Professional Documents
Culture Documents
General Thoughts
The concept itself is an interesting one. Schizophrenia and
hallucinations are things that certainly invoke fear in people, so
because of their prevalence in the story, they allow for a lot of
mystery and a compelling twist. Mental illness itself is of course
the actual villain, and I think keeping that reveal for the very
end was a solid choice that helped keep tension throughout.
The pacing is great. We never stay in one place for too long,
which I appreciate in a psychological mystery/suspense film.
The purple theme throughout is a nice touch. The reveal that The
Color Purple is a favorite book for both Asha and Rameses did
sort of give away the truth that ALL of them are indeed the
archetypes of ONE of them, but I will admit that we had yet to
know who the ONE was. Of course Asha was the main character so I
assumed it would end up being her, but I dont think it was TOO
obvious. I would get some other opinions on this though. Maybe ask
others who read it answer the question: Did you realize they were
archetypes of Asha before Rameses killed himself?
You are missing a few details that could tie things together. For
instance, the stuff with the parents. Really spell out the
parental relationship within one of the flashbacks. And also maybe
consider adding another flashback that further perpetuates the
idea that Mr. Burai is evil and/or could have killed Kali. That
will make the end scene, with Kali standing beside Chanda and Mr.
Burai while Asha is writhing around in a mental institution that
much stronger. It will chill us to the bones when we learn the
truth that Asha was the one with the mental illness all along.
The moment with Mary and Luno and his alien friends is a great
callback to the Ryan and jock moment at the party. I didnt get
the connection until the end, and now Im like Wow! It is a
really great way to allude to the ending, without hitting us over
the head with it.
My only QUESTION is, is Kali even real? Were they really twins? Or
is Kali just another archetype of Asha? My instinct is that she
2.
Formatting, etc.
There are a lot of formatting errors throughout. My Premium
Evaluation would have included all of that, but just know that you
definitely have to clean it up in terms of formatting and
grammar/spelling. Nothing major, as you obviously understand how
to write action and dialogue, and how to jump from one time and
place to another, but there is still a lot of little details to
fix up.
For instance, when you do INT. CAFE, you could easily add to the
scene by describing something like this:
Asha, now 25, is tucked away in the corner of a busy cafe. She
sips tea from a ceramic mug, her eyes fixated on her laptop.
This also means that on page 2 when we see Asha in the cafe, we
dont need it to be capitalized, and no description about her
being the twin of Kali, since we already know that. However you
can say, Asha, now 25, is writing on her laptop...
Page 26 - the silence from the group after learning that Kali is
dead isnt strong enough. We need to see a strong reaction from
them. I mean, if these are schizophrenics lets see them have a
visceral reaction that represents their mental state. Another
option is to simply move Cains dialogue where he quotes
Revelations to right after the Professor says I assure you this
is no joke. The asking of permission to sit in seems too quick of
a jump, so if you cut those lines from Asha and the Professor, you
have a real moment between Asha and the schizophrenics that hits.