Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Schmutzhard E. Multiple Sclerosis and Lyme Borreliosis. Wien. Klin. Wochenschr. 2002 11413 14 539 543
Schmutzhard E. Multiple Sclerosis and Lyme Borreliosis. Wien. Klin. Wochenschr. 2002 11413 14 539 543
539
wiener klinische
wochenschrift
the middle european journal
of medicine
Printed in Austria
Results
Ten topics were identified as being usable and helpful
in the deduction of the causative relationship between
these two diseases. They are listed in Table 1.
Seroepidemiology
Introduction
Multiple sclerosis is a relapsing/remitting or chronic/
progressive disease of presumably autoimmune origin affecting mainly or exclusively the CNS, leading to demyelinisation and remyelinisation. Many pathogenic agents
have been incriminated in being either directly involved in
the pathogenesis or indirectly, i.e. by triggering an autoimmune process within the CNS [50].
Gay and Dick were the first to discuss spirochetes as
the possible causative agents of multiple sclerosis [15],
and Kurtz et al. proposed both relapsing fever and Lyme
disease borreliae as having the capacity to cause a central
nervous system disease equal or similar to multiple sclerosis [24]. Although these medical hypotheses have never
been substantiated by biological, biochemical or molecular-biological findings, other authors have continued to
postulate a causative relationship between multiple sclerosis and spirochetes [4, 10, 15, 27].
The etiology of multiple sclerosis is still a subject of
controversial discussion and it continues to cause considerable uncertainty in the medical community, reflected by
a very recent Polish publication in which a causal relationship between the agent of Lyme borreliosis and multiple
sclerosis is postulated [5].
We aim here to clarify this confusion within the medical community by contrasting epidemiologic, clinical and
diagnostic findings of neuroborreliosis, and in particular
chronic neuroborreliosis, with multiple sclerosis. In addition we discuss the most recent developments in molecular biology and neuroimmunology with respect to these
two diseases. Using deductive methods we believe we
have achieved conclusive results, i. e. we hope to clarify
the relationship between these two diseases.
540
Neuroimaging
No larger series has been published on the neuroimaging presentation of either acute or chronic neuroborreliosis. Nevertheless both cranial computertomography (cCT)
and magnetic resonance tomography (MRT) have been
performed on children and adults with neurological Lyme
disease [11]. Demaerel et al. described ring enhancing
lesions as one possible MRT-feature [8]. This finding
CSF serology
It is well accepted that intrathecal production of specific Borrelia burgdorferi antibodies is one of the hallmarks of diagnosis of neurological Lyme disease. Only
rarely is a negative Lyme serology seen in acute neuroborreliosis patients, and is most likely to be found in
acute neuroborreliosis patients who had have early antibiotic treatment [39]. In chronic neuroborreliosis the intrathecal production of borrelia-specific IgG, IgM (and IgA)
antibodies is typical. Since polyclonal stimulation may
cause a mild increase of various nonspecific antibodies,
including Borrelia burgdorferi antibodies (IgG), commercially available tests may yield positive results. This aspect has been addressed and discussed at length by Coyle
et al. [7] and Lana Peixoto [25], finally reaching the
conclusion that in MS patients a reactive Lyme serology
might test positive. However, this represents the breakdown of the blood brain barrier and never indicates an
autochthonous intrathecal production of specific Borrelia
burgdorferi antibodies [19]. Various methods of identifying intrathecal (autochthonous) production of specific
Borrelia burgdorferi antibodies have been employed, such
as the equilibration of CSF and serum (to bring the albumin levels to equal concentrations by means of diluting
the serum appropriately) or the detection of specific oligoclonal bands within the CSF by CSF electrophoresis.
These methods are extremely helpful in diagnosing chronic neuroborreliosis and differentiating it from multiple
sclerosis [20, 41]. Within the correct clinico-neurological
setting, Lyme serology should be an appropriate method
of differentiating the two diseases of multiple sclerosis
and chronic / progressive neuroborreliosis. This is particularly important since antibodies for neuronal proteins have
been thought to exist in patients with neuroborreliosis,
although the pathogenic relevance of these was never
clearly determined [22]. As in any other progressive
disease of the central nervous system finally leading to
destruction of neuronal cells, it is conceivable that also in
patients with neuroborreliosis antibodies to neuronal proteins released from degenerating neuronal cells are eventually formed. Therefore, the specificity of such antibodies against neuronal proteins clearly needs to be elucidated and validated, particularly with respect to the time
541
542
ate the two disease entities of multiple sclerosis and progressive borrelial encephalomyelitis.
Molecular mimicry
Molecular mimicry is the concept that antigenic determinants of micro-organisms resemble antigenic determinants of the host. It is frequently cited as a plausible
mechanism to account for the association of infections
and autoimmune disease [49, 53].
The currently controversial issue of molecular mimicry in Lyme borreliosis might definitely be an important
issue in chronic neuroborreliosis [1, 21, 28], although
Rose and Mackay looked critically at various human diseases and the role of molecular mimicry [37]. They concluded that, based on analogous sequences of aminoacids
or on cross-reactions of monoclonal antibodies, numerous
examples of molecular mimicry have been reported, but to
date there has been no clear example of a human disease
caused exclusively by molecular mimicry [37]. In view of
recent findings in Lyme arthritis, where molecular mimicry was demonstrated at the single cell level [49], the
statement by Rose and Mackay [37] must at least be
reconsidered.
Dendritic cells
Steinman et al. [46] and Dittel et al. [9] stipulated that
dendritic cells may be crucial in inducing and regulating
immune responses not only against pathogens but also
against autoantigens. Very recently, this issue was addressed by Pashenkov et al. who found two subsets of
dendritic cells within the human cerebrospinal fluid [31].
Whereas myeloid dendritic cells, one of the two subsets,
were found to be elevated in various neuroinflammatory
conditions including MS, optic neuritis, and to some extent also in septic meningoencephalitis and neuroborreliosis, the other subset of dendritic cells the plasmacytoids
were found to be significantly elevated in the CSF of
Lyme neuroborreliosis compared with other neuroinflammatory conditions. The initially elevated number of dendritic cells in the CSF drops dramatically over a few
weeks in acute neuroborreliosis and appropriate antimicrobial chemotherapy.
Conclusion
From this approach of deductive argumentation it is
without doubt that acute neuroborreliosis is a clearly distinct disease entity. Similarly without doubt is the fact that
any form of chronic neuroborreliosis, e. g. progressive
borrelial encephalomyelitis, may present as an MS-like
disease; however, there are many ways to clearly differentiate multiple sclerosis from any form of chronic neuroborreliosis. It is not the task of this deductive outline to
discuss either the treatment protocols for the various
forms of multiple sclerosis or the distinct treatment protocol for neuroborreliosis (the reader is referred to the published practice guidelines for the treatment of Lyme disease by Wormser et al. [52] and Steere et al. [45]).
Since both treatment options and prognosis are different in these two disease entities (multiple sclerosis and
chronic neuroborreliosis) it is necessary to distinguish
them as early as possible and with maximum possible
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
brosspinal fluid in patients with neuroborreliosis and multiple sclerosis. Nervenarzt 61: 248249
Hemmer B, Gran B, Zhao Y, et al (1999) Identification of
candidate T-cell epitopes and molecular mimics in chronic
Lyme disease. Nat Med 5: 13751382
Kaiser R (1995) Intrathecal immune response in patients
with neuroborreliosis: specificity of antibodies for neuronal proteins. J Neurol 242: 319325
Karussis D, Weiner HL, Abramsky O (1999) Multiple
sclerosis vs Lyme disease:a case presentation to a discussant and review of the literature. Mult Scler 5: 395402
Kurtz SK (1986) Relapsing fever/Lyme disease. Multiple
sclerosis. Med Hypotheses 21: 335343
Lana-Peixoto MA (1994) Multiple sclerosis and positive
Lyme serology. Arq Neuropsiquiatr 52: 566571
Lyon-Caen O, Fontaine B, Gout O, et al (1994) Multiple
sclerosis and other related inflammatory disorders of the
central nervous system: differential diagnosis and treatment. Acta Neurol Belg 94: 9297
Marshall V (1988) Multiple sclerosis is a chronic central
nervous system infection by a spirochetal agent. Med Hypotheses 25: 8992
Martin R, Gran B, Zhao Y, et al (2001) Molecular mimicry
and antigen-specific T cell responses in multiple sclerosis
and chronic CNS Lyme disease. J Autoimmun 16: 187
192
Morales DS, Siatkowski RM, Howard CW, et al (2000)
Optic neuritis in children. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus 37: 254259
Pachner AR, Steere AC (1985) The triad of neurologic
manifestations of Lyme disease: meningitis, cranial neuritis, and radiculoneuritis. Neurology 35: 4753
Pashenkov M, Huang YM, Kostulas V, et al (2001) Two
subsets of dendritic cells are present in human cerebrospinal fluid. Brain 124: 480492
Perides G, Tanner-Brown LM, Eskildsen MA, et al (1999)
Borrelia burgdorferi induces matrix metalloproteinases by
neural cultures. J Neurosci Res 15: 779790
Pohl P, Schmutzhard E, Stanek G (1987) Cerebrospinal
fluid findings in neurological manifestations of Lyme disease. Zentralbl Bakteriol Mikrobiol Hyg 263: 314320
Pohl-Koppe A, Logigian EL, Steere AC, et al (1999)
Cross-reactivity of Borrelia burgdorferi and myelin basic
protein-specific T cells is not observed in borrelial encephalomyelitis. Cell Immunol 25: 118123
Reiber H (1998) Cerebrospinal fluid-physiology, analysis
and interpretation of protein patterns for diagnosis of neurological diseases. Mult Scler 4: 99107
Reindl M, Linington C, Brehm U, et al (1999) Antibodies
against the myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein and the
myelin basic protein in multiple sclerosis and other neurological diseases: a comparative study. Brain 122: 2047
2056
Rose NR, Mackay IR (200) Molecular mimicry: a critical
look at exemplary instances in human disease. Cell Mol
Life Sci 57: 542551
543
Correspondence: Prof. Dr. Erich Schmutzhard, Universittsklinik fr Neurologie Innsbruck, Anichstrasse 35, A-6020
Innsbruck, Austria, E-mail: erich.schmutzhard@uibk.ac.at