Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hui Wang, Hongmei Xu, Wencan Li, Beixu Li, Qun Shi, Kaijun Ma, Bi Xiao &
Long Chen
To cite this article: Hui Wang, Hongmei Xu, Wencan Li, Beixu Li, Qun Shi, Kaijun Ma, Bi Xiao &
Long Chen (2019): Forensic appraisal of death due to acute alcohol poisoning: three case reports
and a literature review, Forensic Sciences Research, DOI: 10.1080/20961790.2019.1572259
CASE REPORT
alcohol. A history of intravenous-drip rescue was bodies were frozen, and organ autolysis was not
found in Cases 2 and 3, which may have led to the obvious according to histology. Thus, we consider
decline in the BAC. The relationship between alco- the BAC results to be reliable. Usually, the liquor
hol intake and the BAC is expressed by the pericardii exhibits the highest alcohol concentration,
Widmark formula [25,26]: followed by the left pulmonary vein, aorta, left
heart, pulmonary artery, superior vena cava, inferior
AðgÞ ¼ BAC mg=g BWtðkgÞ rho-factor
vena cava, right heart, right pulmonary vein and
where BAC represents blood-alcohol concentration femoral vein, in decreasing order [29]. Therefore,
in mass/mass unit; BWt represents the body weight taking femoral venous blood simultaneously for a
(kg); A represents the quantity (g) of alcohol BAC test may help reduce the error from diffusion
absorbed and distributed in all body fluids and tis- of gastric contents.
sues at the time the blood sample was taken; and In fatal cases of AAP, detection of other drugs is
the rho-factor differs in different individuals. This not infrequent, of which diazepam is predominant
formula provides a preliminary inference of the [30]. Alcohol can interact with other drugs and pro-
BAC, and verifies the accuracy of the case investiga- mote their toxicological effects. Studies have shown
tion and BAC-test results. that alcohol consumption increases the risk of death
Results of ethanol determination in specimens for heroin users [31]. Methamphetamine and
postmortem can be affected by several factors, of cocaine can enhance the toxicological effects of alco-
which putrefaction and diffusion of gastric contents hol [32]. Meanwhile, the BAC decreases if the num-
postmortem are the most common [1]. Ensuring ber of other drugs in blood increases, which has an
timely submission to the test after death and keep- impact on results [33]. There are cases of death due
ing corpses frozen to inhibit bacterial activity can to alcohol combined with other poisons (e.g. inject-
reduce the interference of putrefaction postmortem. ing drugs while consuming alcohol). Indeed, some
Currently, n-propanol is used as an internal stand- criminals taint alcoholic beverages to commit
ard. However, the theory has been invalidated that crimes. In China, there is a tradition of drinking
if the deceased did not have prior alcohol consump- medicated wine, which may contain toxic compo-
tion, the ratio of alcohol/n-propanol in his/her nents such as venin or aconitine [34]. Therefore, for
blood should be <20 [14]. Therefore, the expected cases of death due to AAP, routine toxicology tests
ratio of alcohol/n-propanol must be determined. should be done to exclude the possibility of death
Ethyl glucuronide (EtG) and ethyl sulfate (EtS) by other poisons. There are many types of toxic
are products of alcohol metabolism, and can be pro- substances, so some rare toxic substances may be
duced only by enzymatic metabolism from the omitted from routine toxicology analysis. Thus, it is
body. Under some circumstances, analyses of these necessary to combine the autopsy, case details, and
ethanol metabolites can be useful to estimate putre- the crime-scene investigation with toxicology tests
faction postmortem. However, EtG has a long half- to make a comprehensive analysis. In all three cases,
life and may be unstable at 30 C or 40 C if blood routine toxicology tests were carried out, and we
samples are stored without preservatives [14]. did not find other meaningful discoveries through
Therefore, EtG cannot show that alcohol consump- case investigation and autopsy. Therefore, other poi-
tion is related directly to the death, and is not suit- sons could be excluded from the causes of death.
able for highly putrefactive corpses. In recent years, extensive studies have interpreted
The urine alcohol concentration (UAC) can help how alcohol-induced inhibition of the respiratory
to analyze alcohol metabolism. The UAC/BAC ratio centres in the brainstem help explain the cause of
could help to ascertain if the absorption and distri- AAP-related death. Acute exposure to alcohol can
bution of alcohol in all fluids is complete. Usually, a influence synaptic transmission, break the delicate
low ratio (both mean and median, 1.18:1) suggests balance between excitatory and inhibitory neurons
that alcohol has been absorbed and distributed com- in the CNS, and inhibit brain functions by altering
pletely [27]. cell membranes, ion channels, enzymes, neurotrans-
Besides its watery nature, the vitreous humour is mitter receptors, and the proteins involved in intra-
less affected by bacterial spread from the intestinal cellular signal transduction [35,36]. In pre-synaptic
tract, which makes it undergo less putrefaction post- signalling, the main function of alcohol is to
mortem and has less redistribution postmortem [1]. increase the release of c-aminobutyric acid (GABA).
Therefore, it can be used as a substitute and reliable According to in vivo and in vitro studies, alcohol
assessment if blood is deficient or if there is putre- intake can increase the GABA concentration signifi-
faction or redistribution postmortem [28]. cantly in some brain regions (amygdala, hippocam-
Our three cases were sent for autopsy and toxi- pus, brainstem) and cause a dose-dependent
cology tests 10, 17 and 18 days after death but the increase in GABA release in Purkinje cells [37,38].
FORENSIC SCIENCES RESEARCH 5
Recent studies have suggested that release of intra- with the case investigation and autopsy. The toxico-
cellular calcium, protein kinase A (PKA), protein logical effects of different drugs and their blood
kinase C (PKC) and adenylate cyclase have roles in concentration should be analyzed to determine the
this increase in the GABA concentration [39]. In true cause of death and the potential role of alcohol.
post-synaptic signalling, alcohol acts mainly on The final feature is a comprehensive analysis of vari-
neurotransmitter receptors and affects their func- ous factors. When considering deaths after alcohol
tions. Alcohol has a non-competitive inhibitory intake, investigators should not simply classify these
effect on N-methyl-D-aspartic acid receptors, which cases as AAP-related death based on their first
are highly sensitive to acute exposure to alcohol by impressions, but instead should exclude other suspi-
inhibiting calcium influx [40]. Furthermore, alcohol cious factors to ensure a strict and accurate foren-
can strengthen the affinity between GABA and sic appraisal.
GABA receptors, increase influx of chloride ions,
and enhance the long-term depression of GABAA
Authors’ contributions
receptors [41]. Experiments have shown that PKC is
necessary for the alcohol-induced potentiation of Hui Wang drafted the manuscript; Hongmei Xu helped
GABAergic function, and that PKCr plays an to draft the manuscript and polished the language;
Wencan Li, Beixu Li and Qun Shi carried out the autopsy
important part in activation of r-subunit-containing
of three cases; Kaijun Ma and Bi Xiao helped to collate
GABAA receptors [41,42]. Alcohol can also act dir- three cases; Long Chen conceived of the manuscript and
ectly on the hydrophobic domain of 5-hydroxytrypt- helped to draft the manuscript. All authors contributed to
amine-3 (5-HT3) receptors, where it makes the the final text and approved it.
opening of these channels more stable, potentiates
the function of 5-HT3 receptors and, eventually, Compliance with ethical standards
enhances CNS depression [43,44].
As stated above, the forensic appraisal of AAP- All procedures undertaken in studies involving human
participants were in accordance with the ethical standards
related death should pay attention to four main fea-
of the institutional and national research committee, and
tures. First, the case information must be consid- with the 1964 Declaration of Helsinki and its later
ered, detailed questioning of witnesses should be amendments or comparable ethical standards. We declare
conducted, and the scene should be surveyed care- that the present study complies with current Chinese law.
fully. People who have died due to AAP often have
a history of alcohol abuse. Empty or partially empty
Consent for publication
bottles of alcoholic beverages – or even vomit – can
be found at the scene of death. Investigators should Informed consent was obtained from each individual’s
family in this study.
pay attention to and collect suspicious items, such
as physical evidence on the body and clothing of the
deceased. If there is suspicion that the deceased had Disclosure statement
consumed adulterated wine or medicinal liquor or The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
had been poisoned with toxic substances other than
an alcoholic beverage, all of the edible food, drink,
and vomit should be sealed and sent for testing. Funding
Data from video surveillance can, in some cases, This research did not receive a specific grant from fund-
help clarify the activities of the deceased and other ing agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-
details. The second feature is a complete and profit sectors.
detailed autopsy. Suspicious injuries or abnormal
body conditions/phenomena postmortem should be References
looked for. AAP-related death exhibits asphyxiation
[1] Kugelberg FC, Jones AW. Interpreting results of
and excludes other causes of death, such as mechan-
ethanol analysis in postmortem specimens: a
ical injury, mechanical asphyxia or electrocution. review of the literature. Forensic Sci Int. 2007;165:
The third feature is common forensic toxicology 10–29.
testing (e.g. BAC). To eliminate interference by dif- [2] Gonzalez-Rubio E, San MI, Lopez-Ruız C, et al.
fusion of gastric contents, blood from the femoral Relationship of moderate alcohol intake and type
vein should be taken for toxicology testing. Samples of beverage with health behaviors and quality of
of urine and the vitreous humour can be taken sim- life in elderly subjects. Qual Life Res. 2016;25:
1931–1942.
ultaneously, if necessary. For highly putrefactive [3] Abramson JL, Williams SA, Krumholz HM, et al.
corpses, extraction of the vitreous humour can be Moderate alcohol consumption and risk of heart
attempted for testing [45]. Meanwhile, routine toxi- failure among older persons. JAMA. 2001;285:
cology tests should be carried out and combined 1971–1977.
6 H. WANG ET AL.
[4] Vonghia L, Leggio L, Ferrulli A, et al. Acute alco- [23] Jones AW. The drunkest drinking driver in
hol intoxication. Eur J Intern Med. 2008;19: Sweden: blood alcohol concentration 0.545% w/v. J
561–567. Stud Alcohol. 1999;60:400–406.
[5] Brewer RD, Swahn MH. Binge drinking and vio- [24] Li R, Hu L, Hu L, et al. Evaluation of acute alco-
lence. JAMA. 2005;294:616–618. hol intoxication as the primary cause of death: a
[6] Shield KD, Parry C, Rehm J. Chronic diseases and diagnostic challenge for forensic pathologists. J
conditions related to alcohol use. Alcohol Res. Forensic Sci. 2017;62:1213–1219.
2013;35:155–173. [25] Widmark EMP. Principles and applications of
[7] Pridemore WA. Weekend effects on binge drink- medicolegal alcohol determinations. Davis (CA):
ing and homicide: the social connection between Biomedical Publications; 1981.
alcohol and violence in Russia. Addiction. 2004;99: [26] Jones AW, Holmgren A. Age and gender differen-
1034–1041. ces in blood-alcohol concentration in apprehended
[8] World Health Organization. Global status report drivers in relation to the amounts of alcohol con-
on alcohol and health 2014. Geneva (Switzerland): sumed. Forensic Sci Int. 2009;188:40–45.
WHO Press; 2014. [27] Jones AW, Holmgren P. Urine/blood ratios of
[9] Afshar M, Netzer G, Salisbury-Afshar E, et al. ethanol in deaths attributed to acute alcohol poi-
Injured patients with very high blood alcohol con- soning and chronic alcoholism. Forensic Sci Int.
centrations. Injury. 2016;47:83–88. 2003;135:206–212.
[10] Baska T, Kl'uckova B, Komarekova I, et al. [28] Halter CC, Laengin A, Al-Ahmad A, et al.
Structure of deaths associated with heavy alcohol Assessment of the stability of the ethanol metabol-
use and their contribution to general mortality in ite ethyl sulfate in standardised degradation tests.
Northwest Slovakia. Int J Public Health. 2016;61: Forensic Sci Int. 2009;186:52–55.
545–551. [29] Furumiya J, Nishimura H, Nakanishi A, et al.
[11] Straka L, Zubor P, Novomesky F, et al. Fatal alco- Postmortem endogenous ethanol production and
hol intoxication in women: a forensic autopsy diffusion from the lung due to aspiration of wood
study from Slovakia. BMC Public Health. 2011;11: chip dust in the work place. Leg Med (Tokyo).
924. 2011;13:210–212.
[12] Deitrich RA, Dunwiddie TV, Harris RA, et al. [30] Darke S, Duflou J, Torok M, et al. Toxicology, cir-
cumstances and pathology of deaths from acute
Mechanism of action of ethanol: initial central ner-
alcohol toxicity. J Forensic Leg Med. 2013;20:
vous system actions. Pharmacol Rev. 1989;41:
1122–1125.
489–537.
[31] Fugelstad A, Ahlner JL, Ceder G, et al. Use of
[13] Langhan ML. Acute alcohol intoxication in adoles-
morphine and 6-monoacetylmorphine in blood for
cents: frequency of respiratory depression. J Emerg
the evaluation of possible risk factors for sudden
Med. 2013;44:1063–1069.
death in 192 heroin users. Addiction. 2003;98:
[14] Liang H, Kuang S, Guo L, et al. Assessment of the
463–470.
role played by n-propanol found in postmortem
[32] Chan LN, Anderson GD. Pharmacokinetic and
blood in the discrimination between antemortem
pharmacodynamic drug interactions with ethanol
consumption and postmortem formation of etha- (alcohol). Clin Pharmacokinet. 2014;53:1115–1136.
nol using rats. J Forensic Sci. 2016;61:122–126. [33] Jones AW, Kugelberg FC, Holmgren A, et al. Drug
[15] Arakawa T, Higuchi K, Fujiwara Y, et al. 15th poisoning deaths in Sweden show a predominance
anniversary of rebamipide: looking ahead to the of ethanol in mono-intoxications, adverse drug-
new mechanisms and new applications. Dig Dis alcohol interactions and poly-drug use. Forensic
Sci. 2005;50(Suppl 1):S3–S11. Sci Int. 2011;206:43–51.
[16] Bujanda L. The effects of alcohol consumption [34] Li HR, Liu L, Zhu SH, et al. Case reports of acon-
upon the gastrointestinal tract. Am J ite poisoning in mainland China from 2004 to
Gastroenterol. 2000;95:3374–3382. 2015: a retrospective analysis. J Forensic Leg Med.
[17] Figueredo VM, Purushottam B. Sudden cardiac 2016;42:68–73.
death and alcohol. London (UK): Springer; 2013. [35] Sommer WH, Spanagel R. Behavioral neurobiology
[18] De Donno A, Marrone M, Santoro VA, et al. A of alcohol addiction. Heidelberg (DE): Springer;
singular case of asphyxia by choking on a hand- 2013.
kerchief: accidental event or suicide to “shut-up” [36] Mukherjee S, Das SK, Vaidyanathan K, et al.
spirits. Clin Ter. 2017;168:e293–e296. Consequences of alcohol consumption on neuro-
[19] Jones AW, Holmgren P. Comparison of blood- transmitters – an overview. Curr Neurovasc Res.
ethanol concentration in deaths attributed to acute 2008;5:266–272.
alcohol poisoning and chronic alcoholism. J [37] Criswell HE, Ming Z, Kelm MK, et al. Brain
Forensic Sci. 2003;48:874–879. regional differences in the effect of ethanol on
[20] Winek CL, Wahba WW, Winek CL, et al. Drug GABA release from presynaptic terminals. J
and chemical blood-level data 2001. Forensic Sci Pharmacol Exp Ther. 2008;326:596–603.
Int. 2001;122:107–123. [38] Roberto M, Madamba SG, Stouffer DG, et al.
[21] Heatley MK, Crane J. The blood alcohol concen- Increased GABA release in the central amygdala of
tration at post-mortem in 175 fatal cases of alcohol ethanol-dependent rats. J Neurosci. 2004;24:
intoxication. Med Sci Law. 1990;30:101–105. 10159–10166.
[22] Tormey WP, Moore TM. Ethanol as a single toxin [39] Kelm MK, Criswell HE, Breese GR. The role of
in non-traumatic deaths – a toxicology perspective. protein kinase A in the ethanol-induced increase
Leg Med (Tokyo). 2013;15:122–125. in spontaneous GABA release onto cerebellar
FORENSIC SCIENCES RESEARCH 7
Purkinje neurons. J Neurophysiol. 2008;100: [43] Lovinger DM. Ethanol potentiates ion current
3417–3428. mediated by 5-HT3 receptors on neuroblastoma
[40] White G, Lovinger DM, Weight FF. Ethanol inhib- cells and isolated neurons. Alcohol Alcohol Suppl.
its NMDA-activated current but does not alter 1991;1:181–185.
GABA-activated current in an isolated adult mam- [44] Barann M, Ruppert K, G€othert M, et al. Increasing
malian neuron. Brain Res. 1990;507:332–336. effect of ethanol on 5-HT3 receptor-mediated 14C-
[41] Lovinger DM, Roberto M. Synaptic effects induced guanidinium influx in N1E-115 neuroblastoma
by alcohol. Curr Top Behav Neurosci. 2013;13: cells. Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch Pharmacol.
31–86. 1995;352:149–156.
[42] Choi DS, Wei W, Deitchman JK, et al. Protein [45] Harper DR. A comparative study of the microbio-
kinase Cd regulates ethanol intoxication and logical contamination of postmortem blood and
enhancement of GABA-stimulated tonic current. J vitreous humour samples taken for ethanol deter-
Neurosci. 2008;28:11890–11899. mination. Forensic Sci Int. 1989;43:37–44.