1.

Abstrak seharusnya menjelaskan secara singkat hasil/performa dari metode yang

diusulkan.

Abstract should explain how good the final result/perform of the proposed method in one
word

2. Cara sitasi tidak sesuai dengan gaya Harvard. Silahkan cek panduan penggunaan sitasi dan
gaya referensi di sini .

The citation is not appropriate with the Harvard citation style. Please check the guide to use
citation and reference in:

The citation is not appropriate to the Harvard reference style. Please check the guide to use
citation and reference in:
http://www.inderscience.com/info/pdf/dl.php?filename=refguide.pdf

3. Jelaskan secara clear dataset yang anda gunakan (IMDB Dataset dan Medical Dataset).
Pada articel tidak terdapat penjelasan kedua dataset tersebut.

Explain dataset (IMDB Dataset dan Medical Dataset) clearly. Both of datasets are not
explained in this paper.

4. Jelaskan CART, NB, MLP-BP

Please present an adequate explanation for CART, NB, MLP-BP

5. Pada tabel ini, tidak dijelaskan dengan baik dimana penggunaan metode yang diusulkan

In table 1 and 2, there is not clearly explained where the proposed method
In table 1 and 2, there is not clearly explained where the suggested method

6. Pada tabel 1 dan 2 tidak ditampilkan hasil running time untuk setiap metode. Sementara
disini dituliskan tujuannya adalah untuk time saving.

In table 1 and 2 do not show the outcomes of running time for each method. While here
written goal is for time saving.

7. Seberapa signifikan kenaikan akurasi?

The paper does not use paired t-test to determine how significant increase in accuracy,
precision, recall, and f-measure.

The paper does not use paired t-test to find out how significant increase in accuracy,
precision, recall, and f-measure for each method.

8. Kesimpulan tidak menjawab masalah yang disampaikan pada bagian introduction

The conclusion does not answer the problem which
The conclusion does not answer the problem presented in the introduction.