You are on page 1of 9

Agnes Pelton and Georgia O’Keeffe:

The Window and the Wall


Michael Zakian

I
n 1929 Agnes Pelton painted Incarnation (fig. 39), an iconic image of a floating
red flower. It was created as a knowing and unusual response to the work of
her younger contemporary Georgia O’Keeffe. Pelton had begun painting her
nature-based, transcendental abstractions only a few years earlier—in the
winter of 1926—while living in relative seclusion in a historic windmill in the
Hamptons.1 Her compositions arose from unconscious sources, usually from dreams
or meditative states that she referred to as “waking visions.” Not one to work in
series or produce variations on a theme, she conceived of each painting as a unique
embodiment of an independent mental image. Drawing inspiration from an interior
source, she almost never made paintings in conscious response to the work of
other artists.
O’Keeffe had introduced her enlarged flowers to the public in a 1925 group
exhibition at the Anderson Galleries in New York, curated by Alfred Stieglitz.2 The
fact that Pelton responded quickly and so uncharacteristically to the art underscores
the curious and provocative parallels that ran through the two artists’ lives. Differing
in age by only six years, they moved in nearly overlapping circles, shared friends
(such as arts patron Mabel Dodge Luhan), and may have known of each other but
probably never met. Both studied with Arthur Wesley Dow and, for a short period
of time around 1920, both had studios in Manhattan.
Most notably, when both women were in middle age, they decided to leave
the East Coast and make the desert their home and source of creative inspiration.
In 1929 O’Keeffe made her first trip to northern New Mexico. She would eventually
be hailed as an icon of American culture for her independent, pioneering spirit. In
January 1932 Pelton left New York and moved permanently to Cathedral City, a small
hamlet in the California desert just outside Palm Springs. For nearly thirty years,
until her death, she worked without accolade or fanfare, known only to small

Fig. 39
Agnes Pelton, Incarnation, 1929
Oil on canvas, 26 x 22 in. (66 x 55.9 cm)
Collection of LeighAnne Stainer, Freemont, California

68 69
Fig. 40 handfuls of admirers, including the much younger Florence Miller Pierce and her was too concerned with external appearance. She complimented O’Keeffe for Fig. 41
Georgia O’Keeffe Georgia O’Keeffe
colleagues in the Transcendental Painting Group in New Mexico.3 When Pelton died painting “enlarged flowers—this way the soul of a flower can possess the whole
Lake George Window (Farmhouse Light Coming on the Plains III,
Window and Door), 1929 in 1961, all but forgotten and unknown, her heirs were offered paintings from her heart of one gazing at it”—but criticized her for creating only a formal solution: 1917
Oil on canvas studio as keepsakes. No one chose her abstractions.4 “She sees first outside . . . then with charming effort makes a decorative canvas Watercolor on newsprint
40 x 30 in. (101.6 x 76.2 cm) 117/8 x 87/8 in. (30.1 x 22.5 cm)
In Pelton’s Incarnation, a disembodied red bloom radiates heat and light as it of it.”5
The Museum of Modern Art, Amon Carter Museum of Art,
New York, Acquired through the floats in the center of a bright-yellow sky. Curtains on either side have just opened, Pelton may not have been fair in emphasizing the decorative, but she Fort Worth, Texas
Richard D. Brixley Bequest
revealing a miraculous vision. At the bottom stand blue icebergs. For Pelton the was correct to note that O’Keeffe had an obsession with physical matter and
flower symbolized a life-giving force that descends from above, providing warmth material form. As seen in Yellow Cactus (1929; fig. 59), O’Keeffe conceived and
to the cold earth below. It is not simply a plant but a veritable sun. As with all her rendered her flowers as solid and massive, looming and confrontational. Filling the
abstractions, this painting is about process, becoming, and a vital, nurturing spirit entire canvas, squeezing out excess space, these forms force themselves into
that animates all of reality. the face of the viewer. Even in an example of modest proportions, such as
As one might expect, Pelton was critical of O’Keeffe’s flowers, which she Poppies (1926; fig. 8), the visual impact is bold, assertive, and uncompromising.
saw as one-dimensional, materialist, and decorative. In her journals from the time, O’Keeffe’s flowers exist as emphatic, organic matter, dominating and consuming
she recorded a rare comment on the work of another artist, noting that O’Keeffe space until they become one with the solid picture plane.

70 71
Fig. 42 By contrast, Pelton thought of her paintings as views through a window
Georgia O’Keeffe
Like all her abstractions, Incarnation is conceived as a stage set and provides a
Music, Pink and Blue No. 2,
1918 glimpse into a fictional space. When she had her first one-person exhibition of
Oil on canvas abstractions at the Montross Gallery in New York City in November 1929, Pelton
35 x 291/8 in. (88.9 x 74 cm)
explained, “These pictures are like little windows, opening to the view of a region not
Whitney Museum of American
Art, New York, Gift of Emily Fisher yet much visited consciously or by intention—an inner realm, rather than an outer
Landau in honor of Tom Armstrong
landscape.”6 Through these windows Pelton imagines and creates entire worlds,
offering access to an ideal place just beyond our own. When O’Keeffe depicted a
window that very year, in Lake George Window (Farmhouse Window and Door) (1929;
fig. 40), she focused on the solid architectural frame. Instead of showing the glass as
transparent, she rendered it as opaque, making it as dense and impenetrable as the
surrounding wall. The metaphor of the window and the wall provides an intriguing
foil for understanding the deeper relationships between Pelton and O’Keeffe, artists
who shared biographical details but maintained distinct and diverging world views.

Fig. 43
Agnes Pelton, Meadowlark’s Song, Winter, 1926
Oil on canvas, 25 x 20 in. (63.5 x 50.8 cm)
Collection of Maurine St. Gaudens, Pasadena, California

72
slivers of color look like cuts or fissures within the flat plane of the paper. This
conception dominates her otherwise ethereal and transcendent Light Coming on the
Plains III (1917; fig. 41), which depicts the morning sun just before it breaks the
horizon.8 Although the image hints at sublime distance and nature’s powers of
transformation, O’Keeffe frames the event within an abstract arch. The effect is one
of viewing the scene through a parabolic opening in an implied wall.
Pelton saw the world as too complex and multidimensional ever to be resolved
successfully into a single flat plane. One of her first abstractions is Meadowlark’s
Song, Winter (1926; fig. 43), a recently rediscovered work that provides fruitful
comparison with O’Keeffe’s Music, Pink and Blue No. 2.9 In this powerfully
synaesthetic painting, Pelton used spiraling vertical ribbons to depict the song of
a bird. These upright arabesques turn and twist dynamically—an expansive,
generative force that enlivens the air and space around it.10 Blue sky appears broken
into a series of distinct arcs and facets. These breaks and discontinuities—a spiritual
rethinking of formal Cubism—represent differing forces, moments, or dimensions
of reality. More than just a painting of sound, this lush and luxuriant work conveys
the complex pulses and burgeoning energies that drive the natural world.

Time

B
ecause Pelton conceived of her paintings as offering a window on to another
world, they involve time. As seen in Ecstasy (1928; fig. 68), she conveyed
time by depicting a process, such as growth or transformation. She explained
that this composition represents a yellow lily that had experienced a burst
of growth so vigorous and ecstatic that it could no longer support itself and had
begun to collapse and die.11 In one static image Pelton represents an entire span
Fig. 44 Various critics have commented on the connection between O’Keeffe’s of life and death, merging Sigmund Freud’s opposing concepts of Eros and Thanatos
Georgia O’Keeffe into a single composition that is celebratory as well as mournful.
paintings and the wall. Carter Ratcliff noted that O’Keeffe “is an artist of surfaces.”
Blue Lines X, 1916
Watercolor and graphite on paper Achille Bonito Oliva wrote that the strength of her work arises from “the Time and transformation are also the subjects of Wells of Jade (1931; fig. 35),
25 x 19 in. (63.5 x 48.3 cm) constructive force of a sort of organic architecture.”7 Although she broke with rigid, in which floating, balloonlike forms represent evaporating water vapor. On the left,
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, rectilinear geometry by introducing gently cursive feminine and synaesthetic droplets have condensed on a smaller bubble and drip back into the pond or lake
New York, Alfred Stieglitz
Collection, 1969 shapes, her strongly tactile art celebrated external form and asserted the elemental below, symbolized by parallel bands of wavy horizontal lines. This painting
power of the critical two-dimensional picture plane. represents the entire cycle of water, from liquid to gas to liquid once again. In Future
An interest in walls and in solid planar surfaces runs throughout O’Keeffe’s (1941; fig. 12), Pelton depicts heaven—a time beyond mortal time on earth. Heavy
career. Her first mature works were motivated by a desire to render the aural, the stone gates mark the passage beyond the physical world.12 Glowing rectangles of
fluid, and the organic, but the idea of the flat wall dominates. Early abstractions, colored light float in the sky, offering a comforting message that everyone has
such as Music, Pink and Blue No. 2 (1918; fig. 42), use lyrical, rhythmic patterning a place in paradise. Just as Ecstasy and Wells of Jade represent the life cycle of a
to convey musical sounds. But the even-handed dispersal of forms across the flower and water, respectively, Future represents the life—and afterlife—of a human
painting suggests mere inflections within a dominant planar surface. In other works being. For Pelton, time was a dynamic, cyclical process that is continually unfolding
of her formative years, such as Blue Lines X (1916; fig. 44), the thin and fragile and never ending.

74 75
While Pelton favored representing grand, epic sequences within one canvas, state of mystical freedom. The low, black, triangular hill on the horizon symbolizes
O’Keeffe painted only single moments in time. Her tendency was to freeze and an earthly and negative “dark, sharp mountain of striving.”17 For Pelton, actual
suspend time, turning the temporal into the eternal. In the mid- to late 1920s she sublimity took place in a spiritual realm, free from practical concerns. She embraced
produced a series of works showing the skunk cabbage.13 Because it is the first to and avidly followed an array of spiritual disciplines, ranging from Helena Blavatsky’s
appear after the winter, this plant is seen as a symbol of spring and the annual theosophy to Agni Yoga, a more obscure doctrine advocated by the Russian émigré
renewal of life. Each work in the series captured a distinct stage in the life cycle. All painter Nicholas Roerich. The title Illumination reflects her belief in a cosmic
were conceived and rendered as separate moments in time. The six canvases in consciousness, a source of a-rational insight that comes from a higher plane.18
O’Keeffe’s Jack-in-Pulpit series (see No.1; fig. 60), produced in March 1930, represent
different approaches to treating artistic form, ranging from realism to almost pure
abstraction. Although the jack-in-the-pulpit plant has an intriguing life cycle
Desert

T
and bears bright-scarlet berries at the end of the season, O’Keeffe gave prime he contrast between these two artists appears most pointedly in the desert
importance to formal and pictorial concerns, focusing on the ways one can make paintings that they produced after moving to the West. Pelton’s Sand Storm
this plant conform to the strict logic of the picture plane. (1932; fig. 71) is probably her first desert abstraction and features a sun that
has been obliterated by swirling gusts of sand. As she explained in her
notebooks, the storm is passing, and the air is beginning to clear.19 The sky responds
Aspiration by sending forth a rainbow, a reassuring sign reflecting Pelton’s conviction that

O’
Keeffe was fascinated by novel forms—by the innovative, modern forms the world is essentially good and benevolent. Although a sandstorm is harsh and
of avant-garde art as well as by the striking and inspiring shapes of the unpleasant, her interpretation is exuberant and optimistic. Even Pelton’s realist
modern, vertical city. From 1925 to 1929 she produced a series of New desert landscapes, such as San Gorgonio in Spring (1932; fig. 10) and Seeds of Date
York City landscapes that celebrated the impact and power of the (1935; fig. 74), reflect her distinctive world view, for they focus on moments when
new, focusing on skyscrapers, as seen in City Night (fig. 45) and Shelton Hotel, the desert is blooming, flourishing, and procreative.
N.Y. No. 1, both from 1926.14 O’Keeffe rendered her buildings as solid geometric slabs O’Keeffe’s Purple Hills (1935; fig. 11) is typical of her New Mexico paintings,
and towering walls, climbing upward to reach new extremes of height. Adhering reflecting a very different sensibility. She took special delight in rendering the desert
to the ethos behind the 1920s search for the “Great American Thing,” she thought as empty and arid. Her achievement was to perceive and capture a rare and delicate
of achievement in terms of worldly accomplishment and material monumentality.15 beauty in the bleak and barren landscape, creased by stark, waterless arroyos. When
Pelton also addressed the theme of heights in the late 1920s but focused on life is present, as in Part of the Cliffs (1937; fig. 62), it appears minimally, as a slight
spiritual desire rather than physical achievement. The Guide (1929; fig. 46) is a band of green. As O’Keeffe explained in 1939: “A red hill doesn’t touch everyone’s
visionary, theatrical composition. An abstract scaffolding of arching lines represents heart as it touches mine and I suppose there is no reason why it should. The red
curtains that unfold in successive layers to reveal a solitary star, the otherworldly hill is a piece of the badlands where even the grass is gone. Badlands roll away
messenger or guide promised in the title. The composition was inspired by Joseph outside my door—hill after hill—red hills of apparently the same sort of earth that
Stella’s depictions of the Brooklyn Bridge, painted over a period of twenty years, you mix with oil to make paint. All the earth colors of the painter’s palette are out
but instead of celebrating human feats of engineering and technology, Pelton there in the many miles of badlands.”20
focused on the star as a beacon of hope. In Illumination (1930; fig. 1), she painted In earth-color pigments O’Keeffe found a ready identity between her
not man-made skyscrapers but reaching, mountainous shapes that yearn to go landscape subjects and the flat surface of her paintings. By using paint in a blunt,
beyond the everyday world. By contrast, she identified the horizontal, sinuous dry, and matter-of-fact manner, she further mimicked the dryness of the scorched
forms at the bottom of the composition as earthbound, lethargic, and negative. After land around her. Pelton preferred to enrich her paint with oil media. Working in
completing the painting, Pelton repainted and greatly enlarged the star in order to layers and with glazes, she created limpid, translucent, glowing surfaces. Whereas
emphasize a transcendental message.16 O’Keeffe made paintings with flat walls of dry, terse color, Pelton used paint in a
Pelton developed this dualistic symbolism further in Orbits (1934; fig. 73), lush, sumptuous manner to reinforce the idea of a wondrous window revealing
which depicts Mount San Jacinto, the mountain above Palm Springs, floating in a fantastic scenes.

76 77
Fig. 45 Fig. 46
Georgia O’Keeffe, City Night, 1926 Agnes Pelton, The Guide, 1929
Oil on canvas, 48 x 30 in. (121.9 x 76.2 cm) Oil on canvas, 301/2 x 201/4 in. (77.5 x 51.4 cm)
The Minneapolis Institute of Arts, Gift of Funds from the Regis Corporation, Mr. and Mrs. W. John Driscoll, Orange County Museum of Art,
the Beim Foundation, the Larsen Fund, and by public subscription Museum purchase with funds provided through prior gift of Lois Outerbridge

78 79
O’Keeffe preferred the desert when it was devoid of life. This aspect of her
Conclusion
sensibility is captured in remarks she made in 1939 about her interest in bones: “To

I
me they are as beautiful as anything I know. To me they are strangely more living n comparing the art of Agnes Pelton and Georgia O’Keeffe, one cannot escape
than the animals walking around. . . . The bones seem to cut sharply to the center the overwhelming differences in their personalities and perspectives. Pelton
of something that is keenly alive on the desert even tho’ it is vast and was a shy, withdrawn, romantic spiritualist who preferred to dwell within the
empty and untouchable—and knows no kindness with all its beauty.”21 As seen in ineffable mysteries of the human mind. O’Keeffe, the pragmatic realist,
such paintings as Goat’s Horn with Red (1945), or Pedernal – From the Ranch I favored the hard, factual worlds of matter and culture. She deserves her
(1956; fig. 65), which features a view through a pelvis, these spare yet sensuous, considerable fame and reputation as an archetypal American Modernist, who
organic shapes have considerable aesthetic appeal. But when O’Keeffe declared her grasped the achievements of advanced European painting in the opening decades
preference for the desiccated, lifeless remains of animals to real living creatures, she of the twentieth century and adapted these concepts to distinctly American subjects
revealed herself as startlingly lacking in empathy. She was able to find great solace and ideals. Employing imagery that was direct, uncomplicated, and accessible,
in the “vast and empty and untouchable” forms of the arid desert probably because O’Keeffe created a body of work that fused the soft and sensuous with the tough
there was something deep within herself that was equally empty and untouchable. and solid. In effecting this balance, she combined two essential currents within the
In contrast, Pelton was a wellspring of empathy. The credibility of her symbols American character—the hedonistic and the puritanical—in a way that has captured
arose from her willingness to identify completely with her subjects. She not only the public’s imagination and that offers a fascinating window into ourselves and
observed stars glowing silently in the night sky but also felt a powerful affinity with our culture.
them and believed that they shone for her. Her art arose directly from her belief in Pelton, for her part, does not deserve the neglect of history. Her mode of
human sympathy and compassion—and stands as a polar opposite to the work of modern art does not fit into ready categories but provides a fascinating parallel and
O’Keeffe, who celebrated the desert because it “knows no kindness with all its beauty.” alternative to the work of the Stieglitz circle.22 Perhaps it is accurate to say that she
was a modern painter who did not embrace Modernism. The rational, critical side
of Modernism tended to encourage pessimism, reductivism, and skepticism,
Vessels concepts foreign to her sensibility. Pelton’s art was based on opposing ideals of

P
elton’s loving sensitivity and unembarrassed empathy are seen in a group optimism, exuberance, and beneficence. In the end, her deeply personal, visionary
of paintings based on vessels, such as Star Gazer (1929; fig. 47), Even Song paintings are highly eccentric but still belong to a grand tradition within American
(1934; fig. 48), and Memory (1937; fig. 76). In Star Gazer, a curious hybrid culture. Like Ralph Waldo Emerson, she was a transcendentalist who perceived the
symbol represents an opening flower bud tightly nestled within a small glass spirit within nature; like Henry David Thoreau, she was the staunch individualist
vase. By conflating the natural and the man-made, Pelton asserts her faith that there who chose a reclusive life in order to define the parameters of her own existence
is a higher consciousness within the universe that protects and nurtures emerging and work. The paintings she left us continue to offer windows on to new and
life. She identified the vessel in Even Song as a ceramic jar that had attained a state unexpected worlds that deserve further exploration.
of enlightenment and glows with inner illumination as it sends forth flowing waters.
She remarked that this vessel was her own body, a clear association of nature’s
abundance with a feminine, procreative force. In Memory, a thin, narrow vase serves
as a conduit and repository for the experiences of a lifetime.
O’Keeffe addressed the theme of vessels and organic life in Head with
Broken Pot (1943), one of a small series on the subject. Both skull (nature) and pot
(culture) are shattered, and the ceramic olla, shown from an angle that reveals none
of its aesthetic qualities, is incapable of providing comfort to the unfortunate
individual resting within it. Although this painting can be seen as a political
statement about the decimation of Native American culture, it is primarily an
expression of O’Keeffe’s frank and unflinching acceptance of mortality.

80 81
Fig. 47 Fig. 48
Agnes Pelton, Star Gazer, 1929 Agnes Pelton, Even Song, 1934
Oil on canvas, 30 x 16 in. (76.2 x 40.6 cm) Oil on canvas, 36 x 22 in. (91.4 x 55.9 cm)
Private collection Collection of LeighAnne Stainer, Fremont, California

82 83
Notes

1. Agnes Pelton lived in the Hayground 6. Pelton, quoted in Zakian, Agnes Pelton, 53. Building’: Gender, Sexuality, Modernism, by focusing on its positive aspects,
Windmill in Water Mill, near Bridgehampton, 7. Carter Ratcliff, “Georgia O’Keeffe and ‘the and Urban Imagery,” Winterthur Portfolio 35 specifically on people’s capacity to have
Long Island, New York, from October 1921 Great American Thing,’” in Georgia O’Keeffe, (Winter 2000): 269–89. enlightened, mystical experiences.
until the summer of 1931. For details about ed. Bice Curiger (Ostfildern-Ruit: Hatje 15. Wanda Corn, The Great American Thing: 19. Pelton, quoted in Zakian, Agnes Pelton, 70.
the artist’s life, see Michael Zakian, Agnes Cantz, 2003), 29; Achille Bonito Oliva, “A Modern Art and National Identity, 1915–1935 20. Georgia O’Keeffe, “About Myself,” in
Pelton: Poet of Nature, exhib. cat. (Palm Constellation of Forms,” in Richard Marshall, (Berkeley ca: University of California Press, Georgia O’Keeffe: Exhibition of Oils and
Springs ca: Palm Springs Desert Museum, Achille Bonito Oliva, and Yvonne Scott, 1999). The phrase “Great American Thing” Pastels, exhib. cat. (New York: An American
1995). Her journals, notebooks, and Georgia O’Keeffe: Nature and Abstraction, was coined by Georgia O’Keeffe to refer to Place, 1939), reprinted in Lynes, Catalogue
correspondence have been preserved as the exhib. cat. (Dublin: Irish Museum of Modern the desire among many artists and writers Raisonné, 1099.
Agnes Pelton Papers 1881–1961, Archives of Art; Milan: Skira; Vancouver: Vancouver Art in the 1920s and 1930s to create a new type 21. Ibid.
American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Gallery, 2007), 27. of art and literature that would 22. Alfred Stieglitz (1864–1946) was a
Washington, D.C., reels 3426–27. 8. For a discussion of this series, see Judith be distinctly and uniquely American. photographer, publisher, and art dealer
2. Barbara Buhler Lynes, Georgia O’Keeffe: Zilczer, “‘Light Coming on the Plains’: 16. Zakian, Agnes Pelton, 56, 111 n. 38. who used his periodicals and galleries to
Catalogue Raisonné (New Haven ct: Yale Georgia O’Keeffe’s Sunrise Series,” Artibus et 17. Ibid., 73. promote young American Modernist
University Press; Washington, D.C.: National Historiae, no. 40 (1999): 191–208. 18. Pelton read and copied passages from painters. The artists in his circle—including
Gallery of Art; Abiquiu nm: Georgia 9. This painting had not been located when Richard Maurice Bucke, Cosmic Marsden Hartley, Arthur Dove, John Marin,
O’Keeffe Foundation, 1999), vol. 2, 1143. I organized Agnes Pelton: Poet of Nature Consciousness: A Study in the Evolution of and Charles Demuth, in addition to
3. Agnes Pelton and New Mexico Modernist in 1995, and was not included in that the Human Mind (Philadelphia: Innes & Stieglitz’s wife, Georgia O’Keeffe—all
Raymond Jonson learned of each other in retrospective. It appeared on the Los Sons, 1901). Bucke was a Canadian doctor produced abstractions inspired by
1933 through the Modernist composer, Angeles art market in early 2008. who supervised a mental institution in nature. See Sarah Greenough, Modern Art
astrologer, and artist Dane Rudhyar. They 10. Pelton identified with the upright arabesque the years before Sigmund Freud’s writings. and America: Alfred Stieglitz and His
began a correspondence that lasted for and in 1932 adopted the image of a spiraling Fascinated by the workings of the mind, New York Galleries (Washington, D.C.:
decades. When Jonson founded the “green flame over a white triangle above he set out to understand human National Gallery of Art; Boston:
Transcendental Painting Group (TPG) in New darkness” as her personal symbol. It draws psychology, not by probing negative Bulfinch Press, 2000).
Mexico in 1938, Pelton was elected its first upon William Hogarth’s “Line of Beauty,” a phenomena, such as neuroses, but
honorary president. Pelton had journeyed double inflected curve, but the analogy with
from New York to Taos in 1919 as a guest of an illuminating flame conveys a higher
Mabel Dodge Luhan (then known as Mabel spiritual calling. See Zakian, Agnes Pelton, 73.
Dodge Sterne)—a full decade before 11. Ibid., 50, 53.
O’Keeffe’s first visit—but most probably she 12. Pelton employed active symbols. Future
did not return to participate in the activities is filled with various symbols based on
of the TPG. Pelton never learned to drive. processes that define steps on the journey
During the height of the TPG she was nearly toward paradise. The orange zigzag line
sixty years old and did not like to travel, hovering at the right represents the back-
especially over long distances. She stayed in and-forth movements of a weaver’s
touch with Jonson and the TPG by post. shuttlecock and stands for the spiritual work
4. Nancy Strow Sheley, “Bringing Light to Life: necessary to enter heaven. The dark
The Art of Agnes Pelton (1881–1961)” (PhD triangular shapes at the left edge and upper-
diss., University of Kansas, 2000), 265. left corner stand for the shutter of a camera,
5. Pelton, quoted in Zakian, Agnes Pelton, 53. which opens in a spiral to reveal a heavenly
Sheley, “Bringing Light to Life” (95, n. 182), vision. See ibid., 93.
comments that Pelton’s notebook attributes 13. Charles C. Eldredge, “Skunk Cabbages,
these remarks to “GMP,” suggesting that Seasons, and Cycles,” in Georgia O’Keeffe:
they may not be her own words. The Visions of the Sublime, ed. Joseph S.
passage does refer to Pelton in the third Czestochowski (Memphis: Torch Press;
person, yet it is filled with the eccentric International Arts, 2004), 63–73.
terminology and syntax typical of her 14. For discussions of O’Keeffe’s New York
own writing. Regardless of who first made skyscraper paintings, see: Anna C. Chave,
this observation, the fact that Pelton “‘Who Will Paint New York?’: ‘The World’s
repeated it without comment or correction New Art Center’ and the Skyscraper
is a good indication that she agreed with Paintings of Georgia O’Keeffe,” American Art
the sentiment. 5 (Winter–Spring 1991): 87–107; and Vivien
Green Fryd, “Georgia O’Keeffe’s ‘Radiator

84 85

You might also like