Comments from legal scholors

The journal of international economic laws repeated that the practice of asking legal scholors and
observers of a ministerial conference to give their reaction comments after the doha ministerial.
Schott gave a general comment, Horlicks questioned if the speedbump he noticed in seattle had
been jumped over, wolff asked a direct questions: ‘what did doha do?; charnovitz explored the
legal status of the doha ministerial declaration and Carmen otero Garcia castrillion examined the
doha ministerial declaration and Carmen otera Garcia – castrillion examined the Doha ministerial
declaration on the TRIPS and public health.

Schott’s assessment of the doha ministerial is neither positivre nor negative. According