Dear,

Greetings from the International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage

(ICID), New Delhi, India!

We are pleased to inform you that the ‘Extended Abstract’ of your

following proposed paper has been accepted for discussion by the 23rd
ICID Congress International Review Committee:

Submission Number: 223

Submission Title: COMPETITIVENESS OF MODULAR CANAL LINING - CASE STUDY OF
APPLICATION IN KS 1 TERTIARY CANAL, CIUJUNG IRRIGATION AREA, BANTEN
Submission Author: Mukhamad Uzaer

It is requested that the full length paper may be prepared in accordance

with the guidelines available at:

<http://www.icid.org/23cong_pap_guidelines.pdf>

by strictly following one of the templates as given below:

23cong_template1 – http://www.icid.org/23cong_template1.dotx

OR

23cong_template2 – http://www.icid.org/23cong_template2.dotx

In ‘23cong_template1’, go to the respective areas of the ‘CLICK

HERE TO ENTER TEXT’ field and paste text inside the field using ‘Keep
Text Only’ option available in ‘Paste Options:’. This option is
available in the ‘Paste Options’ while clicking the right button on
the ‘CLICK HERE…’ field. Avoid using ‘Source Formatting’ or
‘Merge Formatting’ options as they disturb the text formatting. In
case you are using ‘23cong_template2’, simply replace the text as
appropriate.

Non-English speaking authors are requested to get their paper/manuscript

vetted by a person who has sound English language command to avoid back
and forth correspondence later resulting in unnecessary delay.

You are requested to send your full paper on email ID

‘submit_paper@icid.org’ with Subject line as ‘23CONG Full length
paper submission (NUMBER)’ latest by 15 June 2017. As we are following
a tight production schedule, you are requested to submit your full paper
in time to ensure that is included in the 23rd ICID Congress
Proceedings/DVD/USB.

Please visit 23rd ICID Congress website <http://www.icid2017.org> for

availing Early Bird Registration, booking accommodation, tours, and much
more during the Mexico Congress.

Please contact me for clarifications, if any, at e-mail ID icid@icid.org

Happy submission of full paper !

With best regards,

Yours sincerely,
Vijay K. Labhsetwar, PhD
Congress Coordinator

----------------------- REVIEW 1 ---------------------

PAPER: 223
TITLE: COMPETITIVENESS OF MODULAR CANAL LINING - CASE STUDY OF
APPLICATION IN KS 1 TERTIARY CANAL, CIUJUNG IRRIGATION AREA, BANTEN
AUTHORS: Hanhan Ahmad Sofiyuddin, Mukhamad Uzaer, Mulyadi and Eko Winar
Irianto

Overall evaluation: 1 (weak accept)

----------- Overall evaluation -----------

Like in many other countries, structural damages to lined irrigation
canal are found in Indonesia also. The paper discusses the modular
channel lining technology using pre-cast concrete sections to minimize
the damages. However, effort is needed to popularize this technology in
place of the currently used stone masonry work, which is damage-prone. As
a practical solution to the channel lining problem using stone masonry,
the modular concept appears better. The Abstract is put in “Weak
accept― category.

----------------------- REVIEW 2 ---------------------

PAPER: 223
TITLE: COMPETITIVENESS OF MODULAR CANAL LINING - CASE STUDY OF
APPLICATION IN KS 1 TERTIARY CANAL, CIUJUNG IRRIGATION AREA, BANTEN
AUTHORS: Hanhan Ahmad Sofiyuddin, Mukhamad Uzaer, Mulyadi and Eko Winar
Irianto

Overall evaluation: 2 (accept)

----------- Overall evaluation -----------

Although this paper does not deal directly with irrigation techniques as
stated in Question 61, it does describe a unique activity in canal
rehabilitation. The paper also deals with the cultural aspects of
modular lining of canals.