Economizers

http://www.energysolutionscenter.org/BoilerBurner/Eff_Improve/Efficiency/Economizers.asp

Introduction

Flue gases from large boilers are typically 450 - 650°F.

Stack Economizers recover some of this heat for pre-
heating water. The water is most often used for boiler
make-up water or some other need that coincides with
boiler operation.  Stack Economizers should be
considered as an efficiency measure when large amounts
of make-up water are used (ie:  not all condensate is
returned to the boiler or large amounts of live steam are
used in the process so there is no condensate to return) or
there is a simultaneous need for large quantities of hot
water for some other use.

The savings potential is based on the existing stack

temperature, the volume of make-up water needed, and
the hours of operation.  Economizers are available in a
wide range of sizes, from small coil-like units to very large waste heat recovery boilers.

See also Flue Gas Condensers that are used when water and flue gases come in direct contact
with each other.

How They Work

Boiler stack economizers are simply heat exchangers with hot flue gas on one side and water on
the other. Or, in direct contact condensing units, the make-up water is in direct contact with the
flue gases.

Economizers must be sized for the volume of flue gas, its temperature, the maximum pressure
drop allowed through the stack, what kind of fuel is used in the boiler, and how much energy
needs to be recovered. Economizers designed for natural gas only, would likely plug-up if
installed on a coal boiler and would face increased risk of corrosion if installed on an oil-fired
boiler. Some units are designed to keep the flue gases above condensation temperature, and
others are made of materials that resist the corrosive effect of condensed flue gases.
Economics

The savings potential is a function of how much heat can be recovered, which is a function of
how much cold water needs to be heated. A generally accepted "rule of thumb" is that about 5%
of boiler input capacity can be recovered with a properly sized economizer. A higher percentage
can be recovered with a Flue Gas Condenser, assuming there is enough cold water to condense
all of the flue gas that is available. Therefore, for 'ball parking' purposes, start by comparing
boiler input capacity with the need to heat water.

For example: consider a 500 hp boiler with a gas input of 20 million BTUs per Hour.  

20,000,000 BTUs x 5% = 1,000,000 BTUs (100% Load Factor)

1,000,000 BTUs / (1,200 BTUs per Gallon of 200F water) = 833 Gallons per Hour

(1,000,000 BTUs / 80% efficiency) = ~1.2 MCF x $7.00 per MCF Natural Gas = $8.40 per Hour
Value

Savings is reduced by 50% for a 50% Load Factor, etc.

If there is a need for that much hot water, the savings potential of $8.40 per hour would be
multiplied by the number of boiler run hours, or the number of hours that the hot water can be
used. In each application, be sure to consider the boiler Load Factor, the efficiency that the hot
water is otherwise produced at, the cost of natural gas, and the installation cost of the equipment.
If the economizer would be used to heat boiler make-up water, it is necessary to determine the
volume and temperature at the inlet of the economizer. The lower the amount of condensate
return, the higher the volume of make-up water and the higher savings potential.

An economizer that recovers 5% of boiler input should easily have a 2 year payback in a year-
round application.