Community in The Giver to eventually become a flawed and twisted Utopia?
Thesis Statement: While the
Community started as a noble attempt at creating a Utopia, eventually it lost touch with its own history and sheltered its members from all the pain of the world, leading to its downfall. HOW COULD YOU BEGIN THIS?
1) Rhetorical Question:
What kind of person would you be now if
you could never look back at all the mistakes youve made in your life? Can people ever grow if they cant look back? 2) Vivid Image:
A stack of colorful bound leather
encyclopedias sit, gathering dust on shelves stacked twenty feet high, untouched for centuries. Their pages turn brown and dry from neglect as they sit hidden from those who need them most. 3) Bold Statement:
He who never learns history is often bound
to repeat it. 4) Analogy or Comparison
The rampant, hatred and anti-Semitism that
overtook Germany before and during World War 2 led to one of historys most horrific genocides. Adolf Hitler and the Nazis killed countless millions of Jews in the name of racial purity. Their attempt at building a perfect race was eventually stopped and the lessons we learned from this time in history have stayed with us and made us more tolerant people. 5) Extended Metaphor
The Community in Lois Lowrys novel The
Giver is like a horse with blinders on, never being able to look around and appreciate things or look back and see where its been. 6) Definition
Dystopia- a society characterized by misery,
squalor, oppression, disease and overcrowding 7) A Quote
The worst part of holding the memories is
not the pain, its the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared. 8) An Anecdote
When I was a kid stores offered this thing to
pet owners called a shock collar. The point of it was that every time your dog would stray too far off, you could tug on it and it would give a mild shock to your dog and hed eventually learn not to drag you and the leash all over the place. My parents and I thought this was cruel. We refused to buy it. We also spent most of our time being dragged around by our German Shepherd who which weighed about 125 pounds and never got properly trained. He might have learned from a little bit of pain, but we chose not to expose him to it.
Notice, each of these openings has a
relation to the overall thesis, but they just HINT at the thesis. They dont reveal what your essay is about immediately. Now watch me take number seven (quote) and turn it into an intro:
The worst part of holding the memories is not the
pain, its the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared.
This quote, uttered by the Giver, a character in Lois
Lowrys novel, The Giver, speaks of the isolation felt in a world without memories. Indeed, the Utopian society at the center of the novel tries desperately to remove all traces of human suffering from the lives of its members. Books are kept locked up in a store room and memories are kept locked up in the mind of the main character, Jonas. While the Community started as a noble attempt at creating a Utopia, eventually it lost touch with its own history and sheltered its members from all the pain of the world, leading to its downfall.