You are on page 1of 5

10 years of Nature Protocols PERSPECTIVE

The past, present and future of microbiome analyses
Richard Allen White III, Stephen J Callister, Ronald J Moore, Erin S Baker & Janet K Jansson

Over the last decade, technical advances in nucleic acid sequencing and mass spectrometry have enabled faster
and more informative metagenomic, metatranscriptomic, metaproteomic and metabolomic measurements. Here we
review key improvements in multi-omic environmental and human microbiome analyses, and discuss developments
required to address current measurement shortcomings.

Microbes evolved on Earth approximately 3.5 billion years because of the availability of rapid and inexpensive NextGen
ago and eventually occupied every habitable environment in sequencing platforms, it is now possible to sequence complete
© 2016 Nature America, Inc. All rights reserved.

the planet’s biosphere. Although microorganisms are known bacterial genomes in a matter of hours11.
to be responsible for key functions on Earth, such as carbon NextGen sequencing methods have used several different
and nutrient cycling, and determining the health and disease high-throughput platforms. The first was the Roche GS20 454
state of the planet’s plant and animal inhabitants, greater than sequencer, which was based on the polymerase cleavage of
99% of the trillions of microbes thought to exist have yet to be pyrophosphate, also known as pyrosequencing12,13. Although 454
discovered1. In addition, high microbial diversity has made sequencing was a key technological advance, and 454 sequencers
it difficult to study specific functions carried out by complex including the GS20 and GS FLX series machines and reagents
microbial communities in microbiomes (defined as the totality were used for over a decade (approximately 2005 to 2016, http://
of microorganisms and their collective genetic material www.genomeweb.com/sequencing/roche-shutting-down-454-
present in a specific environment such as all microorganisms sequencing-business), it had several drawbacks including high
inhabiting the soil or human gut)2,3. Fortunately, technological cost of sequencing reagents, high homopolymer error rates (i.e.,
advances over the last few decades have greatly facilitated errors in reading through the complex repeats), and surface
studies of complex microbiomes and their functions. Here area loading limitations owing to bead-based DNA molecule
we discuss advances related to nucleic acid sequencing and deposition that restrict the throughput and number of reads
mass spectrometry (MS) analyses that have enabled the obtained. The second NextGen sequencer was the Solexa (now
exploration and understanding of microbiomes across a range Illumina) Genome Analyzer (GA), which was introduced in
of environments as well as in our own bodies3–6.
npg

2006 and incorporated oligonucleotide array flow cells, reversible
chain terminators and bridge PCR reactions14. This technology
Nucleic acid sequencing is now routinely used to sequence DNA and RNA extracted from
Next-generation sequencing. At the forefront of advances in human and environmental microbiomes and can generate >1.8
microbiome research lie the impressive increases in the speed and terabases (TB) of data in a single run. However, the ultimate
throughput of nucleic acid sequencing technologies. In particular, goal was to sequence >18,000 human genomes (~3 gigabase-pair
there has been a revolution in next-generation (NextGen) (Gbp) haploid genome) per year at $1,000 per human genome
sequencing platforms as they have surpassed the traditional (http://www.illumina.com/systems/hiseq-x-sequencing-system/
Sanger sequencing method that dominated the field for nearly system.html). Illumina currently has several technical platforms
three decades (from 1977 to 2005)7. Sequencing a single bacterial including GA, MiSeq and HiSeq machines, with varying
genome using the Sanger dideoxynucleotide-based chain- sequence read lengths (100-300-bp paired-end reads) and
termination approach previously was a major endeavor that took throughputs to try and address this challenge. For example, the
years to complete8,9. The first bacterial genome to be completely maximum read length with overlapping paired reads on a MiSeq
sequenced using the Sanger approach was Haemophilus influenza9 platform is ~500-550 bp, but that platform has lower throughput
in 1995 (with Escherichia coli10 completed in 1997). Currently, than the HiSeq platform, which generates billions of reads per
run (Fig. 1). A relatively new approach developed by Illumina,
Earth and Biological Sciences Directorate, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, called TruSeq synthetic long reads or Moleculo, results in longer
Richland, Washington, USA. Correspondence should be addressed to J.K.J. read lengths (>8 kbp)15, and has facilitated the assembly of highly
(janet.jansson@pnnl.gov) or E.S.B. (erin.baker@pnnl.gov).
complex soil microbiomes16 and other biological samples17,18.
Received 8 June; accepted 19 July; published online 29 September 2016; Initial results from these technological advances are enhancing
doi:10.1038/nprot.2016.148 microbiome assembly into longer contigs16–18.

NATURE PROTOCOLS | VOL.11 NO.11 | 2016 | 2049

This revealed molecules by threading the strands through a Nanopore22. picotiter plate). few mRNA is another emerging and promising single-molecule sequencer. Oxford Nanopore offers an inexpensive way to 1 x 108 potentially sequence very large scaffolds (>50 kbp) and increase Illumina GAIIx (2010) genome closures and reconstruction of genomes directly from Illumina MiSeq v3 environmental samples.26 and in thawing permafrost27. the PacBio platform has become a 1 x 1010 100 robust technology for sequencing microbiome samples for de 1.26. Oxford the utility of metatranscriptomics in validating metagenomics Nanopore can detect DNA modifications like the PacBio platorm. All rights reserved. read length offered by any sequencer (>90 kbp) (Fig.31–34 and long DNA sequence reads of ~10-25 kbp and ~300 Mbp per soil27. and the longest maximum microbial communities28. Average read length in base pairs is log10-transformed and is the fill the complement of functional genes associated with specific factor of the points on the graph (larger points equal longer read microbial groups in diverse environments. Throughput (number of sequence reads) is represented on the our own research has defined the functional gene compositions y axis as follows: Roche 454 technology is per plate (i. Oxford and PacBio platforms are also 1 x 106 Roche GS FLX Titanium Roche GS FLX still too low-throughput for large-scale studies. One example is the single-molecule.e. (SMRT) technology from PacBio that relies on tethered DNA Metatranscriptomics has offered a wealth of knowledge about polymerases and zero-mode waveguides to direct light energy the expression of microbial genes in a variety of ecosystems. and in our own bodies3. NextGen sequencing of total community DNA (i. PacBio and Oxford MinION is per cell. The year of introduction of each sequencing machine represented is shown on the x axis. By contrast. 1. such as DNA methylation. is obtaining high-quality and large- molecular-weight DNA in the range of hundreds of kilobases or Roche GS FLX+ even megabase lengths. through small volumes of liquids19. In addition. PERSPECTIVE Read length (bp) Over the last five years.34. reflecting the immense diversity and biochemical potential of environmental microbiomes remaining to be discovered. However. we used or modified nucleotide bases without chemical modification metatranscriptomics to deduce which organisms identified from during synthesis.. these single-molecule sequences offer Illumina Moleculo future promise to the microbiome community. Emerging sequencing technologies that show great potential for faster and more Metatranscriptomics. spill in the Gulf of Mexico25.11 | 2016 | NATURE PROTOCOLS .28. however. Although Verrucomicrobia of the polymerase21. in water and sediment samples after the Deepwater Horizon oil Illumina technology is per lane. Most of the information obtained about microbiomes has been from the NextGen sequencing 2004 2008 2012 2016 of 16S rRNA genes as a phylogenetic marker for bacteria and Year archaea.. 1)22.23. Gilbert et al. transcripts mapped to their genomes. suggesting that they were Unlike current platforms.com). but for sequence Roche GS20 assembly applications. metagenomics) has made it possible to determine Figure 1 | Advances in sequencing technologies over the last decade. and understanding the relative activities of different members of has an average read length of ~1-2 kbp. A major challenge with these new Illumina GAIIx (2007) technologies. the PacBio platform can detect unusual microbiome in the English Channel. ocean25. PacBio RS II Oxford MinION Sequencing complex microbiomes. Single-molecule sequencing technologies.4..com/ Although advances in DNA sequencing have enabled a better about-us/news). cell or plate 10. real-time by specific organisms over spatial and temporal scales. Recently. human gut30. For example. some of lengths).35.20.000 the PacBio platform needs micrograms of high-molecular-weight DNA (>40 kbp) for library preparation.28.e. The main benefit of the Oxford Nanopore sequencer is its thumb-drive. For example. Mass-spectrometry-based metaproteomic and sized format that can be analyzed on a personal labtop computer metabolomic measurements in real time using wireless technology (https://nanoporetech.pacb. Because of the use of to determine the seasonal expression patterns of the marine tethered polymerases. understanding of microbial phylogenetic and functional gene 2050 | VOL. owing to the wobble soil genomes were active in soil16. The caveat is that Number of sequences per lane.000 novo and metagenomic assembly applications. the Oxford platform does not rely on actually transcriptionally dormant.e. Sequencing total mRNA (i. limiting the samples it Illumina HiSeq X Illumina HiSeq v4 can sequence. a vast majority of these genes have no known function. The Oxford Nanopore sequencing platform were highly abundant in the soil under investigation.24. http://www. DNA sequencing technology 1 x 10 4 improvements have enabled many discoveries of the identities and potential functions of microbes in habitats around the world © 2016 Nature America. Inc. used metatranscriptomics SMRT cell (Fig. PacBio currently offers including acid-mine drainage29.11 NO. the Firmicutes sequencing by synthesis but instead directly sequences nucleic acid genomes were found to be transcriptionally active. informative microbiome studies include single-molecule-based metatranscriptomics) reveals which genes are expressed npg DNA sequencers.

All rights reserved. The instrument and year it was introduced are shown on the x axis. The introduction of electrospray ionization (ESI) in 1984 0 Q Q FT itrap Ultra ctive itrap Elite ctive sion e HF mos 0 LC LT Q. the human gut46. additional technologies such to ameliorate reads and peptide assignments. 3). in the last two decades to refocus the ions while continually bars (values according to left y axis). resolution and throughput. huge ion losses occur36. metabolomics) 700 MS/MS (low resolution) Instrument resolution (x1. the analyzers allowed high-resolution studies in a select number termite gut45. The improvements in these areas resulted resolution scan rates indicated by yellow and blue bars (values according in a decrease in ion losses and higher sensitivity measurements38. A plot of the maximum resolution and MS/ There are still many challenges that need to be addressed in MS scan speeds for MS trapping instruments introduced over order to gain a deeper understanding of the molecular functions the last 15 years (Fig.e. in the early 2000s.e. ocean water of laboratories in the 1990s and into the 2000s. accuracy and MS/MS speed. providing greater insight into scan rates in both the linear ion trap (low resolution) and orbitrap microbial community phenotypes. sediments26. analyzing biomolecules in complex microbiomes by MS is still very difficult owing to the high dynamic range and thousands of components present in a given sample.31–35. However. to right y axis). we expect information on new and already studied npg included higher-resolution measurements and faster MS/MS microbial communities to multiply. the biomolecules of interest are ionized in the source. Thus. or phenomes49.000) 20 are produced under specific conditions. reveals that both of these features have of microbiomes5. In MS analyses of microbiome 400 12 samples.28. permafrost soil27.TQ- b FT a lo b r Q bit a Ex s Or bitrap -Ex rap F xacti ion L -E v Fu s u L L Ve os O O r Q of biomolecules36. interface designs using ion for both resolution and MS/MS acquisition is not usually advised for best funnels and transmission quadrupole regions have been optimized instrument performance. and native prairie soil16 technology made high-resolution capabilities more affordable for have been investigated using either advanced sequencing or MS additional laboratories39. One of the biggest obstacles in microbial been optimized to obtain the best possible biomolecule coverage community analyses are the bioinformatics and computational and accuracy in each measurement. These from a variety of increasingly complex ecosystems (Fig. NATURE PROTOCOLS | VOL. Quadrupole.48. respectively. microbiomes of varying diversity the introduction of the orbitrap37 in 2005. As the technologies continue Advances in orbitrap technology over the past decade have to improve. (high resolution). Microbiomes of increasing complexity: limitations and future directions 2000 2016 Developments in nucleic acid sequencing and MS technologies Figure 3 | Approximate timeline with examples of increasingly complex over the last decade have made it possible to analyze microbiomes microbiomes analyzed by sequencing and/or other omics technologies. 300 8 separated according to their mass-to-charge ratio in the mass analyzer 200 and finally detected. Illustration of magnitude. the orbitrap samples25. time-of-flight and ion cyclotron resonance (ICR) mass study microbiomes in acid mine drainage with low microbial analyzers constituted the majority of mass analyzers used until diversity41. metaproteomics) and metabolites (i.37.40. technologies. or both48 (Fig. u greatly increased the utility of MS measurements for assessment LT T Or Q. 3).. allowing less suppression in the ion Leaf cutter Human gut Permafrost ant colony trap and detector owing to the many molecules present in each microbiome sample. 2). providing metaproteomic or metabolomic 4 100 measurements with high sensitivity.49. PERSPECTIVE compositions in microbiomes. Inc. owing to the bottlenecks.40. Subsequently. This pressure difference accounts for more than nine orders of Figure 2 | The evolution of ion-trap-based MS instruments. using the highest values coupled. One challenge with ESI is that it is performed l ra p Ve bit Or at atmospheric pressure (760 torr). For challenges required the improvement of the mass analyzer with example.47. However. biome-specific as one-dimensional and two-dimensional liquid chromatography separations and gas-phase ion mobility spectrometry are also Microbiome complexity and multi-omics analysis timeline being used to increase the number of proteins and metabolites Extreme Termite Soil and identified. Maximum instrument resolution is shown as red © 2016 Nature America. Whereas ICR mass and complexity.11 NO.11 | 2016 | 2051 . it is also desirable to know which 800 Instrument resolution 24 proteins (i.. including leaf-cutter ant colonies42–44. first to use a combination of sequencing and MS approaches to ion trap. Examples of these include building gene catalogs complexity of microbiome samples. and enabling higher coverage of the proteins and metabolites in a given sample39. and how perturbations 600 MS/MS (high resolution) Scan rate (spectra/s) impact microbial functions. Banfield and co-workers were the respect to resolution. whereas mass analyzers 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 Year introduced normally operate in pressure regimes between 10-6 and 10-11 torr. with MS/MS low-resolution and high- decreasing the pressure38. However. The measurement of proteins and 16 500 metabolites produced by microbiomes in different samples has mainly been achieved using MS. and if the source and mass analyzer regions are not well how instrument resolution and MS/MS scan rates have increased with time to provide users with better measurements. These separation technologies reduce the complexity of environments hindgut Ocean sediment the sample before detection.

T. multi-kb reads resolve complex populations and in addition to the development of bioinformatics programs that detect rare microorganisms. 66–74 (2004). A sequencing method based on real-time integrate the data and provide meaningful biological insights.A. Heather. G. 507–508 (2015). Yamashita. Loman. 9.K. Jansson. J. Science 350. Zero-mode waveguides for single-molecule analysis at do not currently exist. Research (Genomic Science Program) and the Microbiomes in Transition (MinT) 28. USA 113. M. Negative ion source production with electrospray gut—new insights into function. J. 3. et al. Science 299. Science 277.A. ISME J. sediments and the human gut. R.. Whole-genome random sequencing and assembly of Haemophilus influenzae Rd. et al. The sequence of sequencers: The history of sequencing DNA.B. Sea. B.11 | 2016 | NATURE PROTOCOLS .J. active layer and thermokarst Laboratory Directed Research and Development Initiative at the Pacific Northwest bog soil microbiomes. Q. et al.U. L. Initiative with funding from several federal agencies. Locey. e00045-16 © 2016 Nature America. Several other challenges that need microbiomes. Genomic Sci. M & Nyrén. 30. J. USA 105. genomes rather than sequence fragments directly from complex 8. metatranscriptome and single-cell better predictions of the impacts of these changes and facilitating sequencing reveal microbial response to Deepwater Horizon oil spill. J. Nature 437. Nicklen.. (2016). A. sufficient storage and analysis options for terabytes to petabytes 11.C. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is a multi-program 29. Willing BP. et al. & Chain. and more informative nucleic acid sequencing and MS analyses.D. 3. Johnson and C. et al. This research was supported by the Pan-omics Program that 27. 19. All rights reserved.R. to this work and commented on the manuscript at all stages.K. Comolli.nature. R. Metagenomes and metatranscriptomes from the L4 long- 2. Shi. such as higher-resolution ion-mobility high concentrations. S. Murray. higher speed. Tyson. P. Eppley. K. Sci. et al. Nature 480.R. 30. Voskoboynik. Margulies. R. C. assembly of large metagenomes and metatranscriptomes16. 1844–1854. The successes and aspirations. Noll. 534–543 (2015). D. Alivisatos. 208–212 (2015). et al. 8. Real-time DNA sequencing from single polymerase molecules. Moleculo long-read sequencing facilitates assembly and microbiomes5. et al.. pyrophosphate. & Lennon. assembly of complete 7. Brislawn for their assistance in response to Deepwater Horizon oil spill. et al. Mass Spectrom. Acad. & Banfield. of data. Proc. 12.A. PERSPECTIVE annotation platforms for improving interpretation and multi.A. I. ‘Omics’ of the mammalian 36. B. Opin. ISME J.. Curr. Community national laboratory operated by Battelle for the Department of Energy under transcriptomics reveals unexpected high microbial diversity in acidophilic contract DE-AC06-76RL01830.11 NO. E. 434–439 (2012). ISME J.M.F.. Makarov.. metagenomes. V. Proc. 40. Natl. Frias-Lopez.M.J. Thomas. 376–380 (2005). 1453–1462 (1997). 365 (1998). 88. Assessing the performance of the Oxford Nanopore the influence of the complex interplay between members of Technologies MinION. & Graham Cooks R. Ronaghi. & Knight. et al. The complete genome sequence of Escherichia coli K-12. G. et al. Acad.I. 363. 21. Shi. Genomics 107. Uhlén. III et al. Scaling laws predict global microbial diversity. industries and 15. Lamendella. preparing the figures. e3042 (2008). Blattner.S. can quickly analyze microbiomes from a variety of ecosystems. 266–269 (2009).J. 4.K. VerBerkmoes. to be addressed for better microbiome analyses include: extraction Diversity. 53–59 (2008). & Coulson. J. Jansson. Genome Res. 33. Such in-depth knowledge of microbial community phenomes 24. F. such as soil. I. 34.W. eScholarship http://escholarship. Biotechnol. Nat. technologies for metaproteomic and metabolomic measurements. The methylomes of six bacteria. 6. Hultman. Synthetic long-read sequencing reveals intraspecies We also expect the initiative will enable new technologies that diversity in the human microbiome. National Laboratory. Metagenomics reveals sediment microbial community npg ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank N. Detect.T. 1715–1727 (2012).45.A. 5. Stand. Mason. E.C. Accurate.J. the future looks very bright for microbiome 13. R.A.. 5.P. of biomolecules from highly diverse and complex sample matrices. Y. 682–686 (2003). J. and J. Acad. 2011. 1–8 (2015). eLife 2.. & DeLong. A pyrosequencing study in twins shows that gastrointestinal will facilitate a better understanding of how perturbations such as microbial profiles vary with inflammatory bowel disease phenotypes. Biotechnol. Natl. waters. throughput and dynamic range of MS terminating inhibitors. 5970–5975 (2016).. ISME J.J. 1–8 (2016). BMC Biol. 31. et al. J.e1 (2010). Sci. Gilbert.. J. DNA sequencing with chain- ecosystems. Hu. 18. Gordon. J. J.. Goltsman.. 6. Phys. Nat. These technological and computational Science 323. 183–193 (2010).A. Chem. J. N. Genome sequencing in microfabricated high-density picolitre reactors. Accurate whole human genome sequencing using Technology Policy (OSTP) announced a National Microbiome reversible terminator chemistry. et al.I. A. 64–69 (2016).F.J. 368–371 (2011). Science 304. White. Venter. Botryllus schlosseri. et al. research. J. Tyson. M. J.A. foundations focusing on improved technologies for understanding 16. M. Mason.W. Gastroenterology 139. 220–230 (2012). R. 3805–3810 (2008). J.J. Microbiome. and developing statistical and mathematical models to 12. Multi-omics of permafrost. J.W. 23. & Jansson. separations of peptides and metabolites and new databases for 20. 4671–4675 (1984). Nature 459. e00569 (2013). The genome sequence of the colonial chordate. Proc. S. all contributed uptake and conversion of simple carbohydrates. Nucleic Acids Res. M.R. Detection of large numbers of novel sequences in the metatranscriptomes of complex marine microbial communities. Science 281.org/uc/item/04p1x29k. J.K... Inc. 430–443 (2005). Science 269. 25. Metagenomic analysis of a permafrost microbial is funded by the US Department of Energy’s Office of Biological and Environmental community reveals a rapid response to thaw.. Performance comparison of benchtop high-throughput sequencing platforms. Lozupone. 496–512 (1995). Integrated metatranscriptomic and metagenomic analyses of stratified microbial assemblages in the open ocean. Nature 521. et al. USA 74. 1014–1023 (2015). Biomol. 1415–1426 (2012). Environmental genome shotgun sequencing of the Sargasso microbial communities on ecosystem sustainability and health.. et al. Zoetendal. 2052 | VOL. 9. PLoS One 3. Sci. biofilm communities. small RNAs in the ocean’s water column. F. climate change and disease affect microbiome functions. 26. 35. & Fenn. Laver. et al. Levene. A. Microbial community gene expression in ocean surface interests. 1464–1475 (2014). We believe this initiative will prompt even faster genomic binning from complex soil metagenomes. J. improved ecosystem sustainability and human health strategies. 69 (2014). Towards “Tera-Terra”: Terabase sequencing of terrestrial term coastal monitoring station in the Western English Channel. Bentley. & Knight. Nature 456. Mackelprang. & DeLong.G. Gilbert. The Earth Microbiome project: 37. J. Eid. improvements will be vital over the next decade for deciphering 11450–11462 (2012). enabling 25. Metatranscriptomics reveals unique microbial Reprints and permissions information is available online at http://www. 5463–5467 (1977). Quantif. 23. Y. E.. Orbitrap: a new mass spectrometer. the White House Office of Science and 14.M. Nature 489. 6. 133–138 (2009). 1. Challenges aside. Kuleshov. 999–1013 (2011). Metagenome. et al. ISME J. meeting the high computational RAM requirements for de novo 10.R. D. Sanger. 40. Fleischmann. 3. J.html. Jansson. com/reprints/index. Stombaugh.. H. O. the roles of microbes in their natural habitats and determining 22. Li.U. Biotechnol. J. Sharon. molecular assignments. Gilbert. 491–500 (2012). stability and resilience of the human gut microbiota. et al.C. N. The human small intestinal microbiota is driven by rapid AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS R. et al.F. A unified initiative to harness Earth’s omics integration algorithms.. Hardman. E. O. 34.K. Recently. R. et al. A. mSystems 1. 17. et al..B. R. ion source. M. Natl.S. COMPETING FINANCIAL INTERESTS The authors declare no competing financial 32. et al. R.

et al. Jansson. et al. 48. Science microbiota. Aylward.S. EDITOR SUMMARY In this Perspective.C. Rev. R. ISME J. R. R. & Bond. et al. Shotgun metaproteomics of the human distal gut 41. Microbiol. 389–395 (2014). F. Tang. A decade of metaproteomics: 43. 1. 3770–3778 (2013). Leucoagaricus gongylophorus produces diverse enzymes impact C. The fungus gardens of leaf-cutter ants undergo a distinct (2010). J. K. Verberkmoes. Wilmes. Community proteomics of a natural microbial biofilm. Mol. 79. P.11 NO. ISME J. 308. gardens. Biostimulation induces syntrophic interactions that 42. & Smith.O. Handley. Kelly.T. P. A. 294–312 44. theory. Nat.11 | 2016 | 2053 . E. Burnum. 45.K.L.O. Aylward. 3409–3417 (2015). F. et al. Janet Jansson and colleagues review the development of microbiome analysis technologies over the past decade. Advancing the high throughput identification of liver 6.J. Proteome insights into the symbiotic relationship Cell.. et al. 16049 (2016). Huang. Tolmachev. Proteomics 15. Proteomics 15. physiological transition during biomass degradation. between a captive colony of Nasutitermes corniger and its hindgut 40. 2766–2776 (2015). A multi-omic future for microbiome studies. © 2016 Nature America.S.S.D. et al. ISME J.M. Environ. implementations. PLoS One 10. Environ. K. gongylophorus. 46.E. et al. E. S and N cycling in a sediment microbial community. PERSPECTIVE 38. fibrosis protein signatures using multiplexed ion mobility spectrometry. Microbiol. & Baker. J. E. Ram. Mass Spectrom. The ion funnel: e0134752 (2015).. 1915–1920 (2005). 3. Baker.S. Enrichment and broad representation of plant biomass. with ion mobility separations. A. All rights reserved. and comment on the future potential of this fast-moving field. 29. 7. et al.. Heintz-Buschart. 179–189 (2009). where we stand and what the future holds. and applications.L. Microbiol. Appl. 1119–1127 (2014). 39. 161–164 (2011). Enhancing bottom-up and top-down proteomic measurements microbiome. degrading enzymes in the specialized hyphal swellings of Leucoagaricus 49. 5.. Rep. for the degradation of recalcitrant plant polymers in leaf-cutter ant fungus 800–816 (2013).V. the fungal symbiont of leaf-cutter ants. 47. npg NATURE PROTOCOLS | VOL. Proteomics 13. N. Baker. K. Inc. E. et al. Page.