Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
To facilitate increase power station efficiency, steam temperatures and pressures have to be
increased. Efficiency is not only important in reducing the cost of energy production, but
also of vital importance for the reduction of CO2. At present, current plant efficiencies range
from 38% to 46% and operating temperature range is from 565‟C to 620‟C.
Most UK coal fired power stations operate at the lower temperature spectrum, due mainly to
fact that that when most were built back in the 1960‟s and 1970‟s, this was the current state
of technology and material development. For this temperature range, around 570‟C,
generally in the high-pressure region of the turbine, Cr-Mo and Cr-Mo-V steels were
specified for operation. The majority of these early plants will reach the end of their life
within the next few years unless they fit emission controls technologies as required by the
EU‟s large Combustion Plant Directive.
Since the last power stations were built in the UK over 20 years ago, material technologies
have significantly advanced to allow increased steam pressure and temperature. Today,
state off the art coal fired power plant in mainland Europe and Asia operate around 610 to
620‟C and at pressure up to 275Bar (27.5MPa). The benefit of this is plain to see with a
reduction in carbon dioxide emissions of up to 20% per unit of electricity supplied.
To enable operation at these temperatures and pressures, modified 9% Cr Steels are widely
used for high pressure turbine casings, stop valves, control valves, and re heat steam valves.
These components are manufactured from high integrity castings, can be fabricated from
more than one castings, and are fully machined.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
1 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Fig 1a: 600MW Stop Valve Assembly (weight: 23,000kg Cr/Mo/V Steel)
Produced by Goodwin Steel castings Ltd
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
2 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
This short paper discusses the benefit of these steels in the turbine, the critical requirements
that are required to produce high integrity 9% Cr steel castings, and future new advanced
materials for 700„C+ steam operations.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
3 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
4) Reduced wall thickness can be used for the same design conditions, leading to lower
thermal storage and reduced thermal stress.
This last point is very important as thinner components require less time to reach thermal
equilibrium within the station, and therefore, are less likely to be thermo-mechanically
damaged during station cycling. The ability to cycle plant on a daily basis is becoming
important to operators in order to follow load demand and maximise profitability.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
4 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
The production of 9% Cr Steel castings in many ways is a quantum leap in technology, from
the production of the conventional Cr-Mo and Cr-Mo-V power generation steel grades.
Melting Practice:
The melting practice for 9% Cr Steel is far more stringent with regards to chemical
composition control and gas level control than is required for conventional power generation
steel grades.
Fig 3. 10ton Capacity AOD Vessel in operation at Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
5 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Heat Treatment:
Tempering is carried out typically between 700'C and 780'C depending on material grade,
and transforms un-tempered martensite to ductile tempered martensite. Often with castings,
a double temper treatment is applied. This is to ensure that the centre sections of large
castings are completely tempered and any retained austenite after air quenching has been
fully transformed to tempered martensite.
(Fig. 4)
Microstructure:
The final 9% Cr Steel microstructure should be predominantly tempered martensite with less
than 5% delta ferrite.
Delta ferrite is controlled by chemical balance using Cr Equivalent values for differing grades,
and the correct quality heat treatment. Castings cooled too slowly after austenitising will
contain more free ferrite.
The intermediate micro structures such as the as-cast condition, and after FAQ are
particularly stressed structures and highly susceptible to cracking ("clinking"). Heavier
sections increase the risk further and great care must be taken at these stages.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
6 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
This is common with most materials, which are welded, but with 9% Cr Steels this is
particularly relevant due to the high hardness seen in the as-welded condition of both the
weld and HAZ .
Due to martensitic transformations and residual welding mechanical stresses, the weld and
parent material are in a highly stressed condition prior to post weld heat treatment.
Therefore, cooling and heat rates during post weld heat treatment must be carefully
controlled to reduce the risk of stress cracking.
Welding is more often carried out with close to matching parent filler materials. Castings are
always pre heated prior to welding to reduce the thermal gradient between base materials
and weld puddle. Interpass temperatures have to be maintained to prevent hydrogen pickup
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
7 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
and the risk of subsequent hydrogen cracking. After welding castings must be control cooled
to below Mf to ensure full microstructural transformation prior to post weld heat treatment.
P= °C+273(20+log t) x1000
Where t = time in hours.
Tempering at too low LMP will results in too higher hardness of the weld and HAZ and the
toughness will be too low. However, too higher LMP value will cause the weld, HAZ and
parent material to have too lower hardness and, therefore, low strength. Care should be
taken when multiple PWHT conditions are applied to a component, as cumulative hours at
temperature will also over soften the material.
Over Tempering:
This is where the PWHT temperature is too high and the material is heated to above the
lower critical transformation temperature (AC1) and martensite starts to transform back to
austenite. When 9% Cr steels are exposed this temperature, martensite partially re
austenitise and the carbo nitride precipitates are coarsened but do not fully dissolve back
into solution.
The net effect is a part martensite part austenite material that lacks the pinning effect of the
precipitates and therefore the creep rupture properties are substantially reduced.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
8 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Fig.6: Electron backscatter diffraction grain boundary maps from P92 samples given post weld heat
treatment overshoot for 1 minute at (a) 800°C (b) 880°C (c) 900‟C (d) 960°C followed immediately by
tempering at 750°C for 2hrs prior to subsequent cooling to room temperature.
“The effect of simulated post weld heat treatment temperature overshoot on microstructural evolution in
P91 and P92 power plant steels”
Courtesy of Department of Materials, Loughborough University, Loughborough
R.C. MacLachlan, J.J Sanchez-Hanton and R.C Thomson
Under tempering:
This is where the PWHT temperature is too low, and results in materials precipitates not
going to completion or being absent or insufficient in size to stabilise the structure. In
addition to the loss of creep rupture strength that this condition will bring, the material is
also at risk from brittle fracture and stress corrosion cracking.
At these elevated temperature and pressures steels just don‟t have enough strength, so
instead material development has focused on Nickel alloys.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
9 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Fig.7 shows the relative stress rupture strength of various Nickel Alloys put forward as potential candidate
alloys for 700‟C + plant operation.
Nickel alloy development has concentrated on two main groups of alloys, solution
strengthened (SS) and precipitation strengthened (PR) alloys. The solid solution alloys are
lower in strength than their precipitation hardened counter parts, and so have reduced
stress rupture strength, but possess good ductility and weldability. However, for plant
operation above 760°C, only precipitation strengthened Ni alloys look likely to have the
require stress rupture strength.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
10 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Alloys 617 and 625 are alloys of this type. Although both may form intermetallic
precipitates during service this is largely a by-product of their composition and
not by design.
Thus at 1100K:-
23.5 At% Al the flow stress is 29 ksi
26.5 At% Al the flow stress is 87 ksi
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
11 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
For the foundry, successfully producing these alloys as heavy section castings is a further
/
quantum leap in manufacturing complexity, especially for the gamma prime (γ )
strengthened alloys. With these alloys special consideration has to be given to the following:
Melting Practice: Melting practices for Ni Alloys are essentially different from
conventional steel production in many ways. Specialised techniques are required to
prevent oxidation of volatile alloying elements. VOD or AOD melting is employed for
the production of large components.
Pouring Technology: Ni Alloys that are alloyed with Titanium and Aluminium, and
poured in air, have to be poured with great care to prevent oxidation defects on the
surface of the castings. Special techniques have been developed in runner system
design to prevent such defects.
Fig 8: Shows the X-Ray of two similar size feeders, one in Alloy 625 and the other in carbon steel
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
12 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
For Ni Alloy castings to be of any value in the power plant, their ability to be readily
welded is essential, as any castings produced will have to be welded to inlet and
outlet steam pipeline. To further complicate the matter, due to the high expense of
nickel, these alloys will need to be welded to lower temperature material steels in
lower temperature regions of the turbine. This arrangement will therefore
necessitate a heavy section dissimilar weld.
Weld repair of alloys like A625 is pretty weld established, however, heavy walled
fabrication welding of one casting to another is not well established and takes special
techniques and weld procedures to ensure success. Welding of heavy section age
hardened cast alloys such as Inconel 740® and Haynes 282® are less well known,
and are likely to be much more difficult due to the high strength of the material and
relatively low ductility at room temperature.
The power industry standard for many years for non destructive testing techniques has been
magnetic particle inspection (MT) and ultrasonic inspection (UT). These techniques have
been used for accessing the quality of the original steel castings during manufacture, and in
line inspection during service.
Unfortunately, neither of these inspection techniques are acceptable for Ni alloy casting due
to the attenuation seen in Ni Alloys volumetric inspection using ultrasonics, and its poor
magnetic permeability preventing MT from being a feasible technique for surface crack
detection.
The standard techniques for defect detection in Ni alloys are radiography (volumetric) and
Dye Penetrant (surface). Radiography inspection, due to grain size and density of Ni alloy
material, is performed using a linear accelerator for heavy sections castings.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
13 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Fig.9: Macro of a completed Alloy 625 Weld (largest cast Alloy fabrication weld ever
produced)
Machining of Ni Alloys:
Ni alloys are more difficult to machine than conventional steels used in the steam
turbine. This is not so surprising, as the same characteristics that ensure the Ni Alloy
has good high temperature behaviour, is also responsible for the poor machinability
of these alloys.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
14 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
Understandably, machining cost for these materials are far in excess of those for
conventional CMV, Cr-Mo and 9% Cr steels.
Alloy Costs
Ni Alloys are significantly more expensive then conventional power generation grades of steels.
This is compounded with the fact that major constituent elements in Ni alloys are traded on the
stock market, so that prices can vary widely from one week to the next. The graphs below show
the variation in alloying element prices for Nickel 2005 - 2010.
Table 4: Alloy material Costs in descending order (Hi to Low) – Sept 2010
Grade A740® A263 A617 A625 A230 A155
$/Kg $24.1 $24.1 $23.8 $22.2 $21.8 $18
£/Kg £15.11 £15.11 £14.92 £13.91 £13.67 £11.29
Grade MarbN E911 P92 P91 CMV Cr-Mo
$/Kg $3.44 $2.19 $2.23 $1.73 $1.14 $1.13
£/Kg £2.16 £1.37 £1.39 £1.08 £0.71 £0.71
If we take P91 as being unity, then an easy way to look at the relevant Ni Alloy pricing is to
display the costs as a multiplying factor above that of P91.
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
15 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000
Europe’s foremost independent steel and nickel alloy foundry
www.goodwinsteelcastings.com
The previous tables highlight the significant expense of Ni Alloys when compared to that of
conventional power generation steels used for SC and USC steam valves and casing components.
For the power industry to justify the additional costs of the A-USC materials, the cost model for
the operating life of the station, will have to out weight the initial capital outlay for such
advanced materials. It‟s also clear when studying the alloy costs, that the minimum amount of Ni
alloys should be used in the design. This would only be in the hottest and highest temperature
zones, where steam temperatures are in excess of 650°C, and typically 700°C to 725°C.
References:
1)“Superalloys A Technical Guide – Second Addition” ASM Publication M.J.Donachie,
S.J.Donachie ; March 2002
3)”Creep Resistant ferritic Steel for Power Plants” Ingo von Hagen and Walter Bendick
5)”U.S Program for Advanced Ultra Supercritical (A-USC) Coal Fired Power Plants”
Roberts Romanosky - presented at the “4th Symposium on Heat Resistant Steels and Alloys
Used for High Efficiency USC Power Plants 2011”
Steve Roberts
Technical Director
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd
Goodwin Steel Castings Ltd, Ivy House Rd, Hanley, Stoke-on-Trent, UK ST13NR
16 Telephone: +44(0)1782 220000