TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

TOPIC 2 THEORETICAL MODELS OF READING AND

APPROACHES TO TEACH READING

2.0 SYNOPSIS

Topic 2 provides you with an overview of the different models of reading, (bottom-up,
top-down and interactive reading models) and the approaches to teach reading. The
reading models provide insights to the ways different readers approach reading. This
topic also discusses various approaches to teach reading.

2.1 LEARNING OUTCOMES

By the end of this topic, you will be able to:

1. define the meaning of the three theoretical models of reading

2. distinguish the application of the three reading models

3. identify the various approaches to teach reading.

2.2 Framework Of Topic

Theoretical Models
Of Reading

Bottom-up Top-down Interactive

9
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

Theoretical Models of Reading

According to the literature surrounding reading theory there are three primary models
which readers use: bottom-up, top-down and interactive models of reading. These
models have been used to explain the cognitive processes that occur as readers
interact with the text. These reading theories will be discussed in turn.

2.2.1 Bottom-up Reading Model

The central idea of the bottom-up reading model is that reading is a process of
decoding a series of written symbols into aural sounds. Meaning is then derived from
the blending of sounds. The diagram below describes this process.

print discriminating matching blending discriminating pronunciation

every letter phonemes sounds every letter
and
graphemes

meaning

(Cambroune, 1979)

Using this model, readers process each leatter as it is encountered. The letters or
graphemes are then matched to a phoneme of the language. The phonemes are
then blended together to form words. Meaning is then derived at the end of the
process. A typical reading programme that adopts this model is the phonics
approach.

Text processing is linear whereby the incoming data or information has to be

received before the higher level mental stages can transform and recode the
information. Schemata is hierarchically organised from the most specific at the
bottom to the most general at the top.

This model is also known as ‘outside-in’ (Cambourne, 1979) or part-to-whole model.

10
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

2.2.2 Top-down Reading Model

In the top-down model, the reading process is a reverse of the bottom-up model.
Here, reading is conceptually driven. Readers use their background knowledge to
make predictions as they read the text. The following diagram illustrates this model of
text processing.

past experience, selective aspects of sound,

meaning pronunciation if
language intuitions print
and expectations necessary

(Cambroune, 1979)

From this diagram, it can be seen that the model emphasises the reconstruction of
meaning rather than the decoding of form. The interaction of the text is central to the
process and the reader brings to this interaction his/her knowledge of the subject at
hand, his/her knowledge and expectations about how language works, interest,
motivation and attitude towards the subject or content of the text. In other words, the
reader hypotheses or makes an assumption of the text and uses his/her background
knowledge to confirm the hypothesis or assumption or reject the propositions.

As with the bottom-up model, the top-down model also employs a linear text
processing approach.

This model is also known as inside-out model, concept-driven model and whole-to-
part model.

11
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

Exercise 1

What kind of readers are most likely to adopt the top-down reading
approach? Why do you think so?

Exercise 2
In groups of 3, discuss how you use bottom-up reading approach for Year
One pupils. Present your discussion in class.

2.2.3 Interactive Reading Model

The interactive model, like the top-down model, is also reader-driven. It views the
reading process as an interaction between the reader and the text. Stanovich (1980)
claims that readers process text, not by linear processing as advocated in the two
earlier models, but by utilizing information provided simultaneously from several
different sources, and that they can compensate for deficiencies at one level by
drawing on knowledge at other levels. These sources include all those described in
the two earlier models of text processing, that is phonological, lexical, syntactic,
semantic and discourse knowledge. In other words, the interactive model views
reading as a cyclical pattern whereby textual information and the reader’s mental
activities occur simultaneously executing both top-down, bottom-up processing.
When the reader employs the interactive model, he is seen as using his expectations
and prior knowledge to guess the content of the text while contributing the bottom-up
processing to ensure that new information is also utilized.

** A note to teachers **
With the insight that there is more to comprehension that the words on the page
provides, these theoretical models help explain the way our background knowledge
guides the comprehension process and the implications for second language
reading. Eskey and Grabe (1988) suggested two general implications for ESL
reading. First, that a strong, bottom-up foundation of basic identification skill is
12
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

paramount. Second, reading for meaning, that is ultilising the top-down approach
should also be well developed because reading is not just limited to decoding skills.

2.3 Approaches to Teach Reading

Reading ability is best developed in association with writing, listening and speaking
activities. Even in those courses that may be labelled “reading,” your goals can be
best achieved by capitalizing on the interrelationship of skills, especially the reading-
writing connection. It is a mistake to rely on one approach to teach reading because
a method that works for one child may not work at all for another. Good teachers
have recognised that children learn in different ways and need different strategies. In
this module you are introduced to three methods to teach reading. They are using
sight word, language experience and phonics method.

2.3.1 Sight Word Approach

Sight word acquisition is an important building block in the construction of a
child’s ability to read. What is sight word?
Sight words are words that appear so often in a text that readers are able to read by
sight without having to decode them. Sight words are also words that cannot be
decoded and must be memorised by sight. Knowing these high frequency words and
being able to recognise non-decodable words by sight are extremely important skills
for reading fluency. In order to read well, children need to read sight words very
quickly. Memorisation of sight words is necessary and few words at a time are highly
recommended.

The objectives of teaching sight words are to:

 enable pupils to associate the appearance of each sight word with its
sound/pronunciation (sight to sound correspondence)

 read sight words in context

 recognise sight words quickly and effortlessly. (rapid recognition)

13
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

Exercise 1

Based on your experience, what kind of practice can you do to achieve the above
objectives? Work in your study group.

2.3.2 Language Experience Approach

Language experience approach is suitable for all levels of learners. By using the
Language Experience Approach (LEA) to teach beginning readers how to read,
pupils can connect their life experiences with learning written words. The unique
factor about this approach is that the pupils own words are recorded or used as they
describe the event or activity. This allows them to interact with the text and gain
knowledge and understanding through their experience.

The LEA can be used with individual pupils or group. While it is most commonly used
with young emerging readers, it is also effective for teaching struggling readers.

Procedure to use the learning experience approach

1. Have the pupils choose an experience that they would like to write about. For
groups, this should be a shared experience such as a field trip or an activity that
the whole class had participated in. For individual pupils, it could be anything that
the pupil feels is important or interesting, such as a family activity, a story about
their pet or favorite toy, or even a television show or movie that they enjoyed. The
language experience approach can also be used to create fictional stories.

2. Discuss the experience with the pupils. This helps them to clarify what they want to
write about, organize their thoughts, and come up with specific, descriptive
vocabulary.

14
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

3. Write the story down as the pupils dictate it. For groups, have pupils take turns
dictating sentences describing their experience. Record what they say on large
chart paper, repeating the words as they are written. For individual pupils, this can
be done on a single sheet of paper, or it can be made into a book. The writing
should be done in neat, large print rather than cursive, to make it easier for the
pupils to read. Try to stick to the pupils' own words exactly as they are spoken with
a minimum of correction for grammar or sentence structure. It is important for
pupils to see their own words in print, because they have a personal connection to
the words.

4. Read the text aloud. Point to each word as you read it aloud. After reading the text
to the pupils, have them reread it aloud. With a group, call on individual pupils to
read sentences, or have them read chorally as a group while pointing to each
word. Pupils can illustrate their individual texts and read them aloud to the class.
Since the words that the pupils dictate are familiar and are used in a meaningful
context, pupils will be able to read more difficult vocabulary than they might
ordinarily be able to if they simply saw it printed in a book.

2.3.3 Phonics Approach

An alphabetic, phonic approach to teaching reading has been used for centuries. In
the 19th century, this kind of approach began to be called “phonics”. Since then it has
been further developed and modified. Today a phonics approach is used in varying
degrees in most reading instructions. This approach has been included in the KSSR
syllabus.

A phonics approach teaches the relation of the letters (graphemes) to the sounds
(phonemes) they represent. The theory behind the phonics approach is based on two
assumptions: most languages have consistent phonemes (sound) to grapheme
(letter) corelation. Once children have learned the relationships of the letters to the
sounds, they can pronounce printed words by blending the sounds together. Knowing
these relationships helps early readers recognize familiar words accurately and
automatically and "decode" new words.
15
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

Though this approach has been well received, there are some grey areas which
makes it not a complete model or a stand alone approach to teach early reading. For
instance, a child can use phonics to work out that b-a-t means bat because the letters
represent their most common sounds; but phonics is of no help in reading eye as
there is no correspondence between the letters and the sounds the letters represent.
Furthermore, English has its many irregularities, therefore it makes it harder for ESL
learners to identify unfamiliar words. The use of phonics assumes that once readers
know how a word is pronounced, they will associate it with a spoken word they
already know and therefore understands it. However, the problem may arise
especially with intermediate pupils who may come upon a new word which they have
not heard of. So working out how a word might be pronounced is not going to
guarantee understanding.

Phonics may be useful and helpful at the initial stages of developing reading but it
needs to be supported by other methods as the reader’s reading proficiency
develops.

Exercise 3

“Systematic and explicit phonics instruction significantly improves

kindergarten and first grade children's word recognition and spelling.”

Do you agree with the quote above? Justify your answer.

16
 TSL 3063 Teaching Reading Skills and Vocabulary In The Primary ESL Classroom

References

Cambourne, B. (1979). How important is theory to the reading teacher?

Australian Journal of Reading, 2: 78-90

Eskey, D.E. & Grabe, W. (1988). Interactive Models for Second Language Reading:
Perspectives on Instruction. In P. Carrell, J. Devine & D. Eskey. (Eds.),
Interactive approaches to second language reading (pp. 223-38). New York:
Cambridge University Press.

Stanovich, K. (1980). Toward an interactive-compensatory model of individual

differences in the development of reading fluency. Reading Research
Quarterly, 16:32-71.

17