
-4.1

-4.6
-5.1
-5.5
-5.9
-6.4
-8.6
-8.9
-9.3
-9.6
-10.8
-10.8
-11.0
-11.3
-10.8
-11.0
-11.1
-11.4
-11.4
-11.6
-11.7
-11.8
-11.5
-11.5
-11.5
-11.6
-11.5
-11.6
-11.5
-11.1
-9.1
-4.4
-3.9
-4.3
-4.5
-4.9
-5.4
-5.8
-6.0
-6.3
-5.7
-3.4
-3.5
-3.8
-4.1

-11.9
-20.6
-28.2
-37.3
-44.4
-60.0
-69.3
-79.6
-88.4
-103.6
-113.1
-121.9
-128.2
-123.4
-128.7
-136.1
-141.3
-143.5
-149.9
-156.4
-161.5
-158.7
-163.2
-168.2
-174.8
-177.4
-180.7
-179.1
-163.2
-109.2
9.5
29.0
16.1
3.3
-13.6
-31.5
-48.7
-62.2
-70.9
-51.9
42.0
27.8
10.4
-8.3

-20.5
-31.5
-41.2
-52.3
-61.8
-88.8
-99.2
-111.6
-122.1
-144.3
-153.2
-163.7
-171.4
-164.5
-170.7
-178.6
-184.8
-186.6
-194.0
-201.5
-206.8
-201.9
-206.3
-211.7
-218.8
-221.4
-224.9
-222.7
-203.9
-138.8
7.2
30.0
15.0
0.5
-18.5
-38.6
-57.9
-73.1
-83.2
-61.6
46.9
31.1
12.0
-8.4

14.3
25.2
34.7
45.7
55.1
81.7
91.9
104.5
114.9
137.3
146.1
156.7
164.3
157.6
163.7
171.5
177.7
179.4
186.7
194.3
199.6
194.6
199.0
204.5
211.5
214.3
217.7
215.5
196.5
131.6
-14.5
-37.4
-22.4
-7.8
11.2
31.1
50.4
65.7
75.7
54.5
-54.5
-38.5
-19.4
1.0

5.7
14.3
21.8
30.7
37.7
52.9
62.1
72.5
81.2
96.6
105.9
114.9
121.1
116.5
121.7
129.0
134.2
136.3
142.6
149.3
154.2
151.4
155.8
160.9
167.5
170.3
173.5
171.8
155.9
102.0
-16.8
-36.4
-23.5
-10.6
6.2
24.0
41.2
54.8
63.4
44.8
-49.6
-35.2
-17.8
0.8

-8.6
-14.8
-20.3
-26.8
-31.8
-42.1
-48.9
-56.3
-62.7
-73.2
-80.4
-86.8
-91.3
-88.0
-91.9
-97.3
-101.1
-102.8
-107.5
-112.2
-116.0
-114.2
-117.5
-121.2
-126.1
-128.1
-130.6
-129.4
-117.9
-78.8
6.8
21.0
11.6
2.2
-10.2
-23.3
-36.0
-45.9
-52.3
-38.2
30.2
19.8
7.0
-6.9

-10.8
-17.7
-23.7
-30.7
-36.4
-49.7
-56.7
-64.7
-71.5
-83.9
-90.9
-97.7
-102.6
-98.7
-102.8
-108.4
-112.5
-114.0
-119.0
-124.0
-127.8
-125.5
-128.8
-132.6
-137.6
-139.5
-142.1
-140.7
-128.5
-86.5
6.2
21.3
11.3
1.5
-11.4
-25.2
-38.3
-48.7
-55.4
-40.7
31.5
20.6
7.4
-6.9

-8.6
-14.8
-20.3
-26.9
-31.9
-42.2
-49.1
-56.5
-63.0
-73.5
-80.7
-87.1
-91.7
-88.3
-92.2
-97.6
-101.5
-103.2
-107.9
-112.6
-116.4
-114.7
-118.0
-121.7
-126.7
-128.5
-131.1
-129.9
-118.4
-79.3
6.2
20.5
11.0
1.7
-10.8
-24.0
-36.6
-46.5
-52.9
-38.9
29.6
19.3
6.4
-7.4

-10.8
-17.7
-23.7
-30.8
-36.5
-49.8
-56.9
-64.9
-71.8
-84.1
-91.2
-98.0
-102.9
-99.0
-103.1
-108.7
-112.8
-114.4
-119.4
-124.4
-128.2
-125.9
-129.3
-133.0
-138.1
-140.0
-142.5
-141.3
-129.0
-87.0
5.7
20.7
10.7
0.9
-12.1
-25.8
-39.0
-49.3
-56.1
-41.4
30.9
20.1
6.9
-7.4

-15.0
-23.0
-30.0
-38.1
-44.9
-63.7
-71.3
-80.4
-88.0
-103.8
-110.5
-118.2
-123.7
-118.8
-123.4
-129.2
-133.8
-135.2
-140.6
-146.1
-150.0
-146.6
-149.9
-153.9
-159.2
-161.1
-163.7
-162.2
-148.4
-101.0
5.1
21.8
10.7
0.1
-13.9
-28.7
-42.9
-54.1
-61.5
-45.5
33.9
22.3
8.2
-7.0

11.1
19.6
27.0
35.5
42.9
64.3
72.1
81.9
89.9
107.6
114.1
122.4
128.2
122.9
127.6
133.6
138.3
139.6
145.2
151.1
155.0
151.0
154.3
158.5
163.8
166.0
168.5
166.8
152.2
102.0
-11.2
-28.8
-17.3
-6.1
8.4
23.7
38.4
50.1
57.8
41.6
-42.2
-29.9
-15.5
0.1

4.6
11.4
17.3
24.2
29.8
42.7
49.7
57.8
64.6
77.1
84.0
91.0
95.8
92.1
96.1
101.7
105.7
107.2
112.1
117.2
121.0
118.6
121.9
125.8
130.8
132.9
135.4
134.0
121.7
79.8
-12.9
-28.1
-18.2
-8.3
4.7
18.3
31.5
41.9
48.6
34.4
-38.5
-27.5
-14.3
0.0

2.4
8.5
13.8
20.3
25.2
35.0
41.7
49.2
55.5
66.2
73.2
79.7
84.2
81.1
84.9
90.2
94.0
95.6
100.2
105.1
108.8
106.9
110.1
114.0
118.8
121.0
123.4
122.2
110.6
71.6
-14.1
-28.4
-19.0
-9.5
2.8
15.9
28.5
38.5
44.8
31.1
-37.8
-27.1
-14.4
-0.6

4.6
11.3
17.2
24.2
29.7
42.6
49.5
57.6
64.3
76.8
83.7
90.7
95.5
91.8
95.8
101.3
105.3
106.8
111.7
116.8
120.6
118.1
121.4
125.3
130.3
132.4
134.9
133.5
121.1
79.3
-13.5
-28.7
-18.8
-8.8
4.1
17.7
30.8
41.3
48.0
33.6
-39.1
-28.0
-14.8
-0.6

2.4
8.5
13.9
20.3
25.2
35.2
41.9
49.4
55.8
66.4
73.5
80.0
84.5
81.4
85.2
90.6
94.3
95.9
100.6
105.5
109.2
107.4
110.6
114.4
119.3
121.4
123.9
122.7
111.1
72.1
-13.5
-27.8
-18.4
-9.0
3.4
16.5
29.1
39.1
45.4
31.9
-37.3
-26.6
-13.9
-0.1

-17.3
-25.9
-33.4
-42.0
-49.5
-71.3
-79.2
-88.8
-96.8
-114.4
-121.0
-129.1
-135.0
-129.5
-134.3
-140.4
-145.1
-146.4
-152.1
-157.8
-161.8
-157.8
-161.2
-165.3
-170.6
-172.6
-175.2
-173.5
-159.0
-108.7
4.5
22.0
10.5
-0.6
-15.2
-30.5
-45.2
-56.9
-64.6
-48.0
35.2
23.1
8.6
-7.0

8.8
16.7
23.6
31.5
38.2
56.6
64.1
73.3
80.8
96.7
103.3
111.1
116.6
111.9
116.4
122.2
126.6
128.0
133.3
138.9
142.8
139.3
142.5
146.7
151.9
154.0
156.5
154.9
141.1
93.8
-12.4
-29.1
-18.2
-7.4
6.5
21.2
35.4
46.7
54.0
38.4
-41.5
-29.6
-15.6
-0.5

-17.3
-25.9
-33.4
-42.0
-49.5
-71.4
-79.3
-89.0
-97.1
-114.7
-121.3
-129.4
-135.3
-129.8
-134.6
-140.7
-145.5
-146.8
-152.5
-158.2
-162.3
-158.3
-161.7
-165.7
-171.2
-173.1
-175.7
-174.0
-159.5
-109.2
4.0
21.4
9.9
-1.2
-15.8
-31.1
-45.9
-57.5
-65.3
-48.7
34.6
22.6
8.0
-7.5

8.8
16.7
23.6
31.6
38.3
56.8
64.3
73.5
81.1
97.0
103.7
111.4
116.9
112.2
116.7
122.5
127.0
128.4
133.7
139.3
143.2
139.7
143.1
147.1
152.4
154.5
157.0
155.4
141.6
94.3
-11.8
-28.5
-17.6
-6.8
7.1
21.9
36.0
47.3
54.7
39.1
-41.0
-29.1
-15.0
0.0

-15.0
-23.0
-30.0
-38.1
-45.0
-63.9
-71.5
-80.6
-88.2
-104.0
-110.8
-118.5
-124.1
-119.1
-123.7
-129.6
-134.1
-135.6
-141.0
-146.5
-150.5
-147.1
-150.4
-154.4
-159.7
-161.6
-164.2
-162.7
-148.9
-101.5
4.5
21.2
10.1
-0.5
-14.5
-29.3
-43.5
-54.7
-62.1
-46.2
33.3
21.7
7.6
-7.5

11.1
19.6
27.0
35.5
42.8
64.2
71.9
81.7
89.6
107.4
113.8
122.1
127.9
122.6
127.3
133.3
138.0
139.2
144.8
150.7
154.6
150.5
153.8
158.0
163.3
165.5
168.0
166.2
151.6
101.5
-11.8
-29.4
-17.9
-6.7
7.8
23.1
37.7
49.5
57.2
40.9
-42.8
-30.5
-16.0
-0.5

-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.6
-2.6
-2.5
-2.5
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-2.4
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3

-2.3
-2.4
-2.4
-2.5
-2.6
-2.8
-2.9
-2.8
-2.9
-2.9
-3.0
-2.9
-3.0
-2.8
-2.9
-2.9
-3.0
-3.0
-3.1
-3.0
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.1
-3.1
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.3
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.3
-3.4
-3.2
-3.2
-3.3

SpecY
342.61
398.18
484.89
516.58
547.19
684.22
679.57
696.87
693.94
772.83
769.91
782.12
785.51
724.02
728.09
743.17
753.00
745.44
760.10
778.92
785.14
758.98
768.20
783.27
798.40
808.92
819.36
818.75
782.14
649.59
426.29
427.38
433.74
444.05
462.17
485.26
508.00
524.43
522.39
389.75
132.43
94.49
51.42
34.48

Page 1 of 3

4:53 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

BRB Strength Check along Line 4 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

A24

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv4

Dead

Live

-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

Dead
-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

WindMTX
-1.24
-1.59
-1.88
-2.18
-2.53
-4.18
-4.33
-4.65
-4.89
-5.91
-5.82
-6.07
-6.26
-5.95
-6.08
-6.17
-6.30
-6.25
-6.38
-6.52
-6.56
-6.24
-6.25
-6.30
-6.36
-6.37
-6.38
-6.30
-5.86
-4.26
-0.32
0.15
-0.15
-0.39
-0.70
-1.01
-1.31
-1.56
-1.75
-1.38
0.71
0.47
0.23
-0.02

WindMTX
1.24
1.59
1.88
2.18
2.53
4.18
4.33
4.65
4.89
5.91
5.82
6.07
6.26
5.95
6.08
6.17
6.30
6.25
6.38
6.52
6.56
6.24
6.25
6.30
6.36
6.37
6.38
6.30
5.86
4.26
0.32
-0.15
0.15
0.39
0.70
1.01
1.31
1.56
1.75
1.38
-0.71
-0.47
-0.23
0.02

WindFY
10.92
19.08
26.23
34.59
41.46
59.07
67.19
76.71
84.68
100.37
107.97
116.09
121.87
117.07
121.84
128.17
132.91
134.54
140.27
146.15
150.43
147.20
150.88
155.26
160.95
163.20
166.02
164.39
149.91
100.33
-10.02
-27.67
-16.04
-4.65
10.32
26.09
41.28
53.29
61.10
44.32
-40.21
-27.61
-12.45
3.86

WindFY
-10.92
-19.08
-26.23
-34.59
-41.46
-59.07
-67.19
-76.71
-84.68
-100.37
-107.97
-116.09
-121.87
-117.07
-121.84
-128.17
-132.91
-134.54
-140.27
-146.15
-150.43
-147.20
-150.88
-155.26
-160.95
-163.20
-166.02
-164.39
-149.91
-100.33
10.02
27.67
16.04
4.65
-10.32
-26.09
-41.28
-53.29
-61.10
-44.32
40.21
27.61
12.45
-3.86

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

0.9

0.9

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

-1.2
-1.2

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

Figure 6-9 Case 4

WindMTY
-3.56
-4.56
-5.40
-6.25
-7.26
-12.00
-12.44
-13.36
-14.04
-16.96
-16.72
-17.42
-17.99
-17.11
-17.48
-17.73
-18.12
-17.99
-18.37
-18.78
-18.89
-17.97
-18.00
-18.15
-18.34
-18.36
-18.41
-18.18
-16.93
-12.33
-0.95
0.40
-0.48
-1.17
-2.06
-2.97
-3.83
-4.55
-5.12
-4.04
2.05
1.37
0.66
-0.06

15.1
28.2
39.6
52.9
63.8
91.9
104.8
120.1
132.8
157.9
170.1
183.1
192.3
184.7
192.3
202.4
210.0
212.6
221.7
231.2
238.0
232.8
238.6
245.7
254.8
258.5
262.9
260.3
237.1
157.8
-18.8
-47.0
-28.4
-10.2
13.7
39.0
63.2
82.5
95.0
68.3
-67.2
-46.9
-22.7
3.4

-19.8
-32.9
-44.4
-57.8
-68.8
-97.2
-110.2
-125.4
-138.2
-163.2
-175.4
-188.4
-197.7
-189.9
-197.6
-207.7
-215.3
-218.0
-227.2
-236.5
-243.4
-238.3
-244.2
-251.1
-260.3
-263.8
-268.3
-265.7
-242.6
-163.2
13.3
41.5
22.9
4.7
-19.3
-44.5
-68.9
-88.0
-100.6
-73.6
61.5
41.4
17.1
-9.0

10.8
20.5
29.1
39.1
47.3
68.3
78.0
89.5
99.1
118.0
127.1
136.9
143.8
138.1
143.8
151.4
157.1
159.0
165.9
173.0
178.1
174.2
178.6
183.9
190.7
193.5
196.9
194.9
177.5
118.1
-14.4
-35.6
-21.6
-7.9
10.0
28.9
47.1
61.6
70.9
51.0
-50.7
-35.5
-17.4
2.2

-15.4
-25.3
-33.9
-43.9
-52.2
-73.5
-83.2
-94.6
-104.1
-122.9
-132.0
-141.7
-148.7
-142.9
-148.6
-156.2
-161.9
-163.9
-170.8
-177.8
-182.9
-179.1
-183.5
-188.7
-195.5
-198.2
-201.6
-199.6
-182.3
-122.7
9.7
30.8
16.9
3.2
-14.7
-33.7
-51.9
-66.3
-75.7
-55.3
45.8
30.7
12.5
-7.1

10.8
20.5
29.0
39.0
47.2
68.1
77.8
89.3
98.7
117.6
126.7
136.5
143.4
137.7
143.4
150.9
156.6
158.5
165.3
172.4
177.5
173.6
177.9
183.3
190.0
192.9
196.2
194.2
176.8
117.3
-15.1
-36.3
-22.4
-8.7
9.2
28.1
46.3
60.8
70.1
50.1
-51.5
-36.2
-18.1
1.5

-15.4
-25.3
-33.9
-44.0
-52.3
-73.6
-83.4
-94.8
-104.5
-123.3
-132.5
-142.1
-149.1
-143.3
-149.0
-156.7
-162.4
-164.4
-171.3
-178.3
-183.5
-179.7
-184.2
-189.4
-196.2
-198.8
-202.2
-200.3
-183.0
-123.5
8.9
30.1
16.1
2.5
-15.5
-34.5
-52.8
-67.1
-76.5
-56.3
45.0
30.0
11.8
-7.8

-3.8
-4.3
-4.7
-5.0
-5.5
-7.6
-7.8
-8.1
-8.4
-9.6
-9.5
-9.7
-10.0
-9.6
-9.7
-9.8
-10.0
-10.0
-10.1
-10.2
-10.3
-9.9
-9.9
-10.0
-10.0
-10.0
-10.0
-9.9
-9.4
-7.5
-2.7
-2.2
-2.6
-2.8
-3.2
-3.6
-4.0
-4.2
-4.5
-3.8
-1.6
-1.8
-2.2
-2.5

-0.8
-0.4
-0.1
0.2
0.6
2.4
2.6
3.1
3.3
4.6
4.5
4.8
5.1
4.7
4.9
5.0
5.1
5.1
5.2
5.4
5.4
5.1
5.1
5.2
5.2
5.3
5.3
5.2
4.7
2.8
-2.0
-2.5
-2.2
-1.9
-1.5
-1.2
-0.8
-0.5
-0.3
-0.5
-3.3
-3.0
-2.7
-2.4

-3.8
-4.3
-4.7
-5.1
-5.6
-7.8
-8.0
-8.4
-8.7
-9.9
-9.9
-10.1
-10.4
-9.9
-10.1
-10.3
-10.5
-10.5
-10.7
-10.8
-10.9
-10.5
-10.6
-10.6
-10.7
-10.6
-10.7
-10.6
-10.2
-8.2
-3.5
-3.0
-3.4
-3.6
-4.0
-4.4
-4.8
-5.1
-5.3
-4.8
-2.4
-2.5
-2.9
-3.2

-0.8
-0.5
-0.2
0.1
0.5
2.3
2.4
2.8
3.0
4.3
4.1
4.4
4.6
4.4
4.5
4.5
4.6
4.5
4.6
4.9
4.9
4.4
4.4
4.5
4.5
4.7
4.6
4.5
3.9
2.1
-2.7
-3.3
-3.0
-2.7
-2.3
-2.0
-1.7
-1.3
-1.1
-1.5
-4.1
-3.7
-3.4
-3.1

6.5
15.1
22.6
31.5
38.5
53.8
63.0
73.4
82.1
97.4
106.8
115.8
122.0
117.4
122.6
129.9
135.1
137.2
143.5
150.2
155.1
152.3
156.7
161.8
168.4
171.1
174.4
172.7
156.8
102.9
-15.9
-35.5
-22.6
-9.7
7.1
25.0
42.1
55.7
64.4
45.7
-48.7
-34.2
-16.9
1.8

15.0
26.0
35.5
46.5
56.0
82.6
92.8
105.4
115.8
138.2
147.0
157.6
165.2
158.4
164.6
172.4
178.6
180.3
187.6
195.2
200.5
195.5
199.9
205.4
212.4
215.2
218.6
216.4
197.5
132.5
-13.6
-36.4
-21.5
-6.9
12.1
32.1
51.3
66.6
76.7
55.4
-53.6
-37.5
-18.5
1.9

-19.7
-30.7
-40.4
-51.5
-61.0
-87.9
-98.3
-110.7
-121.2
-143.4
-152.3
-162.9
-170.5
-163.6
-169.8
-177.7
-183.9
-185.7
-193.1
-200.6
-205.9
-201.0
-205.4
-210.8
-217.9
-220.5
-224.0
-221.8
-203.0
-137.9
8.2
30.9
15.9
1.4
-17.6
-37.7
-56.9
-72.2
-82.3
-60.7
47.8
32.0
12.9
-7.5

-11.1
-19.8
-27.4
-36.5
-43.5
-59.1
-68.4
-78.7
-87.5
-102.7
-112.2
-121.0
-127.3
-122.5
-127.9
-135.2
-140.4
-142.6
-149.0
-155.5
-160.6
-157.8
-162.2
-167.2
-173.9
-176.5
-179.8
-178.2
-162.3
-108.3
10.4
30.0
17.0
4.3
-12.7
-30.5
-47.8
-61.3
-70.0
-51.0
42.9
28.7
11.4
-7.4

3.2
9.3
14.7
21.1
26.1
36.0
42.8
50.3
56.7
67.3
74.4
80.9
85.4
82.2
86.1
91.4
95.2
96.8
101.5
106.4
110.1
108.3
111.6
115.4
120.2
122.3
124.8
123.6
112.0
73.0
-12.6
-26.9
-17.5
-8.0
4.3
17.4
30.1
40.0
46.4
32.7
-36.3
-25.7
-12.9
0.9

5.4
12.1
18.1
25.0
30.6
43.6
50.6
58.7
65.5
77.9
84.9
91.8
96.7
92.9
97.0
102.5
106.6
108.1
113.0
118.1
121.9
119.5
122.8
126.7
131.7
133.8
136.3
134.9
122.6
80.7
-12.0
-27.2
-17.2
-7.3
5.6
19.3
32.4
42.8
49.5
35.2
-37.6
-26.6
-13.3
0.9

3.2
9.3
14.6
21.1
26.0
35.9
42.6
50.1
56.4
67.0
74.1
80.6
85.1
81.9
85.8
91.1
94.9
96.5
101.1
106.0
109.7
107.8
111.1
114.9
119.7
121.8
124.3
123.1
111.5
72.5
-13.2
-27.5
-18.1
-8.6
3.7
16.8
29.4
39.4
45.7
32.0
-36.9
-26.2
-13.5
0.3

5.4
12.1
18.0
25.0
30.5
43.5
50.4
58.5
65.2
77.7
84.6
91.6
96.4
92.7
96.7
102.2
106.2
107.7
112.6
117.7
121.5
119.1
122.3
126.2
131.2
133.3
135.8
134.4
122.0
80.2
-12.6
-27.7
-17.8
-7.9
5.0
18.6
31.8
42.2
48.9
34.5
-38.2
-27.1
-13.9
0.4

9.6
17.5
24.4
32.4
39.1
57.7
65.2
74.4
82.0
97.9
104.6
112.3
117.8
113.0
117.6
123.4
127.9
129.3
134.6
140.2
144.1
140.7
144.0
148.1
153.3
155.4
157.9
156.3
142.5
95.2
-10.9
-27.6
-16.6
-5.9
8.1
22.8
37.0
48.2
55.6
40.0
-40.0
-28.2
-14.1
1.0

-16.5
-25.1
-32.6
-41.2
-48.6
-70.4
-78.3
-87.9
-95.9
-113.5
-120.1
-128.2
-134.1
-128.7
-133.4
-139.5
-144.2
-145.5
-151.2
-156.9
-160.9
-156.9
-160.3
-164.4
-169.7
-171.7
-174.3
-172.6
-158.0
-107.8
5.4
23.0
11.4
0.3
-14.2
-29.6
-44.3
-56.0
-63.7
-47.1
36.1
24.0
9.5
-6.1

-10.1
-16.9
-22.9
-29.9
-35.6
-48.8
-55.8
-63.8
-70.6
-83.0
-90.0
-96.8
-101.7
-97.9
-102.0
-107.5
-111.6
-113.1
-118.1
-123.1
-126.9
-124.5
-127.8
-131.7
-136.7
-138.6
-141.2
-139.8
-127.5
-85.6
7.1
22.2
12.3
2.4
-10.5
-24.2
-37.4
-47.8
-54.5
-39.8
32.4
21.6
8.3
-6.0

-7.8
-14.0
-19.5
-26.0
-31.1
-41.4
-48.2
-55.6
-62.1
-72.6
-79.8
-86.2
-90.8
-87.4
-91.3
-96.7
-100.6
-102.3
-107.0
-111.7
-115.5
-113.8
-117.1
-120.8
-125.7
-127.6
-130.2
-129.0
-117.5
-78.4
7.2
21.4
11.9
2.6
-9.9
-23.0
-35.7
-45.6
-52.0
-38.0
30.6
20.2
7.4
-6.5

-10.1
-16.9
-22.9
-30.0
-35.6
-48.9
-56.0
-64.0
-70.9
-83.2
-90.3
-97.1
-102.0
-98.1
-102.3
-107.8
-111.9
-113.5
-118.5
-123.5
-127.3
-125.0
-128.3
-132.1
-137.2
-139.1
-141.7
-140.4
-128.1
-86.1
6.6
21.7
11.7
1.9
-11.1
-24.8
-38.1
-48.4
-55.1
-40.5
31.8
21.0
7.8
-6.5

-7.8
-14.0
-19.5
-26.0
-31.0
-41.2
-48.0
-55.4
-61.8
-72.3
-79.5
-85.9
-90.4
-87.1
-91.0
-96.4
-100.2
-101.9
-106.6
-111.3
-115.1
-113.3
-116.6
-120.3
-125.2
-127.2
-129.7
-128.5
-117.0
-77.9
7.7
22.0
12.5
3.2
-9.3
-22.4
-35.0
-45.0
-51.3
-37.3
31.1
20.7
7.9
-5.9

11.8
20.4
27.8
36.3
43.7
65.2
73.0
82.8
90.8
108.5
115.0
123.2
129.1
123.8
128.5
134.5
139.2
140.5
146.1
152.0
155.9
151.9
155.2
159.4
164.7
166.8
169.4
167.7
153.1
102.9
-10.3
-27.9
-16.4
-5.2
9.3
24.6
39.3
51.0
58.7
42.5
-41.3
-29.0
-14.5
1.0

-14.2
-22.2
-29.2
-37.3
-44.2
-63.0
-70.6
-79.7
-87.3
-103.1
-109.9
-117.6
-123.2
-118.2
-122.8
-128.7
-133.2
-134.7
-140.1
-145.6
-149.5
-146.1
-149.5
-153.5
-158.8
-160.7
-163.3
-161.8
-148.0
-100.6
5.4
22.1
11.1
0.5
-13.6
-28.4
-42.6
-53.8
-61.2
-45.3
34.3
22.7
8.6
-6.6

11.8
20.4
27.8
36.3
43.6
65.1
72.8
82.6
90.5
108.2
114.7
122.9
128.8
123.5
128.2
134.2
138.9
140.1
145.7
151.6
155.5
151.4
154.7
158.9
164.2
166.4
168.9
167.2
152.6
102.4
-10.9
-28.5
-17.0
-5.8
8.7
24.0
38.7
50.4
58.1
41.8
-41.9
-29.5
-15.1
0.5

-14.2
-22.2
-29.2
-37.3
-44.1
-62.8
-70.4
-79.5
-87.1
-102.9
-109.6
-117.3
-122.9
-118.0
-122.5
-128.4
-132.9
-134.3
-139.7
-145.2
-149.1
-145.7
-149.0
-153.0
-158.3
-160.2
-162.8
-161.2
-147.5
-100.1
6.0
22.7
11.7
1.0
-13.0
-27.7
-41.9
-53.2
-60.6
-44.6
34.8
23.2
9.1
-6.0

-19.8
-32.9
-44.4
-57.8
-68.8
-97.2
-110.2
-125.4
-138.2
-163.2
-175.4
-188.4
-197.7
-189.9
-197.6
-207.7
-215.3
-218.0
-227.2
-236.5
-243.4
-238.3
-244.2
-251.1
-260.3
-263.8
-268.3
-265.7
-242.6
-163.2
13.3
41.5
22.9
4.7
-19.3
-44.5
-68.9
-88.0
-100.6
-73.6
61.5
41.4
17.1
-9.0

15.1
28.2
39.6
52.9
63.8
91.9
104.8
120.1
132.8
157.9
170.1
183.1
192.3
184.7
192.3
202.4
210.0
212.6
221.7
231.2
238.0
232.8
238.6
245.7
254.8
258.5
262.9
260.3
237.1
157.8
-18.8
-47.0
-28.4
-10.2
13.7
39.0
63.2
82.5
95.0
68.3
-67.2
-46.9
-22.7
3.4

-15.4
-25.3
-33.9
-43.9
-52.2
-73.5
-83.2
-94.6
-104.1
-122.9
-132.0
-141.7
-148.7
-142.9
-148.6
-156.2
-161.9
-163.9
-170.8
-177.8
-182.9
-179.1
-183.5
-188.7
-195.5
-198.2
-201.6
-199.6
-182.3
-122.7
9.7
30.8
16.9
3.2
-14.7
-33.7
-51.9
-66.3
-75.7
-55.3
45.8
30.7
12.5
-7.1

10.8
20.5
29.1
39.1
47.3
68.3
78.0
89.5
99.1
118.0
127.1
136.9
143.8
138.1
143.8
151.4
157.1
159.0
165.9
173.0
178.1
174.2
178.6
183.9
190.7
193.5
196.9
194.9
177.5
118.1
-14.4
-35.6
-21.6
-7.9
10.0
28.9
47.1
61.6
70.9
51.0
-50.7
-35.5
-17.4
2.2

-15.4
-25.3
-33.9
-44.0
-52.3
-73.6
-83.4
-94.8
-104.5
-123.3
-132.5
-142.1
-149.1
-143.3
-149.0
-156.7
-162.4
-164.4
-171.3
-178.3
-183.5
-179.7
-184.2
-189.4
-196.2
-198.8
-202.2
-200.3
-183.0
-123.5
8.9
30.1
16.1
2.5
-15.5
-34.5
-52.8
-67.1
-76.5
-56.3
45.0
30.0
11.8
-7.8

10.8
20.5
29.0
39.0
47.2
68.1
77.8
89.3
98.7
117.6
126.7
136.5
143.4
137.7
143.4
150.9
156.6
158.5
165.3
172.4
177.5
173.6
177.9
183.3
190.0
192.9
196.2
194.2
176.8
117.3
-15.1
-36.3
-22.4
-8.7
9.2
28.1
46.3
60.8
70.1
50.1
-51.5
-36.2
-18.1
1.5

-0.8
-0.4
-0.1
0.2
0.6
2.4
2.6
3.1
3.3
4.6
4.5
4.8
5.1
4.7
4.9
5.0
5.1
5.1
5.2
5.4
5.4
5.1
5.1
5.2
5.2
5.3
5.3
5.2
4.7
2.8
-2.0
-2.5
-2.2
-1.9
-1.5
-1.2
-0.8
-0.5
-0.3
-0.5
-3.3
-3.0
-2.7
-2.4

-3.8
-4.3
-4.7
-5.0
-5.5
-7.6
-7.8
-8.1
-8.4
-9.6
-9.5
-9.7
-10.0
-9.6
-9.7
-9.8
-10.0
-10.0
-10.1
-10.2
-10.3
-9.9
-9.9
-10.0
-10.0
-10.0
-10.0
-9.9
-9.4
-7.5
-2.7
-2.2
-2.6
-2.8
-3.2
-3.6
-4.0
-4.2
-4.5
-3.8
-1.6
-1.8
-2.2
-2.5

-0.8
-0.5
-0.2
0.1
0.5
2.3
2.4
2.8
3.0
4.3
4.1
4.4
4.6
4.4
4.5
4.5
4.6
4.5
4.6
4.9
4.9
4.4
4.4
4.5
4.5
4.7
4.6
4.5
3.9
2.1
-2.7
-3.3
-3.0
-2.7
-2.3
-2.0
-1.7
-1.3
-1.1
-1.5
-4.1
-3.7
-3.4
-3.1

-3.8
-4.3
-4.7
-5.1
-5.6
-7.8
-8.0
-8.4
-8.7
-9.9
-9.9
-10.1
-10.4
-9.9
-10.1
-10.3
-10.5
-10.5
-10.7
-10.8
-10.9
-10.5
-10.6
-10.6
-10.7
-10.6
-10.7
-10.6
-10.2
-8.2
-3.5
-3.0
-3.4
-3.6
-4.0
-4.4
-4.8
-5.1
-5.3
-4.8
-2.4
-2.5
-2.9
-3.2

-11.1
-19.8
-27.4
-36.5
-43.5
-59.1
-68.4
-78.7
-87.5
-102.7
-112.2
-121.0
-127.3
-122.5
-127.9
-135.2
-140.4
-142.6
-149.0
-155.5
-160.6
-157.8
-162.2
-167.2
-173.9
-176.5
-179.8
-178.2
-162.3
-108.3
10.4
30.0
17.0
4.3
-12.7
-30.5
-47.8
-61.3
-70.0
-51.0
42.9
28.7
11.4
-7.4

-19.7
-30.7
-40.4
-51.5
-61.0
-87.9
-98.3
-110.7
-121.2
-143.4
-152.3
-162.9
-170.5
-163.6
-169.8
-177.7
-183.9
-185.7
-193.1
-200.6
-205.9
-201.0
-205.4
-210.8
-217.9
-220.5
-224.0
-221.8
-203.0
-137.9
8.2
30.9
15.9
1.4
-17.6
-37.7
-56.9
-72.2
-82.3
-60.7
47.8
32.0
12.9
-7.5

15.0
26.0
35.5
46.5
56.0
82.6
92.8
105.4
115.8
138.2
147.0
157.6
165.2
158.4
164.6
172.4
178.6
180.3
187.6
195.2
200.5
195.5
199.9
205.4
212.4
215.2
218.6
216.4
197.5
132.5
-13.6
-36.4
-21.5
-6.9
12.1
32.1
51.3
66.6
76.7
55.4
-53.6
-37.5
-18.5
1.9

6.5
15.1
22.6
31.5
38.5
53.8
63.0
73.4
82.1
97.4
106.8
115.8
122.0
117.4
122.6
129.9
135.1
137.2
143.5
150.2
155.1
152.3
156.7
161.8
168.4
171.1
174.4
172.7
156.8
102.9
-15.9
-35.5
-22.6
-9.7
7.1
25.0
42.1
55.7
64.4
45.7
-48.7
-34.2
-16.9
1.8

-7.8
-14.0
-19.5
-26.0
-31.0
-41.2
-48.0
-55.4
-61.8
-72.3
-79.5
-85.9
-90.4
-87.1
-91.0
-96.4
-100.2
-101.9
-106.6
-111.3
-115.1
-113.3
-116.6
-120.3
-125.2
-127.2
-129.7
-128.5
-117.0
-77.9
7.7
22.0
12.5
3.2
-9.3
-22.4
-35.0
-45.0
-51.3
-37.3
31.1
20.7
7.9
-5.9

-10.1
-16.9
-22.9
-29.9
-35.6
-48.8
-55.8
-63.8
-70.6
-83.0
-90.0
-96.8
-101.7
-97.9
-102.0
-107.5
-111.6
-113.1
-118.1
-123.1
-126.9
-124.5
-127.8
-131.7
-136.7
-138.6
-141.2
-139.8
-127.5
-85.6
7.1
22.2
12.3
2.4
-10.5
-24.2
-37.4
-47.8
-54.5
-39.8
32.4
21.6
8.3
-6.0

-7.8
-14.0
-19.5
-26.0
-31.1
-41.4
-48.2
-55.6
-62.1
-72.6
-79.8
-86.2
-90.8
-87.4
-91.3
-96.7
-100.6
-102.3
-107.0
-111.7
-115.5
-113.8
-117.1
-120.8
-125.7
-127.6
-130.2
-129.0
-117.5
-78.4
7.2
21.4
11.9
2.6
-9.9
-23.0
-35.7
-45.6
-52.0
-38.0
30.6
20.2
7.4
-6.5

-10.1
-16.9
-22.9
-30.0
-35.6
-48.9
-56.0
-64.0
-70.9
-83.2
-90.3
-97.1
-102.0
-98.1
-102.3
-107.8
-111.9
-113.5
-118.5
-123.5
-127.3
-125.0
-128.3
-132.1
-137.2
-139.1
-141.7
-140.4
-128.1
-86.1
6.6
21.7
11.7
1.9
-11.1
-24.8
-38.1
-48.4
-55.1
-40.5
31.8
21.0
7.8
-6.5

-14.2
-22.2
-29.2
-37.3
-44.1
-62.8
-70.4
-79.5
-87.1
-102.9
-109.6
-117.3
-122.9
-118.0
-122.5
-128.4
-132.9
-134.3
-139.7
-145.2
-149.1
-145.7
-149.0
-153.0
-158.3
-160.2
-162.8
-161.2
-147.5
-100.1
6.0
22.7
11.7
1.0
-13.0
-27.7
-41.9
-53.2
-60.6
-44.6
34.8
23.2
9.1
-6.0

11.8
20.4
27.8
36.3
43.7
65.2
73.0
82.8
90.8
108.5
115.0
123.2
129.1
123.8
128.5
134.5
139.2
140.5
146.1
152.0
155.9
151.9
155.2
159.4
164.7
166.8
169.4
167.7
153.1
102.9
-10.3
-27.9
-16.4
-5.2
9.3
24.6
39.3
51.0
58.7
42.5
-41.3
-29.0
-14.5
1.0

5.4
12.1
18.1
25.0
30.6
43.6
50.6
58.7
65.5
77.9
84.9
91.8
96.7
92.9
97.0
102.5
106.6
108.1
113.0
118.1
121.9
119.5
122.8
126.7
131.7
133.8
136.3
134.9
122.6
80.7
-12.0
-27.2
-17.2
-7.3
5.6
19.3
32.4
42.8
49.5
35.2
-37.6
-26.6
-13.3
0.9

3.2
9.3
14.6
21.1
26.0
35.9
42.6
50.1
56.4
67.0
74.1
80.6
85.1
81.9
85.8
91.1
94.9
96.5
101.1
106.0
109.7
107.8
111.1
114.9
119.7
121.8
124.3
123.1
111.5
72.5
-13.2
-27.5
-18.1
-8.6
3.7
16.8
29.4
39.4
45.7
32.0
-36.9
-26.2
-13.5
0.3

5.4
12.1
18.0
25.0
30.5
43.5
50.4
58.5
65.2
77.7
84.6
91.6
96.4
92.7
96.7
102.2
106.2
107.7
112.6
117.7
121.5
119.1
122.3
126.2
131.2
133.3
135.8
134.4
122.0
80.2
-12.6
-27.7
-17.8
-7.9
5.0
18.6
31.8
42.2
48.9
34.5
-38.2
-27.1
-13.9
0.4

3.2
9.3
14.7
21.1
26.1
36.0
42.8
50.3
56.7
67.3
74.4
80.9
85.4
82.2
86.1
91.4
95.2
96.8
101.5
106.4
110.1
108.3
111.6
115.4
120.2
122.3
124.8
123.6
112.0
73.0
-12.6
-26.9
-17.5
-8.0
4.3
17.4
30.1
40.0
46.4
32.7
-36.3
-25.7
-12.9
0.9

-16.5
-25.1
-32.6
-41.2
-48.6
-70.4
-78.3
-87.9
-95.9
-113.5
-120.1
-128.2
-134.1
-128.7
-133.4
-139.5
-144.2
-145.5
-151.2
-156.9
-160.9
-156.9
-160.3
-164.4
-169.7
-171.7
-174.3
-172.6
-158.0
-107.8
5.4
23.0
11.4
0.3
-14.2
-29.6
-44.3
-56.0
-63.7
-47.1
36.1
24.0
9.5
-6.1

9.6
17.5
24.4
32.3
39.1
57.5
65.0
74.2
81.7
97.6
104.2
112.0
117.5
112.8
117.3
123.1
127.5
128.9
134.2
139.8
143.7
140.2
143.5
147.6
152.8
154.9
157.4
155.8
142.0
94.7
-11.5
-28.2
-17.2
-6.5
7.4
22.2
36.3
47.6
55.0
39.3
-40.6
-28.7
-14.6
0.4

-16.5
-25.1
-32.6
-41.2
-48.7
-70.5
-78.4
-88.1
-96.2
-113.8
-120.4
-128.5
-134.5
-129.0
-133.7
-139.8
-144.6
-145.9
-151.6
-157.3
-161.4
-157.4
-160.8
-164.8
-170.2
-172.2
-174.8
-173.1
-158.6
-108.3
4.9
22.4
10.8
-0.3
-14.9
-30.2
-45.0
-56.6
-64.3
-47.8
35.5
23.5
9.0
-6.6

9.6
17.5
24.4
32.4
39.1
57.7
65.2
74.4
82.0
97.9
104.6
112.3
117.8
113.0
117.6
123.4
127.9
129.3
134.6
140.2
144.1
140.7
144.0
148.1
153.3
155.4
157.9
156.3
142.5
95.2
-10.9
-27.6
-16.6
-5.9
8.1
22.8
37.0
48.2
55.6
40.0
-40.0
-28.2
-14.1
1.0

WindMTY
3.56
4.56
5.40
6.25
7.26
12.00
12.44
13.36
14.04
16.96
16.72
17.42
17.99
17.11
17.48
17.73
18.12
17.99
18.37
18.78
18.89
17.97
18.00
18.15
18.34
18.36
18.41
18.18
16.93
12.33
0.95
-0.40
0.48
1.17
2.06
2.97
3.83
4.55
5.12
4.04
-2.05
-1.37
-0.66
0.06

Page 2 of 3

4:53 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: Elv4

BRB Strength Check along Line 4 for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15
D15

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16
D16

A7
A7
A7
A7
A7
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

239
239
239
239
239
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462

A25

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead

Live

-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

Dead
-2.58
-2.63
-2.68
-2.73
-2.78
-2.95
-3.01
-2.95
-3.00
-2.94
-2.98
-2.93
-2.97
-2.88
-2.91
-2.95
-2.98
-3.01
-3.04
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.08
-3.02
-3.05
-2.96
-2.99
-3.02
-3.05
-3.00
-3.03
-3.06
-3.09
-3.04
-3.07
-3.10
-3.13
-3.08
-3.11
-2.94
-3.19
-3.07
-3.09
-3.12

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Live

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

0.00
0.01
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
0.09
0.11
0.15
0.14
0.18
0.16
0.18
0.15
0.17
0.18
0.20
0.21
0.23
0.22
0.24
0.26
0.28
0.27
0.29
0.26
0.27
0.29
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.32
0.34
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.35
0.40
0.32
0.29
0.29
0.29

WindMTX
-1.24
-1.59
-1.88
-2.18
-2.53
-4.18
-4.33
-4.65
-4.89
-5.91
-5.82
-6.07
-6.26
-5.95
-6.08
-6.17
-6.30
-6.25
-6.38
-6.52
-6.56
-6.24
-6.25
-6.30
-6.36
-6.37
-6.38
-6.30
-5.86
-4.26
-0.32
0.15
-0.15
-0.39
-0.70
-1.01
-1.31
-1.56
-1.75
-1.38
0.71
0.47
0.23
-0.02

WindMTX
1.24
1.59
1.88
2.18
2.53
4.18
4.33
4.65
4.89
5.91
5.82
6.07
6.26
5.95
6.08
6.17
6.30
6.25
6.38
6.52
6.56
6.24
6.25
6.30
6.36
6.37
6.38
6.30
5.86
4.26
0.32
-0.15
0.15
0.39
0.70
1.01
1.31
1.56
1.75
1.38
-0.71
-0.47
-0.23
0.02

WindFY
10.92
19.08
26.23
34.59
41.46
59.07
67.19
76.71
84.68
100.37
107.97
116.09
121.87
117.07
121.84
128.17
132.91
134.54
140.27
146.15
150.43
147.20
150.88
155.26
160.95
163.20
166.02
164.39
149.91
100.33
-10.02
-27.67
-16.04
-4.65
10.32
26.09
41.28
53.29
61.10
44.32
-40.21
-27.61
-12.45
3.86

WindFY
-10.92
-19.08
-26.23
-34.59
-41.46
-59.07
-67.19
-76.71
-84.68
-100.37
-107.97
-116.09
-121.87
-117.07
-121.84
-128.17
-132.91
-134.54
-140.27
-146.15
-150.43
-147.20
-150.88
-155.26
-160.95
-163.20
-166.02
-164.39
-149.91
-100.33
10.02
27.67
16.04
4.65
-10.32
-26.09
-41.28
-53.29
-61.10
-44.32
40.21
27.61
12.45
-3.86

0.9

0.9

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

WindMTY
-3.56
-4.56
-5.40
-6.25
-7.26
-12.00
-12.44
-13.36
-14.04
-16.96
-16.72
-17.42
-17.99
-17.11
-17.48
-17.73
-18.12
-17.99
-18.37
-18.78
-18.89
-17.97
-18.00
-18.15
-18.34
-18.36
-18.41
-18.18
-16.93
-12.33
-0.95
0.40
-0.48
-1.17
-2.06
-2.97
-3.83
-4.55
-5.12
-4.04
2.05
1.37
0.66
-0.06

9.6
17.5
24.4
32.3
39.1
57.5
65.0
74.2
81.7
97.6
104.2
112.0
117.5
112.8
117.3
123.1
127.5
128.9
134.2
139.8
143.7
140.2
143.5
147.6
152.8
154.9
157.4
155.8
142.0
94.7
-11.5
-28.2
-17.2
-6.5
7.4
22.2
36.3
47.6
55.0
39.3
-40.6
-28.7
-14.6
0.4

-16.5
-25.1
-32.6
-41.2
-48.7
-70.5
-78.4
-88.1
-96.2
-113.8
-120.4
-128.5
-134.5
-129.0
-133.7
-139.8
-144.6
-145.9
-151.6
-157.3
-161.4
-157.4
-160.8
-164.8
-170.2
-172.2
-174.8
-173.1
-158.6
-108.3
4.9
22.4
10.8
-0.3
-14.9
-30.2
-45.0
-56.6
-64.3
-47.8
35.5
23.5
9.0
-6.6

33.6
40.4
49.6
53.7
58.3
78.5
78.9
82.0
82.8
95.0
94.2
96.3
97.4
90.3
91.1
92.8
94.2
93.3
95.2
97.6
98.3
94.4
95.3
97.0
98.7
99.7
100.8
100.4
95.0
75.5
36.4
35.4
36.3
38.5
41.7
45.3
48.8
51.6
52.4
38.9
11.5
7.0
1.9
-0.5

100.9
118.0
144.4
154.2
163.9
207.1
205.9
211.6
211.0
236.3
235.2
239.2
240.4
221.6
222.9
227.5
230.6
228.2
232.8
238.6
240.5
232.2
235.0
239.6
244.2
247.5
250.6
250.3
238.7
196.7
124.1
124.1
126.1
129.6
135.4
142.8
150.0
155.4
155.0
115.0
36.4
24.8
11.5
6.1

20.6
23.7
29.9
31.3
32.1
36.1
34.7
34.9
33.3
35.5
35.7
35.9
35.3
31.7
31.4
32.4
32.6
32.2
32.8
33.9
34.3
33.3
34.0
35.2
36.1
37.3
38.0
38.2
36.8
32.7
31.6
32.7
32.8
32.6
32.6
33.1
33.6
33.9
32.7
22.8
3.2
1.2
-1.5
-2.2

97.0
113.0
138.5
147.5
156.0
194.4
192.7
197.5
196.2
218.4
217.6
221.1
221.8
204.0
205.0
209.4
212.1
209.9
214.0
219.6
221.3
213.9
216.6
221.1
225.5
228.8
231.8
231.7
221.2
183.9
122.7
123.3
125.0
127.8
132.7
139.1
145.4
150.1
149.1
110.1
33.9
23.1
10.5
5.6

-104.4
-120.6
-146.1
-155.3
-164.0
-202.9
-201.3
-205.9
-204.8
-226.8
-226.2
-229.5
-230.3
-212.2
-213.4
-217.8
-220.6
-218.5
-222.7
-228.1
-229.9
-222.6
-225.4
-229.7
-234.2
-237.2
-240.3
-240.3
-230.0
-192.5
-131.3
-132.0
-133.8
-136.5
-141.5
-148.0
-154.4
-158.9
-158.0
-118.6
-43.0
-31.8
-19.3
-14.5

-28.0
-31.2
-37.5
-39.1
-40.1
-44.5
-43.3
-43.3
-41.9
-43.9
-44.2
-44.3
-43.8
-39.9
-39.8
-40.8
-41.1
-40.7
-41.5
-42.5
-42.9
-42.0
-42.8
-43.8
-44.8
-45.7
-46.5
-46.8
-45.6
-41.3
-40.2
-41.5
-41.6
-41.3
-41.4
-41.9
-42.5
-42.7
-41.5
-31.2
-12.3
-10.0
-7.3
-6.7

-41.0
-47.9
-57.3
-61.6
-66.3
-86.9
-87.5
-90.4
-91.4
-103.4
-102.7
-104.6
-105.9
-98.5
-99.4
-101.2
-102.7
-101.9
-103.9
-106.1
-106.9
-103.1
-104.1
-105.6
-107.4
-108.2
-109.3
-109.0
-103.8
-84.1
-45.1
-44.1
-45.2
-47.2
-50.4
-54.2
-57.8
-60.4
-61.3
-47.3
-20.6
-15.8
-10.8
-8.4

-108.3
-125.6
-152.1
-162.0
-171.8
-215.6
-214.5
-220.1
-219.6
-244.7
-243.7
-247.6
-248.9
-229.8
-231.3
-235.9
-239.1
-236.8
-241.4
-247.2
-249.1
-240.9
-243.8
-248.3
-253.0
-256.0
-259.2
-258.9
-247.4
-205.3
-132.8
-132.8
-134.9
-138.3
-144.2
-151.7
-159.0
-164.2
-163.9
-123.4
-45.5
-33.6
-20.3
-15.0

35.6
42.4
51.7
55.8
60.4
80.7
81.1
84.2
85.1
97.2
96.4
98.5
99.6
92.4
93.3
95.0
96.5
95.5
97.5
99.8
100.6
96.7
97.7
99.3
101.0
101.9
103.0
102.6
97.3
77.8
38.7
37.7
38.7
40.8
44.0
47.6
51.2
53.9
54.7
41.1
13.9
9.3
4.3
1.8

102.9
120.0
146.4
156.3
166.0
209.4
208.2
213.9
213.3
238.5
237.4
241.4
242.7
223.8
225.1
229.7
232.8
230.5
235.1
240.9
242.8
234.5
237.3
241.9
246.5
249.7
252.9
252.6
241.0
199.0
126.4
126.4
128.4
131.9
137.8
145.1
152.4
157.7
157.4
117.2
38.8
27.1
13.8
8.5

22.6
25.7
31.9
33.4
34.2
38.3
37.0
37.1
35.6
37.8
38.0
38.2
37.6
33.8
33.6
34.6
34.9
34.4
35.1
36.2
36.5
35.6
36.3
37.5
38.4
39.5
40.3
40.5
39.2
35.0
33.9
35.0
35.1
34.9
35.0
35.4
35.9
36.2
35.0
25.0
5.6
3.5
0.8
0.2

99.0
115.0
140.5
149.6
158.1
196.7
195.0
199.7
198.5
220.7
219.9
223.3
224.0
206.2
207.2
211.6
214.4
212.2
216.3
221.8
223.6
216.2
218.9
223.4
227.8
231.0
234.1
234.0
223.6
186.2
125.0
125.6
127.3
130.1
135.1
141.5
147.8
152.4
151.5
112.4
36.3
25.4
12.8
8.0

-102.4
-118.6
-144.1
-153.2
-161.9
-200.6
-199.0
-203.7
-202.5
-224.6
-223.9
-227.2
-228.0
-210.1
-211.1
-215.6
-218.4
-216.2
-220.4
-225.8
-227.7
-220.3
-223.0
-227.4
-231.9
-235.0
-238.1
-238.0
-227.7
-190.2
-129.0
-129.7
-131.5
-134.2
-139.2
-145.6
-152.0
-156.5
-155.6
-116.3
-40.6
-29.5
-17.0
-12.2

-26.0
-29.2
-35.5
-37.0
-38.0
-42.3
-41.0
-41.1
-39.6
-41.7
-42.0
-42.1
-41.6
-37.7
-37.6
-38.6
-38.9
-38.5
-39.2
-40.2
-40.6
-39.7
-40.4
-41.5
-42.5
-43.5
-44.3
-44.5
-43.3
-39.0
-37.9
-39.1
-39.3
-39.0
-39.1
-39.6
-40.1
-40.4
-39.2
-28.9
-9.9
-7.6
-5.0
-4.4

-39.0
-45.9
-55.3
-59.5
-64.1
-84.7
-85.2
-88.2
-89.1
-101.2
-100.4
-102.4
-103.6
-96.3
-97.2
-99.0
-100.5
-99.6
-101.6
-103.8
-104.6
-100.8
-101.8
-103.3
-105.1
-105.9
-107.0
-106.7
-101.4
-81.8
-42.8
-41.8
-42.8
-44.9
-48.1
-51.8
-55.4
-58.1
-58.9
-45.1
-18.2
-13.5
-8.4
-6.0

-106.3
-123.6
-150.0
-160.0
-169.7
-213.3
-212.2
-217.8
-217.3
-242.4
-241.4
-245.3
-246.6
-227.6
-229.0
-233.7
-236.8
-234.5
-239.1
-244.9
-246.9
-238.6
-241.4
-246.0
-250.6
-253.7
-256.9
-256.7
-245.1
-203.1
-130.5
-130.5
-132.6
-136.0
-141.9
-149.3
-156.6
-161.8
-161.6
-121.2
-43.1
-31.2
-18.0
-12.7

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
102.87
-108.28
120.03
-125.55
146.44
-152.07
156.30
-162.04
166.00
-171.85
209.37
-215.57
208.21
-214.52
213.87
-220.07
213.32
-219.62
238.49
-244.66
237.44
-243.69
241.41
-247.57
242.66
-248.89
223.78
-229.83
225.14
-231.26
229.75
-235.93
232.85
-239.10
230.49
-236.80
235.05
-241.43
240.91
-247.18
242.81
-249.14
234.52
-240.92
238.63
-245.10
245.69
-252.04
254.77
-261.18
258.45
-264.67
262.94
-269.22
260.31
-266.66
241.01
-247.42
199.02
-205.33
126.41
-132.77
126.39
-132.82
128.41
-134.91
131.88
-138.27
137.76
-144.21
145.14
-151.65
152.38
-158.96
157.71
-164.18
157.38
-163.92
117.22
-123.40
61.46
-68.16
41.41
-47.85
17.13
-23.62
8.49
-15.03

0.45
0.52
0.64
0.68
0.72
0.57
0.57
0.58
0.58
0.53
0.53
0.54
0.54
0.50
0.50
0.51
0.52
0.51
0.52
0.54
0.54
0.52
0.53
0.55
0.57
0.57
0.58
0.58
0.54
0.44
0.29
0.29
0.29
0.30
0.31
0.33
0.34
0.36
0.36
0.27
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

-14.2
-22.2
-29.2
-37.3
-44.2
-63.0
-70.6
-79.7
-87.3
-103.1
-109.9
-117.6
-123.2
-118.2
-122.8
-128.7
-133.2
-134.7
-140.1
-145.6
-149.5
-146.1
-149.5
-153.5
-158.8
-160.7
-163.3
-161.8
-148.0
-100.6
5.4
22.1
11.1
0.5
-13.6
-28.4
-42.6
-53.8
-61.2
-45.3
34.3
22.7
8.6
-6.6

11.8
20.4
27.8
36.3
43.6
65.1
72.8
82.6
90.5
108.2
114.7
122.9
128.8
123.5
128.2
134.2
138.9
140.1
145.7
151.6
155.5
151.4
154.7
158.9
164.2
166.4
168.9
167.2
152.6
102.4
-10.9
-28.5
-17.0
-5.8
8.7
24.0
38.7
50.4
58.1
41.8
-41.9
-29.5
-15.1
0.5

33.6
40.4
49.6
53.7
58.3
78.5
78.9
82.0
82.8
95.0
94.2
96.3
97.4
90.3
91.1
92.8
94.2
93.3
95.2
97.6
98.3
94.4
95.3
97.0
98.7
99.7
100.8
100.4
95.0
75.5
36.4
35.4
36.3
38.5
41.7
45.3
48.8
51.6
52.4
38.9
11.5
7.0
1.9
-0.5

100.9
118.0
144.4
154.2
163.9
207.1
205.9
211.6
211.0
236.3
235.2
239.2
240.4
221.6
222.9
227.5
230.6
228.2
232.8
238.6
240.5
232.2
235.0
239.6
244.2
247.5
250.6
250.3
238.7
196.7
124.1
124.1
126.1
129.6
135.4
142.8
150.0
155.4
155.0
115.0
36.4
24.8
11.5
6.1

20.6
23.7
29.9
31.3
32.1
36.1
34.7
34.9
33.3
35.5
35.7
35.9
35.3
31.7
31.4
32.4
32.6
32.2
32.8
33.9
34.3
33.3
34.0
35.2
36.1
37.3
38.0
38.2
36.8
32.7
31.6
32.7
32.8
32.6
32.6
33.1
33.6
33.9
32.7
22.8
3.2
1.2
-1.5
-2.2

97.0
113.0
138.5
147.5
156.0
194.4
192.7
197.5
196.2
218.4
217.6
221.1
221.8
204.0
205.0
209.4
212.1
209.9
214.0
219.6
221.3
213.9
216.6
221.1
225.5
228.8
231.8
231.7
221.2
183.9
122.7
123.3
125.0
127.8
132.7
139.1
145.4
150.1
149.1
110.1
33.9
23.1
10.5
5.6

-104.4
-120.6
-146.1
-155.3
-164.0
-202.9
-201.3
-205.9
-204.8
-226.8
-226.2
-229.5
-230.3
-212.2
-213.4
-217.8
-220.6
-218.5
-222.7
-228.1
-229.9
-222.6
-225.4
-229.7
-234.2
-237.2
-240.3
-240.3
-230.0
-192.5
-131.3
-132.0
-133.8
-136.5
-141.5
-148.0
-154.4
-158.9
-158.0
-118.6
-43.0
-31.8
-19.3
-14.5

-28.0
-31.2
-37.5
-39.1
-40.1
-44.5
-43.3
-43.3
-41.9
-43.9
-44.2
-44.3
-43.8
-39.9
-39.8
-40.8
-41.1
-40.7
-41.5
-42.5
-42.9
-42.0
-42.8
-43.8
-44.8
-45.7
-46.5
-46.8
-45.6
-41.3
-40.2
-41.5
-41.6
-41.3
-41.4
-41.9
-42.5
-42.7
-41.5
-31.2
-12.3
-10.0
-7.3
-6.7

-41.0
-47.9
-57.3
-61.6
-66.3
-86.9
-87.5
-90.4
-91.4
-103.4
-102.7
-104.6
-105.9
-98.5
-99.4
-101.2
-102.7
-101.9
-103.9
-106.1
-106.9
-103.1
-104.1
-105.6
-107.4
-108.2
-109.3
-109.0
-103.8
-84.1
-45.1
-44.1
-45.2
-47.2
-50.4
-54.2
-57.8
-60.4
-61.3
-47.3
-20.6
-15.8
-10.8
-8.4

-108.3
-125.6
-152.1
-162.0
-171.8
-215.6
-214.5
-220.1
-219.6
-244.7
-243.7
-247.6
-248.9
-229.8
-231.3
-235.9
-239.1
-236.8
-241.4
-247.2
-249.1
-240.9
-243.8
-248.3
-253.0
-256.0
-259.2
-258.9
-247.4
-205.3
-132.8
-132.8
-134.9
-138.3
-144.2
-151.7
-159.0
-164.2
-163.9
-123.4
-45.5
-33.6
-20.3
-15.0

35.6
42.4
51.7
55.8
60.4
80.7
81.1
84.2
85.1
97.2
96.4
98.5
99.6
92.4
93.3
95.0
96.5
95.5
97.5
99.8
100.6
96.7
97.7
99.3
101.0
101.9
103.0
102.6
97.3
77.8
38.7
37.7
38.7
40.8
44.0
47.6
51.2
53.9
54.7
41.1
13.9
9.3
4.3
1.8

102.9
120.0
146.4
156.3
166.0
209.4
208.2
213.9
213.3
238.5
237.4
241.4
242.7
223.8
225.1
229.7
232.8
230.5
235.1
240.9
242.8
234.5
237.3
241.9
246.5
249.7
252.9
252.6
241.0
199.0
126.4
126.4
128.4
131.9
137.8
145.1
152.4
157.7
157.4
117.2
38.8
27.1
13.8
8.5

22.6
25.7
31.9
33.4
34.2
38.3
37.0
37.1
35.6
37.8
38.0
38.2
37.6
33.8
33.6
34.6
34.9
34.4
35.1
36.2
36.5
35.6
36.3
37.5
38.4
39.5
40.3
40.5
39.2
35.0
33.9
35.0
35.1
34.9
35.0
35.4
35.9
36.2
35.0
25.0
5.6
3.5
0.8
0.2

99.0
115.0
140.5
149.6
158.1
196.7
195.0
199.7
198.5
220.7
219.9
223.3
224.0
206.2
207.2
211.6
214.4
212.2
216.3
221.8
223.6
216.2
218.9
223.4
227.8
231.0
234.1
234.0
223.6
186.2
125.0
125.6
127.3
130.1
135.1
141.5
147.8
152.4
151.5
112.4
36.3
25.4
12.8
8.0

-102.4
-118.6
-144.1
-153.2
-161.9
-200.6
-199.0
-203.7
-202.5
-224.6
-223.9
-227.2
-228.0
-210.1
-211.1
-215.6
-218.4
-216.2
-220.4
-225.8
-227.7
-220.3
-223.0
-227.4
-231.9
-235.0
-238.1
-238.0
-227.7
-190.2
-129.0
-129.7
-131.5
-134.2
-139.2
-145.6
-152.0
-156.5
-155.6
-116.3
-40.6
-29.5
-17.0
-12.2

-26.0
-29.2
-35.5
-37.0
-38.0
-42.3
-41.0
-41.1
-39.6
-41.7
-42.0
-42.1
-41.6
-37.7
-37.6
-38.6
-38.9
-38.5
-39.2
-40.2
-40.6
-39.7
-40.4
-41.5
-42.5
-43.5
-44.3
-44.5
-43.3
-39.0
-37.9
-39.1
-39.3
-39.0
-39.1
-39.6
-40.1
-40.4
-39.2
-28.9
-9.9
-7.6
-5.0
-4.4

-39.0
-45.9
-55.3
-59.5
-64.1
-84.7
-85.2
-88.2
-89.1
-101.2
-100.4
-102.4
-103.6
-96.3
-97.2
-99.0
-100.5
-99.6
-101.6
-103.8
-104.6
-100.8
-101.8
-103.3
-105.1
-105.9
-107.0
-106.7
-101.4
-81.8
-42.8
-41.8
-42.8
-44.9
-48.1
-51.8
-55.4
-58.1
-58.9
-45.1
-18.2
-13.5
-8.4
-6.0

-106.3
-123.6
-150.0
-160.0
-169.7
-213.3
-212.2
-217.8
-217.3
-242.4
-241.4
-245.3
-246.6
-227.6
-229.0
-233.7
-236.8
-234.5
-239.1
-244.9
-246.9
-238.6
-241.4
-246.0
-250.6
-253.7
-256.9
-256.7
-245.1
-203.1
-130.5
-130.5
-132.6
-136.0
-141.9
-149.3
-156.6
-161.8
-161.6
-121.2
-43.1
-31.2
-18.0
-12.7

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
102.87
-108.28
120.03
-125.55
146.44
-152.07
156.30
-162.04
166.00
-171.85
209.37
-215.57
208.21
-214.52
213.87
-220.07
213.32
-219.62
238.49
-244.66
237.44
-243.69
241.41
-247.57
242.66
-248.89
223.78
-229.83
225.14
-231.26
229.75
-235.93
232.85
-239.10
230.49
-236.80
235.05
-241.43
240.91
-247.18
242.81
-249.14
234.52
-240.92
238.63
-245.10
245.69
-252.04
254.77
-261.18
258.45
-264.67
262.94
-269.22
260.31
-266.66
241.01
-247.42
199.02
-205.33
126.41
-132.77
126.39
-132.82
128.41
-134.91
131.88
-138.27
137.76
-144.21
145.14
-151.65
152.38
-158.96
157.71
-164.18
157.38
-163.92
117.22
-123.40
61.46
-68.16
41.41
-47.85
17.13
-23.62
8.49
-15.03

0.45
0.52
0.64
0.68
0.72
0.57
0.57
0.58
0.58
0.53
0.53
0.54
0.54
0.50
0.50
0.51
0.52
0.51
0.52
0.54
0.54
0.52
0.53
0.55
0.57
0.57
0.58
0.58
0.54
0.44
0.29
0.29
0.29
0.30
0.31
0.33
0.34
0.36
0.36
0.27
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

WindMTY
3.56
4.56
5.40
6.25
7.26
12.00
12.44
13.36
14.04
16.96
16.72
17.42
17.99
17.11
17.48
17.73
18.12
17.99
18.37
18.78
18.89
17.97
18.00
18.15
18.34
18.36
18.41
18.18
16.93
12.33
0.95
-0.40
0.48
1.17
2.06
2.97
3.83
4.55
5.12
4.04
-2.05
-1.37
-0.66
0.06

Page 3 of 3

4:53 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)


11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

087237.10

A26

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

Live

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

4.11
8.39
12.67
16.14
20.14
23.72
27.57
30.84
34.77
37.56
47.70
50.80
55.11
59.17
61.86
68.28
71.02
74.79
78.81
82.48
86.20
89.97
93.80
97.46
101.25
105.01
108.88
112.79
116.75
120.48
124.41
127.81
131.29
134.96
138.39
140.41
140.67
136.87
125.09
83.92
-8.19
-6.43
-2.17
2.71

WindMTX
9.15
9.50
9.80
11.52
11.93
12.13
15.30
15.59
15.80
15.75
21.10
21.20
21.17
20.67
20.49
23.25
22.97
22.48
22.13
21.82
21.34
20.43
19.81
19.25
18.65
18.03
17.35
16.53
15.28
12.87
8.02
6.82
6.42
6.00
5.66
5.37
5.06
4.75
4.38
3.26
0.51
0.33
0.15
-0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

WindMTY
26.30
27.29
28.16
33.11
34.29
34.85
43.98
44.80
45.42
45.26
60.67
60.95
60.88
59.45
58.96
66.90
66.09
64.71
63.69
62.81
61.44
58.85
57.06
55.47
53.75
51.95
50.03
47.66
44.08
37.15
23.16
19.69
18.56
17.36
16.38
15.54
14.65
13.77
12.70
9.46
1.46
0.94
0.44
-0.04

SpecX
404.04
435.68
540.06
587.86
635.53
661.97
735.47
760.81
776.90
782.54
970.70
972.93
990.05
999.11
995.95
1079.33
1075.76
1079.00
1085.73
1093.81
1099.42
1100.34
1107.44
1115.26
1123.19
1133.19
1144.26
1153.95
1158.40
1144.40
1093.98
1100.22
1122.13
1146.92
1173.18
1193.47
1199.85
1173.72
1081.48
742.98
83.05
66.53
38.95
36.60

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

1.2
1

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 4

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

SpecY
251.77
261.40
269.06
314.16
322.96
324.92
410.83
419.31
427.56
427.08
574.02
579.00
582.23
572.04
572.18
648.85
642.56
625.93
613.61
599.96
583.16
556.12
536.54
519.69
502.26
486.27
469.27
448.10
415.92
353.36
227.29
193.43
181.35
170.20
161.12
151.99
142.76
134.17
124.34
92.56
17.47
11.00
5.88
3.43

-0.6
6.2
13.1
18.1
24.5
30.2
35.3
40.5
46.7
51.2
65.5
70.4
77.0
83.4
87.4
96.6
101.0
107.6
114.5
121.0
127.6
134.2
141.0
147.4
153.9
160.1
166.3
172.6
179.0
185.1
191.5
197.5
203.6
209.6
215.2
219.1
220.1
214.6
196.4
131.0
-16.8
-14.1
-7.5
0.1

-13.7
-20.6
-27.5
-33.6
-40.0
-45.7
-53.0
-58.2
-64.5
-69.0
-87.1
-92.2
-99.3
-106.0
-110.6
-121.9
-126.2
-131.7
-137.7
-142.9
-148.2
-153.7
-159.2
-164.5
-170.1
-176.0
-182.1
-188.3
-194.6
-200.4
-206.6
-211.5
-216.5
-222.2
-227.6
-230.3
-230.1
-223.3
-203.9
-137.5
9.4
6.5
-0.5
-8.5

-7.2
-7.1
-7.1
-7.4
-6.9
-6.1
-5.8
-4.9
-3.7
-2.9
-1.4
0.1
2.1
3.7
5.9
8.2
9.7
9.5
9.4
8.2
7.1
5.7
4.2
2.8
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.7
-1.2
-2.9
-2.7
-2.4
-3.5
-4.5
-5.3
-6.2
-5.0
-5.3
-4.3
-3.3
-2.2

-7.2
-7.2
-7.3
-8.1
-8.6
-9.4
-11.9
-12.8
-14.1
-14.8
-20.2
-21.9
-24.4
-26.2
-29.0
-33.4
-34.9
-33.7
-32.7
-30.1
-27.7
-25.2
-22.4
-19.9
-17.4
-17.2
-17.1
-16.9
-16.5
-16.1
-15.8
-12.8
-10.0
-10.0
-10.1
-7.7
-5.5
-3.4
-1.3
-1.6
-2.0
-3.2
-4.7
-6.2

-2.2
2.9
8.1
11.9
17.1
21.9
26.5
31.2
36.7
40.7
53.5
58.3
64.9
70.9
75.7
84.9
89.3
93.9
98.7
102.4
106.2
109.8
113.4
116.9
120.5
125.0
129.7
134.3
138.9
143.3
147.9
150.7
153.8
158.4
162.7
164.5
164.2
159.1
144.5
96.2
-14.7
-11.9
-6.1
0.5

-2.2
2.9
7.9
11.4
15.8
19.4
22.0
25.2
28.9
31.8
39.4
41.8
45.1
48.5
49.6
53.7
55.9
61.5
67.1
73.7
80.1
86.7
93.5
99.9
106.4
111.2
115.8
120.7
125.7
130.6
135.5
142.0
148.5
152.9
157.0
161.3
163.5
160.6
148.2
98.7
-12.2
-11.1
-7.1
-2.4

-12.1
-17.2
-22.3
-26.8
-31.3
-35.0
-39.7
-42.9
-46.8
-49.5
-61.0
-63.6
-67.4
-71.1
-72.7
-78.9
-81.1
-85.6
-90.4
-95.5
-100.7
-106.1
-111.7
-117.0
-122.6
-127.1
-131.6
-136.4
-141.3
-145.9
-150.7
-156.0
-161.3
-165.5
-169.4
-172.5
-173.4
-169.3
-155.7
-105.3
4.9
3.5
-0.9
-6.0

-12.1
-17.3
-22.5
-27.4
-32.6
-37.5
-44.2
-48.8
-54.5
-58.4
-75.1
-80.1
-87.2
-93.5
-98.9
-110.2
-114.5
-118.0
-122.0
-124.3
-126.8
-129.3
-131.6
-134.0
-136.6
-140.9
-145.5
-150.0
-154.4
-158.6
-163.1
-164.7
-166.6
-171.0
-175.2
-175.7
-174.1
-167.8
-152.0
-102.7
7.4
4.4
-1.9
-8.9

8.7
14.3
19.8
25.5
30.7
35.2
42.6
46.9
51.8
55.1
71.8
75.5
80.4
84.5
87.2
97.2
100.2
104.6
109.5
114.2
118.7
122.8
127.2
131.5
135.8
139.7
143.6
147.3
150.7
152.4
151.3
154.6
158.8
162.8
166.6
169.3
169.9
165.6
151.6
101.4
-12.9
-11.1
-6.4
-1.0

-13.2
-8.5
-3.7
-2.2
2.1
6.1
5.9
9.5
13.9
17.3
21.1
24.6
29.6
34.9
38.1
41.4
45.1
50.7
56.4
61.9
67.5
73.7
79.7
85.3
91.1
96.4
101.9
107.7
114.0
121.5
132.1
138.2
143.4
148.4
153.0
156.4
157.8
154.2
141.1
93.5
-14.1
-11.9
-6.8
-0.9

-1.1
-5.9
-10.6
-13.3
-17.6
-21.7
-23.6
-27.1
-31.7
-35.0
-42.7
-46.4
-51.9
-57.5
-61.2
-66.6
-70.2
-74.9
-79.7
-83.7
-88.2
-93.2
-97.9
-102.4
-107.2
-112.3
-117.7
-123.4
-129.5
-136.8
-147.2
-152.2
-156.3
-161.1
-165.5
-167.7
-167.7
-162.9
-148.6
-100.1
6.8
4.3
-1.2
-7.5

Page 1 of 12

-23.1
-28.6
-34.2
-40.9
-46.2
-50.8
-60.3
-64.5
-69.6
-72.8
-93.4
-97.3
-102.7
-107.1
-110.4
-122.4
-125.4
-128.8
-132.8
-136.1
-139.4
-142.2
-145.4
-148.6
-152.0
-155.6
-159.4
-163.0
-166.2
-167.7
-166.5
-168.5
-171.7
-175.5
-179.1
-180.5
-179.9
-174.3
-159.1
-107.9
5.6
3.5
-1.6
-7.4

24.4
25.6
26.7
32.3
34.0
35.3
46.2
47.9
49.5
49.9
69.1
70.5
71.8
71.3
72.2
83.3
83.4
81.7
80.6
78.8
76.4
72.5
69.3
66.5
63.4
61.3
59.1
56.2
51.7
43.3
26.4
21.0
18.5
17.2
16.3
14.7
13.0
11.4
9.7
6.8
-3.2
-3.1
-2.9
-2.8

-38.7
-39.9
-40.9
-47.2
-48.3
-48.4
-59.3
-59.6
-59.5
-58.7
-76.5
-75.8
-74.3
-71.4
-69.2
-77.3
-75.2
-73.5
-72.3
-71.9
-71.0
-68.7
-67.6
-66.6
-65.5
-63.4
-61.0
-58.2
-54.1
-45.9
-29.2
-26.3
-26.0
-24.4
-23.0
-22.6
-22.2
-21.6
-20.8
-15.9
-6.7
-5.3
-4.0
-2.7

24.4
25.5
26.5
31.7
32.7
32.8
41.6
42.0
41.7
41.0
55.0
54.0
52.0
48.8
46.1
52.0
50.0
49.4
49.0
50.1
50.4
49.3
49.4
49.5
49.4
47.5
45.2
42.5
38.5
30.6
14.0
12.3
13.2
11.8
10.5
11.4
12.2
12.9
13.3
9.4
-0.7
-2.2
-4.0
-5.7

-38.7
-40.0
-41.1
-47.7
-49.6
-50.8
-63.9
-65.5
-67.3
-67.6
-90.6
-92.3
-94.1
-93.8
-95.4
-108.5
-108.6
-105.9
-103.9
-100.7
-97.1
-91.9
-87.5
-83.6
-79.6
-77.2
-74.9
-71.9
-67.2
-58.6
-41.6
-35.0
-31.4
-29.9
-28.8
-25.9
-22.9
-20.1
-17.2
-13.3
-4.2
-4.5
-5.1
-5.6

28.5
33.5
38.5
47.2
52.5
56.8
71.1
75.6
80.5
83.3
111.1
115.1
119.8
122.6
125.5
141.8
144.2
146.0
148.5
150.4
151.7
151.4
152.1
152.9
153.6
154.9
156.1
156.7
155.8
150.7
137.2
135.3
136.4
138.3
140.5
140.9
139.8
135.1
122.9
82.8
-10.2
-8.8
-5.0
-0.7

12.0
16.4
20.8
26.5
31.0
35.0
43.5
47.5
52.0
54.9
73.1
76.9
81.7
85.4
88.6
99.9
102.8
105.5
108.7
111.1
113.2
114.6
116.4
118.3
120.0
122.4
124.8
126.9
128.3
127.5
122.8
123.0
124.8
127.5
130.3
131.2
130.7
126.5
115.1
77.0
-11.1
-9.3
-5.3
-0.7

21.1
18.4
15.6
18.1
16.2
14.1
21.4
20.0
17.8
15.6
25.2
23.5
20.5
16.0
14.1
18.8
16.2
11.2
6.5
1.8
-3.6
-10.6
-16.9
-22.6
-28.8
-34.3
-40.1
-46.5
-54.5
-66.3
-86.9
-95.0
-100.2
-104.8
-108.9
-112.0
-113.7
-111.5
-102.4
-68.4
4.6
2.8
-1.1
-5.6

4.6
1.3
-2.0
-2.6
-5.3
-7.8
-6.1
-8.1
-10.6
-12.8
-12.8
-14.7
-17.6
-21.2
-22.8
-23.1
-25.2
-29.3
-33.3
-37.5
-42.1
-47.5
-52.6
-57.3
-62.4
-66.8
-71.4
-76.3
-82.0
-89.5
-101.4
-107.3
-111.7
-115.6
-119.1
-121.7
-122.8
-120.1
-110.3
-74.2
3.6
2.2
-1.4
-5.5

-18.9
-15.6
-12.3
-12.4
-9.3
-6.0
-8.1
-5.1
-1.4
1.7
1.8
5.3
10.2
15.5
19.3
21.3
25.1
29.4
33.8
37.2
41.0
45.4
49.3
53.0
56.8
61.3
65.9
70.8
76.4
83.8
95.5
99.8
102.9
107.1
110.9
112.9
113.4
110.3
100.1
65.8
-12.8
-10.4
-5.8
-0.6

28.5
33.5
38.3
46.8
51.5
55.0
67.7
71.1
74.6
76.6
100.5
102.7
105.0
105.8
105.9
118.4
119.1
121.7
124.8
128.8
132.1
134.1
137.2
140.2
143.1
144.5
145.7
146.5
145.9
141.2
127.9
128.7
132.4
134.2
136.1
138.5
139.2
136.2
125.7
84.8
-8.3
-8.1
-5.8
-2.9

-18.9
-15.7
-12.4
-12.8
-10.2
-7.8
-11.6
-9.6
-7.2
-5.0
-8.8
-7.1
-4.7
-1.3
-0.3
-2.2
0.0
5.1
10.1
15.7
21.4
28.0
34.4
40.2
46.3
50.9
55.5
60.6
66.5
74.3
86.2
93.3
98.9
103.0
106.6
110.5
112.8
111.4
102.8
67.7
-11.0
-9.8
-6.6
-2.9

-42.8
-47.9
-52.9
-62.7
-68.0
-72.4
-88.8
-93.2
-98.3
-101.0
-132.7
-136.9
-142.1
-145.2
-148.7
-167.1
-169.3
-170.1
-171.8
-172.2
-172.3
-170.9
-170.3
-170.0
-169.8
-170.8
-171.9
-172.4
-171.3
-166.0
-152.4
-149.3
-149.2
-151.0
-152.9
-152.1
-149.7
-143.8
-130.5
-89.4
2.9
1.2
-3.0
-7.7

-26.3
-30.8
-35.2
-41.9
-46.5
-50.6
-61.2
-65.1
-69.8
-72.6
-94.7
-98.7
-104.0
-107.9
-111.8
-125.2
-128.0
-129.6
-131.9
-132.9
-133.9
-134.1
-134.6
-135.3
-136.2
-138.3
-140.6
-142.6
-143.8
-142.8
-137.9
-137.0
-137.6
-140.2
-142.7
-142.5
-140.6
-135.2
-122.6
-83.5
3.8
1.8
-2.7
-7.7

-35.4
-32.8
-30.0
-33.6
-31.7
-29.7
-39.1
-37.6
-35.6
-33.3
-46.8
-45.3
-42.8
-38.6
-37.3
-44.0
-41.4
-35.4
-29.8
-23.6
-17.0
-8.8
-1.3
5.5
12.7
18.4
24.3
30.8
39.0
51.1
71.8
81.0
87.3
92.2
96.4
100.8
103.7
102.8
94.9
61.8
-11.9
-10.4
-6.9
-2.8

-35.4
-32.7
-29.9
-33.2
-30.8
-27.8
-35.7
-33.2
-29.8
-26.6
-36.2
-32.9
-28.0
-21.7
-17.6
-20.6
-16.3
-11.1
-6.1
-2.1
2.6
8.6
13.6
18.3
23.2
28.8
34.7
41.1
48.9
60.6
81.1
87.5
91.3
96.3
100.7
103.3
104.3
101.7
92.2
59.9
-13.7
-11.0
-6.1
-0.6

4.6
1.3
-2.1
-3.0
-6.2
-9.6
-9.6
-12.5
-16.5
-19.5
-23.4
-27.1
-32.5
-38.1
-42.5
-46.5
-50.3
-53.6
-57.0
-59.1
-61.6
-64.8
-67.5
-70.1
-72.9
-77.2
-81.8
-86.5
-91.9
-99.1
-110.6
-113.8
-115.7
-119.7
-123.4
-124.1
-123.3
-119.0
-107.6
-72.3
5.5
2.9
-2.2
-7.8

-42.8
-47.8
-52.7
-62.3
-67.0
-70.5
-85.4
-88.8
-92.5
-94.3
-122.1
-124.5
-127.3
-128.3
-129.1
-143.6
-144.2
-145.8
-148.1
-150.7
-152.7
-153.5
-155.4
-157.3
-159.2
-160.4
-161.5
-162.1
-161.5
-156.5
-143.1
-142.7
-145.2
-146.9
-148.6
-149.7
-149.2
-144.9
-133.2
-91.3
1.0
0.6
-2.2
-5.5

12.0
16.4
20.7
26.0
30.0
33.1
40.1
43.1
46.2
48.2
62.5
64.5
66.8
68.5
69.0
76.5
77.7
81.2
84.9
89.5
93.7
97.2
101.5
105.5
109.5
112.0
114.4
116.7
118.4
118.0
113.5
116.5
120.8
123.4
125.9
128.8
130.1
127.6
117.8
78.9
-9.2
-8.7
-6.1
-2.9

-26.3
-30.7
-35.1
-41.5
-45.5
-48.7
-57.8
-60.7
-64.0
-65.9
-84.1
-86.3
-89.1
-91.1
-92.1
-101.7
-102.9
-105.3
-108.2
-111.4
-114.3
-116.7
-119.7
-122.6
-125.6
-127.9
-130.2
-132.4
-133.9
-133.3
-128.6
-130.4
-133.6
-136.1
-138.4
-140.0
-140.1
-136.3
-125.3
-85.4
1.9
1.1
-1.9
-5.5

21.1
18.4
15.5
17.7
15.3
12.2
18.0
15.6
12.0
8.9
14.6
11.1
5.7
-0.8
-5.6
-4.6
-8.9
-13.1
-17.2
-19.8
-23.2
-28.0
-31.8
-35.4
-39.3
-44.7
-50.5
-56.7
-64.4
-75.9
-96.2
-101.5
-104.2
-108.9
-113.2
-114.5
-114.2
-110.4
-99.7
-66.4
6.4
3.5
-1.9
-7.8

1.2
8.0
14.9
20.0
26.4
32.1
37.5
42.7
48.9
53.4
68.2
73.1
79.8
86.2
90.3
99.8
104.2
110.6
117.4
123.8
130.2
136.7
143.3
149.5
156.0
162.1
168.3
174.6
181.0
187.0
193.4
199.2
205.2
211.2
216.8
220.5
221.3
215.7
197.3
131.8
-15.8
-13.1
-6.5
1.2

-11.9
-18.8
-25.7
-31.6
-38.0
-43.8
-50.8
-56.0
-62.3
-66.7
-84.4
-89.5
-96.5
-103.1
-107.7
-118.7
-123.1
-128.7
-134.8
-140.2
-145.7
-151.2
-156.9
-162.3
-168.1
-174.0
-180.1
-186.3
-192.6
-198.5
-204.7
-209.7
-214.9
-220.7
-226.1
-228.9
-228.8
-222.2
-203.0
-136.7
10.4
7.5
0.5
-7.5

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

087237.10

A27

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

0.9

0.9

1.6

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Live

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

4.11
8.39
12.67
16.14
20.14
23.72
27.57
30.84
34.77
37.56
47.70
50.80
55.11
59.17
61.86
68.28
71.02
74.79
78.81
82.48
86.20
89.97
93.80
97.46
101.25
105.01
108.88
112.79
116.75
120.48
124.41
127.81
131.29
134.96
138.39
140.41
140.67
136.87
125.09
83.92
-8.19
-6.43
-2.17
2.71

WindMTX
9.15
9.50
9.80
11.52
11.93
12.13
15.30
15.59
15.80
15.75
21.10
21.20
21.17
20.67
20.49
23.25
22.97
22.48
22.13
21.82
21.34
20.43
19.81
19.25
18.65
18.03
17.35
16.53
15.28
12.87
8.02
6.82
6.42
6.00
5.66
5.37
5.06
4.75
4.38
3.26
0.51
0.33
0.15
-0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

0.9

0.9

1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

-1.2
-1.2

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

Figure 6-9 Case 4

WindMTY
26.30
27.29
28.16
33.11
34.29
34.85
43.98
44.80
45.42
45.26
60.67
60.95
60.88
59.45
58.96
66.90
66.09
64.71
63.69
62.81
61.44
58.85
57.06
55.47
53.75
51.95
50.03
47.66
44.08
37.15
23.16
19.69
18.56
17.36
16.38
15.54
14.65
13.77
12.70
9.46
1.46
0.94
0.44
-0.04

-5.4
-5.3
-5.3
-5.4
-4.9
-4.2
-3.6
-2.7
-1.5
-0.7
1.3
2.8
4.8
6.5
8.8
11.4
12.8
12.5
12.3
11.0
9.6
8.2
6.5
4.9
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.2
3.0
2.7
2.6
0.6
-1.3
-1.1
-0.8
-2.1
-3.3
-4.3
-5.2
-4.2
-4.4
-3.4
-2.3
-1.2

-5.4
-5.4
-5.5
-6.2
-6.7
-7.5
-9.7
-10.5
-11.8
-12.6
-17.5
-19.2
-21.6
-23.4
-26.1
-30.3
-31.7
-30.6
-29.8
-27.3
-25.1
-22.7
-20.1
-17.8
-15.4
-15.2
-15.2
-15.0
-14.6
-14.2
-13.9
-11.1
-8.4
-8.4
-8.5
-6.3
-4.2
-2.3
-0.4
-0.7
-1.1
-2.3
-3.7
-5.1

-0.4
4.7
9.9
13.8
19.0
23.9
28.7
33.4
38.9
42.9
56.2
61.1
67.7
73.8
78.6
88.1
92.5
96.9
101.6
105.1
108.7
112.3
115.7
119.0
122.5
127.0
131.7
136.3
140.9
145.2
149.8
152.5
155.4
159.9
164.3
165.9
165.4
160.2
145.5
97.0
-13.8
-11.0
-5.1
1.6

-0.5
4.7
9.7
13.3
17.7
21.4
24.2
27.4
31.2
34.0
42.1
44.5
47.9
51.3
52.5
56.8
59.1
64.5
70.0
76.4
82.7
89.1
95.8
102.0
108.4
113.1
117.8
122.6
127.7
132.5
137.4
143.8
150.1
154.5
158.5
162.7
164.7
161.7
149.1
99.5
-11.3
-10.1
-6.1
-1.4

-10.3
-15.4
-20.5
-24.9
-29.3
-33.1
-37.4
-40.7
-44.5
-47.3
-58.3
-60.9
-64.6
-68.2
-69.8
-75.8
-77.9
-82.6
-87.5
-92.8
-98.1
-103.7
-109.4
-114.9
-120.5
-125.1
-129.7
-134.4
-139.3
-144.0
-148.8
-154.3
-159.7
-164.0
-167.8
-171.1
-172.2
-168.3
-154.8
-104.4
5.8
4.5
0.1
-4.9

-10.3
-15.5
-20.7
-25.4
-30.6
-35.5
-42.0
-46.6
-52.3
-56.2
-72.4
-77.4
-84.4
-90.7
-96.0
-107.0
-111.4
-115.0
-119.1
-121.5
-124.2
-126.8
-129.3
-131.9
-134.6
-138.9
-143.5
-148.0
-152.5
-156.6
-161.2
-163.0
-165.0
-169.4
-173.6
-174.3
-172.9
-166.8
-151.1
-101.9
8.3
5.3
-0.9
-7.9

10.5
16.1
21.6
27.4
32.7
37.2
44.8
49.1
54.0
57.3
74.5
78.2
83.2
87.4
90.1
100.4
103.3
107.7
112.4
117.0
121.3
125.2
129.5
133.6
137.8
141.7
145.6
149.3
152.6
154.3
153.2
156.3
160.4
164.4
168.2
170.7
171.2
166.7
152.6
102.2
-12.0
-10.2
-5.4
0.1

-11.4
-6.7
-1.9
-0.3
4.0
8.1
8.1
11.7
16.1
19.5
23.8
27.4
32.4
37.7
40.9
44.6
48.2
53.7
59.3
64.6
70.1
76.2
82.0
87.4
93.1
98.4
103.9
109.6
115.9
123.4
134.0
139.9
145.0
150.0
154.6
157.8
159.0
155.3
142.0
94.3
-13.2
-10.9
-5.8
0.1

0.7
-4.1
-8.8
-11.3
-15.7
-19.8
-21.4
-24.9
-29.4
-32.8
-40.0
-43.7
-49.1
-54.7
-58.3
-63.5
-67.1
-71.8
-76.7
-81.0
-85.6
-90.7
-95.6
-100.3
-105.2
-110.3
-115.8
-121.4
-127.6
-134.9
-145.3
-150.4
-154.6
-159.5
-163.9
-166.3
-166.5
-161.8
-147.7
-99.2
7.7
5.3
-0.2
-6.4

Page 2 of 12

-21.3
-26.8
-32.4
-39.0
-44.3
-48.9
-58.1
-62.3
-67.4
-70.6
-90.7
-94.6
-99.9
-104.3
-107.5
-119.3
-122.2
-125.8
-129.9
-133.3
-136.8
-139.8
-143.2
-146.5
-149.9
-153.6
-157.4
-161.1
-164.3
-165.7
-164.6
-166.8
-170.1
-173.9
-177.5
-179.1
-178.6
-173.2
-158.2
-107.1
6.5
4.5
-0.6
-6.4

26.2
27.4
28.5
34.2
36.0
37.2
48.4
50.1
51.7
52.1
71.8
73.2
74.6
74.1
75.1
86.4
86.6
84.8
83.5
81.5
79.0
74.9
71.6
68.7
65.5
63.3
61.0
58.1
53.7
45.2
28.3
22.7
20.1
18.8
17.9
16.1
14.2
12.5
10.6
7.6
-2.2
-2.1
-1.9
-1.7

-36.9
-38.1
-39.1
-45.2
-46.3
-46.4
-57.1
-57.4
-57.3
-56.5
-73.8
-73.0
-71.5
-68.6
-66.4
-74.1
-72.0
-70.5
-69.4
-69.2
-68.4
-66.3
-65.3
-64.5
-63.5
-61.4
-59.0
-56.3
-52.1
-44.0
-27.3
-24.5
-24.4
-22.8
-21.4
-21.2
-21.0
-20.5
-19.9
-15.1
-5.7
-4.4
-3.0
-1.6

26.2
27.3
28.3
33.6
34.7
34.7
43.9
44.2
43.9
43.2
57.7
56.7
54.8
51.7
49.0
55.2
53.2
52.4
51.9
52.8
53.0
51.7
51.7
51.6
51.4
49.5
47.2
44.5
40.5
32.5
15.9
14.0
14.8
13.4
12.1
12.8
13.5
14.0
14.2
10.2
0.2
-1.3
-3.0
-4.7

-36.9
-38.2
-39.3
-45.8
-47.6
-48.9
-61.7
-63.3
-65.1
-65.4
-87.9
-89.6
-91.3
-91.0
-92.5
-105.4
-105.5
-102.9
-101.0
-97.9
-94.5
-89.5
-85.3
-81.5
-77.6
-75.2
-72.9
-69.9
-65.3
-56.6
-39.7
-33.2
-29.8
-28.3
-27.2
-24.5
-21.7
-19.0
-16.2
-12.5
-3.3
-3.5
-4.1
-4.6

30.3
35.3
40.3
49.1
54.4
58.8
73.3
77.8
82.7
85.5
113.8
117.8
122.6
125.4
128.4
145.0
147.3
149.0
151.4
153.1
154.3
153.9
154.4
155.1
155.6
156.9
158.0
158.7
157.8
152.6
139.1
137.0
138.0
139.9
142.0
142.3
141.0
136.2
123.9
83.6
-9.3
-7.8
-4.0
0.4

13.8
18.2
22.6
28.4
32.9
36.9
45.7
49.7
54.2
57.1
75.8
79.6
84.5
88.2
91.5
103.1
105.9
108.5
111.6
113.8
115.8
117.1
118.7
120.4
122.0
124.4
126.8
128.9
130.2
129.4
124.7
124.8
126.4
129.1
131.8
132.6
131.9
127.6
116.0
77.8
-10.2
-8.4
-4.3
0.4

22.9
20.2
17.4
20.1
18.2
16.0
23.6
22.2
20.1
17.8
27.9
26.3
23.3
18.8
17.0
22.0
19.4
14.3
9.4
4.5
-1.0
-8.2
-14.6
-20.5
-26.8
-32.3
-38.1
-44.5
-52.6
-64.4
-85.0
-93.2
-98.6
-103.2
-107.3
-110.6
-112.4
-110.4
-101.5
-67.6
5.5
3.8
-0.1
-4.5

6.4
3.1
-0.2
-0.7
-3.3
-5.8
-3.9
-5.9
-8.4
-10.5
-10.1
-11.9
-14.8
-18.4
-19.9
-19.9
-22.0
-26.2
-30.4
-34.8
-39.5
-45.0
-50.3
-55.2
-60.4
-64.8
-69.4
-74.3
-80.1
-87.6
-99.5
-105.5
-110.1
-114.0
-117.5
-120.3
-121.5
-119.0
-109.4
-73.4
4.6
3.2
-0.4
-4.5

-17.1
-13.8
-10.5
-10.5
-7.3
-4.0
-5.9
-2.9
0.9
3.9
4.5
8.0
13.0
18.3
22.2
24.5
28.2
32.4
36.7
40.0
43.6
47.9
51.6
55.1
58.8
63.3
67.9
72.8
78.4
85.7
97.4
101.6
104.5
108.7
112.5
114.3
114.6
111.3
101.0
66.6
-11.9
-9.5
-4.8
0.4

30.3
35.3
40.1
48.7
53.5
56.9
69.9
73.4
76.9
78.8
103.2
105.4
107.8
108.6
108.8
121.5
122.2
124.7
127.7
131.6
134.7
136.5
139.4
142.3
145.1
146.5
147.7
148.4
147.9
143.1
129.8
130.5
134.0
135.8
137.7
139.9
140.5
137.3
126.6
85.6
-7.4
-7.2
-4.8
-1.9

-17.1
-13.9
-10.6
-10.9
-8.3
-5.9
-9.3
-7.4
-4.9
-2.7
-6.1
-4.4
-1.9
1.5
2.6
1.0
3.1
8.1
13.0
18.4
24.0
30.5
36.6
42.4
48.3
52.9
57.5
62.6
68.5
76.2
88.1
95.0
100.5
104.6
108.2
111.9
114.1
112.5
103.7
68.5
-10.0
-8.9
-5.6
-1.8

-41.0
-46.1
-51.1
-60.8
-66.1
-70.5
-86.6
-91.0
-96.1
-98.8
-130.0
-134.1
-139.3
-142.4
-145.8
-163.9
-166.2
-167.1
-168.9
-169.5
-169.7
-168.4
-168.0
-167.9
-167.7
-168.8
-169.9
-170.4
-169.4
-164.1
-150.5
-147.5
-147.6
-149.4
-151.3
-150.7
-148.5
-142.7
-129.5
-88.5
3.8
2.1
-2.0
-6.7

-24.5
-29.0
-33.4
-40.0
-44.6
-48.6
-59.0
-62.9
-67.6
-70.4
-92.0
-95.9
-101.2
-105.1
-108.9
-122.0
-124.8
-126.6
-129.0
-130.2
-131.3
-131.6
-132.4
-133.2
-134.1
-136.3
-138.6
-140.6
-141.9
-140.9
-136.0
-135.2
-136.0
-138.6
-141.1
-141.1
-139.4
-134.1
-121.6
-82.7
4.7
2.7
-1.7
-6.7

-33.6
-31.0
-28.2
-31.7
-29.8
-27.7
-36.9
-35.4
-33.4
-31.1
-44.1
-42.6
-40.1
-35.8
-34.4
-40.9
-38.3
-32.4
-26.9
-20.9
-14.4
-6.3
0.9
7.7
14.7
20.4
26.3
32.8
40.9
53.0
73.6
82.7
88.9
93.7
98.0
102.2
105.0
103.9
95.9
62.7
-11.0
-9.5
-5.9
-1.8

-33.6
-30.9
-28.1
-31.3
-28.8
-25.9
-33.5
-31.0
-27.6
-24.4
-33.5
-30.2
-25.2
-18.9
-14.7
-17.4
-13.2
-8.1
-3.2
0.7
5.1
11.0
15.9
20.5
25.2
30.8
36.6
43.0
50.8
62.5
82.9
89.3
92.9
97.8
102.3
104.7
105.5
102.8
93.1
60.7
-12.8
-10.1
-5.1
0.5

6.4
3.1
-0.3
-1.1
-4.3
-7.7
-7.4
-10.3
-14.2
-17.2
-20.7
-24.3
-29.7
-35.3
-39.6
-43.4
-47.1
-50.5
-54.1
-56.3
-59.0
-62.4
-65.2
-68.0
-70.9
-75.2
-79.8
-84.6
-90.0
-97.2
-108.8
-112.1
-114.1
-118.1
-121.8
-122.7
-122.1
-117.9
-106.6
-71.5
6.4
3.8
-1.2
-6.7

-41.0
-46.1
-50.9
-60.3
-65.1
-68.6
-83.2
-86.6
-90.2
-92.1
-119.4
-121.7
-124.5
-125.5
-126.2
-140.4
-141.1
-142.8
-145.2
-147.9
-150.2
-151.0
-153.1
-155.1
-157.2
-158.4
-159.5
-160.2
-159.5
-154.5
-141.2
-141.0
-143.6
-145.3
-147.0
-148.3
-147.9
-143.8
-132.3
-90.5
1.9
1.5
-1.2
-4.4

13.8
18.2
22.5
28.0
32.0
35.1
42.3
45.3
48.4
50.4
65.2
67.2
69.6
71.4
71.9
79.6
80.8
84.2
87.8
92.3
96.3
99.7
103.7
107.6
111.5
114.0
116.4
118.6
120.3
119.9
115.4
118.2
122.4
125.0
127.5
130.2
131.4
128.7
118.7
79.7
-8.3
-7.8
-5.1
-1.8

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

V-target=
V-SPECX=
V-SPECY=
SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg


3626.26 kips(85% of Static Base Shear)
11595.55 kips
Scale-X=
12103.43 kips
Scale-Y=
1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

087237.10

A28

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

Model:

121908Model1

3.20
3.34

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Live

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

4.11
8.39
12.67
16.14
20.14
23.72
27.57
30.84
34.77
37.56
47.70
50.80
55.11
59.17
61.86
68.28
71.02
74.79
78.81
82.48
86.20
89.97
93.80
97.46
101.25
105.01
108.88
112.79
116.75
120.48
124.41
127.81
131.29
134.96
138.39
140.41
140.67
136.87
125.09
83.92
-8.19
-6.43
-2.17
2.71

WindMTX
9.15
9.50
9.80
11.52
11.93
12.13
15.30
15.59
15.80
15.75
21.10
21.20
21.17
20.67
20.49
23.25
22.97
22.48
22.13
21.82
21.34
20.43
19.81
19.25
18.65
18.03
17.35
16.53
15.28
12.87
8.02
6.82
6.42
6.00
5.66
5.37
5.06
4.75
4.38
3.26
0.51
0.33
0.15
-0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

0.9

0.9

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

1.429
0.5

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

0.671

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

WindMTY
26.30
27.29
28.16
33.11
34.29
34.85
43.98
44.80
45.42
45.26
60.67
60.95
60.88
59.45
58.96
66.90
66.09
64.71
63.69
62.81
61.44
58.85
57.06
55.47
53.75
51.95
50.03
47.66
44.08
37.15
23.16
19.69
18.56
17.36
16.38
15.54
14.65
13.77
12.70
9.46
1.46
0.94
0.44
-0.04

-24.5
-28.9
-33.3
-39.6
-43.6
-46.7
-55.6
-58.5
-61.8
-63.7
-81.4
-83.5
-86.3
-88.3
-89.2
-98.6
-99.7
-102.3
-105.3
-108.6
-111.7
-114.2
-117.4
-120.4
-123.6
-125.9
-128.3
-130.4
-132.0
-131.4
-126.7
-128.7
-132.0
-134.5
-136.8
-138.6
-138.8
-135.2
-124.4
-84.6
2.8
2.1
-0.9
-4.5

22.9
20.2
17.3
19.6
17.2
14.2
20.2
17.8
14.2
11.1
17.3
13.9
8.5
2.0
-2.7
-1.5
-5.7
-10.0
-14.3
-17.0
-20.6
-25.6
-29.6
-33.3
-37.3
-42.7
-48.5
-54.8
-62.5
-74.0
-94.3
-99.8
-102.6
-107.3
-111.6
-113.1
-113.0
-109.3
-98.8
-65.6
7.3
4.4
-0.9
-6.8

140.5
151.2
184.5
202.9
218.5
226.9
256.4
265.1
270.8
272.6
342.3
343.3
348.7
350.4
349.1
380.8
379.2
379.3
380.8
383.0
384.0
382.5
383.7
385.3
386.8
388.6
390.6
391.8
390.4
380.6
353.5
353.1
359.6
366.5
374.0
380.2
382.1
373.9
344.9
236.8
23.2
17.3
7.9
6.8

104.8
110.6
122.7
140.1
147.1
150.2
181.6
186.5
190.4
190.8
250.2
251.8
254.0
251.7
251.1
280.6
278.4
274.4
271.8
269.4
265.6
258.3
253.8
250.2
246.3
242.5
238.5
233.2
224.1
204.1
161.7
152.8
152.0
151.1
150.9
150.8
149.4
145.1
134.2
93.5
8.7
5.0
0.7
-0.5

-112.3
-121.3
-153.3
-164.8
-179.0
-187.1
-203.6
-210.7
-215.1
-216.9
-264.8
-265.2
-270.6
-274.5
-273.8
-294.2
-293.7
-295.6
-298.2
-301.1
-303.7
-305.7
-308.9
-312.2
-315.7
-320.1
-325.1
-329.9
-334.1
-335.2
-330.7
-335.0
-342.3
-350.9
-359.8
-366.2
-368.3
-360.2
-331.5
-227.9
-28.8
-24.3
-16.4
-16.1

29.0
28.9
21.4
29.8
27.9
26.0
43.5
43.8
44.6
44.0
68.1
69.2
68.3
64.2
64.2
78.1
76.6
71.9
68.1
64.1
59.3
51.8
46.0
40.9
35.5
29.9
23.8
16.6
6.7
-10.6
-43.6
-53.6
-58.6
-64.1
-69.2
-73.1
-75.7
-75.1
-68.7
-45.9
-6.9
-7.4
-6.7
-7.4

Page 3 of 12

-46.1
-46.0
-38.5
-48.2
-46.4
-44.5
-64.6
-64.7
-65.8
-65.1
-93.8
-95.2
-94.8
-91.1
-91.8
-108.2
-106.6
-100.7
-95.8
-90.1
-83.9
-74.9
-67.7
-61.2
-54.7
-48.8
-42.7
-35.3
-25.2
-7.6
25.5
36.9
43.3
49.1
54.4
59.8
63.9
64.7
59.7
38.1
-1.8
-1.6
-2.9
-2.6

95.2
104.2
136.1
146.4
160.5
168.5
182.5
189.7
193.9
195.8
239.1
239.2
244.0
247.6
246.2
264.2
263.7
266.8
270.5
275.1
279.1
282.6
287.3
291.9
296.5
301.2
306.2
311.3
315.6
317.0
312.7
318.4
327.0
335.9
345.0
352.9
356.5
349.8
322.6
220.1
20.0
15.3
6.9
6.1

-157.5
-168.3
-201.6
-221.3
-237.0
-245.5
-277.5
-286.1
-292.0
-293.7
-368.0
-369.3
-375.2
-377.3
-376.7
-410.9
-409.2
-408.1
-408.5
-409.0
-408.5
-405.7
-405.4
-405.7
-406.0
-407.6
-409.4
-410.5
-408.9
-398.7
-371.6
-369.8
-374.9
-381.5
-388.8
-393.6
-394.0
-384.3
-353.9
-244.6
-31.9
-26.3
-17.5
-16.8

-121.9
-127.7
-139.8
-158.5
-165.6
-168.7
-202.6
-207.5
-211.6
-211.9
-275.9
-277.7
-280.6
-278.6
-278.7
-310.7
-308.4
-303.2
-299.6
-295.4
-290.1
-281.4
-275.5
-270.5
-265.5
-261.5
-257.4
-251.9
-242.5
-222.3
-179.7
-169.5
-167.3
-166.1
-165.8
-164.2
-161.3
-155.5
-143.2
-101.3
-17.4
-14.0
-10.2
-9.5

145.0
155.7
189.1
207.8
223.4
231.9
262.0
270.7
276.4
278.2
349.1
350.2
355.7
357.6
356.4
388.8
387.1
386.9
388.2
389.9
390.5
388.7
389.5
390.7
391.9
393.6
395.6
396.8
395.3
385.4
358.3
357.5
363.6
370.4
377.9
383.8
385.3
376.7
347.3
238.8
25.5
19.7
10.5
9.4

109.3
115.2
127.3
145.0
152.0
155.1
187.1
192.1
196.0
196.4
257.0
258.7
261.1
258.8
258.4
288.6
286.4
282.0
279.2
276.3
272.1
264.4
259.6
255.6
251.3
247.6
243.5
238.1
229.0
209.0
166.5
157.3
156.0
155.1
154.9
154.4
152.6
147.9
136.6
95.6
11.0
7.4
3.2
2.1

-107.7
-116.8
-148.7
-159.9
-174.1
-182.2
-198.0
-205.2
-209.5
-211.3
-258.0
-258.3
-263.5
-267.3
-266.5
-286.3
-285.7
-287.9
-290.9
-294.2
-297.2
-299.6
-303.2
-306.8
-310.6
-315.1
-320.1
-325.0
-329.2
-330.4
-325.9
-330.6
-338.2
-346.9
-355.9
-362.7
-365.2
-357.4
-329.1
-225.9
-26.4
-21.9
-13.9
-13.5

33.5
33.4
25.9
34.6
32.8
30.9
49.1
49.3
50.2
49.6
74.9
76.1
75.3
71.3
71.5
86.1
84.5
79.5
75.5
71.0
65.8
58.0
51.8
46.3
40.6
34.9
28.8
21.6
11.6
-5.8
-38.8
-49.2
-54.5
-60.1
-65.3
-69.6
-72.6
-72.4
-66.3
-43.8
-4.6
-5.1
-4.1
-4.8

-41.5
-41.5
-34.0
-43.3
-41.5
-39.6
-59.0
-59.2
-60.2
-59.5
-86.9
-88.3
-87.8
-84.0
-84.5
-100.2
-98.6
-93.1
-88.5
-83.2
-77.3
-68.8
-61.9
-55.8
-49.6
-43.8
-37.7
-30.4
-20.3
-2.8
30.3
41.4
47.4
53.1
58.3
63.3
67.0
67.5
62.1
40.2
0.5
0.8
-0.3
0.1

99.7
108.7
140.7
151.3
165.4
173.5
188.1
195.3
199.5
201.4
245.9
246.1
251.1
254.7
253.6
272.2
271.6
274.4
277.9
282.0
285.6
288.7
293.0
297.3
301.6
306.2
311.2
316.2
320.5
321.9
317.5
322.8
331.0
339.8
348.9
356.4
359.6
352.6
324.9
222.2
22.4
17.7
9.4
8.8

-153.0
-163.8
-197.1
-216.4
-232.1
-240.6
-271.9
-280.5
-286.4
-288.1
-361.2
-362.4
-368.2
-370.2
-369.4
-402.9
-401.2
-400.4
-401.2
-402.1
-402.0
-399.5
-399.6
-400.3
-400.9
-402.5
-404.4
-405.5
-404.0
-393.9
-366.8
-365.4
-370.8
-377.5
-384.8
-390.0
-390.8
-381.5
-351.5
-242.5
-29.6
-23.9
-14.9
-14.1

-117.3
-123.2
-135.3
-153.6
-160.7
-163.8
-197.0
-201.9
-206.0
-206.3
-269.1
-270.8
-273.6
-271.4
-271.3
-302.7
-300.5
-295.5
-292.2
-288.5
-283.6
-275.3
-269.7
-265.1
-260.4
-256.4
-252.4
-246.9
-237.6
-217.5
-175.0
-165.1
-163.2
-162.1
-161.8
-160.6
-158.1
-152.7
-140.8
-99.3
-15.1
-11.7
-7.7
-6.8

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
144.98
-157.52
155.73
-168.29
189.05
-201.64
207.75
-221.29
223.44
-237.01
231.87
-245.50
261.98
-277.47
270.69
-286.11
276.41
-292.00
278.15
-293.67
349.13
-368.01
350.21
-369.28
355.71
-375.23
357.56
-377.30
356.41
-376.69
388.80
-410.88
387.14
-409.17
386.94
-408.08
388.18
-408.54
389.88
-408.99
390.47
-408.52
388.66
-405.66
389.47
-405.39
390.70
-405.66
391.89
-406.00
393.64
-407.55
395.60
-409.44
396.76
-410.49
395.31
-408.89
385.38
-398.74
358.31
-371.56
357.55
-369.78
363.63
-374.86
370.44
-381.49
377.89
-388.78
383.76
-393.57
385.28
-393.98
376.68
-384.30
347.28
-353.86
238.85
-244.56
25.49
-31.90
19.68
-26.30
10.47
-17.47
9.41
-16.75

0.66
0.70
0.84
0.81
0.87
0.90
0.81
0.84
0.85
0.86
0.80
0.80
0.81
0.82
0.82
0.78
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.76
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.75
0.70
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.74
0.72
0.67
0.46
0.07
0.05
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

Dead

Live

-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Dead
-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Live

-4.11
-8.38
-12.63
-16.08
-20.02
-23.55
-27.33
-30.57
-34.42
-37.24
-47.30
-50.40
-54.64
-58.75
-61.38
-67.81
-70.49
-74.29
-78.25
-81.96
-85.63
-89.34
-93.11
-96.78
-100.52
-104.31
-108.12
-111.97
-115.87
-119.62
-123.49
-126.97
-130.39
-133.95
-137.32
-139.44
-139.64
-135.86
-124.02
-82.47
9.44
7.65
3.39
-1.49

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A29

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

6.79
11.11
15.41
24.09
29.16
33.81
43.20
48.24
54.47
59.24
57.57
61.60
66.64
71.16
74.10
83.01
86.23
90.97
95.85
100.55
105.24
109.95
114.69
119.06
123.51
127.28
131.03
134.71
138.33
141.58
144.84
148.13
151.30
153.73
155.74
156.91
156.02
150.87
137.49
92.81
-2.23
-2.68
-0.61
2.10

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.49
-9.79
-11.52
-11.93
-12.12
-15.30
-15.58
-15.80
-15.75
-21.11
-21.21
-21.19
-20.69
-20.53
-23.30
-23.02
-22.55
-22.20
-21.89
-21.41
-20.51
-19.90
-19.34
-18.74
-18.11
-17.45
-16.63
-15.39
-12.98
-8.12
-6.91
-6.52
-6.09
-5.75
-5.45
-5.14
-4.83
-4.46
-3.35
-0.58
-0.39
-0.21
-0.05

WindMTX
10.17
10.47
10.69
15.53
15.95
16.18
22.04
22.57
23.14
23.37
23.67
24.07
24.29
23.95
23.91
27.27
27.05
26.56
26.17
25.78
25.19
24.15
23.36
22.64
21.85
21.08
20.25
19.24
17.78
15.17
10.10
8.65
8.02
7.43
6.94
6.46
5.96
5.48
4.93
3.64
0.73
0.48
0.25
0.02

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.27
-28.13
-33.09
-34.27
-34.82
-43.97
-44.79
-45.41
-45.26
-60.69
-60.98
-60.94
-59.52
-59.05
-67.04
-66.25
-64.89
-63.90
-63.01
-61.65
-59.08
-57.31
-55.72
-54.01
-52.21
-50.30
-47.95
-44.39
-37.44
-23.46
-19.97
-18.83
-17.60
-16.62
-15.78
-14.89
-14.00
-12.92
-9.71
-1.66
-1.12
-0.62
-0.14

WindMTY
29.22
30.08
30.71
44.62
45.85
46.49
63.36
64.88
66.51
67.19
68.05
69.21
69.86
68.89
68.79
78.47
77.85
76.45
75.34
74.22
72.54
69.55
67.29
65.22
62.95
60.76
58.37
55.47
51.30
43.77
29.17
24.97
23.15
21.48
20.06
18.68
17.25
15.88
14.30
10.56
2.12
1.40
0.72
0.05

SpecX
404.04
435.18
539.20
586.27
633.00
658.47
731.14
756.52
771.67
778.20
965.79
968.38
985.20
995.12
991.70
1075.70
1071.89
1075.78
1082.29
1090.94
1096.38
1097.14
1104.10
1112.20
1119.99
1130.33
1141.24
1150.80
1155.12
1141.33
1090.67
1097.52
1119.18
1143.18
1169.20
1190.26
1196.42
1170.43
1077.83
737.40
92.12
74.65
44.93
34.45

SpecX
450.35
488.64
586.69
795.14
848.55
877.65
1056.41
1093.33
1126.34
1149.34
1085.40
1101.55
1127.73
1142.13
1141.76
1252.97
1252.77
1262.66
1274.30
1287.88
1297.89
1302.42
1312.37
1321.79
1330.55
1337.80
1345.21
1350.36
1349.21
1328.90
1270.98
1272.08
1287.36
1301.13
1315.22
1325.44
1319.55
1280.17
1172.67
807.01
66.13
55.07
38.35
35.29

SpecY
251.77
261.89
270.69
317.70
328.13
330.17
413.93
419.08
424.23
422.68
567.69
572.21
574.25
564.98
564.42
641.45
634.76
618.74
606.41
594.03
577.66
551.42
533.28
518.14
502.62
486.37
469.12
447.77
415.50
352.66
226.24
194.35
184.46
172.54
162.77
155.35
148.08
140.68
132.32
101.98
25.61
18.10
11.27
4.78

-6.8
-13.7
-20.6
-25.8
-32.2
-37.9
-43.1
-48.2
-54.4
-58.7
-73.1
-77.9
-84.5
-90.7
-94.7
-104.0
-108.4
-114.9
-121.8
-128.3
-134.8
-141.4
-148.1
-154.4
-161.0
-167.0
-173.2
-179.5
-185.8
-191.9
-198.2
-204.3
-210.4
-216.2
-221.7
-225.7
-226.7
-221.2
-202.8
-136.2
10.3
7.7
1.1
-6.6

6.3
13.1
19.8
25.7
31.9
37.5
44.4
49.6
55.8
60.5
78.3
83.4
90.4
97.3
101.7
113.0
117.2
122.8
128.6
134.0
139.2
144.5
149.8
155.3
160.7
166.8
172.8
178.8
184.9
190.9
197.0
202.0
206.9
212.5
217.7
220.5
220.2
213.6
194.0
127.7
-20.0
-16.8
-9.8
-1.8

-0.3
-0.3
-0.3
0.0
-0.3
-0.9
-1.0
-1.7
-2.5
-3.3
-4.5
-5.9
-7.4
-9.1
-11.0
-13.2
-14.4
-14.0
-13.7
-12.5
-11.1
-9.5
-7.7
-6.3
-4.5
-4.7
-4.5
-4.2
-3.7
-3.6
-3.4
-1.7
-0.1
-0.4
-0.8
0.2
1.2
1.9
2.8
2.9
1.2
0.0
-1.1
-2.2

-0.2
-0.3
-0.5
-0.1
0.1
0.5
2.3
3.1
3.9
5.0
9.7
11.4
13.4
15.7
18.1
22.3
23.3
21.9
20.5
18.2
15.5
12.5
9.3
7.1
4.3
4.5
4.1
3.6
2.8
2.7
2.2
-0.6
-3.5
-3.2
-3.2
-5.3
-7.7
-9.4
-11.6
-11.4
-10.9
-9.1
-7.6
-6.2

-5.2
-10.4
-15.5
-19.3
-24.3
-28.9
-33.4
-37.8
-43.0
-46.9
-59.5
-64.2
-70.4
-76.5
-81.1
-90.2
-94.3
-98.7
-103.3
-107.0
-110.5
-113.9
-117.3
-120.7
-124.0
-128.7
-133.2
-137.6
-142.0
-146.4
-150.9
-153.9
-157.0
-161.5
-165.9
-167.8
-167.5
-162.6
-147.9
-97.9
11.0
8.1
2.2
-4.5

-5.2
-10.4
-15.6
-19.4
-24.0
-28.0
-30.9
-34.2
-38.2
-40.7
-48.8
-51.2
-54.8
-57.9
-59.2
-63.6
-66.0
-71.7
-77.7
-84.0
-90.6
-97.4
-104.5
-110.7
-117.5
-121.8
-126.7
-131.8
-137.0
-141.7
-146.7
-153.1
-159.5
-163.6
-167.7
-172.0
-174.2
-171.1
-158.6
-108.6
1.9
1.2
-2.7
-7.5

4.7
9.8
14.8
19.3
23.8
27.6
32.2
35.6
39.6
42.5
54.0
56.8
60.7
64.5
66.3
72.6
74.9
79.6
84.5
89.7
95.0
100.5
106.2
111.5
117.2
121.6
126.3
131.1
136.1
140.7
145.5
150.8
156.0
159.9
163.7
166.8
167.6
163.5
149.8
100.1
-11.6
-10.3
-6.0
-0.9

4.7
9.7
14.7
19.2
24.0
28.6
34.6
39.2
44.4
48.7
64.7
69.8
76.4
83.1
88.1
99.2
103.1
106.5
110.1
112.7
114.9
117.0
118.9
121.6
123.8
128.5
132.8
137.0
141.0
145.4
149.7
151.6
153.4
157.8
161.9
162.7
161.0
155.0
139.0
89.3
-20.8
-17.1
-10.9
-3.9

-16.2
-21.8
-27.3
-33.2
-38.5
-43.0
-50.5
-54.7
-59.5
-62.7
-79.5
-83.1
-88.0
-92.1
-94.8
-104.8
-107.8
-112.3
-117.1
-121.8
-126.3
-130.3
-134.8
-138.9
-143.2
-147.0
-150.9
-154.6
-158.0
-159.6
-158.5
-161.8
-166.1
-169.9
-173.7
-176.5
-177.0
-172.6
-158.6
-107.3
5.8
4.2
-0.5
-6.0

5.8
1.0
-3.8
-5.5
-9.8
-13.9
-13.8
-17.3
-21.6
-24.9
-28.8
-32.2
-37.2
-42.4
-45.5
-48.9
-52.5
-58.2
-63.8
-69.2
-74.9
-81.1
-87.0
-92.5
-98.3
-103.5
-109.0
-114.7
-121.0
-128.4
-139.0
-145.2
-150.4
-155.3
-159.9
-163.4
-164.7
-161.0
-147.9
-99.2
7.2
5.1
0.0
-5.9

-6.3
-1.7
3.0
5.4
9.6
13.5
15.1
18.7
23.1
26.7
34.0
37.8
43.1
48.9
52.5
57.9
61.4
66.0
70.7
74.9
79.2
84.1
88.7
93.3
98.0
103.3
108.6
114.1
120.1
127.5
137.9
142.9
146.9
151.6
155.9
158.2
158.1
153.5
139.0
90.7
-16.9
-14.2
-8.7
-2.5

15.7
21.1
26.5
33.1
38.2
42.6
51.8
56.1
61.0
64.5
84.7
88.7
94.0
98.6
101.8
113.8
116.6
120.1
124.0
127.5
130.6
133.3
136.4
139.8
143.0
146.8
150.5
154.0
157.1
158.6
157.4
159.5
162.5
166.2
169.7
171.3
170.5
165.0
149.7
98.7
-15.5
-13.2
-8.2
-2.4

-31.8
-33.0
-34.1
-39.7
-41.4
-42.5
-53.4
-54.8
-56.2
-56.5
-75.6
-76.9
-78.0
-77.5
-78.3
-89.2
-89.2
-87.4
-86.1
-84.3
-81.8
-77.6
-74.3
-71.5
-68.2
-66.2
-63.8
-60.8
-56.2
-47.7
-30.8
-25.5
-23.1
-21.9
-21.0
-19.5
-17.8
-16.3
-14.5
-10.6
-2.3
-2.4
-2.6
-2.9

31.3
32.4
33.4
39.7
40.8
41.1
52.2
52.7
52.8
52.1
70.1
69.5
68.3
65.4
63.5
71.6
69.8
68.3
67.3
66.9
66.2
64.2
63.2
62.2
61.4
59.1
56.9
54.3
50.4
42.1
25.5
22.4
22.1
20.3
18.8
18.4
17.9
17.3
16.5
12.7
1.7
0.2
-1.2
-2.5

-31.8
-33.1
-34.2
-39.8
-41.1
-41.5
-50.9
-51.2
-51.4
-50.3
-64.9
-63.9
-62.3
-58.8
-56.4
-62.6
-60.9
-60.5
-60.4
-61.2
-61.8
-61.1
-61.5
-61.4
-61.7
-59.3
-57.3
-54.9
-51.3
-43.0
-26.7
-24.7
-25.7
-24.0
-22.8
-23.6
-24.5
-24.8
-25.3
-21.3
-11.4
-9.3
-7.6
-5.9

31.3
32.4
33.3
39.6
41.1
42.1
54.6
56.2
57.6
58.3
80.8
82.5
83.9
84.0
85.3
98.3
98.0
95.3
92.9
90.0
86.1
80.7
76.0
72.3
68.0
66.0
63.4
60.1
55.3
46.8
29.6
23.2
19.5
18.2
17.1
14.3
11.3
8.8
5.7
2.0
-7.4
-6.6
-6.1
-5.5

-35.9
-41.0
-45.9
-54.7
-59.9
-64.1
-78.3
-82.6
-87.2
-90.0
-117.7
-121.5
-126.1
-128.9
-131.6
-147.9
-150.1
-151.9
-154.2
-156.1
-157.3
-156.8
-157.4
-158.1
-158.7
-160.0
-161.0
-161.5
-160.5
-155.4
-141.8
-140.0
-141.1
-143.1
-145.2
-145.8
-144.6
-139.9
-127.8
-86.3
5.1
3.6
-0.2
-4.6

-19.4
-23.9
-28.3
-33.9
-38.4
-42.2
-50.7
-54.5
-58.7
-61.6
-79.7
-83.3
-87.9
-91.6
-94.7
-106.0
-108.6
-111.2
-114.2
-116.7
-118.7
-119.9
-121.5
-123.3
-124.9
-127.4
-129.6
-131.6
-132.8
-132.0
-127.2
-127.6
-129.4
-132.1
-134.8
-135.9
-135.3
-131.2
-119.7
-80.3
6.1
4.3
0.2
-4.5

-28.5
-25.9
-23.1
-25.7
-23.8
-21.6
-29.1
-27.5
-25.2
-22.9
-32.5
-30.7
-27.7
-23.1
-21.1
-25.8
-23.1
-18.0
-13.3
-8.5
-3.0
4.1
10.4
16.2
22.4
27.9
33.7
40.2
48.2
60.1
80.7
88.7
93.8
98.3
102.2
105.4
107.0
104.8
95.7
62.3
-11.9
-10.2
-6.3
-1.9

-12.0
-8.8
-5.5
-5.0
-2.3
0.2
-1.5
0.6
3.3
5.5
5.5
7.5
10.5
14.2
15.9
16.2
18.4
22.6
26.7
31.0
35.6
41.1
46.2
51.1
56.2
60.6
65.2
70.2
76.0
83.5
95.3
101.2
105.6
109.2
112.6
115.3
116.2
113.5
103.7
68.3
-10.9
-9.5
-5.9
-1.8

11.5
8.2
4.8
4.9
1.9
-1.3
0.9
-1.9
-5.4
-8.4
-8.4
-11.7
-16.3
-21.7
-25.3
-27.2
-30.7
-34.9
-39.1
-42.6
-46.2
-50.4
-54.1
-57.8
-61.4
-65.9
-70.4
-75.1
-80.6
-87.9
-99.6
-104.0
-107.2
-111.3
-115.2
-117.3
-117.8
-114.7
-104.5
-68.8
8.1
5.6
0.9
-4.3

-35.9
-41.0
-46.0
-54.7
-59.7
-63.3
-76.5
-79.9
-83.6
-85.3
-109.7
-111.8
-114.4
-114.9
-115.3
-128.0
-128.9
-131.6
-135.0
-138.8
-142.3
-144.5
-147.8
-150.6
-153.7
-154.8
-156.2
-157.2
-156.8
-151.9
-138.7
-139.4
-143.0
-144.6
-146.5
-148.9
-149.6
-146.3
-135.8
-94.4
-1.8
-1.6
-3.9
-6.8

11.5
8.1
4.7
4.9
2.1
-0.6
2.8
0.8
-1.8
-3.7
-0.4
-1.9
-4.6
-7.7
-8.9
-7.2
-9.5
-14.7
-19.9
-25.3
-31.2
-38.0
-44.5
-50.2
-56.4
-60.8
-65.6
-70.8
-76.9
-84.4
-96.5
-103.5
-109.1
-112.9
-116.6
-120.4
-122.8
-121.1
-112.6
-76.9
1.2
0.4
-2.8
-6.6

35.4
40.3
45.1
54.6
59.6
63.7
79.6
84.0
88.6
91.7
122.9
127.1
132.0
135.5
138.7
157.0
158.9
159.7
161.1
161.8
161.6
159.9
159.0
159.0
158.4
159.8
160.7
160.9
159.6
154.5
140.7
137.7
137.6
139.4
141.2
140.6
138.1
132.4
118.9
77.7
-14.8
-12.6
-8.5
-3.8

18.9
23.2
27.5
33.8
38.1
41.8
52.0
55.9
60.2
63.3
84.9
88.9
93.9
98.2
101.7
115.0
117.5
119.1
121.1
122.4
123.0
122.9
123.2
124.1
124.7
127.2
129.2
130.9
131.9
131.1
126.0
125.3
125.8
128.4
130.8
130.8
128.8
123.7
110.9
71.7
-15.8
-13.3
-8.9
-3.9

28.0
25.2
22.3
25.6
23.6
21.2
30.3
28.9
26.6
24.6
37.7
36.3
33.6
29.6
28.1
34.8
31.9
25.9
20.1
14.2
7.3
-1.1
-8.7
-15.4
-22.7
-28.1
-34.1
-40.8
-49.1
-61.0
-81.8
-91.0
-97.4
-101.9
-106.2
-110.6
-113.5
-112.4
-104.5
-70.8
2.2
1.1
-2.4
-6.5

28.0
25.3
22.4
25.7
23.3
20.5
28.5
26.2
23.1
20.0
29.6
26.6
21.9
15.6
11.7
14.8
10.7
5.7
0.9
-3.2
-7.6
-13.5
-18.3
-22.9
-27.6
-33.3
-39.0
-45.2
-52.8
-64.6
-84.9
-91.6
-95.4
-100.4
-104.9
-107.5
-108.5
-106.0
-96.4
-62.8
9.1
6.3
1.3
-4.3

-12.0
-8.8
-5.6
-5.0
-2.1
0.9
0.3
3.3
6.8
10.2
13.6
17.2
22.3
28.2
32.3
36.2
39.6
42.8
46.0
48.3
50.5
53.4
55.8
58.6
61.1
65.7
70.0
74.5
79.6
87.0
98.4
101.8
103.6
107.7
111.3
112.2
111.2
107.2
95.6
60.2
-17.8
-14.7
-9.6
-4.1

35.4
40.4
45.2
54.6
59.4
62.9
77.7
81.3
85.1
87.1
114.9
117.4
120.3
121.5
122.3
137.0
137.7
139.5
141.8
144.5
146.7
147.5
149.5
151.4
153.5
154.6
155.8
156.5
155.9
150.9
137.5
137.2
139.5
140.9
142.5
143.7
143.1
138.8
127.0
85.8
-7.9
-7.5
-4.8
-1.6

-19.4
-23.9
-28.4
-34.0
-38.2
-41.5
-48.9
-51.8
-55.2
-56.9
-71.7
-73.6
-76.2
-77.6
-78.3
-86.0
-87.4
-91.0
-95.0
-99.4
-103.7
-107.5
-111.9
-115.8
-120.0
-122.2
-124.8
-127.2
-129.1
-128.5
-124.1
-127.0
-131.3
-133.7
-136.1
-139.0
-140.3
-137.6
-127.8
-88.3
-0.8
-0.9
-3.5
-6.7

18.9
23.3
27.6
33.9
37.9
41.1
50.2
53.2
56.6
58.7
76.8
79.1
82.1
84.2
85.3
95.0
96.2
98.9
101.9
105.1
108.1
110.5
113.6
116.6
119.7
122.0
124.4
126.6
128.2
127.6
122.9
124.7
127.7
130.0
132.2
133.9
133.8
130.0
119.0
79.8
-9.0
-8.2
-5.2
-1.7

-28.5
-25.9
-23.2
-25.8
-23.6
-20.9
-27.2
-24.8
-21.6
-18.2
-24.5
-21.0
-15.9
-9.1
-4.7
-5.8
-1.9
2.2
6.0
8.9
12.0
16.5
20.0
23.7
27.3
33.1
38.6
44.6
51.9
63.6
83.8
89.3
91.9
96.7
100.9
102.4
102.0
98.4
87.6
54.2
-18.8
-15.4
-10.0
-4.1

-6.8
-13.6
-20.5
-25.8
-32.1
-37.8
-43.3
-48.4
-54.5
-58.9
-73.7
-78.6
-85.2
-91.5
-95.6
-105.1
-109.5
-115.9
-122.6
-129.0
-135.4
-141.8
-148.3
-154.5
-160.9
-167.0
-173.1
-179.4
-185.7
-191.7
-198.0
-204.0
-210.0
-215.7
-221.2
-225.0
-225.9
-220.2
-201.7
-135.2
11.5
8.8
2.2
-5.5

6.4
13.2
19.9
25.7
31.9
37.5
44.2
49.4
55.6
60.2
77.6
82.7
89.7
96.5
100.8
111.9
116.1
121.8
127.8
133.3
138.6
144.1
149.6
155.2
160.7
166.8
172.9
178.9
185.1
191.0
197.1
202.3
207.3
212.9
218.2
221.2
221.0
214.5
195.1
128.7
-18.8
-15.6
-8.7
-0.8

7.2
14.0
20.9
34.6
42.6
50.0
64.9
73.1
83.0
90.7
88.0
94.5
102.5
109.9
114.5
128.7
133.9
141.4
149.2
156.8
164.3
171.8
179.3
186.4
193.5
199.6
205.6
211.4
217.2
222.4
227.6
232.9
237.9
241.9
245.1
246.9
245.4
237.3
215.8
144.7
-7.9
-8.4
-5.2
-0.8

-14.6
-21.5
-28.5
-42.5
-50.7
-58.2
-73.3
-81.3
-91.3
-98.9
-96.2
-102.6
-110.7
-117.9
-122.6
-136.9
-142.1
-149.7
-157.5
-165.0
-172.5
-180.1
-187.7
-194.6
-201.8
-207.7
-213.7
-219.6
-225.5
-230.6
-235.9
-241.2
-246.2
-250.1
-253.3
-255.2
-253.8
-245.5
-224.1
-152.3
-0.7
0.1
-3.2
-7.6

-3.7
-3.7
-3.7
-3.8
-3.7
-3.6
-3.5
-3.4
-3.2
-3.2
-3.0
-3.0
-2.8
-2.8
-2.7
-2.6
-2.5
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-1.9
-1.7
-1.8
-1.6
-1.8
-1.7
-1.6
-1.4
-1.5
-1.4
-1.5
-1.5
-1.7
-1.7
-1.7
-1.7
-1.8
-1.8
-1.2
-2.1
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3

-3.7
-3.8
-3.9
-4.2
-4.3
-4.5
-4.8
-4.9
-5.1
-4.9
-5.2
-5.1
-5.4
-5.2
-5.3
-5.6
-5.8
-5.9
-6.1
-6.0
-6.2
-6.4
-6.6
-6.5
-6.7
-6.3
-6.5
-6.7
-6.9
-6.7
-6.8
-6.8
-6.8
-6.6
-6.6
-6.6
-6.7
-6.5
-6.5
-6.4
-6.4
-6.0
-6.0
-6.1

4.4
9.6
14.8
25.1
31.2
36.9
48.2
54.3
61.9
67.7
65.8
70.7
76.9
82.3
85.9
96.6
100.6
106.4
112.4
118.0
123.7
129.5
135.3
140.5
146.0
150.4
155.0
159.5
163.9
167.8
171.7
175.6
179.4
182.2
184.6
186.0
184.9
178.7
162.6
109.5
-5.4
-6.0
-3.5
-0.3

4.4
9.6
14.6
24.8
30.7
36.2
47.2
53.2
60.5
66.4
64.2
69.1
74.9
80.5
83.9
94.4
98.1
103.7
109.4
115.1
120.6
126.1
131.6
137.0
142.1
147.0
151.3
155.6
159.8
163.8
167.7
171.6
175.4
178.5
180.9
182.3
181.2
175.2
159.1
105.6
-8.6
-8.8
-6.3
-3.1

-11.9
-17.1
-22.2
-32.7
-38.8
-44.3
-55.5
-61.5
-68.8
-74.5
-72.4
-77.2
-83.1
-88.5
-91.9
-102.6
-106.4
-111.9
-117.7
-123.3
-128.8
-134.4
-140.0
-145.2
-150.5
-155.1
-159.5
-163.8
-168.1
-172.0
-175.9
-179.9
-183.7
-186.8
-189.2
-190.6
-189.6
-183.4
-167.4
-113.2
0.0
0.5
-2.0
-5.3

-11.9
-17.1
-22.4
-33.0
-39.2
-45.0
-56.5
-62.6
-70.2
-75.8
-74.0
-78.8
-85.0
-90.3
-93.9
-104.8
-108.8
-114.7
-120.7
-126.2
-132.0
-137.8
-143.7
-148.8
-154.3
-158.5
-163.1
-167.7
-172.2
-175.9
-179.9
-183.9
-187.7
-190.4
-192.9
-194.3
-193.3
-186.9
-170.9
-117.1
-3.2
-2.3
-4.8
-8.1

16.6
22.1
27.5
43.6
50.1
55.9
74.1
80.8
89.0
95.1
93.4
98.8
105.0
110.2
113.6
128.3
131.8
136.9
142.3
147.5
152.4
156.8
161.5
165.9
170.3
174.0
177.4
180.6
183.2
184.0
181.8
184.0
187.0
189.3
191.1
191.9
190.2
183.5
166.8
111.9
-6.1
-6.8
-4.6
-1.7

-7.8
-3.0
1.9
6.3
11.8
17.1
21.2
26.7
33.4
39.0
36.6
41.0
46.7
52.7
56.2
62.8
66.9
73.2
79.5
85.6
91.9
98.8
105.4
111.6
117.8
123.4
128.8
134.5
140.5
147.6
157.6
163.2
167.8
171.5
174.4
176.4
175.9
170.3
154.9
103.2
-7.8
-8.0
-5.2
-1.7

0.3
-4.5
-9.5
-14.2
-19.9
-25.2
-29.6
-34.9
-41.8
-47.1
-44.8
-49.1
-54.9
-60.6
-64.2
-71.0
-75.1
-81.4
-87.8
-93.8
-100.2
-107.1
-113.8
-119.8
-126.1
-131.5
-137.0
-142.7
-148.8
-155.8
-165.8
-171.5
-176.1
-179.7
-182.7
-184.7
-184.3
-178.6
-163.2
-110.8
-0.7
-0.4
-3.1
-6.7

-24.1
-29.6
-35.1
-51.5
-58.1
-64.0
-82.5
-89.1
-97.3
-103.2
-101.6
-106.9
-113.2
-118.1
-121.6
-136.4
-140.1
-145.2
-150.6
-155.7
-160.6
-165.1
-169.8
-174.2
-178.6
-182.1
-185.6
-188.8
-191.5
-192.2
-190.0
-192.3
-195.3
-197.5
-199.4
-200.2
-198.6
-191.8
-175.1
-119.5
-2.5
-1.5
-3.7
-6.7

31.4
32.4
33.1
49.7
51.2
52.1
72.3
74.3
76.4
77.2
78.4
79.8
80.7
79.6
79.5
91.2
90.5
89.0
87.7
86.4
84.5
81.0
78.4
75.9
73.3
70.5
67.8
64.4
59.4
50.4
32.9
27.8
25.6
23.5
21.8
20.1
18.4
16.7
14.8
10.8
-0.1
-1.1
-1.9
-2.7

-38.8
-39.8
-40.6
-57.4
-58.8
-59.5
-79.7
-81.4
-83.3
-84.0
-85.0
-86.3
-86.9
-85.8
-85.6
-97.1
-96.3
-94.5
-93.1
-91.7
-89.6
-85.9
-83.1
-80.6
-77.8
-75.3
-72.3
-68.8
-63.7
-54.6
-37.1
-32.1
-30.0
-28.1
-26.4
-24.8
-23.0
-21.4
-19.5
-14.5
-5.2
-4.4
-3.6
-2.9

31.4
32.3
33.0
49.4
50.8
51.4
71.3
73.2
74.9
75.9
76.8
78.2
78.8
77.8
77.5
89.0
88.1
86.2
84.8
83.5
81.3
77.6
74.7
72.4
69.5
67.2
64.2
60.5
55.4
46.5
28.9
23.8
21.6
19.8
18.1
16.4
14.7
13.2
11.2
6.9
-3.4
-3.9
-4.7
-5.5

-38.8
-39.9
-40.7
-57.6
-59.3
-60.2
-80.7
-82.5
-84.7
-85.3
-86.6
-87.9
-88.9
-87.5
-87.6
-99.4
-98.8
-97.2
-96.1
-94.6
-92.8
-89.3
-86.8
-84.2
-81.6
-78.7
-75.9
-72.6
-67.7
-58.6
-41.1
-36.1
-33.9
-31.7
-30.0
-28.4
-26.7
-24.9
-23.1
-18.4
-8.4
-7.2
-6.4
-5.7

37.9
42.8
47.4
72.0
78.1
83.1
112.0
118.5
126.2
131.4
131.0
136.1
141.5
144.4
147.0
166.8
169.0
171.6
174.7
177.6
179.9
180.6
182.2
183.6
184.9
185.6
186.1
186.0
184.2
178.0
163.3
161.1
161.7
161.8
161.9
161.2
158.6
152.3
138.3
94.1
-2.5
-3.8
-2.8
-1.2

19.6
23.9
28.2
44.0
49.4
54.0
72.3
77.8
84.5
89.3
88.3
92.7
97.7
101.3
103.9
117.7
120.3
123.8
127.6
131.2
134.5
137.1
140.1
142.8
145.6
147.6
149.6
151.3
152.2
150.7
145.0
145.5
147.3
148.4
149.4
149.6
147.9
142.4
129.5
87.5
-3.8
-4.7
-3.3
-1.2

25.7
22.8
19.7
28.6
25.6
22.2
34.2
31.6
28.1
24.6
27.3
25.1
21.4
16.2
13.5
17.2
13.6
7.7
2.1
-3.5
-9.7
-17.5
-24.5
-30.9
-37.6
-43.7
-49.9
-56.7
-65.0
-77.1
-97.7
-105.8
-110.9
-115.2
-118.7
-121.5
-122.4
-119.5
-109.4
-73.1
1.5
1.0
-1.7
-5.0

7.3
3.9
0.4
0.7
-3.2
-7.0
-5.5
-9.1
-13.6
-17.5
-15.4
-18.3
-22.3
-27.0
-29.6
-31.9
-35.1
-40.1
-45.1
-50.0
-55.1
-61.0
-66.5
-71.7
-76.9
-81.7
-86.4
-91.4
-97.0
-104.4
-115.9
-121.4
-125.3
-128.6
-131.2
-133.1
-133.2
-129.4
-118.2
-79.7
0.2
0.1
-2.2
-5.0

-14.7
-11.4
-7.9
-8.4
-4.5
-0.7
-2.1
1.6
6.4
10.3
8.4
11.4
15.6
20.3
23.0
25.4
28.7
33.9
39.0
43.9
49.2
55.3
60.9
66.1
71.5
76.1
81.0
86.0
91.8
99.2
110.7
116.1
120.0
123.1
125.7
127.5
127.6
123.7
112.6
75.1
-6.3
-6.3
-4.1
-1.3

37.9
42.8
47.3
71.8
77.7
82.6
111.3
117.7
125.1
130.4
129.8
134.9
140.0
143.1
145.5
165.1
167.1
169.6
172.5
175.5
177.5
178.0
179.4
180.9
182.1
183.0
183.4
183.1
181.2
175.1
160.2
158.1
158.7
159.1
159.1
158.5
155.9
149.7
135.7
91.1
-4.9
-5.9
-4.9
-3.3

-14.7
-11.4
-8.0
-8.6
-4.8
-1.2
-2.9
0.8
5.3
9.4
7.2
10.2
14.2
19.0
21.6
23.7
26.9
31.9
36.8
41.8
46.8
52.7
58.2
63.4
68.6
73.6
78.2
83.1
88.7
96.2
107.7
113.1
117.0
120.3
123.0
124.8
124.8
121.1
109.9
72.1
-8.8
-8.5
-6.2
-3.4

-45.3
-50.3
-55.0
-79.9
-86.1
-91.2
-120.4
-126.8
-134.5
-139.5
-139.2
-144.2
-149.6
-152.4
-155.0
-174.9
-177.2
-179.9
-183.1
-185.9
-188.2
-188.9
-190.5
-191.9
-193.2
-193.7
-194.3
-194.2
-192.5
-186.2
-171.5
-169.4
-170.0
-170.0
-170.1
-169.5
-167.0
-160.6
-146.7
-101.7
-6.1
-4.5
-5.5
-7.2

-27.0
-31.4
-35.8
-52.0
-57.4
-62.1
-80.7
-86.1
-92.8
-97.4
-96.5
-100.8
-105.9
-109.2
-111.9
-125.8
-128.5
-132.0
-135.9
-139.4
-142.8
-145.4
-148.5
-151.1
-153.9
-155.7
-157.8
-159.5
-160.5
-158.8
-153.3
-153.8
-155.6
-156.6
-157.6
-157.9
-156.3
-150.7
-137.8
-95.1
-4.7
-3.6
-5.1
-7.2

-33.1
-30.3
-27.3
-36.6
-33.6
-30.3
-42.6
-39.9
-36.4
-32.8
-35.5
-33.2
-29.6
-24.2
-21.5
-25.4
-21.8
-16.0
-10.4
-4.7
1.4
9.2
16.1
22.6
29.3
35.6
41.8
48.5
56.7
68.9
89.5
97.5
102.5
106.9
110.5
113.2
114.0
111.2
101.0
65.5
-10.1
-9.3
-6.6
-3.4

-33.1
-30.3
-27.2
-36.3
-33.2
-29.8
-41.8
-39.0
-35.3
-31.8
-34.3
-32.0
-28.1
-22.9
-20.0
-23.7
-20.0
-14.0
-8.1
-2.5
3.8
11.8
18.8
25.3
32.1
38.2
44.5
51.4
59.8
71.8
92.5
100.5
105.5
109.7
113.2
115.9
116.8
113.8
103.7
68.5
-7.7
-7.2
-4.5
-1.3

7.3
3.9
0.3
0.4
-3.5
-7.5
-6.3
-9.9
-14.7
-18.4
-16.6
-19.5
-23.8
-28.3
-31.1
-33.6
-37.0
-42.2
-47.3
-52.1
-57.5
-63.6
-69.3
-74.4
-79.8
-84.2
-89.1
-94.3
-100.1
-107.3
-118.9
-124.4
-128.3
-131.3
-134.0
-135.9
-136.0
-132.0
-120.9
-82.6
-2.2
-2.0
-4.3
-7.1

-45.3
-50.3
-54.9
-79.7
-85.8
-90.7
-119.7
-125.9
-133.5
-138.5
-138.0
-143.0
-148.2
-151.1
-153.5
-173.3
-175.4
-177.9
-180.8
-183.7
-185.8
-186.3
-187.8
-189.2
-190.4
-191.2
-191.6
-191.3
-189.4
-183.2
-168.4
-166.3
-167.0
-167.3
-167.4
-166.8
-164.3
-158.0
-144.0
-98.7
-3.6
-2.4
-3.4
-5.1

19.6
23.9
28.1
43.8
49.0
53.4
71.6
77.0
83.4
88.3
87.1
91.5
96.3
99.9
102.4
116.0
118.4
121.7
125.4
129.0
132.1
134.5
137.3
140.2
142.7
145.1
146.9
148.4
149.1
147.7
142.0
142.5
144.3
145.7
146.6
146.8
145.1
139.8
126.8
84.6
-6.3
-6.8
-5.4
-3.3

-27.0
-31.4
-35.7
-51.8
-57.0
-61.6
-79.9
-85.3
-91.8
-96.4
-95.3
-99.6
-104.4
-107.9
-110.5
-124.1
-126.6
-130.0
-133.7
-137.2
-140.4
-142.8
-145.7
-148.4
-151.0
-153.2
-155.1
-156.7
-157.4
-155.9
-150.2
-150.8
-152.6
-153.9
-154.9
-155.1
-153.5
-148.1
-135.1
-92.1
-2.3
-1.5
-3.0
-5.1

25.7
22.7
19.5
28.4
25.2
21.7
33.5
30.8
27.0
23.7
26.1
23.9
20.0
14.9
12.0
15.6
11.8
5.7
-0.2
-5.7
-12.1
-20.1
-27.2
-33.6
-40.5
-46.3
-52.6
-59.6
-68.0
-80.0
-100.7
-108.8
-113.9
-117.9
-121.5
-124.2
-125.2
-122.1
-112.0
-76.1
-0.9
-1.1
-3.8
-7.1

8.1
15.0
21.8
35.6
43.6
51.1
66.0
74.1
84.0
91.7
89.0
95.5
103.6
110.9
115.5
129.8
134.9
142.5
150.2
157.8
165.3
172.8
180.4
187.4
194.5
200.6
206.6
212.4
218.2
223.5
228.7
233.9
239.0
242.9
246.1
247.9
246.5
238.3
216.9
145.6
-6.8
-7.4
-4.1
0.2

-13.6
-20.6
-27.5
-41.5
-49.7
-57.1
-72.3
-80.3
-90.3
-97.8
-95.2
-101.6
-109.7
-116.9
-121.6
-135.9
-141.1
-148.7
-156.5
-164.0
-171.5
-179.0
-186.6
-193.6
-200.7
-206.7
-212.7
-218.6
-224.4
-229.6
-234.8
-240.1
-245.2
-249.1
-252.3
-254.2
-252.8
-244.5
-223.1
-151.3
0.4
1.2
-2.2
-6.5

SpecY
271.59
280.71
286.68
415.46
427.41
431.89
586.98
599.00
613.63
617.75
624.61
633.54
638.57
627.87
626.17
712.72
706.29
693.27
682.82
671.82
656.59
630.08
609.97
590.97
570.74
550.31
529.28
503.77
466.90
399.42
268.49
230.90
214.66
199.43
186.82
174.57
161.85
149.37
135.28
101.49
22.95
16.03
9.80
3.79

Page 4 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead

Live

-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Dead
-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Live

-4.11
-8.38
-12.63
-16.08
-20.02
-23.55
-27.33
-30.57
-34.42
-37.24
-47.30
-50.40
-54.64
-58.75
-61.38
-67.81
-70.49
-74.29
-78.25
-81.96
-85.63
-89.34
-93.11
-96.78
-100.52
-104.31
-108.12
-111.97
-115.87
-119.62
-123.49
-126.97
-130.39
-133.95
-137.32
-139.44
-139.64
-135.86
-124.02
-82.47
9.44
7.65
3.39
-1.49

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A30

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

6.79
11.11
15.41
24.09
29.16
33.81
43.20
48.24
54.47
59.24
57.57
61.60
66.64
71.16
74.10
83.01
86.23
90.97
95.85
100.55
105.24
109.95
114.69
119.06
123.51
127.28
131.03
134.71
138.33
141.58
144.84
148.13
151.30
153.73
155.74
156.91
156.02
150.87
137.49
92.81
-2.23
-2.68
-0.61
2.10

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.49
-9.79
-11.52
-11.93
-12.12
-15.30
-15.58
-15.80
-15.75
-21.11
-21.21
-21.19
-20.69
-20.53
-23.30
-23.02
-22.55
-22.20
-21.89
-21.41
-20.51
-19.90
-19.34
-18.74
-18.11
-17.45
-16.63
-15.39
-12.98
-8.12
-6.91
-6.52
-6.09
-5.75
-5.45
-5.14
-4.83
-4.46
-3.35
-0.58
-0.39
-0.21
-0.05

WindMTX
10.17
10.47
10.69
15.53
15.95
16.18
22.04
22.57
23.14
23.37
23.67
24.07
24.29
23.95
23.91
27.27
27.05
26.56
26.17
25.78
25.19
24.15
23.36
22.64
21.85
21.08
20.25
19.24
17.78
15.17
10.10
8.65
8.02
7.43
6.94
6.46
5.96
5.48
4.93
3.64
0.73
0.48
0.25
0.02

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.27
-28.13
-33.09
-34.27
-34.82
-43.97
-44.79
-45.41
-45.26
-60.69
-60.98
-60.94
-59.52
-59.05
-67.04
-66.25
-64.89
-63.90
-63.01
-61.65
-59.08
-57.31
-55.72
-54.01
-52.21
-50.30
-47.95
-44.39
-37.44
-23.46
-19.97
-18.83
-17.60
-16.62
-15.78
-14.89
-14.00
-12.92
-9.71
-1.66
-1.12
-0.62
-0.14

-0.2
-0.2
-0.2
0.0
-0.3
-0.8
-1.2
-1.9
-2.6
-3.5
-5.2
-6.6
-8.2
-10.0
-11.9
-14.4
-15.5
-15.0
-14.5
-13.2
-11.6
-9.9
-7.9
-6.4
-4.5
-4.7
-4.5
-4.1
-3.6
-3.5
-3.2
-1.4
0.4
0.0
-0.3
0.8
2.0
2.8
3.9
4.0
2.5
1.2
0.0
-1.2

-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.1
0.1
0.5
2.1
2.9
3.7
4.8
9.1
10.7
12.6
14.9
17.2
21.1
22.2
20.9
19.7
17.5
14.9
12.1
9.1
7.0
4.3
4.5
4.2
3.6
2.9
2.8
2.3
-0.3
-3.0
-2.8
-2.7
-4.7
-6.9
-8.5
-10.5
-10.4
-9.7
-8.0
-6.5
-5.1

-5.1
-10.3
-15.4
-19.3
-24.3
-28.9
-33.5
-37.9
-43.1
-47.1
-60.2
-64.9
-71.2
-77.4
-81.9
-91.3
-95.4
-99.7
-104.1
-107.7
-111.1
-114.3
-117.5
-120.8
-124.0
-128.7
-133.1
-137.5
-141.8
-146.2
-150.7
-153.6
-156.5
-161.1
-165.4
-167.2
-166.7
-161.6
-146.8
-96.8
12.3
9.2
3.3
-3.4

-5.1
-10.3
-15.5
-19.4
-24.0
-27.9
-31.1
-34.4
-38.4
-40.9
-49.5
-51.9
-55.5
-58.7
-60.1
-64.7
-67.1
-72.7
-78.5
-84.7
-91.2
-97.8
-104.7
-110.8
-117.4
-121.8
-126.7
-131.7
-136.9
-141.5
-146.6
-152.8
-159.1
-163.2
-167.2
-171.3
-173.4
-170.1
-157.5
-107.5
3.1
2.3
-1.7
-6.4

4.7
9.8
14.9
19.3
23.8
27.6
32.1
35.4
39.5
42.2
53.3
56.1
60.0
63.6
65.4
71.4
73.8
78.6
83.7
88.9
94.4
100.1
106.0
111.4
117.2
121.7
126.4
131.2
136.2
140.8
145.7
151.1
156.4
160.4
164.2
167.4
168.5
164.4
150.9
101.1
-10.4
-9.1
-4.9
0.1

4.8
9.8
14.8
19.2
24.1
28.6
34.5
39.0
44.2
48.5
64.0
69.1
75.6
82.3
87.2
98.1
102.0
105.6
109.3
112.0
114.3
116.6
118.7
121.5
123.8
128.5
132.8
137.0
141.2
145.5
149.8
151.9
153.9
158.3
162.4
163.3
161.8
155.9
140.1
90.4
-19.5
-16.0
-9.8
-2.9

-16.1
-21.7
-27.2
-33.1
-38.4
-42.9
-50.7
-54.9
-59.7
-62.9
-80.2
-83.8
-88.8
-92.9
-95.7
-106.0
-108.9
-113.3
-118.0
-122.5
-126.8
-130.7
-135.0
-139.0
-143.2
-147.0
-150.8
-154.5
-157.9
-159.5
-158.4
-161.5
-165.6
-169.4
-173.2
-175.8
-176.2
-171.7
-157.5
-106.2
7.0
5.3
0.5
-5.0

5.9
1.1
-3.7
-5.5
-9.8
-13.9
-14.0
-17.5
-21.8
-25.1
-29.5
-32.9
-37.9
-43.2
-46.4
-50.0
-53.6
-59.1
-64.7
-70.0
-75.4
-81.5
-87.2
-92.6
-98.2
-103.5
-109.0
-114.6
-120.9
-128.3
-138.9
-144.9
-150.0
-154.8
-159.4
-162.7
-163.8
-160.1
-146.8
-98.2
8.4
6.2
1.1
-4.9

-6.2
-1.6
3.1
5.4
9.6
13.6
14.9
18.5
22.9
26.5
33.4
37.1
42.4
48.1
51.7
56.8
60.3
65.0
69.8
74.2
78.7
83.7
88.5
93.2
98.0
103.4
108.7
114.2
120.2
127.6
138.0
143.2
147.3
152.0
156.4
158.8
158.9
154.4
140.2
91.7
-15.7
-13.0
-7.6
-1.4

15.7
21.2
26.6
33.1
38.2
42.6
51.6
55.9
60.8
64.2
84.0
88.0
93.2
97.8
100.9
112.7
115.5
119.1
123.1
126.7
130.1
133.0
136.2
139.6
143.0
146.8
150.5
154.1
157.2
158.8
157.5
159.8
163.0
166.7
170.2
171.9
171.3
166.0
150.9
99.8
-14.3
-12.1
-7.1
-1.3

-31.8
-32.9
-34.0
-39.7
-41.4
-42.4
-53.5
-55.0
-56.3
-56.8
-76.2
-77.6
-78.7
-78.3
-79.1
-90.4
-90.3
-88.4
-86.9
-85.0
-82.3
-78.0
-74.5
-71.6
-68.2
-66.2
-63.7
-60.7
-56.1
-47.6
-30.7
-25.2
-22.6
-21.5
-20.5
-18.8
-17.0
-15.4
-13.4
-9.5
-1.1
-1.3
-1.6
-1.8

31.4
32.5
33.5
39.7
40.9
41.1
52.0
52.5
52.6
51.9
69.4
68.8
67.5
64.6
62.6
70.5
68.7
67.4
66.4
66.2
65.7
63.8
63.0
62.1
61.4
59.1
57.0
54.4
50.5
42.2
25.6
22.7
22.5
20.8
19.3
19.1
18.8
18.2
17.6
13.8
2.9
1.4
-0.1
-1.5

-31.7
-33.0
-34.1
-39.8
-41.1
-41.4
-51.1
-51.4
-51.6
-50.5
-65.5
-64.6
-63.1
-59.7
-57.3
-63.8
-62.1
-61.5
-61.3
-61.9
-62.4
-61.5
-61.8
-61.5
-61.6
-59.3
-57.3
-54.9
-51.1
-42.9
-26.5
-24.4
-25.2
-23.6
-22.3
-22.9
-23.7
-23.9
-24.2
-20.2
-10.2
-8.2
-6.5
-4.8

31.4
32.5
33.4
39.6
41.2
42.1
54.5
56.1
57.4
58.1
80.1
81.8
83.2
83.2
84.4
97.1
96.9
94.3
92.1
89.3
85.6
80.3
75.8
72.2
68.0
66.0
63.4
60.2
55.4
46.9
29.8
23.5
20.0
18.7
17.6
14.9
12.1
9.7
6.8
3.1
-6.2
-5.5
-5.0
-4.5

-35.8
-40.9
-45.8
-54.7
-59.9
-64.0
-78.5
-82.7
-87.4
-90.2
-118.4
-122.2
-126.8
-129.7
-132.5
-149.1
-151.2
-152.8
-155.1
-156.8
-157.8
-157.2
-157.6
-158.2
-158.6
-160.0
-161.0
-161.4
-160.4
-155.3
-141.7
-139.7
-140.7
-142.6
-144.7
-145.1
-143.8
-139.0
-126.6
-85.2
6.3
4.7
0.9
-3.5

-19.3
-23.8
-28.2
-33.9
-38.4
-42.2
-50.9
-54.7
-58.9
-61.8
-80.3
-84.0
-88.7
-92.4
-95.5
-107.1
-109.7
-112.2
-115.1
-117.4
-119.2
-120.3
-121.7
-123.4
-124.9
-127.3
-129.6
-131.5
-132.7
-131.9
-127.0
-127.3
-128.9
-131.6
-134.3
-135.3
-134.5
-130.3
-118.6
-79.2
7.3
5.4
1.3
-3.5

-28.4
-25.8
-23.0
-25.7
-23.8
-21.6
-29.2
-27.7
-25.4
-23.1
-33.2
-31.4
-28.4
-23.9
-21.9
-26.9
-24.2
-19.0
-14.1
-9.2
-3.5
3.7
10.2
16.1
22.4
28.0
33.8
40.3
48.3
60.2
80.8
89.0
94.3
98.7
102.7
106.1
107.8
105.8
96.8
63.4
-10.7
-9.1
-5.2
-0.9

-11.9
-8.7
-5.4
-5.0
-2.3
0.2
-1.6
0.4
3.1
5.3
4.9
6.8
9.8
13.4
15.0
15.1
17.3
21.6
25.9
30.3
35.0
40.7
46.0
50.9
56.2
60.6
65.2
70.2
76.1
83.6
95.4
101.5
106.0
109.7
113.1
115.9
117.1
114.5
104.8
69.4
-9.7
-8.4
-4.8
-0.8

11.6
8.2
4.9
4.9
1.9
-1.3
0.8
-2.0
-5.6
-8.6
-9.0
-12.4
-17.1
-22.5
-26.1
-28.3
-31.8
-35.9
-40.0
-43.3
-46.7
-50.8
-54.3
-57.9
-61.3
-65.9
-70.4
-75.1
-80.4
-87.8
-99.4
-103.8
-106.7
-110.9
-114.7
-116.7
-117.0
-113.8
-103.4
-67.7
9.3
6.7
2.0
-3.3

-35.8
-40.9
-45.9
-54.7
-59.6
-63.3
-76.6
-80.0
-83.8
-85.5
-110.3
-112.5
-115.1
-115.7
-116.1
-129.1
-130.0
-132.6
-135.9
-139.5
-142.8
-144.8
-148.0
-150.7
-153.7
-154.8
-156.1
-157.1
-156.7
-151.8
-138.6
-139.2
-142.6
-144.2
-146.0
-148.2
-148.8
-145.4
-134.7
-93.3
-0.6
-0.4
-2.8
-5.8

11.6
8.2
4.8
4.9
2.1
-0.5
2.6
0.6
-2.0
-4.0
-1.0
-2.6
-5.3
-8.5
-9.8
-8.3
-10.6
-15.7
-20.7
-26.0
-31.8
-38.4
-44.7
-50.3
-56.4
-60.7
-65.5
-70.7
-76.8
-84.3
-96.3
-103.2
-108.7
-112.5
-116.1
-119.8
-122.0
-120.2
-111.4
-75.8
2.4
1.6
-1.7
-5.5

35.5
40.4
45.2
54.6
59.7
63.7
79.4
83.8
88.5
91.5
122.2
126.4
131.3
134.6
137.8
155.8
157.8
158.7
160.2
161.1
161.1
159.5
158.8
158.9
158.4
159.8
160.7
161.0
159.7
154.6
140.8
138.0
138.0
139.8
141.7
141.2
138.9
133.3
120.0
78.8
-13.6
-11.5
-7.4
-2.8

19.0
23.3
27.6
33.9
38.2
41.9
51.8
55.7
60.0
63.1
84.2
88.2
93.1
97.4
100.8
113.9
116.4
118.1
120.2
121.7
122.5
122.5
123.0
124.0
124.7
127.2
129.3
131.0
132.0
131.2
126.2
125.6
126.3
128.9
131.3
131.4
129.6
124.6
112.0
72.8
-14.6
-12.2
-7.8
-2.8

28.1
25.3
22.4
25.6
23.6
21.3
30.2
28.7
26.5
24.4
37.0
35.6
32.9
28.8
27.2
33.7
30.8
24.9
19.3
13.4
6.8
-1.5
-8.9
-15.5
-22.6
-28.1
-34.1
-40.7
-49.0
-60.9
-81.7
-90.7
-96.9
-101.5
-105.7
-110.0
-112.7
-111.4
-103.4
-69.8
3.4
2.3
-1.3
-5.4

28.1
25.3
22.5
25.7
23.4
20.5
28.3
26.0
22.9
19.7
29.0
25.9
21.1
14.8
10.8
13.7
9.6
4.7
0.0
-3.9
-8.1
-13.8
-18.5
-23.0
-27.6
-33.3
-38.9
-45.1
-52.7
-64.5
-84.8
-91.3
-95.0
-99.9
-104.4
-106.9
-107.7
-105.1
-95.3
-61.7
10.3
7.4
2.4
-3.2

-11.9
-8.7
-5.5
-5.0
-2.1
1.0
0.2
3.1
6.7
9.9
12.9
16.5
21.5
27.4
31.4
35.1
38.5
41.8
45.1
47.6
50.0
53.1
55.6
58.5
61.1
65.8
70.1
74.6
79.8
87.1
98.5
102.0
104.1
108.1
111.8
112.8
112.1
108.1
96.7
61.3
-16.6
-13.5
-8.5
-3.0

35.5
40.4
45.3
54.6
59.4
63.0
77.6
81.1
84.9
86.8
114.2
116.7
119.6
120.6
121.4
135.8
136.6
138.5
141.0
143.8
146.1
147.1
149.3
151.3
153.5
154.7
155.9
156.6
156.0
151.1
137.7
137.4
139.9
141.4
143.0
144.3
143.9
139.7
128.1
86.9
-6.7
-6.4
-3.7
-0.5

-19.3
-23.8
-28.3
-34.0
-38.1
-41.4
-49.1
-52.0
-55.4
-57.1
-72.3
-74.3
-76.9
-78.5
-79.2
-87.1
-88.5
-92.0
-95.9
-100.1
-104.3
-107.9
-112.2
-115.9
-119.9
-122.2
-124.7
-127.1
-129.0
-128.4
-123.9
-126.7
-130.8
-133.2
-135.6
-138.4
-139.5
-136.7
-126.7
-87.3
0.5
0.2
-2.4
-5.7

-2.8
-2.8
-2.8
-2.8
-2.7
-2.6
-2.5
-2.4
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-1.9
-1.8
-1.8
-1.7
-1.6
-1.4
-1.3
-1.1
-1.1
-1.0
-0.8
-0.7
-0.7
-0.6
-0.8
-0.7
-0.5
-0.4
-0.5
-0.4
-0.4
-0.5
-0.6
-0.7
-0.7
-0.7
-0.8
-0.8
-0.2
-1.1
-1.2
-1.3
-1.3

-2.8
-2.9
-3.0
-3.2
-3.3
-3.5
-3.8
-3.8
-4.1
-3.9
-4.1
-4.1
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.5
-4.7
-4.9
-5.1
-5.0
-5.2
-5.4
-5.6
-5.5
-5.7
-5.3
-5.5
-5.6
-5.8
-5.7
-5.8
-5.8
-5.8
-5.5
-5.5
-5.6
-5.6
-5.4
-5.5
-5.5
-5.4
-5.0
-5.0
-5.0

5.4
10.5
15.7
26.1
32.2
37.9
49.2
55.3
63.0
68.7
66.8
71.7
77.9
83.3
86.9
97.7
101.6
107.4
113.4
119.0
124.8
130.5
136.3
141.6
147.0
151.4
156.0
160.5
164.9
168.8
172.7
176.7
180.4
183.2
185.6
187.0
185.9
179.7
163.6
110.5
-4.3
-4.9
-2.5
0.8

5.4
10.5
15.6
25.8
31.7
37.2
48.2
54.2
61.5
67.4
65.2
70.1
75.9
81.5
84.9
95.4
99.2
104.7
110.4
116.1
121.6
127.1
132.6
138.0
143.2
148.0
152.4
156.6
160.9
164.9
168.7
172.6
176.4
179.6
182.0
183.3
182.2
176.2
160.1
106.5
-7.5
-7.7
-5.3
-2.0

-10.9
-16.1
-21.3
-31.7
-37.8
-43.3
-54.5
-60.4
-67.8
-73.5
-71.4
-76.1
-82.1
-87.5
-90.9
-101.6
-105.3
-110.9
-116.7
-122.3
-127.8
-133.3
-138.9
-144.2
-149.4
-154.1
-158.5
-162.8
-167.1
-171.0
-174.9
-178.9
-182.7
-185.7
-188.2
-189.6
-188.5
-182.4
-166.3
-112.2
1.1
1.5
-1.0
-4.3

-10.9
-16.2
-21.4
-32.0
-38.2
-44.0
-55.5
-61.5
-69.2
-74.8
-73.0
-77.8
-84.0
-89.3
-92.9
-103.8
-107.8
-113.6
-119.6
-125.2
-131.0
-136.8
-142.6
-147.7
-153.2
-157.5
-162.1
-166.7
-171.1
-174.9
-178.9
-182.9
-186.7
-189.4
-191.8
-193.3
-192.2
-185.9
-169.9
-116.2
-2.2
-1.3
-3.8
-7.1

17.6
23.1
28.5
44.6
51.1
56.9
75.2
81.9
90.0
96.1
94.4
99.8
106.1
111.1
114.6
129.3
132.9
137.9
143.3
148.5
153.4
157.8
162.5
166.9
171.3
175.0
178.5
181.7
184.2
185.0
182.8
185.0
188.1
190.3
192.1
192.9
191.2
184.5
167.8
112.9
-5.0
-5.8
-3.6
-0.6

-6.8
-2.0
2.8
7.3
12.8
18.1
22.2
27.7
34.5
40.0
37.6
42.0
47.8
53.7
57.2
63.8
67.9
74.2
80.5
86.7
93.0
99.8
106.5
112.6
118.9
124.4
129.9
135.5
141.5
148.6
158.6
164.3
168.8
172.5
175.5
177.4
176.9
171.4
155.9
104.2
-6.8
-6.9
-4.2
-0.6

1.3
-3.6
-8.5
-13.2
-18.9
-24.2
-28.5
-33.9
-40.7
-46.1
-43.8
-48.1
-53.9
-59.6
-63.2
-69.9
-74.1
-80.4
-86.7
-92.8
-99.2
-106.1
-112.7
-118.8
-125.1
-130.5
-136.0
-141.6
-147.8
-154.7
-164.8
-170.5
-175.1
-178.6
-181.7
-183.7
-183.2
-177.6
-162.2
-109.8
0.3
0.7
-2.1
-5.7

-23.1
-28.7
-34.2
-50.5
-57.1
-63.0
-81.4
-88.1
-96.3
-102.2
-100.6
-105.8
-112.2
-117.1
-120.6
-135.4
-139.0
-144.1
-149.6
-154.7
-159.6
-164.0
-168.8
-173.1
-177.5
-181.1
-184.6
-187.8
-190.4
-191.2
-189.0
-191.2
-194.3
-196.5
-198.3
-199.2
-197.5
-190.7
-174.0
-118.6
-1.4
-0.5
-2.7
-5.7

32.3
33.3
34.1
50.7
52.2
53.1
73.4
75.3
77.4
78.2
79.4
80.8
81.7
80.6
80.5
92.2
91.6
90.0
88.8
87.4
85.5
82.1
79.5
77.0
74.3
71.6
68.8
65.4
60.5
51.4
33.9
28.9
26.7
24.5
22.8
21.1
19.4
17.7
15.8
11.8
0.9
0.0
-0.9
-1.7

-37.8
-38.9
-39.6
-56.4
-57.8
-58.5
-78.7
-80.4
-82.2
-83.0
-84.0
-85.3
-85.9
-84.8
-84.6
-96.1
-95.3
-93.5
-92.0
-90.7
-88.6
-84.9
-82.0
-79.6
-76.8
-74.3
-71.3
-67.7
-62.6
-53.6
-36.1
-31.1
-28.9
-27.0
-25.4
-23.7
-22.0
-20.4
-18.5
-13.5
-4.1
-3.4
-2.6
-1.8

32.3
33.3
33.9
50.4
51.8
52.4
72.4
74.2
76.0
76.9
77.8
79.2
79.8
78.8
78.6
90.0
89.1
87.3
85.8
84.5
82.4
78.6
75.8
73.4
70.5
68.2
65.2
61.6
56.4
47.5
29.9
24.8
22.7
20.9
19.1
17.5
15.7
14.2
12.3
7.8
-2.3
-2.8
-3.7
-4.5

-37.8
-38.9
-39.8
-56.7
-58.3
-59.2
-79.7
-81.5
-83.6
-84.3
-85.5
-86.9
-87.9
-86.5
-86.6
-98.3
-97.7
-96.2
-95.0
-93.6
-91.7
-88.3
-85.7
-83.1
-80.6
-77.6
-74.9
-71.6
-66.7
-57.5
-40.1
-35.1
-32.9
-30.7
-29.0
-27.4
-25.7
-23.9
-22.1
-17.5
-7.4
-6.2
-5.4
-4.6

38.8
43.7
48.4
73.0
79.1
84.1
113.1
119.5
127.2
132.4
132.0
137.1
142.5
145.4
148.0
167.8
170.0
172.7
175.8
178.7
180.9
181.6
183.2
184.6
186.0
186.6
187.1
187.0
185.3
179.0
164.3
162.1
162.7
162.8
162.9
162.2
159.7
153.4
139.4
95.0
-1.5
-2.8
-1.8
-0.1

20.5
24.9
29.1
45.0
50.4
55.0
73.4
78.9
85.5
90.3
89.4
93.7
98.7
102.3
104.9
118.7
121.3
124.8
128.6
132.2
135.5
138.1
141.1
143.9
146.6
148.6
150.7
152.3
153.2
151.7
146.1
146.5
148.3
149.4
150.4
150.6
149.0
143.5
130.5
88.5
-2.8
-3.6
-2.2
-0.2

26.6
23.7
20.6
29.6
26.6
23.2
35.3
32.6
29.1
25.6
28.3
26.1
22.5
17.2
14.5
18.3
14.7
8.8
3.1
-2.5
-8.7
-16.5
-23.4
-29.9
-36.6
-42.7
-48.9
-55.7
-64.0
-76.0
-96.7
-104.8
-109.8
-114.1
-117.7
-120.4
-121.4
-118.5
-108.3
-72.2
2.6
2.1
-0.7
-3.9

8.3
4.9
1.4
1.6
-2.2
-5.9
-4.5
-8.0
-12.6
-16.5
-14.4
-17.2
-21.3
-26.0
-28.6
-30.9
-34.1
-39.1
-44.1
-48.9
-54.1
-60.0
-65.5
-70.6
-75.9
-80.7
-85.4
-90.3
-96.0
-103.4
-114.9
-120.3
-124.3
-127.5
-130.2
-132.1
-132.1
-128.3
-117.2
-78.7
1.2
1.2
-1.1
-4.0

-13.8
-10.5
-6.9
-7.4
-3.5
0.4
-1.1
2.7
7.4
11.3
9.4
12.4
16.6
21.3
24.0
26.4
29.8
34.9
40.1
45.0
50.2
56.3
62.0
67.1
72.5
77.1
82.0
87.1
92.8
100.2
111.7
117.1
121.0
124.1
126.7
128.6
128.6
124.7
113.6
76.0
-5.3
-5.3
-3.1
-0.2

38.8
43.7
48.3
72.8
78.8
83.6
112.3
118.7
126.2
131.4
130.8
135.9
141.1
144.1
146.5
166.1
168.2
170.6
173.5
176.5
178.5
179.0
180.4
182.0
183.1
184.1
184.4
184.1
182.2
176.1
161.2
159.1
159.7
160.1
160.1
159.5
156.9
150.7
136.7
92.1
-3.9
-4.9
-3.9
-2.2

-13.8
-10.5
-7.1
-7.6
-3.8
-0.1
-1.8
1.8
6.3
10.4
8.2
11.2
15.2
20.0
22.6
24.8
27.9
32.9
37.8
42.8
47.9
53.7
59.2
64.5
69.7
74.6
79.3
84.2
89.8
97.2
108.7
114.1
118.0
121.4
124.0
125.8
125.8
122.1
111.0
73.0
-7.7
-7.4
-5.2
-2.3

-44.4
-49.4
-54.1
-79.0
-85.1
-90.2
-119.4
-125.7
-133.5
-138.5
-138.2
-143.2
-148.6
-151.4
-154.0
-173.9
-176.2
-178.9
-182.0
-184.8
-187.1
-187.9
-189.5
-190.8
-192.2
-192.7
-193.3
-193.2
-191.5
-185.2
-170.4
-168.3
-169.0
-169.0
-169.1
-168.5
-166.0
-159.6
-145.6
-100.7
-5.0
-3.5
-4.5
-6.2

-26.1
-30.5
-34.8
-51.0
-56.4
-61.1
-79.6
-85.1
-91.8
-96.4
-95.5
-99.8
-104.9
-108.2
-110.9
-124.8
-127.4
-131.0
-134.9
-138.4
-141.7
-144.3
-147.4
-150.0
-152.8
-154.7
-156.8
-158.5
-159.4
-157.8
-152.2
-152.8
-154.6
-155.6
-156.6
-156.9
-155.2
-149.7
-136.7
-94.2
-3.7
-2.6
-4.1
-6.1

-32.1
-29.4
-26.3
-35.6
-32.6
-29.3
-41.5
-38.8
-35.3
-31.7
-34.4
-32.2
-28.6
-23.2
-20.5
-24.4
-20.8
-15.0
-9.3
-3.7
2.5
10.2
17.1
23.7
30.3
36.6
42.8
49.5
57.7
69.9
90.5
98.5
103.6
108.0
111.5
114.2
115.1
112.3
102.1
66.5
-9.0
-8.3
-5.6
-2.4

-32.1
-29.3
-26.2
-35.3
-32.2
-28.8
-40.8
-38.0
-34.3
-30.8
-33.2
-31.0
-27.1
-21.9
-19.0
-22.7
-19.0
-12.9
-7.1
-1.5
4.9
12.8
19.9
26.3
33.2
39.2
45.5
52.4
60.8
72.8
93.5
101.6
106.6
110.7
114.2
116.9
117.9
114.9
104.7
69.4
-6.6
-6.2
-3.5
-0.3

8.3
4.8
1.2
1.4
-2.5
-6.5
-5.2
-8.8
-13.7
-17.4
-15.5
-18.5
-22.8
-27.3
-30.1
-32.6
-35.9
-41.1
-46.3
-51.1
-56.4
-62.5
-68.3
-73.3
-78.8
-83.2
-88.1
-93.2
-99.1
-106.3
-117.9
-123.4
-127.3
-130.3
-132.9
-134.8
-134.9
-130.9
-119.9
-81.7
-1.2
-0.9
-3.2
-6.1

-44.4
-49.3
-54.0
-78.7
-84.8
-89.7
-118.6
-124.9
-132.4
-137.5
-137.0
-141.9
-147.2
-150.1
-152.5
-172.3
-174.3
-176.8
-179.8
-182.6
-184.7
-185.3
-186.7
-188.2
-189.3
-190.1
-190.6
-190.3
-188.4
-182.2
-167.4
-165.3
-166.0
-166.2
-166.3
-165.7
-163.2
-156.9
-143.0
-97.8
-2.6
-1.3
-2.4
-4.1

20.5
24.8
29.0
44.8
50.0
54.5
72.6
78.1
84.5
89.3
88.2
92.5
97.3
100.9
103.4
117.0
119.4
122.8
126.4
130.0
133.2
135.5
138.4
141.2
143.7
146.1
148.0
149.5
150.2
148.8
143.0
143.5
145.3
146.7
147.6
147.9
146.2
140.9
127.8
85.5
-5.2
-5.8
-4.3
-2.3

WindMTY
29.22
30.08
30.71
44.62
45.85
46.49
63.36
64.88
66.51
67.19
68.05
69.21
69.86
68.89
68.79
78.47
77.85
76.45
75.34
74.22
72.54
69.55
67.29
65.22
62.95
60.76
58.37
55.47
51.30
43.77
29.17
24.97
23.15
21.48
20.06
18.68
17.25
15.88
14.30
10.56
2.12
1.40
0.72
0.05

Page 5 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2
D2

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3
D3

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead

Live

-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Dead
-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Live

-4.11
-8.38
-12.63
-16.08
-20.02
-23.55
-27.33
-30.57
-34.42
-37.24
-47.30
-50.40
-54.64
-58.75
-61.38
-67.81
-70.49
-74.29
-78.25
-81.96
-85.63
-89.34
-93.11
-96.78
-100.52
-104.31
-108.12
-111.97
-115.87
-119.62
-123.49
-126.97
-130.39
-133.95
-137.32
-139.44
-139.64
-135.86
-124.02
-82.47
9.44
7.65
3.39
-1.49

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A31

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

6.79
11.11
15.41
24.09
29.16
33.81
43.20
48.24
54.47
59.24
57.57
61.60
66.64
71.16
74.10
83.01
86.23
90.97
95.85
100.55
105.24
109.95
114.69
119.06
123.51
127.28
131.03
134.71
138.33
141.58
144.84
148.13
151.30
153.73
155.74
156.91
156.02
150.87
137.49
92.81
-2.23
-2.68
-0.61
2.10

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.49
-9.79
-11.52
-11.93
-12.12
-15.30
-15.58
-15.80
-15.75
-21.11
-21.21
-21.19
-20.69
-20.53
-23.30
-23.02
-22.55
-22.20
-21.89
-21.41
-20.51
-19.90
-19.34
-18.74
-18.11
-17.45
-16.63
-15.39
-12.98
-8.12
-6.91
-6.52
-6.09
-5.75
-5.45
-5.14
-4.83
-4.46
-3.35
-0.58
-0.39
-0.21
-0.05

WindMTX
10.17
10.47
10.69
15.53
15.95
16.18
22.04
22.57
23.14
23.37
23.67
24.07
24.29
23.95
23.91
27.27
27.05
26.56
26.17
25.78
25.19
24.15
23.36
22.64
21.85
21.08
20.25
19.24
17.78
15.17
10.10
8.65
8.02
7.43
6.94
6.46
5.96
5.48
4.93
3.64
0.73
0.48
0.25
0.02

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.27
-28.13
-33.09
-34.27
-34.82
-43.97
-44.79
-45.41
-45.26
-60.69
-60.98
-60.94
-59.52
-59.05
-67.04
-66.25
-64.89
-63.90
-63.01
-61.65
-59.08
-57.31
-55.72
-54.01
-52.21
-50.30
-47.95
-44.39
-37.44
-23.46
-19.97
-18.83
-17.60
-16.62
-15.78
-14.89
-14.00
-12.92
-9.71
-1.66
-1.12
-0.62
-0.14

19.0
23.3
27.7
33.9
38.0
41.1
50.0
53.0
56.4
58.5
76.2
78.4
81.4
83.4
84.4
93.9
95.1
97.9
101.0
104.3
107.5
110.2
113.4
116.5
119.7
122.0
124.4
126.7
128.3
127.7
123.1
125.0
128.2
130.4
132.7
134.5
134.6
131.0
120.1
80.8
-7.7
-7.0
-4.1
-0.6

-28.4
-25.8
-23.1
-25.8
-23.6
-20.8
-27.4
-25.0
-21.8
-18.4
-25.1
-21.7
-16.7
-9.9
-5.6
-6.9
-3.0
1.2
5.1
8.1
11.4
16.1
19.7
23.6
27.4
33.1
38.6
44.6
52.0
63.7
83.9
89.6
92.3
97.1
101.4
103.0
102.8
99.4
88.7
55.3
-17.6
-14.2
-8.9
-3.1

148.7
159.3
192.5
211.8
227.3
235.4
266.6
275.1
280.3
282.4
356.1
357.6
363.3
365.9
365.1
399.4
397.5
396.7
397.0
397.9
397.4
394.5
394.2
394.9
395.3
397.1
398.8
399.8
398.0
388.1
360.7
359.3
364.5
370.8
377.9
383.1
383.6
374.2
343.7
234.7
25.3
19.6
9.9
6.2

113.1
118.9
131.2
150.1
157.5
160.5
193.4
197.4
200.4
200.7
263.8
265.6
268.0
266.5
266.3
298.5
296.0
291.0
287.3
283.7
278.5
269.9
264.4
260.1
255.5
251.6
247.4
241.8
232.3
212.2
169.4
159.8
158.2
156.8
156.1
155.1
152.7
147.5
135.5
94.6
10.5
7.0
2.4
-0.3

-104.0
-112.9
-144.8
-154.8
-168.6
-176.5
-190.7
-198.1
-202.3
-204.3
-247.9
-248.1
-252.9
-256.5
-255.2
-273.4
-272.9
-276.1
-279.9
-284.4
-288.3
-291.7
-296.3
-300.8
-305.2
-309.9
-315.0
-320.0
-324.4
-325.8
-321.4
-327.1
-335.5
-344.2
-353.4
-361.3
-364.7
-357.9
-330.4
-226.5
-32.3
-27.1
-18.2
-15.3

37.2
37.3
30.0
40.1
38.8
36.9
56.2
55.4
55.6
54.7
82.5
83.9
83.2
79.8
80.3
96.6
94.9
89.1
84.2
79.0
72.8
64.1
57.2
51.4
45.4
39.6
33.3
25.8
15.6
-2.0
-35.2
-46.1
-51.8
-57.8
-63.3
-68.2
-71.8
-72.2
-66.7
-43.7
-6.8
-7.0
-6.0
-6.8

-37.8
-38.0
-31.0
-40.2
-39.1
-37.4
-54.7
-53.7
-53.9
-52.6
-76.4
-77.3
-76.1
-72.0
-71.9
-85.9
-84.4
-79.8
-76.1
-72.2
-67.6
-60.5
-55.2
-50.4
-45.7
-39.8
-33.7
-26.6
-16.7
0.9
33.8
43.4
47.6
53.4
58.6
62.0
64.0
63.2
56.2
33.5
-4.8
-3.8
-4.3
-3.2

103.4
112.2
143.8
154.7
168.3
176.0
192.2
199.8
204.0
206.4
254.1
254.7
260.0
264.3
263.6
284.1
283.4
285.5
288.0
291.2
293.5
295.4
298.4
301.7
304.9
309.7
314.5
319.3
323.3
324.7
320.0
324.4
331.3
339.8
348.6
355.2
357.0
348.9
319.9
216.3
20.7
16.3
7.9
5.3

-149.3
-160.0
-193.4
-212.0
-227.6
-235.8
-265.1
-273.4
-278.6
-280.3
-350.0
-351.0
-356.2
-358.1
-356.7
-388.7
-387.0
-387.4
-388.9
-391.2
-392.2
-390.9
-392.2
-393.9
-395.6
-397.3
-399.3
-400.5
-399.1
-389.2
-362.1
-362.1
-368.7
-375.2
-382.6
-389.3
-391.4
-383.2
-354.2
-244.9
-36.9
-30.4
-20.3
-16.2

-113.6
-119.7
-132.2
-150.2
-157.9
-160.9
-191.9
-195.7
-198.6
-198.6
-257.6
-259.0
-260.9
-258.7
-258.0
-287.7
-285.5
-281.6
-279.1
-276.9
-273.3
-266.3
-262.4
-259.1
-255.8
-251.9
-247.9
-242.5
-233.4
-213.3
-170.8
-162.6
-162.4
-161.1
-160.8
-161.3
-160.5
-156.5
-146.0
-104.8
-22.1
-17.8
-12.8
-9.7

148.9
159.5
192.7
211.9
227.4
235.5
266.2
274.6
279.9
281.8
354.5
355.8
361.4
363.8
362.8
396.6
394.7
394.2
394.9
396.2
396.0
393.5
393.7
394.6
395.4
397.1
399.0
400.0
398.3
388.4
361.1
360.1
365.6
372.0
379.2
384.7
385.6
376.6
346.5
237.4
28.4
22.4
12.6
8.9

113.2
119.1
131.5
150.2
157.6
160.6
193.0
196.9
199.9
200.1
262.1
263.8
266.1
264.5
264.1
295.6
293.2
288.5
285.1
281.9
277.1
269.0
263.8
259.8
255.6
251.7
247.5
241.9
232.6
212.5
169.8
160.6
159.3
157.9
157.3
156.8
154.8
149.8
138.3
97.3
13.6
9.9
5.2
2.3

-103.9
-112.7
-144.5
-154.8
-168.5
-176.4
-191.1
-198.5
-202.8
-204.9
-249.6
-249.9
-254.8
-258.6
-257.4
-276.2
-275.7
-278.6
-282.0
-286.2
-289.7
-292.7
-296.9
-301.0
-305.1
-309.8
-314.8
-319.8
-324.1
-325.5
-321.1
-326.4
-334.4
-343.0
-352.1
-359.7
-362.7
-355.5
-327.6
-223.8
-29.2
-24.3
-15.5
-12.7

37.4
37.5
30.3
40.2
38.9
37.0
55.8
55.0
55.1
54.1
80.9
82.1
81.3
77.7
78.0
93.8
92.1
86.6
82.1
77.2
71.4
63.1
56.7
51.1
45.4
39.6
33.4
26.0
15.9
-1.7
-34.9
-45.4
-50.7
-56.6
-62.0
-66.6
-69.7
-69.8
-64.0
-41.0
-3.7
-4.1
-3.3
-4.1

-37.7
-37.8
-30.7
-40.2
-39.0
-37.3
-55.1
-54.2
-54.3
-53.1
-78.0
-79.0
-78.0
-74.1
-74.1
-88.7
-87.1
-82.3
-78.2
-74.0
-69.0
-61.4
-55.7
-50.7
-45.6
-39.7
-33.6
-26.4
-16.4
1.2
34.2
44.1
48.7
54.5
59.8
63.7
66.1
65.5
59.0
36.2
-1.7
-1.0
-1.6
-0.5

103.6
112.4
144.1
154.8
168.4
176.1
191.8
199.3
203.6
205.9
252.4
253.0
258.1
262.3
261.4
281.3
280.6
283.0
285.9
289.4
292.2
294.4
297.8
301.5
305.0
309.7
314.6
319.5
323.6
325.0
320.4
325.1
332.4
341.0
349.9
356.8
359.0
351.3
322.7
219.0
23.8
19.2
10.6
8.0

-149.1
-159.8
-193.2
-211.9
-227.5
-235.7
-265.5
-273.9
-279.1
-280.9
-351.6
-352.7
-358.1
-360.2
-358.9
-391.5
-389.8
-389.8
-391.1
-393.0
-393.6
-391.8
-392.7
-394.2
-395.5
-397.3
-399.2
-400.3
-398.8
-388.9
-361.7
-361.3
-367.6
-374.0
-381.4
-387.6
-389.3
-380.8
-351.4
-242.2
-33.8
-27.5
-17.5
-13.6

-113.5
-119.5
-131.9
-150.2
-157.8
-160.8
-192.3
-196.1
-199.1
-199.2
-259.2
-260.7
-262.8
-260.8
-260.2
-290.6
-288.3
-284.1
-281.3
-278.7
-274.7
-267.3
-262.9
-259.4
-255.7
-251.8
-247.7
-242.3
-233.1
-213.0
-170.4
-161.8
-161.3
-160.0
-159.6
-159.7
-158.4
-154.1
-143.2
-102.1
-19.0
-15.0
-10.0
-7.0

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
148.85
-149.27
159.45
-160.01
192.73
-193.43
211.87
-211.96
227.38
-227.60
235.49
-235.83
266.60
-265.50
275.10
-273.86
280.31
-279.05
282.40
-280.86
356.13
-351.61
357.59
-352.71
363.26
-358.05
365.89
-360.15
365.05
-358.90
399.42
-391.54
397.53
-389.79
396.72
-389.84
397.04
-391.05
397.95
-392.97
397.39
-393.57
394.48
-391.82
394.22
-392.74
394.88
-394.16
395.36
-395.58
397.15
-397.32
398.96
-399.30
399.96
-400.51
398.33
-399.13
388.36
-389.18
361.09
-362.12
360.05
-362.05
365.59
-368.69
371.98
-375.21
379.16
-382.63
384.75
-389.27
385.64
-391.35
376.56
-383.17
346.49
-354.23
237.38
-244.87
28.40
-36.89
22.44
-30.37
12.63
-20.25
8.86
-16.21

0.62
0.67
0.81
0.77
0.83
0.86
0.78
0.80
0.82
0.83
0.77
0.77
0.79
0.79
0.79
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.74
0.74
0.74
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.76
0.75
0.73
0.68
0.68
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.72
0.67
0.46
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

-26.1
-30.5
-34.7
-50.8
-56.0
-60.6
-78.9
-84.2
-90.7
-95.4
-94.3
-98.6
-103.4
-106.9
-109.4
-123.1
-125.6
-129.0
-132.6
-136.2
-139.4
-141.8
-144.6
-147.4
-150.0
-152.2
-154.1
-155.6
-156.4
-154.9
-149.2
-149.7
-151.6
-152.8
-153.8
-154.1
-152.5
-147.1
-134.1
-91.2
-1.2
-0.5
-2.0
-4.0

26.6
23.7
20.5
29.4
26.2
22.7
34.5
31.8
28.0
24.7
27.1
24.9
21.0
15.9
13.0
16.6
12.8
6.7
0.9
-4.7
-11.1
-19.0
-26.2
-32.5
-39.4
-45.2
-51.6
-58.6
-67.0
-79.0
-99.7
-107.8
-112.8
-116.9
-120.4
-123.2
-124.2
-121.1
-111.0
-75.1
0.1
-0.1
-2.8
-6.0

160.8
173.6
204.7
281.3
299.0
308.5
378.1
390.8
402.4
410.1
390.7
396.6
405.2
408.9
408.6
451.0
450.4
452.3
454.9
458.3
460.0
459.0
460.3
461.6
462.5
463.0
463.4
462.7
459.0
446.6
416.7
413.6
416.9
419.9
423.2
425.2
422.2
408.8
373.9
257.0
17.6
13.7
7.9
6.4

119.2
125.5
136.4
194.4
202.9
206.9
270.0
277.1
284.6
288.1
284.1
288.3
292.3
290.5
289.9
326.2
324.3
321.2
319.2
317.2
313.6
306.0
300.9
296.2
290.9
285.6
279.9
272.7
261.5
239.5
194.8
183.6
180.1
176.9
174.4
171.7
167.3
159.9
145.6
101.6
8.0
5.0
1.6
-0.6

-120.8
-132.1
-162.2
-216.0
-231.7
-240.5
-282.6
-293.0
-302.0
-308.7
-288.2
-292.4
-300.1
-305.5
-305.6
-332.6
-333.2
-337.5
-342.1
-347.3
-351.8
-355.6
-360.6
-365.2
-369.7
-373.7
-378.0
-381.9
-384.9
-384.5
-378.2
-382.0
-388.3
-393.9
-399.4
-403.8
-403.1
-391.8
-359.5
-247.8
-23.7
-20.7
-16.1
-15.7

34.7
33.8
26.3
45.2
43.7
42.2
71.8
72.0
73.2
72.4
80.4
81.7
80.7
76.2
75.7
91.1
89.2
84.3
80.1
75.6
70.0
61.6
54.6
48.1
41.2
34.5
27.5
19.3
8.4
-9.9
-43.7
-55.1
-61.4
-67.2
-72.3
-77.0
-80.3
-80.3
-74.4
-49.8
-4.4
-5.3
-5.6
-7.2

-43.5
-42.7
-35.4
-54.6
-53.2
-51.9
-81.7
-81.8
-83.1
-82.1
-90.2
-91.3
-90.4
-85.7
-85.3
-100.8
-99.0
-94.2
-90.0
-85.3
-79.9
-71.5
-64.6
-58.0
-51.1
-44.2
-37.2
-29.1
-18.2
0.1
33.9
45.2
51.5
57.4
62.5
67.1
70.3
70.4
64.5
40.8
-5.8
-4.6
-4.3
-2.8

112.0
123.1
153.2
206.6
222.2
230.8
272.6
283.2
292.1
299.1
278.4
282.7
290.4
296.0
296.0
322.9
323.4
327.6
332.2
337.5
342.0
345.7
350.6
355.3
359.9
364.1
368.2
372.1
375.0
374.8
368.4
372.1
378.3
384.1
389.6
393.9
393.1
382.0
349.6
238.7
13.5
10.8
6.1
5.7

-169.7
-182.5
-213.8
-290.7
-308.6
-318.1
-388.1
-400.7
-412.4
-419.8
-400.5
-406.2
-414.9
-418.4
-418.1
-460.8
-460.1
-462.1
-464.8
-468.0
-469.8
-468.9
-470.2
-471.4
-472.3
-472.7
-473.1
-472.5
-468.8
-456.3
-426.5
-423.5
-426.9
-429.7
-433.0
-435.2
-432.2
-418.7
-383.8
-266.0
-27.9
-23.6
-17.8
-16.4

-128.0
-134.4
-145.5
-203.8
-212.4
-216.6
-280.0
-286.9
-294.5
-297.7
-293.8
-298.0
-302.0
-300.0
-299.5
-335.9
-334.0
-331.1
-329.1
-327.0
-323.4
-315.9
-310.9
-306.0
-300.8
-295.2
-289.6
-282.5
-271.4
-249.2
-204.6
-193.5
-190.1
-186.7
-184.3
-181.6
-177.3
-169.8
-155.5
-110.6
-18.2
-14.9
-11.5
-9.4

163.2
175.9
207.1
283.8
301.5
311.0
380.8
393.4
405.1
412.7
393.3
399.2
407.8
411.4
411.1
453.6
453.0
454.9
457.6
460.8
462.6
461.6
462.9
464.2
465.1
465.6
466.0
465.3
461.6
449.2
419.3
416.3
419.6
422.5
425.8
427.9
424.9
411.5
376.6
259.4
20.3
16.3
10.5
9.0

121.6
127.8
138.8
196.9
205.4
209.5
272.6
279.7
287.2
290.6
286.7
290.9
294.8
293.0
292.5
328.8
326.8
323.9
321.8
319.8
316.2
308.6
303.5
298.8
293.5
288.1
282.5
275.3
264.2
242.1
197.4
186.2
182.8
179.5
177.1
174.3
169.9
162.5
148.2
104.0
10.7
7.6
4.2
2.1

-118.5
-129.7
-159.8
-213.5
-229.2
-237.9
-280.0
-290.4
-299.4
-306.2
-285.6
-289.8
-297.6
-303.0
-303.0
-330.1
-330.6
-334.9
-339.5
-344.7
-349.2
-353.0
-357.9
-362.6
-367.1
-371.2
-375.4
-379.3
-382.3
-382.0
-375.6
-379.4
-385.6
-391.3
-396.8
-401.1
-400.5
-389.2
-356.9
-245.4
-21.0
-18.1
-13.4
-13.0

37.0
36.2
28.7
47.7
46.2
44.8
74.4
74.6
75.8
75.0
83.0
84.2
83.2
78.7
78.2
93.7
91.8
86.9
82.7
78.2
72.6
64.3
57.3
50.7
43.8
37.1
30.1
21.9
11.0
-7.3
-41.1
-52.5
-58.8
-64.6
-69.7
-74.4
-77.7
-77.7
-71.8
-47.4
-1.7
-2.7
-3.0
-4.5

-41.2
-40.4
-33.0
-52.1
-50.7
-49.3
-79.1
-79.2
-80.5
-79.5
-87.6
-88.7
-87.8
-83.2
-82.7
-98.3
-96.4
-91.6
-87.4
-82.7
-77.3
-68.9
-62.0
-55.4
-48.5
-41.6
-34.7
-26.5
-15.6
2.7
36.5
47.9
54.1
60.0
65.1
69.7
73.0
73.0
67.2
43.2
-3.1
-2.0
-1.7
-0.2

114.4
125.5
155.6
209.1
224.7
233.4
275.3
285.8
294.8
301.6
281.0
285.3
293.0
298.5
298.5
325.5
326.0
330.2
334.8
340.1
344.6
348.3
353.2
357.9
362.5
366.6
370.8
374.7
377.7
377.4
371.0
374.7
381.0
386.7
392.2
396.5
395.8
384.6
352.2
241.1
16.2
13.5
8.8
8.3

-167.3
-180.1
-211.4
-288.2
-306.0
-315.6
-385.5
-398.1
-409.7
-417.2
-397.9
-403.7
-412.3
-415.8
-415.6
-458.2
-457.6
-459.5
-462.2
-465.4
-467.2
-466.3
-467.6
-468.8
-469.7
-470.1
-470.5
-469.9
-466.2
-453.8
-423.9
-420.9
-424.2
-427.1
-430.4
-432.5
-429.6
-416.1
-381.2
-263.6
-25.1
-21.0
-15.2
-13.7

-125.7
-132.0
-143.1
-201.3
-209.9
-214.0
-277.3
-284.3
-291.8
-295.2
-291.3
-295.4
-299.4
-297.5
-297.0
-333.4
-331.4
-328.5
-326.5
-324.4
-320.8
-313.3
-308.2
-303.4
-298.2
-292.7
-287.1
-279.9
-268.8
-246.6
-202.0
-190.8
-187.4
-184.1
-181.7
-179.0
-174.6
-167.2
-152.9
-108.2
-15.5
-12.3
-8.9
-6.8

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
163.18
-169.66
175.95
-182.51
207.12
-213.77
283.79
-290.72
301.54
-308.56
311.02
-318.12
380.79
-388.11
393.45
-400.67
405.06
-412.36
412.68
-419.79
393.28
-400.46
399.17
-406.25
407.79
-414.92
411.38
-418.36
411.10
-418.13
453.62
-460.75
452.96
-460.15
454.87
-462.10
457.56
-464.84
460.85
-468.03
462.59
-469.82
461.61
-468.89
462.90
-470.23
464.17
-471.39
465.08
-472.35
465.56
-472.66
465.98
-473.12
465.28
-472.47
461.59
-468.83
449.20
-456.35
419.30
-426.50
416.25
-423.50
419.56
-426.85
422.53
-429.72
425.79
-433.03
427.87
-435.15
424.87
-432.20
411.46
-418.69
376.56
-383.84
259.38
-266.02
20.34
-27.86
16.34
-23.61
10.54
-17.85
9.03
-16.38

0.71
0.76
0.89
0.85
0.90
0.93
0.84
0.87
0.89
0.91
0.87
0.88
0.90
0.91
0.91
0.87
0.87
0.87
0.88
0.88
0.89
0.88
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.88
0.86
0.80
0.80
0.81
0.81
0.82
0.82
0.82
0.79
0.72
0.50
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

WindMTY
29.22
30.08
30.71
44.62
45.85
46.49
63.36
64.88
66.51
67.19
68.05
69.21
69.86
68.89
68.79
78.47
77.85
76.45
75.34
74.22
72.54
69.55
67.29
65.22
62.95
60.76
58.37
55.47
51.30
43.77
29.17
24.97
23.15
21.48
20.06
18.68
17.25
15.88
14.30
10.56
2.12
1.40
0.72
0.05

Page 6 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

Dead

Live

-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Dead
-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Live

-6.79
-11.11
-15.41
-24.09
-29.16
-33.81
-43.20
-48.24
-54.47
-59.24
-57.57
-61.60
-66.64
-71.16
-74.10
-83.01
-86.23
-90.97
-95.85
-100.55
-105.24
-109.95
-114.69
-119.06
-123.51
-127.28
-131.03
-134.71
-138.33
-141.58
-144.84
-148.13
-151.30
-153.73
-155.74
-156.91
-156.02
-150.87
-137.49
-92.81
2.23
2.68
0.61
-2.10

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A32

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

4.11
8.38
12.63
16.08
20.02
23.55
27.33
30.57
34.42
37.24
47.30
50.40
54.64
58.75
61.38
67.81
70.49
74.29
78.25
81.96
85.63
89.34
93.11
96.78
100.52
104.31
108.12
111.97
115.87
119.62
123.49
126.97
130.39
133.95
137.32
139.44
139.64
135.86
124.02
82.47
-9.44
-7.65
-3.39
1.49

WindMTX
-10.17
-10.47
-10.69
-15.53
-15.95
-16.18
-22.04
-22.57
-23.14
-23.37
-23.67
-24.07
-24.29
-23.95
-23.91
-27.27
-27.05
-26.56
-26.17
-25.78
-25.19
-24.15
-23.36
-22.64
-21.85
-21.08
-20.25
-19.24
-17.78
-15.17
-10.10
-8.65
-8.02
-7.43
-6.94
-6.46
-5.96
-5.48
-4.93
-3.64
-0.73
-0.48
-0.25
-0.02

WindMTX
9.15
9.49
9.79
11.52
11.93
12.12
15.30
15.58
15.80
15.75
21.11
21.21
21.19
20.69
20.53
23.30
23.02
22.55
22.20
21.89
21.41
20.51
19.90
19.34
18.74
18.11
17.45
16.63
15.39
12.98
8.12
6.91
6.52
6.09
5.75
5.45
5.14
4.83
4.46
3.35
0.58
0.39
0.21
0.05

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindMTY
-29.22
-30.08
-30.71
-44.62
-45.85
-46.49
-63.36
-64.88
-66.51
-67.19
-68.05
-69.21
-69.86
-68.89
-68.79
-78.47
-77.85
-76.45
-75.34
-74.22
-72.54
-69.55
-67.29
-65.22
-62.95
-60.76
-58.37
-55.47
-51.30
-43.77
-29.17
-24.97
-23.15
-21.48
-20.06
-18.68
-17.25
-15.88
-14.30
-10.56
-2.12
-1.40
-0.72
-0.05

WindMTY
26.30
27.27
28.13
33.09
34.27
34.82
43.97
44.79
45.41
45.26
60.69
60.98
60.94
59.52
59.05
67.04
66.25
64.89
63.90
63.01
61.65
59.08
57.31
55.72
54.01
52.21
50.30
47.95
44.39
37.44
23.46
19.97
18.83
17.60
16.62
15.78
14.89
14.00
12.92
9.71
1.66
1.12
0.62
0.14

SpecX
450.35
488.64
586.69
795.14
848.55
877.65
1056.41
1093.33
1126.34
1149.34
1085.40
1101.55
1127.73
1142.13
1141.76
1252.97
1252.77
1262.66
1274.30
1287.88
1297.89
1302.42
1312.37
1321.79
1330.55
1337.80
1345.21
1350.36
1349.21
1328.90
1270.98
1272.08
1287.36
1301.13
1315.22
1325.44
1319.55
1280.17
1172.67
807.01
66.13
55.07
38.35
35.29

SpecX
404.04
435.18
539.20
586.27
633.00
658.47
731.14
756.52
771.67
778.20
965.79
968.38
985.20
995.12
991.70
1075.70
1071.89
1075.78
1082.29
1090.94
1096.38
1097.14
1104.10
1112.20
1119.99
1130.33
1141.24
1150.80
1155.12
1141.33
1090.67
1097.52
1119.18
1143.18
1169.20
1190.26
1196.42
1170.43
1077.83
737.40
92.12
74.65
44.93
34.45

SpecY
271.59
280.70
286.68
415.46
427.41
431.89
586.98
599.00
613.64
617.75
624.61
633.54
638.56
627.87
626.17
712.72
706.29
693.27
682.82
671.82
656.59
630.08
609.96
590.97
570.74
550.32
529.29
503.77
466.90
399.42
268.49
230.90
214.66
199.43
186.83
174.57
161.85
149.37
135.28
101.49
22.95
16.03
9.80
3.79

-14.6
-21.5
-28.5
-42.5
-50.7
-58.2
-73.3
-81.3
-91.3
-98.9
-96.2
-102.6
-110.7
-117.9
-122.6
-136.9
-142.1
-149.7
-157.5
-165.0
-172.5
-180.1
-187.7
-194.6
-201.8
-207.7
-213.7
-219.6
-225.5
-230.6
-235.9
-241.2
-246.2
-250.1
-253.3
-255.2
-253.8
-245.5
-224.1
-152.3
-0.7
0.1
-3.2
-7.6

7.2
14.0
20.9
34.6
42.6
50.0
64.9
73.1
83.0
90.7
88.0
94.5
102.5
109.9
114.5
128.7
133.9
141.4
149.2
156.8
164.3
171.8
179.3
186.4
193.5
199.6
205.6
211.4
217.2
222.4
227.6
232.9
237.9
241.9
245.1
246.9
245.4
237.3
215.8
144.7
-7.9
-8.4
-5.2
-0.8

-3.7
-3.7
-3.7
-3.8
-3.7
-3.6
-3.5
-3.4
-3.2
-3.2
-3.0
-3.0
-2.8
-2.8
-2.7
-2.6
-2.5
-2.3
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-1.9
-1.7
-1.8
-1.6
-1.8
-1.7
-1.6
-1.4
-1.5
-1.4
-1.5
-1.5
-1.7
-1.7
-1.7
-1.7
-1.8
-1.8
-1.2
-2.1
-2.3
-2.3
-2.3

-3.7
-3.8
-3.9
-4.2
-4.3
-4.5
-4.8
-4.9
-5.1
-4.9
-5.2
-5.1
-5.4
-5.2
-5.3
-5.6
-5.8
-5.9
-6.1
-6.0
-6.2
-6.4
-6.6
-6.5
-6.7
-6.3
-6.5
-6.7
-6.9
-6.7
-6.8
-6.8
-6.8
-6.6
-6.6
-6.6
-6.7
-6.5
-6.5
-6.4
-6.4
-6.0
-6.0
-6.1

-11.9
-17.1
-22.2
-32.7
-38.8
-44.3
-55.5
-61.5
-68.8
-74.5
-72.4
-77.2
-83.1
-88.5
-91.9
-102.6
-106.4
-111.9
-117.7
-123.3
-128.8
-134.4
-140.0
-145.2
-150.5
-155.1
-159.5
-163.8
-168.1
-172.0
-175.9
-179.9
-183.7
-186.8
-189.2
-190.6
-189.6
-183.4
-167.4
-113.2
0.0
0.5
-2.0
-5.3

-11.9
-17.1
-22.4
-33.0
-39.2
-45.0
-56.5
-62.6
-70.2
-75.8
-74.0
-78.8
-85.0
-90.3
-93.9
-104.8
-108.8
-114.7
-120.7
-126.2
-132.0
-137.8
-143.7
-148.8
-154.3
-158.5
-163.1
-167.7
-172.2
-175.9
-179.9
-183.9
-187.7
-190.4
-192.9
-194.3
-193.3
-186.9
-170.9
-117.1
-3.2
-2.3
-4.8
-8.1

4.4
9.6
14.8
25.1
31.2
36.9
48.2
54.3
61.9
67.7
65.8
70.7
76.9
82.3
85.9
96.6
100.6
106.4
112.4
118.0
123.7
129.5
135.3
140.5
146.0
150.4
155.0
159.5
163.9
167.8
171.7
175.6
179.4
182.2
184.6
186.0
184.9
178.7
162.6
109.5
-5.4
-6.0
-3.5
-0.3

4.4
9.6
14.6
24.8
30.7
36.2
47.2
53.2
60.5
66.4
64.2
69.1
74.9
80.5
83.9
94.4
98.1
103.7
109.4
115.1
120.6
126.1
131.6
137.0
142.1
147.0
151.3
155.6
159.8
163.8
167.7
171.6
175.4
178.5
180.9
182.3
181.2
175.2
159.1
105.6
-8.6
-8.8
-6.3
-3.1

-24.1
-29.6
-35.1
-51.5
-58.1
-64.0
-82.5
-89.1
-97.3
-103.2
-101.6
-106.9
-113.2
-118.1
-121.6
-136.4
-140.1
-145.2
-150.6
-155.7
-160.6
-165.1
-169.8
-174.2
-178.6
-182.1
-185.6
-188.8
-191.5
-192.2
-190.0
-192.3
-195.3
-197.5
-199.4
-200.2
-198.6
-191.8
-175.1
-119.5
-2.5
-1.5
-3.7
-6.7

0.3
-4.5
-9.5
-14.2
-19.9
-25.2
-29.6
-34.9
-41.8
-47.1
-44.8
-49.1
-54.9
-60.6
-64.2
-71.0
-75.1
-81.4
-87.8
-93.8
-100.2
-107.1
-113.8
-119.8
-126.1
-131.5
-137.0
-142.7
-148.8
-155.8
-165.8
-171.5
-176.1
-179.7
-182.7
-184.7
-184.3
-178.6
-163.2
-110.8
-0.7
-0.4
-3.1
-6.7

-7.8
-3.0
1.9
6.3
11.8
17.1
21.2
26.7
33.4
39.0
36.6
41.0
46.7
52.7
56.2
62.8
66.9
73.2
79.5
85.6
91.9
98.8
105.4
111.6
117.8
123.4
128.8
134.5
140.5
147.6
157.6
163.2
167.8
171.5
174.4
176.4
175.9
170.3
154.9
103.2
-7.8
-8.0
-5.2
-1.7

16.6
22.1
27.5
43.6
50.1
55.9
74.1
80.8
89.0
95.1
93.4
98.8
105.0
110.2
113.6
128.3
131.8
136.9
142.3
147.5
152.4
156.8
161.5
165.9
170.3
174.0
177.4
180.6
183.2
184.0
181.8
184.0
187.0
189.3
191.1
191.9
190.2
183.5
166.8
111.9
-6.1
-6.8
-4.6
-1.7

-38.8
-39.8
-40.6
-57.4
-58.8
-59.5
-79.7
-81.4
-83.3
-84.0
-85.0
-86.3
-86.9
-85.8
-85.6
-97.1
-96.3
-94.5
-93.1
-91.7
-89.6
-85.9
-83.1
-80.6
-77.8
-75.3
-72.3
-68.8
-63.7
-54.6
-37.1
-32.1
-30.0
-28.1
-26.4
-24.8
-23.0
-21.4
-19.5
-14.5
-5.2
-4.4
-3.6
-2.9

31.4
32.4
33.1
49.7
51.2
52.1
72.3
74.3
76.4
77.2
78.4
79.8
80.7
79.6
79.5
91.2
90.5
89.0
87.7
86.4
84.5
81.0
78.4
75.9
73.3
70.5
67.8
64.4
59.4
50.4
32.9
27.8
25.6
23.5
21.8
20.1
18.4
16.7
14.8
10.8
-0.1
-1.1
-1.9
-2.7

-38.8
-39.9
-40.7
-57.6
-59.3
-60.2
-80.7
-82.5
-84.7
-85.3
-86.6
-87.9
-88.9
-87.5
-87.6
-99.4
-98.8
-97.2
-96.1
-94.6
-92.8
-89.3
-86.8
-84.2
-81.6
-78.7
-75.9
-72.6
-67.7
-58.6
-41.1
-36.1
-33.9
-31.7
-30.0
-28.4
-26.7
-24.9
-23.1
-18.4
-8.4
-7.2
-6.4
-5.7

31.4
32.3
33.0
49.4
50.8
51.4
71.3
73.2
74.9
75.9
76.8
78.2
78.8
77.8
77.5
89.0
88.1
86.2
84.8
83.5
81.3
77.6
74.7
72.4
69.5
67.2
64.2
60.5
55.4
46.5
28.9
23.8
21.6
19.8
18.1
16.4
14.7
13.2
11.2
6.9
-3.4
-3.9
-4.7
-5.5

-45.3
-50.3
-54.9
-79.7
-85.8
-90.7
-119.7
-125.9
-133.5
-138.5
-138.0
-143.0
-148.2
-151.1
-153.5
-173.3
-175.4
-177.9
-180.8
-183.7
-185.8
-186.3
-187.8
-189.2
-190.4
-191.2
-191.6
-191.3
-189.4
-183.2
-168.4
-166.3
-167.0
-167.3
-167.4
-166.8
-164.3
-158.0
-144.0
-98.7
-3.6
-2.4
-3.4
-5.1

-27.0
-31.4
-35.7
-51.8
-57.0
-61.6
-79.9
-85.3
-91.8
-96.4
-95.3
-99.6
-104.4
-107.9
-110.5
-124.1
-126.6
-130.0
-133.7
-137.2
-140.4
-142.8
-145.7
-148.4
-151.0
-153.2
-155.1
-156.7
-157.4
-155.9
-150.2
-150.8
-152.6
-153.9
-154.9
-155.1
-153.5
-148.1
-135.1
-92.1
-2.3
-1.5
-3.0
-5.1

-33.1
-30.3
-27.2
-36.3
-33.2
-29.8
-41.8
-39.0
-35.3
-31.8
-34.3
-32.0
-28.1
-22.9
-20.0
-23.7
-20.0
-14.0
-8.1
-2.5
3.8
11.8
18.8
25.3
32.1
38.2
44.5
51.4
59.8
71.8
92.5
100.5
105.5
109.7
113.2
115.9
116.8
113.8
103.7
68.5
-7.7
-7.2
-4.5
-1.3

-14.7
-11.4
-7.9
-8.4
-4.5
-0.7
-2.1
1.6
6.4
10.3
8.4
11.4
15.6
20.3
23.0
25.4
28.7
33.9
39.0
43.9
49.2
55.3
60.9
66.1
71.5
76.1
81.0
86.0
91.8
99.2
110.7
116.1
120.0
123.1
125.7
127.5
127.6
123.7
112.6
75.1
-6.3
-6.3
-4.1
-1.3

7.3
3.9
0.4
0.7
-3.2
-7.0
-5.5
-9.1
-13.6
-17.5
-15.4
-18.3
-22.3
-27.0
-29.6
-31.9
-35.1
-40.1
-45.1
-50.0
-55.1
-61.0
-66.5
-71.7
-76.9
-81.7
-86.4
-91.4
-97.0
-104.4
-115.9
-121.4
-125.3
-128.6
-131.2
-133.1
-133.2
-129.4
-118.2
-79.7
0.2
0.1
-2.2
-5.0

-45.3
-50.3
-55.0
-79.9
-86.1
-91.2
-120.4
-126.8
-134.5
-139.5
-139.2
-144.2
-149.6
-152.4
-155.0
-174.9
-177.2
-179.9
-183.1
-185.9
-188.2
-188.9
-190.5
-191.9
-193.2
-193.7
-194.3
-194.2
-192.5
-186.2
-171.5
-169.4
-170.0
-170.0
-170.1
-169.5
-167.0
-160.6
-146.7
-101.7
-6.1
-4.5
-5.5
-7.2

7.3
3.9
0.3
0.4
-3.5
-7.5
-6.3
-9.9
-14.7
-18.4
-16.6
-19.5
-23.8
-28.3
-31.1
-33.6
-37.0
-42.2
-47.3
-52.1
-57.5
-63.6
-69.3
-74.4
-79.8
-84.2
-89.1
-94.3
-100.1
-107.3
-118.9
-124.4
-128.3
-131.3
-134.0
-135.9
-136.0
-132.0
-120.9
-82.6
-2.2
-2.0
-4.3
-7.1

37.9
42.8
47.3
71.8
77.7
82.6
111.3
117.7
125.1
130.4
129.8
134.9
140.0
143.1
145.5
165.1
167.1
169.6
172.5
175.5
177.5
178.0
179.4
180.9
182.1
183.0
183.4
183.1
181.2
175.1
160.2
158.1
158.7
159.1
159.1
158.5
155.9
149.7
135.7
91.1
-4.9
-5.9
-4.9
-3.3

19.6
23.9
28.1
43.8
49.0
53.4
71.6
77.0
83.4
88.3
87.1
91.5
96.3
99.9
102.4
116.0
118.4
121.7
125.4
129.0
132.1
134.5
137.3
140.2
142.7
145.1
146.9
148.4
149.1
147.7
142.0
142.5
144.3
145.7
146.6
146.8
145.1
139.8
126.8
84.6
-6.3
-6.8
-5.4
-3.3

25.7
22.7
19.5
28.4
25.2
21.7
33.5
30.8
27.0
23.7
26.1
23.9
20.0
14.9
12.0
15.6
11.8
5.7
-0.2
-5.7
-12.1
-20.1
-27.2
-33.6
-40.5
-46.3
-52.6
-59.6
-68.0
-80.0
-100.7
-108.8
-113.9
-117.9
-121.5
-124.2
-125.2
-122.1
-112.0
-76.1
-0.9
-1.1
-3.8
-7.1

25.7
22.8
19.7
28.6
25.6
22.2
34.2
31.6
28.1
24.6
27.3
25.1
21.4
16.2
13.5
17.2
13.6
7.7
2.1
-3.5
-9.7
-17.5
-24.5
-30.9
-37.6
-43.7
-49.9
-56.7
-65.0
-77.1
-97.7
-105.8
-110.9
-115.2
-118.7
-121.5
-122.4
-119.5
-109.4
-73.1
1.5
1.0
-1.7
-5.0

-14.7
-11.4
-8.0
-8.6
-4.8
-1.2
-2.9
0.8
5.3
9.4
7.2
10.2
14.2
19.0
21.6
23.7
26.9
31.9
36.8
41.8
46.8
52.7
58.2
63.4
68.6
73.6
78.2
83.1
88.7
96.2
107.7
113.1
117.0
120.3
123.0
124.8
124.8
121.1
109.9
72.1
-8.8
-8.5
-6.2
-3.4

37.9
42.8
47.4
72.0
78.1
83.1
112.0
118.5
126.2
131.4
131.0
136.1
141.5
144.4
147.0
166.8
169.0
171.6
174.7
177.6
179.9
180.6
182.2
183.6
184.9
185.6
186.1
186.0
184.2
178.0
163.3
161.1
161.7
161.8
161.9
161.2
158.6
152.3
138.3
94.1
-2.5
-3.8
-2.8
-1.2

-27.0
-31.4
-35.8
-52.0
-57.4
-62.1
-80.7
-86.1
-92.8
-97.4
-96.5
-100.8
-105.9
-109.2
-111.9
-125.8
-128.5
-132.0
-135.9
-139.4
-142.8
-145.4
-148.5
-151.1
-153.9
-155.7
-157.8
-159.5
-160.5
-158.8
-153.3
-153.8
-155.6
-156.6
-157.6
-157.9
-156.3
-150.7
-137.8
-95.1
-4.7
-3.6
-5.1
-7.2

19.6
23.9
28.2
44.0
49.4
54.0
72.3
77.8
84.5
89.3
88.3
92.7
97.7
101.3
103.9
117.7
120.3
123.8
127.6
131.2
134.5
137.1
140.1
142.8
145.6
147.6
149.6
151.3
152.2
150.7
145.0
145.5
147.3
148.4
149.4
149.6
147.9
142.4
129.5
87.5
-3.8
-4.7
-3.3
-1.2

-33.1
-30.3
-27.3
-36.6
-33.6
-30.3
-42.6
-39.9
-36.4
-32.8
-35.5
-33.2
-29.6
-24.2
-21.5
-25.4
-21.8
-16.0
-10.4
-4.7
1.4
9.2
16.1
22.6
29.3
35.6
41.8
48.5
56.7
68.9
89.5
97.5
102.5
106.9
110.5
113.2
114.0
111.2
101.0
65.5
-10.1
-9.3
-6.6
-3.4

-13.6
-20.6
-27.5
-41.5
-49.7
-57.1
-72.3
-80.3
-90.3
-97.8
-95.2
-101.6
-109.7
-116.9
-121.6
-135.9
-141.1
-148.7
-156.5
-164.0
-171.5
-179.0
-186.6
-193.6
-200.7
-206.7
-212.7
-218.6
-224.4
-229.6
-234.8
-240.1
-245.2
-249.1
-252.3
-254.2
-252.8
-244.5
-223.1
-151.3
0.4
1.2
-2.2
-6.5

8.1
15.0
21.8
35.6
43.6
51.1
66.0
74.1
84.0
91.7
89.0
95.5
103.6
110.9
115.5
129.8
134.9
142.5
150.2
157.8
165.3
172.8
180.4
187.4
194.5
200.6
206.6
212.4
218.2
223.5
228.7
233.9
239.0
242.9
246.1
247.9
246.5
238.3
216.9
145.6
-6.8
-7.4
-4.1
0.2

6.3
13.1
19.8
25.7
31.9
37.5
44.4
49.6
55.8
60.5
78.3
83.4
90.4
97.3
101.7
113.0
117.2
122.8
128.6
134.0
139.2
144.5
149.8
155.3
160.7
166.8
172.8
178.8
184.9
190.9
197.0
202.0
206.9
212.5
217.7
220.5
220.2
213.6
194.0
127.7
-20.0
-16.8
-9.8
-1.8

-6.8
-13.7
-20.6
-25.8
-32.2
-37.9
-43.1
-48.2
-54.4
-58.7
-73.1
-77.9
-84.5
-90.7
-94.7
-104.0
-108.4
-114.9
-121.8
-128.3
-134.8
-141.4
-148.1
-154.4
-161.0
-167.0
-173.2
-179.5
-185.8
-191.9
-198.2
-204.3
-210.4
-216.2
-221.7
-225.7
-226.7
-221.2
-202.8
-136.2
10.3
7.7
1.1
-6.6

-0.3
-0.3
-0.3
0.0
-0.3
-0.9
-1.0
-1.7
-2.5
-3.3
-4.5
-5.9
-7.4
-9.1
-11.0
-13.2
-14.4
-14.0
-13.7
-12.5
-11.1
-9.5
-7.7
-6.3
-4.5
-4.7
-4.5
-4.2
-3.7
-3.6
-3.4
-1.7
-0.1
-0.4
-0.8
0.2
1.2
1.9
2.8
2.9
1.2
0.0
-1.1
-2.2

-0.2
-0.3
-0.5
-0.1
0.1
0.5
2.3
3.1
3.9
5.0
9.7
11.4
13.4
15.7
18.1
22.3
23.3
21.9
20.5
18.2
15.5
12.5
9.3
7.1
4.3
4.5
4.1
3.6
2.8
2.7
2.2
-0.6
-3.5
-3.2
-3.2
-5.3
-7.7
-9.4
-11.6
-11.4
-10.9
-9.1
-7.6
-6.2

4.7
9.8
14.8
19.3
23.8
27.6
32.2
35.6
39.6
42.5
54.0
56.8
60.7
64.5
66.3
72.6
74.9
79.6
84.5
89.7
95.0
100.5
106.2
111.5
117.2
121.6
126.3
131.1
136.1
140.7
145.5
150.8
156.0
159.9
163.7
166.8
167.6
163.5
149.8
100.1
-11.6
-10.3
-6.0
-0.9

4.7
9.7
14.7
19.2
24.0
28.6
34.6
39.2
44.4
48.7
64.7
69.8
76.4
83.1
88.1
99.2
103.1
106.5
110.1
112.7
114.9
117.0
118.9
121.6
123.8
128.5
132.8
137.0
141.0
145.4
149.7
151.6
153.4
157.8
161.9
162.7
161.0
155.0
139.0
89.3
-20.8
-17.1
-10.9
-3.9

-5.2
-10.4
-15.5
-19.3
-24.3
-28.9
-33.4
-37.8
-43.0
-46.9
-59.5
-64.2
-70.4
-76.5
-81.1
-90.2
-94.3
-98.7
-103.3
-107.0
-110.5
-113.9
-117.3
-120.7
-124.0
-128.7
-133.2
-137.6
-142.0
-146.4
-150.9
-153.9
-157.0
-161.5
-165.9
-167.8
-167.5
-162.6
-147.9
-97.9
11.0
8.1
2.2
-4.5

-5.2
-10.4
-15.6
-19.4
-24.0
-28.0
-30.9
-34.2
-38.2
-40.7
-48.8
-51.2
-54.8
-57.9
-59.2
-63.6
-66.0
-71.7
-77.7
-84.0
-90.6
-97.4
-104.5
-110.7
-117.5
-121.8
-126.7
-131.8
-137.0
-141.7
-146.7
-153.1
-159.5
-163.6
-167.7
-172.0
-174.2
-171.1
-158.6
-108.6
1.9
1.2
-2.7
-7.5

15.7
21.1
26.5
33.1
38.2
42.6
51.8
56.1
61.0
64.5
84.7
88.7
94.0
98.6
101.8
113.8
116.6
120.1
124.0
127.5
130.6
133.3
136.4
139.8
143.0
146.8
150.5
154.0
157.1
158.6
157.4
159.5
162.5
166.2
169.7
171.3
170.5
165.0
149.7
98.7
-15.5
-13.2
-8.2
-2.4

-6.3
-1.7
3.0
5.4
9.6
13.5
15.1
18.7
23.1
26.7
34.0
37.8
43.1
48.9
52.5
57.9
61.4
66.0
70.7
74.9
79.2
84.1
88.7
93.3
98.0
103.3
108.6
114.1
120.1
127.5
137.9
142.9
146.9
151.6
155.9
158.2
158.1
153.5
139.0
90.7
-16.9
-14.2
-8.7
-2.5

5.8
1.0
-3.8
-5.5
-9.8
-13.9
-13.8
-17.3
-21.6
-24.9
-28.8
-32.2
-37.2
-42.4
-45.5
-48.9
-52.5
-58.2
-63.8
-69.2
-74.9
-81.1
-87.0
-92.5
-98.3
-103.5
-109.0
-114.7
-121.0
-128.4
-139.0
-145.2
-150.4
-155.3
-159.9
-163.4
-164.7
-161.0
-147.9
-99.2
7.2
5.1
0.0
-5.9

-16.2
-21.8
-27.3
-33.2
-38.5
-43.0
-50.5
-54.7
-59.5
-62.7
-79.5
-83.1
-88.0
-92.1
-94.8
-104.8
-107.8
-112.3
-117.1
-121.8
-126.3
-130.3
-134.8
-138.9
-143.2
-147.0
-150.9
-154.6
-158.0
-159.6
-158.5
-161.8
-166.1
-169.9
-173.7
-176.5
-177.0
-172.6
-158.6
-107.3
5.8
4.2
-0.5
-6.0

31.3
32.4
33.4
39.7
40.8
41.1
52.2
52.7
52.8
52.1
70.1
69.5
68.3
65.4
63.5
71.6
69.8
68.3
67.3
66.9
66.2
64.2
63.2
62.2
61.4
59.1
56.9
54.3
50.4
42.1
25.5
22.4
22.1
20.3
18.8
18.4
17.9
17.3
16.5
12.7
1.7
0.2
-1.2
-2.5

-31.8
-33.0
-34.1
-39.7
-41.4
-42.5
-53.4
-54.8
-56.2
-56.5
-75.6
-76.9
-78.0
-77.5
-78.3
-89.2
-89.2
-87.4
-86.1
-84.3
-81.8
-77.6
-74.3
-71.5
-68.2
-66.2
-63.8
-60.8
-56.2
-47.7
-30.8
-25.5
-23.1
-21.9
-21.0
-19.5
-17.8
-16.3
-14.5
-10.6
-2.3
-2.4
-2.6
-2.9

31.3
32.4
33.3
39.6
41.1
42.1
54.6
56.2
57.6
58.3
80.8
82.5
83.9
84.0
85.3
98.3
98.0
95.3
92.9
90.0
86.1
80.7
76.0
72.3
68.0
66.0
63.4
60.1
55.3
46.8
29.6
23.2
19.5
18.2
17.1
14.3
11.3
8.8
5.7
2.0
-7.4
-6.6
-6.1
-5.5

-31.8
-33.1
-34.2
-39.8
-41.1
-41.5
-50.9
-51.2
-51.4
-50.3
-64.9
-63.9
-62.3
-58.8
-56.4
-62.6
-60.9
-60.5
-60.4
-61.2
-61.8
-61.1
-61.5
-61.4
-61.7
-59.3
-57.3
-54.9
-51.3
-43.0
-26.7
-24.7
-25.7
-24.0
-22.8
-23.6
-24.5
-24.8
-25.3
-21.3
-11.4
-9.3
-7.6
-5.9

35.4
40.4
45.2
54.6
59.4
62.9
77.7
81.3
85.1
87.1
114.9
117.4
120.3
121.5
122.3
137.0
137.7
139.5
141.8
144.5
146.7
147.5
149.5
151.4
153.5
154.6
155.8
156.5
155.9
150.9
137.5
137.2
139.5
140.9
142.5
143.7
143.1
138.8
127.0
85.8
-7.9
-7.5
-4.8
-1.6

18.9
23.3
27.6
33.9
37.9
41.1
50.2
53.2
56.6
58.7
76.8
79.1
82.1
84.2
85.3
95.0
96.2
98.9
101.9
105.1
108.1
110.5
113.6
116.6
119.7
122.0
124.4
126.6
128.2
127.6
122.9
124.7
127.7
130.0
132.2
133.9
133.8
130.0
119.0
79.8
-9.0
-8.2
-5.2
-1.7

28.0
25.3
22.4
25.7
23.3
20.5
28.5
26.2
23.1
20.0
29.6
26.6
21.9
15.6
11.7
14.8
10.7
5.7
0.9
-3.2
-7.6
-13.5
-18.3
-22.9
-27.6
-33.3
-39.0
-45.2
-52.8
-64.6
-84.9
-91.6
-95.4
-100.4
-104.9
-107.5
-108.5
-106.0
-96.4
-62.8
9.1
6.3
1.3
-4.3

11.5
8.2
4.8
4.9
1.9
-1.3
0.9
-1.9
-5.4
-8.4
-8.4
-11.7
-16.3
-21.7
-25.3
-27.2
-30.7
-34.9
-39.1
-42.6
-46.2
-50.4
-54.1
-57.8
-61.4
-65.9
-70.4
-75.1
-80.6
-87.9
-99.6
-104.0
-107.2
-111.3
-115.2
-117.3
-117.8
-114.7
-104.5
-68.8
8.1
5.6
0.9
-4.3

-12.0
-8.8
-5.5
-5.0
-2.3
0.2
-1.5
0.6
3.3
5.5
5.5
7.5
10.5
14.2
15.9
16.2
18.4
22.6
26.7
31.0
35.6
41.1
46.2
51.1
56.2
60.6
65.2
70.2
76.0
83.5
95.3
101.2
105.6
109.2
112.6
115.3
116.2
113.5
103.7
68.3
-10.9
-9.5
-5.9
-1.8

35.4
40.3
45.1
54.6
59.6
63.7
79.6
84.0
88.6
91.7
122.9
127.1
132.0
135.5
138.7
157.0
158.9
159.7
161.1
161.8
161.6
159.9
159.0
159.0
158.4
159.8
160.7
160.9
159.6
154.5
140.7
137.7
137.6
139.4
141.2
140.6
138.1
132.4
118.9
77.7
-14.8
-12.6
-8.5
-3.8

-12.0
-8.8
-5.6
-5.0
-2.1
0.9
0.3
3.3
6.8
10.2
13.6
17.2
22.3
28.2
32.3
36.2
39.6
42.8
46.0
48.3
50.5
53.4
55.8
58.6
61.1
65.7
70.0
74.5
79.6
87.0
98.4
101.8
103.6
107.7
111.3
112.2
111.2
107.2
95.6
60.2
-17.8
-14.7
-9.6
-4.1

-35.9
-41.0
-46.0
-54.7
-59.7
-63.3
-76.5
-79.9
-83.6
-85.3
-109.7
-111.8
-114.4
-114.9
-115.3
-128.0
-128.9
-131.6
-135.0
-138.8
-142.3
-144.5
-147.8
-150.6
-153.7
-154.8
-156.2
-157.2
-156.8
-151.9
-138.7
-139.4
-143.0
-144.6
-146.5
-148.9
-149.6
-146.3
-135.8
-94.4
-1.8
-1.6
-3.9
-6.8

-19.4
-23.9
-28.4
-34.0
-38.2
-41.5
-48.9
-51.8
-55.2
-56.9
-71.7
-73.6
-76.2
-77.6
-78.3
-86.0
-87.4
-91.0
-95.0
-99.4
-103.7
-107.5
-111.9
-115.8
-120.0
-122.2
-124.8
-127.2
-129.1
-128.5
-124.1
-127.0
-131.3
-133.7
-136.1
-139.0
-140.3
-137.6
-127.8
-88.3
-0.8
-0.9
-3.5
-6.7

-28.5
-25.9
-23.2
-25.8
-23.6
-20.9
-27.2
-24.8
-21.6
-18.2
-24.5
-21.0
-15.9
-9.1
-4.7
-5.8
-1.9
2.2
6.0
8.9
12.0
16.5
20.0
23.7
27.3
33.1
38.6
44.6
51.9
63.6
83.8
89.3
91.9
96.7
100.9
102.4
102.0
98.4
87.6
54.2
-18.8
-15.4
-10.0
-4.1

-28.5
-25.9
-23.1
-25.7
-23.8
-21.6
-29.1
-27.5
-25.2
-22.9
-32.5
-30.7
-27.7
-23.1
-21.1
-25.8
-23.1
-18.0
-13.3
-8.5
-3.0
4.1
10.4
16.2
22.4
27.9
33.7
40.2
48.2
60.1
80.7
88.7
93.8
98.3
102.2
105.4
107.0
104.8
95.7
62.3
-11.9
-10.2
-6.3
-1.9

11.5
8.1
4.7
4.9
2.1
-0.6
2.8
0.8
-1.8
-3.7
-0.4
-1.9
-4.6
-7.7
-8.9
-7.2
-9.5
-14.7
-19.9
-25.3
-31.2
-38.0
-44.5
-50.2
-56.4
-60.8
-65.6
-70.8
-76.9
-84.4
-96.5
-103.5
-109.1
-112.9
-116.6
-120.4
-122.8
-121.1
-112.6
-76.9
1.2
0.4
-2.8
-6.6

-35.9
-41.0
-45.9
-54.7
-59.9
-64.1
-78.3
-82.6
-87.2
-90.0
-117.7
-121.5
-126.1
-128.9
-131.6
-147.9
-150.1
-151.9
-154.2
-156.1
-157.3
-156.8
-157.4
-158.1
-158.7
-160.0
-161.0
-161.5
-160.5
-155.4
-141.8
-140.0
-141.1
-143.1
-145.2
-145.8
-144.6
-139.9
-127.8
-86.3
5.1
3.6
-0.2
-4.6

18.9
23.2
27.5
33.8
38.1
41.8
52.0
55.9
60.2
63.3
84.9
88.9
93.9
98.2
101.7
115.0
117.5
119.1
121.1
122.4
123.0
122.9
123.2
124.1
124.7
127.2
129.2
130.9
131.9
131.1
126.0
125.3
125.8
128.4
130.8
130.8
128.8
123.7
110.9
71.7
-15.8
-13.3
-8.9
-3.9

-19.4
-23.9
-28.3
-33.9
-38.4
-42.2
-50.7
-54.5
-58.7
-61.6
-79.7
-83.3
-87.9
-91.6
-94.7
-106.0
-108.6
-111.2
-114.2
-116.7
-118.7
-119.9
-121.5
-123.3
-124.9
-127.4
-129.6
-131.6
-132.8
-132.0
-127.2
-127.6
-129.4
-132.1
-134.8
-135.9
-135.3
-131.2
-119.7
-80.3
6.1
4.3
0.2
-4.5

28.0
25.2
22.3
25.6
23.6
21.2
30.3
28.9
26.6
24.6
37.7
36.3
33.6
29.6
28.1
34.8
31.9
25.9
20.1
14.2
7.3
-1.1
-8.7
-15.4
-22.7
-28.1
-34.1
-40.8
-49.1
-61.0
-81.8
-91.0
-97.4
-101.9
-106.2
-110.6
-113.5
-112.4
-104.5
-70.8
2.2
1.1
-2.4
-6.5

6.4
13.2
19.9
25.7
31.9
37.5
44.2
49.4
55.6
60.2
77.6
82.7
89.7
96.5
100.8
111.9
116.1
121.8
127.8
133.3
138.6
144.1
149.6
155.2
160.7
166.8
172.9
178.9
185.1
191.0
197.1
202.3
207.3
212.9
218.2
221.2
221.0
214.5
195.1
128.7
-18.8
-15.6
-8.7
-0.8

-6.8
-13.6
-20.5
-25.8
-32.1
-37.8
-43.3
-48.4
-54.5
-58.9
-73.7
-78.6
-85.2
-91.5
-95.6
-105.1
-109.5
-115.9
-122.6
-129.0
-135.4
-141.8
-148.3
-154.5
-160.9
-167.0
-173.1
-179.4
-185.7
-191.7
-198.0
-204.0
-210.0
-215.7
-221.2
-225.0
-225.9
-220.2
-201.7
-135.2
11.5
8.8
2.2
-5.5

SpecY
251.77
261.89
270.69
317.70
328.14
330.16
413.93
419.07
424.23
422.68
567.69
572.21
574.25
564.98
564.42
641.45
634.76
618.74
606.40
594.02
577.66
551.43
533.28
518.14
502.62
486.37
469.12
447.77
415.49
352.66
226.24
194.35
184.47
172.54
162.77
155.35
148.08
140.68
132.32
101.98
25.61
18.10
11.27
4.78

Page 7 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead

Live

-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Dead
-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Live

-6.79
-11.11
-15.41
-24.09
-29.16
-33.81
-43.20
-48.24
-54.47
-59.24
-57.57
-61.60
-66.64
-71.16
-74.10
-83.01
-86.23
-90.97
-95.85
-100.55
-105.24
-109.95
-114.69
-119.06
-123.51
-127.28
-131.03
-134.71
-138.33
-141.58
-144.84
-148.13
-151.30
-153.73
-155.74
-156.91
-156.02
-150.87
-137.49
-92.81
2.23
2.68
0.61
-2.10

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A33

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

4.11
8.38
12.63
16.08
20.02
23.55
27.33
30.57
34.42
37.24
47.30
50.40
54.64
58.75
61.38
67.81
70.49
74.29
78.25
81.96
85.63
89.34
93.11
96.78
100.52
104.31
108.12
111.97
115.87
119.62
123.49
126.97
130.39
133.95
137.32
139.44
139.64
135.86
124.02
82.47
-9.44
-7.65
-3.39
1.49

WindMTX
-10.17
-10.47
-10.69
-15.53
-15.95
-16.18
-22.04
-22.57
-23.14
-23.37
-23.67
-24.07
-24.29
-23.95
-23.91
-27.27
-27.05
-26.56
-26.17
-25.78
-25.19
-24.15
-23.36
-22.64
-21.85
-21.08
-20.25
-19.24
-17.78
-15.17
-10.10
-8.65
-8.02
-7.43
-6.94
-6.46
-5.96
-5.48
-4.93
-3.64
-0.73
-0.48
-0.25
-0.02

WindMTX
9.15
9.49
9.79
11.52
11.93
12.12
15.30
15.58
15.80
15.75
21.11
21.21
21.19
20.69
20.53
23.30
23.02
22.55
22.20
21.89
21.41
20.51
19.90
19.34
18.74
18.11
17.45
16.63
15.39
12.98
8.12
6.91
6.52
6.09
5.75
5.45
5.14
4.83
4.46
3.35
0.58
0.39
0.21
0.05

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindMTY
-29.22
-30.08
-30.71
-44.62
-45.85
-46.49
-63.36
-64.88
-66.51
-67.19
-68.05
-69.21
-69.86
-68.89
-68.79
-78.47
-77.85
-76.45
-75.34
-74.22
-72.54
-69.55
-67.29
-65.22
-62.95
-60.76
-58.37
-55.47
-51.30
-43.77
-29.17
-24.97
-23.15
-21.48
-20.06
-18.68
-17.25
-15.88
-14.30
-10.56
-2.12
-1.40
-0.72
-0.05

-2.8
-2.8
-2.8
-2.8
-2.7
-2.6
-2.5
-2.4
-2.2
-2.2
-2.0
-1.9
-1.8
-1.8
-1.7
-1.6
-1.4
-1.3
-1.1
-1.1
-1.0
-0.8
-0.7
-0.7
-0.6
-0.8
-0.7
-0.5
-0.4
-0.5
-0.4
-0.4
-0.5
-0.6
-0.7
-0.7
-0.7
-0.8
-0.8
-0.2
-1.1
-1.2
-1.3
-1.3

-2.8
-2.9
-3.0
-3.2
-3.3
-3.5
-3.8
-3.8
-4.1
-3.9
-4.1
-4.1
-4.3
-4.2
-4.3
-4.5
-4.7
-4.9
-5.1
-5.0
-5.2
-5.4
-5.6
-5.5
-5.7
-5.3
-5.5
-5.6
-5.8
-5.7
-5.8
-5.8
-5.8
-5.5
-5.5
-5.6
-5.6
-5.4
-5.5
-5.5
-5.4
-5.0
-5.0
-5.0

-10.9
-16.1
-21.3
-31.7
-37.8
-43.3
-54.5
-60.4
-67.8
-73.5
-71.4
-76.1
-82.1
-87.5
-90.9
-101.6
-105.3
-110.9
-116.7
-122.3
-127.8
-133.3
-138.9
-144.2
-149.4
-154.1
-158.5
-162.8
-167.1
-171.0
-174.9
-178.9
-182.7
-185.7
-188.2
-189.6
-188.5
-182.4
-166.3
-112.2
1.1
1.5
-1.0
-4.3

-10.9
-16.2
-21.4
-32.0
-38.2
-44.0
-55.5
-61.5
-69.2
-74.8
-73.0
-77.8
-84.0
-89.3
-92.9
-103.8
-107.8
-113.6
-119.6
-125.2
-131.0
-136.8
-142.6
-147.7
-153.2
-157.5
-162.1
-166.7
-171.1
-174.9
-178.9
-182.9
-186.7
-189.4
-191.8
-193.3
-192.2
-185.9
-169.9
-116.2
-2.2
-1.3
-3.8
-7.1

5.4
10.5
15.7
26.1
32.2
37.9
49.2
55.3
63.0
68.7
66.8
71.7
77.9
83.3
86.9
97.7
101.6
107.4
113.4
119.0
124.8
130.5
136.3
141.6
147.0
151.4
156.0
160.5
164.9
168.8
172.7
176.7
180.4
183.2
185.6
187.0
185.9
179.7
163.6
110.5
-4.3
-4.9
-2.5
0.8

5.4
10.5
15.6
25.8
31.7
37.2
48.2
54.2
61.5
67.4
65.2
70.1
75.9
81.5
84.9
95.4
99.2
104.7
110.4
116.1
121.6
127.1
132.6
138.0
143.2
148.0
152.4
156.6
160.9
164.9
168.7
172.6
176.4
179.6
182.0
183.3
182.2
176.2
160.1
106.5
-7.5
-7.7
-5.3
-2.0

-23.1
-28.7
-34.2
-50.5
-57.1
-63.0
-81.4
-88.1
-96.3
-102.2
-100.6
-105.8
-112.2
-117.1
-120.6
-135.4
-139.0
-144.1
-149.6
-154.7
-159.6
-164.0
-168.8
-173.1
-177.5
-181.1
-184.6
-187.8
-190.4
-191.2
-189.0
-191.2
-194.3
-196.5
-198.3
-199.2
-197.5
-190.7
-174.0
-118.6
-1.4
-0.5
-2.7
-5.7

1.3
-3.6
-8.5
-13.2
-18.9
-24.2
-28.5
-33.9
-40.7
-46.1
-43.8
-48.1
-53.9
-59.6
-63.2
-69.9
-74.1
-80.4
-86.7
-92.8
-99.2
-106.1
-112.7
-118.8
-125.1
-130.5
-136.0
-141.6
-147.8
-154.7
-164.8
-170.5
-175.1
-178.6
-181.7
-183.7
-183.2
-177.6
-162.2
-109.8
0.3
0.7
-2.1
-5.7

-6.8
-2.0
2.8
7.3
12.8
18.1
22.2
27.7
34.5
40.0
37.6
42.0
47.8
53.7
57.2
63.8
67.9
74.2
80.5
86.7
93.0
99.8
106.5
112.6
118.9
124.4
129.9
135.5
141.5
148.6
158.6
164.3
168.8
172.5
175.5
177.4
176.9
171.4
155.9
104.2
-6.8
-6.9
-4.2
-0.6

17.6
23.1
28.5
44.6
51.1
56.9
75.2
81.9
90.0
96.1
94.4
99.8
106.1
111.1
114.6
129.3
132.9
137.9
143.3
148.5
153.4
157.8
162.5
166.9
171.3
175.0
178.5
181.7
184.2
185.0
182.8
185.0
188.1
190.3
192.1
192.9
191.2
184.5
167.8
112.9
-5.0
-5.8
-3.6
-0.6

-37.8
-38.9
-39.6
-56.4
-57.8
-58.5
-78.7
-80.4
-82.2
-83.0
-84.0
-85.3
-85.9
-84.8
-84.6
-96.1
-95.3
-93.5
-92.0
-90.7
-88.6
-84.9
-82.0
-79.6
-76.8
-74.3
-71.3
-67.7
-62.6
-53.6
-36.1
-31.1
-28.9
-27.0
-25.4
-23.7
-22.0
-20.4
-18.5
-13.5
-4.1
-3.4
-2.6
-1.8

32.3
33.3
34.1
50.7
52.2
53.1
73.4
75.3
77.4
78.2
79.4
80.8
81.7
80.6
80.5
92.2
91.6
90.0
88.8
87.4
85.5
82.1
79.5
77.0
74.3
71.6
68.8
65.4
60.5
51.4
33.9
28.9
26.7
24.5
22.8
21.1
19.4
17.7
15.8
11.8
0.9
0.0
-0.9
-1.7

-37.8
-38.9
-39.8
-56.7
-58.3
-59.2
-79.7
-81.5
-83.6
-84.3
-85.5
-86.9
-87.9
-86.5
-86.6
-98.3
-97.7
-96.2
-95.0
-93.6
-91.7
-88.3
-85.7
-83.1
-80.6
-77.6
-74.9
-71.6
-66.7
-57.5
-40.1
-35.1
-32.9
-30.7
-29.0
-27.4
-25.7
-23.9
-22.1
-17.5
-7.4
-6.2
-5.4
-4.6

32.3
33.3
33.9
50.4
51.8
52.4
72.4
74.2
76.0
76.9
77.8
79.2
79.8
78.8
78.6
90.0
89.1
87.3
85.8
84.5
82.4
78.6
75.8
73.4
70.5
68.2
65.2
61.6
56.4
47.5
29.9
24.8
22.7
20.9
19.1
17.5
15.7
14.2
12.3
7.8
-2.3
-2.8
-3.7
-4.5

-44.4
-49.3
-54.0
-78.7
-84.8
-89.7
-118.6
-124.9
-132.4
-137.5
-137.0
-141.9
-147.2
-150.1
-152.5
-172.3
-174.3
-176.8
-179.8
-182.6
-184.7
-185.3
-186.7
-188.2
-189.3
-190.1
-190.6
-190.3
-188.4
-182.2
-167.4
-165.3
-166.0
-166.2
-166.3
-165.7
-163.2
-156.9
-143.0
-97.8
-2.6
-1.3
-2.4
-4.1

-26.1
-30.5
-34.7
-50.8
-56.0
-60.6
-78.9
-84.2
-90.7
-95.4
-94.3
-98.6
-103.4
-106.9
-109.4
-123.1
-125.6
-129.0
-132.6
-136.2
-139.4
-141.8
-144.6
-147.4
-150.0
-152.2
-154.1
-155.6
-156.4
-154.9
-149.2
-149.7
-151.6
-152.8
-153.8
-154.1
-152.5
-147.1
-134.1
-91.2
-1.2
-0.5
-2.0
-4.0

-32.1
-29.3
-26.2
-35.3
-32.2
-28.8
-40.8
-38.0
-34.3
-30.8
-33.2
-31.0
-27.1
-21.9
-19.0
-22.7
-19.0
-12.9
-7.1
-1.5
4.9
12.8
19.9
26.3
33.2
39.2
45.5
52.4
60.8
72.8
93.5
101.6
106.6
110.7
114.2
116.9
117.9
114.9
104.7
69.4
-6.6
-6.2
-3.5
-0.3

-13.8
-10.5
-6.9
-7.4
-3.5
0.4
-1.1
2.7
7.4
11.3
9.4
12.4
16.6
21.3
24.0
26.4
29.8
34.9
40.1
45.0
50.2
56.3
62.0
67.1
72.5
77.1
82.0
87.1
92.8
100.2
111.7
117.1
121.0
124.1
126.7
128.6
128.6
124.7
113.6
76.0
-5.3
-5.3
-3.1
-0.2

8.3
4.9
1.4
1.6
-2.2
-5.9
-4.5
-8.0
-12.6
-16.5
-14.4
-17.2
-21.3
-26.0
-28.6
-30.9
-34.1
-39.1
-44.1
-48.9
-54.1
-60.0
-65.5
-70.6
-75.9
-80.7
-85.4
-90.3
-96.0
-103.4
-114.9
-120.3
-124.3
-127.5
-130.2
-132.1
-132.1
-128.3
-117.2
-78.7
1.2
1.2
-1.1
-4.0

-44.4
-49.4
-54.1
-79.0
-85.1
-90.2
-119.4
-125.7
-133.5
-138.5
-138.2
-143.2
-148.6
-151.4
-154.0
-173.9
-176.2
-178.9
-182.0
-184.8
-187.1
-187.9
-189.5
-190.8
-192.2
-192.7
-193.3
-193.2
-191.5
-185.2
-170.4
-168.3
-169.0
-169.0
-169.1
-168.5
-166.0
-159.6
-145.6
-100.7
-5.0
-3.5
-4.5
-6.2

8.3
4.8
1.2
1.4
-2.5
-6.5
-5.2
-8.8
-13.7
-17.4
-15.5
-18.5
-22.8
-27.3
-30.1
-32.6
-35.9
-41.1
-46.3
-51.1
-56.4
-62.5
-68.3
-73.3
-78.8
-83.2
-88.1
-93.2
-99.1
-106.3
-117.9
-123.4
-127.3
-130.3
-132.9
-134.8
-134.9
-130.9
-119.9
-81.7
-1.2
-0.9
-3.2
-6.1

38.8
43.7
48.3
72.8
78.8
83.6
112.3
118.7
126.2
131.4
130.8
135.9
141.1
144.1
146.5
166.1
168.2
170.6
173.5
176.5
178.5
179.0
180.4
182.0
183.1
184.1
184.4
184.1
182.2
176.1
161.2
159.1
159.7
160.1
160.1
159.5
156.9
150.7
136.7
92.1
-3.9
-4.9
-3.9
-2.2

20.5
24.8
29.0
44.8
50.0
54.5
72.6
78.1
84.5
89.3
88.2
92.5
97.3
100.9
103.4
117.0
119.4
122.8
126.4
130.0
133.2
135.5
138.4
141.2
143.7
146.1
148.0
149.5
150.2
148.8
143.0
143.5
145.3
146.7
147.6
147.9
146.2
140.9
127.8
85.5
-5.2
-5.8
-4.3
-2.3

26.6
23.7
20.5
29.4
26.2
22.7
34.5
31.8
28.0
24.7
27.1
24.9
21.0
15.9
13.0
16.6
12.8
6.7
0.9
-4.7
-11.1
-19.0
-26.2
-32.5
-39.4
-45.2
-51.6
-58.6
-67.0
-79.0
-99.7
-107.8
-112.8
-116.9
-120.4
-123.2
-124.2
-121.1
-111.0
-75.1
0.1
-0.1
-2.8
-6.0

26.6
23.7
20.6
29.6
26.6
23.2
35.3
32.6
29.1
25.6
28.3
26.1
22.5
17.2
14.5
18.3
14.7
8.8
3.1
-2.5
-8.7
-16.5
-23.4
-29.9
-36.6
-42.7
-48.9
-55.7
-64.0
-76.0
-96.7
-104.8
-109.8
-114.1
-117.7
-120.4
-121.4
-118.5
-108.3
-72.2
2.6
2.1
-0.7
-3.9

-13.8
-10.5
-7.1
-7.6
-3.8
-0.1
-1.8
1.8
6.3
10.4
8.2
11.2
15.2
20.0
22.6
24.8
27.9
32.9
37.8
42.8
47.9
53.7
59.2
64.5
69.7
74.6
79.3
84.2
89.8
97.2
108.7
114.1
118.0
121.4
124.0
125.8
125.8
122.1
111.0
73.0
-7.7
-7.4
-5.2
-2.3

38.8
43.7
48.4
73.0
79.1
84.1
113.1
119.5
127.2
132.4
132.0
137.1
142.5
145.4
148.0
167.8
170.0
172.7
175.8
178.7
180.9
181.6
183.2
184.6
186.0
186.6
187.1
187.0
185.3
179.0
164.3
162.1
162.7
162.8
162.9
162.2
159.7
153.4
139.4
95.0
-1.5
-2.8
-1.8
-0.1

-26.1
-30.5
-34.8
-51.0
-56.4
-61.1
-79.6
-85.1
-91.8
-96.4
-95.5
-99.8
-104.9
-108.2
-110.9
-124.8
-127.4
-131.0
-134.9
-138.4
-141.7
-144.3
-147.4
-150.0
-152.8
-154.7
-156.8
-158.5
-159.4
-157.8
-152.2
-152.8
-154.6
-155.6
-156.6
-156.9
-155.2
-149.7
-136.7
-94.2
-3.7
-2.6
-4.1
-6.1

-0.2
-0.2
-0.2
0.0
-0.3
-0.8
-1.2
-1.9
-2.6
-3.5
-5.2
-6.6
-8.2
-10.0
-11.9
-14.4
-15.5
-15.0
-14.5
-13.2
-11.6
-9.9
-7.9
-6.4
-4.5
-4.7
-4.5
-4.1
-3.6
-3.5
-3.2
-1.4
0.4
0.0
-0.3
0.8
2.0
2.8
3.9
4.0
2.5
1.2
0.0
-1.2

-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.1
0.1
0.5
2.1
2.9
3.7
4.8
9.1
10.7
12.6
14.9
17.2
21.1
22.2
20.9
19.7
17.5
14.9
12.1
9.1
7.0
4.3
4.5
4.2
3.6
2.9
2.8
2.3
-0.3
-3.0
-2.8
-2.7
-4.7
-6.9
-8.5
-10.5
-10.4
-9.7
-8.0
-6.5
-5.1

4.7
9.8
14.9
19.3
23.8
27.6
32.1
35.4
39.5
42.2
53.3
56.1
60.0
63.6
65.4
71.4
73.8
78.6
83.7
88.9
94.4
100.1
106.0
111.4
117.2
121.7
126.4
131.2
136.2
140.8
145.7
151.1
156.4
160.4
164.2
167.4
168.5
164.4
150.9
101.1
-10.4
-9.1
-4.9
0.1

4.8
9.8
14.8
19.2
24.1
28.6
34.5
39.0
44.2
48.5
64.0
69.1
75.6
82.3
87.2
98.1
102.0
105.6
109.3
112.0
114.3
116.6
118.7
121.5
123.8
128.5
132.8
137.0
141.2
145.5
149.8
151.9
153.9
158.3
162.4
163.3
161.8
155.9
140.1
90.4
-19.5
-16.0
-9.8
-2.9

-5.1
-10.3
-15.4
-19.3
-24.3
-28.9
-33.5
-37.9
-43.1
-47.1
-60.2
-64.9
-71.2
-77.4
-81.9
-91.3
-95.4
-99.7
-104.1
-107.7
-111.1
-114.3
-117.5
-120.8
-124.0
-128.7
-133.1
-137.5
-141.8
-146.2
-150.7
-153.6
-156.5
-161.1
-165.4
-167.2
-166.7
-161.6
-146.8
-96.8
12.3
9.2
3.3
-3.4

-5.1
-10.3
-15.5
-19.4
-24.0
-27.9
-31.1
-34.4
-38.4
-40.9
-49.5
-51.9
-55.5
-58.7
-60.1
-64.7
-67.1
-72.7
-78.5
-84.7
-91.2
-97.8
-104.7
-110.8
-117.4
-121.8
-126.7
-131.7
-136.9
-141.5
-146.6
-152.8
-159.1
-163.2
-167.2
-171.3
-173.4
-170.1
-157.5
-107.5
3.1
2.3
-1.7
-6.4

15.7
21.2
26.6
33.1
38.2
42.6
51.6
55.9
60.8
64.2
84.0
88.0
93.2
97.8
100.9
112.7
115.5
119.1
123.1
126.7
130.1
133.0
136.2
139.6
143.0
146.8
150.5
154.1
157.2
158.8
157.5
159.8
163.0
166.7
170.2
171.9
171.3
166.0
150.9
99.8
-14.3
-12.1
-7.1
-1.3

-6.2
-1.6
3.1
5.4
9.6
13.6
14.9
18.5
22.9
26.5
33.4
37.1
42.4
48.1
51.7
56.8
60.3
65.0
69.8
74.2
78.7
83.7
88.5
93.2
98.0
103.4
108.7
114.2
120.2
127.6
138.0
143.2
147.3
152.0
156.4
158.8
158.9
154.4
140.2
91.7
-15.7
-13.0
-7.6
-1.4

5.9
1.1
-3.7
-5.5
-9.8
-13.9
-14.0
-17.5
-21.8
-25.1
-29.5
-32.9
-37.9
-43.2
-46.4
-50.0
-53.6
-59.1
-64.7
-70.0
-75.4
-81.5
-87.2
-92.6
-98.2
-103.5
-109.0
-114.6
-120.9
-128.3
-138.9
-144.9
-150.0
-154.8
-159.4
-162.7
-163.8
-160.1
-146.8
-98.2
8.4
6.2
1.1
-4.9

-16.1
-21.7
-27.2
-33.1
-38.4
-42.9
-50.7
-54.9
-59.7
-62.9
-80.2
-83.8
-88.8
-92.9
-95.7
-106.0
-108.9
-113.3
-118.0
-122.5
-126.8
-130.7
-135.0
-139.0
-143.2
-147.0
-150.8
-154.5
-157.9
-159.5
-158.4
-161.5
-165.6
-169.4
-173.2
-175.8
-176.2
-171.7
-157.5
-106.2
7.0
5.3
0.5
-5.0

31.4
32.5
33.5
39.7
40.9
41.1
52.0
52.5
52.6
51.9
69.4
68.8
67.5
64.6
62.6
70.5
68.7
67.4
66.4
66.2
65.7
63.8
63.0
62.1
61.4
59.1
57.0
54.4
50.5
42.2
25.6
22.7
22.5
20.8
19.3
19.1
18.8
18.2
17.6
13.8
2.9
1.4
-0.1
-1.5

-31.8
-32.9
-34.0
-39.7
-41.4
-42.4
-53.5
-55.0
-56.3
-56.8
-76.2
-77.6
-78.7
-78.3
-79.1
-90.4
-90.3
-88.4
-86.9
-85.0
-82.3
-78.0
-74.5
-71.6
-68.2
-66.2
-63.7
-60.7
-56.1
-47.6
-30.7
-25.2
-22.6
-21.5
-20.5
-18.8
-17.0
-15.4
-13.4
-9.5
-1.1
-1.3
-1.6
-1.8

31.4
32.5
33.4
39.6
41.2
42.1
54.5
56.1
57.4
58.1
80.1
81.8
83.2
83.2
84.4
97.1
96.9
94.3
92.1
89.3
85.6
80.3
75.8
72.2
68.0
66.0
63.4
60.2
55.4
46.9
29.8
23.5
20.0
18.7
17.6
14.9
12.1
9.7
6.8
3.1
-6.2
-5.5
-5.0
-4.5

-31.7
-33.0
-34.1
-39.8
-41.1
-41.4
-51.1
-51.4
-51.6
-50.5
-65.5
-64.6
-63.1
-59.7
-57.3
-63.8
-62.1
-61.5
-61.3
-61.9
-62.4
-61.5
-61.8
-61.5
-61.6
-59.3
-57.3
-54.9
-51.1
-42.9
-26.5
-24.4
-25.2
-23.6
-22.3
-22.9
-23.7
-23.9
-24.2
-20.2
-10.2
-8.2
-6.5
-4.8

35.5
40.4
45.3
54.6
59.4
63.0
77.6
81.1
84.9
86.8
114.2
116.7
119.6
120.6
121.4
135.8
136.6
138.5
141.0
143.8
146.1
147.1
149.3
151.3
153.5
154.7
155.9
156.6
156.0
151.1
137.7
137.4
139.9
141.4
143.0
144.3
143.9
139.7
128.1
86.9
-6.7
-6.4
-3.7
-0.5

19.0
23.3
27.7
33.9
38.0
41.1
50.0
53.0
56.4
58.5
76.2
78.4
81.4
83.4
84.4
93.9
95.1
97.9
101.0
104.3
107.5
110.2
113.4
116.5
119.7
122.0
124.4
126.7
128.3
127.7
123.1
125.0
128.2
130.4
132.7
134.5
134.6
131.0
120.1
80.8
-7.7
-7.0
-4.1
-0.6

28.1
25.3
22.5
25.7
23.4
20.5
28.3
26.0
22.9
19.7
29.0
25.9
21.1
14.8
10.8
13.7
9.6
4.7
0.0
-3.9
-8.1
-13.8
-18.5
-23.0
-27.6
-33.3
-38.9
-45.1
-52.7
-64.5
-84.8
-91.3
-95.0
-99.9
-104.4
-106.9
-107.7
-105.1
-95.3
-61.7
10.3
7.4
2.4
-3.2

11.6
8.2
4.9
4.9
1.9
-1.3
0.8
-2.0
-5.6
-8.6
-9.0
-12.4
-17.1
-22.5
-26.1
-28.3
-31.8
-35.9
-40.0
-43.3
-46.7
-50.8
-54.3
-57.9
-61.3
-65.9
-70.4
-75.1
-80.4
-87.8
-99.4
-103.8
-106.7
-110.9
-114.7
-116.7
-117.0
-113.8
-103.4
-67.7
9.3
6.7
2.0
-3.3

-11.9
-8.7
-5.4
-5.0
-2.3
0.2
-1.6
0.4
3.1
5.3
4.9
6.8
9.8
13.4
15.0
15.1
17.3
21.6
25.9
30.3
35.0
40.7
46.0
50.9
56.2
60.6
65.2
70.2
76.1
83.6
95.4
101.5
106.0
109.7
113.1
115.9
117.1
114.5
104.8
69.4
-9.7
-8.4
-4.8
-0.8

35.5
40.4
45.2
54.6
59.7
63.7
79.4
83.8
88.5
91.5
122.2
126.4
131.3
134.6
137.8
155.8
157.8
158.7
160.2
161.1
161.1
159.5
158.8
158.9
158.4
159.8
160.7
161.0
159.7
154.6
140.8
138.0
138.0
139.8
141.7
141.2
138.9
133.3
120.0
78.8
-13.6
-11.5
-7.4
-2.8

-11.9
-8.7
-5.5
-5.0
-2.1
1.0
0.2
3.1
6.7
9.9
12.9
16.5
21.5
27.4
31.4
35.1
38.5
41.8
45.1
47.6
50.0
53.1
55.6
58.5
61.1
65.8
70.1
74.6
79.8
87.1
98.5
102.0
104.1
108.1
111.8
112.8
112.1
108.1
96.7
61.3
-16.6
-13.5
-8.5
-3.0

-35.8
-40.9
-45.9
-54.7
-59.6
-63.3
-76.6
-80.0
-83.8
-85.5
-110.3
-112.5
-115.1
-115.7
-116.1
-129.1
-130.0
-132.6
-135.9
-139.5
-142.8
-144.8
-148.0
-150.7
-153.7
-154.8
-156.1
-157.1
-156.7
-151.8
-138.6
-139.2
-142.6
-144.2
-146.0
-148.2
-148.8
-145.4
-134.7
-93.3
-0.6
-0.4
-2.8
-5.8

-19.3
-23.8
-28.3
-34.0
-38.1
-41.4
-49.1
-52.0
-55.4
-57.1
-72.3
-74.3
-76.9
-78.5
-79.2
-87.1
-88.5
-92.0
-95.9
-100.1
-104.3
-107.9
-112.2
-115.9
-119.9
-122.2
-124.7
-127.1
-129.0
-128.4
-123.9
-126.7
-130.8
-133.2
-135.6
-138.4
-139.5
-136.7
-126.7
-87.3
0.5
0.2
-2.4
-5.7

-28.4
-25.8
-23.1
-25.8
-23.6
-20.8
-27.4
-25.0
-21.8
-18.4
-25.1
-21.7
-16.7
-9.9
-5.6
-6.9
-3.0
1.2
5.1
8.1
11.4
16.1
19.7
23.6
27.4
33.1
38.6
44.6
52.0
63.7
83.9
89.6
92.3
97.1
101.4
103.0
102.8
99.4
88.7
55.3
-17.6
-14.2
-8.9
-3.1

-28.4
-25.8
-23.0
-25.7
-23.8
-21.6
-29.2
-27.7
-25.4
-23.1
-33.2
-31.4
-28.4
-23.9
-21.9
-26.9
-24.2
-19.0
-14.1
-9.2
-3.5
3.7
10.2
16.1
22.4
28.0
33.8
40.3
48.3
60.2
80.8
89.0
94.3
98.7
102.7
106.1
107.8
105.8
96.8
63.4
-10.7
-9.1
-5.2
-0.9

11.6
8.2
4.8
4.9
2.1
-0.5
2.6
0.6
-2.0
-4.0
-1.0
-2.6
-5.3
-8.5
-9.8
-8.3
-10.6
-15.7
-20.7
-26.0
-31.8
-38.4
-44.7
-50.3
-56.4
-60.7
-65.5
-70.7
-76.8
-84.3
-96.3
-103.2
-108.7
-112.5
-116.1
-119.8
-122.0
-120.2
-111.4
-75.8
2.4
1.6
-1.7
-5.5

-35.8
-40.9
-45.8
-54.7
-59.9
-64.0
-78.5
-82.7
-87.4
-90.2
-118.4
-122.2
-126.8
-129.7
-132.5
-149.1
-151.2
-152.8
-155.1
-156.8
-157.8
-157.2
-157.6
-158.2
-158.6
-160.0
-161.0
-161.4
-160.4
-155.3
-141.7
-139.7
-140.7
-142.6
-144.7
-145.1
-143.8
-139.0
-126.6
-85.2
6.3
4.7
0.9
-3.5

19.0
23.3
27.6
33.9
38.2
41.9
51.8
55.7
60.0
63.1
84.2
88.2
93.1
97.4
100.8
113.9
116.4
118.1
120.2
121.7
122.5
122.5
123.0
124.0
124.7
127.2
129.3
131.0
132.0
131.2
126.2
125.6
126.3
128.9
131.3
131.4
129.6
124.6
112.0
72.8
-14.6
-12.2
-7.8
-2.8

WindMTY
26.30
27.27
28.13
33.09
34.27
34.82
43.97
44.79
45.41
45.26
60.69
60.98
60.94
59.52
59.05
67.04
66.25
64.89
63.90
63.01
61.65
59.08
57.31
55.72
54.01
52.21
50.30
47.95
44.39
37.44
23.46
19.97
18.83
17.60
16.62
15.78
14.89
14.00
12.92
9.71
1.66
1.12
0.62
0.14

Page 8 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41
D41

A7
A7
A7
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5
D5

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead

Live

-3.09
-3.13
-3.17
-3.30
-3.34
-3.38
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.39
-3.42
-3.37
-3.40
-3.32
-3.35
-3.40
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.42
-3.44
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.46
-3.38
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.40
-3.43
-3.45
-3.47
-3.42
-3.45
-3.47
-3.49
-3.44
-3.47
-3.16
-3.58
-3.46
-3.48
-3.50

Dead
-0.20
-0.27
-0.33
-0.04
-0.11
-0.16
0.53
0.59
0.60
0.73
2.15
2.32
2.48
2.73
2.93
3.75
3.68
3.28
2.85
2.37
1.82
1.26
0.71
0.34
-0.11
-0.08
-0.16
-0.26
-0.38
-0.39
-0.49
-0.95
-1.48
-1.54
-1.65
-2.15
-2.72
-3.15
-3.69
-3.57
-4.05
-3.78
-3.63
-3.50

Live

-6.79
-11.11
-15.41
-24.09
-29.16
-33.81
-43.20
-48.24
-54.47
-59.24
-57.57
-61.60
-66.64
-71.16
-74.10
-83.01
-86.23
-90.97
-95.85
-100.55
-105.24
-109.95
-114.69
-119.06
-123.51
-127.28
-131.03
-134.71
-138.33
-141.58
-144.84
-148.13
-151.30
-153.73
-155.74
-156.91
-156.02
-150.87
-137.49
-92.81
2.23
2.68
0.61
-2.10

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

A34

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

4.11
8.38
12.63
16.08
20.02
23.55
27.33
30.57
34.42
37.24
47.30
50.40
54.64
58.75
61.38
67.81
70.49
74.29
78.25
81.96
85.63
89.34
93.11
96.78
100.52
104.31
108.12
111.97
115.87
119.62
123.49
126.97
130.39
133.95
137.32
139.44
139.64
135.86
124.02
82.47
-9.44
-7.65
-3.39
1.49

WindMTX
-10.17
-10.47
-10.69
-15.53
-15.95
-16.18
-22.04
-22.57
-23.14
-23.37
-23.67
-24.07
-24.29
-23.95
-23.91
-27.27
-27.05
-26.56
-26.17
-25.78
-25.19
-24.15
-23.36
-22.64
-21.85
-21.08
-20.25
-19.24
-17.78
-15.17
-10.10
-8.65
-8.02
-7.43
-6.94
-6.46
-5.96
-5.48
-4.93
-3.64
-0.73
-0.48
-0.25
-0.02

WindMTX
9.15
9.49
9.79
11.52
11.93
12.12
15.30
15.58
15.80
15.75
21.11
21.21
21.19
20.69
20.53
23.30
23.02
22.55
22.20
21.89
21.41
20.51
19.90
19.34
18.74
18.11
17.45
16.63
15.39
12.98
8.12
6.91
6.52
6.09
5.75
5.45
5.14
4.83
4.46
3.35
0.58
0.39
0.21
0.05

WindFY
0.00
0.02
0.06
0.12
0.19
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.59
0.53
0.66
0.68
0.80
0.73
0.82
0.93
1.03
1.13
1.24
1.21
1.32
1.43
1.54
1.48
1.59
1.41
1.51
1.60
1.70
1.63
1.68
1.68
1.66
1.53
1.52
1.53
1.54
1.45
1.48
1.64
1.34
1.18
1.17
1.16

WindFY
-0.01
0.02
0.05
0.02
-0.12
-0.42
-1.01
-1.49
-1.98
-2.59
-4.46
-5.41
-6.51
-7.76
-9.10
-11.09
-11.77
-11.22
-10.68
-9.61
-8.30
-6.87
-5.31
-4.18
-2.74
-2.86
-2.69
-2.42
-2.05
-1.96
-1.73
-0.32
1.07
0.87
0.74
1.72
2.78
3.54
4.48
4.48
3.81
2.86
2.05
1.24

WindMTY
-29.22
-30.08
-30.71
-44.62
-45.85
-46.49
-63.36
-64.88
-66.51
-67.19
-68.05
-69.21
-69.86
-68.89
-68.79
-78.47
-77.85
-76.45
-75.34
-74.22
-72.54
-69.55
-67.29
-65.22
-62.95
-60.76
-58.37
-55.47
-51.30
-43.77
-29.17
-24.97
-23.15
-21.48
-20.06
-18.68
-17.25
-15.88
-14.30
-10.56
-2.12
-1.40
-0.72
-0.05

20.5
24.9
29.1
45.0
50.4
55.0
73.4
78.9
85.5
90.3
89.4
93.7
98.7
102.3
104.9
118.7
121.3
124.8
128.6
132.2
135.5
138.1
141.1
143.9
146.6
148.6
150.7
152.3
153.2
151.7
146.1
146.5
148.3
149.4
150.4
150.6
149.0
143.5
130.5
88.5
-2.8
-3.6
-2.2
-0.2

-32.1
-29.4
-26.3
-35.6
-32.6
-29.3
-41.5
-38.8
-35.3
-31.7
-34.4
-32.2
-28.6
-23.2
-20.5
-24.4
-20.8
-15.0
-9.3
-3.7
2.5
10.2
17.1
23.7
30.3
36.6
42.8
49.5
57.7
69.9
90.5
98.5
103.6
108.0
111.5
114.2
115.1
112.3
102.1
66.5
-9.0
-8.3
-5.6
-2.4

160.8
173.6
204.7
281.3
299.0
308.5
378.1
390.8
402.4
410.1
390.7
396.6
405.2
408.9
408.6
451.0
450.4
452.3
454.9
458.3
460.0
459.0
460.3
461.6
462.5
463.0
463.4
462.7
459.0
446.6
416.7
413.6
416.9
419.9
423.2
425.2
422.2
408.8
373.9
257.0
17.6
13.7
7.9
6.4

119.2
125.5
136.4
194.4
202.9
206.9
270.0
277.1
284.6
288.1
284.1
288.3
292.3
290.5
289.9
326.2
324.3
321.2
319.2
317.2
313.6
306.0
300.9
296.2
290.9
285.6
279.9
272.7
261.5
239.5
194.8
183.6
180.1
176.9
174.4
171.7
167.3
159.9
145.6
101.6
8.0
5.0
1.6
-0.6

-120.8
-132.1
-162.2
-216.0
-231.7
-240.5
-282.6
-293.0
-302.0
-308.7
-288.2
-292.4
-300.1
-305.5
-305.6
-332.6
-333.2
-337.5
-342.1
-347.3
-351.8
-355.6
-360.6
-365.2
-369.7
-373.7
-378.0
-381.9
-384.9
-384.5
-378.2
-382.0
-388.3
-393.9
-399.4
-403.8
-403.1
-391.8
-359.5
-247.8
-23.7
-20.7
-16.1
-15.7

34.7
33.8
26.3
45.2
43.7
42.2
71.8
72.0
73.2
72.4
80.4
81.6
80.7
76.2
75.7
91.1
89.2
84.3
80.1
75.6
70.0
61.6
54.6
48.1
41.2
34.5
27.5
19.3
8.4
-9.9
-43.7
-55.1
-61.4
-67.2
-72.3
-77.0
-80.3
-80.3
-74.4
-49.8
-4.4
-5.3
-5.6
-7.2

-43.5
-42.7
-35.4
-54.6
-53.2
-51.9
-81.7
-81.8
-83.1
-82.1
-90.2
-91.3
-90.4
-85.7
-85.3
-100.8
-99.0
-94.2
-90.0
-85.3
-79.9
-71.5
-64.6
-58.0
-51.1
-44.2
-37.2
-29.1
-18.2
0.1
33.9
45.2
51.5
57.4
62.5
67.1
70.3
70.4
64.5
40.8
-5.8
-4.6
-4.3
-2.8

112.0
123.1
153.2
206.6
222.2
230.8
272.6
283.2
292.1
299.1
278.4
282.7
290.4
296.0
296.0
322.9
323.4
327.6
332.2
337.5
342.0
345.7
350.6
355.3
359.9
364.1
368.2
372.1
375.0
374.8
368.4
372.1
378.3
384.1
389.6
393.9
393.1
382.0
349.6
238.7
13.5
10.8
6.1
5.7

-169.7
-182.5
-213.8
-290.7
-308.6
-318.1
-388.1
-400.7
-412.4
-419.8
-400.5
-406.2
-414.9
-418.4
-418.1
-460.8
-460.1
-462.1
-464.8
-468.0
-469.8
-468.9
-470.2
-471.4
-472.3
-472.7
-473.1
-472.5
-468.8
-456.3
-426.5
-423.5
-426.9
-429.7
-433.0
-435.2
-432.2
-418.7
-383.8
-266.0
-27.9
-23.6
-17.8
-16.4

-128.0
-134.4
-145.5
-203.8
-212.4
-216.6
-280.0
-287.0
-294.5
-297.7
-293.8
-298.0
-302.0
-300.0
-299.5
-335.9
-334.0
-331.1
-329.1
-327.0
-323.4
-315.9
-310.9
-306.0
-300.8
-295.2
-289.6
-282.5
-271.4
-249.2
-204.6
-193.5
-190.1
-186.7
-184.3
-181.6
-177.3
-169.8
-155.5
-110.6
-18.2
-14.9
-11.5
-9.4

163.2
175.9
207.1
283.8
301.5
311.0
380.8
393.4
405.1
412.7
393.3
399.2
407.8
411.4
411.1
453.6
453.0
454.9
457.6
460.8
462.6
461.6
462.9
464.2
465.1
465.6
466.0
465.3
461.6
449.2
419.3
416.3
419.6
422.5
425.8
427.9
424.9
411.5
376.6
259.4
20.3
16.3
10.5
9.0

121.6
127.8
138.8
196.9
205.4
209.5
272.6
279.7
287.2
290.6
286.7
290.9
294.8
293.0
292.5
328.8
326.8
323.9
321.8
319.8
316.2
308.6
303.5
298.8
293.5
288.1
282.5
275.3
264.2
242.1
197.4
186.2
182.8
179.5
177.1
174.3
169.9
162.5
148.2
104.0
10.7
7.6
4.2
2.1

-118.5
-129.7
-159.8
-213.5
-229.2
-237.9
-280.0
-290.4
-299.4
-306.2
-285.6
-289.8
-297.6
-303.0
-303.0
-330.1
-330.6
-334.9
-339.5
-344.7
-349.2
-353.0
-357.9
-362.6
-367.1
-371.2
-375.4
-379.3
-382.3
-382.0
-375.6
-379.4
-385.6
-391.3
-396.8
-401.1
-400.5
-389.2
-356.9
-245.4
-21.0
-18.1
-13.4
-13.0

37.0
36.2
28.7
47.7
46.2
44.8
74.4
74.6
75.8
75.0
83.0
84.2
83.2
78.7
78.2
93.7
91.8
86.9
82.7
78.2
72.6
64.3
57.3
50.7
43.8
37.1
30.1
21.9
11.0
-7.3
-41.1
-52.5
-58.8
-64.6
-69.7
-74.4
-77.7
-77.7
-71.8
-47.4
-1.7
-2.7
-3.0
-4.5

-41.2
-40.4
-33.0
-52.1
-50.7
-49.3
-79.1
-79.2
-80.5
-79.5
-87.6
-88.7
-87.8
-83.2
-82.7
-98.3
-96.4
-91.6
-87.4
-82.7
-77.3
-68.9
-62.0
-55.4
-48.5
-41.6
-34.7
-26.5
-15.6
2.7
36.5
47.9
54.1
60.0
65.1
69.7
73.0
73.0
67.2
43.2
-3.1
-2.0
-1.7
-0.2

114.4
125.5
155.6
209.1
224.7
233.4
275.3
285.8
294.8
301.6
281.0
285.3
293.0
298.5
298.5
325.5
326.0
330.2
334.8
340.1
344.6
348.3
353.2
357.9
362.5
366.6
370.8
374.7
377.7
377.4
371.0
374.7
381.0
386.7
392.2
396.5
395.8
384.6
352.2
241.1
16.2
13.5
8.8
8.3

-167.3
-180.1
-211.4
-288.2
-306.0
-315.6
-385.5
-398.1
-409.7
-417.2
-397.9
-403.7
-412.3
-415.8
-415.6
-458.2
-457.6
-459.5
-462.2
-465.4
-467.2
-466.3
-467.6
-468.8
-469.7
-470.1
-470.5
-469.9
-466.2
-453.8
-423.9
-420.9
-424.2
-427.1
-430.4
-432.5
-429.6
-416.1
-381.2
-263.6
-25.1
-21.0
-15.2
-13.7

-125.7
-132.0
-143.1
-201.3
-209.9
-214.0
-277.3
-284.3
-291.9
-295.2
-291.3
-295.4
-299.4
-297.5
-297.0
-333.4
-331.4
-328.5
-326.5
-324.4
-320.8
-313.3
-308.2
-303.4
-298.2
-292.7
-287.1
-279.9
-268.8
-246.6
-202.0
-190.8
-187.4
-184.1
-181.7
-179.0
-174.6
-167.2
-152.9
-108.2
-15.5
-12.3
-8.9
-6.8

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
163.18
-169.66
175.94
-182.51
207.12
-213.77
283.79
-290.72
301.54
-308.56
311.02
-318.12
380.79
-388.11
393.45
-400.67
405.06
-412.36
412.68
-419.79
393.28
-400.46
399.17
-406.25
407.79
-414.92
411.38
-418.36
411.10
-418.13
453.62
-460.75
452.96
-460.15
454.87
-462.10
457.56
-464.84
460.85
-468.03
462.59
-469.82
461.61
-468.89
462.90
-470.23
464.17
-471.39
465.08
-472.35
465.56
-472.66
465.98
-473.12
465.28
-472.47
461.59
-468.83
449.20
-456.35
419.30
-426.50
416.25
-423.50
419.56
-426.85
422.53
-429.72
425.79
-433.03
427.87
-435.15
424.87
-432.20
411.46
-418.69
376.56
-383.84
259.38
-266.02
20.34
-27.86
16.34
-23.61
10.54
-17.85
9.03
-16.38

0.71
0.76
0.89
0.85
0.90
0.93
0.84
0.87
0.89
0.91
0.87
0.88
0.90
0.91
0.91
0.87
0.87
0.87
0.88
0.88
0.89
0.88
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.89
0.88
0.86
0.80
0.80
0.81
0.81
0.82
0.82
0.82
0.79
0.72
0.50
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

-19.3
-23.8
-28.2
-33.9
-38.4
-42.2
-50.9
-54.7
-58.9
-61.8
-80.3
-84.0
-88.7
-92.4
-95.5
-107.1
-109.7
-112.2
-115.1
-117.4
-119.2
-120.3
-121.7
-123.4
-124.9
-127.3
-129.6
-131.5
-132.7
-131.9
-127.0
-127.3
-128.9
-131.6
-134.3
-135.3
-134.5
-130.3
-118.6
-79.2
7.3
5.4
1.3
-3.5

28.1
25.3
22.4
25.6
23.6
21.3
30.2
28.7
26.5
24.4
37.0
35.6
32.9
28.8
27.2
33.7
30.8
24.9
19.3
13.4
6.8
-1.5
-8.9
-15.5
-22.6
-28.1
-34.1
-40.7
-49.0
-60.9
-81.7
-90.7
-96.9
-101.5
-105.7
-110.0
-112.7
-111.4
-103.4
-69.8
3.4
2.3
-1.3
-5.4

148.7
159.3
192.5
211.8
227.3
235.4
266.6
275.1
280.3
282.4
356.1
357.6
363.3
365.9
365.1
399.4
397.5
396.7
397.0
397.9
397.4
394.5
394.2
394.9
395.3
397.1
398.8
399.8
398.0
388.1
360.7
359.3
364.5
370.8
377.9
383.1
383.6
374.2
343.7
234.7
25.3
19.6
9.9
6.2

113.1
118.9
131.2
150.1
157.5
160.5
193.4
197.4
200.4
200.7
263.8
265.6
268.0
266.5
266.3
298.5
296.0
291.0
287.3
283.7
278.5
269.9
264.4
260.1
255.5
251.6
247.4
241.7
232.3
212.2
169.4
159.8
158.2
156.8
156.1
155.1
152.7
147.5
135.5
94.6
10.5
7.0
2.4
-0.3

-104.0
-112.9
-144.8
-154.8
-168.6
-176.5
-190.7
-198.1
-202.3
-204.3
-247.9
-248.1
-252.9
-256.5
-255.2
-273.4
-272.9
-276.1
-279.9
-284.4
-288.3
-291.7
-296.3
-300.8
-305.2
-309.9
-315.0
-320.0
-324.4
-325.8
-321.4
-327.1
-335.5
-344.2
-353.4
-361.3
-364.7
-357.9
-330.4
-226.5
-32.3
-27.1
-18.2
-15.3

37.2
37.3
30.0
40.1
38.8
36.9
56.2
55.4
55.6
54.7
82.5
83.9
83.2
79.8
80.3
96.6
94.9
89.1
84.2
79.0
72.8
64.1
57.2
51.4
45.4
39.6
33.2
25.8
15.6
-2.0
-35.2
-46.1
-51.8
-57.8
-63.3
-68.2
-71.8
-72.2
-66.7
-43.7
-6.8
-7.0
-6.0
-6.8

-37.8
-38.0
-31.0
-40.2
-39.1
-37.4
-54.7
-53.7
-53.8
-52.6
-76.4
-77.3
-76.1
-72.0
-71.9
-85.9
-84.4
-79.8
-76.1
-72.2
-67.6
-60.5
-55.2
-50.4
-45.7
-39.8
-33.7
-26.6
-16.7
0.9
33.8
43.4
47.6
53.4
58.6
62.0
64.0
63.2
56.2
33.5
-4.8
-3.8
-4.3
-3.2

103.4
112.2
143.8
154.7
168.3
176.0
192.2
199.8
204.0
206.4
254.1
254.7
260.0
264.3
263.6
284.1
283.4
285.5
288.0
291.2
293.5
295.4
298.4
301.7
304.9
309.7
314.5
319.3
323.3
324.7
320.0
324.4
331.3
339.8
348.6
355.2
357.0
348.9
319.9
216.3
20.7
16.3
7.9
5.3

-149.3
-160.0
-193.4
-212.0
-227.6
-235.8
-265.1
-273.4
-278.6
-280.3
-350.0
-351.0
-356.2
-358.1
-356.7
-388.7
-387.0
-387.4
-388.9
-391.2
-392.2
-390.9
-392.2
-393.9
-395.6
-397.3
-399.3
-400.5
-399.1
-389.2
-362.1
-362.1
-368.7
-375.2
-382.6
-389.3
-391.4
-383.2
-354.2
-244.9
-36.9
-30.4
-20.3
-16.2

-113.6
-119.7
-132.2
-150.2
-157.9
-160.9
-191.9
-195.7
-198.6
-198.6
-257.6
-259.0
-260.9
-258.7
-258.0
-287.7
-285.5
-281.6
-279.1
-276.9
-273.3
-266.3
-262.4
-259.1
-255.8
-251.9
-247.9
-242.5
-233.4
-213.3
-170.8
-162.6
-162.4
-161.1
-160.8
-161.3
-160.5
-156.5
-146.0
-104.8
-22.1
-17.8
-12.8
-9.7

148.9
159.5
192.7
211.9
227.4
235.5
266.2
274.6
279.9
281.8
354.5
355.8
361.4
363.8
362.8
396.6
394.7
394.2
394.9
396.2
396.0
393.5
393.7
394.6
395.4
397.1
399.0
400.0
398.3
388.4
361.1
360.1
365.6
372.0
379.2
384.7
385.6
376.6
346.5
237.4
28.4
22.4
12.6
8.9

113.2
119.1
131.5
150.2
157.6
160.6
193.0
196.9
199.9
200.1
262.1
263.8
266.1
264.5
264.1
295.6
293.2
288.5
285.1
281.9
277.1
269.0
263.8
259.8
255.6
251.7
247.5
241.9
232.6
212.5
169.8
160.6
159.3
157.9
157.3
156.8
154.8
149.8
138.3
97.3
13.6
9.9
5.2
2.3

-103.9
-112.7
-144.5
-154.8
-168.5
-176.4
-191.1
-198.5
-202.8
-204.9
-249.6
-249.9
-254.8
-258.6
-257.4
-276.2
-275.7
-278.6
-282.0
-286.2
-289.7
-292.7
-296.9
-301.0
-305.1
-309.8
-314.8
-319.8
-324.1
-325.5
-321.1
-326.4
-334.4
-343.0
-352.1
-359.7
-362.7
-355.5
-327.6
-223.8
-29.2
-24.3
-15.5
-12.7

37.4
37.5
30.3
40.2
38.9
37.0
55.8
55.0
55.1
54.1
80.9
82.1
81.3
77.7
78.0
93.8
92.1
86.6
82.1
77.2
71.4
63.1
56.7
51.1
45.4
39.6
33.4
26.0
15.9
-1.7
-34.9
-45.4
-50.7
-56.6
-62.0
-66.6
-69.7
-69.8
-64.0
-41.0
-3.7
-4.1
-3.3
-4.1

-37.7
-37.8
-30.7
-40.2
-39.0
-37.3
-55.1
-54.2
-54.3
-53.1
-78.0
-79.0
-78.0
-74.1
-74.1
-88.7
-87.1
-82.3
-78.2
-74.0
-69.0
-61.4
-55.7
-50.7
-45.6
-39.7
-33.6
-26.4
-16.4
1.2
34.2
44.1
48.7
54.5
59.8
63.7
66.1
65.5
59.0
36.2
-1.7
-1.0
-1.6
-0.5

103.6
112.4
144.1
154.8
168.4
176.1
191.8
199.3
203.6
205.9
252.4
253.0
258.1
262.3
261.4
281.3
280.6
283.0
285.9
289.4
292.2
294.4
297.8
301.5
305.0
309.7
314.6
319.5
323.6
325.0
320.4
325.1
332.4
341.0
349.9
356.8
359.0
351.3
322.7
219.0
23.8
19.2
10.6
8.0

-149.1
-159.8
-193.2
-211.9
-227.5
-235.7
-265.5
-273.9
-279.1
-280.9
-351.6
-352.7
-358.1
-360.2
-358.9
-391.5
-389.8
-389.8
-391.1
-393.0
-393.6
-391.8
-392.7
-394.2
-395.5
-397.3
-399.2
-400.3
-398.8
-388.9
-361.7
-361.3
-367.6
-374.0
-381.4
-387.6
-389.3
-380.8
-351.4
-242.2
-33.8
-27.5
-17.5
-13.6

-113.5
-119.5
-131.9
-150.2
-157.8
-160.8
-192.3
-196.1
-199.1
-199.2
-259.2
-260.7
-262.8
-260.8
-260.2
-290.6
-288.3
-284.1
-281.3
-278.7
-274.7
-267.3
-262.9
-259.4
-255.7
-251.8
-247.7
-242.3
-233.1
-213.0
-170.4
-161.8
-161.3
-160.0
-159.6
-159.7
-158.4
-154.1
-143.2
-102.1
-19.0
-15.0
-10.0
-7.0

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
148.85
-149.27
159.45
-160.01
192.73
-193.43
211.87
-211.96
227.38
-227.60
235.49
-235.83
266.60
-265.50
275.10
-273.86
280.31
-279.05
282.40
-280.86
356.13
-351.61
357.59
-352.71
363.26
-358.06
365.89
-360.15
365.05
-358.90
399.42
-391.54
397.53
-389.79
396.72
-389.84
397.04
-391.05
397.95
-392.97
397.39
-393.57
394.48
-391.82
394.22
-392.74
394.88
-394.16
395.36
-395.58
397.15
-397.32
398.96
-399.30
399.96
-400.51
398.33
-399.13
388.36
-389.18
361.09
-362.12
360.05
-362.05
365.59
-368.69
371.98
-375.21
379.16
-382.63
384.75
-389.27
385.64
-391.35
376.56
-383.17
346.49
-354.23
237.38
-244.87
28.40
-36.89
22.44
-30.37
12.63
-20.25
8.86
-16.21

0.62
0.67
0.81
0.77
0.83
0.86
0.78
0.80
0.82
0.83
0.77
0.77
0.79
0.79
0.79
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.74
0.74
0.74
0.75
0.75
0.75
0.76
0.75
0.73
0.68
0.68
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.72
0.67
0.46
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

WindMTY
26.30
27.27
28.13
33.09
34.27
34.82
43.97
44.79
45.41
45.26
60.69
60.98
60.94
59.52
59.05
67.04
66.25
64.89
63.90
63.01
61.65
59.08
57.31
55.72
54.01
52.21
50.30
47.95
44.39
37.44
23.46
19.97
18.83
17.60
16.62
15.78
14.89
14.00
12.92
9.71
1.66
1.12
0.62
0.14

Page 9 of 12

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Live

A35

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

-4.11
-8.39
-12.67
-16.14
-20.14
-23.72
-27.57
-30.84
-34.77
-37.56
-47.70
-50.80
-55.11
-59.17
-61.86
-68.28
-71.02
-74.79
-78.81
-82.48
-86.20
-89.97
-93.80
-97.46
-101.25
-105.01
-108.88
-112.79
-116.75
-120.48
-124.41
-127.81
-131.29
-134.96
-138.39
-140.41
-140.67
-136.87
-125.09
-83.92
8.19
6.43
2.17
-2.71

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.50
-9.80
-11.52
-11.93
-12.13
-15.30
-15.59
-15.80
-15.75
-21.10
-21.20
-21.17
-20.67
-20.49
-23.25
-22.97
-22.48
-22.13
-21.82
-21.34
-20.43
-19.81
-19.25
-18.65
-18.03
-17.35
-16.53
-15.28
-12.87
-8.02
-6.82
-6.42
-6.00
-5.66
-5.37
-5.06
-4.75
-4.38
-3.26
-0.51
-0.33
-0.15
0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.29
-28.16
-33.11
-34.29
-34.85
-43.98
-44.80
-45.42
-45.26
-60.67
-60.95
-60.88
-59.45
-58.96
-66.90
-66.09
-64.71
-63.69
-62.81
-61.44
-58.85
-57.06
-55.47
-53.75
-51.95
-50.03
-47.66
-44.08
-37.15
-23.16
-19.69
-18.56
-17.36
-16.38
-15.54
-14.65
-13.77
-12.70
-9.46
-1.46
-0.94
-0.44
0.04

SpecX
404.04
435.68
540.06
587.86
635.53
661.97
735.47
760.81
776.90
782.54
970.70
972.93
990.05
999.11
995.95
1079.33
1075.76
1079.00
1085.73
1093.81
1099.42
1100.34
1107.44
1115.26
1123.19
1133.19
1144.26
1153.95
1158.40
1144.40
1093.98
1100.22
1122.13
1146.92
1173.18
1193.47
1199.85
1173.72
1081.48
742.98
83.05
66.53
38.95
36.60

SpecY
251.77
261.40
269.07
314.17
322.97
324.91
410.83
419.31
427.56
427.08
574.02
579.00
582.23
572.04
572.18
648.85
642.56
625.93
613.61
599.96
583.16
556.12
536.54
519.69
502.26
486.27
469.27
448.10
415.91
353.36
227.29
193.44
181.35
170.20
161.12
151.99
142.76
134.17
124.34
92.56
17.47
11.00
5.88
3.43

-13.7
-20.6
-27.5
-33.6
-40.0
-45.7
-53.0
-58.2
-64.5
-69.0
-87.1
-92.2
-99.3
-106.0
-110.6
-121.9
-126.2
-131.7
-137.7
-142.9
-148.2
-153.7
-159.2
-164.5
-170.1
-176.0
-182.1
-188.3
-194.6
-200.4
-206.6
-211.5
-216.5
-222.2
-227.6
-230.3
-230.1
-223.3
-203.9
-137.5
9.4
6.5
-0.5
-8.5

-0.6
6.2
13.1
18.1
24.5
30.2
35.3
40.5
46.7
51.2
65.5
70.4
77.0
83.4
87.4
96.6
101.0
107.6
114.5
121.0
127.6
134.2
141.0
147.4
153.9
160.1
166.3
172.6
179.0
185.1
191.5
197.5
203.6
209.6
215.2
219.1
220.1
214.6
196.4
131.0
-16.8
-14.1
-7.5
0.1

-7.2
-7.1
-7.1
-7.4
-6.9
-6.1
-5.8
-4.9
-3.7
-2.9
-1.4
0.1
2.1
3.7
5.9
8.2
9.7
9.5
9.4
8.2
7.1
5.7
4.2
2.8
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.7
-1.2
-2.9
-2.7
-2.4
-3.5
-4.5
-5.3
-6.2
-5.0
-5.3
-4.3
-3.3
-2.2

-7.2
-7.2
-7.3
-8.1
-8.6
-9.4
-11.9
-12.8
-14.1
-14.8
-20.2
-21.9
-24.4
-26.2
-29.0
-33.4
-34.9
-33.7
-32.7
-30.1
-27.7
-25.2
-22.4
-19.9
-17.4
-17.2
-17.1
-16.9
-16.5
-16.1
-15.8
-12.8
-10.0
-10.0
-10.1
-7.7
-5.5
-3.4
-1.3
-1.6
-2.0
-3.2
-4.7
-6.2

-12.1
-17.2
-22.3
-26.8
-31.3
-35.0
-39.7
-42.9
-46.8
-49.5
-61.0
-63.6
-67.4
-71.1
-72.7
-78.9
-81.1
-85.6
-90.4
-95.5
-100.7
-106.1
-111.7
-117.0
-122.6
-127.1
-131.6
-136.4
-141.3
-145.9
-150.7
-156.0
-161.3
-165.5
-169.4
-172.5
-173.4
-169.3
-155.7
-105.3
4.9
3.5
-0.9
-6.0

-12.1
-17.3
-22.5
-27.4
-32.6
-37.5
-44.2
-48.8
-54.5
-58.4
-75.1
-80.1
-87.2
-93.5
-98.9
-110.2
-114.5
-118.0
-122.0
-124.3
-126.8
-129.3
-131.6
-134.0
-136.6
-140.9
-145.5
-150.0
-154.4
-158.6
-163.1
-164.7
-166.6
-171.0
-175.2
-175.7
-174.1
-167.8
-152.0
-102.7
7.4
4.4
-1.9
-8.9

-2.2
2.9
8.1
11.9
17.1
21.9
26.5
31.2
36.7
40.7
53.5
58.3
64.9
70.9
75.7
84.9
89.3
93.9
98.7
102.4
106.2
109.8
113.4
116.9
120.5
125.0
129.7
134.3
138.9
143.3
147.9
150.7
153.8
158.4
162.7
164.5
164.2
159.1
144.5
96.2
-14.7
-11.9
-6.1
0.5

-2.2
2.9
7.9
11.4
15.8
19.4
22.0
25.2
28.9
31.8
39.4
41.8
45.1
48.5
49.6
53.7
55.9
61.5
67.1
73.7
80.1
86.7
93.5
99.9
106.4
111.2
115.8
120.7
125.7
130.6
135.5
142.0
148.5
152.9
157.0
161.3
163.5
160.6
148.2
98.7
-12.2
-11.1
-7.1
-2.4

-23.1
-28.6
-34.2
-40.9
-46.2
-50.8
-60.3
-64.5
-69.6
-72.8
-93.4
-97.3
-102.7
-107.1
-110.4
-122.4
-125.4
-128.8
-132.8
-136.1
-139.4
-142.2
-145.4
-148.6
-152.0
-155.6
-159.4
-163.0
-166.2
-167.7
-166.5
-168.5
-171.7
-175.5
-179.1
-180.5
-179.9
-174.3
-159.1
-107.9
5.6
3.5
-1.6
-7.4

-1.1
-5.9
-10.6
-13.3
-17.6
-21.7
-23.6
-27.1
-31.7
-35.0
-42.7
-46.4
-51.9
-57.5
-61.2
-66.6
-70.2
-74.9
-79.7
-83.7
-88.2
-93.2
-97.9
-102.4
-107.2
-112.3
-117.7
-123.4
-129.5
-136.8
-147.2
-152.2
-156.3
-161.1
-165.5
-167.7
-167.7
-162.9
-148.6
-100.1
6.8
4.3
-1.2
-7.5

-13.2
-8.5
-3.7
-2.2
2.1
6.1
5.9
9.5
13.9
17.3
21.1
24.6
29.6
34.9
38.1
41.4
45.1
50.7
56.4
61.9
67.5
73.7
79.7
85.3
91.1
96.4
101.9
107.7
114.0
121.5
132.1
138.2
143.4
148.4
153.0
156.4
157.8
154.2
141.1
93.5
-14.1
-11.9
-6.8
-0.9

Page 10 of 12

8.7
14.3
19.8
25.5
30.7
35.2
42.6
46.9
51.8
55.1
71.8
75.5
80.4
84.5
87.2
97.2
100.2
104.6
109.5
114.2
118.7
122.8
127.2
131.5
135.8
139.7
143.6
147.3
150.7
152.4
151.3
154.6
158.8
162.8
166.6
169.3
169.9
165.6
151.6
101.4
-12.9
-11.1
-6.4
-1.0

-38.7
-39.9
-40.9
-47.2
-48.3
-48.4
-59.3
-59.6
-59.5
-58.7
-76.5
-75.8
-74.3
-71.4
-69.2
-77.3
-75.2
-73.5
-72.3
-71.9
-71.0
-68.7
-67.6
-66.6
-65.5
-63.4
-61.0
-58.2
-54.1
-45.9
-29.2
-26.3
-26.0
-24.4
-23.0
-22.6
-22.2
-21.6
-20.8
-15.9
-6.7
-5.3
-4.0
-2.7

24.4
25.6
26.7
32.3
34.0
35.3
46.2
47.9
49.5
49.9
69.1
70.5
71.8
71.3
72.2
83.3
83.4
81.7
80.6
78.8
76.4
72.5
69.3
66.5
63.4
61.3
59.1
56.2
51.7
43.3
26.4
21.0
18.5
17.2
16.3
14.7
13.0
11.4
9.7
6.8
-3.2
-3.1
-2.9
-2.8

-38.7
-40.0
-41.1
-47.7
-49.6
-50.8
-63.9
-65.5
-67.3
-67.6
-90.6
-92.3
-94.1
-93.8
-95.4
-108.5
-108.6
-105.9
-103.9
-100.7
-97.1
-91.9
-87.5
-83.6
-79.6
-77.2
-74.9
-71.9
-67.2
-58.6
-41.6
-35.0
-31.4
-29.9
-28.8
-25.9
-22.9
-20.1
-17.2
-13.3
-4.2
-4.5
-5.1
-5.6

24.4
25.5
26.5
31.7
32.7
32.8
41.6
42.0
41.7
41.0
55.0
54.0
52.0
48.8
46.1
52.0
50.0
49.4
49.0
50.1
50.4
49.3
49.4
49.5
49.4
47.5
45.2
42.5
38.5
30.6
14.0
12.3
13.2
11.8
10.5
11.4
12.2
12.9
13.3
9.4
-0.7
-2.2
-4.0
-5.7

-42.8
-47.8
-52.7
-62.3
-67.0
-70.5
-85.4
-88.8
-92.5
-94.3
-122.1
-124.5
-127.3
-128.3
-129.1
-143.6
-144.2
-145.8
-148.1
-150.7
-152.7
-153.5
-155.4
-157.3
-159.2
-160.4
-161.5
-162.1
-161.5
-156.5
-143.1
-142.7
-145.2
-146.9
-148.6
-149.7
-149.2
-144.9
-133.2
-91.3
1.0
0.6
-2.2
-5.5

-26.3
-30.7
-35.1
-41.5
-45.5
-48.7
-57.8
-60.7
-64.0
-65.9
-84.1
-86.3
-89.1
-91.1
-92.1
-101.7
-102.9
-105.3
-108.2
-111.4
-114.3
-116.7
-119.7
-122.6
-125.6
-127.9
-130.2
-132.4
-133.9
-133.3
-128.6
-130.4
-133.6
-136.1
-138.4
-140.0
-140.1
-136.3
-125.3
-85.4
1.9
1.1
-1.9
-5.5

-35.4
-32.7
-29.9
-33.2
-30.8
-27.8
-35.7
-33.2
-29.8
-26.6
-36.2
-32.9
-28.0
-21.7
-17.6
-20.6
-16.3
-11.1
-6.1
-2.1
2.6
8.6
13.6
18.3
23.2
28.8
34.7
41.1
48.9
60.6
81.1
87.5
91.3
96.3
100.7
103.3
104.3
101.7
92.2
59.9
-13.7
-11.0
-6.1
-0.6

-18.9
-15.6
-12.3
-12.4
-9.3
-6.0
-8.1
-5.1
-1.4
1.7
1.8
5.3
10.2
15.5
19.3
21.3
25.1
29.4
33.8
37.2
41.0
45.4
49.3
53.0
56.8
61.3
65.9
70.8
76.4
83.8
95.5
99.8
102.9
107.1
110.9
112.9
113.4
110.3
100.1
65.8
-12.8
-10.4
-5.8
-0.6

4.6
1.3
-2.0
-2.6
-5.3
-7.8
-6.1
-8.1
-10.6
-12.8
-12.8
-14.7
-17.6
-21.2
-22.8
-23.1
-25.2
-29.3
-33.3
-37.5
-42.1
-47.5
-52.6
-57.3
-62.4
-66.8
-71.4
-76.3
-82.0
-89.5
-101.4
-107.3
-111.7
-115.6
-119.1
-121.7
-122.8
-120.1
-110.3
-74.2
3.6
2.2
-1.4
-5.5

-42.8
-47.9
-52.9
-62.7
-68.0
-72.4
-88.8
-93.2
-98.3
-101.0
-132.7
-136.9
-142.1
-145.2
-148.7
-167.1
-169.3
-170.1
-171.8
-172.2
-172.3
-170.9
-170.3
-170.0
-169.8
-170.8
-171.9
-172.4
-171.3
-166.0
-152.4
-149.3
-149.2
-151.0
-152.9
-152.1
-149.7
-143.8
-130.5
-89.4
2.9
1.2
-3.0
-7.7

4.6
1.3
-2.1
-3.0
-6.2
-9.6
-9.6
-12.5
-16.5
-19.5
-23.4
-27.1
-32.5
-38.1
-42.5
-46.5
-50.3
-53.6
-57.0
-59.1
-61.6
-64.8
-67.5
-70.1
-72.9
-77.2
-81.8
-86.5
-91.9
-99.1
-110.6
-113.8
-115.7
-119.7
-123.4
-124.1
-123.3
-119.0
-107.6
-72.3
5.5
2.9
-2.2
-7.8

28.5
33.5
38.3
46.8
51.5
55.0
67.7
71.1
74.6
76.6
100.5
102.7
105.0
105.8
105.9
118.4
119.1
121.7
124.8
128.8
132.1
134.1
137.2
140.2
143.1
144.5
145.7
146.5
145.9
141.2
127.9
128.7
132.4
134.2
136.1
138.5
139.2
136.2
125.7
84.8
-8.3
-8.1
-5.8
-2.9

12.0
16.4
20.7
26.0
30.0
33.1
40.1
43.1
46.2
48.2
62.5
64.5
66.8
68.5
69.0
76.5
77.7
81.2
84.9
89.5
93.7
97.2
101.5
105.5
109.5
112.0
114.4
116.7
118.4
118.0
113.5
116.5
120.8
123.4
125.9
128.8
130.1
127.6
117.8
78.9
-9.2
-8.7
-6.1
-2.9

21.1
18.4
15.5
17.7
15.3
12.2
18.0
15.6
12.0
8.9
14.6
11.1
5.7
-0.8
-5.6
-4.6
-8.9
-13.1
-17.2
-19.8
-23.2
-28.0
-31.8
-35.4
-39.3
-44.7
-50.5
-56.7
-64.4
-75.9
-96.2
-101.5
-104.2
-108.9
-113.2
-114.5
-114.2
-110.4
-99.7
-66.4
6.4
3.5
-1.9
-7.8

21.1
18.4
15.6
18.1
16.2
14.1
21.4
20.0
17.8
15.6
25.2
23.5
20.5
16.0
14.1
18.8
16.2
11.2
6.5
1.8
-3.6
-10.6
-16.9
-22.6
-28.8
-34.3
-40.1
-46.5
-54.5
-66.3
-86.9
-95.0
-100.2
-104.8
-108.9
-112.0
-113.7
-111.5
-102.4
-68.4
4.6
2.8
-1.1
-5.6

-18.9
-15.7
-12.4
-12.8
-10.2
-7.8
-11.6
-9.6
-7.2
-5.0
-8.8
-7.1
-4.7
-1.3
-0.3
-2.2
0.0
5.1
10.1
15.7
21.4
28.0
34.4
40.2
46.3
50.9
55.5
60.6
66.5
74.3
86.2
93.3
98.9
103.0
106.6
110.5
112.8
111.4
102.8
67.7
-11.0
-9.8
-6.6
-2.9

28.5
33.5
38.5
47.2
52.5
56.8
71.1
75.6
80.5
83.3
111.1
115.1
119.8
122.6
125.5
141.8
144.2
146.0
148.5
150.4
151.7
151.4
152.1
152.9
153.6
154.9
156.1
156.7
155.8
150.7
137.2
135.3
136.4
138.3
140.5
140.9
139.8
135.1
122.9
82.8
-10.2
-8.8
-5.0
-0.7

-26.3
-30.8
-35.2
-41.9
-46.5
-50.6
-61.2
-65.1
-69.8
-72.6
-94.7
-98.7
-104.0
-107.9
-111.8
-125.2
-128.0
-129.6
-131.9
-132.9
-133.9
-134.1
-134.6
-135.3
-136.2
-138.3
-140.6
-142.6
-143.8
-142.8
-137.9
-137.0
-137.6
-140.2
-142.7
-142.5
-140.6
-135.2
-122.6
-83.5
3.8
1.8
-2.7
-7.7

12.0
16.4
20.8
26.5
31.0
35.0
43.5
47.5
52.0
54.9
73.1
76.9
81.7
85.4
88.6
99.9
102.8
105.5
108.7
111.1
113.2
114.6
116.4
118.3
120.0
122.4
124.8
126.9
128.3
127.5
122.8
123.0
124.8
127.5
130.3
131.2
130.7
126.5
115.1
77.0
-11.1
-9.3
-5.3
-0.7

-35.4
-32.8
-30.0
-33.6
-31.7
-29.7
-39.1
-37.6
-35.6
-33.3
-46.8
-45.3
-42.8
-38.6
-37.3
-44.0
-41.4
-35.4
-29.8
-23.6
-17.0
-8.8
-1.3
5.5
12.7
18.4
24.3
30.8
39.0
51.1
71.8
81.0
87.3
92.2
96.4
100.8
103.7
102.8
94.9
61.8
-11.9
-10.4
-6.9
-2.8

-11.9
-18.8
-25.7
-31.6
-38.0
-43.8
-50.8
-56.0
-62.3
-66.7
-84.4
-89.5
-96.5
-103.1
-107.7
-118.7
-123.1
-128.7
-134.8
-140.2
-145.7
-151.2
-156.9
-162.3
-168.1
-174.0
-180.1
-186.3
-192.6
-198.5
-204.7
-209.7
-214.9
-220.7
-226.1
-228.9
-228.8
-222.2
-203.0
-136.7
10.4
7.5
0.5
-7.5

1.2
8.0
14.9
20.0
26.4
32.1
37.5
42.7
48.9
53.4
68.2
73.1
79.8
86.2
90.3
99.8
104.2
110.6
117.4
123.8
130.2
136.7
143.3
149.5
156.0
162.1
168.3
174.6
181.0
187.0
193.4
199.2
205.2
211.2
216.8
220.5
221.3
215.7
197.3
131.8
-15.8
-13.1
-6.5
1.2

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Live

A36

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

-4.11
-8.39
-12.67
-16.14
-20.14
-23.72
-27.57
-30.84
-34.77
-37.56
-47.70
-50.80
-55.11
-59.17
-61.86
-68.28
-71.02
-74.79
-78.81
-82.48
-86.20
-89.97
-93.80
-97.46
-101.25
-105.01
-108.88
-112.79
-116.75
-120.48
-124.41
-127.81
-131.29
-134.96
-138.39
-140.41
-140.67
-136.87
-125.09
-83.92
8.19
6.43
2.17
-2.71

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.50
-9.80
-11.52
-11.93
-12.13
-15.30
-15.59
-15.80
-15.75
-21.10
-21.20
-21.17
-20.67
-20.49
-23.25
-22.97
-22.48
-22.13
-21.82
-21.34
-20.43
-19.81
-19.25
-18.65
-18.03
-17.35
-16.53
-15.28
-12.87
-8.02
-6.82
-6.42
-6.00
-5.66
-5.37
-5.06
-4.75
-4.38
-3.26
-0.51
-0.33
-0.15
0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.29
-28.16
-33.11
-34.29
-34.85
-43.98
-44.80
-45.42
-45.26
-60.67
-60.95
-60.88
-59.45
-58.96
-66.90
-66.09
-64.71
-63.69
-62.81
-61.44
-58.85
-57.06
-55.47
-53.75
-51.95
-50.03
-47.66
-44.08
-37.15
-23.16
-19.69
-18.56
-17.36
-16.38
-15.54
-14.65
-13.77
-12.70
-9.46
-1.46
-0.94
-0.44
0.04

-5.4
-5.3
-5.3
-5.4
-4.9
-4.2
-3.6
-2.7
-1.5
-0.7
1.3
2.8
4.8
6.5
8.8
11.4
12.8
12.5
12.3
11.0
9.6
8.2
6.5
4.9
3.3
3.3
3.3
3.2
3.0
2.7
2.6
0.6
-1.3
-1.1
-0.8
-2.1
-3.3
-4.3
-5.2
-4.2
-4.4
-3.4
-2.3
-1.2

-5.4
-5.4
-5.5
-6.2
-6.7
-7.5
-9.7
-10.5
-11.8
-12.6
-17.5
-19.2
-21.6
-23.4
-26.1
-30.3
-31.7
-30.6
-29.8
-27.3
-25.1
-22.7
-20.1
-17.8
-15.4
-15.2
-15.2
-15.0
-14.6
-14.2
-13.9
-11.1
-8.4
-8.4
-8.5
-6.3
-4.2
-2.3
-0.4
-0.7
-1.1
-2.3
-3.7
-5.1

-10.3
-15.4
-20.5
-24.9
-29.3
-33.1
-37.4
-40.7
-44.5
-47.3
-58.3
-60.9
-64.6
-68.2
-69.8
-75.8
-77.9
-82.6
-87.5
-92.8
-98.1
-103.7
-109.4
-114.9
-120.5
-125.1
-129.7
-134.4
-139.3
-144.0
-148.8
-154.3
-159.7
-164.0
-167.8
-171.1
-172.2
-168.3
-154.8
-104.4
5.8
4.5
0.1
-4.9

-10.3
-15.5
-20.7
-25.4
-30.6
-35.5
-42.0
-46.6
-52.3
-56.2
-72.4
-77.4
-84.4
-90.7
-96.0
-107.0
-111.4
-115.0
-119.1
-121.5
-124.2
-126.8
-129.3
-131.9
-134.6
-138.9
-143.5
-148.0
-152.5
-156.6
-161.2
-163.0
-165.0
-169.4
-173.6
-174.3
-172.9
-166.8
-151.1
-101.9
8.3
5.3
-0.9
-7.9

-0.4
4.7
9.9
13.8
19.0
23.9
28.7
33.4
38.9
42.9
56.2
61.1
67.7
73.8
78.6
88.1
92.5
96.9
101.6
105.1
108.7
112.3
115.7
119.0
122.5
127.0
131.7
136.3
140.9
145.2
149.8
152.5
155.4
159.9
164.3
165.9
165.4
160.2
145.5
97.0
-13.8
-11.0
-5.1
1.6

-0.5
4.7
9.7
13.3
17.7
21.4
24.2
27.4
31.2
34.0
42.1
44.5
47.9
51.3
52.5
56.8
59.1
64.5
70.0
76.4
82.7
89.1
95.8
102.0
108.4
113.1
117.8
122.6
127.7
132.5
137.4
143.8
150.1
154.5
158.5
162.7
164.7
161.7
149.1
99.5
-11.3
-10.1
-6.1
-1.4

-21.3
-26.8
-32.4
-39.0
-44.3
-48.9
-58.1
-62.3
-67.4
-70.6
-90.7
-94.6
-99.9
-104.3
-107.5
-119.3
-122.2
-125.8
-129.9
-133.3
-136.8
-139.8
-143.2
-146.5
-149.9
-153.6
-157.4
-161.1
-164.3
-165.7
-164.6
-166.8
-170.1
-173.9
-177.5
-179.1
-178.6
-173.2
-158.2
-107.1
6.5
4.5
-0.6
-6.4

0.7
-4.1
-8.8
-11.3
-15.7
-19.8
-21.4
-24.9
-29.4
-32.8
-40.0
-43.7
-49.1
-54.7
-58.3
-63.5
-67.1
-71.8
-76.7
-81.0
-85.6
-90.7
-95.6
-100.3
-105.2
-110.3
-115.8
-121.4
-127.6
-134.9
-145.3
-150.4
-154.6
-159.5
-163.9
-166.3
-166.5
-161.8
-147.7
-99.2
7.7
5.3
-0.2
-6.4

-11.4
-6.7
-1.9
-0.3
4.0
8.1
8.1
11.7
16.1
19.5
23.8
27.4
32.4
37.7
40.9
44.6
48.2
53.7
59.3
64.6
70.1
76.2
82.0
87.4
93.1
98.4
103.9
109.6
115.9
123.4
134.0
139.9
145.0
150.0
154.6
157.8
159.0
155.3
142.0
94.3
-13.2
-10.9
-5.8
0.1

Page 11 of 12

10.5
16.1
21.6
27.4
32.7
37.2
44.8
49.1
54.0
57.3
74.5
78.2
83.2
87.4
90.1
100.4
103.3
107.7
112.4
117.0
121.3
125.2
129.5
133.6
137.8
141.7
145.6
149.3
152.6
154.3
153.2
156.3
160.4
164.4
168.2
170.7
171.2
166.7
152.6
102.2
-12.0
-10.2
-5.4
0.1

-36.9
-38.1
-39.1
-45.2
-46.3
-46.4
-57.1
-57.4
-57.3
-56.5
-73.8
-73.0
-71.5
-68.6
-66.4
-74.1
-72.0
-70.5
-69.4
-69.2
-68.4
-66.3
-65.3
-64.5
-63.5
-61.4
-59.0
-56.3
-52.1
-44.0
-27.3
-24.5
-24.4
-22.8
-21.4
-21.2
-21.0
-20.5
-19.9
-15.1
-5.7
-4.4
-3.0
-1.6

26.2
27.4
28.5
34.2
36.0
37.2
48.4
50.1
51.7
52.1
71.8
73.2
74.6
74.1
75.1
86.4
86.6
84.8
83.5
81.5
79.0
74.9
71.6
68.7
65.5
63.3
61.0
58.1
53.7
45.2
28.3
22.7
20.1
18.8
17.9
16.1
14.2
12.5
10.6
7.6
-2.2
-2.1
-1.9
-1.7

-36.9
-38.2
-39.3
-45.8
-47.6
-48.9
-61.7
-63.3
-65.1
-65.4
-87.9
-89.6
-91.3
-91.0
-92.5
-105.4
-105.5
-102.9
-101.0
-97.9
-94.5
-89.5
-85.3
-81.5
-77.6
-75.2
-72.9
-69.9
-65.3
-56.6
-39.7
-33.2
-29.8
-28.3
-27.2
-24.5
-21.7
-19.0
-16.2
-12.5
-3.3
-3.5
-4.1
-4.6

26.2
27.3
28.3
33.6
34.7
34.7
43.9
44.2
43.9
43.2
57.7
56.7
54.8
51.7
49.0
55.2
53.2
52.4
51.9
52.8
53.0
51.7
51.7
51.6
51.4
49.5
47.2
44.5
40.5
32.5
15.9
14.0
14.8
13.4
12.1
12.8
13.5
14.0
14.2
10.2
0.2
-1.3
-3.0
-4.7

-41.0
-46.1
-50.9
-60.3
-65.1
-68.6
-83.2
-86.6
-90.2
-92.1
-119.4
-121.7
-124.5
-125.5
-126.2
-140.4
-141.1
-142.8
-145.2
-147.9
-150.2
-151.0
-153.1
-155.1
-157.2
-158.4
-159.5
-160.2
-159.5
-154.5
-141.2
-141.0
-143.6
-145.3
-147.0
-148.3
-147.9
-143.8
-132.3
-90.5
1.9
1.5
-1.2
-4.4

-24.5
-28.9
-33.3
-39.6
-43.6
-46.7
-55.6
-58.5
-61.8
-63.7
-81.4
-83.5
-86.3
-88.3
-89.2
-98.6
-99.7
-102.3
-105.3
-108.6
-111.7
-114.2
-117.4
-120.4
-123.6
-125.9
-128.3
-130.4
-132.0
-131.4
-126.7
-128.7
-132.0
-134.5
-136.8
-138.6
-138.8
-135.2
-124.4
-84.6
2.8
2.1
-0.9
-4.5

-33.6
-30.9
-28.1
-31.3
-28.8
-25.9
-33.5
-31.0
-27.6
-24.4
-33.5
-30.2
-25.2
-18.9
-14.7
-17.4
-13.2
-8.1
-3.2
0.7
5.1
11.0
15.9
20.5
25.2
30.8
36.6
43.0
50.8
62.5
82.9
89.3
92.9
97.8
102.3
104.7
105.5
102.8
93.1
60.7
-12.8
-10.1
-5.1
0.5

-17.1
-13.8
-10.5
-10.5
-7.3
-4.0
-5.9
-2.9
0.9
3.9
4.5
8.0
13.0
18.3
22.2
24.5
28.2
32.4
36.7
40.0
43.6
47.9
51.6
55.1
58.8
63.3
67.9
72.8
78.4
85.7
97.4
101.6
104.5
108.7
112.5
114.3
114.6
111.3
101.0
66.6
-11.9
-9.5
-4.8
0.4

6.4
3.1
-0.2
-0.7
-3.3
-5.8
-3.9
-5.9
-8.4
-10.5
-10.1
-11.9
-14.8
-18.4
-19.9
-19.9
-22.0
-26.2
-30.4
-34.8
-39.5
-45.0
-50.3
-55.2
-60.4
-64.8
-69.4
-74.3
-80.1
-87.6
-99.5
-105.5
-110.1
-114.0
-117.5
-120.3
-121.5
-119.0
-109.4
-73.4
4.6
3.2
-0.4
-4.5

-41.0
-46.1
-51.1
-60.8
-66.1
-70.5
-86.6
-91.0
-96.1
-98.8
-130.0
-134.1
-139.3
-142.4
-145.8
-163.9
-166.2
-167.1
-168.9
-169.5
-169.7
-168.4
-168.0
-167.9
-167.7
-168.8
-169.9
-170.4
-169.4
-164.1
-150.5
-147.5
-147.6
-149.4
-151.3
-150.7
-148.5
-142.7
-129.5
-88.5
3.8
2.1
-2.0
-6.7

6.4
3.1
-0.3
-1.1
-4.3
-7.7
-7.4
-10.3
-14.2
-17.2
-20.7
-24.3
-29.7
-35.3
-39.6
-43.4
-47.1
-50.5
-54.1
-56.3
-59.0
-62.4
-65.2
-68.0
-70.9
-75.2
-79.8
-84.6
-90.0
-97.2
-108.8
-112.1
-114.1
-118.1
-121.8
-122.7
-122.1
-117.9
-106.6
-71.5
6.4
3.8
-1.2
-6.7

30.3
35.3
40.1
48.7
53.5
56.9
69.9
73.4
76.9
78.8
103.2
105.4
107.8
108.6
108.8
121.5
122.2
124.7
127.7
131.6
134.7
136.5
139.4
142.3
145.1
146.5
147.7
148.4
147.9
143.1
129.8
130.5
134.0
135.8
137.7
139.9
140.5
137.3
126.6
85.6
-7.4
-7.2
-4.8
-1.9

13.8
18.2
22.5
28.0
32.0
35.1
42.3
45.3
48.4
50.4
65.2
67.2
69.6
71.4
71.9
79.6
80.8
84.2
87.8
92.3
96.3
99.7
103.7
107.6
111.5
114.0
116.4
118.6
120.3
119.9
115.4
118.2
122.4
125.0
127.5
130.2
131.4
128.7
118.7
79.7
-8.3
-7.8
-5.1
-1.8

22.9
20.2
17.3
19.6
17.2
14.2
20.2
17.8
14.2
11.1
17.3
13.9
8.5
2.0
-2.7
-1.5
-5.7
-10.0
-14.3
-17.0
-20.6
-25.6
-29.6
-33.3
-37.3
-42.7
-48.5
-54.8
-62.5
-74.0
-94.3
-99.8
-102.6
-107.3
-111.6
-113.1
-113.0
-109.3
-98.8
-65.6
7.3
4.4
-0.9
-6.8

22.9
20.2
17.4
20.1
18.2
16.0
23.6
22.2
20.1
17.8
27.9
26.3
23.3
18.8
17.0
22.0
19.4
14.3
9.4
4.5
-1.0
-8.2
-14.6
-20.5
-26.8
-32.3
-38.1
-44.5
-52.6
-64.4
-85.0
-93.2
-98.6
-103.2
-107.3
-110.6
-112.4
-110.4
-101.5
-67.6
5.5
3.8
-0.1
-4.5

-17.1
-13.9
-10.6
-10.9
-8.3
-5.9
-9.3
-7.4
-4.9
-2.7
-6.1
-4.4
-1.9
1.5
2.6
1.0
3.1
8.1
13.0
18.4
24.0
30.5
36.6
42.4
48.3
52.9
57.5
62.6
68.5
76.2
88.1
95.0
100.5
104.6
108.2
111.9
114.1
112.5
103.7
68.5
-10.0
-8.9
-5.6
-1.8

30.3
35.3
40.3
49.1
54.4
58.8
73.3
77.8
82.7
85.5
113.8
117.8
122.6
125.4
128.4
145.0
147.3
149.0
151.4
153.1
154.3
153.9
154.4
155.1
155.6
156.9
158.0
158.7
157.8
152.6
139.1
137.0
138.0
139.9
142.0
142.3
141.0
136.2
123.9
83.6
-9.3
-7.8
-4.0
0.4

-24.5
-29.0
-33.4
-40.0
-44.6
-48.6
-59.0
-62.9
-67.6
-70.4
-92.0
-95.9
-101.2
-105.1
-108.9
-122.0
-124.8
-126.6
-129.0
-130.2
-131.3
-131.6
-132.4
-133.2
-134.1
-136.3
-138.6
-140.6
-141.9
-140.9
-136.0
-135.2
-136.0
-138.6
-141.1
-141.1
-139.4
-134.1
-121.6
-82.7
4.7
2.7
-1.7
-6.7

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check


sheet: ElvD

BRB Strength Check along Line D for LA BRBF Bldg

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6
D6

A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

239
239
239
274
274
274
342
342
342
342
462
462
462
462
462
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
530
479
479
479
479

Dead
-5.97
-5.98
-6.00
-6.45
-6.46
-6.49
-7.37
-7.34
-7.42
-7.39
-8.99
-9.08
-9.29
-9.40
-9.65
-10.51
-10.49
-10.07
-9.70
-9.10
-8.60
-8.09
-7.58
-7.12
-6.72
-6.62
-6.59
-6.54
-6.47
-6.36
-6.31
-5.83
-5.35
-5.26
-5.19
-4.67
-4.15
-3.62
-3.13
-2.72
-3.05
-3.15
-3.33
-3.50

Live

A37

AD

CHECKED BY

WindFX
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

087237.10
1/23/09

BY

-4.11
-8.39
-12.67
-16.14
-20.14
-23.72
-27.57
-30.84
-34.77
-37.56
-47.70
-50.80
-55.11
-59.17
-61.86
-68.28
-71.02
-74.79
-78.81
-82.48
-86.20
-89.97
-93.80
-97.46
-101.25
-105.01
-108.88
-112.79
-116.75
-120.48
-124.41
-127.81
-131.29
-134.96
-138.39
-140.41
-140.67
-136.87
-125.09
-83.92
8.19
6.43
2.17
-2.71

WindMTX
-9.15
-9.50
-9.80
-11.52
-11.93
-12.13
-15.30
-15.59
-15.80
-15.75
-21.10
-21.20
-21.17
-20.67
-20.49
-23.25
-22.97
-22.48
-22.13
-21.82
-21.34
-20.43
-19.81
-19.25
-18.65
-18.03
-17.35
-16.53
-15.28
-12.87
-8.02
-6.82
-6.42
-6.00
-5.66
-5.37
-5.06
-4.75
-4.38
-3.26
-0.51
-0.33
-0.15
0.01

WindFY
0.01
0.03
0.07
0.23
0.54
1.04
1.90
2.46
3.23
3.71
5.87
6.88
8.26
9.35
10.90
13.02
13.93
13.49
13.17
11.97
10.86
9.65
8.31
7.09
5.85
5.76
5.77
5.68
5.49
5.29
5.16
3.64
2.22
2.27
2.40
1.34
0.30
-0.62
-1.52
-1.07
-1.04
-0.35
0.44
1.24

WindMTY
-26.30
-27.29
-28.16
-33.11
-34.29
-34.85
-43.98
-44.80
-45.42
-45.26
-60.67
-60.95
-60.88
-59.45
-58.96
-66.90
-66.09
-64.71
-63.69
-62.81
-61.44
-58.85
-57.06
-55.47
-53.75
-51.95
-50.03
-47.66
-44.08
-37.15
-23.16
-19.69
-18.56
-17.36
-16.38
-15.54
-14.65
-13.77
-12.70
-9.46
-1.46
-0.94
-0.44
0.04

13.8
18.2
22.6
28.4
32.9
36.9
45.7
49.7
54.2
57.1
75.8
79.6
84.5
88.2
91.5
103.1
105.9
108.5
111.6
113.8
115.8
117.1
118.7
120.4
122.0
124.4
126.8
128.9
130.2
129.4
124.7
124.8
126.4
129.1
131.8
132.6
131.9
127.6
116.0
77.8
-10.2
-8.4
-4.3
0.4

-33.6
-31.0
-28.2
-31.7
-29.8
-27.7
-36.9
-35.4
-33.4
-31.1
-44.1
-42.6
-40.1
-35.8
-34.4
-40.9
-38.3
-32.4
-26.9
-20.9
-14.4
-6.3
0.9
7.7
14.7
20.4
26.3
32.8
40.9
53.0
73.6
82.7
88.9
93.7
98.0
102.2
105.0
103.9
95.9
62.7
-11.0
-9.5
-5.9
-1.8

140.5
151.2
184.5
202.9
218.5
226.9
256.4
265.1
270.8
272.6
342.3
343.3
348.7
350.4
349.1
380.8
379.2
379.3
380.8
383.0
384.0
382.5
383.7
385.3
386.8
388.6
390.6
391.8
390.4
380.6
353.5
353.1
359.6
366.5
374.0
380.2
382.1
373.9
344.9
236.8
23.2
17.3
7.9
6.8

104.8
110.6
122.7
140.1
147.2
150.2
181.5
186.5
190.4
190.8
250.2
251.8
254.0
251.7
251.1
280.6
278.4
274.4
271.8
269.4
265.6
258.3
253.8
250.2
246.3
242.5
238.5
233.2
224.0
204.1
161.7
152.8
152.0
151.1
150.9
150.8
149.4
145.1
134.2
93.5
8.7
5.0
0.7
-0.5

-112.3
-121.3
-153.3
-164.8
-179.0
-187.1
-203.6
-210.7
-215.1
-216.9
-264.8
-265.2
-270.6
-274.5
-273.8
-294.2
-293.7
-295.6
-298.2
-301.1
-303.7
-305.7
-308.9
-312.2
-315.7
-320.1
-325.1
-329.9
-334.1
-335.2
-330.7
-335.0
-342.3
-350.9
-359.8
-366.2
-368.3
-360.2
-331.5
-227.9
-28.8
-24.3
-16.4
-16.1

29.0
28.9
21.4
29.8
27.9
26.0
43.5
43.8
44.6
44.0
68.1
69.2
68.3
64.2
64.2
78.1
76.6
71.9
68.1
64.1
59.3
51.8
46.0
40.9
35.5
29.9
23.8
16.6
6.7
-10.6
-43.6
-53.6
-58.6
-64.1
-69.2
-73.1
-75.7
-75.1
-68.7
-45.9
-6.9
-7.4
-6.7
-7.4

Page 12 of 12

-46.1
-46.0
-38.5
-48.2
-46.4
-44.5
-64.6
-64.7
-65.8
-65.1
-93.8
-95.2
-94.8
-91.1
-91.8
-108.2
-106.6
-100.7
-95.8
-90.1
-83.9
-74.9
-67.7
-61.2
-54.7
-48.8
-42.7
-35.3
-25.2
-7.6
25.5
36.9
43.3
49.1
54.4
59.8
63.9
64.7
59.7
38.1
-1.8
-1.6
-2.9
-2.6

95.2
104.2
136.1
146.4
160.5
168.5
182.5
189.7
193.9
195.8
239.1
239.2
244.0
247.6
246.2
264.2
263.7
266.8
270.5
275.1
279.1
282.6
287.3
291.9
296.5
301.2
306.2
311.3
315.6
317.0
312.7
318.4
327.0
335.9
345.0
352.9
356.5
349.8
322.6
220.1
20.0
15.3
6.9
6.1

-157.5
-168.3
-201.6
-221.3
-237.0
-245.5
-277.5
-286.1
-292.0
-293.7
-368.0
-369.3
-375.2
-377.3
-376.7
-410.9
-409.2
-408.1
-408.5
-409.0
-408.5
-405.7
-405.4
-405.7
-406.0
-407.6
-409.4
-410.5
-408.9
-398.7
-371.6
-369.8
-374.9
-381.5
-388.8
-393.6
-394.0
-384.3
-353.9
-244.6
-31.9
-26.3
-17.5
-16.8

-121.9
-127.7
-139.8
-158.5
-165.6
-168.7
-202.6
-207.5
-211.6
-211.9
-275.9
-277.7
-280.6
-278.6
-278.7
-310.7
-308.4
-303.2
-299.6
-295.4
-290.1
-281.4
-275.5
-270.5
-265.5
-261.5
-257.4
-251.9
-242.5
-222.3
-179.7
-169.5
-167.3
-166.1
-165.8
-164.2
-161.3
-155.5
-143.2
-101.3
-17.4
-14.0
-10.2
-9.5

145.0
155.7
189.1
207.8
223.4
231.9
262.0
270.7
276.4
278.2
349.1
350.2
355.7
357.6
356.4
388.8
387.1
386.9
388.2
389.9
390.5
388.7
389.5
390.7
391.9
393.6
395.6
396.8
395.3
385.4
358.3
357.5
363.6
370.4
377.9
383.8
385.3
376.7
347.3
238.8
25.5
19.7
10.5
9.4

109.3
115.2
127.3
145.0
152.0
155.1
187.1
192.1
196.0
196.4
257.0
258.7
261.1
258.8
258.4
288.6
286.4
282.0
279.2
276.3
272.1
264.4
259.6
255.6
251.3
247.6
243.5
238.1
229.0
209.0
166.5
157.3
156.0
155.1
154.9
154.4
152.6
147.9
136.6
95.6
11.0
7.4
3.2
2.1

-107.7
-116.8
-148.7
-159.9
-174.1
-182.2
-198.0
-205.2
-209.5
-211.3
-258.0
-258.3
-263.5
-267.3
-266.5
-286.3
-285.7
-287.9
-290.9
-294.2
-297.2
-299.6
-303.2
-306.8
-310.6
-315.1
-320.1
-325.0
-329.2
-330.4
-325.9
-330.6
-338.2
-346.9
-355.9
-362.7
-365.2
-357.4
-329.1
-225.9
-26.4
-21.9
-13.9
-13.5

33.5
33.4
25.9
34.7
32.8
30.9
49.1
49.3
50.2
49.6
74.9
76.1
75.3
71.3
71.5
86.1
84.5
79.5
75.5
71.0
65.8
58.0
51.8
46.3
40.6
34.9
28.8
21.6
11.6
-5.8
-38.8
-49.2
-54.5
-60.1
-65.3
-69.6
-72.6
-72.4
-66.3
-43.8
-4.6
-5.1
-4.1
-4.8

-41.5
-41.5
-34.0
-43.3
-41.5
-39.6
-59.0
-59.2
-60.2
-59.5
-86.9
-88.3
-87.8
-84.0
-84.5
-100.2
-98.6
-93.1
-88.5
-83.2
-77.3
-68.8
-61.9
-55.8
-49.6
-43.8
-37.7
-30.4
-20.3
-2.8
30.3
41.4
47.4
53.1
58.3
63.3
67.0
67.5
62.1
40.2
0.5
0.8
-0.3
0.1

99.7
108.7
140.7
151.3
165.4
173.5
188.1
195.3
199.5
201.4
245.9
246.1
251.1
254.7
253.6
272.2
271.6
274.4
277.9
282.0
285.6
288.7
293.0
297.3
301.6
306.2
311.2
316.2
320.5
321.9
317.5
322.8
331.0
339.8
348.9
356.4
359.6
352.6
324.9
222.2
22.4
17.7
9.4
8.8

-153.0
-163.8
-197.1
-216.4
-232.1
-240.6
-271.9
-280.5
-286.4
-288.1
-361.2
-362.4
-368.2
-370.2
-369.4
-402.9
-401.2
-400.4
-401.2
-402.1
-402.0
-399.5
-399.6
-400.3
-400.9
-402.5
-404.4
-405.5
-404.0
-393.9
-366.8
-365.4
-370.8
-377.5
-384.8
-390.0
-390.8
-381.5
-351.5
-242.5
-29.6
-23.9
-14.9
-14.1

-117.3
-123.2
-135.3
-153.6
-160.7
-163.8
-197.0
-201.9
-206.0
-206.3
-269.1
-270.8
-273.6
-271.4
-271.3
-302.7
-300.5
-295.5
-292.2
-288.5
-283.6
-275.3
-269.7
-265.1
-260.4
-256.4
-252.4
-246.9
-237.6
-217.5
-175.0
-165.1
-163.2
-162.1
-161.8
-160.6
-158.1
-152.7
-140.8
-99.3
-15.1
-11.7
-7.7
-6.8

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
144.98
-157.52
155.73
-168.29
189.05
-201.64
207.75
-221.29
223.44
-237.01
231.87
-245.50
261.98
-277.47
270.69
-286.11
276.41
-292.00
278.15
-293.67
349.13
-368.01
350.21
-369.28
355.71
-375.23
357.56
-377.30
356.41
-376.69
388.80
-410.88
387.14
-409.17
386.94
-408.08
388.18
-408.54
389.88
-408.99
390.47
-408.52
388.66
-405.66
389.47
-405.39
390.70
-405.66
391.89
-406.00
393.64
-407.55
395.60
-409.44
396.76
-410.49
395.31
-408.89
385.38
-398.74
358.31
-371.56
357.55
-369.78
363.63
-374.86
370.44
-381.49
377.89
-388.78
383.76
-393.57
385.28
-393.98
376.68
-384.30
347.28
-353.86
238.85
-244.56
25.49
-31.90
19.68
-26.30
10.47
-17.47
9.41
-16.75

0.66
0.70
0.84
0.81
0.87
0.90
0.81
0.84
0.85
0.86
0.80
0.80
0.81
0.82
0.82
0.78
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.76
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.75
0.70
0.70
0.71
0.72
0.73
0.74
0.74
0.72
0.67
0.46
0.07
0.05
0.04
0.03

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:01 PM 2/11/2009

A38
SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

087237.10

DATE

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

CLIENT
SUBJECT

Infilled Column Strength & Stiffness Evaluation

Fy =
f'c =
wc =
C2 =
ws =

50
10
150
0.85
490

1/23/09

BY

AD

CHECKED BY

ksi
ksi
lb/ft3

Ec =

5809.47502 ksi

lb/ft3

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

Col Type

Reinforcing

Quantity Each
Direction

Pl. Thk

Ar

t-wall

Ac

As

As/A-total

b/t

Status

C3

Ic

Eieff

fc Po

ft Po

Wt/Ft

Ibox

I mult

Aeff

Amult

Box18
Box21
Box24
Box27
Box30
Box33
Box36
Box39
Box42
Box45
Box48
Box51
Box54
Box57
Box60

18
21
24
27
30
33
36
39
42
45
48
51
54
57
60

18
21
24
27
30
33
36
39
42
45
48
51
54
57
60

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

1.5
1.5
2.0
2.0
2.5
2.5
2.5
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0

225
324
400
529
625
784
961
1089
1296
1521
1764
2025
2304
2601
2916

99
117
176
200
275
305
335
432
468
504
540
576
612
648
684

30.6%
26.5%
30.6%
27.4%
30.6%
28.0%
25.8%
28.4%
26.5%
24.9%
23.4%
22.1%
21.0%
19.9%
19.0%

10.0
12.0
10.0
11.5
10.0
11.2
12.4
11.0
12.0
13.0
14.0
15.0
16.0
17.0
18.0

OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.9

4.22E+03
8.75E+03
1.33E+04
2.33E+04
3.26E+04
5.12E+04
7.70E+04
9.88E+04
1.40E+05
1.93E+05
2.59E+05
3.42E+05
4.42E+05
5.64E+05
7.09E+05

1.53E+08
2.62E+08
4.85E+08
7.30E+08
1.18E+09
1.65E+09
2.23E+09
3.24E+09
4.19E+09
5.33E+09
6.66E+09
8.23E+09
1.00E+10
1.21E+10
1.45E+10

5146.9
6453.0
9150.0
10872.4
14296.9
16435.5
18688.9
23142.4
25812.0
28596.4
31495.5
34509.4
37638.0
40881.4
44239.5

4455
5265
7920
9000
12375
13725
15075
19440
21060
22680
24300
25920
27540
29160
30780

571.3
735.6
1015.6
1231.6
1586.8
1854.5
2141.0
2604.4
2942.5
3299.4
3675.0
4069.4
4482.5
4914.4
5365.0

4.53E+03
7.46E+03
1.43E+04
2.10E+04
3.49E+04
4.76E+04
6.30E+04
9.40E+04
1.19E+05
1.49E+05
1.83E+05
2.22E+05
2.66E+05
3.16E+05
3.71E+05

1.17
1.21
1.17
1.20
1.17
1.19
1.22
1.19
1.21
1.23
1.26
1.28
1.30
1.32
1.34

4.18E+06
5.28E+06
7.43E+06
8.87E+06
1.16E+07
1.34E+07
1.53E+07
1.89E+07
2.11E+07
2.35E+07
2.59E+07
2.85E+07
3.11E+07
3.39E+07
3.68E+07

1.46
1.55
1.46
1.53
1.46
1.51
1.57
1.50
1.55
1.60
1.65
1.70
1.75
1.80
1.85

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Column Design


sheet: CompCol

Page 1 of 1

5:03 PM
2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Col C/2 Strength Check for LA BRBF Bldg

SDS =
Fy Column=

Floor
Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

BY

A39

087237.10
1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

1.145
50 ksi

Height

Trib Area
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
1168.8
1168.8
1168.8
1168.8

Cum Area
670
400
800
1200
1600
2000
2400
2800
3200
3600
4000
4400
4800
5200
5600
6000
6400
6800
7200
7600
8000
8400
8800
9200
9600
10000
10400
10800
11200
11600
12000
12400
12800
13200
13600
14000
14400
14800
15200
15600

LL Red Fact Dead Load

0.8
0.48
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
1
1
1
1

Reducible
Live Load

95
97
97
97
97
97
97
97
102
102
102
102
102
107
107
107
107
112
112
112
112
117
117
117
117
117
127
127
127
127
127
140
140
140
140
140
142
142
142
150
515.5
85.5
85.5
85.5

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Column Design


sheet: ColC2

Unreducible
Live Load
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
100
40
40
40

Dead Load
38
76.8
115.6
154.4
193.2
232
270.8
309.6
350.4
391.2
432
472.8
513.6
556.4
599.2
642
684.8
729.6
774.4
819.2
864
910.8
957.6
1004.4
1051.2
1098
1148.8
1199.6
1250.4
1301.2
1352
1408
1464
1520
1576
1632
1688.8
1745.6
1802.4
1862.4
2464.9164
2564.8488
2664.7812
2764.7136

Live Load
0.0
12.8
20.5
26.9
33.3
39.7
46.1
52.5
58.9
65.3
71.7
78.1
84.5
90.9
97.3
103.7
110.1
116.5
122.9
129.3
135.7
142.1
148.5
154.9
161.3
167.7
174.1
180.5
186.9
193.3
199.7
206.1
212.5
218.9
225.3
231.7
238.1
244.5
250.9
257.3
374.2
420.9
467.7
514.4

ETABS Br # Bay Length

Brace Type

Brace @ Left
Brace Comprsn. Brace Tension

Brace C Vert Comp Brace T Vert CompETABS Br # Bay Length

D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25

Page 1 of 1

Brace Type

27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

Brace @ Right
Br. Comprsn Brace Tension Brace C Vert Comp

1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3

-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6

1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1241.46
706.41
706.41
706.41
706.41

Brace T Vert Comp Net Brace C

-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-1128.60
-642.19
-642.19
-642.19
-642.19

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1097.31
1241.46
706.41
706.41
706.41
706.41

Net Brace T
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-997.55
-1128.60
-642.19
-642.19
-642.19
-642.19

Pu-Comp
54.3
116.1
175.4
234.1
292.7
351.4
410.0
468.7
530.2
591.7
653.2
714.7
776.2
840.5
904.9
969.3
1033.6
1100.8
1168.1
1235.3
1302.5
1372.6
1442.7
1512.7
1582.8
1652.9
1728.7
1804.5
1880.3
1956.1
3047.9
4147.1
5246.4
6426.9
7607.4
8788.0
9969.6
11151.3
12333.0
13663.4
15289.2
16161.8
17034.4
17907.0

Pu-Tension
25.5
51.5
77.6
103.6
129.6
155.7
181.7
207.7
235.1
262.5
289.9
317.2
344.6
373.3
402.1
430.8
459.5
489.6
519.6
549.7
579.7
611.1
642.5
674.0
705.4
736.8
770.8
804.9
839.0
873.1
-16.5
-902.5
-1788.6
-2748.6
-3708.6
-4668.6
-5628.0
-6587.4
-7546.9
-8635.2
-8873.1
-9448.2
-10023.4
-10598.5

Col Type

Box21
Box21
Box21
Box24
Box24
Box27
Box27
Box30
Box30
Box36
Box36
Box39
Box39
Box39

fc Po

6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
9150.0
9150.0
10872.4
10872.4
14296.9
14296.9
18688.9
18688.9
23142.4
23142.4
23142.4

ft Po

Comp DCR

5265
5265
5265
7920
7920
9000
9000
12375
12375
15075
15075
19440
19440
19440

0.472
0.643
0.813
0.702
0.831
0.808
0.917
0.780
0.863
0.731
0.818
0.698
0.736
0.774

Ten DCR

0.003
0.171
0.340
0.347
0.468
0.519
0.625
0.532
0.610
0.573
0.589
0.486
0.516
0.545

Status

OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:09 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Col D/2 Strength Check for LA BRBF Bldg

SDS =
Fy Column=

Floor
Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

BY

A40

087237.10
1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

1.145
50 ksi

Height

Trib Area
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
670
1147.375
1147.375
1147.375
1147.375

Cum Area
670
670
1340
2010
2680
3350
4020
4690
5360
6030
6700
7370
8040
8710
9380
10050
10720
11390
12060
12730
13400
14070
14740
15410
16080
16750
17420
18090
18760
19430
20100
20770
21440
22110
22780
23450
24120
24790
25460
26130

LL Red Fact Dead Load

0.584
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
1
1
1
1

Reducible
Live Load

95
97
97
97
97
97
97
97
102
102
102
102
102
107
107
107
107
112
112
112
112
117
117
117
117
117
127
127
127
127
127
140
140
140
140
140
142
142
142
150
515.5
85.5
85.5
85.5

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Column Design


sheet: ColD2

Unreducible
Live Load
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
100
40
40
40

Dead Load
63.65
128.64
193.63
258.62
323.61
388.6
453.59
518.58
586.92
655.26
723.6
791.94
860.28
931.97
1003.66
1075.35
1147.04
1222.08
1297.12
1372.16
1447.2
1525.59
1603.98
1682.37
1760.76
1839.15
1924.24
2009.33
2094.42
2179.51
2264.6
2358.4
2452.2
2546
2639.8
2733.6
2828.74
2923.88
3019.02
3119.52
3710.991813
3809.092375
3907.192938
4005.2935

Live Load
0.0
15.7
26.4
37.1
47.8
58.5
69.3
80.0
90.7
101.4
112.1
122.9
133.6
144.3
155.0
165.7
176.5
187.2
197.9
208.6
219.3
230.1
240.8
251.5
262.2
272.9
283.7
294.4
305.1
315.8
326.5
337.3
348.0
358.7
369.4
380.1
390.9
401.6
412.3
423.0
537.7
583.6
629.5
675.4

ETABS Br # Bay Length

D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26
D26

40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
40.0

Brace Type

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

Brace @ Left
Brace Comprsn. Brace Tension

1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1551.8
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3

-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-1410.8
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6

Brace C Vert Comp Brace T Vert CompETABS Br # Bay Length

803.89
803.89
803.89
868.20
868.20
868.20
868.20
868.20
868.20
1038.12
547.06
547.06
547.06
547.06

-730.81
-730.81
-730.81
-789.28
-789.28
-789.28
-789.28
-789.28
-789.28
-943.74
-497.32
-497.32
-497.32
-497.32

D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21

Page 1 of 1

Brace Type
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

Brace @ Right
Br. Comprsn Brace Tension Brace C Vert Comp
344.9
344.9
344.9
344.9
344.9
517.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3
1063.3
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
1436.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9

-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6
-966.6
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-1306.3
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9

243.85
243.85
243.85
243.85
243.85
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
751.86
751.86
751.86
751.86
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
712.69
591.86
591.86
591.86
591.86

Brace T Vert Comp Net Brace C


-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-683.51
-683.51
-683.51
-683.51
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-647.90
-538.05
-538.05
-538.05
-538.05

243.85
243.85
243.85
243.85
243.85
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
365.77
629.93
629.93
629.93
629.93
751.86
751.86
751.86
751.86
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
1016.02
231.22
231.22
231.22
295.54
295.54
295.54
295.54
295.54
295.54
390.22
94.53
94.53
94.53
94.53

Net Brace T
-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-221.68
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-572.67
-683.51
-683.51
-683.51
-683.51
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-923.66
-100.88
-100.88
-100.88
-159.34
-159.34
-159.34
-159.34
-159.34
-159.34
-231.05
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Pu-Comp
334.8
679.3
1021.4
1363.5
1705.6
2169.6
2633.6
3097.6
3566.4
4035.1
4503.9
4972.7
5441.5
6179.2
6917.0
7654.7
8392.5
9256.9
10121.4
10985.8
11850.3
12983.7
14117.1
15250.5
16383.9
17517.3
18660.3
19803.2
20946.2
22089.2
22447.4
22818.0
23188.6
23623.6
24058.5
24493.4
24930.3
25367.1
25804.0
26343.2
27340.3
27597.9
27855.6
28113.3

Pu-Tension
-179.0
-357.0
-535.1
-713.2
-891.2
-1180.2
-1469.1
-1758.0
-2044.6
-2331.3
-2618.0
-2904.6
-3191.3
-3715.8
-4240.4
-4765.0
-5289.5
-5922.7
-6555.8
-7189.0
-7822.2
-8693.2
-9564.3
-10435.3
-11306.4
-12177.4
-13044.0
-13910.6
-14777.1
-15643.7
-15687.5
-15725.4
-15763.4
-15859.8
-15956.2
-16052.6
-16148.1
-16243.6
-16339.1
-16502.7
-16105.8
-16040.0
-15974.2
-15908.3

Col Type
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box21
Box24
Box24
Box24
Box24
Box27
Box27
Box30
Box30
Box33
Box33
Box36
Box36
Box39
Box39
Box39
Box39
Box42
Box42
Box45
Box45
Box48
Box48
Box48
Box48
Box51
Box51
Box51
Box51
Box54
Box54
Box54

fc Po
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
6453.0
9150.0
9150.0
9150.0
9150.0
10872.4
10872.4
14296.9
14296.9
16435.5
16435.5
18688.9
18688.9
23142.4
23142.4
23142.4
23142.4
25812.0
25812.0
28596.4
28596.4
31495.5
31495.5
31495.5
31495.5
34509.4
34509.4
34509.4
34509.4
37638.0
37638.0
37638.0

ft Po

Comp DCR
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
5265
7920
7920
7920
7920
9000
9000
12375
12375
13725
13725
15075
15075
19440
19440
19440
19440
21060
21060
22680
22680
24300
24300
24300
24300
25920
25920
25920
25920
27540
27540
27540

0.052
0.105
0.158
0.211
0.264
0.336
0.408
0.480
0.553
0.625
0.698
0.771
0.843
0.675
0.756
0.837
0.917
0.851
0.931
0.768
0.829
0.790
0.859
0.816
0.877
0.757
0.806
0.856
0.905
0.856
0.870
0.798
0.811
0.750
0.764
0.778
0.792
0.735
0.748
0.763
0.792
0.733
0.740
0.747

Ten DCR
0.034
0.068
0.102
0.135
0.169
0.224
0.279
0.334
0.388
0.443
0.497
0.552
0.606
0.469
0.535
0.602
0.668
0.658
0.728
0.581
0.632
0.633
0.697
0.692
0.750
0.626
0.671
0.716
0.760
0.743
0.745
0.693
0.695
0.653
0.657
0.661
0.665
0.627
0.630
0.637
0.621
0.582
0.580
0.578

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:09 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Col D/3 Strength Check for LA BRBF Bldg

SDS =
Fy Column=

Floor
Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

BY

087237.10
1/23/09
AD

CHECKED BY

A41

1.145
50 ksi

Height

Trib Area
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5
1172.5

Cum Area
670
1172.5
2345
3517.5
4690
5862.5
7035
8207.5
9380
10552.5
11725
12897.5
14070
15242.5
16415
17587.5
18760
19932.5
21105
22277.5
23450
24622.5
25795
26967.5
28140
29312.5
30485
31657.5
32830
34002.5
35175
36347.5
37520
38692.5
39865
41037.5
42210
43382.5
44555
45727.5

LL Red Fact Dead Load

0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
1
1
1
1

95
97
97
97
97
97
97
97
102
102
102
102
102
107
107
107
107
112
112
112
112
117
117
117
117
117
127
127
127
127
127
140
140
140
140
140
142
142
142
150
515.5
85.5
85.5
85.5

Reducible
Live Load
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
100
40
40
40

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Column Design


sheet: ColD3

Unreducible Dead Load Live Load


ETABS Br # Bay Length
Live Load
111.3875
0.0
225.12
18.8
338.8525
37.5
452.585
56.3
566.3175
75.0
680.05
93.8
793.7825
112.6
907.515
131.3
1027.11
150.1
1146.705
168.8
1266.3
187.6
1385.895
206.4
1505.49
225.1
1630.9475
243.9
1756.405
262.6
1881.8625
281.4
2007.32
300.2
2138.64
318.9
2269.96
337.7
2401.28
356.4
2532.6
375.2
2669.7825
394.0
2806.965
412.7
2944.1475
431.5
3081.33
450.2
3218.5125
469.0
3367.42
487.8
3516.3275
506.5
3665.235
525.3
3814.1425
544.0
3963.05
562.8
4127.2
581.6
4291.35
600.3
4455.5
619.1
4619.65
637.8
4783.8
656.6
4950.295
675.4
5116.79
694.1
5283.285
712.9
5459.16
731.6
6063.58375
848.9
6163.8325
895.8
6264.08125
942.7
6364.33
989.6

Brace Type

Brace along X Direction


Brace @ Left
Brace Comprsn.Brace Tension Brace C Vert Comp Brace T Vert Comp
ETABS Br # Bay Length
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1
D1

30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30

Y Direction Brace
Brace Type
A7
A7
A7
A8
A8
A8
A10
A10
A10
A10
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A14
A14
A14
A14

Brace @ Right
Br. Comprsn Brace Tension Brace C Vert Comp Brace T Vert Comp ETABS Br #
402.3
402.3
402.3
459.8
459.8
459.8
574.8
574.8
574.8
574.8
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
890.9
804.7
804.7
804.7
804.7

-365.8
-365.8
-365.8
-418.0
-418.0
-418.0
-522.5
-522.5
-522.5
-522.5
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-809.9
-731.5
-731.5
-731.5
-731.5

Page 1 of 1

269.14
269.14
269.14
307.59
307.59
307.59
384.49
384.49
384.49
384.49
519.06
519.06
519.06
519.06
519.06
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
595.96
684.38
502.66
502.66
502.66
502.66

-244.67
-244.67
-244.67
-279.63
-279.63
-279.63
-349.53
-349.53
-349.53
-349.53
-471.87
-471.87
-471.87
-471.87
-471.87
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-541.78
-622.16
-456.96
-456.96
-456.96
-456.96

D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13
D13

Bay Length

Brace Type
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5

Br. Comprsn

Brace Tension
402.3
402.3
517.3
517.3
517.3
632.2
632.2
632.2
632.2
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9
775.9

-365.8
-365.8
-470.3
-470.3
-470.3
-574.8
-574.8
-574.8
-574.8
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4
-705.4

Use 100%+30% Comb.


Brace C Vert Comp Brace T Vert Comp Net Brace C
Net Brace T
284.49
284.49
365.77
365.77
365.77
447.05
447.05
447.05
447.05
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
548.65
620.73
515.49
515.49
515.49
515.49

-258.62
-258.62
-332.52
-332.52
-332.52
-406.41
-406.41
-406.41
-406.41
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-498.78
-564.30
-468.63
-468.63
-468.63
-468.63

365.23
365.23
446.51
458.05
458.05
539.33
562.40
562.40
562.40
664.00
704.37
704.37
704.37
704.37
704.37
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
760.55
870.60
666.29
666.29
666.29
666.29

-332.03
-332.03
-405.92
-416.41
-416.41
-490.30
-511.27
-511.27
-511.27
-603.64
-640.34
-640.34
-640.34
-640.34
-640.34
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-691.41
-791.45
-605.71
-605.71
-605.71
-605.71

Pu-Comp
524.4
1061.5
1679.9
2309.9
2939.8
3651.1
4385.4
5119.7
5862.4
6706.6
7591.3
8475.9
9360.6
10253.6
11146.7
12095.9
13045.1
14002.7
14960.2
15917.8
16875.4
17841.4
18807.4
19773.3
20739.3
21705.3
22688.0
23670.7
24653.4
25636.1
26618.9
27623.4
28627.9
29632.4
30636.9
31641.4
32649.2
33657.1
34664.9
35796.2
37384.9
38217.8
39050.8
39883.8

Pu-Tension
-257.3
-513.0
-842.6
-1182.7
-1522.8
-1936.8
-2371.7
-2806.7
-3237.7
-3761.1
-4321.2
-4881.3
-5441.4
-5997.5
-6553.7
-7160.9
-7768.1
-8371.4
-8974.7
-9578.0
-10181.3
-10780.7
-11380.0
-11979.4
-12578.7
-13178.1
-13769.6
-14361.1
-14952.6
-15544.1
-16135.6
-16716.8
-17298.1
-17879.4
-18460.6
-19041.9
-19621.6
-20201.3
-20781.0
-21454.4
-21654.6
-22193.0
-22731.5
-23269.9

Col Type
Box18
Box18
Box18
Box18
Box18
Box18
Box18
Box21
Box21
Box24
Box24
Box27
Box27
Box30
Box30
Box33
Box33
Box36
Box36
Box39
Box39
Box39
Box39
Box42
Box42
Box45
Box45
Box45
Box45
Box48
Box48
Box51
Box51
Box51
Box51
Box54
Box54
Box57
Box57
Box57
Box57
Box60
Box60
Box60

fc Po
5146.9
5146.9
5146.9
5146.9
5146.9
5146.9
5146.9
6453.0
6453.0
9150.0
9150.0
10872.4
10872.4
14296.9
14296.9
16435.5
16435.5
18688.9
18688.9
23142.4
23142.4
23142.4
23142.4
25812.0
25812.0
28596.4
28596.4
28596.4
28596.4
31495.5
31495.5
34509.4
34509.4
34509.4
34509.4
37638.0
37638.0
40881.4
40881.4
40881.4
40881.4
44239.5
44239.5
44239.5

ft Po

Comp DCR
4455
4455
4455
4455
4455
4455
4455
5265
5265
7920
7920
9000
9000
12375
12375
13725
13725
15075
15075
19440
19440
19440
19440
21060
21060
22680
22680
22680
22680
24300
24300
25920
25920
25920
25920
27540
27540
29160
29160
29160
29160
30780
30780
30780

0.102
0.206
0.326
0.449
0.571
0.709
0.852
0.793
0.908
0.733
0.830
0.780
0.861
0.717
0.780
0.736
0.794
0.749
0.800
0.688
0.729
0.771
0.813
0.766
0.803
0.759
0.793
0.828
0.862
0.814
0.845
0.800
0.830
0.859
0.888
0.841
0.867
0.823
0.848
0.876
0.914
0.864
0.883
0.902

Ten DCR
0.058
0.115
0.189
0.265
0.342
0.435
0.532
0.533
0.615
0.475
0.546
0.542
0.605
0.485
0.530
0.522
0.566
0.555
0.595
0.493
0.524
0.555
0.585
0.569
0.597
0.581
0.607
0.633
0.659
0.640
0.664
0.645
0.667
0.690
0.712
0.691
0.712
0.693
0.713
0.736
0.743
0.721
0.739
0.756

5:09 PM 2/11/2009

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.

CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

SDS =
Fy Beam=

Floor

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

Floor

Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

1/23/09

BY

Frame Beam Design along Line 2 for LA BRBF Bldg

A42

087237.10

DATE

AD

CHECKED BY

1.145
50 ksi

Height
(ft)
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

Height
(ft)
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
13.5
18
12
12
12
12

Beam Span Brace Label


(ft)
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27
27

D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21
D21

Beam Span Brace Label


(ft)
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40

D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25
D25

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Code Braced Frame Beams


sheet: Line 2

Brace Sec.

A6
A6
A6
A6
A6
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A25
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5
A15.5

Brace Sec.

A25
A25
A25
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A27
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5
A18.5

Comp Cap
(kips)
344.85
344.85
344.85
344.85
344.85
517.275
517.275
517.275
517.275
517.275
517.275
517.275
517.275
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
1063.2875
1063.2875
1063.2875
1063.2875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625
890.8625

Comp Cap
(kips)
1436.875
1436.875
1436.875
1551.825
1551.825
1551.825
1551.825
1551.825
1551.825
1551.825
1063.2875
1063.2875
1063.2875
1063.2875

Tens Cap
(kips)
-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-313.5
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-470.25
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-966.625
-966.625
-966.625
-966.625
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875
-809.875

Tens Cap
(kips)
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1306.25
-1410.75
-1410.75
-1410.75
-1410.75
-1410.75
-1410.75
-1410.75
-966.625
-966.625
-966.625
-966.625

Brace Angle
(radians)
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.7854
0.9273
0.7266
0.7266
0.7266
0.7266

Brace Angle
(radians)
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.5937
0.7328
0.5404
0.5404
0.5404
0.5404

Unb. Up F
(kips)
22.17
22.17
22.17
22.17
22.17
33.25
33.25
33.25
33.25
33.25
33.25
33.25
33.25
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
68.35
68.35
68.35
68.35
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
92.37
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
57.27
64.79
53.81
53.81
53.81
53.81

Unb. Up F
(kips)
73.08
73.08
73.08
78.93
78.93
78.93
78.93
78.93
78.93
94.37
49.73
49.73
49.73
49.73

Unb Moment
(kip-ft)
149.6
149.6
149.6
149.6
149.6
224.4
224.4
224.4
224.4
224.4
224.4
224.4
224.4
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
461.4
461.4
461.4
461.4
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
623.5
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
386.6
437.3
363.2
363.2
363.2
363.2

Unb Moment
(kip-ft)
730.8
730.8
730.8
789.3
789.3
789.3
789.3
789.3
789.3
943.7
497.3
497.3
497.3
497.3

Dead Load
(psf)
80
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
480
54.5
54.5
54.5

Dead Load
(psf)
80
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
79.5
480
54.5
54.5
54.5

Trib Width
(ft)

Addl Dead Line


(kips/ft)

5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
9.75
9.75
9.75
9.75

Trib Width
(ft)

0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25

Addl Dead Line


(kips/ft)

5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
9.75
9.75
9.75
9.75

Page 1 of 1

0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25

Total Moment Beam Comp.


(kip-ft)
(kips)
109.89
110.04
110.04
110.04
110.04
184.86
184.86
184.86
184.86
184.86
184.86
184.86
184.86
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
421.78
421.78
421.78
421.78
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
583.88
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
346.96
397.74
77.03
330.69
330.69
330.69

232.76
232.76
232.76
232.76
232.76
349.14
349.14
349.14
349.14
349.14
349.14
349.14
349.14
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
717.68
717.68
717.68
717.68
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
969.84
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
601.30
510.22
635.57
635.57
635.57
635.57

Total Moment Beam Comp.


(kip-ft)
(kips)
643.58
643.92
643.92
702.38
702.38
702.38
702.38
702.38
702.38
856.85
-164.28
392.46
392.46
392.46

1136.82
1136.82
1136.82
1227.76
1227.76
1227.76
1227.76
1227.76
1227.76
1101.03
1656.90
870.32
870.32
870.32

Collector

CT1
CT1
CT1
CT1
CT1
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT2
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT4
CT4
CT4
CT4
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT5
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3
CT3

Collector

CT14
CT14
CT14
CT15
CT15
CT15
CT15
CT15
CT15
CT15
CT17
CT16
CT16
CT16

Beam

bf/2tf

h/tw

Ca

Seismically
Compact

W14X53
W14X53
W14X53
W14X53
W14X53
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W14X68
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W14X132
W14X132
W14X132
W14X132
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W14X159
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100
W16X100

6.11
6.11
6.11
6.11
6.11
6.97
6.97
6.97
6.97
6.97
6.97
6.97
6.97
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
7.15
7.15
7.15
7.15
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
6.54
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29
5.29

30.9
30.9
30.9
30.9
30.9
27.5
27.5
27.5
27.5
27.5
27.5
27.5
27.5
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
17.7
17.7
17.7
17.7
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
15.3
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2
23.2

0.332
0.332
0.332
0.332
0.332
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.388
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.411
0.411
0.411
0.411
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.461
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.450
0.382
0.476
0.476
0.476
0.476

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Beam

bf/2tf

h/tw

Ca

Seismically
Compact

W14X176
W14X176
W14X176
W14X193
W14X193
W14X193
W14X193
W14X193
W14X193
W14X193
W24X162
W24X131
W24X131
W24X131

5.97
5.97
5.97
5.45
5.45
5.45
5.45
5.45
5.45
5.45
5.31
6.7
6.7
6.7

13.7
13.7
13.7
12.8
12.8
12.8
12.8
12.8
12.8
12.8
30.6
35.6
35.6
35.6

0.488
0.488
0.488
0.480
0.480
0.480
0.480
0.480
0.480
0.431
0.772
0.502
0.502
0.502

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

fMn
(kip-ft)
310.6
310.6
310.6
310.6
310.6
442.3
442.3
442.3
442.3
442.3
442.3
442.3
442.3
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
973.4
973.4
973.4
973.4
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
1195.8
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7
778.7

fMn
(kip-ft)
1333.3
1333.3
1333.3
1479.2
1479.2
1479.2
1479.2
1479.2
1479.2
1479.2
1950.0
1541.7
1541.7
1541.7

fPcr
(kips)
417.1
417.1
417.1
417.1
417.1
655.4
655.4
655.4
655.4
655.4
655.4
655.4
655.4
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
1524.4
1524.4
1524.4
1524.4
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
1864.0
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2
983.2

fPcr
(kips)
2184.0
2184.0
2184.0
2397.1
2397.1
2397.1
2397.1
2397.1
2397.1
2397.1
1916.8
1537.6
1537.6
1537.6

Interaction

0.872
0.873
0.873
0.873
0.873
0.904
0.904
0.904
0.904
0.904
0.904
0.904
0.904
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
0.856
0.856
0.856
0.856
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
0.954
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
1.008
0.973
0.734
1.024
1.024
1.024

Interaction

0.950
0.950
0.950
0.934
0.934
0.934
0.934
0.934
0.934
0.974
0.939
0.792
0.792
0.792

Comment

OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK
OK
OK
Say OK
Say OK
Say OK

Comment

OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:12 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

A43

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
-7.88
-8.82
-12.10
-12.98
-14.26
-15.48
-16.35
-17.58
-18.84
-20.12
-21.19
-26.26
-27.18
-27.11
-27.97
-29.02
-29.51
-28.27
-28.48
-29.09
-29.67
-30.12
-30.55
-30.80
-31.06
-31.28
-31.44
-31.23
-37.22
-35.30
-34.63
-34.41
-34.39
-34.11
-33.76
-33.25
-32.64
-31.30
-28.07
-17.27
4.80
3.23
1.59
-0.05

WindFY
10.30
18.43
32.87
43.58
54.09
60.61
70.84
81.06
91.74
101.29
109.74
137.17
144.54
145.02
152.23
161.51
167.36
162.21
166.63
173.90
178.34
184.43
192.70
197.43
202.98
209.50
216.10
218.12
263.48
258.09
261.50
265.99
272.44
276.18
280.49
281.09
279.63
268.66
235.18
129.63
-79.23
-55.47
-26.64
3.21

WindMTY
-22.66
-25.36
-34.79
-37.29
-40.97
-44.47
-46.97
-50.51
-54.14
-57.82
-60.88
-75.47
-78.15
-77.96
-80.47
-83.50
-84.92
-81.41
-82.03
-83.81
-85.49
-86.80
-88.06
-88.81
-89.61
-90.27
-90.74
-90.17
-107.50
-101.98
-100.09
-99.51
-99.49
-98.71
-97.76
-96.33
-94.61
-90.79
-81.49
-50.21
13.88
9.32
4.60
-0.14

ServSpecX
0.01
0.14
0.29
0.47
0.71
0.98
1.26
1.28
1.54
1.31
1.51
1.51
1.69
1.47
1.61
1.75
1.90
1.83
1.96
2.08
2.20
2.09
2.20
1.92
2.01
2.09
2.18
2.08
2.20
2.28
2.37
2.27
2.36
2.28
2.36
2.30
2.39
2.48
2.57
2.96
2.35
2.35
2.34
2.34

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.6

-1.6

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

ServSpecY
65.54
77.41
122.52
133.56
146.70
144.63
150.21
154.91
156.45
157.27
154.02
176.60
170.34
156.54
154.29
154.07
151.36
140.47
139.56
141.90
141.66
144.57
149.29
154.30
159.62
165.76
171.83
176.05
215.17
213.94
219.92
228.78
238.69
248.15
257.10
264.46
269.11
266.34
245.52
159.96
40.58
28.94
14.60
6.42

-3.6
-4.2
-4.9
-5.5
-6.1
-6.6
-7.1
-6.8
-7.2
-6.4
-6.7
-6.5
-6.8
-6.1
-6.3
-6.5
-6.7
-6.5
-6.7
-6.8
-7.0
-6.7
-6.9
-6.3
-6.4
-6.5
-6.7
-6.4
-6.7
-6.8
-6.9
-6.7
-6.8
-6.6
-6.7
-6.5
-6.6
-6.7
-6.8
-7.0
-7.0
-7.1
-7.3
-7.4

-3.6
-4.2
-5.0
-5.7
-6.4
-7.1
-7.8
-7.5
-8.2
-7.2
-7.7
-7.6
-8.1
-7.4
-7.8
-8.2
-8.6
-8.4
-8.8
-9.2
-9.6
-9.3
-9.7
-8.9
-9.2
-9.6
-9.9
-9.7
-10.2
-10.5
-10.9
-10.6
-11.0
-10.7
-11.1
-10.9
-11.2
-11.5
-11.9
-12.9
-11.7
-11.8
-12.0
-12.1

12.9
25.3
47.7
64.1
80.3
90.1
105.9
122.5
139.1
155.3
168.4
212.4
223.8
225.3
236.5
251.1
260.1
252.1
258.9
270.2
277.1
287.1
300.0
308.3
316.9
327.2
337.5
340.9
413.1
404.3
409.5
416.9
427.0
433.2
439.9
441.1
438.5
420.7
367.0
197.4
-136.1
-98.2
-52.2
-4.6

-20.1
-33.7
-57.5
-75.3
-92.7
-103.8
-120.8
-136.9
-154.5
-168.9
-182.8
-226.5
-238.7
-238.8
-250.6
-265.8
-275.4
-267.0
-274.3
-286.2
-293.6
-303.1
-316.6
-323.5
-332.6
-343.3
-354.1
-357.0
-430.0
-421.6
-427.3
-434.2
-444.8
-450.6
-457.7
-458.4
-456.3
-439.0
-385.6
-217.4
117.4
79.3
33.0
-14.9

Page 1 of 6

8.8
17.9
34.5
46.8
58.8
66.1
77.8
90.4
102.7
115.1
124.9
158.0
166.5
167.7
176.2
187.1
193.9
187.9
193.0
201.6
206.7
214.3
224.0
230.3
236.8
244.5
252.2
254.9
309.1
302.5
306.4
312.0
319.6
324.3
329.4
330.3
328.4
315.1
274.8
147.8
-102.6
-74.3
-39.8
-4.2

-16.0
-26.3
-44.4
-57.8
-71.0
-79.4
-92.2
-104.2
-117.4
-128.0
-138.5
-171.3
-180.4
-180.3
-189.2
-200.5
-207.8
-201.4
-206.9
-215.8
-221.3
-228.4
-238.5
-243.5
-250.4
-258.3
-266.4
-268.6
-323.3
-317.0
-321.2
-326.4
-334.2
-338.5
-343.8
-344.3
-342.7
-329.7
-289.6
-163.3
87.5
58.8
24.1
-11.9

8.8
17.9
34.5
46.7
58.6
65.7
77.3
89.8
102.0
114.4
124.1
157.1
165.5
166.8
175.1
185.8
192.5
186.5
191.5
199.8
204.8
212.4
221.9
228.4
234.7
242.2
249.8
252.5
306.4
299.6
303.4
309.1
316.5
321.2
326.0
327.0
324.9
311.5
271.0
143.4
-106.2
-77.8
-43.4
-7.7

-16.0
-26.3
-44.4
-57.9
-71.2
-79.7
-92.7
-104.7
-118.1
-128.7
-139.3
-172.1
-181.4
-181.2
-190.3
-201.8
-209.2
-202.8
-208.5
-217.6
-223.3
-230.3
-240.6
-245.5
-252.4
-260.6
-268.8
-271.0
-325.9
-319.8
-324.2
-329.3
-337.4
-341.6
-347.1
-347.6
-346.2
-333.3
-293.4
-167.7
84.0
55.3
20.6
-15.4

-13.0
-14.8
-19.4
-21.1
-23.2
-25.2
-26.8
-28.0
-30.0
-30.6
-32.2
-38.2
-39.5
-38.8
-40.1
-41.6
-42.4
-40.6
-41.1
-42.0
-42.9
-43.2
-43.9
-43.6
-44.1
-44.5
-44.8
-44.3
-51.8
-49.6
-49.0
-48.5
-48.6
-48.0
-47.8
-46.9
-46.3
-44.8
-41.1
-28.5
-1.8
-3.8
-6.0
-8.1

5.9
6.4
9.6
10.1
11.0
11.9
12.4
14.2
15.3
17.7
18.6
24.9
25.7
26.2
27.1
28.1
28.4
27.2
27.3
27.8
28.3
29.1
29.4
30.3
30.5
30.6
30.6
30.6
37.6
35.1
34.2
34.1
34.0
33.8
33.3
32.9
32.0
30.3
26.3
13.0
-13.3
-11.6
-9.8
-8.0

-13.0
-14.8
-19.5
-21.2
-23.4
-25.6
-27.3
-28.5
-30.7
-31.3
-33.0
-39.0
-40.6
-39.7
-41.1
-42.8
-43.8
-42.0
-42.7
-43.8
-44.9
-45.1
-46.0
-45.5
-46.1
-46.7
-47.2
-46.7
-54.4
-52.4
-52.0
-51.4
-51.7
-51.2
-51.1
-50.2
-49.8
-48.5
-44.9
-32.9
-5.3
-7.4
-9.5
-11.6

5.9
6.4
9.6
9.9
10.8
11.6
11.9
13.7
14.5
17.0
17.8
24.0
24.7
25.3
26.0
26.9
27.1
25.8
25.7
26.0
26.3
27.2
27.3
28.4
28.4
28.4
28.2
28.2
34.9
32.3
31.2
31.2
30.8
30.7
30.0
29.6
28.5
26.6
22.5
8.5
-16.9
-15.1
-13.3
-11.5

-18.4
-12.5
-7.2
2.0
9.5
12.5
21.2
29.5
37.4
45.4
51.4
67.0
72.2
73.7
79.1
86.3
91.3
89.5
93.8
100.1
103.1
109.2
117.3
122.8
128.2
135.0
142.1
145.5
178.7
178.7
184.8
191.1
198.6
204.3
210.4
213.0
213.1
204.3
175.1
85.3
-87.8
-64.9
-36.1
-6.1

36.0
48.3
76.3
91.5
107.9
119.3
133.9
150.7
167.3
184.1
197.5
248.1
259.8
260.8
272.2
286.7
295.1
284.9
290.7
301.3
308.3
317.5
328.6
335.9
343.3
351.7
359.9
361.9
436.7
423.4
425.0
430.0
437.4
441.2
445.0
444.2
440.2
422.2
370.7
205.8
-121.1
-87.2
-47.1
-5.8

-43.1
-56.8
-86.1
-102.6
-120.3
-132.9
-148.8
-165.0
-182.8
-197.7
-212.0
-262.2
-274.7
-274.3
-286.3
-301.4
-310.4
-299.8
-306.1
-317.3
-324.9
-333.5
-345.2
-351.1
-358.9
-367.8
-376.5
-378.0
-453.6
-440.7
-442.8
-447.3
-455.2
-458.5
-462.8
-461.6
-458.0
-440.4
-389.3
-225.8
102.4
68.3
27.9
-13.8

11.2
4.1
-2.6
-13.1
-21.9
-26.2
-36.1
-43.8
-52.8
-59.0
-65.8
-81.1
-87.1
-87.2
-93.2
-101.0
-106.6
-104.4
-109.2
-116.1
-119.7
-125.2
-133.8
-137.9
-143.9
-151.1
-158.7
-161.6
-195.6
-196.0
-202.6
-208.4
-216.4
-221.6
-228.2
-230.4
-230.9
-222.6
-193.7
-105.3
69.1
45.9
16.8
-13.5

-21.8
-18.4
-17.5
-11.6
-7.1
-6.1
-0.5
4.7
9.5
14.5
18.0
25.2
28.3
29.6
32.8
37.2
40.5
40.4
43.4
47.6
49.3
53.5
59.3
63.2
67.1
72.0
77.2
80.0
99.5
101.2
106.4
111.4
117.1
121.7
126.5
129.0
129.7
124.3
105.3
47.7
-62.5
-46.8
-26.7
-5.7

-7.6
-2.5
4.3
11.8
18.5
21.8
28.9
36.4
43.4
50.7
56.2
72.5
77.2
78.4
83.2
89.5
93.7
91.4
94.7
100.0
102.8
107.8
114.3
118.7
123.1
128.4
133.9
136.2
166.6
164.8
168.8
173.4
179.1
183.1
187.4
188.9
188.5
180.7
155.8
78.8
-71.2
-52.6
-29.6
-5.6

-21.8
-18.4
-17.6
-11.7
-7.3
-6.4
-0.9
4.3
8.9
14.0
17.4
24.5
27.5
28.9
32.0
36.3
39.5
39.4
42.3
46.3
47.9
52.1
57.7
61.8
65.5
70.3
75.4
78.2
97.6
99.1
104.2
109.2
114.7
119.3
124.1
126.6
127.1
121.6
102.4
44.3
-65.2
-49.5
-29.4
-8.4

-7.6
-2.5
4.2
11.7
18.4
21.5
28.6
36.0
42.9
50.2
55.6
71.8
76.5
77.7
82.4
88.6
92.7
90.3
93.6
98.7
101.3
106.4
112.7
117.3
121.5
126.7
132.0
134.4
164.6
162.7
166.6
171.2
176.7
180.8
184.9
186.5
185.9
177.9
153.0
75.5
-73.9
-55.3
-32.2
-8.3

19.0
27.3
45.1
55.6
66.7
74.0
84.1
95.7
107.0
118.6
127.7
161.1
169.1
170.0
177.8
187.7
193.5
187.1
191.2
198.6
203.4
209.9
217.9
223.2
228.5
234.6
240.7
242.4
293.2
284.9
286.8
290.7
296.3
299.5
302.7
302.6
300.1
287.9
252.1
138.1
-87.6
-63.6
-35.0
-5.5

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

A44

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.145
1
1

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
-7.88
-8.82
-12.10
-12.98
-14.26
-15.48
-16.35
-17.58
-18.84
-20.12
-21.19
-26.26
-27.18
-27.11
-27.97
-29.02
-29.51
-28.27
-28.48
-29.09
-29.67
-30.12
-30.55
-30.80
-31.06
-31.28
-31.44
-31.23
-37.22
-35.30
-34.63
-34.41
-34.39
-34.11
-33.76
-33.25
-32.64
-31.30
-28.07
-17.27
4.80
3.23
1.59
-0.05

WindFY
10.30
18.43
32.87
43.58
54.09
60.61
70.84
81.06
91.74
101.29
109.74
137.17
144.54
145.02
152.23
161.51
167.36
162.21
166.63
173.90
178.34
184.43
192.70
197.43
202.98
209.50
216.10
218.12
263.48
258.09
261.50
265.99
272.44
276.18
280.49
281.09
279.63
268.66
235.18
129.63
-79.23
-55.47
-26.64
3.21

0.9

1.6

-1.6

0.9

1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 4

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

0.9

0.9

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 3

WindMTY
-22.66
-25.36
-34.79
-37.29
-40.97
-44.47
-46.97
-50.51
-54.14
-57.82
-60.88
-75.47
-78.15
-77.96
-80.47
-83.50
-84.92
-81.41
-82.03
-83.81
-85.49
-86.80
-88.06
-88.81
-89.61
-90.27
-90.74
-90.17
-107.50
-101.98
-100.09
-99.51
-99.49
-98.71
-97.76
-96.33
-94.61
-90.79
-81.49
-50.21
13.88
9.32
4.60
-0.14

-40.4
-51.6
-76.8
-90.1
-104.6
-115.3
-128.1
-141.3
-155.8
-168.0
-179.7
-222.0
-232.1
-231.7
-241.5
-253.7
-261.0
-251.8
-256.8
-265.7
-271.9
-278.7
-287.9
-292.5
-298.6
-305.4
-312.1
-313.0
-375.1
-363.7
-364.7
-367.8
-373.7
-375.9
-378.8
-377.4
-374.1
-359.7
-318.4
-185.9
80.2
53.1
21.3
-11.5

0.4
-5.9
-14.1
-22.9
-30.8
-35.2
-43.5
-50.3
-58.3
-63.8
-70.0
-86.0
-91.3
-91.2
-96.5
-103.3
-108.0
-105.2
-109.0
-114.7
-117.9
-122.4
-129.3
-132.5
-137.1
-142.8
-148.6
-150.5
-181.5
-180.0
-184.4
-188.5
-194.5
-198.1
-202.7
-203.8
-203.7
-196.2
-171.6
-95.4
55.2
36.3
13.0
-11.3

14.6
10.0
7.7
0.4
-5.3
-7.6
-14.4
-19.1
-24.9
-28.1
-32.4
-39.3
-43.1
-43.1
-46.9
-51.9
-55.9
-55.3
-58.9
-63.6
-65.9
-69.5
-75.8
-78.4
-82.7
-88.1
-93.8
-96.1
-116.4
-118.5
-124.2
-128.7
-134.9
-139.0
-144.3
-146.4
-147.5
-142.5
-123.9
-67.6
43.9
27.9
7.5
-13.8

0.4
-5.9
-14.1
-23.0
-31.0
-35.4
-43.9
-50.7
-58.8
-64.3
-70.6
-86.6
-92.1
-91.9
-97.3
-104.2
-109.0
-106.2
-110.2
-116.0
-119.4
-123.8
-130.8
-133.9
-138.7
-144.5
-150.5
-152.3
-183.4
-182.1
-186.6
-190.7
-196.9
-200.4
-205.1
-206.3
-206.3
-198.9
-174.5
-98.7
52.5
33.7
10.3
-13.9

14.6
10.0
7.7
0.5
-5.1
-7.3
-14.1
-18.6
-24.3
-27.6
-31.8
-38.7
-42.4
-42.4
-46.1
-51.0
-54.8
-54.2
-57.7
-62.3
-64.5
-68.1
-74.2
-77.0
-81.2
-86.4
-92.0
-94.3
-114.4
-116.4
-122.0
-126.5
-132.5
-136.6
-141.8
-143.9
-144.9
-139.8
-121.0
-64.3
46.5
30.5
10.1
-11.2

33.2
43.2
66.9
79.0
92.4
101.9
113.6
127.4
140.9
154.9
165.9
208.4
218.0
218.9
228.2
239.9
246.7
238.0
242.5
251.0
256.8
264.2
272.9
278.7
284.5
291.0
297.3
298.7
360.3
348.5
349.1
352.7
358.3
360.9
363.5
362.5
358.9
344.2
302.7
169.2
-96.2
-69.4
-37.9
-5.4

-26.2
-35.7
-55.0
-66.8
-79.1
-87.7
-99.0
-110.0
-122.4
-132.2
-142.1
-175.3
-183.9
-183.5
-191.9
-202.4
-208.9
-201.9
-206.6
-214.6
-219.9
-225.9
-234.4
-238.4
-244.2
-250.7
-257.3
-258.5
-310.1
-302.3
-304.6
-308.0
-314.1
-316.8
-320.5
-319.9
-317.9
-306.1
-270.7
-158.1
68.9
44.7
15.8
-14.1

33.2
43.2
66.9
78.9
92.2
101.6
113.2
127.0
140.4
154.4
165.3
207.8
217.3
218.2
227.4
239.0
245.7
237.0
241.4
249.7
255.4
262.7
271.4
277.3
282.9
289.3
295.5
296.9
358.3
346.4
346.9
350.5
355.9
358.6
361.0
360.0
356.3
341.5
299.8
165.9
-98.9
-72.1
-40.5
-8.0

-26.2
-35.7
-55.0
-66.7
-78.9
-87.4
-98.7
-109.6
-121.9
-131.8
-141.5
-174.6
-183.2
-182.8
-191.1
-201.5
-207.8
-200.9
-205.5
-213.3
-218.5
-224.5
-232.9
-237.0
-242.6
-249.1
-255.5
-256.7
-308.1
-300.2
-302.3
-305.8
-311.8
-314.5
-318.0
-317.5
-315.3
-303.3
-267.9
-154.8
71.5
47.3
18.4
-11.4

Page 2 of 6

19.0
27.3
45.1
55.5
66.5
73.7
83.7
95.3
106.5
118.1
127.1
160.5
168.3
169.3
177.0
186.7
192.5
186.0
190.0
197.3
201.9
208.5
216.3
221.8
227.0
233.0
238.9
240.6
291.2
282.8
284.5
288.5
294.0
297.1
300.2
300.1
297.5
285.1
249.2
134.8
-90.2
-66.3
-37.7
-8.1

-40.4
-51.6
-76.8
-90.2
-104.8
-115.6
-128.5
-141.7
-156.4
-168.5
-180.3
-222.6
-232.9
-232.4
-242.3
-254.7
-262.0
-252.9
-258.0
-267.0
-273.4
-280.2
-289.5
-293.9
-300.1
-307.1
-313.9
-314.8
-377.1
-365.9
-366.9
-370.0
-376.1
-378.3
-381.3
-379.8
-376.7
-362.5
-321.3
-189.2
77.5
50.5
18.6
-14.2

-2.7
-3.1
-3.6
-3.9
-4.3
-4.6
-5.0
-4.7
-5.0
-4.4
-4.6
-4.4
-4.6
-4.2
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5
-4.5
-4.4
-4.4
-4.1
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2
-4.3
-4.1
-4.2
-4.0
-4.1
-3.9
-4.0
-4.0
-4.0
-4.0
-4.2
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5

-2.7
-3.1
-3.6
-4.1
-4.6
-5.1
-5.6
-5.4
-5.9
-5.3
-5.6
-5.6
-5.9
-5.4
-5.7
-6.0
-6.3
-6.2
-6.5
-6.8
-7.1
-6.9
-7.2
-6.6
-6.9
-7.2
-7.5
-7.3
-7.7
-8.0
-8.3
-8.1
-8.4
-8.2
-8.5
-8.3
-8.6
-8.8
-9.1
-10.0
-8.9
-9.0
-9.1
-9.2

13.8
26.4
49.0
65.7
82.1
92.1
108.0
124.6
141.3
157.2
170.5
214.5
226.0
227.2
238.6
253.2
262.4
254.3
261.2
272.6
279.5
289.5
302.5
310.5
319.3
329.5
339.9
343.3
415.6
406.8
412.1
419.5
429.6
435.8
442.5
443.6
441.1
423.4
369.7
200.4
-133.3
-95.4
-49.4
-1.7

-19.2
-32.6
-56.2
-73.7
-91.0
-101.8
-118.6
-134.8
-152.2
-166.9
-180.7
-224.5
-236.5
-236.8
-248.6
-263.6
-273.2
-264.8
-272.0
-283.9
-291.2
-300.7
-314.1
-321.2
-330.3
-340.9
-351.6
-354.7
-427.5
-419.0
-424.7
-431.7
-442.2
-448.0
-455.0
-455.9
-453.7
-436.3
-382.9
-214.4
120.2
82.1
35.9
-12.0

9.7
19.0
35.9
48.3
60.6
68.0
80.0
92.5
105.0
117.0
127.0
160.0
168.7
169.7
178.2
189.2
196.1
190.1
195.3
203.9
209.1
216.6
226.5
232.5
239.1
246.9
254.7
257.3
311.6
305.0
309.0
314.6
322.2
326.9
332.0
332.8
331.0
317.8
277.6
150.8
-99.9
-71.4
-36.9
-1.2

-15.1
-25.2
-43.0
-56.2
-69.2
-77.4
-90.0
-102.1
-115.2
-126.0
-136.4
-169.2
-178.2
-178.3
-187.1
-198.4
-205.5
-199.2
-204.6
-213.4
-218.9
-226.0
-236.0
-241.3
-248.0
-256.0
-263.9
-266.2
-320.8
-314.4
-318.6
-323.8
-331.6
-336.0
-341.2
-341.8
-340.1
-327.0
-286.9
-160.3
90.3
61.7
27.0
-8.9

9.7
19.0
35.8
48.2
60.3
67.7
79.5
91.9
104.3
116.4
126.2
159.2
167.7
168.8
177.2
188.0
194.7
188.7
193.7
202.2
207.2
214.7
224.4
230.6
237.0
244.6
252.3
254.9
308.9
302.2
306.0
311.6
319.1
323.8
328.7
329.5
327.6
314.2
273.7
146.3
-103.4
-75.0
-40.5
-4.7

-15.1
-25.2
-43.1
-56.4
-69.5
-77.8
-90.5
-102.6
-115.9
-126.7
-137.2
-170.0
-179.2
-179.3
-188.2
-199.6
-206.9
-200.6
-206.2
-215.2
-220.8
-227.9
-238.1
-243.2
-250.1
-258.2
-266.4
-268.6
-323.4
-317.2
-321.6
-326.8
-334.8
-339.1
-344.5
-345.1
-343.6
-330.6
-290.7
-164.8
86.7
58.2
23.5
-12.4

-12.1
-13.7
-18.1
-19.5
-21.4
-23.3
-24.7
-25.9
-27.7
-28.6
-30.1
-36.1
-37.4
-36.8
-38.0
-39.4
-40.1
-38.5
-38.8
-39.7
-40.5
-40.8
-41.4
-41.4
-41.8
-42.1
-42.4
-41.9
-49.3
-47.0
-46.3
-45.9
-46.0
-45.5
-45.1
-44.4
-43.7
-42.2
-38.3
-25.5
1.0
-1.0
-3.1
-5.1

6.8
7.5
11.0
11.6
12.8
13.9
14.6
16.3
17.5
19.6
20.7
26.9
27.9
28.2
29.1
30.2
30.7
29.4
29.5
30.1
30.7
31.5
31.9
32.6
32.8
33.0
33.1
33.0
40.0
37.7
36.8
36.7
36.6
36.4
35.9
35.4
34.6
33.0
29.0
15.9
-10.6
-8.8
-6.9
-5.0

-12.1
-13.7
-18.2
-19.7
-21.7
-23.6
-25.2
-26.4
-28.4
-29.3
-30.9
-36.9
-38.4
-37.8
-39.1
-40.6
-41.5
-39.9
-40.4
-41.4
-42.4
-42.7
-43.5
-43.3
-43.8
-44.3
-44.8
-44.4
-51.9
-49.9
-49.3
-48.9
-49.1
-48.6
-48.4
-47.7
-47.2
-45.8
-42.2
-29.9
-2.6
-4.5
-6.6
-8.6

6.8
7.5
10.9
11.5
12.6
13.5
14.1
15.7
16.8
19.0
19.9
26.1
26.9
27.3
28.0
29.0
29.3
28.0
28.0
28.4
28.8
29.6
29.8
30.6
30.7
30.7
30.7
30.6
37.4
34.9
33.8
33.7
33.4
33.3
32.6
32.1
31.2
29.3
25.2
11.5
-14.1
-12.3
-10.4
-8.5

-17.5
-11.4
-5.9
3.5
11.3
14.5
23.4
31.6
39.7
47.3
53.5
69.0
74.4
75.7
81.1
88.4
93.5
91.7
96.1
102.5
105.6
111.5
119.7
125.0
130.5
137.4
144.6
147.9
181.2
181.2
187.4
193.7
201.3
206.9
213.0
215.6
215.7
207.0
177.9
88.3
-85.0
-62.0
-33.2
-3.1

36.9
49.4
77.6
93.0
109.6
121.2
136.1
152.8
169.6
186.1
199.6
250.2
262.0
262.8
274.3
288.8
297.3
287.1
293.0
303.6
310.8
319.8
331.1
338.1
345.6
354.1
362.4
364.3
439.2
426.0
427.6
432.5
440.1
443.8
447.6
446.8
442.8
424.9
373.4
208.8
-118.3
-84.4
-44.2
-2.8

-42.2
-55.7
-84.8
-101.1
-118.5
-131.0
-146.7
-163.0
-180.5
-195.8
-209.8
-260.2
-272.5
-272.4
-284.2
-299.2
-308.1
-297.6
-303.8
-314.9
-322.4
-331.1
-342.7
-348.8
-356.6
-365.4
-374.1
-375.6
-451.1
-438.2
-440.2
-444.7
-452.6
-456.0
-460.2
-459.0
-455.4
-437.7
-386.6
-222.8
105.2
71.1
30.8
-10.8

12.1
5.2
-1.3
-11.6
-20.2
-24.2
-33.9
-41.7
-50.6
-57.0
-63.7
-79.0
-84.9
-85.2
-91.1
-98.8
-104.3
-102.2
-107.0
-113.7
-117.2
-122.8
-131.4
-135.7
-141.6
-148.8
-156.3
-159.2
-193.1
-193.4
-199.9
-205.9
-213.8
-219.1
-225.5
-227.8
-228.3
-219.9
-191.0
-102.3
71.9
48.7
19.7
-10.5

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

A45

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

1.145
1
1

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

Figure 6-9 Case 4

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12
D12

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
-7.88
-8.82
-12.10
-12.98
-14.26
-15.48
-16.35
-17.58
-18.84
-20.12
-21.19
-26.26
-27.18
-27.11
-27.97
-29.02
-29.51
-28.27
-28.48
-29.09
-29.67
-30.12
-30.55
-30.80
-31.06
-31.28
-31.44
-31.23
-37.22
-35.30
-34.63
-34.41
-34.39
-34.11
-33.76
-33.25
-32.64
-31.30
-28.07
-17.27
4.80
3.23
1.59
-0.05

WindFY
10.30
18.43
32.87
43.58
54.09
60.61
70.84
81.06
91.74
101.29
109.74
137.17
144.54
145.02
152.23
161.51
167.36
162.21
166.63
173.90
178.34
184.43
192.70
197.43
202.98
209.50
216.10
218.12
263.48
258.09
261.50
265.99
272.44
276.18
280.49
281.09
279.63
268.66
235.18
129.63
-79.23
-55.47
-26.64
3.21

WindMTY
-22.66
-25.36
-34.79
-37.29
-40.97
-44.47
-46.97
-50.51
-54.14
-57.82
-60.88
-75.47
-78.15
-77.96
-80.47
-83.50
-84.92
-81.41
-82.03
-83.81
-85.49
-86.80
-88.06
-88.81
-89.61
-90.27
-90.74
-90.17
-107.50
-101.98
-100.09
-99.51
-99.49
-98.71
-97.76
-96.33
-94.61
-90.79
-81.49
-50.21
13.88
9.32
4.60
-0.14

-20.9
-17.3
-16.2
-10.0
-5.4
-4.1
1.7
6.8
11.7
16.5
20.1
27.2
30.4
31.5
34.9
39.4
42.8
42.6
45.7
50.0
51.8
55.9
61.7
65.5
69.4
74.4
79.7
82.4
102.0
103.8
109.1
114.0
119.7
124.2
129.2
131.6
132.3
127.0
108.0
50.6
-59.8
-44.0
-23.8
-2.8

-6.7
-1.4
5.6
13.4
20.3
23.7
31.1
38.5
45.7
52.7
58.3
74.5
79.4
80.4
85.2
91.7
96.0
93.5
97.0
102.4
105.3
110.2
116.7
121.0
125.4
130.8
136.3
138.6
169.1
167.4
171.5
176.0
181.7
185.7
190.0
191.5
191.1
183.4
158.6
81.8
-68.4
-49.8
-26.7
-2.7

-20.9
-17.3
-16.3
-10.1
-5.6
-4.4
1.3
6.4
11.2
16.0
19.5
26.6
29.7
30.9
34.1
38.5
41.8
41.6
44.5
48.7
50.4
54.5
60.1
64.0
67.8
72.7
77.8
80.5
100.1
101.7
106.8
111.8
117.4
121.9
126.7
129.1
129.7
124.3
105.2
47.3
-62.4
-46.6
-26.5
-5.4

-6.7
-1.4
5.6
13.3
20.1
23.5
30.8
38.1
45.1
52.2
57.7
73.9
78.7
79.7
84.4
90.8
94.9
92.5
95.8
101.1
103.8
108.7
115.2
119.5
123.8
129.1
134.5
136.8
167.1
165.3
169.2
173.8
179.3
183.3
187.5
189.0
188.5
180.6
155.7
78.4
-71.1
-52.5
-29.3
-5.3

19.9
28.4
46.5
57.2
68.4
76.0
86.3
97.8
109.3
120.6
129.8
163.2
171.2
172.0
179.8
189.8
195.8
189.3
193.5
201.0
205.8
212.3
220.4
225.5
230.8
237.0
243.1
244.8
295.7
287.5
289.4
293.3
299.0
302.0
305.3
305.1
302.7
290.5
254.8
141.1
-84.8
-60.8
-32.1
-2.5

-39.5
-50.5
-75.4
-88.5
-102.8
-113.3
-125.9
-139.2
-153.6
-166.0
-177.6
-219.9
-230.0
-229.7
-239.4
-251.6
-258.7
-249.6
-254.5
-263.3
-269.5
-276.4
-285.4
-290.2
-296.3
-303.0
-309.7
-310.6
-372.7
-361.2
-362.0
-365.2
-371.1
-373.4
-376.2
-374.8
-371.5
-357.0
-315.7
-182.9
83.0
55.9
24.2
-8.6

1.3
-4.8
-12.8
-21.3
-29.0
-33.2
-41.3
-48.2
-56.0
-61.9
-67.9
-83.9
-89.2
-89.3
-94.4
-101.1
-105.7
-103.0
-106.7
-112.3
-115.5
-120.0
-126.8
-130.2
-134.8
-140.4
-146.2
-148.2
-179.0
-177.5
-181.7
-186.0
-191.9
-195.5
-200.0
-201.3
-201.0
-193.5
-168.9
-92.4
58.0
39.2
15.9
-8.3

15.5
11.1
9.0
2.0
-3.5
-5.6
-12.3
-17.0
-22.6
-26.1
-30.3
-37.3
-40.9
-41.1
-44.8
-49.8
-53.6
-53.1
-56.6
-61.2
-63.5
-67.2
-73.3
-76.2
-80.4
-85.7
-91.4
-93.7
-113.9
-116.0
-121.6
-126.2
-132.3
-136.4
-141.7
-143.8
-144.8
-139.8
-121.2
-64.6
46.6
30.7
10.4
-10.9

1.3
-4.8
-12.8
-21.4
-29.2
-33.5
-41.7
-48.6
-56.6
-62.4
-68.5
-84.6
-89.9
-89.9
-95.2
-102.1
-106.8
-104.0
-107.9
-113.6
-116.9
-121.4
-128.4
-131.7
-136.4
-142.1
-148.0
-150.0
-181.0
-179.6
-184.0
-188.2
-194.2
-197.9
-202.5
-203.7
-203.6
-196.2
-171.7
-95.8
55.3
36.5
13.2
-10.9

Page 3 of 6

15.5
11.1
9.1
2.1
-3.3
-5.3
-11.9
-16.6
-22.1
-25.6
-29.7
-36.6
-40.2
-40.4
-44.0
-48.9
-52.6
-52.0
-55.4
-59.9
-62.0
-65.7
-71.8
-74.7
-78.9
-84.1
-89.5
-91.9
-111.9
-113.9
-119.3
-124.0
-129.9
-134.1
-139.2
-141.4
-142.2
-137.1
-118.3
-61.3
49.3
33.3
13.0
-8.2

34.1
44.3
68.3
80.6
94.1
103.9
115.7
129.5
143.2
156.9
168.0
210.5
220.2
220.8
230.2
242.1
249.0
240.2
244.8
253.4
259.3
266.5
275.4
281.0
286.8
293.4
299.8
301.1
362.8
351.1
351.8
355.3
360.9
363.5
366.1
365.0
361.5
346.9
305.4
172.2
-93.4
-66.6
-35.0
-2.4

-25.3
-34.6
-53.7
-65.2
-77.3
-85.7
-96.9
-108.0
-120.1
-130.3
-140.0
-173.2
-181.7
-181.6
-189.8
-200.2
-206.6
-199.8
-204.4
-212.2
-217.5
-223.5
-232.0
-236.2
-241.9
-248.4
-254.8
-256.1
-307.6
-299.7
-301.9
-305.5
-311.5
-314.3
-317.8
-317.4
-315.3
-303.4
-268.0
-155.1
71.7
47.5
18.7
-11.1

34.1
44.3
68.2
80.5
93.9
103.6
115.4
129.1
142.7
156.4
167.4
209.9
219.5
220.1
229.4
241.2
247.9
239.2
243.6
252.1
257.8
265.1
273.8
279.5
285.2
291.7
298.0
299.3
360.8
349.0
349.5
353.0
358.6
361.1
363.6
362.6
359.0
344.2
302.6
168.9
-96.1
-69.2
-37.6
-5.1

-25.3
-34.6
-53.6
-65.1
-77.1
-85.4
-96.5
-107.5
-119.6
-129.8
-139.4
-172.6
-181.0
-180.9
-189.0
-199.3
-205.6
-198.7
-203.2
-210.9
-216.0
-222.1
-230.4
-234.7
-240.3
-246.7
-253.0
-254.3
-305.6
-297.6
-299.7
-303.2
-309.1
-311.9
-315.3
-314.9
-312.7
-300.6
-265.1
-151.8
74.3
50.1
21.3
-8.5

19.9
28.4
46.4
57.1
68.3
75.7
85.9
97.4
108.7
120.1
129.2
162.6
170.5
171.3
179.0
188.9
194.8
188.2
192.3
199.6
204.4
210.8
218.8
224.0
229.3
235.3
241.3
243.0
293.7
285.4
287.1
291.0
296.6
299.7
302.8
302.7
300.2
287.8
252.0
137.8
-87.4
-63.4
-34.8
-5.2

-39.5
-50.5
-75.5
-88.6
-103.0
-113.6
-126.3
-139.6
-154.1
-166.5
-178.2
-220.5
-230.7
-230.4
-240.2
-252.5
-259.8
-250.7
-255.7
-264.6
-270.9
-277.8
-287.0
-291.7
-297.8
-304.7
-311.5
-312.4
-374.6
-363.3
-364.3
-367.5
-373.5
-375.7
-378.7
-377.3
-374.1
-359.8
-318.5
-186.2
80.3
53.3
21.5
-11.2

16.7
19.9
33.0
36.0
39.7
38.9
40.3
42.0
42.3
43.0
42.0
48.8
46.9
43.0
42.3
42.1
41.2
38.0
37.7
38.3
38.1
39.1
40.4
42.2
43.7
45.4
47.1
48.5
60.0
59.6
61.2
64.0
66.9
69.8
72.4
74.7
76.0
75.1
68.8
43.0
7.1
3.5
-0.9
-3.5

62.5
74.0
118.6
129.2
141.9
139.4
144.6
149.6
150.8
152.2
148.7
171.4
164.9
151.6
149.1
148.7
145.8
135.1
134.0
136.1
135.7
138.8
143.4
148.8
154.0
160.0
165.9
170.3
209.1
207.7
213.5
222.6
232.3
241.9
250.7
258.2
262.7
259.8
238.9
152.9
33.8
22.1
7.7
-0.6

16.7
19.6
32.4
35.1
38.3
36.9
37.8
39.5
39.2
40.4
38.9
45.8
43.5
40.1
39.0
38.6
37.4
34.4
33.8
34.1
33.7
34.9
36.0
38.3
39.6
41.2
42.7
44.3
55.6
55.0
56.5
59.5
62.2
65.3
67.7
70.1
71.2
70.2
63.7
37.1
2.4
-1.2
-5.6
-8.2

62.5
73.9
118.4
128.9
141.5
138.8
143.8
148.8
149.8
151.4
147.8
170.5
163.9
150.7
148.2
147.7
144.7
134.0
132.8
134.9
134.4
137.6
142.0
147.7
152.8
158.7
164.6
169.0
207.8
206.4
212.1
221.2
230.9
240.6
249.3
256.8
261.3
258.3
237.3
151.1
32.4
20.7
6.3
-2.0

-68.5
-80.8
-126.5
-137.9
-151.5
-149.8
-155.8
-160.3
-162.1
-162.3
-159.3
-181.8
-175.8
-161.5
-159.5
-159.4
-156.9
-145.9
-145.1
-147.7
-147.6
-150.3
-155.2
-159.8
-165.3
-171.6
-177.8
-181.9
-221.2
-220.2
-226.3
-235.0
-245.1
-254.4
-263.5
-270.7
-275.5
-272.9
-252.2
-167.0
-47.3
-35.8
-21.5
-13.5

-22.6
-26.5
-40.5
-44.1
-48.3
-47.9
-49.8
-50.9
-51.6
-51.3
-50.5
-57.1
-55.4
-50.9
-50.3
-50.3
-49.6
-46.2
-46.1
-46.9
-46.9
-47.7
-49.2
-50.4
-52.1
-54.1
-56.0
-57.2
-69.1
-68.8
-70.7
-73.3
-76.3
-79.1
-81.9
-84.0
-85.4
-84.7
-78.5
-53.0
-17.3
-13.9
-9.7
-7.3

-22.7
-26.8
-41.1
-45.1
-49.7
-49.9
-52.3
-53.5
-54.6
-53.9
-53.5
-60.2
-58.7
-53.8
-53.5
-53.9
-53.4
-49.9
-50.0
-51.0
-51.3
-51.8
-53.6
-54.3
-56.1
-58.2
-60.3
-61.3
-73.5
-73.4
-75.4
-77.8
-81.1
-83.6
-86.6
-88.6
-90.2
-89.6
-83.7
-58.9
-22.0
-18.6
-14.4
-12.0

-68.5
-80.9
-126.6
-138.2
-151.9
-150.4
-156.6
-161.0
-163.1
-163.1
-160.2
-182.7
-176.8
-162.4
-160.4
-160.5
-158.0
-146.9
-146.3
-148.9
-148.9
-151.6
-156.5
-160.9
-166.5
-172.8
-179.1
-183.1
-222.5
-221.5
-227.7
-236.4
-246.5
-255.8
-264.9
-272.1
-276.9
-274.4
-253.7
-168.8
-48.7
-37.2
-22.9
-14.9

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
62.55
-68.53
73.99
-80.92
118.57
-126.64
129.18
-138.23
141.91
-151.92
139.43
-150.42
144.60
-156.56
152.81
-165.04
169.61
-182.76
186.10
-197.73
199.65
-211.95
250.16
-262.24
261.98
-274.67
262.79
-274.32
274.26
-286.30
288.81
-301.36
297.34
-310.40
287.10
-299.77
292.96
-306.11
303.62
-317.25
310.77
-324.89
319.85
-333.47
331.09
-345.17
338.14
-351.08
345.59
-358.92
354.05
-367.78
362.36
-376.51
364.26
-377.99
439.24
-453.60
425.98
-440.74
427.65
-442.81
432.51
-447.26
440.06
-455.21
443.76
-458.54
447.64
-462.80
446.78
-461.58
442.82
-457.99
424.91
-440.44
373.45
-389.33
208.80
-225.78
120.20
-136.10
82.11
-98.24
35.89
-52.25
-0.62
-15.38

0.29
0.34
0.41
0.45
0.49
0.49
0.51
0.54
0.59
0.64
0.69
0.70
0.73
0.73
0.76
0.80
0.82
0.80
0.81
0.84
0.86
0.89
0.92
0.93
0.95
0.98
1.00
1.00
0.98
0.95
0.96
0.97
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
0.99
0.95
0.84
0.49
0.36
0.26
0.14
0.04

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

Dead=
Live=
WindFX=
WindMTX=
WindFY=
WindMTY=
SpecX=
SpecY=
Comment

1.145
1
1

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

A46

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
7.88
8.82
12.10
12.98
14.26
15.48
16.35
17.58
18.84
20.12
21.19
26.26
27.18
27.11
27.97
29.02
29.51
28.27
28.48
29.09
29.67
30.12
30.55
30.80
31.06
31.28
31.44
31.23
37.22
35.30
34.63
34.41
34.39
34.11
33.76
33.25
32.64
31.30
28.07
17.27
-4.80
-3.23
-1.59
0.05

WindFY
-10.30
-18.43
-32.87
-43.58
-54.09
-60.61
-70.84
-81.06
-91.74
-101.29
-109.74
-137.17
-144.54
-145.02
-152.23
-161.51
-167.36
-162.21
-166.63
-173.90
-178.34
-184.43
-192.70
-197.43
-202.98
-209.50
-216.10
-218.12
-263.48
-258.09
-261.50
-265.99
-272.44
-276.18
-280.49
-281.09
-279.63
-268.66
-235.18
-129.63
79.23
55.47
26.64
-3.21

WindMTY
22.66
25.36
34.79
37.29
40.97
44.47
46.97
50.51
54.14
57.82
60.88
75.47
78.15
77.96
80.47
83.50
84.92
81.41
82.03
83.81
85.49
86.80
88.06
88.81
89.61
90.27
90.74
90.17
107.50
101.98
100.09
99.51
99.49
98.71
97.76
96.33
94.61
90.79
81.49
50.21
-13.88
-9.32
-4.60
0.14

ServSpecX
0.01
0.14
0.29
0.48
0.71
0.98
1.26
1.28
1.54
1.31
1.51
1.51
1.69
1.47
1.61
1.76
1.90
1.83
1.95
2.08
2.20
2.09
2.20
1.92
2.01
2.09
2.18
2.08
2.20
2.28
2.37
2.27
2.36
2.28
2.36
2.30
2.39
2.48
2.57
2.96
2.35
2.35
2.34
2.34

1.2
1
1.6

1.2
1
-1.6

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2

1.6

-1.6

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 1

1.2
1
1.2
1.2

1.2
1
1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
-1.2
1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

1.2
1
-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

Figure 6-9 Case 3

ServSpecY
65.54
77.41
122.52
133.56
146.70
144.63
150.21
154.91
156.45
157.27
154.02
176.60
170.34
156.54
154.29
154.07
151.36
140.47
139.56
141.90
141.66
144.57
149.29
154.30
159.62
165.76
171.83
176.05
215.17
213.94
219.92
228.78
238.69
248.15
257.10
264.46
269.11
266.34
245.52
159.96
40.58
28.94
14.60
6.42

-3.6
-4.2
-4.9
-5.5
-6.1
-6.6
-7.1
-6.8
-7.2
-6.4
-6.7
-6.5
-6.8
-6.1
-6.3
-6.5
-6.7
-6.5
-6.7
-6.8
-7.0
-6.7
-6.9
-6.3
-6.4
-6.5
-6.7
-6.4
-6.7
-6.8
-6.9
-6.7
-6.8
-6.6
-6.7
-6.5
-6.6
-6.7
-6.8
-7.0
-7.0
-7.1
-7.3
-7.4

-3.6
-4.2
-5.0
-5.7
-6.4
-7.1
-7.8
-7.5
-8.2
-7.2
-7.7
-7.6
-8.1
-7.4
-7.8
-8.2
-8.6
-8.4
-8.8
-9.2
-9.6
-9.3
-9.7
-8.9
-9.2
-9.6
-9.9
-9.7
-10.2
-10.5
-10.9
-10.6
-11.0
-10.7
-11.1
-10.9
-11.2
-11.5
-11.9
-12.9
-11.7
-11.8
-12.0
-12.1

-20.1
-33.7
-57.5
-75.3
-92.7
-103.8
-120.8
-136.9
-154.5
-168.9
-182.8
-226.5
-238.7
-238.8
-250.6
-265.8
-275.4
-267.0
-274.3
-286.2
-293.6
-303.1
-316.6
-323.5
-332.6
-343.3
-354.1
-357.0
-430.0
-421.6
-427.3
-434.2
-444.8
-450.6
-457.7
-458.4
-456.3
-439.0
-385.6
-217.4
117.4
79.3
33.0
-14.9

12.9
25.3
47.7
64.1
80.3
90.1
105.9
122.5
139.1
155.3
168.4
212.4
223.8
225.3
236.5
251.1
260.1
252.1
258.9
270.2
277.1
287.1
300.0
308.3
316.9
327.2
337.5
340.9
413.1
404.3
409.5
416.9
427.0
433.2
439.9
441.1
438.5
420.7
367.0
197.4
-136.1
-98.2
-52.2
-4.6

Page 4 of 6

-16.0
-26.3
-44.4
-57.8
-71.0
-79.4
-92.2
-104.2
-117.4
-128.0
-138.5
-171.3
-180.4
-180.3
-189.2
-200.5
-207.8
-201.4
-206.9
-215.8
-221.3
-228.4
-238.5
-243.5
-250.4
-258.3
-266.4
-268.6
-323.3
-317.0
-321.2
-326.4
-334.2
-338.5
-343.8
-344.3
-342.7
-329.7
-289.6
-163.3
87.5
58.8
24.1
-11.9

8.8
17.9
34.5
46.8
58.8
66.1
77.8
90.4
102.7
115.1
124.9
158.0
166.5
167.7
176.2
187.1
193.9
187.9
193.0
201.6
206.7
214.3
224.0
230.3
236.8
244.5
252.2
254.9
309.1
302.5
306.4
312.0
319.6
324.3
329.4
330.3
328.4
315.1
274.8
147.8
-102.6
-74.3
-39.8
-4.2

-16.0
-26.3
-44.4
-57.9
-71.2
-79.7
-92.7
-104.7
-118.1
-128.7
-139.3
-172.1
-181.4
-181.2
-190.3
-201.8
-209.2
-202.8
-208.5
-217.6
-223.3
-230.3
-240.6
-245.5
-252.4
-260.6
-268.8
-271.0
-325.9
-319.8
-324.2
-329.3
-337.4
-341.6
-347.1
-347.6
-346.2
-333.3
-293.4
-167.7
84.0
55.3
20.6
-15.4

8.8
17.9
34.5
46.7
58.6
65.7
77.3
89.8
102.0
114.4
124.1
157.1
165.5
166.8
175.1
185.8
192.5
186.5
191.5
199.8
204.8
212.4
221.9
228.4
234.7
242.2
249.8
252.5
306.4
299.6
303.4
309.1
316.5
321.2
326.0
327.0
324.9
311.5
271.0
143.4
-106.2
-77.8
-43.4
-7.7

5.9
6.4
9.6
10.1
11.0
11.9
12.4
14.2
15.3
17.7
18.6
24.9
25.7
26.2
27.1
28.1
28.4
27.2
27.3
27.8
28.3
29.1
29.4
30.3
30.5
30.6
30.6
30.6
37.6
35.1
34.2
34.1
34.0
33.8
33.3
32.9
32.0
30.3
26.3
13.0
-13.3
-11.6
-9.8
-8.0

-13.0
-14.8
-19.4
-21.1
-23.2
-25.2
-26.8
-28.0
-30.0
-30.6
-32.2
-38.2
-39.5
-38.8
-40.1
-41.6
-42.4
-40.6
-41.1
-42.0
-42.9
-43.2
-43.9
-43.6
-44.1
-44.5
-44.8
-44.3
-51.8
-49.6
-49.0
-48.5
-48.6
-48.0
-47.8
-46.9
-46.3
-44.8
-41.1
-28.5
-1.8
-3.8
-6.0
-8.1

5.9
6.4
9.6
9.9
10.8
11.6
11.9
13.7
14.5
17.0
17.8
24.0
24.7
25.3
26.0
26.9
27.1
25.8
25.7
26.0
26.3
27.2
27.3
28.4
28.4
28.4
28.2
28.2
34.9
32.3
31.2
31.2
30.8
30.7
30.0
29.6
28.5
26.6
22.5
8.5
-16.9
-15.1
-13.3
-11.5

-13.0
-14.8
-19.5
-21.2
-23.4
-25.6
-27.3
-28.5
-30.7
-31.3
-33.0
-39.0
-40.6
-39.7
-41.1
-42.8
-43.8
-42.0
-42.7
-43.8
-44.9
-45.1
-46.0
-45.5
-46.1
-46.7
-47.2
-46.7
-54.4
-52.4
-52.0
-51.4
-51.7
-51.2
-51.1
-50.2
-49.8
-48.5
-44.9
-32.9
-5.3
-7.4
-9.5
-11.6

11.2
4.1
-2.6
-13.1
-21.9
-26.2
-36.1
-43.8
-52.8
-59.0
-65.8
-81.1
-87.1
-87.2
-93.2
-101.0
-106.6
-104.4
-109.2
-116.1
-119.7
-125.2
-133.8
-137.9
-143.9
-151.1
-158.7
-161.6
-195.6
-196.0
-202.6
-208.4
-216.4
-221.6
-228.2
-230.4
-230.9
-222.6
-193.7
-105.3
69.1
45.9
16.8
-13.5

-43.1
-56.8
-86.1
-102.6
-120.3
-132.9
-148.8
-165.0
-182.8
-197.7
-212.0
-262.2
-274.7
-274.3
-286.3
-301.4
-310.4
-299.8
-306.1
-317.3
-324.9
-333.5
-345.2
-351.1
-358.9
-367.8
-376.5
-378.0
-453.6
-440.7
-442.8
-447.3
-455.2
-458.5
-462.8
-461.6
-458.0
-440.4
-389.3
-225.8
102.4
68.3
27.9
-13.8

36.0
48.3
76.3
91.5
107.9
119.3
133.9
150.7
167.3
184.1
197.5
248.1
259.8
260.8
272.2
286.7
295.1
284.9
290.7
301.3
308.3
317.5
328.6
335.9
343.3
351.7
359.9
361.9
436.7
423.4
425.0
430.0
437.4
441.2
445.0
444.2
440.2
422.2
370.7
205.8
-121.1
-87.2
-47.1
-5.8

-18.4
-12.5
-7.2
2.0
9.5
12.5
21.2
29.5
37.4
45.4
51.4
67.0
72.2
73.7
79.1
86.3
91.3
89.5
93.8
100.1
103.1
109.2
117.3
122.8
128.2
135.0
142.1
145.5
178.7
178.7
184.8
191.1
198.6
204.3
210.4
213.0
213.1
204.3
175.1
85.3
-87.8
-64.9
-36.1
-6.1

14.6
10.0
7.7
0.5
-5.1
-7.3
-14.1
-18.6
-24.3
-27.6
-31.8
-38.7
-42.4
-42.4
-46.1
-51.0
-54.8
-54.2
-57.7
-62.3
-64.5
-68.1
-74.2
-77.0
-81.2
-86.4
-92.0
-94.3
-114.4
-116.4
-122.0
-126.5
-132.5
-136.6
-141.8
-143.9
-144.9
-139.8
-121.0
-64.3
46.5
30.5
10.1
-11.2

0.4
-5.9
-14.1
-22.9
-30.8
-35.2
-43.5
-50.3
-58.3
-63.8
-70.0
-86.0
-91.3
-91.2
-96.5
-103.3
-108.0
-105.2
-109.0
-114.7
-117.9
-122.4
-129.3
-132.5
-137.1
-142.8
-148.6
-150.5
-181.5
-180.0
-184.4
-188.5
-194.5
-198.1
-202.7
-203.8
-203.7
-196.2
-171.6
-95.4
55.2
36.3
13.0
-11.3

14.6
10.0
7.7
0.4
-5.3
-7.6
-14.4
-19.1
-24.9
-28.1
-32.4
-39.3
-43.1
-43.1
-46.9
-51.9
-55.9
-55.3
-58.9
-63.6
-65.9
-69.5
-75.8
-78.4
-82.7
-88.1
-93.8
-96.1
-116.4
-118.5
-124.2
-128.7
-134.9
-139.0
-144.3
-146.4
-147.5
-142.5
-123.9
-67.6
43.9
27.9
7.5
-13.8

0.4
-5.9
-14.1
-23.0
-31.0
-35.4
-43.9
-50.7
-58.8
-64.3
-70.6
-86.6
-92.1
-91.9
-97.3
-104.2
-109.0
-106.2
-110.2
-116.0
-119.4
-123.8
-130.8
-133.9
-138.7
-144.5
-150.5
-152.3
-183.4
-182.1
-186.6
-190.7
-196.9
-200.4
-205.1
-206.3
-206.3
-198.9
-174.5
-98.7
52.5
33.7
10.3
-13.9

-26.2
-35.7
-55.0
-66.7
-78.9
-87.4
-98.7
-109.6
-121.9
-131.8
-141.5
-174.6
-183.2
-182.8
-191.1
-201.5
-207.8
-200.9
-205.5
-213.3
-218.5
-224.5
-232.9
-237.0
-242.6
-249.1
-255.5
-256.7
-308.1
-300.2
-302.3
-305.8
-311.8
-314.5
-318.0
-317.5
-315.3
-303.3
-267.9
-154.8
71.5
47.3
18.4
-11.4

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

A47

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.145
1
1

1.2
1
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

1.2
1
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
7.88
8.82
12.10
12.98
14.26
15.48
16.35
17.58
18.84
20.12
21.19
26.26
27.18
27.11
27.97
29.02
29.51
28.27
28.48
29.09
29.67
30.12
30.55
30.80
31.06
31.28
31.44
31.23
37.22
35.30
34.63
34.41
34.39
34.11
33.76
33.25
32.64
31.30
28.07
17.27
-4.80
-3.23
-1.59
0.05

WindFY
-10.30
-18.43
-32.87
-43.58
-54.09
-60.61
-70.84
-81.06
-91.74
-101.29
-109.74
-137.17
-144.54
-145.02
-152.23
-161.51
-167.36
-162.21
-166.63
-173.90
-178.34
-184.43
-192.70
-197.43
-202.98
-209.50
-216.10
-218.12
-263.48
-258.09
-261.50
-265.99
-272.44
-276.18
-280.49
-281.09
-279.63
-268.66
-235.18
-129.63
79.23
55.47
26.64
-3.21

0.9

1.6

-1.6

0.9

1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 4

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

0.9

0.9

-1.6

Figure 6-9 Case 1

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2

1.2

-1.2

-1.2

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

1.2

-1.2

1.2

-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 2

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

1.2
1.2

1.2
-1.2

-1.2
1.2

-1.2
-1.2

Figure 6-9 Case 3

WindMTY
22.66
25.36
34.79
37.29
40.97
44.47
46.97
50.51
54.14
57.82
60.88
75.47
78.15
77.96
80.47
83.50
84.92
81.41
82.03
83.81
85.49
86.80
88.06
88.81
89.61
90.27
90.74
90.17
107.50
101.98
100.09
99.51
99.49
98.71
97.76
96.33
94.61
90.79
81.49
50.21
-13.88
-9.32
-4.60
0.14

33.2
43.2
66.9
79.0
92.4
101.9
113.6
127.4
140.9
154.9
165.9
208.4
218.0
218.9
228.2
239.9
246.7
238.0
242.5
251.0
256.8
264.2
272.9
278.7
284.5
291.0
297.3
298.7
360.3
348.5
349.1
352.7
358.3
360.9
363.5
362.5
358.9
344.2
302.7
169.2
-96.2
-69.4
-37.9
-5.4

-7.6
-2.5
4.3
11.8
18.5
21.8
28.9
36.4
43.4
50.7
56.2
72.5
77.2
78.4
83.2
89.5
93.7
91.4
94.7
100.0
102.8
107.8
114.3
118.7
123.1
128.4
133.9
136.2
166.6
164.8
168.8
173.4
179.1
183.1
187.4
188.9
188.5
180.7
155.8
78.8
-71.2
-52.6
-29.6
-5.6

-21.8
-18.4
-17.6
-11.7
-7.3
-6.4
-0.9
4.3
8.9
14.0
17.4
24.5
27.5
28.9
32.0
36.3
39.5
39.4
42.3
46.3
47.9
52.1
57.7
61.8
65.5
70.3
75.4
78.2
97.6
99.1
104.2
109.2
114.7
119.3
124.1
126.6
127.1
121.6
102.4
44.3
-65.2
-49.5
-29.4
-8.4

-7.6
-2.5
4.2
11.7
18.4
21.5
28.6
36.0
42.9
50.2
55.6
71.8
76.5
77.7
82.4
88.6
92.7
90.3
93.6
98.7
101.3
106.4
112.7
117.3
121.5
126.7
132.0
134.4
164.6
162.7
166.6
171.2
176.7
180.8
184.9
186.5
185.9
177.9
153.0
75.5
-73.9
-55.3
-32.2
-8.3

-21.8
-18.4
-17.5
-11.6
-7.1
-6.1
-0.5
4.7
9.5
14.5
18.0
25.2
28.3
29.6
32.8
37.2
40.5
40.4
43.4
47.6
49.3
53.5
59.3
63.2
67.1
72.0
77.2
80.0
99.5
101.2
106.4
111.4
117.1
121.7
126.5
129.0
129.7
124.3
105.3
47.7
-62.5
-46.8
-26.7
-5.7

-40.4
-51.6
-76.8
-90.1
-104.6
-115.3
-128.1
-141.3
-155.8
-168.0
-179.7
-222.0
-232.1
-231.7
-241.5
-253.7
-261.0
-251.8
-256.8
-265.7
-271.9
-278.7
-287.9
-292.5
-298.6
-305.4
-312.1
-313.0
-375.1
-363.7
-364.7
-367.8
-373.7
-375.9
-378.8
-377.4
-374.1
-359.7
-318.4
-185.9
80.2
53.1
21.3
-11.5

19.0
27.3
45.1
55.5
66.5
73.7
83.7
95.3
106.5
118.1
127.1
160.5
168.3
169.3
177.0
186.7
192.5
186.0
190.0
197.3
201.9
208.5
216.3
221.8
227.0
233.0
238.9
240.6
291.2
282.8
284.5
288.5
294.0
297.1
300.2
300.1
297.5
285.1
249.2
134.8
-90.2
-66.3
-37.7
-8.1

-40.4
-51.6
-76.8
-90.2
-104.8
-115.6
-128.5
-141.7
-156.4
-168.5
-180.3
-222.6
-232.9
-232.4
-242.3
-254.7
-262.0
-252.9
-258.0
-267.0
-273.4
-280.2
-289.5
-293.9
-300.1
-307.1
-313.9
-314.8
-377.1
-365.9
-366.9
-370.0
-376.1
-378.3
-381.3
-379.8
-376.7
-362.5
-321.3
-189.2
77.5
50.5
18.6
-14.2

19.0
27.3
45.1
55.6
66.7
74.0
84.1
95.7
107.0
118.6
127.7
161.1
169.1
170.0
177.8
187.7
193.5
187.1
191.2
198.6
203.4
209.9
217.9
223.2
228.5
234.6
240.7
242.4
293.2
284.9
286.8
290.7
296.3
299.5
302.7
302.6
300.1
287.9
252.1
138.1
-87.6
-63.6
-35.0
-5.5

Page 5 of 6

-26.2
-35.7
-55.0
-66.8
-79.1
-87.7
-99.0
-110.0
-122.4
-132.2
-142.1
-175.3
-183.9
-183.5
-191.9
-202.4
-208.9
-201.9
-206.6
-214.6
-219.9
-225.9
-234.4
-238.4
-244.2
-250.7
-257.3
-258.5
-310.1
-302.3
-304.6
-308.0
-314.1
-316.8
-320.5
-319.9
-317.9
-306.1
-270.7
-158.1
68.9
44.7
15.8
-14.1

33.2
43.2
66.9
78.9
92.2
101.6
113.2
127.0
140.4
154.4
165.3
207.8
217.3
218.2
227.4
239.0
245.7
237.0
241.4
249.7
255.4
262.7
271.4
277.3
282.9
289.3
295.5
296.9
358.3
346.4
346.9
350.5
355.9
358.6
361.0
360.0
356.3
341.5
299.8
165.9
-98.9
-72.1
-40.5
-8.0

-2.7
-3.1
-3.6
-3.9
-4.3
-4.6
-5.0
-4.7
-5.0
-4.4
-4.6
-4.4
-4.6
-4.2
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5
-4.5
-4.4
-4.4
-4.1
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2
-4.1
-4.2
-4.2
-4.3
-4.1
-4.2
-4.0
-4.1
-3.9
-4.0
-4.0
-4.0
-4.0
-4.2
-4.3
-4.4
-4.5

-2.7
-3.1
-3.6
-4.1
-4.6
-5.1
-5.6
-5.4
-5.9
-5.3
-5.6
-5.6
-5.9
-5.4
-5.7
-6.0
-6.3
-6.2
-6.5
-6.8
-7.1
-6.9
-7.2
-6.6
-6.9
-7.2
-7.5
-7.3
-7.7
-8.0
-8.3
-8.1
-8.4
-8.2
-8.5
-8.3
-8.6
-8.8
-9.1
-10.0
-8.9
-9.0
-9.1
-9.2

-19.2
-32.6
-56.2
-73.7
-91.0
-101.8
-118.6
-134.8
-152.2
-166.9
-180.7
-224.5
-236.5
-236.8
-248.6
-263.6
-273.2
-264.8
-272.0
-283.9
-291.2
-300.7
-314.1
-321.2
-330.3
-340.9
-351.6
-354.7
-427.5
-419.0
-424.7
-431.7
-442.2
-448.0
-455.0
-455.9
-453.7
-436.3
-382.9
-214.4
120.2
82.1
35.9
-12.0

13.8
26.4
49.0
65.7
82.1
92.1
108.0
124.6
141.3
157.2
170.5
214.5
226.0
227.2
238.6
253.2
262.4
254.3
261.2
272.6
279.5
289.5
302.5
310.5
319.3
329.5
339.9
343.3
415.6
406.8
412.1
419.5
429.6
435.8
442.5
443.6
441.1
423.4
369.7
200.4
-133.3
-95.4
-49.4
-1.7

-15.1
-25.2
-43.0
-56.2
-69.2
-77.4
-90.0
-102.1
-115.2
-126.0
-136.4
-169.2
-178.2
-178.3
-187.1
-198.4
-205.5
-199.2
-204.6
-213.4
-218.9
-226.0
-236.0
-241.3
-248.0
-256.0
-263.9
-266.2
-320.8
-314.4
-318.6
-323.8
-331.6
-336.0
-341.2
-341.8
-340.1
-327.0
-286.9
-160.3
90.3
61.7
27.0
-8.9

9.7
19.0
35.9
48.3
60.6
68.0
80.0
92.5
105.0
117.0
127.0
160.0
168.7
169.7
178.2
189.2
196.1
190.1
195.3
203.9
209.1
216.6
226.5
232.5
239.1
246.9
254.7
257.3
311.6
305.0
309.0
314.6
322.2
326.9
332.0
332.8
331.0
317.8
277.6
150.8
-99.9
-71.4
-36.9
-1.2

-15.1
-25.2
-43.1
-56.4
-69.5
-77.8
-90.5
-102.6
-115.9
-126.7
-137.2
-170.0
-179.2
-179.3
-188.2
-199.6
-206.9
-200.6
-206.2
-215.2
-220.8
-227.9
-238.1
-243.2
-250.1
-258.2
-266.4
-268.6
-323.4
-317.2
-321.6
-326.8
-334.8
-339.1
-344.5
-345.1
-343.6
-330.6
-290.7
-164.8
86.7
58.2
23.5
-12.4

9.7
19.0
35.8
48.2
60.3
67.7
79.5
91.9
104.3
116.4
126.2
159.2
167.7
168.8
177.2
188.0
194.7
188.7
193.7
202.2
207.2
214.7
224.4
230.6
237.0
244.6
252.3
254.9
308.9
302.2
306.0
311.6
319.1
323.8
328.7
329.5
327.6
314.2
273.7
146.3
-103.4
-75.0
-40.5
-4.7

6.8
7.5
11.0
11.6
12.8
13.9
14.6
16.3
17.5
19.6
20.7
26.9
27.9
28.2
29.1
30.2
30.7
29.4
29.5
30.1
30.7
31.5
31.9
32.6
32.8
33.0
33.1
33.0
40.0
37.7
36.8
36.7
36.6
36.4
35.9
35.4
34.6
33.0
29.0
15.9
-10.6
-8.8
-6.9
-5.0

-12.1
-13.7
-18.1
-19.5
-21.4
-23.3
-24.7
-25.9
-27.7
-28.6
-30.1
-36.1
-37.4
-36.8
-38.0
-39.4
-40.1
-38.5
-38.8
-39.7
-40.5
-40.8
-41.4
-41.4
-41.8
-42.1
-42.4
-41.9
-49.3
-47.0
-46.3
-45.9
-46.0
-45.5
-45.1
-44.4
-43.7
-42.2
-38.3
-25.5
1.0
-1.0
-3.1
-5.1

6.8
7.5
10.9
11.5
12.6
13.5
14.1
15.7
16.8
19.0
19.9
26.1
26.9
27.3
28.0
29.0
29.3
28.0
28.0
28.4
28.8
29.6
29.8
30.6
30.7
30.7
30.7
30.6
37.4
34.9
33.8
33.7
33.4
33.3
32.6
32.1
31.2
29.3
25.2
11.5
-14.1
-12.3
-10.4
-8.5

-12.1
-13.7
-18.2
-19.7
-21.7
-23.6
-25.2
-26.4
-28.4
-29.3
-30.9
-36.9
-38.4
-37.8
-39.1
-40.6
-41.5
-39.9
-40.4
-41.4
-42.4
-42.7
-43.5
-43.3
-43.8
-44.3
-44.8
-44.4
-51.9
-49.9
-49.3
-48.9
-49.1
-48.6
-48.4
-47.7
-47.2
-45.8
-42.2
-29.9
-2.6
-4.5
-6.6
-8.6

12.1
5.2
-1.3
-11.6
-20.2
-24.2
-33.9
-41.7
-50.6
-57.0
-63.7
-79.0
-84.9
-85.2
-91.1
-98.8
-104.3
-102.2
-107.0
-113.7
-117.2
-122.8
-131.4
-135.7
-141.6
-148.8
-156.3
-159.2
-193.1
-193.4
-199.9
-205.9
-213.8
-219.1
-225.5
-227.8
-228.3
-219.9
-191.0
-102.3
71.9
48.7
19.7
-10.5

-42.2
-55.7
-84.8
-101.1
-118.5
-131.0
-146.7
-163.0
-180.5
-195.8
-209.8
-260.2
-272.5
-272.4
-284.2
-299.2
-308.1
-297.6
-303.8
-314.9
-322.4
-331.1
-342.7
-348.8
-356.6
-365.4
-374.1
-375.6
-451.1
-438.2
-440.2
-444.7
-452.6
-456.0
-460.2
-459.0
-455.4
-437.7
-386.6
-222.8
105.2
71.1
30.8
-10.8

36.9
49.4
77.6
93.0
109.6
121.2
136.1
152.8
169.6
186.1
199.6
250.2
262.0
262.8
274.3
288.8
297.3
287.1
293.0
303.6
310.8
319.8
331.1
338.1
345.6
354.1
362.4
364.3
439.2
426.0
427.6
432.5
440.1
443.8
447.6
446.8
442.8
424.9
373.4
208.8
-118.3
-84.4
-44.2
-2.8

-17.5
-11.4
-5.9
3.5
11.3
14.5
23.4
31.6
39.7
47.3
53.5
69.0
74.4
75.7
81.1
88.4
93.5
91.7
96.1
102.5
105.6
111.5
119.7
125.0
130.5
137.4
144.6
147.9
181.2
181.2
187.4
193.7
201.3
206.9
213.0
215.6
215.7
207.0
177.9
88.3
-85.0
-62.0
-33.2
-3.1

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

SHEET NO.
PROJECT NO.
DATE
CLIENT

Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center

SUBJECT

Model:

SDS =
r-X dir =
r -Y dir =

A48

1/23/09

BY

BRB Strength Check along Line 3 for LA BRBF Bldg: PB Dsgn

Scale-X=
Scale-Y=

087237.10

AD

CHECKED BY

011609PBModel1

1.00
1.00

1.145
1
1

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

0.9008
-0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008

-0.9008
0.9008
-0.9008
0.9008

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.25

1
0.3

0.3
1

-1
0.3

-0.3
1

0.3
-1

1
-0.3

-1
-0.3

-0.3
-1

Figure 6-9 Case 4

Story

ETABS #

Section

Capacity

Story40
Story39
Story38
Story37
Story36
Story35
Story34
Story33
Story32
Story31
Story30
Story29
Story28
Story27
Story26
Story25
Story24
Story23
Story22
Story21
Story20
Story19
Story18
Story17
Story16
Story15
Story14
Story13
Story12
Story11
Story10
Story9
Story8
Story7
Story6
Story5
Story4
Story3
Story2
Story1
Ground
B1
B2
B3

D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18
D18

A7
A7
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A9
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A11
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A13.5
A11
A11
A11
A11

239
239
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
308
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
376
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
376
376
376
376

file: C:\Users\adutta\Desktop\087237\EXCEL\Comprehensive Brace Check PBEE Ver2


sheet: Elv3

Dead
-2.99
-3.45
-4.00
-4.47
-4.94
-5.41
-5.88
-5.64
-6.05
-5.36
-5.66
-5.56
-5.83
-5.32
-5.54
-5.77
-6.00
-5.82
-6.04
-6.26
-6.48
-6.26
-6.46
-5.95
-6.13
-6.30
-6.49
-6.31
-6.59
-6.78
-6.96
-6.77
-6.96
-6.79
-6.96
-6.80
-6.96
-7.13
-7.29
-7.78
-7.29
-7.39
-7.48
-7.57

Live

WindFX
0.00
-0.07
-0.14
-0.21
-0.28
-0.35
-0.41
-0.40
-0.45
-0.37
-0.41
-0.40
-0.43
-0.37
-0.40
-0.43
-0.46
-0.43
-0.46
-0.49
-0.51
-0.49
-0.51
-0.45
-0.47
-0.49
-0.51
-0.48
-0.51
-0.53
-0.55
-0.53
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.52
-0.54
-0.55
-0.57
-0.65
-0.59
-0.62
-0.65
-0.69

0.00
0.01
0.02
0.05
0.09
0.15
0.21
0.23
0.30
0.27
0.33
0.35
0.42
0.38
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.58
0.65
0.73
0.81
0.80
0.87
0.80
0.87
0.94
1.01
1.00
1.09
1.17
1.25
1.24
1.32
1.30
1.38
1.37
1.44
1.52
1.59
1.84
1.47
1.47
1.47
1.47

WindMTX
7.88
8.82
12.10
12.98
14.26
15.48
16.35
17.58
18.84
20.12
21.19
26.26
27.18
27.11
27.97
29.02
29.51
28.27
28.48
29.09
29.67
30.12
30.55
30.80
31.06
31.28
31.44
31.23
37.22
35.30
34.63
34.41
34.39
34.11
33.76
33.25
32.64
31.30
28.07
17.27
-4.80
-3.23
-1.59
0.05

WindFY
-10.30
-18.43
-32.87
-43.58
-54.09
-60.61
-70.84
-81.06
-91.74
-101.29
-109.74
-137.17
-144.54
-145.02
-152.23
-161.51
-167.36
-162.21
-166.63
-173.90
-178.34
-184.43
-192.70
-197.43
-202.98
-209.50
-216.10
-218.12
-263.48
-258.09
-261.50
-265.99
-272.44
-276.18
-280.49
-281.09
-279.63
-268.66
-235.18
-129.63
79.23
55.47
26.64
-3.21

WindMTY
22.66
25.36
34.79
37.29
40.97
44.47
46.97
50.51
54.14
57.82
60.88
75.47
78.15
77.96
80.47
83.50
84.92
81.41
82.03
83.81
85.49
86.80
88.06
88.81
89.61
90.27
90.74
90.17
107.50
101.98
100.09
99.51
99.49
98.71
97.76
96.33
94.61
90.79
81.49
50.21
-13.88
-9.32
-4.60
0.14

15.5
11.1
9.1
2.1
-3.3
-5.3
-11.9
-16.6
-22.1
-25.6
-29.7
-36.6
-40.2
-40.4
-44.0
-48.9
-52.6
-52.0
-55.4
-59.9
-62.0
-65.7
-71.8
-74.7
-78.9
-84.1
-89.5
-91.9
-111.9
-113.9
-119.3
-124.0
-129.9
-134.1
-139.2
-141.4
-142.2
-137.1
-118.3
-61.3
49.3
33.3
13.0
-8.2

1.3
-4.8
-12.8
-21.3
-29.0
-33.2
-41.3
-48.2
-56.0
-61.9
-67.9
-83.9
-89.2
-89.3
-94.4
-101.1
-105.7
-103.0
-106.7
-112.3
-115.5
-120.0
-126.8
-130.2
-134.8
-140.4
-146.2
-148.2
-179.0
-177.5
-181.7
-186.0
-191.9
-195.5
-200.0
-201.3
-201.0
-193.5
-168.9
-92.4
58.0
39.2
15.9
-8.3

15.5
11.1
9.0
2.0
-3.5
-5.6
-12.3
-17.0
-22.6
-26.1
-30.3
-37.3
-40.9
-41.1
-44.8
-49.8
-53.6
-53.1
-56.6
-61.2
-63.5
-67.2
-73.3
-76.2
-80.4
-85.7
-91.4
-93.7
-113.9
-116.0
-121.6
-126.2
-132.3
-136.4
-141.7
-143.8
-144.8
-139.8
-121.2
-64.6
46.6
30.7
10.4
-10.9

1.3
-4.8
-12.8
-21.4
-29.2
-33.5
-41.7
-48.6
-56.6
-62.4
-68.5
-84.6
-89.9
-89.9
-95.2
-102.1
-106.8
-104.0
-107.9
-113.6
-116.9
-121.4
-128.4
-131.7
-136.4
-142.1
-148.0
-150.0
-181.0
-179.6
-184.0
-188.2
-194.2
-197.9
-202.5
-203.7
-203.6
-196.2
-171.7
-95.8
55.3
36.5
13.2
-10.9

-25.3
-34.6
-53.6
-65.1
-77.1
-85.4
-96.5
-107.5
-119.6
-129.8
-139.4
-172.6
-181.0
-180.9
-189.0
-199.3
-205.6
-198.7
-203.2
-210.9
-216.0
-222.1
-230.4
-234.7
-240.3
-246.7
-253.0
-254.3
-305.6
-297.6
-299.7
-303.2
-309.1
-311.9
-315.3
-314.9
-312.7
-300.6
-265.1
-151.8
74.3
50.1
21.3
-8.5

34.1
44.3
68.3
80.6
94.1
103.9
115.7
129.5
143.2
156.9
168.0
210.5
220.2
220.8
230.2
242.1
249.0
240.2
244.8
253.4
259.3
266.5
275.4
281.0
286.8
293.4
299.8
301.1
362.8
351.1
351.8
355.3
360.9
363.5
366.1
365.0
361.5
346.9
305.4
172.2
-93.4
-66.6
-35.0
-2.4

-6.7
-1.4
5.6
13.4
20.3
23.7
31.1
38.5
45.7
52.7
58.3
74.5
79.4
80.4
85.2
91.7
96.0
93.5
97.0
102.4
105.3
110.2
116.7
121.0
125.4
130.8
136.3
138.6
169.1
167.4
171.5
176.0
181.7
185.7
190.0
191.5
191.1
183.4
158.6
81.8
-68.4
-49.8
-26.7
-2.7

-20.9
-17.3
-16.3
-10.1
-5.6
-4.4
1.3
6.4
11.2
16.0
19.5
26.6
29.7
30.9
34.1
38.5
41.8
41.6
44.5
48.7
50.4
54.5
60.1
64.0
67.8
72.7
77.8
80.5
100.1
101.7
106.8
111.8
117.4
121.9
126.7
129.1
129.7
124.3
105.2
47.3
-62.4
-46.6
-26.5
-5.4

-6.7
-1.4
5.6
13.3
20.1
23.5
30.8
38.1
45.1
52.2
57.7
73.9
78.7
79.7
84.4
90.8
94.9
92.5
95.8
101.1
103.8
108.7
115.2
119.5
123.8
129.1
134.5
136.8
167.1
165.3
169.2
173.8
179.3
183.3
187.5
189.0
188.5
180.6
155.7
78.4
-71.1
-52.5
-29.3
-5.3

Page 6 of 6

-20.9
-17.3
-16.2
-10.0
-5.4
-4.1
1.7
6.8
11.7
16.5
20.1
27.2
30.4
31.5
34.9
39.4
42.8
42.6
45.7
50.0
51.8
55.9
61.7
65.5
69.4
74.4
79.7
82.4
102.0
103.8
109.1
114.0
119.7
124.2
129.2
131.6
132.3
127.0
108.0
50.6
-59.8
-44.0
-23.8
-2.8

-39.5
-50.5
-75.4
-88.5
-102.8
-113.3
-125.9
-139.2
-153.6
-166.0
-177.6
-219.9
-230.0
-229.7
-239.4
-251.6
-258.7
-249.6
-254.5
-263.3
-269.5
-276.4
-285.4
-290.2
-296.3
-303.0
-309.7
-310.6
-372.7
-361.2
-362.0
-365.2
-371.1
-373.4
-376.2
-374.8
-371.5
-357.0
-315.7
-182.9
83.0
55.9
24.2
-8.6

19.9
28.4
46.4
57.1
68.3
75.7
85.9
97.4
108.7
120.1
129.2
162.6
170.5
171.3
179.0
188.9
194.8
188.2
192.3
199.6
204.4
210.8
218.8
224.0
229.3
235.3
241.3
243.0
293.7
285.4
287.1
291.0
296.6
299.7
302.8
302.7
300.2
287.8
252.0
137.8
-87.4
-63.4
-34.8
-5.2

-39.5
-50.5
-75.5
-88.6
-103.0
-113.6
-126.3
-139.6
-154.1
-166.5
-178.2
-220.5
-230.7
-230.4
-240.2
-252.5
-259.8
-250.7
-255.7
-264.6
-270.9
-277.8
-287.0
-291.7
-297.8
-304.7
-311.5
-312.4
-374.6
-363.3
-364.3
-367.5
-373.5
-375.7
-378.7
-377.3
-374.1
-359.8
-318.5
-186.2
80.3
53.3
21.5
-11.2

19.9
28.4
46.5
57.2
68.4
76.0
86.3
97.8
109.3
120.6
129.8
163.2
171.2
172.0
179.8
189.8
195.8
189.3
193.5
201.0
205.8
212.3
220.4
225.5
230.8
237.0
243.1
244.8
295.7
287.5
289.4
293.3
299.0
302.0
305.3
305.1
302.7
290.5
254.8
141.1
-84.8
-60.8
-32.1
-2.5

-25.3
-34.6
-53.7
-65.2
-77.3
-85.7
-96.9
-108.0
-120.1
-130.3
-140.0
-173.2
-181.7
-181.6
-189.8
-200.2
-206.6
-199.8
-204.4
-212.2
-217.5
-223.5
-232.0
-236.2
-241.9
-248.4
-254.8
-256.1
-307.6
-299.7
-301.9
-305.5
-311.5
-314.3
-317.8
-317.4
-315.3
-303.4
-268.0
-155.1
71.7
47.5
18.7
-11.1

34.1
44.3
68.2
80.5
93.9
103.6
115.4
129.1
142.7
156.4
167.4
209.9
219.5
220.1
229.4
241.2
247.9
239.2
243.6
252.1
257.8
265.1
273.8
279.5
285.2
291.7
298.0
299.3
360.8
349.0
349.5
353.0
358.6
361.1
363.6
362.6
359.0
344.2
302.6
168.9
-96.1
-69.2
-37.6
-5.1

16.7
19.9
33.0
36.0
39.7
38.9
40.3
42.0
42.3
43.0
42.0
48.8
46.9
43.0
42.3
42.1
41.2
38.0
37.7
38.3
38.1
39.1
40.4
42.2
43.7
45.4
47.1
48.5
60.0
59.6
61.2
64.0
66.9
69.8
72.4
74.7
76.0
75.1
68.8
43.0
7.1
3.5
-0.9
-3.5

62.5
74.0
118.6
129.2
141.9
139.4
144.6
149.6
150.8
152.2
148.7
171.4
164.9
151.6
149.1
148.7
145.8
135.1
134.0
136.1
135.7
138.8
143.4
148.8
154.0
160.0
165.9
170.3
209.1
207.7
213.5
222.6
232.3
241.9
250.7
258.2
262.7
259.8
238.9
152.9
33.8
22.1
7.7
-0.6

16.7
19.6
32.4
35.1
38.3
36.9
37.8
39.5
39.2
40.4
38.9
45.8
43.5
40.1
39.0
38.6
37.4
34.4
33.8
34.1
33.7
34.9
36.0
38.3
39.6
41.2
42.7
44.3
55.6
55.0
56.5
59.5
62.2
65.3
67.7
70.1
71.2
70.2
63.7
37.1
2.4
-1.2
-5.6
-8.2

62.5
73.9
118.4
128.9
141.5
138.8
143.8
148.8
149.8
151.4
147.8
170.5
163.9
150.7
148.2
147.7
144.7
134.0
132.8
134.9
134.4
137.6
142.0
147.7
152.8
158.7
164.6
169.0
207.8
206.4
212.1
221.2
230.9
240.6
249.3
256.8
261.3
258.3
237.3
151.1
32.4
20.7
6.3
-2.0

-68.5
-80.8
-126.5
-137.9
-151.5
-149.8
-155.8
-160.3
-162.1
-162.3
-159.3
-181.8
-175.8
-161.5
-159.5
-159.4
-156.9
-145.9
-145.1
-147.7
-147.6
-150.3
-155.2
-159.8
-165.3
-171.6
-177.8
-181.9
-221.2
-220.2
-226.3
-235.0
-245.1
-254.4
-263.5
-270.7
-275.5
-272.9
-252.2
-167.0
-47.3
-35.8
-21.5
-13.5

-22.6
-26.5
-40.5
-44.1
-48.3
-47.9
-49.8
-50.9
-51.6
-51.3
-50.5
-57.1
-55.4
-50.9
-50.3
-50.3
-49.6
-46.2
-46.1
-46.9
-46.9
-47.7
-49.2
-50.4
-52.1
-54.1
-56.0
-57.2
-69.1
-68.8
-70.7
-73.3
-76.3
-79.1
-81.9
-84.0
-85.4
-84.7
-78.5
-53.0
-17.3
-13.9
-9.7
-7.3

-22.7
-26.8
-41.1
-45.1
-49.7
-49.9
-52.3
-53.5
-54.6
-53.9
-53.5
-60.1
-58.7
-53.8
-53.5
-53.9
-53.4
-49.9
-50.0
-51.0
-51.3
-51.8
-53.6
-54.3
-56.1
-58.2
-60.3
-61.3
-73.5
-73.4
-75.4
-77.8
-81.1
-83.6
-86.6
-88.6
-90.2
-89.6
-83.7
-58.9
-22.0
-18.6
-14.4
-12.0

-68.5
-80.9
-126.6
-138.2
-151.9
-150.4
-156.6
-161.0
-163.1
-163.1
-160.2
-182.7
-176.8
-162.4
-160.4
-160.5
-158.0
-146.9
-146.3
-148.9
-148.9
-151.6
-156.5
-160.9
-166.5
-172.8
-179.1
-183.1
-222.5
-221.5
-227.7
-236.4
-246.5
-255.8
-264.9
-272.1
-276.9
-274.4
-253.7
-168.8
-48.7
-37.2
-22.9
-14.9

Maximum Axial Loads


Tension
Compression DCR
62.55
-68.53
73.99
-80.92
118.57
-126.64
129.18
-138.23
141.91
-151.92
139.43
-150.42
144.60
-156.56
152.81
-165.04
169.61
-182.76
186.10
-197.73
199.65
-211.95
250.16
-262.24
261.98
-274.67
262.79
-274.32
274.26
-286.30
288.81
-301.36
297.34
-310.40
287.10
-299.77
292.96
-306.11
303.62
-317.25
310.77
-324.89
319.85
-333.47
331.09
-345.17
338.14
-351.08
345.59
-358.92
354.05
-367.78
362.36
-376.51
364.26
-377.99
439.24
-453.60
425.98
-440.74
427.65
-442.81
432.51
-447.26
440.06
-455.21
443.76
-458.54
447.64
-462.80
446.78
-461.58
442.82
-457.99
424.91
-440.44
373.45
-389.33
208.80
-225.78
120.20
-136.10
82.11
-98.24
35.89
-52.25
-0.62
-15.38

0.29
0.34
0.41
0.45
0.49
0.49
0.51
0.54
0.59
0.64
0.69
0.70
0.73
0.73
0.76
0.80
0.82
0.80
0.81
0.84
0.86
0.89
0.92
0.93
0.95
0.98
1.00
1.00
0.98
0.95
0.96
0.97
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
0.99
0.95
0.84
0.49
0.36
0.26
0.14
0.04

Status
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
Say OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK

5:20 PM 2/11/2009

APPENDIX D: Program Cost Model for PEER


Tall Buildings Study, Concrete
Option, Los Angeles, California

PROGRAM
COST MODEL
for
PEER Tall Buildings Study
Concrete Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
March 8, 2010

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Concrete Structural Option
Los Angeles, California

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

CONTENTS
Page Nos.
Overall Summary

Areas and Control Quantities

Code Based Component Summary

Performance Based Component Summary

14

Performance Based Plus Component Summary

25

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Concrete Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
OVERALL SUMMARY
Gross Floor
Area

Construction Cost (Including Design)


Code Based

$ / SF

$x1,000

683,748 SF

325.77

222,744

Performance Based

683,748 SF

324.89

222,142

Performance Based Plus

683,748 SF

331.60

226,728

FF&E Cost
Furniture & Fittings, (resdential)
Equipment, including computer systems

476,716 SF
476,716 SF

20.00
7.00

9,534
3,337

Personal Property
Personal Contents
Cars in parking (Maximum count)

476,716 SF
520 EA

10.00
25,000.00

4,767
13,000

Please refer to the Inclusions and Exclusions sections of this report

Page 1

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Los Angeles, California
AREAS & CONTROL QUANTITIES
Areas
SF
Enclosed Areas
Basement Levels B1 - B4
Ground Level
Levels 2 - 42
Penthouse

SF

SF

207,024
11,314
463,874
1,536
683,748

SUBTOTAL, Enclosed Area


Covered area
SUBTOTAL, Covered Area @ Value

683,748

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR AREA

Control Quantities
Ratio to Gross
Area
Functional Units
(x1,000)
Number of stories (x1
000)
Gross Area
Enclosed Area
Covered Area
Footprint Area
Volume
Basement Volume
Gross Wall Area
Retaining Wall Area
Finished Wall Area
Windows or Glazing Area
Roof Area - Flat
Roof Area - Sloping
Roof Area - Total
Roof Glazing Area
Interior Partition Length
Finished Area
Elevators (x10,000)
Plumbing Fixtures (x1,000)
Electrical Load

19.28%

310
46
683,748
683,748
0
51,756
7,212,004
2,070,240
212,093
36,000
168,413
40,883
51,756
0
51,756
0
132,334
683,748
6
2,914
6,000

Units
EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
CF
CF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
LF
SF
EA
EA
KW

0.067
0 067
1.000
1.000
0.000
0.076
10.548
3.028
0.310
0.053
0.246
0.060
0.076
0.000
0.076
0.000
0.194
1.000
0.088
4.262
8.775

Page 2

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
CODE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 683,748 SF


$/SF
1. Foundations
2. Vertical Structure
3. Floor & Roof Structures
4. Exterior Cladding
5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

16.35
17.64
30.96
33.35
3.95

11,178
12,060
21,167
22,803
2,699

102.24

69,907

24.75
21.25

16,922
14,530

46.00

31,452

5.73
10.41

3,919
7,120

Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)

16.15

11,039

10 Plumbing Systems
11 Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
12 Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
13 Fire Protection Systems

19.04
13.86
21.33
5.37

13,015
9,475
14,586
3,669

59.59

40,745

223.98

153,144

2.19
1.76
0.73

1,500
1,206
500

4.69

3,206

228.67

156,351

27.44
15.37

18,762
10,507

271.47

185,620

54.29
0.00

37,124
0

325.77

222,744

Shell (1-5)
6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing
7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes
Interiors (6-7)
8. Function Equipment & Specialties
9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14 Site Preparation & Demolition
15 Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16 Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation
is excluded
\
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 3

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Basement Excavation
Excavation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete mat foundation
Excavation and disposal
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 6ksi
Elevator pits

99,173
36,400
14,829
99,173

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

1,487,595
1,820,000
519,015
1,983,460
Excluded

10,278
5,240
1,469,135
10,278
6

CY
SF
LBS
CY
EA

15.00
18.00
1.15
325.00
15,000.00

154,170
94,320
1,689,505
3,340,350
90,000
11,178,415

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Concrete columns
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi
Concrete retaining walls
Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi
Concrete core walls
Formwork to both sides
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi

99,875
972,895
2,048

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
350.00

2,496,875
1,216,119
716,800

36,400
240,240
1,978

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

546,000
300,300
445,050

157,864
1,171,663
5,808

SF
LBS
CY

18.00
1.25
350.00

2,841,552
1,464,579
2,032,800
12,060,075

Page 4

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)

Suspended floors
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab basement slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
8" thick post tensioned slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Post tension tendons
Studrails at columns (9 studrais with 9
studs per rail)
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Ground level slab/roof
12" thick reinforced concrete flat slab ground level
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
High roof
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi

21,103

155,268
768,577
4,792

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

1,552,680
960,721
1,078,200

463,874
1,122,575
459,236

SF
LBS
LBS

10.00
1.25
2.00

4,638,740
1,403,219
918,472

1,476
12,599

LOC
CY

4,000.00
225.00

5,904,000
2,834,775

51,756
455,453
2,109

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

517,560
569,316
474,525

12,850
70,675
437

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

128,500
88,344
98,325
21,167,377

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

168,413
36,000
161,050

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

1,347,304
144,000
241,575

Page 5

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

125,050
400

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

15,006,000
100,000

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

161,050

SF

3.50

563,675

40,883

SF

120.00

4,905,960

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

22,802,514

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

51,756
36,000
40,442

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

517,560
360,000
606,630

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

11,314

SF

6.00

67,884

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

40,442
11,314

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

1,011,050
135,768
2,698,892

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions

1,656
11,880
118,798

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

538,200
1,069,200
8,553,456

Page 6

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Doors, frames & hardware
Unit entrance doors
Standard interior doors
Closet doors at units - allow bi-fold

Quantity

310
2,680
1,240

Unit

EA
EA
EA

Rate

2,250.00
1,800.00
1,000.00

Total

697,500
4,824,000
1,240,000
16,922,356

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation - allow carpet
Residential
Livingrooms - allow wood
Bedrooms - allow carpet
Kitchen - allow stone tile
Bathrooms - allow porcelain tile
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

35.00
6.00

175,000
423,180

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

22.00
6.00
25.00
20.00
10.00
2.00

3,103,100
987,390
1,057,875
940,400
62,360
414,048

1
141,060

EA
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
423,180

282,100
329,130
84,630
94,040
9,354
70,776

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

2.00
1.00
10.00
12.00
12.00
1.00

564,200
329,130
846,300
1,128,480
112,248
70,776

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

125,000
846,360

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

6.00
6.00
6.00
6.00
10.00
2.00

846,300
987,390
253,890
282,120
62,360
414,048
14,530,135

Page 7

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

150
1
1

EA
EA
LS

450.00
110,000.00
25,000.00

67,500
110,000
25,000

1
70,530

LS
SF

25,000.00
0.75

25,000
52,898

141,050
164,565
47,020
42,315
6,236

SF
SF
SF
EA
SF

0.05
0.10
1.00
6.00
2.00

7,053
16,457
47,020
253,890
12,472

310
310
310
310
310
310
310
310

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,700.00
2,000.00
1,000.00
800.00
850.00
450.00
1,200.00
1,200.00

527,000
620,000
310,000
248,000
263,500
139,500
372,000
372,000

LS

450,000.00

450,000

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Specialties
Fire extinguisher cabinets
Trash chute
Parking Garage equipment
Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Kitchen
Special use areas
Residential appliances
Kitchen appliances
Refrigerator
Range
Range hood
Double oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washing machine
Dryer - electric
Window washing equipment

3,919,289

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

176 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

4,928,000
256,000
7,120,000

Page 8

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Lavatories
Tub/shower combo
Showers
Kitchen sinks
Washing machine connection
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

736
736
580
232
310
310
10

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,200.00
1,800.00
350.00
1,700.00
350.00
500.00

1,177,600
883,200
1,044,000
81,200
527,000
108,500
5,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

45,000
1,864,960

1,400
65,040
66,440

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

70,000
2,081,280
597,960

4,772

EA

65.00

310,180

310

EA

900.00

279,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

67,500
1,864,960

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

51,583
86

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,805,422
64,695

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
13,015,457

Page 9

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing: Core Area only
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems: Core Area only
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems: Core Area only
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to Fan Coil Boxes

3,700 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
15,000.00

92,500
30,000

500
500
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

250.00
450.00
10,000.00
5,000.00

125,000
225,000
20,000
10,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
4,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
25,000.00

102,000
120,000
25,000

1,200
1
164

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
57,236

Air handling equipment


Dedicated outside air supply air handler
Individual unit packaged units
Fan Coil Units
Core/Shell
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

220,000
310

CFM
EA

5.00
6,000.00

1,100,000
1,860,000

164
207
220,000

EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

204,415
258,750
55,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Dryer exhaust duct
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

288,790
9,300
3,000
100
80
100,000

LB
LF
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

2,310,320
55,800
18,000
4,000
96,000
250,000

Page 10

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Diffusers, registers and grilles
Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

818
2,633

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

163,532
394,950

736

EA

350.00

257,600

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

288,790

SF

3.00

866,370

Test and balance


Test and balance

288,790

SF

1.25

360,988

Terminal & Package Units


Exhaust fans at toilet rooms

9,475,461

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
metering
Transformer substation 13.8KV/110-208V,
double-ended including secondary
distribution
Distribution switchboards - 110-208V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards
General Purpose Lighting
Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

6,000

KVA

60.00

360,000

6,000
18,600
310
45,000

KVA
AMP
EA
LF

150.00
25.00
1,500.00
80.00

900,000
465,000
465,000
3,600,000

1,500
1,500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

12.00
2.00
4.00

981,192
789,900
828,096

Page 11

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Machine and Equipment Power
Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

16
2
2
6
683,748

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
512,811

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

3.00
3.00
2.00

245,298
1,184,850
414,048

1
310

LS
EA

75,000.00
800.00

75,000
248,000

Security Systems
Main Security System
Tenant Units

683,748
310

SF
EA

0.10
900.00

68,375
279,000

Fire Alarm Systems


Main Fire Alarm Systems

683,748

SF

3.00

2,051,244

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

683,748
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

170,937
25,000

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area
Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Units

14,585,751

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

683,748
683,748

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

2,734,992
683,748

LS

250,000.00

250,000
3,668,740

Page 12

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

48,244

SF

25.00

1,206,100
1,206,100

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 13

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
PERFORMANCE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 683,748 SF


$/SF
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Foundations
Vertical Structure
Floor & Roof Structures
Exterior Cladding
Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

18.23
19.54
26.81
33.35
3.69

12,462
13,362
18,333
22,803
2,526

101.62

69,486

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes

24.75
21.25

16,922
14,530

Interiors (6-7)

46.00

31,452

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation

5.73
10.41

3,919
7,120

Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)

16.15

11,039

19.04
13.86
21.33
5.37

13,015
9,475
14,586
3,669

59.59

40,745

223.36

152,723

2.19
1.76
0.73

1,500
1,206
500

4.69

3,206

228.05

155,929

27.37
15.32

18,711
10,478

270.74

185,118

54.15
0.00

37,024
0

324.89

222,142

Shell (1-5)

10.
11.
12.
13.

Plumbing Systems
Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
Fire Protection Systems

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14. Site Preparation & Demolition
15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16. Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation is excluded
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 14

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Basement Excavation
Excavation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation
Excavation and disposal
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 6ksi
Elevator pits

99,173
36,400
14,829
99,173

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

12,583
7,240
1,872,457
12,583
6

CY
SF
LBS
CY
EA

15.00
18.00
1.15
325.00
15,000.00

1,487,595
1,820,000
519,015
1,983,460
Excluded

188,745
130,320
2,153,326
4,089,475
90,000
12,461,936

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Concrete columns
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi
Concrete retaining walls
Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi
Concrete core walls
Formwork to both sides
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi

99,875
972,895
2,048

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
350.00

2,496,875
1,216,119
716,800

36,400
240,240
1,978

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

546,000
300,300
445,050

157,864
1,961,782
6,706

SF
LBS
CY

18.00
1.25
350.00

2,841,552
2,452,228
2,347,100
13,362,023

Page 15

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)

Suspended floors
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab basement slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
8" thick post tensioned slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Post tension tendons
Studrails at columns (9 studrais with 9
studs per rail)
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Ground level slab/roof
12" thick reinforced concrete flat slab ground level
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
High roof
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi

155,268
768,577
4,792

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

1,552,680
960,721
1,078,200

463,874
1,122,575
459,236

SF
LBS
LBS

10.00
1.25
2.00

4,638,740
1,403,219
918,472

1,476
3

LOC
CY

4,000.00
225.00

5,904,000
675

51,756
455,453
2,109

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

517,560
569,316
474,525

12,850
70,675
437

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

128,500
88,344
98,325
18,333,277

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

168,413
36,000
161,050

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

1,347,304
144,000
241,575

Page 16

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

125,050
400

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

15,006,000
100,000

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

161,050

SF

3.50

563,675

40,883

SF

120.00

4,905,960

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

22,802,514

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

49,940
42,912
31,750

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

499,400
429,120
476,250

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

18,190

SF

6.00

109,140

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

31,750
18,190

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

793,750
218,280
2,525,940

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions

1,656
11,880
118,798

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

538,200
1,069,200
8,553,456

Page 17

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Doors, frames & hardware
Unit entrance doors
Standard interior doors
Closet doors at units - allow bi-fold

Quantity

310
2,680
1,240

Unit

EA
EA
EA

Rate

2,250.00
1,800.00
1,000.00

Total

697,500
4,824,000
1,240,000
16,922,356

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation - allow carpet
Residential
Livingrooms - allow wood
Bedrooms - allow carpet
Kitchen - allow stone tile
Bathrooms - allow ceramic tile
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

35.00
6.00

175,000
423,180

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

22.00
6.00
25.00
20.00
10.00
2.00

3,103,100
987,390
1,057,875
940,400
62,360
414,048

1
141,060

EA
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
423,180

282,100
329,130
84,630
94,040
9,354
70,776

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

2.00
1.00
10.00
12.00
12.00
1.00

564,200
329,130
846,300
1,128,480
112,248
70,776

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

125,000
846,360

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

6.00
6.00
6.00
6.00
10.00
2.00

846,300
987,390
253,890
282,120
62,360
414,048
14,530,135

Page 18

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

150
1
1

EA
EA
LS

450.00
110,000.00
25,000.00

67,500
110,000
25,000

1
70,530

LS
SF

25,000.00
0.75

25,000
52,898

141,050
164,565
47,020
42,315
6,236

SF
SF
SF
EA
SF

0.05
0.10
1.00
6.00
2.00

7,053
16,457
47,020
253,890
12,472

310
310
310
310
310
310
310
310

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,700.00
2,000.00
1,000.00
800.00
850.00
450.00
1,200.00
1,200.00

527,000
620,000
310,000
248,000
263,500
139,500
372,000
372,000

LS

450,000.00

450,000

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Specialties
Fire extinguisher cabinets
Trash chute
Parking Garage equipment
Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Kitchen
Special use areas
Residential appliances
Kitchen appliances
Refrigerator
Range
Range hood
Double oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washing machine
Dryer - electric
Window washing equipment

3,919,289

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

176 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

4,928,000
256,000
7,120,000

Page 19

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Lavatories
Tub/shower combo
Showers
Kitchen sinks
Washing machine connection
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

736
736
580
232
310
310
10

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,200.00
1,800.00
350.00
1,700.00
350.00
500.00

1,177,600
883,200
1,044,000
81,200
527,000
108,500
5,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

45,000
1,864,960

1,400
65,040
66,440

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

70,000
2,081,280
597,960

4,772

EA

65.00

310,180

310

EA

900.00

279,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

67,500
1,864,960

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

51,583
86

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,805,422
64,695

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
13,015,457

Page 20

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing: Core Area only
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems: Core Area only
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems: Core Area only
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to Fan Coil Boxes

3,700 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
15,000.00

92,500
30,000

500
500
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

250.00
450.00
10,000.00
5,000.00

125,000
225,000
20,000
10,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
4,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
25,000.00

102,000
120,000
25,000

1,200
1
164

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
57,236

Air handling equipment


Dedicated outside air supply air handler
Individual unit packaged units
Fan Coil Units
Core/Shell
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

220,000
310

CFM
EA

5.00
6,000.00

1,100,000
1,860,000

164
207
220,000

EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

204,415
258,750
55,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Dryer exhaust duct
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

288,790
9,300
3,000
100
80
100,000

LB
LF
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

2,310,320
55,800
18,000
4,000
96,000
250,000

Page 21

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Diffusers, registers and grilles
Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

818
2,633

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

163,532
394,950

736

EA

350.00

257,600

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

288,790

SF

3.00

866,370

Test and balance


Test and balance

288,790

SF

1.25

360,988

Terminal & Package Units


Exhaust fans at toilet rooms

9,475,461

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
metering
Transformer substation 13.8KV/110-208V,
double-ended including secondary
distribution
Distribution switchboards - 110-208V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards
General Purpose Lighting
Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

6,000

KVA

60.00

360,000

6,000
18,600
310
45,000

KVA
AMP
EA
LF

150.00
25.00
1,500.00
80.00

900,000
465,000
465,000
3,600,000

1,500
1,500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

12.00
2.00
4.00

981,192
789,900
828,096

Page 22

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Machine and Equipment Power
Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

16
2
2
6
683,748

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
512,811

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

3.00
3.00
2.00

245,298
1,184,850
414,048

1
310

LS
EA

75,000.00
800.00

75,000
248,000

Security Systems
Main Security System
Tenant Units

683,748
310

SF
EA

0.10
900.00

68,375
279,000

Fire Alarm Systems


Main Fire Alarm Systems

683,748

SF

3.00

2,051,244

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

683,748
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

170,937
25,000

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area
Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Units

14,585,751

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

683,748
683,748

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

2,734,992
683,748

LS

250,000.00

250,000
3,668,740

Page 23

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

48,244

SF

25.00

1,206,100
1,206,100

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

1 LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 24

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
PERFORMANCE BASED PLUS COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 683,748 SF


$/SF
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Foundations
Vertical Structure
Floor & Roof Structures
Exterior Cladding
Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

Shell (1-5)
6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing
7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes
Interiors (6-7)
8. Function Equipment & Specialties
9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation
Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)
10. Plumbing Systems
11. Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
12. Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
13. Fire Protection Systems
Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)
Total Building Construction (1-13)
14. Site Preparation & Demolition
15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16. Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation is excluded
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

$x1,000

18.60
19.73
30.96
33.35
3.69

12,719
13,489
21,167
22,803
2,526

106.33

72,704

24.75
21.25

16,922
14,530

46.00

31,452

5.73
10.41

3,919
7,120

16.15

11,039

19.04
13.86
21.33
5.37

13,015
9,475
14,586
3,669

59.59

40,745

228.07

155,941

2.19
1.76
0.73

1,500
1,206
500

4.69

3,206

232.76

159,147

27.93
15.64

19,098
10,695

276.33

188,940

55.27
0.00

37,788
0

331.60

226,728

Page 25

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Basement Excavation
Excavation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation
Excavation and disposal
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 6ksi
Elevator pits

99,173
36,400
14,829
99,173

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

1,487,595
1,820,000
519,015
1,983,460

13,044
7,640
1,953,123
13,044
6

CY
SF
LBS
CY
EA

15.00
18.00
1.15
325.00
15,000.00

195,660
137,520
2,246,091
4,239,300
90,000
12,718,641

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Concrete columns
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi
Concrete retaining walls
Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi
Concrete core walls
Formwork to both sides
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi

99,875
972,895
2,048

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
350.00

2,496,875
1,216,119
716,800

36,400
240,240
1,978

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

546,000
300,300
445,050

157,864
1,961,782
7,069

SF
LBS
CY

18.00
1.25
350.00

2,841,552
2,452,228
2,474,150
13,489,073

Page 26

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)
Suspended floors
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab basement slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
8" thick post tensioned slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Post tension tendons
Studrails at columns (9 studrais with 9
studs per rail)
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Ground level slab/roof
12" thick reinforced concrete flat slab ground level
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
High roof
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi

155,268
768,577
4,792

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

1,552,680
960,721
1,078,200

463,874
1,122,575
459,236

SF
LBS
LBS

10.00
1.25
2.00

4,638,740
1,403,219
918,472

1,476
12,599

LOC
CY

4,000.00
225.00

5,904,000
2,834,775

51,756
455,453
2,109

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

517,560
569,316
474,525

12,850
70,675
437

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

128,500
88,344
98,325
21,167,377

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

168,413
36,000
161,050

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

1,347,304
144,000
241,575

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

125,050
400

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

15,006,000
100,000

Page 27

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Interior finish to exterior walls
Gypsum board, taped and sanded

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

161,050

SF

3.50

563,675

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

40,883

SF

120.00

4,905,960

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000
22,802,514

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

49,940
42,912
31,750

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

499,400
429,120
476,250

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

18,190

SF

6.00

109,140

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

31,750
18,190

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

793,750
218,280
2,525,940

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions
Doors, frames & hardware
Unit entrance doors
Standard interior doors
Closet doors at units - allow bi-fold

1,656
11,880
118,798

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

538,200
1,069,200
8,553,456

310
2,680
1,240

EA
EA
EA

2,250.00
1,800.00
1,000.00

697,500
4,824,000
1,240,000
16,922,356

Page 28

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation - allow carpet
Residential
Livingrooms - allow wood
Bedrooms - allow carpet
Kitchen - allow stone tile
Bathrooms - allow ceramic tile
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

35.00
6.00

175,000
423,180

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

22.00
6.00
25.00
20.00
10.00
2.00

3,103,100
987,390
1,057,875
940,400
62,360
414,048

1
141,060

EA
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
423,180

282,100
329,130
84,630
94,040
9,354
70,776

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

2.00
1.00
10.00
12.00
12.00
1.00

564,200
329,130
846,300
1,128,480
112,248
70,776

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

125,000
846,360

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

6.00
6.00
6.00
6.00
10.00
2.00

846,300
987,390
253,890
282,120
62,360
414,048
14,530,135

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Specialties
Fire extinguisher cabinets
Trash chute
Parking Garage equipment

150
1
1

EA
EA
LS

450.00
110,000.00
25,000.00

67,500
110,000
25,000

Page 29

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Kitchen
Special use areas
Residential appliances
Kitchen appliances
Refrigerator
Range
Range hood
Double oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washing machine
Dryer - electric
Window washing equipment

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1
70,530

LS
SF

25,000.00
0.75

25,000
52,898

141,050
164,565
47,020
42,315
6,236

SF
SF
SF
EA
SF

0.05
0.10
1.00
6.00
2.00

7,053
16,457
47,020
253,890
12,472

310
310
310
310
310
310
310
310

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,700.00
2,000.00
1,000.00
800.00
850.00
450.00
1,200.00
1,200.00

527,000
620,000
310,000
248,000
263,500
139,500
372,000
372,000

LS

450,000.00

450,000
3,919,289

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

176 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

4,928,000
256,000
7,120,000

Page 30

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Lavatories
Tub/shower combo
Showers
Kitchen sinks
Washing machine connection
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

736
736
580
232
310
310
10

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,200.00
1,800.00
350.00
1,700.00
350.00
500.00

1,177,600
883,200
1,044,000
81,200
527,000
108,500
5,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

45,000
1,864,960

1,400
65,040
66,440

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

70,000
2,081,280
597,960

4,772

EA

65.00

310,180

310

EA

900.00

279,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

67,500
1,864,960

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

51,583
86

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,805,422
64,695

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
13,015,457

Page 31

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing: Core Area only
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems: Core Area only
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems: Core Area only
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to Fan Coil Boxes

3,700 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
15,000.00

92,500
30,000

500
500
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

250.00
450.00
10,000.00
5,000.00

125,000
225,000
20,000
10,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
4,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
25,000.00

102,000
120,000
25,000

1,200
1
164

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
57,236

Air handling equipment


Dedicated outside air supply air handler
Individual unit packaged units
Fan Coil Units
Core/Shell
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

220,000
310

CFM
EA

5.00
6,000.00

1,100,000
1,860,000

164
207
220,000

EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

204,415
258,750
55,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Dryer exhaust duct
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

288,790
9,300
3,000
100
80
100,000

LB
LF
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

2,310,320
55,800
18,000
4,000
96,000
250,000

Page 32

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Diffusers, registers and grilles
Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

818
2,633

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

163,532
394,950

736

EA

350.00

257,600

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

288,790

SF

3.00

866,370

Test and balance


Test and balance

288,790

SF

1.25

360,988

Terminal & Package Units


Exhaust fans at toilet rooms

9,475,461

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
metering
Transformer substation 13.8KV/110-208V,
double-ended including secondary
distribution
Distribution switchboards - 110-208V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards
General Purpose Lighting
Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

6,000

KVA

60.00

360,000

6,000
18,600
310
45,000

KVA
AMP
EA
LF

150.00
25.00
1,500.00
80.00

900,000
465,000
465,000
3,600,000

1,500
1,500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

12.00
2.00
4.00

981,192
789,900
828,096

Page 33

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Machine and Equipment Power
Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

16
2
2
6
683,748

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
512,811

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

3.00
3.00
2.00

245,298
1,184,850
414,048

1
310

LS
EA

75,000.00
800.00

75,000
248,000

Security Systems
Main Security System
Tenant Units

683,748
310

SF
EA

0.10
900.00

68,375
279,000

Fire Alarm Systems


Main Fire Alarm Systems

683,748

SF

3.00

2,051,244

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

683,748
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

170,937
25,000

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area
Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Units

14,585,751

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

683,748
683,748

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

2,734,992
683,748

LS

250,000.00

250,000
3,668,740

Page 34

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

48,244

SF

25.00

1,206,100
1,206,100

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

1 LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 35

PROGRAM
COST MODEL
for
PEER Tall Buildings Study
Concrete Dual System Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
March 8, 2010

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Concrete Dual System Structural Option
Los Angeles, California

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

CONTENTS
Page Nos.
Overall Summary

Areas and Control Quantities

Code Based Component Summary

Performance Based Component Summary

15

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Concrete Dual System Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
OVERALL SUMMARY
Gross Floor
Area

Construction Cost (Including Design)


Code Based

$ / SF

$x1,000

683,748 SF

347.36

237,508

Performance Based

683,748 SF

411.33

281,245

Performance Based Plus

683,748 SF

411.33

281,245

FF&E Cost
Furniture & Fittings, (resdential)
Equipment, including computer systems

476,716 SF
476,716 SF

20.00
7.00

9,534
3,337

Personal Property
Personal Contents
Cars in parking (Maximum count)

476,716 SF
520 EA

10.00
25,000.00

4,767
13,000

Please refer to the Inclusions and Exclusions sections of this report

Page 1

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Los Angeles, California
AREAS & CONTROL QUANTITIES
Areas
SF
Enclosed Areas
Basement Levels B1 - B4
Ground Level
Levels 2 - 42
Penthouse

SF

SF

207,024
11,314
463,874
1,536
683,748

SUBTOTAL, Enclosed Area


Covered area
SUBTOTAL, Covered Area @ Value

683,748

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR AREA

Control Quantities

Functional Units
(x1,000)
Number of stories (x1
000)
Gross Area
Enclosed Area
Covered Area
Footprint Area
Volume
Basement Volume
Gross Wall Area
Retaining Wall Area
Finished Wall Area
Windows or Glazing Area
Roof Area - Flat
Roof Area - Sloping
Roof Area - Total
Roof Glazing Area
Interior Partition Length
Finished Area
Elevators (x10,000)
Plumbing Fixtures (x1,000)
Electrical Load

20.93%

310
46
683,748
683,748
0
51,756
7,212,004
0
212,093
38,220
135,600
44,400
51,756
0
51,756
0
132,334
683,748
6
2,914
6,000

Units
EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
CF
CF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
LF
SF
EA
EA
KW

Ratio to Gross
Area
0.453
0.067
0 067
1.000
1.000
0.000
0.076
10.548
0.000
0.310
0.056
0.198
0.065
0.076
0.000
0.076
0.000
0.194
1.000
0.088
4.262
8.775

Page 2

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

CODE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY


Gross Area: 683,748 SF
$/SF
1. Foundations
2. Vertical Structure
3. Floor & Roof Structures
4. Exterior Cladding
5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

16.35
21.86
39.07
36.15
3.98

11,178
14,949
26,717
24,720
2,721

117.42

80,286

24.75
21.23

16,922
14,515

45.98

31,437

5.73
10.41

3,919
7,120

Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)

16.15

11,039

10 Plumbing Systems
11 Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
12 Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
13 Fire Protection Systems

19.04
13.86
21.33
5.37

13,015
9,475
14,586
3,669

59.59

40,745

239.13

163,508

2.19
1.76
0.73

1,500
1,206
500

4.69

3,206

243.82

166,714

29.26
16.38

20,006
11,203

289.47

197,923

57.89
0.00

39,585
0

347.36

237,508

Shell (1-5)
6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing
7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes
Interiors (6-7)
8. Function Equipment & Specialties
9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14 Site Preparation & Demolition
15 Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16 Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation
is excluded
\
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 3

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Basement Excavation
Excavation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation
Excavation and disposal
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 6ksi
Elevator pits

99,173
36,400
14,829
99,173

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

1,487,595
1,820,000
519,015
1,983,460
Excluded

10,278
5,240
1,469,135
10,278
6

CY
SF
LBS
CY
EA

15.00
18.00
1.15
325.00
15,000.00

154,170
94,320
1,689,505
3,340,350
90,000
11,178,415

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Concrete columns - moment frames
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
f'c= 10ksi
f'c= 8ksi
f'c= 6ksi
f'c= 5ksi
Concrete columns - standard
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi
Concrete retaining walls
Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

100,415
1,311,700

SF
LBS

25.00
1.25

2,510,375
1,639,625

288
670
350
1,918

CY
CY
CY
CY

450.00
350.00
325.00
225.00

129,600
234,500
113,750
431,550

36,277
343,701
658

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
350.00

906,925
429,626
230,300

38,220
252,252
2,076

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
225.00

955,500
315,315
467,100

Page 4

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Concrete core walls
Formwork to both sides
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
f'c= 6ksi
f'c= 5ksi

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

170,841
474,699

SF
LBS

25.00
1.25

4,271,025
593,374

3,496
2,598

CY
CY

325.00
225.00

1,136,200
584,550
14,949,315

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)

Suspended floors
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab basement slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
8" thick post tensioned slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Post tension tendons
Studrails at columns (9 studrais with 9
studs per rail)
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi
Ground level slab/roof
12" thick reinforced concrete flat slab ground level
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

155,268
768,577
5,271

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

1,552,680
960,721
1,185,975

463,874
1,122,575
459,236

SF
LBS
LBS

10.00
1.25
2.00

4,638,740
1,403,219
918,472

1,476
12,599

LOC
CY

4,000.00
225.00

5,904,000
2,834,775

137,632
1,639,660
4,948

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

2,064,480
2,049,575
1,113,300

51,756
455,453
2,109

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

517,560
569,316
474,525

3,128
35,754
112

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

31,280
44,693
25,200

Page 5

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
High roof
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

12,850
70,675
437

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

128,500
88,344
98,325

3,128
33,109
112

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

46,920
41,386
25,200
26,717,186

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

182,947
38,220
173,820

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

1,463,576
152,880
260,730

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

135,600
560

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

16,272,000
140,000

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

173,820

SF

3.50

608,370

44,400

SF

120.00

5,328,000

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

24,719,556

Page 6

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

51,756
38,220
40,442

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

517,560
382,200
606,630

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

11,314

SF

6.00

67,884

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

40,442
11,314

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

1,011,050
135,768
2,721,092

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions
Doors, frames & hardware
Unit entrance doors
Standard interior doors
Closet doors at units - allow bi-fold

1,656
11,880
118 798
118,798

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72 00
72.00

538,200
1,069,200
8 553 456
8,553,456

310
2,680
1,240

EA
EA
EA

2,250.00
1,800.00
1,000.00

697,500
4,824,000
1,240,000
16,922,356

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation - allow carpet
Residential
Livingrooms - allow wood
Bedrooms - allow carpet
Kitchen - allow stone tile
Bathrooms - allow ceramic tile
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

35.00
6.00

175,000
423,180

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

22.00
6.00
25.00
20.00
10.00
2.00

3,103,100
987,390
1,057,875
940,400
62,360
414,048

Page 7

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1
141,060

EA
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
423,180

282,100
329,130
84,630
94,040
9,354
55,608

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

2.00
1.00
10.00
12.00
12.00
1.00

564,200
329,130
846,300
1,128,480
112,248
55,608

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

125,000
846,360

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

6.00
6.00
6.00
6.00
10.00
2.00

846,300
987,390
253,890
282,120
62,360
414,048
14 514 967
14,514,967

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Specialties
Fire extinguisher cabinets
Trash chute
Parking Garage equipment
Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchens
Bathrooms
Special use areas

150
1
1

EA
EA
LS

450.00
110,000.00
25,000.00

67,500
110,000
25,000

1
70,530

LS
SF

25,000.00
0.75

25,000
52,898

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236

SF
SF
EA
SF
SF

0.05
0.10
6.00
1.00
2.00

7,053
16,457
253,890
47,020
12,472

Page 8

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Residential appliances
Kitchen appliances
Refrigerator
Range
Range hood
Double oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washing machine
Dryer - electric
Window washing equipment

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

310
310
310
310
310
310
310
310

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,700.00
2,000.00
1,000.00
800.00
850.00
450.00
1,200.00
1,200.00

527,000
620,000
310,000
248,000
263,500
139,500
372,000
372,000

LS

450,000.00

450,000
3,919,289

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators
Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

176 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
28
000 00
32,000.00

4,928,000
4
928 000
256,000
7,120,000

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Lavatories
Tub/shower combo
Showers
Kitchen sinks
Washing machine connection
Hose bibbs

736
736
580
232
310
310
10

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,200.00
1,800.00
350.00
1,700.00
350.00
500.00

1,177,600
883,200
1,044,000
81,200
527,000
108,500
5,000

Page 9

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

900
58,280

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

45,000
1,864,960

1,400
65,040
66,440

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

70,000
2,081,280
597,960

4,772

EA

65.00

310,180

310

EA

900.00

279,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

67,500
1,864,960

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

51,583
86

LF
EA

35.00
750.00
750
00

1,805,422
64 695
64,695

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
13,015,457

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing: Core Area only
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems: Core Area only
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.

3,700 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
15,000.00

92,500
30,000

500
500
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

250.00
450.00
10,000.00
5,000.00

125,000
225,000
20,000
10,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

Page 10

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Distribution systems: Core Area only
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to Fan Coil Boxes
Air handling equipment
Dedicated outside air supply air handler
Individual unit packaged units
Fan Coil Units
Core/Shell
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted
Air distribution, return and exhaust
Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Dryer exhaust duct
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner
Diffusers, registers and grilles
Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area
Terminal & Package Units
Exhaust fans at toilet rooms
Controls and instrumentation
DDC Control system

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
4,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
25,000.00

102,000
120,000
25,000

1,200
1
164

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
57,236

220,000
310

CFM
EA

5.00
6,000.00

1,100,000
1,860,000

164
207
220 000
220,000

EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
0 25
0.25

204,415
258,750
55 000
55,000

288,790
9,300
3,000
100
80
100,000

LB
LF
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

2,310,320
55,800
18,000
4,000
96,000
250,000

818
2,633

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

163,532
394,950

736

EA

350.00

257,600

288,790

SF

3.00

866,370

Page 11

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Test and balance
Test and balance

Quantity

288,790

Unit

SF

Rate

1.25

Total

360,988
9,475,461

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
metering
Transformer substation 13.8KV/110-208V,
double-ended including secondary
distribution
Distribution switchboards - 110-208V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards

6,000

KVA

60.00

360,000

6,000
18,600
310
45,000

KVA
AMP
EA
LF

150.00
25.00
1,500.00
80.00

900,000
465,000
465,000
3,600,000

1,500
1,500
1 500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25 00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37 500
37,500

General Purpose Lighting


Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

12.00
2.00
4.00

981,192
789,900
828,096

Machine and Equipment Power


Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

16
2
2
6
683,748

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
512,811

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

3.00
3.00
2.00

245,298
1,184,850
414,048

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area

Page 12

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Units

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1
310

LS
EA

75,000.00
800.00

75,000
248,000

Security Systems
Main Security System
Tenant Units

683,748
310

SF
EA

0.10
900.00

68,375
279,000

Fire Alarm Systems


Main Fire Alarm Systems

683,748

SF

3.00

2,051,244

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

683,748
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

170,937
25,000
14,585,751

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

683,748
683
748
683,748

SF
SF

4.00
4
00
1.00

2,734,992
2
734 992
683,748

LS

250,000.00

250,000
3,668,740

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

48,244

SF

25.00

1,206,100
1,206,100

Page 13

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

LS

500,000.00

Total

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

500,000
500,000

Page 14

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PERFORMANCE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY


Gross Area: 683,748 SF
$/SF
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Foundations
Vertical Structure
Floor & Roof Structures
Exterior Cladding
Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

16.35
22.08
83.76
36.15
3.98

11,178
15,097
57,271
24,720
2,721

162.32

110,987

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes

24.75
21.23

16,922
14,515

Interiors (6-7)

45.98

31,437

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation

5.73
10.41

3,919
7,120

Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)

16.15

11,039

19.04
13.86
21.33
5.37

13,015
9,475
14,586
3,669

59.59

40,745

284.04

194,209

2.19
1.76
0.73

1,500
1,206
500

4.69

3,206

288.73

197,415

34.65
19.40

23,690
13,266

342.77

234,371

68.55
0.00

46,874
0

411.33

281,245

Shell (1-5)

10.
11.
12.
13.

Plumbing Systems
Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
Fire Protection Systems

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14. Site Preparation & Demolition
15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16. Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation is excluded
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 15

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Basement Excavation
Excavation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation
Excavation and disposal
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 6ksi
Elevator pits

99,173
36,400
14,829
99,173

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

10,278
5,240
1,469,135
10,278
6

CY
SF
LBS
CY
EA

15.00
18.00
1.15
325.00
15,000.00

1,487,595
1,820,000
519,015
1,983,460
Excluded

154,170
94,320
1,689,505
3,340,350
90,000
11,178,415

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Concrete columns - moment frames
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
f'c= 10ksi
f'c= 8ksi
f'c= 6ksi
f'c= 5ksi
Concrete columns - standard
Forwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 8ksi
Concrete retaining walls
Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

100,247
1,315,178

SF
LBS

25.00
1.25

2,506,175
1,643,973

371
890
318
1,535

CY
CY
CY
CY

450.00
350.00
325.00
225.00

166,950
311,500
103,350
345,375

36,277
343,701
658

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
350.00

906,925
429,626
230,300

38,220
252,252
2,076

SF
LBS
CY

25.00
1.25
225.00

955,500
315,315
467,100

Page 16

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Concrete core walls
Formwork to both sides
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
f'c= 8ksi
f'c= 6ksi
f'c= 5ksi

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

170,841
447,823

SF
LBS

25.00
1.25

4,271,025
559,779

3,496
1,125
1,310

CY
CY
CY

350.00
325.00
225.00

1,223,600
365,625
294,750
15,096,868

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)

Suspended floors
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab basement slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
8" thick post tensioned slabs
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Post tension tendons
Studrails at columns (9 studrais with 9
studs per rail)
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi
Ground level slab/roof
12" thick reinforced concrete flat slab ground level
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

155,268
768,577
142,329

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

1,552,680
960,721
32,024,025

463,874
1,122,575
459,236

SF
LBS
LBS

10.00
1.25
2.00

4,638,740
1,403,219
918,472

1,476
12,599

LOC
CY

4,000.00
225.00

5,904,000
2,834,775

137,632
1,420,802
4,948

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

2,064,480
1,776,003
1,113,300

51,756
455,453
2,109

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

517,560
569,316
474,525

3,128
30,635
112

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

31,280
38,294
25,200

Page 17

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

High roof
10" thick reinforced concrete flat slab
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5.5ksi
Special moment resisting frame reinforced
concrete beam
Formwork
Reinforcing steel
Concrete, f'c= 5ksi

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

12,850
70,675
437

SF
LBS
CY

10.00
1.25
225.00

128,500
88,344
98,325

3,128
29,994
112

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.25
225.00

46,920
37,493
25,200
57,271,371

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

182,947
38,220
173,820

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

1,463,576
152,880
260,730

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

135,600
560

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

16,272,000
140,000

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

173,820

SF

3.50

608,370

44,400

SF

120.00

5,328,000

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

24,719,556

Page 18

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

51,756
38,220
40,442

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

517,560
382,200
606,630

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

11,314

SF

6.00

67,884

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

40,442
11,314

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

1,011,050
135,768
2,721,092

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions
Doors, frames & hardware
Unit entrance doors
Standard interior doors
Closet doors at units - allow bi-fold

1,656
11,880
118,798

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

538,200
1,069,200
8,553,456

310
2,680
1,240

EA
EA
EA

2,250.00
1,800.00
1,000.00

697,500
4,824,000
1,240,000
16,922,356

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation - allow carpet
Residential
Livingrooms - allow wood
Bedrooms - allow carpet
Kitchen - allow stone tile
Bathrooms - allow ceramic tile
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

35.00
6.00

175,000
423,180

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

22.00
6.00
25.00
20.00
10.00
2.00

3,103,100
987,390
1,057,875
940,400
62,360
414,048

Page 19

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchen
Bathrooms
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1
141,060

EA
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
423,180

282,100
329,130
84,630
94,040
9,354
55,608

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

2.00
1.00
10.00
12.00
12.00
1.00

564,200
329,130
846,300
1,128,480
112,248
55,608

5,000
70,530

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

125,000
846,360

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236
207,024

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

6.00
6.00
6.00
6.00
10.00
2.00

846,300
987,390
253,890
282,120
62,360
414,048
14,514,967

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Specialties
Fire extinguisher cabinets
Trash chute
Parking Garage equipment
Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Residential
Livingrooms
Bedrooms
Kitchens
Bathrooms
Special use areas

150
1
1

EA
EA
LS

450.00
110,000.00
25,000.00

67,500
110,000
25,000

1
70,530

LS
SF

25,000.00
0.75

25,000
52,898

141,050
164,565
42,315
47,020
6,236

SF
SF
EA
SF
SF

0.05
0.10
6.00
1.00
2.00

7,053
16,457
253,890
47,020
12,472

Page 20

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Residential appliances
Kitchen appliances
Refrigerator
Range
Range hood
Double oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washing machine
Dryer - electric
Window washing equipment

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

310
310
310
310
310
310
310
310

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,700.00
2,000.00
1,000.00
800.00
850.00
450.00
1,200.00
1,200.00

527,000
620,000
310,000
248,000
263,500
139,500
372,000
372,000

LS

450,000.00

450,000
3,919,289

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

176 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

4,928,000
256,000
7,120,000

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Lavatories
Tub/shower combo
Showers
Kitchen sinks
Washing machine connection
Hose bibbs

736
736
580
232
310
310
10

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,200.00
1,800.00
350.00
1,700.00
350.00
500.00

1,177,600
883,200
1,044,000
81,200
527,000
108,500
5,000

Page 21

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

900
58,280

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

45,000
1,864,960

1,400
65,040
66,440

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

70,000
2,081,280
597,960

4,772

EA

65.00

310,180

310

EA

900.00

279,000

900
58,280

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

67,500
1,864,960

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

51,583
86

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,805,422
64,695

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
13,015,457

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing: Core Area only
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems: Core Area only
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.

3,700 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
15,000.00

92,500
30,000

500
500
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

250.00
450.00
10,000.00
5,000.00

125,000
225,000
20,000
10,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

Page 22

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Distribution systems: Core Area only
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to Fan Coil Boxes

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
4,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
25,000.00

102,000
120,000
25,000

1,200
1
164

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
57,236

Air handling equipment


Dedicated outside air supply air handler
Individual unit packaged units
Fan Coil Units
Core/Shell
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

220,000
310

CFM
EA

5.00
6,000.00

1,100,000
1,860,000

164
207
220,000

EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

204,415
258,750
55,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Dryer exhaust duct
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

288,790
9,300
3,000
100
80
100,000

LB
LF
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

2,310,320
55,800
18,000
4,000
96,000
250,000

818
2,633

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

163,532
394,950

736

EA

350.00

257,600

288,790

SF

3.00

866,370

Diffusers, registers and grilles


Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area
Terminal & Package Units
Exhaust fans at toilet rooms
Controls and instrumentation
DDC Control system

Page 23

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Test and balance
Test and balance

Quantity

288,790

Unit

SF

Rate

1.25

Total

360,988
9,475,461

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
metering
Transformer substation 13.8KV/110-208V,
double-ended including secondary
distribution
Distribution switchboards - 110-208V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards

6,000

KVA

60.00

360,000

6,000
18,600
310
45,000

KVA
AMP
EA
LF

150.00
25.00
1,500.00
80.00

900,000
465,000
465,000
3,600,000

1,500
1,500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

General Purpose Lighting


Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

12.00
2.00
4.00

981,192
789,900
828,096

Machine and Equipment Power


Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

16
2
2
6
683,748

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
512,811

46

EA

2,500.00

115,000

81,766
394,950
207,024

SF
SF
SF

3.00
3.00
2.00

245,298
1,184,850
414,048

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area

Page 24

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Units

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1
310

LS
EA

75,000.00
800.00

75,000
248,000

Security Systems
Main Security System
Tenant Units

683,748
310

SF
EA

0.10
900.00

68,375
279,000

Fire Alarm Systems


Main Fire Alarm Systems

683,748

SF

3.00

2,051,244

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

683,748
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

170,937
25,000
14,585,751

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

683,748
683,748

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

2,734,992
683,748

LS

250,000.00

250,000
3,668,740

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

48,244

SF

25.00

1,206,100
1,206,100

Page 25

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Concrete Dual System Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

LS

500,000.00

Total

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

500,000
500,000

Page 26

PROGRAM
COST MODEL
for
PEER Tall Buildings Study
Steel Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
March 8, 2010

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Steel Structural Option
Los Angeles, California

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

CONTENTS
Page Nos.
Overall Summary

Areas and Control Quantities

Code Based Component Summary

Performance Based Component Summary

13

Performance Based Plus Component Summary

23

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study


Steel Structural Option
Los Angeles, California
OVERALL SUMMARY
Gross Floor
Area

Construction Cost (Including Design)


Code Based

$ / SF

$x1,000

959,110 SF

369.76

354,636

Performance Based

959,110 SF

354.02

339,546

Performance Based Plus

959,110 SF

359.97

345,251

FF&E Cost
Furniture & Fittings, including system furniture
Equipment, including computer systems

763,350 SF
763,350 SF

50.00
35.00

38,168
26,717

Personal Property
Personal Contents
Cars in parking (Maximum count)

763,350 SF
490 EA

2.00
25,000.00

1,527
12,250

Please refer to the Inclusions and Exclusions sections of this report

Page 1

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Los Angeles, California
AREAS & CONTROL QUANTITIES
Areas
SF
Enclosed Areas
Basement Levels B1 - B4
Ground Level
Levels 1 - 10
Levels 11 - 39

SF

SF

199,760
49,940
181,900
527,510
959,110

SUBTOTAL, Enclosed Area


Covered area
SUBTOTAL, Covered Area @ Value

959,110

TOTAL GROSS FLOOR AREA

Control Quantities

Number of stories (x1,000)


Gross Area
Enclosed Area
Covered Area
Footprint Area
Volume
Basement Volume
Gross Wall Area
Retaining Wall Area
Finished Wall Area
Windows or Glazing Area
Roof Area - Flat
Roof Area - Sloping
Roof Area - Total
Roof Glazing Area
Interior Partition Length
Finished Area
Elevators (x10,000)
Plumbing Fixtures (x1,000)
Electrical Load

44
959,110
959,110
0
49,940
12,301,575
2,397,120
344,565
42,912
301,653
21.89%
75,414
49,940
0
49,940
0
58,608
959,110
6
924
12,000

EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
CF
CF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
LF
SF
EA
EA
KW

Ratio to Gross
Area
0.046
1.000
1.000
0.000
0.052
12.826
2.499
0.359
0.045
0.315
0.079
0.052
0.000
0.052
0.000
0.061
1.000
0.063
0.963
12.512

Page 2

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
CODE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 959,110 SF


$/SF
1. Foundations
2. Vertical Structure
3. Floor & Roof Structures
4. Exterior Cladding
5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

19.53
57.00
26.34
42.43
2.63

18,730
54,668
25,262
40,697
2,526

147.93

141,884

10.18
13.93

9,760
13,358

24.10

23,119

9.87
9.99

9,471
9,584

Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)

19.87

19,055

10 Plumbing Systems
11 Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
12 Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
13 Fire Protection Systems

6.12
29.23
23.64
5.26

5,872
28,033
22,670
5,046

64.25

61,621

256.15

245,679

1.56
1.30
0.52

1,500
1,252
500

3.39

3,252

259.54

248,930

31.15
17.44

29,872
16,728

308.13

295,530

61.63
0.00

59,106
0

369.76

354,636

Shell (1-5)
6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing
7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes
Interiors (6-7)
8. Function Equipment & Specialties
9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14 Site Preparation & Demolition
15 Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16 Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation
is excluded
\
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 3

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Mass excavation
Excavate for basement and mat foundation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete mat foundation, 12'-0"
Elevator pits

140,778
53,640
29,802
140,778

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

2,111,670
2,682,000
1,043,070
2,815,560
Excluded

49,940
6

SF
EA

200.00
15,000.00

9,988,000
90,000
18,730,300

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Wide flange
Box columns
Metal plate frame
Studs- 3/4" diameter, 6" long
Concrete fill
Sprayed fireproofing
Diagonal reinforcing
Buckling restraint braces
1026 k
950 k
703 k
589 k
532 k
513 k
418 k
380 k
342 k
304 k
266 k
228 k
Brace connections
Gusset plates
3/4" thick plate steel welded connection
1" thick plate steel welded connection
2" thick plate steel welded connection

880

TN

4,000.00

3,520,000

5,436
101,088
3,101
880

TN
EA
CY
TN

6,000.00
60.00
450.00
350.00

32,616,000
6,065,280
1,395,450
308,000

1,368
1,260
902
7,326
912
6,516
608
960
836
720
1,252
380

LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF

300.00
225.00
180.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
120.00
120.00
120.00
120.00
100.00
100.00

410,400
283,500
162,360
1,098,900
136,800
977,400
72,960
115,200
100,320
86,400
125,200
38,000

168
1,916
232

EA
EA
EA

1,500.00
2,000.00
4,000.00

252,000
3,832,000
928,000

Page 4

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Concrete retaining walls
18" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
24" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

21,456
283,824
1,311

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
326,398
294,975

21,456
422,059
1,748

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
485,368
393,300
54,667,890

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)
Suspended floors
Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

3,359
101,965
859,230
859,230
3,359

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

13,436,000
254,913
3,866,535
4,296,150
1,175,650

Plaza level slab/roof


Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 16 ga.
9" normal weight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

295
33,988
49,940
49,940
295

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

1,180,000
84,970
224,730
249,700
103,250

High roof
Wide flange framing
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

50
18,190
18,190
50

TN
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
4.50
5.00
350.00

200,000
81,855
90,950
17,500
25,262,203

Page 5

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

301,653
42,912
226,240

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

2,413,224
171,648
339,360

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

226,240
554

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

27,148,800
138,500

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

269,152

SF

3.50

942,032

75,414

SF

120.00

9,049,680

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

40,697,244

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

49,940
42,912
31,750

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

499,400
429,120
476,250

Roof insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

18,190

SF

6.00

109,140

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

31,750
18,190

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

793,750
218,280
2,525,940

Page 6

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions

400
7,276
50,932

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

130,000
654,840
3,667,104

Window walls and borrowed lights

1,020

SF

45.00

45,900

Doors, frames & hardware


Interior doors

2,392

EA

2,200.00

5,262,400
9,760,244

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement

5,000
88,000
44,000
616,350
10,000
195,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

35.00
6.00
15.00
5.00
10.00
2.00

175,000
528,000
660,000
3,081,750
100,000
391,520

Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Restroom walls
Office
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement

1
176,000
79,200
739,620
15,000
52,512

EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

75,000.00
3.00
15.00
1.50
5.00
1.00

75,000
528,000
1,188,000
1,109,430
75,000
52,512

Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
88,000
44,000
616,350
10,000
195,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

25.00
12.00
15.00
5.00
8.00
2.00

125,000
1,056,000
660,000
3,081,750
80,000
391,520
13,358,482

Page 7

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

LS
EA
SF
SF
LS

25,000.00
18,000.00
12.00
20.00
450,000.00

Total

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Office areas
Restroom areas
Window washing equipment

1
40
616,350
44,000
1

25,000
720,000
7,396,200
880,000
450,000
9,471,200

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

22,000.00

1,936,000

264 STOP

28,000.00

7,392,000

8 STOP

32,000.00

256,000
9,584,000

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Urinals
Lavatories
Drinking Fountains and Coolers
Sinks
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation

440
88
264
44
44
44

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,800.00
1,200.00
2,500.00
1,700.00
500.00

704,000
158,400
316,800
110,000
74,800
22,000

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

65,000
443,520

2,600
27,720
30,320

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

130,000
887,040
272,880

1,232

EA

65.00

80,080

LS

200,000.00

200,000

Page 8

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

97,500
443,520

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

47,609
83

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,666,331
62,425

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
5,872,296

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties

43,200 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
35,000.00

1,080,000
70,000

3,000
3,000
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

350.00
550.00
30,000.00
28,000.00

1,050,000
1,650,000
60,000
56,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
36,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
150,000.00

102,000
1,080,000
150,000

Page 9

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to VAV boxes

Quantity

1,200
1
1,517

Unit

LF
LS
EA

Rate

Total

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
531,038

Air handling equipment


Air handler units
VAV boxes
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 600 USF
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

700,000

CFM

5.00

3,500,000

294
1,027
196
700,000

EA
EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

367,500
1,284,063
245,000
175,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

959,110
36,000
750
80
400,000

LB
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

7,672,880
216,000
30,000
96,000
1,000,000

1,470
4,109

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

294,000
616,350

LS

300,000.00

300,000

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

959,110

SF

5.00

4,795,550

Test and balance


Test and balance

959,110

SF

1.25

1,198,888

Diffusers, registers and grilles


Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area
Terminal & Package Units
Exhaust fans to toilet rooms etc.

28,033,268

Page 10

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
Transformer substation 13.8KV/480V,
double-ended including secondary
Distribution switchboards - 480V
Distribution panelboards - 480V
Transformers 480/120V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards

12,000

KVA

60.00

720,000

12,000
12,500
4,000
3,000
8,000
2,000

KVA
AMP
AMP
KVA
AMP
LF

150.00
40.00
25.00
75.00
25.00
120.00

1,800,000
500,000
100,000
225,000
200,000
240,000

1,500
1,500
1,500

KVA
AMP
AMP

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

General Purpose Lighting


Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

44

EA

2,500.00

110,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

12.00
6.00
4.00

1,764,000
3,698,100
783,040

Machine and Equipment Power


Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

16
2
2
6
959,110

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
719,333

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area

88

EA

2,500.00

220,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

3.00
5.00
2.00

441,000
3,081,750
391,520

Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Area

1
616,350

LS
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
1,849,050

Page 11

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Code Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

Security Systems
Security System

959,110

SF

2.00

1,918,220

Fire Alarm Systems


Fire Alarm Systems

959,110

SF

3.00

2,877,330

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

959,110
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

239,778
25,000
22,670,120

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

959,110
959,110

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

3,836,440
959,110

LS

250,000.00

250,000
5,045,550

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

50,060

SF

25.00

1,251,500
1,251,500

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 12

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
PERFORMANCE BASED COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 959,110 SF


$/SF
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Foundations
Vertical Structure
Floor & Roof Structures
Exterior Cladding
Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

$x1,000

17.93
48.39
25.49
42.43
2.63

17,193
46,414
24,449
40,697
2,526

136.88

131,279

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes

10.18
14.34

9,760
13,751

Interiors (6-7)

24.51

23,512

9.48
9.99

9,090
9,584

19.47

18,674

6.12
29.23
23.64
5.26

5,872
28,033
22,670
5,046

64.25

61,621

245.11

235,086

1.56
1.30
0.52

1,500
1,252
500

3.39

3,252

248.50

238,338

29.82
16.70

28,601
16,016

295.02

282,955

59.00
0.00

56,591
0

354.02

339,546

Shell (1-5)

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation
Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)
10.
11.
12.
13.

Plumbing Systems
Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
Fire Protection Systems

Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)


Total Building Construction (1-13)
14. Site Preparation & Demolition
15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16. Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation is excluded
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

Page 13

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Mass excavation
Excavate for basement and Mat foundation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation, 10'-0"
Elevator pits

136,085
51,852
28,807
136,085

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

49,940
6

SF
EA

175.00
15,000.00

2,041,275
2,592,600
1,008,233
2,721,700
Excluded

8,739,500
90,000
17,193,308

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Wide flange
Box columns
Metal plate frame
Studs- 3/4" diameter, 6" long
Concrete fill
Sprayed fireproofing
Diagonal reinforcing
Buckling restraint braces
703 k
589 k
532 k
513 k
418 k
342 k
304 k
266 k
228 k
Brace connections
Gusset plates
3/4" thick plate steel welded connection
1" thick plate steel welded connection

989

TN

4,000.00

3,956,000

4,533
85,200
2,465
989

TN
EA
CY
TN

6,000.00
60.00
450.00
350.00

27,198,000
5,112,000
1,109,250
346,150

850
288
912
926
3,402
11,236
720
872
988

LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF

180.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
120.00
120.00
120.00
100.00
100.00

153,000
43,200
136,800
138,900
408,240
1,348,320
86,400
87,200
98,800

192
1,880

EA
EA

1,500.00
2,000.00

288,000
3,760,000

Page 14

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Concrete retaining walls
18" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
24" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

21,456
283,824
1,311

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
326,398
294,975

21,456
422,059
1,748

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
485,368
393,300
46,413,980

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)
Suspended floors
Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

3,144
101,965
859,230
859,230
3,144

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

12,576,000
254,913
3,866,535
4,296,150
1,100,400

Plaza level slab/roof


Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 16 ga.
9" normal weight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

311
33,988
49,940
49,940
311

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

1,244,000
84,970
224,730
249,700
108,850

High roof
Wide flange framing
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

62
18,190
18,190
62

TN
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
4.50
5.00
350.00

248,000
81,855
90,950
21,700
24,448,753

Page 15

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

301,653
42,912
226,240

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

2,413,224
171,648
339,360

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

226,240
554

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

27,148,800
138,500

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

269,152

SF

3.50

942,032

75,414

SF

120.00

9,049,680

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

40,697,244

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

49,940
42,912
31,750

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

499,400
429,120
476,250

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

18,190

SF

6.00

109,140

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

31,750
18,190

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

793,750
218,280
2,525,940

Page 16

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions

400
7,276
50,932

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

130,000
654,840
3,667,104

Window walls and borrowed lights

1,020

SF

45.00

45,900

Doors, frames & hardware


Interior doors

2,392

EA

2,200.00

5,262,400
9,760,244

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Restroom walls
Office
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
88,000
44,000
584,600
10,000
195,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

35.00
6.00
15.00
5.00
10.00
2.00

175,000
528,000
660,000
2,923,000
100,000
391,520

1
176,000
79,200
1,137,200
33,000
52,512

EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

75,000.00
3.00
15.00
1.50
5.00
1.00

75,000
528,000
1,188,000
1,705,800
165,000
52,512

5,000
88,000
44,000
568,600
22,000
199,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

25.00
12.00
15.00
5.00
8.00
2.00

125,000
1,056,000
660,000
2,843,000
176,000
399,520
13,751,352

Page 17

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

LS
EA
SF
SF
LS

25,000.00
18,000.00
12.00
20.00
450,000.00

Total

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Office areas
Restroom areas
Window washing equipment

1
40
584,600
44,000
1

25,000
720,000
7,015,200
880,000
450,000
9,090,200

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

264 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

7,392,000
256,000
9,584,000

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Urinals
Lavatories
Drinking Fountains and Coolers
Sinks
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation

440
88
264
44
44
44

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,800.00
1,200.00
2,500.00
1,700.00
500.00

704,000
158,400
316,800
110,000
74,800
22,000

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

65,000
443,520

2,600
27,720
30,320

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

130,000
887,040
272,880

1,232

EA

65.00

80,080

LS

200,000.00

200,000

Page 18

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

97,500
443,520

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

47,609
83

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,666,331
62,425

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
5,872,296

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to VAV boxes

43,200 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
35,000.00

1,080,000
70,000

3,000
3,000
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

350.00
550.00
30,000.00
28,000.00

1,050,000
1,650,000
60,000
56,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
36,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
150,000.00

102,000
1,080,000
150,000

1,200
1
1,517

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
531,038

Page 19

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

Air handling equipment


Air handler units
VAV boxes
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 600 USF
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

700,000

CFM

5.00

3,500,000

294
1,027
196
700,000

EA
EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

367,500
1,284,063
245,000
175,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

959,110
36,000
750
80
400,000

LB
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

7,672,880
216,000
30,000
96,000
1,000,000

1,470
4,109

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

294,000
616,350

LS

300,000.00

300,000

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

959,110

SF

5.00

4,795,550

Test and balance


Test and balance

959,110

SF

1.25

1,198,888

Diffusers, registers and grilles


Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area
Terminal & Package Units
Exhaust fans to toilet rooms etc.

28,033,268

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
Transformer substation 13.8KV/480V,
double-ended including secondary
Distribution switchboards - 480V
Distribution panelboards - 480V
Transformers 480/120V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V

12,000

KVA

60.00

720,000

12,000
12,500
4,000
3,000
8,000
2,000

KVA
AMP
AMP
KVA
AMP
LF

150.00
40.00
25.00
75.00
25.00
120.00

1,800,000
500,000
100,000
225,000
200,000
240,000

Page 20

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards

Quantity

1,500
1,500
1,500

Unit

KVA
AMP
AMP

Rate

Total

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

General Purpose Lighting


Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

44

EA

2,500.00

110,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

12.00
6.00
4.00

1,764,000
3,698,100
783,040

Machine and Equipment Power


Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

16
2
2
6
959,110

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
719,333

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area

88

EA

2,500.00

220,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

3.00
5.00
2.00

441,000
3,081,750
391,520

Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Area

1
616,350

LS
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
1,849,050

Security Systems
Security System

959,110

SF

2.00

1,918,220

Fire Alarm Systems


Fire Alarm Systems

959,110

SF

3.00

2,877,330

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

959,110
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

239,778
25,000
22,670,120

Page 21

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

959,110
959,110

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

3,836,440
959,110

LS

250,000.00

250,000
5,045,550

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

50,060

SF

25.00

1,251,500
1,251,500

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

1 LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 22

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
PERFORMANCE BASED PLUS COMPONENT SUMMARY

Gross Area: 959,110 SF


$/SF
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Foundations
Vertical Structure
Floor & Roof Structures
Exterior Cladding
Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights

Shell (1-5)
6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing
7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes
Interiors (6-7)
8. Function Equipment & Specialties
9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation
Equipment & Vertical Transportation (8-9)
10. Plumbing Systems
11. Heating, Ventilating & Air Conditioning
12. Electric Lighting, Power & Communications
13. Fire Protection Systems
Mechanical & Electrical (10-13)
Total Building Construction (1-13)
14. Site Preparation & Demolition
15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping
16. Utilities on Site
Total Site Construction (14-16)
TOTAL BUILDING & SITE (1-16)
General Conditions
Contractor's Overhead & Profit or Fee
PLANNED CONSTRUCTION COST
Design, Management and Inspection
Escalation is excluded
RECOMMENDED BUDGET

12.00%
6.00%
March 2010
20.00%
0.00%
March 2010

$x1,000

17.93
52.90
25.87
42.43
2.63

17,193
50,733
24,814
40,697
2,526

141.76

135,964

10.18
14.34

9,760
13,751

24.51

23,512

8.77
9.99

8,410
9,584

18.76

17,994

6.12
29.23
23.64
5.26

5,872
28,033
22,670
5,046

64.25

61,621

249.28

239,091

1.56
1.30
0.52

1,500
1,252
500

3.39

3,252

252.67

242,343

30.32
16.98

29,081
16,285

299.97

287,709

60.00
0.00

57,542
0

359.97

345,251

Page 23

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1. Foundations
Mass excavation
Excavate for basement and Mat foundation
Shoring at perimeter
Backfill with imported material
Dispose off site
Hazardous material remediation
Foundations
Reinforced concrete Mat foundation, 10'-0"
Elevator pits

136,085
51,852
28,807
136,085

CY
SF
CY
CY

15.00
50.00
35.00
20.00

2,041,275
2,592,600
1,008,233
2,721,700

49,940
6

SF
EA

175.00
15,000.00

8,739,500
90,000
17,193,308

2. Vertical Structure
Columns and pilasters
Wide flange
Box columns
Metal plate frame
Studs- 3/4" diameter, 6" long
Concrete fill
Sprayed fireproofing
Diagonal reinforcing
Buckling restraint braces
950 k
703 k
665 k
589 k
513 k
456 k
418 k
380 k
342 k
304 k
266 k
Brace connections
Gusset plates
3/4" thick plate steel welded connection
1" thick plate steel welded connection
2" thick plate steel welded connection

1,117

TN

4,000.00

4,468,000

4,980
90,144
2,687
1,117

TN
EA
CY
TN

6,000.00
60.00
450.00
350.00

29,880,000
5,408,640
1,209,150
390,950

192
1,458
192
592
926
6,292
8,912
880
228
480
1,252

LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF
LF

225.00
180.00
180.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
120.00
120.00
120.00
120.00
100.00

43,200
262,440
34,560
88,800
138,900
943,800
1,069,440
105,600
27,360
57,600
125,200

128
2,040
16

EA
EA
EA

1,500.00
2,000.00
4,000.00

192,000
4,080,000
64,000

Page 24

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Concrete retaining walls


18" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete
24" Concrete retaining wall
Formwork to one side
Reinforcing steel
Concrete

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

21,456
283,824
1,311

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
326,398
294,975

21,456
422,059
1,748

SF
LBS
CY

15.00
1.15
225.00

321,840
485,368
393,300
50,733,360

3. Floor and Roof Structure


Floor at lowest level
Slab on grade - See foundations (mat slab)
Suspended floors
Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

3,218
101,965
859,230
859,230
3,218

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

12,872,000
254,913
3,866,535
4,296,150
1,126,300

Plaza level slab/roof


Wide flange framing
Channel and angle ledger
3" formlock deck, 16 ga.
9" normal weight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

311
33,988
49,940
49,940
311

TN
LBS
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
2.50
4.50
5.00
350.00

1,244,000
84,970
224,730
249,700
108,850

High roof
Wide flange framing
3" formlock deck, 18 ga.
3 1/4" lightweight concrete
Sprayed fireproofing

72
18,190
18,190
72

TN
SF
SF
TN

4,000.00
4.50
5.00
350.00

288,000
81,855
90,950
25,200
24,814,153

Page 25

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

4. Exterior Cladding
Wall framing, furring and insulation
Exterior wall framing
Furring to interior face of retaining wall
Insulation and vapor barrier

301,653
42,912
226,240

SF
SF
SF

8.00
4.00
1.50

2,413,224
171,648
339,360

Applied exterior finishes


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with
spandrel panels
Parapets & edge detailing

226,240
554

SF
LF

120.00
250.00

27,148,800
138,500

Interior finish to exterior walls


Gypsum board, taped and sanded

269,152

SF

3.50

942,032

Windows, glazing and louvers


Exterior wall finish - curtain wall with glazing

75,414

SF

120.00

9,049,680

Exterior doors, frames and hardware


Glazed Doors & Entrances (allow revolving)
Solid Exterior Doors
Overhead Doors

12
8
2

EA
EA
EA

35,000.00
3,000.00
25,000.00

420,000
24,000
50,000
40,697,244

5. Roofing, Waterproofing & Skylights


Waterproofing
Waterproofing at slab on grade
Waterproofing at retaining wall
Waterproofing membrane under plaza

49,940
42,912
31,750

SF
SF
SF

10.00
10.00
15.00

499,400
429,120
476,250

Insulation
Rigid insulation at roof

18,190

SF

6.00

109,140

Roofing
Balconies & accessible roofs
High roof

31,750
18,190

SF
SF

25.00
12.00

793,750
218,280
2,525,940

Page 26

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

6. Interior Partitions, Doors & Glazing


Partition framing and cores
CMU partitions at basement levels
Core partitions
Standard partitions

400
7,276
50,932

LF
LF
LF

325.00
90.00
72.00

130,000
654,840
3,667,104

Window walls and borrowed lights

1,020

SF

45.00

45,900

Doors, frames & hardware


Interior doors

2,392

EA

2,200.00

5,262,400
9,760,244

7. Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes


Floors including base
Lobby flooring
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Concrete sealer at basement
Walls
Lobby
Core circulation
Restroom walls
Office
Special use areas
Paint to concrete and CMU at basement
Ceilings
Lobby
Core circulation
Restrooms
Office
Special use areas
Paint to exposed structure at basement

5,000
88,000
44,000
584,600
10,000
195,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

35.00
6.00
15.00
5.00
10.00
2.00

175,000
528,000
660,000
2,923,000
100,000
391,520

1
176,000
79,200
1,137,200
33,000
52,512

EA
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

75,000.00
3.00
15.00
1.50
5.00
1.00

75,000
528,000
1,188,000
1,705,800
165,000
52,512

5,000
88,000
44,000
568,600
22,000
199,760

SF
SF
SF
SF
SF
SF

25.00
12.00
15.00
5.00
8.00
2.00

125,000
1,056,000
660,000
2,843,000
176,000
399,520
13,751,352

Page 27

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

LS
EA
SF
SF
LS

25,000.00
18,000.00
12.00
20.00
450,000.00

Total

8. Function Equipment & Specialties


Built in Equipment
Lobby/entry
Core area
Office areas
Restroom areas
Window washing equipment

1
40
584,600
10,000
1

25,000
720,000
7,015,200
200,000
450,000
8,410,200

9. Stairs & Vertical Transportation


Stairs
Regular stair flights
Elevators
Passenger Elevators, gearless traction
Freight Elevators, geared traction, 4 stop

88

EA

264 STOP
8 STOP

22,000.00

1,936,000

28,000.00
32,000.00

7,392,000
256,000
9,584,000

10. Plumbing Systems


Sanitary fixtures and connection piping
Toilets
Urinals
Lavatories
Drinking Fountains and Coolers
Sinks
Hose bibbs
Domestic water and distribution
Cold Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Hot Water Service
Copper piping incl. fittings >2"
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"
Insulation
Valves
Isolation valves to 3/4"
Domestic Water Supply Equipment
Hot water heating and circulation

440
88
264
44
44
44

EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA

1,600.00
1,800.00
1,200.00
2,500.00
1,700.00
500.00

704,000
158,400
316,800
110,000
74,800
22,000

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

50.00
32.00

65,000
443,520

2,600
27,720
30,320

LF
LF
LF

50.00
32.00
9.00

130,000
887,040
272,880

1,232

EA

65.00

80,080

LS

200,000.00

200,000

Page 28

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Sanitary waste
Waste & vent pipework-above ground
Cast Iron No Hub, >6"
Cast Iron No Hub, to 3"
Sanitary waste, vent and service piping
Floor Drains
Rain Water Drainage
Pipe and Fittings
Roof/Overflow Drains
Gas distribution
Copper piping incl. fittings to 2"

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

1,300
13,860

LF
LF

75.00
32.00

97,500
443,520

88

EA

1,000.00

88,000

47,609
83

LF
EA

35.00
750.00

1,666,331
62,425

2,000

LF

25.00

50,000
5,872,296

11. Heating, Ventilation & Air Conditioning


Heat generating systems
Heating hot water boilers, high efficiency
condensing
Heating hot water pumps
Cooling Generating Systems
Cooling towers
Chillers, 2 each
Chilled water pumps
Condenser water pumps
Variable speed drives, vibration isolation,
etc.
Distribution systems
Piping, fittings, valves and insulation
Chilled water
Chilled water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Heating hot water
Heating hot water pipework, fittings,
including insulation
6" - 4"
< = 3"
Valves and specialties
Condenser water
Condenser water pipework, fittings
Valves and specialties
Connections to VAV boxes

43,200 MBTH
2
EA

25.00
35,000.00

1,080,000
70,000

3,000
3,000
2
2

TN
TN
EA
EA

350.00
550.00
30,000.00
28,000.00

1,050,000
1,650,000
60,000
56,000

EA

12,000.00

72,000

1,400
1

LF
LS

95.00
75,000.00

133,000
75,000

1,200
36,000
1

LF
LF
LS

85.00
30.00
150,000.00

102,000
1,080,000
150,000

1,200
1
1,517

LF
LS
EA

90.00
25,000.00
350.00

108,000
25,000
531,038

Page 29

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

Air handling equipment


Air handler units
VAV boxes
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 600 USF
Parking area
Sound attenuation - duct mounted

700,000

CFM

5.00

3,500,000

294
1,027
196
700,000

EA
EA
EA
CFM

1,250.00
1,250.00
1,250.00
0.25

367,500
1,284,063
245,000
175,000

Air distribution, return and exhaust


Galvanized sheet metal ductwork
Flexible ductwork
Dampers, volume
Dampers, smoke/fire
Insulation/duct liner

959,110
36,000
750
80
400,000

LB
LF
EA
EA
SF

8.00
6.00
40.00
1,200.00
2.50

7,672,880
216,000
30,000
96,000
1,000,000

1,470
4,109

EA
EA

200.00
150.00

294,000
616,350

LS

300,000.00

300,000

Controls and instrumentation


DDC Control system

959,110

SF

5.00

4,795,550

Test and balance


Test and balance

959,110

SF

1.25

1,198,888

Diffusers, registers and grilles


Ceiling
Core/Shell
Tenant areas, 1 per 150 USF
Parking area
Terminal & Package Units
Exhaust fans to toilet rooms etc.

28,033,268

12. Electrical Lighting, Power & Communication


Primary Service, Medium voltage
Switchgear 13.8KV including (2) tie
breakers, (2) feeder breakers, and customer
Transformer substation 13.8KV/480V,
double-ended including secondary
Distribution switchboards - 480V
Distribution panelboards - 480V
Transformers 480/120V
Distribution panelboards - 208V
Feeder conduit and wire - 600V

12,000

KVA

60.00

720,000

12,000
12,500
4,000
3,000
8,000
2,000

KVA
AMP
AMP
KVA
AMP
LF

150.00
40.00
25.00
75.00
25.00
120.00

1,800,000
500,000
100,000
225,000
200,000
240,000

Page 30

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description
Emergency and Uninterrupted Power
Emergency Generator
Automatic transfer switch
Distribution panelboards

Quantity

1,500
1,500
1,500

Unit

KVA
AMP
AMP

Rate

Total

350.00
45.00
25.00

525,000
67,500
37,500

General Purpose Lighting


Panelboards
Lighting
Core Area
Tenant Area
Parking area

44

EA

2,500.00

110,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

12.00
6.00
4.00

1,764,000
3,698,100
783,040

Machine and Equipment Power


Connections and switches including conduit
and wire
Elevators
Cooling towers
Chillers
Pumps
Miscellaneous connections

16
2
2
6
959,110

EA
EA
EA
EA
SF

1,000.00
5,000.00
12,000.00
2,000.00
0.75

16,000
10,000
24,000
12,000
719,333

User Convenience Power


Panelboards
Receptacles
Core/Shell
Tenant Area
Parking area

88

EA

2,500.00

220,000

147,000
616,350
195,760

SF
SF
SF

3.00
5.00
2.00

441,000
3,081,750
391,520

Communications
Telephone and communications
Core Area, panels and backbone only
Tenant Area

1
616,350

LS
SF

75,000.00
3.00

75,000
1,849,050

Security Systems
Security System

959,110

SF

2.00

1,918,220

Fire Alarm Systems


Fire Alarm Systems

959,110

SF

3.00

2,877,330

Other Electrical Systems


Grounding Systems
Lightning protection

959,110
1

SF
LS

0.25
25,000.00

239,778
25,000
22,670,120

Page 31

Program Cost Model


March 8, 2010
012-01581.110

PEER Tall Buildings Study Steel Structural Option


Performance Based Plus
Los Angeles, California
Item Description

Quantity

Unit

Rate

Total

13. Fire Protection Systems


Sprinkler and Standpipe Systems
Fire Protection Sprinkler Systems
Standpipe and Hose Systems
Specialties and Other Systems
Smoke Evacuation

959,110
959,110

SF
SF

4.00
1.00

3,836,440
959,110

LS

250,000.00

250,000
5,045,550

14. Site Preparation & Building Demolition


Site Preparation

100,000

SF

15.00

1,500,000
1,500,000

15. Site Paving, Structures & Landscaping


Site Development

50,060

SF

25.00

1,251,500
1,251,500

16. Utilities on Site


Site Utilities

1 LS

500,000.00

500,000
500,000

Page 32

You might also like