Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'The main objective of the present study is to compare the efficacy Ofthree different !i
rc1axa~onteclmiques in reducing symptoms ofhypcrtension. A sample of 40 patientS.was I
selected ftom clinics of West Delhi, All the subjects were established cases of hypertension I
and were under similar medi~on. 'Theirage varied ftom3S to 59 ye&1I.'Theeffect of three
di1fereDtrefaxation techniques, ~.e.Broota Rdaxation Technique,.la~QD.'s ~gressive ;
:~
I
!
Relaxation Teclmique and "Shavasana" were studied and the results are compared with a :. ~
, ;
control (no treatinent) IP'OUP. AnxietysymptOmcbec1dist,bloodpnuure (SBP & ~Bp)and
GSRmeasures havebeencomparedbeforeandafterre1axationsessi~. AtOtal ofBsessionS :: !
on 8 consecutive days were-taken.Sinslefacto1'8Iia1y." ofcOv8ri8nce(ANCOVA)has been ., :
useCion which relaxation technique is the only factor. hsu1ts Ihow that aU the three ~ j
relaXationtherapies are quite df'ective in reducing symptOmsof hypertension as compared :j
~ j.
to the control group. It is furtherob~ed tbateach ofthc three~on therapies produce '1 !
di1ferentforms ofrelaxatione1rects OIlhypertcusion.uShavasana" has beenfoUlidto be the :1 ~
:11
mostejfcctivefollow~ by the Broota~tiontecbniqueandtben l~son'8 Progreuive
Relaxation, . L
.d:
i
. . "
Stratton (1980) .states'~ in the 1ast . atian and ~roota Re18xation techDiques are
decade there has emerged an interest in the forms to aChieve relaxation where 1hepeqcm
treatment of hypertension through nonophar- actlvelypCrformssome activity. .
macologica1 or bdlaviourai methods including.
. ,.
. psychotherapy, hypnosis, placebo, relaxation USJiavaSana"is a from .of passm;
. ~:,il
.' 'therapies and 'cOmbinations of the above. Re- rclaxation. Itis a Yogic posture (1he COIpse like. .
. '.
'.. J,axationtherapy refcrstothe1herapeutic 1:JSe
of posture)tol'emoWfatigue~dtimlDess.lta1so
relaxation as the sole or primary intem:ntion provides a soothingcomfort because it'elimi- . ,.
-- - - - - --- - - -
.-~--- - ---
.. -----..--
I
I
,i
~
30 Relaxation in Hyperten8ion
. . . . '.
from otherphysicalailments like cardiac prob- a) Symptom Check List: A symptom checklist
lems, arthritis, diabetes, neurological deficits, consistingof24 ~ of anxietYwith
etc. The patientS.were selected with the help of some 00111II1OI1pSychological.ancfphysi-'
the practici11
. .g physicians
,,
,of the .~rea.
. , ologica1factors whicharethe characteristic.
. .... , .ofhypertensiveswas used. This check list
, Allthepatientswereestablishedcases has been checked earlier by' two clinical t
of hypertension'and were under similar medi- psychologists In a hQspital settiJig at the
cation. The age of the patients vafied from 3' Shahadfa Hospital for Mental Diseases,
to S9years. All the subjects were males and Delhi. Also included were the verbal proto- .
, I I
(ciiterioo, Y). Dq:etowideiliitialdift'erenccsin Posture ("'DhanurasnaU), RaisiJig the le.gs .
i tJ:te subject, the':Covariatc (X) was included and cycling.Theva1ue of auto suggestion in
pri.niari1y'to adjbst:the measurements ori the the CQDtrol of emotionally disturbing
criterioo ~able 00. h heJped to. reduce the . tIiCn1ghtshas been amply:estabUshed by the
,I expc;rimeuta1error ducto iriitial differences in psychoanalytic school of thought. Brootam
'1 the groups. Thus, it was a single fitctor'Analy- her relaXation techniquemakes'~:ofauto- '
sis of Covarian~ design., ., suggestion with. yogic exercises.. The ad~ !
q i
i .,. ministration of the techniqUe takes aboUt
: i Tools:, . 15-20 antes. The detailed tedWque is i
." ."
'..
1
~ '. giveiJ.in Broota and Dhir, 1990. .
'j The fOlloWing.toolsweteadniiniStered , , .
:1
,; to cach.ofthe40subjeas.inthe ~eni. . b) Jacobson's .prollJ'CSsiveRelaxation Tech-
.
d'
----------------
--~~-- --- _..
I I:
1970). This particular Yogic pos:ture has were.secured 1i'omea~ of the 40 subjects~
, ,.
.beeri knoWn to remove any amount of fa- .,After~ch sessiOnan inttO~e report Was
tigue and tiredness. It has specially been , also Obtained;:the ~e' procedurewas fol- :
, , i h
I
recommended for those who do' not have .Iow~' tOr all the forty patients. Each s~sion' !1
I
lasted for .a'period o( 2Q. ~utes. AU the . . I
I
much energy and stamina or tho~ who get :I
i .tired very easily.. .'Shavasana'" is believed
.to remove aU the tiredoess.ofnerves and
patients were \YSMednot to practice the tech-
riique at,home. In the no ~eDt group, a~ .: !
i
.' I I
i
I
.
! j:r
I . completely loosened. It'is Jcnownto reduce . day, mends on 3rd:day, food ~ 4th day, 'TV".
t blood' pressure and is used in Y9P centers', viewingon Sthday, filmson 6th day, music on.,
I . for pati~ ofhypertensloo. " . 7th &Jy,and;politicson.$.thday. Any Jdnd of ,.
!i emotlooor cci1ttictit;ever exp~~ thetoPic
I
was ~ to genera1,~versatiOl1 so as to
't-
,"
!
I
'd) Control ~up: The subjects of.thiS 'grOUp'
(n=10) were given no re~on therapy. IIi
this case, agener8l, light conversation was
avoidcatharticeffect. . ."
J
;1:
. c8rrledout Withthe subjectsUnrelatedto ; III!
,.
their probl~ of hypertepsian. Care' was . llesUlts "....
taken that~epatieat docS'hot direct his talk
towards hiS own problems, especially hy- Blood Pressure: The'Systolic Blood Pressure
pertension. His attention is to be divertedto ~gs (SBP) and Diastoli~ Blood Pressure
more neutral topics. 'The reason'being that (DBP)readingshaye been
'.
analyzed
'. . I
separate1y.....
if thepatic:at is' allowed to talk about his
physical problems itmay resu1tinto cathar- a) 'lbe SBPmeasureswere subjectcdto analy-
sis. Conversation was carried out for a' . sis .of covariance in. accordance with the
i .periOdof20 minUtes for ~ch subject in this .' desip of the study. Theresults.showthatthe .
group. ThistimewaSe'quivalcatto the time effect.ofie~ODtedmiques is significant,
~tmeilt groups spent in'taking relaxation F(3,3S)-18.11;p<.01; ThiS shows that the
therapy. four. groups differ significantly on SBP.
r-
I
I
.d.y#t!
.",:....
- --- - - - - - -- - - -- - --
I' .-
I 32 Relaxation in HypertonaiOD
i
I
after' accounting fortheregressioo of Yon X atioo (GrOUpI) and the Jacobson Progres-
(ANCOVA). siwPetnationTedm.iqucs (GroupJI)":How-
ever, it is observed form Fig.l that th~
The above rC$Ultsare clearly observable in rCductioointhe SBPis consistti1t1yimprov-
the graphical presentation of the outcomes 'ingwitbtheB~ relaxatiootedmique anct
.' for aU the eight sessions. The-pre- and poSt- inthec:aseofJacobS(D'stecbniquetherc~' r
readings of each subjec::t's SBP were 0b- greater varlatims in the improvementover I I
tained and the ciurcreoce measures (pre mi- the scssiOll$."Sbavasana" is'relatively in~ I
, nus post treatment)were obtainedfor each variantowr the scssioos and gave the beSt
of the 8 days for ~ of the.subjects in each outcome. Tho coDtrolgroup (GroUp IV),
of the groups. The n1eandi1Jcrcnc:ooutcOme however, .shows relatively in rcc:tu~on in
is .presemccl,inFigute 1. . SSP.
. ..
h is observed tha.t the best,outcome, iri teinui b) The DBP measures were.also Sdbjected to
of~ reductiooin'SBPis observec!in analysis of c:ovarianc:e in 'accordance with
Group~ III; which was adDiinistered. thedesip ofthestudy. The results .showtbat .
"Shavasana" - a passive form of relax-" tbeeft'ec::tofrcllP{l'dCliis significant, l'{3,35) '.
ation. h is foUowedby the .BrOOta. ~1ax- - 8.68; p<.OJ.. This shows that the four
.' . . /
.'
'. . '.
. ,
10
'2
'9
.8 ' ,
.
"
. ." ,
. ... .
,
" :,'
.
'. ' ...'.' ... ...
..., ,
:' ..-
. :
.
0
....
......
(,).
7
.g
I)
et 6 {
, .'
I) .. I
(,)
S
U'
It!
....
0
4 tI
r. . .
I)
3
.' ,
i
I
I
2 fit .,
:--,.
" !
... ': .' " . . '. . i
"". ..' .......... . ... I
. 'I
.. ...'.. . I
Q I
I ' 2 ,3 . .~. 4', ,5'- 7' 8
T~eatmCnt Seliions (Days)' !'
i
Figure 1: MeaDDiffe~~ce Me.sur08 of th~'"pur Group. as ..
I
J~: .' Function of .Treatment Sessions (D8Y')
. ,
I
.....
\,
I Shava Asana ~,
'Jacobson ~J:osres.ive R~laxatiOD'~ .-
I' Broota Relaxation Technique (:~m,oUCci Condition. .....
----- ---------
- ---------
groups differ' 'significantly. 00 DBP after , curves represciiting the Broota Rc1axaticJn
acco~g :for the regrcssioo, Qf Y ci1 X . Tedmiquc(Graup l)andthcJ~ ~
(ANCOV A). It is further observed that an greSsivc ~on Tcdm1qUc (~ D).
the.comparisoos among1heactiu~ Ymeans' The bJ,provementin the DBP Un~ the .
with the help of t test, indicate signi1i~ "Shavasna" is however,not so stable as
,difference (p<:.0l) eXcept .comparison be-- . .obt8medfor the 'SBP. Such t1uciuatiOl1S
in
tween the Broota and .Iacobs~ tccbniques. the curve are appareatm. an the four gioups.
,The CODtrorgroups .did not mow visible
SiniiIar procedure" as follOwed in SBP re- ~rOvemcatin both tho SSP andDBP over ,,.
sults, wasusec:ttppreParc1hegraph~owin&' the sessions, . .' .
~ di1fereneemcasures ofthefourgroupl$
to
~ resPect the DBP. Outcome is pre- , Ga1variicskbi '~ lGSR): The ~ I
i
. sentcd in'Figure 2. obtained were su1Uectedto analysis of,covari~ I II.
anee and. the analysis shows that the four I
i,
Here again, it is observed that tlJe best groups ~er sigJ1iftNlnt1yOIlOSR, rt3.3S) =='
'. outcome, in tenDs ofm8ximum.rectuction in . 7.90; ,J7<.01. after accounting for the regres-
DBP is observed in' Grbup ,m ("Shav- . sim of Yon X. .Though M:lCOV A shows a
asan~"): Figure2
. alsoshowsoverlapPingof
. significant~,:but muChreliancecaunot
. .
""
9
. .-
. .:.,
....
'8
..- . .
.. . .. -.....- "
-.
~ .
1)
.g
7 . . ..
0
0
6 ... . .....
u
c:I S
e. ,:'
.\i.i '. 4
....
Q
3
'fJ
o.
2
0
.~..
. . .. .,.. . .... .
.
'
.. '. .
. . .. . . .
. . . . .. ' ,..
",
I
i
j
Iii
I;,
34 Rolaxation in Hypcrtension
.. - .
beput inthe~s variabilityoverthe
1:Jecause not ,that large. .
sessions is high in'aUthe groups. Perhaps. GSR ,.
is not a gOQdindicator:of improvement.in
hyperteosi9Ji, .' . Discussion:
.(;
, .,' ,
AnxietvCheckList:1beo\ltc9meofANCOVA '
Relaxationmethodsseekto elicitcalm-
for the fcwr.groups indicates that the groups ness and hypometabolic state caned the
differ atj;<.OlleW1'ofconfideoce. 1\3.35) =' 4'trophotropbic'respoose" by Hess (1957).
2.49; p<.OI.The outcome is presentedgraphi- Southamet aI. (1982)examinedthe BP lower-
callyandit isobservedthat:tluctu8tionsover , ing effect of 'relaxation,training during the
. thy sessions are minimum in thiS measure~ working'day and suggested thatreJaxation
. '~Shavasana.' gives again the' best reSults and ':therapy'leads to a .reduction in BP that is
overlap in the. curves i'epres'entmg Jacobson evident in :the'natural environmCDt.Similar
and,Br~ techniqtJCSis observed, 11ie curve resultswere found by Dua (1976)in the'reduc-
. repres.eotingthe contiol group is the lowest. the tion o.fanxiety, by Doha. (1984) f~r car-
. results on this measure are wry similartothose diac patientSand by Larason, Bo., and Melin 'I
obtained under the',SBP' and DBP measures, (~986) in the treatment' of chrOnicheadache
~<?u~, the differen~ between the $foups arc etc. ' ',.
~ .. ..
' .....
0
8
....
...
(,)
7""
6
0
(,)
. . 5
0
,..
.-1_. . .
4 .~.
.....
, .
3
. .
.
.. .
..
0, ,
,
.
~.-....
2 . ~
~W.(.~
, " ,
0
1
1
.
. .... . .-,
\::7.
-. .' . .~.",..
2., 3
~~ 4
........
, 5' . '6 8
, 7 .
-Tr~a~~t Sessions (Days) "
'. . .' .. .
3S
I. I .
...u ~~... Ru<h;
.
Vu_" u S;...
~ the presentinvestigationit is o.b- auto-suggestions. Yogic exercises have been
'. .servedthat the three differentrelaxationthera- found'to provide soothing ~ort because
pies prOduce.different effects. .. SJiavasana" these e~ercise~ eliminate' tension and
, proves to '~e the most effective one in the
reduction of ~lood, pressure as it leads to
turbulatians
. ofmUid (BrabmadJari,
, .
1970). ,; '
m-eatestmean differenceson the pre and post- , For ~le, deep breathing checks
treatment sessions. Closely fonowed by this emotional excitement and c;tisturbance; {:)ow"
are the Broota RelaxatiOnTechniqueand the posture activates autonomic' nervous~system' .
Jacobson'sProgressiveRe~tion Technique. ' and the hypothalanttts and alSo these exercises
with are'1nore or less overlapping and show give anew $Clf-coofidencetotbesubject (.Anand,
. similar patterns on the graph: However, the' '1984). Whereas,. the Jacobson's Progressive
. Broota.ReIa~OI1 Techniquehas been found Relaxatioo involves sman ~cle group areas
to pt:oducegreater reductions as comparedto
.
ANXIETX 'CHECKLIST
10
9
'""
8 8
...
=' 7
.'tS
«)
.
-,«) '6'
.(,) , .- . . , .
'S
.-
! ..
5
lot , .. '.. . -.. .. .. .. .' '. ... ..~
, .' . ...
.- : ' . ' ...,
Ij.j 4
...
'A
3,
fa
«)
'. . . ..-- . - - . ... ..
::s 2
. .. . . . ......
-. .. . .
1
,11'
0
1 2 3. 4 S 6 7 8 , :
.' ShavaAsana
' 8. . . . , Jacobson PtogressiveRelaxation
ControlledCondition . .....
'j"I a,roota Relaxation Technique .
-"' j
/.\-.
--- -- - - - - -- - --- - - - - --
Relaxation in Hypertonsion
- -- - - -- - - -- - - - - - -- - - -