Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a journal publication
This quick reference guide gives general
advice on how to improve the quality and
clarity of your writing to increase your
chance of being published in a high-quality
journal. It is not specific to any particular
journal, because each journal has its own
style and preferences.
Check the style guide and requirements of
the journal you are targeting before you
start writing, to save time rewriting and
editing the paper later, and to help get
your paper published more quickly.
Back to basics
Eeny, meeny, miny, mo
where to publish?
Ideally, pick the journal that you are
aiming to publish your paper in before you
start writing. That way, you can shape the
language and structure to fit the audience
and journal needs. This saves editing and
rewriting later.
Your work will attract the best and widest
audience if its published in an
international, peer-reviewed journal.
Try to publish your paper in a specialist
journal related to your work.
Opposites dont always attract
Look for journals in your field that regularly
publish papers similar to yours. This will
improve your chances of being published;
mean your paper is reviewed by people
who understand your topic and can give
appropriate feedback; and help you more
easily reach your intended audience.
Quick reference guide to writing a journal publication.
Timing is everything
Check to see how long it takes between
acceptance and publication. You can see
this on most papers published online. This
will give you a guide for how long it may
take for your paper to be published and
how big the journals back log of papers
to publish is.
Quality, not quantity
Aim for high-quality, peer-reviewed
journals with high circulation and
influence. As a guide, look at things like
citation rates and impact factors, and
where papers with the most impact in your
field have been published. Its often better
to publish fewer papers in quality journals
than more papers in less prestigious
journals (quality, not quantity).
Journal Citation Reports and Scimago
(www.scimagojr.com/) are useful tools to
help you evaluate a journals influence,
impact and quality. They rank journals in
a discipline, based on various metrics,
and consider a journals quality when
listing its citations.
A word about open-access journals
Publishing your paper in an open-access
journal can help you make your findings
quickly and easily accessible. However,
many of these journals have hefty charges
associated with immediately publishing
your work. They (and print journals) may
also charge a handling fee for the
submission process. These charges arent
usually covered by Australian research
grants. Check the journals fine print
and your budget before submitting
or signing anything.
It takes two
Its not enough to just write about
your science thats only half of the
communication process. Communication
involves expression and understanding.
You need to write about your science in a
way that non-experts and people whose first
language isnt English can understand it.
Write clearly, using simple, plain English
as much as possible.
Do as youre told
Journals usually have a style they want
you to follow. Look for the journals current
Instructions to authors on their website.
This document will cover everything,
including whether to use American or
English/Australian spelling; how to
reference; what to abbreviate; what font
type and size to use; margin size; how
long the paper and abstract should be;
how to save and submit, figures, tables
and images/photographs; and what file
type to submit your paper in.
The essentials
Title
The title of your paper is probably the first
thing people will see, and will be the thing
that draws them to it or turns them away
from it. A good title will also help your
paper be indexed and searchable in
online databases.
So, what is a good title?
Its direct, clear and concise (just like the
rest of your paper!). It says exactly what
your paper is about in as few words as
possible. And those words should be real
words no room for jargon, acronyms or
initialisms here, IYKWIM*?
*If you know what I mean.
Authorship
Agreeing on authorship and name order
can be tricky. There isnt a right or wrong
way to do it, but its important that you
check and comply with the National Health
and Medical Research Councils
Australian Code for the Responsible
Conduct of Research. The Authorship
chapter has good guidelines for deciding
authorship and outlines the related
responsibilities of individual researchers
and institutions.
Try to agree on authorship before starting
a paper, or ideally, even before starting
a study. This will help prevent any
confusion and disagreement. The
research team may need to revise
authorship and order later, but at least
you have a base from which to work.
Quick reference guide to writing a journal publication.
Abstract
After the title, the abstract is the thing that
will entice readers to or deter them from
your paper. Abstracts are usually freely
available online, for example, on PubMed.
A good abstract will help readers decide
if the paper/research is relevant to their
interests or not. Sometimes people will
only read or use the abstract, not your
entire paper, so its important to make
abstracts clear, concise and stand alone.
Write your abstract in past tense the
research is complete.
Abstracts should summarise the paper.
Each of the introduction, materials and
methods, results and discussion sections
need to be summarised in a sentence or
two. Make sure your abstract contains the:
1. research context the question or
reason behind why you are doing the
research
2. main objectives and scope of research
3. research methods used
4. research results
5. main conclusion and how this relates
back to the why (point 1).
Introduction
Introductions set the scene for, and help
to engage readers with, your work. They
generally have five main elements.
1. A question or problem
What prompted you to research what
you did? What is the rationale behind
your work? Why is this question/
problem important to society? This
information can capture your readers
attention and get them interested in
your solution.
2. A brief literature review
Summarise what research has been
done to answer this question/address
this problem, and what the knowledge
gap is that youre trying to fill. This
helps to give your research
importance, relevance and context,
and saves readers from having to
research this information for
themselves (unless they want to).
Note: you dont need to do a
comprehensive review only cite
relevant articles.
3. How and why you did it
Outline your overall research method,
and perhaps why you did it in that way.
You dont need to include details here
just a sentence or two, a paragraph
at most. You can give all the nuts and
bolts in the Materials and Methods
section. However, mentioning your
5
Dont
Dont include any results in this
section.
Materials
Be precise. State the exact technical
specifications; quantities; source; method
of preparation; chemical and physical
properties of reagents; temperatures;
times; materials containers were made
from; genus, species and strain of any
plant or animal; and age, sex, genetic
and physiological status of any animal
or human.
Avoid trade names they may not be
known internationally. If you have to use
a trade name, make sure its capitalised
and that the name of the manufacturer
and place of manufacture is listed.
If animals or humans were used in your
research, put the ethics approval
statement here. If humans were used,
also note here that they gave informed
consent (presuming they did, or you
have a serious problem!).
If your content is complicated, for
example, you used many different strains,
mutants or chemicals, use tables and
figures to summarise and clarify
information.
Methods
Describe your research chronologically.
However, if similar experiments (e.g.
assays) were done at different times,
describe them together, rather than in
separate parts of this section.
If the methods you used in your research
have been used before, include
references to publications that describe
the method, so you dont have to describe
it again. However, if the method is new or
unpublished, you will need to describe it
in enough detail for people to reproduce it.
If the method is published but unusual or
recent, you could briefly describe it and
include a reference.
Consider using flow charts (as figures)
to help to explain complicated or long
processes.
If your research involved animals, look
at the ARRIVE guidelines and checklist
for reporting on animal research at
https://www.nc3rs.org.uk/arrive-guidelines.
They include useful tips and things to
remember when discussing animal
research in your paper.
Results section
Your papers Results section should
contain:
a general big picture description of
your research, without repeating the
Methods and Materials section
data from your research.
Do
Write this section in the past tense
the research and data are
complete/from the past.
Keep this section short, direct and
clear. If the Materials and Methods
and Discussion sections are well
written, the Results section should
be the shortest section of your paper.
Use tables, figures or graphs to
present data more clearly if you need
to include a lot of it.
Refer to tables, figures and graphs
in the text.
7
Dont
Include all of the data from your
research only include data that
is relevant, important, meaningful
or affects your findings or story.
Repeat information in tables and
graphs that is already in the main text
(and vice versa).
Use words like its clear, clearly
or obviously when referring to tables
and graphs in the main text. Youll
come across as verbose and rude.
For example, dont say:
Its clear in Table 2 that,
say Table 2 shows that
Graph A obviously shows,
say Graph A illustrates
Discussion section
Acknowledgments
Its good manners to say thank you when
someone helps you.
Tables
Good tables are a clear and effective way
to display data and can help to explain
research findings. They make comparing
and understanding data easy for readers.
But tables can be used too much or in the
wrong way.
Use tables to clearly and easily display:
relevant repetitive data
significant data
numerical data that needs detailed
comparison (use a figure if you need
to show a trend or picture/overview)
exact numbers (e.g. you can use
a graph to show a trend or general
numbers, but decimal points are better
presented in tables than graphs).
Dont use tables:
if data is not significant (it confuses
readers and takes up valuable space)
for only a couple of pieces of data
just include the data in the main text
if data can be easily outlined in a
sentence or two in the main text
if data has already been discussed
in the main text or a figure (it is rarely
necessary to display data in a table
and figure)
for lists of words put them in the
main text.
Titles
Like the main title of your paper, make
each tables title short and sweet,
but clearly state what it is about.
Footnotes
Dont go overboard with footnotes.
Keep them short and make sure they
are relevant and important to the
table/data.
If you need to define the same
abbreviations in more than one tables
footnotes, you can define them in the
footnote of the first table in which they
appear, then in the footnote of later
tables, refer readers to the first table
for the definitions (e.g. See Table 1
for definitions.). However, check the
journals Instructions to authors to
see if this is acceptable.
Quick reference guide to writing a journal publication.
Figures
10
Remember
Only publish repetitive or full data if
its essential to your findings or story.
Put data in a figure or discuss it in
the main text dont do both.
Make the font large and clear enough
to read. This is especially important
because the published version of your
figure will be smaller than the one you
submitted. The font must be large
enough to read when the figures size
is reduced. To check your figures
readability, photocopy it to the size
it will be published.
Use consistent font, size and style
across all figures in your paper.
Use en dashes (not hyphens) for
minus symbols and to indicate
numerical ranges.
Refer to each figure in the main text
of your paper.
Before you submit your completed
paper, check the number order
for each figure is accurate on the
figures and in the main text.
11
References
There are three main rules for references.
Only use significant published
references not unpublished data,
theses, abstracts or secondary
materials.
Check that each reference accurately
represents the original publication,
then check it again.
Make sure references in the
Reference section are listed in the
paper, and vice versa.
Acknowledgements
Written by Louise Pobjoy, Senior Advisor,
Publications and Grants, and adapted from Day, RA
and Gastel, B 2009, How to write and publish a
th
scientific paper, 6 edn, Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge. With input from Professor David
Adams, Professor Peter McIntyre and Dr Fraser
Rogerson.
In-text referencing
Reference specific ideas or content only.
Dont make a general statement about an
authors/researchers discovery, idea or
conclusion without telling the reader what
it actually is.
Put references directly after the relevant
information, not at the end of the sentence
or paragraph. This might mean you have
two or more reference points in a
sentence.
Be kind to past researchers/authors.
Its ok to say if they didnt do something
in a study, but avoid critical wording like
Roberts (2000) ignored or Roberts
(2000) totally overlooked
Its all about style
There are dozens of different referencing
styles that you can use in your paper,
and each journal has a preferred style.
Follow it.
The Instructions to authors for the journal
that you are submitting your paper to will
outline its preferred reference style. If it
doesnt, check past journal issues and/or
ask the editor.
Programs, like Endnote, format references
to suit different journal styles quickly and
relatively easily. You might find it useful to
keep your references in one of these
programs libraries and use it to format
your reference list to suit different
publications.
12