Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Defining or non-defining?
Remember that defining relative clauses are used to add important information. The sentence
would have a different meaning without the defining relative clause.
The first sentence with a defining relative clause tells us which skirt. The second sentence, with a
non-defining relative clause, doesn’t tell us which skirt – it gives us more information about the
skirt. The context (which is missing here) makes it clear which skirt is being talked about.
Non-defining relative clauses can use most relative pronouns (which, whose etc,) but
they CAN’Tuse ‘that’ and the relative pronoun can never be omitted.
Non-defining relative clauses are more often used in written English than in spoken English.
You can tell that a clause is non-defining because it is separated by commas at each end of the
clause.
Task I: Put one word into each of the gaps below. Don’t put options, even if you think more
than one word could fit.
1. Nigel is just about to leave on a three-year trip ______ will take him right around the
world.
2. What’s more, he plans to make the whole journey using only means of
transport ______________ are powered by natural energy.
4. Lake Titicaca, ______________ is often known as the ‘holy lake’, is situated in South
America on the border between Bolivia and Peru. The lives of
people ______________ tools and pottery have been found on its shores have long
remained a mystery.
7. At the same time, it aims to avoid the ‘mass tourism’ ______________ has been a rather
unfortunate development in other areas of similar beauty.
The relative pronoun can only be omitted when it is the object of the clause. When the relative
pronoun is the subject of the clause, it cannot be omitted. You can usually tell when a relative
pronoun is the object of the clause because it is followed by another subject + verb.
Task II: Considering the previous explanation, tick the sentences which can have the relative
pronoun omitted.