12/19/2017 Has demonetisation really boosted income tax collections?

- Livemint

Home » Politics
Last Published: Wed, May 24 2017. 05 10 AM IST

Has demonetisation really boosted income tax collections?

One-off gains from Income Disclosure Scheme 2016 call for scepticism about any immediate claims of demonetisation having widened
India’s income tax net

Roshan Kishore

Enter email for newsletter Sign Up

Union Budget 2017-18 has predicted an annual increase of 25.4% in income tax collections over revised estimate gures for 2016-17. Photo: HT

News reports have quoted government officials making claims about a record increase in the number of income tax payers in
2016-17. Should such claims be seen as a success of demonetisation in forcing unscrupulous individuals to become a part of
income tax net? An analysis of direct tax collection statistics and income tax department’s income tax return (ITR) filing data calls
for scepticism about any immediate claims of demonetisation leading to a dramatic turnaround in India’s direct tax collections.

Union Budget 2017-18 has predicted an annual increase of 25.4% in income tax collections over revised estimate (RE) figures for
2016-17. RE figures for 2016-17 show an annual increase of 23.3% over 2015-16 actual estimates. These growth figures are the
highest in this decade, and seen at face value, suggest a dramatic improvement in India’s income tax base in the past one year.

However 2016-17 income tax collections need to be seen in the context of Income Disclosure Scheme 2016, which led to the
disclosure of Rs65,250 crore of undisclosed income. At 45% rate of taxation, the scheme would have brought in mostly one-time
extra income tax revenue of around Rs30,000 crore.

After adjusting for this value, the annual increase in income tax collections for 2016-17 seems more modest, and as a result, 2017-
18 targets appear to be much more difficult.
Get Notifications

http://www.livemint.com/Politics/C4Q8mpskSbfEzmG8ZWBY9H/Can-we-measure-demonetisations-impact-on-income-tax-collect.html 1/4
12/19/2017 Has demonetisation really boosted income tax collections? - Livemint

ITR e-filing data from income tax department shows that number of ITR filings increased from 43.3 million to 52.9 million
between FY16 and FY17. In absolute terms, the increase is not significantly more than what was achieved between FY15 and FY16.
To be sure, the ITR filing and payment process for the previous fiscal year is still underway and income tax returns/tax payments
could continue to increase. However, data available till now does not suggest a spectacular increase in India’s income tax base due
to demonetisation.

It is reasonable to assume that a large amount of income tax evasion happens on account of non-salaried classes, as those getting
salaries have their taxes deducted at source. The income tax department classifies ITR filings on the basis of type of tax payers
(see details here). At present there are nine such categories, where ITR 1 and 2 represent individuals or Hindu Undivided
Get Notifications

Family (HUFs) earnings from salaries, interest, house income etc. These categories account for close to half of ITR filings in the
country. The ITR filing data for FY17 does not show any significant change in composition of ITR filings by different categories
compared to previous years.

http://www.livemint.com/Politics/C4Q8mpskSbfEzmG8ZWBY9H/Can-we-measure-demonetisations-impact-on-income-tax-collect.html 2/4
12/19/2017 Has demonetisation really boosted income tax collections? - Livemint

To be sure, there could still be an increase in tax collection if such elements have been forced to declare their ill-gotten wealth
(result of under-reported incomes in earlier tax-returns) kept in cash to tax authorities. But for any such increase to be inferred as
a result of demonetisation and not one-off gain due to Income Disclosure Scheme, the trend must sustain itself for a few years
rather than being a one-off thing.

The short point is one must wait for a few years before declaring any significant victory for demonetisation in India’s battle to
bring undisclosed incomes in the tax net.

First Published: Tue, May 23 2017. 09 05 AM IST

TOPICS: DEMONETISATION INCOME TAX COLLECTION INCOME DISCLOSURE SCHEME DEMONETISATION IMPACT TAXPAYERS

You May Like Sponsored Links by Taboola

10 Best Dating Sites for Singles in Meerut City

Online Dating Services | Search Links

Simple Method "Regrows" Hair. Try It Tonight

Regrow Hair Loss

Every Parent Should Watch This Video For Right Parenting!

Flinto Box

Inviting Applications for XLRI's Financial Accounting & Auditing Course

XLRI Executive Online Certi cation

Stock Clearance Sale. Upto 80% Off on Branded Luxury Watches

Royal Watches Club

Losing Your Hair? This ’10 Days’ Hair Oil can Help You!
10 Days Hair Oil

EDITOR'S PICKS »
Get Notifications

http://www.livemint.com/Politics/C4Q8mpskSbfEzmG8ZWBY9H/Can-we-measure-demonetisations-impact-on-income-tax-collect.html 3/4
12/19/2017 Has demonetisation really boosted income tax collections? - Livemint
India’s jobless growth is a myth

Election Results 2017: Narendra Modi-led BJP juggernaut rolls on

What the subterranean shift in Gujarat means for the BJP

Home Lounge Specials

Companies Multimedia Technology

Opinion Money Mint on Sunday

Industry Science Contact Us

Politics Education About Us

Consumer Sports Advertising

Sitemap Brand Stories

DesiMartini Livehindustan

Mint Apps Subscribe

Shine

Hindustantimes

Syndication

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Enter your email Subscribe

Privacy Policy Terms of Use Mint Code RSS

Copyright © 2017 HT Media Ltd. All Rights Reserved

Get Notifications

http://www.livemint.com/Politics/C4Q8mpskSbfEzmG8ZWBY9H/Can-we-measure-demonetisations-impact-on-income-tax-collect.html 4/4