Relay Coordination Methodology PDF

Relay Coordination Study Methodology
ABB June 2008

ABB Relay Co-ordination Methodology
Department: Author: Status: Date: Language: Revision: Page:
PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 2/27
Table of Contents
Table of Contents .................................................................................................................... 2
List of Figures .......................................................................................................................... 3
1. Relay Co-ordination Study ........................................................................................ 4
1.1 Data collection and mapping ........................................................................................ 4
1.2 Overcurrent protection guidelines ................................................................................ 4
1.2.1 Conductors........................................................................................................... 4
1.2.2 Motors .................................................................................................................. 5
1.2.3 Transformers........................................................................................................ 6
1.2.4 Generators ........................................................................................................... 6
1.3 Time-current characteristic plots .................................................................................. 6
1.3.1 Curve Interpretation ............................................................................................. 6
1.3.2 Curve variations ................................................................................................... 7
1.3.3 Time-overcurrent relays ....................................................................................... 7
1.4 Co-ordination Settings & Criteria.................................................................................. 8
1.4.1 Selection of PSM ................................................................................................. 8
1.4.2 Selection of TMS.................................................................................................. 9
1.5 Procedure ................................................................................................................... 10
1.6 Points to be noted while doing relay coordination ...................................................... 11
1.7 Case Study ................................................................................................................. 11
1.7.1 Coordination of earth fault by fuse..................................................................... 11
1.7.2 Sample protection calculation for a sub-station................................................. 15
1.7.3 Earth fault protection for High Resistance grounded systems........................ 21
1.8 Earth Fault Detection Techniques in an Ungrounded System ................................... 24
1.8.1 Open delta connection of PT ............................................................................. 24
1.8.2 Core balance current transformer (CBCT)......................................................... 24
1.8.3 Earthing Transformer ......................................................................................... 26
We reserve all rights in this document and in the information therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties
without express authority was strictly forbidden.
INABB, CONSULTING
List of Figures
Figure 1-1 System considered for earth fault coordination by fuse......................................... 11
Figure 1-2 Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal Without CTIs ..... 12
Figure 1-3 Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal With CTIs .......... 13
Figure 1-4Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal With proposed relay
................................................................................................................................................. 14
Figure 1-5 Sample Calculation for a Sub-Station .................................................................... 15
Figure 1-6 3-phase fault on LV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1.............................................. 18
Figure 1-7 3-phase fault on HV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1 ............................................. 19
Figure 1-8 3-phase fault on LV side of Smelter Auxiliary T/F 1............................................... 20
Figure 1-9 Sample protection calculation for high resistance grounded systems................... 21
Figure 1-10 Single- phase to ground fault on Unit LV T/F primary side .................................. 23
Figure 1-11 Open delta connection of PT ............................................................................ 24
Figure 1-12 Core balance CT encircling all phase and neutral conductors ............................ 25
Figure 1-13 Physical installation of core balance CT for shielded cable termination.............. 26
Figure 1-14 Connection diagram for earthing transformer ...................................................... 27
INABB, CONSULTING
1. Relay Co-ordination Study

Relay co-ordination implies quality of selectivity among the protective devices, particularly in
over-current protection devices. Over-current devices represent the largest installed base of
protective equipment in any power system and may be considered the backbone of any
protection strategy.
Over-currents in a power distribution system can occur as a result of both normal (motor
starting, transformer inrush, etc.) and abnormal (ground fault, line-to-line fault, etc.)
conditions. In either case, the basic purpose of current-sensing protective devices is to detect
the abnormal over-current with proper coordination, to operate selectively and to protect
equipment properly by minimizing the outage of the rest of the system.
Relay operating characteristics and their setting must be carefully selected in order to achieve
selectivity. The aim is to switch off only the fault component and to leave the rest of the power
system in service in order to minimize supply interruptions and to ensure stability. Protection
should be as sensitive as possible to detect faults at the lowest possible current level of both
phase and ground faults. However, it should remain stable under all permissible load,
overload and through-fault conditions.
Primary Protection: The protective system, which is expected to operate in response to a

fault in the protected zone.
Back- Up Protection: A protective system intended to supplement the main protection in

case the latter should be ineffective, or to deal with faults in those parts of the power system
that are not readily included in the operating zones of the main protection.
1.1 Data collection and mapping

To perform a coordination study, the following information is collected and modeled:
a. A single-line diagram of the power system involved, showing the type and rating of
the protective devices and their associated current transformers.
b. The impedance in ohms, percent or per unit of all power transformers, rotating
machines and feeder circuits.
c. The starting current requirements of motors.
d. The grid short circuit MVA.
1.2 Overcurrent protection guidelines

Before proceeding with overcurrent coordination, the individual load or branch circuit
protection should be applied in accordance with accepted guidelines recommended or
mandated by the National Electrical Code (NEC), American National Standards Institute
(ANSI), Canadian Standards Association (CSA), Canadian Electrical Code (CEC),
International Electro-technical Commission (IEC), and the Institute of Electronic and Electrical
Engineers (IEEE), or a similar code or body, where applicable. The NEC is primarily a safety
code; but does offer specific protection requirements for electrical equipment.
1.2.1 Conductors
Continued over currents increase the resistance heating (I2R) of conductors and can
decrease cable insulation life and cause failures. Conductors are normally protected by
overcurrent protective devices, with the pickup settings based on the cable ampacity. The
NEC provides rules for the protection of conductors. These rules are generally based on the
long-time pickup rating of the protective device and the normal full-load rating (or ampacity) of
the conductor.
INABB, CONSULTING
The conductor short-time heating limits, based on short-circuit currents or on allowable

emergency overload currents, are additional points that should be plotted to ensure that the
protective devices provide adequate protection for the conductor.
In coordinating system protection, the conductor should be able to withstand the maximum
through-fault current for a time equivalent to the tripping time of the upstream protective
device. Another factor in protecting the circuit cable is the maximum short-circuit current
available at the extremity of the cable circuit. The conductor insulation should not be
damaged by the high conductor temperature resulting from current flowing to a fault beyond
the cable termination. As a guide in preventing insulation damage, curves of conductor size
and short circuit current based on temperatures that damage insulation are available from
cable manufacturers. In coordinating system protection, the cable should be able to withstand
the maximum through short-circuit current for a time equivalent to the tripping time of the
primary relay protection or total clearing time of the fuse. Many times this requirement
determines the minimum conductor size applicable to a particular power system. If it is not
possible to select a device that will protect the cable insulation, it is recommended that a
conductor large enough to carry the current without insulation damage be used.
1.2.2 Motors
The overcurrent protection of motors includes both overload and short-circuit protection, as
required by the NEC. However, additional factors should be considered when applying
overcurrent protective devices to motors. These factors include locked-rotor current,
acceleration time, and safe stall time. Complications arise from the fact that the same devices
that protect the motor from thermal damage must also allow the motor to start.
Motor protection points that are generally plotted on the overcurrent coordination curve
include root-mean-square (rms) asymmetrical starting current, locked-rotor current,
acceleration time, allowable stall time, and full-load current. The motor starting curve normally
shows the symmetrical starting current, but the initial starting current is asymmetrical with the
maximum occurring at a 0.5 cycle. Peak-current-sensing protective devices are sensitive to
this current. Therefore, engineering judgment should be used when choosing the protective
device type and settings to account for the asymmetrical current during startup to prevent
false tripping of the short-circuit protective device. A typical rms asymmetrical starting inrush
current would be about 1.76 times the symmetrical locked-rotor current. The point on the
voltage waveform influences this inrush factor on each phase when the contactor closes, the
X/R ratio of the power system, and the X/R ratio of the motor. This inrush factor could be as
high as 2 to 3 times for stiff power systems for large high-efficiency motors. The locked-rotor
current should be obtained from manufacturers data. The acceleration time of the motor,
based on the normal means used to start the motor and driven load, should be plotted. The
motor acceleration time can be obtained from the motor manufacturer. The motor permissive
stall time, which may be given as both hot and cold stall times, should be plotted as well. The
overcurrent protection should give enough time delay to allow the motor to start, but not so
much that the operating time at locked-rotor current is above the permissive stall times. If the
acceleration time is above the stall time, special relaying considerations may be required. The
motor full-load current should be plotted, and a benchmark should also be plotted for the
maximum permitted overcurrent device setting for overload protection based on the NEC.
Motor overload and short-circuit protection are often provided by a combination of devices.
On low-voltage systems, this combination is usually an overload relay with a current-limiting
fuse or an overload relay with a low-voltage circuit breaker. The overload relay should be
selected (or set) based on the full-load current and service factor of the motor. The fuse or
circuit breaker should be selected or set to protect the motor circuit during short circuits, but
should not interrupt normal starting currents. As a result, the time-current characteristic (TCC)
of the combination device must fall below and to the left of the motor thermal limit curve and
fall above and to the right of the motor starting curve.
INABB, CONSULTING
1.2.3 Transformers
Transformers are subject not only to insulation damage from prolonged overloads and short
circuits, but also to mechanical damage from the tremendous stresses experienced during a
fault. Because of their importance in the plant electrical distribution system, the transformer
should be not only well protected, but also secure from inadvertent trips due to faults
elsewhere in the system. The transformers be protected from overcurrent with the use of
protective devices on the primary and secondary. The important factors to be considered
when coordinating transformer protective relays are
Transformer voltage, kilovolt amperes, and impedance ratings

Primary and secondary winding connections
Connected load
Transformer magnetizing inrush current
Transformer thermal and mechanical protection curves
Short-circuit current available on both the primary and secondary
IEEE Standard C57.109-1993 recommends protection based on the size of the transformer
and the number of estimated through-faults that the transformer is expected to encounter.
The through-fault protection curves contained in IEEE Standard C57.109-1993 should be
used as the basis for setting transformer overcurrent protective relays. In addition, the
maximum inrush current, usually assumed to be at 0.1 s and ranging from 8 to 12 times the
transformer self-cooled rated current, should be plotted to ensure the protective relays do not
trip on transformer energization.
A final protection point is the maximum permitted overcurrent setting for overload and short
circuit protection based on NEC rules. The overcurrent device on the transformer primary
should provide protection against thermal and mechanical damage; yet allow the normal
connected load to flow.
1.2.4 Generators
Generators are complex and require a variety of protective devices. Overcurrent devices
usually provide backup protection to other generator relays, such as differential.
Because the short-circuit current available from a generator decreases over time, the use of
standard overcurrent relays is not practical. The relay pickup setting should be low enough to
trip in response to the minimum sustainable generator contribution (i.e., synchronous current
E/Xd), but should not trip unnecessarily due to normal overloads. To accommodate these
requirements, a voltage-restrained or voltage-controlled overcurrent relay (Device 51V) is
used. This device allows the relay to differentiate between system faults and generator faults.
When a fault occurs near the generator, the depressed voltage allows the voltage-restrained
relay to become more sensitive. The voltage-controlled relay operates as a simple switched
overcurrent relay. Both of these relays require coordination with local and upstream protective
devices. The voltage- restrained overcurrent relay should be selective over its entire range of
operation. In addition, many small, low-voltage generators are protected only by MCCBs or
power circuit breakers with direct acting trip devices. These protective devices may provide
fault protection for the generator, but probably will not provide any backup protection for
system faults, due to the generator decrement.
1.3 Time-current characteristic plots

1.3.1 Curve Interpretation
A basic understanding of TCC plots is the foundation for performing any coordination study. A
TCC curve defines the operating time of a protective device for various magnitudes of
operating current. Published curves assume that the operating current is consistent for the
period of operation. What is generally described as a typical time-current coordination plot
INABB, CONSULTING
actually consists of multiple device curves plotted on a single page. The device curves are
plotted on log-log paper with time on the ordinate and current on the abscissa. The time scale
normally covers a range from 0.01 s to 1000 s; however, any desired current scale can be
obtained by simply multiplying the existing scale by an appropriate factor of ten. The
multiplying factor chosen and the voltage level on which the currents are based should be
noted on the coordination plot.
On a typical coordination plot, time zero is considered as the time at which the fault occurs,
and all times shown on the plot are the elapsed time from that point. The relative position of
the device characteristic curves on the plot reflects the response time of each device for a
given fault-current magnitude. The region below and to the left of the characteristic curve is
the non-operate area. For current magnitudes and durations in this region, the overcurrent
device does not operate. The region above and to the right is the operate (or tripping) area.
For simple radial systems, all devices between the fault and the power source experience
roughly the same fault current.
Starting at time 0.01 seconds and a given value of fault current and proceeding upwards
along the plot at the value of fault current, the first device whose curve is intersected should
be the first device to operate. The intersection at this point also indicates the device operating
time. Continuing along the abscissa, the next curve should be the closest upstream protective
device, which provides backup protection. In general, to minimize the loss of service, this
upstream device should not operate until the first device is given adequate time (or margin) to
detect and clear the fault.
1.3.2 Curve variations

In order to coordinate various combinations of devices, an understanding of their operation
and characteristic curve is necessary. Two basic forms of characteristic curves are drawn:
single-line and banded. The single-line curve, characteristic of overcurrent relays, indicates
the approximate time that the device will close its contacts to initiate the opening of a circuit
breaker. For a fault current F1, the device operates at time T1. The total time for the fault to be
cleared is time T1 plus setting errors, manufacturing tolerances, and breaker tripping time.
Interrupting times for medium- and high-voltage circuit breakers activated from a relay signal
are typically on the order of 1.5 cycles to 8 cycles. The interrupting times of low-voltage circuit
breakers and insulated case circuit breakers (ICCBs) are acknowledged to be in the range of
3 cycles to 5 cycles. MCCBs can have clearing times as low as 0.5 cycles.
1.3.3 Time-overcurrent relays

A time-overcurrent relay characteristic is generally plotted as a single-line curve. Curves for
specific relays are provided by the manufacturer on log-log paper and include the available
range of time-delay (or time-dial) settings. The term time dial originates from the
electromechanical time-overcurrent relays that have a dial with continuous adjustment from
typically 0.1 to 10. Indentations on the dial correspond to the characteristic curve numbers
provided by the manufacturer. Selection of any other position requires curve extrapolation and
testing of the relay to ensure proper settings. The term time dial has carried over to static
relays where adjustment of the time delay is also provided. The major difference is that static
technology provides a greater degree of curve selectivity and accuracy.
For a given current, the time dial selection indicates the time required for the relay to close its
output contacts. The higher the time-dial setting, the greater the time to contact closure. This
feature is useful when Coordination Time Intervals (CTIs) are being established. The
characteristic curve can be moved on the coordination plot as required to achieve
coordination. The pickup current of the relay is determined by the CT ratio and the tap setting
of the relay. The pickup current selection provides the flexibility to move the characteristic left
and right on the coordination plot, and the time dial provides adjustment up and down.
Characteristics of time-overcurrent relays have historically been defined as either inverse or
definite time. The definite-time relay operates within a given time regardless of the magnitude
INABB, CONSULTING
of the current, as long as the current is generally several multiples of minimum pickup and
below the saturation limit of the CTs. The inverse time-delay relay has an operating time that
is inversely proportional to the current magnitude. In other words, the higher the fault current
magnitude, the faster the relay operates. Manufacturers may also offer other types of relay
characteristics, such as a fixed-time curve, I2t curve (i.e., a form of inverse-time curve), and
curves corresponding to different international standards.
Within the inverse characteristic, several families of curves exist with different degrees of
inversity. When exposed to a given input current above the minimum pickup value and with
identical time-dial settings, an extremely inverse relay operates faster than a very inverse
relay, which in turn operates faster than a standard inverse relay. The relay having an inverse
or very inverse characteristic is most commonly used, and ideally the same inverse
characteristic is used throughout the system. Relays with definite-time characteristics are
used in medium-voltage motor protection circuits, ground-fault protection, and any similar
application where a wide range of fault currents may exist with few stages of coordination.
Selection of relay curve characteristics is often based upon preferences or standardization. In
other words, the application is more of an art than a science.
1.4 Co-ordination Settings & Criteria

There are two basic adjustable settings on all inverse time relays; one is the current setting
usually known as the Plug Setting Multiplier (PSM) and the other is Time Multiplier Setting
(TMS).
Pr imary current Pr imary current Pr imary current

PSM = = =
Pr imary setting current Re lay current setting CT Ratio Pr imary operating current
Top
TMS =
Tm
Where,
Top = the required time of operation
Tm = the time operation at TMS=1.0 for maximum fault current
1.4.1 Selection of PSM

The pick-up values of phase over current inverse time relays are normally set 20% above the
maximum equipment rated current, provided that sufficient short circuit current was available.
Earth fault inverse time relays are subjected to residual current, which allows a much more
sensitive setting, as load currents do not have to be considered (except 4-wire circuits with
single-phase load). In solidly and low-resistance grounded systems a setting of 20 to 30%
equipment rated current is generally applied, providing enough margin for expected
unbalanced currents. High-resistance grounding requires much more sensitive setting.
For inverse time over current relays, the current setting should be done at the minimum fault
current because if the relays are sensitive for the minimum fault current, it will automatically
sense maximum fault current.
Instantaneous elements to be set above inverse time relay pick-up values to protect against
short length faults. The instantaneous element was the first line of defense, which was
backed up by inverse time element. In the absence of the instantaneous element the inverse
element provides the primary protection.
Following equations to be used to calculate PSM of protective relay.
INABB, CONSULTING
I F > P.O.C. > ( I RL + I STM I FLM )
Where,
P.O.C. = Desired Primary Operating current of relay
IRL = Maximum running load current
ISTM = Highest rating drive starting current
IFLM = Highest rating drive full load current
IF = Minimum fault current relay to sense
Pr imary Operating Current ( P.O.C.)

Pick Up
C.T . Ratio
1.4.2 Selection of TMS

The relay farthest from the source should be set to operate in the minimum possible time. For
succeeding relays towards the source a time delay step should be given. For inverse time
over-current relays the time setting should be done at the maximum fault current. If the relay
has proper selectivity at the maximum fault current, it will automatically have a higher
selectivity at the minimum fault current, as the curve was more inverse at lower fault currents.
Earth fault can be provided with definite time over-current relays due to limited values of fault
currents and restricted by neutral impedances. Fortunately the grading of earth fault relays,
unlike over-current phase relays, was normally limited to one system voltage due to general
usage of delta / star step down transformer, as the earth fault at star-side reflects as phase
fault in delta winding.
Following equations to be used to calculate TSM of protective relay.
t1 = t0 + td
Where,
t1 = Desired operating time
t0 = Downstream relay / fuse operating time
td = Discrimination in time
Desired relay operating time t1

= Desired TMS setting
Re lay operating time @ selected PSM and TMS = 1.0
Time discrimination is taken as 200 300 msec for relay to relay or fuse to relay considering
the time intervals mentioned in Table 1-1.
Table 1-1 Composition of Time discrimination between relays

Coordination Time Interval (CTI)
Components
Electromechanical Static
Circuit breaker operating time 0.08 s 0.08 s
Relay over travel 0.10 s 0.00 s
Relay tolerance and setting errors 0.12 s 0.12 s
Total CTI 0.30 s 0.20 s
Note: All short-circuit currents considered for relay co-ordination are calculated based on IEC-
60909, 2001 standard. The CTI mentioned in Table 1-1 are taken from IEEE Standard 242-
2001.
INABB, CONSULTING
1.5 Procedure
Overcurrent coordination is a trial-and-error procedure in which the TCC curves of the various
devices in series are graphically plotted on log-log paper so that selective coordination may
be achieved. The device setting process is a compromise between the opposite goals of
maximum equipment protection and maximum service continuity; therefore, complete
selective coordination may not be achieved in all systems. The following procedure shows the
logical progression of steps needed to effectively construct the time current coordination plots
and set the time-overcurrent protective devices in the system.
1. Select the circuit to be coordinated. Start at the loads in the circuit (at the lowest
voltage level) and work back toward the power source. Determine the branch circuit
with the largest current setting. Typically, this point will be the largest motor on the
branch circuit due to the high inrush current seen during starting. However, a feeder
branch circuit should be selected if it has a higher current setting.
2. Select the proper current scale. Considering a large system or one with more than
one voltage transformation, the characteristic curve of the smallest device is plotted
as far to the left of the paper as possible so that the curves are not crowded at the
right of the paper. The maximum short-circuit level on the system is the limit of the
curves to the right, unless it seems desirable to observe the possible behavior of a
device above the level of short-circuit current on the system under study. The number
of trip characteristics plotted on one sheet of paper should be limited. More than four
or five curves on one sheet become confusing, particularly if the curves overlap. All
relay characteristics should be plotted on a common scale even though they are at
different voltage levels. As an example, consider a system on which a 750 kVA
transformer with a 4160 V delta primary and a 480 V wye secondary. Assume that
this transformer is equipped with a primary circuit breaker and a main secondary
circuit breaker supplying some feeder circuit breakers. On this system, full-load
current of the transformer at 480 V is (750 103)/(480 3) = 902 A. When 902 A is
flowing in the secondary of the transformer, the current in the primary of the
transformer is the same value of current (i.e., 902 A) multiplied by the voltage ratio of
the transformer (480/4160 = 0.115). In the case under consideration, the primary
current would be 902 0.115 = 104 A. If the full-load current is established to be 1
per unit, then 902 A at 480 V = 104 A at 4160 V. As far as the time-current
coordination curve is concerned, both 104 A at 4160 V and 902 A at 480 V represents
the same value of circuit current: full load of the 750 kVA transformer and 1 per unit
current. Plotting current on the time-current plot, 902 A at 480 V is the same as
plotting 104 A at 4160 V. This type of manipulation permits the study of devices with
several different system voltage levels on one coordination plot if the proper current
scales are selected for the plot.
3. Draw a small one-line diagram of the circuit that is to be plotted on this curve to use
as reference for the characteristic curves on the plot with the devices on the diagram.
4. On the log-log graph paper, indicate these important points (if applicable):
a. Available maximum short-circuit currents.
b. Full-load currents of transformers and significant load-flow currents.
c. I2t damage points or curves for transformers, cables, motors, and other
equipment.
d. Transformer inrush current points.
e. The motor-starting curve indicating the locked-rotor current, full-load current,
and acceleration time of the motor.
f. Short-time rating of switchboards and switchgear.
5. Begin plotting the protective device characteristic curves on the plot starting at the
lowest voltage level and largest load. Once a specific current scale has been
selected, calculate the proper multipliers for the various voltage levels considered in
the study. Characteristic curves for the protective devices and damage curves for the
equipment can then be placed on a smooth bright surface such as a white sheet of
paper or on an illuminated translucent viewing box or drawing box. The sheet of log-
log paper on which the study is being made is placed on top of the protective device
INABB, CONSULTING
characteristic curve or equipment damage curve with the current scale of the study
lined up with that of the device or damage curves. The curves for all the various
settings and ratings of devices being studied may then be traced or examined.
The selective coordination of the protective devices should be based on the limiting
characteristics of the particular devices in series, the boundaries imposed on the various
protective devices by the full-load currents, short-circuit currents, motor-starting currents,
thermal damage curves, and any applicable standards or NEC requirements.
1.6 Points to be noted while doing relay coordination

The following points to be noted while doing relay coordination:
1. In a particular feeder, there are two CTs available; one is for metering and the other is
for protection. For relay coordination, consider the protection CT.
2. In some cases, for earth fault detection CBCTs are used. For coordinating earth faults
this should be considered.
3. The plug setting of the relay should be the minimum of CT ratio, cable rating or
transformer rated current.
1.7 Case Study

1.7.1 Coordination of earth fault by fuse
Consider the system shown in Figure 1-1 for earth fault coordination. Consider an earth fault
on motor terminal, ASB.
Figure 1-1 System considered for earth fault coordination by fuse
INABB, CONSULTING
1000 s
O/G to SWBD # 102A-SWBD 104A
I>>=600A T=0.130pu
IEC255-3 normal inverse
O/G to TR-1A
I=250A T=0.100pu
O/G to PMCC 1A
100 s I=300A T=0.250pu
O/G to F_MCC # 11 I/C-1
I=100A T=1.0pu
O/G to SWBD 104A-HVTR-1A
I>>=1875A T=0.020s
I>>=750A T=0.250pu
10.0 s
Ik O/G to SWBD # 102A-SWBD 104A
1.0 s
to TR-1A
0.100 s
current
FaultO/G
3*I0
0.010 s
0.415 kV:0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA 100 kA 1000 kA
6.6 kV: 0.010 kA 0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA
Fig.No.: 0209152411
Curves aligned to fault current!
Figure 1-2 Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal Without CTIs
The coordination curves without any coordination time intervals are shown in Figure 1-2. For
impedance faults (fault currents < 1 kA), the relay at PCC incomer will operate first followed
by fuse and ACB.
INABB, CONSULTING
By adjusting the PSM and TSM of ACB and relay, the coordination curves are shown in
Figure 1-3. In this case the fuse will operate first, however for first back-up the ACB and relay
at PCC incomer may operate simultaneously (ACB dont have earth fault characteristic).
Moreover, there is no coordination between fuse and ACB as the CTI between fuse and ACB
is less than 100 msec.
1000 s
O/G to TR-1A
I=500A T=0.550pu
O/G to PMCC 1A-N_MCC11 I/C-1
I=300A T=1.0pu
O/G to SWBD 104A-HVTR-1A
I>>=3000A T=0.020s
100 s I>>=188A T=0.310pu
O/G to MCC # 11 I/C-1
I=100A T=1.0pu
SBEF TR-1A
I0>=625A T=0.470pu
10.0 s
1.0 s
to TR-1A
0.100 s
current
FaultO/G
3*I0
0.010 s
0.415 kV:0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA 100 kA 1000 kA
6.6 kV: 0.010 kA 0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA
Fig.No.: 0319132111
Figure 1-3 Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal With CTIs
INABB, CONSULTING
To avoid this situation, a relay having extremely inverse and definite-time characteristic is
proposed and the coordination curves are given in Figure 1-4.
1000 s
O/G to SWBD # 102A-SWBD 103A
I>>=1000A T=0.130pu
O/G to SWBD 103A-HV_TR # 203
I>>=3400A T=0.020s
I>>=200A T=0.290pu
100 s
O/G to TR # 203
I=480A T=0.600pu
O/G of PCC # 301A
I0>=179A T=0.480pu
IEC255-3 extremely inverse
I0>=1210A T=0.290s
10.0 s O/G to ASB
I=100A T=1.0pu
1.0 s
to TR # 203
0.100 s
current
FaultO/G
3*I0
0.010 s
0.415 kV:0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA 100 kA 1000 kA 10001 kA
6.6 kV: 0.010 kA 0.100 kA 1.0 kA 10.0 kA 100 kA
Fig.No.: 0208154223
Figure 1-4Coordination curves for an earth fault on ASB motor terminal With
proposed relay
INABB, CONSULTING
1.7.2 Sample protection calculation for a sub-station
220 kV Smelter BUS

200/1
3-ph: 0.687 kA
Top: 810 msec 3-ph: 0.793 kA
Top: 750 msec
Aux. X'mer # 1_Ph1
3-ph: 21.89 kA O/G_Aux TR1 to BUS1_Ph1 O/G_Aux TR1 to BUS3_Ph1

Top: 570 msec
2000/1 6.6 kV Main S/S_BUS1_Ph1 6.6 kV Main S/S_BUS3_Ph1 2000/1
1250/1 1250/1
3-ph: 21.89 kA 3-ph: 25.29 kA F3
Top: 350 msec Top: 540 msec
O/G_POTROOM S/S#1_BUS1_Ph1 O/G_POTROOM S/S#1_BUS2_Ph1
3-ph: 21.89 kA
Top: 230 msec
1250/1
POTROOM S/S#1_BUS1_Ph1 1250/1 POTROOM S/S#1_BUS2_Ph1 1250/1
150/1
3-ph: 1.906 kA 3-ph: 21.89 kA
Top: 500 msec Top: 10 msec
F2
Aux. TR MCC-11-1_Ph1
3-ph: 29.3 kA
Top: 250 msec
F1
Figure 1-5 Sample Calculation for a Sub-Station

Setting of 6.6/0.433 kV Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1 Primary side Protection:
Settings of Inverse P/F relay (51)
Transformer ID: Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1
Transformer rating: 6.6/0.433 kV, 1.25 MVA
HV side CT Ratio: 150/1 A
Relay Type: 7SJ61
Relay characteristics: Normal Inverse
Plug setting range: 0.1-4A (insteps of 0.01A)
Time setting range: 0.05-3.2 (insteps of 0.01)
Plug Setting: The transformer rated current should be the basis to decide plug setting of the
inverse phase fault relay. Considering 100% of transformer rated current the proposed plug
setting = 109.3/150 = 0.73 A.
Proposed Settings: 0.73 A
INABB, CONSULTING
Time Setting: For a 3 phase fault at the LV side of transformer, ACB operates in 0.25s. In
case it fails to operate, the P/F relay at the transformer primary should clear the fault. Its Top
should be set in excess to the Top of the LT side of the transformer. Keeping a time margin of
0.25s, the Top of the P/F relay at the transformer primary should be 0.5s (0.25 + 0.25 = 0.5).
The TMS should be kept at 0.21 which gives Top = 0.5 sec.
Proposed Settings: 0.21
Settings of P/F Instantaneous relay (50)

Transformer ID: Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1
Relay Type: 7SJ61
Relay characteristics: Definite time
Time setting range: 0-60 (insteps of 0.01)
Plug Setting: The high set unit should not operate instantaneously for downstream fault.
Thus HS unit is to be set for more than the transfer fault at LV side. The setting should also
be more than the transformer excitation current (it should not pick up during transformer
charging).
Transformer secondary fault current = 29.3 kA

Reflected fault current at primary = 1.906 kA
Transformer charging current = 10x 109.3 A = 1.093 kA
Comparing the transformer charging current and reflected fault current, the high set pick up is
to be kept more than reflected fault current of 1.906 kA. Considering the safety margin of
60%, it can be set at 1.6*1.906 = 3.04 kA. The setting is 3040/150 = 20 A (approximately).
Proposed Settings: 20 A, 0.01 s

Setting of Auxiliary T/F 1 Primary Protection:
Settings of P/F relay (51)
Transformer ID: Auxiliary T/F 1
Transformer rating: 220/6.9kV, 40 MVA
T/F rated current on HV side = 105 A
Relay Type: 7SJ63
Relay characteristics: Normal Inverse
Time setting range: 0.05-3.2 (insteps of 0.01)
Plug Setting: The plug setting is kept at 120% of the transformer rated current. =
1.2*105/200 = 0.63 A
Proposed Settings: 0.63 A
Time Setting: For a three-phase fault on the secondary side of Auxiliary T/F 1, the P/F relay
on secondary side shall operate in 0.54 s. In case of failure of this relay, the relay on HT side
should isolate the fault. Taking a CTI of 0.2 s, the Top of P/F relay should be operate at 0.74 s
(0.54+0.2 = 0.74s). A TMS of 0.2 gives Top of 0.75 s. Thus this setting is proposed.
Proposed Settings: 0.2
Settings of P/F Instantaneous relay (50)

INABB, CONSULTING

Relay Type: 7SJ63
Relay characteristics: Definite Time
Plug Setting: The high set unit should not operate instantaneously for downstream fault.
Thus HS unit is to be set for more than the transfer fault at secondary. The setting also to be
more than the transformer excitation current (it should not pick up during transformer
charging).
Reflected fault current on HV side = 793 A
Transformer inrush = 10* Ifl = 10*105 =1050 A
Comparing the transformer charging current and reflected fault current, the high set pick up is
to be kept more than transformer inrush current of 1050 A. Considering the safety margin of
60%, it can be set at 1.6*1.05 = 1.68 kA. The setting is 1680/200 = 8 A (approximately).
Settings of Directional E/F Instantaneous relay (67N)

Relay Type: 7SJ63
Plug Setting: Earth fault current doesnt get reflected on the primary side due to the vector
group of the transformer (YNd11). The E/F hi-set setting of the transformer is kept at 200% of
transformer rating. It should be kept at 2*105/200 = 1.05 A. Keep the PSM at 1A (nearest
value). Here, the earth fault should be directional. If it is a non-directional relay, for a single
phase to ground fault on grid incomer the relay at auxiliary t/f primary should operate
instantaneously. This is happening because of YNd11 vector group of auxiliary transformer.
Simulation results:
A three phase to ground fault on LV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1 is simulated in NEPLAN
and the result of simulation is shown in Figure 1-6. For a fault current of 29.05 kA, the ACB on
the LV side of the transformer will operate in 250 msec. If this fault is not cleared by this relay
due to some failure, over current relay on the HV side of the transformer will operate in 500
msec, which acts as a backup.
This fault current will vary depending upon the network condition and the ground impedance.
For fault currents below 29.05 kA, proper margin in operating time is maintained between LV
and HV overcurrent relays, which ensure proper relay coordination.
A three phase to ground fault on the HV side of the Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1 is simulated in
NEPLAN and the simulations results are shown in Figure 1-7. For a fault current of 21.89 kA,
the phase fault -instantaneous relay on the HV side of the transformer operates in 10 msec. If
the fault is not cleared by this relay (due to some failure), over current relay (inverse type) on
the Pot Room incomer will operate in 230 msec, which acts as a backup. If it fails to operate,
the relay on Pot Room feeder at 6.6 kV Main sub-station side should operate at 350 msec.
Even, this relay also fails to operate the relay at 6.6 kV Main sub-station incomer (feeding
from secondary side of Auxiliary T/F) side should operate at 570 msec.
INABB, CONSULTING
A three phase to ground fault on the LV side of the Auxiliary T/F 1 is simulated in NEPLAN
and the simulations results are shown in Figure 1-8. For a fault current of 25.29 kA, the relay
on the LV side of the transformer operates in 540 msec. If the fault is not cleared by this relay
(due to some failure), the relay on Auxiliary T/F primary should operate at 750 msec, which
acts as a backup.
Figure 1-6 3-phase fault on LV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1
INABB, CONSULTING
Figure 1-7 3-phase fault on HV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1
INABB, CONSULTING
Figure 1-8 3-phase fault on LV side of Smelter Auxiliary T/F 1
INABB, CONSULTING
1.7.3 Earth fault protection for High Resistance grounded

systems
UNIT #1 BUS
UAT
I/C_UAT_BUS2
I/C_UAT_BUS1 3-ph: 21.05 kA, Top: 300 mec

3-ph: 12.86 kA, Top: 500 mec 1-ph: 0.191 kA, Top: 300 mec 3-ph: 21.05 kA, Top: 500 mec
1-ph: 0.191 kA, Top: 500 mec 1-ph: 0.191 kA, Top: 500 mec
UAT_BUS1 2000/5 2000/5 B/C_UAT UAT_BUS2 2000/5
200/5
F2
UNIT LV T/R - 1
3-ph: 32.47 kA, Top: 250 mec

1-ph: 33.18 kA, Top: 250 mec F1
Figure 1-9 Sample protection calculation for high resistance grounded systems
Settings of E/F Instantaneous relay on Unit LV T/F 1(50N)
Transformer ID: Unit LV T/F
Relay Type: RCS-9624C
Plug Setting: Earth fault current doesnt get reflected on the primary side due to the vector
group of the transformer (Dyn11). Because of high resistance (19.92 ohms) grounding of
UAT, the fault current at Unit LV T/F primary comes around 200 A. The E/F Instantaneous
relay setting is kept at 10-30% of the fault current. The plug setting to be 200*0.25*5/200 =
1.25 A
Proposed Settings: 1.25 A, 0.05 s
Settings of E/F High-Set relay on UAT Bus-coupler (50N)

CT Ratio: 2000/5 A
Plug Setting: Because of high resistance (19.92 ohms) grounding of UAT, the fault current
through bus-coupler comes around 190 A. The E/F High-Set relay setting is kept at 50A. The
plug setting to be 50*5/2000 = 0.13 A.
INABB, CONSULTING
Time Setting: For a 1 phase fault at Unit LV T/F primary, the relay on primary side should
operate at 0.05 sec. If, it fails to operate, the relay on bus-coupler shall operate in 0.3 sec
(0.05+0.25 = 0.3 sec).
Proposed Settings: 0.13 A, 0.3
Settings of E/F High-Set relay (50N)

CT Ratio: 2000/5 A
Plug Setting: Because of high resistance (19.92 ohms) grounding of UAT, the fault current
through incomer to Bus 1 comes around 190 A. The E/F High-Set relay setting is kept at 50A.
The plug setting to be 50*5/2000 = 0.13 A.
Time Setting: For a 1 phase fault at Unit LV T/F primary, the relay on bus-coupler should
operate at 0.3 sec. If, it fails to operate, the relay on incomer to Bus 1 shall operate in 0.5 sec
(0.3+0.2 = 0.5 sec).
Proposed Settings: 0.13 A, 0.5 s
The simulation results for earth fault on Unit LV transformer primary are shown in Figure 1-10.
INABB, CONSULTING
Figure 1-10 Single- phase to ground fault on Unit LV T/F primary side
INABB, CONSULTING
1.8 Earth Fault Detection Techniques in an Ungrounded

System
In an ungrounded system, it is difficult to find the earth fault by conventional relays. The
following are options for earth fault detection techniques in ungrounded system (6.6 kV
Smelter Auxiliary).
! Short Term Implementation:
# Open delta connection of PT on each 6.6 kV bus (Main distribution panel and
individual substation buses), which can be used for annunciation.
# Core Balanced Current Transformer (CBCT) on each 6.6 kV feeder, which
can be used for tripping.
! Long Term Implementation:
# Installation of Earthing Transformer on Delta side of Smelter auxiliary
transformers.
1.8.1 Open delta connection of PT

The potential transformer can be connected in open-delta as shown in Figure 1-11. A voltage-
sensing relay is connected across the secondary winding of PT. During normal condition, the
voltage developed across PT secondary is zero. If, any ground fault occurs, there will be
voltage developed across the relay and it will sense the faulty section. In general, open-delta
connection of PT is used for alarm only.
PT Primary
R Y B
PT Secondary
Voltage Sensing
relay
Figure 1-11 Open delta connection of PT
1.8.2 Core balance current transformer (CBCT)

The core-balance method is based on primary current phasor addition or flux summation. The
remaining zero-sequence component, if any, is then transformed to the secondary. The core-
balance CT or sensor is the basis of several low-voltage ground-fault protective systems.
(The core-balance CT is frequently called a zero-sequence sensor or window CT, but the
term core balance is preferable because it more specifically describes the function of the CT.)
INABB, CONSULTING
The principle of the core-balance CT circuit is shown in Figure 1-12. All load-carrying
conductors pass through the same opening in the CT and are surrounded by the same
magnetic core. Core-balance CTs are available in several convenient shapes and sizes,
including rectangular designs for use over bus bars. This method can be more sensitive than
the residual method because the sensor rating is large enough for the possible imbalance, not
for the individual conductor load current.
Under normal conditions [i.e., balanced, unbalanced, or single-phase load currents or short
circuits not involving ground (if all conductors are properly enclosed)], all current flows out and
returns through the CT. The net flux produced in the CT core is zero, and no current flows in
the ground relay. When a ground fault occurs, the ground-fault current returns through the
equipment grounding circuit conductor (and possibly other ground paths) and bypasses the
CT. The flux produced in the CT core is proportional to the ground-fault current, and a
proportional current flows from the CT secondary to the relay circuit. Relays connected to
core-balance CTs can be made quite sensitive. However, care is necessary to prevent false
opening from unbalanced inrush currents that may saturate the CT core or through faults not
involving ground. If only phase conductors are enclosed and neutral current is not zero, the
transformed current is proportional to the load zero-sequence or neutral current. Systems with
grounded conductors, such as cable shielding, should have the CT surround only the phase
and neutral conductors, if applicable, and not the grounded conductor.
Figure 1-12 Core balance CT encircling all phase and neutral conductors
By properly matching the CT and relay, ground-fault detection can be made as sensitive as
the application requires. The speed of the relay limits damage and may be adjustable (for
current or time, or both) in order to obtain selectivity. Many ground protective systems now
have solid-state relays specially designed to operate with core-balance CTs. The relays in
turn open the circuit protective device. Power circuit breakers, MCCBs with shunt trips, or
electrically operated fused switches can be used. The last category includes service
protectors, which use circuit breaker contacts and mechanisms, but depend on current-
limiting fuses to interrupt the high available short-circuit currents. Fused contactors and
combination motor starters may be used where the device-interrupting capability equals or
exceeds the available ground-fault current.
INABB, CONSULTING
Figure 1-13 Physical installation of core balance CT for shielded cable termination
Figure 1-13 shows a typical termination of a medium-voltage shielded cable. After the cable is
pulled up through the core-balance CT, the cable jacket is removed to expose the shielding
tape or braid. Jumpering the shields together, the connection to the ground is made after this
shield lead are brought back through the CT. This precaution would have been necessary
only if the shield had been pulled through the CT. Between multiple shield ground
connections on a single conductor cable, a potential exists that drives a circulating current,
often of such a magnitude as to require derating of the cable ampacity. When applying the
core-balance CT, the effects of this circulating current should be subtracted from the
measuring circuit.
1.8.3 Earthing Transformer

A zigzag (earthing) transformer is a special purpose transformer. It has primary windings but
no secondary winding. Earthing transformers are used to create a neutral point in a three-
phase system, which provides possibility for neutral earthing. The earthing can be through an
arc-suppression reactor, a neutral earthing reactor or resistor or directly.
The design can be a transformer with just one winding, which is zigzag connected. The zero
sequence impedance of such a winding is normally quite low, but it can be increased if the
purpose is to limit the current through the transformer in case of an earth fault somewhere in
the system. Consider a three-phase Y (wye) transformer with an earth connection on the
neutral point. Cut each winding in the middle so that the winding splits into two. Turn the outer
winding around and rejoin the outer winding to the next phase in the sequence (i.e. outer A
phase connects to inner B phase, outer B phase connects to inner C phase, and outer C
phase connects to inner A phase). This device is the zigzag transformer. Connection diagram
for earthing transformer is shown in Figure 1-14.
INABB, CONSULTING
Figure 1-14 Connection diagram for earthing transformer

During undisturbed system operation with balanced (symmetrical) voltages the current
through the earthing transformer is small & of the same size as the magnetizing current.
Unbalanced voltages will cause some higher currents flowing through the earthing
transformer, which it must be capable to carry. An alternative connection to the zigzag is
star/delta connection where the delta connected winding will compensate the zero sequence
magnetic fields so it will be confined to a leakage field between the star and the delta winding
and make the zero sequence impedance of the transformer relatively small. However, if it is
desired to increase the zero sequence impedance, this can be achieved by opening the delta
connection and insert a reactor or resistor.
Earthing transformers are usually oil immersed and may be installed outdoor. In cases where
a separate reactor is connected between the transformer neutral and earth, the reactor and
the transformer can be incorporated in the same tank. When the earthing transformer is going
to be used together with an arc-suppression reactor, the rated current (and its duration) of the
earthing transformer will be determined by the data for the arc-suppression reactor. If the
earthing transformer is used for directly earthing or through a current limiting reactor, the
neutral current through the transformer will be high but the duration is limited to a few
seconds. Earthing transformer must be designed to withstand the thermal and mechanical
effects of the rated neutral current. The characteristic of earthing transformer should be
selected to match the property of the system.
Most of the time in service the loading of earthing transformers is very low. It is the randomly
occurring short duration currents that cause any heating of significance. Ageing of the
cellulose materials is then not a matter of concern. Regarding acceptable temperatures there
are two aspects to consider. The temperature during currents of say 10 seconds duration
must not cause softening of the winding conductor material, say 250oC for copper and 200oC
for aluminium. For currents with duration in the order of hours or more, temperatures that
cause excessive gas development in the oil should be avoided. Temperatures for items in
direct contact with the oil should then not exceed 140oC.
The system earth fault protection relay may not be effective at low currents. To prevent
damage to earthing transformer by such current, oil thermometer with alarm/trip contacts is
recommended. Alternatively, the value of maximum continuous earth fault current may be
declared and sensitive protection provided. The applicable standard for earthing transformers
is IEC 60076-6.
INABB, CONSULTING

Relay Coordination Methodology PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Relay Coordination Methodology PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Relay Coordination Study Methodology

ABB June 2008

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 2/27

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 3/27

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 4/27

1. Relay Co-ordination Study

Primary Protection: The protective system, which is expected to operate in response to a

Back- Up Protection: A protective system intended to supplement the main protection in

1.1 Data collection and mapping

1.2 Overcurrent protection guidelines

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 5/27

The conductor short-time heating limits, based on short-circuit currents or on allowable

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 6/27

Transformer voltage, kilovolt amperes, and impedance ratings

1.3 Time-current characteristic plots

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 7/27

1.3.2 Curve variations

1.3.3 Time-overcurrent relays

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 8/27

1.4 Co-ordination Settings & Criteria

Pr imary current Pr imary current Pr imary current

1.4.1 Selection of PSM

Following equations to be used to calculate PSM of protective relay.

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 9/27

I F > P.O.C. > ( I RL + I STM I FLM )

Pr imary Operating Current ( P.O.C.)

1.4.2 Selection of TMS

Following equations to be used to calculate TSM of protective relay.

Desired relay operating time t1

Table 1-1 Composition of Time discrimination between relays

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 10/27

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 11/27

1.6 Points to be noted while doing relay coordination

1.7 Case Study

Figure 1-1 System considered for earth fault coordination by fuse

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 12/27

Ik O/G to SWBD # 102A-SWBD 104A

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 13/27

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 14/27

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 15/27

1.7.2 Sample protection calculation for a sub-station

220 kV Smelter BUS

Aux. X'mer # 1_Ph1

3-ph: 21.89 kA O/G_Aux TR1 to BUS1_Ph1 O/G_Aux TR1 to BUS3_Ph1

O/G_POTROOM S/S#1_BUS1_Ph1 O/G_POTROOM S/S#1_BUS2_Ph1

Figure 1-5 Sample Calculation for a Sub-Station

Proposed Settings: 0.73 A

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 16/27

Proposed Settings: 0.21

Settings of P/F Instantaneous relay (50)

Transformer secondary fault current = 29.3 kA

Proposed Settings: 20 A, 0.01 s

Proposed Settings: 0.63 A

Proposed Settings: 0.2

Settings of P/F Instantaneous relay (50)

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 17/27

T/F rated current on HV side = 105 A

Settings of Directional E/F Instantaneous relay (67N)

Proposed Settings: 1 A, 0.01 s

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 18/27

Figure 1-6 3-phase fault on LV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1

PTSY-C Uma KM documentation 02/06/2008 en 0 19/27

Figure 1-7 3-phase fault on HV side of Auxiliary T/F MCC 11-1