Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Amber Li
Dr. Mitchell
UWRT 1104-040
18 October 2017
What many people dont understand about the world is that global conflicts are a constant
occurrence. Through this essay there will be detailed explanations and examples of different
types of global conflicts in different nations other than America. Different outcomes of these
conflicts will help us acknowledge the importance of understanding them, and developing ways
to prevent these conflicts. According to scholars, global conflicts have been on a rise from 1946-
present day. Conflict is a part of life. We cant hide from it, cant avoid it, but if we try, we can
resolve it. ("Stefan Wolff: The path to ending ethnic conflicts | TED Talk | TED.com."
2010.20). This quote discusses how conflicts are all around us in daily life and how getting
caught up in conflict is inevitable. Despite that fact there are multiple conflict resolutions and
negotiations that can be promoted to stop the continuation or start of new conflicts.
The idea that historians and conflict scholars put forth, reveals that both agree the best
way to learn is to gain knowledge about the less known situations as well as the popular
situations. For example, what we hear most is the conflict that the U.S. Military is involved in
the war in Iraq and Afghanistan. What other conflicts is there in the world? When there are only
certain conflict events that people learn about, the stereotypes start to develop, and other related
conflicts tend to be forgotten or buried in the past. In short, to be able to find out why global
2
conflicts are on the rise, learn about the least known conflicts to gain a wider perspective on it. In
brief, the civil war in Libya; Territorial Disputes in Ukraine; and the Yugoslav Wars are included
in maintaining a stand on global conflicts. Furthermore, these are also examples of civil wars and
It is important to keep an open mind and gain knowledge about conflicts like ethnic
cleansing or civil wars that help bring out ways to prevent conflicts from happening again. First,
consider the historical account of the breakup of Yugoslavia during the Yugoslav wars from
1989-1992. Former Yugoslavia was made up of six constituent republics joined under one
Geography Crash ...." 25 Mar. 2017, Accessed 15 Nov. 2017. )2( "Breakup of Yugoslavia -
demonstrate this a documentary about Basketball starting in Yugoslavia was made called Once
Brothers. The title itself gives off an emotional connotation to how one harmful act by a player
broke the teammates up for good politically. In addition, the documentary follows the point of
view of Vlade Divac from the moment Yugoslavia won the National Basketball Championships
in Argentina. Vlade performed one innocent move of taking a Croatian flag from a Croat saying,
Yugoslavia is one, and threw the flag on the ground. This was of course caught on camera by
the press and quickly became viral amongst the citizens of Yugoslavia. (3 "30 For 30 Once
1
"Centripetal vs. Centrifugal Forces: AP Human Geography Crash ...." 25 Mar. 2017,
https://www.albert.io/blog/centripetal-vs-centrifugal-forces-ap-human-geography-crash-course/.
Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.
2
"Breakup of Yugoslavia - Wikipedia." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakup_of_Yugoslavia. Accessed
15 Nov. 2017.
3
(# "30 For 30 Once Brothers-Bir Zamanlar Kardetiler (Trke Altyazl ...." 27 Aug. 2013,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DKYoktdtxOI.)
3
created a good reason for the Croatians to interpret that the Serbians had ill intentions on them.
Since the Serbians at the time gained all control of the government of Yugoslavia, Croatians
thought it was unfair that only Serbians got to rule. Vlade, who threw the Croatian flag down on
the ground was a Serb. That one move Vlade thought was innocent was viewed differently by
masses. Not only did he destroy the feeling of brotherhood amongst the Yugoslavian players, his
actions also lead to an inter republic war breaking out. Vlade had to suffer through not only the
breakup of his nation but also the dissolution of his brotherhood relationship with his teammates
in basketball. Differing ideologies creates different ideas about how independence can be
reached.
Like many wars, cultural and religious differences amongst the ethnic groups solidified
the impending breakup of Yugoslavia. Due to the leadership of former leader Slobodan
Milosevic, inter-ethnic tensions in Bosnia, Herzegovina, and Croatia rose causing centrifugal
Nationalist forces to break up relationships. ( "Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...."
What the republics wanted was the end of Milosevic abusing power of the Serbs and
independence from the Communist powers (5"The Breakup of Yugoslavia, 19901992 - Office
15 Nov. 2017.). As I informed before, in former Yugoslavia, there were civil wars which
4
"The Breakup of Yugoslavia, 19901992 - Office of the Historian."
https://history.state.gov/milestones/1989-1992/breakup-yugoslavia. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.)
5
"Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17 Nov. 2017, https://www.cfr.org/interactives/global-
conflict-tracker. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.
4
occurred in Slovenia between Belgrade and the Slovenes. Next conflicts in Serbia dominated
Then there was the war in Bosnia-Herzegovina in which ethnic cleansing was initiated.
Ethnic Cleansing was initiated by the Serbs and Croats against large populations of Muslim
Bosniaks. It broke up families and friends in all the republics because of the hostile atmosphere
in the nation. Secondly, there is the Civil war in Libya with the fall of Libyas Colonel
Muammar Al-Gaddafi (Gaddafi) in 2011, Libya has been struggling to rebuild their state
institutions. Its former leader is Fayez al-Sarraj who is also serving as the Government of
National Accord 6(Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17 Nov. 2017,
state Gaddafi left Libya in the country is now buried in chaotic unrest. However, the main
obstacle which is preventing the government from resolving the unrest, is that there is no control
over the rebel militias which have risen in power and strength. Certain leaders tried to resolve the
With no organization trying to prevent these Jihadists loyal to Gaddafi took advantage of
the political instability and gained land to broaden their range of violence and launch even more
attacks. In addition to the tensions, the UN tried to resolve the conflicts between the Jihadists and
citizens of Libya, but to no avail. What ended up happening was that the UN tried backing a
Government of National Accord to discuss plans of creating a new government. However, once
arriving in Libya to have negotiations with the lawmakers refuted the negotiation. Moreover, the
battle between the two warring groups of Jihadist and rebel Militias have resulted in recurring
bloodshed. Karl Marlantes reasons, People cant judge rationally when it is a religious fight.
6
"Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17 Nov. 2017, https://www.cfr.org/interactives/global-
conflict-tracker. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.
5
(Marlantes, Page 54). Marlantes is trying to express that when religions that are looked down
upon are involved then people tend to be closed minded. What tends to happen is that
condemnation is brought down upon certain religions which makes it even harder for individuals
to discern which side is right and which side is wrong. Without the correct political resolutions,
laws, or leadership then Libya will time and time again fall vulnerable to extremist forces
wishing to seize power. Indeed, there needs to be more emphasis put on the severity of these
conflicts. Currently there is a recent conflict which deals with the territorial dispute in Ukraine.
Accordingly in Ukraine, statistics reveal that 10,090 people have been killed while 1.6
million people are internally displaced (7 "Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17
The front line of this territorial conflict is about two hundred and eighty miles long in Ukraine.
Circumstances in Ukraine seem dim because of the frequency of shelling and violent skirmishes
that are still going on. What exactly caused this violent manner to be uprooted? The main cause
asserts the result of Russia blaming Ukraine for plotting terrorist attacks on Crimea. Russia,
however carried out a large war and military exercises in Crimea to show Russian control over
the territory. The incident started out as a protest directed toward Ukrainian president, Viktor
Yanukovich, because he rejected a deal the citizens wanted to take place (8 "Global Conflict
conflict-tracker. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.). The people felt like they were not being listened to,
and felt wronged. With more problems to be found and resolved people like us need to be more
curious to what is happening there. When we do it helps promote the moral code that our country
7
"Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17 Nov. 2017, https://www.cfr.org/interactives/global-
conflict-tracker. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.
8
"Global Conflict Tracker - Council on Foreign ...." 17 Nov. 2017, https://www.cfr.org/interactives/global-
conflict-tracker. Accessed 15 Nov. 2017.
6
has abided by. The United States is finding ways to help resolve this tension through the UN, .
Ethnic scholar Stefan Wolff points out, There is no bad war and no good peace. (The meaning
of this quote is that there is no single bad war, because all wars throughout history are equally as
bad. There really is no peace that will be lasting because of different ideas amongst the citizens
of countries which if not handled well may turn into small conflicts.
Why is it important to be curious about conflicts and how can they be prevented?
Lieutenant Murphey Archibald gave advice in a lecture to, Think hard about what you hear or
learn, go behind it, have an open mind; dont accept everything you learn or hear. (Lieutenant
Murphey Archibald, Vietnam War Veteran Global Connections Course Lecture. October 18,
2017.). If everyone can be more engaged in finding out the nitty gritty details of how any conflict
happens there may be hope in preventing other mistakes from happening. Archibald insists that
people should question everything that people say. He also reminded the audience to not be
afraid to ask the dumb questions or any question that has not been asked yet. Some steps that can
be taken to prevent conflicts include: sustainable peace organizations in countries and better
leadership and government officials. Leadership is important to gain more order in the nation.
War is societys dirty work, usually done by kids cleaning up failures perpetrated by adults.
(Marlantes, 184). This quote makes people think deeply about how sometimes nations are being
led by an inexperienced child which results in the military coming in to clean up the mess that
is left behind by their decisions. The next step will be to find better ways in having negotiations
about conflicts.
An important one is to have better negotiations and policies put forth to put ends to civil
wars. The preferred way is to allow all conflict parties to see their core conflicts and address any
questions or concerns that need to be brought up. For citizens of that country the rights of the
7
individuals and communities should be voiced at every negotiation so neither side is felt to be
left in the dark. Being in a difficult situation and making difficult decisions will eventually
create more responsibility. Dont be afraid to be curious. Dont forget to ask the hard questions.
(Lieutenant Murphey Archibald, Vietnam War Veteran Global Connections Course Lecture.
October 18, 2017.). Lieutenant Archibald reveals that sometimes individuals will not fully
understand the actual conflict unless they are right in the middle of it. Though, experiencing and
learning more about the conflict will cause us to be more responsible and mature in choosing
decisions. It is okay to be curious about different conflicts and to ask the questions that are hard
to answer. Hence these are the key in discovering what needs to be taken into consideration for
conflicts to be resolved. In like manner it is important to keep in mind is that Peace is the start of
reconciliation, not the end of everything because it takes time. It is the people's responsibility to
be open minded and aware of what is going on around the world rather than not ask the hard
questions.
In conclusion the key to better understanding how to prevent future incidents of conflicts
from arising, is to be informed on what is going on in the world around us. Many people tend to
overlook certain important factors as to why conflicts are becoming recurring and seem to not
care about how conflicts can be fixed. Conflicts are part of human nature and will always be
around us. It is up to the people to be more open minded and critical of the information given on
global conflicts so that steps can be taken to resolve these said conflicts. We should care about
the hard topics even if we havent experienced conflicts like these. To care and spreading the
Annotated Bibliography
Berg, Peter. Once Brothers. Youtube, uploaded by Umut Yasar, 27 August 2013,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DKYoktdtxOI
This documentary on 30 for 30 is a primary source. The main idea of the video is to follow NBA
basketball player Vlade Divac (Serbian) and Drazen Petrovic (Croatian) through the breakup of
Yugoslavia due to ethnic tensions between two states during the early 1990s. Their story
involved sports mixed with political differences. After World War II Yugoslavia was introduced
as six different republics united under similar economic currencies. Vlade Divac was a basketball
player in the Yugoslavian National Team, which included Croatian, Serbian, Bosnian, and
Macedonian players. During one critical basketball tournament Yugoslavia won gold at the
World Championships (Argentina 1990). Drazen and Vlade embraced each other and their team
since they were as close as brothers could get. Everyone was celebrating and one person, a Croat
held up and waved the Croatian flag to celebrate. Vlade out of impulse took the flag out of the
person's hand and threw it on the ground announcing Yugoslavia is united., but little did Vlade
know that that one move would damage the relationship between his whole team. His actions
were caught on news and spread around the nation, causing the Serbians to feel elated since the
Serbs were the ones in charge of the government. Yet hatred and betrayal were felt from the
9
Croatians since the action made them feel like they were being stepped on. A civil war broke out
involving ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia which affected many relationships. Lots of people died
and it got so bad that from 1991-1992 tensions were so tense Yugoslavia started to break apart.
The scope of this documentary is that starting from the beginning Vlade Divac wished to go back
in time to find out what happened to his team, his friends, his brothers. The organization who
filmed this 30 for 30 films was ESPN, director Peter Berg. For this documentary series about
issues, teams, people, and tensions ESPN hired award-winning directors, Denzel Washington
and
Forest Whitaker They worked with NBA to produce that documentary. Denzel Washington is
known for winning three Golden Globes awards for his acting, producing, and directing jobs. He
has also won two Academy awards. This source is extremely credible due to it being a fact-based
documentary which follows Vlade Divac through the actual civil war in Yugoslavia. Volume 1
aired October 6, 2009 to December 10, 2010. The date of the source fits with the timeline for my
topic of the reasons for mass killings and genocide. It has helped me realize that ethnic tensions
in any country can end badly and effect many citizens. Vlade and Petrovic completely cut of
communications when playing basketball for their own NBA teams in America. When they did
know that the other was back in Yugoslavia to visit, neither tried to visit each other due to what
Vlade did with the Croatian flag at that fateful game. I did not know that even ethnic differences
could reach relationships through sports too. This source is very helpful in helping me extinguish
how political and economic aspects are related to the start of ethnic cleansing or civil war. This
source also reveals that respect towards different nationalities and races needs to be implemented
Blum, R, GH Stanton, S Sagi, and ED Richter. "'ethnic Cleansing' Bleaches the Atrocities of
In volume 18 Issue 2 of the European Journal of Public Health they define what the actual
nationalism. The acts of genocide are greatly used with Xenophobic totalitarian regimes
and political mass murder on large scales. Examples include Armenian genocide in the
Ottoman Empire in 1915. The Soviets in 1988 used the term Atnicheskie Christki to
massacres. Like Hitler with the Jews; and Stalin with the deportation of over two million
members of ethnic minorities to slave labor camps in Serbia. In both situations, more than
hundreds and thousands of lives were lost. The conflict in Bosnia can be labeled as
genocide while Kosovo at that time was claimed as ethnic cleansing. Prominent genocide
legal scholar William Schabas says that ethnic cleansing can never be labeled as
genocide because the real intent is to drive out a population, whereas genocide is the
destroying of the populations. In Bosnia, Kosovo, Rwanda, and Darfur while diplomats
debated negotiations, perpetrators raped, killed, and tortured civilians. The UN had
diplomatic excuses to make which allowed 1.6 million crisis affected people and about
70,000 deaths by late 2004. The numbers quickly rising to 400,000 deaths. This source is
which covers how people should not use the word Ethnic Cleansing to describe acts of
genocide. For this there are multiple authors of this journal including Rony Blum,
11
Gregory H. Stanton, Shira Sagi, and Elihu D. Richtor. It is a popular source since it
targets readers for learning about specific word definitions. The audience includes public
health specialists and any person interested in Journals about the difference between
genocide and ethnic cleansing. These journals were published in 2008 which fits in with
my timeline of global conflicts involving mass killings. Truthfully this source is not
useful to me because it reiterates the information I learned from my other sources. It also
only distinguishes how journalists, the UN, and social media wrongly labels what
conflicts are genocides and which are ethnic cleansing. This source seems to have a lot of
references at the end of the journal to other books or articles in google scholar or another
place. I do not know if this source is reliable. Since it contains info I already know from
Center for Preventive Action. Global Conflict Tracker, Council of Foreign Relations, 1921,
www.cfr.org/interactives/global-conflict-tracker#!/global-conflict-tracker. Accessed
The Global Conflicts Tracker website is a primary source showcasing critical, significant, or
formatted so navigation on the website is easy. The dots which symbolize different
conflicts vary in color on the map with critical/urgent (red dot), significant (orange dot),
and Limited cases (green dot). The connection between the colors signify how these
conflicts impacts U.S Interests. There are three major types of conflicts to focus on the
website which are Civil Wars, Territorial Disputes, and Transnational Terrorism. The
summary of the various information on this website contain those three topics. Civil War
12
in Libya has an estimated 6,000 Islamic fighters and 434,869 internationally displaced
persons. In March 30, 2016, the UN tried to back a Government of national accord which
arrived in Libya to discuss a plan for a new government to take control. Libyan
lawmakers rejected the proposal harshly and snubbed the UNs efforts to find a resolution
between the two warring factions in Libya. About 76,000 refugees made their journey in
a boat from Libya to Europe due to the constant bloodshed between the factions of
Jihadists and militias. This problem is rated critical (red dot) for the US. Ukraine is
having a territorial conflict causing death of 10,090 people and 1.6 million people
displaced. The front line of this conflict is 280 miles long in Ukraine. This conflict started
in early 2014 and recently has reached a stalemate. Frequent shelling and skirmishes still
go on and violence has spiked. Rises in civilian casualties has risen concerns of further
escalation of the conflict. The main reason Ukraine is doing bad is because Russia
blamed Ukraine for plotting terrorist attacks in Crimea. Russia however carried a large
war and military exercises in Crimea to show Russian control over the territory. It first
started out as a protest towards Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanukovich, who rejected a
deal for greater economic integration. Rated significant (Orange dot) The last conflict is
the Islamist Militancy in Pakistan which goes under the title Transnational Terrorism.
Attacks slowed through 2015 but there was an attack on Bacha Khan University which
killed twenty-one people. This attack revealed their resiliency to carry out attacks. Not
soon after a suicide bombing attack was made on a hospital targeting lawyers, killing
more than seventy-five people and injuring 100. Attacks on Christians, the court system,
and Pakistani security forces are on a rise there. There are 130 estimated number of
nuclear weapons in Pakistan. 2,799 number of militants killed by drones flown in by the
13
U.S. since 2006, and 655 million dollars in U.S foreign assistance. Rated significant
(orange dot).The source was created by the Council on Foreign Relations and the Center
for Preventive Action. CFR was formed in the year of 1921 and does not take
can look up information and articles on international matters. This global conflict tracker
is objective because it provides fact based details on conflicts around the world. This
executives, journalists, editors, and any other citizen to help them better understand the
world and the foreign choices made. It is different than my other sources because it goes
into more detail about certain events and misunderstandings which lead to the start of
terrorist attacks or civil wars. It reveals more statistical numbers on how many lives were
lost or how many civilians got injured in the skirmish. Information is updated daily with
the last revision September 20, 2017. It will go into my research project due to its
accuracy in providing factual evidence of mass killings and or genocides around the
world. The Council on Foreign Relations does not take institutional positions on matters
of policy. This source is reliable and trustworthy because the CFR is a leading foreign
policy organization that shares information to better inform what is going on in the world.
It has helped me realize that engagement in ethnic conflicts are more complex than
Wolff, Stefan. The Path to ending Ethnic Conflicts. Tedtalks, uploaded by TEDtalks, 10 July
2010,
www.ted.com/talks/stefan_wolff_the_path_to_ending_ethnic_conflicts
14
The Path to ending Ethnic Conflicts, is a talk presented at a TED conference in front of
an audience of other scholars. TEDGlobal posted it on their website so the public could
Scholar who studies prevention and settlement of Ethnic Conflicts. The lecture provided
a different side of conflicts revealing that there is hope for settling on peace and
agreements between governments only if they take the chance to work together. Ethnic
conflicts are a constant presence as a major international security threat these past few
decades. Torture, Rape, and ethnic cleansing have become effective non-lethal weapons
in civil wars around the globe. We are met with bad news and haunting images of how
civil wars have affected people. Some examples include the Russia and Georgia Five Day
War. There was a genocide in Rwanda in 1994, with a death of 800,000 civilians
slaughtered like pigs. In 2007 citizens in Kenya protested presidential elections, the
skirmish killing and displacing thousands of people. In Kyrgyzstan levels of violence has
risen between ethnic Kyrgyz and Ethnic Uzbeks. What needs to be found are possible
sustainable solutions to end these tensions. However, after the Cold War there has been
an overall decline in civil wars. In fact, 30% fewer than a decade ago. There is no bad
war and no good peace. Why are the numbers of civil wars decreasing? Three factors
answer the question which include leadership, diplomacy, and Institutional Design.
Violence numbers are decreasing due to military solutions, cease fire agreements, and
peace negotiations. In Africa Wolffs colleague noted that The ceasefire on Tuesday
night was just in time for a genocide on Wednesday morning. In other words, the
negotiations in Africa on preventing civil wars to erupt failed. However, there are
examples of good news on this topic. There was a historic agreement in Northern Ireland
15
during 1998 signed by Senator George Mitchell. This agreement imposed very clear
their core conflicts and questions addressed. The rights of individuals and entire
communities were clearly voiced too. Modifications were put into place on the peace
agreement by the Irish and British governments in 2006 and 2008. Macedonia in 2001
ended their civil war as well as Liberia in 2003, and the successful ending of the ethnic
conflict in Aceh in Indonesia in 2005. With all three cases leaders came together to
develop peace agreements and compromises to end the tensions. The source came from a
ethnic conflicts named Stefan Wolff. However, the speech seemed to involve both
objective and biased perspectives on ethnic civil wars. Wolff tended to include his
opinions throughout stating The good news is.... institutions can choose to come
together to form negotiations and agreements on the conflicts. The key dates and
specific events included in the source is reliable because they are facts. Though Wolffs
opinion on how to prevent ethnic conflicts and have sustainable peace can be
questionable. The audience targeted for this speech includes other scholars anyone
interested in the topic, in other words public. This source was helpful for me in the fact
that Wolff added some detail on what happened to lead these underdeveloped countries
into civil war. I would use this in my research to have as examples of how lack of
leadership, diplomacy, and institutional design can cause nations to fall into conflicts.
The source made me see a different side of conflict, not only the bad side but also the
good. There are always improvements that can be made in worldwide negotiations on
peace.
16