You are on page 1of 12

Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No.

2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

The perception of the practitioners and students towards the subject


of forensic accounting and fraud examination
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti1, Unti Ludigdo2, Gugus Irianto3
1
University of Jember, Kalimantan Street 37, Campus Bumi Tegal Boto, Jember, 68121, East Java, Indonesia
2, 3
University of Brawijaya, Veteran Street, Malang, 65145, East Java, Indonesia

ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT


Article history: This research aims to analyze the insight of practitioners, academicians, and ac-
Received 30 April 2014 counting students toward forensic accounting and fraud examination course as if
Revised 24 July 2014 integrating into accounting curriculum. It also analyzes the difference of practitio-
Accepted 1 August 2014 ners, academicians and accounting students insight’s regarding demand, interest,
career, obstacles, benefits and topics of forensic accounting and fraud examination
JEL Classification: as if integrating into accounting curriculum. The results indicate that practitioners,
M41 academicians and accounting students are encouraging forensic accounting and
fraud examination course should be integrated into accounting curriculum. It also
Key words: indicate that there were some significant differences exist regarding demand, inter-
Forensic Accounting, est, career, obstacles, beneficial and topics of forensic accounting and fraud exami-
Fraud Examination, nation (FAFE). The results are useful for universities that consider integrating
FAFE, forensic accounting and fraud examination course into accounting curriculum,
Accounting Curriculum, hence redesign their forensic accounting and fraud examination course that relevant
Fraud. with Indonesian’s necessitate.

DOI: ABSTRAK
10.14414/jebav.14.1702011
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis persepsi praktisi, akademisi dan maha-
siswa akuntansi terhadap mata kuliah forensic accounting dan fraud examination
(FAFE) apabila diintegrasikan ke dalam kurikulum jurusan akuntansi. Penelitian
ini juga menganalisis perbedaan persepsi praktisi akuntansi, akademisi akuntansi
dan mahasiswa akuntansi terhadap permintaan, minat, potensi karir, kendala, man-
faat, dan topik bahasan akuntansi forensik dan fraud examination apabila diintegra-
sikan ke dalam kurikulum jurusan akuntansi.Hasilnya menunjukkan bahwa prak-
tisi, akademisi dan mahasiswa akuntansi mendukung mata kuliah akuntansi foren-
sik dan fraud examination diintegrasikan ke dalam kurikulum jurusan akuntansi.
Lebih lanjut, hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa terdapat perbedaan persepsi
antara praktisi, akademisi dan mahasiswa akuntansi terhadap minat, potensi karir,
kendala, manfaat dan topik bahasan FAFE. Penelitian ini memiliki implikasi berupa
perlunya perumusan kembali silabus dan materi akuntansi forensik dan fraud ex-
amination yang lebih relevan dengan kebutuhan Indonesia, juga sebagai bahan
pertimbangan bagi perguruan tinggi untuk mengintegrasikan mata kuliah FAFE ke
dalam kurikulum jurusan akuntansi.

1. INTRODUCTION able to detect fraud. This raises a question such as


There has been widely impact of corruption and who should be responsible for detecting fraud in
this threatens the existence of a nation if such action financial statements.
has been structured. Besides that, such evil corpora- All accountants insist that it is not their re-
tions also have contributed to the country's eco- sponsibility for detecting fraud in a financial state-
nomic downturn. The total losses will be rising ment audit process. On the other hand, the court
when the professionals committed and participated actually holds the opinion that the accountant is the
in fraudulence. This is because accountants are not party responsible for the failure to detect fraud in

* Corresponding author, email address: 1 yunania2006@yahoo.co.id.

281
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

financial statements (Buckhoffet al. 2010). However, accounting. The scope of forensic accounting con-
Rezaee & Riley (2010: xi) argue that accountants sists of three areas, namely litigation support, ex-
cannot be blamed. Accountants simply apply the pert witness and fraud examination. Litigation
knowledge and skills they have been learned. The support is the field of forensic accounting services
portion of the teaching and training of accountant’s participating in the legal field as a consultant to
antifraud they got while studying in college must translate the financial information through critical
be judged to be sufficient, or even not at all. analysis to find indications of fraud.
The amount of losses incurred and increased In such a case, expert witness is an accountant
frequency of fraud have been documented in many with the knowledge, skills, experience or special
studies such as studies conducted by PWC (2011); training, to assist judges, prosecutors, lawyers and
Rezaee & Riley (2010: 8-16, 313); Buckhoffet al. others to understand the accounting jargon and
(2010); Zadeh and Ramazani (2012); Zango (2012) translate financial information, to help them formu-
and Efiong (2012). All proceeds in those studies late conclusions or decisions on facts beyond their
were to recommend about urgency integration understanding and experience about FAFE (Ojo
courses of accounting forensic and fraud examina- 2012; Rezaee and Riley 2010: 308). For example,
tion (FAFE) in the curriculum of accounting majors. Albrecht et al. (2011) defines fraud examination as a
The goal for the student as a prospective account- methodology to uncover and prove whether the
ant has insight FAFE, at least the ability to detect allegations of fraud does occur, ranging from the
fraud and facilitate the transition from classroom beginning to the disposition process, including
learning to the selection of his career as a profes- search for evidence, interviewing, writing reports
sional accountant in the field of FAFE. and giving expert testimony.
In reference to such argument above, most of Thus, fraud examination is a fairly broad cov-
the universities, especially in America, many of erage of science to be sub material in an accounting
which offer FAFE, either as separate courses or class, because they do not provide review material
programs (Singleton & Singleton 2010: 35). In Indo- those students need FAFE as potential fraud and
nesia, only a few universities have integrated the accountant to understand all the details. FAFE does
material in the curriculum department FAFE ac- not have enough space in the curriculum of ac-
counting. Furthermore, this study tries to find out counting majors (Shinde et al. 2013). Therefore,
how the perception of practitioners, academics and accounting practitioners emphasize the importance
students of accounting towards the integration of FAFE and recommends that integrate college
the curriculum subjects FAFE accounting majors courses on curriculum FAFE accounting majors
and differences in perceptions of practitioners, aca- (Rezaee and Riley 2010: 315). Likewise with the
demics and students about the accounting curricu- practitioner accountants in Indonesia also supports
lum integration of FAFE in accounting majors. integration into the curriculum FAFE accounting
majors. Attitudes of accounting practitioners who
2. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK support the integration of the curriculum subjects
There are two ways to gain something illegally FAFE accounting majors shown in several studies.
namely (1) use of physical force; (2) the trick in Specifically, accounting practitioners respond
such a way to obtain the desired asset. The first to the demand above and public interest in educa-
way is called as a robbery, and the second way is tion and practice. All FAFE services will increase in
referred to as fraud (Albrecht et al. 2011: 7). TWG the future. Accounting practitioners also believe
(in Kranacher et al. 2010: 25) defines fraud as a strongly there will be a lot of benefits that can be
fraud attempt in order to influence the victim to gained from the teaching and practice of FAFE ser-
give up valuable objects or attorney or presenting vices for educational institutions, students and
false data instead of actual facts. In order to handle companies (Shinde et al. 2013; Zango 2012; Albrecht
the fraud required a more sophisticated tool, not et al. 2011: 16; Kranacher et al. 2010: 35-36).
just a tool to detect fraud, but also examine, inves- More specifically, accounting academics realize
tigate, investigate, prosecute, prosecute, and so on. that it considers necessary and essential to facilitate
All these are forensic accounting. accounting students with FAFE courses in the ac-
Again, forensic Accounting is defined by the counting curriculum. In fact, some of the educa-
TWG (in Kranacher et al. 2010: 25) as the applica- tional institutions have responded to the impor-
tion of principles, theories and disciplines of ac- tance and support the integration of courses in the
counting on the facts and hypotheses associated curriculum FAFE accounting majors. Accounting
with legal disputes and include every branch of academics FAFE supports integration into the cur-

282
Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No. 2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

riculum of accounting majors will be of great bene- grating the subject of FAFE into accounting. This
fit, especially to the three stakeholders, namely study sees the major curriculum that seeks to de-
educational institutions, students and companies or scribe the perceptions of practitioners, academics,
employers (Zango 2012; Stambaugh et al. 2012; Car- and students towards the integration between ac-
lino 2010). counting courses as accounting majors with FAFE
Accounting students to specialize or take in the curriculum.
courses FAFE FAFE more sensitive to the symp- On the contrary, this study also compares the
toms of fraud. A forensic accountant is one of the perceptions of the three groups on the integration
promising careers. Demand for accounting students of curriculum subject of FAFE with accounting ma-
who have qualified FAFE has increased rapidly and jors. Using data collection instruments developed
this will be growing (Kranacher and Wells 2010: further than the instruments made by Rezaee et al.
36). Many accounting students who are interested (2004), which consists of 3 parts. First, it is the per-
in attending in FAFE and many companies also sonal identity of the respondents.
want to recruit graduates who have qualified ac- Second, the gist which has a question about the
counting majors FAFE. This situation becomes respondent's perception towards FFE measured
more interesting when some academics that admin- using a nominal scale and ordinal Likert scale 1-4,
ister accounting courses FAFE, revealed that sub- which consists of; (1) recognize, know and under-
jects FAFE is a subject that is quite popular and stand FAFE; (2) the demand for the teaching and
many of the accounting students selected choice of practice of the three areas of FAFE services in the
courses in the curriculum of accounting majors future; (3) The public interest in the teaching and
(Meier, et al. 2010; Buckhoff and Shrader, in Efiong FAFE as service practice and the third area in the
2012). future; (4) the potential for a career in the third
Robbins (2012: 166), implicitly stated that an practice area of FAFE services in the future; (5) the
individual's perception of the object is very likely to nature of teaching FAFE; (6) the level of study of-
have differences from the other individual's percep- fered; (7) FAFE with its obstacle in a course curricu-
tion of the same object. Inter-individual differences lum integration with accounting majors; (8) the
in perception are caused by feelings of individuals benefits of teaching and practice service of FAFE;
who received different functions and this is caused and (9) whether these are considered important
by the tendency of the difference. Usually, an indi- topic to be discussed in FAFE.
vidual will choose the appropriate sense interesting Third, it consists of: (1) questions from the re-
and important of the discovery. Accounting practi- spondents; and (2) Open comments of respondents
tioners and academics have significant differences to the integration of the curriculum subjects FAFE
in perception about the topics of discussion are accounting majors.
important and need to be present in subjects FAFE. The population includes practitioners, academ-
All in all, accounting practitioners tend to be ics, and students of accounting. The sample selec-
more confident than accounting academics that the tion criteria are as follows: (1) Practitioners of ac-
teaching and practice of FAFE services provide counting are Financial Inspection Board (BPK)
many benefits to the stakeholders. In addition, ac- auditors who have experience of the investigative
counting practitioners tend to choose subjects that audit. (2) Academics are accountant educator who
FAFE is not merged in the other lectures, but rather teaches courses in accounting (in particular subject
it stands as a separate and distinct subject. On the of FAFE, and auditing or still in the auditing
other hand, it is more academic subjects if it is in branch) at the University in East Java with the pro-
fact more appropriate when being integrated into visions; (a) has an Accounting profession education
other subjects such as auditing and financial ac- (PPAk) and master of accounting program; (b) a
counting (Zango 2012). member of Association to Advance Collegiate
Schools of Business (ACSB); and (c) integrating
3. RESEARCH METHOD FAFE the curriculum. Brawijaya University and the
This survey research that is a descriptive study University of Airlangga University Surabaya be-
which tests hypotheses (explanatory) using descrip- came institutions purposively selected as the study
tive and explanatory methods. This is due to the sample. (3) The student of masters of accounting in
fact that the core of the discussion is the questions the accounting profession who has taken courses or
about perceptions of the three groups of respon- auditing and FAFE.
dents namely accounting practitioners, academics The number of 335 samples was divided into
accounting, and accounting students towards inte- 76 person accounting practitioners, academics ac-

283
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

Table 1
Degree of Questionnaires Returned
Questionnaires BPK Academicians Students Total
Distributed to 76 40 219 335
Not returned 0 5 91 96
Not Used 1 0 38 39
Used 75 35 90 200
Degree of response (%) 98.7 87.0 41.0 59.7
Source: processed primary data.

Table 2
Test of Instrument Validity
Total of Item score
Item No Description
Pearson Correlation Sig. (2-tailed) N
Item – 1 0.947** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 2 0.864** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 3 0.918** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 4 0.832** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 5a 0.803** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 5b 0.693** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 6 0.930** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 7 0.842** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 8 0.938** 0.000 200 Valid
Item – 9 0.526** 0.000 200 Valid
Source: processed primary data.
Detail: **Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

counting 40 and 219 accounting students. Primary Results


data collected from the entire questionnaire that was The Reliability and Validity of Data
sent with the rate of return as shown in Table 1. The results of each test of the validity of the re-
The next is that the quantitative data were ana- search instrument items with α = 0.05 and this indi-
lyzed using univariate and multivariate statistics. cates that all items are considered eligible instru-
Univariate analysis was done on the basis of data ments or with the validity of the instrument, as
collected with the aim to describe the number and shown in Table 2.
distribution of each variable as a representation of The test of the instrument reliability obtained
the characteristics of the respondents (practitioners, Cronbach alpha value of 0.961. This means that the
academics, and students of accounting). Multivari- instrument used to collect research data qualify
ate analyze was done to test the hypothesis that has reliability with reliability criteria perfectly.
been developed to examine the differences in per-
ceptions between practitioners, academicians, and Respondent’s Perception of the FAFE Course
students of the relevance of accounting education Accounting practitioners recognize FAFE entirely
in FAFE. Kruskall-Wallis test is considered appro- (100%). They also considered that FAFE course is
priate for an analysis instrument to compare differ- very beneficial when integrated into the course
ences in the perception of three independent sam- curriculum of accounting. Most of them (92.00%)
ples from different populations (practitioners, aca- are the practitioners who hope that FAFE subject
demics and students of accounting) with ordinal should be integrated into a curriculum as a com-
scale or interval scale but not normally distributed. pulsory subject for students of accounting. Even
they expect (90.70%) of FAFE subject must stand-
4. DATA ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION alone subject, and given to undergraduate level
In terms of the findings and the discussion, the students (81.30%). Basically, practitioners of ac-
study relates to the reliability and validity of the counting support FAFE courses to be integrated in
data first and them the results are presented in ta- the curriculum of accounting majors.
bles then discussed. In general (80.0%) accounting academics are

284
Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No. 2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

familiar with FAFE. They considered that subject of Table 3


FAFE is very beneficial when included in the Test of Statisticsa,b
course curriculum of accounting, especially for Perception
building the character, knowledge, and skills of Chi-Square 10.376
forensic accountants. Academicians perceive that df 2
FAFE course does not need to be compulsory sub- Asymp. Sig. 0.006
ject. It is simply used as elective courses (85.70%) a. Kruskal Wallis Test
b. Grouping Variable: Group
and as separate subject (80.00%), with the argu- Source: Processed primary data by SPSS.
ment: (1) gives freedom to the students to choose
specificity or interest in the study who wants to be are differences in the perception of the public inter-
explored. (2) an already crowded curriculum does est in the teaching and practice of FAFE services in
not allow for expansion (requiring a new course) the field of litigation support with the KW test that
instead of being elective courses. shows the value of 7.487. In the field of fraud ex-
The academicians found FAFE course is given amination with tests, it shows the value of 7.942
to students of the undergraduate program (85.70%), KW. Differences in perceptions among the three
with the argument; (1) can support the chosen ca- groups of respondents were also found in the ca-
reer, such as working at the firm, CPC, and so on, reer potential FAFE FAFE in services and litigation
(2) facilitate the students of the science of the new support services in the field of fraud examination
accounting, is being developed, and much needed, FAFE. In this case, the KW test shows values
(3) the importance of considering the implications respectively 6.057 and 9.647.
of the provision of courses in the learning process Accounting academicians expect over the in-
FAFE, need to learn at least basic knowledge FAFE. creasing development of the two fields FAFE ser-
Basically, the accounting students support the cur- vices (litigation support and fraud examination)
riculum of FAFE to be integrated in accounting more than the two other respondents, namely ac-
majors. counting practitioners and accounting students.
In contrast to the practitioners and academi- The difference of perception between the three
cians, only 71.10% of accounting students know groups of respondents on demand, interest, and
and understand FAFE. The majority (76.70%) stu- potential careers in the field of teaching and prac-
dents found the course of FAFE does not need to be tice FAFE services, provide expert testimony, not
placed as a compulsory subject but simply become statistically significant (with a value of 3.208 KW
elective courses. Nevertheless, 85.60% of students each; 1.314, and 0.769).
found the course FAFE placed as a stand-alone In relation to the previous studies, Zango
course in the accounting curriculum courses. As (2012) found that accounting practitioners have
academics, students found the course better FAFE great certainty when demand and interest in the
given early in the stratum one (66.70%). Basically two areas of teaching and practice FAFE services
accounting student support FAFE integrated can increase. Both areas are litigation support and
courses in the curriculum of accounting majors. expert testimony. This suggests that accounting
academicians today have realized the importance
Differences in Perceptions of Respondents on of integrating the curriculum FAFE accounting
Curriculum Integration FAFE majors to produce accounting graduates who have
Results of Kruskal-Wallis (KW) test H or H = 10.376 a minimum of added value in the ability to detect
values obtained the following chi-square distribu- fraud. This condition is a good start to encourage
tion with degrees of freedom or df = 2 (see Table 3). the integration of accounting academics in support
For p-value = 0.006, it is much smaller than α = of the curriculum subjects FAFE accounting ma-
0.05, then Ho: η1 = η2 = η3 is rejected. Thus, there jors.
are differences in perceptions between practitio- Differences in perceptions among the three
ners, academics, and students of accounting to groups of respondents regarding the obstacles
FAFE subjects to be integrated in the curriculum of faced to integrate FAFE courses on accounting ma-
accounting majors. jors curriculum are due to a lack of financial re-
This study supports the research by Zango sources (value of 7.515 KW) and lack of employ-
(2012), which indicates there is a difference be- ment opportunities (19.777 KW values). The stu-
tween the perceptions of accounting practitioners dents believe more than accounting academicians
and academicians on the subject of integration in do that they lack of financial resources and lack of
the curriculum FAFE in accounting majors. There employment opportunities including a major ob-

285
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

stacle in the integration of the curriculum subjects 125). For that reason, companies can rely on the
FAFE accounting majors. expertise of forensic accountants to establish a con-
On the other hand, accounting practitioners sistent system of corporate governance, distribute
consider the lack of employment opportunities is and valid information to outside companies, ensur-
not a major constraint. The third respondents have ing that the policies and objectives of the company
different perceptions of the benefits of teaching and integrated into the systems of internal control,
practice FAFE services. The differences among the fraud prevention systems design and investigate
three groups of respondents are significant at 5% immediately so there are signs of fraud.
and the value of 5.964 KW, indicating that the aca- Demand for human resources and scientific
demics more confident when teaching and practice expertise to master FAFE increase and this phe-
FAFE services can satisfy the public demand for the nomenon is seen as a very important benefit by
teaching and practice of FAFE services. Demand for accounting academics (mean response 4.257). This
accounting graduates who have qualified in detect- is considered quite important by accounting practi-
ing fraud and forensic accounting will increase tioners and accounting students (mean response
rapidly. This can create opportunities for high 3.747 and 4.089). The difference between the three
schools, universities and institutions to provide is very significant at 1% and the KW value of 9.913,
teaching courses at the institution FAFE (Shinde et indicating that accounting academics more confi-
al. 2013). dent if the presence of the teaching and practice of
To highlight the credibility of the financial the demand for services FAFE people who master
statements is considered a very important benefit the skill and science FAFE will increase. Both CPC,
by accounting academicians (mean response: the Commission, as well as several studies (Zango
4.457), and quite important for accounting practi- 2012; Zadeh and Ramazani 2012; Efiong 2012;
tioners (response mean: 3.987) and accounting stu- Shinde et al. 2013) indicates that the demand for
dents (mean response: 4.156). The differences forensic accountants will continue to rise, but de-
among the three groups of respondents are very mand and supply on a qualified accounting gradu-
significant at 1% and the value of 8.117 KW, indi- ates forensics is not balanced, so that the presence
cating that accounting academics strongly believes of either FAFE courses and programs, the demand
that teaching FAFE will strengthen the credibility for people or graduates who master the skill and
of financial statements. Fraud is well designed and science FAFE will be fulfilled.
sophisticated and it always succeed in undermin- The responses to the teaching and practice of
ing the company's assets and threatening the integ- university services FAFE has important benefits to
rity of the financial reporting of the company, prepare accounting students who will assist in the
unless the company has educated and trained ac- process of litigation shows that practitioners and
countants in FAFE, can act and think properly de- accounting students agree (mean response 3.733
tective (Singleton and Singleton 2010: 15 & 21; and 3.900), while accounting academics strongly
Rezaee and Riley 2010: 88). agree (mean response 4.286). The differences
The response to the claim that the teaching and among the three groups of respondents are signifi-
practice of university services FAFE has important cant at 5% and the value of 7.233 KW, indicating
benefits to support responsible corporate govern- that accounting academics more confident when
ance shows that accounting practitioners and ac- teaching and practice FAFE services essential in
counting students quite agree (mean 4.133 and preparing accounting students who would later be
4.267 response). Yet, academicians strongly agree involved as a consultant in litigation support.
(mean response 4.829). The differences among the Forensic accountant as a consultant in the liti-
three groups of respondents are very significant at gation support always helps lawyers for the detec-
1% and the value of 22.698 KW indicates that ac- tion and analysis of data in a variety of criminal
counting academics more confident when teaching and civil cases (Rezaee and Riley 2010: 308; Ojo
and practice support services can FAFE responsible 2012). In this case, preparing accounting students to
corporate governance. give expert testimony is seen as a very important
Various reports of various financial scandals in benefit by accounting academics (mean response of
various companies in different countries and the 4,400), and is considered quite important by ac-
response regulator have attracted much attention in counting practitioners and accounting students
the jargon of corporate governance and its role in (mean 3.373 and 3.889 response). The differences
improving the quality, reliability and transparency among the three groups of respondents are very
of financial reporting (Rezaee and Riley 2010: 121- significant at 1% and the value of 24.609 KW, indi-

286
Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No. 2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

cating that accounting academics more confident if gation and recovery of losses from financial crimes,
the presence of the teaching and practice of the fraud and FAFE on a digital scope (11.669 KW
FAFE services will help future accounting students value is significant at 1%); research and analysis
to provide expert testimony. (19.023 KW value is significant at 1%); assessment
This study indicates that accounting academi- of loss and damage (14.409 KW value significant at
cians have been fully supportive to prepare ac- 1%); conflict resolution (10.123 KW value is signifi-
counting students with a better understanding of cant at 1%); and arbitration (16.941 KW value is
the ins and outs of becoming a party providing significant at 1%).
expert testimony. Forensic accountants who pro-
vide expert testimony in court, helping judges, Discussion
prosecutors and others who were in the court to Now that the demand, interest, and potential career
understand the field beyond their understanding for services FAFE are increasing. Therefore, the
and competence in complex financial cases, where teaching and practice in the field of litigation sup-
forensic accountants have the ability to explain the port, expert testimony and examination of fraud in
accounting jargon in language that could under- the future will be responded largely increased by
stood (Singleton and Singleton 2010: 306, Rezaee the three groups of respondents. The third group of
and Riley 2010: 308). respondents also felt a great need for practice FAFE
Perception of the three groups of respondents services in the future, as well as perceived by the
regarding the teaching and practice of student ser- Commission which also takes the role of a forensic
vices FAFE make more desirable in the job market, auditor to help unload the cases of corruption with
the benefits of the smallest contribution. Mean dif- the process of proving that complicated.
ference was statistically significant at the 1% and However, until now the commission still does
the value of 14.189 KW, indicating that accounting not have forensic accountants, forensic accountants,
academics (mean responses 3.914) considers the in which seeking the figure is very difficult (in-
teaching and practice of FAFE services as important fokorupsi.com). The managing director of the Insti-
to make students more desirable in the job market tute for Development of Fraud Auditing (LPFA)
rather than accounting practitioners and accounting Drs. Soekardi Hoesodo said that the lack of optimal
students (mean 3.413 response and 3.844). utilization of FAFE to control corruption in Indone-
In order to provide recommendations and an sia cannot be separated from the lack of experts in
overview of the course syllabus content of FAFE, it the field. It seems that number of accountants in
requires at least three groups of respondents’ per- Indonesia is only about less than 200 people who
ception to examine the topic of what is considered become a forensic accountant. This number is not
important to be given in the course syllabus FAFE. balanced by the number of inhabitants and corrup-
The perception of the three respondent groups was tion cases in Indonesia (pikiranrakyat.com).
statistically different at the 13 topics of the 16 top- For example, a survey conducted by Zango
ics. These topics include: the nature of criminology (2012); Shinde et al. (2013); and the Zadeh and
(6.419 KW value is significant at 1%); dynamics of Ramazani (2012) show that demand and public
criminology (5.421 KW value significant at 5%); interest in the teaching and practice of FAFE ser-
scope of fraud and financial crime (11.412 KW vices in the future will increase. The last few years,
value significant at 1%); ethics (14.556 KW value is the demand for the teaching and practice of FAFE
significant at 1%); prevention, anticipation, detec- services have proliferated in many aspects of busi-
tion, investigation and recovery of losses due to ness. Many companies are requesting services
misappropriation of assets (value of 4.874 KW sig- FAFE to handle some activities related to it. Thus,
nificant at 5%). the demand for graduates or young accountants
Besides the above, it also deals with preven- who have vigilance against fraud and educated in
tion, anticipation, detection, investigation and re- the white collar crime, fraud and forensic account-
covery of losses due to corruption (KW value of ing is also increasing rapidly (Boys 2013).
5.670 significant at 1%); prevention, anticipation, Another study conducted by Kessler Interna-
detection, investigation and recovery of losses due tional shows that the increased demand for forensic
to misstatement (27.750 KW value is significant at accountants (Bukics 2010). The high demand for
1%); prevention, anticipation, detection, investiga- services in the field of FAFE practice is unfortu-
tion and recovery of losses due to irregularities of nately far exceeding the number of available foren-
financial statements (14.502 KW value is significant sic accountants (Boys 2013). Shinde et al. (2013)
at 1%); prevention, anticipation, detection, investi- noted that due to increased demand for forensic

287
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

accountants, the university is expected to offer Second, it is currently circulating in some


courses and increase the number of FAFE the ac- bookstores, the work entitled M.Theodorus Tuana-
counting department curriculum. kotta Forensic Accounting and Investigative Audit,
Also several surveys indicate that a potential and other book entitled Counting Losses in the
career as a forensic accountant and many potential State Treasury of the Corruption, Fraud Detection
students interested in accounting today. US News then Accounting The Financial Numbers Game
and World Report preach on the main page that works Mulford and Comiskey which has been
forensic accountants is ranked a career with one of translated into Indonesian, which will assist in the
the eight most secure career in America for several implementation of the course.
years, even 40% of the 100 best KAP is developing The second obstacle is financial problems
forensic and fraud services (Meier et al. 2010 ). (mean response 3.050). Rezaee et al. (in Efiong 2012)
Forensic accountant is seen as a career-best. actually considers the financial issues as the biggest
However, the reality is still a little bit of accounting obstacle in the integration efforts on curriculum
programs at some universities that offer courses in subjects FAFE accounting majors. The development
the curriculum FAFE (Zadeh and Ramazani 2012; of science and expertise as a forensic accountant
Shinde et al. 2013; Meier et al. 2010). On the other requires significant investment and not all universi-
hand, many obstacles that must be addressed when ties have the funds for the development of account-
integrating and implementing the curriculum sub- ing academics in the new field. Implementing the
jects FAFE accounting majors. The third group of expert speakers presenting lectures by forensic ac-
respondents admitted that indeed there are several countants also need funding. Although in need of
obstacles in the integration process FAFE subjects funds, the benefits to be received far greater than
into the curriculum of accounting majors. Statisti- the funds will be issued.
cally, there are significant differences between the Solutions to such problems can be by overcom-
three groups of respondents to the obstacles en- ing the financial problems that is to raise funds
countered in the integration of the curriculum sub- from alumni and optimize the utilization of other
ject of FAFE in accounting majors. resources owned by the university to obtain other
The greatest obstacle is the lack of teaching ma- incentives. Another solution can be coping with
terials on FAFE (response mean 3.245). It is also due accounting academicians by helping them and the
to the lack of teaching materials that have become a faculty such as by facilitating the students with
major obstacle in the lecture. Rezaee et al. (2004) theory and group discussion in the classroom as
stated that teaching materials are still limited and well utilizing the university programs, such as Em-
in accordance with the curriculum to be one of the ployment Practices (PKL), to cooperate with agen-
major obstacles to the integration of the three cies or institutions with experience in the field of
courses in the curriculum FAFE accounting majors. FAFE to conduct training and provide case studies
Each constraint must be solved so that the planning FAFE ever handled real in Indonesia by the agency
can be run properly. or institution concerned to establish the sensitivity
There are some solutions to overcome these of detecting fraud in the process of investigating
obstacles. First, ACFE provides a set of video at a and preparing reports. This method was also con-
low price for accounting academics. For example, if ducted by West Virginia University (WVU) that the
accounting academia initiative to register as a interaction between students and experts in the
member of ACFE Educator Associate, will be asked learning process FAFE contributes greatly to stu-
to contribute a registration fee of $ 35 (for dents’ learning activities (Fleming et al. 2008).
Rp315.000, - the exchange rate is assumed to be Third, the entire group of respondents found
9,000 in number). Benefits of becoming a member employment constraint (response mean 2.910). This
ACFE Educator Associate quite a lot, such as get- result is in contrast to previous studies (Rezaee et
ting a free magazine Fraud Magazine, access to the al. 2004), this indicates that employment is the fifth
ACFE website that has hundreds of articles and constraint. This can be caused by respondents' pes-
other documents on all matters related to the pre- simism world employment trends and labor market
vention and detection of fraud. If universities are in Indonesia. In Indonesia, the development of sci-
interested to offer its own programs or in the exist- ence FAFE is still far from complete, of the many
ing curriculum and joined the ACFE Anti-Fraud KAP only a few that offer services FAFE, the reason
Education Partnership, will receive the entire pack- for a niche market that is still minimal. Moreover,
age of 11 video ACFE fraud, package syllabus and operational standards and certification exams fo-
books and various materials to assist the lecture. rensic accountants still inadequate, so far when

288
Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No. 2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

compared with Australia which are formulating For example, the dean gave permission FAFE
Forensic Accounting Standards, even Canada and program to operate and even in the most difficult
the USA already have a forensic accounting stan- moments and issues that arise, dean willing to help
dards and as usual raw Indonesia will adopt the and fully support (Young 2008).
standards which made the other countries. An ad- All three groups of respondents generally
ditional issue is the forensic accountant must have found a lack of student interest as the last obstacle
the ability multitalented (Menantangbatas 2008). (the mean response 2.590). This indicates that stu-
Furthermore, the trend of the world of work dent interest is large enough so that no major ob-
today is 1 in 3 unemployed workers, and in Indo- stacles to the integration of the curriculum subjects
nesia as a result of the economic crisis estimated 29 FAFE accounting majors. Seda and Peterson (2008)
million people have participated in the labor mar- also showed that a lack of student interest is a con-
ket (www.ilo.org). Central burro of Statistics (BPS) straint that the smallest among other constraints.
(www.bps.go.id) showed that the unemployment Constraints faced quite a lot, but the benefits
rate has decreased after 2005, when the year is the received far greater. According to the respondents,
year with the highest unemployment rate. How- the main benefit received from teaching courses to
ever, Kadin LP3E judge, stated the government's students FAFE accounting is to support good cor-
claim that the unemployment rate fell was not en- porate governance or corporate governance (re-
tirely true. Because the decrease is only switched to sponse mean 4.315). Failure of corporate communi-
the group underemployment, due to government cations structure has made the business community
policy that considers the category that works a aware that there is a great need for professionals
minimum of 1 hour per week can be called as un- who are experts in identifying, expressing and pre-
employed. Pessimism is associated with the fact vent weaknesses in three areas, namely: poor cor-
that many people who work not in accordance with porate governance, internal control weaknesses and
the field of science is practiced (Watz 2012). irregularities financial statements. The contribution
The anomaly should not be an obstacle to de- of forensic accountants in supporting is very large
velop them. It is lack of support from the admini- in GCG.
stration or academic occupy the fourth position The background of the knowledge in the field
(mean response 2.835). Administrative or academic of forensic accountants and legal foundation is nec-
can create an effective learning environment for essary in shaping corporate governance, can help
students, in a manner such that FAFE designing formulate policy and establish authority covering a
courses, and other courses that have a basic knowl- lot of things, as the following: (1) ensure the har-
edge of the material charge and range of expertise monious combination between the management
that is essential for carrying out forensic services in and the board of directors; (2) designing appropri-
the future (Boys 2013). Administrative and aca- ate accountability to the board of directors and the
demic collaboration with faculty officials play a audit committee; (3) the proper allocation of power
role in finding qualified accounting academics as between owners, management and board of direc-
forensic accountants, in order to produce graduates tors; and (4) ensure the existence of a code of con-
who are different than previous graduates, which duct that applied to all employees and manage-
has the ability to detect and prevent fraud (Fletcher ment (Zango 2012; Rezaee and Riley 2010: 124).
et al. 2008). Administrative support is essential in Second, it is to strengthen the credibility of fi-
developing courses in the curriculum of FAFE in nancial reporting (response mean 4.145). Forensic
accounting majors. accountants strengthen the financial reporting
There is no or lack of faculty support with the process by preventing, detecting and reporting
mean response 2.810 (political process in formulat- financial fraud, investment fraud, bribery, bank
ing curriculum policy) caused by lack of under- fraud, credit card fraud, electronic funds transfer
standing regarding the official faculty dangerous fraud, computer fraud, and so on, in a way to make
crisis that could be caused by the fraud. Another fraud more easily evaluated and evaluate compli-
reason is the faculty did not want to add FAFE ance with the law and regulations (Zango 2012).
courses into existing curriculum. Faculty are also Third, it may prepare the students or young
responsible for finding academic staff that have accountants to carry out the fraud examination
qualifications as a teacher FAFE, the problem is the services (response mean 4.080). FAFE is critical
numbers are still a little (Efiong 2008). At Florida given to students to prepare them in the assign-
Atlantic University dean of the business faculty is ment revealed fraud and universities have a major
very supportive FAFE program. role in making them. Forensic accountants have

289
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

had more than one tool in detecting the alleged pares data to be used to counter the testimony of
fraud on financial crimes and trace illicit funds the opposing party (Rezaee and Riley 2010: 308). As
from illegal activities (Shinde et al. 2013; Efiong a fellow attorney in criminal and civil cases, the
2012). young accountant will be better prepared for his
Fourth, it can help the government in the case role as a litigation consultant if it has received a
of terrorism and money laundering (mean response teaching FAFE.
4.030). Terrorists and insurgents always use the Seventh, it can prepare students as those who
proceeds of fraud to fund its operations and laun- provide expert testimony (response mean 3.785).
der money. Forensic accountants have a vital role to Forensic accountants as people who give expert
look for signs of suspicious financial transactions, testimony were considered in behavior, including
both individuals and organizations, as well as creativity, calm disposition, competence and inge-
evaluating the accounting records and the bank of nuity in communication during court proceedings.
the person or organization suspected of being ter- Counterparty will always try to discredit a state-
rorists. Financial scandals big companies and even ment challenging accountant with knowledge, as-
the September 11 attacks on the World Trade Cen- sumptions, experience or ability to analyze the data
ter where terrorists use the international banking (Albrecht et al. 2011: 632).
system to fund the action, transfer funds and hide Eighth, the student is more desirable in the job
their funds, is evidence that young accountants market (response mean 3,695). The third group of
need to get FAFE courses primarily in the areas of respondents thought that students would be more
fraud prevention, fraud anticipation, detection, desirable in the job market is not a major benefit of
investigation and recovery of losses due to fraud the teaching and practice of FAFE services. Re-
(Albrecht et al. 2011: 582). search Zango (2012) also showed that the respon-
Fifth, it can satisfy the public demand for the dents did not think that the students in the job
teaching and practice of FAFE services, and de- market would be more desirable is relevant benefits
mand for someone who mastered the skill and sci- received from the teaching of forensic accounting.
ence of FAFE will increase (mean response 3.990). Accounting practitioners assume that for the time
With the large number of cases of fraud by em- being as accountant forensic accountants specializa-
ployees or management, abuse and other financial tion has not been too much to absorb.
crimes that happen in people's lives now, the ac- A tremendous benefit can be obtained from the
countant must master FAFE expertise and skills to administration of FAFE courses to students and
help prevent, detect and investigate financial provide significant added value for graduates
crimes such. Integrating and offers programs and (Shinde et al. 2013). In order to provide added
courses FAFE to accounting students, the first step value, it is necessary to design a model curriculum
is very important to educate young accountant in that is tailored to the business climate, political,
the future, so the young accountant is equipped educational, social, and culture in Indonesia. Cur-
with the knowledge to prevent and detect fraud riculum model developed is a curriculum that inte-
(Shinde et al. 2013; Efiong 2012, Zango 2012). grates courses FAFE. All three groups of respon-
Sixth, it should prepare students who will as- dents have the perception that the following topics
sist in the litigation process (response mean 3.905). are very important and relevant to be used as learn-
Forensic accountants are needed in a case in which ing materials of FAFE (mean response equals over
the financial information requires in-depth analysis 4,000).
of the alleged violation of applicable laws. Forensic It also includes prevention, anticipation, detec-
accountants are always requested a variety of in- tion, investigation and recovery of losses due to
formation and advice by lawyers on cases that re- corruption (mean response 4.415); prevention, an-
quire accounting data and other financial cases for ticipation, detection, investigation and recovery of
further processing the case to court (Albrecht 2011: losses from financial crimes, fraud and forensic
626). accounting at the scope or digital environment
Lawyers believe that the expertises of forensic (mean responses 4.355); prevention, anticipation,
accountants are very helpful in criminal and civil detection, investigation and recovery of losses from
cases. One of the services of forensic accountants as financial crimes (mean responses 4.325).
consultants’ very helpful litigation attorney needs The next deals with prevention, anticipation,
in terms of detection and data analysis. Attorneys detection, investigation and recovery of losses due
always use the detection and analysis of data to to irregularities of financial statements (mean re-
determine the stage of the cases handled and pre- sponses 4.280); prevention, anticipation, detection,

290
Journal of Economics, Business, and Accountancy Ventura Vol. 17, No. 2, August 2014, pages 281 – 292

investigation and recovery of losses due to abuse of help the student prepare for the litigation process,
the asset (the mean response 4.230); scope of fraud and satisfy the public demand for the teaching and
and financial crime (mean response 4.220), legal practice of FAFE services.
(response mean 4,200), losses and damage assess- Fifth, there are three different groups of re-
ment (mean response 4.175), prevention, anticipa- spondents’ perception to 13 of 16 topics as the
tion, detection, investigation and recovery of losses choice of the material in the course FAFE.
due to misstatement of financial statements (mean The reviews this topic includes such as the na-
responses 4.140); research and analysis (response ture of criminology; dynamics criminology; scope
mean 4,100), ethics (the mean response 4.095), and of fraud and financial crimes; ethics; prevention,
the resolution of conflicts or disputes (response anticipation, detection, investigation and recovery
mean 4.000). of losses are due to misappropriation of assets.
Next is that the prevention, anticipation, detec-
5. CONCLUSION, IMPLICATION, SUGGES- tion, investigation and recovery of losses are due
TION, AND LIMITATIONS to corruption; prevention, anticipation, detection,
This study indicates that the perception of each investigation, and recovery of losses due to mis-
respondent group (practitioners, academics, and statement; prevention, anticipation, detection,
student accounting) support FAFE subjects to be investigation and recovery of losses due to irregu-
integrated in the curriculum of accounting majors. larities of financial statements; prevention, antici-
The majority of all three groups of respondents pation, detection, investigation and recovery of
recognize know and understand forensic account- losses from financial crimes, fraud & FAFE the
ing. The majority of all three groups of respondents digital scope; research and analysis; loss and dam-
viewed FAFE need to exist in the curriculum, but age assessment; conflict resolution, and arbitra-
its nature as elective courses and stand as a sepa- tion.
rate subject, and is deemed more appropriate if It is expected that accounting majors at many
conducted from a single stratum. However, there universities begin to integrate FAFE into the cur-
are differences in perceptions between practitio- riculum in accounting majors. It is the fact that pub-
ners, academicians, and students of accounting that lic demand for accountants who have the ability to
FAFE subjects can be integrated in the curriculum detect fraud is increasing. In that case, professional
of accounting majors. This difference in perception bodies are expected to support integration into the
found in the following. curriculum FAFE accounting majors at universities
First, public interest in the teaching and prac- in Indonesia, both by providing training for mem-
tice of FAFE services, where three different respon- bers of IAI FAFE especially from accounting aca-
dents’ perception on the teaching and practice of demics at reasonable costs, and appeal to the uni-
FAFE services in the areas of litigation support and versity about the importance of the benefits derived
fraud examination. from integration into the curriculum of FAFE in
Secondly, the potential careers of the three accounting programs.
practices of FAFE services, where three different Such above phenomenon needs to reevaluate
respondents perception on FAFE services practice the structure, content, and learning of FAFE, taking
in the areas of litigation support and fraud exami- into account the results of this research for policies.
nation. Besides that, it can continue to innovate in develop-
Third, the entire groups of respondents have ing teaching methods in teaching FAFE. Profes-
different perceptions of a lack of financial resources sional bodies and other institutions can organize a
and employment opportunities as constraints of national workshop on the formulation of curricu-
FAFE integration into the curriculum of accounting lum FAFE professional and relevant to the needs of
majors. Indonesia, as practiced by NIJ USA.
Fourth, there are benefits received from the Limitations include such as the ability to gen-
teaching and practice of FAFE services, where three eralize beyond the sample, no test for non-response
different groups of respondents perception towards bias and the sample size is relatively small when
the statement points to prepare students who will compared to the entire population. Furthermore,
provide expert testimony, supports the responsible the content of the questionnaire can be likely re-
corporate governance, the student is more desirable lated to the list of questions and answer choices
in the job market, the demand for people who mas- which may not be understood properly by the re-
ter the skills and FAFE science increases, strengthen spondents. Thus, it might delicately be bias in
the credibility of financial reporting, which will terms of overall generalization for others.

291
Septarina Prita Dania Sofianti: The perception of …

REFERENCES accountability and ethic, Vol. 8/1, pp. 1-9.


Albrecht, WS, et al. 2011, Fraud examination, Fourth Ojo, Marianne, 2012, Forensic accounting and the law:
edition, South-Western, a division of Thomson The forensic accountant in the capacity of an expert
Learning, USA. witness, (Online), <papers.ssrn.com>, viewed
Anonim, 2011, KPK butuh auditor forensik untuk usut 20 July 2014.
kasus korupsi besar, (Online), <in- Pikiran Rakyat, 2010, Akuntansi forensik perlu masuk
fokorupsi.com>, viewed 20 June 2012. kurikulum, (Online), <www.pikiran-
Anonim, Tren sosial dan ketenagakerjaan di Indonesia rakyat.com>, viewed 20 April 2012.
2011: Mempromosikan pertumbuhan lapangan Pricewaterhousecoopers, 2011, Cyber crime: Protect-
kerja di tingkat propinsi, (Online), ing against the growing threat global economics
<www.ilo.org>, viewed 12 August 2012. crime survey, (Online), <www.pwc.com>,
Anonim, Pengangguran terbuka menurut pendidikan viewed 14 December 2012.
tertinggi, (Online), <www.bps.go.id>, Viewed Rezaee, Z, DL Crumbley and RC Elmore, 2004, ‘Fo-
12 Agustus 2012. rensic accounting education: A survey of aca-
Boys, Jennete, 2013, Forensic accounting in New Zea- demicians and practitioners’, Forensic Account-
land: Exploring the gap between education and ing Education, vol. 6, pp. 193-231.
practice, (Online), www.studymode.com/, Rezaee, Z, and R Riley, 2010, Financial statement
viewed 20 July 2014. fraud: Prevention and detection, Second edition,
Buckhoff, T, L Higgins, and D Sinclair, 2010, ‘A John Wiley & Son, Inc. USA.
fraud audit: do you need one?’, Journal of ap- Robbins, SP, and TA Judge, 2012, Organizational
plied business research, Vol. 26/5, pp. 29-33. Behavior, 15th Edition, Prentice Hall, USA.
Bukics, RML 2010, ‘The 150-credit-hour require- Seda, MK, and BK Peterson, 2008, ‘The emergence
ment is a forensic accounting education oppor- of forensic accounting programs in higher edu-
tunity’, Pensylvania CPA Journal, Vol. 81/3, pp. cation’, Management Accounting, quarterly 9/3,
20. pp. 15-23.
Carlino, B 2010, ‘Forensic skills in high demand’, Shinde, JS, US Shinde, and W Raymond, 2013, ‘Fo-
Accounting Today, May 24 – June 6, pp. 1. rensic examination cognizance: An empirical
Efiong, EJ 2012, ‘Forensic accounting education: An study’, Advances in management, Vol. 6/3, pp.
exploration of level of awareness in developing 43-54.
economies – Nigeria as a case study’, Interna- Singleton, TW, and AJ Singleton, 2010, Fraud audit-
tional journal of business and management, Vol. ing and forensic accounting, Fourth edition, John
7/4, pp. 26-34. Wiley & Sons, Inc. USA.
Fleming, AS, TA Pearson and RA Riley, 2008, ‘West Stambaugh, CT, M Tipgos, FW Carpenter, and LM
Virginia University: Forensic accounting and Smith, 2012, ‘Using Benford analysis to detect
fraud investigation’, Issues in accounting educa- fraud’, Internal auditing, May-June, pp. 24-29.
tion, Vol. 23/4, pp. 573-580. Watz, 2012, Rizal Ramli desak pertegas kriteria miskin,
Fletcher, LB, LN Higgins, JL Mooney, and TA <citizenjournalizm.com>, viewed August 2012.
Buckhoff, 2008, ‘Our school’s campaign for dis- Young, GR 2008, ‘Forensic accounting and FAU: An
tinction in forensic accounting’, Southern Busi- executive graduate programme’, Issues in ac-
ness Review, Vol. 33/1, pp. 15-27. counting education, Vol. 23/4, pp. 593-599.
Kranacher, MJ, R. Riley, and JT Wells, 2010, Forensic Zadeh, HA, and M Ramazani, 2012, ‘Accountant’s
Accounting and Fraud Examination, First edition, perception of forensic accounting (Case study
John Wiley & Sons, Inc. USA. of Iran)’, Global journal of management and busi-
Menantangbatas, 2008, Perkembangan akuntansi ness research, Vol. 12/6, pp. 1-4.
forensik di Indonesia, (Online), <word- Zango, AG 2012, ‘The relevance of forensic account-
press.com>, viewed 15 December 2012. ing education in financial reporting’,Working
Meier, HH, RR Kamath and Y He, 2010, ‘Courses paper series, Umaru Musa Yar’Adua University
on forensics and fraud examination in the ac- – Departement of Accounting, Faculty of Social
counting curriculum’, Journal of leadership, and Management Sciences.

292

You might also like