Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Deondra Taylor
Dr. McCully
26 October 2017
Like many American’s that night of November 8th, 2016, I was among the many who
were shocked and horrified at the election of President Trump. Many people were angry,
confused shocked and in utter denial that someone who is immature, rude, and narcissistic could
ever become president of the country. However, it is possible that a president such as Trump
predicted even before his election did the history of America predict a president like Trump
coming into office? Did the history of America’s imperialism, ethnocentrism, nationalism, and
racism result in Trump's election? How about the Obama administration, the Democratic
Candidate Hillary Clinton, as well as his use of social media, and his background in business?
Because of America’s history, and the view that America is losing their place in the world.
Because of the feeling that Americans are being put on the backburner because of globalization,
the feeling of loss of power and control of the majority. In the eyes of Trump’s supporters, he
represents the resurgence of American exceptionalism, regaining their place in the world and
From the beginning, America has always been a place of nonconformity, and
individualism. When the Puritans arrived in America, they were finally able to practice and
preach their own ideas, as they were viewed as outsiders in their home country, however, in
America they were the ones who sowed the seeds and shaped American nationalism and culture.
Taylor 2
These people believed that they were “God’s chosen people.”, many of the people who moved
here believed that this was the land that God has chosen for them and that they needed to educate
and convert, and integrate English culture to the American Indians; and if they are unwilling to
do this to forcibly removing them from the land. This sense of nationalism only increased over
time, resulting in westward expansion under the principle of manifest destiny, to expand
American territory as well as American culture. Which started with the Dred Scott case, this case
prevented Congress to decide if slavery will be abolished in every state expanding further west
and expanding the country into Mexico’s territory. This need to expand America’s culture and
willingness to blame and attack other countries and people(s) to express the idea that American
Then came the 2016 presidential elections, where Trump was able to bring up this old
made it clear during his presidential run that he is an “America first” president, and there is no
greater example of that than his campaign slogan “Make America Great Again.” this implies that
in some way and at some point, America has lost what made it exceptional, that somehow
American people and culture are under attack and that he is the only person who can restore
America to its former glory. Trump made it clear that American minorities, as well as people
who practice Islam, are enemies to American safety and threaten their culture. He said things
like, “When Mexico is sending its people, they’re not sending their best…They’re bringing
drugs, they’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume are good people.” (Heilpern).
Trump also makes the statement that “This all happened because, frankly, there’s no
assimilation. They are not assimilating…They want to go by sharia law. They want sharia law.
They don’t want the laws that we have. They want sharia law” (Johnson and Hauslohner). That
Taylor 3
these people somehow take away American wellness and decency, and that he is the redeemer of
American purity and safety. Trump was able to take advantage of people’s fear and uncertainty
by using American minorities, specifically Muslims, as a scape goat for America’s problems. He
Trump is a nonconformist. He did not fit the presidential norm, he never played by the
rules, and he does not fit the presidential stereotype of being well spoken, polite, politically
correct, and respectable. Throughout his campaign, he was an outsider, a fresh face to American
politics. He always spoke his mind rather than give into the political jargon that democratic
presidential candidate, Hillary Clinton was already familiar with, who was already seen as
untrustworthy by many republicans as well as democrats. Trump’s rhetoric made him stand out
from the beginning of his presidential campaign and remained consistent until and beyond his
presidential election. The only differences between Trump’s ideals and puritan ideals are the
reasons for the failing of America are the loss of power and wealth, instead of a loss of moral,
and blaming it on others rather than looking inward. Puritan’s would report on the evils of the
land to the people, much in the same way Trump would. With his comments on Mexican and
Muslim immigrants are echoes of Puritan witch hunts. By ensuing irrational fear of
misunderstood groups of people or people who are been grossly represented by awful stereotypes
of their society, Trump is pursuing a modern-day witch hunt. The irrational fear that consumed
the puritan’s in the wake of the witch trains led to a rash generalization of women being witches,
leading to many women being unfairly brutalized and murdered. This is the same case with
minorities of this country. Many minorities were and are blamed by trump for the downfalls of
this country, and plagued by negative and damaging stereotypes that can lead to wrongful
This is shown in many of the speeches he gave throughout his campaign, and during his
presidential run; speech can be broken down into three different elements, first is that “America,
once great, is now weak and repeatedly humiliated by others…. America’s decline was framed as
resulting from the actions of its enemies…the third part of Trump’s argument went on to identify
the all-important solution: himself” (Haslam). These three key elements I feel are what
By stating that America is no longer the leader of the world, and is slowly losing power
to other countries such as Russia and China, Trump was already able to grab a hold of one part of
his voter base. For years, people have lost faith in their government, especially Obama’s
administration and how it dealt with situations such as economic decline, healthcare, as well as
ISIS and other forms of terrorism. People felt as though they weren’t being protected nor were
they being heard by the previous government. Trump responded to these fears by saying, “Our
country is in serious trouble. We don’t have victories anymore. We used to have victories, but
we don’t have them. When was the last time anybody saw us beating, let’s say, China in a trade
deal? They kill us.” (Haslam). Trump was able to tap into what older, and some younger
Americans fears about the future of the country. Many older Americans feel that the success,
power, respect, and economy have declined, which makes Trump’s campaign promises and
This Slogan is a cry of nostalgia that appeals to voters young and old, to bring back
America to its roots, to make America the top priority in an increasingly globalized world.
Trump is the first presidents, in recent years, to claim that America is not the superpower of the
world. American now is “any but exceptional, indispensable, or great, though he alone could
make it great again” (Engelhardt). This simple sentence acknowledges that other countries, other
Taylor 5
global superpowers like China and Mexico, don’t respect America’s place in the world anymore.
Their economies are constantly growing, job prospects are on the rise, and China is closing in on
The 1950’s and 1960’s, the years between World War 2 and before the Vietnam war,
were considered the “golden years of American power, America was a country of undoubted
power and greatness, a country that every president praised in the past. For example, John F.
Kennedys pre-inaugural speech about his plans for Washington, here he quoted Puritan John
Winthrop, wanting to create a country that people can look up to, and unspoken greatness of
American society at that time. We shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship,
support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.”
(Engelhardt). This sense of national pride and strength is something that many Trump supporters
believe American society lacks today, at that time America was viewed as the country of
opportunity, a country that you can come to empty handed, create a business, then build yourself
up to greatness. However, businesses are outsourcing jobs for cheap labor, it’s harder to create
small business and have them flourish, and that entrepreneurship is disappearing.
A core belief of Trump voters was that American economic decline was caused by its
external enemies, such as China and Mexico, and many other countries that he deems evil, or
hostile to American interest. He blamed them for the abundance of unemployment that has
ravished many areas of the country, claiming that these countries cheat, and take jobs away from
American citizens. “Our real unemployment is anywhere from 18 to 20 percent. Don’t believe
the 5.6 Don’t believe it. That’s right. A lot of people up there can’t get jobs… because there are
no jobs, because China has our jobs, and Mexico has our jobs. They all have jobs” (Haslam).
Trump encouraged the idea that our economy and job market was in constant decline because of
Taylor 6
the outsourcing of factory jobs, to other countries such as the two stated above. Instead of
looking within the country for a problem, he instead placed the blame on other countries for the
shortcomings of our own. Blaming this takes the eye off what is really hurting the economy with
is the automation of jobs. Many of the jobs will be unable to come back due to the evolution of
programs and robots. Another thing that hurts the economy is because of the oligarchy of
American society. Big businesses stifle the ability for smaller own businesses to flourish. He
offered no explanations of why we aren’t producing more entrepreneurs, how to help nourish
Trump represents the traditional American dream, of building his business up from
scratch. Though he began with a “small loan of a million dollars,” he builds many businesses,
and create jobs for many Americans. This is what many of his supporters see. If Trump was able
to successfully build up a business and increase his worth, he should be able to improve
America’s economy, help produce American businesses, and bring jobs back to American soil.
During one of his rallies, he talked about his commitment to keeping companies on U.S. soil:
“Remember years ago, we used to proudly display ‘Made in the USA…We don’t see it…I don’t
see it anymore. We ought to start doing that. Any of the manufacturers that were doing a lot of
talking to a lot of companies that were thinking about leaving, and I tell ya, I don’t think they’re
going to be leaving so fast anymore” (Savransky). Now, it is no surprise that many of the jobs
formerly placed in American towns have been exported to China as well as Mexico; However,
Trump completely requires the reasons this has occurred, it’s cheaper, people are willing to work
more for less pay, and possibly looser laws. In 2013 it was reported that the jobs that were most
affected by this are technology, call centers, human resources, and manufacturing (Amadeo).
Because of this many American’s found themselves unemployed, according to Amadeo, that if
Taylor 7
14 million jobs are outsourced equals 7.5 million unemployed Americans, and if these jobs were
ever to return about 5.7 million would receive part-time jobs. However, these businesses are
unwilling to move back because even though American’s have the skills needed for the job,
Americans are unwilling to take a lower pay, like people in Mexico, China, and India.
Trump’s huge campaign promises really elevated him in the polls, especially in parts of
the America, mainly the rust belt, coal towns, and other small towns where people feel as though
he was going to be the one to do it. Trump elevated himself as the person who can restore
America’s economy and job market. People in middle America, and other rural areas believe that
since he is a business man and not a politician, he would be able to use his background to
influence companies to move back to American soil, and hire “legal Americans.” He set himself
up as someone who would be the savior of lower-class and working white Americans across the
nation who felt as though their voices were being drowned out by “minorities” or felt ignored by
The third element of trumps argument was to place himself as the savior of these people,
that he was the only person who could truly re-elevate America back to its former glory. He set
himself apart from other politicians, by showing himself as a successful business man who
knows how to get things done and make deals. He also argues that. According to Trump, “One of
the big banks came to me and said, ‘Donald, you don’t have enough borrowings. Could we loan
you $4 billion?’ I don’t need it. I don’t want it” (Haslam). Trump was able to effectively put
himself in a place where he could be the only candidate to “restore” America, because he cannot
be corrupt, like Hillary due to bribery, to what it once was. He is also able to effectively assess
and engage his audience, to a point where many of his supporters feel that they have a personal
connection to him. “I beat China all the time. All the time… I will bring it back bigger, and
Taylor 8
better, and stronger than ever before. And we will make America great again” (Haslam). By
using some key words such as we, you, us, he establishes a strong personal connection between
Trump’s campaign was running in a truly unique fashion, not once during his presidential
campaign did I see a campaign ad on television, most of his campaign was through media
attention from the shocking things he did said, or someone dug up, his twitter, and his rallies.
Trump, unlike any other president, focused not on the well populated traditional campaign stops,
people who regularly voted in the election. Instead, Trump engaged unlikely voters during the
primaries, his campaign relied mostly on free media, frequent Tv appearances, and the use of the
internet.
During his campaign Trump dominated the airways and social media news cycles, everyday
always, there is no doubt that Trump won social media during his campaign run, and by doing
this was much more engaged with his voters compared to the other campaign runners. A director
of social media analyzed the trends and metrics during the election and found that,
“Overall, online interest in candidate Trump was three times higher than Clinton, according to
Google trends analysis. Trump was the most Googled candidate, and most mentioned on Twitter
and Facebook. Trump had 4 million more Twitter followers than Clinton. Clinton’s social media
engagement increased somewhat by the third debate, but by then many voters had made up their
minds.” (Khan).
His social media exposure was surely a key component to his victory, one thing that Trump had
going for him that the other candidates didn’t was his ability to market himself due to being a
business man. Trump new the importance of making himself known and was already well known
Taylor 9
before entering politics, running television shows, and being a very popular businessman. Aside
from that he also knows how to capture people attention he is a performer, and knew that using
Trump and his campaign team also just knew how to work social media in a way that
Clinton’s team didn’t, though Clinton without a doubt is much more polished during debates,
rallies, and speeches however when it came to social media, that is where the majority of the
attention is placed, because of this he is able to get information out through his own accounts
with instant reactions, as well as non-stop media attention, good or bad, from just about every
A big downfall for the Clinton campaign was that unlike trump she was ridged, a product of
politics, while Trump is the furthest thing, and he took advantage of this. Clinton’s media
presence was nothing attention grabbing, “Trump’s tweets are provocative because they strike
raw nerves, speaking bodly to themes that people struggle to work through: race, nationalism
verses globalism, financial insecurity, status inequity, sexism, and more” (Bickart, Fournier,
Nisenholtz). This raw presentation of himself creates a strong personal connection between
himself and his supporters. Trump used twitter to address his audience as individuals, his tweets
show exactly who he is and who he will be in office. This authenticity caused a stronger base of
His ability to connect to his voter base is what really set him apart from other
competitors, he embodied traditional family values, a hard-working business man, who works for
his money, which appeals to many older and/ or traditional Americans. He also spoke to many
Americans who were tired of a traditional president, in a time of political correctness many of his
supporters feel as though they are not able to voice many of their opinions without being
Taylor 10
attacked. To them, Trump represented what they desired that they can speak on, criticize and
insult as much as they please without the annoyance of someone who disagreed with their
statement or how it was said. He spoke to middle America people who feel as though they are
being left behind and forgotten by the U.S government in favor of wealthier more urban areas,
fulfilling their needs and improving their living space, while theirs fall into ruin due to the ruin of
the coal region as well as the outsourcing of jobs that use to allow these areas of America to
flourish. He spoke to the small businessmen and women, who believed that with a little hard
work their American Dream could be achieved. People like this saw something in Trump that
they couldn’t see in any other Republican President or couldn’t see in Hillary Clinton.
Not only did the people who he ran against help Trump clench the 2016 presidential
election, it could be argued that the Obama administration also pushed Trump into the white
house. Obama helped Trumps electoral win by ignoring the plights of rural America. Unlike
urban areas, rural America ran on manufacturing jobs that have been there for years. While the
city has an abundance of finance and service industries that have created 1000’s of jobs. Though
Obama was able to relieve some of the burden of middle America with his healthcare policy,
Obama never truly addressed the employment crises in these areas of the United States,
especially with the 2012 elections where neither he nor Mitt Romney targeted the economic
problems that were gaining traction. “This sense of neglect made rural Americans more receptive
to outsider candidates and unconventional political rhetoric. What happened in 2012 made white
rural Americans open to the kind of messages that Trump would make to them four years later”
(Orejel). Trump was able to pick up the pieces that Obama dropped by having a consistent
message on the loss of manufacturing jobs, horrible trade policies, and regulations that failed the
Taylor 11
people of these areas. His pro-business policies are what gained the faith of the people of middle
America.
The issue of healthcare also possibly helped Trump with the election, “according to USA
Today’s exit polls, half of the middle class voted for Trump, as did half of voters who make
$100,000 a year or more…Similarly, in the primaries, the median household income of a Trump
voter was $72,000-more than the $61,000 the median Hillary Clinton voter made.” (Khazan).
Many people who voted for Trump believed that Obamacare oversteps its boundaries, while
many Clinton voters believed that it could do more (Khazan). Though the policies did a lot for
many lower-class American being able to get the coverage it put a strain on many of America’s
income brackets. Under the affordable care at people who couldn’t get health insurance under
their employers can receive subsidies to by state-based health insurance, however, those are only
offered by people who earn well above the poverty line, which led to people who didn’t qualify
Trumps promise to repeal and replace Obama’s healthcare policy though vague was
enough for some of his supporters to vote for him. Many of his voters believe that Obamacare
meddles too much into the lives of ordinary American citizens. Trump promised that the
healthcare bill that he would pass during his presidential run would allow every American to be
covered, and would be a lot less expensive for every American citizen. “We’re going to have
insurance for everybody…There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it,
you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us.” (Jackson) he promises no cuts to Medicaid,
that no one will lose coverage, it won’t worsen the financial stability of American homes, and
that every American will be taken care of. These promises also would put a huge tax break on
the wealthy as well as insurers, and prevent federal funds from reimbursing planned parenthood
Taylor 12
for any health services it provides. These promises really helped Trump especially the removal
of tax dollars going to planned parenthood since most of his voters are outspokenly prolife.
The stance on immigration is also one that struck a cord with many of Trumps supporters.
Many people believed that Obama’s immigration policies were too lax on who can come into the
country, and supposedly the amount of illegal immigration in the United States has increased
since his election. Obama also implemented the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program
better known as DACA to allowed children who were brought over by their guardians as kids
can receive a renewable two-year period of deferred action from deportation and are eligible to
work in the U.S. This helped millions of people to be able to remain in a country that they are
familiar with instead of being shipped back to one where they possibly don’t know the culture
nor the language. Yet, this program was met with criticism from many Trump supporters. Also,
Obama’s stance of letting refugees into the U.S. didn’t sit well with many Trump supporters,
seeing them as threats to the U.S. and the statement that they refuse or even attempt to assimilate
into American society. Going as far to claim that they want to implement sharia law on
American soil. It was stated that the Obama administration, “plans to admit 110,000 refugees
from around the world to the United States over the next year.” (Toosi and Kim). This 2016 goal
didn’t sit well with many republicans claiming that it undermines American culture, and
Many of Trump’s supporters want a complete removal of all illegal immigrants, whom
they see as criminals. Many people who want to see the end of these immigration policies
believe that these people pose a security threat, that they bring crime, and drugs, and gangs into
the U.S. They also believe that these people coming over are stealing jobs from American
citizens, and are an economic burden due to welfare, health care and educational costs of their
Taylor 13
children. A poll taken by Doherty showed that “66% of registered voters who supported Trump
in the general election call immigration a very big problem in the country…79% of Trump
support favor building a wall along the entire U.S.-Mexico border…Just 35% of Trump
supporters say undocumented immigrants take jobs U.S. citizens would like to have, and a third
say that they are less hard-working and honest than citizens.” (Doherty). Illegal immigration has
been apart of Trump’s rhetoric from the beginning of his campaign and is most strongly used in
his repeated statement that he is going to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, to stop
people crossing the border and strop the transportation of drugs into the country. In the case of
taking in refugees from war torn countries, especially Syrian refugees was debate point in the
2016 presidential election, with Donald Trump wanting to end the Syrian refugee program all
together, arguing that terrorist could be hiding among them. “We must remain compassionate
towards refugees, but we also need to make sure that we use common sense, said House
President Obama unilaterally increases the number of refugees resettled in the United States each
year and gives little thought as to how it will impact local communities.” (Toosi and Kim). The
Republicans believe that opening the border could expose the United States to many more
terrorist attacks, many Trump supporters believe that it threatens American culture. Trump's
response to this was to implement a travel ban, banning immigrants from several countries in the
middle east. By doing this many Trump supporters believe that it creates a safer space for
American citizens, and preserves American culture, that many of them felt was under threat.
Obama administration’s stance on gun control also helped Trump's case, throughout his
8-year run as president there was always arguments of him wanting to take away guns from
American citizens, taking away their 2nd amendment rights. Obama argues that allowing easy
Taylor 14
access to guns are a danger to American citizens, and this is shown again and again through
constant mass shootings that plague American society. “Reinstate the assault weapons ban. Make
it harder for terrorists to use these weapons to kill us. Otherwise despite extraordinary efforts
across out government… these kinds of events are going to keep on happening, and the weapons
are only going to get more powerful.” (Wheaton), Obama’s argument on the 2nd Amendment is
that tougher regulations on certain types of guns, and making it more difficult to obtain guns,
with pushing for more background checks, and a lengthy mental evaluation to obtain a gun.
Many people looked at the Obama administration as imposing on their American rights,
by attempting to make it harder for citizens to obtain guns, and banning, or attempting to ban,
certain types of guns that ordinary American citizens could use. “91 percent of Republican gun
owners say owning a firearm is essential to their freedom compared with 43 percent of
Democratic gun owners.” (Porter). During his Campaign, Trump promised that he would defend
the rights of gun owners, and received strong support from the National Rifal Association. A poll
taken by Pew Research Center showed that about “90 percent of Trump supporters backed gun
rights over gun control. The same poll showed that 44 percent of Republicans and Republican-
leaning independents own firearms, compared to just 20 percent of Democrats and Democrat-
leaning independents.” (Porter). From the beginning of his campaign, Trump argued that the
government should allow gun rights for law-abiding citizens and argue that armed citizens could
help end the mass shooting epidemic. Which many of his supporters agree with, arguing that if
there is an armed citizen during one of these attacks they will be able to better protect themselves
from harm, and help ends a mass shooting event, with fewer causalities and not having to rely on
There is no argument that they way that Trump handled his campaign, confused some,
empowered others, and angered many. However, if you look back at American history,
America’s since of superiority, the displacement of American Indians, racism, wars we waged,
previous presidential administrations and a loss of American sense of identity and their loss of
power in the scope of globalization pushed Trump into the Whitehouse. Many of Trump
supporters believe that under Trump America can return to the greatness that it once held. Many
of Trump supporters fear what the world is becoming with the looming threat of terrorist attacks,
the influx of immigrants and refugees threatening American identity, the loss of many
manufacturing jobs on American soil and that he isn’t a traditional president. In his supporter’s
eyes, Trump represents core American values, and an embodiment of what they want in a
president, someone who will put America first, bring jobs back to middle America and bring
back American greatness and culture which they feel has been stolen from them under the
Obama administration. To them, Trump is the savior that America needs a president that will
revive the American dream, uphold conservative laws, protect their guns, and help elevate many
Works Cited
ANDERSON, MARK CRONLUIMD. "Trump's Appeal to Myth and the 2016 Presidential
Election." Journal of Psychohistory, vol. 45, no. 1, Summer2017, pp. 41-45. EBSCOhost,
proxy-
bloomu.klnpa.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h
&AN=123727569&site=eds-live&scope=site.
REICHER, STEPHEN D. and S. ALEXANDER HASLAM. "How Trump Won." Scientific
American Mind, vol. 28, no. 2, Mar/Apr2017, pp. 42-50. EBSCOhost, proxy-
bloomu.klnpa.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=pbh
&AN=121080938&site=eds-live&scope=site.
Heilpern, Will. “Trump campaign: 11 outrageous quotes” CNN, 19 January, 2017.
Johnson, Jenna and Hauslohner, Abigail. “‘I think Islam hates us’: A timeline of Trump’s
comments about Islam and Muslims”. TheWashingtonPost , 20 May, 2017.
Khan, Laeeq. “Trump won thanks to social media” Thehill, 15 November, 2016.
Bickart, Barbara, et al. "What Trump Understands about Using Social Media to Drive
Attention." Harvard Business Review Digital Articles, 3/1/2017, pp. 2-5. EBSCOhost,
proxy-
bloomu.klnpa.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=bth
&AN=121776479&site=eds-live&scope=site.
Engelhardt, Tom. “What Trump really means when he says he’ll made America great again” .
TheNation. 26 April, 2016.
Savransky, Rebecca. “Trump doubles down on pledge to hire American”. Thehill. 29 December,
2016.
Amadeo, Kimberly. “How outsourcing jobs affects the U.S. economy” TheBalance, 30 March,
2017.
Orejel, Keith. “Why Trump Won Rural America” Dissentmagazine, 16 October, 2017.
Khazan, Olga. “How Obamacare Helped Trump” TheAtlantic. 9 November, 2017.
Jackson, Henry. “6 promises Trump has made about healthcare” Politico. 13 March, 2017.
Sakuma, Amanda. “Obama Leaves Behind a Mixed Legacy on Immigration” nbcnews. 15
January, 2017.
Semotiuk, Andy. “How Trump Could Handle the Millions of Illegal Immigrants Living in the
U.S.” Forbes. 8 November, 2017.
Doherty, Carroll. “5 facts about Trump supporters’ views of immigration” pewresearch. 25
August, 2016.
Taylor 17
Kim, Seung Min and Toosi, Nahal. “Obama raises refugee goal to 110,000, infuriating GOP”
Politico. 13 September, 2016.
Wheaton, Sarah. “Obama argues for gun controls as a way to fight terror” Politico. 14 June,
2016.
Porter, Tom. “Bannon warns Trump increasing gun controls would be “end of everything”:
Report” Newsweek. 3 October, 2017.