MODELLING BUSINESS PROCESSES

IN LOGISTICS WITH THE USE

OF DIAGRAMS BPMN AND UML
Dariusz Badura, Prof.
!"#$ %&'$()*+,'
-.(/0!1(234,5467#!,8$49:!.(+;$<4=,)$.

Abstract
>"04?$?0!4!010$!+"0142"041@(2$#()(234$. 41@5A+(0.+34,54B=CD4$. 4-CE4
)$.&@$&014(.4#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&4(.4),&(12(+*4>"0!0480!0428,40F$'?)014,54?!,+0114', 0))(.&G41@??)34+"$(.4),&(12(+14$. 4?!, @+2(,.4),&(12(+1*4
E,&(12(+1413120'4(14', 0))0 4$242"04"(&"0124 ,'$(.4)0/0)4@1(.&4+$10412@ 34(.4
+,.2$(.0!42!$.1?,!24$. 40F0'?)$!34?!, @+2(,.4?!,+01142,40F$'(.042"04#,2"4
', 0))(.&4)$.&@$&014(.4'$.34$1?0+21*4C, 0))(.&4(14+$!!(0 4,@24(.4$4', @)$!4#$1(145,!4"(0!$!+"(+$)413120'14&0.0!$))34@1(.&4B=CD4H*I4$. 4-CE4H*I*4
J,'?)0'0.2$!34 @104 ,54 #,2"4 ', 0))(.&4 2,,)14 8$14 100.4 .0+011$!34 5,!4 #@1(.0114 ?!,+0114 K,84 $. 4 (.5,!'$2(,.4 ?!,+0114 01(&.*4 >"04 ?!,?,10 4 ', 0)14
?!,/( 014'$.34#0.0A2145,!4', 0))0!1<4$.$)32(+14$. 4$+2@$)4?!$+2(2(,.0!14,54
),&(12(+14$+2(/(2(01*
Keywords:4B=CD4 ($&!$'<4-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'*4#@1(.0114?!,+0114',0))(.&<4),&(12(+4?!,+011<4(.5,!'$2(,.413120'

Introduction
B@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&4(142"04('?,!2$.240)0'0.24(.4B@1(.0114=!,+0114
C$.$&0'0.24$242"0(!4('?)0'0.2$2(,.4?"$104$1480))4$142"04$+2(/(234,54!0?!010.2(.&42"04?!,+011014,54$.40.20!?!(10*4>"040F?0!('0.214(.42"04!0$)48,!) 4$!04
@1@$))34/0!340F?0.1(/04$. 4 ,4.,24$)),842,42$L04(.2,4$++,@.245@))4.@'#0!4
,54 ?$!$'020!14 2"0104 ?!,+01101*4 B@1(.0114 =!,+0114 C$.$&0'0.24 MB=CN4 !0O@(!014$41?0+(A+4 01+!(?2(,.4)$.&@$&0<42"04&!$?"(+$)4!0?!010.2$2(,.4,541@+"4
$4 01+!(?2(,.4(142"04#01248$342,4+,''@.(+$2(/04?!010.2$2(,.4,542"04?!,?,10 4
1,)@2(,.*
=!,+0114', 0))(.&4#0+,'014',!04$. 4',!04$.4('?,!2$.242$1L4.,24,.)34
5,!42"04?@!?,104,541,528$!040.&(.00!(.&4#@24$)1,45,!4'$.34,2"0!4?@!?,1014
#01( 0142"04 0/0),?'0.24,541,528$!0*4>"0!05,!04(24(14.0+011$!342,40/$)@$204

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

2"04O@$)(234,54?!,+0114', 0)145!,'4 (550!0.24/(08?,(.21*4>"(14(140/0.4',!04

('?,!2$.24 $14 2"04 (.+!0$1(.&4 .@'#0!4 ,54 (550!0.24 0. 4 @10!1<4 (550!0.24 ?@!?,1014$. 42"04$/$()$#()(234,54 (550!0.24', 0))(.&420+".(O@014$. 4', 0))(.&4
2,,)14)0$ 142,4$4"(&"0!4+,'?)0F(234,54(.5,!'$2(,.4', 0)1*4
R.42"04(.5,!'$2(,.413120'4 01(&.4?!,+01142"0!04$!04@10 428,4$??!,$+"01G
S4 T#U
0+24,!(0.20 4$??!,$+"<4(.48"(+"42"0!04$!04( 0.2(A0 4,#U
0+214$. 4
@10 41@+"45$+()(2(014$14$#12!$+2(,.<40.+$?1@)$2(,.<4(."0!(2$.+04$. 4
?,)3',!?"(1'*
S4 V@.+2(,.$)4,!(0.20 4$??!,$+"<4(.48"(+"42"0!04$!04( 0.2(A0 45@.+2(,.14$. 4$+2(/(2(014,5413120'*4W4&!,@?4,54?!('(2(/04$+2(/(2(014+$.4
#04$11(&.0 42,4$4?$!2(+@)$!4!,)0*4
R.4 2"04 $+2@$)4 01(&.4 ?!,+011<4 #,2"4 $??!,$+"014 $!04 @10 4 1('@)2$.0,@1)34
8(2"4 $4 5,+@14 ,.4 ,.04 ,54 2"0'*4 R.4 2"04 ,#U
0+2X,!(0.20 4 $??!,$+"<4 ,#U
0+214 $!04
( 0.2(A0 <4 $. 4 5,!4 2"0'<4 (.4 2@!.<4 $!04 0A.0 4 !01?,.1(#()(234 ('?)0'0.20 4
@1(.&42"04( 0.2(A0 45@.+2(,.14M,!4'02", 1N*4Y@+"4$.4$??!,$+"4(.4', 0))(.&4
#@1(.0114?!,+011014+$.4#04(.+,'?!0"0.1(#)045,!42"04#@1(.01141( 0*4W4&,, 4
1@??,!245,!4#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&4(14$+2(/(23X,!(0.20 4$??!,$+"*4R2420. 4
2,4 0A.04$4#@1(.0114?!,+0114$14$41?0+(A+4,! 0!(.&4,54$+2(/(2(014M(*0*42$1L1N*4
W242"04?!010.2<42"0!04$!0410/0!$)4', 0))(.&4)$.&@$&0148"(+"4 0A.042"04
#$1(+40)0'0.2145,!4+,.12!@+2(.&4#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0)1*4>"04'$(.14$!04(.4
"(12,!(+$)4,! 0!G4
S4 =02!(4.0214$. 4+,),@!4=02!(4.0214M=02!(4Z[QHN*4
S4 \/0.2X !(/0.4=!,+0114J"$(.14M\=JN4@10 48(2"(.4W]RY45!$'08,!L4
MW$)124Z[[[N*
S4 -CE4W+2(/(2346($&!$'1<42"04?!,+0114', 0))(.&4)$.&@$&04,54-CE4
MTC94HII^N*4
S4 _024W.,2"0!4` ,!LK,84E$.&@$&04M_W` EN4(14#@()24,.42"048,!LK,84
?$220!.4$.$)31(14MW$)12<4a,5120 04HIIHb4W$)124024$)*4HIIPN*
S4 B@1(.0114 =!,+0114 \F0+@2(,.4 E$.&@$&04 5,!4 ` 0#4 Y0!/(+014
MB=\Ec` YN42,4', 0)40F0+@2$#)04?!,+011014MTWYRY4HII^N*
B@1(.0114=!,+0114C, 0))(.&4D,2$2(,.4MB=CDN42,4 01+!(#042"04#@1(.0114?!,+011014@1(.&4.,2$2(,.1412$. $! (;0 4#34TC94MTC94HIZZN*
S4 B@1(.0114=!,+0114C, 0))(.&4E$.&@$&04MB=CEN4(14$4)$.&@$&045,!4
#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&*4B=CE48$14$4?!,?,10 4)$.&@$&0<4#@24
.,84 2"04 B=CR4MB@1(.0114 =!,+0114 C$.$&0'0.24 R.(2($2(/04 N4 "$14
!,??0 41@??,!245,!42"(14(.45$/,@!4,54B=\Ec` Y4MB=CE4HIIHN*4
>"04+,.1( 0!$2(,.14'$ 0444(.42"(14$!2(+)048())4#045,+@10 4,.428,4.,2$2(,.1G4
-CE4 $+2(/(234 ($&!$'4 $. 4 B=CD*4 >,4 0550+2(/0)34 01+!(#04 #@1(.0114 ?!,+01101<42"04-CE4)$.&@$&04@. 0!&,.04$41(&.(A+$.240/,)@2(,.45!,'41('?)04
&!$?"(+$)4)$.&@$&04 01+!(#(.&41,528$!04?!,U
0+242,4/0!34+,'?)0F42,,)42,4 01+!(#042"04/$!(,@140)0'0.214,54#@1(.0114?!,+01101*4a,80/0!<4-CE41@??,!214
PQ

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

?!('$!()34 ,#U
0+2X,!(0.20 4 $??!,$+"*4 >"04 ',124 ('?,!2$.24 -CE4 ($&!$'14
(.+)@ 042"04@104+$104 ($&!$'<4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'<412$204 ($&!$'4$. 4+)$114 ($&!$'*4V!,'42"04?,(.24,54/(084,54#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4(142"04',124(.20!012(.&*4>$#)04Z4?!010.214$4+,'?$!(1,.4,542"04$+2(/(234
($&!$'40)0'0.2148(2"40)0'0.214,54B=CD4 ($&!$'*
B@1(.0114 =!,+0114 C, 0))(.&4 E$.&@$&04 $14 $4 '02$)$.&@$&04 5,!4 ', 0))(.&4#@1(.0114?!,+011014$. 4#@1(.0114 $2$4?!,/( 014$.4$#12!$+20 40F0+@2(,.4
', 0)45,!4+,))$#,!$2(/04$. 42!$.1$+2(,.$)4#@1(.0114?!,+011014#$10 4,.42"04
2!$.1$+2(,.$)4 A.(20X12$204 '$+"(.04 +,.+0?2*4 >"04 -CE4 2$L014 $.4 ,#U
0+2X,!(0.20 4 $??!,$+"4 2,4 2"04 ', 0))(.&4 ,54 $??)(+$2(,.1<4 8"0!0$14 B=CD4 2$L014
$4?!,+011X,!(0.20 4$??!,$+"42,4', 0))(.&4,5413120'1*4>"04B=CD4"$14$45,+@14 ,.4 #@1(.0114 ?!,+011014 01+!(?2(,.<4 2"04 -CE4 "$14 $4 5,+@14 ,.4 1,528$!04
01(&.4', 0))(.&*4>"@1<4#,2"4.,2$2(,.14$!04.,24+,'?02(2(/0<4#@24$!04 (550!0.24
/(0814,.413120'1*4>"04B=CD4$. 42"04-CE4$!04+,'?$2(#)048(2"40$+"4,2"0!*4
W4#@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0)4 ,014.,24.0+011$!()34"$/042,4#04('?)0'0.20 4$14$.4
$@2,'$20 4#@1(.0114?!,+0114(.4$4?!,+01140F0+@2(,.4)$.&@$&0*4R24(14$48$345,!4
2"040F+"$.&04,54L.,8)0 &04#02800.40.&(.00!14$. 4!0?!010.2$2(/014,54/$!(,@14
A0) 1*4>"0!04(142"04+$10<4(.48"(+"4#@1(.0114?!,+011014$. 4?$!2(+(?$.214+$.4#04
'$??0 42,4+,.12!@+2141@+"4$14@104+$1014$. 4#0"$/(,@!$)4', 0)14(.42"04-CE*
B=CD4 (14 $4 12$. $! 4 1024 ,54 &!$?"(+$)4 ($&!$''(.&4 +,./0.2(,.14 5,!4 01+!(#(.&4#@1(.0114?!,+01101*4R24$)),8142,4/(1@$)(;04$4!(+"41024,54?!,+0114K,84
10'$.2(+14 8(2"(.4 $4 ?!,+0114 $. 4 2"04 +,''@.(+$2(,.4 #02800.4 (. 0?0. 0.24
?!,+01101*4 R24 "$14 #00.4 01(&.0 4 2,4 1@??,!24 +$?2@!04 ,54 1@5A+(0.24 02$()4 2,4
$)),84(242,4#042"04#$104,54$.40F0+@2$#)04?!,+0114 01+!(?2(,.*4>"0!04$!0410/0!$)4)$.&@$&01444$('0 4+, (.&4$. 4('?)0'0.2$2(,.4,542"04', 0)14 01+!(#0 4
B=CD4 ($&!$'1*4W',.&4,2"0!142"0104$!04B=\E4$. 4B=CE*4
B=\E4(14)$.&@$&04#$10 4,.4dCE412$. $! *4R248$14 01(&.45,!4 01+!(#(.&4
$4#@1(.0114?!,+0114(.48"(+"4',124,542"042$1L14!0?!010.24(.20!$+2(,.14#02800.4
2"04?!,+0114$. 40F20!.$)4` 0#410!/(+01*4>"04B=\E4?!,+0110142"0'10)/014$!04
!0?!010.20 4$14$4` 0#410!/(+01<4$. 4$!04!0$)(;0 4#34$4B=\E40.&(.048"(+"4
0F0+@20142"04?!,+0114 01+!(?2(,.*4W42!$.1)$2(,.42,4B=\E4(141?0+(A0 4(.42"04
B=CD412$. $! <4#0+$@104B=\E4(14+@!!0.2)34+,.1( 0!0 42"04',124('?,!2$.24
12$. $! 45,!40F0+@2(,.4)$.&@$&01*4B@24#34 01(&.42"0!04$!041,'04)('(2$2(,.14
,.42"04?!,+01142,?,),&(0142"$24+$.4#04 01+!(#0 4(.4B=\E<41,4(24(14?,11(#)042,4
!0?!010.24?!,+011014(.4B=CD42"$24+$..,24#04'$??0 42,4B=\E*4
B=CE48$14 0/0),?0 4#342"04B@1(.0114=!,+0114C$.$&0'0.24R.(2($2(/042,4
', 0)4#@1(.0114?!,+011014$. 4(24(14$)1,4#$10 4,.4dCE412$. $! *4R24"$14#00.4
!,??0 4(.41@??,!24,54B@1(.0114=!,+0114\F0+@2(,.4E$.&@$&0*4W+2(/(2(014(.4
$4B=CE4?0!5,!'41?0+(A+45@.+2(,.14$. 4$!040(2"0!41('?)04,!4+,'?)0F*4Y('?)04$+2(/(2(0141@+"4$14$+2(,.<4$11(&.<4+$))<4+,'?0.1$20<402+*<4+$..,24#045@!2"0!4
0+,'?,10 4$. 4?0!5,!'4$41(.&)04,?0!$2(,.*4J,'?)0F4$+2(/(2(0141@+"4$14$))<4
P^

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

10O@0.+0<4K,8<418(2+"<4?(+L<402+*<4$!04+,'?,10 4,54,.04,!4',!04$+2(/(2(014
$. 4 (!0+242"040F0+@2(,.4,54$.4$+2(/(2345!,'4$.,2"0!4$+2(/(234102*4B=CE4$. 4
B=\E4$!04(.20. 0 45,!4'(11(,.X+!(2(+$)4$??)(+$2(,.14#341@??,!2(.&413.+"!,.,@14$. 4$13.+"!,.,@14 (12!(#@20 42!$.1$+2(,.1*
` "34B=CD4"$14#0+,'041,4?,?@)$!f4-10!140F?0+24.,2$2(,.<48"(+"48())4
$)),84', 0))(.&4,54$ /$.+0 4+,'?,1(204#@1(.0114?!,+01101*4W4?!,?,10 4.,2$2(,.40'0!&014.,242,41,)/04.,24,.)34,) 4?!,#)0'1*4R241",@) 4#04+,'?02(2(/04
(.42!$ (2(,.$)4$??)(+$2(,.14$. 4,?0.4.084,??,!2@.(2(01*4W4', 0)4+$.4#04$.$)3;0 4$. 4('?!,/0 4,!&$.(;$2(,.g
14?!,+01101*4
B=CD4?!,/( 014$4.,2$2(,.42"$24+$.4#04!0$ ()34@. 0!12$. $#)04#34$))4@10!1G45!,'42"04#@1(.0114$.$)312148",4', 0)42"04?!,+011014+,.+0?2@$))3<42,42"04
20+".(+$)4 0/0),?0!14 !01?,.1(#)04 5,!4 ('?)0'0.2(.&4 2"04 20+".,),&34 5,!4 2"04
?!,+01101<42,42"04?0,?)048",48())4'$.$&0!4$. 4',.(2,!42"04?!,+01101*4B,2"4
2"04#@1(.0114$. 420+".(+$)41( 014,542"04,!&$.(;$2(,.4+$.4A. 4$4+,'',.4)$.&@$&0*4>"034+$.4#,2"4@. 0!12$. 4$. 42"$24'002142"0(!4!01?0+2(/04.00 145,!4
?!0+(1(,.4$. 4.,2$2(,.4K0F(#()(23*4>"(141"$!0 4)$.&@$&04&(/042"04,??,!2@.(234
2,4@104.0848$314,548,!L(.&42,&02"0!*4R24!01@)214(.42"04 0?),3'0.24,54.084
$. 4',!04K0F(#)04$??)(+$2(,.1*4

1. BPMN and UML Activity Diagram notation

B=CD4&0.0!$))34 0A.014$.4$#12!$+24', 0)4$. 42"04&!$''$!4@10 42,40F?!0114$4&0.0!(+4?!,+011*4W141@+"<4(24+$.4#04@10 42,4 0A.040.20!?!(104#@1(.0114
?!,+01101<4+,'?)0F4` 0#410!/(+014$. 4'@)2(?$!234+,))$#,!$2(,.1*
>"04B=CD4+$.4$??!,$+"4#34,!&$.(;(.&40)0'0.214(.45,@!4+$20&,!(01G4
S4 ` ,!LK,840)0'0.21G4
S4 $+2(/(2(01<4
S4 0/0.21<4
S4 &$208$31<4
S4 10O@0.+04K,8<
S4 T!&$.(;(.&40)0'0.21G4
S4 ?,,)1<4
S4 18(')$.01<4
S4 &!,@?1<
S4 ]0$ $#()(2340)0'0.21G4
S4 $..,2$2(,.<4
S4 )(.L1<4
S4 Y?0+($)4#0"$/(,@!40)0'0.21G4
S4 '011$&01<4
S4 '011$&04K,8<4
S4 1(&.$)1<4
S4 2('0!1<4
Pe

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

S4 0!!,!1<4
S4 !0?0$2(.&<4
S4 +,!!0)$2(,.*
` (2"4 U@124 $4 5084 0)0'0.214 5!,'4 A!124 2"!004 +$20&,!(014 2"0!04 +$.4 !$84
$4#@1(.0114?!,+0114 ($&!$'4$. 4#0&(.42,4#@() 4$. 4@. 0!12$. 4$4?!,+011*4\$+"4
,54` ,!LK,840)0'0.214"$/0410/0!$)423?01<4$. 4$))4,542"010423?014+$.4#04+,..0+20 4(.4$410O@0.+0*4W+2(/(2(014'0$.142$1L142"$24$!04?0!5,!'0 4(.42"04?!,+0114
#34"@'$.1<4#34$@2,'$2(,.<4,!4#341@#?!,+01101*4\/0.214$!04@10 42,412$!24,!40. 4
?!,+011<4 $. 4 $)1,4 2,4 '$.$&04 1?0+(A+4 $+2(,.14 @!(.&4 $4 8,!LK,8*4 >"0!04 $!04
2"!00423?04,540/0.21G412$!2<4(.20!'0 ($204$. 40. 40/0.21*4Intermediate events
8"(+"48())4$550+242"04K,84,542"04?!,+011<4,++@!4#02800.4$4start event andan
end event*4>"0348())4.,2412$!24,!4 (!0+2)3420!'(.$2042"04?!,+011*49$208$314$!04
@10 42,410?$!$204,!4U,(.24?!,+0114K,8*4>"04 01+!(#0 40)0'0.214+$.4#04)(.L0 4
2,&02"0!4#34$.4$!!,84!0?!010.2(.&4$410O@0.+04,54K,84MV(&@!04ZN4
V(&@!04Z*4 Y3'#,)14 ,54 8,!LK,84 0)0'0.21G4 $N4 $+2(/(2(01<4 #N4 0/0.21<4 +N4 &$208$31<4 N4 10O@0.+04K,8

T!&$.(;(.&4 0)0'0.214 $!04 @10 4 2,4 +,))0+24 ,54 2"04 ?!,+0114 K,84 0)0'0.21*4 =,,)4 +,.2$(.14 $4 1(.&)0<4 +,'?)0204 ?!,+011*4 ` ,!LK,84 +$..,24 )0$/04
$4?,,)*4W42!$.150!4$+2(,.4,!4 $2$45!,'4,.04?,,)h?!,+01142,4$.,2"0!4+$.4#04!0$)(;0 4@1(.&40/0.21*4W418(')$.04(14@10 42,4"0)?4,!&$.(;042"04?!,+0114#$10 4
,.4!,)014(*0*48",4 ,0148"$2*4` ,!LK,84+!,1101418(')$.04#,@. $!(014$14(54
2"034 ( 4.,240F(12*4>"034$!04?@!0)345,!4,!&$.(;$2(,.$)4+)$!(23*49!,@?4(14@10 4
2,40.+),104$4&!,@?(.&4,5450$2@!0 4&!$?"(+$)40)0'0.21*4R24 ,014.,24$550+2410O@0.+04K,84MV(&@!04HN*

18(')$.04H

?,,)

18(')$.04Z

V(&@!04H*4-1(.&4,54,!&$.(;(.&40)0'0.2413'#,)1G4?,,)<418(')$.01<4&!,@?1

P[

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

]0$ $#()(2340)0'0.214"$/04.,40550+24$24$))4,.42"04$+2@$)4?!,+0114K,8*4>0F24
$..,2$2(,.4$)),842,4?$1204.,2014$))4,/0!4$4', 0)48(2"40F?)$.$2(,.145,!4+)$!(23*4E(.L14$)),842,4+@24$4?!,+01142"$24"$14#0+,'042,,4),.&42,4!0$ 40$1()3<4$. 4
1('?)34+,.2(.@042"04?!,+0114,.4$.,2"0!4)(.04MV(&@!04PN*
V(&@!04P*4Y3'#,)14,54!0$ $#()(2340)0'0.21G4$N420F24$..,2$2(,.<4#N4(.?@24$. 4,@2?@24)(.L1

Y?0+($)4#0"$/(,@!40)0'0.214$)),842,4 01(&.40F0+@2$#)048,!LK,842"$24+$.4
#0"$/04(.4+,'?)0F48$31*4C011$&014$. 4'011$&04K,840)0'0.214$!04@10 42,4
2!$.150!4 $+2(,.4 ,!4 $2$4 5!,'4 ,.04 ?,,)h?!,+0114 2,4 $.,2"0!4 $. 4 2,4 +,!!0)$204
!0)$20 4?!,+01101*4Y(&.$)14$!04@10 42,410. 4 $2$42,4'@)2(?)04$+2(/(2(0141('@)2$.0,@1)3*4 J,!!0)$2(,.4 (14 @10 4 2,4 +,,! (.$204 ?!,&!0114 #02800.4 2,4 !@..(.&4
?!,+0114 (.12$.+01*4 >('0!14 $!04 @10 4 2,4 )$@.+"4 ?0!(, (+4 $+2(/(2(01<4 ,!4 2,4 0.1@!042"$24$.4$+2(/(234"$??0.148(2"(.4$41?0+(A0 4 0$ )(.0*4\!!,!14$!04@10 4
2,4 0A.04#0"$/(,@!48"0.42"0413120'40.+,@.20!140!!,!*4]0?0$2(.&4(14@10 42,4
!0?0$24#0"$/(,@!<41@+"4$14'@)2(?)04)$@.+"014,542"041$'042$1L<4,!4!0?0$2(.&4
2"041$'042$1L4'@)2(?)042('014MV(&@!04cN*4
V(&@!04c*4 Y3'#,)14,541?0+($)4#0"$/(,@!40)0'0.21G4$N42!$.150!4$+2(,.4#342"!,84$. 4+$2+"4
'011$&0b4#N42"!,84$. 4+$2+"41(&.$)40)0'0.2b4+N4+,!!0)$2(,.40/0.24M'011$&0Nb4 N4
2('0413'#,)40)0'0.2b40N413'#,)4,54$+2(/(2348(2"40!!,!410!/(+0b45N413'#,)4,54
!0?0$2(.&4$+2(/(23

B=CD4$. 4-CE4$!04#@()24(.4$4"(0!$!+"(+$)4'$..0!<412$!2(.&45!,'42"04
&0.0!$)45,!'4,542"0413120'4', 0)<42"!,@&"41@++011(/04+)$!(A+$2(,.4?!,+011014 ,!4 $+2(/(2(01<4 2,4 2"04 02$()0 4 ', 0)*4 R.4 2"04 A.$)4 120?4 ,54 2"04 ', 0)(.&<4
?!,+011014#0+,'040)0'0.2$!34$+2(/(2(014,!42$1L1*4>"04?!,+011<48"(+"4(14.,24
cI

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

(/( 0 4,.42"041('?)0!4?!,+01101<4+$.4#040F?)$(.0 4$242"04.0F24)0/0)4,542"04"(0!$!+"3*4>"(14?!,+0114M+,))$?10 4?!,+011N4(. (+$2014(214 0/0),?'0.24#34$41(&.4

ijk4(.1( 042"04?!,+011h
$+2(/(23413'#,)*4D@'#0!4,54"(0!$!+"34)0/0)14 0?0. 14
,.42"04+,'?)0F(234,542"040.2(!04?!,+011<4#0+$@1042"04 0/0),?0 4?!,+0114(.4
2"04.0F24)0/0)4+$.4$)1,4+,.2$(.4+,))$?10 4?!,+01101*
B=CD4 $. 4 -CE4 $+2(/(234 ($&!$'14 "$/04 1('()$!4 50$2@!014 $. 4 0$104 ,54
@10*4 B,2"4 B=CD4 $. 4 -CE4 W64 $)),84 2"04 ', 0)(.&4 ,54 +,'?)0F4 10O@0.+014,542$1L14$. 4$+2(/(2(01*4B@24-CE41@??,!214?!('$!()34,#U
0+2X,!(0.20 4$??!,$+"*4R.4$ (2(,.42,4$+2(/(234., 014$. 4+,.2!,)4., 014'$34$??0$!4., 014
,#U
0+21*4 >3?(+$))34 ,#U
0+24 ., 04 +,..0+214 28,4 ., 014 ,54 $+2(/(234 MV(&@!04 l$N*4
>"(14 '0$.14 2"$24 2"04 ,#U
0+24 ?!010.20 4 (14 2"04 !01@)24 ,54 2"04 $+2(/(234 $. 4 (24 (14
?$110 4,.42,42"04.0F24$+2(/(23*4Y3'#,)4,542"04$+2(/(234., 04+$.4+,.2$(.4!0+2$.&)014(. (+$204(.?@24$. 4,@2?@24?$!$'020!14$. 412!0$'1*4>"@1<42"04-CE4
$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4 01+!(#0142"04K,84,54 $2$4$. 4(.5,!'$2(,.4?!,+011(.&4(.4
2"04', 0))0 413120'*
V(&@!04l*4 $N4>8,4,#U0+24K,84$!!,814)(.L(.&4,#U0+24., 014$. 4$+2(,.1b4#N4D,2$2(,.4,542"04
$+2(/(2348(2"4(.?@24$. 4,@2?@2412!0$'1

W)2",@&"4 2"04 ,#U

0+2(/014 ,54 2"04 @104 ,54 ($&!$'1<4 B=CD4 $. 4 -CE4 W64
$!04 (550!0.240)0'0.214,542"0428,423?014,54 ($&!$'14$!041('()$!<42"034"$/04
1('()$!4'0$.(.&1*4>$#)04Z41",8142"04+,'?$!(1,.4,54'$U
,!40)0'0.214,542"04
28,4&!$?"(+$)4)$.&@$&01*4>"042$#)04 ,014.,24(.+)@ 042"045@))41024,540/0.214
$. 42"0423?014&$201*4>"034$!04.,240F$+240O@(/$)0.214(.42"04$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4
5,!42"04B=CD40)0'0.21*4W)1,<4 ,4.,242!0$242"04?!010.20 40)0'0.214$. 42"0(!4
(.20!?!02$2(,.4 $14 $4 +,'?)0204 1024 ,54 &!$?"(+$)4 13'#,)14 $. 4 2"0(!4 '0$.(.&1*4
>"04 +,'?)0204 01+!(?2(,.4 +$.4 #04 5,@. 4 (.4 2"04 12$. $! 14 ,54 #,2"4 )$.&@$&014B=CD4$. 4-CE4$..,@.+0 4#342"04TC94MT#U
0+24C$.$&0'0.249!,@?N4
MTC94HIZZb4B=CE4HIIHN*
cZ

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

>$#)04Z*4J,'?$!(1,.4,54B=CD4$. 4-CE4W64 ($&!$'140)0'0.21

BPMN

cH

Description

UML
activity diagram

Description

Y2$!24\/0.24(. (+$2014
8"0!04$4?$!2(+@)$!4
=!,+0114,!4J",!0,&!$?"348())412$!2

J,.2!,)4., 01G
B0&(..(.&4
,54W+2(/(234V),8

\. 4\/0.24(. (+$2014
8"0!04$4=!,+0114,!4
+",!0,&!$?"348())40.

J,.2!,)4., 01G
\. 4,54W+2(/(234V),8

T55X=$&04J,..0+2,!4
8())41",848"0!04
$4Y0O@0.+04V),8

J,.2!,)4., 01G
W+2(/(2340 &04
+,..0+2,!4S4(.?@2

)0$/014,.04?$&04$. 4
thenrestartson
2"04.0F24?$&0*

J,.2!,)4., 01G
W+2(/(2340 &04
+,..0+2,!4S4,@2?@24
MK,84A.$)N

C0!&(.&G40F+)@1(/04
+,'#(.(.&4,5428,4,!4
',!04?$2"14(.2,4,.04
?$2"4MT]Xm,(.N*4
W4C0!&(.&4\F+)@1(/04
9$208$34(14@10 42,4
1",842"04'0!&(.&4
,54'@)2(?)04Y0O@0.+04
V),81

J,.2!,)4., 01G
C0!&04., 0

V,!LG4C@)2(?)04T@2&,(.&4Y0O@0.+04V),814
>"(148())4#04@10 4@1@$))34(.4+,'#(.$2(,.4
8(2"4$.349$208$3*

60+(1(,.4., 0
8(2"4+,.2!,)4K,81

9$208$34J,.2!,)4>3?04
=$!$))0)49$208$34
U,(.(.&

J,.2!,)4., 01G
m,(.4., 0

9$208$34J,.2!,)4>3?04
=$!$))0)49$208$34
5,!L(.&

J,.2!,)4., 01G
V,!L4., 048(2"4K,81

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

9$208$34J,.2!,)4
>3?0G4(.+)@1(/0<4
0/0.2X4#$10 <4+,'?)0F
R.20!'0 ($2040/0.21G4
i>"!,8(.&k41(&.$)4$. 4
'011$&0

Y0. 4Y(&.$)4W+2(/(234
W+2(,.

R.20!'0 ($2040/0.21G4
iJ$2+"(.&k41(&.$)4$. 4
'011$&0

]0+0(/04Y(&.$)4W+2(/(234W+2(,.

Timerintermediate
0/0.2

W+2(,.4,54$++0?242('04
0/0.24&0.0!$2(.&

W.4W+2(/(234(14$4&0.0!(+420!'45,!48,!L42"$24
+,'?$.34(.4$4=!,+011*4
W.4W+2(/(234+$.4#04
$2,'(+4,!4+,'?,@. *

W+2(,.45!,'4J,'?)0204
W+2(/(2(01<4V@. $'0.2$)4W+2(/(2(01<4
Y2!@+2@!0 4W+2(/(2(01<4
J,'?)0204Y2!@+2@!0 4
W+2(/(2(01

>"0423?014,54W+2(/(2(0142"$24$!04$4?$!24
,54$4=!,+0114C, 0)4
$!0G4Y@#X4=!,+0114$. 4
>$1L*4W4Y@#X=!,+0114
(14$4+,'?,@. 4W+2(/(2342"$24(14(.+)@ 0 4
8(2"(.4$4=!,+011*4R24(14
+,'?,@. 4(.42"$24(24
+$.4#04#!,L0.4 ,8.4
(.2,4$4A.0!4)0/0)4,54
02$()42"!,@&"4$41024,54
1@#XW+2(/(2(01*

Y@#XW+2(/(23

2. Exemplary logistic process model

R.4#@1(.011<4),&(12(+14'$34"$/040(2"0!4$.4(.20!.$)45,+@14M(.#,@. 4),&(12(+1N4 ,!4 $.4 0F20!.$)4 5,+@14 M,@2#,@. 4 ),&(12(+1N<4 +,/0!(.&4 2"04 K,84 $. 4 12,!$&04,54'$20!($)145!,'4?,(.24,54,!(&(.42,4?,(.24,54+,.1@'?2(,.4M1@??)3X+"$(.4
'$.$&0'0.2N*4>"04'$(.45@.+2(,.14,54$4O@$)(A0 4),&(12(+($.4(.+)@ 04(./0.2,!34 '$.$&0'0.2<4 ?@!+"$1(.&<4 2!$.1?,!2$2(,.<4 8$!0",@1(.&<4 '$20!($)4 "$.)(.&<4 ?$+L$&(.&<4 10+@!(23<4 +,.1@)2$2(,.<4 $. 4 2"04 ,!&$.(;(.&4 $. 4 ?)$..(.&4
,542"0104$+2(/(2(01*4]01?,.1(/04),&(12(+1413120'4$))4$),.&42"041@??)34+"$(.4(14
10/0!0)34 0$)(.&48(2"48,!LK,84'$.$&0'0.2413120'*4E,&(12(+($.14+,'#(.04
$4?!,5011(,.$)4L.,8)0 &04,540$+"4,542"01045@.+2(,.142,4+,,! (.$204!01,@!+014
(.4$.4,!&$.(;$2(,.*
\F$'?)014,542"04@104,54B=CD4 ($&!$'14+$.4#045,@. 4(.42"04)(20!$2@!04
Mn"$##$;(4 024 $)*4 HIZP$b4n"$##$;(4 024 $)*4 HIZP#b4n,.(081L(4 024 $)*4 HIIQN*4
cP

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

>"04 $!2(+)04 Mn,.(081L(4 024 $)*4 HIIQN4 01+!(#014 $4 1('?)04 ', 0)4 ,54 ),&(12(+4
+"$(.14(.48"(+"4$ (2(,.$))34=02!(4.021480!04@10 42,41('@)$2042"04?!,+01101*4
R.42"(1410+2(,.4B@1(.0114=!,+0114C, 0)4$. 4D,2$2(,.4(14@10 42,4!0?!010.242"04
5@.+2(,.$)412!@+2@!04$. 4$+2(/(2(014,54!050!0.+04),&(12(+1413120'4$??)(+$#)04
(.41'$))4$. 4'0 (@'40.20!?!(1014MYC\N40./(!,.'0.2*4B0),84$!040F$'?)014
,54', 0))(.&42"0428,4?!,+01101G4C@)2(', $)4E,&(12(+14J"$(.14$. 4=!, @+2(,.4E,&(12(+1*

2.1. Modellingof multimodallogistics chains

C@)2(', $)4 ),&(12(+4 +"$(.4 (14 2"04 (.20!+,..0+20 4 1024 ,54 #@1(.0114 ?!,+0@!014 $. 4 #@1(.0114 ?$!2.0!14 2"$24 '$.$&04 2"04 K,84 ,54 &,, 14 $. 4 (.5,!'$2(,.45!,'42"04,.04?,(.240*&*4?!, @+2(,.<42"!,@&"4(.20!'0 ($204., 01<42,42"04
$.,2"0!4 ,.04 0*&*4 2,4 2"04 0. 4 +,.1@'0!*4 R.4 2"(14 0F$'?)04 8())4 #04 ?!010.20 4
$4 ?!,#)0'<4 (.4 8"(+"4 2"04 2!$.1?,!2$2(,.4 @.(24 (14 $4 1(.&)04 +,.2$(.0!*4 R.4 1@+"4
$41(2@$2(,.4804+$.4 (12(.&@(1"42"!004#$1(+423?014,54., 01G
S4 !,$ 420!'(.$)<
S4 2!$(.420!'(.$)<
S4 10$4?,!2*
\$+"4 ,54 2"!004 '0$.14 ,54 2!$.1?,!24 (14 01+!(#0 4 #34 #@1(.0114 ?!,+0114 (.4
B=C4 D,2$2(,.*4 V(&@!04 Q4 ?!010.214 0F0'?)$!34 ', 0)4 ,54 2"04 >!$(.4 >0!'(.$)4
., 04', 0))0 4(.4B=CD*4],$ 4>!$.1?,!24=$!2<4>!$(.4>0!'(.$)4$. 4>!$(.4
>!$.1?,!24=$!24$!04( 0.2(A0 4$14?,,)14S4)$.01*4W41(.&)04+,..0+2(,.4#02800.4
28,4 20!'(.$)14 +$.4 #04 01+!(#0 4 #34 ,.04 ,!4 ',!04 ?!,+01101<4 0?0. (.&4 ,.4
.@'#0!4,54?"$1014,542!$.1?,!2$2(,.412$&0*
V(&@!04Q*4B@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0)4,542"0420!'(.$)4., 04@1(.&4B=C4D,2$2(,.

44

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

>"04 E(.L14 ., 014 M0/0.21N4 '$L04 ?,11(#)04 2,4 +,..0+24 ', 0)14 ,54 $.,2"0!4
20!'(.$)1*4>"(14', 0)45,+@1014,.42"04K,84,54#@1(.0114?!,+011014$. 4!0)$2(,.1"(?14 #02800.4 2"0'*4 R.5,!'$2(,.4 ?!,+011014 1@+"4 $14 2"04 !0+0(/(.&4 $. 4
10. (.&48$3#())14$. 4'$.$&04,5412,!$&04+,.2$(.0!14(14,.)341(&.$))0 *4=!,+011014(.42"0420!'(.$)4., 048$14$)1,4', 0))0 4@1(.&4-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4
MV(&@!04^N*4R.42"(14+$1042"04 ($&!$'4(145,+@10 4,.4?!,+011014,54!0&(12!$2(,.4
$. 4?!,+011(.&*
V(&@!04^*4B@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0)4,542"0420!'(.$)4., 04@1(.&4-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'

2.2. Example of modellingof the inbound logistic system

>"04 $!+"(20+2@!04 ,54 (.#,@. 4 ),&(12(+14 13120'4 (14 ,!&$.(;0 4 (.2,4 1'$))0!4
?$!214$141@#X13120'14$. 4$.$)32(+$))34 0/0),?0 *4W.$)31(14$. 4( 0.2(A+$2(,.4
,54B=C4!0O@(!0'0.2145,!4),&(12(+1413120'4(142"04A!124120?4(.42"04', 0))(.&*4
>"04 5,)),8(.&4 0F$'?)04 +,.+0!.14 2"04 ?!, @+2(,.4 ),&(12(+1*4 >"04 ?!, @+2(,.4
),&(12(+14+,.+0!.14),&(12(+4?!,+0110148(2"(.4$4/$)@04$ (.&413120'*4R24$('14
2,40.1@!042"$240$+"4'$+"(.04$. 48,!L12$2(,.4!0+0(/0142"04!0O@(!0 4?!, @+24
(.42"04!0O@(!0 4O@$.2(234$. 4O@$)(234$242"04!0O@(!0 42('0*4>"040110.+04,542"04
+,.+0!.4(142,412!0$')(.04$. 4+,.2!,)42"04K,842"!,@&"4/$)@0X$ (.&4?!,+011014$. 42,40)('(.$2041@?0!K@,@14?!,+01101*4=!, @+2(,.4),&(12(+14+$.4,?0!$204
(.40F(12(.&4$1480))4$14.084'$.@5$+2@!0*
B=CD4 ($&!$'4 $14 $4 ?!, @+2(,.4 ', 0)4 $24 (214 "(&"0124 ,'$(.4 )0/0)4 !0?!010.2145@)A)'0.24,542"048,!L4,! 0!4$14!01?,. (.&42,42"04!0+0(/0 4+@12,'0!4
cl

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

,! 0!*4Y$)014$. 4o@$)(23460?$!2'0.214$!04( 0.2(A0 4$1410?$!$20)34#)$+L4#,F4

)$.01<4C$.@5$+2@!0!4$14$#12!$+24?,,)48(2"4=!, @+2(,.460?$!2'0.24$. 4Y",?4
K,,!4$14)$.01*4R.42"04C$.@5$+2@!0!4?,,)42"0410O@0.2($)4K,84,54?!,+011014(14
'$??0 4,@242"!,@&"4+,..0+2(.&42"0'45!,'4$412$!240/0.24@?42,4$.40. 40/0.24
@1(.&4"$??34K,8420+".(O@04MV(&@!04eN*4>"04?!, @+2(,.4?!,+0114(142!(&&0!0 4
#34 ` ,!L4 ,! 0!4 iY2$!2k4 0/0.24 '011$&04 5!,'4 Y$)014 0?$!2'0.2*4 J,))$?10 4
1@#X?!,+0114,54==4!0O@(!0'0.24(.48"(+"4$4i?)@1k41(&.4(.42"04),80!X+0.2!04,54
2"041"$?04(. (+$20142"$242"04$+2(/(234(14$41@#X?!,+0114$. 4"$14$4),80!4)0/0)4,54
02$()4MV(&@!04[$N*4]01?0+2(/0)342"045,!'$2(,.4,541@#X?!,+011014$)1,4$??)(014
2,42"04$+2(/(234$14$4?!,+011G4=!, @+2(,.4=)$..(.&<4Y02X@?4T?0!$2(.&4=!,+0114
$. 4T?0!$2(.&4=!,+0114MV(&@!04[$<4#<4$. 4+N*
>"04 ==4 !0O@(!0'0.24 ?!,+0114 5,)),80 4 #34 =!, @+2(,.4 =)$..(.&4 =!,+0114
)0$ 142,42"04-? $2(.&4=!, @+2(,.4=)$.4Y3120'42$1L*4>"04?!, @+2(,.4?)$.4$. 4
2"04)(124,54!0O@(!0'0.214(1410.242,4Y",?4K,,!<4o@$)(23460?$!2'0.24$. 4` $!0",@104#34R11@04?!, @+2(,.4?)$.4?(+L(.&42$1L*4>"(142$1L4(1420!'(.$20 48(2"4
$4iC011$&0k40. 40/0.2*4V(&@!04[4())@12!$2014'0.2(,.0 <4+,))$?10 41@#X?!,+01101*4R.42"04.0F24120?<42"04', 0)4(.4A!124"$??34K,84(141@??)0'0.20 4#34
$)20!.$2(/04?$2"1<40F+0?2(,.1<4$+2(/(2(014$. 4!0O@(!0 4$!205$+21*
V(&@!04e*4>"04B=CD4 ($&!$'4', 0)4,54=!, @+2(,.4Y3120'

cQ

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

V(&@!04[*4\F?$. 0 41@#X?!,+01101G4$N4==4!0O@(!0'0.21b4#N4=!, @+2(,.4=)$..(.&b4+N4Y024

@?4T?0!$2(.&4?!,+011b4 N4T?0!$2(.&4=!,+011

>"04-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4'$L04?,11(#)04', 0))(.&4,542"04+,'?)02041+0.$!(,4,54'$20!($)42!$.1'(11(,.4$. 42!$.15,!'$2(,.4@?42,42"04A.(1"0 4&,, 1*4

R245,+@1014,.4(.5,!'$2(,.4$. 4?"31(+$)4,#U
0+24K,8*46$2$4,.4+@!!0.24?!, @+2(,.4$!04+,))0+20 4(.42"045$+()(234Y$/0 4R20'14pp+0.2!$)B@550!qq*4602$()14,54
2"04=!, @+2(,.4=)$.4$. 4R./0.2,!34$!0412,!0 4(.4,#U
0+214pp $2$12,!3qq*4>"04
-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4?!010.214+, 0 4 $2$4@10 4 (!0+2)342,4+,.2!,)4?!, @+2(,.4$. 42"04T=J4 $2$4@10 4$14$412$. $! 4,54 $2$40F+"$.&04(.42"04(. @12!($)4
$@2,'$2(,.41?$+04$. 4(.4,2"0!4(. @12!(01*4

c^

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

V(&@!04ZI*4 >"04-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'4$14$4'02$X', 0)4,54` R=4M` ,!L4(.4?!,+011N

Y,@!+0G4T8.412@ 344n"$##$;(4024$)*4HIZP$*

Concl
usions
>"04 $!2(+)04 01+!(#014 2"04 @104 ,54 B=CD4 ($&!$'14 $. 4 -CE4 W+2(/(234
6($&!$'14 5,!4 ', 0))(.&4 ),&(12(+14 ?!,+01101*4 -CE4 W+2(/(234 6($&!$'14 $!04
5,+@10 4,.42"04?!010.2$2(,.4,54(.5,!'$2(,.4K,84$. 4!01,@!+0142$L(.&4(.2,4
$++,@.242"04,#U
0+2X,!(0.20 450$2@!014,542"04?!,+011*4R.4+,.2!$12<4B=CD4 ($&!$'145,+@14,.42"04?!,+0110142$L(.&4(.2,4$++,@.242"040/0.214 020!'(.(.&4
2"04!@.14$. 4#!$.+"(.&4,542"0104K,81*4>"04'$(.4,#U
0+2(/04,54-CE4(14', 0))(.&42"0413120'4 @!(.&4(214 01(&.*4
E,&(12(+14 ?!,+011014 $!04 ?$!$))0)4 ',/0'0.24 ,54 !01,@!+01<4 8"02"0!4 (.4 0F20!.$)4,!4(.20!.$)4M0&<4'$.@5$+2@!(.&N4$!0$4$. 4?!,/( (.&4(.5,!'$2(,.4$#,@24
2"04',/0'0.2<4$1480))4$140.1@!(.&42"04?!,?0!4'$.$&0'0.24,542"(14',/0'0.2*4
B=CD4$)2",@&"4.,24 (12(.&@(1"4#02800.42"0423?04,542!$.1'(220 4'011$&01<4
(2410?$!$20142"04+,.20.24,54$4#@1(.0114?!,+01145!,'42"041$'04(.5,!'$2(,.*
J,0F(120.+04,54(.5,!'$2(,.4?!,+011(.&48(2"42"04+,@!104,54#@1(.0114?!,+011014(142"040110.+04,54', 0!.4'$.$&0'0.2413120'1*4Y,'02('01<4",80/0!<4
,520.4+$@1014+,.5@1(,.4(.42"04 01(&.4$. 4', 0))(.&*4>"04$??0$!$.+04,542"04
B=CD4 ($&!$'14(142"0(!41(&.(A+$.24$ /$.2$&0*4R.4+,.2!$12<42"04-CE4$+2(/(234 ($&!$'14$!04+!0$20 410?$!$20)345,!42"04', 0)4,542"040./(!,.'0.24$. 42,4
', 0)42"0413120'*4
ce

Modelling business processes in logistics with the use of diagrams BPMN...

-CE4 $+2(/(234 ($&!$'4 5,+@1014 ,.)34 ,.4 2"04 ?$!24 ,54 2"04 $+2(/(234 ,54 2"04
#@1(.0114?!,+0110142"$24(./,)/042"04?!,+011(.&4,54(.5,!'$2(,.<41@+"4$142"04
?!0?$!$2(,.4 ,54 $.4 0.+, 0 4 )(124 ,54 $+2(/(2(014 $. 4 0)0'0.214 ,54 ?!, @+2(,.*4
>"0!04(.2!, @+014,.42"04$+2(/(234 ($&!$'14$)1,4 02$()0 4(.5,!'$2(,.4$#,@24
2"04(.?@24 $2$4$. 4,@2?@24 $2$4,540$+"4$+2(/(2(01*4
>"04 @2()(234 ,54 #,2"4 23?014 ,54 ($&!$'14 +,.A!'0 4 #34 .@'0!,@14 ?@#)(+$2(,.14(.42"04A0) 4,54#@1(.0114', 0))(.&4$. 4$4/$!(0234,542,,)142,41@??,!242"04
+!0$2(,.4 ,54 1@+"4 ($&!$'1*4 V,!4 0F$'?)0<4 $4 +,''0!+($)4 13120'4 \.20!?!(104
W!+"(20+240.$#)0143,@42,4+!0$204#,2"4 ($&!$'14(.4-CE4$. 4B=CD*4>"0!04(14
$)1,4$45!0042,,)4,!42,,)14(.42"045!004/0!1(,.*4R.4'$.341@+"42,,)145,!40F$'?)04
1",@) 4#04'0.2(,.0 G4Y2$!4-CE<4W!&,-CE<4B(;W&(4=!,+0114C, 0))0!*4R.4
$ (2(,.42,42"04?,11(#()(234,54$4&!$?"(+$)4!0?!010.2$2(,.4,54 ($&!$'40)0'0.21<4
2"01042,,)14"$/042"04',124,?2(,.142,4/0!(5342"0(!4+,!!0+2.0114$. 45,!4B=CD4
($&!$''(.&4 2,,)14 +$.4 1('@)$204 2"04 ?!,+01101*4 R.4 2"(14 10+,. 4 +$10<4 2"04
B=CD4 ($&!$'4(142!$.1)$20 4(.2,4$4)$.&@$&04,54#@1(.0114', 0))(.&G4B=CE4
,!4Y]CE4MY('@)$2(,.4]050!0.+04C$!LX@?4E$.&@$&0N*4R24(14$)1,4?,11(#)042,4
2!$.15,!'4 B=CD4 ($&!$'4 2,4 B=\Ec` Y4 1+!(?24 2,4 +!0$204 .028,!L4 10!/(+04
13120'4MB$ @!$4HIZHN*

References
Z*4 W$)124/$.4 0!<4`*C*=*4MZ[[[N<4V,!'$)(;$2(,.4$. 4/0!(A+$2(,.4,540/0.2X !(/0.4?!,+0114+"$(.1<4R.5,!'$2(,.4r4Y,528$!04>0+".,),&3<4s,)*4cZ<4D,*4ZI<4??*4QP[XQlI*
H*4 W$)124/$.4 0!<4`*C*=*<4a,5120 0420!<4W*a*C*4MHIIHN<4_W` EG4_024$.,2"0!48,!LK,84)$.&@$&0<4o->4>0+".(+$)4!0?,!2<4VR>X4>]XHIIHXIQ<4o@00.1)$. 4-.(/0!1(234,54>0+".,),&3<4B!(1#$.0*
P*4 W$)124/$.4 0!<4`*C*=*<4a,5120 0420!<4W*a*C*<4n(0?@1;081L(<4B<4B$!!,1<4W*=*4MHIIPN<4
` ,!LK,84?$220!.1<46(12!(#@20 4$. 4=$!$))0)46$2$#$101<4s,)*4Zc<4D,*4Z<4??*4lXlZ*
c*4 B$ @!$<4 6*4 MHIZHN<4 C, 0),8$.(04 $?)(L$+U
(4 (4 @1t@&4 (.20!.02,83+"<4 (.G4 =(L(08(+;<4=*4M\ *N<4u$12,1,8$.($4R.20!.02@<4` 3 $8.(+28,4` 3v1;0U4Y;L,t34B(;.01@4
8467#!,8(049:!.(+;0U<467#!,8$49:!.(+;$*
l*4 B=CE*,!&*4B@1(.0114=!,+0114C, 0))(.&4E$.&@$&04MB=CEN<4$/$()$#)04,.)(.04$2G4
888*#?'(*,!&4M$++0110 4Z4D,/0'#0!4HIIHN*
Q*4 n"$##$;(<4C*]*<4a$1$.<4C*n*<4Y@)$('$.<4]*<4Y"$?(gR<4W*4MHIZP$N<4B@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0))(.&4(.4?!, @+2(,.4),&(12(+1G4+,'?)0'0.2$!34@104,54B=CD4$. 4-CE<4
C( )0X\$124m,@!.$)4,54Y+(0.2(A+4]010$!+"<4s,)*4Zl<4D,*4c<4??*4lZQSlH[*
^*4 n"$##$;(<4C*]*<4a$1$.<4C*n*<4Y@)$('$.<4]*<4Y"$?(gR<4W*4MHIZP#N<4B@1(.0114?!,+0114', 0)(.&45,!4 ,'$(.4(.#,@. 4),&(12(+1413120'G4$.$)32(+4?0!1?0+2(/048(2"4
B=CD4H*I<4m,@!.$)4,54B$1(+4$. 4W??)(0 4Y+(0.2(A+4]010$!+"<4s,)*4P<4D,*4[<4??*4
lQ[Xl^e*4
e*4 n,.(081L(<4]*<46;(0)(.1L(<4W*<4W'#,!1L(<4n*4MHIIQN<4-104,54?02!(4.0214$. 4#@1(.0114?!,+011014'$.$&0'0.24.,2$2(,.4(.4', 0))(.&4$. 41('@)$2(,.4,54'@)2(', c[

Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4

$)4),&(12(+14+"$(.1<4=!,+00 (.&145!,'4HIth4\@!,?0$.4J,.50!0.+04,.4C, 0))(.&4
$. 4Y('@)$2(,.4S4\JCY*
[*4 TWYRY4MHII^N<4` 0#410!/(+014#@1(.0114?!,+0114K,,!40F0+@2(,.4)$.&@$&04/0!1(,.4
H*I*4+,''(220041?0+(A+$2(,.*
ZI*4TC94 MHII^N<4 -.(A0 4 ', 0))(.&4 )$.&@$&0G4 1@?0!12!@+2@!0<4 >0+".(+$)4 !0?,!2<4
/0!1(,.4H*Z*Z*
ZZ*4TC94 MHIZZN<4 B@1(.0114 ?!,+0114 ', 0)4 $. 4 .,2$2(,.4 MB=CD4 H*IN<4 5,!'$)hHIZZXIZXIP<4$/$()$#)04,.)(.04$2G4"22?Gh
h888*,'&*,!&h
1?0+hB=CDhH*I*
ZH*4=02!(<4 J*4 MZ[QHN<4 V@. $'0.2$)14 ,54 $4 2"0,!34 ,54 $13.+"!,.,@14 (.5,!'$2(,.4 K,8<4
RVR=4J,.&!011<4??*4PeQXP[I*

lI