Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
A comparative study on various components of nutritional interest, such as water, protein, total amino acids, ash and minerals,
in mushrooms of dierent species (Pleurotus ostreatus, Pleurotus eryngii, Pleurotus pulmunarius and Lentinula edodes) was carried
out. Mushrooms were cultivated on the same compost (wheat straw added with 15% of sugar beet) and analysed immediately after
harvest to avoid any interfering parameters. The limiting amino acid was also evaluated and the relevant protein chemical score was
calculated. The moisture content of the edible mushrooms studied is high (ranging from 85.2 to 94.7%) and the ash contents range
from 6.9 to 10.5% on a dry basis. Potassium is the most abundant mineral element followed by magnesium. Total nitrogen varies
from 3.47 to 7.93% (dry basis), and P. ostreatus species has the largest variability among the samples analysed. The most abundant
amino acids in mushrooms, expressed as percentages of total amino acids, are glutamic acid (12.820.9%), aspartic acid (9.1
12.1%) and arginine (3.711.7%), but in the analysed P. pulmunarius and L. entinus edodes a particularly low percentage of argi-
nine (3.7 and 5.7%) has been detected. The chemical score generally ranges from 96 to 110%, the limiting amino acid being leucine
or/and lysine. # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
0308-8146/99/$ - see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0308 -8 146(98)00212 -X
478 P. Manzi et al. / Food Chemistry 65 (1999) 477482
pulmunarius (SMR 126), P. eryngii (SMR 172, SMR Detector (Camberly, UK) was used for mineral
173, SMR 133) and L. edodes (SMR 90), belonging to determination.
the Mushroom Collection of the National Research Amino acids were analysed by a Beckman 120C
Council (Montelibretti, Roma-I), were cultivated in an amino acid analyser (Beckman Instruments Inc., Palo
Italian farm (Castelluccio, Senise Potenza-I) and ana- Alto, CA,) utilising a column 320.9 cm packed with a
lysed immediately after harvesting. resin of polysulphonic acid and an ISCO spectro-
photometer detector (Hengoed, UK).
2.2. Chemicals An HPLC analytical system comprising a Waters
(Milford MA) model 501 solvent delivery system with a
All reagents (Carlo Erba, Milan, I) were of analytical C18 column 25 cm5 m (Supelco) and a spectro-
or HPLC grade, as required. Standards of amino acids uorometer model LS 40 (PerkinElmer) was used for
and minerals were obtained from Beckman Inc. (Palo tryptophan determination.
Alto, CA) and from Merck (Darmstadt, Germany),
respectively. 2.4. Methods
Edible mushrooms N Pa Pb
AA P. ostraetus P. ostraetus P. ostreatus P. ostreatus P. ostreatus P. ostreatus P. ostreatus P. ostraetus P. pulmunarius P. eryngii ferulae P. eryngii P. eryngii L. edodes
(SMR 122) (SMR 125) (SMR 127) (SMR 128) (SMR 129) (SMR 131) (SMR 132) (SMR 138) (SMR 126) (SMR 133) (SMR 172) (SMR 173) (SMR 90)
479
480 P. Manzi et al. / Food Chemistry 65 (1999) 477482
by performic acid to convert methionine into methio- utilised, may not be accurate for all the species of
nine sulphone and cysteine into cysteic acid (Schram, mushroom and may be partially responsible for the
Moore & Bigwood, 1954). Tryptophan determination uctuations. In fact chitin, the nitrogen containing
was carried out by isocratic reversed-phase high perfor- polysaccharide of the fungal cell walls, is present in dif-
mance liquid chromatography and uorescence detection ferent amounts in the various mushroom species and, as
after alkaline hydrolysis (Steven & Jorg, 1989). Protein a consequence, the multiplicative factor may not be
chemical score and limiting aminoacids were evaluated perfectly suitable for all the samples. A protein estimate
using the FAO reference protein (FAO/WHO, 1991). can be obtained from the sum of the amount of each
amino acid expressed as percentage of dry or wet sam-
ple. These last data are usually higher than the previous
3. Results and discussion ones but P. eryngii samples show a good correspon-
dence between the two values while, P. pulmunarius
In Table 1 the moisture content of the edible mush- shows a level of protein calculated from nitrogen higher
rooms studied is reported. The values range from 85.2 than that calculated from amino acids. The lack of
to 94.7%, conrming the high moisture content of these mathematical proportionality among these results could
products (Breene, 1990). This variability is exclusively be explained assuming a dierent amount of nitrogen-
dependent on the mushroom species since other interfer- containing compounds in the studied samples. Actually,
ing parameters such as post-harvest period, temperature, further studies now in progress bear evidence of chitin-
relative humidity during growth (Bano & Rajarathnam, chitosan levels considerably higher in P. pulmunarius
1988) and storage have been standardised in this research. and P. eryngii than in P. ostreatus.
In Table 2 nitrogen and protein contents on dry basis In Table 3 the amino acid content is reported as the
and on wet weight are reported. Total nitrogen varies percentage of the sum of amino acids. The most abun-
from 3.47 to 7.93% (dry basis) and from 0.35 to 1.12% dant compounds are glutamic acid, aspartic acid, and
(wet weight) and, in particular, L. edodes shows the arginine, even if in the samples of P. pulmunarius and
lowest nitrogen content. P. ostreatus samples reveal the L. edodes the percentages of arginine are not as high as
largest variability ranging from 4.55 to 7.93% (dry in the other mushrooms. The largest variability among
basis), while in the P. eryngii samples more homo- the amino acids can be observed in the P. ostreatus
geneous values can be observed (5.23, 5.20 and 5.30%, samples, while P. eryngii (SMR 172, 173, 133) seem to
dry basis). This large variability can be ascribed, as be more constant in composition.
already reported in the literature (Crisan & Sands, 1978; In Table 4 the contents of two unusual amino acids,
Bano & Rajarathnam, 1988; Ragunathan, Gurusamy, g-amino butyric acid (GABA) and ornithine, are
Palariswamy, & Swaminathan, 1996), to the large genetic shown. Both compounds are characterised by a peculiar
manipulation that P.ostreatus underwent. physiological activity: GABA is a non essential amino
A great variability can also be observed among the acid that functions as a neurotransmitter in the central
species of P. ostreatus in the protein contents, obtained nervous system by decreasing neuron activity, while
from nitrogen using 4.38 as the conversion factor ornithine is a precursor in the synthesis of arginine. All
(Braaksma & Schaap, 1996). This factor, even if widely the analysed samples contain these amino acids, but in
Table 4
Contents of unusual amino acid in edible mushrooms (mg/100 g). Data are means of triplicatesstandard deviation
dierent amount and, apparently, without any correla- lysine in L. edodes. However, the protein chemical score,
tion with mushroom species. i.e. the percentage of the FAO recommended level pro-
In order to obtain a nutritional evaluation of the vided by the limiting amino acid, is generally high and
quality of proteins from mushroom, a comparison varies from 110 to 96% in P. ostreatus and from 111 to
between the fungal essential amino acids and the human 102% in P. eryngii conrming the good biological value
requirements was performed. The levels of essential of fungal proteins. On the other hand, a low chemical
amino acid in P. ostreatus and in the other mushrooms score (53%) can be calculated for the protein of P. pul-
studied, calculated as percentage of the relevant levels of munarius but the limited number of samples studied
the FAO pattern, are reported in Figs. 1 and 2, respec- does not allow us to generalise this result.
tively. The limiting amino acid, i.e. the amino acid less Table 5 shows the ash and mineral contents of the
eective in providing the amount stated by the FAO samples analysed. The total ash contents range from
reference pattern, is leucine and/or lysine in P. ostreatus 6.9 to 10.5% on a dry basis and from 0.52 to 1.15%
samples, leucine in P. eryngii and P. pulmunarius and on wet weight. As regards the mineral constituents, in
Fig. 1. Levels of essential amino acids calculated as % of the relevant levels of FAO pattern in P. ostreatus.
Fig. 2. Levels of essential amino acids calculated as % of the relevant levels of FAO pattern in P. eryngii (SMR 172, SMR 173, SMR 133),
P. pulmunarius (SMR 126) and L. edodes (SMR 90).
482 P. Manzi et al. / Food Chemistry 65 (1999) 477482
Table 5
Ash (g/100 g) and mineral (mg/100 g) contents of edible mushrooms. Data are means of triplicatesstandard deviations
Edible ASH Na K Mg Ca
mushrooms
d.w. w.w. d.w. w.w. d.w. w.w. d.w. w.w. d.w. w.w.
P. ostreatus (SMR 122) 7.800.74 1.150.11 136.04.6 20.10.7 2682.353.0 395.97.8 166.12.3 24.50.3 23.51.8 3.50.3
P. ostreatus (SMR 125) 7.990.87 0.910.10 84.912.8 9.61.5 2338.245.2 270.85.1 177.95.6 20.20.6 34.31.1 3.90.1
P. ostreatus (SMR 127) 8.491.40 0.730.12 53.50.2 4.60.1 2965.2143.0 253.812.3 166.41.3 14.20.1 23.60.4 2.00.1
P. ostreatus (SMR 129) 9.130.65 0.600.04 57.40.5 3.70.1 3365.073.0 219.048.0 203.21.4 13.20.1 48.61.5 3.20.1
P. ostreatus (SMR 132) 9.701.30 0.520.07 25.25.7 1.30.3 3443.8109.0 182.55.8 161.410.0 8.60.5 25.97.5 1.40.4
P. ostreatus (SMR 138) 6.890.72 0.930.10 48.33.2 6.50.4 2184.667.0 284.59.0 165.33.1 22.30.4 23.68.2 3.21.1
P. pulmunarius (SMR 126) 8.350.77 1.030.09 103.42.1 12.70.3 2818.936.0 346.74.4 183.82.0 22.60.3 19.12.1 2.30.3
P. eryngii ferulae (SMR 133) 8.610.17 1.000.02 44.16.2 5.20.7 2611.087.0 309.010.3 134.57.0 16.00.8 28.412.1 3.71.5
P. eryngii (SMR 172) 9.160.26 0.760.02 50.41.1 4.20.1 3095.040.0 257.33.4 144.415.6 12.00.3 33.70.4 2.80.1
P. eryngii (SMR 173) 10.550.31 0.900.03 76.62.8 6.50.2 4054.3244.2 346.520.9 187.212.1 16.01.0 35.36.5 3.00.4
L. edodes (SMR 90) 7.080.33 0.710.03 100.61.0 10.10.1 2647.55.2 264.76.8 116.55.2 11.60.5 42.31.8 4.20.2