Title

Credibility if
author/organization
using an appositive
rhetorical situation
w/ intended
audience

Summary: two,
three meaty
sentences written
objectively

Does this
voice agree/
disagree with
others?

Great quote with My

appropriate signal analysis/
phrase.
thoughts
can be
more
casual.

Other

1. Success and
Understanding. By:Jean
Piaget. Published by
Harvard University
Press, 1978. Cambridge
Mass.

She is a Published
author and she
talks about how
people succeed in
her field.

This talks about

how to be a
success in the
architectural world
and allows us to
see some insight
on how to do so. It
also shows how to
be able to build
some things
carefully such as
houses of cards.

This voice
generally
agrees with
everyone on
this subject.
It also seems
to be that the
road to
success is not
easy but it is
worth it.

It wont hold the

other one up. I
think this one
(the vertical
card) holds up
that one.

This piece
really talks
to me
about what
it takes to
succeed
and what
to expect.

Generally
my opinion
has been
that you
only need
yourself to
succeed but
it varies by
the person.
The author
talks about
how they
believe
success and
how they
describe it.

2. Scott Adams Secret

of Success: Failure.
By: Scott Adams. Web
published by the New
York Times

He is credible due
to the publication
of the New York
Times.

Success is not
known without
knowing what
failure or loss is.
You dont need to
pass to succeed but
it helps to fail as
well.

Disagrees
with others
about needing
to succeed to
pass.

If you're just
starting your
journey toward
success
however you
define itor
you're wondering
what you've been

It shows
another
side to
someone's
insight
into what
succeeding
means.

The author
agrees with
what I say
that you can
not truly
succeed
until you
fail.

doing wrong until

now, you might
find some novel
ideas here.
3. The One Thing
Successful People Do
Every Day by: William
Arruda.
Web published by
Forbes.com

He is credible
because the
rhetorical talks
speak out to me
and he is a
published author in
the Forbes journal.

Letting people
know what they do
to succeed will let
them continue to
do so. Also, this
article talks about
business success
and real world
success.

Agrees with
the others by
talking about
knowing how
to see their
own success
and their own
achievements.

Acknowledge
what makes you
great. Your team
members and
clients are too
busy to notice
your daily
victories, so its
important to take
a brief moment
for selfcongratulations.

Speaks
more to an
adult
because it
is more
business
oriented
and
focuses
more on
jobs.

The author
talks about
succeeding
in the real
world and
business
success.

4. 13 Ways to Use a
Journal to Grow in
Success. Published by
Huffingtonpost.com

I believe that the

article is credible
because it was
published by the
Huffington Post
and they are
credible as a news
source.

Talks about how

keeping a journal
will let you see
what you need to
do to succeed.
Knowing the
process will make
it easier to repeat it
in future events.

Speaks on a
different level
but generally
agrees with
the others on
how to
succeed.

Carry your
journal
everywhere.
Have a few
minutes at the
cafe between
meetings? Record
how the first
meeting went,
how youre
feeling afterward,
and what you
might have done
differently if you
could.

Speaks on
a different
level and
talks more
about how
to succeed
opposed to
what
success is.

Author talks
about what
they did to
succeed and
how they
documented
it. Tries to
help others
and tells
them how
they did it.

5. Ethnic Enclaves and

the Economic Success
of Immigrants
Evidence from a
Natural Experiment.
By: Per-Anders Edin,
Peter Fredriksson and
Olof slund.
Published by Oxford
Journals, web.

The author and

article are credible
because they are
published by a
credible journal
and that they are
being used by
many other authors
who are also
credible.

The article talks

about how
immigrants are
successful because
they are willing to
adapt and do any
job that they think
is suited for them.
It also talks about
how resourceful
they are and how
they are also some
of the hardest
workers.

Generally
agrees with a
majority of
the authors
and they are
helping me
prove my
point.

We find
substantive
evidence of
sorting across
locations. When
sorting is taken
into account,
living in enclaves
improves labor
market outcomes
for less skilled
immigrants: the
earnings gain
associated with a
standard
deviation
increase in ethnic
concentration is
13 percent.

Is more
formal
than the
other
articles are
is cited by
many
other
articles.

Authors are
well
appreciated
by others
and are seen
and praised
quite highly
amongst
their peers.

6. Gender Differences
in Implicit Self-Esteem
Following a Romantic
Partners Success or
Failure by: Kate A.
Ratliff and Shigehiro
Oishi. Published by
Journal of Personality
and Social Psychology

The authors are

credible because
they are published
by the American
Psychological
Association and
they were
published in the
Journal of

It talks about how

people think that
someone can be
attractive just
based on how
confident they are.
It also talks about
how other people
depending on

Generally
agrees with
others but
talks more
about
attractive
success
opposed to

Although the
self-evaluation
maintenance
model has
produced a
considerable
literature, the
present research
is unique in at

They
prove a
good point
and take a
good look
into what
makes us
attractive.

They are
seen as
good in
their fields
because
they are
published in
such a high
journal.

 2013 American
Psychological
Association 2013, Vol.
105, No. 4, 688 702.

Personality and
Social Psychology.

gender can be
different on how
they feel on
making it with
another person or
if theyll strike out.
After their date,
their mood would
be monitored on
how they did.

7. Measuring Success
in Economics by:
Daniel Hamermesh.
Published by Vox.
web.

I believe that this is

credible because he
is a professor at the
University of
London, England.

The article tells us

how there can be
success in the
economy by
watching and
trying to predict
what will happen.
It also talks about
how the author
helps his students
understand how
they can succeed
as well.

least four ways.

Agrees with
the others and
tells how to
succeed in the
money game.

Much scholarly
research
published in
other journals
has an impact
that exceeds that
of research
published in the
most prestigious
outlets.

Talks a lot
about
economic
success
and could
be a good
example
for the real
world.

He is well
appreciated
and talks
very well
about how
he has seen
success and
what it
takes to
succeed.