Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EDRE 4860
Annotated Bibliography
1. Daiute, C., & Dalton, B. (1993). Collaboration between children learning to write:
A study on a group of seven to nine-year-old children in third grade who wrote both
individual and collaborative stories over a 3-month period. The study focuses on whether
collaborating in writing at a young age is beneficial for end product in terms of creativity and
final product. Stories written by these students are analyzed in the study, in addition to a
transcript of the collaboration process that occurs between the students who collaborate
together as they create their stories. The focus of this study works on both intellectual and
social energies that students use and create in their text creations.
2. Ennis, R. P., Jolivette, K., & Losinski, M. (2017). The effects of writing choice
This study was one of interest to me specifically because it involved the focal group of six
female students with emotional and behavioral disorders. The students had just completed
grades 7-10, and were working on what effects would occur when given the choice of their
own designed prompt for written narratives. Although this study was abandoned due to null
original question of whether writing prompts have a negative or positive affect on writing for
students. The fact that this study was unsuccessful because of the choice prompts leads me to
believe that there are specific cases where this strategy of writing isnt a one-size-fits-all
verbal or written prompt that identifies two or more response options a student may make.
(p. 186)
3. Hudson, R. F., Lane, H. B., & Mercer, C. D. (2005). Writing prompts: The role of
This study looks into whether or not writing prompts effect the compositional fluency of
second-grade students, in addition to examining how differing spelling level and handwriting
fluency may or may not effect those results. Six separate narratives per student written in
reaction to writing prompts are analyzed for this study, particularly looking at different ways
that they can presented. Students are instructed to use copying, dictation, discussion,
demonstrates that students in the fourth, eighth, and eleventh grades have not improved much
4. Joshua, M., Andrade, W. E., Garber-Budzyn, S., Greene, V., Hassan, E., Jones, N.
M., Valentine, S. (2007). The effects of pictures and prompts on the writing of
students in primary grades: Action research by graduate students at California
This particular study is more focused on how childrens writing can be affected when given
picture-specific prompts for writing, rather than just a word or question prompt. The study
worked with elementary students from kindergarten through second grade, and had two
phases of research. It is an interesting read because it delves into the theory of whether using
a picture alongside a writing prompt or simply a writing prompt without a picture has a better
affect on student writing. The results are interesting and seem to point to a need for necessary
background experience and understanding of the English language in order for students to be
truly successful. The results also showed that in kindergarten as well as with second-
language learners, a picture accompanying a writing prompt is best for writing success,
We know that pictures and art as created by children and incorporated into the writing
process facilitate better writing by helping to shape childrens ideas and by providing them
with a tool for thinking through, organizing, and designing stories. (p. 82)
5. Roth, K., & Guinee, K. (2011). Ten minutes a day: The impact of interactive writing
This article focused on a specific type of writing strategy called Interactive Writing that is
primarily used with young students in independent writing. The study used first graders from
an urban school in a densely populated metropolitan area. It examined the effects of students
writing ability and product when responding to a writing prompt after participating in
Interactive Writing learning. I chose this article because it not only looked into the uses of
writing prompts, but it also analyzed what happened when an additional writing strategy, that
of Interactive Writing, was included. The results showed that writing improved in both
independent writing for these students, but they also scored higher in nine out of 10 of
during which the teacher and students work together to construct a meaningful text while
6. Tompkins, G. E. (2012). Teaching Writing: Balancing Process and Product (6th ed.).
Teaching generating skills: explaining five strategies for generating ideas for writing stories
which include brainstorming, clustering, drawing, quick writing, and talking. Brainstorming
includes creating lists of words and phrases that pertain to a topic. Clustering has the
appearance of a spiders web or concept map, used to cluster the ideas that were
drawing pictures that correspond with ideas that have been generated for writing. Quick
writing is thought of as quick bursts of thinking written on paper, usually written between
three to five minutes. Talking involves using partners and pairs to help with coming up with
Students use the generating strategy to gather ideas and collect words for writing. (p. 37)
7. Tompkins, G. E. (2012). Teaching Writing: Balancing Process and Product (6th ed.).
Teaching prewriting skills: explaining how students can choose a topic that has a purpose,
and organize it into coherent thoughts. Considering choosing a topic, considering purpose,
considering audience, considering genre, and gathering & organizing ideas. This chapter was
very vocal in the importance of generating ideas for writing stories rather than automatically
knowing what the topic will be. The following quote deals with this sentiment exactly, and I
The traditional notion that writers have thought out their topic completely is ridiculous: if
writers wait for ideas to fully develop, theyll wait forever. (p. 6)
8. Zumbrunn, S., & Bruning, R. (2013;2012;). Improving the writing and knowledge of
This study focused primarily on the effects of using a specific strategy called Self-Regulated
Strategy Development (SRSD) for instruction involving the writing skills and understanding.
The participants of the study included six first grade students, and they wrote story based
writing after being instructed with the SRSD strategy. I chose this article because it is another
example of using picture prompts in writing, and it also incorporates a specific strategy
(SRSD) when exploring writing through picture prompts. I wanted to compile a list of
potential strategies to use in conjunction with implementing a written or picture prompt for
writing production and instruction. The results of this study were positive, and showed a
beneficial improvement for the first graders writing skills at the conclusion of using the
If, as some research has shown, even very young writers are able to develop basic writing
developing such skills very early in the schooling years might help circumvent future writing