Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Complications of Adenotonsillectomy in Patients Younger Than 3 Years
Complications of Adenotonsillectomy in Patients Younger Than 3 Years
ONLINE FIRST
Complications of Adenotonsillectomy in Patients
Younger Than 3 Years
Dennis J. Spencer, BS; Jacqueline E. Jones, MD
Objective: To evaluate the complication rate for ad- most children (76.5%) between 23 and 31 months of age.
enotonsillectomy in children younger than 3 years, with- Among the patients whose records were reviewed, 80
out a diagnosis of severe obstructive sleep apnea, to as- (93.0%) did not experience any intraoperative or post-
sess the necessity for postoperative inpatient admission. operative complications. Dehydration was the most com-
mon complication and was the cause of all documented
Design: Retrospective medical record review (January readmissions (4.7%) in our patients who ranged in age
1, 2003, through October 31, 2009). from 14 to 30 months. Two patients had other compli-
cations, reactive airway disease (n=1) and postoperative
Setting: Tertiary care academic medical center. fever (n=1), which were identified and treated in the post-
anesthesia care unit, resulting in same-day discharge. No
Patients: Retrospective medical record review of 105 pa-
airway complications were noted in our study.
tients younger than 3 years who underwent adenotonsil-
lectomy performed by a single surgeon. Nineteen patients
Conclusions: Our study reveals a low complication rate
were excluded from our review because of incomplete medi-
in children younger than 3 years. The recommenda-
cal records or severe underlying disease, leaving a total of
86 patients with medical records available for inclusion in tions for mandatory admission for children younger than
our study. Patient medical records were deidentified and 3 years should be reexamined. Criteria for inpatient ad-
reviewed for age, sex, indications for surgery, intraopera- mission for children younger than 3 years should be based
tive and perioperative interventions, and postoperative com- on preoperative and postoperative clinical evaluation of
plications. One child with a diagnosis of severe obstruc- the patient and an evaluation of the family resources for
tive sleep apnea was excluded from the study. adequately caring for young children at home in the post-
operative period. These recommendations apply only to
Main Outcome Measures: Complications, includ- otherwise healthy children (American Society of Anes-
ing bleeding, dehydration requiring admission, and air- thesiologists classifications I and II) without a diagnosis
way intervention, during the intraoperative or periopera- of severe obstructive sleep apnea syndrome.
tive period were recorded.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2012;138(4):335-339.
Results: The mean age of the study population was ap- Published online March 19, 2012.
proximately 27.5 months (range, 13-35 months), with doi:10.1001/archoto.2012.1
A
T AN ANNUAL RATE OF AP- Head and Neck Surgery (AAOHNS) set
proximately 250 000 cases, guidelines recommending children
adenotonsillectomy re- younger than 3 years be treated in the in-
mains one of the most fre- patient service after adenotonsillec-
quently performed surgi- tomy.2 These recommendations were based
cal procedures by otolaryngologists in the on studies from the 1980s and early 1990s
United States.1 Primary and secondary that documented young patients to be at
hemorrhages are the major complica- greater risk for postoperative complica-
tions for all patients undergoing adenoton- tions, requiring readmission and inpa-
Author Affiliations: Weill sillectomy. Minor complications, such as tient care.
Cornell Medical College and
dehydration and refractory emesis, are of In addition to age, the AAOHNS rec-
The Rockefeller University
(Mr Spencer), and particular concern in the very young, in ommends that candidates for outpatient
New YorkPresbyterian part because of this populations limited tonsillectomy who are undergoing sur-
Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical hemodynamic reserve. In 1996, the Pedi- gery in a nonemergency fashion meet
Center (Dr Jones), New York, atric Otolaryngology Committee of the physical status criteria consistent with the
New York. American Academy of Otolaryngology/ American Society of Anesthesiologists
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 138 (NO. 4), APR 2012 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
335
A retrospective medical record review was performed analyz- Of the 105 patients whose medical records were re-
ing 105 pediatric patients younger than 3 years who under- viewed, 19 were excluded because of inadequate post-
went sequential adenotonsillectomy performed by a single sur- operative follow-up records (n=15), a prior diagnosis of
geon in a metropolitan-based practice. Institutional review board
approval from Weill Cornell Medical College was granted be-
severe obstructive sleep apnea (n=1), or the presence of
fore the studys onset. Medical records were reviewed from op- severe underlying medical conditions unrelated to their
erations performed from January 1, 2003, through October 31, need for adenotonsillectomy (n=3). The resulting 86 pa-
2009, at New YorkPresbyterian Hospital, a tertiary care medi- tients were determined to be healthy with or without very
cal center in New York City. Patient medical records were de- mild systemic disease as is consistent with the physical
identified and reviewed for age, sex, indications for surgery, status of ASA classifications I and II.
intraoperative and perioperative interventions, and postopera- Eighty-three of the 86 patients (96.5%) underwent sur-
tive complications. For the purposes of this study, intraopera- gery for an obstructive airwayrelated disease with an ad-
tive and perioperative interventions were defined as any treat- mitting diagnosis of either adenotonsillar hypertrophy
ment or intervention not part of routine care during the first or obstructive sleep apnea. Two patients (2.3%) under-
24 hours after surgery. Postoperative complications were de-
fined as any event serious enough to require readmission to a
went adenotonsillectomy for chronic or recurrent ton-
hospital or an emergency department or requiring operative in- sillitis. Eighty-one patients (94.2%) underwent electro-
tervention. Expected scenarios that met this criterion include cautery adenotonsillectomy procedures, whereas 5
hemorrhage (primary or secondary) and severe pain that re- patients (5.8%) underwent operations aided by a micro-
sulted in significant impairment of oral intake. Files were ex- debrider device. The mean age of the study population
amined for postoperative complications that may have oc- was approximately 27.5 months (range, 13-35 months),
curred within 3 weeks of surgery. Children with obstructive with most (76.5%) 23 to 31 months of age. A total of
sleep apnea deemed severe by a preoperative sleep study were 66.0% of the population was male and 34.0% female.
excluded from analysis. All children with significant comor-
bid medical conditions, such as severe asthma, heart disease,
or bleeding disorders, were also excluded from consideration.
SURGICAL OUTCOMES
All surgical procedures were supervised by a single pediat-
ric otolaryngologist ( J.E.J.), allowing for a generally standard- Among the 86 patients whose medical records were re-
ized technical method and preferred anesthesia protocol. Pa- viewed, 80 (93.0%) did not experience any intraopera-
tients were allowed clear liquids up to 2 hours before their tive or postoperative complications (Table 1). No pa-
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 138 (NO. 4), APR 2012 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
336
a Excluding the 28.0% of patients who were electively admitted for 24-hour
inpatient service.
Table 2. Documented Complications According to Patient
Demographics
vealed to us that many children who were electively ad-
Patient No./Sex/Age, mitted overnight meet all the criteria to be discharged
mo Complication Postoperative Day
home within 6 hours of completion of their surgery and
1/F/24 Dehydration 2 therefore perhaps did not require inpatient admission.
2/M/18 Dehydration 6 We therefore undertook the process of a retrospective re-
3/F/14 Dehydration 6
4/M/30 Dehydration 2
view of our patient population of children younger than
5/F/30 Reactive airway 0a 3 years undergoing adenotonsillectomy to further ad-
6/M/24 Fever 0a dress this question.
In our retrospective analysis of patients younger than
a Postoperative day 0 denotes that the complication was treated in the 3 years, complications after adenotonsillectomies were
postanesthesia care unit on the same day as the surgery. generally mild and were typically linked to dehydra-
tion. Only 2 patients experienced perioperative compli-
cations that required additional interventions in the re-
tients who underwent microdebrider-aided procedures covery room. No patients experienced severe airway
(n=5) were observed to experience complications. complications or hemorrhage in this study. Although all
Dehydration was the most common complication and complications were observed in patients who under-
was the cause of all documented readmissions (4.7%) in went electrocautery adenotonsillectomy procedures, the
our patients who ranged in age from 14 to 30 months. significantly smaller sample size of patients who under-
Our readmissions occurred between postoperative days went microdebrider-aided surgical procedures pre-
2 and 6. The sex ratio for incidence of dehydration was cludes a statistically relevant determination of a relative
1:1 among readmitted patients. Two patients experi- safety profile between the 2 techniques.
enced other complications, reactive airway disease (n=1) Our study demographic had a lower frequency of pa-
and postoperative fever (n=1), which were identified and tients 12 to 26 months of age than patients older than
treated in the postanesthesia care unit (PACU), result- 27 months. Significantly, in the 5-month span of pa-
ing in same-day discharge (Table 2). The only patient tient ages from 27 to 31 months, we report on 49 ad-
to receive additional oxygen therapy was the patient enotonsillectomy cases, constituting 57.0% of our total
treated for reactive airway disease in the recovery room. study patient population. The overrepresentation of pa-
tients in this particularly defined age range necessarily
HOSPITAL EVALUATION BEFORE DISCHARGE limits the trends that might be extrapolated from age ex-
tremes of the included patients in the study. Statistical
Patients spent on average approximately 152 minutes in significance was not reached when using the t test to com-
the PACU, excluding the 11 (12.8%) who were sched- pare the studys overall complication rate (6 of 86, 7.0%)
uled for 24-hour inpatient observation postoperatively. with rates from the grouped cohorts 12 to 26 months of
Patient stay in the PACU ranged from 60 to 360 min- age (4 of 28, 14.3%; P=.12) and 27 to 36 months of age
utes (Table 3). Patients who were electively admitted (2 of 58, 3.45%; P=.18). When viewed collectively, how-
postoperatively because of their age were evaluated in the ever, this studys overall complication rate falls beneath
inpatient unit at a minimum of 6 hours postoperatively the proposed 10% complication rate ceiling deemed ac-
for possible discharge. No patient who was electively ad- ceptable for ambulatory procedures as proposed by some
mitted received supplemental oxygen therapy. in the field.13
The geographic location from which these data were
COMMENT acquired may also affect the results observed. Our pa-
tient population was completely composed of children
The American Academy of Pediatrics and AAOHNS guide- from a metropolitan areabased practice. All patients were
lines state that all children younger than 3 years who were cared for at home and lived in a family setting where a
undergoing adenotonsillectomy should be admitted over- responsible adult was readily available to care for the child
night for postoperative observation. Our experience in during the postoperative period. All patients lived within
caring for these children during the past several years re- a 112 hour commute of the hospital.
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 138 (NO. 4), APR 2012 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
337
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 138 (NO. 4), APR 2012 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
338
ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG/ VOL 138 (NO. 4), APR 2012 WWW.ARCHOTO.COM
339