Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Dorota Dziedziewicz & Maciej Karwowski (2015) Development of children's
creative visual imagination: a theoretical model and enhancement programmes, Education
3-13, 43:4, 382-392, DOI: 10.1080/03004279.2015.1020646
Download by: [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] Date: 05 June 2016, At: 11:18
Education 3-13, 2015
Vol. 43, No. 4, 382392, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03004279.2015.1020646
Academy of Special Education, Creative Education Lab, 40 Szczesliwicka St., 02-353 Warsaw, Poland
(Received 19 August 2014; accepted 25 November 2014)
Downloaded by [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] at 11:18 05 June 2016
This paper presents a new theoretical model of creative imagination and its applications
in early education. The model sees creative imagination as composed of three inter-
related components: vividness of images, their originality, and the level of
transformation of imageries. We explore the theoretical and practical consequences of
this new model. At the theoretical level, we argue that it is important to analyse
creative visual imagination as both a process (understood as a cognitive mechanism)
and typologically (revealing different types of creative imagination). On a practical
level, we present preliminary applications and discuss several creativity training
programmes for developing childrens creative imagination understood as the
effective and coordinated cooperation between vividness, originality, and
transformative ability of images.
Keywords: creative imagery; creative imagination; imagery development
Introduction
Imagination is the engine of childrens creativity (Vygotsky [1930] 2004). Studies into chil-
drens creative imagination have a long history but many important questions remain unan-
swered. Scholars have yet to develop creative imagination theories to the same degree that
models of divergent thinking, insight, or remote associations have been developed.
This paper opens with a short discussion of the history of studies of imagination.
However, our main purpose is to present a new model of visual creative imagination,
which foregrounds the prole analysis of vividness, originality, and transformative
ability. This model has become the matrix, on the basis of which we describe programmes
that develop childrens creative imagination. Practitioners working with children may look
for additional inspiration in the presentation of the imagination training Eureka, in which
stimulation is based on the described model and on the three elements of creative imagin-
ation: vividness, originality, and transformative ability. These are shown to be key charac-
teristics that are indispensable for the effective functioning of imagination and thus deserve
attention in educational contexts.
2015 ASPE
Education 3-13 383
own theory of fantasy a mental activity that results in the creation of something new, for
example, new images, original ideas, thoughts, compositions, new image combinations, a
new way of ordering them, and new interrelations. Accentuating the elements of newness
and value (subjective or objective), the author emphasised that creative imagination
(fantasy) rejects emulation, imitation, and copying. Moreover, he also characterised two
hypothetical mechanisms of creative imagination anaxiomatisation and hyperaxiomatisa-
tion. Anaxiomatisation is associated with the lack of determined direction, rejecting routine
ways of solving a task, diminishing the importance of commonplace views, and widening
existing categories of meanings. Hyperaxiomatisation carries out a stabilising function and
concerns evaluation of created imagery.
At the beginning of the 1990s, Ward (1994) presented the concept of structured imagin-
ation. In this concept, the operation of creative imagination comes down to generating new
fragments of knowledge within the frame of existing domains, for example, imagining an
animal living on a planet other than Earth, a person relies on the characteristics of a typical
dog. Conceptual expansion or providing new structure to notions (e.g. by adding new
characteristics) is responsible for this process.
The aforementioned theories emphasise the creative function of the imagination,
although they accentuate its different mechanisms. In the description of its operation, the
ability to generate vivid and complex imageries, the ability to manipulate the images,
and originality as the basic characteristics of creative imagination are often emphasised
(Ward 1994) (Table 1).
High and low levels of these three dimensions are of particular importance in edu-
cational assessment. Assessments of childrens creative imaging abilities enable edu-
cational activities to be designed so that they respond to their developmental abilities
and needs. We developed a new test, which provides us with the opportunity to assess crea-
tive imagination using this new model (Dziedziewicz and Karwowski under review).
theme of the ctionalisation is travelling with your minds eye to various countries,
cities, and regions. The programmes fundamental task is to stimulate the development
of a childs creativity (including creative imagination), as well as intercultural competences,
such as intercultural sensitivity and cultural self-awareness. Fictionalisation can also be
based on the presentation of a particular heros adventures. This can be a hero or a hand-
made puppet mascot, for example, Gacus the bat in the programme Upside down: the inven-
tive world of two- and three-year-olds (Dziedziewicz and Karwowska 2010). Not always,
however, must the hero be physically present in the classroom. Hero ctionalisation may
also be represented only in the book, such as Dragony Kai, hero of the programme Crea-
tive doodle: the adventures of dragony Kai (Dziedziewicz, Gajda, and Karwowska 2011a,
2011b; Dziedziewicz, Oldzka, and Karwowski 2013) or even in mind in role-play training
in creativity (Karwowski and Soszyski 2008).
In work with younger children, ctionalisation centred around the adventures of the
main heroes is usually very efcient in the development of creative imagination. Anthropo-
morphisation of the presented world and personication of the hero make it easier for chil-
dren to understand both described adventures and the hero (Piaget 1926). For example, the
creative doodles programme was demonstrated to be most effective among four-year-olds
(Dziedziewicz, Oldzka, and Karwowski 2013), although its effectiveness among ve- and
six-year-olds was also satisfactory. Stimulation of creative imagination for this type of
activity can be enhanced by the inclusion of pretend play. Because of this, children are
able to detach from what they perceive in the given moment (Duffy 2006). Also thanks
to such fun activities, young children naturally give new meanings to objects and hence
activate their creative imagining abilities; for example, pillows on the oor become an
obstacle course and a paper plate becomes a driving wheel.
During ctionalised classes with older children imagery techniques can be applied. The
purpose of these techniques is to activate and direct imagery processes. They are about
recreating or creating mental images, most frequently with the full involvement of the
senses (Gur and Reyher 1976; Scott, Leritz, and Mumford 2004) (Table 2).
Regardless of the type of ctionalisation, classes of this type should form a coherent
whole. All proposed plays and exercises should be bonded by the plot of a real or imaginary
story told by the teacher. Systematic organisation of this type of activity stimulates not just
cognitive, emotional, and social development, but is also conducive to developing a childs
imagination. In order for the world described during fun activities to actually take shape,
children must rst create it in their imagination. An evaluation study of the Creativity
Compass programme conrmed the effectiveness of ctionalisation in the stimulation of
creative imagination development (Dziedziewicz, Gajda, and Karwowski 2014). The
study, both in pre-test and in post-test, examined childrens creative imagination with the
Education 3-13 387
Table 2. Creativity Compass example activities using the SCAMPER imaginary technique.
Modifying verbs and control question Example activity Road trafc in Delhi
Substitute (What can it be substituted Task: Children sitting at a long table in the middle of
with?) which paper tape symbolising the streets in Delhi is
Combine (Can it be combined with glued. Each child draws a picture of at least two means
something else?) of transport, then, using questions from the SCAMPER
Adapt (Can something be adapted from technique, changes the selected features of the drawn
somewhere?) transport. On this basis, children draw a vehicle that
Modify, magnify, minify (Can colour, can handle the road trafc in Delhi, caused by a street
movement, sound be changed?) blocked by cow, which in the beliefs of Hindus is
Put to other uses (Can it be used for regarded as sacred and inviolable. At the end, children
different purposes?) put their drawings on paper tape, creating a long trafc
Downloaded by [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] at 11:18 05 June 2016
Eliminate (Is everything necessary?) jam and talk about their projects. They can also create
Rearrange, reverse (Can proportions be prototypes of vehicles, for example, with aluminium
changed?) foil. The play ends with the awarding of patents,
conrming the novelty of created vehicles
Discovery: Understanding the specics of daily life in
Delhi (jammed streets) and worship of sacred cows,
which embody the Hindu goddess Prithvi, Mother
Earth
use of the Franck Drawing Completion Test (Anastasi and Schaefer 1971). Prior to the
experiment, the creative imagination level of children in the experimental group did not
differ signicantly from the results of the control group. After its completion, there was
a statistically signicant increase in the creative imagination in the group of children
who participated in the activities carried out under this programme.
from their everyday lives. Curious facts about the invention are included, for example, aty-
pical uses or functions of the invention, thematically connected records, amusing or surpris-
ing anecdotes about the creators, and how the invention came to be.
The purpose of the imagery phase is to stimulate creative imagining abilities. At this
stage, the activities are focused on developing creative ideations that take shape from the
material of past observation, but signicantly stray away from remembered reality. More-
over, children develop the ability to create symbols and metaphors within the frame of an
image code. Animating the representations and making them dynamic are possible, thanks
to the use of, for example, personication, but also by means of imaging movement and
imagining fantastic stories and tales.
The stage of transforming stimulates the ability to change and control imagery. At this
stage, the activities refer to basic operations of transforming the representations, such as
Downloaded by [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] at 11:18 05 June 2016
Table 3. Example activities from the scenario that refers to the invention of a hairdryer.
Training stage Example activities
Preparation A new version of a hairdryer
Starting point: The rst hairdryers were used not just to dry hair, but also to cure
ailments, such as rheumatism
Activity: The children are to come up with an alternative use for a hairdryer so
that it could be used by representatives of other professions, such as a cook,
teacher, mail-person, etc. Then, children are to imagine the event they have
just invented where a hairdryer is used for the rst time in this unusual way,
and to describe or summarise it in the form of a story star (Buehl 2001):
Who? Where? When? What happened? How did it end? Listening to the
stories of their classmates they are to imagine these activities with their eyes
closed
Creative imaging Thoughts and words
Activity: The children are to imagine an extraordinary hairdryer that has human
features it thinks and talks and shows different emotions. Then, the children
are to select one emotion the hairdryer feels (e.g. curiosity, surprise, sadness,
pride, shame, anger, fear, surprise) and add the words it says and draw its
thoughts. The activity is preceded by a short visualisation that shows
situations where we experience various emotions. The children can draw
additional elements of the hairdryer that are unusual and that render the
character of the selected emotion. At the end, the children present their work
and imagined stories that refer to the cause of the described emotion
Creative An untypical photograph
transforming Activity: The children are to draw a representation of elements of an untypical
photograph on the basis of bits of a told story. At the end, they can also draw
other, optional elements that make it easier to tell the situation that the photo
proposes
Imagining instructions: Imagine that you are entering a room. You look up at
the ceiling and instead of a chandelier there is a hairdryer. Take a close
look at it. What colour is it? What shape? Is it on? [Draw it] There is
something green on the carpet and it smells. Come closer to it to look at it?
What is it? [Draw it] Something soft is next to it and it makes funny sounds.
Can you hear them? What might it be? Do you know? [Draw it] In the same
room, by an open window, there is someone standing in a very strange pose.
What do you think happened? What is this person doing? Who is it? Do you
know this person? [Draw it]
390 D. Dziedziewicz and M. Karwowski
Discussion
The theoretical model of creative imagination presented in this paper places special empha-
sis on vividness, transformativeness, and originality key characteristics that are indispen-
Downloaded by [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] at 11:18 05 June 2016
sable for the effective functioning of imagination. Previous research shows that vividness,
transformativeness, and originality may be effectively supported even among young chil-
dren (three- to four-year-olds) (Dziedziewicz, Gajda, and Karwowski 2014; Dziedziewicz,
Oldzka, and Karwowski 2013). Importantly, it is possible to support the development of
these elements of imagination in many ways and place different emphases in various inter-
ventional and educational programmes (Scott, Leritz, and Mumford 2004). Activities based
on artistic activity so typical for preschool classes mainly concentrate on vividness and
focus less on the transformativeness and originality of childrens creations. On the other
hand, typical activities that are based on the creativity training method strongly emphasise
originality, and leave the two remaining elements aside to some extent. This is why the most
fundamental aim of the programmes, which we briey discussed earlier, and also other
activities aimed at stimulating childrens creative imagination, should be to balance
imagery, originality, and transformativeness, maybe even focusing more on the latter. It
is perhaps justied to see a basic mechanism that is responsible for creative imagination
precisely in the ability to transform. This is why children should have effective support
in mastering the active transformation of their own representations.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Vlad Petre Glaveanu for his helpful comments to the previous version of this paper.
Funding
The study was supported by a grant from National Science Centre, Poland for the rst author [grant
number UMO 2011/03/N/HS6/05153].
References
Anastasi, A., and C. E. Schaefer. 1971. The Franck Drawing Completion Test as a Measure of
Creativity. Journal of Genetic Psychology: Research and Theory on Human Development 119
(1): 312.
Atwood, G. 1971. An Experimental Study of Visual Imagination and Memory. Cognitive
Psychology 2: 290299.
Barraca, J., B. Poveda, T. Artola, P. Mosteiro, N. Sanchez, and I. Ancillo. 2010. Three Version of a
New Test for Assessing Creativity in Spanish Population (PIC-N, PIC-J, PIC-A). ECHA
Conference, Paris, July 79.
Brtolo, H. 2005. Visual Imagery without Visual Perception? Psicologica 26: 173188.
Buehl, D. 2001. Classroom Strategies for Interactive Learning. Newark, DE: International Reading
Association.
Education 3-13 391
Campos, A., A. Lopez, M. Gonzalez, and M. J. Perez-Fabello. 2000. Aspects of Creativity Affected
by Imaging Capacity. North American Journal of Psychology 2 (2): 313323.
Duffy, B. 2006. Supporting Creativity and Imagination in the Early Years. New York: Open
University Press.
Dziedziewicz, D., A. Gajda, and E. Karwowska. 2011a. Twrcze bazgroy. Przygody Waki Graki.
Gdask: Wydawnictwo Harmonia.
Dziedziewicz, D., A. Gajda, and E. Karwowska. 2011b. Twrcze bazgroy. Nowe przygody Waki
Graki. Gdask: Wydawnictwo Harmonia.
Dziedziewicz, D., A. Gajda, and M. Karwowski. 2014. Developing Intercultural Competence and
Creativity. Thinking Skills and Creativity 13: 3242.
Dziedziewicz, D., and E. Karwowska. 2010. Do gryno gami. Pomysowy wiat 2 latka i modszego
przedszkolaka. Gdask: Harmonia.
Dziedziewicz, D., and M. Karwowski. under review. Measuring Creative Imagery Abilities.
Frontiers in Psychology.
Downloaded by [Aristotle University of Thessaloniki] at 11:18 05 June 2016
Shaw, G. E., and S. T. DeMers. 1986. The Relationship of Imagery to Originality, Flexibility and
Fluency in Creative Thinking. Journal of Mental Imagery 10: 6574.
Smolucha, L., and F. C. Smolucha. 1986. L.S. Vygotskys Theory of Creative Imagination. Paper
presented at 94th annual convention of the American Psychological Association, Washington,
DC.
Thompson, W. L., Y. Hsiao, and S. M. Kosslyn. 2011. Dissociation Between Visual Mental
Imagery. Journal of Cognitive Psychology 23: 256263.
Vellera, C., and M. L. Gavard-Perret. 2012. Is Mental Imagery Ability an Element for Identifying
Creative Consumers. http://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00851322.
Vygotsky, L. S. [y1930] 2004. Imagination and Creativity in Childhood. Journal of Russian and
East European Psychology 1 (42): 797.
Vygotsky, L. S. [y1931] 1991. Imagination and Creativity in the Adolescent. Soviet Psychology 29:
7388.
Ward, T. B. 1994. Structured Imagination: The Role of Category Structure in Exemplar Generation.
Cognitive Psychology 27: 140.