You are on page 1of 14

 BY JULIE KNERR, NCTM

Foundational
Concepts
Of Technique For
Beginning Piano

MTNA e-JOURNAL
Students
3

SEPTEMBER 2009
hen I began teaching piano teaching in order to learn how they taught

W after graduating from college, I


was ill-equipped, having taken
one pedagogy class and pos-
sessing almost no teaching
experience. However, I did have a love for chil-
dren, good teaching instincts and a knack for
sequencing concepts, which allowed me to be
technique. After my dissertation was com-
pleted, I continued observing and interview-
ing more teachers to collect additional data
for a future book on the topic of teaching
technique to elementary level students.
The following “Research Teachers” were
included in my research study:
somewhat successful with my students. But I  Marvin Blickenstaff, Collegetown,
wondered if I was teaching my students cor- Pennsylvania
rectly, specifically in the area of technical  Mary Craig Powell, Columbus, Ohio
development.  Carolyn Shaak, Denver, Colorado
Therefore, when the time came to choose  Nancy Breth, Arlington, Virginia
my dissertation topic for my Ph.D. at the  Nina Polonsky, Columbus, Ohio
University of Oklahoma, I chose to take a  Olga Radosavljevich, Cleveland, Ohio
closer look at the topic of technique in ele-  Ella Karasik, Cleveland, Ohio
mentary-level piano students. In 2006 I com-  Thu Carey, Houston, Texas
pleted this qualitative research study1 in  John Weems, Houston, Texas
which I interviewed and observed several  Suzanne Guy, Norfolk, Virginia
teachers well known for their pre-college
These research teachers rep- comfortable piano playing. the piano more difficult.
resent different schools of According to the research Students should use a foot-
thought regarding technical teachers, aspects of good pos- stool or pedal extender to
development and piano teach- ture include: provide a firm base of sup-
ing. For example, Mary Craig  Height of the Bench: The port for the feet until they are
Powell uses the Suzuki bench should be at a height tall enough to reach the floor.
method, while Carolyn Shaak that the forearms, when in Piano Hand Shape
incorporates the ideas of Orff playing position, are level or Several of the research teach-
and Montessori. Nina Polonsky slightly higher than the key- ers objected to the term “hand
represents the Russian school, board. Carpet squares are position,” because they believed
while Thu Carey and John preferable to cushions to this term denotes a stiff, set
Weems use concepts from the boost a student’s sitting hand rather than a hand that
Dorothy Taubman approach. I position because they form a is flexible to accommodate the
welcomed this variety of teach- firm base of balance. gesture of a particular passage.
ing philosophies in my  Distance from the Although it is true that
research because I wanted to Keyboard: The approach advanced pianists use different
SEPTEMBER 2009

study a range of ideas and described by Faber and hand shapes to play varying
teaching styles. Faber 2 of putting the arms passages, all the research
After interviews and observa- straight so that the fists teachers stressed that it is
tions with the research teachers, touch the fallboard is the imperative for beginning stu-
all of whom have varying ideas best way to check for dis- dents to form a correct piano
about relating to students, use tance from the keyboard hand shape in the first months
an assortment of method books (Photo A). of piano playing. Letting a stu-
4 and materials and have dis- dent play with a poor hand
parate teaching personalities, I shape in the early years leads
MTNA e-JOURNAL

started to see trends related to to many technical and musical


the teaching of technique that problems in later years. The
transcended the variations in research teachers stressed the
the research teachers’ styles, following components of a good
methods and philosophies. In piano hand shape.
this article I will describe these  The bridge of the hand
trends as they relate to teaching should be up (Photo B), not
technique to beginning stu- Photo A collapsed (Photo C).
dents. Because these concepts
are common to all the research  The student should sit tall
teachers, they can form the on the sitting bones with the
foundation for a philosophy of head straight and on top of
teaching technique that can the spine. For more detail in
apply to any teacher and stu- the body structure of the
dent. spine in relation to the head
Part I discusses the techni- and other skeletal details
cal concepts common to the important to piano playing,
research teachers. Part II see What Every Pianist Needs Photo B
describes a practical way for to Know about the Body, by
any teacher to implement Mark, Gary and Miles.3
these concepts to beginning  Sitting tall requires that the
piano students. feet be firmly on the floor. The
body should be balanced over
Part I. Technical the feet, with a secondary
Concepts balance over the sitting
Posture bones. Dangling feet puts all
Proper posture at the piano the balance on the sitting
is imperative for injury-free, bones, which makes playing Photo C
 The thumb plays on the cor- straight or over curled (Photo through persistence and
ner tip (Photo D), not flat on J). Teachers should beware patience. Curving the fingers
its side (Photo E) and is gen- of using pictures in method more is not the solution to
tly curved inward (Photo F), books, which often feature this problem (Photo M). This
not outward (Photo G). pictures of a hand shape puts the bones of the fingers
that is too curved. in a position where they can-
not collapse, but at the
expense of mobility, since
fingers that are very curved
cannot move quickly

Photo D

MTNA e-JOURNAL
Photo H Photo K

5
Photo E

SEPTEMBER 2009
Photo I
Photo L

Photo F

Photo J
Photo M

 The nail joint of each finger


should be strong (Photo K)
rather than collapsed (Photo
Photo G L), because collapsing nail
joints do not allow the stu-
dent to kinesthetically per-
 Fingers should be gently ceive and control the key.
curved (Photo H) (Photo I). It The research teachers agreed
is easier to move the fingers that collapsing nail joints is
when they are gently curved, a common problem that
rather than when they are needs to be addressed Video 1
(Video 1). Instead of curving Extreme ranges of motion in
the fingers more, students the wrist, whether up (Photo
should learn the feeling of T), down (Photo U) or laterally,
“strong finger nail joints” should be avoided, as this can
by: Pressing on the teacher’s cause injury.
joints, and then having the
teacher press on the stu-
dent’s joints (Photo N).
Photo P

Photo T
SEPTEMBER 2009

Photo N

 Playing repeated rhythm pat- Photo Q


terns such as with each fin-
ger on a table or on the
piano, and (Video 2).
6
Photo U
MTNA e-JOURNAL

In the case of harmonic


intervals or chords, proper
Photo R alignment of the arm depends
on two criteria. First, the arm
Alignment should align with the hand in
The arm should stay aligned the most comfortable and
Video 2
behind the finger playing so straight position between the
the hand is not injured through extremes of the notes within
 Making finger circles ulnar deviation (Photo S) or the interval or chord, like this
between the thumb and each twisting in the wrists. (Photo V), not like this (Photo
finger (Photo O) (Photo P) W), where the extreme fingers
(Photo Q) (Photo R). are lined up on the keys. The
arm and hand are not aligned,
causing ulnar deviation and
putting stress on the wrist.

Photo O

Photo S Photo V
Photo W Photo BB
Video 3
Second, the position of the shape of the chord in terms of
arm depends on the register of Often, the correct alignment black and white keys.
the keys in relation to the means that the thumb is clos- Powell provided a powerful
body. For example, if the right er to the edge of the white key illustration of exactly where
hand is playing a chord close while the 5th finger is further the student should play on the

MTNA e-JOURNAL
to middle C (Photo X), the in towards the fallboard (Photo length of the key by placing
alignment will be different Z). This prevents the hand pieces of removable tape on
from the same chord played in from being ulnar deviated the correct places on each key.
the high register of the piano (Photo AA). However, depend- In this way, the student could
ing on the register of the pas- visually see the shape of a pat-
tern and begin to think about
not just which key to play, but 7
where on the key to play
(Video 4). Carey, Weems, Guy

SEPTEMBER 2009
Photo X
Photo Z

Video 4

and Breth all coached their


students regularly throughout
Photo Y
Photo AA the lessons about where to
play on the key in order to
(Photo Y) in relation to how the sage, the opposite might be stay aligned.
arm is angled to the body. true, such as this interval at Keeping a Small Hand
When playing an accompani- the highest register of the Nearly all the research
ment pattern such as Alberti piano (Photo BB). The key is to teachers believed that unnec-
bass, the student should play plan the most comfortable essarily stretching the hands
the pattern as a blocked chord alignment before playing a of children was dangerous.
first to find the proper align- passage, taking into considera- Legato was often sacrificed to
ment and angle between the tion the position of the body prevent stretching of the hand.
body, arm and hand (Video 3). and arm in relation to the reg- Instead of reaching for notes
ister of the chord and the with the fingers in a leaping
passage, the arm should move Up and Over the Keys
the hand to a new note. In the Photo CC If the hand is playing with a
event that a stretch is tall bridge, on the corner of the
unavoidable, the hand should thumb, with strong fingernail
return to a small and relaxed joints, the hand is put in a
position as soon as possible position of approaching the
after the stretch. Weems noted keys from above. Students who
that when rotation is used, a have collapsed bridges, fingers
leap can sound legato even if or flat thumbs tend to
the keys are not being physi- approach the keys from below,
cally connected (Video 5). making it difficult to transfer
the support of the arm to the
Photo DD playing finger (Video 8). Weems
SEPTEMBER 2009

Video 5
8 the fingers to help them relax.
Relaxed Non-Playing Fingers This will gradually help the Video 8
MTNA e-JOURNAL

In key depression, the arm student learn the difference in


aligns behind the playing fin- sensation between relaxed and also noted that when a finger
ger to support it in key depres- tense non-playing fingers. plays with the support of the
sion (Video 6). The finger A relaxed thumb is especially arm, there is a slight moving
important. Carrying tension in forward from the elbow. If a
the thumb makes the whole student tends to play with col-
hand tense, because it is lapsed bridges or knuckles, the
impossible to have a tense teacher may think the main
thumb while the other fingers problem is in the hand and
stay relaxed. Stopping the stu- strive to fix the hand shape.
dent periodically to check the However, the problem may real-
non-playing thumb by jiggling ly lie further back, in the fore-
the thumb up from under- arm. Having the student play
neath is an effective way to with a slight forward motion
Video 6 help the student form an from the elbow on each note
awareness of the feeling of a can help to rectify the hand
balances the weight of the arm relaxed thumb (Video 7). position problems (Video 9).
on the bottom of the key. The
non-playing fingers should be
relaxed (Photo CC), which
means that the fingers are not
necessarily on the keys, but
that they are more straight
than curled. Curled fingers are
not relaxed fingers (Photo DD).
If fingers are curled or sticking
up, the teacher should stop
the student often and touch Video 7 Video 9
This translates to thinking of begin to play legato with a Second, children’s fingers
playing up and over the keys forearm stroke on each note are small and weak, and the
rather than from underneath. (Video 11), followed by the keys of the modern piano
Articulation require more weight than the
The research teachers had keyboard instruments a few
mixed opinions regarding centuries ago. The arm work-
whether legato or non-legato ing in conjunction with the fin-
should be the first articulation gers provides the weight
that students learn. Most of the necessary for children to pro-
research teachers stated that duce a healthy tone at the
non-legato should come first. piano and to play the piano
The few who believed legato without injury.
should be taught first said that In my experience judging
if a student could not success- Video 11 festivals, I see many young
fully play legato at first, the students using their fingers
student was allowed to play more subtle finger work, which alone with no awareness of the

MTNA e-JOURNAL
non-legato for a short time to combines one arm gesture for role of the arm (Video 13).
gain more control before legato a phrase of several notes
was attempted. This means (Video 12).
that non-legato is the easier
articulation to begin with.
Most method books do not
specify how the beginning 9
pieces are to be played,
whether students should use

SEPTEMBER 2009
fingers or arm as the primary
playing unit, or whether the
articulation should be non- Video 13
legato or legato. After inter-
viewing and observing the Video 12 I believe this is because most
research teachers, I have come method books used by stu-
to the conclusion that until Forearm First, Fingers dents and teachers emphasize
students have control over the Second finger numbers from the
basic movement of the fore- There are two main reasons beginning and do not provide
arm, have formed a proper children should play the piano any instruction about which
hand shape and have gained using the large motions of part of the body should be
some basic finger dexterity, all their forearms as the primary used to play those specific fin-
beginning pieces in method playing apparatus to support ger numbers. This leads the
books should be played non- the fingers, which are the sec- student and teacher to assume
legato with a forearm stroke ondary playing apparatus. that as long as the correct fin-
(Video 10). Later, students can First, children have more con- gers are used, the piece is
trol over their large muscles being played properly.
than their small muscles. In general, when using the
Therefore, they have more con- arm as the primary playing unit
trol and freedom at the key- while the fingers take the role of
board when they use their very active, but secondary play-
arms to help their fingers play, ing units, the arm should stay
rather than just focusing on behind the finger that is playing
playing the right keys with the to support that finger in pro-
right fingers, without help ducing the tone. This coordina-
from the arm. tion of the arm and fingers
Video 10 results in the following:
 The arm adjusts for each fin- that used by Shaak, Guy and the first semester of piano
ger, creating what might be Breth. Either way is effective. study. They are based on
called a “choreography of An individual’s teaching style observations of the research
gestures.” The arm moves in may be drawn to one method teachers and formulated
forward, backward, lateral, rather than another. around the technical concepts
circular or rotating shapes Summary found in Part I of this article.
with the hand and fingers From the very beginning of The exercises are called
depending on the shape of study, teachers should work to Piano Safari Technique exercis-
the passage (Video 14). ensure the student is in con- es because they are based on
trol of the following aspects of an animal theme that appeals
piano technique: to young students and because
 Proper posture my colleague Katie Fisher and I
 A relaxed but controlled are writing a piano method
piano hand shape called Piano Safari, which
 Approaching the keys from incorporates these exercises
SEPTEMBER 2009

above (pianosafari.com).
 Keeping the arm behind the It should be noted that play-
finger that is playing ing these exercises is not
 Alignment between the arm enough to develop a good tech-
Video 14 and hand and finger nique. The exercises must be
 A small and relaxed hand played correctly, with attention
 This choreography results in that avoids stretching to concepts such as hand
10 a synthesis of rhythm and  Relaxed non-playing fingers shape, alignment and relaxed
gesture, furthering the musi-  Playing beginning pieces with non-playing fingers that were
MTNA e-JOURNAL

cal expression of the phrase. a forearm stroke and a non- discussed in Part I. The
This choreography has been legato articulation, followed teacher should first study and
codified by the Taubman by legato articulation when play the exercises to under-
approach through a set of the student has basic control stand the goals and gestures of
rules denoting when the of the playing apparatus each exercise in order to teach
pianist should play further in These aspects will result in a it correctly to the student. For
toward the fallboard, out choreography of gestures that most students, these exercises
toward the edge of the keys, at produce relaxed, coordinated will take several weeks to mas-
various angles to the key, with and musical playing. ter. Teachers must persistently
single and double rotations work with students until they
and so on. Two of the research Part II. Practical can play the exercises confi-
teachers, Carey and Weems, Application dently and comfortably. Instant
have had great success teach- Piano Safari Technique results are rare.
ing their students these rules. Exercises The exercises are cumulative
Through following the gener- After observing and inter- and are taught by rote.
al guidelines in Part I of this viewing the research teachers, Notation is provided for teacher
article, all teachers can incor- I decided that for my own and parent reference. Having
porate the foundational princi- teaching, designing a series of the corresponding stuffed ani-
ples that result in a technical exercises would help mal “watch” and “encourage”
choreography of gestures with- me organize my teaching of the student can provide extra
in their own teaching style, technical concepts important fun and motivation. Once these
whether the teacher prefers to beginning pianists. The fol- exercises are learned, the ges-
stated rules for movement, lowing exercises help students tures they teach can be applied
such as those used by Weems, develop the choreographic ges- to repertoire pieces the student
Powell and Carey; or whether tures necessary to successfully is studying. In fact, I have
the teacher’s style favors a play the repertoire in the first found the students often find
more conversational approach two years of study and are the gestures in pieces faster
to teaching movement, such as designed to be introduced in than I do!
Exercise 1. Exercise 2.
Grizzly Bear Zechariah Zebra
(based on exer- (Blickenstaff,
cises by Powell, Shaak)
Polonsky and Goals: fast and
Powell) free movement of
Goals: arm the forearm, firm
weight, relaxed nail joints
hand and I was surprised
thumb, wrist when three of the
flexibility, graceful arching movement between first research
octaves teachers I observed all had their students prac-
I begin teaching the “grizzly bear” by having a tice this exercise in the beginning weeks of
group of students stand with their arms by study. I asked Powell why this “twinkle varia-
their sides. I talk about how my sleeping tion” from the Suzuki4 violin method had been
stuffed bear is floppy and heavy, just like their transferred to the piano, and she gave three

MTNA e-JOURNAL
arms should be. I jiggle their arms as they rest reasons:
at their side to check for relaxation. 1. Students play fast from the beginning, so as
When we play the “grizzly bear,” I hold the not to develop a fear of playing fast. Also, for
student’s arm and hand for the first few weeks children, fast is fun!
to allow the student to understand the feeling 2. Repeating a note with the same finger helps
of the exercise (Video 15). Gradually, the stu- strengthen the finger nail joints.
dent learns to use his own arm weight to drop 3. If a student can play this exercise fast, it 11
into the key shows that the arm is loose, since it is diffi-
without my cult to play this exercise at a fast tempo

SEPTEMBER 2009
help. I play an when the arm is too tense.
accompani- Powell calls this exercise “Mississippi hop
ment of low frog.” When I observed Marvin Blickenstaff, he
chords to make used the same exercise, calling it “Ebeneezer
the exercise sneezer.” Carolyn Shaak also used it, calling it
sound more “Colorado
like a grizzly mountain.”
bear (Video After three
Video 15 16). teachers in my
research used
this exercise, I
decided it must
be useful for
students, and
“Zechariah
zebra” was Video 17
added to the
Piano Safari
Technique
Video 16 exercises.
Helping the
student play by
holding the
hand and fin-
ger will help
the student be
more success- Video 18
ful at first (Video 17). Students can then play Exercise 4. Kangaroo
the exercise themselves (Video 18). (Shaak)
Goals: fast and free
forearm movement,
firm nail joints, accura-
cy and confidence
“Kangaroo” is a reit-
eration of the tech-
Exercise 3. Persian nique used in
Cat (Nearly all research “Zechariah zebra,” but
teachers use this tech- is more advanced than
nique in pieces) Goals: “Zechariah zebra”
free and rhythmic fore- because
arm movement, moving there is no
around the keyboard, pause
SEPTEMBER 2009

wrist flexibility between fin-


“Persian cat” has two phases. ger changes
1. Students practice “Persian cat” non-legato (Video 21).
with a forearm movement on each note and
a non-legato
articulation
(the notes
are separate
12 Video 21
but not as
MTNA e-JOURNAL

short as
staccato)
(Video 19).
2. Once stu-
dents have Exercise 5. Flying
control of Video 19 Squirrel Goals: down up
“Persian cat” wrist motion and flexibility,
non-legato, they learn “Persian cat” legato, legato three-note slurs,
where a forearm movement on each note is graceful arching movement
combined with fingers that connect the notes between octaves, one arm
to form lega- movement per phrase
to (Video After students master
20). The “Persian cat” non-legato
beginning and “Persian
pieces are cat” legato, Video 22
played with they start
“Persian cat incorporating
technique,” groups of notes
non-legato into one arm
first and gesture. This is
then legato, a more
Video 20
for the first advanced form
several years of study while gradually also of legato (Video
incorporating “flying squirrel,” Exercise 5. 22).
Exercise 6. Elephant video is an
Moonwalk example of
Goals: Development working with a
of the outer fingers of student to
the hand in a proper make the
position, arm weight, “monkey exer-
wrist flexibility, align- cise” better.
ment These exercises
“Elephant moonwalk” is an extension of “griz- will not be per-
zly bear” and requires control of the outsides of fect immediate- Video 25
the hand and more control regarding which ly, but must be
notes are worked on for perfection. (Video 25).
played. It
should be
played slowly,
simulating an
elephant that

MTNA e-JOURNAL
falls with a
thud onto the
moon and then
gently floats up Exercise 8.
in weightless- Video 23 Lazy Turtle
ness (Video 23). Goals: inter-
vals, arm 13
weight, align-
ment

SEPTEMBER 2009
This is an
Exercise 7. Monkey extension of
Swinging (Blickenstaff, “grizzly bear”
Shaak, Weems, Carey) and “elephant
Goals: rotation, lega- moonwalk”
to, alignment that focuses on
This is a beginning the control of
rotation exercise. intervals (Video
Alignment is very 26).
important. The thumb
should be on the end
of the white key while
the 5th finger is further in to prevent ulnar
deviation. Also, it is imperative that the non-
playing fingers are relaxed and that the student
thinks of the Video 26
thumb as
being one
unit while
the other
four fingers Application to Music
are a unit I have found that children readily apply the
with and gestures taught in the Piano Safari Technique
support the exercises to their repertoire pieces. Because the
5th finger exercises have become cemented in a student’s
(Video 24). muscle memory, when I say, “Use more Grizzly
The following Video 24 Bear right here,” about a specific place in a
piece, the student automatically releases more Example 2. Melody, Op. 39, No. 2, by
arm weight and drops into a key with a fuller Kabalevsky.7 Level 1.
sound. Or I can say, “Where is the Monkey
spot?” and the student finds the places to use
rotation. Of course, I also use the standard
terms, such as rotation, arm weight, down up
and so forth with the student. However, stu-
dents seem to retain the motions better
through the use of an animal theme and
stuffed animals. The right hand uses “monkey” technique, a
Below are four examples of how the Piano rotating motion where the arm stays behind the
Safari Technique exercises can be incorporated finger playing. The left hand uses “lazy turtle”
into standard literature. Levels refer to the lev- technique combined with “flying squirrel” tech-
eling system of Jane Magrath.5 nique, where
Example 1. Duet by Köhler.6 Level 1. arm weight
sinks into the
SEPTEMBER 2009

first harmon-
ic interval
followed by
an up motion
on the sec-
ond harmon-
Video 27 Students first ic interval
practice this (Video 29). Video 29
14
piece with
MTNA e-JOURNAL

“Persian cat” Example 3. Folk Dance, from First Term at


legato tech- the Piano, No. 5, by Bartok.8 Level 2.
nique (Video
27). Then they
play it with
“flying squirrel”
technique
based on the
slur marks (m.
1, 2, 4) (Video This piece can be practiced slowly with
28). There are “Persian cat”
also “kangaroo” legato tech-
rhythms in m. nique for
3. deep tone
In the Piano and loose-
Safari system, ness in the
Video 28 technique is arms. Then
combined with the phrases
rhythmic are grouped
impulse using “flying
through tapping the “Zechariah zebra” ,“kanga- squirrel” Video 30
roo” and “Persian cat” rhythmic pat- technique
terns on a table and playing them on the piano, (Video 30). This piece also contains “Zechariah
as shown in the video under the section, Piano zebra” (m. 1) and “kangaroo” rhythms (m. 2).
Hand Shape. Students then recognize these pat-
terns in pieces, which reinforces the relation-
ship between the technical gesture and the
rhythmic pattern.
Example 4. Arabesque, Op. 100, No. 2, by parents dedicated to their musical education
Burgmüller.9 Level 3 and teachers who cared greatly about every
aspect of their piano education.
Technique was stressed in each studio
because technique is the foundation to all
future piano playing. I hope that this glimpse
into my research will provide information that

MTNA e-JOURNAL
will be as helpful for other piano teachers as it
has been for me in my own teaching of tech-
The right hand uses “monkey” technique nique.
(rotation) while left hand uses “flying squirrel” 
technique (down up) (Video 31). Using these dif-
ferent gestures
between hands NOTES 15
is complicated 1. Julie Knerr, “Formation of Piano
at first, but pro- Technique In Elementary Level Piano Students:

SEPTEMBER 2009
vides greater An Exploration of Teaching Elementary Level
rhythmic energy Technical Concepts According to Authors and
and relaxed Teachers from 1925 to the Present,” (Ph.D.
freedom of diss., University of Oklahoma, 2006).
movement when 2. Randall Faber and Nancy Faber, Piano
mastered. Adventures, Lesson Book, Primer Level (Fort
Children who Video 31 Lauderdale, FL: FJH, 1995), 3.
analyze for ges- 3. Thomas Mark, Roberta Gary and Thom
tures from the beginning of study do not find Miles, What Every Pianist Needs to Know About
complicated coordinations difficult by the time the Body (Chicago: GIA Publications, 2003).
they reach this level. 4. Sinichi Suzuki, Suzuki Violin School, V. 1
(Secaucus, NJ: Summy-Birchard, 1975)
Conclusion 5. Jane Magrath, The Pianist’s Guide to
Interviewing and observing the research Standard Teaching and Performance Literature
teachers provided me with a completely new (Van Nuys, CA: Alfred Publishing Company,
perspective regarding the teaching of technique 1995).
to beginning students. I was impressed with 6. Keith Snell, ed., Piano Repertoire,
the great importance the research teachers Romantic/Twentieth Century, Preparatory (San
placed on the beginning stages of study, exhib- Diego, CA: Kjos Music Publishing, 1997), 7.
ited by their professional and exacting 7. Snell, 15.
approach to their student’s learning from the 8. Ibid., 15.
very first lesson, regardless of the child’s per- 9. Keith Snell, ed., Piano Repertoire,
ceived “talent.” I was happy to discover that the Romantic/Twentieth Century, Level 3 (San
children I observed were not “prodigies.” They Diego, CA: Kjos Music Publishing, 1997), 9.
were just very well trained students who had
Bibliography Mark, Thomas, Roberta Gary, and Thom Miles.
Faber, Randall, and Nancy Faber. Piano What Every Pianist Needs to Know About the
Adventures, Lesson Book, Primer Body. Chicago: GIA Publications, 2003.
Level. Fort Lauderdale, FL: FJH, 1995. Snell, Keith, ed. Piano Repertoire,
Knerr, Julie. “Formation of Piano Technique In Romantic/Twentieth Century, Preparatory.
Elementary Level Piano Students: San Diego, CA: Kjos Music Publishing, 1997.
SEPTEMBER 2009

An Exploration of Teaching Elementary Level Snell, Keith, ed. Piano Repertoire,


Technical Concepts According to Authors and Romantic/Twentieth Century, Level 3. San
Teachers from 1925 to the Present.” Ph.D. Diego, CA: Kjos Music Publishing, 1997.
diss., University of Oklahoma, 2006. Suzuki, Sinichi. Suzuki Violin School, V. 1.
Magrath, Jane. The Pianist’s Guide to Standard Secaucus, NJ: Summy-Birchard, 1975.
Teaching and Performance Literature. Van
Nuys, CA: Alfred Publishing Company, 1995.
16
MTNA e-JOURNAL

Julie Knerr, NCTM, is on the adjunct piano faculty at the


Wanda L. Bass School of Music www.okcu.edu/Music at
Oklahoma City University www.okcu.edu, where she teaches
group piano and is an accompanist. She also maintains a pri-
vate studio in Norman, Oklahoma. Until recently, Knerr was
assistant professor of piano and pedagogy at University of
Missouri, where and children's piano lessons; directed the
group piano program; and created and directed the Piano
Safari program for children. She holds a Ph.D. degree in music
education with an emphasis in piano pedagogy from the
University of Oklahoma, where her dissertation on elementary-level piano technique
was nominated for the Best Ph.D. Dissertation Award in 2006. Additional degrees
include M.M. degrees in piano performance and piano pedagogy from the University
of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, where Knerr studied both piano and harpsichord,
and a B.M. degree in piano performance from the University of Puget Sound.

You might also like