tempts t0 promote a
re men who had ousted
“whiff of grapeshe
skinned Corsican named Napoleon Bonaparte, who from being the Directory’s
saviour and servant was soon to prove its master.
How are we to explain this almost incredible French Revolution, this astounding
lispersed the mob. ‘The officer in command was a sallow-
mixture of idealism and courage and cowardice, reform and tyranny?
(Chiefly by bearing in mind this fact - that France, a country undergoing a radical
reshaping of her organs of government, at the critical moment was plunged into
war, both national and eivil. War, with the fear it generates, often produces
reckless violence against opponents at home, and so it was in the French Revolu-
tion. Further, the democratic creed of the French Revolutionaries, based on
idcalism rather than practicability at the time, encouraged the belief that the mob
is always right, and robbed leader after leader of the will or courage to halt the
mob when it was obviously wrong. By the system of open debates in Assembly,
Convention, Clubs and local committees, those who urged moderation were
always liable to be shouted down and accused of the unforgivable offence of
counter-revolutionary sentiments. Worst of all, pethaps, was the permission given
in July 1792 to the local assemblies ofthe forty-eight Paris sections (the electoral
dis consider themselves in permanent session. This meant thatthe fanatics
could always outstay the wearied moderates and reverse any decisions they dis-
liked. At critical moments, too, the undue importance of the Municipal Govern
‘ment of Paris, or Commune, which was early captured by the extreme Left, had a
disastrous effect on the more moderate Conve
‘Thus partly because of the war, internal and external, partly because of the
genuine difficulty of keeping a hold on a country freed from the shackles of
centuries, partly because theories of the revolutionaries and the
practice of open debating, partly because of the independence of the Commune
and the sections, the conduct of afairs rapidly drifted into the hands of extremists,
and the Revolution developed from a movement for peaceful reform into a welter
terrorism and bloodshed. Yet it must never be forgotten that when the frenzy
violence died, the permanent benefits of reform remained. These did not
include democracy, for France had shown herself as yet incapable of it. They did,
however, include equality before the law, admin i
the unreal
CHAPTER 5
The Revolutionary Wars and the
Rise of Napoleon Bonaparte
1. From the First Coalition to the Treaty of Amiens,
1793-1802
We must now follow the career of the fascinating and repellent genius who in
almost equal measure restored and ruined France, We have seen how, for a num-
ber of reasons including the threat of her doctrines and the occupation of the
Austrian Netherlands, the war which revolutionary France had declared against
‘Austria in 1792 had by 1793 developed into a war against a European coalition
‘The price of France’s initial failure in this was the Terror and dictatorship.
{orship, directed mainly by the Committee of Public Safety, succeeded
xy situation. By 1795 the work of Carnot and others on the
‘only planned campaigns and organised armies but also
sad the advance at Fleurus in 1794 which recaptured
enthusiasm of the ragged French troops had
xr. Holland, too, had not only failed on land
driven Prussia and Spain from the
and lost a fleet captured by a cavalry charge across the ice, but had also been
‘compelled to make a peace which put her forces at the disposal of France. The
borated with the French, and
1 into the Batavian Republic
1d the main originator and pay-
Europe, though she
capture of Toulon
Spanish in 1793 (and its loss four months unsuccessful expedi-
in Brittany, det
First Coalition,
Fleurus
Formation of
Batavian RepuAlls, the Pyrenees, and
the oceans. Already in October 1795 the Austrian Netherlands had been declared
planned to attack Austr
were snch armies to attad
addition a third army was to enter
capture the Austrian possessions there,
I via the Tyrol. The soldier app
from Toulon in 1
friendless, one-m¢
umphed over his revol
ie had been on the spot in the diffi
and his prompt order to fetch cannons and fire on the mob had saved the new
'y. His rewards were the command of the
ly in love and who had useful aristocratic connections.
March 1796, after a two-day honeymoon, Bonaparte departed for
in a month he had pulled his lx, ill-equipped, and disorganised troops
the
I find there honour, glory, and wealth.” A few days after he
he had suoceeded in his frst object of separating the Austrian and,
Sardinia was demanding peace from a general
ery, no cavalry, and no boots’ The rest of
+. By biliant strategy and marching he
superior opponents into positions where they
their forces against his entre strength
had preserved her exist
|, and that even. where
iped the French, were thus soon to find
was, it was
“Treaty
CampoFrance enriched and glorified, and the name of Napoleon
Bonaparte sent ringing throug]
t, Britain, who would never feel secure
while a major sea-power occupied the coast of the Low Countries. Accordingly
1797 saw a determined French effort to crush her. It was, indeed, a critical year
for Britain with no allies, an imminent revolt in Ireland, mutinies in the fleet,
crisis, and control in India threatened by the French
inspired Tippoo Sahib. But the schemes of France went astray, in spite of the
fact land and Spain had now to act as her allies and move their fleets at
her dictation, At the end of 1796 an attempted French invasion of Ireland at
Bantry Bay had been scattered by storms, and the French efforts of 1798 to carry
aid tothe revolt of Wolfe Tone and his United Irishmen were little more successful
‘The graver danger to Britain during these years in fact came from France's
compulsory allies rather than her own disorganised navies, until Jervis and
Nelson (his second-in-command, whose initiative won the day) defeated the
off Cape St Vincent and Duncan disposed of the Dutch at Camperdown.
for the moment was safe
was left to the conqueror of Italy to devise a more brilliant, if fundament
impracticable, scheme of attacking the obstinate island. Knowing that Bi
as a world power to whom commerce was the life-blood, Bonaparte planne
capture Egypt (which was part of the Ottoman or Turkish Empi in Bi
trade in the Mediterranean, and possibly even advance overland and seize India.
‘The fascination which the East had exercised over his mind from boyhood urged
hhim on, as well as that vaulting ambition which My glory is threadbare,
‘This little Europe is too small a ficld. Great celebrity can be won only in the East.”
‘The Directory readily approved the proposal ~ Bonaparte was becoming so
powerful that it might be wise to keep him away from France. So with an army of
38,000, « large group of scientists and antiquarians and 400 boats, and with the
whole expedition financed by plunder from two new French vassal-republics
(the Helvetic and the Roman), Bonaparte sailed from Toulon for Egypt. Eluding
Nelson, he took Malta from the Knights of St John en route, cleverly continued
to give Nelson the slip, and arrived off Alexandria in July 1798. Before the month
was out he had overwhelmed the famous Turkish cavalry force, the Mamelukes,
at the Battle of the Pyramids (‘Forty cent
‘Nelson came on the French fleet at anchor in Aboukir
‘0 cutting off French communications with Europe.
‘ments Bonaparte could not advance to In
thus driven into adopting
Syria, pushing through
and smashing the Ottoman Empire.
Proved an easy victim (he again posed as the ‘
ce to help defend the city. Frustrated,
‘crush a 1
republic in Naples, and captured Piedm«
ined because her halfomad ‘Tsar Paul was s
John and resented Bonaparte’s move towards the E
juld be reserved for Russian and Turkish influence. From
the French troops were being expelled by the fierce
sack general Suvorov, while the other French armies were hanging on with
ir conquests on the Rhine, in the Netherlands, and in Switzerland.
re were, too, rumours of royalist plots and treachery among French generals,
ince a wave of unpopularity was almost submerging the Directory. The
nwers stole away from Egypt in two
is, leaving his deserted expedition to its favourite 5
to find a substitute for hops, and fishing in the Nil
Mamelukes, and lea
‘concern for the Knights
i despite having taken it
ith this situation partly by
Second Coali
Napoleon overthro
the Directory
October-Novembs
1799: the coup d
of Brumaire
‘The Consulate, 18
‘Treaty of Luné
1801
‘The Armed Neutr:ns, 1802
04
{that iron, timber, and corn could be seized
1, for example), and partly by smashing the
The Danes were given twenty-four hours t0 with=
league, and refused; during the subsequent British attack Nelson
did hs famous telescope trick to ignore the instructions of Sir Hyde Parker
Further, the assassination of Tsar Paul by a court party in Russia tired of his
insane suspicions helped the British cause, for his successor, ‘Tsar Alexander I,
‘was opposed to France.
“The year 1801 thus finished with Britain triumphant in the Mediterranean and
the Baltic. Farther afield, on the suggestion of the exiled Prince of Orange, she
had occupied the Dutch possessions of Ceylon and the Cape of Good Hope; and
she had also captured Trinidad from the Spanish, France was eq
fon the European continent. On both sides there were accordingly
peace, and in March
important terms were
Malta to the Knights
return France was t
key
now, it seemed, devote
he Cape to the Dutch and
Ceylon and 1 ; and in
2. Napoleon Bonaparte’s Achievements in France as
First Consul and Emperor, 1800-14
‘Asa general, Bonaparte’s genius was, finally, unproductive, because he took on
tions which in different
ive work dates from his years as
free from war when he could
forms have endured tot
First Consul (1800-0) wl
government into an imperial dictatorshi
He kept representative
ith himself as the Emperor Napoleon,
ins only in a powerless form, but secured the
’s central government perished with him. However, his earlier
jon of local government (an area which the revolutionaries of 1789 had
--chaos) became the basis of the modern French system. As First
and owed their positions to, the central government, They
in the Département, the sub-Prefect in the Arrondissement, and
Consulate made
is largely
neglected elementary edu
jon by fou
itary secondary
jence and mathematics were
subjects studied
fea expected to contol virtua
feat ne nntutons catered for gs“ dono
te ay plan nsuction for ung females, sid Napleon,
eden sn nab for them, Dect they are never ele upon
oe
ae etl them wo consid themes the re Hb
ne soed ie en of talent by founc Legion of
‘000 new hereditary nobles, incl
xlrod counts, quite apart from the members of
is eft hia mak on
Bonaparte, foal hisirelgiows nature this
een had sere te Chichi Fane
aa gins had nought bout iis conic
ae aesiuionary deities as the Guddess of Reason and the
eee tof fashion the Chur in Franc in 1800
Patan Rome, Neverthees, the overwhelming
ote heart even if the incu were
drive a hard bargain with Rom:
s. The French State was to choo
nd generally control
Education
‘The Legion of
Honour, 1802ior
Church, which would be under only the nominal leadership of the Pope. Above
the Church lands confiscated atthe Revolution were not to be returned. Thus
the peasants were won over to Bonaparte not only because he restored their religion
bbut because he saw that they kept their recent gains. The Concordat did not
please everyone ~ one distinguished general was overheard to remark
Deum which celebrated the reconciliation: “The only thing lacking at
‘mony is the million dead men who died to get rid of this nonsense.” Bon,
however, knew he was on firm ground in appealing to :
He saw in religion what he called ‘the cement of ~ something
useful in binding men together and keeping them satisfied, something that young
ladies especially should study to make them meck and obedient wives. In other
words, religion was for Bonaparte only an instrument. The true depth of his
Catholicism may be judged from the way he later annexed the Papal States and
had the Pope carried off to Franc
created, and advisory boards set up for many manufactures, arts, and eras, High
Protective tariff sheltered French industries from foreign competition; technieal
schools, prizes, loans, and exhibitions encouraged new processes; and France,
deprived of certain staple articles by the Continental System,? managed to
develop effective substitutes such as chicory for coffee and beet for cane-sugar.
New cotton machines were invented and factory acts passed. Further, by main-
taining a stable currency based on gold, and by his creation of the Bank of France
while First Consul, Napoleon won the support ofall the business interests.
In fact, by an elaborate series of decrees Napoleon’ government regulated almost
the whole of the national life—art, the theatre, the press, commerce, industry, and
mn. This regulation was not all gain. High tariffs meant great hardship for
consumers in the form of increased prices, government censorship greatly
freedom of publication, and regulation of industry hindered as well as
sd industrial development.
Whatever the merits of his general fina
i and commercial policy, there is
ss treasures stolen from Ttaly
inebleau were restored, ‘The planning of a great group of arterial
om the Arc de Triomphe and the clearing of the Tuileries
1808 — until, in
test was perhaps the
Jaws of France on such topics
them. After the old tangle
ind Baronial laws which had been complica-
gs of the committee which reviewed the lawyers’ drafts,
isive influence on its development. Often he was able to secure
‘or to place his weight behind clauses which increased the power of
hhusband or the father ~ Napoleon’s great of authority.
Saw o n wed few legal rights
iscivil code was not a very progressive document
women and permitted a father to have his child temporarily imprisoned.
confirmed the legal equality of male citizen, helped to bring social
and enabled Frenchmen ~ and others ~ to understand the main principles
in South America. Through
widely adopted by different states in Europe and in South A Zh
‘nde therefore Napoleon helped to give one of the main bulwarks of domestic
4 great legal system — not only to France, but to the world,renewal
CHAPTER 6
The Struggle Against Napoleon
1. From the Renewal of War to the Height of
Napoleon’s Power, 1803-10
‘The Peace of Amiens was always unlikely to give more than a short breathing
space. It did not mention a question of the greatest importance to Brit
French annexation of the Austrian Netherlands; and it left both sides still d
suspicious and
thout the real will to peace. France refused to give any greater
freedom to British trade; British caricaturists refused to be kinder to Bonaparte
too, was clearly planning to extend her influence in the Near East, India,
‘West Indies ~ but equally clearly Britain would brook no important
two rivals
‘were at war again, France being helped by Spain after the British seizure of some
Spanish treasure ships destined as subsidy for France,
‘The struggle whi wed was a more personal one
‘war against France. By 1804, when Bonaparte rid himself of his fellow Consuls
and became the Emperor Napoleon, the flame of the French Revol
dying down. ‘Thenceforth Europe had to deal
ther than the burning zeal of a nation.
the intention of mounting a direct attack on Bri
an enormous force in camp at Boulogne. “The Chan
needs but a little courage to cross.’ So an army of 10%
or the venture, and some 1,500
Napoleon first mar-
he said, tsa ditch
sh grasped the plan. Having thus secured an over-
the Channel, the F panish fleets could safely
ish newspapers! When
Napoleon did, and he got it once more from the English newspaper
Villeneuve approached Spanish waters he therefore found a British fore from the
el der Admin Clr reny nee him, Moreover, hugh fw
inch ships had managed to slip out of Rochefort, the main naval force in the
French Atlantic ports, that at Brest, had not escaped blockade at all. Seeing his
tottering, Villeneuve obeyed his alternative orders and put in at the
naval tacties: we only know one manoeuvre,
just what the enemy wants us to do.”
rage, Napoleon now broke camp at Boulogne and prepared to lead his army
t Austria, as a third Coalition, in which Britain and Russia were joined by
in the year, It was aimed against Napoleon’s
and declared himself King of Italy. Napoleon was
to the enemy. Speedily the men from the Boulogne
‘were marching to central Europe as only the French armies could march —
im to convey forces to Naples. Disregarding
wt-minute order superseding him, the French admiral sailed, and on 21st
October 1805 the thirty-three French and Spanish ships confronted the twenty
Nelson and Collingwood off Cape Trafalgar. When the day finished
favourite mode of attack (breaking the enemy line and concentrating a
ime) had won its last and greatest
rnch navy was crippled, and the luckless Villeneuve committed suicide.
st of the war Britain was safe from invasion, and British sea-power,
in his first great bat
sd a crushing defeat
Austrians and Russians at
‘he news of this second and
Nelson fol
Villeneuve 3
‘Third
Ulm and
AusterlitayFerenc sateite Ste.
J Preencsties
TE intepenser Sets
rv tate Sito
RUSSIAN EMPIRE
FINLAND,
8
ff, ,
i;
Bia:
ay!
=
28
Fa
2 as
eS
2:
ge
22
ae.
unexpected disast
and worn.
steed 10 hand over to Napo
' possessions in Italy inelucling Venice atl to reduce her
German states. With Austria powerless, Na
set up a union of west German states kn
y soon declared their resignation from the old Holy Roman Empire, whi
Napoleon then declared he could no longer recognise. Francis of Austria thereupon
‘esigned as its head, to become Emperor of Austria instead; and the Holy
nan Empire, which had endured in name at last fora thousand years, came to
a
‘turn of Prussia came next. Prussia had not joined the Coalition
Jena, 1806
ive against him. In doing this he could count on the help of the Poles, to whom,
many other peoples at first, he appeared as ‘the liberator’, He encountered
ler recognised Napoleon's arrangements on the Continent, including the
federation ofthe Rhine andthe seting up of a new Grand Duchy of Warsaw.
im Alexander received the promise of a free hand in Eastern Europe and a
inthe Turkish Empire when it was to be annexed. More important
‘ered Brin should refuse to give up her enol conquest or her
in Napoleon's “Continental System’. At the same time, Prussia made
promises.
The Continental System was the basis of Napoleon’ strategy from this point, ‘The Continent
falgar Napoleon had come to realize that Britain could not be con- System
ec by sea, and he therefore sought to use against her nota military or naval but
“ ic weapon ~in other words, to strike a deathblow to her trade and wealth
It was a policy which the earlier Revolutionary governments had initiated, but
th he was to systematise. For this purpose he issued from Berlin in 1806, after
of Jena and later from Milan a series of orders known as the Berlin and Berlin and Mile
Decrees, the effect of which was to forbid France or any of her alles or Decrees, 1806
tory to accept British goods, which were to be confiscated whenever
allowing her to import certain French goods
uy but not to sell), Napoleon hoped to rob Britain of her
financial criss, and bring his enemy to bankruptcy.
e successful, it would have to be applied
807 he had crowned
ww. Yet his capacity for chewing. seemed unlimited,med the Grand I
nd secure in the new Russian alliance, he hoped that the
‘seods would soon settle his last outstanding problem,
n was swift and effective
ountries which accepted Napoe!
locks ' Port excluding British vessels was to be deprived
the opportunity of rer nations. Britain thus aimed at
inent of alternative sources of supply, causing rising prices and
inst Napoe
any French navy wi
ichy of Warsaw.
the vessels were duly sur-
danger being thus removed, Britain «
+ Orders in Council effectv
and the grim trade war began to stifle the
{impression on the extrem:
priests, they firmly resolved not to accept
+809, had caused the Pope to be kidnapped and thi
in M
of the Peninsula to Nap
her army ~a highly important des
tory at Baylen and the British and Port
808 fortune began to desert the French in the
, by a mutual arrangement
tra ~ staged a desper
rkation at Corunna, but prev
as the Convention
a hurried
Portugal,
ide turned again, The
landed again in Portugal
here he defeated King Joseph at Talaverahere else had they operated in a barren
Population, French commanders indifferent
wvements only from Napoleon in Austria,
ten depended on the English newspapers for his information ft
cavalrymen was necessary to get a message from e
ry to get a message from one village to another,
a smaller umber would be murdered by peasants. Slowly Wellington aves
strong and prepared w advance. Theft cack ner apecig "
great edifice, a
Elsewhere, the system as yet remained
to Walcheren, off the m
succeed in fighting, I
victim to the swamps and
Austria, too, tempted to try conclusions once more by French failures in
found Napoleon still far too strong at the battle of Wagram, lost even
ritory, and had to promise to enforce the Con
‘was made to ally with Napoleon and supply him with a new
Marie Louise ~ for Josephine had not provided the Emperor
‘now conveniently divorced
tan sent an expedition
land, but it did not even
Lingering under inefficient com-
ope was secure and that his
tain and the Peninsula - would soon be cleared up,
EFFECT OF THE CONTINENTAL SYSTEM ON BRITAIN (1H
ITAIN (THROUGH FRENCH
Before. After. ~)
sugar and
laid up and
ied to his dependent allies or conquests
to compensate forall the improvements
iections that his government had made. In 1811 came the revolt whic
the beginning of the end. The Tsar, tired of doing without Brit
is goods, annoyed at the annexation of a relative’s territory (Oldenberg),
'y Napoleon's marriage with an Austrian rather than a Russian princess,
re to help him in his Eastern ambitions, broke
was one of the most appalling
retreat;andasthey
they devastated the country, denuding it of supplies and shelter. The
ling army could not be fed; death and desertion carried off thousands, so
the cold set in two-thirds had disappeared. Napoleon struggled
nw, hoping that its capture would end not only the war but all the
supply. Outside the capital the greatest battle of the campaign was
Borodino - which the French won at the cost of 30,000 horses and 50,000
the dead left seven or eight deep on the field of conflict.
‘opponents. After five weeks in the ruined cit
‘but turn back ~ and, since Russian armies
reat over the desolate li
Borodino had to be encountered again, but one man at least was not
e most beautiful battlefield I have ever seen in my life’, remarked
on. By Novernber the cold had come to complete the catastrophe. As they
‘with Ney in the rear heroically fighting a battle a day against the ever-
ssing Russian forces, the Emperor realised that his presence was essential in
rebuild the shattered military strength of his Empire.
ly 42,000 men, the Prussians had adopted a
Campaign, 1812
Borodino
‘The retreat from
Moscowapply the
ssians, and Swedes had managed
ipzig, 1813 (sometimes known as the ‘Battle of the Leipzig, 1813
the French forces were overwhelmed. Rapidly they retreated across
the Allies in pursuit. Rejecting a very generous peace offer which
ven France her ‘natural frontiers’ and so left her withthe Rhineland
im, Napoleon laid himself open tothe inevitable an invasion of France
the Peninsula Wellington during 1811 had succeeded in liberating
Peninsular War
v 13
mtuguese forces were
were about to do so
Invasion of France
(who by the Treaty of Chat
and agreed on some of their peace
on first to accept terms and then
short service, and so had a reserve about 120,000 strong.
the Prussian War |
a as his kingdom.
lcon was already waiting in the wings. Just before his
fench Senate, guided by alleyrand, a former bishop and foreign
the Republic and Napoleon, set up a provisional government and
or the restoration of the Bourbon line. ‘This was in accordance with the Restoration of
he Allies. The new king was the elder surviving brother of the executed Bourbon monarchy
XVI. He took the title of Louis XVIII, and to make his accession more Louis XVITL
the French, promised to rule by the terms of a Charter which guaran-
jon, He had some difficulty in leaving his exile in
in five years transformed an almost medieval
secured
snd wal fr mages cheweres had broke
which certain land was ot i a
head ps a pens mene
iota therm
‘even greater
imposed no armyoboao
LUMINATIONS FOR THE PEACE OF PARIS,
sham, illuminated to celebrate the peace
asclighting began in coal mine offices near Whiteha
m Murdoch for lighting factories in the English
slater used for lighting
muscholds until the second half of the nineteenth
from about 1792.
es, but did not become general in
century. Even then it was largely
an capitals. Apart from this, F
d be represented at this
ut the redistribution 0
war in Europe enabled Bi
ports, and the seizure
ish-born American subjects from American ships. Britain in fact was on the
greatest
eof
‘rench delegate,
ision and bring France into the select,
is by inducing Britain and Austria
rate should Russia or Prussia attempt to e
was threatening). When news of this leaked o
over when a still more alarming piece of
.ews that Napoleon had decamped from
instant action, Within about an
law and renew hostilities against him,
ined by many smaller powers. More striking
e Congress
ns, was signed on th June 1815, nine days before the last great
at Waterloo,
‘The tactics ofin strongly be
Savoy (which she had occupied
sth-east. In addition they
army of occupati
ks of art, At
and Prussia
France, and
on) and some frontier areas in the
indemnity, and suffer
eturn of the remaining I
1 Waterloo Napoleon died
fe had spent much of his time ind arranging the history of his career to
he best advantage. Europe would never again be troubled by hishim wholeheartedly after 1806,
them little freedom. ‘The Italians,
utch were all overtaxed. In Russia and Spain the French revolu-
very backward peoples, and here he
ing. Further, after his introduction
the whole of Europe. It was a task beyond the power of any one man or any one
nation, even when the man was Napoleon and the nation the French. Even if he
‘Turkish Empire, to
(on, a demon he him-
the beginnings
lamage that can
IAPTER 7
‘he ‘Congress System’
: Congress of Vienna and the Post-War
‘ment, 1814-15
jes and the other European powers met at Vienna in the autumn of
ced two main tasks, The fist was to make or approve detailed arrange.
or sharing the spoils of victory, bearing in mind thatthe great powers had
tmade a number of preliminary agreements. This had to be done without
ctors at each other's throats. The second task was, in so doing, to
(a stable Europe unlikely to sufer further great upheavals
ih representatives of all the European states were invited, and the confer~
‘nas convened in the name of seven Allies and France it was understood that
sion-making would be reserved to the ‘Big Four’ among the Allis ~
‘Prussia and Russia, The chief delegates of these powers ~ the
Minister Metternich, the British Foreign Secretary Cast
‘sian Chancellor Hardenberg, and the Russian Foreign
‘was overshadowed by his master, Tsar Alexander I) ~met
house to discus the whole range of Congress business, but
wiwers were confined to more restricted matters and their own partic
‘Congress was very old, however, the chief French delegat
sated power which had caused all the trouble, Tal
jing that the blame for past event
‘hogged the major business, m cother represent
ime on their hands; Fos this reason the Congress proved to be one
Congress of Vienna,
1814-15
‘The Four Major
Powers —
~and the Fifth
‘Talleyrand and
Aegitimacy”