You are on page 1of 8

MEDICINE

© 2010 Scientific American


Reprogramming cells from your own
body could give them the therapeutic
power of embryonic stem cells,
without the political controversy
BY KO N R A D H O C H E D L I N G E R

KEY CONCEPTS
■ Induced pluripotent stem cells
are mature body cells that have
been made to change their
identities and revert to an em-
bryolike state — without the
BRYAN CHRISTIE DESIGN

help of eggs or embryos.


■ Rejuvenating the normal body
cells of any individual —then
converting them to any of the
220 human cell types — could
yield new disease treatments
and custom replacement tissues.
■ Scientists are now working
to understand how these cells
are able to reverse their biologi-
cal clocks and whether the new-
est kind of stem cell will prove
as powerful as embryonic cells.
—The Editors

SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN 47
© 2010 Scientific American
I
remember my excitement one morning in the cures, such as type 1 diabetes, Alzheimer’s dis-
winter of 2006 when I peered through a mi-
Throughout human ease and Parkinson’s disease. The possibility of
croscope in my laboratory and saw a colony history people changing a cell’s identity just by delivering a few
of cells that looked just like embryonic stem select genes has transformed the way scientists
cells. They were clustered in a little heap, after have dreamed of think about human development as well.
dividing in a petri dish for almost three weeks. Throughout history people have dreamed of
And they were glowing with the same colorful
ƂPFKPIC(QWPVCKP finding a Fountain of Youth to escape the con-
fluorescent markers scientists take as one sign of of Youth to escape sequences of aging and disease, and the ability
an embryonic cell’s “pluripotency”— its ability to return an adult body cell to an embryonic
to give rise to any type of tissue in an organism’s the consequences of state would certainly appear to be as close as
body. But the cells I was looking at did not come humanity has come to that fantasy so far. Of
from any embryo: they were regular adult mouse aging and disease. course, the technology is still in its infancy.
cells that had seemingly been rejuvenated by the Many important questions must be answered
addition of a simple cocktail of genes. before anyone can say whether iPSCs will
Could it really be so easy to roll back the in- change the practice of medicine or even whether
ternal clock of any mammalian cell and return they will actually prove equivalent to the more
it to an embryonic state? I was not the only one controversial embryonic stem cells.
wondering at the time. Shinya Yamanaka of the
University of Kyoto and his colleagues had just Primordial Power
published a groundbreaking study in August To understand the hopes inspired by the discov-
2006 that revealed their formula for creating ery of iPSCs, one must return to what makes
what they called induced pluripotent stem cells embryos so special. Current iPSC studies rely
(iPSCs) from the skin cells of mice. Researchers heavily on techniques and concepts developed
had been struggling for years to understand and in work with embryonic cells over the past
control the enormous potential of embryonic 30 years, particularly the phenomenon of pluri-
stem cells to produce customized tissues for use potency. Mammalian development is normally
in medicine and research— as well as contend- a one way-street, where cells become progres-
ing with political and ethical controversies over sively more specialized and less versatile with
the use of embryos, scientific setbacks and false time, a process called differentiation. Only dur-
hopes generated by previous “breakthroughs” ing a brief window very early in development
that did not pan out. So stem cell scientists were do all the cells within an embryo possess the
surprised and a little bit skeptical of the Japa- ability to become any of the 220 cell types
nese group’s results at first. But that morning in in the human body. Extracting those cells
the lab, I could see firsthand the results of fol- and growing them in culture gives rise to em-
lowing Yamanaka’s recipe. bryonic stem cells. The ability of true embry-
Other scientists were also able to reproduce onic stem cells to indefinitely maintain their
his achievement, and improved techniques for capacity to generate any tissue type defines the
making and testing iPSCs have come rapidly term “pluripotent.”
over the past few years. Today thousands of sci- Even in a late-stage embryo, stem cells have
entists worldwide are working to develop the specialized to the extent that they can give rise
potential of iPSCs to help in understanding and only to specific families of cell types, such as
treating human diseases that have so far defied those in muscle and bone. These cells are con-
COURTESY OF HYESOO KIM AND LORENZ STUDER Sloan-Kettering Institute

sidered “multipotent,” but they are no longer


pluripotent. In an adult, all that remains of
those precursors are so-called adult stem cells
that replenish mature cells within a tissue. Blood
stem cells continuously regenerate the 12 dif-
ferent blood and immune cell types, for exam-

THERAPEUTIC PROMISE
Neurons (left) were generated from induced pluripotent cells that were made from the skin
cells of patients with Parkinson’s disease. With the ability to take a mature body cell and
convert it to an embryonic state, then into any desired tissue type, scientists will be able to
study how a variety of diseases arise, develop and test drugs that hinder the disease process
and, eventually, produce healthy replacement tissues for use in treating illnesses.

48 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN M a y 2 0 10
© 2010 Scientific American
[BASICS]

A Biological Clock
In the developing human body, a cell’s possible identities become restricted with
time and increased specialization— although induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs)
seem to break those rules. Normally only the cells of an early embryo are pluripo-
tent: able to become any cell type in the adult body. Later, embryo cells commit to
lineages that limit their potential fates to specific tissue families, making them
multipotent. In the adult body, stem cells are still more specialized. Mature body
cells are said to be terminally differentiated — locked into their identities. Repro-
gramming rewinds the internal clock of mature body cells to a pluripotent state. Early embryo
(5–6 days)

Induced pluripotent
stem cells Mature body cells

Lineage-committed
cells
Blood cells

Reprogramming Skin Late embryo


(15–16 days)

Muscle
Skin

Hair

CELLULAR POTENTIAL
Adult stem cells
Pluripotent: Can give rise
to any cell type
Multipotent: Can give rise
to cells within a tissue family
Terminally differentiated:
Locked into one identity

ple, and skin stem cells are responsible for re- been removed. This DNA-egg hybrid then de-
growing our skin and hair every few weeks. velops into an early-stage embryo from which
In mammals the one thing that never hap- pluripotent stem cells can be extracted.
TAMI TOLPA (illustration); PHILIPPE PSAILA Photo Researchers, Inc. (stem cell nuclear transfer)

pens under normal circumstances is for a cell to Since the cloning of Dolly the sheep was re-
dedifferentiate, that is, revert back to a more vealed in 1997 and the first isolation of human
primitive type. Indeed, the only exception to embryonic stem cells in 1998, nuclear transfer
this rule is cancer cells, which can become less has received considerable attention as a possi-
differentiated than the tissue in which they first ble means of producing custom-tailored pluri-
arise. Unfortunately, some cancer cells can also potent stem cells to replace any tissue damaged
continue to divide endlessly, displaying an im- through injury or disease. Poorly understood
mortality similar to that of pluripotent cells. factors within the egg do seem to genuinely re-
Until recently, the only way to turn back the juvenate the genetic material of the adult donor
developmental clock of a normal adult cell was cell — even telomeres, the caps protecting the
through elaborate manipulations to trick it into CLONING ends of chromosomes that wear away with age,
behaving like an embryonic cell, a process Transferring the nucleus of a mature are restored to a youthful state. Yet despite
termed cellular reprogramming. The oldest ap- cell into an egg is another method of progress with animals, attempts to produce hu-
reprogramming a person’s adult DNA
proach to achieving reprogramming is somatic man embryonic stem cells through cloning have
to an embryonic state. Attempts to
cell nuclear transfer, or “cloning,” which in- derive embryonic stem cells from remained unsuccessful.
volves injecting the genetic material from an human-clone embryos have so far Yamanaka and his group went around this
adult cell into an egg cell whose own DNA has failed for unknown reasons. impasse by taking a novel approach to turning

w w w. S c i e n t i f i c A m e r i c a n . c o m SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN 49
© 2010 Scientific American
[MILESTONES]

Rapid Progress toward Safe Cell Rejuvenation


Just four years ago scientists in Japan first showed that a set of genes ferried by a retrovirus could transform the skin cells of adult mice into pluripotent stem
cells. Many researchers have since been working to achieve the same end in simpler, safer and more efficient ways—key steps to making therapy a reality.

Mouse skin cell Nonintegrating virus

DNA

Reprogramming
genes

iPSCs
Retrovirus

iPSCs
2006 2007–2008
Shinya Yamanaka inserts four genes normally Other researchers reproduce Yamanaka’s
active in embryos into a modified retrovirus, accomplishment in mouse and human
which he then injects into mouse skin cells. The cells. Experiments also show that delivery of
virus inserts the genes into the mouse DNA, and the four reprogramming genes by viruses that
the genes then begin reprogramming the skin do not permanently integrate into cellular
cells into induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs). DNA still succeeds in producing iPSCs.

adult cells directly into pluripotent cells with- cus of iPSC research right now, as scientists
out the use of eggs or embryos. Instead of intro- work to establish what these cells really are and
ducing adult genetic material into an egg, they what they are capable of doing.
reasoned that introducing the genes normally
active only in embryos into an adult cell might Identity Crisis
be sufficient to reprogram that cell into an em- Although iPSC colonies may look like embry-

TAMI TOLPA (illustration); COURTESY OF ALEXANDER MEISSNER Harvard University AND MARIUS WERNIG Stanford University (mouse embryos)
bryolike state. Their first feat was to identify a onic stem cells under a microscope and may dis-
cocktail of two dozen different genes that play the molecular markers associated with
are turned on in pluripotent cells but silent in pluripotent cells, the unequivocal proof of their
adult cells. When introduced into skin cells us- pluripotency comes from functional testing—
ing retroviruses as delivery vehicles, these genes can the cells do all the things a pluripotent cell,
then almost magically reprogrammed the iden- by definition, can do? Even embryo cell colo-
tity of the skin cells into that of pluripotent nies can contain some dud cells that do not dis-
cells. With further experiments, Yamanaka play the pluripotency of a true embryonic stem
then found that only four genes — Oct4, Sox2, cell, and scientists have developed a few routine
Klf4 and c-Myc — were actually necessary to tests to gauge a cell’s pluripotency. With increas-
produce iPSCs. ing stringency, they are: the ability of stem cells
As soon as several independent laboratories, to produce a wide variety of body cell types in
including mine, successfully reproduced the re- a petri dish when exposed to the appropriate
sults, this magic trick became a biological fact. TESTING CELLS’ developmental cues; the ability of stem cells to
By now about a dozen different adult cell types TRUE POTENTIAL produce a teratoma (a type of tumor containing
from a total of four different species (mouse, hu- Gold-standard laboratory tests to cells from all embryonic tissue lineages) when
determine whether stem cells are truly
man, rat and monkey) have been reprogrammed injected under the skin of a mouse; and the
pluripotent aim to demonstrate that
into iPSCs, and certainly more will follow. The the cells can give rise to any tissue type capacity, when injected into an early-stage
discovery of iPSCs is so thrilling to stem cell re- in the body. When injected into an mouse embryo, to contribute to the develop-
searchers because they can circumvent the tech- early mouse embryo, for example, ment of all tissue lineages, including germ cells,
nical complexities of cloning and avoid most of fluorescently marked pluripotent cells in the resulting newborn mouse.
should integrate throughout the body
the ethical and legal constraints associated with Whereas embryonic stem cells generally pass
of the developing mouse (bright green,
human embryo research. This new pluripotent above). Finding alternative methods of all these tests, many iPSCs do not. Closer ex-
cell type is not without its own problems, how- verifying the pluripotency of human amination of the cells that fail has revealed that
ever. Quality control and safety are the main fo- iPSCs is an important goal. the viruses used to deliver the four key repro-

50 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN M a y 2 0 10
© 2010 Scientific American
GENE-ACTIVATION
MARKERS
Reprogramming
Skin cell identity
Days 9–15: Failed
Reprogramming proteins reprogramming Pluripotency

Day 1: Reprogramming
genes activate
Reprogramming genes
iPSCs

Days 9–15: Day 21: iPSC colony


Reprogramming
under way

2008–2009 2009–2010
Scientists demonstrate that iPSCs can be Scientists focus on raising efficiency by identify-
made using retroviruses carrying only three ing distinct patterns of gene activation (re-
of the original Yamanaka reprogramming vealed by fluorescent markers) characterizing
genes, then only two, or just by introducing cells that will successfully convert to iPSCs. Skin
the proteins encoded by the four reprogram- cell identity and reprogramming-gene markers
ming genes directly into cells. give way to pluripotency markers.

gramming genes into skin cells are often not iPSCs into developing mouse embryos later
properly shut off, and important genes in the formed cancers as a consequence of residual
cells’ original DNA are not properly turned on, retrovirus activity.
resulting in cells that have lost their skin cell One of the main problems with using retro-
identity without gaining a pluripotent identity. viruses as gene-delivery vehicles is that these
These partially reprogrammed cells therefore kinds of viruses (HIV is one example) integrate
do not qualify as authentic pluripotent cells. themselves directly into the host cell’s DNA
Ongoing studies of iPSCs that do pass all the strand, becoming a part of its genome. This
pluripotency tests are aimed at pinpointing the [THE AUTHOR] ability allows the added genes to reside perma-
differences that distinguish a “good” from a nently and remain active in the host cell, but de-
“bad” iPSC. Thorsten Schlaeger, George Daley pending on where the virus inserts itself, it can
and their colleagues at Harvard University, for cause DNA damage that sparks cancerous
example, recently identified a pattern of gene changes in the cell. In efforts to produce safer
activity in skin cells undergoing the lengthy iPSCs, therefore, many labs have developed
(about three weeks) process of changing their methods that avoid permanent genetic manipu-
identity to that of pluripotent cells. The fluores- lation of cells.
cent markers displayed by these cells during the My research group has used a modified type
transition distinguished them from cells in the of adenovirus, which normally causes the com-
Konrad Hochedlinger is associ-
same colony that would not ultimately become ate professor of stem cell and
mon cold in humans, to deliver the four repro-
iPSCs, and so this marker pattern could be used regenerative biology at Harvard gramming genes into mouse cells without inte-
as an early indicator of successful conversion. University and a faculty member of grating into the cellular genome. Adenoviruses
COURTESY OF SAM RILEY Massachusetts General Hospital

Because scientists cannot ethically perform the Harvard Stem Cell Institute and persist inside the cells for only a short period—
the Howard Hughes Medical
the most stringent pluripotency test by inject- just long enough to convert them into iPSCs.
Institute. In his laboratory at
ing human iPSCs into human embryos, it is ab- Massachusetts General Hospital,
When we injected the resulting pluripotent cells
solutely critical to ensure that human iPSCs ful- he works toward understanding into mouse embryos, they readily became incor-
fill all other criteria of pluripotency. These in- the biology of stem cells and porated into the developing animals, which
clude the complete silencing of the potentially cellular reprogramming and their were all tumor-free as adults. This discovery,
potential use in the treatment of
harmful viruses employed to deliver the repro- along with several alternative approaches to
disease. He is also a scientific
gramming genes. Yamanaka’s team members adviser to iPierian, a biopharma-
producing virus-free iPSCs, should eliminate a
discovered, for example, that one third of ceutical company developing major roadblock to one day applying iPSCs di-
the mice that they had generated by injecting products based on stem cells. rectly in human therapies.

w w w. S c i e n t i f i c A m e r i c a n . c o m SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN 51
© 2010 Scientific American
[THERAPY POSSIBILITIES]

Custom-Tailored Cells to Cure Disease


An ability to transform a patient’s skin or blood cells into iPSCs and then into any other type of cell could cure diseases in two ways: in the very near future,
by allowing scientists to “model” illnesses and test drugs in a petri dish and, perhaps in another decade, by repairing or replacing diseased tissues.

APPLICATION STATUS

DISEASE MODELING ■ Human iPSCs have already been used to generate


Convert iPSCs derived from 12 tissue types, including cells representing diverse
patients into the affected disorders such as Parkinson’s disease and diabetes
tissue type, then study ■ Symptoms of smooth muscular atrophy and familial
disease progression and drug dysautonomia have been “treated” in cultured cells
responses in those cells

CELL THERAPY ■ 10 years or more in the future


Convert iPSCs derived from ■ iPSC-derived neurons have been transplanted into
a sick patient into healthy rats to treat a version of Parkinson’s
cells for transplantation into
that individual ■ iPSC-derived blood progenitor cells with corrected
iPSC colony sickle cell anemia genes cured the disease in mice

Ultimately, researchers hope to produce This technique also offers the possibility of
iPSCs without using any type of virus, but in- repairing disease-causing genetic mutations be-
stead by simply exposing adult cells to a combi- fore reintroducing the new cells, an approach
nation of drugs that mimic the effect of the re- that has been used with the adult stem cells that
programming genes. Sheng Ding of the Scripps naturally regenerate some tissues. Success has
Research Institute, Douglas A. Melton of Har- been limited, though, because those precursor
vard and others have already identified chemi- cells are notoriously difficult to grow and ma-
cals that can substitute for each of the four re- nipulate outside the body.
programming genes in that each chemical acti- Recent experiments in mice suggest that
vates a pathway of molecular interactions inside treating genetic disorders in this manner with
a cell that would be activated by the gene. When iPSCs is indeed feasible. Specifically, Rudolf
the four drugs have been tried together, howev- Jaenisch of the Massachusetts Institute of Tech-
er, they proved insufficient to make pluripotent nology showed in 2007 that iPSCs could cure
cells. It may only be a matter of time, though, sickle cell anemia in an animal. The disease re-
until researchers find the right cocktail and con- sults from a single genetic mutation that causes
centration of drugs to reprogram body cells into red blood cells to adopt a deformed crescentlike
iPSCs without ever using viruses. shape. In this proof-of-concept study, investiga-

COURTESY OF KONRAD HOCHEDLINGER AND MATTHIAS STADTFELD Massachusetts General Hospital (mouse)
COURTESY OF WILLIAM COLLINS Deepak Srivastava Lab, Gladstone Institute of Cardiovascular Disease (iPSC);
tors first reprogrammed skin cells from the mice
Healing Cells? into iPSCs. They then replaced the disease-caus-
Because pluripotent cells are capable of generat- ing gene in the iPSCs with a healthy version and
ing any type of tissue in the body, the application coaxed the “repaired” iPSCs into becoming
that most captures the public imagination is the blood-forming stem cells. After transplantation
possibility of using iPSCs to produce replace- back into the anemic mice, the healthy precur-
ment parts for cells and organs damaged by dis- sors produced normal red blood cells. In prin-
ease: neurons lost to Parkinson’s or a spinal cord ETHICS UNCLEAR ciple, this method could be applied to any other
injury, for instance, or cardiac tissue destroyed Injecting iPSCs into a developing disease in humans for which the underlying
by a heart attack. The ability to convert adult mouse embryo yields a chimeric gene mutation is known.
animal (above) that displays the
cells from the intended recipient of such a trans- The multimillion-dollar question is how
presence of foreign cells in its mixed
plant into pluripotent cells and then coax those coat colors. The same technique long it might take before iPSCs can be used to
cells into the desired tissue would mean the could, in theory, create a chimeric treat people. For the reasons already outlined,
replacement part is perfectly matched, genetical- human embryo; iPSCs could also safety and control are absolutely essential be-
ly and immunologically, with the recipient’s theoretically generate sperm and fore any iPSC-derived cells could be tested in
eggs to produce a human embryo
body. Moreover, easily accessible skin cells could humans. Current strategies to push embryonic
through traditional in vitro fertiliza-
be used to produce any kind of needed cell, tion. The pluripotency of iPSCs thus stem cells or iPSCs into fully differentiated ma-
including those in hard-to-reach organs and tis- could raise some of the same ethical ture cell types cannot yet efficiently eliminate
sues, such as the brain or pancreas. issues as human embryo research. the occasional immature stem cells that might

52 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN M a y 2 0 10
© 2010 Scientific American
seed a tumor. An example underscoring why Challenges and Hope
this is such a problem comes from a recent ex- Although iPSCs clearly circumvent some of the
periment in transplanting iPSC-derived dop- ethical and legal controversies surrounding
amine-making neurons, which are the cells lost embryonic cells, their pluripotency has yet to be
in Parkinson’s patients, into rats suffering a ver- completely understood or controlled, and
sion of the human disease. Although the rats embryonic stem cells therefore remain the gold
clearly benefited from the engrafted cells, some standard for any pluripotent cell type.
of the animals also eventually developed tera- Important unanswered questions include the
tomas in their brain. practical issue of whether the conversion of body
In light of the fast pace of discoveries so far, cells into iPSCs and the conversion of iPSCs into
however, it is optimistic but not unreasonable therapeutically relevant cell types can ever be
to estimate that such obstacles could be over- CELLS FOR SALE made efficient enough for widespread use. Also
come in as little as 10 years, and transplantation The first commercially marketed unresolved is whether iPSCs retain any memory
product made from human iPSCs,
of iPSC-derived cells might then be ready for of the body cell type from which they are de-
a heart cell line called iCell Cardio-
human testing to begin. But iPSCs could well myocytes, is intended for use by rived, a factor that could limit their ability to be
demonstrate their therapeutic value much soon- pharmaceutical companies to test converted into any other type of cell. We have
er. The study and treatment of many tissue- the effects of potential heart drugs. gained some insight into the mechanisms by
destroying diseases, such as type 1 diabetes, which a mature cell transforms into a pluripo-
Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s, are limited by sci- tent cell, but the process of reprogramming—
entists’ ability to obtain the affected tissues for how only a few genes manage to rewire the en-
study or to grow them in cultures for extended tire program of a mature cell into that of an em-
periods, and iPSCs could therefore be of enor- bryonic cell—is still largely a black box.
mous service in so-called disease modeling. Tackling such questions will require the con-
The idea is to derive iPSCs from affected pa- tinued use of embryonic cells as a reference
tients’ skin or blood cells and then convert them point and will determine whether embryonic
into the cell types involved in the patients’ dis- stem cells may be more effective for certain
eases. Both Clive N. Svendsen of the University types of applications and iPSCs for others.
of Wisconsin–Madison and Lorenz Studer of Moreover, as truly pluripotent cells, iPSCs may
the Sloan-Kettering Institute recently derived raise ethical issues similar to concerns over em-
iPSCs from the cells of patients with the devas- bryonic cells because, in theory at least, iPSCs
tating disorders smooth muscular atrophy and ➥ MORE TO could be used to generate human embryos [see
familial dysautonomia, respectively. When the EXPLORE box on opposite page].
iPSCs were transformed into the cell types af- Induction of Pluripotent Stem Nevertheless, from a scientific standpoint
fected in each of those diseases, the cultured Cells from Mouse Embryonic and progress in the field of cellular reprogramming
Adult Fibroblast Cultures by
cells recapitulated the abnormalities just as they in recent years is truly astounding. Advances in
Defined Factors. Kazutoshi Takahasi
are seen in patients. and Shinya Yamanaka in Cell, cloning and, more recently, the discovery of
This process could allow researchers to study Vol. 126, No. 4, pages 663–676. iPSCs have refuted the old dogma that the iden-
the development of a disease in a petri dish, with Published online August 10, 2006. tity of cells is irreversibly locked once they have
the advantage of having a potentially endless differentiated. Both techniques have raised the
Epigenetic Reprogramming and
supply of new cells, because the original iPSCs possibility, at least, of reprogramming the iden-
Induced Pluripotency. Konrad
can be maintained indefinitely. Ultimately, the Hochedlinger and Kathrin Plath in tity of a body cell from one type of tissue into
goal of academic scientists as well as pharma- Development, Vol. 136, No. 4, pages that of any other tissue type just by manipulat-
ceutical companies is to use these petri dish 509–523; February 15, 2009. ing a few genetic switches. Understanding how
models to better understand the disease process this rewiring works at a mechanistic level will
Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells
and identify novel drugs to treat the illness. keep researchers energized and busy for years
COURTESY OF CELLULAR DYNAMICS INTERNATIONAL, INC.

and Reprogramming: Seeing the


This extremely promising use of iPSCs is not Science through the Hype. Juan to come.
far off at all. Indeed, when Svendsen and Studer Carlos Izpisúa Belmonte, James Ellis, Only time can reveal whether iPSCs or relat-
exposed their cell cultures to experimental Konrad Hochedlinger and Shinya ed technologies will indeed become the modern
drugs in each study, the disease “symptoms” Yamanaka in Nature Reviews Genetics, Fountain of Youth. I personally think there is a
Vol. 10, No. 12, pages 878–883.
were partially alleviated in the cells. This prin- good chance they will. Certainly iPSCs will
Published online October 27, 2009.
ciple can now be applied to many other disor- continue to influence approaches to the study
ders for which treatments do not yet exist, and and treatment of many devastating diseases and
unlike transplanting cells into individuals, the
➥ Find an enriched multimedia
have the potential to revolutionize medicine in
version of this article at
result may be the development of drugs from www.ScientificAmeri- the 21st century as profoundly as vaccines and
which millions could benefit. can.com/interactive antibiotics did in the 20th century. ■

w w w. S c i e n t i f i c A m e r i c a n . c o m SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN 53
© 2010 Scientific American

You might also like