Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E
#1
28
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
KEY POINTS
Dehydration of >2% body mass deficit has been shown to impair football-specific performance, including intermittent high-intensity sprinting and
dribbling skills. Dehydration is prevalent in football players, especially when training or match play takes place in a hot environment.
Football players often start practice/match play in a dehydrated state, as indicated by measurements of urine specific gravity.
In football, the opportunity for fluid intake during match play is rare; therefore, an effective hydration strategy is required.
1
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
anaerobic performance are less likely to be affected by dehydration In another study, Edwards et al. (2007) demonstrated that post-
(Ali & Williams, 2013; Cheuvront & Kenefick, 2014). Some authors match (90-min; 21-24C, 55% relative humidity) performance of the
argue that reductions in body mass (i.e., dehydration) during a Yo-Yo Intermittent Recovery Test (YYRT) was impaired when no fluid
weight-bearing activity, such as football, might be advantageous was given to the players (leading to 2.4% dehydration) compared to
to force production and vertical jump height (Viitasalo et al., 1987). when fluid was provided (leading to 0.7% dehydration). Interestingly,
However, there is no evidence to support this notion. For example, another one of the experimental trials was a mouth rinse protocol
in one study, a diuretic-induced reduction in body mass by 2.5% had where players washed their mouths with plain water in a volume
no effect on sprint and power performance (Watson et al., 2005). corresponding to 2 ml/kg body mass, without swallowing the fluid.
Likewise, there was no correlation between the reduction in body Mouth rinse resulted in 2.1% dehydration, which also reduced
mass and vertical jump height (Watson et al., 2005), suggesting that the total distance run by the football players during the YYRT. In
dehydration provides no advantage for weight-bearing activities like addition, RPE was significantly higher in the no-fluid condition in
football. comparison to mouth rinse and fluid intake trials. Another interesting
aspect of this study was that in the fluid intake trial players drank an
McGregor et al. (1999) were the first to test the effects of dehydration amount of fluid corresponding to 80% of their pre-estimated fluid
on football-specific performance. In this study, ratings of perceived loss, replaced at time points replicating match play opportunities
exertion (RPE) were higher toward the end of the 90-min for rehydration. This protocol resulted in a body mass loss of only
Loughborough Shuttle Running Test (LIST) (13-20C, 57% relative 0.7%, thus representing a potential strategy to avoid significant
humidity) when no fluid was given to the players (resulting in 2.5% dehydration in football players.
dehydration) compared to when fluid was provided (resulting in 1.4%
dehydration) (Figure 1, panel A). Likewise, 2.5% dehydration slowed Most recently, Owen et al. (2013) examined the effect of dehydration
sprint time at the end of LIST in comparison to 1.4% dehydration on football skills (i.e., passing and shooting) and intermittent high-
(Figure 1, panel B). This study also showed that football-specific intensity running performance after the 90-minute LIST protocol
skill performance (i.e., dribbling skill) decreased by 5% from pre- in a temperate environment (19C, 59% relative humidity). Despite
to post-LIST with 2.5% dehydration, but was maintained with 1.4% differences in fluid intake (no fluid, ad libitum and prescribed volume)
dehydration. Altogether, the results of this experiment suggested and dehydration (2.5%, 1.1% and 0.3%, respectively), football skills
that dehydration of 2.5% body mass deficit increases RPE and and intermittent high-intensity exercise performance were similar
impairs sprinting and football dribbling skills toward the end of 90- after the LIST. These results are in disagreement with previous
min intermittent high-intensity exercise. However, 2.5% dehydration research demonstrating that dehydration negatively affects football
had no impact on football players mental concentration test scores sprinting and skill performance (Edwards et al., 2007; McGregor et
at the end of LIST. al., 1999). Explanations for the contradictory results might be related
Figure 1 to the type of performance test employed. The skill performance
test in McGregor et al. (1999) consisted of dribbling a ball through
A) cones, whereas in Owen et al. (2013) the test involved shooting and
20
passing a ball. However, it is difficult to draw firm conclusions from
Rating of Perceived Exertion
3
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
libitum, which reinforces the need for an individualized hydration observed in elite football players. It is therefore reasonable to
plan to avoid significant dehydration. Another interesting finding in speculate that referees are at as much risk of developing sweat-
this study was that players consumed fluid to replace only ~50% of induced dehydration as football players. Very few studies have been
their sweat losses resulting in 1.6 0.7% dehydration (see Table 1). performed with referees and linesmen. Da Silva and Fernandez
Other studies have reported that football players only replace about (2003) measured six referees and six assistants during six different
~50% of fluid lost during training and competition (Aragn-Vargas et matches performed in a temperate environment (20 1C, 77 4
al., 2009; Shirreffs et al., 2006) indicating that relying on thirst may % relative humidity). Referees lost 1.2 0.1 kg, corresponding to
not be enough to prevent significant dehydration (see Figure 2). 1.6 0.1% of their pre-match body mass. Assistant referees lost
Figure 2 0.5 0.1 kg of their body mass, corresponding to 0.6 0.2% of
their pre-match body mass. An interesting finding was that referees
6000 experienced a significant ~4% decrease in plasma volume, whereas
5000 assistants had a non-significant increase of 2.5%. While dehydration
4000 might have influenced the greater reduction in plasma volume
observed in referees, it is likely that the assumed greater distance
(ml)
3000
run by referees in comparison to the assistants could exacerbate the
2000 reported changes in plasma volume.
1000
0 In another study, the same group of researchers investigated
the effect of changes in the hydration status on the referees
Sweat Loss Fluid Intake performance (Da Silva et al., 2011). Ten referees were assessed
during three official matches (23 1C, 67 4% relative humidity).
Figure 2. Fluid balance in professional soccer players (mean SD; In one match, participants were asked to consume mineral water
n = 17) resulting in 3.4% dehydration. Adapted from Aragn-Vargas ad libitum while in the other matches they consumed a prescribed
et al., Eur. J. Sports. Sci. 9(5):269-276; 2009. volume of mineral water or a carbohydrate-electrolyte solution
corresponding to 1% of their baseline body mass (0.5% before the
Female Players match and 0.5% during halftime). When drinking mineral water ad
There is an increasing number of female football players across libitum, referees incurred 2.0 0.2% dehydration. The body mass
the world. However, the information about sweat and electrolyte deficit was significantly attenuated to 1.3 0.2% dehydration when
balance in female football players is limited to a few studies during referees drank the prescribed volume of mineral water and to 1.0
training; no data are available during actual match play (Gibson et 0.2% when consuming the prescribed volume of carbohydrate-
al., 2012; Kilding et al., 2009). One study compared the response electrolyte drink. A time motion recording system was used to
of female football players in two different training sessions on two determine total distance run as well as distance covered by walking,
separate days (Kilding et al., 2009). Results are reported in Table 1. jogging, running, sprinting and backwards running. Consumption of
In summary, sweating rate and electrolyte losses were small during the carbohydrate-electrolyte solution was associated with less time
football-specific training in cool conditions. More recently, another spent in lower-speed activities (i.e., jogging) and more time spent
study measured fluid and sodium balance in elite junior womens in the more intense activities (i.e., backwards running). However,
football players during a practice in a cool environment (Gibson et minimal differences in activity were found between ad libitum (2.0%
al., 2012). Results from this study are also summarized in Table 1. An dehydration) and prescribed (1.3% dehydration) mineral water
interesting finding of this study was that 45% of the 34 female football trials. These results indicate that the implementation of a hydration
players presented to practice in a dehydrated state (USG > 1.020 strategy as opposed to ad libitum drinking in football referees may
g/ml). However, sweating rates and sodium losses during training help prevent significant dehydration (i.e., >2% body mass deficit).
were low, corroborating the Kilding et al. (2009) study. Although However, more work is needed to determine the effect of dehydration
these results are in agreement with early studies suggesting that on referee activity levels as well as other aspects of refereeing a
women have lower sweat and electrolyte losses than men (Bar-Or, football match, such as alertness and decision-making.
1998), more studies, particularly in the heat and during actual match
play, are warranted.
Referees
One referee and two assistants (linesmen) supervise a football
match. The distance covered by a referee during a match varies
from ~9 to 11 km and average heart rate is ~165 beats/min
(Catterall et al., 1993; Johnston et al., 1994). Consequently, the
physical demand imposed on a referee is nearly as much as that
4
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
Type of Activity,
Study n/Level of Player/Sex Sweat Loss (ml) Fluid Intake (ml) Dehydration (% BML)
Duration /Environment
17 professionals
Aragn-Vargas et al. Official match, 90 min /
4448 1216 1948 954 3.4 1.1
2009 35 1C, RH = 35 4
Male
6 referees and 6
Referees: 1600 130 Referees: 320 60 Referees: 1.6 0.1
Da Silva & Fernandez, assistants Match-play, 90 min / 20
2003 1C, RH = 77 4%
Assistants: 790 190 Assistants: 250 90 Assistants: 0.6 0.2
Male
26 professionals
Training practice, 90 min
Shirreffs et al. 2005 2193 365 972 335 1.6 0.6
/ 32 3C, RH 20 5%
Male
Values are mean standard deviation. BML = body mass loss, RH = relative humidity, T1 = Training practice 1, T2 = Training practice 2.
5
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
PRACTICAL STRATEGIES
Education about the importance of fluid ingestion to football players
performance is fundamental and should start in the early stages of
their career.
Use the urine color chart before training and match play to identify
players who are dehydrated. Clear to light yellow (lemonade)
indicates a well hydrated state. Consider using urine specific gravity
(USG) as well. USG greater than 1.020 g/ml indicates dehydration.
Track changes in body mass during training and match play in
different environmental conditions to determine individual sweating
rates and hydration habits. This will help identify players who are at
risk of significant dehydration.
6
Sports Science Exchange (2014) Vol. 27, No. 128, 1-7
REFERENCES
Ali, A, and C. Williams (2013). Isokinetic and isometric muscle function of the knee Maughan, R.J., P. Watson, G.H. Evans, N. Broad, S. Shirreffs (2007) Water balance
extensors and flexors during simulated soccer activity: effect of exercise and and salt losses in competitive football. Int. J. Sport Nutr. Exerc. Metab. 17,
dehydration. J Sports Sci. 31(8):907-16. 583-594.
Aragn-Vargas, L.F., J. Moncada-Jimnez, J. Hernndes-Elizondo, A. Barrenechea, McGregor, S.J., C.W. Nicholas, H.K. Lakomy, C. Williams (1999) The influence
M. Monde-Alvarado (2009) Evaluation of pre-game hydration status, heat of intermittent high-intensity shuttle running and fluid ingestion on the
stress, and uid balance during professional soccer competition in the heat. performance of a soccer skill. J Sports Sci. 17(11):895-903.
Eur. J. Sport. Sci. 9:269276. Mohr, M., L. Nybo, J. Grantham, S. Racinais (2012) Physiological responses and
Arnaoutis, G., S.A. Kavouras, Y.P. Kotsis, Y.E. Tsekouras, M. Makrillos, C.N. Bardis physical performance during football in the heat. PLoS One. 7(6):e39202.
(2013) Ad libitum fluid intake does not prevent dehydration in suboptimally Owen, J.A., S.J. Kehoe, S.J. Oliver (2013) Influence of fluid intake on soccer
hydrated young soccer players during a training session of a summer camp. performance in a temperate environment. J. Sports Sci. 31(1):1-10.
Int. J. Sport Nutr. Exerc. Metab. 23(3):245-51. Sawka, M.N., L.M. Burke, E.R. Eichner, R.J. Maughan, S.J. Montain, N.S.
Bangsbo, J., M. Mohr, P. Krustrup (2006) Physical and metabolic demands of Stachenfeld (2007) American College of Sports Medicine position stand:
training and match play in the elite player. J. Sports Sci. 24:665-674. Exercise and fluid replacement. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 39:377-390.
Bangsbo. J (2014). Physiological Demands of Football. Sports Science Exchange Shirreffs, S.M., L.F. Aragon-Vargas, M. Chamorro, R.J. Maughan, L. Serratosa, J.J.
#1. www.gssiweb.com. Zachwieja (2005) The sweating response of elite professional soccer players
Bar-Or, O (1998) Effects of age and gender on sweating pattern during exercise. Int to training in the heat. Int. J. Sports Med. 26(2):90-5.
J Sports Med. 19 (suppl. 2); 106-107. Shirreffs, S.M., M.N. Sawka, M. Stone (2006) Water and electrolyte needs for
Catterall, C., T. Reilly, G. Atkinson, A. Coldwells (1993) Analysis of the work rates football training and match play. J. Sports Sci. 24, 699-707.
and heart rates of association football referees. Br J Sports Med. 27(3):193-6. Shirreffs, S.M., M.N. Sawka (2011) Fluid and electrolyte needs for training,
Cheuvront, S.N., R.W. Kenefick (2014) Dehydration: Physiology, Assessment, and competition, and recovery. J Sports Sci. 29 Suppl 1:S39-46.
Performance Effects. Compr Physiol. 4:257-285. Stachenfeld N. Assessing hydration in the laboratory and field. Sports Science
Cheuvront, S.N., R.W. Kenefick, S.J. Montain, MN Sawka (2010) Mechanisms of Exchange (2013) Vol. 26, No. 111, 1-4.
aerobic performance impairment with heat stress and dehydration. J Appl Viitasalo, J.T., H. Kyrlinen, C. Bosco, M. Alen (1987) Effects of rapid weight
Physiol. 109:1989-1995. reduction on force production and vertical jumping height. Int. J. Sports Med.
Da Silva, A.I., L.C. Fernandes, R. Fernandez (2011) Time motion analysis of 8(4):281-5.
football (soccer) referees during official matches in relation to the type of fluid Watson, G., D.A. Judelson, L.E. Armstrong, S.W. Yeargin, D.J. Casa, C.M. Maresh
consumed. Braz. J. Med. Biol. Res. 44(8):801-9. (2005) Influence of diuretic-induced dehydration on competitive sprint and
Da Silva, A.I., R. Fernandez (2003) Dehydration of football referees during a match. power performance. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 37(7):1168-74.
Br. J. Sports Med. 37(6):502-6. Williams, C.A., J. Blackwell (2012) Hydration status, fluid intake, and electrolyte
Da Silva, R.P., T. Mndel, A.J. Natali, M.G.B. Filho, R.C.G. Alfenas, J.R.P. Lima, losses in youth soccer players. Int. J. Sports Physiol. Perform. 7, 367-374.
F.G Belfort, P.R.N.R. Lopes, Marins JCB (2012) Pre-game hydration status,
sweat loss, and fluid intake in elite Brazilian young male soccer players during
competition. J. Sports Sci. 30(1): 37-42.
Decher, N.R., D.J. Casa, S.W. Yeargin, M.S. Ganio, M.L. Levreault, C.L. Dann, C.T.
James, M.A. McCaffrey, C.B. Oconnor, S.W. Brown (2008) Hydration status,
knowledge, and behavior in youths at summer sports camps. Int J Sports
Physiol Perform. 3(3):262-78.
Duffield R., A. McCall, A.J. Coutts, J.J Peiffer (2012) Hydration, sweat and
thermoregulatory responses to professional football training in the heat. J.
Sports Sci. 30(10):957-965.
Edwards, A.M., M.E. Mann, M.J. Marfell-Jones, D.M Rankin, T.D. Noakes, D.P.
Shillington (2007) Influence of moderate dehydration on soccer performance:
physiological responses to 45 min of outdoor match-play and the immediate
subsequent performance of sport-specific and mental concentration tests. Br.
J. Sports Med. 41(6):385-91.
FIFA.http://www.fifa.com/aboutfifa/footballdevelopment/medical/playershealth/
risks/heat.html assessed in May 7th 2014.
Gibson, J.C., L.A. Stuart-Hill, W. Pethick, C.A. Gaul (2012) Hydration status and fluid
and sodium balance in elite Canadian junior women's soccer players in a cool
environment. Appl. Physiol. Nutr. Metab. 37(5):931-7.
Johnston, L., L. McNaughton (1994) The physiological requirements of Soccer
refereeing. Aust. J. Sci. Med. Sport. 26(3-4):67-72.
Kilding, A.E., H. Tunstall, E. Wraith, M. Good, C. Gammon, C. Smith (2009) Sweat
rate and sweat electrolyte composition in international female soccer players
during game specific training. Int. J. Sports Med. 30(6):443-7.
Kirkendall, D.T. (2000) Physiology of soccer. In. Exercise and Sports Science, edited
by E. William, E. Garret, Jr., and D.T. Kirkendall. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins,
Philadelphia.
Maughan, R.J., S.M. Shirreffs, J.B. Leiper (2007) Errors in the estimation of hydration
status from changes in body mass. J Sports Sci 25:797-804.