You are on page 1of 15

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

ScienceDirect

Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

-<9F8 "BH9FB5H=CB5@ 9C;F5D<M,MADCG=IA


(& 

::97HGC:HCDC;F5D<M5B87@=A5H9CBH<997C@C;MC:
-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB C:-IF?9M
"6F5<=AH5@5M5 +979D :96 &YB=FRNHYF?7
(
,6(793,495-,5.7(6/>51:?>2:2$40;,7809>?307#:71,>
)
,6(793,495-,5.7(6/>(201,807$40;,7809>(201,807#:71,>
*
.,$40;,7809>,6(793,495-59(4>?307#:71,>

"#!#

-<9 -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG =B H<9 GCIH< C: -IF?9M 5F9 5B CFC;9B=7 69@H A5=B@M @M=B; =B H<9 K9GH
95GH 8=F97H=CB K=H< K9GH9FB 5B8
79BHF5@D5FHG @C75H98CBH<9&98=H9FF5B95B 7C5GH@=B9 -<95@H=HI89 C:H<=G ACIBH5=BCIG7<5=B 9L7998G A9H9FG 5H GCA9D@579G
-<=G GHI8M K5G 75FF=98 CIH =B CF89F HC 89H9FA=B9 H<9 97C@C;=75@ 9::97HG C: H<9 HCDC;F5D<=75@ 5B8 7@=A5H=7 :57HCFG CB -5IFIG
&CIBH5=BG -<985H5CBH<95F955B8H<9 GI6>97HK5GGIFJ9M98 7C@@97H98 5B5@MN98 5B87@5GG=:=98=BH9FAGC:H<9F9@9J5B79HCH<9
HCD=7 5B8 H<9 5F95   =;=H5@ @9J5H=CB &C89@ & C: H<9 -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG 5B8 =HG J=7=B=HM K5G 7F95H98 HC 89H9FA=B9 H<9
HCDC;F5D<=75@ 7CB8=H=CBG     G75@98 A5DG K9F9 IG98 HC 89H9FA=B9 H<9 ;9C@C;=75@ :95HIF9G C: H<9 5F95  5H5 CB ;9C@C;M
HCDC;F5D<M  5B8 7@=A5H9 K9F9 7CAD=@98 @=A5H=7 85H5 K5G DFCJ=898 6M 8=::9F9BH A9H9CFC@C;=75@ GH5H=CBG 5B8 9J5@I5H98  -<9
97C@C;=75@ 7CB8=H=CBGC: H<9GHI8M5F95K9F9 5@GC 89H9FA=B98 A5D 8=GD@5M=B;H<985H5C6H5=B985B8H<997C@C;=75@7CB8=H=CBG
C:H<95F95 K5GDFC8I798 @@:IB85A9BH5@85H5CBHCDC;F5D<M K5G 7CAD5F98K=H<97C@C;=75@:95HIF9G =BCF89F HC:=B8CIHH<9
=BH9FF9@5H=CBG<=DG -<F99 8=GH=B7H J9;9H5H=CB69@HGK9F989H97H98 -<95GD97H:57HCF=G=ADCFH5BH:CFH<9F979DH=CBC:GC@5FF58=5H=CB
5B8K=B8 5B8:CFH<9DF9J9BH=CBC:H<9:FCBHG ,@CD9 =B7@=B5H=CB=GH<9A5=B:57HCF:CFGC=@5B8D5F9BHA5H9F=5@9FCG=CB

© 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
O -<9IH<CFG )I6@=G<986M@G9J=9F%H8
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013.
,9@97H=CB5B8D99F
F9J=9KIB89FF9GDCBG=6=@=HMC:+979D:9 &IB=F(NHIF?5B8"6F5<=AH5@5M
,><57+8-CDC;F5D<M97C@C;M -5IFIG&CIBH5=BG&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB

CFF9GDCB8=B;5IH<CF -9@ 




 :5LBCB9
3(02(++7,88 F979D9:9<CHA5=@ 7CA

1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013.
doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.02.091
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 143

 #!$#

-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB C:-IF?9M 5F9ACIBH5=BCIG5F95G899D@M8=GG97H986MH<9F=J9FG5G


7CAD5F98HCCH<9FACIBH5=BCIG5F95GC:-IF?9M -<=GG=HI5H=CB=G7CBG=89F56@MF9GDCBG=6@9:CFH<9D@5BH8=GHF=6IH=CB
5B8 DFC8I7H=J=HM C: :CF9GHG 99D@M 8=GG97H98 5B8 <=;< HCDC;F5D<M 7CBH5=BG AI7< ACF9 D@5BHG H<5B @CK 5B8 :@5H
HCDC;F5D<M -<9 FI;;98HCDC;F5D<M K=H< A5BM<56=H5HGGIDDCFHGH<9;FCKH<C: 5@5F;9BIA69FC: D@5BHG69@CB;=B;
HC8=::9F9BHD<MHC;9C;F5D<=75@F9;=CBG (BH<9CH<9F<5B8 5@H=HI89G 56CJ9  A 7CBHF=6IH9 H<F99 J9FH=75@NCB5H=CB
C:J9;9H5H=CB ?BCKB5G CFC
J9;9H5H=CB69@HG GD97H:57HCF9GD97=5@@MBCFH<5B8GCIH<G@CD9GC:H<9ACIBH5=BG5B8
J5@@9MG=B H<9 G5A9F9;=CB 5F97CJ9F986M 8=::9F9BHJ9;9H5H=CB7CAAIB=H=9G89D9B8=B;CBGC@5FF58=5H=CBF979=J98
-<9 8=F97H=CB C: ACIBH5=B F5B;9G :CFAG 5 65FF=9F HC H<9 ACJ=B; C: K=B8G 5B8 :FCBHG 5B8 H<9=F G@CD9 DF9J9BHG H<9
:FCBHG H<9F9:CF9 ;9HH=B; AI7< ACF9 DF97=D=H5H=CB H<5B 657?K5F8 G=89  -<9 K=89 5B8 899D J5@@9M 9LH9B8=B; =B 5
D5F5@@9@8=F97H=CBC:8CA=B5BH K=B8G 7CBHF=6IH9GHC H<9 ACJ9A9BH H<FCI;<H<9=BH9FB5@ G=89 C:H<9 ACIBH5=BG -<9
ACIBH5=BG 5@GC DFC8I79 :X<B K=B8G =B H<9 @CK@5B8G LDCG98 D5F9BH A5H9F=5@G 5B8 CF FC7?G 5G 5 F9GI@H C: 9FCG=CB
7CBG=89F56@M89H9FA=B9H<98=GHF=6IH=CBC:J9;9H5H=CB5B8DFC8I7H=J=HM
"BH<=GGHI8MH<9HCDC;F5D<=79::97HGCBH<9G=H9=B89LCFDFC8I7H=J=HMC::CF9GHGH5B8G=BH<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG =G
8=G7IGG98 6975IG9 ?5FGH=7 @5B8G 7CBH5=B=B; GD97=5@ HCDC;F5D<=7 :CFAG <5J9 =ADCFH5B79 =B H9FAG C: 97C@C;=75@
7CB8=H=CBG HH9ADHG<5J9699BA589HC9B@=;<H9BH<9 =ADCFH5B79C: DF9G9BH HCDC;F5D<=7:CFA5H=CBG=BH<997C@C;M
C:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG ;9CACFD<C@C;=75@ 9J5@I5H=CBC:H<9 5F95<5G5@GC699BGIAA5F=N98

=;  -<9@C75H=CBC:H<9GHI8M5F95

 ##!"

-<9 C6G9FJ5H=CBG =B7@I898 =B H<=G GHI8M 7CJ9F H<9 D9F=C8 69HK99B 
  -<9 97C@C;=75@ GHI8=9G CB 7985F
,+7:820)(40 F98D=B904:8)7:90(5B86@57?D=B904:840.7( HC;9H<9FK=H< GC=@GIFJ9MG:CFAH<9A5=B85H5
C:H<=G=BJ9GH=;5H=CBK<=7<7CJ9FGH<9 GHI8M5F95 @C75H98=B H<9&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB C:-IF?9M -<9A5DGC:A95B
5BBI5@ H9AD9F5HIF95B8DF97=D=H5H=CB5F9DF9G9BH98 GC5GHCGHF9GGH<9=ADCFH5B79C:HCDC;F5D<M=BH<98=GHF=6IH=CBC:
H9AD9F5HIF9 5B8 DF97=D=H5H=CB  IF=B; H<9 :=9@8 C6G9FJ5H=CBG H<9 F9@5H=CBG<=DG 5ACB; D5F9BH A5H9F=5@G FC7?G
HCDC;F5D<=7 :95HIF9G GI7< 5G 5@H=HI89  5GD97HG 5B8 7@=A5H=7 85H5 K9F9 H5?9B =BHC 7CBG=89F5H=CB HC :=B8 CIH H<9
144 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

8=GHF=6IH=CB C: J9;9H5H=CB 5B8 :CF9GH G=H9 =B89L   "B CF89F HC G<CK HCDC;F5D<=7 9::97HG CB H<9 97C@C;M C: -5IFIG
&CIBH5=BGH<9J9;9H5H=CB8=GHF=6IH=CB K5G CJ9F@5DD98CBHCDC;F5D<=7DFC:=@9G

 "!%#"  "$""


 ,53576/525.0*(2 ;52:9054 5- #(:7:85:49(048

-5IFIG &CIBH5=BG 5F9 CB9 C: H<9 A5=B F5B;9G C: @D=B9 &CIBH5=BG 9LH9B8=B; =B H<9 GCIH<9FB D5FH C: B5HC@=5
K<=7< F=G9 56FIDH@M :FCA H<9 &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 IDHC 5B 5@H=HI89 C:   A9H9FG 7CBH5=B=B; 5@ACGH 5@@ FC7?G
69@CB;=B;HC5@@;9C@C;=75@9F5G
' -<9G9 FC7?G5F9A5=B@M5GGC7=5H98K=H<G7<=GHG5B8@=A9GHCB9G C77IFF=B; CBH<9GCIH<9FBD5FHG C:H<9
-5_9@=)@5H95I=BH<9BCFH<C:B5AIF FMGH5@@=N98)5@59CNC=7@=A9GHCBG C77IDMH<9ACGHD5FHC:H<9C@?5F5B8@5
ACIBH5=BG=BH<9'C:-5IFIG 5B8BCFH<9FBD5FHC:'IF&CIBH5=BG=BH<995GHC: -5IFIG
"' -<9 DF9G9BH
85M -5IFIG &CIBH5=B F5B;9 K5G C77ID=98 6M -9H<MG (795B =B K<=7< ACGH@M @=A9GHCB9
A5H9F=5@ 577IAI@5H98 CB H<9 C795B=7 7FIGH 7CADCG98 C: D9F=8CH=H9
G9FD5BH=B9 8IF=B; H<9 &9GCNC=7  "H GH5FH98
ID@=:H=B; 8I9HC H<9GI68I7H=CBC::F=75D@5H9GHFCI;<H<9&98=H9FF5B95B65G=B -CK5F8H<99B8C:&9GCNC=7 5@ACGH
5@@ D5FHG C: H<9 -5IFIG &CIBH5=B 5F95G 9A9F;98 :FCA H<9 G95 5B8 ?5FGH=:=75H=CB DFC79GG 7CAA9B798 HC 89J9@CD
H5@5M 
!#!&-<=G75B69H9FA98 5G H<9:IB85A9BH5@ D9F=C8:CF G<5D=B;C:H<9DF9G9BH
85MHCDC;F5D<M IF=B;H<9
(@=;C79B9 H<9 D5FCLMGA D<5G9 C: H<9 @D=B9 CFC;9B=7 ACJ9A9BHG C77IFF98 =B DF9
(@=;C79B9 ACGH@M GI6A9F;98
CIH7FCDG K9F9 GI6>97H98 HC :C@8=B; 5B8 GCA9 @=A9GHCB9 K5G 7FMGH5@@=N98 5B8 GCA9 DCFHG C: H<9 C795B=7 7FIGH
8=GG97H985B8 ID@=:H98 IF=B;H<9&=C79B9  ACGHD5FHC:H<9 -5IFIG&CIBH5=BG K5G GI6>97H98HCJ9FH=75@H97HCB=7
ACJ9A9BHG 75@@98 DCGH
@D=B9 ACJ9A9BHG @=?9 A5BM D5FH C: B5HC@=5  G 5 F9GI@H C: H<9G9 J9FH=75@ ACJ9A9BHG
H97HCB=7;F569BG K9F9:CFA985@CB;H<9:5I@HNCB9G5B8ACGHC: H<9G9K9F9 C77ID=986MH<9G<5@@CKG955B8@5?9
"B8998  H<9 ;F569BG GI7< 5G I75?  9MG9<=F
,9M8=G9<=F 5B8 7=D5M5A 9H7  K9F9 C77ID=98 6M H<9 @5?9G =B H<9
K9GH9FBD5FHC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG IF=B;&=C79B9 H<9A=88@9D5FHC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BGK5GC77ID=986M
H<9 &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 =B K<=7< 75@75F9CIG A5H9F=5@G K9F9 89DCG=H98 8I9 HC H<9 GI6G=89B79 9J9BHG H5@5M 5
6  H5@5M ,9(2   :9  
-CK5F8GH<99B8C:H<9-9FH=5FM D9F=C8 H<9 -5IFIG&CIBH5=BF5B;9<58699B7CAD@9H9@MID@=:H98 F9GI@H=B;=B H<9
=B7F95G9C:?5FGH=:=75H=CB6975IG9H<965G9@9J9@C:H<9?5FGH=7@5B8@CK9F98 -<IGK5H9F8F5=B=B;C:H<9ID@=:H985F95G
69;5B HC 8=GGC@J9 @=A9GHCB9 5@CB; H<9 7F57? GMGH9A 5B8 :5I@H @=B9G =;    -<9 ;FCIB8 K5H9F GMGH9A 5B8 75J9G
69;5B 89J9@CD=B;  &5=B DC@>9G K9F9 :CFA98  9GD97=5@@M 5@CB; H<9 K95? NCB9 :=HH=B; :5I@H @=B9G &5=B DC@>9G
5DD95F=B; K=H<=B H<9 ;F569BG GI7< 5G I75?  ,9?=  @A5@=  P9@H=?7= 5B8 ,IZ@5 <5J9 H<IG :CFA98 M;9B 
Y@85@^    Y@85@^ 5B8'5N=?
IF=B; H<9 *I5H9FB5FM D9F=C8  H<9 ID@=:H=B; C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=B 7CBH=BI98  =H K5G C77ID=98 6M ;@57=9FG 56CJ9
 A9@9J5H=CBG =BH<9%5GH @57=5@)9F=C8 K<=7< C77IFF98 =B 
 $)

  #565.7(6/0*,(9:7,8

 
 2909:+,
-<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG69;=B=BH<9GCIH<K9GHC:B5HC@=5-9?9)9B=BGI@55B87CBH=BI95@CB;H<9&98=H9FF5B95B
7C5GH;9B9F5@@M =BH<9 
08=F97H=CB -<9 D5FH =BH<9&98=H9FF5B95B F9;=CB =G 75@@9809GH9FB5B8&=88@9-5IFIG -<9
09GH9FB D5FHG 5F9 8=GG97H98 6M H<9 J9FH=75@ H97HCB=7 ACJ9A9BHG DFCJ=8=B; H97HCB=7 ;F569B 9LH9B8=B; =B ,
'0
8=F97H=CB -<9GIAA=HG 56CJ9  AC77IF=BH<9K9GH9FB-5IFIG5B8H<995GH9FBD5FHC:H<9&=88@9-5IFIG -<9
ACIBH5=BGK=H< <=;<9GHGIAA=HG5F9?  A -5<H5@^ =B? ACIBH5=B F5B;9A $C<I A $5HF5B7=?
A=BH<909GH9FB-5IFIG1^@8^NA &989HG=NA=BH<9C@?5F&CIBH5=BG $5F5B:=@ A A
5B8  A =B H<9 @5 &CIBH5=BG =B H<9 95GH9FB D5FH C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG  "H 75B 69 G5=8 H<5H 69HK99B H<9
&98=H9FF5B95B 7C5GH 5B8 IDD9F D5FHG C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG H<9 F9@5H=J9 5@H=HI89 @=9G 5FCIB8 5H @95GH   A -<9
F9@5H=J9 5@H=HI89 69HK99B H<9 89DF9GG=CBG 5B8 H<9=F 9B7=F7@=B; <=;<@5B8G =B ;9B9F5@ =G 5H @95GH   A  CF 9L5AD@9
F9@5H=J95@H=HI89=BH<9@A5@=89DF9GG=CB=GB95F@M A
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 145

   203(9,
-<9 GHI8M5F95 9LD9F=9B79G HMD=75@ &98=H9FF5B95B7@=A5H97<5F57H9F=N986MF5=BM5B8 A=@8 K=BH9FG5B8F5=B@9GG
5B8<CHGIAA9FG 6IHHCDC;F5D<=7 :95HIF9G 9GD97=5@@M5@H=HI895B85GD97H 7F95H9 A=7FC5B8@C75@7@=A5H9G=BH<9GHI8M
5F95=; 

=;  @=A5H9HMD9GC:-IF?9MH5@5M 

! ##-<9A95B 5BBI5@ DF97=D=H5H=CB7<5B;9G69HK99B  AA5B8  AA89D9B8=B;A5=B@MCBH<9


HCDC;F5D<=7 7<5F57H9F=GH=7G =;    ,CIH<95GH :57=B; G@CD9G C: BH5@M5 I@: F979=J9 ACF9 F5=B M8=B?9BH 
AA 9_?CB5?AA ?G9?= AA 6IH5HH<9Y?
%YH:=1=@8=F=ACF9GH+9G95F7<GH5H=CB5H5B9@9J5H=CBC:
  A   ?A '0 C: BH5@M5 M95F@M F5=B:5@@ =G  AA  &95B 5BBI5@ DF97=D=H5H=CB =G @9GG H<5B   AA =B H<9
F5=BG<58CK 5F95G 9B7=F7@98 6M <=;<@5B8G 5B8 657?K5F8 89DF9GG=CBG C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG  CF 9L5AD@9  5BBI5@
DF97=D=H5H=CB8FCDG 69@CK  AA =B GCA9M95FG5G@CK5G AA=B&IH65G=B 79BHF5@D5FHC:-5IFIG &CIBH5=BG
@H=HI89=GF9GDCBG=6@9:CFH<9=B7F95G9C:DF97=D=H5H=CB 5GK9@@5GJ9FH=75@NCB5H=CBC:J9;9H5H=CB 5B8 GC=@:CFA=B;
DFC79GG -<9F9:CF9 5B 56FIDHF=G=B;C: -5IFIG&CIBH5=BG:FCAH<97C5GHC:H<9&98=H9FF5B95B,9575IG9=B7F95G9G
<IA=8=HM -<9 :FCBHG 7CA=B; :FCA H<9 &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 8IF=B; H<9 F5=BM D9F=C8 69HK99B (7HC69F 5B8 DF=@ 5F9
;9B9F5@@MDF9J9BH986M-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG -<=G=GH<9A5=B F95GCB :CF=B7F95G9C:DF97=D=H5H=CBCBH<9G@CD9G:57=B;
GCIH< "B8998HCH5@ 5BBI5@ F5=B:5@@=GCJ9F  AA=BH<97C5GH5@5F955B8 CB H<9GCIH<:57=B;G@CD9G =H =B7F95G9G
AAD9F A=B7F95G9C:5@H=HI8969HK99B&5B5J;5H5B89_?CB5?HCKBG =BH<9'C: I@:C: BH5@M5
-<9F9 =G ;9B9F5@ 5=F 7=F7I@5H=CB :FCA H<9 &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 HCK5F8G -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG 8IF=B; H<9 GIAA9F
G95GCB  -<9 <IA=8 5=F A5GG F=G=B; :FCA H<9 GCIH<9FB G@CD9G C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG =G H<9 A5=B F95GCB C: :C; 5B8
CFC;F5D<=7 F5=B :CFA5H=CB 5B8 =B7F95G9 C: F9@5H=J9 <IA=8=HM C: 5=F A5GG9G =;      BCH<9F @C75@ 7CB8=H=CB
DF9J5=@G 69HK99B I@: C: "G?9B89FIB 5B8 BH5?M5
$5<F5A5BA5F5G H97HCB=7 ;F569B =B H<9 95GH9FB D5FH C:
&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB !9F9H<95=FA5GG9G 7CA=B;:FCAH<9 I@:C:"G?9B89FIB@958HCH<9:C;5B8CFC;F5D<=7F5=B
CBH<9 G@CD9G:579G I@:C:"G?9B89FIB=; 5 6 +9@5H=J9<IA=8=HM=G<=;<9F8IF=B;H<9J9;9H5H=CBD9F=C8 5B8
=B K=BH9F -<=G=GF9GDCBG=6@9:CFH<9897F95G9C:9J5DCHF5BGD=F5H=CBCBH<9GCIH<:57=B;G@CD9GC:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG
-CK5F8H<9657?K5F8D5FHGC:&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB 5F=8=HM=B7F95G9G8I9 HCH<97CBH=B9BH5@9::97HG 9GD97=5@@MK=H<
H<9897F95G9C:DF97=D=H5H=CB5B8F9@5H=J9<IA=8=HM=; 
146 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

=;  &95B5BBI5@DF97=D=H5H=CB8=GHF=6IH=CBC:-IF?9M

=;   -<9 :CFA5H=CB C: :C; 5B8 CFC;F5D<=7 F5=B CB H<9 GCIH<9FB G@CD9G C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG K=H< H<9 F=G9 C: 5=F A5GG9G 7CA=B; :FCA H<9
&98=H9FF5B95B

 !#$!&95B5BBI5@H9AD9F5HIF9 =G B95F@M =BH<97C5GH5@@5B8 6IH 897F95G9G 5G@CK5GIB89FC=B


H<9 IDD9F D5FH C: H<9 C@?5F 5B8 @5 ACIBH5=BG =B H<9 95GH  #5BI5FM H9AD9F5HIF9 =G   =B H<9 7C5GH5@ 5F95G 6IH
IB89F:F99N=B;DC=BH5H5B9@9J5H=CBC: A -<9#I@MH9AD9F5HIF969HK99BH<97C5GHC:&98=H9FF5B95B,955B8
H<9IDD9FD5FHJ5F=9G69HK99BC5B8
C=; 
-<99L=GH9B79C:H<F995@H=HI8=B5@J9;9H5H=CB69@HG=B-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG=GA5=B@MK=H<F9GD97HHCH<95@H=HI89H<5H
7<5B;9GDF97=D=H5H=CB5B8H9AD9F5HIF9

  "502(4+6(7,493(9,70(2

-<97@=A5H=7GC=@HMD9C:GHI8M5F95=GF988=G<&98=H9FF5B95BGC=@@:=GC@CF8C L9F5@:GI6CF8CCBH<9:@5H5B8
?5FGH=7@5B8 "BH<9657?K5F889DF9GG=CBGK<=7<:579G9A=5F=87@=A5H97CB8=H=CB7<9GHBIHGC=@7CBH5=B=B;75F6CB5H9
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 147

577IAI@5H=CB =B GI6GC=@ 5DD95FG  +9A5=B=B; 5F95G 5F9 7CJ9F98 6M =BHF5NCB5@ GC=@G BH=GC@G 5B8 "B79DH=GC@G
F9:@97H=B;H<9D<MG=75@5B87<9A=75@DFCD9FH=9GC:D5F9BHA5H9F=5@G8I9HC9FCG=CB

=;  =GHF=6IH=CBC:F9@5H=J9<IA=8=HM=B#I@M

=;  &95B5BBI5@H9AD9F5HIF98=GHF=6IH=CB=B-IF?9M

  %,.,9(9054

/9;9H5H=CB 8=GHF=6IH=CB BCH56@M :CF9GHG 5B8 H<9=F J9;9H5H=CB 7CADCG=H=CB 7<5B;9G 89D9B8=B; CB 5@H=HI89  5GD97H
:57HCFG K<=7< 89H9FA=B9 H<9 H9AD9F5HIF9 5B8 DF97=D=H5H=CB 8=GHF=6IH=CB  -<9 5@H=HI8=B5@ 69@HG C: J9;9H5H=CB 5F9 5G
:C@@CK
148 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

 
 :,+09,77(4,(4),29 
3
-<=G69@H =BK<=7<HMD=75@&98=H9FF5B95B7@=A5H9DF9J5=@G =G 7<5F57H9F=N986MA=@85B8F5=BMK=BH9FG5B8<CH5B8
F5=B@9GGGIAA9FG =GH<9B5H=J95F95 C:8=GHF=6IH=CB C:&98=H9FF5B95BJ9;9H5H=CB 7C@C;=75@@M 04:8)7:90( 7@=A5L
HF99 C: &98=H9FF5B95B 7@=A5H=7 F9;=CB =G J9FM F9G=GH5BH HC GIAA9F 8FCI;<H  6IH DFC8I7H=J=HM =G ;CC8 =B H<9 5F95G
K<=7<F979=J956IB85BHDF97=D=H5H=CB5B8;FCIB8K5H9F@9J9@=G<=;< "HDF9:9FGGIBBM5B8 CF 5F95GF979=J=B; 8=F97H
GC@5F F58=5H=CB  :CF H<=G F95GCB 04:8 )7:90( :CF9GHG F=G9G 5G <=;< 5G   A CB H<9 GCIH< :57=B; G@CD9G C: -5IFIG
&CIBH5=BG "HGG998G;9FA=B5H9 CB@M CBH<9A=B9F5@GC=@G=BH<9CD9BGIBBMD@579G -<9B5HIF5@@M C77IFF=B; A5EI=G
:CFA5H=CBG C77IF 5G5B IB89FGHCFMC: 04:8)7:90( :CF9GHG )FC8I7H=J9:CF9GHG5F9C6G9FJ98=BH<95F95GK<=7< F979=J9
F5=B=BGIAA9F =BH<9BCFH<95GH9FBD5FHC: PI?IFCJ5=7=@=5BD@5=B B8=F=B8=GHF=7HH5@5M ,9(2  =CA5GG
DFC8I7H=J=HM 5B8 H<9 D<MG=C;BCA=7 :95HIF9G C: 04:8 )7:90( 5F9 89H9FA=B98 6M H<9 D<MG=75@ 5B8 7<9A=75@
7<5F57H9F=GH=7G C: D5F9BH A5H9F=5@G  5B8 H9AD9F5HIF9  H<9 5ACIBH C: DF97=D=H5H=CB 5B8 ;FCIB8 K5H9F @9J9@  -<9
6=CA5GG DFC8I7H=J=HM =G HCC @CK =B 9LDCG98 D9F=8CH=H9
G9FD9BH=B9 D5F9BH A5H9F=5@  CF 9L5AD@9  F98 D=B9
GH5B8G C77IFF=B;CB@CK5B8IBK95H<9F98G9FD9BH=B9
D9F=8CH=H9D5F9BHA5H9F=5@=BH<95HU5)9B=BGI@5 5@GC5H GCA9
D@579GC:7C5GH5@5F95G69HK99BBH5@M55B8$IA@I75 0C:BH5@M5 I@:5B8=BH<9J=7=B=HMC:$XM79Z=N@5?95F9=B
G<FI66M:CFA )FC8I7H=J9 04:8)7:90( GH5B8GC77IF69HK99B
 A65G98CBH<9897F95G9C:B=;<HH9AD9F5HIF9
K<=7< @958G HC 5 897F95G9C:HF5BGD=F5H=CB5G7CAD5F98 HC H<97C5GH5@5F95 "B588=H=CBHCH<=GK9@@K95H<9F98G7<=GHG
7CBH5=B=B;F=7<D@5BHBIHF=A9BHG7F95H9GI=H56@9 <56=H5H:CFH<9;FCKH<C:HF99G
&5EI=G J9;9H5H=CB B5HIF5@@M ;FCK=B; =B H<9 IB89FGHCFM C: F98 D=B9 :CF9GH =G K=89GDF958 K<9F9 F98 D=B9 :CF9GHG
K9F989GHFCM98=BH<97C5GH5@69@HC:&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB H5@5M (NHIF? ,9(2      (NHIF?
 =;  IHH<95F=8D5FHC:H<9&IH65G=B =G H<9A5EI=G5B8;5FF=EI9J9;9H5H=CB8=GHF=6IH=CB5F95G ,5?75@=
5B8(NHIF? 

   75,+09,77(4,(4,29
-<9 9L=GH9B79 C: CFC
A98=H9FF5B95B :CF9GH 69@H =G F9@5H98 HC <=;< 5@H=HI89 C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG -<=G 69@H =G H<9
A5=B GDF958=B; 5F95 :CF 7CB=:9FCIG :CF9GHG 7CADCG98 C: 7985F ,+7:8 20)(40  6@57? D=B9 04:8 40.7( 5B8 :=F
)0,8*020*0*( K<=7<;FCKIB89FH<97C@8
GI6<IA=87CB8=H=CBG %C75@97C@C;=75@7CB8=H=CBG89H9FA=B9H<9DIF=HM
5B8GDF958=B;5F95GC:GI7<HF99G=;  

=;   9B9F5@J9;9H5H=CB69@HG=B&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB

04:8 40.7( :CF9GHG ;FCK =B H<9 HF5BG=H=CB5@ F9;=CB 69HK99B A5F=H=A9 5B8 7CBH=B9BH5@ 7@=A5H9  -<9F9:CF9 GI7<
:CF9GHG5F9C6G9FJ9869HK99B 5B8 A=BH<9ID@5B85F95C:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG5B8=BH<9657?K5F8D5FHC:
&98=H9FF5B95B F9;=CB  =B7@I8=B; %5?9G ,I6F9;=CB  '0 D5FH C: H<9 &98=H9FF5B95B ;9C;F5D<=75@ F9;=CB  )IF9 5B8
;CC8 04:840.7( GH5B8GC77IF5FCIB8%5?99M_9<=F %5?9Z=F8=F 5B8,XZYHD@5H95I9LH9B8=B;69HK99BBH5@M5

5N=D5G5 5B8 =B H<9 95GH9FB D5FH C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG $5FG5BH^ 8=GHF=7H CB K<=7< GCA9K<5H 7CBH=B9BH5@ 9::97HG
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 149

DF9J5=@ H5@5M 5B8 :9    =;      -<9M ;FCK J9FM K9@@ CB H<9 GC:H D5F9BH A5H9F=5@G GI7< 5G :@MG7< 5B8
7C@@IJ=5@89DCG=HG5B85F9C:H9B5GGC7=5H98K=H< ,+7:820)(40 5B8 )0,8*020*0*( =BH<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG
)0,8 *020*0*( ;FCKG J9FM K9@@ CB H<9 8=::IG98 D@579G K=H< @CK F58=5H=CB CB H<9 BCFH< :57=B; G@CD9G 5B8 :C;;M
5F95 5GK9@@5G 5ACB; 04:840.7( 5B8 ,+7:820)(40 HF99G -<9G9:CF9GHGA5=B@MC77IF69HK99B
 ACBH<9
G@CD9G:57=B;BCFH< 5B8DIF9GH5B8G C77IF CB@MCBH<9BCFH<:57=B;G@CD9G5B8=B:C;;M5F95G -<9CDH=AIA;FCKH<
5F95G 5F9 ;9B9F5@@M K=89GDF958 69HK99B 
  A  )IF9 5B8 DFC8I7H=J9 )0,8 *020*0*( :CF9GHG C77IF =B
P5A@^M5M@5@C75@=HM 'C:85B5 K<=@9DCCFCB9=G 7CAACB CBH<9 GCIH<9FBG@CD9GC:-5<H5@=ACIBH5=B 69HK99B
"BB9F B5HC@=5 5B8 &98=H9FF5B95B F9;=CB =;   =;  )0,8 *020*0*( :CF9GHG 5F9 5@GC K=89GDF958 69HK99B 
5B8 ACBH<9:C;;M5F95GC:'IFA5BCGACIBH5=BG 95GHC:"G?9B89FIB I@:=;   DIF9GH5B8C77IFG
CBH<9GCIH<:57=B;G@CD9G5@GCK<=7<=B8=75H9G7CAD@9H989GHFI7H=CBC: 04:840.7( 5B8 ,+7:820)(40 5F95G=; 



=;  -<98=GHF=6IH=CBC:HF99G F9@5H98HC HCDC;F5D<MCBH<995GH7C5GHC:BH5@M5 I@: 985F :=FA=L98:CF9GH=G


7CAACB=BH<9:C;;M5F95C:-5<H5@^ &CIBH5=B

=;  -<9DFC:=@9G<CK=B;H<9=ADCFH5B79C:5@H=HI89 5GD97H5B87CBH=B9BH5@=HM=BH<98=GHF=6IH=CBC:J9;9H5H=CB69HK99B&9FG=B5B8.@I?^_@5


GCIH<9FBD5FHC:"BB9FB5HC@=5 -<99L=GH9B79C:DIF95B8DFC8I7H=J9 )0,8 *020*0*( 89D9B8G CBH<9:C;F979=J98 6M -5IFIG&CIBH5=BG

@=A5H=75@@M ,+7:820)(40 ;FCKGIB89F7CC@5B8GI6<IA=87CB8=H=CBGK<=7<DF9J5=@8IF=B;J9;9H5H=CBD9F=C8


5B8A95B5BBI5@H9AD9F5HIF97<5B;9G69HK99B C5B8C A95B5BBI5@DF97=D=H5H=CB=G<=;<9FH<5B AA=BH<9
B5H=J9C77IFF9B795F95G 5B8=HDF9:9FGGBCKM5F95GCBK<=7<G998G69;=BHC;9FA=B5H9 985F:CF9GHG5GA=L985B8
DIF9GH5B8G 5F97CAACB69HK99B
 A=BH<9J9FH=75@8=F97H=CB=BH<9GCIH<9FBD5FHG69HK99B 5B8
150 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

AC:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG 5B8
 A=BH<9ID@5B8D5FHC:'IF&CIBH5=BG -<97985FGH5B8G89G79B85G@CK5G

 A=BH<995GH9FBD5FHC:'IF&CIBH5=BG 0C:&5F5G
BH5?M5;F569BH5@5M6 CM85? CM85?
,9(2   "H75B697@95F@MG5=8H<5H 7985F5JC=8GH<99LHF9A9A5F=H=A95GK9@@5G7CBH=B9BH5@5F95GC:B5HC@=5
-<9CDH=AIA;FCK=B;5F95GC:7985F=GH<9F9:CF9 7CAACB CBH<9BCFH<G@CD9GC:-9?9)9B=BGI@5K<=7<=G@C75H98=B
H<9HF5BG=H=CB5@F9;=CBHC69H9FA98NCBC97CHCB99LH9B8=B;69HK99B &98=H9FF5B95B5B8"BB9FB5HC@=5H5@5M 
=;   
20)(40 ;FCKGCBH<9<IA=8D@579GIB89FH<9=AD57HC:K=B8G7CA=B;:FCA6CH<&98=H9FF5B95B,955B8H9G=5B
K=B8G 7CA=B; :FCA H<9 BCFH< =B H<9 657?K5F8 D5FH C: &98=H9FF5B95B F9;=CB  9GH ;FCK=B; 5F95 C77IFG =B H<9
P^Z@^?5F55B8C?IN X@@C75@=HMCBH<9BCFH<G@CD9C:&CIBH5=B=BH<9,C:@A5@=89DF9GG=CB !9F9:=FGHG=H97@5GG
7985F:CF9GH5DD95FG -<9F9=G5ACBIA9BH5@7985FHF99B5A98$CU+5A 7985F5;98 M95FG A =B<9=;<H5B8
A =B8=5A9H9F 5H5B9@9J5H=CBC: A=; 

=;    -<9 8=GHF=6IH=CB C: J9;9H5H=CB 69HK99B G9B J5@@9M B95F &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 5B8 C@<=G5F =BB9F D5FH C: C: -9?9 )9B=BGI@5  !9F9 H<9
8CA=B5B79C: 04:840.7( CBH<9GCIH<9FB:57=B; G@CD9G C: C@<=G5F 89DF9GG=CB5B89L=GH9B79C: ,+7:820)(40 CBH<9ID@5B85F95GG<CKG
H<997C@C;=75@DF9:9F9B79C:GI7<HF99G=B577CF85B79K=H<H<9HCDC;F5D<=75@7CB8=H=CBG

=;   -<9 J9;9H5H=CB DFC:=@9 C: 'IF &CIBH5=BG @M=B; 69HK99B CFHMC@ 7=HM  =B "G?9B89FIB I@: &98=H9FF5B95B ,95 5B8 BH5?M5

$5<F5A5BA5F5_;F569B
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 151

985F;FCKGCB5@@D5F9BHA5H9F=5@GB5A9@MA5F@M89DCG=H G7<=GH EI5FHN=H9 5B8@=A9GHCB9G69@CB;=B;HC-9FH=5FM


&9GCNC=7 5B8 )5@9CNC=7 9F5G  -<9 DIF9 ,+7:8 20)(40 GH5B8G CB@M C77IF CB H<9 G@CD9G :57=B; BCFH< =B H<9 -5IFIG
&CIBH5=BG 6IHDFC8I7H=J97985FCB@M;FCKGCBH<9?5FGH=7@5B8G =BH<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BGH5@5M  :9  
-<9K9GH:57=B;G@CD9GC:'IF&CIBH5=BG:CFA58=GH=B7H<56=H5H6975IG9H<9F9=G5;9B9F5@5=F:@CK:FCA I@:C:
"G?9B89FIB HC BH5?M5
$5<F5A5BA5F5_ 89DF9GG=CB  -<9 F=G=B; <IA=8 5B8 <CH 5=F A5GG9G 7CA=B; :FCA I@: C:
"G?9B89FIBCBH<9K9GH:57=B;G@CD9G@958HCH<9:CFA5H=CBC::C;5B8CFC;F5D<=7F5=B K<=7<GIDDCFHGH<9;FCKH<C:
6FC58@95J98:CF9GHG7CADCG98C: (.:8570,49(208 GD97=9GC: 24:8*,7 (89(4,( 5B8 (7604:8 9H7 5B8GCA9
<M8FCD<MH=7G<FI6G@=?9 574:83(857>2:8(;,22(4(:=:88,36,7;07,48 5B8GCCB I79@ ,9(2  =; 

#IB=D9F :406,7:8 ,=*,28(  -5,90+08803( :CF9GHG 5F9 7CAACB CB H<9 -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG =B D@579G K<9F9
7CB=:9FCIG :CF9GHG  7CADCG98 C: 7985F 5B8 6@57? D=B9 <5J9 699B 9BH=F9@M 7@95F98 09 75B G5M H<5H >IB=D9F
7CAAIB=H=9G75B69H5?9B=BHC7CBG=89F5H=CB5G 5 F9;F9GG=J95B8 CFG97CB85FM GI779GG=CB ;FCID "B8998H<9 G998G
CF=;=B5H=B;:FCAH<99L7F9A9BHGC:H<96=F8G95G=@M;9FA=B5H9=BH<989GHFCM987CB=:9FCIG:CF9GH5F95G "BH<9<=;<9F
D5FH C: H<9 :CF9GH 69@H :406,7:8 *533:408 GGD 4(4( C77IFG  (B H<9 CH<9F <5B8 >IB=D9F 7CAAIB=H=9G 5F9 5@GC
7CAACB HCK5F8GH<9 =B@5B8D5FHC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG
(5? :,7*:820)(40 04-,*9570( *,7708:CF9GHG5F9A5=B@M C77IF CBHF5BG=H=CB5@69@H69HK99BIH<9FAC
5B8(FC
&98=H9FF5B95B69@H5B89LH9B85G569@H5H5B5@H=HI89C:
 A 5B85F97CAACB=BH<9K9GH9FB5B8
95GH9FBD5FHGC:H<9-5IFIG -<97CAACBGD97=9GC:H<9C5?:CF9GHG5F9 :,7*:820)(40 -7(04,995 *,7708 5B8 
04-,*9570(
-CK5F8 H<9 =B@5B8 D5FHG C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG J9;9H5H=CB 7CADCG=H=CB =G GI6>97H HC 7<5B;9 5G 7CAD5F98 HC H<9
GCIH<9FB D5FH C: &98=H9FF5B95B +9;=CB  "B H<9G9 5F95G 04:8 40.7( 5B8 :,7*:8 :CF9GHG H9B8 HC :CFA 8CA=B5BH
J9;9H5H=CB  "B H<9 95GH9FB =BG=89 5B8 '0 D5FH C: -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG  :CF 9L5AD@9 04:8 40.7( :CF9GHG 7CJ9F H<9
<=;<@5B8G=;  

=;  /9;9H5H=CBDFC:=@9=BH<9'=B@5B8D5FHC:&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB G=H=GG<CKB6@57?D=B9=GK=89GDF9585B8F=G9GIDHC A=BH<9


=B@5B8G97H=CBC:-5IFIGCBK<=7<5GCA9K<5H7CBH=B9BH5@9::97HGDF9J5=@G

-CDC;F5D<=75@7CB8=H=CBGBCH56@M75BMCBJ5@@9M5B8899D?5FGH=789DF9GG=CBDFCJ=895F9:I;95F95:CFH<9;FCKH<
C: D5GH J9;9H5H=CB HC;9H<9F K=H< GCA9 <M8FCD<MH=7 J9;9H5H=CB  CF H<=G F95GCB  =H =G DCGG=6@9 HC :=B8 F9@=7HG C: H<9
IFC
,=69F=5BD<MHC;9C;F5D<=75@F95@A=BH<9?5FGH=789DF9GG=CBGC:989;C@5B85JF5N&CIBH5=BG5B8H<9K9GH9FB
G@CD9GC:H<9'IF&CIBH5=BGH5@5M5 CF=BGH5B79 :,7*:8;:2*(40*( K<=7<=G5B9B89A=75B8F9@=7HGD97=9G
:CF -5IFIG &CIBH5=BG ;FCKG CB@M K=H<=B H<9 ?5FGH=7 89DF9GG=CB GI7< 5G 8C@=B9G =B H<9 989;C@ 5B8 5JF5N
ACIBH5=BG =;  "BH<=G<56=H5H5;FCIDC:<IA=8HF99G5B8G<FI6G69@CB;=B;HCIFC
,=69F=5B9@9A9BHGGI7<5G
,CF6IG 957304(208#020(7:)7(7(=04:8,=*,28057$23:8.2()7( 5B8 897>(*(76040-520( C77IF -<975BMCBJ5@@9MG
75@@98C75?5B89<9BB9A=BH<9IDD9FHF=6IH5F=9GC:9F85BF=J9F:@CK=B;=BHC&98=H9FF5B95B,957CBH5=BA5BM
8=::9F9BH:CFAGC:J9;9H5H=CB
152 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

=; 55B86 -<9G@CD9G:57=B;&98=H9FF5B95B,95C:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG5F9;9B9F5@@M7CJ9F986M:C;


7@CI8G 8I9HCH<9F=G=B; <IA=85=FA5GG
7CA=B;:FCA&98=H9FF5B95B,95

=;  04:8)7:90(40.7()0,8*020*0*(,+7:820)(40:406,7:8 =;   5BMCB J5@@9M C: C75? GHF95A H<9 IDD9F 65G=B C: $58=B7=?
,=*,28(-5,90+08803( 5F9C6G9FJ98 HC;9H<9F=B H<99<9BB9A5BMCB +=J9F ,+7:820)(4004:840.7(04:8)7:90( 5B8G<FI6G/022>7,(
J5@@9MH<5H7IH6M$58=B7=?F=J9F:@CK=B;=BHC&98=H9FF5B95B,95 C: 2(90-520( 7):9:8 (4+7(*/4, :4,+5 7>9:8 *533:408 (:7:8
&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB 45)0208 5B8 2(9(4:8570,49(208 5F9GD97=9G;FCK=B; <=;<HC;9H8=F97H
@=;<H

=;  :,7*:8;:2*(40*( 5B 9B89A=7 C5? GD97=9G ACGH@M ;FCKG =B =;  )IF95B8DFC8I7H=J97985F:CF9GHCBH<9BCFH<:57=B;G@CD9GC:
H<9 ?5FGH=7 89DF9GG=CBG C: 989;C@ ,0 C: %5?9 Z=F8=F 5B8 5F@5 ACIBH5=B =B H<9 ,0 C: @A5@^ 89DF9GG=CB  !9F9 ACBIA9BH 7985F
&CIBH5=BG 0C:%5?99M_9<=F=BH<90C:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG B5A98 $CU+5A 7985F =G A H5@@K=H< A8=5A9H9F5B8M95FG
C@85H5B9@9J5H=CBC: A
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 153

=;  04:840.7( 5B8 ,+7:820)(40 A=L98:CF9GH=BH<9-5IFIG =;  )IF95B8DFC8I7H=J9 )0,8*020*0*( :CF9GH;FCKGIB89F:C;;M


ACIBH5=BG 7CB8=H=CB=B5A@=M5M@5@C75@=HM 'C:&9FG=B7=HM

=;  )FC8I7H=J9)=BIGB=;F5:CF9GHK<=7<=G7CAACBCBH<9BCFH< =;  5;IGCF=9BH5@=G:CF9GH7CAACB=BH<9:C;;M5F95=BH<9BCFH<


:57=B;G@CD9 C:989;X@&CIBH5=BG 0C:%5?9 9M_9<=F C:B8^F^B 5GH9FB&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB

"BH<9G9J5@@9M69G=89G 04:8)7:90(,+7:820)(40)0,8*020*0*((4+04:840.7( 5<IA=8&98=H9FF5B95BA5EI=G


J9;9H5H=CBC77IFK=H<GD97=9G@=?9 "9>7(=5--0*04(2087):9:8(4+7(*/4,:4,+57>9:8*533:408%09,=(.4:8
*(89:8,70:352,(4+,7 5B8<IA=8
A=@8GD97=9G@=?9 #(=:8)(**(9(57>2:8(;,22(4(574:83(882(9(4:8
570,49(20824:8.2:90458("57):8957304(208:=:88,36,7;07,48,2908(:897(2085904:8 GD

   ":)(2604,/,7)(*,5:8;,.,9(9054),29
-<=G69@H69;=BG5:H9FH<9B5HIF5@H=A69F@=B95B8;C9GCBHCH<9IDD9FD5FHC:H<9GIAA=HC:-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG "B
H<9?5FGH=7@5B8H<=G69@H C77IFG 5G5FC7?M@5B8K=H<J9FMGD5FG9<9F6579CIGGD97=9G 6IH;F5GG@5B8G5F98CA=B5BHCB
H<9?5FGH=789DF9GG=CBGK=H<H<=7?GC=@ 5B8G7<=GHGK=H<K5H9F<C@8=B;75D57=HM5F9<=;<
@H=HI89 5@GC 89H9FA=B9G GC=@ :CFA5H=CB 5B8 =HG 7<9A=75@ 5B8 CF;5B=7 7CBH9BH (N?5B ,9 (2    +988=G<
&98=H9FF5B95B GC=@ 8CA=B5BH =B H<9 I
&98=H9FF5B95B NCB9  7<5B;9G =BHC 85F? F988=G< &98=H9FF5B95B GC=@ 8I9 HC
577IAI@5H=CBC:CF;5B=7A5H9F=5@577IAI@5H=CB "BH<9GI65@D=B9NCB9CB975BG99G<5@@CK<=;< ACIBH5=B;F5GGGC=@G
G<CK=B;K95?57=8F957H=CB5B8F=7<CF;5B=77CBH9BH

 86,*9-(*957

-<9 8=F97H=CB C: GCIH< 5B8 BCFH< G@CD9G C: ACIBH5=BG 5B8 J5@@9MG =G =ADCFH5BH =B H9FAG C: H<9 GC@5F F58=5H=CB
=BH9BG=HM G5;9B9F5@FI@9=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB <IA=8=HM=G<=;<9FCBH<9GCIH<G@CD9GH<5BBCFH<9FBG@CD9G
=BH<9GCIH<9FBD5FHC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=B 6975IG9GCIH<9FBG@CD9G5F9F5=BM F979=J=B;8=F97HF58=5H=CB5B8<IA=8
154 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

5=FA5GG9G7CA=B;:FCA&98=H9FF5B95B,95 "BH<9657?K5F8D5FHC:&98=H9FF5B95B F9;=CBBCFH<9FBIDG@CD9G:CFA5


<IA=8 <56=H5H 8I9 HC @CK 8=F97H F58=5H=CB 5B8 <IA=8 K=B8G 6@CK=B; :FCA H<9 BCFH<9FB G97HCFG  CF H<=G F95GCB 5
GCA9K<5H<IA=8:CF9GH C77IFG CBH<9BCFH<9FBG@CD9G 9GH9L5AD@9G75B69;=J9B:FCA@A5@=89DF9GG=CB K<9F9
BCFH< :57=B; G@CD9G <5J9 DIF9 5B8 DFC8I7H=J9 7985F :CF9GHG =;   K<9F95G GCIH<9FB G@CD9G 5F9 H<9 A5=B
8=GHF=6IH=CB5@5F95GC:>IB=D9F5B8C5?7CAAIB=H=9G=;  
,CIH<9FBG@CD9GC:H<9657?K5F8CFGCIH<9FBD5FHC:&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB=GH<9B5H=J9C77IFF9B795F95C:8FM
:CF9GHG7CADCG98C: 04:840.7( 5B8H<9GD97=9GC: :,7*:8 5B8 :406,7:8

  !# !"##&#!!

$5FGH=7@5B8G=B-5IFIGACIBH5=BCIG5F95G7CBHF=6IH9HCH<9=B7F95G9C:6=C@C;=75@F=7<B9GG6975IG9H<9M7CBH5=B
A5BM @C75@ 5B8 A=7FC <56=H5HG  -<9 6CHHCA C: J5@@9M K=H< 85AD 5B8 H<=7? GC=@ 7CJ9F GIDDCFHG H<9 ;FCKH< C:
<M8FCD<MH=7 J9;9H5H=CB  $5FGH=7 @5B8G 9GD97=5@@M 89DF9GG=CBG 5F9 5@GC H<9 F9:I;9 5F95G C: GCA9 9B89A=7 5B8 F9@=7H
D@5BHG 5B8 H<9=F 7CAAIB=H=9G CF 9L5AD@9 :,7*:8 ;:2*(40*( K<=7< =G 5B 9B89A=7 5(1 GD97=9G 5B8 "(3):*:8
40.7(#(=:8)(**(9(57>2:8(;,22(4(574:83(8:=:8 G,36,7;07,48 9H7 K<=7<5F9H<9F9@=7HGD97=9G;FCK=B;
=BG=89H<98C@=B9G=BH<95JF5G5B8989;C@&CIBH5=BG=BH<9K9GH9FBD5FHC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG ,=B798C@=B9
K5@@G;=J95DFCH97H=CB:FCAH<9K=B8 H<=7?GC=@7CJ9F=BH<98C@=B9:CFA5:5JCIF56@9<56=H5H:CFH<9 ;FCKH<C:GCA9
<M8FCD<MH=7GD97=9G@=?9 "(3):*:8,):2:8"40.7(#020(7:)7(*,7*(36,897, 5B8 ;:2*(40*( =; 
-<975BMCBJ5@@9M=BH<9-5IFIG=GC:GD97=5@=ADCFH5B79=BH9FAGC:HCDC;F5D<M5B8J9;9H5H=CBF=7<B9GG "B8998
GCA9<IA=8A5EI=G9@9A9BHGGI7<5G ,70:352,(4+,7 7>9:8*533:408 (:7:845)0208 %09,=(.4:8*(89:8 24:8
.2:90458( 2(9(4:8 570,49(208 "(20= GD 5F9 7CAACB =B H<=G 5F95  -<9 69GH 9L5AD@9 =G ;=J9B :FCA C75? 5B8
9<9BB9AJ5@@9MGK<=7<5F9H<9IDD9FHF=6IH5F=9GC: 9F85BF=J9F:@CK=B;=BHCH<9&98=H9FF5B95B,95


$""

-CDC;F5D<=7 :95HIF9G GI7<5G5@H=HI89 5GD97H G@CD9=B7@=B5H=CB5B8@5B8:CFA9H7 C:H<9GHI8M5F957CBG=89F56@M


89H9FA=B9H<98=GHF=6IH=CBC:DF97=D=H5H=CB H9AD9F5HIF95B8D@5BH7CAAIB=H=9G5B86=CA5GGDFC8I7H=J=HM "B-5IFIG
&CIBH5=BG F=G=B;IDHC A H<9 8=GG97H=CB 6MH<9F=J9FG :CF ACF9H<5B A=GA5=B@MF9@5H98HCH<9J9FH=75@
H97HCB=7ACJ9A9BHG K<=7< C77IFF988IF=B;'9CH97HCB=7D9F=C8 ?BCKB5GDCGH5@D=B9ACJ9A9BHG -<9<=;<5@H=HI89
5B85GD97HC:J5@@9MG@CD9G5B889DF9GG=CBG5B8FI;;98?5FGH=7@5B8:CFAG7F95H9A=7FC5B8@C75@<56=H5HG=BH9FAGC:
97C@C;=75@7CB8=H=CBG -<95@H=HI89F=G=B;56CJ9 A=BH<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG@958G HCH<F995@H=HI8=B5@J9;9H5H=CB
69@HG 5
 A 04:8 )7:90( :CF9GH NCB9  6    A CFC
A98=H9FF5B95B NCB9  7 .DD9F D5FH C: ACIBH5=BG
ACF9H<5B A=GGI65@D=B9<9F6579CIGNCB9 5B8G<5@@CK GC=@HMD9 GD97H:57HCF=G=ADCFH5BHHCF979=J9GC@5F
F58=5H=CB 5B8 K=B8  5B8 HC DF9J9BH H<9 :FCBHG  -<9 GCIH<9FB G@CD9G C: -5IFIG 5F9 H<9 F5=BM 5F95G 8I9 HC H<9 :FCBHG
7CA=B;:FCAH<9&98=H9FF5B95B -<989DF9GG=CBGGI7<5G&IH @A5@= IF8IF5B87=;C@9H7 5F9 @C75H98 =BH<9F5=B
G<58CK5F95G ,@CD9=B7@=B5H=CB=GH<9A5=B:57HCF:CFGC=@5B8D5F9BHA5H9F=5@9FCG=CB <9F9 -<95F95GK=H<:CF9GHG
89GHFCM98CBH<9 GC:H A5F@M @CK79A9BH98G5B8M A5H9F=5@G<5J9699BGI6>97H98HC;I@@M9FCG=CB -<9ID@=:H=B;C:
-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG5G5K<C@9<5G75IG98F9>IJ9B5H=CBC::@IJ=5@9FCG=CBGCH<5H899DJ5@@9MG 5HH5=B5 F9@5H=J95@H=HI89
C: ACF9 H<5B   A  -<9 ?5FGH=7 89DF9GG=CB 5B8 75BMCB J5@@9M :CFA 8=GH=B7H <56=H5HG 5B8 5@@CK ;FCKH< C: GCA9
9B89A=7 5B8 F9@=7H GD97=9G 5B8 6=C@C;=75@ F=7<B9GG CB GI7< 5F95G =G <=;<9F H<5B CH<9F 5F95G  $5FGH=7 @5B8G 7F95H9
GI=H56@9 7CB8=H=CB :CF H<9 HF99G 5B8 5F9 7CJ9F98 6M 89BG9 :CF9GHG =B H<9 IB8=GHIF698 5F95G  -<9 G998 ;9FA=B5H=CB
GI779GG:I@@M C77IFG=B H<97F57?G7CBH5=B=B;GC=@ K<=7< 9B<5B79G H<9 F9;9B9F5H=CBDFC79GG

!"

?A5B 1  -YF?=M9(FA5B/9>9H5GMCBI B?5F5TB=J9FG=H9G=15M^B@5F^ B?5F5 -IF?9M


H5@5M" " ,9N9F 5B8! I?IF *525.0*(2756,790,85-9/,(9:7(2**:77,4*,7,(8(4+!,.05404.5-",,+#7(48-,75-5-!,+604,
04:8)7:90( -9B04#:71,> &=B=GHFMC:CF9GHFM =F97HCFMC:,998+9G95F7<)I6@ BC  B?5F5
H5@5M "  !,.05404.5-",,+#7(48-,75-04,86,*0,8 04:40.7(04:8)7:90( 5B8 04:8">2;,89708=B-IF?9M &=B=GHFMC:CF9GHFM
=F97HCFMC:,998+9G95F7<)I6@ 'C  B?5F5
Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156 155

H5@5M " 5 !,.05404.5-",,+#7(48-,75-0*,(570,49(208 =B-IF?9M &=B=GHFMC:CF9GHFM =F97H C:,998+9G95F7<)I6@ 'C 


B?5F5
H5@5M " 5 %,.,9(9054-573(905485-#:71,>-F5J5IL89@"BGH 89 VC;F5D<=989+9=AG 

H5@5M " 6 ,4,7(2*525.0*(2756,790,85-9/,(9:7(2**:77,4*,7,(85-,+(7,+7:80)(40!0*/(4+!,.05404.5-",,+
#7(48-,75-,+(704#:71,> B?5F5 9B9F5@=F97HCFMC:CF9GHFM)I6@=75H=CB'C  DD B?5F5
H5@5M "  /9;9H5H=CB@9J9@GC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BGC:&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB=B-IF?9M 9;95B 9C;F5D<=75@#CIFB5@ 

H5@5M "  #/,(2,5.,5.7(6/>5-9/,,(7(89753(9,2,0895*,4,95(72>525*,4,(4+:3(436(*9 "NA=F ;9.B=J )F9GG
H5@5M "  %,.,9(9054,5.7(6/>5-#:71,> ;9.B=J9FG=HM)F9GG "NA=F -IF?9M ",' DD
H5@5M "   7CF9;=CBGC:-IF?9M &=B=GHFMC:CF9GHFM)I6@=75H=CB 'C  D "NA=F -IF?9M
H5@5M "   ::97HGC:H<9H97HCB=7ACJ9A9BHGCBH<9?5FGH=:=75H=CB=BB5HC@=5 -IF?9M 7H55FGC@C;=75  DD 
 
H5@5M "   +9@=7H5B89B89A=7D@5BHGD97=9GF9:@97H=B;7@=A5H=77<5B;9G=BB5H5@=5 "B7C@C;M5B8BJ=FCBA9BH.FCA5FD5H<=5BGHC
-5IFIG&CIBH5=B )FC7798=B;GC:H< -IF?9M
+CA5B=5B7589A=7,9A=B5F 8G " H5@5M + :9 & "9@9B=7N5B8 5@H95BI DD 

H5@5M "  :9 +   7CF9;=CBGC:H<9&98=H9FF5B95BF955B8H<9%5?9G+9;=CBC:-IF?9M "BH9FB5H=CB5@,MADCG=IA CB 9C;F5D<M "
H5@5M5B8+ :98G )FC7998=B;G DD 

H5@5M " :9 +    7C@C;MC:H<9B5HC@=5B@57?)=B904:840.7(7452+ GI6GD (22(80(4( %5A6 !C@A6C95B8=HG=J=8=B;=BHC
+9;=CBG=B-9FAGC:,998-F5BG:9F &=B=GHFMC:CF9GHFM5B8BJ=FCBA9BH)I6@  B?5F5 ",'
 



H5@5M " :9 +   7C@C;=75@HHF=6IH9G5B8=GHF=6IH=CBC:B5HC@=5B@57?)=B9304:840.7( FBC@8 GI6GD D5@@5G=5B5
%5A6 !C@A6C94=B-IF?9M #CIFB5@C:BJ=FCBA9BH5@=C@C;M  

H5@5M " :9 +   7C@C;MC:,7CHG)=B904:88>2;,89708 J5F 8>2;,89708 CF9GHG5B8H<9=F=J=8=B;=BHC+9;=CBG=B-9FAGC:,998
HF5BG:9F &IB=GHFMC:BJ=FCBA9BH5B8CF9GHFM)I6@  ",'
 


 B?5F5
H5@5M "  :9 +  ,CM?5B    ;52:9054(4+*525.0*(2756,790,85-#(:7:85:49(048 "B:9 F5J=BG (NHIF? H5@5M8G
BJ=FCBA9BH5B8I@HIF9=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB )5FH" <5DH9F(B9 D 
 5A6F=8;9,7<C@5FG)I6@=G<=B; '9K75GH@9 .$
CM85? &  ,+7:820)(40&5;B=:=79BH-F99CFA=B;%5F;9CF9GHG=B-IF?9M "BH9FB5H=CB5@9B8FC@C;M,C7=9HM 195FCC? D


CM85? & =F=? ! J9P5@^?CZ@I &   =C@C;M5B8,=@J=7I@HIF9C:-IF?=G<+98)=B9)=BIG6FIH=5-9B  (FA5B7^@^Z^ 9@=_H=FA9J9
(FA5B15B;^B@5F^=@9&Y7589@9!=NA9H@9F=B=9GH9?@9A9/5?:^15M^B^ %5N9F(:G9H&5H655G^ G B?5F5
CM85?& J9P5@^?CZ@I&   =C@C;M5B8,=@J=7I@HIF9C:%965BCB985F98FIG@=65B= +=7< (FA5B7^@^Z^ 9@=_H=FA9J9(FA5B
15B;^B@5F^=@9&Y7589@9!=NA9H@9F=B=9GH9?@9A9/5?:^15M^B^ %5N9F(:G9H&5H655G^ G B?5F5
:9 +  73,4,1!0;,7(804(9:7(24;07543,49(2756,790,8 .)I6@=75H=CB 'C   DD ",'
 


:9 +   BH<FCDC;9B=789;F585H=CBC:B5HIF5@J9;9H5H=CB=B?5FGH97CGMGH9AG=BH<9GCIH<9FB-IF?9M  9CD<MG=75@+9G95F7<6GHF57HG
JC@  IFCD95B 9CG7=9B79G.B=CB
:9 +   %5B89;F585H=CB=B-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG,CIH<9FB-IF?9M IFCD95B 9CG7=9B79G.B=CB B8 9B9F5@GG9A6@M  .

9CD<MG=75@+9G95F7<6GHF57HG /C@IA9 BC  


:9 +    05.,5.7(6/>704*06(28%,.,9(9054(4+'55.,5.7(6/> &$&)I6@ ",'
 



:9 + ?=B7=   IF965@ "   FCG=CBB5@MG=GC:^B8^?@^F99?5H7<A9BH'0C:-IF?9M.G=B; ",5G98CB+IG@98&9H<C8
F9G9B=IGBJ=FCBA9BH5@I@@9H=B  

I79@  ,  (N?5B  $  9@=?  ,  1I79@   (NHIF? &     B (J9FJ=9K C: H<9 9C6CH5B=75@ ,HFI7HIF9 C: -IF?=G< 04:8 8>2;,89708 5B8
(7604:8),9:2:8 CF9GHG )5?=GH5B#CIFB5@C:CH5BM  

I=8CHH=  ) +9;5HC , #=A9B9N
565@@9FC -<9A5>CF:CF9GHHMD9G=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95B 0CF@80=@8@=:9IB8 +CA9 "H5@M
Y@85@^ '   $5FGHACFD<C@C;=G7<9,HI8=9B=A 96=9H89G)C@>9GMGH9AJCB$9GH9@09GH@=7<9FH<9-5IFIG -IF?9= -I6=B;9B 9C;
,HI8=9B 
Y@85@^ '  ,9M8=G9<=F5B8?G9?=65IL=H989DCG=HG5B8H<9=FF9@5H=CBHCD5@9C?5FGHD<CB9A9B=B5=BH<9-5IFIGG&CIBH5=BG CB; C:H<9
5FH<,7= CB(775GG=CBH<9 H<B C:-IF?=G<+9DI6@=7 DD
 
Y@85@^ '  ?G9?=DC@>9G -<9:CFA5H=CB5B89JC@IH=CBC:=BH9FACBH5B9D@5=B=BH<9?5FGH=7@5B8GC:H<9-5IFIG&CIBH5=BG=B-IF?=G<
9C@I@@ C:-IF?=G<,C7 

Y@85@^ ' 5B8'5N=? %  -<9?5FGH=79JC@IH=CBC:-=B5NH9D975J9GMGH9A5B8=HG=AA98=5H9GIFFCIB8=B;G I@@ C: 9CACF<C@C;M 
 

$5BH5F7^   ?89B=NX@;9G=B898CZ5@5Z5UJ9U5@^HYF@9F=B=BM5M^@^_^=@96X@;9G9@M9H=_A9CFH5A^XN9@@=?@9F=5F5G^B85?==@=_?=@9F\ T
(FA5B5? 15M BC
&5M9F ! ?GCM !  &(2+,7+,7#B71,0  IGH5J=G7<9F/9F@5; ,HHIH;5FH  9FA5BM
(N?5B  $  I@GCM ,  &9FH   (NHIF? & &IMG     )@5BH 8=GHF=6IH=CB
5@H=HI89 5B8 @5B8:CFA F9@5H=CBG<=DG =B ?5FGH=7 G=B?<C@9G C:
&98=H9FF5B95BF9;=CB -IF?9M #CIFB5@C:BJ=FCBA9BH5@=C@C;M ,D97=5@"GGI9  

(NHIF? & 9@=?  15F7^  ?GCM  9C@=    BCJ9FJ=9KC:D@5BH8=J9FG=HM @5B8IG95B889;F585H=CB=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95B
F9;=CBC:-IF?9M 4;07543,49(2(4(.,3,49,(29/  DD 

(NHIF? &  9A=7= 1  CF?  ,97A9B (  ;9B9F5@577CIBHC:<=;<ACIBH5=B:@CF55B8J9;9H5H=CBC:&98=H9FF5B95B D5FHC:-YF?=M9
;9.B=J 5:74(25-(*:29>5-"*0,4*, 
DD 

(NHIF? &  I79@ ,  ,5?75@= ,  CF?   15F7=   CF?   BCJ9FJ=9KC:D@5BH8=J9FG=HM5B8@5B889;F585H=CB=BH9F57H=CBG=BH<9
95GH9FB&98=H9FF5B95B <5DH9F "B'5HIF5@BJ=FCBA9BH5B8I@HIF9=BH<9&98=H9FF5B95B+9;=CB8G :9 ,9(2  5A6F=8;9,7<C@5FG
)I6@ .$ DD

(NHIF? &  ,97A9B (  $CB8C $  /9;9H5H=CB=B9;95BF9;=CBC:-IF?9M &9A 57 "BH9; FHG
,7= !=FCG<=A5  

156 Ibrahim Atalay et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 142 – 156

(NHIF? &   +97CJ9FM5B8F9<56=@=H5H=CBC:A98=H9FF5B95BHMD997CGMGH9A


75G9GHI8M:FCA-IF?=G<A5EI=G "BJ5@I5H=B;5B8
'-(
+0 8G  +5DDCFH  %  5I89H ) 5@CK ,DF=B;9F
/9F@5; 9F@=B DD

)5FC@@M    -<9!=;<&CIBH5=B/9;9H5H=CBC:-IF?9M
5,H5H9C:H<9FH+9DCFH "B7@I8=B;5=FGHBBCH5H98CBGD97HIGC:H<9&5>CF
,MBH5L5-IF?#CH

*I9N9@ )  -<9:CF9GHJ9;9H5H=CBC:-IF?9M )FC7+CM,C78=B6IF;<

,5?75@= & ,  (NHIF? &   7C
)<MG=C@C;=75@9<5J=CIFC: ,CA9&98=H9FF5B95B)@5BHG 5G,I=H56@95B8=85H9G:CF+97@5A5H=CBC:
9;F5898F95G #CIFB5@C:F=8BJ=FCBA9BHG  

,D5BCG "  +58C;@CI $ &  +5:HCM5BB=G 1   ,=H9EI5@=HM9::97HGCBDCGH
:=F9F9;9B9F5H=CBC: 04:8)7:90( :CF9GHCB5 F99?=G@5B8
6620,+%,.,9(9054"*0,4*, 

J5B29=GH 0 CHH9A5 ,  %5H9*I5H9FB5FMJ9;9H5H=CBC:H<9'95F5GH 9=<9:H92IA -Y6=B;9FH@5G89G/CF89F9B(F=9BHG+9=<9 'F
 F %I8K=;+9=7<9FH/9F@5;
0=9G6589B
15@H^F^?   -<9:@CF=GH=77CADCG=H=CBC:A5>CF:CF9GHG=B-IF?9M \ T (FA5B5?Y@H9G=15M^B@5F^   
1^@A5N + IHH , # $CF?IH    )@5BH=J9FG=HM5B89::97HGC:BJ=FCBA9BH5@DFC6@9AG=B-IF?9M #CIFB5@ C:BJ=FCBA9BH5@)FCH97H=CB
5B87C@C;M DD 

1I79@  (NHIF? &   ;9C6CH5B=75@GIFJ9MC: 04:840.7( GGD 6(22(80(4( :CF9GHG=B-IF?9M )@5BH%=:9=B,CIH<
09GH9BHF5@G=5
/H<"BH9FB ,MAD DD 
 -5G<?9BH .N69?=GH5B
2C<5FM &  ,5)59(40*(2-5:4+(905485-9/,0++2,(89 JC@G ,HIHH;5FH  IGH5J=G7<9F/9F@5;

You might also like