You are on page 1of 10

NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

capacity breakdown, and current licensing


Status of Low Pressure trends.
PE Process Licensing
Types of Process Technologies
Dr. Faisal H. Syed Low-pressure polyethylene processes are
Dr. William D. Vernon used in the production of linear low-density
polyethylene (LLDPE) and high-density
polyethylene (HDPE). Low-density
polyethylenes are produced via high-
Introduction pressure processes (either autoclave or
tubular), and are not relevant to this
discussion. There are 3 major types of low-
Not all organizations have the capabilities or pressure technologies, namely (1) slurry, (2)
want to investing in acquiring the solution, and (3) gas phase.
capabilities to develop process
technologies. Instead, licensing third party A slurry process is conducted in an inert
technology enables many organizations to diluent in which the catalyst is affixed to an
utilize state-of-the-art process know-how to inert support, and the polymer formed
fulfill their resin needs or to enter a during production remains suspended in the
particular market, without having to invest liquid medium, never dissolving. Slurry
heavily in developing proprietary process processes can be sub-divided into
technologies. conventional slurry loops and cascade
reactor, the later being capable of producing
Typically, a company desiring to produce bimodal products.
polyethylene would acquire a license for a
particular process technology, and perhaps In a solution process both the catalyst and
catalyst technologies as well, from a the resulting polymer remain dissolved in a
process licensor. Currently, there are over solvent that must subsequently be removed
25 licensors offering technologies to to isolate the polymer.
produce linear polyethylenes. There are
many factors associated with picking an Gas-phase processes are either of the
appropriate technology license including, stirred-bed type or the fluidized-bed type.
but not limited to, (1) capability of the Supported catalysts are the rule in gas-
process to produce the desired resin phase processes as well.
grades, (2) breadth of the process
technology, (3) ability to produce specialty Each type of process has limitations on the
grades, (4) catalyst options, and (5) most breadth of resins its can produce. Exhibit 1
importantly, cost. Many times, licensees illustrates the capabilities of different
overlook the importance of factors other processes as it pertains to density and melt
than cost in making their discussion, which index. Resins produced via the slurry
may lead to technologies that are unable to process are limited to densities greater than
expand with the future needs of the 0.937 g/cm3, and a melt index up to 10
licensee. g/min. Solution processes have a wider
window of operation in terms of densities
This article discusses the status of the most and melt indexes. Gas-phase reactors have
popular low-pressure process technology the widest operating window, but
used to produce linear polyethylene, encounters difficulties in producing resins
including a description of the process with very low densities due to stickiness and
technology, process capabilities, regional particle agglomeration.

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 18
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

Exhibit 1
0.967
Homopolymer

Hostalen Cascade Phillips


Mitsui Slurry Solvay
Nissan/Equistar/Maruzen
0.939 USI
Nisseki
Borstar
Density (g/cm3)

0.920

Gas
Solution
0.914 Unipol/Unipol II
Innovene
Spherilene Dowlex
Evolué Compact
Lupotech G Sclairtech

0.900
0.01 0.1 1.0 10 100

Melt Index (g/10 min)

The practical lower density limit for


Slurry polyethylene produced in a slurry loop slurry
reactor is slightly below 0.94 g/cm3. To
Phillips Slurry Loop (Licensor: Chevron produce the lowest densities it is necessary
Phillips) to increase the level of comonomer in the
reactor significantly, since conventional
The Phillips slurry loop process, sometimes catalysts incorporate comonomer
referred to as the loop slurry process, sluggishly. The higher concentration of
depicted in Exhibit 2, supported catalyst, comonomer makes the diluent a better
ethylene, and comonomer, usually hexene- solvent for the polymer, especially the
1, are injected into a vertical, loop-shaped lower-Mw fraction, causing swelling of the
reactor filled with isobutane diluent. Reactor particles which leads to potential reactor
pressure is approximately 37 bar, and fouling.
reactor temperature is in the range of 85-
100°C. Exhibit 2

The mixture of catalyst particles, growing Fresh Diluent


(isobutane)
To
Catalyst
polymer particles, comonomers, and diluent Ethylene
Recovery
M
is pumped around the loop, and polymer Compressor Fractionator

particles are harvested by directing a


M
portion of the slurry to the settling legs,
where the polymer particles settle toward M
M
the bottom, then venting the concentrated Ethylene
Flash
Chamber
slurry to a medium-pressure separator to Reactor
To
Diluent
remove solvent and unreacted monomers Comonomer
Make-up
Recycle Diluent Recovery
Purge

then conveying the particles to an extruder N2 Column

To Extruder
where they are melted, compounded with
additives, and pelletized.

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 19
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

Phillips developed a version of the chrome towards the bottom, then re-directed to
catalyst that synthesizes comonomer from another loop reactor. Hydrogen is flashed
ethylene in situ. The result is that lower- off prior to introduction in the second loop,
density polyethylenes can be produced and additional monomer, comonomer and
since comonomer is being synthesized at hydrogen (if desired) are added, and the
the catalyst surface then is being consumed mixture recirculated in the second loop,
immediately. In 1993 Phillips introduced the before being harvested.
material produced using this catalyst as
LDLPE - low-density linear PE. Hostalen (Licensor: Basell)

Solvay Loop (Licensor: Solvay) A mixture of monomer, comonomer,


hydrogen and hexane (diluent) is
Catalyst, ethylene, comonomer (if desired), continuously fed to the reactors operating at
and hydrogen are injected into a vertical, temperatures ranging from 75-85 ºC and
loop-shaped reactor filled with isobutane pressures of 5-10 bar, as depicted in Exhibit
diluent, as shown in Exhibit 3. Reactor 4. The reactor conditions in each reactor
pressure is approximately 30 bar, and may be varied independently. The polymer
reactor temperature is in the range of 75-80 suspension flows from the reactors into a
ºC. The mixture of catalyst particles, common post reactor where conversion rate
growing polymer particles, comonomer, approaches 98%. The suspension is
hydrogen, and diluent is pumped around the centrifugally separated, the polymer dried,
loop. Polymer particles are harvested via then it is sent to the extruder for
the settling legs by venting the concentrated pelletization. The CSTR reactors may be
slurry to a medium-pressure separating operated in parallel or series to produce
vessel. The solvent and unreacted unimodal or bimodal grades, respectively.
monomer are flashed, treated, and recycled
back to the loop reactor. The polymer Exhibit 4
particles are further stripped, dried, and
conveyed to an extruder where they are
melted, compounded with additives, and Catalyst

pelletized.

Exhibit 3
Make-up Centrifuge
Catalyst
Ethylene
Diluent Treater Comonomer
Recovery Dryer
Hydrogen
Ethylene Hexane
From Butene
Recovery

Condenser
Recycle
Tower

Cocatalyst
Reactor
Hydrogen
Comonomer
Flash Stripper Centrifuge
Nissan (Licensor Nissan)
Catalyst

Dryer The Nissan slurry process, used to produce


HDPE, is based on a stirred tank reactor as
shown in Exhibit 5. Catalyst, ethylene,
comonomer, and hydrogen are fed to the
If bimodal resin is desired, the polymer reactor which uses hexane diluent. The
particles from the first loop reactor can be reactor is operated in a temperature range
transferred to another loop reactor by of 65-85°C at a pressure of 10-14 bar.
directing a portion of the slurry to settling Polymer slurry exiting the reactor is sent to
legs, where the polymer particles settle a flash vessel to remove volatiles then fed

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 20
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

to a centrifuge where the diluent is


removed. The dried powder is
Solution
compounded, extruded, and pelletized. The
process has been refined through the joint Dowlex (Proprietary: Dow)
efforts of Nissan, Maruzen, and Equistar.
Dow developed the Dowlex process to
Exhibit 5 produce linear polyethylenes comprising
octene-1 comonomer. As shown in a
Additives
Note: Dual Reactors schematic representation in Exhibit 7, the
Catalyst
principle hardware consists of 2 stirred tank
Hydrogen Extrusion
and
reactors in series filled with an isoparaffin
Butene Reactor 1&2 Pelletizing solvent (a mixture of C8 and C9
Ethylene
isoparaffins). Ethylene, octene-1, and
Hexane
catalyst are introduced into the reactors,
Blending where they remain in solution. The reactors
are run at approximately 160°C and 27 bar,
Separation
and
and total residence time in the reactors is
To
Distillation
Drying ca. 30 minutes. When the solution exits the
Shipping second reactor it is flashed to remove
ethylene monomer. Solvent and residual
octene-1 are removed in a 2-stage flash
CX Process (Licensor: Mitsui) unit, and the remaining polymer melt is
compounded with additives, extruded, and
The Mitsui process comprises 2 continuous, pelletized. Dow has not made the process
stirred-tank reactors of identical size that available for license.
are operated in series to produce film resins
with bimodal MWDs (Exhibit 6). The diluent Exhibit 7
is hexane, and the usual comonomer is
butene-1. Typical conditions are an
operating pressure of 7.8 bar, an operating
temperature of 85°C, and a 45-minute Solvent Drum

residence time per reactor. Polymer is


isolated and pelletized in straightforward
fashion in the Mitsui process. Monomer
Stripper
Additives

Exhibit 6 Handling

Flash Reactor
Additives Catalyst
Adiabatic
Reactors
Packaging
Extrusion
Ethylene and
Comonomer Pelletizing
Hydrogen
Catalyst

Sclairtech/AST (Licensor: NOVA)

NOVA acquired the rights to SCLAIRTECH


Shipping technology, the SCLAIR  trademark, and
the worldwide SCLAIRTECH licensing
business when it acquired DuPont Canada's
polyethylene business in 1994.

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 21
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

SCLAIRTECH operates at temperatures up proprietary solvent lighter than cyclohexane;


to 300°C in cyclohexane solution. (2) introduction of ethylene and comonomer
Polymerization is very rapid, requiring less into the reactor directly rather than their
than 2 minutes, so small reactors can turn being introduced predissolved; (3)
out relatively large volumes of polymer. The maximum reactor temperature of less than
extrusion and stripping sections of a 200°C, (4) a stripper section that can
SCLAIRTECH plant are also designed to accommodate lower-density polyethylenes,
facilitate very quick transitions between and (5) no deashing is required. AST is
products, on the order of 30 minutes. The said to be significantly more economical to
SCLAIRTECH process produces polymers build and operate than SCLAIRTECH, and it
from the LLDPE to the HDPE range using is claimed to take advantage of synergies
butene-1 or octene-1 comonomers. when an AST-based plant is built in
conjunction with an ethylene cracker.
Exhibit 8
Compact (Licensor: Stamicarbon-SABIC)
Reactor #1 Reactor #2

Steam
The Compact solution process was
Hydrogen
originally developed by DSM in the 1970s to
Catalyst
produce HDPE. It was adapted in the
1980s to produce linear medium- and low-
density polyethylenes based on butene-1 or
Solvent
Deactivator Stabilizer
octene-1 comonomers using proprietary
Extrusion Ziegler catalysts. The Compact solution
Ethylene
&
Pelletizing process is capable of producing
polyethylenes across a density range of
1-Octene
0.900 to 0.967 g/cm3 and a melt-index
range of 0.8 to 100 using propylene,
Advanced SCLAIRTECH technology, or butene-1, or octene-1 comonomers.
AST, is a significantly updated version of
SCLAIRTECH technology based on a In the Compact solution process, depicted
number of modifications and centered on a in Exhibit 9, ethylene and comonomer,
set of 2 sequential autoclave reactors, each usually octene-1, are dissolved in hexane,
fitted with independent monomer, cooled, and fed to a stirred, liquid-filled
comonomer, and catalyst feed systems plus reactor. The reactor is operated
high-intensity mixing technology. Discrete adiabatically, so it is necessary to precool
polymers can be produced in each reactor the reactor feed to control temperature. The
under a different set of tightly controlled enthalpy of polymerization raises the reactor
conditions, enabling production of novel to its normal operating temperature, ca.
polyethylenes with bimodal MWDs having 200°C. Molecular weight is controlled by
specific end-use properties. The short hydrogen. Ethylene conversion of at least
residence times that figure heavily in 95% is achieved during a short reactor
SCLAIRTECH technology are retained in residence time.
AST. Densities ranging from 0.905 to 0.967
g/cm3 with melt indices ranging from 0.2 to The hot solution exits the reactor into
150 dg/10 min can be produced in the AST vessels where volatiles plus the major
process. Exhibit 8 is a schematic of the portion of the hexane are flashed off, and
AST reactor system. catalyst residues are deactivated. The
polymer concentrate is fed to a degassing
AST differs in several ways from its extruder where the residual hexane and
predecessor, including (1) use of a octene-1 are flashed, the appropriate

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 22
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

additives are compounded, and the MWD. There are only 2 Unipol II lines in the
polyethylene is pelletized and transported to world, a Union Carbide plant in Taft,
silos for pack out. Louisiana, and one belonging to EQUATE
Petrochemical Company K.S.C., a Union
Exhibit 9
Carbide joint venture with Petrochemical
Octene-- 1 Industries Company and Boubyan
Petrochemical Company in Shuaiba,
Inert Purge
Octene Solvent
Kuwait.
Recovery Purification

Hexane
The production rate of a Unipol reactor is
determined by the amount of heat that can
Mixing Area Reactor #1 Flash Catalyst
Deactivator #2 Flash
be removed. To increase the heat-removal
capacity of the fluidized bed Union Carbide
Ethylene Deactivation
Agent Extruder
developed what it called condensed-mode
Hydrogen operation. The recycle stream is partially
Catalyst
condensed, and some liquid is re-injected
Silos
into the system. The enthalpy of
vaporization absorbs extra heat, enabling
higher production rates. In the mid 1990s
Gas-Phase Exxon developed and patented what it
refers to as Super Condensed Mode
Technology that enables even higher
Unipol (Licensor: Univation)
production rates. SCMT is one of the
technical cornerstones of Univation
The Unipol process was developed by
Union Carbide during the late 1960s and Technologies.
early 1970s in an effort to enable production
of HDPE and LLDPE in a low-pressure, Exhibit 10
fluidized bed reactor significantly cheaper to
build and operate than conventional high- Reactor

pressure or solution processes. Unipol was Cycle


Compressor
Cycle
first applied to HDPE production in 1968 Cooler
Product
and to LLDPE production in 1975. Exhibit Chamber

10 depicts a schematic of the Unipol Catalyst*

process. Supported catalyst is fed into a * chrome or Ziegler Product


Blow Tank
reactor where it is fluidized in a stream of Recycle Stream

ethylene, comonomer, and hydrogen. C2= , comonomer, H2 Degassing


To Extrusion &
Polyethylene forms on the fluidized catalyst Pack Out

particles. Unreacted gases are continually


withdrawn from the reactor, compressed,
cooled, and recycled. Polymer particles are Innovene (Licensor: BP Amoco)
removed from the reactor through a
differential valve, conveyed to an extruder, The other major fluidized-bed production
compounded with the appropriate additive technology for polyethylene production is
formulations, and pelletized. BP Amoco’s Innovene process. A block
diagram of the Innovene process is shown
Unipol II, which comprises not one but 2 in Exhibit 11. Though Innovene is very
reactors, appeared on the scene in 1992 similar to Unipol, there are a few
with the intent to provide Union Carbide differences. In Innovene the recycle stream
(and potential licensees) with the ability to is passed through a cyclone to capture
produce polyethylenes having a bimodal solids in the gas stream in order to eliminate

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 23
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

fouling of the compressor and the heat fluidized-bed process. Residence time in
exchangers and minimize cross the process is ca. 2.5 hours. Basell says
contamination during product transitions. the advantages of Spherilene over
The Innovene design features 2 heat competitive gas-phase processes include
exchangers in the recycle loop whereas the (1) the reactor can be started up empty, (2)
Unipol design has only one heat exchanger. fouling is minimal, (3) grade transitions are
rapid, and (4) steam stripping of the powder
In 1995 BP introduced its version of prior to compounding minimized
condensed-mode operation that it called hydrocarbon contaminants.
“High Productivity” technology. Univation
and BP ended up in court over the rights to Basell has not had much success in
condensed-mode operation, and Univation licensing the Spherilene process. Due to
prevailed. over capacity issues in North America,
Basell recently closed down the Spherilene
Exhibit 11 plant in Lake Charles, LA. It is anticipated
Cyclone
that Basell will slowly phase-out this
technology platform.
C 2= , comonomer, H2
Reactor

Gas Recycle Exhibit 12


Monomers Monomers
Recovery Recovery
Degasser

Catalyst*
Degassing
* chrome or Ziegler
Column

Additives
Compressor To Extrusion &
Pack Out
Steam

Extruder

Catalyst +
Cocatalyst
Reagents PE
Spherilene (Licensor: Basell) Monomers,
Comonomers
Pellets

Hydrogen

Long the major player in polypropylene


production technology, Basell has a
polyethylene production process as well. In
1990 Himont embarked on an effort to Inter-Process Competition
design a polyethylene process based on the
extensive experience it had garnered during The processes described above, along with
development of the very popular Spheripol others, compete with one another for the
polypropylene process, and it announced it production of linear polyethylenes. Some
had perfected the process in 1993, calling it are optimized for the production of either
Spherilene. Taking another cue from its HDPE or LLDPE, and others are efficient at
polypropylene technology, Himont designed swing operation. Exhibit 13 shows the
a catalyst for the process based on its overlap between the different processes in
Reactor Granule Technology that gives the the realm of linear polyethylenes.
final product a spherical morphology.
Exhibit 14 shows the breakdown on linear
A schematic of the Spherilene process is polyethylene capacity by type and process.
shown in Exhibit 12. Catalyst is fed initially The current global capacity of linear
to a prepolymerization reactor, actually a polyethylene processes is in excess of 96
small slurry loop, where it is precoated with billion pounds. Approximately, 63% of linear
polyethylene then injected into the first polyethylenes are HDPE resins, of which
reactor. Spherilene is a multireactor, 67% are unimodal and 23% bimodal resins.

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 24
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

Exhibit 13
Slurry Solution

HDPE LLDPE
Hostalen Unimodal Gas Compact
Mitsui Unipol, Innovene Dowlex
Nissan/Equistar/Maruzen Sclairtech
Nisseki Unimodal Slurry Solution
Phillips Phillips Compact, Dowlex, Sclairtech
Solvay
Solvay USI
USI
Borstar Bimodal Slurry Bimodal Gas
Hostalen Unipol II, Spherilene
Mitsui
Nissan

Fluid Bed

Evolué
Lupotech G
Innovene
Spherilene
Unipol
Unipol II

Sixty-five percent of HDPE resins are (26% each). North America also holds the
produced via slurry processes, 25% using largest share for slurry processes (31%),
gas-phase processes, and 10% with followed by Other Asia (29%), and Western
solution processes. Europe (19%). Largest producers of solution
processes are located in North America
Linear low-density polyethylenes account (34%) and Western Europe (24%).
for 37% of all linear polyethylenes.
Compared to HDPE, only 4% of LLDPE The linear polyethylene capacities are
resins are produced via slurry processes, divided by licensor in Exhibit 16. The top
75% using gas-phase processes (the five largest licensors, in terms of capacity
dominant process type for LLDPE), and licensed, in descending order are (1)
21% using solution processes. Univation Technologies, (2) Chevron
Phillips, (3) BP, (4) Mitsui, and (5) Dow.
Exhibit 15 shows the regional
differences/similarities in the type of process Univation is the largest licensor, accounting
utilized to produce linear polyethylene. Gas for 29% or 28 billion pounds with their gas-
and slurry processes hold an equal share of phase Unipol process. The second largest
the linear polyethylene market accounting licensor is Chevron Phillips with 15% or
for 85% of the total capacity, the remainder 14.5 billion pounds. BP and Mitsui each
being solution processes. have approximately 10% or 9.6 billion
pounds. Dow accounts for 7% or 6.9 billion
North America holds the largest share of pounds, however the Dowlex process is
gas-phase processes (33%), followed by currently unavailable for third party
Rest of the World and Other Asia categories licensing.

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 25
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

Exhibit 14 – Linear PE Capacity by Type and Process

LLDPE, 37% HDPE, 63%


36,075 MM Lbs. 60,250 MM Lbs.
Unimodal 40,600 MM Lbs.
Bimodal 19,650 MM Lbs.

Slurry, 4%
Slurry, 65%

Gas, 75% Gas, 25%


Sol’n, 10%
Sol’n, 21%

Source: Chemical Market Resources, Inc.

Exhibit 15 – Linear PE Capacity by Type and Region

Solution, 15%
13,635 MM Lbs.

NA 34%
W.Europe 24%
Japan 3%
Other Asia 16%
ROW 23%
Gas, 43%
41,900 MM Lbs.
NA 33%
W.Europe 10%
Japan 5%
Other Asia 26%
ROW 26%
Slurry, 42%
40,790 MM Lbs.

NA 31%
W.Europe 19%
Japan 7%
Other Asia 29%
ROW 14%

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 26
NEW GENERATION POLYOLEFINS

Exhibit 17 – Linear PE Capacity Breakdown By Licensor


Others, 11 %

Mitsui, 9% Univation, 29%


(Slurry) Unipol (Gas)

Stamicarbon, 2%
Compact (Solution)

NOVA, 5%
Sclairtech (Solution)

Solvay, 2%
Dow, 7 % (Slurry)
Dowlex (solution)
Nissan, 3%
(Slurry)
Basell, 5%
Hostalen (Slurry) Basell, 2%
Spherilene (Gas)

BP, 10%
Chevron Phillips, 15%
Innovene (Gas)
Slurry Loop (Slurry)

such process. Solution processes are well


Future Trends suited for higher-value added products such
as octene-1 based resins. Nova Chemicals
Gas-phase capacity has experienced a has recently brought online its 850 million
healthy growth rate over the past ten years pound Advanced Sclairtech plant at the
growing at an average rate of 6.1%. Gas- Joffre, Calgary site. Although, only about
phase processes are very economical at 180 million pounds of resin was produced
producing commodity grade resins, and last year, the company plans to ramp up
thus are popular with resin producers in production to keep pace with demand.
China and other Asian countries.
An addition 12.1 billion pounds of linear
Slurry capacity has grown at an average polyethylene capacity is expected to come
rate of 5.1%, although bimodal slurry on stream by 2007. Approximately 50% of
processes have seen growth rates in the capacity addition will be based on gas-
excess of 7% in the past five years, mainly phase technologies, 48% on slurry, and 2%
due to bimodal pipe resin markets in on solution.
Western Europe, and bimodal films in Asia.
Bimodal resins are being driven by the film, To learn more about these and other
blow molding, and pipe markets, where the polyolefins technologies, please attend the
bimodality provides enhanced processing
2002 Polyolefins & Elastomers Licensing
and performance characteristics.
Fair scheduled for September 17, 2002 at
the Hilton NASA Clear Lake, Houston, TX.
Solution processes have experienced the
Please review program on the next page.
lowest growth rates mainly due to lack of
third-party licensing activity, and perhaps
the level of difficulty involved with operating

Chemical Market Resources, Inc.


CMR Tel: (281) 333-3313 Fax: 333-3361
June/July 2002/Volume 7/Issue No 6 Page 27

You might also like