Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Application status of XLPE insulated submarine cable used in offshore wind farm in
China
Hongliang Zhang1, Jianmin Zhang1, Lewis Duan2, Shuhong Xie3, Jianlin Xue1
1
Zhongtian Technology Submarine Cable Co., Ltd, Nantong, People’s Republic of China
2
ZTT International Co., Ltd, Nantong, People’s Republic of China
3
Zhongtian Technology Group Co., Ltd, Nantong, People’s Republic of China
E-mail: zhanghongliang@chinaztt.com
Published in The Journal of Engineering; Received on 5th October 2017; Accepted on 1st November 2017
Abstract: The application of cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE)-insulated submarine cable used in offshore wind farms in China is discussed.
Different from onshore wind farms, the cable connects fans of offshore wind farms and transmits electric energy to booster stations installed
under water. Therefore, to a certain extent, a mass of offshore wind farm construction in China promoted the development of XLPE-insulated
submarine cable. The aim of the application of XLPE-insulated submarine cable for China’s offshore wind power, first summarised the struc-
tural characteristics of three-core AC submarine cable and introduced results of product structure improvement, production equipment upgrad-
ing and performance stability verification in the process of cable voltage levels of 35 to 110 and 220 kV. The product features and insulation
structure design method of flexible DC submarine cable have been analysed. Finally, according to the trend of a large capacity and high seas
construction for offshore wind farms, the application of XLPE-insulated submarine cable will focus on wet-type structure interconnecting sub-
marine cable and high-voltage flexible direct current submarine cable in the future.
This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707
Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/) doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421
Fig. 2 Hierarchical structure diagram of 110 kV three-core XLPE-insulated
Fig. 1 Hierarchical structure diagram of 35 kV three-core XLPE-insulated optical fibre composite submarine cable for Zhuhai Guishan project
optical fibre composite submarine cable
3.1 Application of AC 110 kV three-core submarine cable Table 1 Main performance of 110 kV three-core XLPE-insulated
submarine cable for Zhuhai Guishan project
In April 2013, the South China Sea Wind Power Joint Development
Co, Ltd presided over the development of Zhuhai Guishan 198 MW Items Data Unit
wind farm project officially issued AC 110 kV three-core optical
fibre composite submarine cable tender notice. Zhuhai Guishan approximate outer diameter 193 mm
wind farm was located in the Pearl River estuary of the approximate weight (in air) 76 kg/m
Lingdingyang bay, and planned to install 66 offshore wind turbines 20°C DC resistance of conductor ≤0.0366 Ω/km
with single capacity of 3 MW, while constructing a wind farm 90°C AC resistance of conductor ≤0.0488 Ω/km
booster station on the Guishan island, Dongao island, by the capacitance 0.170 μF/km
Dawan island network project. Before the offshore wind power inductance 0.406 mH/km
project was built in Zhuhai Guishan, high-voltage three-core sub- maximum allowable working temperature on 90 °C
marine cable was subject to the design and tooling equipment, conductor
and monopolised by foreign manufacturers [7]. This project maximum allowable temperature on conductor for 250 °C
opened the era of independent high-voltage three-core submarine short circuit
cable in China. reference capacity (air temperature 40°C, not 590 A
The structure of AC 110 kV three-core optical fibre composite exposed to direct sunlight)
short-circuit current on conductor 78.8 kA/1 s
submarine cable was generally the same as the medium-voltage
short-circuit current on metal shield 20.3 kA/1 s
cable that had been used; the model was HYJQF41-F 64/110
maximum allowable tension 210 kN
3×500+24B1+4B4+4A1a; single-mode optical fibre and simultan-
maximum allowable pressure 20 kN/m
eous monitoring multimode fibre are applied in the same optical minimum bending radius for installation 4000 mm
fibre unit. Fig. 2 is a hierarchical structure diagram of AC 110 kV
J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707 This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons
doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421 Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/)
of the insulation layer, lead sheath and PE sheath production, the Table 2 Main performance of 220 kV three-core XLPE-insulated
theoretical outside diameter and unit weight of the power core submarine cable for Xiangshui project
were ∼80 mm and 16 kg/m, respectively. If the continuous produc-
tion length is 20 km, the installation of each power core disk Items Data Unit
required a carrying capacity of 32 ton, so the ordinary planetary
cabling machine could not meet high-voltage three-core submarine approximate outer diameter 247 mm
cable for long-term continuous needs. approximate weight (in air) 110 kg/m
20°C DC resistance of conductor ≤0.0366 Ω/km
A Vertical cable twisting equipment was transformed to twist
90°C AC resistance of conductor ≤0.0488 Ω/km
three single cable cores together, it has three turntables which
capacitance 0.131 μF/km
could bear the weight of 350 tons. Fig. 3 is the vertical cabling
inductance 0.460 mH/km
machine with an automatic tray.
maximum allowable working temperature on 90 °C
As shown in Fig. 3, the vertical cable machine was equipped conductor
with a plurality of thread-cutting discs in addition to the maximum allowable temperature on conductor 250 °C
three large-scale automatic turntables, and is used for the simul- for short circuit
taneous cabling of the optical fibre unit and the forming filler reference capacity (air temperature 40°C, not 760 A
bar. After completion of the high-voltage power cores and fibre exposed to direct sunlight)
unit twisted together, the product flow to the cable machine in short-circuit current on conductor 72.1 kA/1 s
series with the wire armour, asphalt coating and the outer layer short-circuit current on metal shield 34.2 kA/1 s
of the interlocking production line, then stockpiled maximum allowable tension 275 kN
synchronously. maximum allowable pressure 20 kN/m
The successful development of the three-core high-voltage sub- minimum bending radius for installation 4400 Mm
marine cable had importance in economic and social value for
not only reflected in the technical progress, but also reduced the
use of the same transmission capacity of single-core high-voltage
submarine cable production costs, laying costs and operation and in Xiangshui County of Guandong Saltery; Sanwei saltworks
maintenance costs. outer sea, offshore distance of about 10 km, selected the first
domestic 220 kV three-core submarine cable, which was
produced by Zhongtian Technology Submarine Cable Co,
3.2 Era ushered in AC 220 kV three-core high-voltage cable
Ltd [8].
After the first 110 kV three-core submarine cable successfully For the structural design and process control of 220 kV three-
detected by the national testing organisation, and completion of core submarine cable used in Xiangshui offshore wind farm for ref-
large length production, CNPEC Rudong 150 MW offshore wind erence experiences of the 110 kV three-core submarine cable, the
farm, Huaneng Rudong 300 MW offshore wind farm were sub- model used was HYJQF41-F 127/220 3×500+2×(34B1+2A1b),
sequently built in China, all chose domestic 110 kV three-core sub- the product structure was the same as the 110 kV three-core sub-
marine cable connected offshore booster station to the grid on land. marine cable for Zhuhai Guishan project; the main performance
With the production and application of high-voltage three-core sub- was shown in Table 2.
marine cable experience accumulated, and increasing offshore wind Xiangshui offshore wind farm project is currently the only one
farm design capacity, the first 220 kV three-core submarine cable running offshore wind farm project, which made use of 220 kV
was put into operation in 2015. three-core submarine cable as the main circuit that had the largest
Investment was made by the Three Gorges group of Jiangsu size and heaviest weight in the domestic product; the development
offshore; Xiangshui 202 MW offshore wind farm was located process in addition to ensuring electrical performance meets the
standards and requirements of the project. In order to ensure that
the product in the production and laying process of mechanical
stress would not lead to wire and light unit quality damage,
bending tensile test was carried out while 220 kV three-core sub-
marine cable was developed.
The bending tensile test was used to simulate the situation of sub-
marine cable withstanding the tension during progress of construc-
tion, and the test device diagram is shown in Fig. 4.
Two-hundred and twenty kilovolt three-core submarine cable
bending tensile test in accordance with GB/T 32346.1-2015GB/T
32346.1-2015 ‘Rated voltage 220 kV (Um = 252 kV) XLPE insu-
lated large length AC submarine cables and accessories part 1:
Fig. 3 Vertical cabling machine with automatic turntable Fig. 4 Schematic diagram of bending test
This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707
Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/) doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421
test methods and requirements’ [9], according to the installation of
Fig. 4, the test needed to complete the winding, straightening,
winding process on a turning wheel in a submarine cable sample
of not <30 m. The sample shall be subjected to three cycles.
During the test, the tension applied to the submarine cable was
121 kN according to the recommended calculation method in the
standard. Before the test, two optical fibres were chosen randomly
from the sample and connected to the CD500 type fibre optic
tester after the ring is connected. The fibre performance changed
to determine whether the fibre suffered from destructive stress
during the sample withstanding the force or not. Fig. 5 shows add-
itional attenuation situation of the fibre under 1330 nm wavelength
during bending tensile test.
According to the results of the bending tensile test, the additional Fig. 6 Hierarchical structure diagram of ±160 kV XLPE-insulated optical
fibre composite submarine DC cable
attenuation of composite fibre unit in 220 kV three-core submarine
cable was <0.05 dB, which meet the requirement of the test. This
type of cable had passed the type test of the third-party testing
agency, the main facilities of Jiangsu Xiangshui wind power
project achieved power generation in October 2016, and now is
running well.
J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707 This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons
doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421 Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/)
As shown in Fig. 4, compared with high-voltage AC submarine
cable, the biggest feature of the DC cable was that it has only a
power core, greatly saving the cost of manufacturing. In addition,
in the case that the conveying capacity was about 200 MW,
NanAo flexible DC cable project used ±160 kV DC submarine
cable, the diameter and unit weight were greatly reduced, compared
to 110 kV three-core submarine cable of Zhuhai Guishan wind
power project and 220 kV three-core AC submarine cable of
Jiangsu Xiang shui offshore wind power project, it was convenient
for long-term transporting and laying.
In addition to the differences in structure, the insulation design of
the DC cable was more complex than that of AC cable. For
Fig. 9 Hierarchical structure diagram of wet-type submarine cable
XLPE-insulated DC cable, the DC transmission will cause the accu-
mulation of space charge in the insulation layer, which may cause
electrical field distortion of the insulation layer, resulting in de- type of cable was known as a wet-type submarine cable for now.
crease in electrical performance [11]. In addition, the DC cable in- Fig. 9 shows a typical structure of wet-type submarine cable.
sulation layer showed the resistive distribution of the electric field, As shown in Fig. 9, compared with the split-phase lead sheath
which was not only related to the structure and size of the insulated submarine cable, water-resistance performance of the submarine
wire core, but also related to the temperature distribution of the in- cable mainly depended on the semi-conductive PE sheath. In con-
sulation layer. Therefore, the DC cable insulation structure design trast to this, compared with lead plus PE sheath, a single layer of
needed to consider the electric field and thermal field coupling the water resistance of the wet-type submarine cable is still relative-
problem [12]. ly poor. Therefore, water-tree-retardant insulation material usually
Currently, the finite-element analysis method was used to solve used to ensure electrical performance of non-lead sheath submarine
the multi-physics coupling problem of DC cable insulation. cable under long-term underwater operation [14], but the operation
Taking ±160 kV-1 × 500 mm2 DC cable of NanAO flexible DC experience of non-lead submarine cable was short-lived for the
cable project as an example, the finite-element analysis software moment, especially if the voltage levels of interconnecting cable
was used to carry out simulating analysis of electric field distribu- increased to 66 kV, it was uncertain whether the existed
tion of the submarine cable under no load and rated load. water-tree-retardant insulation material could meet the require-
From the finite-element simulation results above, the maximum ments. Currently, the relevant international institutions are studying
electric field strength of insulation was 13.5 kV/mm on the outer the underwater operating test standards of wet-type submarine
surface of the conductor screen, and the minimum electric field dis- cable, used for evaluating the long-term operation of such products.
tributed on the inner surface of the insulation screen was 7.6 V/mm The related research work is still in progress, the wet-type submar-
when ±160 kV DC cable under no-load operating; the maximum ine cable would be a great development direction in the future.
electric field strength of the insulation was 12.2 kV/mm on the
outer surface of the conductor screen, and the minimum electric
field distributed on the inner surface of the insulation screen was 5.2 Application proportion expected increase of HVDC
8.5 V/mm when ±160 kV DC cable under rated-load (625 A) oper- submarine cable
ating, at this stage, the corresponding conductor operating tempera- According to the statistics of relevant departments, at present, the
ture was 53°C, less than the maximum operating temperature of 70° total resources of offshore wind energy could be developed as
C of DC cable [13]. It was shown that as the load increases, the elec- 7.5 × 108 kW in China, and more than 60% of that has a long dis-
tric field distribution was removed and the electric field of the insu- tance over 50 km. Using the HVAC cable as the main circuit, in
lation screen increased. It could be seen that under the same addition to increasing the cost of manufacturing and laying, also
insulation structure, size and voltage, the distribution of electric caused significant power loss. In comparison, VSC-HVDC trans-
field of insulation was obviously different with different load con- mission technology has obvious advantages in terms of cost and re-
ditions. Therefore, it was necessary to repeatedly verify the choice ducing loss, although the investment on construction of converter
of insulation thickness by combining the actual operating condi- equipment in the early investment was higher, but for long-term
tions and load of the cable in the project when designing the insu- plan, the construction of long-distance offshore wind farm would
lation structure of DC cable. be more inclined to HVDC submarine cable [15].
Currently, the voltage of XLPE-insulated flexible DC cable had
5 Development trend of XLPE-insulated submarine cable in reached ±525 kV, and with the strategic direction of building a
offshore wind farms global energy internet proposed in China, the State Grid
5.1 Interconnecting submarine cable to develop 66 kV and Corporation had set up the project to integrate domestic cable and
wet-type structure accessory manufacturers to develop ±500 kV flexible DC cable
system, intended for the construction of offshore power intercon-
With the capacity increase of offshore wind turbines, some projects nection, so ultra-high-voltage flexible DC cable product develop-
with a stand-alone capacity of 9 MW offshore wind turbine were ment and application would be the focus of national power
being built according to some relevant reports. Therefore, 35 kV construction in the next few years.
AC submarine cable used in interconnecting has been already sig-
nificantly insufficient; the development of submarine cable with a
6 Conclusion
higher voltage level would be an inevitable trend. Sequentially,
with the increasing of interconnecting cable voltage and the aware- This paper introduced the application of XLPE-insulated submarine
ness of environmental protection enhanced, lead used as a metal cable in offshore wind farm with the representative offshore wind
screen would not be able to meet short-circuit current capacity or power project in China, mainly introduced the key problems and
environmental requirements. To solve the problems above, copper work on the development of HVAC three-core submarine cable
wires would be used as a metal screen instead of lead, the metal and HVDC flexible cable, then described in detail the improvement
screen twisted by copper wires could not ensure a good water- of technology and equipment of HVAC three-core submarine cable,
resistance performance as lead sheath, therefore, that caused a the typical mechanical performance test method of large-size
higher demand of submarine cable under long-term work, this HVAC submarine cable and the design process with finite-element
This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707
Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/) doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421
analysis method for HVDC flexible cable insulation structure. In [7] Duan L., Li F., Chen P., ET AL.: ‘Impacts of offshore wind farms on
addition, after analysing the research progress of the submarine local networks voltage and wind power penetration limit’, Autom.
cable technology, combined with the development trend of the off- Electr. Power Syst., 2015, (14), pp. 162–167
[8] Zhao Y., Zhang J., Ma Z., ET AL.: ‘Design and manufacturing of
shore wind power at home and abroad, the paper put forward the
220 kV three-core submarine fiber optic composite power cable for
development direction of XLPE-insulated cable to the wet-type Xiangshui offshore windfarm’, High Volt. Eng., 2016, (5), pp. 19–21
structure interconnecting cable and HVDC flexible accessing tech- [9] GB/T 32346.1-2015: ‘Long AC submarine cables with cross-linked
nology in offshore wind power area. polyethylene insulation and their accessories for rated voltage of
220 kV (Um = 252 kV) – part1: test methods and requirements’
7 References (Standards Press of China, Beijing, 2016)
[10] Zhang H., Xie S., Yin Y., ET AL.: ‘Selection and verification of insu-
lation and sheath structure of ±320 kV DC cables for Xiamen flexible
[1] Xiao Q., Jia S.: ‘Development status and technology analysis of off-
DC transmission project’, High Volt. Eng., 2016, (10), pp. 3139–3146
shore wind power in China’, East China Electr. Power, 2010, 38, (2),
pp. 0277–0280 [11] Wang X., Wang C., Zhu Y., ET AL.: ‘Space charge profiles in XLPE
[2] Lu Q.: ‘Probabilistic dynamic optimization design for support struc- nano dielectrics used for HVDC plastic cable insulation’, High
ture of offshore wind turbines’, J. Vib. Shock, 2013, 32, (17), pp. Volt. Eng., 2015, 41, (4), pp. 1096–1103
46–51 [12] Liu T., Fu M., Hou S., ET AL.: ‘Mechanism of space charge distribution
[3] Liu G., Cao J., Lu Y., ET AL.: ‘Selection criteria of high-voltage sub- in XLPE used in HVDC cables under temperature gradient’, High
marine cables for offshore wind farms by life cycle cost’, High Volt. Volt. Eng., 2015, 41, (8), pp. 2665–2673
Eng., 2015, 41, (8), pp. 2674–2680 [13] Hu M., Zhang J., Xie S., ET AL.: ‘Design and test of ±160 kV DC cable
[4] Zhang Z.: ‘Design of electrical systems for Donghai great bridge on the first flexible HVDC transmission project’. 6th Int. Conf. on
100 MW oddshore wind farm’, Power Energy, 2012, 33, (1), pp. Electricity Distribution, Shenzhen, 2014
49–51 [14] Zhou K., Yang M., Tao W., ET AL.: ‘Propagation characteristics of
[5] Wu J., Zheng Y., Wu H.: ‘Design and production of three core power water trees in XLPE power cables under single polarity DC
optical cable part I: structure design’, Electr. Wire Cable, 2012, (3), voltage’, High Volt. Eng., 2015, 41, (4), pp. 1075–1083
pp. 20–22 [15] Ma W., Wu F., Yang Y., ET AL.: ‘Flexible HVDC transmission tech-
[6] Zhao L.: ‘Wind power development in intertidal area in China’, Wind nology’s today and tomorrow’, High Volt. Eng., 2014, 40, (8), pp.
Power, 2013, (7), pp. 16–19 2429–2439
J. Eng., 2017, Vol. 2017, Iss. 13, pp. 702–707 This is an open access article published by the IET under the Creative Commons
doi: 10.1049/joe.2017.0421 Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/)