You are on page 1of 2

Does one know that one is not a brain in a vat?

The brain in a vat is a philosophy thought experiment


about knowledge and reality, it is a notable ideas that claim
by Hilary Putnam. This is a modernized version of Rene
Descartess Evil demon, a concept in his Meditations on
First philosophy. These hypothesis both denying that the
external world existences, the whole world that our senses
present to us is just an illusion of our own mind.

The brain in a vat argument says to imagine our brain


are possible connected and simulated by a computer
program in a vat. What important is that no one can be
sure the he or she is not being in such a situation, then we
can not make sure that our beliefs about the outside world
are true. And to construct the skeptical this argument:

1. If one knows any beliefs about the external


world, then one knows that one is not a brain in a vat.
2. But one does not know that one is not a brain in
a vat.
3. So, one does not knows any beliefs about the
external world.

The reason why this argument became one of a


formidable challenge to epistemological externalism is that
here is a strongest premise to support is argument: no one
can know that one is not a brain in a vat. Because in reality
no one can be the men who go outside to seek the truth in
Platos Cave.

One of the problems about brain in a vat argument,


is quite logical impossibility to belief that his/her hands do
not exists in reality. So it means consider of our self-
knowledge and the basic senses, it is plausibly we have a
good enough reason to says hey, I am not a brain in a vat,
just look at my hands! But this reason in fact does not
provide any explanation about the external world
problems,we still can not sure that I am not a brain in a
vat.

The brain in a vat seem is an unsolved question to


us,whatever people says knowing that he is not a brain in a
vat just can not persuade every one this skeptical
argument is false, cause we dont have some kind of
Gods eye to check our brain.

You might also like